Fraud, Waste and Abuse in Government Programs: Prevention Starts Early
Summary
Hannah Lee defines fraud as intentional deception, waste as inefficient spending, and abuse as improper use of authority. Emily McKee details Operation Ghostbuster, a DOJ case involving stolen identities used to create fake FAFSA accounts for 'ghost students' at US colleges. Red flags for fraudulent contractors include recently formed companies, unidentified beneficial owners, and residential addresses. Vulnerabilities in government programs stem from high transaction volumes, limited oversight, and technology lags. Prevention requires robust controls, employee training, and periodic reviews to ensure transparency and eligibility.
Key takeaways
- 1 Government programs are vulnerable due to high transaction volumes, limited oversight resources, complex eligibility rules, and a technology lag compared to the private sector.
Emily McKee · 5:53
- 2 Prevention requires adequate controls, employee training to spot fraud hallmarks, robust procurement vetting, and periodic reviews.
Emily McKee · 7:43
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 2:23
Introduction and Definitions
Hannah Lee introduces the topic of fraud, waste, and abuse in government programs during Fraud Awareness Week. She defines fraud as intentional deception, waste as careless or inefficient spending without intent to break the law, and abuse as the improper use of authority or resources.
- 2:23 – 3:47
Operation Ghostbuster Case Study
Emily McKee discusses Operation Ghostbuster, a DOJ investigation into large-scale student aid fraud. The scheme involves using stolen identities to create fraudulent FAFSA accounts for fictitious 'ghost students' at US colleges, diverting millions over four years.
- 3:47 – 5:38
Red Flags for Vendors and Contractors
Red flags for identifying fraudulent government contractors include recently formed companies, inability to identify beneficial owners, residential or non-existent addresses, businesses in financial distress, and adverse media coverage.
- 5:38 – 7:12
Vulnerabilities in Government Programs
Government programs are vulnerable due to high transaction volumes, limited oversight resources, complex eligibility rules, and a technology lag compared to the private sector, which fraudsters exploit.
- 7:12 – 9:30
Prevention and Controls
Prevention requires adequate controls, employee training to spot fraud hallmarks, robust procurement vetting, and periodic reviews. Contractors must ensure transparency and verify that beneficiaries are legitimate and eligible.
Do your own research
- Verify DOJ press releases and court documents related to Operation Ghostbuster for case specifics and outcomes.
- Review FAFSA eligibility rules and verification processes to understand potential loopholes.
- Check government contractor databases for beneficial ownership disclosures and corporate formation dates.
- Assess government agency technology infrastructure reports to identify known technology lags compared to private sector standards.
- Read GAO reports on fraud, waste, and abuse in federal student aid programs for historical context and statistics.
- Look for adverse media coverage on major government contractors to identify potential red flags.
- Review employee training materials from government agencies to assess fraud detection protocols.
- Examine procurement vetting procedures used by major government agencies to evaluate transparency and verification steps.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Hannah Lee: Hello everyone. In recognition of Fraud Awareness Week, today we are having a conversation about an issue that affects all of us. Fraud, waste, and abuse involving government programs and public funds. So we hear those three words used together quite a bit, but what do they really mean? And how do these issues show up in the real world? And maybe most importantly, how can they be identified? and prevented? My name is Hannah Lee. I am a manager in the forensics and litigation services department at Weaver. And joining me today is my colleague, Emily McKee, who is a senior manager in the FLS group. And we're going to explore some of those questions together. So, Emily, before we get started, would you like to introduce yourself?
0:49Emily McKee: Sure, thank you, Hannah. So I have 10 years of experience in this field, both in the investigation space and litigation, focusing on commercial bribery, and then more recently in litigation and also fraud, waste, and abuse in the public sector.
1:04Hannah Lee: Great. Thank you, Emily. So now let's start with the basics. So we hear the terms fraud, waste, abuse, and improper payments used together. And I think it can be easy to assume they all mean the same thing. So how would you distinguish between them and why are those distinctions important?
1:24Emily McKee: Sure. So fraud is the intentional use of deception, things like making false statements, misrepresenting, um, fraudulently creating documents that otherwise wouldn't have existed or wouldn't have existed in those forms to obtain money, proper. property, services, really anything of value. While waste uh doesn't have that intent component. It's careless, it's uh could be extravagant spending, inefficient spending, and unnecessary use of resources. No law is broken, no deception may occur. Uh, it's just uh, you know, extravagant and inefficient. Abuse uh is more of a positional offense. So someone improperly using their position, their authority, um, the resources that they have authority over in a manner that's either unreasonable or inconsistent with expected behavior. It also may not rise to the level of fraud. It might not violate a specific law. Um so when we're talking about fraud versus waste versus abuse, really the key is intent.
2:23Hannah Lee: Gotcha. So those definitions are really helpful. But I think this becomes much easier to understand when we look at a real world example. So we hear about government fraud schemes in the news pretty regularly. And um one recent example is an operation that the Department of Justice refers to as Operation Ghostbuster. And Emily, like, can you walk us through what happened and maybe why this case is significant?
2:50Emily McKee: Absolutely. So it's an exciting title. It's a you know kind of an attention grabbing name that they've given this investigation, but it's a nationwide Department of Justice investigation. It was announced just last week and it targets large scale student aid fraud. It's a scheme in which criminals use stolen identities. They created fraudulent FAFSA accounts, the federal financial aid accounts. They've enrolled fictitious students that the DOJ is calling ghost students, hence the term ghostbusters. And they're enrolling these students at colleges and universities across the United States. And so, according to the DOJ in their initial press release, the scheme has diverted millions of dollars over at least the past four years. The initial indictment was against five defendants, and the DOJ sees seized more than seven. $750,000 and tied this initial group of charges back to a scheme operating out of Kenya.
3:47Hannah Lee: And this is where I think an investigator's perspective becomes really important. So we're interested not merely in whether something went wrong, but why it went wrong. So what red flags would cause you to maybe dig deeper into a government? contractor, a funding recipient, or a payment?
4:07Emily McKee: Sure. So when we're talking about the government, they're dealing with many different vendors, many different uh users of their service. And so when we're looking on the vendor side, things like companies that are recently formed that don't have, you know, a long track record of work history that maybe were formed shortly prior to beginning the government contract. Um, if there's an a inability to identify the beneficial owner, so maybe the company is owned by a company is owned by a company, and you you never truly get down to who, you know, what person owns a company. Um if their address is maybe a residential address, an address that doesn't exist Um, or potentially appears to belong to a different business altogether,
4:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,
4:50Emily McKee: some more red flags. would be businesses in financial distress if that's publicly available information. Um, and then any adverse media surrounding the company, sometimes smoke is just smoke, but sometimes when there's smoke, there's fire.
5:03Hannah Lee: And so when you identify those red flags, what evidence would help you distinguish just an innocent mistake or a control weakness from intentional misconduct?
5:14Emily McKee: So intent can be tricky. Um, however, sometimes we'll get lucky with things like communications that you know indicate some kind of uh intentional actions being taken, sometimes certain authorizations that could only come from a particular individual. Um, and sometimes again, those communications and those behavioral patterns will line up to show collusion or an intent to commit a certain act.
5:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
5:38Hannah Lee: let's step back from the individual transaction or the investigation for a moment and let's look at the broader environment. So, what is it about governmental programs that can make them vulnerable to fraud, waste, and abuse?
5:53Emily McKee: So there's a number of different aspects of government programs. uh, First of all, is just the volume when you're serving, you know, the 300 plus million uh people. of the United States of America. That's quite a lot of individuals, it's quite a lot of business, quite a lot of money moving back and forth. So you've got large volumes of money in transactions. Uh, and part of that is that there are limited oversight resources. So you can't be evaluating every single transaction, um, every single vendor. You have to sort of risk rank um what you're looking at. Part of it is also that. these programs can have complex eligibility rules where maybe it's not evident on the face of a payment why it was made to someone that it shouldn't have been made to, and it requires a deeper level of understanding, which again gets to that resource allocation issue. There's also a kind of a technology lag between,
6:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
6:45Emily McKee: I think, the the private sector and government where maybe they don't have the analytical tools that. the private sector is using, and and fraudsters unfortunately can at times use that to stay ahead. So I think right now we're seeing kind of a a good versus evil technology, technological fight really, um, between you know the fraudsters defrauding the government and the government is trying to protect its resources and claw them back.
7:09Hannah Lee: Yeah, definitely.
7:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
7:12Hannah Lee: so this leads us to probably the most important part of our conversation, which is preventing the fraud, waste, and abuse from even happening. And we've talked quite a bit about what an investigator might look for, but prevention and detection obviously don't begin only when an investigator gets involved. So what role do employees, management, contractors, and others working with government programs play in recognizing and reporting potential concerns?
7:43Emily McKee: Yeah. So obviously the best fraud is a fraud that never happens because you've got adequate controls in place, adequate safeguards, things like that. Um and so for employees, it really can be down to a training issue, um, making sure that employees are trained to spot the hallmarks of fraud, also making sure that there are robust procurement programs, making sure that your vendors have been vetted, that you know, the address has been checked, that the website's been checked, that the ownership has been checked, et cetera. And making sure that there's a legitimate business use for using a particular vendor over another. Related to Operation Ghostbusters, it looks like making sure that your employees are trained to recognize the signs of a fraudulent customer, essentially. So is the person receiving the benefit of these services a legitimate beneficiary? Are they allowed to receive that benefit under the rules? Um, and truly in this instance, do they exist? And so when we're talking about
8:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um the
8:48Emily McKee: the government side, I think first it's recognizing. then it's having the adequate controls in place and then it's doing periodical reviews to make sure that, you know, if you looked at it a few years ago, are you gonna look at it again?
9:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
9:01Emily McKee: and then on the contractor side is making that information available, making it transparent um and working with, you know, the governmental entity to aid in that procurement process.
9:11Hannah Lee: Yeah, definitely. Well, Emily, thank you for sharing. your insights with us, and thank you everyone for joining us in Fraud Awareness Week and be on the lookout on your feed for more content from Weaver.