Dr. Amanda outlines five reasons to avoid Roth conversions in 2026, citing tax inefficiencies and specific life circumstances.
Summary
Dr. Amanda presents five reasons why Roth conversions may be inadvisable in 2026, warning that poor timing can lead to unnecessary taxes and higher Medicare premiums. She argues that converting when funds are needed soon negates long-term benefits due to five-year rules. The speaker highlights that conversions add taxable income, potentially triggering IRMAA cliffs or reducing tax credits, and advises paying taxes from outside funds. She also notes the 'widow's penalty' regarding future tax brackets for surviving spouses and states that converting for charitable bequests is unnecessary since charities do not pay income tax.
Key takeaways
- 1 A Roth conversion is not universally beneficial; executing it without a plan can result in unnecessary taxes and increased Medicare premiums.
Dr. Amanda · 0:19
- 2 So a $100,000 conversion could add $100,000 to your taxable income. And that can create a significant tax bill. Ideally, you have money outside of your retirement accounts available to pay for those taxes.
Dr. Amanda · 2:58
- 3 bonus. bonuses or interest crediting opportunities that may help you offset some of the cost of converting. Now, those features don't eliminate your taxes and they come with contract terms and trade-offs, but they're worth understanding as a part of the overall strategy.
Dr. Amanda · 3:38
- 4 a surviving spouse could eventually face a higher tax bill, higher tax rate filing as a single taxpayer. This is known as the widow's penalty.
Dr. Amanda · 4:38
- 5 Medicare IRMAA uses income from two years prior to determine Part B and D premiums, and crossing a threshold by even one penny can trigger a higher premium tier.
Dr. Amanda · 5:18
- 6 Qualified charities generally don't pay income taxes when they inherit traditional IRA assets. So why I voluntarily pay taxes to convert money that the charity could receive without owing income taxes? You might be creating an unnecessary tax expense.
Dr. Amanda · 6:37
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 1:19
Introduction and Roth Conversion Overview
Dr. Amanda introduces five reasons to avoid Roth conversions in 2026, noting the December 31st deadline for tax year inclusion. She warns that incorrect decisions can lead to unnecessary taxes, higher Medicare premiums, or unexpected financial consequences.
- 1:19 – 2:58
Reason 1: Needing Money Soon and Five-Year Rules
The speaker explains that converting and immediately spending negates long-term benefits. She details two five-year rules: one for tax-free earnings (starting from the first Roth IRA funding year) and one for conversion-related early withdrawal penalties, which generally cease at age 59 1/2.
- 2:58 – 3:58
Reason 2: No Tax Payment Plan
Conversions add taxable income to the current year, potentially creating a large tax bill. The speaker advises having funds outside retirement accounts to pay these taxes to preserve the full converted amount, though some Roth-friendly annuities offer bonuses to offset costs.
- 3:58 – 4:58
Reason 3: Future Tax Rates and the Widow's Penalty
Converting when in a high bracket but expecting lower future income may be inefficient. The speaker highlights the 'widow's penalty,' where surviving spouses may face higher single-filer tax rates due to Social Security, pensions, and RMDs, suggesting smaller conversions over multiple years.
- 4:58 – 6:17
Reason 4: Triggering Additional Costs (IRMAA, SS Tax, Credits)
Conversions can increase income enough to trigger Medicare IRMAA cliffs, make more Social Security taxable, or reduce eligibility for income-based tax credits. The speaker emphasizes evaluating the broader financial picture beyond just the tax bracket.
- 6:17 – 7:39
Reason 5: Leaving IRA to Charity
Converting traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs before leaving them to qualified charities is unnecessary because charities do not pay income tax on inherited traditional IRA assets. This differs from leaving assets to individual heirs, where Roth withdrawals are tax-free.
- 7:39 – 9:59
Roth-Friendly Annuities and Safe Money Bucket
The speaker distinguishes between equities (growth/volatility) and a 'safe money bucket' using Roth-friendly annuities. These products offer principal protection from market declines, interest crediting based on indices with a 0% floor, and potential lifetime income options.
- 9:59 – 13:09
Annuity Features and Ongoing Coordination
Roth-friendly annuities may allow partial conversions over years to manage tax planning and offer bonuses to offset tax costs. The speaker describes a process where her team coordinates with tax professionals and carriers in Q4 to handle paperwork and reporting for clients.
Claims worth verifying
To count for the 2026 tax year, a Roth conversion generally needs to be completed by December 31st, 2026.
Dr. Amanda ·0:00
How to verify: IRS Publication 590-B (Individual Retirement Arrances) or IRS.gov guidance on Roth conversion deadlines for tax year 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Roth IRAs share the same five-year starting date for tax-free earnings based on the first tax year any Roth IRA was funded.
Dr. Amanda ·2:19
How to verify: IRS Publication 590-B, Section on 'Qualified Rollover Contributions' and 'Five-Year Rule' for earnings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The five-year rule for early withdrawal penalties on conversions generally ceases to be an issue at age 59 and a half.
Dr. Amanda ·2:38
How to verify: IRS Publication 590-B, Section on 'Early Distributions' and 'Exceptions to the 10% Additional Tax'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A $100,000 Roth conversion adds $100,000 to taxable income for the year.
Dr. Amanda ·3:18
How to verify: IRS Form 8606 (Nondeductible IRAs) instructions and Form 1040 instructions regarding taxable conversions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Medicare IRMAA looks at income from two years earlier to determine Part B and D premiums.
Dr. Amanda ·5:18
How to verify: Social Security Administration (SSA) website on 'Medicare Premiums' and 'Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount (IRMAA)'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Qualified charities do not pay income taxes when they inherit traditional IRA assets.
Dr. Amanda ·6:37
How to verify: IRS Publication 590-B, Section on 'Charitable Distributions' and 'Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs)'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Fixed Indexed Annuities (FIAs) offer a 0% floor of protection against market declines.
Dr. Amanda ·9:18
How to verify: FIA contract illustrations and prospectuses from insurance carriers (e.g., Allianz, Lincoln Financial) detailing index crediting methods. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Roth-friendly annuities may allow partial conversions from a traditional IRA annuity into a Roth IRA annuity over multiple years.
Dr. Amanda ·10:19
How to verify: Specific annuity product prospectuses or carrier websites (e.g., New York Life, MetLife) describing 'Roth Conversion' features. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify current IRS tax brackets for 2026 and projected future rates to assess conversion efficiency.
- Review Medicare IRMAA income thresholds for the relevant tax year, noting the two-year lookback period for premiums.
- Confirm the specific five-year rule start date for your first Roth IRA to determine tax-free earnings eligibility.
- Check if any Roth-friendly annuities offer bonuses or interest crediting features that offset conversion costs, and read the prospectus for principal protection terms.
- Consult a tax professional to model the impact of conversion income on Social Security taxation and eligibility for income-based tax credits.
- Evaluate estate plans to determine if charitable bequests are made from traditional IRAs, where no income tax is due to the charity.
- Assess the 'widow's penalty' risk by modeling surviving spouse tax brackets under single-filer status with combined income sources.
- Review the specific five-year rule for early withdrawal penalties on conversions, which ceases at age 59 1/2.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Dr. Amanda: If you're thinking about doing a Roth conversion in 2026, the clock is ticking. To count for this tax year, your conversion generally needs to be completed by December 31st. But before you rush to convert your traditional IRA, your 401k, your TSP into a Roth IRA, there's a bigger question. Should you even be doing
- 0:19
- Dr. Amanda: a Roth conversion? Because while Roth conversions can be a powerful retirement planning strategy, they're not right for everyone. And making the wrong decision could mean paying unnecessary taxes, increasing your Medicare premiums, or creating financial consequences you didn't anticipate. So, in this lesson,
- 0:39
- Dr. Amanda: I'm gonna walk you through five reasons you might not want to do a Roth conversion. And then if you've decided that converting does make sense, I'll explain why you might consider using a Roth friendly annuity as part of your retirement strategy. Because deciding to convert is only half the equation. You also need to decide
- 0:59
- Dr. Amanda: where that money should go. I'm Dr. Amanda. Welcome to the Retirement Income School. This is your place for financial education on how to protect your wealth and generate guaranteed lifetime income so you can retire financially relaxed. I specialize in safety. safe money solutions and retirement income planning, including helping
- 1:19
- Dr. Amanda: clients evaluate and execute Roth conversions using Roth friendly annuities. But before we talk about those solutions, let's look at five reasons you might want to think twice about converting. Reason number one you need the money soon. One of the biggest advantages of a Roth IRA is the opportunity for. tax
- 1:39
- Dr. Amanda: free growth and qualified tax free withdrawals. But if you're converting money today, paying taxes on it, and immediately spending, you may not be getting the full long term benefit. Now, a question I frequently hear is what about the five year Roth clock? There are actually two different five year rules. The
- 1:59
- Dr. Amanda: first determines whether your Roth IRA earnings qualify for tax free withdrawals. If you're at least 59 and a half and you've satisfied the five year tax requirement, your Roth IRA withdrawals generally qualify for tax free treatment. And here's what's important your Roth IRAs share the same five year
- 2:19
- Dr. Amanda: starting date based on the first tax year you funded any Roth IRA. You don't start a new qualified distribution clock every time. you open another Roth IRA. There's also a separate five-year rule for each conversion related to potential early withdrawal penalties. But generally, once you're
- 2:38
- Dr. Amanda: 59 and a half, that particular penalty is no longer an issue. So the takeaway is this: just because you can access your Roth money doesn't necessarily mean converting money, you need a immediately is the best strategy. And that brings us to reason number two. And that reason is no tax payment plan.
- 2:58
- Dr. Amanda: Where will the money come from to pay for taxes on the conversion? When you convert traditional IRA money into a Roth IRA, the taxable amount is generally added to your income for that year. So a $100,000 conversion could add $100,000 to your taxable income. And that can create a significant
- 3:18
- Dr. Amanda: tax bill. Ideally, you have money outside of your retirement accounts available to pay for those taxes. That allows you to keep the full converted amount inside your Roth. But what if you don't have that money available? Does that automatically mean you shouldn't convert? Not necessarily. Certain Roth friendly annuities offer
- 3:38
- Dr. Amanda: bonus. bonuses or interest crediting opportunities that may help you offset some of the cost of converting. Now, those features don't eliminate your taxes and they come with contract terms and trade-offs, but they're worth understanding as a part of the overall strategy. The important thing is having a plan for the taxes before you convert. The third
- 3:58
- Dr. Amanda: reason that you may not want to convert is that your future tax rate may be lower. And this reason is all about timing. You want to consider are you better off paying taxes today or paying them later? Let's say you're in a relatively high tax bracket today, but you expect your income to drop significantly after retirement, it
- 4:18
- Dr. Amanda: might make more sense to wait until you're in a lower tax bracket. But what if you're already retired and you haven't started RMDs, required? minimum distributions? You might be in a lower tax bracket now, but your income could increase once Social Security, pensions, and RMDs come into play. And
- 4:38
- Dr. Amanda: a surviving spouse could eventually face a higher tax bill, higher tax rate filing as a single taxpayer. This is known as the widow's penalty. And that's why we don't just look at this year's taxes. We look at your potential tax situation throughout retirement. And remember, Roth conversions don't have to be all or nothing.
- 4:58
- Dr. Amanda: You can potentially convert smaller amounts over several years. And that brings us to reason number four you may not want to do a Roth conversion, and it's that your conversion could trigger other costs. This is important to know. Your income tax bill isn't necessarily the only cost of a Roth conversion. There are three
- 5:18
- Dr. Amanda: things to consider. First, you've got Medicare premiums. A Roth conversion can increase your income enough to trigger Irma, the income related monthly adjustment amount. Medicare currently looks at your income from two years earlier to determine whether you'll pay higher part B and D premiums. And here's what's important Irma has
- 5:38
- Dr. Amanda: income clearly. cliffs. Crossing a threshold even by one penny can move you into a higher premium tier. Now, does that automatically mean you shouldn't convert? Absolutely not. Sometimes paying higher Medicare premiums temporarily may be worthwhile for a better long term tax outcome. But you want to
- 5:58
- Dr. Amanda: understand the potential cost. Second, Social Security taxation. A Roth conversion could cause more of your Social Security benefits to be taxable. And third, certain tax credits and deductions. Because conversions increase your income, they can affect eligibility for some income-based tax benefits. So remember, don't
- 6:17
- Dr. Amanda: evaluate a Roth conversion based on your tax bracket alone. You gotta look at the bigger financial picture. And this brings us to the fifth reason you may not want to conversion. convert, and that's if you're leaving your IRA to charity. If you're planning to leave your traditional IRA to a qualified charity, converting those dollars might not make sense.
- 6:37
- Dr. Amanda: Here's why. Qualified charities generally don't pay income taxes when they inherit traditional IRA assets. So why I voluntarily pay taxes to convert money that the charity could receive without owing income taxes? You might be creating an unnecessary tax expense. Now that's different from leaving retirement
- 6:57
- Dr. Amanda: assets to your children or other individual beneficiaries. For those beneficiaries, a Roth IRA can provide a valuable advantage. Qualified Roth IRA withdrawals can provide an income tax-free Tax free inheritance. And that's one compelling reason to consider converting. So we've covered five reasons you might not want to convert,
- 7:17
- Dr. Amanda: but there are also excellent reasons why people do convert. Tax free growth, qualified tax free withdrawals, no lifetime RMDs for the original Roth IRA owner, and income tax free inheritance for heirs. So let's say you've weighed the pros and cons and you've decided a Roth conversion makes sense. What
- 7:37
- Dr. Amanda: happens next? Here's the big question.
- 7:39
- Dr. Amanda: where should your Roth money go? Because a Roth IRA is an account with specific tax treatment. It's not an investment or an insurance product by itself. You still need to decide how to position those assets inside of it. One option is your equities bucket. That's where you might hold stocks, ETFs, and other
- 7:59
- Dr. Amanda: market based investments. These are gonna going to offer growth potential. but also come with market volatility and the possibility of losses. And equities can certainly be an important part of a diversified retirement portfolio. But there's another bucket that I specialize in, and that's your safe money bucket. This is where we look at
- 8:19
- Dr. Amanda: solutions that are designed to protect principal from market declines and offer interest crediting opportunities and potential. potentially provide guaranteed lifetime income. And one of the primary tools we use is annuities, specifically certain annuities designed to support Roth conversion strategies. Let's call these
- 8:39
- Dr. Amanda: Roth friendly annuities. And Roth friendly annuities offer four potential benefits. The first is principal protection. With an FIA or a fixed indexed annuity, your protected contract. value isn't directly exposed to stock market declines. You don't receive a negative index credit simply because the index
- 8:59
- Dr. Amanda: goes down. Second, an FIA would be a safe money allocation in your portfolio. You might have an equities bucket for market-based growth and a safe money bucket for protected accumulation or income planning. It's about understanding how those different parts of your retirement plan can work together. Third, there's interest crediting potential. Fixed indexed
- 9:18
- Dr. Amanda: annuities can earn interest based on external index performance. You're not directly invested in the market. Instead, you're tracking indices and you've got a 0% floor of protection, but the possibility for upside gain. And fourth, you've got lifetime income options. Some annuities offer contractual guarantees that can provide lifetime income.
- 9:39
- Dr. Amanda: This would be an FIA with an income rider. And when the applicable Roth IRA distribution requirements are satisfied, the income can be received tax-free. So a Roth friendly annuity can potentially serve different purposes: protected accumulation, lifetime income, or both. Now, what specifically makes an
- 9:59
- Dr. Amanda: annuity Roth friendly? It's about certain carriers offer. offering features that make ongoing Roth conversion planning easier. For example, some allow partial conversions from a traditional IRA annuity into a Roth IRA annuity over multiple years. This gives you flexibility to coordinate your conversion
- 10:19
- Dr. Amanda: amounts with your tax planning. If you want to go more in depth there, I've talked about this in my Roth friendly annuity lesson. Another feature of a Roth friendly annuity carrier would be that some products also offer bonuses or index crediting opportunities that may help offset part of the cost of conversion taxes. And bonuses don't eliminate your tax
- 10:38
- Dr. Amanda: liability. Unfortunately, you're never gonna get out of paying taxes. Instead, they're just helping you offset the tax liability. And so these features might be worth evaluating depending on your portfolio structure and your. legacy goals. Next, and here's something I especially want to emphasize: when you work with us, we help you coordinate the Roth conversion
- 10:58
- Dr. Amanda: process year after year. Typically during the fourth quarter, we revisit your strategy and we help you coordinate with your tax professional to determine the conversion amount that may make sense for you. And then we work with the Roth friendly insurance carrier to facilitate the conversion paperwork. The carrier processes and reports the applicable
- 11:17
- Dr. Amanda: transactions. So you have all the IRA paperwork you need to give to your tax professional at tax time. That means you have a team helping coordinate the moving parts. And for many clients, that ongoing support is an important part of the value because Roth conversion planning isn't just about selecting an annuity, it's about having a coordinated process. So let's
- 11:37
- Dr. Amanda: bring all of this together.
- 11:39
- Dr. Amanda: Before doing a Roth conversion, I want you to think about three questions. Number one, should you convert? We've covered five reasons a conversion might not make sense, along with some of the long-term benefits. Number two, how much should you convert? Because converting everything in one year isn't necessarily the best strategy. Smaller
- 11:59
- Dr. Amanda: conversions over several years may make more sense for you. And number three, where should your money go? Do you want market-based growth, principal protection, interest crediting potential, or guaranteed income for life that's tax-free? The answer depends on your personal retirement goals. So the right Roth conversion starts with the right plan.
- 12:19
- Dr. Amanda: Alright, it's time to take action. If you're approaching retirement or you're already retired and you're interested in exploring how a Roth friendly annuity might fit into your retirement strategy, I'd love to have a conversation with you. Just go to retirementincome.school, click on the link at the top of the page that says book a QA call.
- 12:39
- Dr. Amanda: We'll talk about your situation and what you're wanting to accomplish and whether the safe money solutions that I specialize in might be a good fit for you. If you found this lesson helpful, be sure to give it a thumbs up and subscribe to the retirement. Income School channel, where I'll continue to help you keep your money safe and make it last so you can enjoy retirement. This content is for
- 12:59
- Dr. Amanda: educational purposes only and is not financial, legal, or tax advice. Always consult a qualified professional before making decisions about your retirement.