Speakers advise against buying Anthropic IPO day one, citing historical post-IPO underperformance
Summary
Speaker 0 and Justin Dyer argue against purchasing Anthropic stock on its IPO day, characterizing the initial buying frenzy as a 'stampede' that lacks long-term pricing advantages. They compare venture capital to building a sports franchise, emphasizing the need for early-stage scouting in key hubs to secure lower valuations before public markets price in hype. The speakers cite data showing that the 12 largest IPOs since 2008 all lost more than 10% in their first year, using Facebook, SpaceX, and Rivian as case studies of post-IPO underperformance. They conclude that investors should maintain diversification, commit capital year-over-year to capture unpredictable outliers, and wait for market settlement before reassessing public listings.
Key takeaways
- 1 The hundred-year investors should definitely not buy anthropic on day one. That's a stampede. You're participating in a stampede, and that's typically not how you get pricing that you will be happy about for the next hundred years.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 0:00
- 2 Treat venture capital like building a sports franchise: hire scouts in major ecosystems (Silicon Valley, NYC, Seattle, Miami) to identify talent early.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 3:47
- 3 Facebook serves as a case study where a generational company had a 'terrible' first year post-IPO, highlighting the disconnect between business quality and short-term stock performance.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 9:00
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 3:47
Intro and Anthropic IPO Context
Speaker 0 advises against buying Anthropic on day one, calling it a 'stampede' that lacks long-term pricing advantage. Justin Dyer introduces the concept of letting the 'bandwagon clear' before investing.
- 3:47 – 6:01
Private Market Strategy and Scouting
Speaker 0 compares venture capital to building a sports franchise, emphasizing the need for a scouting department in key hubs like Silicon Valley, New York, Seattle, and Miami to find early-stage talent at lower valuations.
- 6:01 – 8:21
Diversification and Year-over-Year Commitment
Justin Dyer adds that while scouts help identify winners, most startups fail, necessitating diversification across regions and a disciplined, year-over-year commitment to capital deployment to capture outliers like SpaceX or Anthropic.
- 8:21 – 9:00
Public Market Approach: Avoiding the First Year
Speaker 0 argues that the first 12 months post-IPO are statistically poor for returns, citing data that the 12 largest IPOs since 2008 all lost more than 10% in their first year.
- 9:00 – 12:50
Case Studies: Facebook, SpaceX, and Rivian
Speaker 0 notes Facebook had a terrible first year despite being a generational company, SpaceX trades below its IPO day price, and Rivian dropped 81% in its first year, illustrating the risks of buying into IPO hype.
- 12:50 – 17:03
Conclusion: Discipline and Long-Term View
The speakers conclude that Anthropic is one company in a 100-year journey, urging investors to avoid chasing hype, maintain diversification across years, and wait for the market to settle before reassessing public listings.
Claims worth verifying
Anthropic opened its first day of trading at $111.50, well above its $83 IPO price, in the largest IPO on record.
Justin Dyer ·1:04
How to verify: SEC EDGAR filing for Anthropic's S-1 registration statement and NYSE/NASDAQ opening price data for the first trading day. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAnthropic's first valuation was sub-$500 million.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·5:26
How to verify: Historical Crunchbase or PitchBook data for Anthropic's seed/series A funding rounds. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The first twelve months after an IPO are statistically bad for the business; the twelve biggest IPOs since 2008 all traded at more than a 10% loss in that first year.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·8:40
How to verify: Calculate total return (price change + dividends) for the 12 largest IPOs by size since 2008 using Bloomberg or Capital IQ data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceFacebook had a terrible first year after its IPO.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·9:00
How to verify: Compare Facebook's (META) stock price on its IPO day (May 18, 2026) to its price one year later (May 2026) using Yahoo Finance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceSpaceX is trading down from the first day of trading.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·10:00
How to verify: Compare SpaceX's current private market valuation per share (from recent funding rounds) to its valuation at the time of its IPO (if applicable) or compare to public peers; note: SpaceX is private, so verify via recent funding round valuations reported by Bloomberg/Reuters. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Rivian's stock was down 81% in its first year after IPO.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·14:42
How to verify: Compare Rivian's (RIVN) stock price on its IPO day (Nov 10, 2026) to its price one year later (Nov 2026) using Yahoo Finance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAnthropic's initial valuation was sub-$500 million.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·5:26
How to verify: Review press releases or financial news archives for Anthropic's seed funding round valuation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Anthropic IPO'd at $83 a share.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·2:17
How to verify: SEC EDGAR filing for Anthropic's S-1 registration statement. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceRivian was down 80% on the year in its first year.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·15:02
How to verify: Compare Rivian's (RIVN) stock price on its IPO day (Nov 10, 2026) to its price one year later (Nov 2026) using Yahoo Finance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Miami is a new, hot hub for venture capital talent.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·5:06
How to verify: Review venture capital activity reports from sources like PitchBook or CB Insights for Miami-based VC deals post-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the claim that the 12 largest IPOs since 2008 all lost >10% in year one by checking CRSP or S&P Global IPO databases.
- Review Rivian's (RIVN) stock price history from its November 2021 IPO to confirm the 81% first-year decline.
- Check Anthropic's initial private valuation rounds (Series A/B) to compare against its public offering price.
- Analyze Facebook's (META) stock performance during its first 12 months post-IPO to assess the 'terrible first year' claim.
- Identify current venture capital scouting hubs mentioned (Silicon Valley, NYC, Seattle, Miami) and assess local deal flow data.
- Review SpaceX's current public market valuation (if applicable) or recent private valuation reports to compare against its historical IPO-day price.
- Assess the diversification strategy of major VC firms to understand how they manage the risk of startup failure.
- Check for any conflicts of interest or sponsorships related to Anthropic or the speakers' investment vehicles.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): The hundred-year investors should definitely not buy anthropic on day one. That's a stampede. You're participating in a stampede, and that's typically not how you get pricing that you will be happy about for the next hundred years. Typically, when everyone has access, it's not cool anymore, and you're not getting any form of advantage. So that advantage needs to be thoughtfully orchestrated in the private markets when values. are substantially more attractive. And that takes work, effort, and discipline to actually execute properly.
0:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
0:34Justin Dyer: terminology we use here is let the bandwagon clear. This is one day on a journey of a hundred years.
0:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey
0:44Justin Dyer: everyone, welcome back to another episode of AWM Insights. It's your host, Justin Dyer, Chief Investment Officer here at AWM Capital, joined as always by Mina Hana, Portfolio Manager here at AWM. And my co-host here is uh hopefully you all know. Um, tune in, subscribe, make sure you're listening to this on a weekly basis. Um, and give us comments on and feedback on the on the content. Today it's a big day. We're recording this Thursday, November 19th. Um it it assuming you're you are paying attention, it's the uh first day of trading for Anthropic, uh rocketed to the rarefied air of being a trillion-dollar company in the public markets. Um, also the largest IPO in history. Um, so lots going on. You're probably seeing it, hearing about it quite a bit. And we're just going to dive into it. How to think about it? How should the hundred-year family think about this event today? And we're going to start that conversation by simply saying, actually, what should people not do? What should the hundred-year family, the hundred-year investor, not do, Mina?
1:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, the hundred hundred-year year investors should definitely not buy anthropic on day one. We've seen this with space. SpaceX. There was a pop. It's actually pretty funny. Uh, we're recording this kind of in the middle of the trading day. Anthropic IPO'd at 83 bucks a share. It's spiked up to one eleven and it's already down fifteen percent from there. So when you think about what you absolutely shouldn't do is you shouldn't hop on the bandwagon and get in while everyone else is getting in and when the floodgates open. That's a stampede. You're participating in a stampede. And that's typically not how you get pricing that you will be happy about for the next hundred years. So I would say resisting the urge to participate when everyone else is and when the hype train has already taken off is 100% what you should do. And and yeah, getting ahead of yourself. and buying in at $111 is absolutely not what you should do.
2:55Justin Dyer: Yeah, right. That's just driven by the hype train, FOMO, whatever you want to call it. You know, when any when anytime emotions are driving financial decisions, usually they're a bad thing, but it's definitely always a time to pause, reflect, refocus, and really go back to the basics, um, which which we're gonna going to get in today. Maybe before we speak a little bit more granularly about the 100 year family and anthropic specifically, I want to just talk about high level venture. Last episode, we talked about just like the barbell approach that really we should apply here. We're certainly going to revisit that concept. But right, it's not that we went and we picked anthropic. When we're investing in private markets, when we're investing in venture capitals, venture capital, excuse me, just unravel real quickly, high-level how we think about it, why we think about it the way we do.
3:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, I would think about it kind of as putting together an organization. You know, Eric always uh uses the phrase athlete CEO. You could sort of think about it as like an athlete owner putting together an organization, a ball club that should perform. One of the big responsibilities there is to hire a scouting department and to have good scouts in on your team to identify talent. Now, there are going to be situations where you have the top overall pick and you're able to extract tremendous value as an owner and as a ball club by having that pick and having that player come through your organization. And there's also a pretty strategic opportunity that you have of being able to draft, you know, a Cy Young winner in the ninth round that adds tremendous value to your organization. So what we do is we create that scouting department. We partner with the best scouts in venture capital. A lot of them do live in the Silicon Bay area. Um, Silicon Bay Valley. A lot of them also operate in other major ecosystems, New York City, Seattle, Miami. Miami's a new, a new hot hub. But they're in these ecosystems that a lot of hot, hot
5:06talent arises from, and they're able to get access to this talent early, and ideally for also lower prices. You're not buying in at multi-billion dollar valuations. You're getting in early. You know, we were just talking about before this call. Anthropic's first valuation was sub-a billion dollars. Actually, the first, yeah, their first one was sub actually $500 million. If you're able to get in there and you know pick that Cy Young winner in the ninth round, they can add tremendous value to your organization. And you can ride that way. wave up. And then you're not worried about pricing. You're buying in at the a fraction of the price, and you get to enjoy the run-up. And you're participating either way in the hype train, but the cost of your seat makes a whole lot more sense.
5:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
5:55Justin Dyer: totally. I and I I would just add to that. I think an astute observer for what would say, well, okay, that makes a ton of sense. But actually, there's a ton of startups each and every year, and actually most of them go bankrupt. So how do you know which ones to pick, right? Okay, well, those are the scouts. The scouts we partner with certainly have that ability, but even they get some things wrong. And we we then take the approach that we want multiple scouts scouring multiple areas. like you said, multiple regions, but those regions need to have a have a purpose and um uh uh an ecosystem that really supports what we are trying to invest in, which quite simply with with venture capital is innovation. But then the other piece, which you didn't hit on, but I think is is equally important is the year-over-year year over year commitment to this. You don't know when the next SpaceX is going to be started. You don't know when the next Anthropic or OpenAI are going to launch. And so you need that disciplined deployment of capital each and every year to have exposure to the the innovation of economy. So you can participate in days like this, in events like this. That is certainly how we think about it from a from a private market standpoint. You want
7:15to be there as early as possible in an example like Anthropics. So you're benefiting much more than participating or having an entry point on day one in the public markets, which to your point doesn't generally work out. SpaceX is kind of a recent example uh of that. And so kind of, I guess with that comment, let's let's do j jump into the transition from private markets, right? Okay, we want to get as in as early as possible. You're you're thinking about this as building an organization, not just building a team based on one single individual. That is, you know, said differently, diversification really, both in in terms of time and then also number of shots on goal. But now we're we're here sitting today anthropic's going public. We believe in diversification in the public markets almost just as much, arguably even more, if you will, than the private markets. Um how how do we think about it in terms of investing in Anthropic for the hundred year family now that it is public?
8:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. Um the w the way we think about it is sort of we want wanna to buy buy low. low, we wanna buy, as we said, in the private markets early on. We don't want to buy high and hope that we're selling for higher later because we get lucky. So there is a crazy, crazy period. The first twelve months after an IPO are actually bad for the business, uh, for the most part, statistically. We were running this data internally. The twelve biggest IPOs since 2008, they've all traded at more than 10% of a loss in that first year. And a lot of them actually end the year at a pretty substantial loss. I think Facebook was was the big one. Facebook had a terrible first year, and they're still a generational business and company. So it's not like you don't want to own Facebook. You probably just want to avoid Facebook in that year that it IPOs because it's a little bit of a shit show for lack of a better term. And the stock is settling still. So the market is still getting used to the stock. The market's also getting new information for the first time. Big part of being a publicly traded business is sort of like operating in a house without without any any real walls. You're operating in a glass house. And a lot of times the market. doesn't like what it
9:40sees in your house. So it takes some time for things to really settle down. After a year, our investment philosophy is you have reevaluate the business. At that point, typically the business is also selling for or valued at a lot less than the initial IPO day. SpaceX is a great value example of that. It is down. from the first day of trading. So if you bought SpaceX and you bought into the hype, you've ridden that wave down. You wait a year, you see how the business is actually doing, and then you think about thoughtfully entering at the right time. But it's not just throw your money at it when an indice includes it or when you're actually able to click the buy button. in Schwab or whatever trading platform you you use, it's hey, look at the data. The data's soft for the first year. So how do we actually thoughtfully get exposure when the hooliganism is is gone? Yeah,
10:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right.
10:42Justin Dyer: I think we're gonna we're working on a blog post right now where well, you know, the the terminology we use here is let the bandwagon clear. I actually really, really like that. The the point to underscore here is IPOs are not bad inherently. It's actually a really good event or milestone within investing, within capital markets, as we say in the world of finance. It's a great milestone going from public market or private markets to public markets. It's creating liquidity. We use this barbell approach to make sure we're trying to get exposure to all of these incredibly successful companies as early as possible in the private markets. There's a lot of hype and bandwagon riding right around this period with respect to anthropic and a lot of IPOs. We don't really want to play in that world. There's too much noise, there's too much high. hype, there's too much uh distortion really. And so we want the dust to settle and thoughtfully maintain exposure or reintroduce exposure in the public markets in the thoughtful way, once all that um
11:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh uh
11:55Justin Dyer: hype, dust, you know, you pick your word, kind of goes goes by the wayside. And typically that takes 12-ish or so months. Every every uh company is different, every IPO is different. Um, but it is, it's a great reminder. It's an important event we're we're witnessing today, most definitely. But there's a right way and a wrong way to play it. We talked about this barbell approach early in the private markets, discipline and patience in the public markets. What else is it worthwhile to underscore or highlight? with respect to the hundred-year family when it comes to events like this? If you can think of any, mean out just that, right? This is one day on a journey of a hundred years. Yes, it's meaningful. Yes, we're excited to have exposure in the right way as design that we, you know, that we've just talked about. Um,
12:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
12:50Justin Dyer: really. it's just a little bump in the road at the same point in time. You can't get overly excited. It's not ideally going to make or break anyone, um, so long as we're we're staying disciplined, focus on what you can control for the hundred year family.
13:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. Um I'd say I'd say three big just concluding points, and some of these we've already discussed. The first one is this is not ever the end all be-all. We talked about this before, before our call. This is one company, and it's a tremendously successful outcome. But at the end of the day, there are going to be other businesses that do very, very well. And there are other businesses that are probably right where anthropic was in 2021, valued at, you know, $480 million that are going to have trillion dollars. dollar outcomes. So when you think about investing, it's not backing the truck into any one opportunity. It's properly diversifying, like you, like you mentioned, and sort of to that point, diversifying across years and across time is so important. A team doesn't just participate in one draft and then call it, call it a day and fire their scouting department and just go on vacation. If you do that, you're not going to have an organization for that much longer. So when you think about the hundred-year family, it is about being disciplined. It's about drafting players in every single round and making sure that you have exposure to the ninth round Cy Young winner that inevitably will come out if you can properly identify them.
14:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
14:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): then the last piece, kind of sort of about just chasing hype and being disciplined. These things need to be thoughtfully orchestrated. It's not about just hitting the React button and getting in whenever everyone else is getting in. Rivian is a great example of this as well. Their first year, I think they were down 81%. And everyone, I remember, I remember this well. Uh This is one of the few where I was actually in the business for Rivian IPS. IPOing and everyone was saying this is gonna be the next next Tesla, it's gonna be a trillion dollar business, let's absolutely get after it. And it was down eighty percent on the year. So it's a lot more nuanced than than what meets the eye. And typically when everyone has access, it's not cool anymore. And you're not getting any form of advantage. So that advantage needs to be thoughtfully orchestrated in the private markets when values are substantially more attractive. And that takes work, effort, and discipline to actually execute properly.
15:28Justin Dyer: Yeah. Awesome. And I think it's a great, great place to wrap. I also want to remind listeners that yes, big day, uh, we're we're super happy. and thankful that we're we're a part of it. We actually don't know what the final kind of number impact will be because with IPOs, when you're going from private market investors to public market investing, generally there's a lockup and you actually can't sell your shares immediately. So there's uh some numbers and and events and time that just needs to pass with respect to us and our clients. and the actual impact. As it stands today, very positive. We will we will see how things unfold well into the future. But no, like Mina just said, it's um it's a great day, but it's not kind of the end-all be-all. You have to really approach things like this with patience and a statistical mindset that really is stacking the odds in your favor for the hundred-year family. That is certainly. how we approach investing on your behalf. And we're privileged to be serving you all. If you have any questions, definitely shoot us a text. Yes,
16:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): 626-862-0355.
16:37Justin Dyer: Always helpful to get uh topics to discuss on this podcast directly from you all. But until next time, own your wealth, make an impact, and always be a pro. Thanks for listening.