SPGI faces AI fears and rating cycle headwinds but retains benchmark moat; speakers initiate small position
Summary
Speakers analyze S&P Global (SPGI) as a high-quality benchmark business trading at a discount due to AI-driven fears over its Capital IQ segment and cyclical pressures on its ratings division. They argue that the core Ratings, Indices, and Energy segments possess wide moats with 60-70% operating margins, driven by network effects and regulatory trust. While acknowledging near-term headwinds from rising interest rates and potential AI disruption to data services, the hosts highlight structural strengths like surveillance fees and a massive refinancing wall. The episode concludes with the hosts initiating a small position in SPGI, citing insider buying and a valuation model that suggests significant upside from current levels.
Key takeaways
- 1 SPGI collects 'tolls' from the financial system via licensing its S&P funded indices to asset managers and as one of the world's three biggest credit rating agencies.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 1:41
- 2 Surveillance fees (recurring monitoring fees) constitute roughly half of ratings revenue and grew even during downturns, providing a structural floor to earnings that transactional fees do not.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 44:32
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 3:11
Intro and SPGI Context
Speakers introduce S&P Global (SPGI) as a high-quality business that has become cheaper after a five-year flat stock performance, driven by AI fears impacting its Capital IQ segment and rising interest rates affecting its ratings business.
- 3:11 – 13:53
SPGI Business Segments and Benchmark Moat
SPGI operates four segments: Ratings, Indices (S&P 500/Dow), Energy (Platts), and Market Intelligence (Capital IQ). The first three are benchmark franchises with 60-70% operating margins, acting like utilities with uncapped pricing power due to network effects and regulatory trust.
- 13:53 – 31:45
AI Disruption Risks to Capital IQ
The market fears AI will disrupt Capital IQ's seat-based SaaS model by reducing the need for human analysts to use the interface. This led to a ~$40 billion market cap loss in February 2026, though speakers argue SPGI's proprietary data and MCP integration mitigate this risk.
- 31:45 – 33:09
Ratings Business Cyclicality
The ratings business is cyclical and tied to debt issuance volumes. Rising interest rates and potential AI bubble bursts could reduce borrowing activity, negatively impacting SPGI's largest profit pool.
- 33:09 – 35:34
Cyclical Risks and AI Debt Boom
Speaker 1 discusses the timing mismatch between debt issuance and profit recognition, noting that record debt issuance by AI companies like Anthropic and OpenAI drove double-digit ratings revenue growth in H1 2026. The second quarter was the best in history with margins near 70%, driven by hyperscaler debt issuance exceeding annual assumptions.
- 35:34 – 38:27
Macro Headwinds and Market Disruption
Shawn O’Malley notes that the Fed’s rate hike in September 2026 and high Treasury yields have shifted the macro backdrop from a tailwind to a headwind for ratings. Speaker 1 highlights bear arguments regarding AI disruption to market intelligence and a cyclical peak in ratings, citing falling demand for hyperscaler bonds and credit downgrades for companies like Oracle and CoreWeave.
- 38:27 – 42:47
Private Credit Stress and Blue Owl Exposure
O’Malley warns of a potential down year in ratings, referencing a 26% revenue drop in 2022. He highlights stress in private credit, particularly Blue Owl’s exposure to software companies vulnerable to AI disruption, which has led to stagnant stock performance and redemption limits in private credit funds.
- 42:47 – 46:50
Structural Cushions and Refinancing Wall
O’Malley argues that surveillance fees provide a recurring baseline for ratings revenue even during issuance slumps. Speaker 1 points to a $11-12 trillion refinancing wall over the next 4-5 years, noting that higher rates increase borrowing costs but do not eliminate the need to refinance, thus sustaining rating fees.
- 46:50 – 53:17
Market Share Dominance and Moat Resilience
Speaker 1 cites Warren Buffett’s long ownership of Moody’s as evidence of the ratings moat, noting that the duopoly (SPGI, MCO) plus Fitch controls ~95% of rated debt. O’Malley adds that SPGI rates 99% of US industrial bonds and survived the 2008 crisis with market share intact, proving the institution's systemic importance.
- 53:17 – 59:40
Spin-offs and Capital IQ Divestiture
The speakers discuss SPGI’s simplification efforts, including the July 2026 spin-off of Mobility Global (Carfax) and the reorganization of Market Intelligence. They highlight the potential sale or spin-off of Capital IQ, which would remove the weakest revenue link and allow SPGI to act as a neutral data supplier to AI-native research tools.
- 59:40 – 1:04:08
Index Business Dominance and CBOE Extension
The index business has posted 14 consecutive record quarters, benefiting from $20 trillion in S&P 500-indexed funds. A key development is the 25-year extension of the exclusive CBOE S&P 500 options license through 2051, with terms stepping up in 2027, though CBOE claims the pricing impact is de minimis.
- 1:04:08 – 1:06:35
Index Integrity and Passive Investing Risks
O’Malley praises SPGI’s decision to exclude SpaceX from the S&P 500 due to lack of profitability, maintaining index integrity. However, he notes the risk that as passive fund fees approach zero, the revenue share paid to index providers may compress, a concern previously cited for avoiding MSCI.
- 1:06:35 – 1:08:07
Prediction Markets Partnership with Kalshi
Speaker 3 discusses S&P Global's partnership with prediction market company Kalshi to provide benchmark data for these markets. Speaker 1 expresses skepticism about the legality and societal impact of prediction markets but acknowledges S&P's strategic move to be a standard-setter in emerging markets.
- 1:08:07 – 1:26:11
Platts Energy Business and Geopolitical Impact
The speakers analyze how the Iran War and resulting energy price shocks affect S&P Platts. While volatility can boost trading, extreme volatility may reduce trading desk activity, impacting revenue. Renewals with Middle East customers are reportedly returning to pre-war levels.
Claims worth verifying
The stock has been on something of a roller coaster ride and now looking back over the last five years, the stock is almost exactly flat.
Shawn O’Malley ·0:43
How to verify: Check S&P Global (SPGI) stock price history on Yahoo Finance or Bloomberg for the 5-year period prior to the episode date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The so-called SaaS apocalypse where software stocks got hammered over AI fears, and now the Fed is raising interest rates, which is was a problem for SP's credit ratings business.
Shawn O’Malley ·1:02
How to verify: Verify Fed rate hike announcements via Federal Reserve press releases; check S&P Global earnings reports for ratings revenue trends correlated with rate changes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
We had a big spin-off with a second spin-off possibly on the way... Mobility... is now gone after being spun off.
Shawn O’Malley ·2:01
How to verify: Check S&P Global (SPGI) SEC filings (Form 8-K or 10-K) for the spin-off of Mobility and announcements regarding Capital IQ. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe first three of those segments are what the company calls its benchmark businesses. And they drive roughly two-thirds of revenue and about 80% of operating profit... ratings and indices, which boast margins in the 60 to 70 percent range.
Shawn O’Malley ·4:43
How to verify: Check S&P Global (SPGI) latest quarterly earnings release or 10-K filing for segment revenue and operating income breakdowns. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceA year ago, when I pitched you on the stock, there actually was another division, a fifth one. So that was mobility, which consisted of Carfax and a lot of automotive data. And that's now gone after being spun off.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·4:28
How to verify: Check S&P Global (SPGI) investor relations page or SEC filings for the history of the Mobility segment and its spin-off. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe stock fell as much as 19% that morning. And by the time the dust had settled, it was trading at the cheapest multiple that it had seen in five years. And something like forty billion dollars of market capitalization just disappeared from SP in about 10 days.
Shawn O’Malley ·15:48
How to verify: Check S&P Global (SPGI) stock price chart for February 2026; calculate market cap change from ~$40B loss; verify P/E ratio against 5-year historical data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceSubscriptions to capital IQ drive something like 6% of company revenue and even less of profit.
Shawn O’Malley ·21:58
How to verify: Check S&P Global (SPGI) earnings call transcripts or 10-K for segment revenue details, specifically Market Intelligence/Capital IQ contribution. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAccording to management, the data in market intelligence that is completely undifferentiated... only contributes to less than 5% of revenue.
Shawn O’Malley ·22:18
How to verify: Check S&P Global (SPGI) earnings call transcripts for management commentary on data differentiation and revenue contribution. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In February, about 80 customers were using SP's data that way through an MCP. And by the second quarter, that number had jumped to over 500.
Shawn O’Malley ·28:11
How to verify: Check S&P Global (SPGI) Q2 2026 earnings report or investor presentation for details on MCP adoption and customer counts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A study by OpenAI... measured error rates across financial data providers... SPs came in at under 3% against about six and a half for the next best competitor.
Shawn O’Malley ·29:56
How to verify: Search for the specific OpenAI study or report cited by the speaker regarding financial data provider error rates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Hyperscalers issued ~$240 billion of debt in the first nine months of 2026, more than SPGI assumed for the entire year.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·34:08
How to verify: SPGI Q3 2026 Earnings Report or SEC 10-Q filing; compare with market debt issuance data from Bloomberg or Refinitiv. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceSPGI's ratings division margins pushed to 70% in Q2 2026, the best quarter in the division's history.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·34:08
How to verify: SPGI Q2 2026 Earnings Report; check operating margin for the Ratings & Analytics segment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
SPGI's private market ratings revenue was up 60% in Q2 2026.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·34:48
How to verify: SPGI Q2 2026 Earnings Report; check revenue growth for Private Market Ratings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
SPGI's stock traded at nearly 60x earnings and fell to ~26x earnings over three years.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·36:32
How to verify: Historical stock price and SPGA earnings data from Yahoo Finance or Bloomberg; calculate trailing P/E. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Fed raised rates for the first time in three years in September 2026.
Shawn O’Malley ·35:53
How to verify: Federal Reserve FOMC meeting minutes and press conference transcripts for September 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The 10-year Treasury yield hit its highest level since 2002, sitting above 5% in 2026.
Shawn O’Malley ·36:13
How to verify: US Treasury yield data from FRED (Federal Reserve Economic Data) or Bloomberg. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Ratings revenue fell 26% and operating profit fell 35% in 2022.
Shawn O’Malley ·38:27
How to verify: SPGI 2022 Annual Report (10-K); compare 2022 vs 2026 revenue and operating income for the Ratings segment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceBlue Owl stock has been 'dead money' due to exposure to software companies disrupted by AI.
Shawn O’Malley ·40:15
How to verify: Blue Owl Capital (OBDC) stock price performance over the relevant period; check earnings calls for commentary on software loan performance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
SPGI rates ~99% of industrial bonds in the United States.
Shawn O’Malley ·47:40
How to verify: SPGI Investor Presentation or Annual Report; verify against total US industrial bond issuance data from SIFMA or Bloomberg. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Cboe and SP Dow Jones Indices announced a 25-year extension of their exclusive S&P 500 options license through 2051.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·1:03:11
How to verify: Press release from Cboe Global Markets or S&P Dow Jones Indices dated late September 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
S&P Global announced a partnership with Kalshi to bring its benchmarks into prediction markets.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·1:06:55
How to verify: S&P Global press releases or investor presentations regarding partnerships with Kalshi; Kalshi press releases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Platts is the benchmark for approximately 70% of the world's seaborne crude.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·1:08:36
How to verify: S&P Global annual reports or investor presentations detailing Platts market share; industry reports on crude oil pricing benchmarks. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Renewals with Middle East customers for Platts are returning to pre-war levels in Q3.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·1:08:51
How to verify: S&P Global Q3 earnings call transcript or SEC filings (10-Q) discussing regional performance and customer renewals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceCboe licenses S&P 500 benchmarks and pays usage-based royalties to S&P Global.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·1:09:50
How to verify: S&P Global annual reports detailing revenue by segment; Cboe regulatory filings regarding licensing agreements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceBill Ackman's Pershing Square disclosed a new position in S&P Global over the summer.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·1:11:13
How to verify: SEC Form 13F filings for Pershing Square Capital Management for the relevant quarter. For recent events, verify 2026-08-22 through 2026-11-22. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDo your own research
- Verify the current market cap and valuation multiples (P/E, EV/EBITDA) against the five-year historical averages cited.
- Review SPGI's latest 10-K and 10-Q filings to confirm the revenue split between Capital IQ (~6%) and the benchmark segments.
- Check the latest debt issuance volumes for hyperscalers (OpenAI, Anthropic) and compare against SPGI's guidance assumptions.
- Analyze the CBOE S&P 500 options license extension terms, specifically the stepping pricing mechanism and the 'de minimis' claim by CBOE.
- Confirm the status of the Capital IQ divestiture or spin-off plans mentioned by CEO Martina Chung.
- Review insider trading disclosures (Form 4) for CEO Martina Chung and other executives to verify the $3.5 million purchase at ~$430.
- Assess the impact of the $1 billion annual IHS Markit amortization on reported EPS versus adjusted operating metrics.
- Monitor private credit stress indicators, particularly Blue Owl's exposure to software companies, as a leading indicator for rating downgrades.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): You're listening to TIP.
0:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Welcome back to the Investors Podcast, episode 863. And not too long ago, Sean, you revisited Shopify. And unfortunately, we figured out that the company is still priced for perfection and a bit too expensive for us. So I'm actually looking forward to today because we are looking at another high quality business, but this time it should be relatively cheaper.
0:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
0:23Shawn O’Malley: you and Kyle have for sure done most of the stock pitches this year. And and when I've done them, uh like you said, I I haven't found a ton of investments. I just jump off the page for being so cheap. But it is an interesting time for us to be looking back at my old employer, SP Global. And so we both love the business when we've looked at it. And we thought though the stock was a bit richly priced last year, and that has actually aged pretty well because the stock has been on something of a roller coaster ride and now looking back over the last five years, the stock is almost exactly flat. And since we last looked at it, though, we've had the so-called SaaS apocalypse where software stocks got hammered over AI fears, and now the Fed is raising interest rates, which is was a problem for SP's credit ratings business. So a lot has happened, and the stock has is cheaper in a sense. It's grown into its valuation, but there's also more uncertainty facing the company too.
1:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, that's the trade-off. We unfortunately have to accept when we added Netflix to the portfolio recently after the market narrative really soured on the company. You actually went on a 10-minute monologue in one of our YouTube live streams about how that is exactly when you have to step up. And it's not easy mentally, but that's why market. Manga used to say investing is simple but not easy. And there really is no doubt that S P Global is a fantastic company. We decided that too when we first looked at it. And it's involved in almost every part of the financial system. So you're talking, you know, collecting tolls in doing so, from licensing its S P for funded index to asset managers to being one of the world's three biggest credit grading rating agencies.
2:01Shawn O’Malley: And beyond these external factors like interest rates and AI, we've also seen some big changes internally at SP Global or SPGI using the ticker. We might refer to it that way today. We had a big spin-off with a second spin-off possibly on the way. So as always, there is plenty to talk about. So let's get to
2:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
2:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Since twenty 2014, fourteen, with more than 200 million downloads, we have interviewed the world's best investors, studied deeply the principles of value investing, and uncovered many compelling investment opportunities. We focus on understanding businesses and intrinsic value, investing accordingly, and sharing everything we learn with you. This show is not investment advice, it's intended for informational and entertainment purposes only. All opinions expressed by hosts and guests are solely their own, and they may have investment in the securities discussed. Now for your hosts, Sean O'Malley and Daniel Manka.
3:11Shawn O’Malley: So before we get into what's changed, let's just spend a few minutes on what SP Global actually sells. So everyone's on the same page. And for starters, SP Global today is really four businesses. There's Ratings, which is a credit rating agency and the largest profit pool in the company. There's SP Dow Jones Indices, which is what famously owns and maintains the S SP P 500 and the Dow and a few actually thousands. thousand other benchmarks that are much lesser known. And then there's the energy side of the business, which used to be called Commodity Insights when I was working there, and is built around Platz, which is the price benchmark that most of the world's physical oil and gas trades are basically settled against. And then there's market intelligence, and that is the data and software division. that is home to Capital IQ. And that is the terminal I used to answer support tickets in for my first job out of college. So some nostalgia there. And it's also the part of the business I should mention that is really something of a software as a service. And that has grabbed the attention of some of the more bearish arguments out there in the market about SP being vulnerable to AI disruption and different. in different ways.
4:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
4:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): year ago, when I pitched you on the stock, there actually was another division, a fifth one. So that was mobility, which consisted of Carfax and a lot of automotive data. And that's now gone after being spun off. We talked about it last time. Now the spun-off has actually gone through.
4:43Shawn O’Malley: So the first three of those segments are what the company calls its benchmark businesses. And they drive roughly two-thirds of revenue and about 80% of operating profit, as you know, Daniel. And the company's CEO, Martina Chung, has emphasized a few times now that SP Global is a benchmarks business for the financial industry at large, which leaves sort of their SaaS interface, capital IQ, Bloomberg alternative as something of an odd man out. So perhaps it's not a surprise. that they're looking to either shop it off or spend it off. And on its own, market intelligence would for sure be considered a high quality business. Not as high quality as the rest of SP, but the desktop product line, which just refers to CapIQ, that is, like I said, SP's alternative to Facet, if you're familiar with that, and the Bloomberg terminal, famously, that faces. some serious uncertainty. And despite its strengths, the broader market intelligence division very much pales in comparison to SP's other segments. And it actually has the lowest profit margins of the four, which I think says something more about how unbelievably profitable the other parts of the business are than really anything.
5:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
6:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): definitely does. I mean, adjusted operating margins are somewhere. in the low to mid 30s, which is actually around alphabets, operating profitability. So market intelligence would strike you as a great business until you then compare it with ratings and indices, which boast margins in the 60 to 70 percent range, which just shows you how essential these businesses are to the financial markets in general, because otherwise you can definitely not take that much margin. So a market intelligence is no albatross, but it does make sense why there have been rumors about, you know, its desktop product line being spun off to form a new company because it is definitely weighing on, I would say, the market's excitement about the rest of the company's assets. And you will often hear this called conglomerate discounts. So when basically one company houses a mix of businesses of very different quality, and then investors tend to value the whole thing for less than they would actually pay for. the pieces on their own. So that's when you start hearing, hey, you know, maybe we should break up this company, and then the parts would be worth more standalone than under the same roof.
7:00Shawn O’Malley: We talked about that a good bit recently in the show with General Electric, too, right? I mean, they ended up splitting into three different companies and actually created a ton of shareholder value in doing so.
7:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Exactly. I think the crown jewel there has been the aerospace business. which is what we also covered. And it has by far the best margins and I would say an impenetrable mode. And when that was hidden away, more or less under these less pristine businesses, it definitely couldn't be valued in the way that I would say the company deserved. And in GE's case, you also had this financing business for a while, which obviously adds additional risk that investors are worried about. You usually don't want to be in these situations where there's a lot of financial risk that could basically blow. up the entire company, which, as we discussed in the episode, almost happened in 2008. And the thing to understand about a benchmark business, now talking about S P again, is that the product isn't strictly data and it also isn't necessarily analysis either. So the product is a standard that the rest of the financial system has agreed to basically use. So bond funds, right, rated BBB minus or better by S SP P into their investment. rules. And BBB minus being the cutoff for investment grade and basically the safer end of the bond market and banks in Europe, for example, will then hold capital against assets based on those ratings. So in that same vein, some of the biggest index funds in the world sell themselves as, for example, tracking the S P 500. And in oil markets, many contracts for Middle Eastern crude sold into Asia. price the oil at a premium or discount to benchmarks such as Platz Dubai and
8:31Oman. So basically the benchmark becomes the common reference point around which buyers and sellers transact. And that's what makes these businesses so difficult to displace because the competitor needs more than just you know a better analytical tool, it would also need customers and then often their counterparties to then agree to change the reference point they already use. So the benchmark businesses are, I would say, less like software and more like a utility with uncapped pricing power.
8:57Shawn O’Malley: There's a lot of inertia around benchmarks once they've been widely accepted. It's sort of like trying to change the language that we use. Like this is just the preferred term that people like to go to. And rather than re-explain the ratings mode from scratch, but we just play. a short clip here from our original episode because actually I think you did it better than I could.
9:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
9:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): perhaps it makes sense to illustrate the natural mode that the ratings business has once more, because it's
9:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
9:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you just look at it, you feel like it's more of a regulatory mode. And I would say what helps is just assuming that there's, for example, a Simply new rating agency that can massively undercut SP prices. And then you kind of think about, okay, what would that mean? Intuitively, you would think that SP's customers would just leave and get their ratings from this new agency. However, there's a big difference in your interest cost based on the rating agency that the company uses. So if a company issues, let's say a $500 million bond that is rated by an agency other than SP, Moody's, or Fitch, it will have to pay higher interest rates as if it had used one of those big three agencies. And that's the case. because the bank just trusts ratings from those companies just significantly more. And that reduces the risk of the bond. And therefore, if the risk is lower, the bank is willing to give out the loan at a lower interest rate. The money customers can save because of the S P rating makes upcoming competition almost impossible. So if you issue a $500 million bond and you assume an 80 basis point difference between the interest it has to pay when getting a rating from S P versus a lower tier rating agency, then just 80 basis points, which is 0.8%. However, on a bond with half a billion dollars, that can easily be a multi million dollar annual difference, an annual one. So let's assume you have it over five years. Each year, for example, you would have extra costs of let's say $3 million. And considering the cost of a couple of hundred thousand dollars for
10:47a rating, it would even make sense, economic sense, to go with an SP S rating. P even if the competitor doesn't charge you anything for the rating.
10:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
10:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): definitely feels like it violates the rules of capitalism, but I think that's what makes this such an extraordinary business model. So being a global standard is maybe the best business model out there. Just look at, for example, Verasign, which collects a small fee every time that someone registers or renews in use, a the website address endingin.com, ending in.com, which obviously still happens quite a lot. And it sounds way too good to be true, but it's not, mainly because it's so difficult to become recognized as a global standard, whether that's in website domains like ProSign did it or with credit ratings. And if we started issuing, let's say a Sean and Daniel credit rating for free, and then try to challenge SP Global, they would unfortunately be totally useless because if you could even get a company to take you seriously, that company would get lost. laughed out of the room, I assume, when they walk into a bank saying, Hey, this is our stamp of approval from, well, you know, us as some upstart ratings agency. And there's obviously a huge amount of career risks here, too, where no one at the bank is going to lose their job from making a loan to a company with a firm stamp of approval from SP. Whereas if they go, some new upstart, just like our new business venture, and the loan goes sideways. the banker behind that deal is definitely going to lose their job. And there's no upside. It's basically all downside for the lender to trust a new rating that doesn't have decades of data behind it, where you can say, okay, for a company
12:14with this score from SP, we know with pretty high statistical confidence that this is the default range.
12:21Shawn O’Malley: So I like this idea of us starting a ratings agency. Maybe uh we'll have to give that a try as an alternative. to podcasting. But it is sort of how you get this bizarre economic reality where a new competitor that comes in and would want to undercut SP on price is basically making a completely futile effort, right? The issuer of the debt pays for the rating. So they're always going to go with the rating agency that they believe gives them the best chance of paying less than interesting. in interest. But it actually hasn't always been that way, I should say. Back in the day, investors, not borrowers, would pay to see credit ratings for companies. So the dynamic was flipped. So as an investor, you and I would subscribe to a company like SP's ratings manual, and then you would see all the different ratings on companies. And the business model changed in the early. 1970s, in large part due to adoption of the photocopier. And once subscribers could Xerox reports and hand them around for free, that subscription model basically broke. And you had this dynamic where the agencies started charging the borrower instead.
13:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
13:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): find it so interesting to look back at these things because you see how very significant changes. to the business model did not end up killing them. And I think there's probably a lesson or two in there about the current state of disruption through AI. And speaking of paradigm shifts in tech, let's actually get to AI because of course we can't go an episode these days without talking about it. I I feel like by now AI is uh sort of a preset chapter in each episode where we basically go into
14:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
14:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): unique story for each company and then try
14:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to.
14:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): figure out how it will benefit or be heard by AI. So what is your verdict on on S P
14:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): oh
14:09Shawn O’Malley: I don't know if I have a verdict but I I'll start with you know there's there's definitely concerns about seat based pricing as it's known, especially for the cap IQ terminal in the market intelligence division. And so historically JP Morgan for example, they would maybe come to S SP P and say, hey, we have a hundred new junior bankers that need to get set up with access to CapIQ data so they can help with working on deals. And then JP Morgan would pay for each one of those bankers to basically get their own account set up. And one fear, I would say, at a pretty high level, is simply that there'll be fewer employees at SP's clients due to AI. job disruption. So basically, subscription revenues will fall off because maybe JP Morgan only needs half as many accounts to do the same amount of work as it took five years ago. And that really isn't unique to SP global. This is the narrative we've heard around the entire SaaS apocalypse, from Adobe to Salesforce, uncertainty around the future of the seat seat-based based pricing model is a wide concern. And if we rewind actually to the first week of February, when Anthropic released a set of plugins for its Claude assistant, one of them being for legal work, the market reaction was to sell
15:28every company that makes money selling information to professionals. So you had Thomson Reuters for lawyers, and then the whole financial data complex got hit. And that was the London Stock Exchange group. Factset, MSCI, ICE, and SP Global, a lot of acronyms. And then a week later, SP reported earnings, and the guidance for the rest of 2026 came in really a little light. And so the stock fell as much as 19% that morning. And by the time the dust had settled, it was trading at the cheapest multiple that it had seen in five years. And something like forty billion dollars of market capitalization just disappeared from SP in about 10 days.
16:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
16:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): gotta admit, the timing is a little funny to me personally, because I think February is exactly when I personally switched to Claude for bullying some of the models or at least help with it. And thanks for the recommendation to some of the members in our community who actually said back then that Claude is way better than ChatGPT, which is what we used before that. And then I got you hooked as well. And now I think it's fair to say that TIP's backbone runs to a substantial amount on Claude. No, I'm just kidding, of course. But it is definitely telling that the same month that AI was knocking $40 billion off SP Global, I was discovering that Claude was a way better modeling assistant than anything that I had personally used before. And it's not like I was SP's target customer anyway, but it was one of those moments where. you just realize that things are actually changing and they are changing fast. And with Claude, I could literally build a financial model on a company in a fraction of the time compared to doing it manually or even using any other LLM out there at the time. So the market spheres weren't totally irrational. CAPIQ isn't all about modeling, but the CAPIQ plugin in Excel is actually a pretty popular feature. And I only worked with FactSat, not CAPIQ before, but the Excel plugin was definitely one of the best things. And the bigger issue ultimately is that capital IQ is a screen that you know an analyst clicks through to find data or commentary. And so if an AI assistant can do the
17:29clicking and the reading and the human doesn't need the screen anymore, then why would you pay for the seed? So for a company like FactSat FactZat in particular, which is almost entirely an interface. that's a real problem. So Factzat stock actually fell by more than a third in about two months earlier this year, and Morningstar even took away its mode rating entirely. And I think the two of us discussed whether we want to cover that company, but we did figure out that they're so exposed to this problem that likely it doesn't make sense.
17:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
17:56Shawn O’Malley: you strip out the interface, what only matters then is the financial data. And this became a lot more tangible for me recently when I was setting up a recurring claude automation to send me a custom morning newsletter with updates on the companies at track. And I've now, I don't know, against your without your permission, I've signed you up for the same AI newsletter. So now you get that in your inbox every afternoon. So you're welcome for that. But I quickly saw how if you didn't have a financial data platform to tie into there's only so much Cloud can do, right? It's confined to whatever data it can pull for free off of Google search, basically. And unfortunately, one of our sponsors, Fiscal AI, has what's called an MCP. This is something I've recently learned about. It's basically an integration that lets an AI assistant tap directly into its data source. And so, anyways, as soon as I connected the fiscal MCP into my cloud account, my agents had access to a whole world of financial data at any time, whether my computer was on or off. And so where I might have logged into a terminal in the past, like Bloomberg or Faxet or Capital IQ to find the data I was looking for. Now I could just simply ask Claude to do it on my behalf, which is a way easier experience. And another example would be to imagine if you never needed to, let's
19:16say, log into Salesforce again. And you just asked your AI assistant to pull up whatever customer info you needed. That is sort of the idea of what we're talking about. And you take some complicated platform that takes dozens of hours of training to learn, and then you boil it down to the underlying data and then let an AI sort through it on your behalf. And I found that to be very powerful. I mean, in preparation for this episode, one of the things I did was. with the MCP connected, I just typed into Claude build a 10 year chart of SP's stock price and price to earnings ratio overlaid. And it did it immediately, which is incredible. You know, it's kind of a time saver on the margins, right? Like I could have gone and created that chart, but the LLM can definitely do it faster than me. And then you can imagine for more complex charting and calculations that you're trying to run, it becomes even more of a time saver. And the great thing for SP is that they own the underlying data in many cases. So, you know, in fact, a lot of the company financials that you see on sites like Yahoo Finance come from SP. I learned that when I was working at SP. And basically, SP has the data and the benchmarks that shape a huge portion of financial markets. And that makes them very vastly better positioned to overcome churn and cap IQ subscriptions. That's that's how I think of it.
20:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
20:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): point you're making here is basically why the markets are so bearish on software overall, especially in you know the last couple of months. I think by now the trade has kind of turned around, at least to some extent. But I mean, we've kept Adobe in the portfolio for a long time, right? And we still own it, obviously, because we see its tools as truly being developed. differentiated. But a lot of software is simply a sort of a layer between the data and the user experience. So it's a way to organize things for humans. And if agents are going to be increasingly doing things on our behalf, then the value of a whole lot of software actually goes to zero. And I know that's a popular argument out there right now, at least. And you know, you've said before that when you worked on the capsule IQ support desk, the questions you got all day were things like, how do I find this data? How do I pull it into Excel? How do I make this screen do that? And so forth. And I was actually on the other side of that call, asking those questions to the people from FactSat. So I definitely know how that feels. And as you said earlier too, especially with the good MCP, an AI assistant can do all those tasks for you. So I don't think software interfaces are are broadly safe. And I would say the same even for SP's market intelligence business.
21:38Shawn O’Malley: For me, the the question really is how significant is this to the company's long-term earnings power? How important is not just the market intelligence business, but the cap IQ interface? And to that end, I've got a few data points. Subscriptions to capital IQ drive something like 6% of company revenue and even less of profit. And according to management, the data in market intelligence that is completely undifferentiated, meaning the stuff that you could really find anywhere else that's commoditized, that only contributes to less than 5% of revenue. And so obviously, the most valuable data on capital IQ is that unique data that nobody else has. And to me, that implies that this issue is pretty well contained.
22:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): We actually also talked about this last time. too, right? So maybe we'll just listen back to another clip of that episode because I think we do did a quite good job of just explaining how exactly it works. 95% of SP's data in this segment is proprietary. You can't just access this or scrape it and then train AI models on it, not unless you would have direct access to SP's data feeds. So
22:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
22:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): more realistic outcome in my mind isn't that AI replaces SP, but that SP. uses AI to just make its products significantly better and also more efficient. I think it's also worth remembering that outside of CapIQ, most of SP's businesses aren't just selling data. A big part of the value proposition that SP offers is trust. I mean credit ratings, benchmarks, and price assessment, all of that just depends highly on the credibility of the company. And no AI startup can just replicate that over. overnight.
23:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
23:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): actually quite interesting how our thinking has shifted since then, because back then I said that there might be AI making CAPIQ a better platform, basically. And now I think that we probably both buy onto the idea that actually will reduce the value of these interfaces, where in a lot of cases, certainly not all of them, but a lot, you're just paying to have the underlying data integrated into your LLM of choice. And there's obviously a big shift, honestly. I mean a year ago we would have said, well, CAPIQ terminals weren't going anywhere anytime soon, especially because they own all of their data. And now we're probably closer to the idea that the terminal value at least of many of these software interfaces is going to zero. And I mean it will probably take a lot of time before that is going to happen, but it seems vastly more plausible already than it did just a year ago.
24:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Let's
24:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): take a quick break and hear from today's sponsors.
24:05Shawn O’Malley: Early in my career, I was shipping away at student loans and it felt like it would never end. I'd make a payment, check the balance, and it barely moved. What finally changed my mindset was seeing a real finish line. A date I could actually circle on the calendar. That's what Monarch's debt pay down simulator gives you. It uses your real balances and payments to show your exact. debt free date. Then you can run different scenarios side by side, like adding an extra hundred dollars a month, and instantly see how much sooner you'd be done. Watching that timeline shrink is really motivating and you're the one in control of the plan. Plus, a quick check in on your phone or laptop tells you exactly where your money stands. stance. It's so important to manage your finances, and I believe Monarch can help. you in doing so. Write your own money story with Monarch. Use code WSB at monarch.com to get your first year of Monarch Core half-off at just $50. That's 50% off your first year at Monarch.com with code WSB. B. Interested in futures trading and looking for a place to get started with plus Plus500 500 futures. You can explore some of the world's most active markets, all from one easy-to-use platform. Trade futures on popular assets like the SP 500, NASDAQ, oil, gold,
25:24Bitcoin, Forex, and more. Whether markets are moving in crypto, commodities, or indices, there's always something to follow. Plus 500 Futures is designed to make trading straightforward with a the platform you can access wherever you are, right from your phone, and you can get started with a minimum deposit. of just $10. Not ready to trade with real funds? Try the free unlimited demo account first and explore the platform without putting real money at risk. Backed by nearly 20 years of experience and trusts by millions of customers worldwide, plus 500 gives you the tools to stay connected to the futures markets. Visit us.plus500.com to learn more. Trading in futures involves risk of loss and is not suitable for everyone. Not all applicants will qualify. Plus 500, it's trading with a plus. In investing, we always ask where a company's real edge comes from. With AI, the models keep getting better and cheaper, so the model alone isn't the edge. Context is everything your business actually knows. That's what Glean does. It pulls together what's scattered across your company's tools. like documents, conversations, and who's working on what. Your employees and AI agents get the full picture, and the access controls you already have stay in place. Glean also isn't tied to one AI provider. It works with more than 40 models and picks the best one for each job,
26:43weighing performance against cost. You're not overpaying and you're never stuck with yesterday's model. I use Glean and you should too. Glean, the context platform for enterprise AI. Visit Glean.com slash TIP to unlock an exclusive offer just for listeners of the investors podcast. That's glean.com slash TIP. Glean.com slash TIP. Terms and conditions apply.
27:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): All right, back to the show.
27:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
27:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I
27:11Shawn O’Malley: mean, I think there's something to be said for being able to, you know, when we said the terminal value, that means like the long term, this is the direction that it's trending in. You could say the terminal value of cable TV is also zero, even though it's taken 20 years for Netflix to disrupt cable TV, and cable TV is still very widely watched. Yet it is a business in decline. And no matter what, the way I think about it for SP is. AI agents will need clean, licensed, citable data. And the company that owns that data is not going to be displaced from the value chain, at least not entirely. And so like fiscal AI, SP Global has its own MCP connector for customers to use. And you have to already be a paying customer with a subscription to the Capital IQ platform. to use it. And AI models don't get to train on that data, but that is how SP to me stays indispensable. And in February, about 80 customers were using SP's data that way through an MCP. And by the second quarter, that number had jumped to over 500. And the volume of API calls, meaning how often the machines are hitting the data and using it, was growing something like
28:28So this has been a popular initiative that's been rolled out to say the least.
28:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Using the MCP, I'm not surprised at all. It's a huge time saver for us, and probably even more so for people who build 10 financial models a day. And then once again, you can say this for basically all companies, the SAS component, but the big question is how the dynamic you're describing actually affects pricing. So right now an MCP. access is usually paired with a platform subscription. But if customers begin to overwhelmingly demand the option to only pay for the MCP, SP will eventually succumb to that. So we've gotten some anecdotes from management on this actually, but nothing super concrete yet. And a couple of clients, that's what SP is telling us, paid 35 to 45% more at renewal for data that's been cleaned up and labeled. so it works well with the AI they're using. And the buy side client apparently switched to SP from a competitor, even though SP was about 20% more expensive because they thought the data was just more reliable and therefore also more valuable. And there was an instance too where a large bank tested a frontier model in a sandbox, liked it. Then And they started start rolling it out and then it had to shut it down because employees actually couldn't trust or verify the output. that they've gotten. So they ended up coming back to SP and reactivated their subscriptions where there was much higher data fidelity. So I don't know how much you can give on these anecdotes that management puts into the earnings calls, but I do think knowing SP, it's
29:53a sign for how valuable the data overall still is.
29:56Shawn O’Malley: There is also a study by OpenAI of all people that measured error rates across. financial data providers when the data is fed to a model. And SPs came in at under 3% against about six and a half for the next best competitor. In a world where AI is doing the reading on your behalf and the sifting through the data for you, the reliability of the inputs, the data inputs really is the product. And the company with the best. inputs ends up as the most valuable part of the chain. And today you pay for data and the AI access sort of comes along for free. But eventually, pricing may shift toward paying for how much you use. And nobody really knows yet what that does to revenue in comparison to that seat-based pricing model that we were talking about.
30:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
30:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): just to be fair to the bears, I think the platform part of market intelligence. aka capital IQ, is growing slowly in the lowest single digits now. And it does seem to be impacted. So what's happening is that renewals with big clients are just taking longer. And that's mostly because everyone's negotiating with AI rights they get, or basically the AI rights they want, and then they can see how far they can get SP to go. So the interface really is under pressure. I think that's fair to say. And although management recently said that those drawn-out negotiations are mostly behind them, now that they've standardized the AI terms in their contract, it's still impacting the numbers, at least for now.
31:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
31:25Shawn O’Malley: think the point we're trying to make is that to the extent that this is true, capital IQ is not hugely consequential to SP S P global's intrinsic value. Ultimately. So we probably shouldn't linger on it long. longer than we need to, right? It's been a source of concern for the markets, and it seems like a very important part of the company. But as we've tried to argue, it's not as much as the perception would suggest. And what I want to talk with you about next is definitely a more consequential debate for the stock, which is what will happen to the ratings business. And I say that not just because the Fed is hiking rates, though that definitely does not help, but because if we ever get a moment where it's clear AI was a bubble and it has popped, we're going to see a drought in debt issuance. That's just the reality. And since SP gets paid, when borrowers come to them asking to have their debt rated, they're looking to raise more money from the financial markets. Then if you
32:25get the situation where there's less borrowing. activity because the financial markets have frozen up, that is bad for the ratings business. And it is a very lucrative business to be in, one of the best business models we've ever studied with a wide, wide moat. But it does absolutely have cyclicality baked into it. It's not like a software subscription business where at least before AI, it was up and to the right, and you never had. to worry about that really declining. There is some volatility naturally based on the flows of the financial markets.
33:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Or than to be in the revenues and profits of companies, then what you might see is that there's a timing issue where you know a lot of the debt has to be repaid and you don't yet see the profits actually coming in, and then you have a problem. And usually, if you invest in the best companies possible, that doesn't matter too much in the long term. In this case, you would actually buy into a company that is very directly, maybe has the most direct connection to exactly that part of the market if that should happen. You can also argue that again, on a longer time horizon, they will be fine. But there's certainly going to be a lot of volatility when that happens. Just last year, for example, there was a record year for debt issuance, and this year has been even bigger, thanks in large part to all the debt, of course, being issued by companies like Anthropic, OpenAI, and the MAC 7, like you alluded to. And they're all raising capital to fund data centers, chip purchases, and energy for data centers and so on. So there's a whole chain, a value chain basically surrounding AI that is being financed by debt and ratings revenue grew double digits in the first half alone. And the second quarter was the best quarter in the division's history, with margins actually pushing 70%. So I think that says a lot about you know where we're standing in the cycle. And as you mentioned before, the AI buildout is being financed with bonds. So the hyperscalers issue something like $240 billion of debt in the first nine months of this
34:28year, which is more than SP had assumed for the entire year. And big tech now carries more weight in some of the major investment grade bond indexes than banks do, which is insane to think about. And we also saw appetites for mergers and acquisitions to come back, which makes sense when you have equity markets returning to all-time highs. And fortunately for SP, every MA M and A deal needs a rating. And then there's also private credit, which for a long time was a world without ratings, but it is starting to now also want them, especially with the last couple of years and the insane growth that you saw in those private credit markets. And SP's private market ratings revenue was up 60% in the second quarter for context. So if you remember all of that, you know how the economics work, most of the costs in ratings are fixed. So that means analysts are already. on the payroll, meaning when issuance spikes, almost every incremental dollar of fees goes straight to the operating profit of a company like S P, which is why the division's profit margin jumped about three percentage points in a single quarter, which is insane for a company of that size. And it's a wonderful business when the sun is out.
35:34Shawn O’Malley: I like that. When the sun is out, it's a good metaphor. And to continue that metaphor, we're starting to see some clouds gather, I guess you could say. And in our last episode on S P that we did, we said the environment of interest rate cuts was bullish for SP. And we were right, but that assumption only lasted a year. And in September, we saw the Fed raise raised rates for the first time in three years, and fuel prices from the Iranian. Iran war, inflation from AI capex booms, tariffs, all of it has pushed the Fed into tightening. And the consensus is that we'll have one more quarter point hike before the year is out for 2026. And with the 10-year Treasury sitting a little above 5% after briefly hitting its highest level since 2002, the macro backdrop under the ratings business. has really flipped from what I would say is a tailwind to a headwind.
36:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): There definitely are some headwinds for SP now. I think the major bear argument would be that you have market intelligence getting disrupted by AI, and the ratings business is probably at a cyclical top. So even though the stock has come down from trading at nearly 60 times earnings to about 26 times earnings in just three years, it's not nearly as cheap. as it seems, because if you adjust for that, probably the stock is more expensive than it looks at first glance. And there's a once in a generation wave of AI debt that may not repeat, and markets are already pushing back on it. And demand for hyperscaler bonds, as we could see, and also the deals, measured by how many dollars of orders come in for every dollar of bonds sold, went from nearly five times in February of this year to under two just by the summer. So then you add to that stuff like the SpaceX IPO and the SpaceX bond trading at junk-like yields within weeks of being issued. And we also had that little market panic about the Neo Cloud Core Weave and its bonds. And Oracle has seen its overall credit rating get dragged down as well. So there's definitely a lot of stuff going on in the market. And to grossly oversimplify when your credit rating goes down, you have to pay more interest to borrow. So companies typically borrow less, and that also means fewer new bonds for SP to rate.
37:47Shawn O’Malley: It is a challenge for them, but that hasn't prevented our colleague Stig Broderson a few weeks ago in his mastermind episode. Did actually also pitch SP. So the audience is probably reasonably familiar with SP after we covered it last year, and then after Stig pitched it. and now we're talking about it again. So we'll have in the show notes a link to Stig's pitch for SPGI from that mastermind episode. So you'll be able to listen to that. And we go in a little more in-depth here, but you can definitely hear his perspective as well if you miss that episode. But going back to the conversation here about where we are in the rating cycle, I would definitely say that I'm wary because we've seen what a down year can look like in ratings. And that was in 2022. Ratings revenue fell 26%, and operating profit fell 35%. So that's a third of the profit in the biggest division of the company just gone in 12 months. And while actually the private credit world has really started to look like a promising growth engine, that market is also now visible. visibly distressed as well, partly because, well, I'm sure you can guess
38:55why. Of course, it's because of AI, right? Everything's because of AI these days. Uh, there is truth to that, though, in this case. Instead of going out and selling bonds with the help of an investment bank to hundreds or thousands of different investors who contribute to a slice, the way to think about private credit is it's more like borrowing directly from one big investor. investment fund. So maybe think Blue Owl or Apollo. Those are both pretty big names in the private credit space. And obviously it's way too simplified, but the point is that private credit was more of a niche thing in the past, targeting companies that weren't big enough to get ratings. But you have now had devoted funds increasingly moving into this area as banks have become more and more hesitant to lend to small and medium sized enterprises after the great financial crisis. They're trying to put that risk off their balance sheet. And so, anyways, it's a bit of a tangent I've found myself on here, Daniel. But a lot more lending has occurred through private credit channels in recent years. And what that term private credit even means is starting to change as companies like SP get more involved. And as I said, that was seen as a big a tailwind for SP going forward. And I think it probably can be. But a chunk of this private credit market has included lending to software companies, many of which are at significant risk of being disrupted by
40:15AI, especially because they're smaller software players and they don't have some of the more deeply entrenched motes like a company like Salesforce or Adobe. So they're much more vulnerable. And that's exactly why Blue Owl stock has been dead money. They're one of the biggest private credit lenders with a huge portfolio of software companies that they lend to. And the market just does not like the loans they've made. They're not optimistic about the prospects of a lot of those businesses that were seen as some of the safest you could lend to because they had these stable recurring software subscriptions where you could look at it and say, hey, every month we have a rough idea of how much recurring cash flow there's going to be. Typically that would be a a beacon of stability, but AI has flipped that upside down.
41:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Maybe we should actually take another look at Blue Owl at some point. I think it was one of the companies that you pitched at the right of the beginning of this podcast. broadcast. So it's been a while and I know that some people in the community are invested or at least looking at the company. So maybe it's a good idea to look at that company at some point too. And you've definitely seen several product credit funds begin limiting redemptions. And a few big refinancings actually fail. So yeah, I think if I'm a bear, I'm thinking you're paying 26 times earnings for that company. And that was produced in the best issuance environment in the industry or that the industry has basically ever seen. So yes, rates go up in that case. but it's not wildly expensive. But it certainly isn't one of those obvious one-foot hurdles that Buffett keeps talking about that you want to step over because it's an easy decision to make. And even if there isn't a dramatic blowup tied to AI that rocks markets like it was during the dot-com bubble or maybe in 2008, you still have to think about the ratings growth could slow down or stall out entirely. And I think that's more likely to happen that you don't see this major boom that some people expect, but that just slowly over time, you see that let's say the hype surrounding AI and investments is going to get slower and decline basically. And it kind of reminds me of Netflix during the pandemic. So you had this external factor that created this incredibly ripe business opportunity because everyone was sitting
42:21at home, which pulled several years worth of growth forward. And then on the other side, Netflix. has done so well, but you basically had three years of growth compressed into just one year. And that was a head when that they're probably just now getting fully passed, which is also part of why we think that currently the stock is quite attractive, because a lot of the slower growth that you have seen in the last couple of years has still been this pullback or basically this pull forward of Off demand from COVID.
42:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
42:47Shawn O’Malley: would agree with you. There's a pretty high likelihood I would say that ratings will have a down year in the next 18 months. And it's purely speculative, but kind of th idea is to be directionally correct. But also at the same time, we can afford to be patient. We know how structurally important SP's ratings business is. And so long as the financial markets continue to expand, Band generally, that business will do well over time. So it does also feel like a moment where you can do some time arbitrage. Professional investors have to sell if it looks like the next two or three quarters will be disappointing. But as individual investors, we have the luxury of being able to completely look past that. And whether that ends up breaking the thesis or just tests, it'll be hard to say. But I would definitely argue that it feels more likely to be the second, because I think SP after every market crash and economic recession has only really emerged stronger and more entrenched as a reliable ratings agency even after the 2008 financial crisis where a lot of their integrity was called into question. Their role in the financial system has only widened. So even that that big of a crisis really did not damage their market share. And what I also like about the ratings business is that it sort of has a built-in cushion.
44:06So even when issuance slows, when borrowing slows, SP keeps collecting what are known as surveillance fees, which are recurring fees that companies pay to have their existing ratings monitored and kept up to date, hence the surveillance fee term. So there's a lot of cyclicality for the business generally. but there is something of a recurring baseline that puts a floor under the downside.
44:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So roughly half of ratings revenue is that recurring monitoring fee. And it definitely grew every single year, even through the last downturn. So transaction revenue is actually the part that swings when it's a more cyclical time. And then there's a so-called refinancing wall that's also looming. So that's basically SP. publishing every year. There's something like 11 or 12 trillion dollars of debt that SP already rates coming due over the next four to five years. And with the peak being in 2028, and that debt has to be refinanced whether the 10 years at 3% or 5% or even 7%. So higher rates change the price of borrowing, not the need to borrow. And a company that refinances at a higher interest rate still pays the same rating fee.
45:19Shawn O’Malley: The lending cycle moves the timing of issuance around, but it doesn't move the maturities that have already been set, right? I mean, that's for sure. And just to touch on private credit again, there is an interesting angle, I think, to consider there. And so stress in private credit is bad for the funds, but in some ways it is an opportunity for. SP to expand its market share, the amount of private credit debt that is being paid to rate and monitor. So it's sort of a mixed thing, right? The whole reason private loans don't carry ratings, or at least they didn't in the past, is because they really didn't feel like there was a need to when everything was was going up and it was quite easy. You know, access to capital was sort of very loose. And so now pension funds and insurers, though, are becoming more conservative with their risk appetites in private lending and they want more transparency. And that's exactly where an institution like SP Ratings can come in and enter the picture. And the company has launched a
46:19handful of private credit benchmarks, and it's building a cheaper product called a credit estimate for loans that don't need a full rating. And then Washington is pushing to let private assets into 401ks, which really can't happen without independent risk measures, which again is an opportunity for SP. So if we put that super simply, stress creates demand for measurements of risks and benchmarks. And that is, as we've talked about this entire recording, what SP does best.
46:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
46:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): actually we can just look at one of our favorite investors and see what he did because Berkshire has owned Moody's, which is SP's closest rival for about 25 years now. And he owned it through three issuance droughts. And the thing that got Buffett comfortable wasn't any particular issuance forecasts. It was more that the major ratings agencies came out of every single one of those droughts with the same share of the market. So SP, Moody's, and Fitch together. still rate something like 95% of the world's rated debt. And the big investment great deals almost always carry both an S P and a Moody's rating. And that's what makes the down year just a down year rather than the start of something worse. And that's what I mentioned earlier when I said that if you own the biggest and the best companies, even if there are a couple of years where the business is not doing well in 10 years' time, likely it will be a bigger and better business. And that's exactly where you want to be
47:40Shawn O’Malley: And just to put the share in perspective, SP rates about 99% of the industrial bonds in the United States. And when you have that kind of share, the cycle is really the main thing that can potentially set you back. It's not so much competition. And we know the cycle always ends. And if we zoom out, really the bigger long-term long term risk, honestly, is losing trust. in S P as an institution. And having the borrower, for example, pay for its own rating is something of a built-in conflict of interest, even though that's been the status quo for a long time. And after 2008, when the agencies had stamped their triple A ratings, the highest level of approval on mortgage bonds that ended up blowing up, S P paid about a billion and a half dollars to settle with the Justice Department and the states. And so that was a huge reputational blow. And yet, as I said a moment ago, its market share barely budged. And to me, that tells you how wide SP's ratings moat is, where you can have this kind of crisis in confidence, and still we end up back at relying. on SP just as much, if not more.
48:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Could you imagine the two of us doing this podcast in 2006 or seven and then knowing about the financial crisis? And then what would have we thought about SP moody and so forth getting out of this crisis? I think there was a zero chance in my mind that they would get out of this and they just keep the same share that they had prior. And they did it. I think there's just no stamp of a approval for them that shows how important they are to the system and just how unlikely it is for them to lose the market share and just the position they have in the financial ecosystem. And actually the third quarter report that we just saw is also a pretty good illustration of all of that at once. So the build issuance, which is the dollar value of new debt issued that SP charges a credit rating fee on. So that grew 8% And the first three quarters of this year were the three strongest quarters for issuance the company has ever had. And yet, ratings revenue actually only grew 2-3% in the quarter because it was lapping last year's monster third quarter. So there were tough comms for it to be it. And that's because they shifted the mix toward big investment great deals and away from those riskier junk bonds and leveraged loans, which pay SP significantly more. per dollar rated. And in fact, if you strip out the the hyperscaler deals in itself, the issuance would have only grown in the low single digits. So that's something about the concentration of issuance right now.
50:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Let's take a quick break and hear from today's sponsors.
50:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
50:16Shawn O’Malley: know that sinking feeling when a meeting ends, everyone's nodding along, and two days later you realize nobody wrote down who was doing what. That's why I use granola. Granola is an AI powered notepad that makes your meeting notes useful. It captures what happens in your meetings and it turns it into clean, structured notes with decisions and action items pulled out and made easy to find. On days with back to back calls like guest prep and team check ins, community calls, I used to spend the gaps cleaning up messy notes and trying to remember who owned. what. Now I stay in the conversation, and weeks later, everything is searchable in one place. Once you try it on a first meeting, it's hard to go without. You can try it totally free. Head to granola.ai slash WSB. That's granola.ai slash WSB to get your time back. Go to granola.ai granola.ai/slash slash WSB and try it on your next call. You don't need me to tell you that rent and mortgages are only getting more expensive. That's why Built created three credit cards designed to offer the richest rewards on rent, mortgage, and everything else you spend on. Whether you rent or own, you can earn up to 1.25x 25X points on every housing payment
51:36without the transaction fee, no matter where you live. points can be redeemed for flights, hotels, lift rides, a future housing payment, and much more. Turn one of the most unavoidable payments in your life into the most rewarding. Find the car that's right for you and apply at joinbuilt.com slash TIP. That's J-O-I-N-B-I-L-T I-n b-i-l t dot com slash T I P. Use our link so they know we sent you. Terms apply, subject to approval and eligibility. Built cards are issued by column NA, member FDIC, pursuant to license from MasterCard International, Incorporated. Interested in futures trading and looking for a place to get started? With Plus500 Futures, you can explore some of the world's most active markets, all from one easy-to-use platform. Trade futures on popular assets. like the SP 500, Nasdaq, oil, gold, Bitcoin, Forex, and more. Whether markets are moving in crypto, commodities, or indices, there's always something to follow. Plus 500 Futures is designed to make trading straightforward with a platform you can access wherever you are, right from your phone. And you can get started with a minimum deposit of just $10. Not ready to trade with real funds? Try the free unlimited demo account first and explore the platform. without putting real money at risk. Backed by nearly 20 years of
52:55experience and trusts by millions of customers worldwide, plus 500 gives you the tools to stay connected to the futures markets. Visit us.com to learn more. Trading in futures involves risk of loss and is not suitable for everyone. Not all applicants will qualify. Plus 500, it's trading with a plus.
53:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
53:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): right,
53:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): back
53:16Shawn O’Malley: to the show.
53:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No,
53:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): it's all good points. And maybe if we're gonna take a more optimistic note, one of the one of the things
53:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
53:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): makes me most excited about SPGI right now is
53:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how the
53:26Shawn O’Malley: company
53:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): has spent the last year making itself a simpler company. You know, we're we're simple guys, Daniel, right? We we like black and white businesses and we like when conglomerates get broken up and it's easier for us to understand. And when we start with their former mobility segment, that was spun off on July 1st. This was the automotive data business. And so Carfax and everything around it. And it was spun off a new public company called Mobility Global. And
53:56Shawn O’Malley: shareholders Holders got one share of the new company for every SP share. And it was the lowest margin. division in the group. It had the least to do with capital markets. And it was a piece that came along with the IHS market merger. They did a few years ago, and it just never really fit. And so removing it lifts the company's overall profit margins by an entire percentage point.
54:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And I should say that in this case, actually the company that benefited was the power parent company, so SP, because the market hasn't been kind to. the spin-off itself. Last year, there were reports that we also mentioned in our pitch that private equity would actually pay $10 to $12 billion for the mobility spin-off or the part of the business. As a standalone company, though, it's now trading at about $5 billion. So significantly below those estimates.
54:44Shawn O’Malley: Just a The week after that spin-off, you had another big change come through within market intelligence. The company reordered.
54:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): reorganized the whole division into two lines. And so one line is called Kincho Data and Platforms, which includes data feeds plus capital IQ. And then the other one is enterprise solutions. And this includes things like the software that powers much of the global loan market and portfolio monitoring tools that are used and private equity. And this
55:11Shawn O’Malley: enterprise
55:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): solutions group is growing about 10% while the data. feeds are growing high single digits as well. And
55:18Shawn O’Malley: CapIQ, the financial data terminal that we've talked a bit about today, is growing revenue at low single digit percentages. So it is again the weaker link of the entire company, but also the weaker link within the market intelligence division.
55:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
55:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): basically, to summarize, they have separated the things they are available valuable from the more vulnerable. parts of the market intelligence division.
55:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
55:42Shawn O’Malley: I think that's right. And then on September 1st, Bloomberg reported that
55:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): SP is considering spending off capital IQ entirely as its own public company at a valuation in the high single-digit billions, potentially. And then on the latest earnings call, management actually made this only clearer that they're looking to shop capital IQ in addition to considering. a spinoff. So I like the idea of trimming your weakest links here and also cutting out capital IQ. I think makes SP much less of a tech company, which in this case is actually a a good thing, even though we think of tech as having been really the best performing sector of the last few decades. And it it allows them to double down on the best parts of the business, which are ratings, indices. and energy, without all the distraction that has come with trying to run a desktop terminal business, competing with Facet and Bloomberg for software subscriptions.
56:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Judge by the reaction to the news, I think the market does seem to like the idea of getting rid of capsule IQ You one way or another, meaning spinning it off or just selling it. And I think that tells you there's a conglomerate disk. discount, which we mentioned earlier, sitting on SP's shares right now. And one of our favorite books is The Outsiders by William Thorndike. And that book is basically all about how CEOs can make or break shareholder returns with these kinds of capital decisions. And what I think about SP's capital allocation, it seems very mixed to me. And we discussed this actually also before the call. So you had multiple reorganizations and now a possible spin or sale. of one of their flagship products, which isn't necessarily a ringing endorsement of being focused, especially after the mobility spin-off, which in itself was probably the right decision. No questions about that. But it also opens up a question about the initial acquisition. I mean, they paid forty-four billion dollars for AHS market, and it doesn't seem like they had any idea of what they're actually getting into there.
57:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): For as much prey as praise SP gets by investors, I haven't felt that aligns well with some of the actual decisions they've made in recent years. But there is another interesting business reason for them to separate from the capital IQ desktop product. A lot of the new AI native research tools like AlphaSense are reluctant to lean on SP's data because capital IQ competes with them. And if you take capital IQ, out of house, S P becomes more of a neutral supplier of data to every front end software interface, including the ones that are trying to kill and beat Capital IQ. And so it's sort of similar in a way. Maybe this is a stretch, Daniel, but it reminds me of what Uber has done as being a neutral aggregator for autonomous vehicle companies. But uh, you know.
58:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Of course it does. You're
58:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): gonna say that I
58:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): we had to bring Uber in the mix here.
58:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah. Everything reminds you of Uber. But uh, you know, I mean, if we look at SP, they certainly haven't been shy about trimming weak links in the business either. And since 2013, this company has sold the education side of its business. It also sold off JD Power, the engineering business, and then it sold off a derivatives processing. joint venture. And then now it's spun off mobility, which was Carfax. And each time it subtracts something that doesn't compound, like one of the benchmarking businesses, the share of profit that comes from those benchmarking businesses goes up. And so does the quality of the entire enterprise. And therefore the multiple that the market should be willing to pay to. own shares in the remaining company.
59:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): What's a bit frustrating here and kind of gives me a mixed feeling is that SP seems to be aware of the fact that they're trading at a discount because they are this conglomerate. And then they try to solve that and spin off businesses or sell them. But every now and then, every couple of years, you see them getting into another huge merger or takeover. And that just seems very contradictory to me.
59:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): To be fair, that was done under the previous CEO. So really at best, we can say Martina Chung's capital allocation skills are mostly untested. Selling or spending off CapIQ after spending the mobility division last year are really the two main things we can look at. But I want to talk more about indices because it has been the best performing. part of the company and it just signed a pretty consequential contract. So for context, the index business has now reported 14 consecutive record quarters. And this year, we also saw the first ETF in history pass $1 trillion in assets under management. And lo and behold, it is an S P 500 tied index fund. And it's not one fund that's driving all the success, though, for SP as a company. There's roughly $20 trillion in funds that are indexed or benchmarked to the SP $500 index alone.
1:00:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:00:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): just to remind folks how the indices actually make money, so basically, every time someone puts a dollar into an index fund, the fund manager pays SP a tiny sliver of that. dollar each year. So it's a fraction of a penny for the right to use the name, basically. And that doesn't sound like much, but if you think about trillions of dollars, it definitely adds up quite fast. And the reason they pay that fee is because of branding, which kind of sounds funny because you know the S P 500, you think about it as just an index, but it's the best known stock index in the world. And that is definitely worth something. So there's no end to how many investments. investment strategies you can invest in. But if you're a fund manager and you can mention that it's tied to the most well-known stock index, that certainly isn't going to hurt when you try to raise assets. And I should also add that when someone tries to trade an SP 500 option or future, the exchange pays SP a small royalty on each of those contracts. So the index itself costs almost nothing to maintain once it exists, obviously. And so then every dollar that is coming in is basically a dollar of profit.
1:01:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:01:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): think it's fair to say SP Global may be the biggest beneficiary of the passive investing revolution of the last few decades, where you've seen this explosion in assets under management invested in the stock market, and particular in these index fonts. that are tied to indexes and who else produces indexes. Well there's some competitors, but S P definitely leads the way. And S P five hundred is probably the one where you could go out on the street and ask the average person, Hey, do you know what this is? And they might not know exactly, but they'll say, Yeah, that's a like a stock market thing. You know, it's a stock market index. And and point being that's pretty good for how esoteric the financial markets can be. That's actually pretty incredible that you have such broad brand awareness. And that's what I love about SP generally as a potential investment, is that they just they benefit from the rise of passive investing. They benefit from more debt issuance, these massive sort of of mega trends of just the expansion of the financialization of our economy.
1:02:51and the global economy too, that all really ripples back to benefit them. And just on that second piece you mentioned on royalties on derivatives, in late September, CBOE and SP Dow Jones indices announced a 25 year extension of their exclusive license for S SP P 500 options through 2051. And so for context, the CBOE stands for the Chicago Board Options Exchange. And they have had an exclusive arrangement since 1983 with SP. And those options are some of the most liquid products on Earth, with a close to a billion contracts being traded a year. And what will happen is the terms will step up in 2027, which management has said, well, will add a couple of points of growth to the index division at SP. But at the same time, CBOE has called the impact of this increase in pricing on its growth as being de minimis, which tells you that SP didn't squeeze them as much as they could have.
1:03:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): That's what I was going to ask because CBOE's stock jumped something like five to ten percent on the news on that day. And that sometimes tells you that maybe SP left some money on the table, or at least that's what the market thinks.
1:04:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): They might have left a little, but we've talked about this with FICO in the past. There's something to be said as an industry standard for not extorting your customers relentlessly with price hikes and just abusing Using that privileged position. Then if SP had used the renewal to extract a huge increase, every exchange and fund manager would probably start thinking about at least the possibility of using alternatives. And the whole advantage of owning a widely recognized benchmark is that nobody thinks of the alternatives. And if we look at the SpaceX IPO in June, that was the biggest IPO in history. And there was much debate over which indexes SpaceX would be included in. And NASDAQ changed its rules so. SpaceX could get into its indexes faster. And the FTSE FTSE Financial Times Stock Exchange Russell did the same. But SP remained firm that if SpaceX couldn't qualify on its own merits, then it wouldn't be included and it didn't qualify.
1:05:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Which I personally like, liked, but there were definitely some people criticizing it at the time. And basically the argument was that any an index is meant to represent the market and it can't just leave out the biggest IPO in history. And I mean we covered SpaceX. You also sent me an article just recently about how it maybe be more attractive than the market or at least some parts of the market believe. I haven't yet read it. I will definitely get to it tonight, but I can definitely get the argument of saying, well, if you don't meet the criteria, we don't include you.
1:05:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah, and I I think that logic applies for a lot of indexes. But the integrity of the index to some extent relies on the fact that you have to be a profitable company for consecutive quarters to be included in the SP 500. So I think choosing not to compromise on that is the right decision. And SpaceX, I'm sure, will eventually find its way into the S SP P 500 index. And all of that said, the index business is not without. risks, which is why we previously passed on investing in a more pure play index competitor of SP's MSCI. And our concern was that basically as index funds keep getting cheaper, it leaves less and less room to pay the index provider a fee. And that was sort of speculative on our end. But we also just didn't love the price that MSCI was trading at. And when you do look at some of the biggest passive index funds in the world, many of them are effectively approaching zero fees, which is a great thing for the median retail investor. And maybe not so great of a thing for fund managers and the benchmarks behind them in terms of the share of the economics as that pool of fees diminishes. But new opportunities. are emerging too, right? The day before earnings, SP Dow Jones
1:06:55indices announced a partnership with Calci, the prediction markets company that will bring its benchmarks into prediction markets. And whenever a new market forms, I think SP they want to be the standard that it settles against. And I I have hesitations about that. I mean, there's some real questions about the legality of prediction markets and in their positive. or negative effect on society, but there's no doubt that they've exploded onto the national scene. And I don't blame SP for wanting to treat that as a legitimate business opportunity.
1:07:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, uh similar to you, uh I personally don't have any touch points with them, but I can't say that I'm uh a big fan. And then again, I'm also of the opinion that grown up people can decide what to do with their own money. So if they decide to gamble with it, that's fine with me. I'm not sure I fully understand what the partnership is supposed to achieve, but as you said, S P is eager to be a front runner on these things, so it's likely a good deal for them. We talked about trust and what S P stands for. It's questionable whether Calci fits that criteria, but then And again, it's a huge part of the financial market and it's only getting bigger. So I definitely think it it makes sense. And maybe just to move forward here, how about we go to S ⁇ P's energy business, which we didn't yet talk about? And I would just ask you, how does especially the conflict we've seen in the Middle East impact Platz? Because that's something that we obviously couldn't cover a year ago when I first pitched.
1:08:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
1:08:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): sure everyone knows that the Iran War that started back in February set off one of the biggest energy price shocks since the 1970s. And you would think that would be good for a business that sells oil price data, but it's not quite that straightforward. So Platts is the benchmark for something like 70% of the world's seaborne crude. And normally a bit of volatility is good for business because it means there's more trading activity. But when the volatility gets really extreme, trading desks will typically take a step back. And actually, SP's trading services revenue can then fall with that. And the third quarter. did look a bit healthier, with management saying that renewals with its Middle East customers are returning to pre-war levels. But we'll see if that lasts. Obviously, nobody knows.
1:09:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Maybe you can just give a few tangible examples to just really make clear how SP generates revenue in its energy division.
1:09:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah. So think about maybe an oil refinery that buys crude oil. and then sells products like gasoline and diesel. So crude oil is the input, gasoline and diesel are the output. It needs reliable prices for specific products and locations. And then SP's Platt Businesses publishes price assessments that would help the refinery negotiate deals and value its inventory. And the refinery pays a subscription then to access those prices. through reports or or through access to live data feeds. And another example would be to think about a financial markets exchange that offers a futures contract whose settlement value is tied to a Platz price assessment. So think about the C B O E, as we talked about. They're licensing that benchmark from SP and then paying a usage-based royalty, usage in the sense of how much trading volume there is. So basically. more trading in those contracts generally means more royalties for SP, which is a separate revenue stream from selling subscriptions to the underlying price data. So there is a bit of diversification there. And so if you just think about another example here to round it out, imagine a company that's considering building a new natural gas project. They're gonna going to want to forecast supply and demand and prices to judge whether the economics of that specific project makes
1:10:30sense. So what they're going to do is go ahead and buy an a research and analytics subscription from SP, or they may even hire S P as a project consultant directly. So one generates recurring subscription revenue, the other generates project fees. But all around, you can hopefully get the idea that it's a pretty good business to be in.
1:10:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It definitely helps. And as you said, I think especially in the long term, regardless of what happens in the short term, I think it's a strong business to be in. And just because it came to my mind, I I yesterday read the the Pershing Square investment letter that came out. And obviously I couldn't help myself but notice that once again, there's some form of overlap that we have with Bill Blackman. Ackman. We have some positions already, you know, Universal Music Group. that Ackman was invested in, and we still are. And then you have Netflix, you have Amazon, and obviously we have your favorite company, Uber. And now Pershing Square, which I should mention quickly is Bill Ackman's firm, disclosed a new position also in SP Global over the summer. So if we do end up buying SP, people might again accuse us of uh copying Ackman on this move. And Ackman's argument basically is pretty is similar to what we're saying. So that investors have basically fixated on threats to a single digit slice of the company and lost sight of the fact that future annex growth will be driven almost entirely by the benchmark business. So the small part that we're talking about again is capital IQ, which we talked about could either be spun off or sold. And it's not a major part of how SP actually makes money.
1:12:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
1:12:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): certainly don't want to blindly follow any other investment. investors into investments, right? I mean, we know that borrowed conviction does not last. But hey, I mean, it is nice to know that somebody with a a pretty successful track record thinks similarly about a company in the way that you do. And another super investor that we think highly of and take inspiration from is Tom Gaynor of Markel. And we're pretty excited to say actually that in March of this. year, we're going to be having a private dinner with him. So if you've ever wanted to have the chance to sit at a table of five, six, seven, eight people, probably less than a dozen at most, and have an intimate conversation with one of the most successful value investors in the world, a billionaire, CEO of a major corporation. This is a really incredible. chance to do so that we're facilitating. And Tom Gaynor and Markel are friends of the show. And basically, this is an opportunity we're making available only to members of the TIP inner circle community, which is our most premium and most exclusive investor community that we offer. So you can just go to the investorspodcast.com/slash investorspodcast.com slash inner circle or go to the investorspodcast.com. and under the mastermind dropdown, you'll find a page for inner circle. And you can apply to
1:13:19join the community, and that will give you the opportunity to attend and join us for a dinner with Tom Gaynor. Anything you want to add there, Daniel?
1:13:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Uh maybe. I don't know if it's a selling argument, but if you apply and we usually have calls that you know we host, and it's either Sean or me sitting on that call, we just talked. talk for about 20 to 30 minutes, sometimes it's longer than that, and assess whether you would be a good fit. So we can basically immediately tell you what the community is about if you have any questions. And we also get a feel for whether it's a good fit. And as Sean said, then you have these incredible opportunities of sitting at a table with some of the best investors in the world that otherwise would most likely not be possible.
1:13:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Well, that's our spiel. But uh we hope you'll consider joining us. for that very special dinner with Tom in Richmond, Virginia in March. But something else that's interesting getting back to SP is that there's been pretty significant insider buying this year for the first time in a while. Martina Chung, SP CEO, plus the head of the index business and two directors all bought in the open market earlier this year at around $430 a share. And they bought something like three and a half million. dollars worth of stock between them. And getting more skin in the game at the top is always great, especially since that's one of the things we were more critical of the company when we looked at them in the past. The counter-argument is still that insiders only own about 0.1% of the total shares outstanding, which is overall very low. But it is also interesting that in the last year, the company has returned more than all of its free cash flow to shareholders. And so in the last 12 months, they've spent around seven billion dollars on buybacks, funded partly with the $2 billion dividend that the mobility division paid as kind of a one-off on the way out the door. And then they also raise their dividend to SP shareholders for the 53rd Third straight year. So they're doing a great job returning capital to shareholders. And it's always a good thing to see that when they're using the corporate money to buy back the stock,
1:15:19management personally is using their own money to buy the stock too, which is sort of a a reiteration of their conviction in that capital allocation decision.
1:15:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:15:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): we should mention that for a new CEO, it's always difficult to build a sizable position in a company the size of SP. S P. So while 0.1% point one percent doesn't sound like a lot and it's not. for a new CEO, again, it's difficult to build positions that we usually are used for founders, let's say five or six percent of the company. And we talked about mergers and acquisitions before and that we don't like the capital allocation in the past. So now seeing that there's a new CEO and they return a lot of capital to shareholders is definitely a good thing. If I want to spin it, and I don't like to be that person, but if I want to spin it negatively, you could say that shrinking the share count is a good chunk of why they even beat earnings this past quarter. So it's very much a good thing that they seem to be more aggressive about repurchases as the valuation multiple has contracted further and further, which is what we discussed earlier too. They've actually repurchased twice as much stock as they did two years ago when the stock traded at nearly twice the PE multiple. So that's good capital allocation. And you could also make the argument that when you trade at 60 times earnings, maybe the acquisitions that they did make sense at the time, simply because buying back shares at a 60x multiple is not the best use of capital either. So for a company with that and 40x medium PE over the last five years, there's not a ton of organic growth going on. I guess that's why the multiple has come down so much. I kind of like the idea of now paying back shares shared us when even if we are at had the a top, the valuation is only
1:16:49at 26 twenty-six times. So what do you say? Talking about valuation here, how about we talk about your model and you tell us what's the fair value of the company now compared to maybe a year ago?
1:16:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Valuation time. All right. Yeah, let's do it. It's one of our favorite parts of the episodes here. We've updated our model on SP and the link for that is in the show notes. As always, we try to be as transparent as possible. You can see the very basic model we put together. We don't like to get lost. in the weeds and sort of like try to get directionally a correct or you know reasonable estimation of what a company would be worth to a buyer who wanted to acquire 100% of it. And so like I said, I don't want to get lost in the weeds, but for anyone looking at SP's financials, you should know that they're impacted by a billion dollars a year's worth of amortization from that IHS market dealer. So that's still lingering and impacting them. And it's basically an accounting expense for the intangible assets they bought, like customer relationships that spread out over many years. But it doesn't cost them any cash today since they paid for that deal in stock four years ago. So that's just something to be aware of. And still, if management is going to keep making big MA
1:17:57deals like that, then it is sort of hard to justify stripping that out as a one-off cost. But if you see that as a one-time thing and you don't think management's going to make any more acquisitions like that, it is much more reasonable to go with the adjusted numbers that management provides that basically say, you know, hey, this is not representative of the operating business going forward. So you should ignore those costs. And then for the exit multiple, meaning the price of to earnings ratio that we assume the stock will trade at by the end of our forecast, I use the the same range as last time, which works out to about 27 times, which is about where the stock is trading at the time of recording, and is a pretty significant discount to where it's traded over the last five and 10 years on average. So not a super conservative multiple, but I think a reasonably conservative multiple relative. to how the market has thought about valuing S P previously. And like I said, that's roughly in line with SP's own long run average forward multiple. So we're assuming that the stock will essentially get back to normal and not to a premium. And then with an 8% discount rate, which is the minimum yearly return we would want for owning an equity instead of choosing to own bonds, I get a fair value. of about five hundred dollars a share and then an
1:19:17intrinsic value target, but arbitrarily with a 20% margin of safety of around $400 is when I think it could potentially start to look very attractive. And like I said, my valuation is a bit more conservative than others because I want to make sure I included the effects of the down cycle in the ratings business that we've talked about and what that will look like when whenever AI CapEx normalizes and we see less borrowing from the hyperscalers. And against the stock at around $450 per share at the time of recording, they had a little bit of a run up into earnings. Shares are definitely, I would say, in the ballpark of being a decent entry price to nibble on. As long as we're on the same page, that we both like the businesses. business's prospects longer term in the management and the capital allocation and all of that.
1:20:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:20:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): think S P is definitely a business that we want to own in the long term. Even last year, I think we agreed on that when I did the pitch. And now it's only about the question of what price do you want to pay? And if you look at the history of S P and look at the multiples that the market used to pay for this company, 27 is definitely not an expensive multiple. It's not a premium to what the company used to trade at. It's also not that conservative, especially if you think about the timing right now, having a pretty bullish market for S P and then thinking about what could happen if you see that cycle turnaround. And it's actually interesting to look at the history and just compare what happened to the stock. So when there was a down cycle, did the multiple go up because the earnings went down but the market knew about the quality or did the multiple come down as well? And then you get this double whammy that makes, you know, the margin of safety even more relevant because the stock could go down significantly lower. And those were just some of my thoughts here. But what do you think, before I chime in again, of where does this leave us? What do you think we should do with with S P at these prices?
1:21:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
1:21:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): like I said, I'm I'm kind of we've wanted to own S SP P for a long time, and we cover so many companies, and there's always so much going on in the market. We When you don't have a bit of portfolio exposure to a business, it you just it's easy to miss opportunities and forget about it. And because of that, even if it's not a screaming buy, I think we can do pretty well at these prices. I wouldn't say it's obviously an asymmetry Symmetry in the probability distribution where, you know, it's very, very likely that we're going to generate a double-digit Kager over you know a five or 10 year period. At the same time, I like the idea of owning a business of this quality. It's one you can sleep pretty soundly at night owning. And so if we take a little bite at maybe one percent, one and a half percent of our portfolio, because we have trimmed some holdings recently. We have a little bit of cash to deploy, I think that would be a very pragmatic. thing for us to do where we recognize ultimately this is a business that we would want to own at a full five percent weighting. We consider five percent to be sort of a standard size, and then anything more than that is meant to reflect sort of excess conviction in a position. So Google and Uber are some of our positions that have the highest weightings in our portfolio at around 10%.
1:22:26And yeah, I would love to see SP be a 5% weighting in the portfolio. We just have to get the right price. And I don't think this moment in time gives us a big enough margin of safety to go all in at making SP a 5% weighting, but we can nibble on it. And if we get another chance to buy shares closer to $400 or below, I would love to double down and fill in the other three and a half percent of that position. But yeah, tell me how you think about it.
1:22:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:22:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): could definitely get on board with that. I think we sort of missed the point when the shares were actually cheaper than the last time we pitched it. And part of that, as you said, is that we look at so many businesses that it's hard to keep track with all of them. So if you might think, well, if it's only a one or two percent position, why even add it in the first place? Primarily so it stays on our radar and we actually check the earnings all the time. We know exactly what the stock is doing. So that if the stock is going way below $400, where we think it should be a full position, which means 5%, that we can actually buy the stock. And I think that's a a pretty, pretty good tactic to play this. And if that's how we decide, I would say we go for let's do one and a half percent right now, again, more of a tracker position, and then we can double down when we think the price has become even. more attractive than it is today. And I should say that you mentioned it, we sold some positions. So that means compared to some of the last few weeks, where we always had to make the opportunity cost assessment based on we have to sell a position to invest in a new one. Now we actually have a lot
1:23:55of capital, which means we don't need to sell position and can just allocate some of that capital, which makes the decision slightly easier. at least for me personally, to now add SP at these prices with a little position.
1:24:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Okay. All right. Well it sounds good. And we try to keep things up to date with our portfolio on the podcast here. We do also have our newsletter, the intrinsic value newsletter that you can sign up for free for at the investorspodcast.com, where we share weekly updates on the companies we follow and also break down new businesses as well. So that's a great way to keep up with how we're thinking about things. And then also we try to do a YouTube live stream once a week. So if you go and subscribe to the intrinsic value podcast on YouTube, if you hit the subscribe button, you will get notifications when we go live and you can listen into our live streams and where we talk through making some of these decisions in real time. But I'll go ahead and close things out. Today's quote comes from Charlie Munger, who said, the big money is not in the buying, in the selling, but in the waiting. And we've been patient about finding the right entry price. And now we get a chance to enjoy some of the waiting with SP as we watch this company
1:25:07continue to compound. And with that, we'll see you all again next time.
1:25:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Thanks for listening to TIP. Follow the Investors Podcast on your favorite podcast app and visit theinvestorspodcast.com for show notes and educational resources. This podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and does not provide financial, investment, tax, or legal advice. The content is impersonal and does not consider your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principle, and past performance is not a guarantee of future results. Listeners should do their own research and consult a qualified professional before making any financial decisions. Nothing on this show is a recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell any security or other financial product. Hosts, guests, and the investors podcast network may hold positions in securities discussed and may change those positions at any time without notice. References to any third-party products, services, or advertisers do not constitute endorsements, and the investors' podcast network is not responsible. for any claims made by them. Copyright by the Investors Podcast Network, all rights reserved.