The Making Money Simple Podcast

Anthropic IPO Index Inclusion Mechanics and Historical Underperformance Risks

12 min Listen to the original Episode page
IPOsIndex FundsNasdaqMarket MechanicsVenture CapitalSpaceXAnthropic

Summary

Speakers analyze Anthropic's Nasdaq listing, noting that rule changes by Nasdaq and MSCI/FTSE will force index funds to buy shares quickly despite low free float. They contrast this with S&P 500 rules that delay inclusion for at least a year due to profitability requirements. Historical data from Jay Ritter is cited to show IPOs typically lag public markets by ~18% over three years. The speaker compares Anthropic to SpaceX, noting that early investors in SpaceX are largely down while global ETFs remained flat. Consequently, the speaker declines to buy directly, preferring indirect exposure via index funds and warning of insider lockup expirations.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    SpaceX entered FTSE/MSCI indices within 5-10 trading days and Nasdaq 100 within 15 days due to these new faster rules.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 3:19

  2. 2
    own? How much will it impact your returns? When it comes to index weighting, it's normally based on that free float that I mentioned, not the headline valuation.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 5:39

  3. 3
    can be unlocked for insiders within 76 days. So the free float grows as that lockup ends. So that weight creeps up over time as the index fund rebalances.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 6:58

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 2:19

    IPO Overview and Index Fund Impact

    Anthropic (ANT) lists on Nasdaq with a ~$1-1.4T valuation, raising tens of billions. The speaker notes that while it won't break index funds, rule changes by Nasdaq and MSCI/FTSE will force index funds to buy shares quickly, potentially at inflated prices before lockups expire.

  2. 2:19 – 5:39

    Index Mechanics and Free Float

    The speaker explains the three layers of index investing. Nasdaq changed rules to allow faster inclusion of mega-cap IPOs by lowering the free float requirement from 10% to 6%, whereas S&P 500 kept strict rules (profitability + 10% float), delaying Anthropic's inclusion for at least a year.

  3. 5:39 – 7:29

    Portfolio Weighting and Insider Risks

    Index weighting is based on free float, not total valuation. Anthropic is expected to weight ~0.1% in global funds and ~1% in Nasdaq 100. The speaker warns that insider lockups expire within 76 days, increasing free float and potentially forcing index funds to buy more shares as insiders sell.

  4. 7:29 – 10:15

    IPO Historical Performance and SpaceX Comparison

    Historical data from Ritter shows IPOs lag public markets by ~18% over three years. The speaker compares Anthropic to SpaceX, noting that most SpaceX day-one buyers are down, while global ETFs remained flat, suggesting retail IPO buyers often underperform.

  5. 10:15 – 11:45

    Speaker's Investment Decision

    The speaker will not buy Anthropic directly due to lack of deep research and high valuation risk, preferring to hold it indirectly via global index funds. They advise any direct investment to be a small satellite position due to IPO volatility.

Claims worth verifying

Anthropic lists on Nasdaq with ticker ANT and a valuation of $1-1.4 trillion.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:00

How to verify: Check Nasdaq listing details and press releases from Anthropic or financial news outlets for the IPO valuation and ticker. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Anthropic raised tens of billions of dollars, second only to SpaceX's June raise.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:19

How to verify: Review SEC filing S-1 or S-1/A for Anthropic's IPO proceeds and compare with SpaceX's private placement data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Only ~6% of Anthropic shares are available as free float.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:39

How to verify: Check the Nasdaq prospectus or the company's S-1 filing for the free float percentage. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Nasdaq changed rules to allow 6% free float for index inclusion, down from 10%.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·4:39

How to verify: Review Nasdaq Index Rules documentation or press releases regarding index inclusion criteria changes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

S&P 500 kept strict rules requiring profitability and 10% free float.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·5:19

How to verify: Check S&P Dow Jones Indices methodology for S&P 500 inclusion criteria. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Ritter study (1975-84) found IPOs returned 34.5% vs 61.9% for similar public companies over 3 years.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·8:17

How to verify: Locate Jay Ritter's academic paper 'Initial Returns of IPOs' or his updated database on the University of Florida's Warrington College of Business website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

IPOs from 1980 onwards lagged the market by ~18% over first three years.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·8:37

How to verify: Verify against Jay Ritter's updated IPO performance data or S&P 500 total return indices. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Nasdaq data shows almost two-thirds of IPOs were behind the market three years later.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·8:57

How to verify: Check Nasdaq's published IPO performance reports or third-party analyses citing this data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

SpaceX IPO price buyers are down, while global ETFs were flat over the same period.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·9:36

How to verify: Compare SpaceX secondary market price data (e.g., from Forge or EquityZen) with a global ETF (e.g., VT) performance from June 2026 to Nov 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Do your own research

  • Verify Nasdaq Rule 5700 series changes regarding free float requirements for mega-cap IPOs.
  • Check MSCI and FTSE index methodology documents for specific inclusion criteria and effective dates for new rules.
  • Review S&P Dow Jones Indices methodology for S&P 500 inclusion requirements, specifically profitability and free float thresholds.
  • Access Jay Ritter's IPO database or academic papers on IPO long-term performance (1975-1984 cohort) to verify the 34.5% vs 61.9% return figures.
  • Analyze Anthropic's S-1 filing for insider lockup expiration dates and total shares outstanding versus free float.
  • Compare current SpaceX investor returns against global ETF benchmarks using public market data.
  • Monitor Nasdaq 100 and global index fund holdings for changes following index rebalancing announcements.
  • Assess the impact of insider lockup expirations on share supply and potential price volatility.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Anthropic, the company behind Claude, lists on the Nasdaq today with the ticker symbol ANT or Ant. And it's safe to say this company has not been moving at an ant's pace. The company was only created about five years ago. It already has over 16 billion in revenue for the first half of this year alone. And it's one of the biggest IPOs ever, roughly a trillion dollars on day one. So I'm not sure the ticker symbol Ant and does it very much justice. If you've got a global index fund like myself, then you will probably own a tiny slice of it within the next few weeks, whether you like it or not, and there's nothing you can do about it. Will it break your index fund? I don't think so, but there's a bit going on behind the scenes that I'm not a fan of. And if you are currently investing in an index fund, then you need to understand this. As IPOs are pretty terrible investments in most cases, as I'll show you shortly. We're gonna go through all of this and more in this video to break down the anthropic IPO and how it directly impacts you. Just to be really clear as well, in this video, we're gonna be talking about investing. None of this is financial advice. And of course, with investing, your capital is at risk and past performance doesn't guarantee future returns. First, let's go through the key numbers of this IPO in 60 seconds. To be transparent, I'm recording this on the Tuesday, and the IPO is being priced on the

1:19Wednesday because as of Thursday, the 19th of November 2026, Anthropic will be trading on the NASDAQ. And the figures you can now see on screen are the final figures as of Thursday. As of today, Anthropic has been listed. Anthropic are raising tens of billions of dollars, most likely second only to how much SpaceX raised. in June. Valued at roughly $1 to $1.4 trillion, but only around 6% of the company is actually being sold. Remember that one, as it'll be important in a minute. If you did want to buy Anthropic shares directly, there was a UK offer at the IPO price through platforms like Hargree's Lansdown and AJ Bell. But that closed on Wednesday, the 18th. So now it is a case of buying it on the stock market like any. other US share. And now that it is listed, you can buy it on platforms that offer US shares like Trading 2 on Two, Lightyear, and IG. And I imagine more platforms will add it in over time because it'll probably be very popular. On screens are the one that I know of. If I've missed any, please let me know

2:19down below. Let's talk about how this IPO will impact your index fund. It's a little bit technical, but this is the most important part of the video. As a quick recap, there are three layers: the index provider, the fund provider, and the broker. The index provider picks the companies that go in the list. For example, SP, pick the 500 companies. The fund provider then provides a fund that tracks the list of companies that index. For example, Vanguard with VUSA, V USA, V UAG, then offer an ETF that tracks the underlying index. The broker then lets you buy the actual investment. For example, Trading 2 on 2 will offer this index fund or ETF that we can then actually invest in. Normally, a stock that just lists doesn't automatically get added into the underlying index. There's normally a bit of a waiting period and certain criteria, often quite strict criteria, that needs to be met. For these new range of mega cap IPOs, however, some of the rules have been circumvented slightly to let the companies in the indexes

3:19much quicker. With SpaceX being the most recent example, it went into the FTSE and MSCI global indices within five to ten trading days after listing, and into the Nasdaq 100 after 15 trading days, which is under Nasdaq's The new faster rules. Before it would have had to wait around three months. This is something I'm not a fan of. It happened with SpaceX, and the exact same will happen with Anthropic. The reason why is that these index funds are then forced to buy this brand new stock very soon after it lists. This is before the price has time to settle, and just as insiders and early investors might want to offload their stock to make loads of money. To me, it just seems like it allows, allowed, yeah, those insiders and big banks and institutions that might have also been involved. in the IPO to offload shares a maybe artificially increased price because of the hype to us retail investors. And because these hyped up IPOs are often heavily promoted to us as retail investors, and Anthropic's IPO has been no different. Now, just to be clear, FTSE and MSCI already had fast entry rules for these types of big IPOs. So Anthropic was always going to end up in some global funds like the ones I use myself quite quickly. And you can see on screen just how that played out with SpaceX with some real examples from a very recent mega IPO. But NASDAQ is the main index provider

4:39who has changed its rules for these IPOs and they've done it this year. In simple terms, only around 6% of anthropic shares are actually available to buy. That is what is called the free. flow. Nasdaq's old rules said at least 10% had to be available. So they essentially changed the rules to let companies like this in much quicker. So if you have a global fund in your portfolio, yes, you will own some anthropic very soon. If you hold a Nasdaq 100 fund in your portfolio, yes, you will also own some anthropic very soon. But this doesn't apply to the SP 500 because they stayed strong and did not change. their rules. They were considering it, but it didn't change, which I'm a fan of. So it'll be at least a year until Anthropic can join the SP 500. But to be honest, it could potentially be years and years. Because for the SP's rules, it also needs to be profitable on paper and have at least 10% of the shares available to buy. So a lot of people watching will probably be investing indirectly in anthropic. The big question then is how much will you actually? own? How much will it impact your returns? When it comes to index weighting, it's normally based on that free float that I mentioned, not the headline valuation. So one trillion sounds like a lot, but only six percent, a small amount, is floating, which means only six percent is available on the public market to buy and sell. And that is a big factor in terms of how much this

5:58company specifically will then make up of the underlying index. SpaceX went in. in terms of a global index fund at about 0.1%. It does depend on a specific index fund, of course, but Anthropic is likely to be quite similar. It will likely come in at around 0.1% as well of a global fund, maybe slightly less. Which I'll be honest isn't massively concerning. It will actually be a very small part of your global index fund or ETF. The weighting in the Nasdaq 100, because it's a small list of companies. will be much larger, but it'll still likely only come in at around 1% of that index. So to answer the question, no, it most likely won't break your index fund. But the bit I don't like is the mechanics of it all, because index funds have to buy all the companies in the list at their weight-ins. And that is a hidden cost of index fund investing that often isn't talked about. You have to buy whatever companies are in the list. regardless of the price. At the same time, up to 1.6 billion shares roughly, about twice as many as the IPO, can be unlocked for insiders within 76 days. So the free float grows as that lockup ends. So that weight creeps up over time as the index fund rebalances. And I think that is where there is a risk that retail investors like us could be holding the bag. Although I guess the counteract. to counteract that again, the good thing is it will be a very small part of our global

7:18funds, probably around 0.1%, maybe even less. On the business itself, it does seem to be growing at an exponential rate. I mean, I personally use Claude pretty much every day these days. So the big question is: should you just buy this stock directly? Surely with AI taking over, it's a no-brainer. Maybe, but maybe not. The reality is, unfortunately, no one really knows. And I think when it comes to this sort of thing with a new stock listing, it's exciting, an emerging industry, it really depends on who you ask. And of course, the people that are most optimistic and pessimistic are the ones that will get all the clicks and views. I personally don't have any idea to be transparent whether this will do well or badly. So I wanted to look at IPOs more holistically to see how they've done in the past and whether we should actually put money in new IPOs. like this one. And the bottom line is IPOs historically haven't performed very well. The most famous study on this was by Ritter, who looked at over one and a half thousand US IPOs from 1975 to 84. Three years after listing, those IPOs returned 34.5%. Similar companies already on the stock market returned 61.9%. So IPOs did roughly half. as well. Importantly, the worst returns came from the most hyped up companies, which could be a bit of foreshadowing for what's going on right now with these mega IPOs. His more recent data

8:37tells a similar story. IPOs from 1980 onwards lagged the market by around 18% over their first three years on average. To be fair, bigger IPOs have tended to do better, so it definitely doesn't mean that this anthropic IPO is doomed. But the past overall data on IPOs doesn't look too promising, and Nasdaq, even themselves, where Anthropic is listening, have some data on this. They found that almost two-thirds of IPOs were behind the market three years later. Day one pops are quite common, but they're often not sustained. And the big winners really are those who got the IPO at the IPO price, and actually, even more than that, those who got in early. the founders, the early employees, the banks, the institutions, the early investors, and so on. I'm not trying to be too pessimistic because I genuinely really like Claude, but that is what the past data shows. But and I thought this would be an interesting one, let's look at some more recent data with a very recent IPO, SpaceX. How has that actually performed since his IPO earlier on this year? If you got shares at the IPO price, you are slightly up. But most people who bought on day one are down, some by quite a lot. And over the same period, a global ETF has been pretty much flat. So most people who bought SpaceX on its first day would have been better off just sticking with a global ETF. Now, of course, this isn't to say the anthropic

9:56IPO won't do amazingly well from day one, or the SpaceX IPO won't bounce back, be the best performing investment. over the next 10 years, and literally take us all to space. I guess the bottom line is no one really knows, but this is a common trend that we see with IPOs, particularly the hyped up one, and I just wanted to make you aware of that. So maybe the most important question: am I going to buy it and should you buy it? Honestly, I don't know. It genuinely is a brilliant product, but I personally haven't researched and understood the company enough. And just because it's a brilliant product doesn't necessarily mean it will be a good investment if it's set at a high price. So I am thinking I probably won't invest in it directly. I was a little bit tempted, even just to put a little bit of money in for a bit of fun, but I think I probably won't. And for people that are planning on putting some money in it, I would say just keep it as a sensible allocation of your portfolio. Individual stocks are obviously. riskier than index funds and they can be much more volatile. And I think that's heightened because of the IPO. So of course, it's up to you how much to put into it. But if you are gonna put money into it, I would say keep it as a small satellite position in your overall portfolio. If you are planning on investing in it,

11:07please let me know in the comments down below. And yeah, to honest, I will own it anyway, indirectly through my global index funds fund in the matter of a few weeks. at whatever weight is decided from the index. And if it does perform well and there is more shares that become available, then this will slowly grow to be a larger part of the global index fund and really any index fund it's included in, including the Nasdaq 100. So yeah, I'm still gonna be investing every month into my global fund and will own a tiny, tiny little slice of Anthropic in the process. That wraps up this one. And if you want to watch another video, of mine, I'll link another relevant video on screen now. A massive thanks for watching and I'll see you in the next investing video.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights