Thomas Coleman explains historical US Treasury yield curve reconstruction and bond return drivers
Summary
Thomas S. Coleman discusses the complexities of reconstructing US Treasury yield curves from 1925, citing challenges like changing tax regimes and callable bonds. He explains how 'flower bonds' and self-selection bias complicate historical valuation. Coleman distinguishes between yield return and excess return, noting that long-term bond volatility is driven by duration. The speakers conclude that long-term bond returns are primarily driven by yield, with excess returns averaging near zero over extended periods.
Key takeaways
- 1 in a 10-year or a 30-year bond than there is in a in a one-month. There's much more opportunity for gain, but obviously much more opportunity for loss as well. The volatility is going to be much higher.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 35:01
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 1:24
Introduction and Project Background
Host Lotta Moberg introduces guest Thomas S. Coleman, a professor at the University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy and co-author of 'Exponential Wealth: Centuries of Stock and Bond Returns.' Coleman discusses his long-standing collaboration with Roger Ibbotson and Larry Fisher to reconstruct US Treasury yield curves using historical data dating back to 1925.
- 1:24 – 8:53
Data Challenges and Historical Bond Features
Coleman explains that reconstructing historical yield curves is complex due to changing bond characteristics. He notes that bonds from the 1920s through the 1980s were subject to varying tax regimes (fully taxable, partially taxable, tax-exempt), were often callable, and included unique features like 'flower bonds' eligible for estate tax payment at par.
- 8:53 – 13:01
Callable Bonds and Valuation Complexity
The speakers discuss callable bonds, where the issuer (the Treasury) could redeem the bond at par (100) after a certain period. Coleman explains that this embedded option complicates pricing because it prevents the use of simple present value discounting, requiring models similar to Black-Scholes to account for the possibility of early redemption when yields are low.
- 13:01 – 16:32
Flower Bonds and Self-Selection Bias
Coleman describes 'flower bonds' as bonds that could be used to pay federal estate taxes at face value (100) even if trading below par. He highlights the difficulty in valuing them due to 'self-selection bias,' where only individuals with specific health or estate planning needs would hold them, making it nearly impossible to fully disentangle their 'put' value from market prices.
- 16:32 – 22:24
Tax Regimes and Yield Curve Construction
To address historical tax changes, Coleman states the project estimates three separate yield curves: one for partially tax-exempt bonds (1920s), one for fully tax-exempt bonds (1930s), and one for fully taxable bonds (1940s onward). These curves are pasted together, with users explicitly warned about the regime shifts.
- 22:24 – 26:12
Duration and Return Volatility
Coleman clarifies that longer-term bonds have higher return volatility than shorter-term bonds due to duration. He explains that while the yield return (coupon) is similar across maturities, the 'excess return' (capital gains/losses) is significantly more volatile for long bonds because their prices are more sensitive to interest rate changes over a longer horizon.
- 26:12 – 30:33
Macaulay Duration and Sensitivity
The discussion covers the origin of 'duration,' introduced by Macaulay as a weighted average time to cash flows. Coleman notes that Larry Fisher was likely the first to connect this measure of 'length' to price sensitivity to interest rates, a dual meaning that still causes confusion in finance today.
- 30:33 – 34:27
Yield Return vs. Excess Return
Coleman breaks total bond returns into two components: the yield return (income/coupon) and the excess return (capital gains/losses). He emphasizes that while total return is what matters for investors, the excess return component drives the volatility differences between short-term and long-term bonds.
- 34:27 – 35:53
Capital Gains vs. Yield Return in Short-Term Trading
Speaker_0 and Speaker_1 discuss that day traders in fixed income seek capital gains (excess return) rather than coupon income. Speaker_1 notes that longer-term bonds like 10-year or 30-year treasuries offer higher volatility and greater opportunity for both gain and loss compared to short-term instruments like one-month bonds.
- 35:53 – 37:09
Long-Term Bond Returns Driven by Yield
Speaker_1 uses the Aesop's fable of the tortoise and the hare to illustrate that while short-term trading seeks capital gains, long-term bond returns are primarily driven by the steady accumulation of yield. Speaker_1 states that over long periods, the excess return (capital gains/losses) averages close to zero, making yield the dominant component of total return.
- 37:09 – 39:02
Historical Yield Trends and Periods
Speaker_0 summarizes the history of bond yields as a pyramid shape, rising until around 1980 and then declining. Speaker_1 confirms this, noting that the first period saw rising yields (negative excess return for bondholders) and the second period saw falling yields (positive excess return).
Claims worth verifying
Thomas Coleman is a professor at the University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:35
How to verify: University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy faculty directory or Thomas Coleman's professional biography on the CFA Institute website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Coleman, along with Roger Ibbotson and Larry Fisher, were the first to build Treasury curves using the CRISP US Treasury bond files.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:55
How to verify: Academic publications by Coleman, Ibbotson, and Fisher from the 1990s, such as 'Treasury Yields and Bond Returns' published by Moody's or Ibbotson Associates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The CRISP database contains monthly end-of-month bond prices for publicly traded US Treasuries starting from December 1925.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·3:35
How to verify: CRISP database documentation or the CRISSP (Center for Research in Security Prices) at Columbia University archives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
US Treasury bonds were callable for most of their history up until the 1980s or 1990s.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·2:42
How to verify: Historical US Treasury issuance records or academic papers on the history of US debt management. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
'Flower bonds' were eligible for payment of estate taxes at par (100) even if trading below market price.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·7:48
How to verify: US Treasury historical publications on 'Flower Bonds' or IRS historical rulings on estate tax payments using Treasury securities. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Macaulay duration was originally introduced to measure the length of a bond, not its price sensitivity.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·27:18
How to verify: Frederick Macaulay's 2026 book 'Some Theoretical Problems Suggested by the Movements of Interest Rates, Bond Yields and Stock Prices in the United States Since 1856.' For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Larry Fisher was the first person to connect Macaulay duration to bond price sensitivity.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·28:18
How to verify: Larry Fisher's academic articles, such as 'Yields, Yields to Maturity, and Bond Price Sensitivity' or 'The Duration of Bonds and the Term Structure of Interest Rates.' For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
US Treasury bonds issued in the 1960s and 1970s had a coupon cap of 4.25%.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·21:11
How to verify: US Treasury historical issuance data or academic papers on the impact of coupon caps on Treasury issuance in the 1960s and 1970s. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The project estimates three separate yield curves for partially exempt, fully exempt, and fully taxable bonds.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·16:52
How to verify: The methodology section of the 'Exponential Wealth' book or related academic papers by Coleman, Ibbotson, and Fisher. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The CRISP database data is now collected daily by Trist, but the project focuses on monthly data.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·5:27
How to verify: CRISP database documentation or CRISSP website updates regarding data frequency. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Short-term bond trading focuses on capturing capital gains (excess return) rather than coupon income.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·34:45
How to verify: Review fixed income trading strategies and definitions of 'excess return' in CFA Institute curriculum or standard finance textbooks (e.g., Fabozzi, Fixed Income Analysis). For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
10-year and 30-year bonds have much higher volatility and opportunity for gain/loss than one-month bonds.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·35:01
How to verify: Calculate historical standard deviation of total returns for US Treasury 10-year, 30-year, and 1-month bills using FRED (Federal Reserve Economic Data) or CUSIP data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Over long periods, the excess return (capital gains) of bonds averages close to zero.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·36:32
How to verify: Access the 'Exponential Wealth' book by CFA Institute Research Foundation, specifically the chapters co-authored by Thomas Coleman, to verify the statistical breakdown of bond returns. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Total bond returns are almost entirely derived from yield return, not capital gains, over the long run.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·36:32
How to verify: Reproduce the calculation using historical US Treasury data (2026-present) from the Federal Reserve or CUSIP, decomposing total return into income and price change components. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bond yields rose until around 1980 and then declined, forming a 'pyramid' shape.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·37:09
How to verify: Plot the 10-year US Treasury constant maturity rate from FRED (Series DGS10) for the period 2026-2026 to observe the peak around 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The period before 1980 saw negative excess returns for bondholders due to rising yields.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·37:09
How to verify: Analyze historical bond returns from 2026-2026, noting that rising interest rates cause bond prices to fall, resulting in negative capital gains. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the CRISP database data availability and methodology via the University of Chicago Booth School of Business or related academic repositories.
- Review the specific tax laws applicable to US Treasuries in the 1920s, 1930s, and 1940s to understand the 'partially' vs 'fully' exempt classifications.
- Check the definition and calculation of Macaulay Duration versus Modified Duration in standard fixed income textbooks to clarify the historical attribution to Larry Fisher.
- Examine the 'flower bond' provisions in the Internal Revenue Code of the era to understand the estate tax payment mechanism and its market implications.
- Analyze the 'Exponential Wealth' book's methodology for pasting together yield curves from different tax regimes to assess potential discontinuities.
- Look for counter-arguments regarding the stability of the 'excess return averages zero' claim in different market cycles or inflation environments.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): CFA Institute Live 2027, where better investment judgment is built. At forums in Hong Kong and Toronto, delegates will strengthen their professional judgment under pressure through keynotes, practitioner discussions, decision lab workshops, and simulation studio workshops.
0:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Go
0:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to CFA Institute.org and visit the upcoming events page to learn
0:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): more.
0:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): This is the Financial Thought Exchange Podcast, where you learn from the leading thinkers in finance. I'm your host, Lauder Moberg, and my guest today is Thomas Coleman. And he is a professor at the University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy. And he was also the one who, together with Roger Ibotson and Lawrence Fisher, were the very first to build Treasury curves using the Fisher's CRISP US Treasury bond files. He has also 20 years of experience in the financial industry. And he's also here as the co-author of two chapters in our new publication: Exponential Wealth, Centuries of Stock and Bond Returns, which we will discuss today. So thank you so much for being here and thank you so much for the contribution to this book.
1:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
1:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Lana, thank you. Thank you for having me. It's a pleasure.
1:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
1:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the focus of our conversation here is bonds, yield curves. So it's all in the fixed income space. And anyone who's ever seen a Bloomberg terminal will assume that we kind of have all the data and we know so much. And you go back in time, of course, and it's a history. hist project. But um first, I guess maybe you can correct me in the presumption that why you dig through the data, don't we have them already? Don't we haven't we collected all the data on bonds by by now?
1:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yes. So so we have a we have an immense amount of data on bonds. Um but that's actually part of the challenge um is that uh there's it's just a variety of uh bonds. And I'll talk about a little later, an issue around 2008. But if you go back into history, it gets pretty messy and complicated because you go back to the 20s and the 30s and the 40s, there were bonds under different tax regimes. regime. So some treasury bonds were fully taxable, others were partially taxable. tax exempt, others were fully tax exempt. And so that sort of just uh complicates the issue. Uh treasury bonds up until the uh 80s or 90s were uh long-dated bonds were callal. And so again, that uh introduces Produces complications and issues. So so looking back in time, uh it really becomes uh a much more complicated. The bonds today are really pretty simple and transparent. Um, but trying to disentangle it going backwards in time,
3:02going far back in time is more difficult.
3:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
3:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's exactly what your project was about, right? Maybe you can give us an overview of the treasury yield curve project here that you pursued. What what has
3:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
3:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): entailed?
3:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Actually, as you mentioned in the introduction, the the project goes back many years with Larry Fisher and Roger Ibotson and I working together. I I kind of hate to say how long ago it was, but uh in the early 1990s, using the CRISP, the Center for Research and Security Prices bond data that Larry Fisher originally started collecting. This is a database of all of the treasuries that are publicly traded and month by month. So starting in December of 1925, end of month up to you know 2025 now. And trying to bit fit a curve across all of those different bills at the short end, notes, and bonds in the in the longer end. Um, so we we did that project um and fitted uh yield curves, published it, uh Moody's supported us in that uh publication. Um, and Ibots and Associates
4:19published the uh the data. Um, we've come back to it, Roger and I came back to it in the past couple of years with the uh the the publication of embedding it in a wider analysis of returns over the past hundred and hundred plus years.
4:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
4:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): what kind of data are you working with then? Is it is other historical yield data in the old records? Like you you did mention the years, but just to emphasize, we're talking 100 hundred years back So here. Is it do you have the yields or is it
4:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the prices that we're doing starting?
4:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Are bond prices for end of month for the Treasury, for the the traded, publicly traded securities. So you know, at the moment, there's what I mean, I don't know, 400 issues, 400 bonds to. that are out there trading. And this database goes back, as I say, the original data were monthly. Now Trist collects some daily data, but we're still focused. We're focused on the monthly data. And it is the bond prices. Um, so we need to take those prices. Um, we don't want to convert them just into the yield to maturity for each bond on its own. but we want to think about a market and a yield curve across um the different bonds. So, how does a two-year and a three-year and a five-year bond fit together in terms of thinking about the underlying structure of the market, the forward curve or For the yield curve, embedding all of
5:59the bonds in that, in that structure? Does that does that make sense? But we're using we're using those original prices that were traded uh and and that that Larry originally went back and and recorded. And then um starting in the 60s and 70s, uh were recorded on a monthly ongoing basis.
6:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So for those who knows what it what is included in numbers having to do with bonds, right? So there's the price. There is you would have probably the maturity and the coupon. And from there you can do everything or
6:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): yes, yes. So sorry, I I should have been more explicit, but you're absolutely right. So we've got the price, um, but we need the characteristics of the bond. So we need the coupon, the maturity. There's going to be a variety of other characteristics. All treasuries today are uh pay coupons semi semi-annually. annually. There were a few uh bonds that paid uh coupons quarterly way back. Also, characteristics, for example, is the bond callable and on what date? Now, no bonds today are that are issued today are callable, and all of the callable bonds have have matured. But for most of the history, up through oh, the even there. were the remaining callable bonds, uh some of the bonds were callable. Uh so those characteristics. Also the amounts outstanding. So what was the the issue amount uh that was available to the public? Sorry, what would be the other characteristics? So price,
7:31coupon, maturity date, callable if it's callable. There's a really fun character. characteristics of bonds, which were issued, I think, up until the 1980s, where some bonds were eligible for payment of estate taxes at par. So, you know, if I have a bond in my estate, I die. I can uh use that to satisfy federal government uh estate taxes,
8:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
8:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): the government will accept it at 100. If it's trading at 80 in the market, you know, and my estate went out and and bought it or I bought it before I died at 80, I still get to give it to the government worth 100. Of course, obviously that provides a big uh kicker to the value if the market is trading with high yields so that bond prices would g go low. Um So that's another characteristic, but we need to understand and sort of incorporate all of those characteristics and the implications and from in market implications into our fitting of those uh of the yield curve.
8:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
8:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): patchy data um is uh sounds like a big of enough problem. Now we have all these features. No, it's good that you bring up the the what was called the flower bonds, right?
8:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Sorry, those are
8:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): flower bonds. And
8:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of course, the
8:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): reason they're called flower bonds is because you know they they are uh part of the sort of if somebody dies, they're a nice benefit.
9:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Right. So uh first is high level. Um, it might not be obvious what callable bond means. Uh just some people might not be thinking about fixed income every day. So callable, that's something that the issuer, so this is the the treasury at this uh in this example, can do something, right? And they can decide that we're done, we're closing this contract now. And like you say, it was at par. So it will be that's where like it becomes also uh asymmetric because hey, if you're actually caught a call, like in in normal markets, we know that it's something that oh it's good you know if it goes up or or something like that but basically right if it's if it means that they can buy something you want to buy something that it's the the the price is below right usually yeah I should say like this do you want to buy something at a fixed price because that's what the call is if it if it's higher right and that's when the yield is high uh is low.
9:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah. So so so thank you
10:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean
10:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I'm and I'm so so you know, it's this has been I I I've been in the fixed income markets for so long that I forget to sort of explain some of the very basic ideas. But you're right, a call bond is that the government issues the bond, it would generally be a 30-year bond. That so the long bond, they would issue a 30-year bond and write, and it was written into the contract, then that after 10 years or after 20 years, the government would have the right to call that bond. Um, in other words, they could redeem that bond for a price of 100. Now, of course, if yields were very low and the bond was thereby trading at a very high price, well, you know, for the government to be able to to be able to redeem that and pay it, you know, buy it for 100 a hundred was uh very valuable. Of course, investors, when they buy it, they know that that option is in there and they'll need to calculate that price. But it means that we can't use a simple present value discounting formula. We've got to embed into the formula for the calculation of the price that option, the possibility that. if the uh if yields go very low, so that prices go
11:20high, then the government will call that bond back. Um so that's just an added additional uh sort of complication in terms of the calculation of the of the the present value of the bond and that's going gonna to then affect the how we calculate the the the forward curve and the yield curve.
11:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
11:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): not to go into the math here at all, but is it complicated? Like would somebody be able to see, like, okay, here's the formula, just do this, or is it a lot of like nuance and it always gets complicated when there's a call involved?
11:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, so I don't know. Um, you know, fifty years ago, options were incredibly complicated because nobody really knew how to do it. Then black controls. and Shoals, uh, you know, Myron Scholes and Fisher Black uh came along, published their famous paper. Um, Robert Merton as well, uh, they won the Nobel Prize for that. And everybody today knows how to calculate uh a Black Scholes option price. And that's basically what we're doing. It's still an approximation because the actual option that's embedded in the treasury. can be exercised at multiple dates. So I don't know. Is it complicated with modern computers? Not really. Um, but it's not just a simple present value calculation.
12:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And so on the other side, then we have we have calls, and then we have puts. And you didn't say the word put, but that's basically what a flower bond was, right? Now I can sell it. if under certain circumstances, right? You can sell it anytime. Like you said, we want to understand maybe a little bit just because it's such a quirky thing in history. You realize how you know a different security isn't it's not that that simple. But um, but this means that I actually want to do that when price is is low, right? Um
13:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): right. There's
13:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the yield
13:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
13:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): high. So then it's the other way. So now we're in the opposite situation here. Yeah.
13:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And and in that case, it's the owner of the bond, the the investor, not the issuer, not the government that has the put. But you know, that put is kind of now that gets complicated to evaluate properly because, of course, it depends on the the death of the owner. So there's no formula you can use for. calculating the economic value of that since it really depends on the particular owner, and different owners will have different prices. So that's a real challenge. Um, Larry Fisher did a lot of work on this, and what he did was identify specific bonds that in a particular month were trading, particularly with that uh put value. And uh so trying to separate out bonds that were trading as what he called them uh flower barns bonds par excellence, the sort of very had a lot of that flower value in them, and other bonds which were not trading um that way. And so we're using using his list to try to uh disentangle that effect. But listen, I'll be honest, you go back. to some of the earlier years, and there are only flower bonds at the long end of the of the yield curve.
14:34And it's I don't think it's really possible. We're certainly don't claim to have been able to completely unravel. And so some of these market prices Is just embed that implicit put price in there. And I don't think there's any good way to to pull that out or net it out.
14:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Right. And don't want to think too much on this because it's not all about flower bones. Pit's such a quirky thing. The the it's um you could you could think that you're using some kind of demographic data and thinking about let's assume there's a normal distribution of the holdings and how people are old and young, but that doesn't work because of course if you have higher income. which means you're older, you're more likely holding, and there might be a strategy, right? You bought this because you wanted this feature because you know that this might happen within the next 10 years.
15:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, yeah. It's just it's okay. I mean, sorry, I don't want to get too much off topic, but this is actually the uh a classic example of what economists call self-selection, where who's going to go out and buy? those flower bonds par excellence? The ones that are trading at a really low price. Well, it's of course the people who are who are old, frail, but they have the the individual personal knowledge of what their health is. Um, and that's something that if we're looking from the outside, you know, we can't say. So the people who are going to buy those are people who particularly select into it. So yeah, it it's a really interesting problem. I mean, I think we do some some reasonable approximations, or not approximations, but trying to to filter out the worst or the bonds that are trading most with the most flower value, but we can't filter it all out.
16:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. So other quirks, right? Uh we didn't mention taxes law. a lot. There are different taxation rules for bonds that have not always been the same. How do you deal with things like that?
16:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So, yeah, with the taxation at the moment, we simply estimate three different curves. So, in the uh early period starting in 1925, we it's most of the bonds issued are are partially tax exempt. And then we come into the 30s and they're fully tax exempt. Now, these bonds were are overlapping. And so I think there's more work could be done there. And we're working on that. But at the moment, we're simply estimating here is a partially exempt curve using only these partially exempt bonds. Then here's this fully tax exempt curve. And then here is the fully taxable bond curve starting in the 1940s. We sort of paste them together. recognizing, but being explicit and letting uh letting users know of the dates that we paste them together. We're working on, I think there's some better ways to do that, but that's sort of the the the challenge going back into the to the 20s, 30s, and 40s, um, and and how we've addressed the challenge. I think we're trying to be pretty honest in in the book of how. we address these some of these challenges.
17:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It's probably the right way to go for your purposes. How about a person you hear people say, you know, yields are higher now than they were in such and such? Somebody picks up your research and they will say something about comparing yields today, then with the time I when all these all these bonds were tax excent, accent, does that risk becoming like is there is a way? to kind of, yeah, on average it's just two percent more or anything like that? Like, because otherwise that comparison always gonna be wrong, right? Because because of the different regimes.
18:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah. So I'm I I'm I'm not I don't think of it as the comparison being wrong as so much as saying, you know, what was available at the time for investors and comparing what was available in say 1928 with what is available today. It's not a it's not a fully apples and orange, I mean it's not a fully apples and apples comparison, but it is the comparison and a valid comparison between what was available in the market at the time and what's available in the market now or some other some other time. I mean, I think, you know, we're working on some some ways to to be able to sort of unpack that comparison and make it a little more transparent. But at the moment, you know, what it is is again not fully apples and apples, but recognizing that was what is was available at the time and we can compare it and a legitimate comparison with what investors can buy today.
19:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): In all cases, you would think the yields are lower Or if something is tax exempt, right? Tax exempt absent means mean it's is more more the attractive.
19:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yes, yes. Um, because the I mean what we think of um is that the decisions we make are on after tax income. If there is a tax in there, that's going to mean the uh essentially the return we get, the price we get is going to be less than we would otherwise. And so a tax exempt bond is going to, for the same price, be worth more. Um, and so yes, the yield would be lower.
19:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Kind
19:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of, I guess what we're seeing with Munis now, if you are
19:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it's exactly
19:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in the state where
19:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you get it. Yeah.
19:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
19:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Munis are the perfect comparison because those are are our our tax exempt. And so, you know, the the 1920s, 1930s, federal bonds were tax exempt, exact comparison with munis today.
20:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, fascinating. So let's there's one more quirk if you want to say anything about it. You also mentioned that there was a period or certain in bonds that have had capped coupons, meaning you're not allowed to issue where the higher coupon than a certain does that have an implication of adjustments you need to make?
20:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, so it sort of has echoes of you know today's um legislation with uh caps on the uh a different type of cap, but right debt limits. So Congress apparently in 1914, nineteen fourteen when they issued the Panama Canal. Bonds. Um I I I don't know. I should know, but but a very um early uh cap on the coupon that could be paid on government bonds. Uh but these were bonds. So we come through to the sixties 60s and seventies 70s, and market yields are rising as inflation. started being embedded into the economy. And so to issue a bond apart, the government would have to have a higher coupon. And they hit that limit of 4.25. So they stopped issuing bonds. Notes, for whatever reason, uh were not notes, shorter issuance, um, were not subject to that same uh cap. And so notes continued to be issued, but there was a period when bonds simply were not issued. And then notes and bonds, the older bonds, which were now low coupon relative to
21:51the market, the older bonds seemed to be trading at a somewhat uh different clientele to the um higher coupon notes in the sort of seven to ten year range.
22:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): At
22:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): least our listeners get a sense of there's a lot that you have to think about and adjust for here. And I could have 10 follow up questions for a lot of things here, but I will not because I do want to move on to uh this a little bit high level of of the findings here. And maybe I I want to start here just um this is a quiz question that I would have gotten wrong, which is if you would ask somebody, do you which bond do you think have uh higher volatility of returns? Is it shorter maturity bonds or longer maturity bonds, higher volatility? Now I would have thought it was shorter because one, I think about the fact that yields move around and you have the central banks, they change rate total time, and that tends to affect the shorter, uh shorter maturity. That is completely wrong. It was wrong accordingly. finding. So can you give me some light on what what's going on here? How to think about the volatility returns? And it's actually the other way around.
22:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
22:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): actually the other other way around, but there's a very good reason that if you, you know, let's just think about a two-year bond versus a 10-year bond. On a two-year bond, you're locked in for two years. You get that coupon and the the final payment. uh it you know over the next two years. Um, and so if market rates go up and down, you've got that risk for two years. If you have a 10-year bond, um, you've got that risk for 10 years. So, you know, what uh everybody in the fixed income market talks It about duration, um, which is well, uh we'll come. back to duration to the to the term duration in just a moment. But what it what it represents, Macaulay originally developed this idea to try to capture the idea of how long a bond is when a bond actually pays coupons intermediate, Immediate, right? If you have a bond that pays only a final coupon at year 10, clearly, how long? is it? 10 years, no question. And that coupon, that that single payment in 10 years, it's going to be a lot more sensitive than a single payment in two years, right? And so that's the fundamental idea for why a
24:1710-year bond is going to be a lot more volatile. Simply, you've got the risk of rates over the next 10 years.
24:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Does that hold then even if you're doing a rolling strategy, it's not contingent of me holding it for 10 years? Like if if I would be selling and buying these every year.
24:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): If I'm if I'm buying it today and selling it at a month, my two-year bond, uh, let's take it extreme. Let's say that I just buy a one-month bond. And so I buy it today and you know, I buy it at 99, say. And in one year, I mean, in one month, it's going to be worth 100. You know, that's locked in. If I buy a 10 year, right, I'd buy it today at some price. Now, in one month, that price may go, you know.
25:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): For
25:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): my one month, I know I know I'm going gonna to get get 100 100 in in one one month. month.
25:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But for
25:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): But for my 10 year, right, if yields go up, the price of that 10-year can go down by quite a bit. So, you know, maybe I'm expecting to get 100 in one month, but who knows? Maybe I'll get 99. On the other hand, maybe I'll get 101, right? I may get a capital gain or I may get a capital loss. But so even for that one month rolling, um, it's just gonna going to be a lot more volatile. if what I am buying month by month is a 10-year rather than a one-month or a one-year or a two-year. Um, does that I I think that I think
25:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
25:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): answers
25:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the question.
25:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Um but just coming back to duration for a minute. So before he introduced this idea of duration, obviously, if it's only a single uh cash flow in year 10, it's 10 years long. But they but his question was: okay, if if the if there's cash flows in between, how do I think about that? And he just had this wonderful idea of using a weighted average of all of those coupon payments. And that measures how long the bond is, taking into account not only the final payment, but all of those intermediate payments. And so a 10-year bond, a bond with the final payment in 10 years, might have this sort of Macaulay duration. How long it is is sort of the weighted average might be 8.3 or something like that. And that Macaulay duration then serves as a very useful measure of the sensitivity of the bond.
26:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
26:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Was
26:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
26:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that a fluke uh uh observation that like once he'd done this, he said it's interesting to know what the actual like average maturity of all the payments rather than just the final payments. Uh and lo and behold, when they got that number, it just happened to be a number that perfectly measures the sensitivity to interest rate of the price.
27:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
27:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): know?
27:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Or
27:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): did they know that from the beginning?
27:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): This is a really interesting question. Go to any textbook. And so this word duration, this term duration, was originally introduced by by Macaulay. And he was explicitly using it for comparing the length of one bond to another bond, but he was thinking about the length of the bond. He was not asking questions. It turns out if you go back and read his original chapter in the book, he was not asking about the sensitivity of a 10-year bond versus a two-year bond. He was strictly thinking about the maturity. And that's why he gave the name duration. Turns out, as far as I've been able to determine, the first person who kind of made this connection. between the Macaulay duration, the length of the bond, a weighted length, and the sensitivity turned out to have been Larry Fisher. And so I, to be honest, you know, I've gone back and read some of this stuff, you know, Larry Fisher in an original article, and
28:18then later uh Fisher and Weil classic articles, but I'm not even sure that Larry realized that Larry Fisher realized. he was the kind of the first one to make this connection between the duration as how long a bond is and the duration as the sensitivity of the bond. And now in the financial market, everybody uses the word duration. And sometimes they mean this how long a bond is, and sometimes they're using the word to talk about the uh sensitivity. Two different meanings, one word, and and actually, I think to my mind, that creates, you know, sometimes a fair amount of confusion.
29:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, yeah. I mean, the textbook will just say it as if it's a matter of fact and how obvious it is that they're both at the same time. Yeah,
29:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it wouldn't would be always obvious to me
29:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): if I only knew one of them.
29:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, yeah. It's it's it's really interesting, and I think sort of keeping in mind that this this idea, because it's a really useful idea of how long the weighted average you know length of a bond, that's the Macaulay duration, really useful concept. It happens to be the same number or very close to the same number as the sensitivity. What's you know, how much does the bond price change? What's the percentage change in the bond price? for uh a change in yields? So I'm sorry, Laura, I'm getting off into these sort of technical things, but it's it's stuff that I've spent a lot of time living with, and I really kind of enjoy
29:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
29:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): No, thank you. Um, I I want to touch on a little bit of the findings here. And um, for you listening, Thing, this is our first out of two conversations. So um knowing more about how we're actually putting this together, you will find in our next conversation is to touch on we've been talking about returns and we haven't been very explicit. And you actually break down returns in in different parts. So um so there's the yield part, there's the income part, which I think was coupon, and the total return. I'm thinking it's all of this, but then there's the total return in excess of the yield. So which one of this should is it important that people kind of understand here? Do we need to understand all of them?
30:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): The the the the important thing is the total return. Okay. You buy it today, you pay a hundred today, and one month from now, how much do you get? You know, it do you get back one oh this one 101, oh one is it ninety 99? nine one 101, oh one in which case you've you know you've got a nice positive return If it's 99, you've lost. And so that's that's really the matters. And in some sense, that's the only thing that matters is what is your total return. But it's very useful conceptually to split that into two parts. One is what are you getting paid in terms of the yield, in terms of the coupon? And the other is then the the returning return in excess. which essentially is a capital gain or a loss. And so conceptually we can make that split, but I should point out that that really is a conceptual split, um, but a very useful one. Because, you know, during periods when coupons and yields are high, we are being essentially compensated for buying that bond and being paid. um a a sort of a an income return, yield return. Does that does that make does that make sense?
31:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. And I I think in this, if I if I throw one more thing into this uh mix is uh you you mentioned that the the return if you remove the yields in the excess of yield, that's the more volatile part.
32:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Absolutely.
32:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Maybe
32:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's helpful, like oh, so is that the coupons then? Or is it that's mostly what people would think about maybe like why would that be volatile? What is that?
32:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Okay, so the the the the yield return is essentially we can think of it as the coupon. Um, the coupon that you get paid. Now, you know, on a treasury you only get paid every six months, but we can sort of think of what on a monthly basis, what should you get paid? That's essentially kind of the market coupon. If the you know, back in 2018, um coupons were down, market yields were down one percent, you know, you would expect to earn month by month, uh, you know, over six months over a year, a uh one 1% percent return. But on any particular month, going from the end of January to the end of February, rates may go up, market rates may go down. Now, if you buy a one-month bond, so I buy today and the bond matures or the bill matures in one month,
33:09I've locked in and that's going to be the yield that I earn. That is the market yield. But if I buy a 10-year bond, yeah, I should expect to get that yield, but prices may go up, prices may go down, bond prices go up and down, minute by minute, day by day, month by month. And that excess over what is the coupon, what is the yield, that's the the excess, that's essentially a capital gain. And that's going to be a hugely amount more volatile for 10 years than it is for a um one month bill. And you know, the the volatility of that excess return for the 10 10-year year is going to be,
34:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
34:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): quite large, and it's gonna it's gonna overwhelm the volatility of that yield on that um 10-year treasury. The volatility of the yield return on the one month and the 10-year will be pretty much the same. They should be the same, but the volatility of the excess on that 10-year 10 year is going to be very high, and on the one month, there'll be no volatility of the the excess.
34:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): If I think about in the real world, if you meet somebody and they say, I'm a day trader, and what do you what do you do? I do fixed income. You're clearly not doing that as a day trader, meaning trading in and out several times a day because this coupon is X. It's like what
34:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're
34:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): expecting to happen to the price. And that's a return in itself.
34:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): That's the excess. That's that's the return in excess of yield. That's the capital gain. If somebody somebody's trading bonds, you know, on a very short-term basis, that's what they're trying to capture. And that's going to be, you know, much more opportunity
35:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
35:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): a 10-year or a 30-year bond than there is in a in a one-month. There's much more opportunity for gain, but obviously much more opportunity for loss as well. The volatility is going to be much higher.
35:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
35:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you. Yeah. So I think this has been a good overview of what the project is and the some of the issues that you come across. Just to wrap up, it would be great to just hear from you. If there's now that we talked about the breakdowns in return, and there's a lot of numbers in there, anyone can look into. And of course, everybody should read the chapter, read the book, and read specifically these two chapters, and you get a lot of the findings in. there that we're not gonna cover any specific numbers here. But is there anything from this breakdown when you broke it down into these components that might surprise our listeners here in terms of higher or lower or other different periods?
35:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I I I think this idea that you've that that we've just been talking about the breakdown between or the split between the uh yield return and the return in excess of yield. You know, Roger has this this very nice, and we put it into the book. It's it's the Aesop's fable of the the the tortoise and the hare. If you're a day trader, you're not buying and selling treasuries because you're gonna earn a uh coupon of, you know, what in a day, five cents in a day or something. But you know what? Over the long term, that's what matters is that yield return. And if you look at our tables, the return that you calculate, the total return, almost all of that comes from the yield return. The excess return, the capital gain averages out to be close to zero. And so if you're going to earn anything from fixed income,
36:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're
36:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): going gonna earn it over the long run um on the the income return, the yield, the the the return on yield.
36:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
37:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): over the very long run, right? It works over the hundred years that you're looking at. And is it fair to summarize the history of bond as there was a neg
37:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
37:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the excess of yields, right? Was actually negative up to 1980 around there? And then since then, on average, it's been positive.
37:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): If you look at the graph of yields, it is a pyramid. It goes up through, yeah, as you say, roughly 1980, and then down. And that's kind of a whole story if you split it into those two periods. That uh that that yields rose, the the uh return on in excess over that first half period. Um you've lost money if you were a bondholder and of the last the second period. But you know, even on relatively shorter periods like decades, it really is the uh the the yield return. Um it's it's again it's the story of the tortoise and the hare. In the long run, the uh the tortoise just you know plodding along um that yield return month after month. is what accumulates.
38:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's one gist of the history of bonds. But of course, if you read the chapters, uh there's so much more, it's very, very rich. And um, for you who listen here, you are a little bit smarter about fixed income now. But if you want to really take it up a notch, you should listen to our next conversation. And um, so we will see you on that other side. So thank you so much for tuning in. This is the Financial Thought Exchange Podcast. Thank you, Thomas, for being here. And um, I've been your host, Vladimir. Um, our our guest here is Thomas Coleman. He's the co-authors of two of the chapters in our new publication from the Research Foundation called Exponential Wealth: Centuries of Stocks and Bond Return. returned, And we will see you in our next conversation.
38:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): For more information. please visit rpc.cfainstitute.org slash research-foundation.