Homeowners return to insolvency as pre-con condo shortfalls and rate hikes erode equity
Summary
Doug Hoyes and Scott Terrio discuss a sharp rise in homeowners filing for bankruptcy or proposals, jumping from 1.6% in 2022 to 11% in 2026. Terrio identifies three primary drivers: pre-construction condo appraisal shortfalls, cash-flow negative investment properties, and leveraged primary residences. Developers are increasingly litigating against buyers who cannot close, while co-signers face joint and several liability for full mortgage debts. The speakers warn that delaying insolvency advice exacerbates financial entanglements and that outcomes depend on individual circumstances rather than fixed percentages.
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 1:37
Introduction and Host Banter
Doug Hoyes introduces Scott Terrio, Manager of Consumer Insolvency at Hoyes Michalos, to discuss why homeowners are returning for debt help. The hosts exchange pleasantries and acknowledge the new studio setup.
- 1:37 – 3:03
Homeownership in Insolvency Statistics
Doug Hoyes presents data showing the percentage of his clients filing for consumer proposals or bankruptcy who own a home. This figure dropped from ~29% in 2011 to 1.6% in 2022, but has risen to ~11% in 2026. He also mentions an unreleased 'real estate adjacent' index that is 30% higher than the base homeowners index.
- 3:03 – 5:14
Reasons for Return to Insolvency
Scott Terrio explains that homeowners stopped calling during the housing boom (2020-2022) due to rising equity but are returning now. He cites interest rate hikes from 2022-2023 as a key factor that changed sentiment and made debt unmanageable via home equity.
- 5:14 – 8:24
Scenario 1: Pre-Construction Condo Shortfalls
Terrio describes the 'pre-con condo disaster' where buyers signed agreements years ago at high prices. Upon completion, units appraise for less than the purchase price, causing banks to refuse full financing. Buyers face losing deposits and facing lawsuits from developers for breach of contract.
- 8:24 – 12:29
Developer Litigation Strategies
Developers are increasingly suing buyers for shortfalls using court-ordered appraisals rather than waiting for actual resale. Developers may also choose to rent out unsold units themselves or sell them in bulk to investors to crystallize losses, while still pursuing legal action against defaulting buyers.
- 12:29 – 19:43
Scenario 2: Cash-Flow Negative Investment Properties
Terrio identifies a trend of non-professional landlords buying investment condos in 2020-2022 using borrowed funds and co-signers. These properties are now cash-flow negative due to lower rents and higher costs, with negative equity, leaving owners with no equity and monthly losses.
- 19:43 – 23:12
Scenario 3: Leveraging Primary Residence for Investments
Older homeowners (60s) who owned homes for decades leveraged their equity to buy investment properties during the late boom. When prices fell, they lost significant equity in their primary residence while holding underwater investment assets, creating a severe debt trap.
- 23:12 – 24:33
Unexpected Pre-Construction Closing Costs
Scott Terrio describes a scenario where a buyer of a pre-construction condo faced unexpected closing costs of $19,000-$21,000 four years after purchase. These costs included interim occupancy fees, development charges, utility connections, and HST on investment purchases, which were not fully appreciated by the buyer until closing.
- 24:33 – 26:25
High-Cost Financing for Closing Costs
To cover the unexpected closing costs, a homeowner took a $16,000 loan from an installment lender at 33.4% interest and used remaining credit on an unsecured line of credit. This significantly increased the homeowner's monthly debt servicing costs, compounding existing unsecured debt and tax debt.
- 26:25 – 28:08
Occupancy Costs Between Keys and Registration
Doug Hoyes explains that buyers may need to pay occupancy costs to the builder between receiving keys and the building's official registration. These costs, which can be $4,000-$5,000 per month for two to three months, are effectively rent paid to the builder and are often underestimated by buyers.
- 28:08 – 33:08
Joint and Several Liability in Co-Signing
Terrio highlights the legal concept of joint and several liability, where a co-signer (e.g., a parent owning 1% of a property) is 100% liable for the entire mortgage debt if the primary borrower defaults. This risk is often misunderstood by those who co-sign to help family members qualify for mortgages.
- 33:08 – 34:15
Insolvency Outcomes Vary by Case
Terrio notes that insolvency outcomes are not fixed percentages (e.g., paying 30% of debts) but depend on individual circumstances, income, and assets. Licensed Insolvency Trustees interpret the rules to determine the best exit strategy, which may involve a proposal or bankruptcy.
- 34:15 – 38:42
Importance of Early Intervention
Both speakers emphasize that debt problems do not resolve themselves and that early intervention is critical. Terrio states it is harder to undo bad moves than to prevent them, and delaying advice often leads to more complex financial entanglements.
Claims worth verifying
In 2011, 29% of Hoyes Michalos clients filing for consumer proposal or bankruptcy owned a home.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:50
How to verify: Review Hoyes Michalos internal client statistics or public reports from the firm for the year 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In 2022, the percentage of clients owning a home dropped to 1.6%, with August 2022 being zero.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·2:15
How to verify: Review Hoyes Michalos internal client statistics or public reports from the firm for the year 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In 2026, the percentage of clients owning a home is around 11%.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·2:26
How to verify: Review Hoyes Michalos internal client statistics or public reports from the firm for the year 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Interest rates increased eight to ten times between February 2020 and summer/September 2023.
Scott Terrio ·4:17
How to verify: Check Bank of Canada overnight rate history from February 2026 to September 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Pre-construction condos take three to five years to build.
Scott Terrio ·5:54
How to verify: Review standard construction timelines for residential developments in Toronto/GTA via municipal building permits or industry reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Developers are using court-ordered appraisals to crystallize losses rather than waiting for resale.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·9:01
How to verify: Search Ontario Superior Court of Justice case law for pre-construction condo breach of contract rulings involving appraisals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Doug Hoyes bought a townhouse in 1989 and sold it seven years later for a 10% loss.
Scott Terrio ·17:56
How to verify: Verify Doug Hoyes' personal investment history via his published books or interviews. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The 'real estate adjacent' index is 30% higher than the base homeowners index.
Doug Hoyes ·2:47
How to verify: Request the specific methodology and data from Hoyes Michalos, as the index is unreleased. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Installment loans for closing costs can have interest rates around 33.4%.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·24:49
How to verify: Check provincial consumer protection agencies or financial regulatory bodies for average interest rates on short-term installment loans; review lender disclosures for high-cost credit products. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Occupancy costs for pre-construction condos can be $4,000-$5,000 per month for 2-3 months between key possession and registration.
