2Humans Podcast

Speakers argue UK wealth inequality stems from property speculation and privatization, advocating land value tax and nationalization.

33 min Listen to the original
UK EconomyWealth InequalityProperty MarketPublic PolicyGDPNationalizationLand Value Tax

Summary

Ross and Fit It discuss UK wealth inequality, describing a 'K-shaped' economy where the wealthy grow richer while the majority struggle. They attribute this to an over-reliance on property as an investment vehicle, which stifles productivity and labor mobility. Fit It critiques GDP as a well-being metric, citing Amartya Sen, while Ross highlights chronic underinvestment in infrastructure. The hosts debate policy solutions, with Fit It favoring a wealth tax and Ross advocating for a land value tax and nationalization of natural monopolies.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Ross identifies unaffordable property prices as the core structural problem, arguing property is used as an investment resource rather than for living or productivity.

    Ross · 5:38

  2. 2
    Britain has chronically failed to increase productivity. I think one of the reasons for that is, as I already mentioned, the concentration of wealth in housing assets rather than in investment in infrastructure and business.

    Ross · 12:07

Episode sections

  1. 0:06 – 3:38

    Introduction and Wealth Inequality Overview

    Ross and Fit It introduce the topic of UK wealth inequality, noting the recent change in Prime Minister and the shift in political direction. Fit It outlines a five-stage wealth pyramid, arguing that the bottom three tiers are getting poorer while the top two become significantly wealthier, leading to a 'K-shaped' economy where GDP growth masks widespread financial struggle for the majority.

  2. 3:38 – 10:17

    High Rents, Struggling Shops, and the Property Problem

    The speakers debate the decline of independent shops, with Ross attributing it to prohibitively high commercial rents and property prices rather than competition. He argues that the UK's over-reliance on property as an investment vehicle stifles productivity, hinders labor mobility, and makes housing unaffordable, creating a cycle of wage stagnation and high costs.

  3. 10:17 – 19:43

    GDP, Productivity, and Well-being Metrics

    Fit It critiques GDP per capita as a metric for well-being, citing Amartya Sen's view that the quality of life of the poorest defines a society's success. Ross adds that chronic underinvestment in infrastructure and the privatization of monopolies have led to low productivity and high costs for essentials like energy, further suppressing wages despite total GDP growth.

  4. 19:43 – 31:08

    Wealth Tax vs. Land Value Tax

    The hosts discuss policy solutions, with Fit It advocating for a wealth tax on assets like stocks to redistribute income and increase housing supply. Ross counters that a land value tax is more effective for productivity, as it discourages holding empty land, incentivizes development, and targets the root cause of high rents without the complexity of valuing diverse private assets.

  5. 31:08 – 32:07

    Policy proposals for housing and infrastructure

    Ross argues for reducing veto power over new construction and taxing land equally regardless of use to incentivize development. He suggests linking new developments to local infrastructure needs, potentially funded by wealth taxes or general economic growth.

  6. 32:07 – 32:40

    Nationalization of natural monopolies

    Ross advocates for nationalizing natural monopolies such as railways, energy, and water, arguing that privatization is nonsensical when consumers have no alternative providers.

  7. 32:40 – 33:16

    Conclusion and call to action

    Ross summarizes the discussion as a complex topic with many opinions and invites listeners to share their views on what is wrong with the British economy and state.

Claims worth verifying

Andy Burnham is going to be at the head of Labour.

Fit It ·0:21

How to verify: Check UK government appointment records or Labour Party announcements for November 2026/2026 regarding the Prime Minister and party leadership. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The UK has seen a big change in wealth inequality in the past six years since COVID.

Fit It ·0:21

How to verify: Consult ONS (Office for National Statistics) wealth data reports comparing pre-pandemic (2026-2026) and post-pandemic (2026-2026) periods. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The UK has one of the lowest income taxes in the whole of Europe.

Ross ·15:00

How to verify: Compare UK personal income tax rates and effective tax burdens against other EU/EEA nations using OECD Tax Database or Eurostat data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

HS2 has already cost a hundred billion pounds.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·22:08

How to verify: Check UK Department for Transport reports or National Audit Office (NAO) reviews on HS2 project costs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Andy Burnham capped bus fares to two pounds.

Fit It ·26:20

How to verify: Verify Greater Manchester Combined Authority (GMCA) transport policy announcements and fare structures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Andy Burnham removed VAT on energy bills.

Fit It ·26:20

How to verify: Check UK HMRC announcements or government budget statements regarding VAT rates on domestic energy. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Ross suggests decreasing people's power to veto new properties and increasing incentives to develop land by taxing it the same whether empty or not.

Ross ·31:08

How to verify: Check UK planning policy documents and land tax legislation (e.g., HMRC records on Stamp Duty or Council Tax bands) to see if such policy changes are proposed or enacted. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Ross proposes building local infrastructure (dentist offices, post offices) for new developments, potentially funded by a wealth tax.

Ross ·31:28

How to verify: Review UK government proposals for 'Section 106' agreements or Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) rates in local council planning portals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Ross states that changing economic cycles will inevitably cause some people to lose out and others to win.

Ross ·32:07

How to verify: This is a subjective economic assertion; verify by checking historical UK economic transition data (e.g., ONS data on job losses/gains during industrial shifts) for evidence of distributional impacts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Ross claims railways, energy, and water are natural monopolies that should be nationalized because people cannot choose alternatives.

Ross ·32:07

How to verify: Verify the current ownership structure of UK rail (Network Rail/TOCs), energy (National Grid, E.ON, British Gas, etc.), and water (Thames Water, etc.) via company investor relations pages or OFWAT/OFGEM regulatory reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Ross implies that nationalizing these sectors would fix issues in the country.

Ross ·32:27

How to verify: Compare performance metrics (service quality, investment levels) of UK nationalized sectors (e.g., National Health Service, Network Rail) against privatized counterparts or historical data using ONS and regulator reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify UK wealth distribution data via the Office for National Statistics (ONS) Wealth in the UK reports.
  • Check Amartya Sen's publications on well-being metrics and capability approach.
  • Review Kate Raworth's 'Donor Economics' for the 'Donut Economics' framework.
  • Analyze UK land value tax proposals from the Centre for Land Value Taxation.
  • Assess UK infrastructure productivity statistics from the Office for National Statistics.
  • Investigate UK privatization records in energy, water, and rail sectors via government reports.
  • Compare UK GDP per capita growth against median household income trends from ONS.
  • Research tax incentives for UK property investment via HMRC guidelines.
Full transcriptexpand

0:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey

0:06Ross: everybody, my name is Ross. And

0:08Fit It: I'm Fit It.

0:09Ross: And today we're two humans, two PhD students, talking about is Britain rich or poor, wealth inequality in the country, and trying to get to the heart of the problem of what is wrong and how we can fix it.

0:21Fit It: This is a timely topic because we changed the Prime Minister. And Andy Dy Burnham is gonna be at the head of Labour. labor. And as we have uh heard in the past six years since COVID, there has been a big change in wealth inequality in the UK. And we want to discuss what is the underlying trend here. And so Ross and I will be presenting our perspectives and what we think is the direction of the country at the current stage.

0:44Ross: There's been a lot of talking about this. As you say, probably because we're changing things up with the Prime Minister and he's got a a little bit of a different direction to go. down. I think the wind is actually starting to go in the right direction for what I think is wrong. And there's something that consistently comes up time and time again. But I think you wanted to start off with a an idea that you had. And I think if we start with that, then we can get into debating about it.

1:08Fit It: Yeah. Yeah, sounds good. Um one of the concepts that I think it's uh quite a hot topic on the podcast. is the way that I view wealth and income as a society. So I think that there is a pyramid that has five stages. At the bottom stage, the lowest, you get uh homeless and poor people. Then in the fourth level from the bottom, you get the middle class that lives paycheck to paycheck. So this is most people in the UK and Europe. Then we get to the upper middle class, these are people that can usually save some of their paycheck. and they have a good retirement plan. And then we move into the top two brackets that are significantly wealthy compared to the bottom three. That is usually millionaires, people that have a really successful career. Usually we're talking about athletes, artists, authors, somebody that has been able to leverage their knowledge or Your career in a different way. And then we have generational wealth, which is the highest, and these are people that have hundreds of millions. of pounds and perhaps even billions of pounds. And these are usually individuals that don't have to work and probably their families will never have to work for the future. And so the reason why we decided to do this podcast is that I think that the bottom three levels are getting significantly poorer compared to the top two. And so if you walk down the high streets in the UK, uh, we have lived in London, I've lived in Edinburgh, you've lived in

2:26Canada. Cambridge, you can see that there is a trend of luxury brands coming up. And the reason why I think that is, is that there is only a very small percentage of the population that can afford to spend money, and this is the super wealthy individuals. So what's happening is that you're not gonna see independent shops, but you're just gonna see products are relatively expensive, only few people can afford them. And these brands have understood that they need to tailor their products. product to the only audience that can afford to spend money. And I think that the problem here is that when we look at GDP in a country, we see that GDP is going up. The UK is making a lot of money. But then if you actually look at the average person, the people that are in the bottom three brackets, they can't save any money. We see that the food prices has gone up, utility bills have gone up. And so we get what many economists in uh the US have defined the K shaped economy. So half of the economy is going up and half of the economy is going down. And sometimes the average to a trend that seems positive. And so the government that is looking at GDP thinks that there is nothing wrong with the economy. But I think that this trend is getting worse. And so yeah, this is my main argument for today. And I don't know, Ross, what you think, but perhaps you can jump in here and let us know.

3:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

3:38Ross: if I try and pick out the main bits, you're saying that you you are saying that there's two economies going on in the UK, and there's people getting richer who can afford to buy nice stuff, and then there's people getting poorer who can't really afford to buy anything. I think even people who are on bad salaries and don't make up a lot of money will still splash out on nice stuff and get themselves in debt, and that's another problem. But this idea of the K K-shaped shaped economy and the lack of independence on the high street, I think there's actually why do so why are you saying that there's a lack of independence on the high street, right? Because I do actually see quite a lot of independent places in places like Cambridge. I guess the taste is more towards that in Cambridge, for example. And the quality is always a lot better. And it's probably more expensive. I think there's just a an element of natural competition in here somewhat. If you make a poor quality place, no matter who you are, if the business gets forced out by by chain brands, maybe there's an element of uh natural selection happening there, right? But if your business is highly successful and you find a good niche and you make quality produce or you make something great, then I think you still have an absolutely big chance of success. Except there's a big problem, which I think is really at the heart of all of this, and it's the cost of renting a shop. the actual building. And we've got a huge problem in this country that affects everything. It's the reason why we have bad productivity.

4:58It's the reason that we have a struggling high street. It's the reason that people's wages are not going up, which creates this cycle. Wages stay stagnant, prices keep going up. That makes it harder to make business. And the reason is property prices are out of control and that they've th they've become way, way, way too expensive. And it's become prohibitively expensive to buy a house and to rent a shop. There's many infinite other things that you could be doing with the property things, but that's the core of the reason. And uh the UK has got a really bad problem with this, I think. And in my view, it's not necessarily a one percent problem. The UK has its share of super rich people, I guess, but not actually as bad. as some other places like the US. I think the real problem with the UK for me is this unaffordable property. We use property as an investment resource rather than an actual productivity and living resource. So it creates several problems. It's very difficult to start a business that needs space and shop floors

5:58and such. It becomes very difficult for labor labour to be m moving around. It creates massive obstacles. Are you you already said it? Places like Cambridge and Oxford and London are so expensive to live in that a lot of people can't live there. Or it's very difficult to find a house or a flat in these places. So how do you expect people, Oh, I got a great new job in London, but I can't afford it to even live anywhere near the job. So

6:20Fit It: I agree with you with the most of the points. And I think that firstly, that's exactly the reason why we need independent shops. Because this is the only way that an average person has to build wealth and then be able to retire. In my opinion, being a millionaire is shouldn't be a rarity. When you look at the amount of assets that are in the country and the amount of GDP that we have in the country, we could have half the population being a millionaire instead of having few people being billionaires and and nobody else. It's just a way of how the wealth is distributed, in my opinion. And then recovery. regarding transport, I agree 100% with you that transport is one of the indication of how well the economy is doing because you need to be able to move qualified workforce from one place to the other so that you can create hubs in specific sectors across the country. And so we need all the pharmaceutical researchers to be in Cambridge and we need all the mechanical engineers to be in London and so on. The thing though that we need to be careful at

7:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is that

7:16Fit It: to see

7:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the problem with this

7:17Ross: is that

7:18Fit It: Yeah.

7:20Ross: Britain has had decades of under investment. I think it it became privatized after failures of the nationalised state in the seventies, and then heavy privatization in the eighties, and then a real suspicion of nationalised nationalized services and investment by the Tory government. was super low. Austerity meant that they weren't really putting money into anything. It's actually not at all the way people build wealth in this country, that they make a small business and succeed with it. How do most people try and build wealth? There is one dominant way. They buy a house. They buy a house and wait for it to appreciate five times by the time they retire. And then maybe they downsize and release some of the equity. And that is the core issue. I really do believe it. The idea that this if you were given five hundred thousand pounds, for example, how would you invest that money? Would you invest it in uh UK businesses? It's possible to do that through certain schemes. You could invest it in the stock market in the FTSE one hundred

8:20UK stocks if you want. That's not a bad idea, not that much growth recently, I guess, compared to American stocks, but whatever you could if you. wanted to prioritize British stocks. There's no incentivization, but you could. No, I I think the way that I would invest that 500,000 pounds is to buy a decent sized house somewhere or a flat or something near in an area I thought was gonna gentrify and then sell it in ten years, right?

8:44Fit It: That's

8:44Ross: what people do. And th they do it because it's the only way that it's the best asset. There's the financially in tax incentivized to do so. It appreciates well. Business seems risky.

8:54Fit It: I mean a house appreciates very slowly and it doesn't generate any income. But I can see the argument of being.

9:02Ross: Well, you could buy a house and then rent it out and then your asset pays for itself. And it appreciates. And people block a lot of the infrastructure project in this country because the value of people's homes has become their savings and their their retirement plan. And the government is terrified of doing anything that can reduce that. So affordability in this country really comes down to rental prices and if we're worried about everything else going up in price and the inflationary costs of everything. Brexit didn't help, but I think a lot of it comes down to underinvestment, using housing as an asset too much. It's not a hundred percent bad, but I think using leaning on it way too much. Privatization of monopolies in this country leads to out of control, profiteering on things that should be fairly priced. We have bad energy policies, which you know all about from your research, which means that energy is way overpriced. And when several things are overpriced, everything else comes up to meet it as well. And we've had wage stagnation because these things are all happening at the same time as GDP not growing, which is your central thing that you began with. So actually GDP is growing, but GDP per person is growing extremely slow, much way slower than GDP total.

10:17Fit It: Yeah. And I'm gonna add a couple of things to your list. I would first say pensions. There is the triple lock of pensions, which means that the pensions that we have guaranteed to people are too high. compared to how much people are paying in taxes because we don't have that many people working. Then education, financial education, it's one of the reasons why people, as you say, invest in houses or they don't save enough instead of investing in the stock market, for example. And then third, GDP per capita is not a reasonable metric to to quantify the well-being well being of the people in the in country. We should be looking at other things. Because in the end, the and this was uh Amarty Asend that said it, which uh was an economist and philosopher, very well known, and he talks about philosophic philosophical concepts such as the well being of society. And he was saying that the best metric of the well being of a society is uh the quality of life of the poorest people in the country. So of course we're gonna have the billionaires to see their investments go up twenty percent to

11:17thirty percent a year, and that drives the average GDP of the whole country up, even if everybody else is losing money. So we should be talking about the perhaps the rent per income, how much are people paying per rent as a percentage of their income?

11:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We should be

11:32Fit It: talking about their health. At what age they can retire, how much savings they have, we should be measuring something else.

11:38Ross: Yeah. I mean this growth economy that we've built means that it's really difficult to we've talked about this in a previous episode as well, where it's difficult to uh keep all the services like healthcare and retirement pensions and things going. You need growth all the time to fund that because you need to you need to borrow money and then expect to have more money later to pay off the debts that you've already used to to pay for stuff. Um

12:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so

12:07Ross: we rely on growing the economy by uh having more people, or we rely on growing the economy by increasing productivity. Britain has chronically failed to increase productivity. I think one of the reasons for that is, as I already mentioned, the concentration of wealth in housing assets rather than in investment in infrastructure and business. and things that would actually enable people to move around the country to do better work. Say I got a I live in the north and I could probably apply for that job down in London, but it costs double my rent. Why I haven't got enough savings to to even look for a flat and even if I did I'd be downgrading my quality of life massively. Why would I do

12:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that?

