trading places

Speaker argues Dutch tulip mania lacked systemic economic damage and challenges historical exaggerations of the 1637 crash

25 min Listen to the original Episode page
Financial HistoryDutch RepublicTulip ManiaMarket BubblesDerivativesEconomic HistoryVOCCalvinism

Summary

The speaker promotes his book 'A Brief History of Financial Bubbles,' outlining three structural conditions for bubbles: long economic expansion, wealth concentration, and easy money. He details the rise of the Dutch East India Company (VOC) and the cultural factors that directed Dutch capital into tulip cultivation. The episode describes the unregulated, leveraged trading of tulip contracts in taverns and the subsequent price collapse in 1637. Finally, the speaker cites empirical research to argue that the crash caused no recession or bankruptcies, suggesting historical accounts of the damage were exaggerated for moralizing purposes.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    profitable company of all time, again, adjusting for growth and inflation, is more valuable than by 1620 and until about 1720, it's more valuable than NVIDIA and uh Alphabet and Microsoft combined.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 6:13

Episode sections

  1. 0:10 – 2:15

    Introduction and Book Promotion

    Speaker introduces the podcast episode as a promotion for his book, 'A Brief History of Financial Bubbles,' noting it is a number one Amazon bestseller in economics and economic history. He outlines the book's structure, covering ten historical bubbles, starting with Amsterdam in 1636 and ending with AI.

  2. 2:15 – 3:36

    Three Conditions for Bubbles and Dutch Economic Context

    The speaker outlines three prerequisites for bubbles: long economic expansion, wealth concentration, and easy money. He explains how the fall of Antwerp in 1581 drove skilled migrants to Amsterdam, fueling a seafaring economy that became the richest per capita in the world by the early 1600s.

  3. 3:36 – 6:25

    The Dutch East India Company (VOC) and Financial Innovation

    The speaker discusses the founding of the Amsterdam Stock Exchange in 1602 and the Dutch East India Company (VOC). He notes the VOC held a monopoly on spices and eventually became worth $10 trillion in today's dollars, making it the most profitable company historically, surpassing NVIDIA and Alphabet combined by 1620.

  4. 6:25 – 8:11

    Arrival and Early History of Tulips in the Netherlands

    Tulips arrived in the Dutch Republic around 1562, reportedly by accident via hay bales from Istanbul. Botanist Carolus Clusius documented the flowers and identified 'broken' varieties with rare colors as the most valuable, driving early interest.

  5. 8:11 – 10:30

    Cultural Factors: Calvinism and Spending Habits

    The speaker argues that Dutch Calvinist culture discouraged ostentatious spending on silks and carriages, leading the wealthy to invest in modest homes with gardens. This cultural preference for natural beauty helped direct capital into tulip cultivation rather than luxury goods.

  6. 10:30 – 15:26

    Tavern Trading and Derivatives

    Unlike the regulated Amsterdam Stock Exchange, the tulip trade occurred in smoky taverns among amateurs. By 1634, trading shifted to leveraged forward contracts, allowing buyers to put down small deposits (e.g., 10 guilders) to control larger positions, similar to buying on margin.

  7. 15:26 – 18:35

    Peak Valuations and the Semper Augustus

    At the peak, the Semper Augustus tulip reportedly fetched 10,000 guilders, three times the price of the nicest house in Amsterdam. The speaker contrasts this with the cost of basic goods, noting 13 guilders bought a ton of herring and 400 guilders bought four oxen.

  8. 18:35 – 24:32

    The Crash and Historical Exaggeration

    Prices collapsed after a failed auction in Haarlem on February 3, 1637, with prices dropping ~90% by May. The speaker cites empirical research showing the bust caused no recession, no bankruptcies, and only a 3-6% hit to Dutch GDP, arguing historians like Charles Mackay exaggerated the damage for moralizing purposes.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
NVIDIANVDAequityneutralSo the Dutch East India Company, the most profitable company of all time, again, adjusting for growth and inflation, is more valuable than by 1620 and until about 1720, it's more valuable than NVIDIA and uh Alphabet and Microsoft combined.
AlphabetGOOGLequityneutralSo the Dutch East India Company, the most profitable company of all time, again, adjusting for growth and inflation, is more valuable than by 1620 and until about 1720, it's more valuable than NVIDIA and uh Alphabet and Microsoft combined.
MicrosoftMSFTequityneutralSo the Dutch East India Company, the most profitable company of all time, again, adjusting for growth and inflation, is more valuable than by 1620 and until about 1720, it's more valuable than NVIDIA and uh Alphabet and Microsoft combined.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

The book 'A Brief History of Financial Bubbles' is the number one bestseller on Amazon in economics, international economics, economic history, and public finance.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:44

How to verify: Check Amazon Best Sellers in Books for the categories 'Economics', 'Economic History', and 'Public Finance' for the week of November 19, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Dutch East India Company (VOC) is worth approximately $10 trillion in today's dollars.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·6:13

How to verify: Calculate the VOC's historical market capitalization using inflation-adjusted GDP and stock price data from the Amsterdam Stock Exchange archives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The VOC was more valuable than NVIDIA, Alphabet, and Microsoft combined by 1620.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·6:13

How to verify: Compare the VOC's historical valuation against the combined market capitalizations of NVIDIA, Alphabet, and Microsoft as of the 2026 verification date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The first stock exchange where shares could be bought and sold was the Amsterdam Stock Exchange in 1602.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·3:48

How to verify: Consult historical records of the Amsterdam Stock Exchange and compare with the Antwerp Bourse (1531) to verify the distinction between commodity trading and share trading. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Semper Augustus tulip fetched 10,000 guilders at the peak of the bubble.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·15:59

How to verify: Search historical auction records and trade logs from 1636-1637 for documented sales of Semper Augustus bulbs at 10,000 guilders. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The highest recorded trade for a tulip was 5,200 guilders for a non-Semper Augustus variety.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·17:07

How to verify: Review historical trade registries from the Dutch Republic to identify the maximum documented price paid for a tulip bulb. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Tulip prices dropped approximately 90% between February 9, 1637, and May 1, 1637.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·20:14

How to verify: Analyze price indices constructed from historical auction records and tavern trade logs for the specified period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The tulip bubble bust resulted in a 3% to 6% loss of Dutch GDP.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·22:13

How to verify: Review empirical economic studies on the Dutch Republic's GDP in the 1630s and 1640s, specifically citing research by Anne Goldgar. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

There were no bankruptcies resulting from the tulip bubble.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·22:50

How to verify: Search Dutch court records and bankruptcy registries from the 1630s and 1640s for any filings linked to tulip contract defaults. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The South Sea Company and Mississippi Company were each more valuable than NVIDIA at their peak in 1720.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·23:30

How to verify: Compare the peak historical valuations of the South Sea and Mississippi companies against NVIDIA's market capitalization as of November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Do your own research

  • Verify the VOC's market capitalization relative to modern tech giants using historical GDP deflators and primary VOC share price records.
  • Check Charles Mackay's 'Extraordinary Delusions and the Madness of Crowds' for the origin of the exaggerated crash narrative.
  • Review empirical economic studies on Dutch GDP and bankruptcy rates in 1637 to assess the claim of no systemic damage.
  • Research the legal status of forward contracts in the Dutch Republic to understand the regulatory environment of tavern trading.
  • Investigate the provenance of the 'Semper Augustus' 10,000 guilder price tag to confirm if it appears in any official auction records.
  • Compare the cultural spending habits of Dutch Calvinists against contemporary records of luxury goods imports.
  • Analyze the impact of the fall of Antwerp (1581) on Amsterdam's demographic and economic growth using historical census data.
  • Review primary sources on the Dutch East India Company's use of Portuguese intelligence to assess the 'stolen maps' claim.
Full transcriptexpand

0:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Hello everyone, welcome to a very special edition of our very bad podcast, Trading Places VC. We're going to talk today about what I hope is a very good book called A Brief History of Financial Bubbles.

0:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm

0:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): kind of biased. This is uh my baby, I'm the author. It launched over the summer. It hit the Kindle store in September. It's been climbing the charts. And as of the week, this week, right before the Thanksgiving week, it is the number one bestseller on Amazon in a number of categories, including economics, international economics, economic history, also public finance. Here it is on the bestseller list. Number one, it's right ahead of the odious and intellectually bankrupt. the deficit myth from Stephanie Kelton. Don't bother to read that book. Um, you should go check out Ray Dalio. He is number three on the list right now with the very, very good How Countries Go Broke. But let me tell you about my book. It goes through the 10 biggest bubbles in economic history. It begins with Amsterdam in 1636. It kind of ends with is AI a bubble? Um, so if you want to know the answer to that question, you're gonna have to wait about 10 chapters. But um never fear, we're gonna do 10 of these little episodes over the next couple of weeks, one on each chapter, and we're gonna walk through what happened in each of the bubbles causes, consequences, some of the common themes, some of the recurring patterns, a little bit of like why don't we learn from prior bubbles? And then um a lot of color and context on the background of each of the bubbles, which goes into the sociology, the history. some of the economics of it, and uh and then what do governments do when

1:43they clean up the bubbles? And do they make the right decisions and and what are implications for investors? I hope you win you enjoyed the book and uh hope you'll listen into the first of the 10 chapters, which starts with the Amsterdam tulip bubble. We're gonna going to start with a Dutch tulip bubble, uh, which is why I'm wearing my Dutch V VOC, O C Dutch East India Company t-shirt today. The Dutch East India Company is a sponsor of trading places. So when you think spice from Indonesia, think VOC first. Okay? Thank you. We'll make your sponsor very happy. In my book, I outline three things that happen in advance of all of these financial bubbles. First of all, there's a long period of economic expansion, just widely felt economic growth and prosperity.

2:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

2:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): second is a concentration of wealth into a large homogeneous subset of the population, and the third is easy money. Amsterdam in the 1630s fits all three of these criteria. There's a religious war that breaks out in 1581 between Catholic Spain and the United Provinces, which are Protestant. Those Protestant provinces break off to become the Netherlands or the Dutch Republic. is what it's called at the time. The capital of Europe at the time is Antwerp. At least the financial capital of Europe is. But the siege and fall of Antwerp in this war drives tens of thousands of emigrants north from Antwerp into Amsterdam. It is,

3:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

3:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, basically skilled craftsmen, craftsman. It is um wealthy. merchants, it is intellectual elites who leave Antwerp at the time because of the siege, and then it's Sephardic Jews and it's Protestants who don't want to be under the um the Kaffla king. Today you can drive this in about two hours on the A16 and the A4, but

3:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um

3:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it was a lot tougher back then. But they fuel a seafaring economy which becomes the richest per capita in the world by the early 1600s. And in 1602, there's a huge influx of financial innovation, which begins with the Amsterdam Stock Exchange. The first bourse in the world was Antwerp, which really begins in 1531. But this is the first stock exchange where you can buy and sell shares of a stock. And the company that is founded where you can buy and sell shares is the VOC or the Dutch East India Company. Um You'll hear me you'll you'll hear me refer to this as the VOC because it stands for Verenigde Ostenditch Kompagnie or VOC. In English, that would be the United East India Company. And for nearly 200 years, this company holds an absolute monopoly between Europe and Indonesia and eventually India and China in things like nutmeg and cloves and tobacco and cinnamon and black and black and white pepper.

4:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,

4:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): very, very lucrative spices.

4:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hold

4:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): up, boys. Did I say tobacco? It's on the school with tobacco. Tobacco, the the Dutch East India Company didn't create a monopoly of tobacco. What are you talking about?

4:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,

4:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): there's they're a sponsor of ours? These guys?

4:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,

4:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Marlborough's a sponsor of ours. So we have to we have to push tobacco. All right. So

4:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,

4:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but even if it's false, do we really want to be telling our viewers like false things? for money? Are we are we sinking that low? We are? Okay. All right, cool.

4:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All right,

4:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): everyone. So uh the Dutch East India Company has become this uh this great monopoly in all these spices, including tobacco. Thank you very much. And by sixteen oh seven, there's an active market in the Dutch East India Company shares, not only in buying and selling the shares, but also in derivatives, forward contracts, what the Dutch would call tetaman handle. This begins in 1607, and that's followed by a trade in call options and put options by about the 1610, 1611 timeframe. The history of this company, by the way, is amazing. It's founded by Dutch entrepreneurs who were competing for the highly lucrative spice trade in um in uh Indonesia.

5:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um, a

5:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Dutch merchant named Jan Huyghan von Linschoten Linschutten steals Portuguese maps, which had protected the Portuguese monopoly and the lucrative spice trade that they had with India, Indonesia, China, and Japan for nearly a hundred years, really ever since Vasco da Gama first sailed to India in 1497. Well, they steal these maps and now they begin to compete with the Portuguese traders. And then in 1602, they combined to find to found one company to consolidate the trade for the Dutch. And this company, the Dutch East Indication. India Company, eventually becomes worth the equivalent in today's dollars of $10 trillion, okay, to control for inflation and economic growth. So the Dutch East India Company, the most profitable company of all time, again, adjusting for growth and inflation, is more valuable than by 1620 and until about 1720, it's more valuable than NVIDIA and uh Alphabet and Microsoft combined. Into this culture of financial innovation comes a new, very attractive object of desire, the tulip. It comes over from the Kazakhstan mountains, the unimaginably vast and beautiful Kazakhstan mountains, probably by way of Ottoman conquerors in the 1500s. And it ends up coming to the Dutch Republic around 1562. The first reported sighting of the tulip is in is by a Flemish merchant who really

6:53buys it by accident. He had ordered bales of hay from Istanbul, and he finds these things, he doesn't know what they are, in these bales of hay. And so what does he do? He thinks they're he thinks these stowaways are Turkish onions. He cooks them up, he makes himself a soup. Um, the soup tastes horrible, and so he he doesn't eat most of it, and he throws what he doesn't cook up into his backyard uh next to his cabin. cabbages. Well, in the spring of 1563, he's stunned to see some little flowers, red and yellow petals poking out from his cabbage patch. Luckily, he recognizes them as something pretty and something pretty special, and he calls up a buddy on his um on his cell phone at the time. His buddy is Joris Rye. He gives Joris Rye Raya a buzz, and Joris Rye knows a guy who knows a guy, and the guy that he knows is Carolus Clucius, who is a major scientist in Europe at the time. He's a professor at the university, he's a specialist in botany, and he is the guy who basically puts tulips on the map. He is the first major scientist to write about the tulip. He documents its many varietals, he catalogues them. He figures out tulip breaking, which is a phenomenon where, like, a plain tulip, solid-colored solid colored tulip, has all these

7:59like um stripes and you know, flames and and uh rare contrasting colors and feathers. And it's these broken varieties that become the most valuable parts of the tulip trade in the subsequent years.

8:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): One

8:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): other point I'd like to just make about the

8:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

8:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Dutch tulip trade, why does it happen in Amsterdam? Why not in London or Paris or these other big you know commercial centers? A big part of the reason is what you're allowed to spend your money on. If you're in France at the time in the 1620s and 30s, here's what you look like. You're buying a lot of fancy clothes, fancy silts, you're spending money on retinues, on carriages, on gilded carriages, on beautiful houses. This is how you mark yourself in the aristocracy. This is what people look like in the Dutch Republic in the 1620s. Boring, boring, boring. Why is that? Well remember I said there were Protestants. Well there were more than that. They There were actually the Dutch Reformed Church. They wouldn't call themselves Calvinists That's a very British term, maybe derogatory.

8:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They

8:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): wouldn't call themselves Puritans either. Again, a very British term, but that's what they were. They were not spending money on outward displays of ostentation and wealth, um, like the French or the English were. They were spending money in ways that venerated God. So what do you spend your money on if you're in the Dutch Republic in the sixteen thirties? Um, not fancy clothing, but you can buy house a a nice modest house, which at least on the exterior is modest. You can do some nice interior art. That's acceptable. What do you put in a house? Uh a garden. What do you put in a garden? Flowers. These are the things that venerate God and celebrate his magnificence, right? Not fancy silk clothing, but but things like natur things with natural beauty, like flowers. Another interesting point about the Dutch tooled tulip trade, which I think very few people recognize today.

9:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,

9:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I talked about the Dutch stock exchange, the Amsterdam Stock Exchange, and how we had over 400 commodities being traded there at its peak. It was shares of the Dutch East India Company, but also bills of exchange and forward contracts and options and herring and spice and whale oil and sugar and copper and saltpeter and Baltic grain and North Sea herring. But the one thing that was not traded in the Amsterdam Stock Exchange was tulips, because the stock exchange was heavily regulated, mostly populated with international brokers and professional financiers and merchant regents, and they were trading in financial commodities. And a lot of the tulip trade was done by low and middle-class amateurs, so craftspeople, People, weavers and bakers, and you know, blacksmiths and local florists. And these people had never set. foot inside the boars.

10:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,

10:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): where do these amateur traders do their work? Um, it turned out they did it in taverns, inns, bars. If you've ever been to a bar in Amsterdam, you kind of know where this is headed. Back then, every inn was filled with smoke.

10:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh

10:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it was a dense, eye-watering eye watering fog so thick you couldn't see across the room. Some of that smoke was from the the peat burning fires, which were the only source of heat in Amsterdam and and um in Altmar and Enquisen in the winter. And some of it was just from pipes. Dutchmen were smoking pipes constantly in those days. So you get this eye watering smoke. There's a lot of drinking happening as well. Why? Because the Dutch drink a lot. If you've ever gone out with a Dutchman, you already know that you they drink a lot. Koreans are pretty good. Japanese are pretty good, but the Dutch really take the cake. Even for a continent and at a time where drinking was commonplace, the Dutch stood out as like Europe's most prolific and maybe most notorious tiplers.

11:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A

11:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): night of drinking could be done for less than a guilder. So beer was cheap. Water, completely undrinkable. Why? Because of the bleacheries. There's a significant part of the country's economy and landscape are the bleacheries, and they put out a lot of wastewater into the local rivers and streams with chemicals like hydrogen peroxide. You don't want to drink the water in Amsterdam or in, you know, Alkmar in the 1630s. Tea and coffee, you mean you can drink that, but those are little known luxuries.

11:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um

11:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): beer is plentiful, it's cheap, it's with every meal. And this is what people were using to negotiate in close deal. deals or drinking beer. And then when they close a deal on a uh particularly great tulip,

12:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,

12:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): they would drink wine, which is another, you know, expensive luxury, but not to be had uh at every meal. It was um, you know, it's very uh very special and very expensive.

12:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,

12:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): around about 1634,

12:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a

12:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): whole bunch of tourists begin to join the party. These are not professional florists, but these are now all the craftspeople and all. the maidservants and all the uh the bakers and the butchers and the candlestick makers who begin to trade in tulips. And they're doing it mostly at the local bar.

12:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Up

12:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): until 1634, here's what the tulip trade more or less looked like. You had a merchant on the right, let's call him Jan. You have a merchant on the left, let's call her Anna. Jan would send money to Anna, she would send back a flower, very clean, very simple, right?

12:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Beginning

12:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in about 1634, the trade begins to move almost exclusively to forward contracts, to derivatives, which had spawned around the time of the Dutch East India Company and the development of contracts and derivatives around the trade and those shares. Here's how a forward contract would work. Anna would say to Jan, hey, I don't have a flower right now.

13:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Give

13:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): me until the spring of 1635. When the flowers bloom, I'll send you the two. tulip. Okay. Sight unseen, but trust me, the tulip will be beautiful. Jan says, fine. I'll tell you what, I'll give you 10 gilders now to get that flower on the cum. I'll give you 90 gilders later when we actually consummate the trade in the spring. Cool, she says, cool. And that's how the trade happens in forward contracts. Really beginning in 1634, this is the way that all these trades happen. Well watch what happens when the price of flowers begins to go

13:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): up. Okay.

13:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So Jan says to Yana, I'm going to give you 10 gilders now, I'll give you 90 gilders later, total of 100.

13:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): She

13:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): says, great, I'll get you the flower in the spring. What if the price of the flower goes up to 120 gilders?

13:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well

13:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Jan says, I mean, I guess I could I guess I could hang on to my flower, but if I want to make a quick profit, why don't I sell my flower? I don't have it yet. It's coming in the spring, but why don't I sell this flower to my buddy Hendrik? Okay. He's a he's an incoming seafaring merchant. He's coming in on the tides. He's got a bunch of money from Indonesia. He'll pay me 120 gilders. And I will ask Hendrik, hey, give me 30 guilders now. I'll pay him 90 later for a total of 120 gilders. guilders.

14:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

14:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): watch what look what happens. to Han. Han is given 10 guilders out for his investment. He's now flipped

14:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it

14:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and getting 30 gilders back. He's tripled his money. He's gonna have to pay 90 gilders over to Anna in the spring, but he's got 90 coming from Hendrick in the spring. And so he's even Steven, right? He's gonna he's uh he's he's washed his debts and his liabilities with his incoming assets, and he's made three times his initial investment. What's left? Well, there's a flower. Hendrik needs a flower. from Jan in the spring. Jan says, no, no, no, don't come to me. Go to Anna. She owes me a flower. She'll get you her flower in the spring. We're all good, right?

15:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

15:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this is how the derivatives trade happens in tulips. Again, again, 1634, leverage, leveraged forward contracts. It's kind of like buying on margin. They wouldn't they wouldn't call it that at the time, but that's what happens when you buy stock on margin. You put some money down now, you borrow the rest. leverage. It's a good thing when prices go up because you can make multiples of your investment. But when prices go down, leverage works the other way. Just keep that in mind as we continue the story. Okay. Um, at the very top of the tulip trade, the Semper Augustus is the the number one uh flower at the very, very top of the market as the market begins to reach its fair feverish pitch. the Semper Augustus becomes legendary. It's very, very few trades that actually happen, but they are shrouded in mystery. Um, according to lore, the Semper Augustus fetches a price of 10,000 guilders, somewhere in 1636, 1637. That's a lot of money. Um, just for context, school teachers in Amsterdam at the time made about 150 to 250 gilders a year. Okay. So we're talking about, you know, 50 times, between 15 and 100 times the salary of an average school teacher. Um, if you're a Dutch merchant at the time, you can you may be making three to four hundred gilders a year. So we're still talking about a

16:19lot of money for normal people. You could also buy for one ton, you can also buy for 13 gilders a ton of Dutch. herring. So if you're if you're hungry, 13 gilders will get you a ton of Dutch herring. That's how that's how crazy the the valuation of the Semper Augustus flower is relative to things like food. Um, what else could you get with money? Well, for 400 gilders, you can get four fat oxen. That'll feed your family for about a year for 400 gilders. For 3,000 guilders,

16:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

16:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): can get a beautiful, beautiful house on the Amstel River. So at the top of the market, allegedly, the Semper Augustus is going for a price that is three times the price of the nicest house in Amsterdam. There are not a lot of recorded trades on any of these flowers. The highest recorded trade that I could find officially was 5,200 guilders for not the Semper Augustus, but for a different flower.

17:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,

17:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): The Semper Augustus never actually recorded. records trades above 5,200, but there are legends and there are stories told which feel like, you know, the mystery around Dashell Hammett's crime novel, The Maltese Falcon, which talks of transactions that are, you know, breathless and highly fictionalized between mysterious wealthy men and their scandalous motives. It seems like at the top of the market the m the a mysterious collector owns most of these flowers. most of these semper gustas in the 1630s. It's thought, and my theory is that the guy who did it was Adrian Powell, who was a director of the Dutch East India Company. But nobody knows for sure. How did the bubble end? Um, I talk about in my book how sometimes these markets move without a catalyst. There's no, you know, interest rate hike, there's no fraud, there's no company going bankrupt, um, there's no famous CEO going to jail. Sometimes these markets just move like flocks of starlings or shoals of fish. You know, when you see the first bird in a in a flock turn left or right, and the entire flock flows with that bird. Or sometimes that happens with fish. The first one moves and everyone moves with them. Some sometime in the early, you know, sixteen 1620s twenties the market swarm decided tulips were valuable. And then in sixteen 1637, thirty seven the bust comes swiftly, like a brittle fog rolling in over Holland from the North Sea or from the

18:32Zydersee on a wintry February morning.

18:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It

18:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): all happens with a busted auction on February 3rd, 1637. And that happens in a town called Harlem,

18:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): which

18:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): along with Amsterdam was one of the two big epicenters of the whole bubble.

18:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,

18:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): we don't really know exactly how the auction went, you know, of course, but here's how I think it probably went. The auctioneer would have opened with an offering of lesser flowers, with the Kronen or Swister's bulbs, maybe, and then he has an asking price of maybe 1250 guilders. So, you know, just kind of a warm-up, an appetizer for what's to come next. But on this day, there are no bidders.

19:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

19:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the auctioneer probably lowers the price very cautiously to there maybe may be 1100 guilders, guilters or even a thousand guilders. But again, there are no bidders.

19:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If

19:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you've ever worked on a trading floor like I have, you might imagine what happens next. In all likelihood, there would have been moments of just awkward silence, no one building nervous glances being exchanged between the traders, nobody not quite knowing what's gonna, you know, happen next. And then maybe there's a uh a hubbub. People start to murmur like, what's going on? Maybe it rises to a panic. And all the traders are now really worried. And I would imagine that they would just end. the auction right there. Nothing gets sold, nothing gets done, no act, no activity happens. And now word begins to spread. From Altmar to Amsterdam to Enkhuizen, um, all of a sudden the word is out. There are no buyers, there are no bidders for tulips at this price.

19:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This

19:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is an index of tulip prices that I constructed based on data. It goes from November twelfth, 12th, sixteen 1636. thirty-six. You'll see the peak happens around February third. 3rd, 1637. There is some activity in on uh February 5th and February 9th, actually some very successful auctions. And then there's like a complete break. There's a discontinuity in that line. Why is that? Because there's just no activity. Between February 9th and May 1st of 1637, it seems like the market drops by about 90%. But even that overstates it because uh or sorry, even that understates it because there's just no activity on the down. downside. There's no secondary market, no volume, no activity. And so there's a discont discontinuity in the price. Um up until February 5th to the 9th, there is activity happening in various places in Amsterdam.

20:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,

20:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): but until you know the whole month of February goes by, the whole month of March and April go by, and nothing is happening. And all of a sudden the market emerges and some trades get done at a 90% discount from where they were before. So very, very rapid drop in the price. And um, and just like that, you know, the bubble goes away.

20:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What

20:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): are some of the consequences of the of the bubble? Um, you know, early literature in uh for people who looked at this, like Charles McKay, who wrote Extraordinary Popular Delusions in the Madness of Crowns, he documented what happened in the Dutch tulip Tula bubble. And um, and he talks about, you know, the massive heartache. and economic dislocation that happened as a result of the bubble. And it's there's a lot of the a lot of that is a cautionary tale about just the consequences of manias and panics and people who kind of become irrational and irrationally tied to certain asset valuations. And there's some moralizing in there. A lot of the Protestants and the Calvinists at the time, the Pantheteers, were also similarly talking. about how people committed suicide, ruined their lives, and all this speculation led to no good. But there's a lot of moralizing in there, right? There's a lot of um there's a lot of uh sermonizing in there. Empirical economists have looked at it more carefully. And by the way, and Charles McKay was a very influential writer and people like John Kenneth Galbreth and um

21:57N. NW W. Posthumus, very famous economists, took that stuff and and wrote about those episodes and probably exaggerated the entire impact of the whole bubble. More recently, empirical economists have really looked at this and said, we don't think that's exactly

22:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right.

22:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Based on my math, the size of the bubble popping probably amounted to about between three and six percent of Dutch GDP at the time.

22:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean,

22:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that ain't nothing, but for an economy growing at five 5 to 10% ten percent annually, um,

22:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it didn't

22:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): seem like it doesn't seem like that should be the end of the world.

22:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,

22:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): what is unequivocally true, just based on the empirical science, there was no significant recession in the Dutch Republic at the time, no loss of GDP per capita in the 1630s and 1640s. Um, and Goldgar, an economist and researcher, has looked and said she couldn't find any bankruptcies. Not a single bankruptcy that happened as a result of the Dutch tulip. bubble popping. Different from other bubbles we'll study, this was isolated from the banking system. It didn't compromise the uh money supply or the banking system of the country. So it didn't create a financial panic. In fact, Anne Golgard says there are only 37 people who spent more than 300 yilders on a tulip. So very, very small impact and overstated by people like Charles McKay. So I think what that tells you is there was a bubble, it popped, the concept. consequences, though, have been greatly exaggerated by historians, probably for some, you know, some uh moralizing reasons, but um, it's a fascinating episode nonetheless, and the first of the many bubbles that we'll study. The bubble we'll talk about next time happened in London and in Paris in the 1720s. It affected two huge companies, the South Sea Company and the Mississippi Company. They were both both formed in the 1720s. 1710s at their peak in 1720. They were each more valuable in today's dollars than NVIDIA.

23:46And then they very, very quickly, very, very quickly those bubbles popped, and they were worth very, very little or nothing at all by the early 1720s. Unlike the Dutch tulip bubble, very influential bubble on economic history, it definitely shaped the history and the trajectory of. both England and France from the 1720s onward. England came out of that bubble looking very, very good because of the way they managed it.

24:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,

24:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): France, not so much, and eventually plunged into the French Revolution. And uh more than one monarch, shall we say, lost their heads. If you're curious to learn more about that one, uh tune in for tune in around Thanksgiving for our next release of Trading Places VC, a very, very bad podcast, but hopefully talking about a very good book. Thank you. See you next time. Bye-bye.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights