John McCabe argues Bitcoin adoption requires marketing incentives and cashback rather than ideological persuasion
Summary
John McCabe argues that Bitcoin adoption hinges on marketing strategies rather than technical improvements, proposing that merchants treat Bitcoin as a customer acquisition channel. He suggests targeting 'single-issue shoppers' and the 'Bitcoin curious' through real-time cashback incentives that allow fiat payments with Bitcoin rewards. McCabe contrasts this with traditional credit card rewards, which he dismisses as 'fiat rails with Bitcoin decoration.' He highlights Steak 'n Shake as a model merchant that retains Bitcoin on its balance sheet, creating a competitive advantage. The discussion also covers the 'Saturday Bitcoin Rally' pilot program and the elimination of chargeback risks as key benefits for merchants.
Key takeaways
- 1 Bitcoin is analyzed as a two-sided market similar to Airbnb or Uber, where both Bitcoiners and merchants must be incentivized to participate.
John McCabe · 4:52
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 0:39
Bitcoin as a Marketing Channel and Merchant Acquisition
John McCabe argues that Bitcoin should be viewed primarily as a marketing channel for new customer acquisition rather than just a payment method. He suggests that merchants can achieve significant benefits by targeting Bitcoiners, who act as 'single-issue shoppers' willing to travel or change behavior to support Bitcoin-friendly businesses.
- 0:39 – 6:00
Targeting the 'Bitcoin Curious' via Cashback Incentives
McCabe proposes a future where consumers earn Bitcoin cashback rewards by redirecting existing spending to Bitcoin-friendly merchants. He believes this approach is more effective than trying to 'orange pill' normies ideologically, instead targeting the 'Bitcoin curious' with economic incentives.
- 6:00 – 15:41
Barriers to Bitcoin Medium-of-Exchange Adoption
The speakers discuss friction points preventing widespread Bitcoin spending, including tax anxiety in the US and the small total addressable market of self-custodied Bitcoiners. McCabe notes that data often conflates ETF holders with actual Bitcoin users, making market size difficult to assess.
- 15:41 – 21:17
MasterCard Loyalty Frameworks and Card-Linked Offers
McCabe explains his background at MasterCard, describing card-linked offers (CLOs) where merchants pay for targeted discounts based on transaction history. He highlights that new customer acquisition is the most difficult and expensive part of merchant marketing budgets in the fiat system.
- 21:17 – 23:49
Steak 'n Shake Case Study and 'Single-Issue Shoppers'
McCabe cites Steak 'n Shake's Bitcoin acceptance as a successful marketing campaign that drove significant foot traffic from Bitcoiners willing to travel long distances. He uses this to illustrate the concept of 'single-issue shoppers' who prioritize supporting Bitcoin over convenience or price.
- 23:49 – 28:46
Real-Time Bitcoin Cashback and Fiat-to-Bitcoin Settlement
The discussion outlines a proposed solution where consumers pay in fiat but merchants receive Bitcoin, allowing users to maintain their stacks while earning real-time Bitcoin cashback via Lightning. This is presented as superior to delayed fiat statement credits.
- 28:46 – 31:51
Long-Tail Merchants and Lifetime Value
McCabe identifies long-tail online merchants (e.g., local wine stores) as key targets. He hypothesizes that redirecting existing category spend from US Bitcoiners could double their revenue, allowing them to offer high initial cashback (20-30%) to acquire customers, followed by lower 'evergreen' rewards.
- 31:51 – 32:11
Competitive Landscape: Fold and Credit Cards
The segment concludes with a question about the competitive landscape, specifically comparing McCabe's approach to existing Bitcoin rewards programs like Fold and traditional credit card rewards, setting up a discussion on differentiation.
- 32:11 – 34:41
Credit Card Rewards vs. Bitcoin-Friendly Merchants
John McCabe distinguishes between credit cards offering Bitcoin rewards (which he calls 'fiat rails with Bitcoin decoration') and merchants who actively seek Bitcoiners as customers. He argues that credit card rewards are limited and do not support the Bitcoin ecosystem's growth, whereas supporting Bitcoin-friendly merchants provides a competitive advantage to those businesses.
- 34:41 – 36:23
Steak 'n Shake as a Bitcoin Treasury Company
McCabe highlights Steak 'n Shake as a prime example of a merchant that not only accepts Bitcoin but retains it on its balance sheet, effectively becoming a 'Bitcoin treasury' company. He contrasts this with merchants who merely convert Bitcoin to fiat, emphasizing the importance of merchants holding Bitcoin to build a treasury position.
- 36:23 – 38:29
Saturday Bitcoin Rally Pilot Program
The speaker describes a pilot program on SaturdayBitcoin.com where they rally Bitcoiners to spend at a specific merchant each Saturday. The goal is to demonstrate new customer acquisition to merchants, using data from these rallies to convince other businesses to become Bitcoin-friendly.
- 38:29 – 42:30
Bitcoin Strategy as a 'Bolt-On' Competitive Advantage
McCabe compares the adoption of Bitcoin to the rise of e-commerce, arguing that a Bitcoin strategy should be a 'bolt-on' that does not disrupt a merchant's existing fiat strategy. He believes this approach allows merchants to attract Bitcoiners without significant operational changes, creating a win-win scenario.
- 42:30 – 47:13
Two-Sided Market Dynamics and Chicken-and-Egg Problem
The discussion addresses the 'chicken-and-egg' problem of two-sided markets. McCabe notes that while there are ~27,000 Bitcoin-accepting stores globally, the challenge is mobilizing demand. He suggests that the well-networked Bitcoin community helps seed the demand side, while open-source data like BTC Map helps seed the supply side.
- 47:13 – 1:17:04
Square's Bitcoin Onboarding and Merchant Awareness
McCabe discusses Square's onboarding of millions of merchants to accept Bitcoin. He distinguishes between merchants who are 'Bitcoin-friendly' (actively seeking Bitcoiners) and those who simply have the technical capability to accept Bitcoin without marketing to the community. He argues that the latter group offers less value for new customer acquisition.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| BitcoinBTC | crypto | mixed | Is the biggest barrier to Bitcoin medium exchange adoption just Bitcoin adoption itself? Eliminate the friction and add incentives so it becomes completely rational to use Bitcoin as payment. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
John McCabe worked at MasterCard for just over 10 years in merchant loyalty.
John McCabe ·2:35
How to verify: LinkedIn profile of John McCabe; SEC filings or press releases from MasterCard listing his employment history. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceJohn McCabe worked at Yahoo for nine years.
John McCabe ·2:51
How to verify: LinkedIn profile of John McCabe; SEC filings or press releases from Yahoo listing his employment history. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceSteak 'n Shake went live to accept Bitcoin about a year and a half prior to the interview (approx. mid-2025).
John McCabe ·21:37
How to verify: Press releases from Steak 'n Shake; news articles from 2026 confirming the Bitcoin payment integration date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Steak 'n Shake made changes to their menu and started doing beef tallow fries.
John McCabe ·22:32
How to verify: Steak 'n Shake menu archives; news articles from 2026-2026 regarding menu changes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Card-linked offers (CLOs) are distributed through banking relationships like Wells Fargo, Bank of America, and Chase.
John McCabe ·17:21
How to verify: Marketing materials or terms of service from MasterCard/Visa detailing their merchant offer distribution partners; bank reward program pages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
New customer acquisition accounts for approximately 2% of the overall marketing budget in card-linked offer programs.
John McCabe ·19:38
How to verify: Internal MasterCard documentation or industry reports on card-linked offer budget allocation (if publicly available); general marketing industry benchmarks for CAC vs. retention. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bitcoiners are willing to travel 20 miles or more to use Steak 'n Shake after Bitcoin acceptance.
John McCabe ·23:12
How to verify: Social media posts (Twitter/X) from users around the time of Steak 'n Shake's Bitcoin launch expressing intent to travel. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bitcoin cashback via Lightning can be received within one second of a qualifying spend.
John McCabe ·24:53
How to verify: Technical documentation of Lightning Network transaction speeds; case studies from providers offering instant Bitcoin cashback. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
High initial cashback offers (20-30%) are possible because merchants gain the lifetime value of the customer.
John McCabe ·30:55
How to verify: Financial models of customer lifetime value (CLV) in retail; merchant case studies showing ROI on high-discount acquisition offers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
There are approximately 21 million Bitcoin.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·27:15
How to verify: Bitcoin whitepaper; blockchain explorer data confirming the supply cap. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Credit card rewards denominated in Bitcoin are typically 1-2%, with Coinbase marketing up to 4% for customers with hundreds of thousands in custody.
John McCabe ·33:24
How to verify: Check Coinbase Card terms and conditions for reward rates and custody requirements; verify typical credit card cashback rates via financial news or card issuer disclosures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Steak 'n Shake initially converted Bitcoin to fiat but now retains Bitcoin on its balance sheet.
John McCabe ·34:41
How to verify: Review Steak 'n Shake's public statements, press releases, or financial filings regarding their Bitcoin treasury strategy. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThere are approximately 27,000 stores globally listed as accepting Bitcoin on McCabe's platform.
John McCabe ·42:55
How to verify: Visit SaturdayBitcoin.com or BTCMap.org and count the number of listed merchants. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Square has onboarded up to 4 million US merchants to accept Bitcoin.
John McCabe ·47:53
How to verify: Review Square/Block's official announcements or press releases regarding merchant onboarding numbers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bitcoin payments eliminate chargeback risk and fraud for merchants.
John McCabe ·53:29
How to verify: Consult Bitcoin documentation on transaction finality and compare with credit card chargeback policies from major card networks (Visa/Mastercard). For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Nassim Taleb discusses the concept of the 'intransigent minority' in his books.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·46:15
How to verify: Search Nassim Taleb's books (e.g., 'Antifragile', 'The Bed of Procrustes') for the term 'intransigent minority' or related concepts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The 'Saturday Bitcoin Rally' pilot program is scheduled for November 28th.
John McCabe ·37:03
How to verify: Check the SaturdayBitcoin.com website or social media announcements for the date of the first rally. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bitcoiners represent a small segment that could become a powerful political constituency if they reach 1-3% of US spend.
John McCabe ·46:35
How to verify: Calculate US consumer spending data to determine the percentage represented by Bitcoin transactions; review political lobbying disclosures for Bitcoin-related entities. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Credit card companies act as gatekeepers extracting financial energy from transactions.
John McCabe ·54:49
How to verify: Analyze credit card interchange fees and merchant discount rates compared to Bitcoin transaction fees. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Peony Lane Wine is a Bitcoin-friendly merchant and a candidate for the rally.
John McCabe ·45:04
How to verify: Visit Peony Lane Wine's website or social media to confirm Bitcoin acceptance and marketing. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bitcoin cashback can be received in real-time, whereas fiat systems cannot provide this specific real-time reward mechanism.
John McCabe ·1:06:41
How to verify: Compare settlement times of Bitcoin transactions (on-chain or lightning) with traditional credit card or bank settlement cycles (typically 1-3 business days) using financial industry standards or payment processor documentation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Traditional loyalty programs like Starbucks points and airline miles are inflationary and lose value over time due to dilution.
John McCabe ·1:03:56
How to verify: Review Starbucks Rewards terms and conditions regarding point expiration and devaluation policies, and analyze historical airline mileage inflation data from financial reports of major airlines. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bitcoin cashback rewards can be set at 5%, which is higher than equivalent credit card rewards.
John McCabe ·1:04:31
How to verify: Compare the proposed 5% Bitcoin cashback rate against average cashback rates for standard credit cards (typically 1-2%) using credit card comparison websites or Federal Reserve data on consumer credit. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The business benefits of accepting Bitcoin (customer acquisition, margin recapture) are independent of Bitcoin's price.
John McCabe ·1:07:45
How to verify: Analyze merchant financial statements from companies that adopted Bitcoin payments (e.g., MicroStrategy, Tesla, or smaller retailers) to isolate revenue growth from crypto price fluctuations, or review accounting standards for crypto asset recognition. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Saturday Bitcoin was launched approximately six weeks before the episode release date of 2026-11-20.
John McCabe ·1:13:31
How to verify: Check the 'About' page or archive history of SaturdayBitcoin.com to confirm the launch date relative to November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Steak 'n Shake's public financial filings to confirm Bitcoin holdings on their balance sheet.
- Check the current number of merchants listed on BTC Map versus Square's reported Bitcoin-accepting merchant count.
- Review US tax regulations regarding cryptocurrency transactions to assess the validity of 'tax anxiety' as a barrier.
- Compare typical credit card cashback rates (1-2%) with proposed Bitcoin cashback rates (5-30%) for accuracy.
- Investigate the operational model of SaturdayBitcoin.com to understand how merchant acquisition data is collected and reported.
- Assess the legal and accounting implications for merchants holding Bitcoin versus converting to fiat immediately.
- Look for independent studies on the effectiveness of card-linked offers (CLOs) in driving new customer acquisition.
- Check the 'Last Coin Standing' website for the specific calculators and tools mentioned to evaluate their methodology.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00John McCabe: Is the biggest barrier to Bitcoin medium exchange adoption just Bitcoin adoption itself? Eliminate the friction and add incentives so it becomes completely rational to use Bitcoin as payment. Part of our effort is to educate merchants on the opportunity and to think of Bitcoin not so much just as a payment channel, but more more as a marketing channel in a way. I think we can be very successful with new customer acquisition and achieve. significant uh benefits for the merchant there. I think for for that subset of Bitcoiners, those ones who s who went to Stake and Shake and Spent, um, you could almost think of them as single issue shoppers in a way. I love the single issue shoppers. I'm I'm more excited about making Bitcoin Bitcoin-friendly friendly businesses disproportionately successful. Imagine you wake up every day. with more SATS than you did the previous day, and all you've done is redirect your existing spend behavior
0:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in the
0:59John McCabe: same categories you already spend, but now redirected to Bitcoin-friendly merchants and who are pr who are participating in this program, giving Bitcoin cashback rewards. So that's the kind of future I'm working towards. The the vast majority of consumers of normies, you know, are we we're not gonna be successful orange pilling them. I think it's that Bitcoin Curious group. Hopefully this becomes the easiest way to orange pill someone, orange pill a normie going forward.
1:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): John
1:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): McCabe, excited to have you on here.
1:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We were talking about it.
1:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Today is not that day, but perhaps uh perhaps soon, maybe in a bull market, uh, which I think we are in.
2:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
2:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): wanna I want to get your thoughts in the on that probably a little bit later too. But you know, we're uh we're at we're at the bottom of the bowl is how I how I like to think of it. So once maybe once that bull market hits, uh I'll I'll I'll be flying people around, but it's it's not happening right now. So this will have to do.
2:15John McCabe: Sounds good. Yeah, I would agree. Um yeah, so my you know, Walker, nice to be with you here. Um my name is John McCabe. Um I'm uh a Bitcoiner, uh Bitcoin maximalist. Um being a bit been Bitcoiner since 2017. Um, my most recent background, I think, which you know may be interesting in the Bitcoin context, is um I worked at MasterCard for just over 10 years. And um I worked in merchant loyalty. And uh so it was interesting to be a Bitcoiner in the context of going to my Fiat mining job every day um on MasterCard stuff. Prior to that, I was at Yahoo actually for nine years as well. So I've been working out here in the San Francisco Bay Area. So have kind of the financial background and also the consumer internet background. Yeah, so I think working in merchant loyalty sort of opened open my eyes to a lot of opportunities um for potentially making Bitcoin success. successful as a medium of exchange. And that's my focus right now with a new website that I co-founded with a colleague called SaturdayBitcoin dot com.
3:24And at Saturday Bitcoin we're very much um connecting Bitcoiners initially, but hopefully ultimately the Bitcoin curious and normies with merchants who are Bitcoin friendly. So we're very much keen to grow the group of Bitcoiners who are willing to consider Bitcoin or who care about Bitcoin as medium of exchange, who care about Bitcoin payments, and care about supporting Bitcoin friendly merchants. And ultimately, um, and I'll get into it a little bit more, I I I I think what we have right now when we consider um Bitcoin in the medium of exchange context, we have big we have a sub segment of Bitcoiners. who I think um have an ideological motivation to help Bitcoin succeed and help Bitcoin succeed as payments and medium of exchange, but we don't really have an economic motivation. And in fact we have frictions in place that sort of um limit uh the interest in a lot of Bitcoiners in considering Bitcoin as medium of exchange. So the focus tends to be on store value and and many Bitcoiners even either outright dismiss Bitcoin as medium of exchange, or I've heard people say that, oh, it comes about in about 10 years' time or later. Even Safediam I think
4:36of it coming later. However, I would say that working at MasterCard in merchant loyalty has given me some, I think, unique perspectives on how we can make Bitcoin successful right now as Bitcoin medium of exchange. And one of the ways to one of the frameworks I think it's useful to think about this is to think of it as a two-sided market. Not unlike if you think of Air Airbnb where you have hosts and you have guests and Uber where you have drivers and you have um passengers. Bitcoin is very similar. It's a uh we we are we are the demand side if you will. We are Bitcoiners who hold Bitcoin um and we spend in the regular economy. Um and we have merchants on the other side who are interested in attracting customers and attracting uh potentially attracting Bitcoiners. And I think with that framework, um what I what I believe and what I what I see the opportunity is that um we can make both Bitcoiners and merchants successful.
5:39um to the point where Bitcoin actually becomes the apex predator um payment method and the preferred payment method um which sounds like a very ambitious goal but I can walk through some of the things um some of the ways that we can get there and some of the things that we are working on and will be working on at Saturday Bitcoin to help us get
5:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there.
6:00John McCabe: Just pause there and
6:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, I appreciate the the intro there. Maybe it's just kind of a starting point.
6:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): W
6:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I mean, what in your analysis, what do you think has been the the major friction for most Bitcoiners? Like I have some things in my mind that I know and I try to spend Bitcoin as much as I can. If I if I have the option in person, uh if I have the option online, I try to spend Bitcoin. I often will do it for for uh you know for privacy reasons as well. If I'm, you know, there are various uh VPM or uh VPN or uh eSIM services that will accept in Bitcoin and no account needed, and that's like a
6:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's
6:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): a great thing to be able to do. Uh but I'm curious in terms of kind of you know, that may be a bit of a niche thing that you know maybe people who
6:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
6:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): small handful of people that are more privacy conscious may engage in. But more broadly, I mean, is the biggest barrier to Bitcoin medium exchange adoption just Bitcoin adoption? itself? Or do you think even within the people who are already, you know, Bitcoiners who have already adopted Bitcoin, there's a deeper barrier there that's holding more people back from using it on a frequent basis?
7:04John McCabe: Yeah. No, I I think that's an excellent question, and it is a very foundational question. And I would say broadly speaking, there are uh two answers. There are two aspects. to the overall answer. The first is that word friction, as you mentioned. And I would say the friction is um you could characterize it in in two ways. The first is that there are in in most countries and including the US, um technically there are tax implications or tax consequences of spending Bitcoin. Even though a lot of people actually claim that, like, well, I I can do spend and replace, and I do do spend and replace, or some people call it r replace and spend, um, just overall there is an an anxiety around potential tax consequences, whatever the actual facts are. So some Bitcoiners they just don't want to go there because they don't want the hassle of having to report anything. Or even in in most cases, there's there's a lot of Bitcoiners who would consider spending and they don't care about uh the tax implications that like if they're if you're buying a cup of coffee or something they don't expect a knock on the door from the IRS. But uh but it still brings up a potential ang anxiety which is a is a friction. The other um I I think another aspect on the friction side is what you also mentioned is that there's uh a limited number of us who have Bitcoin and um that's one of
8:24the things I hope to solve for and I can touch on that. a little bit later.
8:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
8:30John McCabe: it's it's it's you could say it's a small segment of people who have Bitcoin. So the actual total addressable market of Bitcoiners is relatively small. It's actually hard to get data on that actually like actually the number of Bitcoiners I've done quite a bit of research on it and and there's there's a couple of challenges. One is that a lot of the data conflates people who own um Bitcoin in an ETF or Bitcoin held at an exchange versus self-custody. It's very hard to get data on the specifics there. Um
9:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because
9:01John McCabe: you you you'll get very high numbers for people who own Bitcoin, but technically it's in an ETF or it's even in a mutual fund or MSTR. So it's uh a uh so that that's one challenge. The other is that a lot of the data conflates uh Bitcoin. ownership with crypto ownership, unfortunately. So it's very hard to get uh specifics there as well. And I I I really hate to um sort of c to make the mistake of c conflating um anything to do with crypto with with Bitcoin. Um but the other side of the coin, like moving away from the frictions, uh the other aspect is that there is a lack of incentives to use Bitcoin.
9:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
9:37John McCabe: and it's also potentially inconvenient to use Bitcoin as well. Most of us we use, especially in the US, actually, a lot of other countries they use cash or debit card. Like debit card is surprisingly much more popular in Europe than credit card. Here in the US, I think credit card is is more popular and more typically used. And so it's a convenience. factor. You can use it anywhere. You don't have to ask the merchant can you use credit card? Like in 99.9% of cases you you can and that's the understood method. And there's also typically some benefits associated with using the credit card to the consumer where they get some rewards like one or two or even three percent cash back depending on the category and depending on the card that they have. So they're just naturally in the habit of like, oh, I use my credit card and I get some benefit for that, some reward. They don't track it very carefully necessarily, but they know there's a reward associated with the card. There's also the aspect that um some Bitcoiner or some some consumers recognize that they have what you would call consumer protection there. Um where they if they really have to do a chargeback technically they they they can and we can get into that on um some of the interesting dynamics there um in the
10:53Bitcoin context. Um but um so so yeah, I I think in order to overcome this and in order for Bitcoin to become the preferred payment by Bitcoiners, there's a few things that that we need. Um we need to reduce or mitigate or eliminate the friction that I mentioned. And and I have some pathways in order for us to get there. And also to add in incentives um so that it actually becomes preferred for the Bitcoiner where it's it's not only ideologic there's not only an ideological or mission-based motivation to spend with Bitcoiner with with Bitcoin as a Bitcoiner, there's also an economic motivation that is superior to the alternative and to use Bitcoin for payment. And then so yeah, I think um I think that's the goal. That's what we have to recognize is to is from first principles to eliminate the friction and add incentives. So it becomes completely rational to use um Bitcoin as payment.
11:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Blockstream Jade Plus delivers robust security with fully open. source hardware and software. Its unique genuine check feature ensures your device is authentic, giving you ultimate peace of mind. With versatile connectivity options, including Bluetooth, USB C, built in camera, and SD card, Jade Plus offers unparalleled Paralleled flexibility in managing your Bitcoin. Whether you prefer wireless convenience or air gapped security, Jade has you covered. Its innovative design features a durable metal case, a bright 1.9 inch color screen, and intuitive navigation buttons that make managing your Bitcoin straightforward and enjoyable. Jade Plus also supports secure air gapped transactions via QR code signing using the Jade Link storage device, keeping your Bitcoin safe without compromising convenience. Visit store.blockstream.com and use my coupon code WACKER for an exclusive 10% discount on your Blockstream Jade Plus. Protect your Bitcoin, sleep better, stack harder. Are you staring down a big tax bill this year? Maybe you sold a business, maybe you've got a required distribution coming out of your IRA. Maybe you sold some Bitcoin, heaven forbid.
13:17Or maybe it's all three. If you caught my conversation with Jesse Gilger, you already know the team at Verify Wealth. It includes former Unchained and Metaplanet team members who've spent years in Bitcoin custody and financial planning. They bring that Bitcoin experience to your whole financial plan, taxes, estate, custody, and taxes. how your Bitcoin fits alongside everything else you own. Year end tax moves can be some of the best bang for your buck when there's a strategy behind them. Verify Wealth can look at where the tax bill is coming from, what you hold, and which moves are still on the table before december thirty first. They are Bitcoin focused, not crypto, no altcoin pitches, led by a CFP professional. who understands why you hold Bitcoin and builds the plan with that at the center, not just bolted on at the end. A planning conversation in October or November beats a scramble with your accountant in April. Head to verifywealth.com slash Ash walker to book a call. Again, that's
14:23verifywealth.com slash walker. Quick disclosure, verify wealth paid for this placement. I am not a client of theirs, just a believer in what they are building. Nothing in this podcast should be taken as individual financial advice. I want to also maybe get into some of the what you think might help from a regulatory perspective. Uh not that most Bitcoiners are too interested in in that, but it's I I know from talking to enough Bitcoiners that the as you mentioned. like
14:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
14:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): they may not expect an IRS knock on their door, but they also don't want to give the IRS any reason to knock on their door. If they
15:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): want an
15:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): excuse to do it for some other reason, but they have the
15:03John McCabe: Sure
15:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
15:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): they can't find an inroad there, well they'll, you know, if they need to find a way, they'll try to find a way, and maybe this is it, because you didn't report
15:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): your
15:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): cost basis for the Bitcoin you spent on that cup of coffee. You
15:15John McCabe: you
15:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): evil law-breaking Bitcoiner. But I I want to talk a little bit about the incentives that you mentioned. Um if that's a good place to start, because I I assume perhaps one of them is around, you know, I know some and some uh folks have done some things like this or w do some things in their either online stores or in person, but you know, discounting things if you pay in Bitcoin, basically. Yeah. Uh is that the kind of thing you're talking about, or does it go more broadly? than
15:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that? It
15:41John McCabe: is. I mean, I would I would probably frame it slightly differently, but you are hitting the nail on the head. So my and actually what may be interesting is to give a little bit more context on the work that um I did at MasterCard and how kind of Fiat World works from an incentive standpoint and from a kind of a marketing channel standpoint. I then I then I think I think that's an interesting frame. framing to then consider the equivalent in the Bitcoin denominated world where I think it gets very interesting. So at at MasterCard, um one of the one of the typical frameworks that we use to help merchants become successful is we have um programs um
16:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
16:22John McCabe: what what you would call card-linked offers, card-linked offers or CLO programs. And what that means is that you all of us um have a fiat bank account and if you go into that account, you'll see um opportunities where they have merchant offers and where you s you get sometimes a material uh discount as you say, it's called a statement credit or cashback, where you might get twenty percent back if you shop at Macy's within the next 40 days, or you get uh $10 back if you spend $50 or more at X X Door. And they're typically marquee merchants that um have relationships with MasterCard. And obviously it's not just MasterCard, you know, Visa, Cardalytics, a lot of programs like this. Um, but the uh the i i idea is that uh you get um often a quite a material discount. And what happens is um those offers are part of a marketing campaign that. the merchant launches with a partner like mastercard who ultimately then um
17:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
17:21John McCabe: helps distribute those offers through the banking relationships like whether be it Wells Fargo Bank of America Chase that's where your offers show up and the interesting thing is there are they're typically targeted offers and they're based on your transaction history so for example you might shop at Bloomingdale's but you don't shop at May Macy's. So you shop in the category, but m but we would know that, oh, you're not a Macy's customer, but you're very active in the category. So then you're a very interesting target for Macy's, for example, because we we have that transaction history. It's actually um it it the the the actual um it's actually quite private, surprisingly, in that we don't know if you're male, female, uh what age you are, where you live, what your name is. but we know in this program that you have these um this spend profile. And that's how we do the targeting. We don't need to know anything else actually, you just know the spend profile. So in a in a way there is a lot of privacy there. The reason I
18:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mentioned that I'm not sure if I'm sorry to interrupt
18:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): but pr presumably you can it's very easy for you guys or f when you were there, it's very easy to extrapolate whether it's a man or a woman just by spending history. right?
18:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
18:26John McCabe: mean
18:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
18:27John McCabe: could you could guess, but the interesting thing is it it it often doesn't necessarily matter because if you're spending in a particular store in a particular category like if you're s if you're buying, say, um makeup on a regular basis, I mean ultimately that's that's the signal. Um w whether you happen to be a man or a woman, it may not
18:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): actually matter in a way it's it's
18:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you almost don't care.
18:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
18:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): uh
18:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): exactly Exactly, it's the point.
18:51John McCabe: Yeah, yeah. It's it's interesting because uh arguably it's it's where the you you you sort of walk the walk versus talk the talk. Like if that's your spend profile, like that's that's the biggest signal that that we have versus your your demographics or um
19:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): anything
19:04John McCabe: else. Um
19:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): sorry to
19:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): interrupt those
19:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): intr
19:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): that was uh
19:09John McCabe: it it is actually fascinating. I mean it's one of the reasons I stayed there for over ten years. It was very intellectually stimulating. I was rarely bored, actually. But what I'm getting to actually is that say a merchant has a million-dollar budget to spend uh with MasterCard. Um the typically the very first question that merchant asks that they're very interested in is new customers, new customer acquisition. That's that's a very uh important goal. Um and in fact the um interesting part is that um that's the most difficult goal. And so what happens is we end up spending about say 2% of the overall marketing budget on new customer acquisition. And the other the other um um part of the budget is typically spent on what we would call categories like um lapsed users who like consumers who used to shop with you but haven't recently. And that differs depending on the category. Like for a grocery store, someone who hasn't shopped with you in a couple of months might be a lapsed customer, whereas say a furniture store it might be a couple of years, kind of thing.
20:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
20:12John McCabe: it differs depending on the store and category, what what lapsed means. And the other one would be loyalty where you actually do shop with a merchant, but we want to get you to shop more frequently or have higher basket size and essentially shift more of your category spend to that merchant. And that's again where we can be very successful in spending that budget. And the reason is hopefully it makes sense when you think of it, is that getting new customers for a merchant is a very difficult goal because you're looking to achieve a significant change in behavior for that customer. They're already loyal to another store, they're already familiar, they already go there regularly, they like the brand, and there's any number of reasons why they go to that other store and they don't go to to to this new store we were trying to market. So um so that that's I'll I'll just kind of pause there on the on you know how sort of marketing works in card linked offer world where I worked at MasterCard. But what I will say is that in the Bitcoin denominated world I see tremendous opportunity and if you're just as an example
21:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
21:17John McCabe: the the opportunity I see is instead of having uh being relatively unsuccessful at new customer acquisition, I think we can be very successful with new customer acquisition and achieve significant uh benefits for the merchant there. And just as an example, you're probably, and many of the listeners would be familiar with uh stake and shake, uh where they went live to accept. Bitcoin about a year and a half ago. Um, and now it's it was an interesting kind of campaign in a way because it was quite a public campaign. Um, I think they had one or two people in their C suite who are Bitcoiners, or they they must have because they were so motivated. Um, but the results were tremendous. Um now, of course, it's uh we actually don't have I don't have the public data on exactly how many Bitcoin um how many people they. had um um spending Bitcoin um on on on at the rollout. But I think it was significant and the the um some of the senior management of the team when they've been up on stage talking at conferences and that conferences and that, they've echoed the uh the
22:17fact that uh they were tremendously successful due to Bitcoiner Bitcoin or participation and spending Bitcoin. There was were a few other changes they made, like they made changes to their menu. and they started doing beef tallow fries. And you know, so there's other variables at work. It's hard to pinpoint the success. I'm sure internally in Steak and Shake they they are much more aware of exactly what the success was. But but anyway, um I think what what's very interesting is, and I have some I have some slides in this, I don't have them at at hand right now, but if you go back and look at when Steak and Shake launched, and the people who posted on on Twitter, there were some crazy stories or people saying, um, oh my God, I've never been to Steak and Shake but before I'm going for the first time or the nearest Steak and Shake to me is 20 miles away. I'm jumping in the car now with the family. Like you will never see um stuff like that on any other category. So so one of the implications of this is that I think for for that subset of Bitcoiners, those ones who went to Stake and Shake and Spent,
23:20you could almost think of them as single issue shoppers in a way. Because what I'm thinking about is this scenario where we bring on board new merchants who raise their hand and say, okay, we're Bitcoin friendly. We want to attract. Bitcoiners, we recognize the value of the segment. And then t to to to close the loop on the point you made earlier about um rewards or discounts, um the way I think of it or the way we frame it is um Bitcoin cashback, cashback rewards. So Bitcoin cashback Back rewards might still think about the exact um terminology to use, but the idea would be that um and this is again better than the the the fiat model. So in in the fiat world, when you get the 20% back, say from Macy's when you shop there and make a qualifying spend for an offer that you receive from your bank,
24:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
24:17John McCabe: when you make that when you go to the register and you make that spend, or if you go to the website and make that that that that spend, you actually don't know then if it really worked. You're you have to wait about three days. um for the statement credit to come through. So it's it's a statement credit on your credit card account.
24:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
24:33John McCabe: so you're just wondering, hey, did that really happen? Whereas in the Bitcoin world, um what we're working on is is the solution where you make that you make that qualifying spend and within one second on Lightning you get Bitcoin back. So you say you spend a hundred, you spend the equivalent of a hundred dollars in in in in Bitcoin, you get whatever it is, ten ten dollars back in in real time essentially. So you have that that that confidence. And that's a kind of a magical moment as well.
25:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
25:00John McCabe: other in in the other um thing I would mention that is is critical, which we're we're working through, is the idea that um and this this touches on the idea that okay, it's a small segment now of Bitcoiners who are willing to spend Bitcoin, but imagine um
25:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): where
25:15John McCabe: you spend fiat,
25:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
25:17John McCabe: but the merchant receives Bitcoin. So you can sort of have your cake and eat it is a way to think of it. So you're not decreasing your stack. And in fact, the what the solutions that we're working on are such that
25:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as
25:30John McCabe: a as a Bitcoiner, imagine you wake up every day um with more sats than you did the the previous day, and all you've done is redirect your existing spend behavior in the same categories you already spend, but now redirect it to Bitcoin-friendly merchants who are who are participating in this program, giving Bitcoin cashback rewards. So that's the kind of future I'm working towards. And I think it's a very bright fruit future for Bitcoin and Uh Bitcoin Bitcoin as is a medium of exchange.
26:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): A couple of points quick. I love the single issue shoppers. And it's funny that you said that because right as you were about to say that, I was just thinking in my head, I was thinking about the last election and how Bitcoin and let's be honest, the broader crypto ecosystem. I mean single issue voters, right? And right as that word popped into my head, you were like single issue shoppers. So clearly you know you've thought from that angle. Uh you thought you were thinking from that angle a long time before I was, but that's I think that is such an important thing. This is a very interesting like you were talking about demographics earlier, like looking at Bitcoiners as a demographic, even though by traditional demographic markers they may be widely varied. But being able and you probably have a there's probably a more technical term for this from the uh the from your world that that you know of, but however you want to bucket Bitcoiners out, they're a very weird and kind of remarkable sort of group, right? Because they will do things that aren't necessarily in in their uh economic or time or any any like best interest per se, simply to support a business because that business is supporting Bitcoin.
27:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like
27:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I
27:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
27:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I'm struggling to think of any other type of group that would do something like this. Like you've literally got Bitcoiners who are saying, like, screw the tax implications, I'll spend and replace, and hope the IRS doesn't come knocking. Uh they're saying, you know what? Uh I know that there's only 21 million, but I'm still gonna spend this incredibly scarce thing, even though you know Gresham's law may dictate otherwise. So I'm gonna go against that as well. Uh I'm gonna go drive and go out of my way to a place I've never been before and take a chance in this new place because simply because they said we accept Bitcoin. That's a pretty remarkable, remarkable thing.
27:46John McCabe: It absolutely is. And and you you you'll see actually on our um on our website, um Saturdaybitcoin.com, there's a library of strategy content there. And one of the pieces goes into who are the Bitcoiners and why they're so so valuable. So you have to yeah, put part of our effort is to educate merchants on the opportunity. Um to think of Bitcoin uh not so much just as a payments channel, but mar more as a marketing channel in a way. And I think this is also an an interesting framing that I'm really focusing a lot on. And it's one of the things that we rarely hear Here in the Bitcoin space on the topic of medium of exchange. It's talk we just talk about it like a payments channel. But it's really, I in my mind, it's much better thought of as a marketing channel for merchants, where we can make merchants significantly successful. Now, the other thing I will go into, and I I go into this in a lot of the research and strategy pieces that we have on the site to help educate merchants is that it the the the the sort of um version of the bitcoin strategy for merchants is a little different depending on the merchant category and the merchant characteristics and I'll just give you an e example is that I would say one of our one of our key targets right now where we can hopefully drive more near
29:06term success is a merchant with an online channel in in the US so um and what we what you would call a long tail merchant. And just as an example, like one of the ones I use because I'm into wine as as a hobby. And so there's so a local wine store is a pretty good example of this where if if they sell online, if they have an online channel, if they have a website and they ship wine,
29:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
29:32John McCabe: the reason is that say this wine store does,
29:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
29:35John McCabe: making these numbers up, but say they do two to three million dollars per year. in in business. It's not like wine.com or anything like that. It's a, you know, it's it's a long tail wine store. Um, but the opportunity is to mobilize the audience of US Bitcoiners. And I don't know how many we can get. I want to get as many as possible, but we can target our spend, uh our category spend for those of us who are into wine at that one store. And we could even potentially transform their business overnight. We could turn that two to three million dollars into five or six million dollars for that year if we just redirect our existing category spend. It's also interesting if stores if stores like that have relatively high margin businesses, because then they can afford to give a higher reward, a higher uh Bitcoin cashback reward. Another thing I will note is that, and this is a lur this is a key learning from the MasterCard side, is that the new customer acquisition offers
30:35or discounts as you as you phrase it, cashback can be, can be very material, like uh depending on the category. I mean they can be they can be very high. The surprisingly high offers could be 20% twenty percent back, 30% thirty percent back, because what you're gaining is not just the that that sale, but you're gaining um the potential lifetime value of that of that customer. Now only a certain percentage of those customers are going to um are going to come back and do repeat spend. But my hypothesis is that Bitcoiners, when we I I identify the Bitcoin Bitcoin-friendly friendly merchant, um our hope and my hypothesis is that we will redirect our spend to those merchants over time, especially when they remain Bitcoin friendly and they have what we what I would term an evergreen offer. So which would be after that, that first spend, the idea would be that they would get a lower offer. It could just be 5%. But the idea then is that it's still always better than credit card.
31:36So it's always, it starts to become economically rational. then to focus your spend at the uh Bitcoin-friendly merchant.
31:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): You know, Bitcoin rewards, credit cards. There's been obviously a couple of uh large launches. I I have one that's a MasterCard, right? Um and you know, there's uh Fold has been doing uh Bitcoin rewards. in various ways for a while. Um what what's what's your perspective on that? And is that something that you know Bitcoin as an MOE sort of competes with? Because people, you know, Bitcoiners especially say, oh, okay, well, you know, sure, getting some SATS back or bits back if you're a uh if you're a bit person versus a sat person sounds great. But you know, why do that when I can still just spend on credit and still get some SATS back? Sure, maybe it's not as much, maybe it's only 1% or 2% or 3% or whatever, depending on the category. Do you view that as something that's a hindrance to Bitcoin medium of exchange adoption broadly? Or is that is that, you know, again, just sort of like a is that a different animal we're talking about there?
32:45John McCabe: Yeah, it's a very interesting question and a um a very uh it's a very good point. There's a couple of couple of thoughts I I have there. Um the th the first is that all of those credit cards, whether it's the Coinbase card or the Gemini card or the full card or that, um I I think of them um as they're they're all still completely on fiat rails. And the term I use and I hope it's not too too much of a derogatory term, but um I think of it as fiat. rails with Bitcoin decoration in a way. That they have the Bitcoin reward. Like the your reward is denominated in in in Bitcoin. But yeah, the the the couple of limitations there is that the reward um is likely to be relatively low. Like you say typic the typical one or two percent. I know that there's like Coinbase technically will market some high reward like four 4% percent or something, but you have to literally have custody of a few hundred thousand dollars there. It's not a very um legitimate uh c comparison. Um but so so that's one thing is it's it's more limited reward. But the other more important thing is that um a couple of things actually the first is that um when you're when you use that card at a at a merchant, of course you can use it anywhere because it's a MasterCard or Visa, that merchant um
34:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
34:04John McCabe: not Bitcoin friendly. They're just a regular merchant and they don't care about Bitcoin. They don't know about Bitcoin and they don't know you're getting Bitcoin rewards. They don't know that you care about Bitcoin. They don't know you are a Bitcoiner. And what I'm much more interested in is to support Bitcoin-friendly merchants who raise their hand and say, Yes, I'm interested in attracting Bitcoiners. And many of those merchants will also ultimately obviously they'll be receiving Bitcoin as payment. And I want to, my goal is to maximize that as much as possible so that it starts out as maybe 1% of their business, but then gets a 2%, 3%. And then it potentially we have We a lot of those merchants hopefully keeping Bitcoin on their balance sheet and taking it to the next level. And this is what stake Stakenshake insurance. did. I mean, i initially it I I believe in the first day they were converting Bitcoin to to to fiat, but now they not only are they retaining that Bitcoin on their balance sheet, they're actually they've become a kind of a Bitcoin uh I I I don't know what the right term is. I mean they're not a Bitcoin treasury company per se, but they're they're what
35:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they're a Bitcoin
35:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): treasury. Yeah. Yeah.
35:10John McCabe: They're a company with a Bitcoin treasury and and not only are they retaining it, but they're they're they're looking at their other assets and converting them into Bitcoin, looking at their other cash assets that would normally be in cash. So um so I'm very much more excited by that. I'm I'm more excited about making Bitcoin friendly businesses disproportionately successful. And this is another term that we don't hear on the Bitcoin space much as it relates to medium exchange, and it's one that I use all the time is merchant competitive. advantage through Bitcoin. That's absolutely um half of the focus of our of what we do. I mentioned it's a two-sided market earlier where we want to attract as many Bitcoiners as possible and the Bitcoin curious and ultimately normies. But the other part is that um we want to make the Bitcoin-friendly friendly merchants um very successful. We want more sort of mini stake and shakes, if you will. Um so uh and like I said, I I think one of the powerful dynamics there is how successful we can be with new customer acquisition, um, which which businesses love. And that that wine store example I mentioned earlier, if we if we do just as an example, this sort of long tail business with a reasonably high margin, um, with an online
36:23channel, um and that's our that's our focus right now. And in fact we we are running a a new program on this site where we have a rally every Saturday like our our website saturdaybitcoin dot com the interesting um sort of uh special event we have there our our intention is every Saturday we pick a specific merchant a single merchant and we try to rally as many Bitcoiners to spend at that at that merchant and so every week it's a new a new merchant. So we just hope it'd be fun. And it's a it's a simple, lightweight way to make one of those merchants successful. And we'll get the results back and from the merchant at the end of the of of the day every Saturday to see how they did and how many new sales that we got for them and so forth. So that's a way we're it's a pilot that we're we're starting. um Not this coming Saturday but the following Saturday Saturday um November twenty 28th, eighth I I believe.
37:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do
37:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you intend to then use that data sort of as
37:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean
37:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): as a basically a you know a case study to bring to other businesses
37:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
37:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): say, look, here you know, we have a large group
37:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
37:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): motivated individuals who want to spend their Bitcoin. They will come and give you
37:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): business.
37:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It's it's like, you know, you know, flip the switch on and and and do well.
37:37John McCabe: Absolutely. I mean I
37:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
37:38John McCabe: think
37:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's a good thing.
37:39John McCabe: the opportunity here is to make it a win win win for for the merchant, for Bitcoiners and for us to grow this grow this uh business. Um
37:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): where
37:49John McCabe: birth bitcoin then become like one w uh another way to think about this is that um there's a parallel of thinking about this uh compared to say the launch of e e e-commerce commerce in in the the United United States. States. Um if If you think you back think back in the year 1999, only point six percent of all commerce in the United States was from uh online um website. Um but soon after, like um in very very quickly, most merchants realized, oh, we need a um we need an e-commerce strategy, um, we need a website, like what are best practices here? And now, of course, it's totally normalized. and every business has a website and sells online if if it can and if it makes sense to do so. So it's become table stakes. And I think a really interesting opportunity is for us to normalize the idea of merchants having a Bitcoin strategy, uh a Bitcoin uh competitive advantage strategy, and um
38:49so that they accept. Bitcoin. And what we're trying to do is to is to create that strategy as a kind of a bolt-on strategy. And another interesting way to think about the Bitcoin strategy is that most of the time in business when you pick a particular strategy, you actually close off other strategic opportunities. Like you it's a forcing factor. Um, Like say you you're you're a product leadership, it means that you're not going to have low, low prices. Or if you have a customer intimacy um strategy, it means you're you're gonna have higher prices, or it's not as gonna be as scalable. I mean, there's all these, it's essentially a series of of trade-offs when you pick a strategy. What's nice about the Bitcoin strategy for merchants, it's more of a bolt-on strategy. It's one where it does not disrupt uh the the broader strategies that the merchant has in in fiat world. If they raise their hand and say, hey, we want to become Bitcoin friendly, which means we want to welcome Bitcoiners and uh we will have some Bitcoin reward Bitcoin specific rewards for those Bitcoiners, um, they can be very successful and they don't have to really do much. They they they don't have to sit around a table and for hours and figure anything out. Like like basically we can just come in and say, Okay, you're accepting Bitcoin now and our job then is to drive the um that uh demand, drive the Bitcoiners to their, to their business. They
40:09don't even have to do a press release or tell anyone about it necessarily. Now it always helps if they do what Stake and Shake did and they go more more more vocal. It can only help. But it's not not necessary because I think um uh because what we're we're trying to do is to is to rally the Bitcoiners on their behalf. Um if that makes sense.
40:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No,
40:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it it makes perfect sense. And I'm curious too, I mean so with with what you guys are doing, you're uh you're offering this as basically a a service, but also let's say a community organizing type of endeavor. Is that a correct assessment?
40:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Aaron Powell
40:46John McCabe: I would say um we're we're definitely not uh I would definitely not never characterize yourselves as anything close to a social network, if you will. Like in fact, we we have we've already met a few times with uh Mateo at um Club Orange, and uh you know we're we're looking for synergistic ways um because our our focus is very much on connecting consumers with merchants. So it's that merchant merchant-to-consumer to consumer connection that we're very focused on, very interested in. Whereas I think say Club Orange is more uh peer-to-peer sort of connections. So um so community is not a word I necessarily use, but um but uh yeah, I I think our focus right now is um more of an online focus, but you'll see from our website we absolutely um show every single um business globally that uh we know e accepts Bitcoin. Um so we do have it's it is useful from a local standpoint. Um but we're we're putting most of
41:49our effort right now is in online in in the US because for any two sided market you kind of have to start somewhere. And um the US is the is the best market in a way because it's the biggest group of Bitcoiners. And by um by featuring some online merchants who are Bitcoin friendly, we feel that's that's the best way to to get traction and uh grow.
42:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
42:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): and you you know you mentioned this kind of the the crux of the two-sided market, which is the chicken and the egg situation, right? Because obviously, okay, if you want merchants to accept Bitcoin, well you need to have Bitcoiners willing to spend Bitcoin, but if you want to have Bitcoiners willing to spend Bitcoin, you need to make sure there's enough merchants that actually accept Bitcoin
42:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that they
42:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): have ways to spend it. And I mean so how long do you think it takes to get to get past it? Because obviously there's you know both sides need to be need to be worked on, right? But how do you how do you actually get from where we are now to a place where you have a much larger percentage of even not even saying new Bitcoiners, but just the existing Bitcoin uh ecosystem. wanting to spend on a large enough amount of merchants that can actually accept
42:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
42:55John McCabe: Yeah. Well um right now um we have about twenty seven thousand stores listed on our website that uh take take Bitcoin. That's that's globally. Um just in the US it's about yeah because we we do leverage uh open source data as well like um BTC map um and and so forth. The one thing I'll say though is that uh we definitely encourage um merchants to come to the site and uh claim their their business because right now um we're representing the all of the merchants that uh we know take take big Bitcoin for payment. But if the merchant comes and claims their their business, they can do a few other things. Uh they're they're noted as a verified merchant then, and then uh they can add uh products that they're they're featuring on their site. and they can add a potential reward, um, cash uh Bitcoin cash back um for paying in in Bitcoin. So that's definitely something that we encourage. But yeah, the the interesting thing with the Bitcoiner with this space is it is a two sided market and the idea of chicken
43:55and egg is always a challenge. I would say that um we have it a little bit easier than most chicken and egg businesses because um the Bitcoin community is relatively well networked. Like we're all on X dot dot dot com. We see what's going on, we join spaces, we listen to podcasts. So I'm hoping the word gets out um so we can get more Bitcoiners who who join um Saturday Bitcoin and then are willing to um um support Bitcoin Bitcoin-friendly friendly merchants. And then on the other side of the coin, like I said, we um because Bitcoin uh BTC Map and other open source um information is out there, we've managed to accumulate um quite a good supply side of helping users uh find and discover Bitcoin-friendly businesses. So in some ways we've sort of um seeded um both sides of the market like we're not starting from from scratch. The other interesting a couple of other points though is is the rally I mentioned earlier. Like we you can go to our website and you can be on the wait list for our first rally. And we only need that need even a handful of people for it for it for it to be successful. So our our first mate merchant it looks like it's going to be Peony Lane
45:04wine who I know some of you may know of them are in the Bitcoin
45:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): space. Yeah
45:08John McCabe: yeah yeah exactly I I've bought some wine from Ben before um so
45:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): listen to this we'll
45:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): spend some Bitcoin at Peony
45:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Lane Lanewine
45:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): dot com.
45:16John McCabe: Exact Well actually, you know, what I'd prefer is if you go to our rally and spend. And the reason is that to you to the point you made earlier, is that if we can demonstrate uh so this is a a rally to spend at Peony Wayne Lane on just a single day, um Saturday the twenty eighth, and you can see it on our site and you can just sign up and you'll get an email reminder. And uh but when we spend on that day, then we start to show the power of Bitcoiners that we can mobilize and we're willing to do the thing that you mentioned. Like we're supporting a Bitcoin-friendly merchant. We are part of a group. We're part of we're we're a force to be reckoned with ultimately. Like the more Bitcoiners step up and are willing to support Bitcoin-friendly merchants, then it becomes an even more powerful case study to orange pill the next merchant and the next merchant and the next merchant. And when you touched on earlier about um you mentioned the term political, um there's another interesting thing to think about is
46:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
46:15John McCabe: I think uh Nassim Taleb covers it in his books this idea of the intransigent Transigent minority. So right now, uh Bitcoin Bitcoiners are maybe a small enough segment that people don't care about us very much or they don't pay attention to us very much. But once we become that sort of one percent of of US spend or two percent or three percent or whatever the number gets to, um then we become a very powerful political political constituency that um I think we'll just see a sus s a societal sea change towards what we want to see is more Bitcoin normalized. as as money. So I think this is one of the new it's it's like a new front on the war, if you will. I mean, there there's a lot of military m metaphors I often think about, but um Bitcoin as a medium of exchange is like opening up a new new front um on a war. And um and I think um yeah I I think it can be very useful and uh powerful. And and an another thing you touched on earlier is and maybe we can talk about that, is the um is you mentioned you talked about the Square merchant and how Square has um onboarded a lot. And I think it it it it is a very positive development and it's very e exciting. Um I think there's also limitations there as well. Um so the first is
47:33that um we only I I think um Jack had mentioned that they've they're essentially onboarding, have onboarded or are in the process of finalizing onboarding all of the U.S. square merchants. Maybe it's even beyond US as well. And I think the number is as high as four million potentially. Um of course, most of them are more small, small businesses than that. Um I think right now, though, or over the last year when they have been onboarding merchants, there was an option for them to also add themselves to be to the BTC map. to be discovered. And I think that there's only a limited number of those. I think in our database, maybe 8,500 or so we have of those businesses. I think what's worth noting is that I I would not characterize those businesses as Bitcoin friendly though. I mean it's really something most of them are not even aware that they can technically
48:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
48:25John McCabe: take Bitcoin for for payments. payment. Um so um I think it's an opportunity. It's an opportunity to um to more easily orange pill those businesses because at least it saves them a certain step. Like right now, if you talk to a regular business in your area and you want to orange pill them and you want them to accept Bitcoin, then that business has to typically jump through a few hoops in order to to take Bitcoin. So at least with Square Merchants, that's already taken care of. So I do think there's there's lower friction there essentially to on on on boarding them. But I do um as as a Bitcoiner who wants to see Bitcoin succeed, um I am I am more interested in the businesses that more that raise their hand and say, Yes, I'm this is this is very interesting. Tell me more. I want to attract Bitcoiners, I want to uh accept Bitcoin, I may even want to build a Bitcoin position, I want to give Bitcoiners some um cash Bitcoin cashback reward to incentivize them to come here. So I I do think there's a distinction and a difference, but it's it's definitely a very positive development and it helps us
49:28get there faster.
49:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
49:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think just to hit on the square piece a bit of it more, one of the interesting things about that is if I'm not mistaken, like they they initially were it was a an opt-in, right? And then they moved to a limited pilot of uh opt-out if you want to opt out. Like it'll be turned on by default. So you don't have to do anything. People can come and they can pay with
49:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
49:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): with Bitcoin.
49:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
49:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you can have it you know just keep receiving in fiat, I believe, or you can, you know, have it be received in Bitcoin too, which I that that I find really interesting. Um and then now I think their their idea is as you said, was to,
50:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and I
50:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): think this was just a couple of of weeks ago that they announced this, was that they'd basically turned that on as uh it's opt-in by default, opt-out if you want it, because it's again, it's no it's not forcing them to accept Bitcoin.
50:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
50:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it's saying, Hey, you know, you're people are going to be able to pay in Bitcoin if they want to. You'll keep receiving in dollars, you
50:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
50:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you're none the wiser, basically. But people have the option, they have more. spending uh spend side, customer side optionality. I'm curious, you know, plain, because I agree with a lot of what you said there, um, in terms of wanting to support businesses that are perhaps more actively saying, Hey, I'm Penny Lane Wine is a great example. Ben's very much like my customers are Bitcoiners. I'm a Bitcoiner, I love Bitcoiners, I want to accept Bitcoin. Yeah, I'll accept your fiat too. But like I am a Bitcoiner, this is a Bitcoin business, this is come drink my Bitcoin wine. Uh and you should go do that. It's it's fantastic wine. Shout out to Ben. And he's a great guy, too. And he had to deal with a bunch of bears this year. Not even Bitcoin bears, just literal bears. Um, so you know, uh, go give him some support. But maybe playing devil's advocate here,
51:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
51:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): think it's I can make the argument that actually I see a huge benefit in Bitcoin being used uh without people being any. the wiser. As Bitcoin or other Bitcoin layers, like a lot of the stuff like what Spark is doing, that that is just something that becomes becomes part of the fabric, becomes part of the rails upon which money rides. Regardless of whether the you know money riding it is is uh you know a fiat instrument or a Bitcoin instrument, it's using these superior Bitcoin rails or Bitcoin. you know,
51:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
51:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): secondary or tertiary layer rails
51:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as
51:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): the mechanism by which value is transferred, regardless of how that value is denominated. And then giving the optionality to the both the customer side and the merchant side to say, you know, ex pay with what you want, accept what you want. Like you know, and not discounting your your points here, but I do think there is some some benefit to that. And I'm curious where you see
52:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
52:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): almost sounds like you're saying, not trying to put words in your mouth, so please correct me, that that maybe uh doesn't move the needle as far as, quote, Bitcoin adoption as much as the more active pursuit of we accept Bitcoin. Am I characterizing your argument fairly?
52:21John McCabe: Yeah, I I think I I I think everything you said was correct. Um I think um there's a there's a few points to un unpack there maybe. Uh the first is like yes, a a business like Square who doesn't even pay attention to how they're receiving payment and they just retroactively maybe realize later, oh, like one percent of our um payments were in Bitcoin. That's interesting. Tell to me more. Or it's it's been sitting there in our balance sheet, like what what's happened to the value of that? Oh, it's gone up in value. or down in value. I think certainly just um taking payment with with Bitcoin is is is a positive thing generally. The the next the the next thing to think about is um
53:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
53:10John McCabe: the payments made in Bitcoin um because it's essentially like cash finality it's it's um it's a bearer instrument. And what's interesting about that from the merchant standpoint, and of course it varies depending on the merchant category, is that um you essentially the the merchant essentially eliminates uh chargeback risk or uh credit card fraud from that um uh from those uh payments. And and actually that can be very interesting for business, um, for certain businesses in certain categories who have very high. fraud. And it e there's even the idea the concept of what's called friendly friendly fraud, where somebody makes a purchase and then they know knowingly do a a charge back, even though they know very well that uh, you know so so it's um now now on the other side of the coin I I recognize and acknowledge there are times when um the from the consumer standpoint that you want those consumer um protections. If you're dealing with what you think is a dodgy merchant you've never dealt with before, you could argue that hey, it's good to have some some consumer consumer protection. But on the other side of the spectrum, I mean many of us, I can think in my own um uh from my own uh experience, like there's a grocery store near me that I I'm pretty confident is relatively low margins. I've been going there for for years, and from a convenience standpoint, I tend to use credit card just like everyone else does. And I will never do a chargeback with that store. Um,
54:29because if I if I buy something like milk and it's gone off or something, I can bring it back and they'll just give me another bottle. I don't need to rely on consumer protection for that. But I'm essentially forcing them to pay for that protection that I'll never use. Like it's it's a kind of a deadweight loss. Like it's a gatekeeper who's extracting financial um economic energy from the transaction that isn't really providing any benefit. And I think um one of the many things I really like about Bitcoin as a medium of exchange is that it helps us bring more of a more of a peer-to-peer connection between we at we consumers and and and the merchant, like how how it used to be a hundred years ago or so. Um whereas credit card companies have essentially in in inserted themselves as a kind of a gatekeeper um in the middle of that transaction, arguably providing um limited, limited value. Um But um the the the other thing on the merchants on the merchant standpoint as it relates to Square though, um, and this is this is sort of echoing the point I made earlier, is that um if the merchant is a square merchant and we know they just happen to be capable of accepting Bitcoin, I do think there's a distinction.
55:39because they're not really going to get new customer acquisition from that. Because we won't even know that they that they take Bitcoin. Like maybe we'll get we'll walk into the store and we'll see that they're using a square terminal. And I'm sure some of us will will make the effort to pay in Bitcoin and maybe even start up a conversation with the merchant. But but I think it's it's a more powerful framing of the relationship if we kind of normalize the idea of a merchant sort of um consciously having a Bitcoin strategy, taking a Bitcoin strategy, potentially giving some Bitcoin cash back, really welcoming Bitcoiners sort of explicitly as opposed to passively or implicitly. Because I would rather redirect my span to those stores and I'd like other Bitcoiners to do likewise. Because then we can we can get the mentality that, like, hey, uh, Bitcoiners are this very powerful segment out there, and they are looking for the right merchants. Um, they are looking for Bitcoin-friendly merchants, so we should become
56:43Bitcoin-friendly. I think that's the um that's the idea that I would will I'd like to see normalize more. And I think that's how we become successful. how we make Bitcoin successful and grow by making merchants realize that Bitcoiners are a valuable segment that they need to reach out to. One other final point I mentioned that touch it mentioned that touches on an earlier point you may you made about the chicken and egg and making sure that there's sufficient scale on both sides of the market to be successful. And it's it's another benefit of the on on the Bitcoin side is that for many categories, we only need one or two merchants, especially like I mentioned on on the online side, we only need one or two merchants to make it actionable, like one or two merchants per category to make it actionable for uh for users in the US market and to to redirect most or potentially even all of that category spend to those Bitcoin-friendly merchants. Like the wine store I mentioned. I mean, if if you if the as long as the wines are reasonably
57:51priced competitive and they have a good selection, I mean, as a wine lover, I could I could consider redirecting all of my wine spend span to to to that store. And if we had two or three wine stores, it wouldn't necessarily
58:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be.
58:03John McCabe: mean that much extra to me. As long as I have a one one good one, that's that's fine. Now in other categories like um say clothing, it that we we need a lot more merchants because you have formal wear, sportswear, casual wear for kids, whatever it is. There there's a lot uh you you most of us typically don't buy our clothes from one store. So for certain categories you need more of a selection.
58:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
58:26John McCabe: there are but it I'm just trying to get across this point that when we look at credit card, how credit cards work and how we typically spend with our credit card, we can spend anywhere and we can spend in any store. And I would just make the comment that we do not have to replicate that on the on the Bitcoin side in order to be successful. Just that limited coverage starts to be extremely meaningful. And we can make a real real dent in overall shopping behavior in that by just having one or two merchants in in most categories, it starts to make a big impact.
59:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Let
59:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): me ask you too, zooming out a little bit, what's kind of your more longer term game theory? Because I I hear everything you're saying. I think it's it's uh I agree with uh basically everything you've said here, and I think it's a fantastic initiative and people should go. check out SaturdayBitcoin.com. Uh as we zoom out a little bit, like the way we're talking about it right now, it's kind of like getting things not off the ground, because let's say, you know, there are a good number of merchants, you
59:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
59:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you listed uh I forget what the exact number was worldwide, but it was maybe twenty-seven thousand that you guys
59:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): have covered so far. Which
59:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): is yeah. Yeah, which is which is fantastic. Uh and talking about getting these various, you know, getting sort of uh c categorical coverage so that people wanting to spend Bitcoin have a means to do that across various aspects of their life where they need uh you know, they need goods or services, they can spend Bitcoin and not have to feel like they're sacrificing for quality or availability. Longer term,
59:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
59:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): terms of really uh, you know, right now it seems that we're talking kind of about Bitcoiners who are or people that are already Bitcoin. Bitcoiners
1:00:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
1:00:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): who already want to spend Bitcoin, or maybe are Bitcoiners but haven't had a good haven't had you know the opportunity to spend Bitcoin, don't know about all the options that are available to them to spend Bitcoin.
1:00:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): How
1:00:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): do you take this then to more broadly increasing Bitcoin adoption? How how do you how do
1:00:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
1:00:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): incentivize people that are not yet Bitcoiners, aren't down the rabbit hole?
1:00:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Is
1:00:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): does it come down to uh, you know, hey, uh cost of everything is is too damn high. Uh so hey, if you spend with Bitcoin at these merchants, then you can, you know, buy Bitcoin and then spend it and you're gonna get, you know, you're gonna end up paying less than if you would have spent on a credit card. Like is is that the how you envision it or is there another aspect to it as well?
1:00:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No,
1:00:44John McCabe: I I I think it's a very good question. And um I can definitely share a few thoughts I have there. It's um
1:00:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:00:53John McCabe: would say personally, and all of us have a different personal experience here, but um I've managed to orange pill a number of my close friends. Some of them to go completely into Bitcoin, um, like even their big even their full retirement, everything into Bitcoin. Um others, I have a few friends who are in that category where they manage to get to one Bitcoin kind of thing. There's at least two or three people sort of in that area and they they feel that that's a kind of a milestone that they hit and they're very they're happy about it, but that that's it. And I guess I would call those people the Bitcoin curious. Like like they would not identify themselves as Bitcoiners. They don't buy into the the mission-driven And ethos and that necessarily, but they would read, they'd listen to some podcasts and they're they're familiar. It's one of those things in a way that once you do get a bit a little bit of Bitcoin, you learn a little bit more about it, and then you get a little bit more and you learn a little bit more about it. So it's an iterative process. And we all started somewhere. I mean, I I would be embarrassed to discuss how I started because most of us we start uh looking at like a few years ago, you'd look at the space as like, oh, this is the crypto space, and Bitcoin is one of the cryptos, and let's learn about all the crypto. cryptos, whatever. And like very few of us sort of um spontaneously start as Bitcoin maximalists. It's it's a journey. We have to we have to get there. And I think um so there is this
1:02:13segment that I would I would um characterize as Bitcoin curious, um, who are not Bitcoiners, certainly not Bitcoin maximalists. And I think um that's a category of people, especially if they don't even have to have Bitcoin. to begin with, like I touched on earlier, the idea of a wallet where you have um you have a fiat wallet. You can think of something like Strike or or River, but you can have it set up in a way um where when you're spending through this framework that we we've we're still working on and we haven't built it out fully yet. But the idea is that you would spend at a Bitcoin friendly merchant and know that they're receiving Bitcoin in real time uh for payment, but you're only using fiat to to pay. And then you get Bitcoin back in real time as a as a cat Bitcoin cash back benefit. Then maybe if a couple of things happen, right? Two or three things happen. The first is that a lot of normies uh right now, one of their criticisms of Bitcoin is that, oh you you can't spend it anywhere, you can't use it as money. Um it's not legal tender, whatever. That's that's one of the criticisms, right? Um
1:03:16well well now now we start to we start to burst that that that that bubble where where it it it is more uh you you can use it at at more more merchants. And and I'm I'm very interested in helping to onboard more what I call marquee merchants as well, not just uh the kind of Lululemons or uh that of the world. Um I think there's there's a big opportunity there. Um so you you start to be able to use it at more more merchants, more useful merchants. But the other kind of penny drops then is that the rewards that you get, hopefully over time, they go up in value. And and that's not the case with any other rewards. Every other single reward, I mean, it goes down in value and um even things like um Starbucks points and that I mean, some of these programs are terrible where they they just sort of inflate um their their the points.
1:04:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): They're fiat on top of
1:04:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the thing. Absolutely like airline.
1:04:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): There's no scarcity
1:04:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there
1:04:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): whatsoever.
1:04:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
1:04:11John McCabe: absolutely. Um so I I think um I think that's another powerful um like where where the the the idea of your rewards going up in uh up up in value. And the other maybe final point there is that is the idea of the rewards being quite material. So I mentioned the idea of a new customer acquisition reward earlier. Um so that that's very, very, very powerful. And the second is is the idea of an evergreen reward then. So after that new customer acquisition reward um for the merchant you get you still get a material um Bitcoin cash back of like say just say around five percent, which would be more than any any equivalent credit card reward. award. So I think I think it's another area then where the penny drops and and the the consumer starts to think like wait a minute, like this this is pretty great. Like like I'm getting rewards. They tend to go up in value. They're they're much higher than I than I get with credit card and I'm making the merchant more successful. Like they're actually increasing market share. Um
1:05:11so um yeah it's not it's not perfect. I One other thing I realize I notice as well is that, you know, there's the the vast majority of consumers of normies, you know, are we not going to be successful orange building them. I think it's that Bitcoin Curious group. It's the groups that says, tell me more, but how about this, how about that, that we can all collectively work on. But I think this is this is arguably one of the most ex exciting things about this in my mind is that hopefully this becomes the easiest way to orange pill someone, orange pill a normie going forward. Because right now, when you consider trying to orange pill someone, you typically have to talk to them about setting up a river account and just buying Bitcoin or setting up Coinbase account or whatever, buying Bitcoin, hodling, just sitting there and passively doing nothing, you know, and and you know, doing nothing. in Bitcoin is often the very best, best strategy. I'm not suggesting otherwise. But now we have a much more interesting proposition where like, okay, you don't even need to in it in invest in Bitcoin. You don't need to buy Bitcoin. You just need to redirect your existing, you do you need to download this this app, this experience, and you just need to redirect your existing spend behavior to these Bitcoin-friendly merchants. And and you'll start to earn
1:06:28Bitcoin. Like I hesitate to use the word earn as well. And even see the way Bitcoin is better, like like I mentioned earlier, the way you can um the reward comes in real time. Like there's there a long list of things like that that work even better in the Bitcoin space than they do in the in the fiat space. Fiat actually can't can't give that um real-time reward
1:07:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
1:07:02John McCabe: one other
1:07:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): thing
1:07:02John McCabe: I'll mention I
1:07:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just
1:07:04John McCabe: to make sure I don't I don't lose sight of it, it's another interesting point potentially, is um
1:07:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
1:07:10John McCabe: a a criticism of of Bitcoin um from from normies or from from even potentially certain merchants would be like, oh um, Bitcoin is too volatile. We we hear that a lot. Um the interesting thing um in the in everything I've talked about um is that the benefits around new customer acquisition and and then the the secondary benefits around recaptured margin where they're not paying credit card fees or chargeback or and um um fraud risk and also potentially getting higher repeat spend from Bitcoiners. All of those benefits are completely independent of Bitcoin's price, of Bitcoin's exchange rate to the US dollar. Now of course they if they do leave it on the balance sheet, you know, maybe that will go down, maybe it will go uh go up. But the important point is all of the all of the business benefits, they're completely independent of Bitcoin price. So so what one of the things when we're talking to merchants, a very interesting um approach is to talk about this completely dispassionate of Bitcoin. Like in many ways, we don't need the merchant to become a Bitcoiner, to become a Bitcoin believer. Now it's better if they do, and we hope that they do over time. And um, but um if we just talk about the new
1:08:25customer acquisition, the recaptured margin of this, and then retaining this incredibly powerful and useful consumer segment, I mean, all of those arguments we could make those arguments without even mentioning Bitcoin. But what I will say is that as long as but then moving on to Bitcoin and moving on to the idea of Bitcoin accumulating on their balance sheet potentially for businesses that are cash flow positive, I would say that there is no sort of volatility risk risk per se, because it's it's all incremental business that they're getting. It's only going to be 1% initially, 2%, 3%, 4%, anyway. Um So it's all sort of gravy, if you will. Um so So it's it's a nice process. problem to have essentially it like worrying about volatility for like revenue you're getting from net new customers. And chances are it in any way goes up in value, not down in value over over time. Um like it's it's very it's very powerful. Um so it's not like they have to sell the Bitcoin to make payroll or something. It's just net new revenue. And when they're cash flow positive, it's just an an incremental.
1:09:39revenue channel that they could just leave alone and it doesn't impact their their their core business. And in in in fact, the incremental revenue can actually even increase their overall margin because to the extent that they have fixed assets, like the the the wine store I mentioned earlier, they only have say a certain number of employees at that store. They're paying a certain rent for the facilities. If we can achieve higher throughput for them, and even if they have more scale, they're getting better prices on the wine from their wholesaler, they're getting better shipping costs. So it becomes an even an even bigger benefit beyond the revenue, they're actually getting higher margin by spreading the fixed costs over more. So there's there's just so many layers of of benefit we can bring to bear um for the for the merchant.
1:10:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): what's your what's your sort of pitch uh to to bitcoiners themselves who are hesitant to still spend their bitcoin like what how do you how how do you address this you know you you you're going up to
1:10:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
1:10:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): talk with somebody at a conference about you know uh whatever it may be and you know they're you go to pay with Bitcoin and they go to not pay with Bitcoin. What what's your pitch to get them over the line as a Bitcoiner to start actually using Bitcoin as a medium of exchange?
1:10:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
1:10:52John McCabe: I think it's a great question. I I I think I'd I'll I'll probably have to work on my pitch. I'm not sure I have a great one right now.
1:11:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:11:00John McCabe: would say that my my my goal is to um
1:11:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
1:11:06John McCabe: I like we mentioned at the very start of the call, there's the idea that we have friction right now. We're we have potential taxable events and that And I understand that most Bitcoiners, we want to wake up every day with the same amount of Bitcoin or more than we had the previous day. And we we're a little uncomfortable about waking up with less and less. Longer term, we want to eliminate the points of friction and add the economic incentive so that it's perfectly rational for them to be spending Bitcoin. And in fact, if they're not spending Bitcoin, they're they're missing out on SATS. Like they're they're they're actually missing out on the opportunity to stack even more SATs. Um so it it becomes so they're kind of dumb in a way to not take advantage of it. Um but right now where we are, um it's it's it's frankly, it it is the the the segment of Bitcoiners who are sufficiently mission driven and sufficiently care about Bitcoin and Bitcoin as a medium of exchange that are probably the best candidates. And I certainly met quite a few of those people. Like it's one thing I've learned. I've I was recently at the Bitcoin Alpha conference and I met a few diehard Bitcoiners there who
1:12:18they're the kind of Bitcoiners who when they when they go to a merchant, it's like they they they try to orange bill every merchant they come into contact with and they try to spend their Bitcoin at their merchant and so there there there's definitely a motivated segment out there. I I don't know how big that segment is, but they're definitely our i i ideal um consumer right now, our ideal Bitcoiner that we want to come to Saturday Bitcoin and start um supporting Bitcoin friendly merchants. Uh I I think there's a lot of fun in it. There's a real fun factor as a Bitcoiner. Um I think it's a way that we can actively participate to make Bitcoin more successful. Like I touched on earlier, the idea of just hodling Bitcoin day to day. I mean, that's great. And generally that's the that's the best, you could argue that's the best strategy. But I really love the idea of also being able to actively contribute and participate to make Bitcoin more successful. Um I like I love the idea of supporting. Bitcoin-friendly merchants and making them more successful and making their competitors less successful, essentially by you know moving my spend uh from the other merchants to the Bitcoin-friendly ones. And I think if there's enough of us, um, we can make a difference. Um
1:13:31so um I think it's gonna get easier, it's gonna get better. I think we're gonna remove the frictions we're gonna add in in. incentives, and I think that will really catalyze and turbocharge our efforts. But right now we're we're in what I characterize as this sort of phase one. And you know, we've only we only launched this site about six weeks ago. Um, so um we have a lot of work to to do. Uh we're we're early in this journey, and I would ask Bitcoiners as well to come along with us for the journey as well. And you know, you know. keep it keep up with what we're doing and give us feedback as well. We're really keen to get feedback.
1:14:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
1:14:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): yeah definitely do encourage people because I obviously prepping for this show, I started checking out the site and it is it's really nice. It's a really nice site. Go so and I've uh always been a fan of trying to support anyone who is willing to accept Bitcoin uh, because I'm certainly willing to spend it and then we're replace it. And you know, so don't worry, IRS. I'm I'm good over here. Uh but and go spend uh at PN Lane Wine as well, um, and and do it for this uh the Saturday Bitcoin day. Uh we're we're getting up here against the end of the time. Just want to see if there's anything else we didn't get a chance to cover yet on this perspective or anywhere else you want to send people. Um I think we've said SaturdayBitcoin.com. a number of times. So hopefully people have that. It'll be down in the show notes as well. Anywhere else you want to direct people to or if they want to get in touch with you, maybe they want to you know get more involved in all this, uh, what's the best way to do
1:15:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that?
1:15:03John McCabe: Yeah, um so definitely like I'm uh John at Saturdaybitcoin.com. Uh definitely feel free to reach out and uh we'd would love any feedback. We'd also love to support um Bitcoin friendly merchants as well. You can you you can um be on our site for for free. It's a it's a free listing and we will go to efforts to promote you and um you can be part of our one of our upcoming wa uh rallies as well. So we have two or three merchants lined up for the next few few rallies. It's gonna be every Saturday. Um the only other area I would say um I would mention mention for Bitcoiners to check out work that I do, I have a personal website, lastcoinstanding.com. I'm Last Coinstanding on on Twitter, where I I've created uh it's a personal project where I've created tools and calculators and explorations uh for Bitcoin education and also to help Bitcoiners with um interesting kind of life events like if they have real estate, uh real estate versus Bitcoin, you know, rental property versus Bitcoin, um, how to survive bear markets, um, how to stress test your Bitcoin positions, um, portfolio allocation and um retirement, um considering Bitcoin in the context of retirement. So I have about about 50 explorations there and um some foundational education on Bitcoin as well. So um
1:16:23hope you can you can check that out and also um I'm keen to always get feedback there or suggestions. So that's it.
1:16:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, really appreciate your time. We had some other topics we were may maybe gonna get into, but we're just gonna have to do this again uh and have a dedicated session on those. But this was fascinating. I do appreciate the efforts, and I think we need more Bitcoin MOE adoption uh at all times. So uh love to see Bitcoin business or businesses accepting Bitcoin NGU. and uh appreciate what you're doing to make that happen. So thanks so much for coming on John.
1:16:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thanks,
1:16:55John McCabe: Walker. Appreciate it. It was a lot of fun. Thank you.