Podcast discusses Social Security solvency, projected 2032 shortfall, and potential benefit reductions.
Summary
Sarah Avila and Elizabeth Williams explain that Social Security is a pay-as-you-go system funded by current payroll taxes, not a savings account that can 'go broke.' They note the worker-to-beneficiary ratio has dropped from five to three since 1960, leading to a projected trust fund depletion by 2032. At that point, incoming taxes would cover only about 75% of promised benefits. The speakers outline legislative proposals such as raising the retirement age or taxable income cap to address the shortfall. They advise clients to stress-test financial plans assuming a 20-25% benefit reduction.
Key takeaways
- 1 Social Security is a pay-as-you-go system where current payroll taxes fund current retirees.
Sarah Avila · 0:00
- 2 The worker-to-beneficiary ratio declined from five workers per retiree in 1960 to approximately three today.
Elizabeth Williams · 1:49
- 3 Yeah, so a lot of people don't realize this, but your income is only taxed up to a certain amount. So this year that amount is $184,500.
Sarah Avila · 6:35
- 4 So for Social Security directly, an employee puts in 6.2% of their paycheck up to that limit that we talked about. Right and their employer puts in the same.
Sarah Avila · 7:15
- 5 Financial planners should stress-test retirement plans by assuming a 20-25% reduction in Social Security benefits.
Sarah Avila · 9:53
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 1:01
Introduction and Social Security Structure
Sarah Avila and Elizabeth Williams introduce the topic of Social Security solvency, clarifying that the program is a pay-as-you-go system funded by current payroll taxes. They note that while headlines suggest bankruptcy, the system will continue to pay benefits as long as workers contribute, though potential shortfalls may reduce benefit amounts.
- 1:01 – 2:56
Historical Context and Trust Fund Mechanics
Elizabeth Williams highlights historical worker-to-beneficiary ratios, noting a surplus in 1960 with five workers per retiree compared to approximately three today. Sarah Avila explains that past surpluses were held in a trust fund to cover future shortfalls, which is now being depleted.
- 2:56 – 4:45
Projected Shortfall and Political Response
The speakers discuss the distinction between 'going broke' and facing a funding shortfall, citing a projection that by 2032, only enough revenue will exist to pay slightly over three-quarters of promised benefits. Elizabeth Williams mentions bipartisan efforts in Congress, including Senator Tim Kaine, to address the issue before the 2032 deadline.
- 4:45 – 6:20
Proposed Reforms and Demographic Drivers
Sarah Avila identifies two primary drivers of the shortfall: increased life expectancy and a declining workforce participation rate relative to retirees. Elizabeth Williams outlines four common legislative proposals to restore solvency: raising the retirement age, increasing payroll taxes, raising the taxable income cap, and modifying benefit calculations.
- 6:20 – 7:34
Taxable Income Cap and FICA Details
Sarah Avila explains that FICA taxes apply only up to a specific income limit, which she states is $184,500 for the current year. She notes that high earners pay taxes on only this portion of their income, and both employees and employers contribute 6.2% each toward Social Security.
- 7:34 – 10:46
Impact on Different Generations and Claiming Strategies
The speakers discuss how reforms historically grandfathered in current retirees while applying changes to younger workers. Elizabeth Williams advises clients to model financial plans assuming a potential 22% benefit reduction to test resilience, while Sarah Avila suggests planning for a 20-25% reduction as a prudent baseline.
- 10:46 – 14:10
Ongoing Planning and Disclosure
Elizabeth Williams emphasizes the importance of reviewing claiming strategies and adjusting plans annually to account for legislative changes. The episode concludes with a call to action for consultations and standard financial disclosures regarding securities and advisory services.
Claims worth verifying
Social Security is a pay-as-you-go system where current taxes fund current retirees.
Sarah Avila ·0:00
How to verify: U.S. Social Security Administration (SSA) official website explanation of how Social Security works; SSA Publications. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
By 2032, Social Security will have enough revenue to pay only slightly over three-quarters of promised benefits.
Sarah Avila ·1:46
How to verify: SSA Trustees Report (most recent annual report); check the 'OASDI Combined Trust Funds' section for the year of depletion and the percentage of benefits payable thereafter. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In 1960, there were five workers for every Social Security beneficiary.
Elizabeth Williams ·2:03
How to verify: SSA Historical Data on the Old-Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance (OASDI) Program; historical worker-to-beneficiary ratios. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Currently, there are approximately three workers in the workforce for every Social Security beneficiary.
Elizabeth Williams ·2:10
How to verify: SSA Historical Data on OASDI Program; current worker-to-beneficiary ratios. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Senator Tim Kaine is part of a bipartisan group addressing Social Security solvency.
Elizabeth Williams ·4:23
How to verify: U.S. Senate website for Senator Tim Kaine; news archives from 2026-08-03 to 2026-11-03 regarding Social Security legislation and Kaine's involvement. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The taxable income cap for FICA taxes is $184,500.
Sarah Avila ·6:35
How to verify: IRS Publication 15 (Circular E) for the relevant tax year; SSA wage base limits. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Employees and employers each pay a 6.2% FICA tax for Social Security.
Sarah Avila ·7:15
How to verify: IRS Publication 15; Internal Revenue Code Section 3101 and 3111. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Historically, current retirees are grandfathered into old rules when Social Security reforms are implemented, while younger workers are subject to new rules.
Sarah Avila ·7:46
How to verify: Historical records of Social Security reforms (e.g., 2026 Amendments); SSA historical documents on benefit adjustments for different cohorts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the 2032 depletion date and 75% payment ratio using the Social Security Administration's 2025 Trustees Report.
- Confirm the current year's taxable income cap ($184,500) on the IRS website or SSA.gov.
- Check the current worker-to-beneficiary ratio using Census Bureau data or SSA historical tables.
- Review Senator Tim Kaine's legislative proposals and co-sponsors via Congress.gov.
- Analyze the impact of raising the retirement age on different demographic cohorts using SSA actuarial tools.
- Assess personal retirement readiness by modeling a 20-25% benefit cut in financial planning software.
- Look for counter-arguments from economists who dispute the 2032 timeline or the severity of the shortfall.
- Identify any conflicts of interest if the speakers are selling specific retirement products or advisory services.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Sarah Avila: When you hear a headline, oh, that social security is going broke, that doesn't mean that social security is completely running out of money. Because as we talked about, it is a pay as you go system. So as long as people are still working and paying payroll taxes, there will be Social Security.
- 0:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hi,
- 0:26
- Sarah Avila: I'm Sarah. Avila, CFP and Financial Advisor with VLP Financial Advisors.
- 0:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 0:31
- Elizabeth Williams: I'm Elizabeth Williams, Financial Advisor with VLP Financial Advisors. And we're here today because of the big question. We've been reading about it in the headlines. Sarah, what's the big question?
- 0:43
- Sarah Avila: Is social security going broke? We hear it from our clients all the time. It's a big question, it's a big concern for everybody. And so we're here to talk about the facts, what's going on, and what reform measures are going to be taken, hopefully going to be taken, to fix the solvency of the system.
- 1:01
- Elizabeth Williams: So, Sarah, I think we should just start with how did Social Security get started?
- 1:06
- Sarah Avila: Yeah, so I think that's good to talk about for any of our viewers today, to talk about how the system works right now. So social security was designed as a pay as you go system, meaning that the people that are paying taxes now, those FICA taxes, are going directly to the benefits to the current
- 1:26
- Sarah Avila: retirees. Social Security was developed in 1935 and at the time it worked great. And and it still works great for the most part. However, it's estimated that in the year 2032 that there will only be enough to pay a little over three quarters of the benefit that everybody's promised
- 1:46
- Sarah Avila: for various reasons that we can talk about in a little bit.
- 1:49
- Elizabeth Williams: Well I like the fact that you brought up though that it started in 1935. And just to share some historical numbers, in 1960 we saw actually a surplus. We had for every beneficiary
- 2:03
- Elizabeth Williams: retiree receiving benefits, there were five workers that were putting into Social Security.
- 2:10
- Elizabeth Williams: And today there's approximately three workers in the workforce that are putting in and uh for every beneficiary. And that is quickly declining and it's going to even dwindle more and more.
- 2:25
- Sarah Avila: Yeah, that's right. And and actually there was a surplus for many years. So up until about five years ago or so, we had a surplus. And so all of that surplus, that extra money that we were receiving in payroll taxes, that the government was receiving in payroll taxes, went into a trust fund. So for this exact purpose. So that
- 2:45
- Sarah Avila: when we encountered a shortfall, we'd be able to take money from that trust fund to give every everybody to kind of top it up to give everybody the benefit that they were promised.
- 2:56
- Elizabeth Williams: Yes, I just want to even piggyback on that. When you talk about the trust fund, I think it's really important to differentiate between the headlines, Social Security is going broke, versus really what is happening with the trust fund, because it's I think there's some miscommunication.
- 3:15
- Sarah Avila: Yeah, exactly. So when you hear a headline, oh, that Social Security is going broke, that doesn't mean that Social Security is completely running out of money. Because as we talked about, it is a pay as you go system. So as long as people are still working and paying payroll taxes, there will be Social Security. But That if no reform happens,
- 3:35
- Sarah Avila: then people will only be able to get a little over three three-quarters quarters of the benefit that they're promised. But in the past, you know, they there's been a lot of changes throughout Social Security throughout the years. And reform has happened in the past. And so we do believe that reform will happen again. It's just a matter of when it happens because
- 3:55
- Elizabeth Williams: Congress coming together.
