Craig Rosenthal on fiduciary duty, litigation threats, and AI benchmarking in healthcare
Summary
Craig Rosenthal, CEO of HealthPlanIQ, discusses the transition of fiduciary oversight from retirement plans to healthcare, citing regulatory shifts and litigation risks. He describes facing legal threats from healthcare vendors and highlights the lack of transparency in fully insured plans compared to self-funded ones. Rosenthal argues that AI-driven benchmarking tools are currently inadequate for self-funded employers due to data granularity issues, advocating instead for independent fee reasonableness assessments. The episode covers the complexities of healthcare contracts, the role of EMTALA in emergency care, and the potential for increased fiduciary liability for employers.
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 0:37
Sponsor Read and Introduction
Ray Cobra introduces the episode and acknowledges the sponsor, Benefixa Healthcare Consultants, which offers healthcare cost reduction and zero-dollar out-of-pocket plan design services. He welcomes guest Craig Rosenthal, CEO of HealthPlanIQ.
- 0:37 – 3:03
Craig Rosenthal's Career Origins and Entrepreneurial Spirit
Craig Rosenthal recounts starting his career in 1987 at Dreyfus, where he worked in the 401(k) business. He describes a formative moment at age 23 when he pushed back against a vice chairman's objection to his idea, realizing he needed to be an entrepreneur rather than a corporate employee.
- 3:03 – 11:42
Building a Product Line and Quitting Corporate Life
Rosenthal details building a $100 million revenue product line at a large public company around 1995. He quit immediately after receiving only a $10,000 bonus, citing misaligned compensation and a desire for autonomy, despite having one child and twins on the way with his first wife.
- 11:42 – 17:07
Independent Consulting and Co-founding Fiduciary Benchmarks
After quitting, Rosenthal ran a successful one-person consulting firm leveraging his reputation for integrity. In 2007-2008, he was recruited to co-found Fiduciary Benchmarks, the first independent benchmarking firm in the retirement plan space, after identifying a gap in how the product was marketed.
- 17:07 – 20:40
Regulation 408(b)(2) and the Evolution of Fiduciary Oversight
Rosenthal explains that Regulation 408(b)(2), drafted in 2008 and implemented in 2012, required service providers to disclose fees and services, driving the retirement plan fiduciary market. He notes that healthcare is now experiencing a similar shift driven by regulation, litigation, and consumerism.
- 20:40 – 25:50
Retirement Advisors Entering Healthcare and Fee Compression
Rosenthal states that 50% of HealthPlanIQ's revenue now comes from retirement advisors moving into healthcare, as they are already comfortable with fiduciary oversight. He argues that retirement fees have been compressed, potentially overcorrected, citing an advisor earning $80k-$100k for a 15,000-employee plan versus a healthcare broker earning ~$2M for a $300M spend.
- 25:50 – 35:19
Fee Structures and Fiduciary Pricing
Craig Rosenthal argues that retirement advisors should charge flat fees based on work hours and liability premiums rather than percentage-based compensation to avoid conflicts of interest. He notes that litigation risk increases with plan size, necessitating a liability premium component in pricing.
- 35:19 – 37:27
Market Saturation and the Pivot to Healthcare
Rosenthal states that Fiduciary Decisions has benchmarked 60% of 401(k) plans in the U.S., leaving little room for growth in retirement services. This market dominance prompted him to leave and enter the healthcare sector, which he views as having similar fiduciary needs but less maturity.
- 37:27 – 40:35
Hostile Industry Dynamics and Legal Threats
Rosenthal describes the healthcare industry as having 'institutionalized bad behavior' and compares it to 'The Sopranos.' He recounts receiving threats from industry players who promised to 'drain you of your funds' and make him 'cease to exist' through legal means if he challenged their practices.
- 40:35 – 48:42
Personal Healthcare Experiences and Provider Quality
Rosenthal shares a positive experience at a new Columbia/New York Presbyterian hospital, citing seamless digital scheduling, immediate test results, and direct doctor communication. He contrasts this with his previous insurer, Blue Cross Blue Shield, which denied his back surgery and demanded excessive physical therapy.
- 48:42 – 50:03
AI in Healthcare Contracts and Future Outlook
The speakers discuss the potential for AI to improve healthcare efficiency and contract analysis. Rosenthal notes that AI analysis of a bundled health plan contract revealed it lacked commitments, questioning if it was even a valid contract.
- 50:03 – 51:13
AI Analysis of Healthcare Contracts
Craig Rosenthal describes using AI to analyze a bundled health plan contract, which returned that it lacked commitments and might not even be a valid contract. This highlights the non-committal language common in healthcare vendor agreements compared to retirement plan contracts.
- 51:13 – 55:30
Legal Protection for ER Patients
Ray Cobra discusses Al Lewis, a Harvard-trained attorney, who provides free legal language to protect patients from surprise medical bills in ERs by leveraging the EMTALA law. He mentions a high-profile small claims case in Ohio involving this strategy.
- 55:30 – 1:43:26
Fiduciary Status and Data Access
Craig Rosenthal argues that any entity touching plan assets is a fiduciary and that employers have a right to data for fee reasonableness assessments. He predicts litigation will force vendors to provide this data, similar to retirement plan requirements.
Claims worth verifying
Fiduciary Decisions has benchmarked 60% of the 401(k) plans in the country.
Craig Rosenthal ·35:19
How to verify: Check Fiduciary Decisions' marketing materials, press releases, or company website for market share claims; cross-reference with industry reports on 401(k) plan administration. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Litigation in retirement has been on plans with a hundred million dollars or more in assets, with nothing meaningful underneath that.
Craig Rosenthal ·27:28
How to verify: Search PACER ( federal court records) or legal databases for ERISA litigation involving plan assets under $100 million to assess frequency and significance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Morningstar charges six basis points to be an investment fiduciary.
Ray Cobra ·29:04
How to verify: Review Morningstar's public fee schedules or fiduciary service agreements for investment advisory or fiduciary pricing. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The healthcare industry is a six trillion dollar industry.
Ray Cobra ·37:06
How to verify: Check U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) National Health Expenditure (NHE) data for total healthcare spending figures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Blue Cross Blue Shield demanded 30 physical therapy appointments before approving back surgery, then wanted more after the therapist said they weren't helping.
Craig Rosenthal ·46:13
How to verify: This is a personal anecdote; verification would require Rosenthal's medical records or insurance correspondence, which are private. However, general Blue Cross Blue Shield prior authorization policies for physical therapy can be reviewed via their public provider manuals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AI analysis of a bundled health plan contract revealed there were no commitments in it.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·49:56
How to verify: This is a specific anecdote about a proprietary analysis. Verification is difficult without the specific contract and AI tool output, but the claim highlights a potential flaw in contract drafting that could be tested by running similar contracts through AI legal review tools. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Steve Wiggins was the first CEO of United Healthcare in the Northeast.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·38:37
How to verify: Check Steve Wiggins' LinkedIn profile, UnitedHealth Group historical leadership records, or news archives for his tenure and title at UnitedHealthcare. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Fiduciary Decisions is market dominant and profitable.
Craig Rosenthal ·35:19
How to verify: As a private company, financials are not public. Verification would require access to their internal financial statements or third-party due diligence reports if available. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
HealthPlanIQ gives employers an independent fee reasonableness assessment of their network, TPA, PBM, stop loss carrier and broker.
Craig Rosenthal ·50:20
How to verify: Review the HealthPlanIQ website (healthplaniq.ai) for service descriptions and client case studies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Craig Rosenthal co-founded Fiduciary Decisions, which has benchmarked 60% of the 401(k) plans in the country.
Craig Rosenthal ·50:20
How to verify: Check Fiduciary Decisions' marketing materials or SEC filings if they are a registered investment adviser. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceCraig Rosenthal was handed a $10,000 bonus and quit on the spot after building a $100 million product line.
Craig Rosenthal ·50:20
How to verify: Verify through Craig Rosenthal's LinkedIn profile or public interviews discussing his departure from Fiduciary Decisions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Warren Buffett called medical costs the tapeworm of American economic competitiveness.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·50:49
How to verify: Search Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway shareholder letters or public speeches for this specific quote. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Al Lewis is a Harvard trained attorney and Jeopardy contestant.
Ray Cobra ·51:13
How to verify: Check Al Lewis's professional bio on Quisify's website or Jeopardy contestant archives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
EMTALA (Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act) protects patients from being personally responsible for costs over and above insurance in ERs.
Ray Cobra ·53:01
How to verify: Review the text of the EMTALA statute (42 U.S.C. § 1395dd) or CMS guidelines on emergency care obligations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A district court ruled that 'Locked In' was acting as a fiduciary when offering voluntary long-term disability benefits.
Ray Cobra ·1:03:42
How to verify: Search federal court dockets for cases involving 'Locked In' and fiduciary status regarding voluntary benefits. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Fully insured health plans are a 'black box' where fee reasonableness is hard to determine.
Craig Rosenthal ·57:23
How to verify: Review ERISA regulations and industry reports on the transparency differences between self-funded and fully insured plans. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
HealthPlanIQ charges $2 PEPM with a minimum of $3,000 and a maximum of $100,000.
Ray Cobra ·1:16:18
How to verify: Review HealthPlanIQ's pricing page at healthplaniq.ai or request a sample fee schedule from the company. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Fiduciary Decisions benchmarked 60% of the 401(k) plans in the country.
Craig Rosenthal ·1:18:17
How to verify: Check Fiduciary Decisions' marketing materials or company history on their website or SEC filings if publicly traded (likely private). For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThere are 75,000 self-funded plans in the country.
Ray Cobra ·1:22:55
How to verify: Verify against Department of Labor (DOL) or Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) data on self-funded health plans. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The ACA of 2021 required transparency obligations that remain unfulfilled six years later.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:23:46
How to verify: Review the text of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) provisions regarding transparency and compare with DOL enforcement actions or employer compliance reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Carriers threaten employers to switch providers if they submit data directives.
Craig Rosenthal ·1:27:16
How to verify: Review HealthPlanIQ's case studies or legal filings related to data directive responses from carriers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceMark Cuban endorses AI-based benchmarking tools that are useless for self-funded employers.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:35:57
How to verify: Check Mark Cuban's social media posts or endorsements on LinkedIn and compare with the capabilities of Form 5500 data for self-funded plans. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Amazon and Chase failed in their attempts to create their own healthcare alternatives.
Ray Cobra ·1:32:48
How to verify: Review news articles and company announcements regarding Amazon's Haven and Chase's healthcare initiatives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Attorneys are starting to go after big pharma and it is 'starting to bubble'.
Ray Cobra ·1:38:18
How to verify: Search legal news databases (e.g., LexisNexis, Westlaw) or court dockets for recent lawsuits or regulatory actions involving major pharmaceutical companies to identify emerging litigation trends. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the 'Locked In' district court ruling cited by Rosenthal regarding fiduciary status for voluntary benefits.
- Check OpenSecrets.org for campaign contributions from healthcare entities to politicians mentioned, such as Kamala Harris and Donald Trump.
- Review the specific terms of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) of 2021 regarding transparency obligations and gag clauses.
- Assess whether current AI benchmarking tools rely on Form 5500 data, which may lack granularity for self-funded plans.
- Investigate the 'selectivity bias' in incumbent broker RFPs by comparing their criteria against independent fiduciary standards.
- Look for recent litigation involving surprise medical bills and EMTALA enforcement to understand patient protection mechanisms.
- Compare fee structures of self-funded vs. fully insured plans to determine potential for negotiation and data access.
- Read HealthPlanIQ's fee reasonableness assessment framework to understand how they balance cost against quality and outcomes.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Ray Cobra: This episode of Broken Healthcare Podcast is brought to you by Benefixa Healthcare Consultants. Visit benefixa.com to learn what's possible. Reduce the cost of healthcare for your organization. Deliver better outcomes for your people. And yes, design health plans that give your people a path to zero-dollar out-of-pocket Out of pocket cost costs for healthcare. Visit benefixa.com today.
0:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Get ready to take control of your healthcare. Here's your host, Ray Cobra.
0:37Ray Cobra: And we're live, ladies and gentlemen. Welcome to Broken Healthcare. My name is Ray Cobra. I am your host, and I'm delighted to have with us in the studio today Mr. Craig Rosenthal with Health Plan IQ. Did I get all that right?
0:50Craig Rosenthal: You did right. Fantastic.
0:52Ray Cobra: Excellent. Excellent. Excellent. Well, hey, thanks for joining. Thanks for being here. And so uh sorry about the traffic, man. Craig doesn't live too far from you know studios in Queens, New York City, top of the food chain. Traffic can be a bitch at times, and you ran into a little bit of that today. You know,
1:10Craig Rosenthal: I'd hope to be here on time,
1:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
1:12Craig Rosenthal: I'm here
1:12Ray Cobra: and
1:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
1:13Craig Rosenthal: energized. So
1:15Ray Cobra: you were not very tardy and considering how bad traffic can be, you did just fine. So glad you got here in one piece. That's the main thing for sure. So we our I guess our paths crossed at uh a conference. Was it HCAA where we met or Health Rosetta?
1:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
1:34Ray Cobra: Rosetta Fest.
1:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yes.
1:36Ray Cobra: Right? Uh so health uh Health Rosetta is the organization as a broker advisor. In that role, we are Health Rosetta Advisors. And for those of you who don't know, Health Rosetta was founded by Dave Chase, who originally spun up the healthcare unit at Microsoft. Real smart guy, dedicated, passionate about healthcare and um, you know, just doing better, right? That's that's kind of the the general. premise. And Rosetta Fest was kind of spun off of that. I I'm not sure if the chicken or the egg came first, what the story was there, but it's turned into quite an event where healthcare providers, direct primary care physicians, uh providers on uh uh on the product and service side of the business, employers all get together, and we ran into one another. there. So uh we kind of hit it off. I I I thought you had an interesting um product and we're gonna we're gonna talk about health plan IQ.
2:36But before we get into all that stuff, uh I'd like to learn a little bit more about you, Mr. Rosenthal. So where did it all begin? Uh there's no soft couch here, but that's what I kinda wanna want you to kind of relax. Close your eyes. and and tell us a story.
2:52Craig Rosenthal: Okay. Um well I was born a small child. We'll start there. But let's let's fast forward because no one's interested in my childhood.
3:01Ray Cobra: Fast forward.
3:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Go
3:02Ray Cobra: ahead.
3:03Craig Rosenthal: So um I've essentially been working in and around retirement since 1987.
3:08Ray Cobra: Okay. Okay. The financial side of the business.
3:11Craig Rosenthal: The financial side. So started early on, um at at Dreyfus, which at the time was bigger than Fidelity, um, which is shocking because now Dreyfus is no longer in existence. And um built out their 401k business back in the day, you know, as a project manager. And that piqued my interest in the retirement business. And at the time, right, and we'll talk about this. The retirement business looked a little bit like healthcare does today. Right. In terms of the behaviors, the lack of transparency, the confusion about who was getting paid, what they were doing for what they were getting paid. But it wasn't really it was something that I was aware of, but not something I was involved with until two thousand eight. Um, I was running a consulting shop.
3:58Ray Cobra: That's an interesting year.
3:59Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. Yeah.
4:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
4:01Craig Rosenthal: There was
4:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): stuff
4:02Craig Rosenthal: going on. Not yeah. Not the best time to start a business.
4:05Ray Cobra: Yeah.
4:06Craig Rosenthal: But it um
4:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
4:07Craig Rosenthal: I had an independent consulting firm. It was just me. Um uh Craig Rosenthal independent consulting LLC.
4:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
4:15Craig Rosenthal: If you haven't heard of it before, it was it was huge. Um
4:20Ray Cobra: and I'm I'm I'm guessing you were securities licensed and all that stuff, or not so much.
4:24Craig Rosenthal: No, no. I mean, yes, I I had my sixty five, my sixty seven, but I never got my seven because I was never an advisor.
4:31Ray Cobra: I I see. Okay
4:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know,
4:32Craig Rosenthal: I I I interfaced with employers and employees.
4:38Ray Cobra: Yeah.
4:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
4:38Craig Rosenthal: not at an advice level.
4:40Ray Cobra: Okay.
4:40Craig Rosenthal: Right? That's not where I wanted to go. So
4:42Ray Cobra: w how did you interface? What were you doing?
4:44Craig Rosenthal: So I mean, the first job in my career, I literally was manning the eight 800 hundred number. Oh,
4:50Ray Cobra: that was
4:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
4:51Craig Rosenthal: very first job in my career.
4:52Ray Cobra: Okay.
4:52Craig Rosenthal: People calling to check in to make sure that their money market was safe. Got
4:56Ray Cobra: it.
4:56Craig Rosenthal: And I was like, your dollar from yesterday is your dollar today. And you
5:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): were like,
5:01Ray Cobra: hello, the connection is terrible. I'm sorry, you're gonna have to call back. Click.
5:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
5:06Craig Rosenthal: six months of doing that, and I went into my mo boss's job and I have an uh my boss's office, sorry, and said, You have two choices. Um, I can leave. or you can find a different job for me. And she's like, You seem talented and maybe interested. So we're going to put you in the management training program.
5:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
5:25Craig Rosenthal: I went into the management training program, and that honestly was one of the most interesting um times in my career because I found myself interfacing with the chairman, the CEO, the board of Drive. Dreyfus.
5:39Ray Cobra: Oh wow.
5:39Craig Rosenthal: Which at the time was the country's biggest mutual fund company.
5:42Ray Cobra: Sure.
5:43Craig Rosenthal: And so that was the beginning of my skill development, if you will.
5:47Ray Cobra: Yeah.
5:48Craig Rosenthal: And it also was when I realized I needed to be an entrepreneur. Because good ideas in big corporations don't always go where they're supposed to.
5:57Ray Cobra: Right. Right. They often don't go where they're supposed to. Yeah.
6:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
6:01Craig Rosenthal: and I remember I developed an idea. I was presenting it to the board. The vice chairman was pushing back on my idea.
6:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
6:11Craig Rosenthal: I was pushing back on him. And my boss was kicking me under the table, asking me to stop, basically. But I knew the discussion was worthwhile. And I knew that my point was right, even though I was talking to some. someone that was higher on the food chain than me.
6:29Ray Cobra: Yeah.
6:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
6:29Craig Rosenthal: I was like, one word, entrepreneur.
6:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
6:32Craig Rosenthal: is where I'm going. And I knew it at that time.
6:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): How
6:35Ray Cobra: young a man are you then?
6:38Craig Rosenthal: Eighty seven, twenty-three.
6:40Ray Cobra: Yeah.
6:40Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
6:41Ray Cobra: That's that's that's early to get that I I I don't want to say it's early to get that bug because I I I feel like I'm a lifelong entrepreneur. and naturally I worked for employers. But I was never I never felt fulfilled, never felt settled, and always had my my mind always goes. And I think you're born with that. I don't think I don't think everyone has that. So I and I think that started at a very early age. But to to put those pieces together and define yourself as an entrepreneur at twenty three, I think is is early, which I think is phenomenal.
7:22Craig Rosenthal: Well,
7:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
7:23Craig Rosenthal: w it was it was the formative moment, but what happened was there was a delay, right? And the delay was largely I'm a young man, I'm starting to like date seriously, I'm having a family, and I'm like, do I want to entrepreneur right now?
7:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,
7:40Craig Rosenthal: what I did is I kept on the path of corporate jobs, and I was working at another large public company, not Dreyfus anymore, a different company. And um, I build a product for them which turns into a hundred million dollar revenue line.
7:54Ray Cobra: Wow. And
7:54Craig Rosenthal: I'm saying to myself, this is gonna be my year, promotion, raise, bonus, year end comes
8:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and they
8:01Craig Rosenthal: cut me a check for. $10,000.
8:04Ray Cobra: Right.
8:04Craig Rosenthal: This was uh what would this have been around 1995-ish?
8:09Ray Cobra: Right.
8:09Craig Rosenthal: Um, ten thousand dollars, not bad.
8:12Ray Cobra: Yeah,
8:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
8:12Craig Rosenthal: as compensation for a hundred million dollar product line,
8:15Ray Cobra: right?
8:15Craig Rosenthal: Not bad. So again, I go to my boss and
8:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like,
8:18Craig Rosenthal: is this all that's in this for me? And he's like, Well, you know, you're on the right path. And I was like, Listen, this is a decision-making decision making point for both of us. So I find myself in the office. of the CEO.
8:28Ray Cobra: Mm-hmm.
8:28Craig Rosenthal: That because I
8:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
8:30Craig Rosenthal: did respect me. Right.
8:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They
8:31Craig Rosenthal: did build something good. So I'm in them with the CEO and I was like, listen, ten thousand dollars for a hundred million, it seems not aligned to me. And he said, Well, you know, we're a Midwestern company. We don't really believe in variable compensation. You're on a good career path. Eventually you'll get taken care of. I was like, I hate to tell you this right now in front of you, but I'm not here anymore. I'm leaving. And he's like,
8:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Are
8:55Craig Rosenthal: you sure? And I was like, if ten thousand dollars is your answer, I'm leaving. And that was the final nail in the corporate
9:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): problem.
9:03Ray Cobra: Wow.
9:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
9:04Craig Rosenthal: was it.
9:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
9:05Ray Cobra: that took some balls. Yeah. You're a young man at that point. You're right. You're a 100% hundred percent in the right, but I would I I have two observations there. One you know, I remember being 23, 25. You don't fucking think about this stuff. The average person doesn't walk around, I don't think, thinking analytically about their career and their trajectory, and doing the calculus, if you will, that you did back then. I commend you because that that's an early age to put all that together. It's one thing, I'm not saying that an average 23, 25-year-old in that environment wouldn't feel like they've they were done wrong. That's different, that's a different thing. I'm not talking about that. But I'm what I'm talking about is having the clarity to recognize. that, have a conversation with the CEO.
10:07Did you know that was going to be your move? Or was that like, did you go into that room saying,
10:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
10:14Ray Cobra: they don't give me this, I'm telling them I'm leaving, or was that an in-the-moment decision?
10:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
10:20Craig Rosenthal: Ray, we're both lifelong New Yorkers. Um my nickname growing up was The Hammer.
10:28Ray Cobra: Okay.
10:28Craig Rosenthal: And the reason all my friends called me The Hammer was because like I'd be walking along doing fine. And then there would just be this like swish that you know you get when the hammer comes and it hits the nail on the head and it goes in in one.
10:41Ray Cobra: Yeah.
10:41Craig Rosenthal: It that was that situation. Like it was the hammer coming out. It was like, no, I'm not doing this. You're never gonna going to take care of me, or you're not gonna going take to care of me. on my time frame.
10:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right. And
10:52Craig Rosenthal: am I ever going to be happy doing this? Because I don't like meetings. Right. I don't like forms.
10:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
10:57Ray Cobra: Yeah. You
10:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know?
10:58Ray Cobra: Yeah.
10:59Craig Rosenthal: And and so it I didn't have a plan. Yeah.
11:02Ray Cobra: Which
11:02Craig Rosenthal: was evident when I went home and told my wife I quit. Um
11:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you what?
11:07Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. We had um we had one child at the time and we had twins on the way,
11:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Wait,
11:12Ray Cobra: is this the same wife?
11:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Different wife.
11:15Craig Rosenthal: now.
11:15Ray Cobra: Okay, different
11:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): wife. Okay. This is my
11:17Craig Rosenthal: first wife, now ex-wife.
11:19Ray Cobra: We'll get to that story and the audience will understand why I clarified that question. But okay, that makes sense.
11:25Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
11:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
11:26Craig Rosenthal: we had one child, we had two more on the way.
11:28Ray Cobra: Wow.
11:29Craig Rosenthal: And I quit. And she's like, what are you gonna do now? And I was like, something on my own.
11:35Ray Cobra: Wow. Yeah.
11:37Craig Rosenthal: And that was the birth. of Craig Grosenthal, Independent Consulting LLC.
11:42Ray Cobra: Okay.
11:43Craig Rosenthal: And um,
11:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
11:45Craig Rosenthal: I was doing a lot of business and financial services. I was a one-person shop and I was killing it.
11:50Ray Cobra: Wow.
11:50Craig Rosenthal: Killing it.
11:51Ray Cobra: Okay.
11:51Craig Rosenthal: Like making more money than I even make today.
11:57Ray Cobra: Huh.
11:57Craig Rosenthal: Okay. And um
11:59Ray Cobra: how are you how are you acquiring clients? Because that's a challenge. for everyone. How do you you know, it's one thing to hang out a shingle and say, I'm going for it. It's a totally other thing to succeed. And and one of the har I mean, you know the statistics on on you know the numbers of how many businesses are formed and how many are still around the next year, let alone three years. Yeah. The odds are way against. And and I think one of the biggest problems is just getting people to to buy in, you know, wh why should they invest in you? Yeah.
12:34Craig Rosenthal: Who
12:35Ray Cobra: the hell are you?
12:36Craig Rosenthal: Um great question. Um so you know, before LinkedIn, if anyone could remember the time before LinkedIn, you still had a network. Yeah.
12:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
12:45Craig Rosenthal: It was just through phone calls and in in-person person meetings. It wasn't like liking pictures. Yeah.
12:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
12:50Craig Rosenthal: know And so my clients and my uh vendors at my prior jobs, my brand is credit, credibility, trust, integrity. That's my brand. Yeah. I may not do the right thing every time, but it won't be because I'm not trying or because I'm not honest. Right. And so those people all came and they were big brands. They were, you know, Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley. there's people like that.
13:16Ray Cobra: Wow.
13:16Craig Rosenthal: That were new they could put me on a project.
13:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
13:19Craig Rosenthal: would watch out for their best interest. I would charge them honestly. And so I was doing really well for a one-man shop.
13:27Ray Cobra: And what was your what was your IP, if you will? Like why you and why didn't they say, Oh, we could assign this to, you know, Jeff down the hall. He could do this for us.
13:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
13:39Craig Rosenthal: it's it's interesting how you never know where your life is gonna go, right? So um I went to college, sure.
13:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
13:47Ray Cobra: I
13:47Craig Rosenthal: also went to culinary school. Oh
13:49Ray Cobra: wow, because
13:49Craig Rosenthal: I thought I wanted to be a chef.
13:51Ray Cobra: Okay.
13:51Craig Rosenthal: Um, but it turns out that my superpower, if I have one, is building product. So when when when I was working at these public companies, I was building product. Right. And when I started my consulting business, they were like, this guy knows how to build product for advisors, because we've seen him do it.
14:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
14:11Ray Cobra: So
14:11Craig Rosenthal: they were like, come build product or come evaluate product or come help us improve product. And that's still what I'm doing today just for myself.
14:20Ray Cobra: Right.
14:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Huh.
14:21Ray Cobra: And I guess they recognize that. You know, they're there you developed a reputation as someone that was gonna do what he said he was going to do. And I guess that just, you know, that that blossomed.
14:35Craig Rosenthal: It it hasn't hurt me because there are a lot of people that don't do what
14:39Ray Cobra: they
14:39Craig Rosenthal: say they're gonna do. Right. Talk about an entire industry that probably operates
14:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that way.
14:44Craig Rosenthal: Um Um yeah. sorry, I'm not going there yet, but I will. Yeah,
14:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah.
14:48Craig Rosenthal: Um and and so you know, I've used that over and over again. Trust me, I'm gonna build a good product.
14:56Ray Cobra: Yeah. Excellent. Yeah. And and so you're you're talking mid nineties time frame?
15:04Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
15:04Ray Cobra: And how long do you continue doing that?
15:08Craig Rosenthal: Um, you know, all the way up until um
15:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): two
15:14Craig Rosenthal: thousand 2007, 2008, when a friend of mine called me and said, I just met these two guys. They have a really good idea.
15:23Ray Cobra: We're gonna short the housing market.
15:26Craig Rosenthal: Yes. Come on. No, it wasn't that.
15:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
15:30Craig Rosenthal: that would
15:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): have been
15:30Craig Rosenthal: fantastic.
15:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
15:32Craig Rosenthal: would have worked out better. No. Um my friend was uh uh president of a large financial services for firm. He called me, said, I met just met these two guys. They have a great idea, but they're
15:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
15:44Craig Rosenthal: way they're looking at bringing it to the market is not proper. And I told them they need to meet you. So I meet them, they did have a great idea.
15:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um, they
15:54Craig Rosenthal: were not approaching the market or the audience correctly. Directly. And so I said, I'm happy to consult for you guys. Thirty 30 days into the consulting business, they said. here's what we want you to do.
16:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
16:04Craig Rosenthal: want you to close down your consulting firm. We want you to come here. We're going to give you a slug of equity. You're going to become a co-founder of this business.
16:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
16:13Craig Rosenthal: I had to wind down my consulting firm. You can't really just turn the business off, but I wound it down because I thought the idea they had was needed.
16:22Ray Cobra: Okay. And
16:23Craig Rosenthal: I felt I could make it better.
16:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
16:25Craig Rosenthal: so that was for Fiduciary Benchmarks, which was the first independent benchmarking firm in the retirement plan space. And they they had the right idea. They just didn't package it properly to the right audience.
16:41Ray Cobra: And so for for the audience who may not be familiar, kind of frame the evolution of that. Because I I guess I guess this all started with ERISA, right? In 1974, ERISA was passed. And in, you know, part of ERISA was employers must act in a fiduciary capacity when it comes to health and welfare. Right. And and so
17:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
17:08Ray Cobra: 401k plans and the retirement plans were kind of the first. frontier, if you will, for this idea of
17:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): an
17:22Ray Cobra: employer's uh fiduciary responsibility. And you correct me if I'm wrong, because I was not in that space. But for many, many years, it was like the Wild West.
17:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Absolutely.
17:32Ray Cobra: No one was no one no one was acting in a fiduciary capacity. Right. Was there a moment where that you can identify where that changed year timeframe example?
17:43Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. So just a point of clarity also, part of that fiduciary responsibility is that you have to understand the reasonableness of your service providers, right? And that's what was the genesis of fiduciary benchmarks at the time was that specific fiduciary responsibility, determining the fee reasonableness of service providers. for retirement plans. So the moment that changed everything, so in um 2008, regulation 408B2 was drafted, right? And that's the regulation that requires service providers to issue a fee disclosure that states not only what they're being paid, right,
18:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
18:22Craig Rosenthal: what they're doing for it.
18:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
18:24Craig Rosenthal: the unfortunate part, as we all know, politics. sometimes gets in the way of a good idea.