12:44Ross: You know, the these are some of the reasons why our productivity is down. It's not because British people are fundamentally unproductive people. it's because the economy is kind of gearing itself in this twisted way that makes it difficult. The things that would increase productivity are not being fed, they're not being grow, they're not being grown. We're growing a GDP, but we're not growing the actual fundamentals of what grows the economy. If we talk about like metrics, maybe what we should really be talking about is our are people able to live in a nice place? Are they able to feed themselves and have nice food? Are they able to go where they want to go? You know, GDP shouldn't really be everything. It should be are people having this a lifestyle that is nice, right?

13:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh

13:29Ross: if we want to reference a few people at this stage, uh one of the people I'm quoting right now is is a a guy that's been going doing the rounds on YouTube and TikTok lately, Henry Fudge. And he's got this idea of the rentier black hole. He's the guy who's talking a lot about the assets in the UK being sucked into a black hole.

13:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh

13:48Ross: there's a you know, there's several people that are similar stuff. Gary Stevenson did a lot of podcasting recently and he's got a book. And if we want to talk about GDP not being the actual a hundred percent definition of uh

14:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what

14:01Ross: makes a good a society to be in and a different type of economy that we could start thinking about. There was a book called Donut Economics by an author Kate Roworth and she wrote about instead of trying to constantly increase GDP, we should actually try and keep it in a defined set of limits, like not too much growth and not too much decrease, in a way that protects the environment, but also protects the economy and keeps it alive. and active but doesn't have this constant need for growth. Because actually ultimately we have this constant need for endless, endless growth. We're already seeing climate change and these issues with over consumption. Imagine another fifty years of constant high growth drive to to just grow all the time. It's just not sustainable on a planetary level. Yeah, the other problem with the UK has always been this classic thing people say in a country that's trying to be a tax environment like America, where people want low tax on their wages and things. We actually have one of the lowest income taxes in the whole of Europe. We also want a highly socialized safety net state system like the rest of Europe, with the NHS uh some benefits for people who are out of work or or the elderly, for example. And the two just don't square. Like you just can't have this system where you're trying to keep your taxes low and

15:20people lose their minds when taxes increase and still demand a fully funded healthcare system in the age of long lives and high populations of elderly and increasing costs of medicine and lower productivity of workforce. It's just not working. Maybe that's more of a reason why the problem feels so acute rather than the actual core of the issue. But it's a sort of organizational problem. So how would you sum up all the things we've said about the the problems with the UK and if any of them differ from mine? Yours is more about the sort of concept of this K economy, right? Like the rich are fine and the poor are actually somewhat unseen, unable to buy anything under the surface. And you think that's why the economy looks like it's growing but feels stagnant.

16:03Fit It: Yes, I have a dystopian view of what's happening. And I think that there is a risk that there's gonna be few people owning everything. A majority of the population that will leave paycheck to paycheck for the rest of their lives and will never retire. This is what I think will happen. And the reason is extremely simple. The reason is that when you get your paycheck, most of your expenses are already assigned to specific costs. You have your rent, you have your food, you have your utility bills, and that covers your whole paycheck, really. And so what happens is that what we're actually just doing is our employers is giving us money, and then we're gonna give it to these companies that provide these services for us. And these companies are owned by massive corporations that are linked to tier one and two, mostly tier one and two. individuals. And so these people are literally just getting paid our salary directly from our employer to them. That's what I think it's happening. The way to break the cycle is to redistribute wealth, because unfortunately, we also live in a society where if you look back in the 1960s, assets were extremely cheap. So a house would be four, five, six times at most your salary. And so what it meant is that. for people it made a lot more sense to have a job and have a good income rather than buying houses to rent them out to people because the rent was too low back

17:22then. But nowadays we live in a place where you can just charge so much for rent and

17:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

17:28Fit It: so there is an incentive for all these people who have money to just buy more assets because you can generate a lot more wealth by renting a house rather than finding a job or investing in technology. So if we tie back with some of the most known figures in our Gary's economics, it explains very well why it is important to tax wealth instead of taxing work. But I think that you summarized very well all the problems that we have with

17:52Ross: government. And If people's wages went up in the same way that prices go up, then uh happy days. We're not gonna have this problem. And I personally I don't think there's this need for this is maybe something you you think that everybody should be an entrepreneur, and I think it's a cool idea. But I

18:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think

18:17Ross: there's nothing wrong with having a good salary and you you do live as an employee, but if you're paid well and you can afford everything good in life and have a nice house, a nice family, retire and live well, there's nothing wrong with that at all. But to do that, we need to increase the productivity of the country because right now the wages are so stagnant that it can be an unlivable situation. And although I know we went back and forth what makes a luxury item at the beginning, the truth is that you're right. People struggle to buy the necessities at this point because of the w stagnant wages. How do we increase their productivity? To make something productive, you have to build manufacturing. capability and make stuff in the country. You have to create things, make software, build companies. It shouldn't be just funneling money into a basically static supply of housing that just essentially doesn't grow by barely anything. So you're basically just funneling more and more money into a static asset that barely grows. And that means that housing becomes unaffordable as just a basic place to live. And then we can't build any

19:17big infrastructure because it will affect people's housing price. And we can't do that because it's people's survival pot. If their housing price went down, they're screwed because that's their retirement plan. They don't have investments and they barely have a pension, but they've got a house. Uh you can't make a high street independent coffee brand because it costs you a million quid to rent the shop shopfront front on a Cambridge High Street. That's why there's no productivity in this country. It's too expensive with the housing. So but there's a way to fix it. It's the classic idea of the land value tax, right? I love this concept. I think it's good. So you you tax people based on the value of the land that they own, not the assets that they have, or even the wealth that they have. Because wealth tax is incredibly difficult to quantify because people's wealth is usually locked up in stock. ownership or company ownership that you can't touch, and some of it's in cars or paintings or stuff inside their private housing that you can't get into easily, and it's just really difficult to quantify their wealth, right? Someone can be a

20:17billionaire or a trillionaire these days on paper, but actually if you try to tried spin that down and tax it in a way that didn't force them to sell stock, which is debatably a good or a bad thing, but let's go with the assumption that you shouldn't really force people to sell their property to pay their tax and stock cancels the property. It's difficult to tax wealth, right?

20:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's easy to

20:37Ross: tax.

20:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I don't think

20:37Fit It: I don't think that's true. Because companies do their quarterly reports every three months. We know exactly what the earnings of the companies are, we know exactly what the value of the stock market is. Governments should just say you pay your you know, your wealth tax either once a year or either once every quarter based on the value of the stock at this time of day on the last day of the quarter, and that's it. It's not that hard because there is plenty of apps that track your stocks and the value of properties and everything. I get it that there's some properties that So one year they're worth half a million pounds and the next year worth two million pounds that can happen. But in that case you just do some sort of estimation. And if you are in the position where you have a hundred million pounds and the government is taxing you, if you pay half a million pounds in taxes more, it shouldn't be a problem really. And if you did, then HMRC could give you a tax refund or anything like that. I'm sure that this could be easily done.

21:33Ross: The 1% richest in this country, let's say we generate 50 billion pounds extra tax revenue. Let's let's work with that, okay? If they make a successful business, we're gonna tax the hell out of you and and take tons of it away from you. That fair or otherwise, it probably wouldn't be good for the productivity problem, right? And an extra thirty 30 billion quid in the British economy. probably, frankly, isn't gonna go that far to solve a lot of the issues that we

22:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): had.

22:08Ross: When you think about how HS two has already cost a hundred billion pounds. An extra thirty billion a year, yeah, it's quite a lot of money, but it's not really gonna solve any of the fundamental issues. Like how is that gonna solve the productivity issue? How is that gonna solve people's rental crisis? How is that gonna make people's wages go up? How is that gonna make uh everything fall into place? A bit of extra money in the government's pocket is nice. And I guess they could cut some other taxes, but apart from that, how do you see it working? I don't really see how that works.

22:36Fit It: If let's say you had 30 billion pounds of taxes, the ultra wealthy would be the ultra wealthy would be selling something. So they would either be selling property, they would be selling land or they would will be selling something. And so this would already decrease the property values across the whole market because there would be a a a flood of supply coming in, making it available. And now you cannot sell it back to another ultra wealthy individual because he also has to pay taxes at the same time. And so all of a sudden you have a lot of people from those bottom tiers that can now jump into the the property market.

23:13Ross: I think the wealth tax could work. to a degree for that reason, but it doesn't fundamentally incentivize decreasing rent, I think, and making people's lives more affordable. You can buy a house and get yourself on that housing ladder, and yeah, maybe it will help to stem the ridiculous rise in prices that happens when it's all owned by a few housing conglomerates that basically own half the housing in the UK. But

23:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they're

23:38Ross: usually owned by companies, not individuals, firstly. And then if we make a land value tax that will tax the value of land, firstly, if you have empty properties, you're losing massive amounts of money on that. You're just holding property to hope it goes up, you're losing money. So you would rent it. That would increase the amount of rental properties available straight away. It would de de-incentivize incentivize buying up tons of properties and it would make it very difficult to hide the wealth in a way that was creatively tax evasive, you know what I mean? Land is land.

24:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's

24:12Ross: and the land can be more or less expensive based on things surrounding it. But a really pure land value tax doesn't take into account what you build on it. It just takes into account part of the land, right?

24:23Fit It: Yeah, I agree with you. I think we need to be careful though, because the reason why taxes exist is that it needs to be a fair way to redistribute wealth. That is what taxes are. And so we need to make sure that if it is a land tax, for example, we are targeting the right people that have tens of millions of pounds worth worth of land and that they're not using it in

24:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

24:44Fit It: best way for the well being of society and everyone.

24:48Ross: I think the thing about the land tax is that it's quite it's it's basically straight to the argument of increasing the productivity of a country, right?

24:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It

24:56Ross: encourages people to build on emptied patches of land, essentially. Whereas I think what a lot of these economists who are debating it right now are talking about is actually more creative policy when it comes to valuation. It's what we do on some of episodes where we try and think of creative policy ways to push down inequality and and do things in a way that naturally incentivizes wage increases. So maybe for the second bit of the episode we could talk about some of the solutions that that make a bit more sense. The w I I think the wealth tax on paper sounds good, but all you'll end up doing, yeah, you'll you'll increase the supply of housing a bit and you'll add wealth into the economy a bit. So it's not a fundamentally bad idea, but I don't think it's the only way you can fix what's wrong with the UK.

25:40Fit It: Okay, so the things that we agree that the we're not working out in the UK at the moment include transport is too expensive, there is too much government debt, taxes are too low, or at least relatively low compared to the amount of social services that people expect to receive. Uh the cost of housing is extremely high, the cost of rent is extremely high. Highly skilled jobs are relatively low in terms of uh salary, and we have seen that inflation. The the consumer price index has gone up a lot faster than salary raises have gone up. Um I think these were the main ones that we agreed on. Then we mentioned pensions, the fact that we have the triple lock. So I think Andy Burnham started very well. He started with uh capping bus fares to two pounds. I think that's a good starting point. He removed the VATs. to energy bills so that people can pay less uh for their electricity and gas. That's also something else I like. He's now thinking about reducing taxes for independent businesses. So I think these three starting points are already quite solid.

26:42Ross: He's talked about doing um a reduction in in uh business rates for productive things on the high streets, such as things that are good for social reasons like pubs and music venues and things like that. And increasing them as slightly on things like vape shops and or things that don't really add a huge amount to the social or cohesion of a of a high street. So yeah, I agree. I think he's done some really good stuff. He's even started to talk about things like the land value tax and restructuring the tax system a bit to kinda kind of push the economy towards what we were saying where it it helps to sh incentivize lowering of rents and to incentivize uh productive investment building of of things. But I think he's on the right wave node to this. I think he's thinking about exactly these things and I think he's got a good mindset about it actually. I think he's thinking in exactly the same way about some of these problems.

27:32Fit It: And I have a couple of things to add. I mean firstly I really like the fact that he was given the opportunity because he lived a lot closer to the people compared to some of the MPs that we have in London, in my opinion. He lived in Manchester. Manchester wasn't the cool place that it's today with a lot of new businesses, a lot of new startups, lower cost of life, higher quality of life at the same time. So I think he did a great job in Manchester. And I think that hopefully he will be able to bring some of his experience of again thinking back at those five pyramids. focusing on those bottom three, helping the people at the bottom three, because that's the majority of the population. That's ninety-nine percent of people living at the bottom three. So when we think about taxes and wealth, I know that it doesn't sound nice to say we need to tax the people that make ten millions a year, but that is less than the one percent of the population. So the remaining ninety ninety-nine nine percent will actually see a significant decrease in the cost of life. if we did that. So I think that looking into that is very important. And then one last thing that

28:32I think is worth mentioning, because obviously politics is a very broad field and it's really difficult to make a dent in a field so there is it's just there's so much inertia. The ball is rolling, it's Has been rolling like this for decades, if not centuries. So it's really difficult to change the direction in which a whole country is going. going. So as an individual, as a person, I think that the things that make difference on the day-to-day life are firstly educating oneself, and this is something that we say all the time, and we've made other podcasts about economics in the UK, in our podcast series, so learning about how politics works, learning about how economics works, and then understanding that we need to some extent I call it cut the burn. So reduce your expenses on a monthly basis. That's usually what I focus on personally. And that's something that has allowed me to save more money and feel more confident about my retirement plan going forward. So think about you know saving money for retirement and investing. It's so that you're building wealth by yourself.

29:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

29:39Ross: think a bit of a wealth tax, an increase in a wealth tax is a good thing for sure. Yeah, I get it. But I don't think it solves all the problems. And I don't think telling people to just not buy luxuries and don't buy new clothes and things and don't buy a coffee for yourselves. I don't think that's right. I don't think we should have an economy where people can't buy a treat or a nice new pair of clothes every once in a while. I think that goes to what we were saying before. But I think that people should be able to save up money, maybe a bit of a pension. I don't think pensions are inherently bad, evil things. Maybe have a bit of your own savings. Not all in your house and you should uh but basically you should be able to have rent that doesn't cripple your monthly income. You should have wages that match the price of things on the street. You should have a high street that doesn't make it prohibitively expensive for independent businesses to to set up there. And you should basically have a country that feels like it works.

30:31Fit It: This probably brings us back to that um to that same idea. I also just wanted to add in case it in case I sound like a Russian communist or something. That I do wish for everybody to be wealthy and build builder their wealth and I think that everybody should aim at having a multi million dollar net worth. I just think that after you have ten million pounds of net worth, you're not gonna need anything more probably for your quality of life. So it would be probably from a philosophical perspective, human decency, making sure that everybody else in society who does also has some dignity in the quality of life.

31:08Ross: Yeah. I think to sum up what I've already said about this, I think you need to decrease people's power of V veto for new properties. Uh so if we have decrease people's ability to prevent construction products and and development of land. Increase the incentivization to develop and make land productive by making it taxed the same as if it's empty or if it's not, so people were building it. Maybe you could increase people's ability to say yes as well as a third one. Instead of just making housing targets, they could actually build something for that development. in the local area. For example, if you need everybody saying there's not enough dentist offices or post offices or things for the the big developments, and that's probably true. But you could build more and then some for each one of these things. Maybe you could fund it with the wealth tax, for example, or if the productivity of the country goes up as a whole, then the whole thing will be end up funding itself because the entire country will feel more wealthy and will have that money to invest. I think the difficult thing is that you need the money in the first place to start investing. So you need to break the cycle somehow, and that's going to be painful no matter which way you look at it, because changing a cycle means you're always going to have some people who lose out and some people who win, right? So we've got this situation where we uh terrified of nationalization. I also think we should nationalize natural monopoly things like railways, energy, water. It makes absolutely no sense for them. to be

32:27privatized. Because people cannot choose an alternative. They they are simply given what they're given. I think those are several things I think will go a long way to fix this country. Whole bunch of stuff there, and hopefully we successfully stitch it into an episode for you guys. But let us know what you think. This is a a very complex topic. with a whole lot of different opinions that a lot of people have. So if you have an idea of what you think is wrong with the British economy and state, do let us know down below.

33:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh

33:03Ross: thanks everybody.

33:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We'll

33:05Ross: see you in the next

33:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time.

33:07Fit It: Thank you. Bye-bye.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights