InFi: the Future of Finance

Speaker argues FAA grounding and surge pricing reflect market inefficiencies vs. government failures

30 min Listen to the original Episode page
FAAAir TravelSurge PricingMarket SignalsGovernment RegulationPrivate InsuranceSupply and DemandEconomic Incentives

Summary

The speaker discusses the FAA's decision to ground all flights due to a contractor's maintenance error, arguing that government-run systems like air traffic control are prone to catastrophic failures. He addresses complaints about high Uber and hotel prices following the grounding, asserting that these price spikes are not 'gouging' but necessary market signals that ration demand and elicit increased supply during periods of scarcity. The speaker contrasts government regulation with private insurance, citing the ValuJet crash to argue that private insurers have financial incentives to enforce safety, whereas the FAA received more funding after failures, creating perverse incentives. He explains that surge pricing for Ubers and hotels serves two functions: it rations the existing supply to those with the highest urgency and incentivizes more drivers and hosts to enter the market, increasing total supply. Finally, the speaker argues that the ability to charge high prices during emergencies incentivizes hoteliers to build more capacity than they would otherwise, preventing underbuilding relative to peak demand scenarios.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    that is prices went way up for Ubers and hotel rooms. And so, of course, whenever something like this happens, a lot of people were complaining about that. Like, oh, in the midst of this calamity, you've got these jerks over here. gouging the public and you know, taking advantage of them when they're already down, kicking them while they're down, kind of thing. And so there ought to be a law. The government should look into this, that sort of thing. All right. So as a standard free market economist, let me explain why that's actually what we want to have happen in situations like this. So this is a classic example of this kind of scenario where the thing that seems very antisocial and stuff that the government should stamp out, or at least social opinion really ought to keep in check, it's actually performing a vital social function.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 1:00

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 1:00

    FAA Grounding and Government Inefficiency

    The speaker discusses the FAA's decision to ground all flights for several hours due to a contractor's maintenance error in Arkansas. He argues that government-run systems like air traffic control are prone to catastrophic failures when errors occur, contrasting this with a decentralized market system.

  2. 1:00 – 7:08

    Price Gouging and Market Signals

    The speaker addresses complaints about high Uber and hotel prices following the grounding. He argues that these price spikes are not 'gouging' but necessary market signals that ration demand and elicit increased supply during periods of scarcity.

  3. 7:08 – 10:18

    Incentives in Safety Regulation

    The speaker contrasts government regulation with private insurance, citing the ValuJet crash. He argues that private insurers have financial incentives to enforce safety, whereas the FAA received more funding after failures, creating perverse incentives.

  4. 10:18 – 22:46

    Economic Function of Surge Pricing

    The speaker explains that surge pricing for Ubers and hotels serves two functions: it rations the existing supply to those with the highest urgency and incentivizes more drivers and hosts to enter the market, increasing total supply.

  5. 22:46 – 29:34

    Long-Term Capacity and Profit Signals

    The speaker argues that the ability to charge high prices during emergencies incentivizes hoteliers to build more capacity than they would otherwise. Without these potential profits, entrepreneurs would underbuild relative to peak demand scenarios.

Do your own research

  • Verify the specific maintenance error in Arkansas that triggered the FAA grounding decision.
  • Review FAA funding changes following safety failures to assess the claim of perverse incentives.
  • Analyze historical data on hotel capacity expansion relative to peak demand scenarios.
  • Check private insurance safety enforcement mechanisms compared to government regulatory bodies.
  • Examine Uber and hotel pricing algorithms during the grounding event to verify supply/demand responses.
  • Look for counter-arguments regarding the definition of 'price gouging' in legal contexts.
  • Assess the economic impact of the ValuJet crash on insurance vs. regulatory funding.
  • Research the efficiency of decentralized market systems versus centralized government systems in critical infrastructure.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Again, that's just one among many problems with having the government be in charge of something like let's make sure all the air traffic control is up to snuff in the country. Well, then that means when they screw something up, the whole thing goes down. Welcome to InFi, the future of finance.

0:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey

0:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): everybody, welcome back to the InFi podcast. After last week's, some would say epic, others. would say exhausting, foray into the world of Goldman Sachs, interview questions, and subgame perfect Nash Equilibria with lions eating steaks and looking ahead 252 rounds. I thought, why don't we do something more basic in this episode? Specifically, I want to respond to the complaints I had seen on social media after the FAA grounded all the flights. several days ago at this point, as I'm recording this, for several hours, leading to thousands of stranded passengers. And then, of course, what happened in the wake of that is prices went way up for Ubers and hotel rooms. And so, of course, whenever something like this happens, a lot of people were complaining about that. Like, oh, in the midst of this calamity, you've got these jerks over here. gouging the public and you know, taking advantage of them when they're already down, kicking them while they're down, kind of thing. And so there ought to be a law. The government should look into this, that sort of thing. All right. So as a standard free market economist, let me explain why that's actually what we want to have happen in situations like this. So this is a classic example of this kind of scenario where the thing that seems very

1:40antisocial and stuff that the government should stamp out, or at least social opinion really ought to keep in check, it's actually performing a vital social function. All right. So let's walk through it. So before I I get into the price gouging stuff, though, let me just spend a few minutes on the whole issue of the FAA grounding all the planes. Now, some people are saying, oh, this was definitely a cyber attack, whether it was from Iranian agents or whoever,

2:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there are

2:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a lot of people think this this was an attack and it's just a cover story that the government's giving because they don't want people to panic and they don't want to look like they didn't were caught with their pants down. Especially in conjunction with, as I'm recording this now, there were several other things that happened. There was the Microsoft outage, I think the day before, the situation with the planes or air traffic control, I should say, more specifically. And then also the following week, like a bunch of banks went down temporarily. And then there's even I think the day after that, there were reports of the NSA's own servers being down, things like that. So clearly a lot is afoot in these recent as I'm recording it. It's not even a full week since all this stuff has been dropping. And so some people are saying, come on, that seems like a Britney pretty, pretty big coincidence that they have to ground all the flights in the country because according to the official story, some contractor, I think it was in Arkansas, they finally revealed, was just doing some routine maintenance, updating some old equipment. And then it was like pinging the service repeatedly to try to get back online. And then that was rippling throughout the system and causing other air traffic control equipment. across the country from having temporary falling out of connectivity with the system. And so out of an abundance of caution, when they couldn't figure out exactly what was going on, they just said, hey, everybody stop right now until we figure this out. And then

3:27it took them four hours to resume. Okay. So that's the official story. So, like I say, in conjunction with all these other stories, there's Or some people saying that's not what happened. They're just saying that. Okay. That may be, I don't have any. inside information, but I'll put it this way: people know the FAA is so antiquated and the government in general is so incompetent and their systems are so poorly designed that that could be a cover story that they could get away with saying, right? That they could say to the people, oh yeah, because some contractor was fixing something in Arkansas. That's why we had to say to the entire country, nobody can take off for the next four hours. Like that's kind of a crazy story, but yet, uh, we've heard worse from government officials. So just let me dwell on that for a minute. Let's not breeze through that too quickly. This, among other reasons, this is why free market oriented economists don't like services to be provided by the government. Because in addition to all the other problems that you could list.

4:27there is the issue of when you concentrate power like that, if they screw it up, the impact is wider.

4:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All

4:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): right. So put it to this way, all the air traffic in the United States was grounded, but in other countries it was still working. Right. I mean, I guess if there was like a flight from Mexico in And the United States, maybe that one would have been grounded, but you get the point I'm making. Whereas like if you had a one world government and we said, oh, instead of having this crazy patchwork quilt of different overlapping jurisdictions and things like that, why don't we just have one world government and have uniform air traffic control regulations and a system in place to make sure they all communicate with each other? If they had had that, well, then the whole world would have been shut down. Okay, or going a different way, if Texas had seceded five years ago or California had broken away. when Trump got elected, as many people in the CalExit movement and Texit movements respectively would have, if they had gotten their way, would have happened. Then the FAA going down would not have brought down California or Texas respectively, depending on which scenario we're talking about. Okay. So again, that's just one among many problems with having the government be in charge of something like let's make sure all the air track. traffic control is up to snuff in the country. Well then that means when they screw something up, the

5:44whole thing goes down. Okay. And on that point too, in case it's not on your radar, no pun intended, the FAA systems are truly antiquated. And I was talking to a pilot one time. I wanted him to tell this story on my personal podcast and he originally agreed, but then later he changed his mind 'cause mind because he he didn't want to get in trouble with

6:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.

6:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): his job. But he was telling me just how antiquated the the systems were and he said one time he was landing a plane and it was snowing and the equipment, the guidance that he was getting and so on, he just pulled out his iPhone and pulled it up like as if he were, you know, driving as he's landing the plane. So he's you know he's not super high up. And he said that's he used his phone to help him land, make sure he was on the runway and everything. So whether you want to believe that story or not, I'm just saying there's systems, not just from that guy's anecdote, but from plenty of people I've talked to in the space are saying that yeah, the FAA systems are ludicrously antiquated. And so what happened in the wake of this crazy story, where again the official narrative is, oh yeah, a contractor was changing something in Arkansas, and that's why we had to ground the entire country. country's airlines for several hours. The response, of course, is not to say, you know what, let's go look and fire the top sixteen people who were involved with this, because that's unacceptable. That's crazy. No, the response is, hey, we need billions of dollars pronto, because we got to upgrade everything.

7:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,

7:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so yet another reason that having government provision of vital services is a bad method. of delivering them. Because look at the incentives, look at how it's structured, that whenever they really screw something up, the solution is typically not that they go out of business and say, well, we tried having the government provide air traffic control. They royally screw that. It'd be hard to come up with a more contrived scenario where because some contractor's fixing something, the whole thing goes down. That's kind of crazy. I guess you had your show. shot at FAA. Now we're going to try to decentralize it and have either the states do it themselves, or my preferred solution is to have it be a market-based system. No, that's not what happens. Instead, they get rewarded with billions of dollars and more funding. And that happened like when I was younger, there was a bad plane crash in the Everglades. I think the airline at that time was called Value Jet. And then they changed their name. And then it had turned

8:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): out

8:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): when they did the investigation that among other things, so yes, the airline was cutting corners. That's ValueJet, right? But if memory serves, it was also the FAA inspectors were like signing off on stuff that they shouldn't have. Like, in other words, they were not enforcing their own protocols, or at least for that particular flight that ended up crashing the Everglades. Okay. And so in the wake of that, what happened? The FAA got more funding. The reason that's so fresh in my mind is because I think I was in high school at the time and I wrote a piece to my local newspaper that they published because someone wrote a letter.

8:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, it

8:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): wasn't a letter there. Someone, it was an op ed piece that I was responding to. And they said, Oh, these crazy libertarians want to cut government spending, but in the wake of the Everglades crash, normal people want the FAA to get beefed up funding. And so then I wrote a thing and I was I won't go into it here. I went through a whole analysis of how could privately provided um regulation have solved it. Like, like what would it mean if you got rid of the FAA? Like that just means, oh, there'd just be a crapshoot and airlines would be doing all kinds of crazy. And I had said no, there would be insurance companies would fill the breach. And that part of what you would get when you bought a plane ticket was a pledge that, yeah. if something happens, the plane goes down or whatever, that will compensate your estate a million dollars or whatever, $500,000. And that the insurance company that was on the hook for that would then have an incentive to do like, you know, random drug and alcohol tests of the pilots, to have inspectors show up and check the maintenance logs on the aircraft and all the things that the FAA does now. But

9:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

9:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): difference would be if there's a big plane crash, the private insurance company that had signed off on that flight, they would be out millions of dollars. In contrast, under the system that we had in in effect at the time, when the plane went down in part because the FAA inspectors were asleep at the wheel, what happened is the FAA They got more money. All

9:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right.

9:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So saying, which system do you think is more likely to produce more vigilance? on enforcing the safety protocols and stuff like that? So we see the similar pattern here. All right. So now let's pivot to the complaints about so-called price gouging. Again, once thousands of people got stranded, the natural outcome of that effect was you had very high price increases for Ubers and hotel rooms around the airports. And a lot of people don't like that. Profiteering, taking advantage of people when they're already down, that kind of stuff. All right. So the fundamental problem when something like that happens is there's either a sharp spike in demand or a drop in supply or both, depending on the scenario. Right. So this happens a lot with natural disasters. Or if there's an impending uh storm's coming and people are trying to get out of town, and then look that pushes up prices at the gas stations, stuff like that. Or there's gonna be a big blizzard and people rush to the grocery stores to clear out all the bottled water and batteries and stuff like that. And so some people running the stores jack up their prices and oh, it's unconscionable. You know, they call the attorney general, they got a hotline for this kind of shenanigans, okay? So again, economically speaking, what's going on in these

11:18scenarios is it's a combination of either a sharp spike in demand or a sharp fall in supply or both. And that, of course, means the market clearing price goes up when those one or more of those, or what I should say, one or both of those things happen. All right. And so as an economist, you're not going to be surprised that I'm going to tell you the market clearing price means something. It communicates information to everybody, and messing with it and not letting it do its job is like someone has a fever and you put the thermometer in their mouth and it's going up and it's going to, you know, ninety-nine, a hundred, a hundred wet. And someone goes, quick, get some ice cubes and put the ice cubes on the thermometer to bring that bad boy down. And okay, you could do that, but now the thermometer is not doing its job. If the person really is running a 102, you need to know that. Okay. And likewise, if a hotel room near an airport is normally $80 a night, but then because of all the stranded

12:19passengers, it jumps up to 150. That number means something. And that needs to be communicated and people's the way they respond to that number being 150 instead of 80 is significant. And that's what we need to have happen. It's what you want to happen. All right. So this is pretty straightforward stuff, but I'll just walk through it in case you've never heard someone make a case like this before. Or also I should say, if I imagine a lot of listeners to this podcast, if you're naturally inclined to defer to respecting private property and voluntary market outcomes, should have the benefit of the doubt. But on something like this, you feel a little queasy about it and your faith is being challenged, and then you want someone to come in and kind of reassure you that no, no, no, this is okay. Trust the plan. Okay. Here's what I what I would say. There's two things that happen happens when the price goes up. One is it rations the demand for the item.

13:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

13:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the other thing is it elicits more supply. And that's exactly what we want to have happen in situations where there's a temporary imbalance where the supply has crashed and/or the demand has spiked such that even though before supply and demand were roughly equal, now there's this big gap. There's a big shortage where at the old price, you know, more people wanted the item than there were units to go around. That's what a shortage is.

13:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

13:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so the higher the spike in the price tries to bring those two back into balance so that the supply that is still available is now being allocated to the fewer people who want out to buy that high price.

14:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.

14:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And so you say, well yeah, that's mechanically what's going on, but why should I like that? And so let me just give you a little insight into that. So why don't we start with probably the transportation's the easier one to think through.

14:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

14:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a bunch of people are straying at the airport. They weren't planning on it. They gotta get to where they're going. They're either gonna take a long ride to go somewhere far away, or they're just gonna take a ride to the hotels or whatever. Take a ride maybe out to a car ride. rental place, who knows what. They know some people in the area, whatever the case may be, a lot more people are now on the curb at the airport trying to use their smartphone to book an Uber. And they're also lining up to take the conventional taxis and everything too. Okay. And so there are people who have different levels of urgency for how badly they want to get into a vehicle sooner rather than later. And it's not perfect, but the price is a method of rationing, right? So you got some family with, you know, they got the dad's carrying one toddler at his arms, and the mom's got an infant and a stroller, and the kids need to be changed, and the baby needs to be fed, and they're they've been up all day traveling and that kind of stuff, and they really need to get to a hotel. They might be willing to pay a lot to see, you know, this is really we don't want to wait around two hours. Like we want to go right now to the hotel. Okay, I'm kind of lumping in two of the scenarios at once. And so yeah, even though they would have preferred not to pay more for the Uber ride that, you know, normally would have been a forty dollar charge to go, but now it's a hundred to go not

15:34too far to the hotel. And then when I say when they get there instead of it being eighty, 80, which it normally would have been now it's 150 or whatever. Still the dad pulls out, you know, does it on his phone with the Uber, and when he gets to the hotel, he has no problem swiping his card and getting in and everyone's settled. Just oh, what a crazy day. And do you know how we know that he's okay paying those prices? Because he does. If it really were so expensive that it wasn't worth it to him at that price, if he didn't benefit from it, he wouldn't. pay it. Okay, so let's be clear. I'm not saying he benefits from the price being high compared to a situation where there weren't this unusual degree of scarcity and the price were lower and he still got to use those items. Obviously, he would have preferred to take the Uber for $40 forty dollars rather than $80 eighty

16:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or

16:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): whatever numbers I said. I forgot what my example was.

16:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And he

16:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): would have preferred to stay in the hotel room at 80 rather than having to pay 150. But I'm saying if those weren't options, if the Uber ride is 80 and the hotel's 150, and to say, does he still prefer

16:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to

16:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): take the Uber at that price and to take the hotel room at that price compared to not using them at all? The answer is yes. And how do we know? Because he paid those prices. Whereas other people didn't. That's what it means when

16:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they're not.

16:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the price rises high enough to ration the quantity, the available supply, it's because other people dropped out. At that price, maybe there's some teenager or something who is trying to come home from school, and you say it calls his parents and like, oh yeah, they canceled all the flights. I went to get an Uber and it would you can't believe how much it was. And and then also the hotels around here and are nuts. So yeah, I got guess I'm going to sleep at the airport. And that's unfortunate. But the point being, given that there are not enough Ubers to get everyone, especially like within an hour of this happening, to the hotels,

17:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there

17:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): just aren't enough vehicles. There has to be some method of allocating, like of deciding well, who gets to get in the Uber and who has to not. And so I'm saying you want.

17:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

17:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): family with the kids probably to get it, and the teenager who, eh, I'll just go lie down somewhere in a terminal, you know, stretch out where there's not a lot of people around, then I'll look at my Instagram or something. That's kind of what you want to have happen, and that isn't actually what will happen. All right. But it's better than just that. So if that's all the high price did was allocate the scarce quantity among the existing users. that would still be fine. That would still be a valuable social function. But the high price does something else, particularly when we're talking about Ubers, right? This wouldn't have been as obvious back in the day when the government was protecting us from fly by night vehicle operators, and we just have, you know, official taxi cabs with the medallion and everything because it's a highly regulated service. But now that we have the wild west of Uber and Lyft and so on, and these uh mercenary taxis that come in, the supply of transportation services can expand like an accordion as long as there's surge pricing. There are people that normally at that time, you know, when those flights all got grounded and there was a

18:43huge surge in people who were trying to get from their airports to the local hotels or wherever, go back home if they had just gotten there, you know, whatever. And so the that surge pricing that Uber and Lyft allow is what elicits more supply. People who otherwise would have been watching a game or something or working a different job or sleeping in or whatever, they all now, because their phone's blown up, showing them the fares that are available, how much they could get if they just get in their car A and turn it on to activate it and they're going to the airport and picking up fares, that gets more people to do that. Right. So again, the problem is there's a bunch of people now at the airport who need to go elsewhere using cars compared to the normal scenario. And so what do you do? You come up with a way that of the people that are waiting to take the vehicle, the ones who don't really want to take it right away,

19:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

19:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it wouldn't be as inconvenient for them to do something else, they walk away. But the people who really absolutely want to get into a vehicle as soon as possible, they're the ones that stay. And it's not just a fixed number of vehicles. Now there's an expansion in how many are available to provide rides because of that surge pricing. Okay. So you can see the two-pronged approach by which that helps tackle both sides of the coin. Okay. Similar thing with the hotel rooms, that it's a work trip or something. And oh geez, a bunch of us were all gonna go down to Phoenix for this conference, that you know it's a trade group conference or something. And oh man, we're all stuck down at the airport. And is it worth going? Oh geez, and let's just go to the the hotel down the street, and then they see how much the rooms are. So if the rooms have had been normally priced. maybe each person would have gotten their own room. But now because they're double what they normally are, maybe the CFO of their company says, Yeah, we'll comp the things, but you guys gotta double up. That's crazy. We're not gonna I'm not gonna pay for you each to all get hotel rooms that are three hundred dollars a pop. That's crazy. The guys can room and the women, you know, they they would do that, but you get the point.

20:47And so again, that's what you wanna want to have happen. That you don't want it to be in situations where people could, without too much inconvenience, double up if they're just staying for one night anyway. You want them to do that in a situation where the rooms are very scarce, where there's a lot more people who are want to stay at the hotel than there are rooms to go around. You want them among themselves to figure out ways of making that happen. And again, notice it's not that you wouldn't want the government. or some stranger to go through and and figure out how that pairing is going to happen. You gotta let people do it themselves. Like I said, and like if it were a male and female work colleagues who are flying the CFO, unless the price were ludicrously, I probably would say, yeah, you guys can get separate rooms, where if it's two guys, you know. So I'm just saying things like that. Or if it's a family and if the prices were reasonable, normal, typical, they would have said, Oh yeah, you know, your mother and I and the baby will stay in one room and then, you know, you two referring to their teenage kids, you can get a separate room. But if the hotel rooms are triple what they normally are, maybe they're gonna say, no no, for this one night, we're all staying in one room and you guys will get the futons and you can sleep on the couch and blah, blah, blah. You, you know, do that kind of thing, which again is what you

22:07want. But you're not going to probably have complete strangers in the lobby of the hotel, like saying, Hey, you want to split a room? Or maybe you will. They could do that depending on how much the price is, and depending on how desperate the people are. But again, that's what the market price does. It communicates communicate how scarce is this thing, and then less lets people make voluntary consumers. consensual arrangements among themselves in light of that information? But they need to know the number that communicates valuable data. Okay. And then the last element of it, you might say, okay, sure, there it's rationing supply the available quantity, but at least in the Uber case, I can kind of see with the surge pricing how that would make more vehicles available. No, the the stock of hotel rooms. is what it is. The fact that the price spikes doesn't all of a sudden create more hotel rooms, give me a break. And that's not accurate. So for one thing, especially with like Airbnb and those types of things, that is analogous to the Uber situation, where there could be situations. I don't know whether just 'cause just because I haven't ever been a landlord, or I don't know if that's the right word. Yeah. On Airbnb, I've only been a customer. So I don't know if they have situations like where surge pricing allows people to put their room up that normally it wouldn't be available. I don't know how that works

23:26exactly, but I think it possibly could work like that. But beyond that, even just taking conventional hotels, when you're building a hotel and deciding how much how many rooms do we want to create, like how how big of a building we're gonna do, how many total rooms we're gonna have, you're gonna make estimates.

23:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

23:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so one of the things, especially if you're located near an airport,

23:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that

23:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you would take into account is you know seasonal trends and stuff like that. And the fact that, oh, yeah, sometimes there's a snowstorm and the planes are all grounded. Again, you wouldn't be doing a scenario. Well, geez, what if there was a contractor in our Arkansas and the whole country went to? You wouldn't do that, but it's not unusual, like I say, for air for hotels near airports for there to be a local situation that leads to a bunch of canceled flights. And so there's a big surge from people for that reason, just you know, in your local area, not over the whole country near the airports. And so you're gonna going to take that into account when you're deciding how big of a hotel. do we want to build? How many rooms is it going to have? And partly, like I say, what you take into account is to say, okay, you can look at your normal trends, but then say there will periodically be unusual scenarios where we're going to sell out. And in fact, and we can charge an unusually high root rate and still sell out. And so in scenarios like that, we would have wished we had a little bit. more capacity. And so knowing that there are those occasions

24:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): where

24:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the price is going to go through the roof and you're going to still be able to sell out, you would on the margin, other things equal, build more capacity. When you originally were deciding, yeah, we're going to build a new hotel here, put it, you know, in this area, we're buying the On land, blah, blah, blah. Talking to the architects, how big do we want to make this thing? Knowing there are scenarios like that. And for that to work, it has to be the case that you're legally allowed to do that, and that like the community's not going to be so mad at you if you do it that they're going to punish you, like either like through vandalism or something, or just, well, I'm not taking my business with them anymore to their properties anymore, given how they treated us back on the snowstorm of Ought Eight. So that's where. there is it's more subtle, but it's still a true mechanism that the ability to charge to price gouge when there's situations like that means the hotels are going to have more rooms than they otherwise would have. And hence when those calamities hit, there are more rooms to go around than otherwise would have been the case.

26:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

26:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so I'm saying even there, there is a sense in which the supply is higher because of the possibility and the legality and socially acceptable outcome that hotels can jack up the rates when there's a huge demand for people to check in.

26:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All right.

26:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So again, which is exactly what you want to have happen. Ironically, if it weren't for that, like you could imagine socialists or, you know, interventionists saying, Oh, geez, the profit motive. I mean, the people are so short sighted that if there's a once in every three year or five year calamity in a certain region, the amount of people that want to stay in the hotels is just triple what it normally is. These short sighted capitalists won't build accordingly. They'll just make short short-term term projections because they just want their quick buck and they want to cut costs and whatever, whereas if they were built according to long-term planners and engineers and people who are concerned about traffic flows and stuff like that, and had a far-sighted view, we would build more capacity. So you could easily imagine them critiquing capitalism through that avenue. And I'm saying the way it works, and again, this this isn't arbitrary, this is exactly what provides the right incentives. is for people to forecast, like I say, those

27:17those surges. Because it matters how likely it is. You don't want to build a huge capacity on the off chance that there's earthquakes everywhere else around you and that everybody within a 30-mile radius wants to come stay at your hotel. And so let's build accordingly. Like, no, that's that's too ludicrous of a scenario. You would be overbuilding if you did that. And so, geez, there's lots of

27:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): things.

27:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): competing. You know, how do you make the right decision? And a non-arbitrary way is to say, maximize the expected profit. And that's what the market economy rewards entrepreneurs for doing.

27:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It

27:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): doesn't force you to do that. You're allowed to make to, you know, you can certainly lose money if you want, or probably more realistically, you don't have to maximize the expected rate of return on your financial. capital, right? If someone's trying to decide on a project and they could build a used bookstore or they could build a laser tag facility or something. And you could just imagine the owner, the potential owner, the guy who owns the property thinking of the two different things, saying, just running a used bookstore, or if I have to hire a manager, but just being able to come in, and it's my property and my area and my building in a used bookstore. that just I like that. That appeals to me more than having a bunch of rowdy kids running around shooting each other with the laser guns and yelling and screaming in the parking lot, whatever, and hanging around smoking outside with their buddies. Even if they thought they would make 17% on their capital with the laser tag thing, but only make 12% with the bookstore, there's nothing saying they have to do the laser tag thing. They're allowed. to do the thing that they that gives them more psychic satisfaction with a lower market rate of return. They can do that. But the point is the numbers are important. They need to know that to make a rational decision. If the laser tag thing were going to pay 17% and the bookstore was going to pay 2%, is there in terms of a return? Maybe then they would

29:11say, Yeah, I like the bookstore better, but I can't ignore that disparity. So you need to know what the numbers are. All right. Well, I will wrap up there. I hope some of you have learned something, giving you food for thought in this episode. Stay safe, everybody, especially when you're flying. See you next

29:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights