Ahead In The Count

MLB CBA Expiration: Small-Market Success and Record 2026 Attendance Drive Negotiation Debate

17 min Listen to the original Episode page
MLBCollective Bargaining AgreementSports BusinessSmall Market TeamsFan Engagement

Summary

Host Nolan Alexander and guests Chase Murray and Jeremy Hermida discuss the upcoming expiration of the MLB Collective Bargaining Agreement on December 1, focusing on potential salary cap and floor implementations. Jeremy Hermida argues that the 2026 postseason success of small-market teams like the Guardians, Brewers, and Rays proves organizational quality outweighs payroll size, comparing this dynamic to the NFL. The hosts cite record 2026 attendance of 71.7 million and strong TV ratings as evidence of fan interest driven by competitive balance and rule changes. They dismiss early owner proposals for a $258M cap as media posturing, expecting serious negotiations to begin closer to the deadline. Minor league baseball attendance trends and the potential impact of CBA disruptions on the minor league season are also analyzed.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    MLB attendance reached 71.7 million fans in 2026, an average of just under 30,000 per game, marking the fourth consecutive year of growth.

    Nolan Alexander · 5:48

  2. 2
    The Rays nearly doubled their attendance to 1.4 million after returning to Tropicana Field, and the White Sox added over 500,000 fans to reach 2 million after returning to the postseason, linking competitiveness to fan engagement.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 7:10

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 1:22

    Intro and CBA Expiration Context

    Host Nolan Alexander introduces the podcast and guests Chase Murray and Jeremy Hermida, noting the current MLB Collective Bargaining Agreement expires December 1. The discussion focuses on the upcoming negotiations regarding a salary cap and floor.

  2. 1:22 – 5:48

    Small Market Success and Organizational Philosophy

    Jeremy Hermida argues that the success of small-market teams like the Guardians, Brewers, and Rays in the 2026 postseason demonstrates that organizational quality, not payroll size, drives winning. He compares this to the NFL, where well-run franchises succeed regardless of spending.

  3. 5:48 – 9:04

    Attendance, Ratings, and Fan Experience Drivers

    Nolan Alexander cites record attendance (71.7 million fans) and strong TV ratings (postseason avg 5.4 million viewers) for 2026. Chase Murray and Jeremy Hermida attribute this to competitive balance, the return of teams like the Rays and White Sox to contention, and rule changes like the pitch clock and ABS.

  4. 9:04 – 11:59

    Minor League Baseball Outlook

    The hosts discuss minor league baseball, noting attendance declined for three consecutive years. They speculate that if the CBA does not disrupt the minor league season, attendance could surge, though the exclusion of 40-man roster players might limit the appeal of seeing top prospects.

  5. 11:59 – 16:56

    Early CBA Proposals and Negotiation Posturing

    Jeremy Hermida dismisses early owner proposals (e.g., $258M cap, $180M floor) as media posturing rather than serious negotiation starting points. Chase Murray agrees, noting that actual negotiations will likely begin closer to the deadline as both sides avoid losing games.

Claims worth verifying

The current MLB collective bargaining agreement expires December 1, covering the 2022-2026 period.

Nolan Alexander ·1:02

How to verify: Check the official MLB CBA text or MLB.com news releases regarding the expiration date and term of the agreement. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Guardians, Brewers, and Rays were three of the four teams in the 2026 LCS (final four), with the Dodgers being the exception.

Nolan Alexander ·1:22

How to verify: Verify MLB 2026 postseason bracket and results via MLB.com or Baseball Reference. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Under the latest owner proposal, the Guardians, Brewers, and Rays would have to raise their payrolls.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·1:52

How to verify: Compare the specific payroll figures of these teams against the proposed salary floor in the latest CBA proposal documents released by MLB owners. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The NFL has a salary cap, which allows well-run franchises to succeed consistently.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·2:52

How to verify: Review NFL CBA documents confirming the existence of a salary cap and compare team performance data against payroll. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

MLB attendance grew for four consecutive years, reaching 71.7 million fans in 2026.

Nolan Alexander ·5:48

How to verify: Check MLB official attendance statistics for the 2026 season and compare with prior years' data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The 2026 postseason averaged 5.4 million viewers, the strongest since 2019.

Nolan Alexander ·6:08

How to verify: Consult Nielsen ratings data for MLB postseason broadcasts and compare with historical ratings from 2019-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The 2026 NLCS was the highest-rated LCS in 11 years.

Nolan Alexander ·6:27

How to verify: Review Nielsen ratings for all LCS series from 2026 to 2026 to confirm the ranking. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Game 1 of the 2026 NLCS had over 10 million viewers.

Nolan Alexander ·6:27

How to verify: Check Nielsen ratings for the specific game broadcast. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

National broadcasts had early season bumps of almost 50% in 2026.

Nolan Alexander ·6:27

How to verify: Compare Nielsen ratings for early-season national MLB broadcasts in 2026 versus 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Streaming and local audiences were up 24% in 2026.

Nolan Alexander ·6:47

How to verify: Review MLB's internal streaming data or third-party analytics reports (e.g., Statcast, MLB Advanced Media reports) for 2026 viewership metrics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the exact expiration date of the current MLB CBA and the specific terms of the 'owner proposal' regarding the $258M cap and $180M floor cited by Jeremy Hermida.
  • Check MLB.com or the Commissioner's Office for official 2026 attendance figures (71.7 million) and postseason TV ratings (5.4 million average) to confirm the reported growth trends.
  • Review the 2026 MLB standings and playoff bracket to confirm the participation of the Guardians, Brewers, and Rays in the LCS and their respective payroll sizes relative to other teams.
  • Analyze MLB attendance data for the Cleveland Guardians, Milwaukee Brewers, Tampa Bay Rays, and Chicago White Sox to verify the claimed attendance increases linked to postseason contention.
  • Examine minor league baseball attendance reports for the past three years to assess the validity of the claim that attendance has declined for three consecutive years.
  • Look for historical TV ratings data from Nielsen or MLB to verify the claim that the 2026 NLCS was the highest-rated LCS in 11 years.
  • Research the NFL's salary cap structure and compare it to MLB's proposed cap/floor system to evaluate the speaker's comparison regarding organizational success versus spending.
  • Investigate the specific rule changes mentioned (pitch clock, ABS) and their reported impact on game pace and viewer engagement in 2026.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Nolan Alexander: Welcome to Ahead in the Count, presented by BIP Wealth. Our baseball division combines their collegiate and professional playing experience with financial acumen to provide expertise in life on and off the field. We aim to give ball players and their families a better understanding about their unique lifestyle, the opportunities that come from playing this game, and insight. into the complex financial world. This is Ahead and the Count, hosted by Nolan Alexander from VIP Wealth.

0:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We're

0:42Nolan Alexander: back on Ahead and the Count. Chase Murray, Jeremy Hermita joining us today. Guys, we spent our last episode talking about what stood out from 2026. the trend lines in baseball, what we enjoyed, and what was an eventful year capped off by a fun postseason and the Brewers taking down the race. We want to continue that conversation looking ahead to the offseason and the end of the current CBA, which is set to expire on December 1st at midnight for the previous CBA 22 through 26. And that's been an ongoing discussion in baseball. even dating back to the last year or so. With that, I think it presents an interesting topic that the teams that had success, three of the four teams that were in the postseason in the final four, the LCS championships, NL and AL, smaller market teams, Guardians, Brewers, Rays, the Dodgers Rodgers being the exception there. And of course, it was the Rays and the Brewers playing in the fall classic. What does that mean? Does it mean anything in in the temperature of the room in baseball heading into this CBA where a salary cap, a salary floor as well, seemed to be the hot button topics? What do you think about that, Jeremy?

1:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I actually think it was uniquely a great thing for baseball all around. When you look at those three of the four teams, like you said, between Cleveland, Milwaukee, and Tampa. under the latest proposal that they've had, those three teams would have to raise their payroll. And for what? They just made it to the LCS and and they were three of the best teams in baseball, obviously, at the end and throughout the regular season. To me, it goes to clearly show that it's not the size of payroll that defines a team. You can go spend as much money as you want. Doesn't mean the product on the field is going to be spectacular. Those are all well well-run run organizations from the top down, from scouting to player development to front offices, how they handle their big league staff. Like they have been year after year great organizations. And it just really goes to show that it's not about signing big-time free agents, where although that's what makes the headlines, it's about creating a team. To me, I can kind of use it as like a football analogy. We're like, yeah, you know, football has a salary cap. That's great. Well, there's well-run franchises that consistently year after year. have a good product. And that's where those three organizations in baseball fall for me. And there's also some that just can't ever seem to get their act together in the NFL. And there's kind of the same thing in Major League Baseball where I don't think it's dollars spent. I think it's ownership, organizational philosophy, how you go about your business and the message you're creating, your player development, how much you're willing to invest in that. To me,

3:12that's what defines organizations and what gets some of these. teams to where they're supposed to

3:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be. It's

3:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): a huge Jeremy's comparison to the NFL. You hear the NFL call to Copycat League when it comes to different offensive playbooks or defensive playbooks that kind of get recycled, it seems, throughout the league on a week-to-week basis. And you look at this year, the last couple of years, then you look into we kind of touched on this last time. If You look at what next year might look like, these different rosters being constructed, you're gonna look at these. teams, the small market teams with other teams that don't necessarily have the payroll and see probably some big changes as far as how they construct their roster.

3:48Nolan Alexander: I absolutely think that's going to be interesting. Do you feel like there's one side when it comes to a voice in these discussions that weighs more than the other when it comes to those that have power, or either there being a small market or a big market team, or is it equal across the board in their voice?

4:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): That's a great question. And honestly, uh hard to give a definitive answer on that. But when you see some of these, and I think it was just a perfect example this year, how it all finished up leading into this. It was almost like a fairy tale ending to the major league season when it comes from what's approaching with the CBA of its ownership and it's how you run an organization. I think you can see that across all major sports. You look at Tampa, they have a well-run organization year after year, have a hard time either creating the revenue or spending nearly as much as what everybody else does, but they put a terrific product out there every single year. And I think a lot of other teams and people that are maybe more in favor of a cap need to take a look in the mirror and realize what do they do differently than the team that I'm a fan of or the team that spends four. times what they do. How do they consistently keep doing that? How has Milwaukee got to this point? How does Cleveland seem to be there every single year? And they don't spend a ton. There's more than one way to go about it as a team, but they have a secret sauce and they have something that they do. And like I said, to me to

5:07circle back, it's ownership down, organizational philosophy, and how they go about their business and how they've gone about it for years. year after year and just creating that culture and creating that environment within the organization, all the way from local scouts all the way up through the top. I think that they have done a terrific job of it. And hopefully it causes a lot more organizations to kind of take note. Still want those big time free agents to go out there and get their payday. I think they should. They've earned it. You know, they're they're the best in the world at of what they do, but it doesn't mean that always equates to wins, and it doesn't mean there's not a place on rosters for. kind of that quote unquote mid-tier guy that is just a grinder of a ball player. And if you want to mix both of those together, hopefully we get to see what some of that looks like as

5:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well.

5:48Nolan Alexander: I do like that, Jeremy. And and Chase, what's interesting with this is this also coincides with the game being in a great spot. Attendance for Major League Baseball has grown four consecutive years. This year in 2026. Major League Baseball brought in 71.7 million fans. That's an average of just under 30,000 per game. Television ratings, which is like the big topic in sports across the board now, right? The postseason averaged 5.4 million viewers. It's one of the strongest going back to pre-COVID in 2019. The LCS and the NL LCS to be exact, in which the Brewers swept right past the Dodgers, it was the highest. highest-rated LCS in 11 years. Game one had over 10 million viewers. National broadcasts across the board had early season bumps of almost 50%. Streaming audiences, which that's a kind of a different topic now. Uh I have my own opinions on where all you gotta go to watch baseball, but people are watching it. Streaming and of local audiences were up 24% twenty-four percent in 2026. two thousand and twenty-six. I mean, people. are as excited about baseball as they have been in a long time. So there's a lot of good going on as far as interest goes. And Chase, I just think it's so interesting that it coincides with everything that Jeremy just talked about, leading into the end of the current C BA terms, December first.

7:07What do you think?

7:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

7:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): think that this shows that winning matters. I mean, you look at uh attendance, the rays nearly doubled their attendance to about 1.4 million after returning to Tropicana Field. The White Sox added more than 500,000 fans, reaching about 2 million after their return to the postseason. So you look at both those teams kind of getting more competitive and winning, that matters a ton. Being able to compete and not be out of it by halfway through the season, that's where you lose fans. So to have everybody competitive, when I say everybody, meaning these small markets. market teams in the World Series, it makes the game overall more fun. I do think that there's a component of viewership and streaming to your point, where you have the MLB leaning into maybe a little bit more of that film room website where guys are able to go online and see highlights and you have YouTube videos, social media. So I think all in all sports are in a great place, but absolutely baseball is in a tremendous spot and this gives it that punch of okay, it wasn't the Dodgers again. So there is some parody in this game as well. So it makes it a lot of fun.

8:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): No, I think some of it in my eyes too circles back to

8:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

8:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): pitch clock and the pace of play. And baseball made a viable effort and a valiant effort that worked to make it a more fan-friendly viewership and to want people to come to a ballpark on a Tuesday night and not have to watch a three hour and forty minute game. was just hard to do sometimes. And I think baseball realized that and they made the adjustments. And I think the fans have adopted terrifically to it. A little bit more faster pace between innings is quicker, pitching changes are quicker. The whole the whole nine yards just moves at a faster pace. I think the ABS, like we touched about, was probably very well adopted from a fan experience in the ballpark and at home. You know, you kind of get on the edge of your seat and like, oh, ah, is he right? Is that a ball as a strike? So I think all those little things

8:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to go.

8:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): along with just the quality of baseball that was played. When you mesh all those things together, it really made for a great product this season from a fan and from a a die hard baseball guy's experience as well of watching it all come together.

9:04Nolan Alexander: Well, major league baseball continued its surge in attendance for the fourth consecutive year. Minor league baseball actually declined in attendance for the third consecutive year. And something that we had brought forward in conversation prior to this recording of all the scenarios that could play out this offseason with the negotiations for the C BA. Minor league baseball, it seems like there's a stronger odds that they're going to play and not be affected as much with that. So there's a chance that attendance could surge in minor league baseball this year. Again, there's a pathway for it. We'll we'll obviously see what happens. But Chase and Jeremy, you both played in the minor leagues. What are your viewpoints? What are you thinking about here in 2027 with everything going on here in the C BA? But there's a chance that minor league baseball may have a bigger window and a brighter light than it did before.

9:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

9:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): to your point, Nolan, this would put the spotlight, so to speak, on minor league baseball. One caveat being anybody that's on the forty 40 man roster, they wouldn't be able to play on these minor league teams. So fans go to see these minor league teams and rosters, and you're looking to see the next big leaguers. And the guys that are on that 40 man roster typically are the guys that are gonna end up being in the big leagues at some point here soon. So while they will be the only baseball to see and kind of have that spotlight, and they likely will get some fans out of that. A big piece or a big chunk of what makes Minor League baseball special is be able to say, hey, I saw that guy when he was in high A. I saw him when he was in double A in this city somewhere in in America. But that would be a huge caveat to the popularity of what Myor League Baseball might be able to have at the onset of this season.

10:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): No, and I hope we have both. I hope we don't get to a point where it's just Minor League Baseball just from a fans perspective, an ex ex-player player perspective. I I really hope we don't ever get to that point. You never know. Still kinda far out there, I guess, to make a firm prediction on it. But minor league baseball has such a warm place in a lot of small towns throughout America. I remember taking my son to a game in Bradenton to watch the the A-ball team there. And Connor Griffin hit a walk-off homer and came up and s signed a little mini fan bat, whatever you call those little tiny bats from the gift store. And he still has it in his room. And he now he gets to see Connor Griffin on TV. He's like, I remember when he signed that and he had to walk off homer. Like those are the moments that that are created throughout the country in minor league baseball. And and I hope fans continue to lean into it and the attendance can kind of bounce back no matter what compared to the big league side. So you get in some of those little minor league towns, like there's just some nostalgia there and and the guys that are coming through, no matter to me, whether you're on the 40 men rush or not, like you're still the really best at what you do in the country. And I think that the quality of minor league baseball is probably ticked up just from the quality of players. And they're putting a great product out there. So I hope we get to see both of them and we continue to have the fan attendance and we continue to have the the love of baseball grow on both sides, minor league and big

11:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): league. Yeah,

11:56Nolan Alexander: I hope so too. And Jeremy, you had said that

11:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

11:59Nolan Alexander: can't make a firm prediction right now and it's kind of far off. What's the latest proposal that's out there at the time of this recording? It's Wednesday, November fourth, so early November. What's the latest out there and and what sort of stock are you putting into the recent headlines?

12:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Personally, I don't put a ton of stock in what the owners are throwing out there in early November. I'm not speaking for them. Uh this is just kind of my opinion, but I think what they're throwing out there is is almost been crumpled up and thrown in the trash can at this point. I don't think that they're real serious negotiations and they're not taken that way. It almost seems like more media posturing from my angle than it does. But $258 million cap, a $180 million floor. So I mean if you kind of look at that right now, if that were to be approved, like you have 12 teams that are below that $180 million floor. And I think you have eight that are above the cap. Like it's a lot of restructuring that would have to happen in baseball. And have having sat in union meetings and having listened to Mike Wiener talk and Tony Clark and those guys that lead those, and I like I just hope it doesn't turn into something where it tarnishes what the fans love about baseball. We've seen it before, but I can't see any of these proposals that the owners are throwing out there and honestly taking them seriously right now. I get why they're doing it. I understand that that's part of how negotiations go, but I think there'll be a point a in time of when we get into the new year where both sides really roll up their sleeves and hopefully both sides roll up their sleeves and really try to get a deal done right now. But to me at this point, these are kind of just,

13:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): hey,

13:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): let's toss this out in the media and see if we can get a reaction to

13:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.

13:29Nolan Alexander: Chase, you kind of feel the same way at this point here in early November. Nothing that oh goodness, we're gonna take this and and run with it and the tides are shifting back and forth right now. Just

13:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): kind

13:39Nolan Alexander: of wait and continue to get trusted information as it comes

13:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): out.

13:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Absolutely. The more information we can gather, the better, obviously. And to Jeremy's point, as we get closer to not only the deadline, I think as we get closer to a season coming upon us, that's when the actual negotiations will will start. Because yeah, the last offer that was thrown out, not that it was laughable, but this being that okay for the salary cap to be pushed back one year that's still the whole deal weighs on the fact that there is going to be a salary cap at some point so that's obviously the stance of players saying no chance and that's the part of the owner saying okay let's try to slip that in it's not going to happen that way. So again this is the beginning stages of what seems like a little bit of a longer stretch here but with the momentum that baseball has right now getting closer and closer to the season season, I don't think anybody wants to lose games. So I think that'll kind of be the pressing part that we'll get a deal together.

14:36Nolan Alexander: And during that stretch, we'll be with you here on ahead in the count. Chase Murray, Jeremy Hermito with us. And as we wrap this one up, I'm not gonna hit you with a trivia like how we did in our last episode, but coming up on Thanksgiving,

14:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what are

14:50Nolan Alexander: you gentlemen thinking? thankful for?

14:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's

14:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): a great one. I'm thankful for my wife, my dog, my family, friends, co-workers, and uh the ability to go see my family in northern uh Kentucky for Thanksgiving. That'll be a lot of fun and get together with them. Always love getting up there and getting all the uh extended family together, watch some football and eat some good food.

15:11Nolan Alexander: You're not thankful for your Bengals bangles this year?

15:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Not at

15:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all. How

15:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): about you, Jeremy?

15:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That

15:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): is a good question. I kind of echo a little bit what Chase said. Uh a friends, family. Like I think you're thankful for the health of the majority of people in my close circle. I'm thankful for just having a blessed opportunity to be in a position that we are to help guys and have our family close to it and everything that we do. It's like just all around, honestly, I'm thankful for the gifts that the Lord has given me and allowing me to go on in life and hopefully give back some and do well in his name.

15:44Nolan Alexander: Very well said, guys. I'm thankful for y'all. Thank you for joining us today on Ahead in the Count.

15:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank

15:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you, Nolan.

15:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Thank you, Nolan.

15:51Nolan Alexander: This has been Ahead in the Count from BIP Wealth. We hope you enjoy today's episode and learn something new. If you'd like to get in touch with a member of today's show, click the show note. notes for their contact info. Or visit bipwealth.com. I'm Nolan Alexander and thanks for listening.

16:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

16:20Nolan Alexander: opinions in the preceding commentary as of June 16th, sixteenth, subject to change. Provided for informational purposes only. Specific investments may not be suitable for all listeners, and no offer or recommendation of any investment or investing strategy is intended or implied by your choosing to listen to this podcast. Some information was obtained from third-party sources we consider reliable, but we do not guarantee the facts cited are accurate or complete. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. All investments involve risks, including loss of principle. This podcast is not intended to be relied upon as a forecast or investment advice regarding a particular investment or the markets in general, nor is it intended to predict or depict performance of any investment. We may execute transactions and securities that may not be consistent with what is mentioned here. Investors should consult their financial advisor on the strategy best for them. Listeners should seek tax advice based under particular circumstances. for an independent tax advisor, as tax laws are subject to interpretation, legislative change, and unique to every specific taxpayer's particular set of facts and circumstances.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights