Jyoti Banerjee on Transition Labs and Regenerative Finance for Systems Change
Summary
Jyoti Banerjee, CEO of North Star Transition, discusses the failure of single-point solutions in addressing systemic issues like agricultural degradation. He describes how Transition Labs convene 'disconnected allies' to co-create regenerative visions through behavioral science and empathy-building. Banerjee critiques current economic valuation methods that prioritize short-term cash flows over nature-based solutions. He outlines a 'bazaar' approach to investment origination that relies on bottom-up collaboration rather than top-down planning. The episode highlights the need for transition finance that reshapes public money and engages supply chains to support systemic change.
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 0:47
Defining Degenerative vs. Regenerative Systems
Speaker_0 defines a degenerative system by its negative outcomes, such as climate emergency, biodiversity crisis, and water/health crises, contrasting this with the undefined concept of a regenerative system.
- 0:47 – 4:07
Podcast Introduction and Guest Background
Host Monica Altamirano de Jong introduces the podcast's focus on changing investment origination and introduces guest Jyoti Banerjee, CEO of North Star Transition, highlighting his role in creating the International Integrated Reporting Framework and his background in impact investing and tech entrepreneurship.
- 4:07 – 7:43
The Wye/Usk Watershed Crisis
Banerjee describes the Wye/Usk watershed in Wales as a beloved landscape suffering from severe pollution, citing front-page news coverage due to nutrient runoff, sewage, and intensive poultry farming.
- 7:43 – 9:14
Failure of Single-Point Solutions
Banerjee argues that fragmented interventions, such as government nutrient trading platforms, have failed to improve river health because they address symptoms rather than the systemic drivers of land management practices.
- 9:14 – 12:51
Root Causes of Agricultural Degradation
Banerjee reveals that 50% of river pollution comes from farm runoff, driven by a system where farmers lose money annually (average -£7,000) and thus maximize yield through intensive, chemical-heavy methods that damage soil and water.
- 12:51 – 21:50
Transition Labs and Disconnected Allies
Banerjee explains the purpose of Transition Labs: to convene 'disconnected allies' (farmers, utilities, authorities) to co-create a regenerative vision, starting by building empathy and connections among stakeholders who previously blamed each other.
- 21:50 – 29:56
Behavioral Science and Scaling Interventions
North Star Transition collaborated with UCL's Climate Action Unit to develop methods for collaboration, surfacing over 100 interventions in the Wye/Usk lab and packaging them into scalable, investable action packages.
- 29:56 – 37:57
Critique of Economic Valuation in Water Industry
Banerjee criticizes the UK water industry's 'value for money' test, which prioritizes short-term net present value of cash flows, leading to a preference for concrete infrastructure over nature-based solutions despite a £3.3bn allocation for nature.
- 37:57 – 40:33
Motivation and the North Star Concept
Speaker_0 explains that North Star Transition focuses on shifting systems rather than blaming individuals, driven by a personal motivation to act as an ambassador for a kingdom of peace and abundance. Speaker_1 connects this to a 'nature north star' focused on creating conditions for abundance.
- 40:33 – 42:09
The Role of the Systems Orchestrator
Speaker_0 describes the role of a 'systems orchestrator' who facilitates stakeholder relationships and empathy before applying entrepreneurial approaches to turn ideas into impactful actions. This involves identifying necessary resources, blockers, and enabling factors for transformational projects.
- 42:09 – 44:31
Regional Architecture and Resource Conflicts
Speaker_0 highlights that individual transformational ideas often compete for the same scarce resources like land and water, requiring a regional architecture to manage conflicts. This includes addressing regulatory barriers and understanding why the current system persists due to existing funding structures.
- 44:31 – 45:55
Wales Farming Subsidies and Profitability
Speaker_0 states that Welsh farmers have negative average earnings but receive £250 million in subsidies, which allows them to continue destructive practices. Farmers express a desire for profitability and resilience but resist being told how to farm or adopt the term 'regenerative'.
- 45:55 – 49:49
Climate Resilience and Product Mix Reimagining
Speaker_0 cites the worst summer in UK recorded history, featuring drought and floods, as evidence of the need for environmental resilience. He contrasts UK commodity production in the Fens with Dutch capital-intensive horticulture, arguing for a reimagined product mix including energy, tourism, and nature restoration.
- 49:49 – 59:20
Bazaar vs. Cathedral Approaches to Investment
Speaker_0 uses the 'bazaar' analogy from open-source software (like Linux) to describe a bottom-up, collaborative approach to investment origination, contrasting it with the top-down 'cathedral' approach. This involves allowing local participation and joining their work together rather than imposing a single plan.
Claims worth verifying
The current global system is degenerative, producing outcomes like climate emergency, biodiversity crisis, water crisis, health crisis, and inequality.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:20
How to verify: Check scientific reports from IPCC (climate), IPBES (biodiversity), and WHO (health) for crisis declarations; review UN SDG reports for inequality metrics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Wye/Usk watershed has seen a 95% reduction in salmon over 20 years.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·7:15
How to verify: Search for 'Wye/Usk salmon population decline 95%' in UK government environmental reports, Environment Agency publications, or academic studies on river ecology. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
There are 103 integrated poultry units in the Wye/Usk landscape raising 24 million chickens a year.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·6:19
How to verify: Check DEFRA (Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs) statistics on poultry units in Wales/England or local planning records for the Wye/Usk catchment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
University studies show poultry accounts for only one-sixth of the pollution in the Wye/Usk river.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·8:47
How to verify: Search for peer-reviewed studies or university research papers on nutrient sources in the Wye/Usk catchment, specifically citing poultry contribution percentages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Farm runoff accounts for approximately 50% of the pollution in the Wye/Usk river.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·9:14
How to verify: Verify via Environment Agency nutrient trading platform reports or academic studies on agricultural runoff in the Wye/Usk watershed. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The average earning of a farm in the Wye/Usk area is minus £7,000 a year.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·9:54
How to verify: Check NFU (National Farmers' Union) surveys or agricultural economic reports for the specific region of Southeast Wales/West England. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The UK water industry agreed to a £103 billion spend over the last determination period.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·30:15
How to verify: Search for 'Ofwat PR24 determination' or 'Ofwat PR19 determination' on the Ofwat (Office of Water Services) website for the total program of spend. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
£3.3 billion was set aside by water companies for nature in their five-year budget.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·30:38
How to verify: Check Ofwat's 'Programme of Spend' documents for the specific allocation to 'nature' or 'environmental improvement' within the £103bn total. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jyoti Banerjee was part of the team that created the International Integrated Reporting Framework.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·2:47
How to verify: Check the official IFRS Foundation website or historical press releases from the International Integrated Reporting Council (IIRC) for team member credits. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
North Star Transition runs regional transformation programs across England, Scotland, and Wales.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·2:27
How to verify: Visit the North Star Transition website or check their annual reports for geographic scope of projects. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
North Star Transition is an organisation leading regional transformation programmes across England, Scotland, and Wales.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·37:57
How to verify: Check the 'About' or 'Our Work' section of the North Star Transition website or their LinkedIn company page for regional project listings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Speaker_0 is a follower of Jesus Christ and wants to be an ambassador for the kingdom he talked about.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·38:27
How to verify: Verify via Speaker_0's personal biography on the North Star Transition website or professional profiles like LinkedIn. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The average earning for farmers in Wales is negative.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·44:31
How to verify: Search for 'Welsh farming average earnings negative' or check reports from the Welsh Government's Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs or the National Farmers Union of Wales. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
£250 million of subsidy is paid out to Welsh farmers.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·44:43
How to verify: Check the Welsh Government's annual report on agricultural subsidies or the UK Government's DEFRA subsidy data for Wales. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The summer in the UK in the year of the podcast (2026) was the worst in the history of recorded summers.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·45:55
How to verify: Search for 'UK summer 2026 weather record' or check Met Office reports for 2026 UK climate data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
48% of all Grade 1 soil in the UK is in the Fens.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·47:14
How to verify: Search for 'Fens Grade 1 soil percentage UK' or check reports from the Environment Agency or the Fenland Water Partnership. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Dutch farmers produce 40 times per acre what is produced in the Fens with commodities.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·47:56
How to verify: Search for 'Dutch vs UK farming yield per acre comparison' or check agricultural statistics from Wageningen University or the UK Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Speaker_0 works with over a dozen financial institutions to explore transition finance mechanisms.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·55:29
How to verify: Check North Star Transition's case studies or partner lists on their website for named financial institution collaborations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Institutional investors reject carbon credits and biodiversity credits in favor of financial returns.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·55:49
How to verify: Search for 'institutional investor stance on carbon credits biodiversity credits' or check reports from the Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures (TNFD) or major asset managers' sustainability reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Most nature finance in the UK is philanthropic money rather than commercial return-seeking capital.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·56:05
How to verify: Search for 'UK nature finance market report' or check reports from the Natural Capital Committee or the UK Green Investment Bank. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the claim that UK farmers have an average loss of £7,000/year by checking DEFRA's Farm Business Survey data.
- Check the £250 million subsidy figure for Welsh farmers against UK Government spending reports.
- Assess the Wye/Usk watershed pollution sources using Environment Agency data on nutrient runoff and sewage.
- Review North Star Transition's case studies for evidence of scalable interventions and their financial outcomes.
- Examine the UK Treasury's adoption of systemic views mentioned in the preview for Part Two.
- Look for counter-arguments to the 'bazaar' approach regarding coordination costs and scalability in complex infrastructure projects.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the question that often came back to us was: well, what do you mean by a regenerative system? And we thought, we don't even have a definition for this. However, we've kind of got the counter-definition. But we know what a degenerative system is. And a degenerative system has degenerative outcomes. And today's system is a degenerative system because it has a degenerative outcome like the climate emergency. It has a degenerative outcome. like a biodiversity crisis. It has a degenerative outcome because water is in crisis. We have health in crisis. We have inequalities in crisis. Everywhere we've taken our business, financial, economic system around planet Earth, we end up with these crises.
0:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Welcome to Investing in Regeneration. These This podcasts. podcast is about changing how we understand, plan, and finance projects so that finance becomes a driver for better decisions, not just the last step in the process. In each episode, we unpack a real deal or initiative to three lenses: understanding, planning, and financing. We explore how it came about, who work together, and what needs to change for these innovations to become mainstream. Because the real bottleneck is not capital. It is how investments are originated, structured, and brought to bankability. Our financial systems can do more than financing change. They can help shape
1:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
1:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Welcome to Investing in Regeneration. I'm Monica Altamirano de Young. And today's guest is Jyoty Jyoti Baneshi, CEO of North Star Transition. And this is our very first two-part episode. Our conversation was way too rich and so inspiring, so we have decided to share it in two parts. This is also one of the cases that demonstrate a new mission mission-driven driven investment planning approach where the whole process is. oriented towards societal outcomes and across sectors. And in this first part, we start with the reverning crisis and the people trying to change its futures together. So let's begin. Good afternoon, everyone. I'm very happy to be welcoming today Joti Banner, who is the co-founder and CEO of North Star Transition, which is an organization, as you will hear much more in some minutes, focusing on system systems change.
2:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
2:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): North Star Transition runs regional transformation programs across England, Scotland, and Wales. And Jotti was part of the team that created the International Integrated Reporting Framework, which many of you probably have heard about, and has been an impact investor for over 20 years. As a tech entrepreneur, his company operated from London and Silicon Valley, and Jyoti Jyoty has a master. master's degree in economics and a MBA. Welcome, Jyoti.
2:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Thank you. I'm looking forward to the conversation, Monica.
2:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Thank you. Today we will unpack not one deal, but actually an approach that is changing investment origination in the United Kingdom. And these are the so-called transition labs that North Star Transition is leading. For example, in the Y and Earth. USC in Wales, we will refer to that case, but they have many more that Jodie will share with us about. And this case, we also had it very recently, is featured in the European Investment Bank Group white paper that is about how do we future proof Europe's water systems, right? And I think it has been a great source of inspiration for many of the people who attended this first Water Force. roundtable. So, Jyotti, we are here to talk about this incredible innovation that you're setting in motion. I would love to ask, why spending all of this effort in this innovation? Why, as you have some other times also explained in conversations, why can't fragmented projects and single
3:59sector interventions reverse this ecological and economic decline that we see all around the world, actually?
4:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So thank you for inviting me into this conversation. When you think about the kind of work we've been involved in, and uh you referenced the work we're doing across Southeast Wales and the west of England, and that's a project we call Why Ask USK Transition Lab. And the landscape is really actually a beautiful one. It's much loved. People love that place. They often think back to when they were kids going on holiday there. They think of the times they've been out there hiking or fishing, or the people who live there love that place. You know, Britain's biggest book festival happens on the banks of the River Wai, which is the fourth longest river in the UK. Coming as I do from India, of course, a long river in the UK is not a very long river at all, but I'll put that to one side. But this is a much loved landscape. But actually, it's in the news on a regular basis. And we're talking front-page front page news in the UK. And when a river becomes front page news, it's never because it's such a beautiful place and it's such a lovely place and we should all go there on holiday. It's because it is, it's in a real mess. And
5:27basically, over the last 20 years, what we have seen is that the river has just got worse and worse and worse. And the accusations that have come against. the people who might be causing the problems are basically that we have nutrients in the river, nitrates and phosphates. We have got sewage in the river. And it's basically there are a couple of villains in the story that are usually picked on. And one is that there are 103 integrated poultry units in the landscape. And they raise about 24 million chickens a year. And this is pretty much intensive poultry, and somehow or the other, the chickens that are reared rare in this landscape, they're their poo. pood ends up in the river.
6:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Wow.
6:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And so the stuff that was used to grow the food that gets fed to the chickens, the phosphates and uh, you know, the the chemicals that were used to grow that food, which is often soya grown in Latin America, by the way, and then shipped across to the UK. that stuff ends up in the river. So the accusation against the chicken farmers is, well, you're spoiling our river. And then the water company releases untreated sewage into the river. And so you put that together, and what you have is a river that suffers from algae. of different sorts. The natural vegetation is getting hammered. We've had a 95% reduction in the salmon in the river over 20 years. So when when you have that kind of situation, people want to just do that the one thing that'll fix it. You know,
7:35can we get the nitrates out? Can we get the phosphates out? Can we do something about the sewage?
7:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Very, very like punctual. Yeah.
7:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. It's this is our metric. This is what we can identify as being a problem. Let's go and do something about
7:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
7:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And so you then got to ask the question, well, who's causing the problem? Oh, it's those poultry farmers. We need to do something about that, etc. et cetera. And what I find interesting about that kind of approach is that it hasn't got us anywhere.
8:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
8:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, the government has attempted to put together a nutrient trading platform so that not just the poultry farmers, but the farmers who are using nitrates and phosphates on their soil can basically participate in a trading system that allows them to get some money if they use less of the chemicals.
8:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
8:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that is so far not made the difference that we need to see out there. So the question that we came to when we were introduced to the area, question we were asking is: is there another way to do this? Why do we have these problems? And actually, the really interesting thing about it is that even though the chickens and the poultry get so much attention, according to university studies, they only account for about a sixth of the pollution on the Y. And the water utility, which is releasing untreated sewage, is also probably another sixth of the pollution. So there's a great big other chunk that's not getting any attention. And actually,
9:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): around
9:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): 50% of the pollution that happens in the river is actually runoff from our farms. It's our land management practices. And the crazy thing about how this has worked out is that the farms spend money buying these chemicals because it's part of their understanding of this is how we maximize our. yield. They want to maximize their yield because they want to produce more and sell more. And the mindset is driven largely by the fact that the average earning of a farm in the area is minus 7,000 pounds a year. They lose money every Yeah. year. But they are driving yield and productivity as much as they possibly can. in the most intensive ways possible. So, you know, a farmer who's going whole hog on this might be buying high-yielding seed, providing that seed with a diet of chemicals, fertilizers, pesticides, etc., to give it the best chance. They need more water than normal seed. They need more equipment to spread all this stuff around. They need more diesel to run that equipment. The whole package is an
10:33expensive package. And so actually what we have achieved in the landscape is we are doing farming in a way that is damaging Managing to the pocketbooks of the farmers. We're doing farming in a way that is hammering the environment. You know, soil health is poor, the water courses are in trouble. And then when we try and fix the problems, we pick one little element in the problem and say, We're gonna try and do nutrient management because that'll do it. Well, no, you can't take the nutrients out of the river if you're gonna going continue to putting them on the land. So
11:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is there another way?
11:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Expensive, yeah.
11:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So is there another way to reimagine the system so that it is healthy for the people who live and work in that place? It is positive for the economy, it's positive for nature, it's positive for relationships. So that's the kind of backdrop. And I can give you lots of such examples where a single point solution
11:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): actually
11:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): isn't going to get us to the place because the single point solution assumes we can change one little thing in the system. But if the day-to-day practices of the people who live in that place depends on being able to use the nitrates and the phosphates or do the chicken farming or whatever else it is that is happening, then all we're doing here is we're trying to lessen the blow. But we're not actually transformational in any way. The transformational challenge is the real challenge.
12:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Thank you so much. I really take from what you say that these single points solutions, somehow we have a fixation, I think, everywhere on those, focusing on a specific metrics tricks like the nutrients. But actually when you start to analyze this. place, it was like a lose-lose game, right? That's what you were pointing towards. So is this the place where you started with this approach or were other places and overall the transition laps, could you tell us a little bit more like what they are, what they are not, and also the way they are meant to change the metabolism of a place?
12:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. So the purpose of creating a transition lab was really because we were asking the question: how would this entire region, how would this landscape become regenerative? And we use the language of regenerative because we heard farmers talk about regenerative farming. And I'm not a farmer. You know, I grew up in a city of New Delhi, and I've lived for much of my adult life in London. I don't have much farming background. But when I heard farmers talk about being regenerative, I thought, yeah, that makes sense. They're working with nature, they're collaborating with nature, they are working with others in the landscape. That's what we want the system to look like. Wouldn't it be great if the system would be regenerative? So we use the language of, a regenerative system to say we want the whole of the landscape and the systems therein, whether it's food or farming or health or transport or housing or energy, whatever we're talking about. We want those systems to be part of a regenerative system, one that's working. that works with nature, doesn't hammer nature, one that doesn't exploit humans. So we asked the question, what
14:10would it take to make a landscape regenerative?
14:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
14:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the problem, of course, that we had being a tiny little organization set up six years ago, is that we didn't actually have a plan for it. We didn't have a clue how we were going. going to solve that. But it has never stopped us in the past from going out to do things. And we decided: hey, we want to invite people into a conversation about what a regenerative system could look like. And the question that often came back to us was: well, what do you mean by a regenerative system? And we thought. we don't even have a definition for this. However, we've kind of got the counter definition. But we know what a degenerative system is. And the degenerative system has degenerative outcomes. And today's system is a degenerative system because it has a degenerative outcome like the climate emergency. It has a degenerative outcome like a biodiversity crisis. It has a degenerative outcome. outcome
15:15because water is in crisis. We have health in crisis. We have inequalities in crisis. Everywhere we've taken our business, financial, economic system around planet Earth, we end up with these crises. So the question is: is there another way to make the system work? And that for us is what we're looking for is not to say we have a target for what a regenerative system is like, but we have a target we're running away from, which is the degenerative system. And our invitation to the people in the landscape was to say, Hey, come and join us and let's work out together what a regenerative system might look like. So that was kind of the starting point.
16:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): What I take from you is that the wording regenerative came actually from the farmers, right? So that's I think that says that there is that longing for this change there. But also I think it's in a way the fact that you were not coming from there, from that background, and that you are creating space where you can hold the question and the space to rethink and reimagine, as you say, is probably yeah, very powerful because now we're jumping in in all of the in all of our wonderful job and world, but also in our degenerative system. Seems like everybody has a formula. And the fact that you're holding the space to say, wait a minute, how do we find the formula? Maybe it's exactly the way to get out of this certitude that is very single point focus.
16:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, and actually for us, when we arrive in a landscape, what we have discovered is that there is a pattern. We usually invite people to come and talk about what a regenerative system would look like, what a regenerative economy or landscape would look like. that they want to live in and they want to participate in, raise their families in. And people come with their ideas. And I remember the first conversations we were having in the why us transition lab. One person said, I want the salmon back in the rivers. Somebody else said, I want renewable energy to be freely available. to all of us. Somebody else said, I want this place to be a place my kids can grow up in and think of as home. I want them to jump into the rivers and not be concerned about their health. You know, the ideas that people had about what a regenerative system could look like came from very different parts of their own human experience.
18:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, very close to their longings and
18:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah, and yet what I found interesting was if you put the whole picture of what they wanted, actually a regenerative place would give them that. And so we were able to invite them to step into conversations with each other. to say, actually, you want the same thing. The outcome of what a regenerative system would look like for you could look like your children being raised in a happy environment or eating good food or you know, the salmon are back in the river, whatever it is. But what we found was when you bring the people together, and we were bringing people from across multiple domains,
18:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
18:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): we're talking hundreds of people. When we brought them together, we discovered that often they didn't know each other. That's the first thing. They don't know each other. And when they don't know each other, they have no connection Interaction with each other. And they lack a sense of empathy for each other. Because they there's no relationship there.
19:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, they're like strangers to each other.
19:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They're
19:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): strangers, yeah. So I'm meeting Monica, and Monica wants the salmon back. Well, do I really care? Because I'm thinking about renewable energy. You know, we're not even on the same page. And the second bit was in some instances, they did know each other, but they didn't like each other. other. Because they believed the other side was part of the problem.
19:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah. Yeah. They were blaming each other in a way
19:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for it. The
19:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): playing game is high. And so then the question became how do you bring? We adopted the term disconnected allies. How do you bring the disconnected allies together? And they were disconnected allies because actually their vision of what they wanted in the future should have put them in the same place to fight together. But they were disconnected from each other. So the first part of a transition lab journey is really: how do you connect the disconnected? How do you build relationships between them? And how do you build empathy?
20:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Because
20:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): without that, there's no shared landscape, there's no shared objective, no vision as to where they want to go. So that's our starting point.
20:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Wow, beautiful. Thank you. And I think it's very aligned. No, I mean, I mean, from all the regeneration authors, I like many of them, but Paul Hawkins said indeed that what we're leaving living now is a is the result of a massive disconnection, no, between people. between people and nature, and within nature. So he also says there are no quick uh technological fixes. It's all about weaving back these connections. And I love that you said that in a way it was like this or blaming each other, so the blame game or the not knowing each other, so I don't basically care of what you want. That through weaving this connection back, backs you start. to set in motion, right? And like a maybe shared understanding of each other longing. And what I also understand from you is that when you start to do that, you start to see a pattern that actually everyone could get these outcomes.
21:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. And I think for us what's been interesting is that we had to learn how to bring these people together. how to get them to collaborate, how to get them to share a common vision. And we worked very closely with a behavioral science team at University College London. And they worked with us to develop a method by which we could use the best of behavioral science. It's a climate action unit at uh UCL, and we're so deep deeply appreciative of the work that Dr. Chris DeMaier and his team have done with us because they have really freely given off their knowledge and skills and resources to help us do this work. So it's been great. And the direction of travel that we went in was we invited people to say, okay, if you think this place would be
22:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
22:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): place of regeneration or revitalization or any of the thriving language you might want to use, what do you think would change? What do you think this landscape could look like? What would be the actions that people want to carry out? And people came up with ideas as to what they saw as possible in a landscape.
22:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
22:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it was exciting. because we were beginning to see some really big picture ideas as to we'd like to see this change. We want to see this happen. We have already started doing this at small scale, but wouldn't it be great if we could do this at large scale? So in the why ask, we surfaced Selfist somewhere between 105 and 110 possible interventions that could happen. in the landscape. And the reality of it is that almost none of those interventions were going to be transformational. Because most people don't have that as their objective. They just want to do something on their farm or in their local neighborhood or something. But the question we were asking was. what if we could take this idea that you have shared, or even this idea that you have started, and can we do something at scale with this?
23:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, yeah.
23:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
23:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): so you took the essence of what they were thinking, but then challenged them to make it transformational.
23:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And we asked the question, how would you scale this up? And actually, across the 100 plus interventions, some of them connected with each other. What if we could connect those bits and make them work? And if you look at the work we've done in Fenn's transition lab, which is in the east of England, that's a collaboration we do with Anglian Water and the Environment Agency and a program that they run called Future. Fenz Integrated Adaptation. It's asking the questions about the future of the Fenz area, which actually is very similar to the Fenz area in Holland. Because it was Dutch engineers who reclaimed the land in Holland, and then they came over to England and did the same kind of work 400 years ago. And now we're asking the question: what would a reconstruction? regenerative fence look like? And there we've had over 220 potential interventions that people have shared with us. And what we've done is we've packaged up those interventions into about 10 different packages of actions that could happen. And these actions are about
25:11food and agriculture, they're about reimagining. water in the whole kind of circular economy model for water. We're looking at uh re-wetting the peat and restoring the natural landscape in places. We're looking at using construction materials uh that are locally grown, using palluticulture. Pelludiculture, We're looking at how a water market can be put in. We're talking about a range of actions, but we're also looking at how do we reimagine how economic networks work across the area so that we can make this a valuable part of the UK PLC. And when you ask those kinds of questions, what has come up is an approach that allows us to then say, how do we make this real? And so the idea is very different from just imposing concepts from on high. It's really ground up. These are actions people want to see, they believe in them. And we are exploring if we can take these actions but make them, you know, powerful and to make them
26:23viable, to make them investable. what would it look like?
26:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
26:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you're nurturing these seeds of change. You could say that we're already there. Wow. I will ask more on this because I have been like traditionally on the infrastructure world, which is you know, you have master planning and then you have top down. And then as I went more into the regeneration community, indeed I see lots of this bottom-up bottom up approach. And something I I we love and we we all will almost uh get to that, is yeah, how do you foresee we can bring these worlds together? But before that, because I truly believe that thank you so much for sharing this, Jotti has been really inspiring to hear all the changes that you're setting in in motion. And I think beyond the environmental aspects, right? In a very divided world as we are today, why what you're doing there is in a way also deeply and very important to the social contract that we have, which we see in crisis too, right? Now, we'd love to now talk more about you. I'm I'm sure that as I grow older, that's going quite quick. But anyway, I can really see that changes happen when there are people who are committed. who are conquering their own fear to take steps and challenge the status quo, right? And going much beyond what their you could
27:47say, the job, no description was, or maybe their own ideas of success at the beginning get stretched by this mission that that they embark on. So I would love to know, no, more about you, yourself, your journey. Could you could you tell us I mean, I know there have been a lot of changes in your career, but could you tell us a little bit about you? What has been and what has led you to take this step? Any like red threads that you see also running through your life in terms of the type of impact you want to achieve?
28:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think the reality of the world that we live in today is that it is in a deeply destructive place. You could imagine we have crossed seven of the nine planetary boundaries during the course of the last 20, 25 years. So it during my adult life, I don't want to take all the blame for this, but it's really my generation that has done this. The most intense extraction possible, the biggest drive towards wealth creation, but wealth creation with zero regard for the impacts that it would have, the negative impacts it would have on nature, the negative impacts on people and relationships and and so on. And for me, I have two kids. and
29:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
29:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): are gonna grow up facing these challenges. These challenges are going to shape and define their generation. And I at least want them to feel dad tried. Dad did you know, he's made an attempt. So, in a sense, there is a personal journey here that I want to be part of something. But I'm also really badly equipped to make this journey. You know, I trained as an economist, and I've realized that us economists have a lot to answer for because we have reduced relationships, we've reduced nature to economic numbers. Let me illustrate that for you. In the UK, the water industry. agrees with the water regulator five year program of spend. And that spend over the last determination was 103 billion pounds.