Scott Terrio ·26:46
How to verify: Review pre-construction purchase agreements for occupancy fee clauses; consult real estate forums or legal guides on Canadian pre-construction purchases for typical cost ranges. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Joint and several liability means a co-signer is 100% liable for the entire mortgage debt, regardless of equity ownership percentage.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·28:24
How to verify: Consult provincial real estate law resources or legal textbooks on joint and several liability in mortgage contracts; review standard mortgage forms for liability clauses. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Insolvency outcomes are not fixed percentages (e.g., 30% of debts) but vary based on individual circumstances, income, and assets.
Scott Terrio ·33:27
How to verify: Review the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) and guidelines from Licensed Insolvency Trustees; consult case studies or official insolvency statistics for outcome variations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Pre-construction condo buyers may face unexpected closing costs four years after purchase.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·23:21
How to verify: Review pre-construction purchase agreements for clauses detailing closing costs; consult provincial real estate regulatory bodies for typical fee structures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Homeowners may use home equity to cover mortgage payments when rental income is insufficient.
Scott Terrio ·21:52
How to verify: Review personal financial case studies or insolvency filings involving rental property owners; consult real estate investment forums for common strategies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-21 through 2026-11-21. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDo your own research
- Verify the Hoyes Michalos client demographic data by reviewing their annual reports or public statements on homeowner insolvency trends.
- Check current pre-construction condo completion timelines and appraisal standards in major Canadian markets like Toronto or Vancouver.
- Review provincial laws regarding 'joint and several liability' for mortgage co-signers to understand legal exposure.
- Research typical closing costs for pre-construction units, including development charges, utility connections, and HST rules for investment properties.
- Analyze current occupancy fee structures charged by major developers during the period between key possession and title registration.
- Compare current mortgage interest rates against 2020-2022 lows to assess the impact on cash-flow negative investment properties.
- Look for recent court cases involving developer litigation against pre-construction buyers for breach of contract.
- Consult a Licensed Insolvency Trustee to understand how individual income and asset profiles affect proposal vs. bankruptcy outcomes.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Doug Hoyes: If you own a home and you're behind on debt, you used to have an exit. That exit is closing. Scott Terrio is here. Let's begin.
0:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
0:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): is Debt Free and 30. Here's your host, Doug Hoys.
0:18Doug Hoyes: Scott Terrio is our manager of consumer insolvency here at Hoys Boys. Michael is dealing mostly with clients in the GTA, Toronto, and Etobicoke, but he talks to people from all around the province. So today we're going to tap into that expertise to discuss what's happening with homeowners in debt. So, Scott, welcome back and welcome to the new studio.
0:37Scott Terrio: It's great. It really is fabulous. And the term expertise is a little is added pressure. I didn't read
0:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it. Well, it was
0:43Doug Hoyes: it's in my script.
0:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I read it exactly as you
0:45Doug Hoyes: wrote
0:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it for me. So I
0:47Scott Terrio: uh I I I like to avoid that because then I have to say something smart about
0:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it. but the
0:51Scott Terrio: odds of that are clear.
0:52Doug Hoyes: We'll edit all the other stuff out if we don't have to. So you were last on the big podcast here on episode 586 about a year ago, and we talked about home equity and HELOCs and what your pal Ron Butler calls dog crate condos. Yes. And here's why you're here. For most of the last decade, homeowners in financial trouble didn't call us. You know this. You've been here for many years. They didn't need to. They're calling again today. So today, why they stopped calling, why they're back, who's calling, and what you can do if you're one of them. That includes the part almost nobody understands what happens when the bank sells your house, and that isn't enough.
1:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
1:29Doug Hoyes: let's start there. They're calling again.
1:32Scott Terrio: Yes.
1:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:32Doug Hoyes: I'm gonna going get to you to tell me some some uh you know what you're seeing on the ground, but first let me give you some numbers.
1:39Scott Terrio: Sure.
1:40Doug Hoyes: The exit I opened with is home equity. So for more than twenty years, and we've tracked this how many people filing a consumer proposal or bankruptcy with us own a home? We call it the Hoys
1:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Michaelist
1:51Doug Hoyes: homeowners
1:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): bankruptcy.
1:52Scott Terrio: People are highly interested in that.
1:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's a very
1:54Doug Hoyes: interesting one.
1:55Scott Terrio: It's such a simple thing.
1:56Doug Hoyes: Yeah, because it is the percentage of our clients on the day they file who own a home. So in 2011 for the year, it was around 29%. It got up to about a third at part partly during in part for part of the year. So nearly three in ten. Yeah. By 2022, it was 1.6%.
2:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
2:15Scott Terrio: And there was one month where it was zero.
2:17Doug Hoyes: Zero. August of twenty twenty-two, it was zero. Now we are back to around give or take eleven percent this year.
2:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
2:27Doug Hoyes: so we're kind of back to one in nine. And I've actually got a separate index which I have not released yet that is real estate adjacent. So not just people who own a home, but people who used to own a home and it got foreclosed, or maybe they work in the real estate agent or whatever. And that index is about thirty 30% percent higher than the base
2:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one. So
2:49Doug Hoyes: instead of
2:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
2:50Scott Terrio: thought meant. it meant like you lived next to a homeowner.
2:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, but that would be a good good proximal
2:56Scott Terrio: homeowners index.
2:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
2:57Doug Hoyes: the point is we are seeing a lot more people with um real estate related issues.
3:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
3:03Doug Hoyes: you're on the front lines. I would like you to give us just off the top of your head, what are the the common scenarios you're seeing, Yeah.
3:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
3:13Doug Hoyes: then we'll delve into them.
3:14Scott Terrio: Yeah. So it's we're in uh November 2026 now, and I'd say for about a year, maybe a year and a half, we've had homeowners calling us regularly. That's my in my in my where I work anyway, so um, which is GTA largely. So um yeah, there was almost, you know, very, very few, almost no homeowners that we spoke to for a very long time there, and that was because of the housing boom. As you said, when house prices are going up twenty percent all the time and people that are are swimming in home equity, they don't need us for very much. Exactly. Um, because they, as you mentioned, they have off ramps, you know,
3:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right
3:51Scott Terrio: from the debt highway, I guess. Um yeah,
3:53Doug Hoyes: my credit cards went up fifty thousand dollars, but my house went up two hundred thousand dollars yesterday.
3:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. I
3:58Doug Hoyes: refinance refinanced something.
3:59Scott Terrio: Yeah, I either I either pay it off by cashing something out or I refinance or whatever, so they did all kinds of things that they didn't need us. Now they need us because of a number of things. From 2022 to 2023, interest rates went up ten times, I think, over that, or eight. I
4:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): forget how
4:17Scott Terrio: many.
4:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Somebody will
4:18Scott Terrio: know that.
4:18Doug Hoyes: They they were essentially zero.
4:20Scott Terrio: Yeah, and they just went up a little bit, a little bit, a little bit. I think it was eight or ten increases from February 2020. twenty twenty-two to to summer or September twenty twenty three. So I mentioned that because you had said, you know, our zero month, our zero bankruptcy homeowners bankruptcy index percentage month was August twenty twenty
4:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): two.
4:38Doug Hoyes: August twenty twenty two.
4:39Scott Terrio: Two, right. Yeah. So that yeah, and so uh they'd probably had about four or five increases under their belt by that point, or maybe three. Uh but the the mentality changed, right? Like Canada's such a housing. sensitive country. It's
4:52Doug Hoyes: our only industry.
4:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's all we do here.
4:54Scott Terrio: We we sell each other homes. Um and so what happened was the sentiment at from twenty twenty two to twenty twenty twenty three just kind of went like this. And so you know then you get into the actual numbers and problems where people's debt that's accumulated, unsecured debt, um, gets to be problematic and they can't solve it via their host. So they're calling us. And what I'm seeing, and what I'm sure you're seeing, and our other people are seeing, are a few things. Number one, and the big one is the pre construction condo uh disaster, I would call it. Um so this is just for background this is people who bought a a condo that wasn't built. So we're putting up a condo, and I they put a nice sales. center, a little sales center built there. Usually it's next door across the street or somewhere. And there's going to be a building here someday. And they sell a bunch of units. They're going to sell all the units in the condo so that they can get their macro financing to put the the development together. Okay, great. Condos take three, four, five years to build something like that, depending on how big they are and if there's a labor shortage or whatever. So people bought people signed a purchase agreement. So I'm gonna buy this condo when it's built for this much money. Okay, great. So then in the intervening four years, the problem is from that era
6:13of 2020, 2021, 2022 or so, people went and bought a whole lot of those right then. Well, now they're getting built. Um and when they complete, the people can't close them because the value went from here. to here. So the bank is not going to give you $700,000 for something that's worth $500.
6:31Doug Hoyes: Right. I paid a I paid a million bucks for it.
6:33Scott Terrio: Yeah.
6:34Doug Hoyes: And it it praises out at $700,000.
6:36Scott Terrio: That's a big problem.
6:37Doug Hoyes: And we're not just making up numbers. You and I have seen
6:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): every day.
6:41Doug Hoyes: Exactly that
6:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): every day.
6:42Doug Hoyes: So I go to the bank and I say, Hey, can you I I put a 10% down payment down. Yeah. So I only need 900,000. And the bank
6:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): goes,
6:48Doug Hoyes: it's worth 700,000. seven hundred thousand.
6:49Scott Terrio: Yeah. Or I put 20% twenty down percent payment.
6:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. So you're
6:52Doug Hoyes: still not you're still short.
6:53Scott Terrio: Yeah. And so so this is generally that's what we're I'm seeing tons of that. Right. And I mean, I again I work in the GTA m primarily, so for me, that's a lot I guess it's a lot higher um instances of of of that happening. But that's the big one right now. And the problem with that is if you can't close, number one, you've given your deposit, and either it was a one one-time time deposit or it's one of these staggered ones where it's I give you twenty thousand today, I've signed the agreement. In thirty days, sixty days, ninety, a hundred and twenty, there's four more and they're all different amounts. Yep. And then there's one on closing usually, unless you've given them the whole deposit at the at the one time. Um and so people are, you know, in the intervening four years or whatever, while those this things being built, they've paid one, two, three, four of these, or they've given them the whole thing. But the sometimes they don't pay the last. one or two, right? Because now they know I'm not closing. I'm not giving you 40 grand when I know I can't close the the the property. So I've lost all this deposit money. Um, and now the developers are starting to say, Hey, we're going to sue you because you didn't. Where's my word here? It's breach of contract. So you were you were gonna buy this place for 700,000, it's now worth 500. That's not my problem. It's your probable. It is the developer's problem. And so therefore they're starting to get you know lawyers' letters and lawsuits and that kind of thing. And so we're seeing a ton of that.
8:11Doug Hoyes: Yeah. Yeah. And I guess why don't we just skip to the practical advice section of the show here, which we normally do at the end. So when someone tells you about their pre-con problem,
8:22Scott Terrio: Yeah.
8:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
8:23Doug Hoyes: do you tell them?
8:24Scott Terrio: Well, so uh yeah, so you either
8:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
8:27Scott Terrio: if you're getting sued, then okay, what what the developer is saying is I'm suing you for you know a huge amount of money. Um it it's we're s this is still playing out.
8:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So we're
8:38Scott Terrio: we're still learning this stuff
8:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as
8:39Scott Terrio: recently as last week,
8:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): actually.
8:41Scott Terrio: Um in terms of the stuff that you had discovered, which was okay, we used to think that um the the th we can just estimate a shortfall and and the and the and and the developer will
8:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
8:55Doug Hoyes: yeah. The the the typical approach was okay, wait till the developer sells it to somebody else. Yes
9:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
9:01Doug Hoyes: now they know how much they've lost.
9:03Scott Terrio: Yeah. So instead of waiting for an actual sale, now the developers can go to court and get an appraisal that it's worth now this much instead of this much.
9:11Doug Hoyes: Yeah. And to to illustrate the scope of this problem, you take that typical building you're talking about. Let's say it's a hundred units.
9:18Scott Terrio: Yeah.
9:18Doug Hoyes: Okay. And
9:20Scott Terrio: generously, it's usually like
9:22Doug Hoyes: well, I mean, it could be a super tall building, but it could
9:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be twenty units. I don't want to
9:25Scott Terrio: Torontoize this too
9:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): much. It's
9:27Scott Terrio: like, yeah, it's so give a hundred.
9:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
9:28Doug Hoyes: let's say it's a hundred units, and let's say they were a million dollars each. Yeah. And everybody's put down their ten 10%, percent, but the the units are now worth seven $700,000. hundred thousand.
9:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
9:37Doug Hoyes: So let's say that four 40% of the buyers can't close.
9:40Scott Terrio: Yeah. And that's typical.
9:42Doug Hoyes: That's not unusual.
9:43Scott Terrio: Because I ask people when they calling what do you know about the building, right? Because they're all talking. They're talking to agents,
9:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they're talking
9:50Scott Terrio: to the developer, they're talking to the developer's lawyer. I mean, they're hearing things. And yeah, usually it's like 30% of the building is empty
9:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or 40. Or forty is not going to be. Well,
9:58Scott Terrio: think about that. You're a developer who's putting together this multi-year, multi multi-hundred hundred million. dollar place, your financing's on the line because these guys aren't closing,
10:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right?
10:07Scott Terrio: So yes.
10:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, the builder might have
10:09Doug Hoyes: borrowed 50 or 100 million dollars from the bank.
10:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
10:12Scott Terrio: the bank's upset.
10:13Doug Hoyes: And the builder can't close because he's not getting
10:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all the
10:15Doug Hoyes: money because you can't close.
10:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
10:17Doug Hoyes: what we used to say is okay, well, the builder has to sell the unit, so he can't sell it to you because you can't close. So he'll
10:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): sell
10:23Doug Hoyes: it to someone else. But if he's got 40 units, he's not going to sell all 40 units of in one day.
10:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No,
10:27Scott Terrio: and and we've had developers who actually said, I don't want to flood the market.
10:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No. Like
10:31Scott Terrio: because all the developers do that.
10:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
10:33Scott Terrio: Crisis go like this.
10:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And they're already a seven hundred
10:35Doug Hoyes: thousand dollar unit is worth three hundred thousand.
10:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Instead of five hundred. Yeah, it
10:38Doug Hoyes: gets totally way closer.
10:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
10:39Scott Terrio: So they're all they're all terrified to to to list all these things for a stupidly low amount. Uh number one, it won't get them their financing in their macro financing. And but also it just it it's just gonna kill prices everywhere.
10:52Doug Hoyes: Right. So so what the developer can do is okay, well, I'll sell one at a time. It might be two years before I get around to selling your unit. Okay, great, talk to you in two years. Right. Or they can go to, I don't know, BlackRock or whoever the big rich guys are and say, look, why don't you buy all 40 and you can turn them into rentals? To
11:09Scott Terrio: Costco.
11:10Doug Hoyes: Costco, there
11:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you go. Like buying like buying forty 40 cases of toilet paper. We'll
11:14Doug Hoyes: buy it and in bulk. Except
11:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's condos.
11:16Doug Hoyes: Yeah. And so instead of you know selling them for 700,000, we'll sell them to you for 550. But at least we've crystallized our loss. But then the newest thing we're seeing is the developers are going, Well, we don't even want to do that. We're gonna put we're gonna rent them out ourselves. Yep.
11:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
11:30Doug Hoyes: know, and then three or four years from now, when the market recovers, we'll be able to sell them. In the meantime,
11:36Scott Terrio: still sue you.
11:37Doug Hoyes: Well, we're still you're gonna we're sue going you. to but what we're going to do is get an appraiser or evaluator to say, okay, if
11:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
11:42Doug Hoyes: rent is this much, then the the unit is worth that much. Therefore, we can crystallize our loss. And that's actually bizarrely a good outcome for both the builder and the purchaser because like the builder's not getting all their money, but maybe instead of depressing the price to 500,000, it appraises at six. Yeah. And so they're only suing you. for slightly less of a shortfall. Yeah. The point is, you can no longer take my advice that I used to give, which is, oh, well, just wait until
12:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
12:12Doug Hoyes: gets there. Yeah. Once the lawsuit starts, the clock is ticking, and it's something you got to deal with. So okay. So that's pre-cons. It's not a pretty situation. We'll be talking about this for for years and years. Now you said you had about four different kind of scenarios. So pre-con is one. Yes.
12:29Scott Terrio: So
12:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what's number two? So
12:30Scott Terrio: I'm trying to give people an idea of what are the what are the situations that people are calling us with who are homeowners. Okay. So one of them which well I I hadn't even thought of uh before before people had started calling us with who are homeowners again was someone who rents their own place but bought an investment property. Okay. That one I didn't see coming. Um so in other words, I rent where I live and I've rented where I've lived for a long time, but I wanted to get in the housing market in late in the boom. Again, this is a 2020, 2021, 2022 phenomenon mostly. Uh and I went and I I I borrowed everything I could from everyone I know or whatever, and my savings and I I don't know, my unsecured lines of credit, my dad gave me some money, whatever. Um and I got maybe three or four people on on the mortgage and the title in order to get qualified to buy this rental property. Okay. And then the rental property has gone sideways. Yep. So you know none of these people are professional landlords, of course. They're just doing it and winging it. Uh and so then what has happened of course is that So you've had all kinds of situations where you know their tenant paid for a year and then stopped or left and then rent price prices mean time went down. So now my mortgage payment is, I don't know, twenty five hundred, and I'm getting instead of getting twenty one hundred, I'm getting seventeen hundred or or maybe not that dramatic. But
13:50even if it's a few hundred bucks and you're tight and there's inflation and all these things are pressurizing your monthly budget, all of a sudden you're getting squeezed over a two two-year year period and you're just losing money every year. month.
14:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
14:01Doug Hoyes: and every single and I'm making a statement here that is not entirely true, but let's pretend it's true. Every single landlord for the last 15 years who has rented out a condo has lost money every month because the mortgage payment, property taxes, condo fees are always higher than what the rent is. Yep. Now, if you had a 50% down payment, what I said is not true, but in general, that's the way it worked. And the landlord is like, yeah, but I don't care. I'm losing $1,000 a month on a cash flow basis, but the condo's going up in value $5,000 a
14:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): month.
14:33Doug Hoyes: So I'm going to sell and get out. Well, now what you're describing is the the exact opposite.
14:37Scott Terrio: Well, so their cash flow negative and
14:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): their
14:39Scott Terrio: balance sheet are underwater, right?
14:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Your income
14:41Doug Hoyes: statement and your balance sheet
14:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is negative. So
14:43Scott Terrio: you're screwed on both your income statement and your balance sheet now. Um well
14:46Doug Hoyes: just on that point, because someone's watching this going, okay, that sounds crazy. Why? would someone buy a property and not live in it? Well, the answer is what they bought was a tiny condo. Yeah, these
14:57Scott Terrio: are
14:58Doug Hoyes: 450 square feet. Yeah,
14:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm not a multiplex.
15:01Doug Hoyes: No, this is purely as an investment. I'm gonna keep living with my family, I'm gonna keep renting whatever.
15:06Scott Terrio: Yeah, and and someone else is gonna pay them my mortgage on that house and someday I'll I'll
15:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): own a
15:11Scott Terrio: house that's worth half a million bucks free and clear.
15:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So at the time it
15:14Doug Hoyes: made sense. now
15:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah these
15:16Scott Terrio: decisions were all made when this stuff was happening.
15:19Doug Hoyes: House prices always go up
15:20Scott Terrio: nobody nobody did this with the scenario we're seeing now. It it happened over the intervening four years or whatever. So um so the sentiment at the time was sensible. Okay, maybe they went to a real estate seminar, okay, okay and bought
15:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): some crypto while
15:33Scott Terrio: they were there. But like but now things have changed dramatically and they're caught in this, right? So another another scenario,
15:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
15:41Scott Terrio: this one's very common right now.
15:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well, and just so
15:43Doug Hoyes: just to finish that scenario, then our advice on that is kind of the same as in scenario one in number one, it's like there's no good answer here for you, dude.
15:51Scott Terrio: Well, our advice on that one is frankly commonly cut and run.
15:55Doug Hoyes: Right.
15:56Scott Terrio: Like like there's no there's negative equity, sometimes substantial. Okay, so your house is the the the reverse. investment property is not worth anything, you're paying through the nose for it because your rent is underwater on a cash flow monthly basis. And so what's there? Yeah, right. And and and the other thing about this, and when I tell people that, and I'm sure you know this, they say, Well, I'll I'll I'll list it and sell it then and I'll just get out. Right. You don't why?
16:22Doug Hoyes: Yeah.
16:22Scott Terrio: Let let like walk away from it because if it's if it's negative equity in the first place, you're not making any money off it. Yeah. It's a headache to sell it. Um and
16:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
16:32Scott Terrio: don't I don't think with the market the way it is, um, like uh people say, Well, if I sell it, I'll get more for it. Well, you'll get what the market will give you. And at this point, you know, if you let it go to the bank, people people think, Well, the bank's gonna dump it. Well, no, the bank is gonna sell it for what the market's gonna give them. They might go a little lower, but at this point, if it's a hundred grand
16:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
16:53Scott Terrio: a hundred and twenty grand,
16:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what's
16:54Doug Hoyes: the difference?
16:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What
16:55Scott Terrio: are you doing, right?
16:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
16:56Doug Hoyes: and I I agree with you. Our advice is crunch the numbers. And if there's negative two hundred thousand in equity and
17:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're
17:02Doug Hoyes: bleeding two thousand dollars a month, unless you think the real estate market is gonna pick up tomorrow, then you And might as well walk away. Now, of course, it means you're gonna lose whatever you put into it and you're probably
17:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): talking
17:15Doug Hoyes: to us about a proposal or a bankruptcy.
17:17Scott Terrio: For sure. But
17:18Doug Hoyes: you know,
17:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
17:18Scott Terrio: you're already in in trouble.
17:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): How
17:21Scott Terrio: many years is it gonna be that you're gonna do this until that comes back? Right. No one knows that. Right. And but but all the sentiment right now is it's gonna be a while
17:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because
17:29Scott Terrio: people are comparing this to the nineties, where it was like a like a slow burn, right? It
17:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was just
17:34Scott Terrio: like really bad for a long time. It wasn't dramatically bad.
17:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
17:37Scott Terrio: what we've seen is it house prices have already gone like this. I don't think they're gonna go like this, but they're probably just gonna level out at a at a kind of a crappy level for a while.
17:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well, and
17:46Doug Hoyes: and I was alive during the nineteen nineties.
17:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, me too.
17:49Doug Hoyes: Um and I bought my first I've told this story a thousand times, but I bought my a townhouse in nineteen eighty nine on the north end of Toronto.
17:56Scott Terrio: Great move.
17:56Doug Hoyes: Great move. Seven years later, I sold it for a ten percent loss.
18:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Seven years later. That's what I'm talking
18:02Scott Terrio: about. here.
18:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
18:03Scott Terrio: like like that could be what
18:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this dude is facing, right?
18:06Scott Terrio: And so, okay, if you want to do that, keep doing it.
18:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
18:10Scott Terrio: I think we're a restructuring business.
18:13Doug Hoyes: Yeah.
18:13Scott Terrio: Like you called us because you have a major debt problem. Um, and so uh this is your chance to to kind of start clean your life up. It might take you four or five years, but you will come out of it with no debt and with none of the these anchor assets on on
18:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): your on your books. They have eighty to a hundred grand and
18:35Scott Terrio: credit card, line of credit, tax debt, whatever. Um, you know, in this case that I just told you about is the guy's actually self employed too, so he's got a ton of tax debt too. So, dude, just restructure your life, right?
18:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Get
18:47Scott Terrio: get you made some moves that weren't your fault. The market didn't do what you thought it was going to do. Nobody saw that coming. So okay, great. But now get yourself set up
18:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to to to
18:57Scott Terrio: fight again, right?
18:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
18:58Doug Hoyes: And you're right. It's
19:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): gonna take you five or
19:03Doug Hoyes: at least
19:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be
19:04Doug Hoyes: still in the same boat.
19:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
19:05Doug Hoyes: So better to start over. Yeah.
19:07Scott Terrio: Okay.
19:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So the
19:07Scott Terrio: discussion at that point is like make a dis make a hard decision or or or
19:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): keep doing this. difficult
19:13Doug Hoyes: decisions.
19:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
19:13Doug Hoyes: worked hard. I own it. but
19:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): sometimes like when you when you
19:17Scott Terrio: tell people that they might get back to you in three months,
19:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right?
19:20Scott Terrio: Because that's normal, right? Like this is a big decision. Okay, so uh he's got to make all there's all these moving parts. And so we say, Well, you know what, think about that. And
19:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): then if you have
19:29Scott Terrio: questions, email me. We usually like typically what happens is we'll answer questions over the course of a month or two, things get sorted out, you end up funneling everything down into a decision, right?
19:39Doug Hoyes: And that's just the way it works. So okay, so what is item number three on your list?
19:43Scott Terrio: Okay, so
19:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): a lot of older people, let's say in their 60s,
19:48Doug Hoyes: okay. I'm 62, so I wouldn't
19:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): call that
19:50Doug Hoyes: old. Okay.
19:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So Doug is
19:51Scott Terrio: an older person.
19:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Just
19:53Scott Terrio: I'm going on
19:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): video record here for that.
19:55Scott Terrio: Sorry.
19:56Doug Hoyes: That's okay. I'm not offended.
19:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
19:57Scott Terrio: I regret that.
19:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I know
19:58Doug Hoyes: I'm old.
19:59Scott Terrio: Sean can maybe edit that.
20:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
20:00Scott Terrio: um so they own their house. that they've owned for a long time. A long time, 20, 30 years. And that house at some point had substantial equity because if they hadn't, you know, re-leveraged or refinanced along the way and then the housing boom hit, well,
20:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
20:15Scott Terrio: the place should be easily paid
20:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): off. So
20:18Scott Terrio: what but what they've been doing, or what they what I've been seeing, is people who have been longtime homeowners and maybe cottage owners too. have gone and bought investment properties. And so during the boom, um, and again late in the boom, 2021, 22, that's the one that's typically the what we're seeing in terms of time frame. They went and bought an investment property, leveraging their equity, you know, involving family members or whatever it with all good intentions.
20:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right?
20:44Scott Terrio: Okay, we're gonna buy this, and again, there's someone's gonna pay my mortgage
20:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
20:48Scott Terrio: us, and it's someday, you know, my two sons will have. that property uh free and clear and great. We did
20:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a great
20:54Scott Terrio: move and uh we're dead
20:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): now,
20:55Scott Terrio: but everybody's in good shape. So but the problem is again, the market took over and had something to say about that. And so, you know, prices went down, uh, their home price went down. So now what they did is they had they had their home with all this equity, but over time to to to get the investment property they leveraged that equity. Okay, so now they have maybe half the equity in the house that they did before. Um, and then things started to fall apart. So they, you know, they had a tenant for a while in that place, and then that tenant left again. And this is so typical. Like, like I said, I know I said that before, but that's because I see it all the time. And then they had another tenant who stopped paying them
21:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for two.
21:39Scott Terrio: years. And it's hard to get rid of somebody. Like it's hard to
21:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): evict someone quickly.
21:42Scott Terrio: Right. It takes time. Um, and so but the the whole time that is happening, you're having to pay that mortgage payment, three thousand one month or whatever, over two years is
21:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a lot of money.
21:52Scott Terrio: And so they're going back and they're sometimes using their house to do it because they can't do it out of cash flow. So they're eroding their own equity. Meanwhile, this property they bought has gone down 30% in value. And one of the tenants wrecked the place. And so they had to go in and they had to once they got the guy out, um, they had to go in and renovate. And he was in the early stages of starting to grow up.
22:13Doug Hoyes: Oh, good.
22:14Scott Terrio: And this is on the 20th floor of a building. Like
22:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can you
22:16Doug Hoyes: imagine?
22:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
22:17Scott Terrio: Anyway, nightmare. But the point is they were doing good. Uh they went to do something else. Now they're not doing so good. So uh I think people took advantage of having these long time properties and all this equity and went out and got other things to try and improve their situation for either for themselves or their kids, and things didn't work out because things happened in the market that weren't expected.
22:39Doug Hoyes: Yeah. And again, for me to take their side of it, it's like, look, I've owned this property for fifteen years and it's done great for me. I've
22:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
22:45Doug Hoyes: built up all this equity, why not do it again?
22:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
22:48Doug Hoyes: So I take some of the equity over here. and
22:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): then we're going to be able to do this.
22:52Doug Hoyes: No, no.
22:54Scott Terrio: But this is what we're seeing. Yeah. And so that's my my third scenario is you know, people who have who are
22:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): generally generally
23:00Scott Terrio: older, who have built up like a lot of equity in a house and went and did a couple of moves, but those moves didn't go so good.
23:06Doug Hoyes: Yeah. And we're we're definitely seeing that.
23:08Scott Terrio: Yeah.
23:08Doug Hoyes: Okay. And what's number four on your list of uh
23:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So this
23:12Scott Terrio: one I found interesting. And this is related exactly to pre- con, I can we're back to the pre construction thing, but it's a different aspect of it. It's unexpected closing costs
23:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
23:21Scott Terrio: when you buy a pre construction condo. I didn't know any of this.
23:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
23:25Scott Terrio: talked to a guy and he said, Yeah, I got hit with when it was closing uh time. That's where the condo got built, you know, four three years later, four years later, whatever. And I had paid my deposit installments and I it was good. But then I got a letter from the developer. saying, Hey, it's about time to close next month. Great, let's uh you guys owe us uh 19 grand for what? Well, for this tax and this municipal tax and this and this and this and then and then there's like I've got a list here.
23:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
23:53Scott Terrio: Look at them.
23:53Doug Hoyes: Yep.
23:54Scott Terrio: Interim occupancy fees, development charges and levies, utility connection charges, HST on investment purchases, Tyrion Terry on warranty and vote like okay. And and I I did some research on this and talked to uh an agent and they confirmed that yeah, like typically it's somewhere between seven thousand and twenty-five thousand that these things could be. Well, if you don't have that
24:17Doug Hoyes: sitting there in cash in your pocket,
24:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're
24:18Scott Terrio: not actually closing,
24:19Doug Hoyes: yeah.
24:20Scott Terrio: Right? Because that's all part of the purchase agreement. It's on page fifteen. Okay, so you didn't read it, okay, and I get that, but but these are things. that people and in in this case, this guy had twenty one thousand. There it is, there. He couldn't pay that.
24:32Doug Hoyes: Yeah.
24:33Scott Terrio: So he went and took a loan,
24:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
24:35Scott Terrio: it was because his income's not that great and because he has all this other unsecured debt, credit
24:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): cards,
24:41Scott Terrio: tax debt, he's self employed, he had to go to an installment lender.
24:44Doug Hoyes: Yeah.
24:45Scott Terrio: So he went and got where am I here? Sixteen grand at thirty thirty-four four percent.
24:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): He
24:49Scott Terrio: was desperate. Yeah.
24:51Doug Hoyes: One
24:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): point under the legal limit.
24:52Scott Terrio: Because if you've got a closing date on a property you bought four years ago, this is
24:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
24:58Scott Terrio: big deal for you, right? And so again, not the blame game. He doesn't have family. He can't get sixteen grand or twenty one grand from anybody. So he got sixteen from these guys, and he's like, I I know that was crazy, but I had to do it. And then he took the other five from an unsecured line of credit that he still had a little bit of room on the bank. was like, I guess they didn't notice you. Okay. So boom. So he did that. But now he's got this other stuff and he's got, as I mentioned, all these other debts.
25:22Doug Hoyes: Yeah.
25:23Scott Terrio: So his minimum payments per month on his unsecured debts, his total like m debt servicing costs for the month, just went up dramatically. And and usually those loans are the killer. Yeah. Right. Like we see people who have like
25:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): four or five
25:36Scott Terrio: four or five debts that they've carried forever. but that's the last draw. And for him, it was like I as soon as he did it, he knew, but he's like, I had to close, right? And I get that. You're under a tremendous amount of pressure. And if you don't have any family support, what do you do? Right. So that's another scenario where you know it's just it's just a mess that was completely unexpected Expected for that whole time frame. Yeah.
25:58Doug Hoyes: If
25:59Scott Terrio: he'd have known that four years ago, he would have got the money together, right?
26:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, like
26:02Scott Terrio: letting like let me know. But and the final irony on that
26:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one. So
26:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I looked the building up.
26:10Scott Terrio: So I want to know what's going on. And right across the street from the building is an installment lender who I
26:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): won't say which
26:17Scott Terrio: one, and an L CBO.
26:18Doug Hoyes: Yeah. Yeah.
26:19Scott Terrio: I'm just like, oh boy, this is this was written in stone.
26:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like how did
26:24Scott Terrio: they know?
26:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
26:25Doug Hoyes: Well, and and I think this conversation. concept of occupancy costs might not be something people are fully aware of. So you the the building is gonna close on March the first, but you can actually move in on January the first.
26:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
26:41Doug Hoyes: So because so what you're gonna do is rent your
26:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): own
26:44Doug Hoyes: unit from the builder
26:46Scott Terrio: during that time frame.
26:46Doug Hoyes: During that time frame. And the rental costs cost can easily be the occupancy cost, four or five thousand bucks a month. Yeah. We see that all the time.
26:55Scott Terrio: Because the the building has to register,
26:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
26:57Scott Terrio: think, or
26:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I may be wrong of the term.
27:01Doug Hoyes: And a certain number of units have to close
27:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in order for that to happen.
27:05Scott Terrio: Paid to the developer between the day you get your keys and the day the building officially registers.
27:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
27:11Scott Terrio: Which could be months.
27:12Doug Hoyes: Right. Yeah, it's it's very typically to see two or three months.
27:15Scott Terrio: Yeah.
27:16Doug Hoyes: And but
27:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it could
27:16Scott Terrio: be it could be a bit longer than
27:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the builder's like,
27:19Doug Hoyes: well, your unit's done. We've still got all this legal stuff to do. So why don't you move in, put up your curtains, all that kind of stuff. Yeah. And so that's cool. I haven't had to get the mortgage yet. Yeah. But now I'm paying these occupancy costs. Well, am I moving?
27:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm renting my own place.
27:32Doug Hoyes: I'm renting my own place.
27:33Scott Terrio: No.
27:34Doug Hoyes: And okay, I I had factored in that the mortgage was going to cost me three thousand bucks a month or whatever. But now I'm paying five thousand bucks a month in occupancy costs. Yeah. It's a it's a big number. So
27:44Scott Terrio: entangled in all of this, sorry, but uh I need to jump to a a a general point here. Entangled in all of this, there's very rarely do I speak to someone where it's just them. Okay. There's always not always, there's almost always another party involved on the mortgage. on the title, whatever. So, you know, to to get these deals together, sometimes people have had to get their brother, their dad, their friend, whatever, on title and on more on mortgage specifically. And so now we're into joint and several. The legal concept of joint and several, which means You're on the hook. You're on the ho you any
28:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): party
28:24Scott Terrio: to a death. is on the hook for the whole thing. 100%. Okay. You are so my my favorite one is where the dude is on title for one percent.
28:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Mm-hmm.
28:37Scott Terrio: And this is a different concept of the one percenter. Um but they're on the mortgage. Okay, so let me get this straight. The sweet deal you've secured here is that you own one percent of the of the of the equity. if there is any or of the asset but you have a hundred percent of the debt that's a crappy deal
28:56Doug Hoyes: but
28:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that is
28:56Scott Terrio: so common
28:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all the
28:57Doug Hoyes: time all the time
28:59Scott Terrio: every day
28:59Doug Hoyes: and the the common scenario is my kid who's thirty years old wants to buy a property can't do it on their own so I say okay I'll help you out I'll co-sign the mortgage and the bank says well no only the owners can co-sign on the mortgage okay I'll take one 1%. percent my kid is ninety 99%. nine percent yeah so I own one percent 1% to qualify for the mortgage, but if things go south and the mortgage is a shortfall, they can come after me for the entire amount.
29:21Scott Terrio: Yeah. And and a lot of times what people think or the the perception they have of it is if I'm co-signing for you, I'm getting you over the line. But really, what you're doing is you're putting yourself on the hook because now the
29:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): bank
29:35Scott Terrio: can come after you as well as me. Yeah. And so uh that I think the notion. during the boom, the notion was um that co signing just got me the mortgage.
29:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
29:44Scott Terrio: then dad was out.
29:45Doug Hoyes: Didn't matter prices going up, who can't
29:47Scott Terrio: so that's the problem is that when when they give us these scenarios, th all these people are pulled into it. Yeah.
29:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay. And that's
29:54Scott Terrio: and that's all the time.
29:56Doug Hoyes: And I'm
29:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh you
29:57Doug Hoyes: know uh my general advice is don't co sign. That's my advice. Now, okay, but it's my kid, he wants to buy house, whatever. Well
30:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): then what's done
30:03Scott Terrio: is done.
30:04Doug Hoyes: Yeah. So then what you want to do then is give your kid a hundred thousand bucks or two hundred thousand or three hundred thousand, because that's ultimately what you might be on the hook for. And if you can't do it, then you shouldn't be co signing.
30:14Scott Terrio: Yeah. So in other words, the you know, give them give them the money as a gift and just be done with it, right? Um because
30:22Doug Hoyes: the money's gone anyways.
30:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
30:23Scott Terrio: and then you're not c they're not coming after you later if something goes sideways.
30:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Or
30:27Doug Hoyes: I guess the interim would be fine, I will register a second mortgage on your property so that if you know there is ever any equity I can get paid back, but I don't expect to ever see it. Right. Now that does complicate the mortgage process. So again
30:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
30:40Scott Terrio: we've seen I've seen that.
30:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. So talk to
30:42Doug Hoyes: a talk to an expert.
30:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So that's
30:43Scott Terrio: kind of the big um And you know, I uh there's the scenarios, but also the general co signing and you know people being on the hook for things that you know had no notion of that when they did it, of course, but that's just the way the market went. And so again,
30:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
30:58Scott Terrio: you know, we can't undo that, but you know, we walk them through the steps that okay, let's get out of this in the least damaging way, right?
31:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yep.
31:05Doug Hoyes: And that's what we're trying to do. And these conversations for us are always very difficult because you thought you did the right thing, you wanted to get into the housing. market, everybody else was doing really well at it. Yeah. And here you are three or four years later in far worse position. Yeah. And you got guys like us saying, Oh, well, I guess you're gonna have to walk away from the house and either do a proposal or go bankrupt. And that's not what you want to hear. Right. But unfortunately, sometimes, unless you've got access to money to make it right, that's
31:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just the answer.
31:35Scott Terrio: I have very rarely, though, encountered a uh a discussion or a conversation. or a filing where our pure objectivity wasn't appreciated either at the time or certainly later.
31:46Doug Hoyes: Yeah.
31:47Scott Terrio: Because yeah, it's a t a difficult conversation, okay? But most people who've called us have already done their soul searching. That's done. That's behind them. And that's why it takes them so long to call us, by the way, right? Like it takes them a year or two to call us because they're not calling us going, Oh, I I really need to start worrying about this. They've
32:07Doug Hoyes: been worrying about
32:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that. Yeah, they've they've
32:09Scott Terrio: done that. And so our our benefit for them is I look at this set of circumstances and go, well, here's what I see. And they're like, Nobody has laid it out like that because I can't I'm too invested in it, right? I'm too emotionally invested. It's my kids, it's my sister, whatever. And so, you know, it's a difficult conversation, yes, but it's actually a very good one.
32:29Doug Hoyes: Yeah. And I say to people, look, I'm an accountant. I'm looking at the numbers.
32:33Scott Terrio: Yeah.
32:34Doug Hoyes: I've never been to your property. I don't know your family. I have no emotional investment in this. So I'm just giving you the straight numbers.
32:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
32:40Scott Terrio: And you can be blunt and still be nice. Yeah. Like it these
32:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
32:44Scott Terrio: don't tell them, ah Oh yeah, that was, you know, here's what you gotta do. Like it's it's a it's a flowing conversation. It's, you know, they're nice people, they just made a bad move or two, or the market did.
32:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
32:55Scott Terrio: they made a good move, but the market then didn't do what they thought it was gonna do. Okay, well we'll
32:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): fix it,
32:59Scott Terrio: right?
32:59Doug Hoyes: Yeah, and I think you're right, people appreciate that. Um and when you put the numbers on a piece of paper, the numbers are the numbers. You can't really object to what they are.
33:08Scott Terrio: Yeah, and then when and then when it gets to the discussion, if it does, of an insolvency proceeding, which usually it does, um the law's the law, right? So like there's all kinds of rules with this stuff. So I take your set of circumstances, and this is why you know websites saying you'll pay thirty percent of your debts aren't true because every single situation is different. Sometimes it's thirty, sometimes it's sixty, sometimes it's twenty. Um but we take a set of facts, put them in a big funnel, and go, Okay, well we we can't do this, we can do this, we go down to here, we can do this, here's what it's gonna cost you, here's what matters, here's what doesn't, here's what assets come into play, here's what assets don't, here's where your income comes in, all that stuff. So people I think appreciate that we're walking them through the rules. We don't make the rules. Yeah. Our job is to interpret the rules in your situation and figure out what the best way out of this for you is.
34:00Doug Hoyes: Yeah, and that's why our advice is talk to us. or some other license and yeah, other licensed and trip installed.
34:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There's one
34:07Scott Terrio: takeaway here. I think it's that these these things I've just laid out are are a mess. Mm-hmm. And they didn't happen overnight.
34:15Doug Hoyes: Yep.
34:15Scott Terrio: They it took a while for the mess to happen. So um I think it was the no country control where he says, uh, it's a mess, and then the guy says, Well, if it's not, it'll do until the mess gets here. Yep. Like so,
34:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
34:28Scott Terrio: like the problem is it's a it's a mess that needs a whole bunch of untangling. The sooner you call us in the mess, the better. Period. I don't think there's a scenario where that's not true. Yeah. Um, because it's harder for us to undo bad moves than it is to prevent bad moves.
34:43Doug Hoyes: Yep. Debt problems don't go away on their own. That's
34:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): true. And time is the enemy
34:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): of debt. death.
34:47Doug Hoyes: Yeah. So we're gonna do a show where movie quests. quotes, because Ted's always doing these movie quotes, and I'm
34:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): going,
34:53Doug Hoyes: I don't even know what that movie is.
34:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It'll do until the
34:55Scott Terrio: mess gets here.
34:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There you go.
34:56Scott Terrio: So
34:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Tommy
34:56Scott Terrio: Tommy Lee Jones delivered that.
34:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That'll be in
34:58Doug Hoyes: our
34:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And he was
34:59Scott Terrio: perfect for it.
34:59Doug Hoyes: In our summertime compilation of of movie quotes. So okay, we are up against the clock here. Are there any final comments you want to make? I think you summarized it pretty good. Call
35:09Scott Terrio: early.
35:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
35:09Doug Hoyes: call early
35:10Scott Terrio: honestly that was my yeah I I just can't tell you how how many times I speak to someone or you do where you wish you had spoken to
35:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): them
35:18Scott Terrio: six months ago.
35:19Doug Hoyes: Before you cashed in your RSP and did all this other thing and you're still in the same boat. Yeah,
35:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah. Like honestly, a lot of that
35:25Scott Terrio: stuff is very important. Um and it also I mean the other thing it'll do is make you feel better. You called somebody in the like usually our discussion with them is sort of the gateway where okay, things start to turn around, right? Generally speaking. Or
35:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the low point.
35:38Scott Terrio: Yeah, and I've had people who never called us again for a year. But then
35:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I had
35:42Scott Terrio: a guy email me last night overnight. I was on my phone this morning. Boom. He's like, Hey, remember we spoke, you know, a few months ago. It was two years. I looked it up. Yeah. Like it's yeah. Right. But in his mind, it wasn't that long ago because he's thinking about all the time. I know the name, and I'm like, oh, okay. And I go and I find all my notes on the computer, and okay, we're gonna fix this now. But he had to do two or three things in the meantime. Yep. Yeah. He had to move, he had to this, he had to get the divorced, whatever. Right. And so, you know, all these things don't necessarily all the solution is not necessarily next month, right? Sometimes it's further out. But we we we get you to make moves that are good and then we file. Or we or we can file soon if that if that's the case.
36:17Doug Hoyes: Yep. So I agree the the sooner the better.
36:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
36:21Doug Hoyes: excellent. Well Scott, thank you for making the trip to the mothership here at the big studio in in Kitchener.
36:26Scott Terrio: Fancy new podcast.
36:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's beautiful, isn't it?
36:29Doug Hoyes: So for those of you who are watching on YouTube or wherever else, obviously don't forget to you know hit the subscribe and the notification and whatever. Um the most viewed podcast we ever did on Debt Free and 30 was you and I. We recorded it back in our old Toronto office many years ago talking about HELOCs. Helox. So I suspect a bunch of people will be watching this as well. So if you've got you questions or comments, leave them on YouTube or wherever else, whatever other podcasting thing you're you're listening to this on. And if you would like to have Scott back with other comments and stories, because I was looking at my script and I got to the first half of page one.
37:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
37:05Doug Hoyes: didn't look at any script. was. But uh hopefully that was helpful to see w What I think is most helpful is to understand how
37:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to do that.
37:15Doug Hoyes: the other guy is perceiving it. Because half the comments I get are, well, that person was stupid to have been doing that. Well, you've never been in their shoes, so you don't understand what the mindset was at the time. And then the other half of the people are, yeah, I totally get exactly what's going on. So I think hopefully we've been able to show show both sides of it. So so that is our show for today. And as Scott said, talking to us is free. It doesn't cost you anything to find out where you stand. You can go to Hoys.tips/slash start hyphen here. We'll put a link in the show notes. Um, and uh we can we can talk about uh talk about your situation or just go to hoys.com.
37:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
37:50Scott Terrio: tipster.
37:50Doug Hoyes: The tipster. There you go.
37:52Scott Terrio: Doug's the tipster.
37:53Doug Hoyes: Exactly. Um, and Scott alluded today to what happens when um there's more than one person involved in this. I think it's going to be next week's. show where Ted and I are going to talk about what happens when your partner has debt and you don't. So that will tie in nicely to what we're doing here. So, Scott, thank you very much for being here. That is our show for today. Please like and subscribe. Thanks for listening. Until next week, I'm Doug Hoys. That was Debt Free in 30. Thirty, Or in this case, 38. thirty-eight, But hey, good enough. Thanks for being here.