18:29Ray Cobra: Uh-huh.
18:29Craig Rosenthal: So um 482 was drafted in 2008, but it wasn't implemented till 2012 because of presidential gyrations, administration changes. Um in 2012, when 482s became the standard, that's when fiduciary and retirement plans took off. Because you now knew what your advisor was getting paid, what they were doing for it. And it kind of was the disintermediation in the indirect compensation that was a problem in retirement as obviously a huge problem in healthcare.
19:03Ray Cobra: Sure.
19:04Craig Rosenthal: So it gave us all the impetus we needed to build the uh the reasonableness of retirement plan business. Because we now had 48 48B2 B2 as our sort of wind in our sales.
19:15Ray Cobra: Got it. Got it. So that was the moment.
19:17Craig Rosenthal: That was the moment.
19:19Ray Cobra: And I'm sure there were probably examples of companies that lawsuits were brought and you know, kind of the day of reckoning is here. That must have gotten the attention of the C-suite and CEOs. And, you know, hey, we we need to get our arms around this. And so if I'm if I'm correct. in saying that, then that's like the perfect storm for the services that you're offering.
19:43Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. Um, you know, there's this triumvirate of things that happen that drive businesses like fiduciary benchmarks, fiduciary decisions, which is what fiduciary benchmarks became. And even health plan IQ today, you're gonna have regulation because you you need the disclosure, the transparency, et cetera, to do. reasonableness. You're gonna have litigation, which changes industries. And then last but not least, and this is a much bigger driver in healthcare than retirement: consumerism. In retirement, the fees were not, they were hurting returns, but they weren't hurting people. Healthcare, you cannot have double-digit double digit increases. It's unsustainable. You can't. So regulation, litigation, consumerism, that's the perfect storm.
20:32Ray Cobra: Got it. And and so you you did that until when?
20:38Craig Rosenthal: I'm still doing that right now as I'm talking to you.
20:40Ray Cobra: You're still you're still in that business on the financial side of the house.
20:45Craig Rosenthal: I I'm a principal of the firm, can't really go anywhere, you know, gotta continue my dabbling. there. Right.
20:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean,
20:52Craig Rosenthal: obviously my role there is lessening. Yes. Cause I've raised money and built a business in the healthcare space. And my shareholders would like it if I paid attention.
21:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
21:01Craig Rosenthal: So um, so I do spend, you know, a portion of my time still in retirement helping that side. And I spend a portion of my time in healthcare. Now, here's the interesting thing.
21:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Two years
21:14Craig Rosenthal: ago. when I drafted the business plan for health plan IQ, I attributed zero, zero revenue to retirement plan advisors working in healthcare. I've now changed my estimate to 50% of my revenue being from retirement advisors coming over to healthcare.
21:34Ray Cobra: No kidding.
21:35Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
21:36Ray Cobra: Very interesting.
21:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What
21:38Ray Cobra: do you think? is behind that?
21:40Craig Rosenthal: Um, number one, they've been acting as fiduciaries for call it 15 years.
21:46Ray Cobra: Yeah.
21:47Craig Rosenthal: So they're incredibly comfortable acting as a fiduciary. So they don't even have to disintermediate the broker that's on the health plan today. They just can come in and say, hey, for a flat fee, I'll help you with the fiduciary oversight on both your plans.
22:02Ray Cobra: Both the retirement and the healthcare side.
22:05Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
22:05Ray Cobra: Huh.
22:06Craig Rosenthal: Because they've already got the skills. And honestly, based on what's going on in healthcare,
22:10Ray Cobra: yeah.
22:11Craig Rosenthal: I'm almost thinking an independent fiduciary oversight is better than having, say, the broker become a fiduciary.
22:18Ray Cobra: Yeah. Oh, what well, it I think we could definitely agree on it should never be the incumbent broker. Right. Ever.
22:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
22:26Ray Cobra: like asking the fox to guard the hen house. Yeah. Right. There's just no matter how much you love your broker, you definitely need to have a different set of eyes on your healthcare spend. Otherwise, you're just you're pissing in the wind. It's just it's not gonna work.
22:41Craig Rosenthal: And and
22:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Ray,
22:43Craig Rosenthal: I'll I'll give you a specific example, right? So retirement's been through the full fiduciary life cycle. right? Um, everybody's fees have been compressed to some extent.
22:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
22:57Craig Rosenthal: just to be clear, that's not all fiduciary.
22:59Ray Cobra: Yeah.
23:00Craig Rosenthal: Some of that is innovation, some of that is evolution. Yeah. Like retirement wasn't incredibly broken, right? It was an industry that had grown since 1974. nineteen seventy four, It wasn't as efficient as it could be. New ways of investing came. out, costs came down, but
23:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there
23:17Craig Rosenthal: was compression. You know, so
23:23Ray Cobra: well I remember looking back in the early 2000s at our IRA plans or our SEP IRA plans, and I think they were through Morningstar.
23:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think
23:37Ray Cobra: Morningstar Morningstore what were the funds, and it was through New York life.
23:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
23:42Ray Cobra: I I remember I didn't pay much attention to it, but I kept getting statements, and the statements were were like negative. And I was like, what the hell is going on? And finally I said, you know what? I'm gonna open a Charles Schwab account and I'm gonna manage this myself. And it was a complete night and day. experience. Like when I when I decided to take command of my own finances, the I mean the curve just did a 180. Yeah. It was insane. And it was a lot of it was just um mismanagement, uh compounding fees and stuff like that. And I'm sure you saw that all the time.
24:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
24:25Craig Rosenthal: mean, like I said. there were there were bad actors, but there was also just a an industry in need of a move, right? Of a change.
24:33Ray Cobra: Yeah.
24:33Craig Rosenthal: And, you know, here here's where we're at right now. After after that full evolution, fiduciary, everything. I'm not sure that the service providers in the retirement industry are being paid properly anymore. I think we may have overcorrected.
24:51Ray Cobra: Okay.
24:51Craig Rosenthal: Right. And and I'll give you the example, right? If you take um, let's say a 15,000 employee company, that advisor is probably getting paid $80
25:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
25:03Craig Rosenthal: $100,000 to oversee their retirement plan.
25:07Ray Cobra: Okay.
25:08Craig Rosenthal: If you know, extrapolate a 15,000 employee healthcare health care cost, What are you gonna guess that is?
25:16Ray Cobra: 15,000 employees?
25:18Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. Um
25:19Ray Cobra: 15,000. Yeah,
25:20Craig Rosenthal: 15,000.
25:21Ray Cobra: You're probably looking on the order of 300 million.
25:24Craig Rosenthal: Okay. 300 million. The broker is probably getting paid two million-ish, something,
25:31Ray Cobra: maybe. Yeah. I don't know.
25:33Craig Rosenthal: Guess. Yes.
25:33Ray Cobra: Yeah.
25:33Craig Rosenthal: So look at the difference between say that 80 eighty to 100,000 a hundred thousand and that two million.
25:38Ray Cobra: And
25:38Craig Rosenthal: and the retirement advisor, their work is documented and known.
25:43Ray Cobra: Right.
25:44Craig Rosenthal: The healthcare broker, their work may not be documented or known.
25:47Ray Cobra: Yeah.
25:48Craig Rosenthal: You know? And so,
25:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
25:51Craig Rosenthal: know, you have to be careful with this whole process that you don't overcorrect.
25:55Ray Cobra: Right.
25:56Craig Rosenthal: Because now, and this is part of the change in my thinking, part of the reason retirement advisors are really interested in how health is supplemental income.
26:05Ray Cobra: Sure.
26:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
26:06Craig Rosenthal: it's not wrong if they're doing work for it.
26:09Ray Cobra: Yeah.
26:09Craig Rosenthal: But they shouldn't have to.
26:12Ray Cobra: Yeah. I mean, uh I think it it requires a different skill set, but n certainly nothing that can't be learned. Uh, you know, a good friend of mine in the in the business said, you know, um, a trained monkey can be a broker. That might be overstating it a little bit. A little bit. Uh, but you know, the the reality is um how does it work typically in in retirement? I mean, you threw some numbers around and and what do you think it should be? Should it be a percentage of the the planned funds? Should it be uh directly correlated to you know the work? hours or an LOE? How how does it typically work?
26:54Craig Rosenthal: So I think there's a there's a bunch of factors, right? And unfortunately what's happened in retirement is the pond has not changed. So everyone's fishing in the same pond. Yeah. So part of what they're doing to determine their pricing is they're pricing the win business.
27:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
27:08Craig Rosenthal: And that drives prices down also. Yeah. Because they're all competing for the same plans. So I think the factors that get considered are the amount of work, right? I I think there's got to be a liability premium, right? Because all the litigation in retirement has been on plans with a hundred million dollars or more in assets. There's been nothing meaningful underneath that.
27:30Ray Cobra: Right.
27:30Craig Rosenthal: So
27:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
27:32Craig Rosenthal: would charge a liability premium. The
27:34Ray Cobra: bigger
27:34Craig Rosenthal: the plan, the more I got to charge because there's a chance I'm going to end up in court defending myself. And and and then, like you said, there's a um hourly p component.
27:43Ray Cobra: Yeah.
27:44Craig Rosenthal: We we developed something at
27:45Ray Cobra: can you buy an insurance policy for that, or is it just pure risk that you're taking on?
27:50Craig Rosenthal: Oh no, everybody has insurance, but that doesn't, you know, there's brand risk, there's
27:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no
27:55Ray Cobra: and all that stuff,
27:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right? Yeah, there's
27:57Craig Rosenthal: five there's fiduciary liability insurance, there's E and O insurance. Right.
28:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
28:01Craig Rosenthal: at the end of the day, it's not only about the money, there's brand risk.
28:04Ray Cobra: Yeah. You
28:04Craig Rosenthal: know, you get sued, it doesn't help you with your next sale.
28:08Ray Cobra: You
28:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think?
28:09Craig Rosenthal: I know.
28:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I know.
28:12Ray Cobra: Yeah.
28:13Craig Rosenthal: Um, so I you know, I think everyone should think carefully about how they price. And we develop something at fiduciary decisions that we call fee point. And what fee point does is everything has a cost or a price, right? You're a good broker, your hourly rate is $300. I'm making it up,
28:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right?
28:34Craig Rosenthal: So if you're gonna work 20 hours on a plan times $300, that's a component of your pricing. Yeah. Right. So um, likewise, um, Morningstar Hugh You referenced earlier, they charge to be a fiduciary on investments, as do other companies. like InvestNet, et cetera. So the the fee, the publicly available fee schedules are available for being an investment fiduciary. So if you were a retirement advisor acting as a um investment fiduciary,
29:04Ray Cobra: yeah,
29:05Craig Rosenthal: we could literally say, well, Morningstar charges six basis points to do that. You're not Morningstar, but you could certainly justify four basis points for doing that.
29:14Ray Cobra: You know.
29:15Craig Rosenthal: and this is the kind of mentality that sort of building blocks of pricing that helps a fiduciary defend themselves.
29:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But I
29:24Craig Rosenthal: do I do want to touch on one thing you said. I think
29:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
29:28Craig Rosenthal: you're gonna act as a fiduciary, you almost have to have a flat fee. It's very difficult. Your fat Fed your flat fee can be calculated. based on all these factors we
29:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just
29:40Craig Rosenthal: discussed. Right. But to have variable comp based on
29:44Ray Cobra: percentage of savings, that sort of thing. It's
29:47Craig Rosenthal: very hard to justify that as a fiduciary.
29:49Ray Cobra: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I don't I don't disagree with that. Yeah. I I think there is a balance.
29:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
29:57Ray Cobra: Uh because I I know plenty of advisors that
30:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
30:02Ray Cobra: that do charge
30:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
30:07Ray Cobra: bonus compensation if they hit certain levels. And I think there's something to be said for that. I think that CEOs like the idea of an advisor having skin in the game. And so if you can clearly kind of define, Fine, you know, this is our expectation, if we hit this threshold, we earn a bonus. If we get in between this range, we we deserve a higher bonus. And I I do think that there are business professionals and executives out there that like that because it it it's it's it's alignment. But I I also agree that um you can get a little ridiculous if you if you just leave that open-ended. I think there's gotta got to be a cap at some point where you say, ultimately, the work that we're doing, at least when it comes to healthcare, is about managing the plan dollars and helping you spend spend
31:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): plan
31:05Ray Cobra: dollars wisely. If all of that goes back in the pocket to a consultant, then it's not residing with the plan and it can't be distributed. amongst the plan members. And that kind of defeats the whole purpose.
31:19Craig Rosenthal: Right. And and you know, if you go back to the legal underpinnings, the legal underpinnings aren't lowest costs. The the
31:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know
31:27Craig Rosenthal: the the legal underpinnings are appropriate cost for the value you're receiving and the outcomes you're achieving, right? That's what you want to do. Yeah. So do you want a service provider that's incented to cut your costs endlessly because they're going to get paid a bonus?
31:42Ray Cobra: Right.
31:43Craig Rosenthal: Or do you want to make sure your employees are achieving their retirement outcomes, getting the healthcare goals they're, you know, supposed to have um or outcomes, I should say, as opposed to goals. Yeah. You know, that's really where you want to go. That's the intersection of cost and outcomes and value is sort of nirvana.
32:01Ray Cobra: Yeah. Yeah. And so getting back to your example in the finance world, in that fifteen thousand member organization, how big is the retirement pool?
32:12Craig Rosenthal: Um billions.
32:13Ray Cobra: Billions.
32:14Craig Rosenthal: Billions. I don't remember if it's three or five, but it's billions.
32:17Ray Cobra: Right.
32:17Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
32:18Ray Cobra: Right. And and so there's a there's a defined fee in that scenario. How does now put your put your CEO cap on? If you're sitting there and you take away what you obviously know about this this world, how do how would you evaluate a consultant coming to you saying, you know, what is the pitch to to the employer and how would you go about making that decision?
32:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
32:47Craig Rosenthal: you know, you know what's interesting? I think retirement has gotten sort of routine, right? So it's very difficult to differentiate yourself. It's very different to pitch cost savings. You there is some argument that you can produce better outcomes, maybe.
33:03Ray Cobra: Yeah.
33:04Craig Rosenthal: But like the whole cost side of it has been static. Right. Like you would have to make a serious argument to a CEO to go from 80,000 to 120,000 because they don't see the need. Yeah.
33:17Ray Cobra: The
33:18Craig Rosenthal: retirement plan is on cruise control.
33:19Ray Cobra: That's kind of what I'm getting at. How do you do the math?
33:23Craig Rosenthal: Um, I I think it's really challenging, honestly. And I think that that's what I don't like
33:28Ray Cobra: is
33:29Craig Rosenthal: the fact that the fees have become disconnected from what's important. Right. What's important is is that in this case, advisor,
33:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): get
33:38Craig Rosenthal: getting participants or employees to a better retirement outcome.
33:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
33:43Craig Rosenthal: that ultimately is all that's left.
33:44Ray Cobra: Right.
33:45Craig Rosenthal: And and and you know, there's some fertile territory. And I know, you know, this is more healthcare than retirement. There's some fertile territory. There's some new products that um, you know, whether it be like managed accounts or retirement income products that will help employees in their retirement years.
34:02Ray Cobra: Yeah.
34:03Craig Rosenthal: But other than that, this is why retirement advisors are starting to look at other things.
34:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
34:09Craig Rosenthal: ran into one of my retirement advisor friends and I asked him how his business was. And he's like, Oh, retirement's running itself. I'm doing high net worth now.
34:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
34:18Craig Rosenthal: I was like, why are you doing that? And he's like, Because when I meet somebody that has $50 fifty million, dollars,
34:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
34:24Craig Rosenthal: know, and I charge them a flat fee on that. that's more impactful to me than another retirement plan. And I think that's the same logic that's gonna drive them into health.
34:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
34:36Craig Rosenthal: that's why I'm changing my mentality about it.
34:39Ray Cobra: Got it. And so you identified I mean you're one of the you're one of the people, right? You're you're kind of living proof of someone that is making identified the need in healthcare. and not not necessarily made a transition, but saw an opportunity to uh have another revenue driver in your business in very much the same way that, you know, folks that are financial, you know, in in that fiduciary
35:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
35:06Ray Cobra: acting in that fiduciary financial capacity are now seeing the opportunity in healthcare.
35:11Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. I mean let's
35:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): W
35:12Ray Cobra: what was it? What what what what was it that brought what was the aha moment where you're like, oh shit.
35:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
35:19Craig Rosenthal: I'll I'll be honest with you. Um fiduciary decisions is market dominant. We've benchmarked sixty percent of the four one K plans in this country.
35:29Ray Cobra: Wow.
35:30Craig Rosenthal: There is not a lot of growth left in that.
35:32Ray Cobra: Yeah.
35:32Craig Rosenthal: Right? You know, we've got a handful of record keepers that we don't work with, we've got a handful of advisors we don't work with. Yeah. But
35:38Ray Cobra: we're
35:39Craig Rosenthal: market dominant. So I was like, where is the growth and excitement? Plus, keep in mind they've been doing it for 18 years. Right.
35:44Ray Cobra: If
35:45Craig Rosenthal: you're an entrepreneur, you don't do anything for 18 years.
35:47Ray Cobra: Like,
35:49Craig Rosenthal: you know, I I I guilty.
35:52Ray Cobra: Yeah. Yeah.
35:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. So
35:53Craig Rosenthal: so I I started talking to my partners about other avenues. And they were like, what do you think is interesting? I was like, healthcare is obvious.
36:02Ray Cobra: Yeah.
36:03Craig Rosenthal: There is an industry that needs fiduciary, that needs reasonableness, determination, that needs some method of improving itself. And um they were a little hesitant to do it because our brand was in retirement. We are profitable. We didn't, you know,
36:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
36:18Craig Rosenthal: didn't want to invest the profits in building a new business.
36:21Ray Cobra: Yeah.
36:22Craig Rosenthal: Um, they didn't feel we had the intellectual capital to do it because we didn't have any health air care healthcare expertise.
36:28Ray Cobra: Yeah.
36:28Craig Rosenthal: So we debated it for a couple of years. And then I said to them, guys, would you mind if I did it myself? And they're like, You're a co-inventor on the patent. Enjoy. Go do your own thing. You've helped, you know? And so I reached out to my network and I said, I need two things.
36:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
36:43Craig Rosenthal: need a subject matter matter expert in healthcare.
36:45Ray Cobra: Yep.
36:46Craig Rosenthal: And I need a sort of startup mentor. Right. Not because I don't know how to do a startup, but healthcare required a different level of startup.
36:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Huh.
36:57Craig Rosenthal: Right?
36:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
36:58Craig Rosenthal: Because you've got to prepare for a storm.
37:01Ray Cobra: Yeah.
37:02Craig Rosenthal: You've got to prepare for duration.
37:04Ray Cobra: A storm.
37:04Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
37:06Ray Cobra: So you're talking about a six trillion dollar industry with a lot of very powerful entities. that like things just the way they are.
37:17Craig Rosenthal: Yes.
37:18Ray Cobra: That's not a storm.
37:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
37:21Ray Cobra: that's utter world obliteration.
37:25Craig Rosenthal: So
37:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people
37:27Craig Rosenthal: ask me like how my transition is going into healthcare. Yeah. And I tell them, you know, it's fine. I feel like I stepped into an episode of The Sopranos. You know, it's it's it's instant institutionalized
37:41Ray Cobra: mafia.
37:42Craig Rosenthal: Um, I'm gonna try and say it a different way. It's
37:45Ray Cobra: we called we call the big three, you know, drug companies the cartel. Okay.
37:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So you
37:50Ray Cobra: might as well just
37:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
37:51Ray Cobra: know, just get it over with.
37:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
37:53Craig Rosenthal: right. But
37:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I I I just
37:55Craig Rosenthal: it's it's institutionalized bad behavior.
37:59Ray Cobra: Yes. Right.
37:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
38:00Ray Cobra: That's you cleaned it up quite a bit. I I
38:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I like
38:02Ray Cobra: the Sopranos, right? reference better. Yeah.
38:04Craig Rosenthal: I
38:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean
38:04Craig Rosenthal: I mean I I I've had people, you know, since we're gonna stick with the Sopranos analogy.
38:09Ray Cobra: Yeah, sure.
38:10Craig Rosenthal: Um, people in the in the industry have said they were gonna whack me. And not in a physical harm way, but they were like we will seek our we will sick our legal interns on you, drain you of your funds, and you will cease to exist.
38:23Ray Cobra: Right. You will submit.
38:24Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
38:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
38:25Ray Cobra: And
38:25Craig Rosenthal: I was like, Well, you can try that, but we're going to do that in a public arena if we're going to do that. So if you think I'm going to sit quietly and take it, you're wrong.
38:32Ray Cobra: Right.
38:33Craig Rosenthal: Like I'll be on podcasts, I'll I'll go everywhere.
38:35Ray Cobra: Yeah, yeah.
38:36Craig Rosenthal: You know.
38:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
38:37Ray Cobra: think that's what we need. You know, I had I had, I don't know if you're familiar with Steve Wiggins, but we had him on the podcast. He was a former CEO, I think the first CEO of United Healthcare in the Northeast. And he spun up a company called Ox Bridge. Mm-hmm. And they do direct contracting and stuff like that. And uh, you know, I I I I asked Steve, I said, you know, you're going up against this machine. And he was like, Bring it. He said, I know where all the bodies buried. And that's the attitude you have to take. You can't, you can't, you know, you can't give in to terrorists. That's not gonna going to get it done.
39:11Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. I mean,
39:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
39:13Craig Rosenthal: you'll notice, right? Um, we haven't talked about this yet, but the way we succeeded in retirement,
39:19Ray Cobra: yeah.
39:20Craig Rosenthal: Um, it's not
39:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
39:21Craig Rosenthal: you get viewed strictly as a commoditizer,
39:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): strictly
39:25Craig Rosenthal: as a cost entity,
39:26Ray Cobra: yeah,
39:27Craig Rosenthal: they're gonna crush you. Right? They're going to. Even even the do good retirement firms
39:33Ray Cobra: Yeah.
39:33Craig Rosenthal: wouldn't have done business with us if they thought we were just a commoditizer. So the important thing to say is to stick to that message of reasonableness because guess what? You know, per the story I was telling you earlier.
39:45Ray Cobra: I'm sorry, buy commoditizer, define that for me.
39:49Craig Rosenthal: So commoditizer is hi, I'm here to drop make sure your fees go down.
39:53Ray Cobra: Right.
39:53Craig Rosenthal: That's a commoditizer.
39:54Ray Cobra: Right.
39:55Craig Rosenthal: You have no value, you're no different than anyone else. Right. I'm here to cut your fees.
39:59Ray Cobra: Right.
39:59Craig Rosenthal: And as per the story I was telling you earlier this morning. that new hospital that I'm going to, I'm happy to pay extra money to go there. It is top of the line, patient focused, technology enabled. I feel comfortable.
40:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Tell
40:14Ray Cobra: us about that experience.
40:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,
40:18Craig Rosenthal: yeah. No, I'm I'm gonna violate my own HIPAA rights right
40:21Ray Cobra: now. So that's not violating.
40:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Come on, stop it. I'm
40:24Craig Rosenthal: kidding. It's
40:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): my data, I'll do it what with I.
40:27Craig Rosenthal: want.
40:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes.
40:27Craig Rosenthal: Which is what every employer in the country should
40:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): say.
40:30Ray Cobra: Yes. Go ahead.
40:31Craig Rosenthal: It's my date, I'll do with it what I want. Repeat after me.
40:34Ray Cobra: Thank you.
40:35Craig Rosenthal: Yes. Um, so I have a back injury. Um, I need surgery. I know it. Everyone knows it. My wife told me a new hospital opened in Westchester. I should check it out. It's Columbia, New York Presbyterian.
40:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
40:48Craig Rosenthal: went online, I reviewed the doctor's credentials. I booked an appointment online.
40:53Ray Cobra: Wow.
40:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
40:53Craig Rosenthal: didn't call anybody. I didn't do anything. I looked at their schedule. I said, that appointment works for me. I showed up. The hospital is new and clean. You
41:00Ray Cobra: did you get a Yelp review or Google or was it five stars?
41:06Craig Rosenthal: I'm going to build them a statue. I
41:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean,
41:08Craig Rosenthal: this is the way healthcare
41:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There
41:09Craig Rosenthal: should be. Um, you know, look, loop they emailed me a barcode. I walked into the hospital, I scanned my barcode, it told me where to go, what to do. I didn't wait more than five minutes for the doctor. The doctor prescribed uh a test, an MRI, and I'm like, um, okay, I'll call, I'll make an appointment. She's like, No, no, no, my my medical assistant will come in, tell you what it's gonna cost, and you'll write walk right down the hallway and get it done.
41:32Ray Cobra: Now is that That's because they're they're just that good or they don't have any clients?
41:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
41:37Craig Rosenthal: right now they don't have any clients. because it's a new hospital. Right. But as word gets out,
41:42Ray Cobra: yeah. I
41:42Craig Rosenthal: mean it's getting more difficult, honestly. In the few months I've been going there, people have started to hear, so they're starting the book up.
41:48Ray Cobra: Yeah.
41:49Craig Rosenthal: But
41:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no,
41:50Craig Rosenthal: they've just built for
41:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): today.
41:51Ray Cobra: And I'm kidding, but it's a very encouraging story, right? Because you have this house. I mean, you're in the New York City area, but you're not in Manhattan, yeah, which is where, you know, all the big giant institutions are. And so you you you had a wonderful experience.
42:06Craig Rosenthal: Well, get get this. It gets better. Yeah.
42:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
42:08Craig Rosenthal: I walk down there, I get my test, I drive home, call it 45 minutes. I get home, and there's a little there's a little notification on my phone saying, you know, the radiologist has reviewed the results. Here are the results. So the results were in the app. And then maybe an hour later, the doctor messaged me on my phone and said, I've reviewed. the results.
42:27Ray Cobra: Wow. That's phenomenal.
42:29Craig Rosenthal: I'm happy to pay a little bit extra for that.
42:32Ray Cobra: Yeah. Yeah.
42:33Craig Rosenthal: No extra facility, no extra time. Everybody's engaged. Phenomenal.
42:39Ray Cobra: And and you had this isn't your first appointment to get seen for this, or is it at this point?
42:45Craig Rosenthal: Um I've been seeing doctors for years.
42:47Ray Cobra: And and you've gotten a mixed bag of opinions. or have have they all said, hey, it's just a matter of time, sooner or rather than you know, sooner or later you're gonna have to address this? Has anyone said, you know, you're be because so the the kind of the the the famous quote about back surgeries are, you know, um what the hell is it? Um
43:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
43:16Ray Cobra: know what the most likely outcome of back surgery is, a second back surgery. Yeah. Right? Because it's one of those areas where it's it's just a little bit of a question mark. Yeah. I You know, I and and and I'm pontificating here, but
43:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
43:39Ray Cobra: don't think there are a lot of really great surgeons that do it supremely well. And so
43:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh I
43:48Ray Cobra: I just think you have to really be very careful about I would anyway. I would I would want you know, and it's it's funny because as a consultant in your business, what's the first question anybody asks? Do you have references? Yeah. We're going in for back surgery. I want to talk to some patients. Yeah.
44:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. Yeah.
44:07Ray Cobra: Right? I want I want to talk to patients two years out, three years out, five years out. We don't do that typically. Yeah. But I would, you know, because it's just like it's you have one back, you have one spine. So and and look, my my brother had back surgery. I started telling you, he's a
44:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): he's a
44:27Ray Cobra: career, you know, long drummer. If you listen to the Broken Healthcare podcast, that's Jimmy on drums in the intro. Um he's a kick ass drummer, and you know, he had years of you know sitting upright playing a kit. He had back surgery, and the surgeon said, like your back muscles to to get through to do what we had to do, we've never seen anything like that. And he was like, Yeah. well that's you know that's 50 years of playing the drums. Yeah. And um I told him, you know, I was like, be really careful, you know, make sure you thoroughly vet the surgeon. I looked at the surgeon, I was like, guy seems pretty good, um, you know, based on everything that I that I could find. And they ended up having to do a spinal fusion and he had some other stuff going on. And, you know, thankfully, he came through with flying colors and he had no choice. Like he was having trouble getting around, walking. It it made a huge improvement in his life. But it's one of those things where I'm like, just make sure. Make sure that you're at the point where there's no options. Your pain and in getting around is just your quality. of life is deteriorating, and and you know, just get some kind of affirmation that you're gonna get a good result. If you get
45:47like, oh, we'll see. That's like that's a big fat no.
45:51Craig Rosenthal: It's it's a coin toss.
45:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
45:53Craig Rosenthal: really is. And and I've heard that from everybody. And I think, you know, I mentioned mention this to you. Uh the last doctor I was seeing, you know, Harvard and Yale educated. So probably pretty capable. Yeah. He recommended surgery. Um, the insurance company, um, who I won't mention, Blue Cross Blue Shield, um, they said, no, we don't agree with surgery. Want you to do 30 physical therapy appointments before you attempt that.
46:18Ray Cobra: Right.
46:19Craig Rosenthal: And so then um
46:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
46:21Craig Rosenthal: do the 30 physical therapy appointments. Harvard Yale doctor goes back to Blue Cross Blue Shield, says no better results. Physical therapist says this is a waste of time. How about surgery now? And they're like, No, you know, he gets up to a hundred physical therapy appointments a year or whatever. He should keep going. The physical therapist said there's nothing I can do to help
46:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you. And
46:39Craig Rosenthal: they wanted to send me back there.
46:41Ray Cobra: That's insane.
46:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
46:44Ray Cobra: what did you do?
46:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
46:45Craig Rosenthal: left Harvard Yale doctor because he couldn't win the argument with the carrier to get the surgery.
46:51Ray Cobra: Okay. Now
46:51Craig Rosenthal: we've switched switched over to Columbia, New York Presbyterian, and you know, we're waiting to see where we go with surgery now.
46:58Ray Cobra: But it's a matter of the insurance carrier blessing the surgery. Otherwise, you'd be paying out of pocket. And I'm sure it's a quarter of a million dollar surgery. Easy, probably.
47:09Craig Rosenthal: It's yeah, it's definitely six figures. I don't know what it is. But listen, Ray, we all know, right? Healthcare makes no sense.
47:15Ray Cobra: My
47:16Craig Rosenthal: first wife diagnosed with cancer and they turned down her chemotherapy on the first pass. And we're like, how do you do that?
47:23Ray Cobra: Yeah. I
47:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean,
47:24Craig Rosenthal: we argued and we got her her treatment,
47:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
47:26Craig Rosenthal: like like that obviously is not someone that was paying attention to that decision. Cancer is not optional
47:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): treatment.
47:33Ray Cobra: No, not at all. Not at all. Uh n now there there are, you know, plenty of three. stories and and actually I think the I think the statistic is
47:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
47:45Ray Cobra: I I don't want to say it because I'm gonna get it wrong, but there's a there's a higher percentage than you would think of chemotherapy prescriptions that are inappropriate.
47:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
47:58Ray Cobra: In other words, they're prescribing the wrong drug for this particular type of cancer. Yes. Happens more often than not. Yeah. And it's just m mind numbing. Like, can't do your job. I'm a Jets fan. That's a Bill Belichick quote. But I love that quote. Do your fucking job. Yeah. Get it right. Yeah. Like you're playing with people's lives. Yeah. And so anyway, sorry to hear that about your your first wife. That's horrible, but you y ultimately they got it squared away.
48:24Craig Rosenthal: Yeah, it was all squared away and resolved, and it was probably like a glitch, but it's a terrible
48:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): glitch.
48:29Ray Cobra: And and that's infuriating. Yeah.
48:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And and
48:31Ray Cobra: you know, in the meantime, clock is ticking, this cancer is growing inside of your body, and you're you're you're on hold listening to elevator music.
48:38Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. And you and you know, not to like jump ahead into the future, but all of these mistakes.
48:43Ray Cobra: Yeah.
48:44Craig Rosenthal: Like, yes, AI is error prone right now, Yeah.
48:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
48:47Craig Rosenthal: it's incrementally getting better every day.
48:49Ray Cobra: Yeah.
48:50Craig Rosenthal: And front end a lot of this stuff with AI and let let it become more efficient. Yeah. Unless you have a reason not to.
48:57Ray Cobra: Yeah.
48:58Craig Rosenthal: Right?
48:58Ray Cobra: Yeah. No, I I think AI, I'm not a doomsday guy. I I don't think it's going to be the end of humanity. I think it's going to make things much, much better. At least I hope that's the outcome. I've heard both sides of the argument. Both sides of the argument are compelling. But the there the reality is I I think humanity prevails. Uh and and and I think this is we're living in very interesting times.
49:24Craig Rosenthal: I'm I'm a huge AI proponent. I see all positives. I I acknowledge, listen, is there potential for negative? For sure.
49:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like
49:31Craig Rosenthal: we already see it's trying to hack platforms without our permission.
49:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
49:35Craig Rosenthal: But that's okay. I will tell you, um, so when we built Health Plan IQ, we envisioned some utilization of AI in specific places. One of those was contract reading. And the very first set of contracts I ran through AI, the question was Are you sure this is a contract? It doesn't seem very committal.
49:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And I that's not a joke.
49:58Ray Cobra: There's no consideration. That's not
49:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a joke.
50:00Ray Cobra: Well,
50:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's
50:01Craig Rosenthal: not a joke.
50:02Ray Cobra: Really? That
50:03Craig Rosenthal: that was Gemini's opinion of a healthcare contract. It was like we don't really feel that this is a contract. There
50:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are no commitments in it. And and
50:09Craig Rosenthal: it's you know,
50:11Ray Cobra: was now was that a was that a TPA contract? Was it a a PBM contract?
50:16Craig Rosenthal: It was a bundled
50:18Ray Cobra: a bundled uh health plan. Yeah,
50:20Craig Rosenthal: bundled health plan.
50:21Ray Cobra: Okay.
50:21Craig Rosenthal: So, you know, everything was rolled into one.
50:24Ray Cobra: Yeah.
50:24Craig Rosenthal: And it you know, my problem coming from retirement.
50:28Ray Cobra: Yeah.
50:29Craig Rosenthal: Um, services are not might, may, will, can. They're I am providing this service.
50:34Ray Cobra: Right.
50:35Craig Rosenthal: These contracts are non committal.
50:37Ray Cobra: Yeah. Yeah.
50:38Craig Rosenthal: And I don't know how
50:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
50:41Craig Rosenthal: is going to be challenging, right? I have a lot of friends that are lawyers. But how does a lawyer write that contract and feel good about it?
50:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Warren
50:49Ray Cobra: Buffett called medical costs the tapeworm of American economic competitiveness. Now there's a man who knows his numbers. Find out what's eating your bottom line and what those dollars could be doing for your people.
51:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Let
51:01Ray Cobra: Benefixa sit on your side of the table. Better health care, better economics, better benefits. Visit Benefixa dot com today. Oh. Did a lawyer write that contract? That uh uh you would you would think so, uh, but you know, where did he get his law degree? I had I had Al Lewis on the show. He's a Harvard trained attorney.
51:23Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
51:24Ray Cobra: And, you know, he he's in a lawsuit. He's not in a lawsuit. He's helping a woman. So do you know Al at all? Al Al's Al Al's hilarious. Shout out to Al Lewis. So he runs a company called Quisify. Uh he was a a Jeopardy contestant who probably would be a grand champion if not competing against the greatest grand grand champions of all time. So and and and Hal, who taught economics at Harvard, lost Final Jeopardy because he couldn't do the math. Sorry, Al. True story.
52:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
52:03Ray Cobra: but Hal uh has something that he put out there, which is a a great public service. And it is a it's language that one would write into they would basically strike the language that a hospital gives you in the ER and write in the language that Hal provides. provides to protect the patient financially from being raked over the coals. And um
52:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we
52:37Ray Cobra: have a link out there in the show description if you want to check out Al's uh
52:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
52:41Ray Cobra: episode or you can go to quizify.com to download it. It's called Prevent Consent. And essentially, when you walk into the ER, you know, you may be bleeding out, you may have chest pain. Someone shoves a consent form in front of you. There are two uh two things that you know they're basically asking you for. One is the consent to treat you. You got to sign that one. The other is that you're personally responsible for anything that happens, you're personally responsible financially for anything that happens over and above insurance. You're not required to sign that because of a law called Mtala, emergency medical,
53:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
53:20Ray Cobra: emergency medical treatment and active labor law. And essentially Al's language can save people from, you know, financial hardship. Anyway, um there's a a claim that's brought and it's in small claims court and it's this has got to be the highest uh you know cost small claims, you know, proceeding ever. It's been litigated for literally months. I don't know what the outcome is, but Al talks about the the attorney who's the you know the plaintiff representing the hospital graduating from like the number 200th law school. He's like this guy. you know, he doesn't know whether to shit or wind his watch. And he he's basically making an argument. And the judge in the case is brilliant, by the way. You know, it's everything that you'd want in a judge. And you could you could actually watch the trial online. I think it's in the state of Ohio, but you can hear the judge asking thoughtful questions and the absurd answers. that are coming from the plaintiff's attorney. Al is not in the courtroom. It's just the uh it's just the patient.
54:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
54:34Ray Cobra: anyway, it's an interesting case. I don't know how we got there, but anyway.
54:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well um
54:39Ray Cobra: yeah, it's it's not always the uh it's not always the the the the
54:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
54:49Ray Cobra: Harvard surgeon, I think. that's going to you know get it right. And it some sometimes it like in in your case, hopefully, whoever it is that you're dealing with at New York Press is gonna get this thing approved.
55:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
55:07Craig Rosenthal: mean that's what we're hoping, right? But um healthcare's a mystery, right? We we don't know. You don't know, like you don't even know what until it happens.
55:16Ray Cobra: Yeah.
55:16Craig Rosenthal: Right. And you know, I don't I don't want to come off the contracts yet, right? Can we go back to the contracts?
55:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh, yeah, please.
55:22Craig Rosenthal: Because I I gotta tell you some stuff.
55:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
55:24Ray Cobra: think that I think that's where I yeah, I I got sidetracked there with the
55:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Al
55:27Ray Cobra: Lewis story. But the contracts.
55:29Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. So
55:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
55:31Craig Rosenthal: number of contracts that I've seen that say you cannot use your data for the purposes of conducting a pricing. assessment on your health plan
55:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
55:41Craig Rosenthal: concerning. Cause admittedly, the who's a fiduciary in healthcare land is foggy at best. Right? Not if you're holding people to the letter of the law, but just I'm saying nobody knows what their is role and responsibility is right now.
55:59Ray Cobra: Yeah.
55:59Craig Rosenthal: It's pretty clear to me, like if you're touching plan assets. you're a fiduciary.
56:04Ray Cobra: Yeah.
56:05Craig Rosenthal: Right. Um, oh, and by the way, let's come back and talk about lawyers for a second after this story.
56:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Because I've
56:10Craig Rosenthal: got some great lawyer stories. Um, so anybody that's touching plan assets is a fiduciary. That for me is a pretty clear line, right? So to tell someone that
56:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
56:23Craig Rosenthal: cannot use your data for the purposes of assessing fee reasonableness. when it's a hundred percent certainty that the employer is a fiduciary. If if no one else is, I'm shocked. But
56:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
56:34Craig Rosenthal: employer 100% is. Yeah. You can't deny them their data for the purposes of doing a fee reasonableness check. You cannot.
56:41Ray Cobra: Yeah.
56:41Craig Rosenthal: And that is gonna come that is going to be
56:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
56:45Craig Rosenthal: point of contention. Like
56:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
56:50Craig Rosenthal: lawyer that determines that all they're gonna do is sue large employers for the purposes of getting to the point in discovery where they can say, What do you do on your retirement plan? And they see this whole fiduciary process, and then so say, Show me the same stuff for the health plan,
57:07Ray Cobra: and
57:07Craig Rosenthal: they can't. Yeah, that's game over.
57:09Ray Cobra: Because
57:10Craig Rosenthal: you can do that to almost every large plan plant in the country right now. They're not doing the same things.
57:15Ray Cobra: And are you talking about a specific like uh self-funded arrangement or does this apply to fully insured plans as well?
57:23Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. We're we're completely focused on self-funded because fully insured is a black box that you're not going to be able to figure out.
57:30Ray Cobra: Right.
57:30Craig Rosenthal: And I and I think I don't agree with this, but the argument that you're buying an all all-you-can-eat, you can eat,
57:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
57:36Craig Rosenthal: know, healthcare solution,
57:37Ray Cobra: yeah, it's
57:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's
57:38Craig Rosenthal: gonna going make to make fee reasonableness arguments hard to do for a while. Eventually, believe me, their day is coming too. Yeah.
57:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
57:45Craig Rosenthal: right now, self-funded, at least we can get to the data fully insured you can't.
57:49Ray Cobra: So what what would you tell an employer that might be listening or or watching this?
57:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
57:55Ray Cobra: you know, what should they do to protect themselves?
57:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
57:59Craig Rosenthal: mean, you're probably in a better position to call out the number of employees. but let's say 200 employees and up.
58:05Ray Cobra: Yeah.
58:06Craig Rosenthal: You should probably be evaluating alternatives other than fully insured.
58:09Ray Cobra: Yeah.
58:10Craig Rosenthal: Right?
58:10Ray Cobra: Yeah.
58:11Craig Rosenthal: I mean, self funded, direct contracting, there are all these things out there that give you an opportunity at least to get better transparency.
58:19Ray Cobra: Yeah.
58:20Craig Rosenthal: And negotiate. Fully insured, there's no negotiation. It's just thank you, sir, sir. May I have another
58:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one?
58:25Ray Cobra: well you're prepaying for an unknown future risk. Yeah. Right. And so that's no way to buy anything. And so, regardless of the size of the group, I would tell any employer pay attention. You know, just pay attention. Don't, you know, don't leave this decision to the last three minutes of the year when your broker comes in and, you know, presents a spreadsheet with three bad you choices. know, one worse than the next. Plan a little bit of time, have a cup of coffee, take a look at, you know, where you are today, think about where you'd like to be tomorrow. And is your broker helping you get there? And if they're not, it it may be time for an independent review.
59:09Craig Rosenthal: And, you know, Ray, that's a really good point that ties back to something we were talking about earlier.
59:14Ray Cobra: Yeah.
59:14Craig Rosenthal: That that three option solution that you just talked about,
59:19Ray Cobra: you
59:19Craig Rosenthal: know, that's what we call in the retirement world. And I'm sure the healthcare terminology is the same. You know, that's an RFP. Yeah. Right. Well, if the person choosing the people that are included in the RFP
59:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): stands to gain
59:32Craig Rosenthal: from it,
59:33Ray Cobra: Yeah.
59:33Craig Rosenthal: that is selectivity bias.
59:35Ray Cobra: Yeah.
59:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
59:35Craig Rosenthal: you, as a fiduciary, should not be standing for that. No,
59:38Ray Cobra: that's gold. garbage. That's garbage. When when the incumbent broker lays out the criteria to participate in the request for proposal, we call that there's a Sicilian word. My dad, my my father-in-law is Sicilian. You know what the word is? Bullshit. That's bullshit. Come on, man. Like you you can't, it doesn't work that way. Yeah.
1:00:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:00:01Ray Cobra: think we've overcomplicated. things. I really do. You know, I I I know that there are, you know, huge firms out there, the McKinseys and the Millimans of the world, and you know, they have uh amazing staff and they produce beautiful reports. At the end of the day, it really is very simple. What has the trend been over the past five years? Have you had
1:00:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
1:00:27Ray Cobra: level trend? Have you had 3% increases, 8% increases, double-digit increases? That's been compounding. Where are you today?
1:00:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:00:37Ray Cobra: where would you like to be in five or 10 years? And if you keep doing the things that you've been doing for the past five years, do you think you'll get there? It's really not more complicated than that. And then what are my options? That's what we try to do. Yeah. It's it's basically let's cut out all of the bullshit and just do an honest, fair assessment of where we are in space. And it's not hard to do. You know, we have a wonderful uh Kaiser Family Foundation that gives us incredible data every year. And that's what we use as a benchmark. Where are you against the Kaiser Family Foundation? benchmark? Are you paying more? Are you paying less? What does your plan design look like? Could your people even afford it? Can they afford to get sick and go to the hospital? We know the answer to that. Most of them can't. So the reality is you we really need to dumb it down and we we need good leadership. Like you strike me as a bright leader. We need people in leadership roles
1:01:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
1:01:38Ray Cobra: get involved. and to say, we need to take a look at this because this is the number one expense that we have behind payroll. And it doesn't matter that we're, you know, a white-collar firm and we can afford it. The question is, how how many millions of dollars are we squandering that could be going to other initiatives to drive, you know, our initiatives forward, to make our company better, to provide, you know, more for our people.
1:02:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There
1:02:04Ray Cobra: aren't enough people doing that in this business. And I don't know what your experience has been so far, but in healthcare, it does kind of seem a little mafia-like when it comes to, you know, breaking that uh trusted broker advisor role. It's almost it it is a cemented relationship. I often you know, I've said on the on the show before, one of the hardest things that I've ever tried to do in sales is displace an incumbent broker. Very difficult. And we know statistically that a broker could be doing a poor job, meaning rates could be increasing every year. And on average, the broker tenure is six years. On average. That's crazy.
1:02:48Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
1:02:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:02:48Craig Rosenthal: mean, there's going to be some breakage coming, Ray. because for for a bunch of reasons, right?
1:02:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
1:02:53Craig Rosenthal: litig the pace of litigation is going to pick
1:02:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): up.
1:02:56Craig Rosenthal: Um, we've been living in an unsustainable, positive economic environment for a while now. When that turns and it's going to turn, not that I'm rooting for it, but it has to.
1:03:07Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:03:08Craig Rosenthal: Um, companies are going to be stretched. Yeah.
1:03:10Ray Cobra: And
1:03:11Craig Rosenthal: are they going to take another 15% healthcare increase when they're their sales are down, when they're laying off employees, when all these things are happening?
1:03:19Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:03:19Craig Rosenthal: All these things are going to get them to say, well, you know, Bob, my broker, has been a great guy for six years, but I I need to look for savings, and Bob's not delivering it.
1:03:28Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:03:29Craig Rosenthal: You know, and it's going to be challenging. I I agree with your say You're saying unseating an incumbent is hard.
1:03:35Ray Cobra: Very hard.
1:03:36Craig Rosenthal: But the the storm that is going to disrupt healthcare is clearly on the horizon. Yeah.
1:03:42Ray Cobra: I
1:03:42Craig Rosenthal: don't know if you saw it this morning, but um locked in, not the brokerage, just the employer.
1:03:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
1:03:50Craig Rosenthal: a district court said that their offer of voluntary benefits, I think it was a long-term disability policy to their employees, that they were acting as a fiduciary when they did that.
1:04:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): huh
1:04:01Craig Rosenthal: Because the way they pitched it. They said we pre-negotiated a discount for you it's part of our benefits package that is all fiduciary behavior locked in is an advisory firm
1:04:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how
1:04:12Craig Rosenthal: did they not realize that
1:04:13Ray Cobra: yeah
1:04:14Craig Rosenthal: so now they're gonna be on the hook for fixing this long-term liability lawsuit that is against them
1:04:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh.
1:04:21Craig Rosenthal: obviously it's early in the court case but that first finding is pretty interesting
1:04:25Ray Cobra: interesting no I did not know that.
1:04:28Craig Rosenthal: So can we talk about lawyers for a second?
1:04:30Ray Cobra: Yeah, yeah, let's go. Um I what's a good start? Uh
1:04:34Craig Rosenthal: well go ahead.
1:04:34Ray Cobra: Uh no, I I gave away the punchline. Two thousand lawyers what what's what do you call two thousand lawyers chained to the bottom of the ocean? A good start. But um bum. Go ahead. I'll
1:04:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): start by saying that the
1:04:49Craig Rosenthal: lawyer I have working for me now, I really like.
1:04:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay. Good. Now,
1:04:52Craig Rosenthal: why am I on my third lawyer is an interesting question.
1:04:55Ray Cobra: Okay, why are you on your third lawyer?
1:04:57Craig Rosenthal: Okay. So I am a two-year-old company and I'm on my third attorney.
1:05:00Ray Cobra: Okay.
1:05:01Craig Rosenthal: And here's here's what I think in though happened. Attorney number one,
1:05:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
1:05:06Craig Rosenthal: I'm gonna keep this really vague. Yeah.
1:05:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Because
1:05:08Craig Rosenthal: attorneys love Oh,
1:05:09Ray Cobra: yeah,
1:05:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they love
1:05:10Ray Cobra: litigation,
1:05:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): sure.
1:05:11Craig Rosenthal: Attorney number one, why did they not? do what they were supposed to do for my firm? Because now they're working for a company that might be a competitor of mine.
1:05:21Ray Cobra: Okay.
1:05:23Craig Rosenthal: They didn't call me.
1:05:24Ray Cobra: They didn't say that
1:05:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we have a conflict.
1:05:26Craig Rosenthal: They just stopped responding. They
1:05:28Ray Cobra: just stopped responding.
1:05:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:05:29Craig Rosenthal: then I saw a post saying, Hey, I'm now associated with a company that could be a competitor of yours.
1:05:35Ray Cobra: Oh, come on.
1:05:36Craig Rosenthal: True story.
1:05:37Ray Cobra: Yeah. I mean that's that's that's a clear conflict. Uh
1:05:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:05:40Ray Cobra: mean typically uh you know a reputable law firm will query you and if they have a client on the horizon or, you know, that that that if if they have a client that's doing something similar, they say we can't work with you.
1:05:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
1:05:55Ray Cobra: Right? That's a thing.
1:05:56Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. Well I went through that thing with them with law firm number two. Law firm number two
1:06:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): very
1:06:03Craig Rosenthal: reputable firm. Yeah. Um, went through their conflict committee, came back with, hey, listen, we represent a bunch of firms in the insurance industry. Right. But, you know, if and when we cross paths, you know, we'll have you sign a conflict statement, we'll have them sign a conflict statement. Take me on as a client, and then I start having discussions like this. Uh here's what I need.
1:06:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What
1:06:24Craig Rosenthal: do you need, Craig? I need a white paper that's that says if a TPA does these things, they are a de facto fiduciary. He's like, I can't really write that. I was like, why can't you write that? And he's like, Well, then, you know, there's nuances around being a de facto fiduciary. And I'm like, what would the nuances be around if you're handling plan assets, you're a fiduciary? Is there a nuance there I'm missing? Next thing I know, you know, hey, we've gotten really busy.
1:06:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:06:51Craig Rosenthal: don't feel I'm being difficult.
1:06:52Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:06:53Craig Rosenthal: I'm not a lawyer, but I know the difference between right and wrong.
1:06:56Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:06:56Craig Rosenthal: And to write a white paper that says if you do the following things, you're a fiduciary, any lawyer should be able to do that.
1:07:02Ray Cobra: How is a TPA managing plan assets though? If a T if a TPA, a third party administrator, essentially is um
1:07:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know
1:07:14Ray Cobra: taking money from the employer and paying vendors, where is their fiduciary responsibility?
1:07:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
1:07:22Craig Rosenthal: if they have any discretion,
1:07:24Ray Cobra: yeah,
1:07:24Craig Rosenthal: right? If
1:07:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
1:07:25Craig Rosenthal: have any discretion, they're a fiduciary.
1:07:27Ray Cobra: If they have discretion.
1:07:29Craig Rosenthal: Any discretion, right? Like if they're only writing a check when directed by the employer, maybe not.
1:07:35Ray Cobra: Right.
1:07:35Craig Rosenthal: Right? And it that's fine. But if they have discretion, or let's say they're doing um what we talked about earlier, savings recapture.
1:07:44Ray Cobra: Yeah. If
1:07:44Craig Rosenthal: they're doing that, that that's potential conflict of interest. It already puts them in a position. But these are things that can be clearly documented. That's the great thing about the law. It's open to interpretation.
1:07:57Ray Cobra: Right.
1:07:57Craig Rosenthal: But you can give straight guidance.
1:07:59Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:08:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. Right.
1:08:01Craig Rosenthal: And so it's
1:08:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
1:08:03Craig Rosenthal: very challenging.
1:08:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
1:08:04Ray Cobra: that is the beauty of AI because I I have um a client right now that we're doing work for and a contract came across from a new TPA. And, you know, we put it through AI and there were a couple of conflicts. Like just and not conflicts, but things that need to be specified. It was it was too open open-ended. ended.
1:08:25Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
1:08:26Ray Cobra: And so yeah, I mean, you read contracts, know what you're signing, because after the fact, it's too late, right? Like you can't you you can't rewrite a contract once it's signed. It's signed. You agreed to this.
1:08:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
1:08:42Ray Cobra: but I think AI is definitely it it's helped our organization immensely in that regard.
1:08:47Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. I mean I think AI is going to help and you know depending on the organization you can't fight it anyway.
1:08:53Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:08:53Craig Rosenthal: You know, like a small TPA, sure. Maybe you can fight with them. Sure.
1:08:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You're
1:08:58Craig Rosenthal: going to fight with United Healthcare.
1:08:59Ray Cobra: Yeah. It's going to be good luck with that.
1:09:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
1:09:01Ray Cobra: So
1:09:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
1:09:02Craig Rosenthal: I, you know, I think people have to make good decisions up front. I think they have to start evaluating.
1:09:07Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:09:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like
1:09:08Craig Rosenthal: we said earlier. So
1:09:09Ray Cobra: how'd you find your third attorney?
1:09:11Craig Rosenthal: So I went to the best place possible.
1:09:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I went
1:09:14Craig Rosenthal: to retirement.
1:09:15Ray Cobra: Okay.
1:09:16Craig Rosenthal: Because I he knows fiduciaries, he's not afraid of a fight.
1:09:19Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:09:19Craig Rosenthal: And doesn't have any insurance clients.
1:09:22Ray Cobra: Okay. There you go.
1:09:23Craig Rosenthal: So
1:09:24Ray Cobra: So it's working out okay. We're not gonna we're not going for number four.
1:09:28Craig Rosenthal: No.
1:09:29Ray Cobra: No. No,
1:09:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I got
1:09:30Craig Rosenthal: I gotta I got a business to run. By the way, I'm coming back. Um you are now going to put down your Kaiser Family Foundation. benchmarks and use healthplane IQ.
1:09:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I caught you there. I heard that. We're
1:09:44Craig Rosenthal: gonna fix that for you.
1:09:45Ray Cobra: All right. Well, we have a project that we're working on called Benefit Proof. I'd love to, you know, show you a little bit of that. Maybe there's a collaboration here in the future.
1:09:53Craig Rosenthal: Okay. This is a little awkward right now, but yeah, we're going for it. Let's
1:09:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do it.
1:09:57Ray Cobra: Yeah, Absolutely. So yeah, no, uh I I think the point is.
1:10:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
1:10:04Ray Cobra: can't manage what you can't measure.
1:10:05Craig Rosenthal: Right.
1:10:06Ray Cobra: And you know, to give an employer and an advisor tools where they can actually point to something and say, This is this is what we're aiming for, or this is possible. This is what the average is. Are we better than the average? or are we worse than the average? If we're worse than the average, why? Is there a reason why? You know, and some of the things that we take into account, you know, the Kaiser Family Foundation numbers are typically a blended number. Well, what if the employee population is all singles and there aren't families involved and there aren't spouses involved? Well, that skews the number. You have to take that into account. So,
1:10:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
1:10:54Ray Cobra: put the the average employer, and even I'm going to say the the the good advisor doesn't necessarily think about this stuff. They're they're focused on doing their job and moving on. And doing their job and moving on. And healthcare Care is not the primary job of any employer, right? Unless you you're a Warren Buffett fan, in which case he's he said, you know, GM is a healthcare company with an auto unit attached. Right. But there's a guy that understands the numbers backwards and forwards and is horrified when he sees a balance sheet and a PL and he's like, What the hell is going on here? Right. Why are we spending so much money on healthcare?
1:11:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
1:11:31Ray Cobra: that's what's going on. It's it's and and most people don't have
1:11:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
1:11:38Ray Cobra: first clue. about how to fix it.
1:11:41Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
1:11:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:11:42Ray Cobra: I think that's where health plan so tell me a little bit more about health plan IQ. What you you're you're focused on the self funded market,
1:11:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): two
1:11:51Ray Cobra: hundred employees and up, I I think is what I heard you say is kind of wh where it all starts.
1:11:56Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
1:11:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
1:11:57Ray Cobra: who who who's your client? The employer, the advisor, both anybody else?
1:12:03Craig Rosenthal: Um so
1:12:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when
1:12:06Craig Rosenthal: you're a fiduciary support mechanism, you you have to work for anyone that's trying to support the fiduciary.
1:12:13Ray Cobra: Yep.
1:12:14Craig Rosenthal: So
1:12:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): now
1:12:15Craig Rosenthal: the interesting part, and um
1:12:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
1:12:18Craig Rosenthal: just mentioned Warren Buffett. Warren Buffett's also the source of the 10,000 ten thousand hours to be an expert in something, right?
1:12:24Ray Cobra: Okay.
1:12:25Craig Rosenthal: I think he is.
1:12:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
1:12:26Craig Rosenthal: so eighteen years benchmarking retirement plans.
1:12:30Ray Cobra: I
1:12:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I never
1:12:31Craig Rosenthal: work less than twenty five hundred hours a year. So I'm forty thousand hours into benchmarking.
1:12:37Ray Cobra: Right.
1:12:37Craig Rosenthal: Right. So
1:12:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:12:38Craig Rosenthal: I know a little bit about it
1:12:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at this
1:12:40Craig Rosenthal: point.
1:12:41Ray Cobra: And and more than know a little bit about it, but you have a you have a demonstrated track record for success. Yes. And that's that's it's important to state that as well.
1:12:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
1:12:51Craig Rosenthal: Well especially in the age
1:12:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of AI. That's true. That's true. We've seen people, I know
1:12:59Craig Rosenthal: people like
1:12:59Ray Cobra: that.
1:13:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
1:13:00Craig Rosenthal: no, and then it and it's true because in the age of AI, um, doing a startup isn't as hard as it used to be. You can
1:13:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): build
1:13:07Craig Rosenthal: your own software, you don't even need a development team. Yeah. So I see all these sort of benchmarking firms popping up on LinkedIn
1:13:14Ray Cobra: that
1:13:14Craig Rosenthal: have been built. on AI, and they don't know the damage they're doing.
1:13:18Ray Cobra: Right.
1:13:19Craig Rosenthal: They have no idea.
1:13:20Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:13:20Craig Rosenthal: And what's interesting is for me, this is Groundhog Day.
1:13:23Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:13:24Craig Rosenthal: Because I had competitors in the retirement plan space that built half baked products also.
1:13:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
1:13:29Craig Rosenthal: And what did they end up doing?
1:13:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They
1:13:31Craig Rosenthal: ended up hurting the industry. They ended up getting people sued. They ended up basically going under.
1:13:36Ray Cobra: Right.
1:13:37Craig Rosenthal: And that these firms are doing the same thing. I could save them a lot of time.
1:13:40Ray Cobra: Yeah. I
1:13:41Craig Rosenthal: could just point out what they're doing wrong right now.
1:13:43Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:13:43Craig Rosenthal: Um, the problem is, and this kind of ties into something that you were just saying, and I'll I'll connect it to health plan IQ in a second. Um the skill level
1:13:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
1:13:54Craig Rosenthal: work on health plans, whether it be the broker or the employer, should be more CFO-like CFO like because it's much more. analytical than say what needs to occur on the retirement plan side, because it's so heavily money movement oriented. Right. And
1:14:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): part
1:14:13Craig Rosenthal: of the problem, part of the challenge in building a product is how do you build something that's simple enough for somebody like you said that's not full full-time time on healthcare to understand what they're looking at, but it's still got to be running. right.
1:14:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right?
1:14:28Craig Rosenthal: You can't wave simple and wrong is not acceptable. It's got to be simple and right.
1:14:34Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:14:35Craig Rosenthal: And so striking that balance is really hard. So who our end product is designed for the employer because at the end of the day, they're the fiduciary no matter what. Yeah.
1:14:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
1:14:46Craig Rosenthal: Because they have higher and fire on everybody else.
1:14:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
1:14:48Craig Rosenthal: regardless of who else is a fiduciary. it's designed for the employer. But who the purchaser is,
1:14:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): could
1:14:55Craig Rosenthal: be the TPA, could be the stop loss, could be the broker. We're agnostic.
1:15:00Ray Cobra: Okay.
1:15:01Craig Rosenthal: We're an independent third party that supports people wanting to make good decisions.
1:15:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
1:15:06Craig Rosenthal: what we are.
1:15:07Ray Cobra: How do you charge?
1:15:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
1:15:09Craig Rosenthal: it's interesting. So um I started out um
1:15:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): with
1:15:15Craig Rosenthal: my partners charging like a subscription fee. Because it's healthcare, you know, what's interesting in benchmarking, the best practices are if you're a large plan, you benchmark every year.
1:15:26Ray Cobra: If you're
1:15:26Craig Rosenthal: a medium-sized plan, you benchmark every other year. If you're a small plan, benchmark every three years. Because not there there aren't as many moving parts in retirement.
1:15:34Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:15:35Craig Rosenthal: Healthcare pricing changes every year, design changes every year. Everything changes every year.
1:15:40Ray Cobra: Every quarter, every month.
1:15:41Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
1:15:42Ray Cobra: So
1:15:43Craig Rosenthal: we were an annual subscription. We came up with flat fee pricing, you know, um ranging from 3,000 to 100,000 based on
1:15:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
1:15:52Craig Rosenthal: size of the planet.
1:15:53Ray Cobra: Size and scope.
1:15:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:15:54Craig Rosenthal: again, coming back to my idea of liability premium. Yeah. I'm more likely to be an expert witness on that $100 hundred million dollar spend than I am on the five $5 million dollar. spend.
1:16:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
1:16:03Craig Rosenthal: So that's why the range of pricing.
1:16:05Ray Cobra: Right.
1:16:05Craig Rosenthal: But then as we evolved into the industry, we found that nobody wanted to pay a flat fee. Everything is PEPM.
1:16:13Ray Cobra: So
1:16:13Craig Rosenthal: we translated the $3,000 to $100,000 into a P P E PM price.
1:16:18Ray Cobra: Okay.
1:16:18Craig Rosenthal: So it's $2 P E PM with a minimum of $3,000 three thousand and a max of $100,000. a hundred thousand.
1:16:23Ray Cobra: Okay. Got it.
1:16:25Craig Rosenthal: Relatively simple.
1:16:27Ray Cobra: Right. All right. That makes sense.
1:16:28Craig Rosenthal: And it's
1:16:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
1:16:29Craig Rosenthal: know, when I look at an advisor charging twenty five, forty dollars P E P M.
1:16:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. Two
1:16:36Craig Rosenthal: dollars is nothing.
1:16:37Ray Cobra: Yeah. Yeah.
1:16:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know?
1:16:38Ray Cobra: Yeah. And and what does an employer get for that two dollars? So
1:16:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
1:16:42Ray Cobra: are you delivering?
1:16:43Craig Rosenthal: So what I'm delivering is an annual fee reasonableness report that looks at the the big service providers, the network, the T TPA, the PBM, the stop loss, and the broker,
1:16:54Ray Cobra: and
1:16:54Craig Rosenthal: develop and delivers a fee reasonableness assessment for each one. What's a fee reasonableness assessment you ask? You want to ask?
1:17:02Ray Cobra: You just said it. Okay,
1:17:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so you don't have to say it again.
1:17:04Ray Cobra: So
1:17:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
1:17:05Craig Rosenthal: fee reasonableness assessment, think of it as almost a scale.
1:17:08Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:17:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): On
1:17:09Craig Rosenthal: the left hand side, you've got cost. On the right hand side, you've got quality, service, outcomes, and value.
1:17:15Ray Cobra: Okay.
1:17:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:17:16Craig Rosenthal: we measure those for each as best we can, right? Because man, the data in healthcare is insufficient.
1:17:23Ray Cobra: Yep.
1:17:23Craig Rosenthal: So one of my biggest challenges is waking up every day, knowing with absolute certainty that I know the right way to benchmark, and knowing with the same absolute certainty that the data doesn't exist in healthcare.
1:17:37Ray Cobra: So
1:17:37Craig Rosenthal: in a lot of cases, what I'm giving is frameworks for better decision making, because the data, frankly, doesn't exist.
1:17:44Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:17:45Craig Rosenthal: You know,
1:17:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:17:46Craig Rosenthal: come into healthcare and I'm like, so what's the definition of a good outcome in healthcare? And somebody's like, um, quality care at a reasonable cost. And I'm like, that's a mission statement. That's not a that's not an outcome. An outcome's a number.
1:17:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
1:17:59Ray Cobra: Do
1:18:00Craig Rosenthal: you guys have a number? There's no number.
1:18:01Ray Cobra: No.
1:18:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
1:18:02Craig Rosenthal: we've worked on some numbers. We've got some stuff where throwing out there as first passes. What I can tell you is in a much more defined and a much more reasonable industry, retirement,
1:18:16Ray Cobra: yep.
1:18:17Craig Rosenthal: We've had seven major report releases as a result of 140 plus prototypes, right? Over 18 years. Healthcare, I'm two years into this. This is version one, prototype one. And you know, what we need to happen is kind of what we were joking about before. Employers when employers own their data,
1:18:40Ray Cobra: right,
1:18:40Craig Rosenthal: and the data is a complete data set, not some of the subset of trash we see today,
1:18:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): then
1:18:47Craig Rosenthal: true benchmarking will be possible.
1:18:49Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:18:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
1:18:50Ray Cobra: And that's I think that's the key. It and again, just getting back to common sense, because I I believe I'm a I'm a huge fan of common sense. It rules the day, right? Employers, whether they are in a fully insured plan or a self-funded plan, deserve access to their data. Period. End of sentence. And they need to understand the math of healthcare. And it's very simple math. Take your spend, if you're a large employer, 100 plus, 85% of your spend is claims.
1:19:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
1:19:30Ray Cobra: you want to move the needle in healthcare, focus on claims. Yeah. If you give employees uh a healthcare ID card, that is one of the major carriers and they can access healthcare at will, you've essentially given them a credit card with no spending limit. That's no way to manage anything. And so you must focus and manage claims prospectively before the event happens whenever possible. Obviously, in an emergency situation. not much you could do about that. But it's really as simple as that. And then it's a matter of kind of getting to your point, taking a look at who you're working with today, and determining
1:20:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are
1:20:18Ray Cobra: we getting value here? Do we have control? Are they uh
1:20:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
1:20:25Ray Cobra: are are they impeding our progress or are they helping us get to where we want to go? It's common sense stuff. And uh the the other thing that I would mention is
1:20:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
1:20:36Ray Cobra: can't just build with a CFO in mind. You have to build with culture in mind, whether that's a CFO that is focused on not only the numbers, but also the impact, or where that's the head of people. saying we need to worry about recruiting and retention. Healthcare is a big part of the reason why people work for us today. We need to have a blend of those two things. And I'm very encouraged. I gotta tell you, Craig, I see, you know, very innovative uh products that are coming out on the market. Uh I think uh I I don't think I know the market is ripe for disruption.
1:21:18Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
1:21:19Ray Cobra: The pessimistic side of me always in the back of my mind references the six trillion dollar machine that likes things just the way they are. But getting back to your one of your initial points or comments, um, this is just unsustainable. Yeah. The the the the US economy and businesses, which represent more than half of health spend in the United States, 165 million Americans covered by private insurance through their employer, we can't sustain double digit increases compounded over time. It's just do the math. It's no way. So we're we're definitely at an inflection point. The first guy that I heard say that we're in a healthcare bubble, rest God rest the soul, was Marshall Allen.
1:22:09Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
1:22:09Ray Cobra: And he, you know, uh tragically died uh way too young. But he, you know, he's an investigative journalist, reporter who wanted wanted to make things right in healthcare. And when I heard him say that,
1:22:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
1:22:24Ray Cobra: next words out of my mouth were, he's right.
1:22:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
1:22:27Ray Cobra: Because never a truer statement has ever been said. So what's your what's your big, hairy, audacious goal with health plan IQ? Where do you see this thing going?
1:22:39Craig Rosenthal: So kind of tying into what you were just saying,
1:22:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah.
1:22:42Craig Rosenthal: I'm anticipating this is a big boat. It's gonna take a while to turn.
1:22:46Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:22:46Craig Rosenthal: Right. So there's only, I don't know, 70, 75. 75,000 self-funded plans in the country. So we're not talking about like yeah
1:22:55Ray Cobra: what
1:22:55Craig Rosenthal: I had in the retirement side, 800,000 plans.
1:22:58Ray Cobra: Right.
1:22:58Craig Rosenthal: We don't have that. So what I what I want to do, right? And I and I think this is important because um
1:23:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
1:23:05Craig Rosenthal: gonna I'm gonna um preach a little bit, but I think you'll be okay with this. Um it's all gonna come back to data.
1:23:13Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:23:13Craig Rosenthal: Right. And um
1:23:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
1:23:17Craig Rosenthal: is gonna be um it's gotta be a movement, right? It no one person is gonna get this done. It's gotta be a series, it's gotta be a group of people, like a large group of people.
1:23:27Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:23:28Craig Rosenthal: And and it can't just be complaining. It's gotta be working towards active Of solutions. And I'll like give you an example. If I told you that. the CAA of 2021 required you to do something and it's now 2027 and you haven't done it in the last six years,
1:23:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how
1:23:46Craig Rosenthal: motivated are you to do that?
1:23:47Ray Cobra: Not it's like walking across the street in the middle of the street in Manhattan. Everybody does it.
1:23:52Craig Rosenthal: I'm tired of I'm tired of seeing CAA twenty twenty one obligation post just stop.
1:23:58Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:23:59Craig Rosenthal: Like start doing something about it, and I'll give you a perfect example. Yeah.
1:24:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:24:03Craig Rosenthal: and by the way, um, I'm always careful with names just because you know I don't want to disparage someone.
1:24:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Blue
1:24:09Ray Cobra: Cross Blue Shield.
1:24:10Craig Rosenthal: Well, except except then
1:24:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): maybe. I said a couple of
1:24:14Ray Cobra: names.
1:24:14Craig Rosenthal: Um,
1:24:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
1:24:15Ray Cobra: we like the names. I'm not
1:24:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
1:24:17Ray Cobra: not telling you to name names now.
1:24:19Craig Rosenthal: But no, these are these are smaller companies that are more victims, I
1:24:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think,
1:24:23Craig Rosenthal: than than perpetrators.
1:24:25Ray Cobra: Yep.
1:24:25Craig Rosenthal: So I need data, right? Benchmarking is a data business.
1:24:31Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:24:31Craig Rosenthal: And and you got to have a foundation before you can even benchmark your first plan because I need a comparison group or a
1:24:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): peer group.
1:24:38Ray Cobra: Sure.
1:24:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
1:24:39Craig Rosenthal: I've signed all kinds of agreements to bring in all kinds of peer data. And each time I do that, I have this moment of regret, right? I'm not going to mention names. I'm just going to tell you. So first one. data was trash, just flat out unusable trash. I was like, what do you actually do with this? And how are you monetizing it?
1:24:58Ray Cobra: Right.
1:24:59Craig Rosenthal: Right. So forget that. Second one, um, they have hundreds of plans.
1:25:05Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:25:05Craig Rosenthal: I get the first file and it's a subset of that. And I'm like, why is it a subset? Well, this represents the plans we're allowed to share data.
1:25:13Ray Cobra: Oh, God.
1:25:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
1:25:17Craig Rosenthal: gag clause is supposedly not doable anymore. Sharing, you know, sharing
1:25:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): data
1:25:22Craig Rosenthal: should be allowed.
1:25:23Ray Cobra: Sure.
1:25:23Craig Rosenthal: I'm my best case scenario with any of the people I'm doing data with is I've been able to get like roughly 50% of what they have.
1:25:33Ray Cobra: That's so funny. That
1:25:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): means well, it's not.
1:25:35Craig Rosenthal: It's not
1:25:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): funny. No,
1:25:36Ray Cobra: it's funny. fun. It's funny because literally I'm working on a project uh and interacting with AI, and that was one of my comments to AI. I'm not optimistic that the majority of our prospective clients are going to have access to the data that we need. And you're just confirming that. It's it's e even though CA, you know, 2021 passed gag clauses, which means, you know, uh an insurance carrier, for example, can't write something into their contract that says that they can't share information, blah, blah, blah.
1:26:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
1:26:17Ray Cobra: all of that stuff, it's it's just like it's like a law with no teeth.
1:26:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:26:22Craig Rosenthal: mean, the good news is, right, last week we had uh the DOL Treasury and HSS all group together and start talking about enforcement. Like enforcement will rattle some cages, litigation will rattle some cages. The problem is, and I experienced this, and I'm gonna tell you about this. Some point I'll answer one of your questions directly. It may not be today, but at some point I'll do it.
1:26:43Ray Cobra: You're doing fine.
1:26:44Craig Rosenthal: Um, you know, the problem is
1:26:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
1:26:48Craig Rosenthal: I had it our attorney, the good one.
1:26:50Ray Cobra: yeah,
1:26:51Craig Rosenthal: drafted something called a data directive. It's basically a letter from the employer.
1:26:56Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:26:56Craig Rosenthal: Not a letter, a form that we've created with legal language in it that says, I am authorizing you to release all the data that Health Plan IQ needs to satisfy my responsibilities under ERISA and 48P2. 482.
1:27:10Ray Cobra: Okay.
1:27:11Craig Rosenthal: Submitted one of those, and the answer that the employer got. back was you can submit this form, but if you just tell us to go ahead with it, we're just going to recommend you go find another service provider.
1:27:23Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:27:24Craig Rosenthal: If that's the mentality out there, this is going to be challenging. Now, here's the good news. Because you asked probably two hours ago, where do I want to go with healthcare
1:27:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): IQ?
1:27:33Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:27:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:27:36Craig Rosenthal: don't need to make a lot of headway with healthcare. health plan IQ to make a lot of impact. As soon as people start seeing the reports on the street,
1:27:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
1:27:46Craig Rosenthal: becomes like I'll tell two friends and I'll tell two friends. It'll become viral on its own. So I just need the ability, which I have right now. Yep. For plans between 200 and 7500 employees, my doors are open right now.
1:28:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:28:01Craig Rosenthal: could benchmark you today.
1:28:02Ray Cobra: Yep.
1:28:03Craig Rosenthal: I have enough data. And as soon as those reports start trickling out and the service providers see them and they're like, oh, wait a minute. This is not only trying to help me explain my cost, but it's also explaining to my clients what I'm doing for it.
1:28:17Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:28:17Craig Rosenthal: For some people, that's gonna be okay.
1:28:20Ray Cobra: For
1:28:20Craig Rosenthal: others, clearly not, but
1:28:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
1:28:22Craig Rosenthal: some, it's gonna be okay. So my lofty goals,
1:28:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
1:28:25Craig Rosenthal: I can get to ten percent of the self-funded plans in the next three years, small 7500,
1:28:32Ray Cobra: yeah.
1:28:33Craig Rosenthal: I've done my job.
1:28:35Ray Cobra: Got it.
1:28:35Craig Rosenthal: Not not
1:28:36Ray Cobra: to
1:28:37Craig Rosenthal: the end, but I've done my job.
1:28:39Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:28:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh. I
1:28:42Ray Cobra: commend you. I mean, it's it it it it's a noble pursuit. You know, uh um
1:28:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
1:28:51Ray Cobra: if I'm gonna speak plainly and having my own podcast allows me to fucking speak plainly,
1:28:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh you
1:28:59Ray Cobra: know, I'm gonna indict our politicians on the healthcare issue. And and I don't think it's a left-right thing. It's on both sides of the aisle. And you're gonna you tune into the Broken Healthcare podcast, you're gonna going hear to me say this again and again and again because our politicians are in the pockets of the cartel and of the mafia that is healthcare. They're all on the take. Go to opensecrets.org, type in Kamala Harris, type in Donald Trump, and you'll see the millions of dollars that those campaigns have received from uh, you know, those those entities. everybody is on the take and they're selling the American people down the river. And until we have some type of a framework where we hold our Congress people, our senators, our people in power accountable. I think an example needs to be made of. The trouble is who you w what are you gonna you gonna clean shop? You can't do it. So it's a very difficult problem,
1:30:08but
1:30:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we
1:30:09Ray Cobra: need someone with the courage and the balls to draw a line in the sand and say, We're we're fixing this. Yeah. Like we're not tak we're not taking these contributions anymore. It's over. I don't know if there is an amnesty thing that needs to happen. but we need a major correction in healthcare. And it's, I'm sorry for, you know, for saying that, but it's truly the way that I feel. And I'll tell you another thing that's not very popular that I say. Courtside tickets to the Knicks, tickets to the masters, being flown in private jets. These are some of the perks. that these big brokerage houses and insurance carriers are lauding their clients with.
1:30:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do
1:30:57Ray Cobra: you think that factors into the decision that's being made? Oh, I fucking think it does. I do. Sorry, but it's just the truth. And so we as leaders need to stand up and say, enough. Like my organization. organization's people are not for sale. And I think fiduciary is a is a good step in that direction. But people need to start making decisions for the right reasons. And, you know, needless to say, we do analysis, and you know, these this is real money. If you have a company that's operating on a 20% margin or a 10% margin,
1:31:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
1:31:40Ray Cobra: you're showing them a five million dollar return, they have to generate 20, 30 million dollars in revenue to appreciate that bottom line EPITA.
1:31:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
1:31:49Ray Cobra: Like, is that not enough? You know, buy your own fucking master's tickets. Yeah. Like start paying attention to this shit and let's get the ship back under control. Let's upright the ship. Uh it's you know, I'm I'm passionate about this. I'm frustrated by it. And I I really I I don't think until we see some bold moves, we're we're gonna we're gonna see the changes that we'd like to see. It's just how I feel.
1:32:20Craig Rosenthal: You're not you're not wrong, Ray. Um, I mean, I got distracted for a second when you said courtside nick tickets because that excited me. but you're not wrong. Um you know,
1:32:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
1:32:30Craig Rosenthal: what's interesting is there are two examples of sort of the too big to fail that make me wonder about healthcare.
1:32:38Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:32:39Craig Rosenthal: Right. So too big to fail was the what was it, like Amazon and um Chase and you know the whole healthcare
1:32:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): thing they did.
1:32:48Ray Cobra: Yeah, yeah.
1:32:49Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. Um that obviously did. not work
1:32:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): out. And those guys clearly
1:32:52Craig Rosenthal: too big to fail.
1:32:53Ray Cobra: Right.
1:32:54Craig Rosenthal: But on the other hand,
1:32:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): look
1:32:56Craig Rosenthal: at what Mark Cuban's doing. Like he is doesn't care,
1:33:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): which
1:33:01Craig Rosenthal: is helpful. No one can stop him from what he wants to do.
1:33:04Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:33:05Craig Rosenthal: Um, posting his contracts online, saying whatever he wants to say, speaking everywhere.
1:33:10Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:33:11Craig Rosenthal: So maybe the pressure comes instead of I think the first example of too big to fail failed because they tried to um be healthcare.
1:33:23Ray Cobra: Like
1:33:23Craig Rosenthal: they were trying to create their own healthcare alternative.
1:33:26Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:33:27Craig Rosenthal: And I think that was probably too big to happen.
1:33:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
1:33:29Ray Cobra: they went into the teeth of the six trillion dollar machine. Yeah.
1:33:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:33:32Ray Cobra: they were like, oh, if you want to do that, then we're gonna we're gonna stop, you know,
1:33:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): being
1:33:38Ray Cobra: your client.
1:33:39Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
1:33:40Ray Cobra: And you know, see how that feels. And they were like, oh shit, what do you mean?
1:33:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
1:33:46Craig Rosenthal: maybe it's more of a death by a thousand cuts instead of that approach. Maybe we need more Mark Cubans who
1:33:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are
1:33:52Craig Rosenthal: big enough to like eat away at the PBMs and poke at the PBMs.
1:33:56Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:33:57Craig Rosenthal: Um and don't get me wrong, I'm sure that business is doing well, but at least their pricing is understandable.
1:34:03Ray Cobra: Well, he's in that business because he's a capitalist and and he sees an opportunity. Yeah. You know, and so I'm not saying what I I applaud what he's doing for sure. There are other entities that have been doing what he's doing for a long time now.
1:34:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
1:34:17Ray Cobra: And and we know who the good players are.
1:34:19Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
1:34:19Ray Cobra: So, you know, he's one of several, but he's also um he he he's he's got a he's got a pretty good platform. He's
1:34:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): got an amazing
1:34:29Craig Rosenthal: platform.
1:34:29Ray Cobra: He's very recognizable and you know he commands authority and and he's not going to be steamrolled. You know we need that. Absolutely. We we need as much attention on this problem as we could possibly get.
1:34:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:34:44Craig Rosenthal: mean I I have a circle of entrepreneurs in the healthcare space now that we all get together and talk. Yeah.
1:34:49Ray Cobra: And
1:34:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
1:34:49Craig Rosenthal: like listen your solution is brilliant. You're brilliant, but no one cares because you're a voice lost in a sea of voices.
1:34:56Ray Cobra: Right.
1:34:57Craig Rosenthal: Mark Cuban doesn't have that problem. No. So the and and you know what's interesting? And I don't know how I say this without offending Mark Cuban when I probably need him to
1:35:05Ray Cobra: Oh, he's he's got thick skin, don't worry.
1:35:07Craig Rosenthal: But but you know, I'm Well not even sure like when his social media and I'm sure he has a team. It's not him. Yeah. But his social media endorses.
1:35:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh you don't think
1:35:18Ray Cobra: he's on LinkedIn personally? No.
1:35:20Craig Rosenthal: Um not not at all hours like he is. Like I know, like because I see his workout videos, so I know he at least.
1:35:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm not Mark
1:35:27Ray Cobra: Cuban and I'm not on LinkedIn. I'm all I'm all over LinkedIn. But it's not me.
1:35:32Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. Um so but he endorses some things that are not good for healthcare.
1:35:39Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:35:40Craig Rosenthal: And I would love to tell him that.
1:35:43Ray Cobra: You
1:35:43Craig Rosenthal: know, because his endorsement raises boats, which frankly shouldn't be raised.
1:35:51Ray Cobra: Example.
1:35:52Craig Rosenthal: Like these 5500-based AI-based uh you know analytics and benchmarking Marking tools,
1:35:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they're
1:35:58Craig Rosenthal: a disaster for the industry, I'm telling you. There's nothing in the 5500 that you can do that's beneficial for an employer.
1:36:05Ray Cobra: There's nothing useful in a 5500.
1:36:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Not
1:36:07Ray Cobra: for a self-funded employer.
1:36:08Craig Rosenthal: Then why are there
1:36:10Ray Cobra: fully insured employer? Yes. You can you can glean some good insight. But
1:36:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
1:36:14Ray Cobra: a self-funded employee, there's nothing in a 5500 that's going to help
1:36:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me.
1:36:20Ray Cobra: I'll I'll I'll figure out who their broker is. Yeah. Okay. I don't I don't care who their broker is.
1:36:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There are half a
1:36:25Craig Rosenthal: dozen startups right now, all pumping stuff out. And and he likes their posts and he reshares their posts. And I'm like,
1:36:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what are you doing, dude?
1:36:33Ray Cobra: That's funny. Listen, he listen, he's brilliant, he's knowledgeable, his learning curve and and his ability to get acclimated and know what he knows in the space is commendable.
1:36:45Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
1:36:45Ray Cobra: But there's a lot uh there's a lot that he doesn't know. Yeah. A lot. With
1:36:49Craig Rosenthal: that said, I'd love to educate. him.
1:36:51Ray Cobra: Yeah. Yeah. Hey. You know. Listen, he's welcome to come on the show.
1:36:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um how
1:36:56Ray Cobra: do people find
1:36:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you? It's
1:36:58Craig Rosenthal: a great question. So we're uh online at www.healthplaniq.ai.
1:37:04Ray Cobra: Okay.
1:37:04Craig Rosenthal: We're online uh on LinkedIn at healthplan IQ.
1:37:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
1:37:09Craig Rosenthal: Craig at Healthplanik.ai. healthplaniq.ai.
1:37:11Ray Cobra: Okay.
1:37:12Craig Rosenthal: Not giving out my phone number, that's
1:37:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a little too personal. That's all right. That's okay.
1:37:15Craig Rosenthal: Craig at healthplanik.ai, hit me up.
1:37:18Ray Cobra: Okay.
1:37:18Craig Rosenthal: Um, you know, we're interested in working with anybody that either wants to improve plans, wants to forward the fiduciary message and mission.
1:37:29Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:37:29Craig Rosenthal: Cause honestly, if you think about everything we discussed today,
1:37:33Ray Cobra: yeah,
1:37:34Craig Rosenthal: the thing that is most likely to fix healthcare is fiduciary. Government's going to take a really long time. Litigation is going to take a really long time. Consumer consumerism is going to be a slow roll.
1:37:46Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:37:47Craig Rosenthal: But you start tagging people as fiduciaries.
1:37:50Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:37:50Craig Rosenthal: Literally tag
1:37:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): them.
1:37:52Craig Rosenthal: That will change.
1:37:54Ray Cobra: Yeah. I don't know that I agree with you a hundred percent because I think. it's gonna take an impetus to get them to care. It's kind of like the jaywalking analogy that we just shared. Yeah. Until until they really believe that their ass is at risk, where it's gonna be business as usual. But I I think I think we're gonna get there. I think that you know there are gonna be there have already been a few losses. lawsuits and I've had attorneys on that, you know, go after go after big pharma and they've said, you know, we're starting to it's starting to bubble.
1:38:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:38:37Ray Cobra: don't know what the what what that moment is going to be. But what I would say is even though fiduciary is your product, employers should get engaged regardlessly. regardless of the fact that they're fiduciaries. Should they do the right thing, that's a given. Of course they should. And they should understand what their responsibilities are. And I think that's where you come in.
1:39:03Craig Rosenthal: Yeah.
1:39:04Ray Cobra: Um, and safeguard their organizations and safeguard themselves. Because whether you know it or not, folks, if you are in the C-suite, C suite, if you are on a healthcare steering committee, you could be named personally. in a lawsuit that one of your employees brings because your pl their planned hours were not spent wisely.
1:39:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:39:25Ray Cobra: mean, that should get your attention.
1:39:27Craig Rosenthal: They're personally liable. And you know what we do in retirement, we remind employers that not only are they decision makers, but they're actually participants in the plan as well. So whatever they give to their employees, they're stuck with also.
1:39:39Ray Cobra: Right. Right. Yeah, a hundred percent. Yeah. No, it's there's no downside to being a better fiduciary. Yeah. If if there is such a thing. To to you know, doing your job as the employer, managing plan assets wisely. And I think health plan IQ, where where do you come in? You you are kind of stop one on their due diligence. Are are we are we meeting the standard, right? And and if they could check that box, then they know they're in a much better place.
1:40:14Craig Rosenthal: I mean, we'll see how things evolve, but in the like retirement side, if you had a benchmarking report, you could get a discount on your fiduciary liability insurance. You could, you know, we didn't talk about this, but frankly, if you're a large employer, you don't request a health plan IQ report. You have your attorney request it. It then becomes attorney client privileged. And then you decide when you get sued if you want to use it because it's attorney client privileged. Like these this is smart risk management that right now, and
1:40:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Ray,
1:40:50Craig Rosenthal: this is where. like there's a little bit of a rub, right? They're doing it on the retirement side. They're doing it. I can tell you right now, I'm looking you in the face. 60%
1:41:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
1:41:02Craig Rosenthal: the companies are doing it on the retirement side.
1:41:05Ray Cobra: What you just described, having their attorney
1:41:08Craig Rosenthal: benchmarking, just generally benchmarking.
1:41:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
1:41:10Craig Rosenthal: Yeah. The the attorney claim privilege thing is a lot smaller because it's really the biggest. companies that are really concerned. Yeah.
1:41:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know,
1:41:17Craig Rosenthal: 100 million and up.
1:41:18Ray Cobra: Sure.
1:41:18Craig Rosenthal: But
1:41:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
1:41:19Craig Rosenthal: they're doing it on the retirement side, and and this is part of, by the way, the the JP Morgan lawsuit.
1:41:25Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:41:25Craig Rosenthal: Like they they were like, you're JP Morgan. You're claiming you don't understand how to shop
1:41:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
1:41:29Ray Cobra: healthcare.
1:41:30Craig Rosenthal: So
1:41:31Ray Cobra: and you hold the conference every year, which is revered as one of the best. Yeah.
1:41:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like
1:41:35Craig Rosenthal: so,
1:41:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
1:41:37Craig Rosenthal: I said, I think if you're acting like a fiduciary on the retirement side,
1:41:41Ray Cobra: yeah,
1:41:41Craig Rosenthal: and you're spending 10X more on the health side, and you're not doing anything. There's no benchmarking going on.
1:41:50Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:41:51Craig Rosenthal: Are are people doing RFPs? Maybe. Are they looking at surveys? Maybe.
1:41:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
1:41:55Craig Rosenthal: But good luck.
1:41:56Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:41:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
1:41:57Craig Rosenthal: defending that.
1:41:58Ray Cobra: RFPs are only worth the paper they're written on, you know, and that's the other thing. It's because because there an RFP exists does not mean that you did dil due diligence. It doesn't. It's it's it's the minimum, if you ask me.
1:42:14Craig Rosenthal: That honestly was just in a lawsuit that happened on the retirement side the other day, uh Trader Joe's.
1:42:20Ray Cobra: Oh really?
1:42:21Craig Rosenthal: Um
1:42:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
1:42:22Craig Rosenthal: said, yeah, you did an RFP, but you didn't do anything with it. It
1:42:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): doesn't look like you
1:42:25Craig Rosenthal: negotiated, you didn't do anything.
1:42:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
1:42:27Craig Rosenthal: just you got the paper and you put it in a file.
1:42:29Ray Cobra: Right. You went through the motions. Great. Good job.
1:42:32Craig Rosenthal: So I think, you know,
1:42:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there
1:42:35Craig Rosenthal: are hints of enforcement coming.
1:42:36Ray Cobra: Yeah.
1:42:37Craig Rosenthal: There are definite signs of litigation coming. There there's regulation coming. Yeah.
1:42:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know,
1:42:42Craig Rosenthal: always in the works. People should just do what's right. And doing what's right means acting like a fiduciary.
1:42:47Ray Cobra: A hundred percent. I I think always always do what's right. Stay focused, keep your eye on the prize. This is a huge expense. Pay attention. Yeah. That's it. Pay attention. Pay attention, baby. All right, Craig. Uh it's been a pleasure having you. Healthplan IQ, folks. Until next time, love always. Take care.
1:43:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): All right. That's a wrap. Hit like, follow, and subscribe, and we'll catch you next
1:43:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time.