- 3:57
- Sarah Avila: Yes. That's
- 3:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): another
- 3:58
- Sarah Avila: big part of it.
- 3:58
- Elizabeth Williams: It's truly a bipartisan solution. We see both Democrats and Republicans.
- 4:03
- Elizabeth Williams: coming together, and I do like to give a shout out just because we are in Virginia and Senator Kane is part of this bipartisan group that is putting forth a couple different solutions and he has been quoted recently saying, We are not asleep at the wheel. We are looking at this seriously and we're coming up with various
- 4:23
- Elizabeth Williams: solutions because twenty 2032 thirty two is right around the corner.
- 4:27
- Sarah Avila: It's true. And it's reassuring to know that they're not just putting it on the back burner, that they are looking into it and that they are coming up with uh, you know, potential solutions. I know it's not it's not a quick fix or an easy fix. There are certain things that can be done, but deciding what is going to be done is a harder question to answer. Yeah.
- 4:45
- Elizabeth Williams: Well, Sarah, how did we get here?
- 4:47
- Sarah Avila: Social Security, like we talked about, has gone through changes throughout the years.
- 4:51
- Sarah Avila: But I mean really the there's two big issues at play. So one is that people are living longer. Ultimately a great thing, but it also means that, you know, it's more benefits that have to come out to go to pay to those beneficiaries, those retirees. And as you mentioned, there's we're not
- 5:11
- Sarah Avila: having enough kids.
- 5:12
- Elizabeth Williams: Right. Fewer people in the workforce.
- 5:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yep.
- 5:15
- Sarah Avila: Fewer people in the workforce paying into the program.
- 5:18
- Elizabeth Williams: Right.
- 5:18
- Sarah Avila: So, you know, you put those two together and now we have, you know, a shortfall with trust funds that are going to be depleted potentially in 2032 and some reform that needs to happen in order to keep everything solvent.
- 5:32
- Elizabeth Williams: Next would really be good to talk about the solutions that have been proposed. Again, we're not here to say what what the solution is, but I think there there are a number of ideas that have been have been proposed in Congress and you know four that get talked about regularly are possibly increasing the retirement
- 5:51
- Elizabeth Williams: age. Yes that's been done before. Also increasing the payroll taxes, that could be a possibility, or increasing the income that's actually subject to Social Security. And then the last would be modifying the actual calculation. So
- 6:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Exactly.
- 6:08
- Elizabeth Williams: I mean, we we don't know exactly what's going to happen, but at least there's real talk and there's also a deadline. Yeah. Something's gonna have to happen in the near future.
- 6:19
- Sarah Avila: Exactly.
- 6:20
- Elizabeth Williams: So we've talked about how the different solutions, but I think it's also important to talk about if you've we were to increase the amount of income that's taxed, what does that look like? What is it today and what would versus the solution?
- 6:35
- Sarah Avila: Yeah, so a lot of people don't realize this, but your income is only taxed up to a certain amount. So this year that amount is $184,500. So if you're a person that makes, let's just say, $200,000, you're not getting taxed on that entire $200,000. You're getting taxed, um
- 6:55
- Sarah Avila: this these the FICA tax, I should mention, on $184,500. So a millionaire, for example, most of his or her income is not taxed. It's only that $184,500. So when we talk about raising the income cap, that's what they're talking about. So you know, making more of your income taxable.
- 7:15
- Sarah Avila: having those FICA taxes. And I should mention, too, that the employee is not the only one that pays those FICA taxes. Also the employer. So for Social Security directly, an employee puts in 6.2% of their paycheck up to that limit that we talked about. Right and their employer puts in the same.
- 7:34
- Elizabeth Williams: So we've talked about the various solutions, and this is something that is going to impact everybody. However, how does it impact today's retiree versus, let's say, a 40-year-old?
- 7:46
- Sarah Avila: In the past, whenever they've implemented reform for Social Security, the people that the current retirees are people that were very close to retirement age were grandfathered into To the old roles. Whereas the younger people were the ones that were subject to the the new. newer roles. So, you know, we've seen the social security age,
- 8:06
- Sarah Avila: like the full what's considered your full retirement age, go up a few times throughout, you know, history. And additionally, we've seen those FICA taxes also, you know, go up and down throughout the course of the program.
- 8:19
- Elizabeth Williams: Well, so this really brings me to the planning process. And everyone is gonna going to be impacted in some way, but as a 40-year-old versus somebody in their 70s, there's more time to plan accordingly. Look at, okay, what's the number needed to meet your goals in retirement, and how do we help you and
- 8:40
- Elizabeth Williams: prepare for whatever changes lie ahead? Versus, yes, you're somebody that's already benefiting from the Social Security system, and maybe there will be some type of reform that could impact. them, but the likelihood is that they would historically we've seen this be grandfathered in.
- 8:57
- Sarah Avila: Yeah. Now I know that both of us have worked with clients that are asking about Social Security, whether we should incorporate it into their financial plan in 100% of the benefits that they're promised or, you know, some different percentage. Can you tell us a little bit about your experience with the
- 9:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): process of the process of the process
- 9:15
- Sarah Avila: clients and you know what kinds of measures you're taking with the financial planning regarding Social Security?
- 9:21
- Elizabeth Williams: Every situation is a little bit different. If they're married, if they're divorced, and looking at different claiming strategies. But yes, we're also looking at the what ifs and looking at reducing benefits by 22% twenty-two percent because that is the approximate. amount if we did get to twenty thirty-two
- 9:41
- Elizabeth Williams: and didn't do anything. We are looking at testing their financial plan, making sure that it does work if the worst case scenario did come true.
- 9:52
- Sarah Avila: Yeah.
- 9:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
- 9:53
- Sarah Avila: And I can say the same. So it doesn't make sense to say, oh well, Social Security may not be there at all, because that's simply not the case. But what I've done with clients it sounds like you've done similar things, is reducing it by a certain percentage, to maybe 20 to 25%, somewhere in that range, just in case no reform happens.
- 10:13
- Sarah Avila: Part of the process with financial planning is to try and and be as accurate as possible with the things that the factors that we can control or are the things that we know. So, you know, when we're trying to figure out what numbers to put in for Social Security, putting 100% in, I mean, that could still happen, but it's good to test the
- 10:32
- Sarah Avila: plan at, you know, a reduction in of twenty or twenty-five percent in the benefits just to see how the plan works over the long run and if there's any changes that a client would need to make in preparation for what could happen.
- 10:46
- Elizabeth Williams: Well and I think it's important to understand that everybody's situation is different. And that's why it it's very important to sit down with us, go back through your financial plan if we haven't dusted it off yet for this year, and look at your situation and when it would be best to claim versus
- 11:06
- Elizabeth Williams: maybe when your spouse claims and look at, okay, well if we take Social Security at this age versus this age, how is it going to impact our plan? And then make the adjustment if there's no reform. So we just want to be able to look at every scenario and be able to give you peace of mind
- 11:26
- Elizabeth Williams: with the facts that we know today.
- 11:28
- Sarah Avila: Exactly. And you know, it's possible that we may have to change it up if we hear more from Congress about any legislation that's been passed for any reform on the Social Security system. But that's the nice thing about planning is that we can tweak things along the way, and that's why we do it consistently at least once a year to
- 11:48
- Sarah Avila: update clients' plans. Because if you don't, then they get too far off track and it's harder to get back on track. Right.
- 11:55
- Elizabeth Williams: So okay, so we encourage you to reach out to us with any questions. And again, if it's time to review your financial plan, we want to sit down, we want to go through whatever concerns that you have and really emphasize we are doing what we can to stay abreast of the information and
- 12:15
- Elizabeth Williams: incorporate that into our financial planning process.
- 12:18
- Sarah Avila: Exactly. Well that kind of wraps up what we had to talk about, just kind of hitting the big points. But I want to encourage any of our viewers to let us know if there are additional questions that they have about the Social Security Solvency or just any podcasts that they'd enjoy seeing in the future.
- 12:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 12:36
- Elizabeth Williams: please reach out. We look forward to hearing from you soon.
- 12:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Thank you for listening to this episode. If you like what you heard, please subscribe to our podcast and share our podcast with family and friends who are ready to start planning their retirement. Book your complimentary consultation now at VLP. VLPFA.com. And now for necessary disclosures. Securities offered through SoteraWell Services, LLC, Member, FINRA,
- 12:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): SIPC. Advisory services offered through Sotera Investment Advisors, LLC, a registered investment advisor. SATERA is under separate ownership from any other named entity. The views depicted in this material are for informational purposes only and are not necessarily those of SATARWALLE. Sotero Well Services LLC. They should not be considered specific advice or
- 13:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): recommendations for any individual. Neither Sotero Wealth Services LLC nor any of its representatives may give legal or tax advice. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. There is no assurance that any investment strategy will be successful. The views stated in this podcast are not necessarily the opinion of Sotero Wall Wealth Services LLC in the and
- 13:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): should not be construed directly or indirectly as an offer to buy or sell any securities mentioned. Due to the volatility within markets mentioned, opinions are subject to change without notice. Information is based on sources believed to be reliable. However, their accuracy or completeness cannot be guaranteed. Past performance does not guarantee future results. VLP Financial
- 13:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Advisors, 1751 seventeen fifty one Pinnacle Drive, Suite 425. four
- 14:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): two two two two two two two two two two
- 14:02
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): five McLean, Virginia two two one zero two seven zero three three five six four three six zero.