30:18And there's been deep concern that the water industry is not focused on nature. It's doing stuff that's deeply down. damaging to nature and it's not investing in nature. So somehow or the other, there was an agreement made with the water companies that 3.3 billion pounds would be put aside for nature in their five year budget. But when the Then water companies have to decide on what's the
30:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): best
30:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): way to implement whatever intervention they're planning to carry out. They have to meet one test. And that test is value for money for their customers. Value for money is pretty much a really poor economic test. Why do I say that? It seems like a fairly straightforward thing. You know, value for money. Why wouldn't you want to deliver it? Of course. But when we measure value for money, we usually say, what's the lowest cost way of doing something? And when we're assessing cost, we're trying to find, in effect, the net present value of the cash flows really involved in a project.
31:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And for
31:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): me, what we end up with is that we will look at an action where we are going to invest something that will allow nature to work. But the net present value of a nature-based intervention
31:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
31:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): going to give us a really bad outcome because nature might take 10 years to get its act together. And we will continue to get the benefits for the next 50 to 100 years. But those first 10 years pretty much mean, you know what? We should just put in some pipes and steel and concrete. We can turn a valve and press a button,
32:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
32:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): we get an immediate benefit.
32:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Until we find, like we're finding now. that there is no water, right? Like you can put the
32:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): bikes, but
32:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): on it, you know, the economic terms of that discussion mean that that 3.3 billion that they have set aside, they're probably not gonna spend it. Because we can't meet the economic tests for what would be value for money for customers. Yet we're very happy to spend 100 billion over the next five years to hammer nature as hard as possible.
32:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
32:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): we don't have to really ask many questions about value for money there, because of course we've constructed the system to deliver the right economic answers. So
33:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's like
33:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): the system is rigged, right?
33:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It is rigged. It is rigged. And us economists have a huge penalty. to pay in this thing. So sadly, I I have to admit that I trained as an economist. I've never worked as one. I I'd be a rubbish economist because I ask all these stupid questions all the time. That was my background. But the work I've done over the last thirty years or so has been as an entrepreneur in the tech sector and as an impact investor and so on. So it's it's a different journey.
33:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): No, I I completely understand. And though if you look at what you're doing now also, because a lot of the people also that you convene in these labs are investment professionals, and kind of like that deeper care for the future of your children, is there something that you think had it somehow deceived much, much long ago during your childhood or what your parents you know brought you so in a way you have a organization that is called the North Star Transition. What somehow in the most deeper sense you feel is your North Star
34:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So I'm gonna give you two different answers to that question. The first thing is at a more immediate level I was involved with this venture fund that I had collaborated in creating. And we were investing in businesses that were committed to making a difference in their communities. And about 10 years into that journey, I met somebody and she was asking me questions about the investments we were making. And she said, Are you an impact investor? And I had never heard the term before at that point. So we had started in 2001. And I'd somehow or the other managed to reach 2010 without any concept of this term, impact investing. And she said, It sounds like you're an impact investor.
35:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
35:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I was like, Really? That's so interesting. But for me, what was the takeaway I had from the conversation? was that every business is an impact business.
35:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
35:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, we have this artificial justification that we put down to say, oh, an impact business does good things in this area or in that area. Actually, every single business is an impact business. You could be an oil company or a tobacco company or a gambling company or a regenerative farm. You're going to have impacts across human capital, across social capital, across natural capital, across financial capital, across intellectual capital, across these different capitals. You are every single entity is an impact business. The question is, do we care about our impact? Do we even know what our impacts are? And for me, that was part of the journey. into thinking about what would be a holistic framework that any business could use. And that is what resulted in the integrated reporting framework. And it's exciting to see that there are literally thousands of businesses using that kind of multicapital framework. in their thinking today. But the sad reality is it hasn't changed a thing. Our systems are still broken. And we are still in
36:37a place of crisis. And people use a reporting framework like integrated reporting to report on what they do, but they don't use it to shape their understanding of w how they manage their impact. impacts. So for me, part of the journey of North Star Transition is to say, actually, these people who produce reports on their multi-capital impacts, but actually it's not changing anything, why is that? Why are we in that situation? Well, we're in that situation because the system that they live in. requires them to act in particular ways. The system that they live in requires them to make sure that they are delivering financial capital gains, regardless of what happened to the other capitals. So they can say whatever they like in their beautiful, elegant reports, but their actions tell us that they're driven by that system.
37:37So not North start. Star Transition was really asking the question: is there another North Star that we can use? And you know, the sailors of old would be lost on the seas, but when they could see the North Star, then they knew how to navigate. And so we want to ask the question: what is that North Star? What is it that we should be using? And we use the word. transition because we're not simply saying we should go and cut off the heads of all the people who are running today's system. We're saying we all have to learn how to shift out of the model that we're in today to a different place. So this is kind of the journey that I've been on.
38:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Of
38:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): course you also ask asked the question, what was my motivation? And that's certainly a personal thing, because for me as a follower of Jesus Christ, I want to be an ambassador for the kind of kingdom that he talked about. A kingdom where where relationships would be strong, where there'd be no more sorrow and pain, there wouldn't be exploitation. You know, people would live together and do so in peace.
38:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We've
38:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): got
38:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): their
38:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): full potential, right?
38:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. But you know, that we would live life abundantly. What does it mean to do that? I have no idea. But I want to be an ambassador. I want to be a proponent of that.
39:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I love that. They love abundantly. And I think that's also the more I go into regenerative design and so forth, it's like nature does. Maybe that's the North Star right? You know, the nature north star is how do we get the conditions for abundance, right? And somehow we have done that differently. So now thank you so much for sharing. Seems to me as I was listening to you that you started that is really like a quest of
39:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
39:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): becoming more responsible for the impact that you were delivering. But as you went more into that question, now with north the north. Star transition and the different transition labs, you want to go deeper into that understanding of what are the incentives that are there for people to keep delivering the same outcomes, even though they might want to report in good impact terms. So now I want to talk about the planning on the investment origination part of the investment cycle, right? Like, so when do you you have to talk talked about these different transitions? transition labs that you are facilitating and nurturing? You could tell us like how does it work? So, could you tell us normally after that very initial part of hundreds of people that start to bring their ideas? How does that go from there? Who is around the table? Farmer, water, utilities, local authorities, and so forth. But how do the roles also change between you could say that that the initial moment and as you advance towards developing an investment portfolio that is transformational?
40:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, so it's an interesting challenge. And I was speaking to somebody the other day who was telling me about the development of the concept of a systems orchestrator. You know, that we don't necessarily use that language, but it is a really interesting idea. that the system needs a facilitator, conductor, you know, orchestrator. And for me, our role initially was to bring the different stakeholders together so that they could share their ideas, build their relationships, build the empathy with each other, and begin to start the journey of imagining. what could be the actions that could take us to a different place. But then as you explore the actions, then our role is really to bring some of that kind of entrepreneurial approach. What does it take to take an idea and a problem and make it into something that could be impactful, transformational, all of that?
41:39And that is about understanding what specific actions need to be carried out, who needs to carry them out, what are the issues that it might face, what are the blockers and the hurdles and and so on. Who needs to be in the room to enable these ideas to develop? And what resources do they need to get there? So when you look at the kind of packages of actions that we have come up with in the FENS, and I can share
42:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
42:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): link with you with the reports that we have produced for the local stakeholders to say this is how your particular ideas can actually become real. But one of the challenges we have is that each of the ideas are actually saying, I want to do my idea, and I'm going to need some land to do it because I'm thinking about doing something transformational with agriculture or transformational with the landscape and nature or transformational because I'm going to use the land for renewable energy or whatever. And quite likely in the fence, fens, they're they are also going to talk about water,
42:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
42:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): they want to use water and in some way because water is a scarce resource in the fans. So, how they use that water. And when you look at the interventions, on their own, they look really interesting. But actually, they need the same land and the same water, and probably are approaching the same capital.
43:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
43:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so then at that point, you realize that now. we have a different challenge. It isn't just the investment origination. It's working out what is the regional architecture that enables this transformation to happen. Because of course, we can always invest in the one idea that would be a fantastic idea to do. But would that actually make a difference in the landscape? if that idea also needs something else to happen on the side? Or that idea is going to be in conflict with something else. So part of the orchestration challenge then is to think about what are the enabling factors that we need to get around. The fact that actually there are a couple of ideas in there today that would be a lead. illegal because the regulatory barriers will say you can't do that. And so we need to get to a place where we can bring the regulators to the table so that they can actually go forward in a way. But then we also have I to ask questions: why does the system continue to persist in the way it is? today? Well, it's because the system
44:31is funded to continue this way. It is resourced to continue. So, you know, I told you about the farmers and the why ask. The average earning is negative.
44:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
44:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): there's 250 million pounds of subsidy that's paid out to Welsh farmers. And what that does. it allows them somehow or the other to survive and continue doing what they do.
44:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I continue the, in a way, this destructive
44:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): This destructive damaging uh approach. And if you asked farmers, would you like to be profitable? Well, they're gonna put their hand up and say, Yes, I want to be profitable. By the way, you can't ask them to be regenerative because then they say, Oh, you can't tell me how to do farming. So we never talk about being regenerative when it comes to farming. We talk about regenerative for the system, but not for the farmers. If you say, Do you want to be profitable? Well, of course they want to be profitable. Do you want to be resilient? Yes, they want to be resilient. And by resilient, it might be that they need to be financially and economically resilient. not carry a massive debt burden that they just have to support the interest payments for. And it could also be that they need to be environmentally resilient so they can handle you know, we've had the worst summer
45:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
45:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the history of recorded summers in the UK this year.
46:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And also
46:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): here in Europe, we were just discussing. that last week. Yeah.
46:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. And so you have that, but before that, we had some of the biggest floods possible. So you've got drought, you've got flood, you've got biodiversity loss. How do you operate to be resilient in those terms? Well, you have to work with nature. But you can't simply say to a farmer, well, you should just become profitable. and resilient. They can't because quite often they're stuck inside a system that won't let them shift.
46:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah.
46:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So part of the challenge is how do you create the transition finance that enables them to move out? How do you create the transition resources, which sometimes are I'll simply let's rethink what you do and how you do it? Let's rethink to use language. that I would have used in the tech sector. I want to think about what's the right product mix that comes off the land. If you look at the fens, the fens is the most productive soil in the UK. 48% of all the grade one, that's the best quality land in the UK, is actually in the fens.
47:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,
47:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): what do we do with the most productive soils in the UK? We produce wheat. And no one can tell fens wheat from non-fenz wheat. That's all just a commodity. We produce potatoes. We produce onions.
47:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
47:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, we produce undifferentiated commodities.
47:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
47:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): when you contrast it with what the Dutch farmers do. do, with the same kind of land on their side, it's highly capital intensive because they put in glass and it's all undercover horticulture. The output from those farms can be 40 times per acre what is produced when it's And just commodities. So we need to help farmers not just change how they do. farming to do today's farming. We need to reimagine what the product makes that says, how much of the land are we going to use for these kinds of foods? How much of the land will we use for energy? How much of the land will we use because actually we're going to do tourism and Bs or whatever it is? How much of the land will we restore for nature? Because that's what we need to see happen.
48:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think this is something that that came out of last year's discussion, but also is coming out in Europe. We had this natural capital financing facility and a lot of cases were documented. And yeah, the future is certainly on the one hand, projects that can generate different revenue streams, right? Like stacking, which is something I will ask you also about. But on the other hand, multi-purpose landscapes, right? That you consciously also balance that some will produce, you could say, no, and and generate money. And some you might need to conserve and devote to that biodiversity, so that the productive part is much more productive, right? Like if you so I think definitely that combination of functions. But then the question that you were asking about how do you create that architecture? that does help to kind of cross subsidize or support this harmony, right? If it's just like, okay, I'm the owner of the part that produce and generates the more value and then who will then finance the, you know, conservation, biodiversity oriented piece? But they need each other, right? So how do you create this architecture and orchestra orchestrate that they can be developing balance? So maybe I have one more question regarding the planning, because I was reading about your work and I think uh you referred to
49:49a bazaar kind of approach, right? Versus uh, for example, sometimes also people talk about a cathedral approach to the development of investable propositions. Could you tell us you refer, I think a little bit to it before, but what is that this this bazaar approach and what are you experiencing? How long it takes to go from these sharing ambitions about what regenerative looks like towards getting some of these ideas really become investable?
50:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So the bazaar and cathedral analogy really again goes back to my life in tech. because within tech there were ideas around were the approaches by which we could develop software platforms. And one approach was that one organization, let's say Microsoft, would go and put together a great big plan.
50:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
50:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): was like a detailed blueprint. Here's what our software is going to do. Here's how it's going to work. We're going to hire the developers to put all the pieces into Windows. It will cover the printer drivers, the video display drivers.
51:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
51:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, we will have apps that will run on it. And you know Microsoft created Windows using that approach. And somebody likened that to building a cathedral. You need to have a plan and a vision for what this building is going to look like. Someone needs to put that together. Someone needs to work out what resources are needed. Someone needs to pay for that. Someone needs to go and get all the builders, and you need to make sure the bricks and the stone comes come before the glass. And you know, all of that coordination has to happen. And that is how you build a cathedral. It's a very top-down view of life. But a bazaar is something different. It's like you can put a few tables out on a street and say, we're just going to see who comes along. And somebody comes along and brings their farm output. Somebody else comes along and says, I do needlework. Someone else is a potter and they bring their thing. And pretty soon you have a little bazaar where people can come and they can trade with each other and they learn how to do stuff. And the concept of
52:12a bazaar in the software world was really how open source platforms were created, where things like Linux and so on, different developers across the world collaborated with each other. No one had a great big plan as to what needed to happen. Everyone did the bit that they wanted to do, but it all worked together. And eventually that became a very powerful platform. But today, almost all the web platforms around the world run on that kind of technology.
52:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
52:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the bazaar in cathedral idea is something we've taken to our own work, which is if you're going to have gonna a have a cathedral, someone has to build the plan from on high and then drop that plan into a landscape and say, this is now what we're going to do. And they have to resource it and fund it and so on. But if you have a bazaar, actually you're allowing the local people to participate together. And then you have to join their work so that it all works together. And in terms of financing this bizarre approach, what we've realized is you don't just create one finance approach. You actually need five different elements of finance working together. And so what we have been exploring is how do you bring the public money in where quite often today, the public money is being used to allow the current system to continue. Whereas we don't want that. We want the regenerative system to prosper. How do you reshape the flows of public money so that they're not stopping and halting what needs to happen with the regenerative system? Secondly, there's supply chain money. There are very big commercial operators who
54:04depend on these landscapes for their commercial actions and purposes. How do you help them understand that unless these landscapes are healthy and that the people who operate in them are healthy, you're not going to get the long-term resilience of their own profitability and cash flows and their product lives and so on.
54:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
54:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): third thing we see is that there are some things that are just not fundable at all. You can't put money on it because there's no justification for putting the money or the risks are too high, and no one's willing to put the money. So you actually quite often have to go and get some philanthropic funding to go and fill in the gaps. But you also need need local citizens just to take part. You know, for example, what if I want to put in renewable energy in my home? You know, there's 20 of us on our street and we're all doing it together and we're all sharing in some way in that. And that's kind of locally crowdsourced money that becomes part of the overall regenerative journey. And then we need the money that enables the transition to happen. And that's where I think institutional money, finance needs to come into play. But what finance tells us, we work with over a dozen financial institutions around the world to explore how these mechanisms can be constructed. And they say to us, don't come to us with carbon credits, don't come to us with biodiversity credits. We don't want that kind of stuff. We just want to know we, you know, we have to produce a financial return. And most of the nature finance stuff, there is no
55:49financial return. There are no cash flows relating to these things. So if we have found quite a few actions in the UK where there is nature finance in play, but pretty much wh regardless of who's given that money. it's philanthropic money.
56:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah.
56:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It might
56:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): come from a
56:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): bank, it might come from a commercial operator, but it's just money they're giving because they want to help they want to do something positive. But if you want commercial money, and that's money where there is a return, and it's very clear that there will be mechanisms by which this money will be managed, it'll be stewarded and all that sort of stuff. And you have to build different kinds of mechanisms to enable that to happen. So we are really interested in exploring all five of those paths. And we know that actually in the FENS landscape, for example, part of the regional architecture challenge isn't just simply who's going to use what land for what purpose and what water for what purpose and so on. It's also about creating the vehicles that bring these different sources of finance into one workable solution. We're talking about
56:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): contracting arrangements between all of these
57:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): correct. Someone needs to be credible for doing that. I hear people say, well let's set up a community interest company because the community interest company will do this work on behalf of the of the community. It's like yeah, but which community interest company is going to be credible when they're talking to XYZ Bank? Absolutely not a single one of them. So we need to reshape our understanding of how this stuff is going to work.
57:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I can feel because I have also kind of been working in between those worlds, right? So sometimes everybody has the best intentions, but each one stays stay on their lane and you're trying to get them to find ways to find the middle way, right? Meanwhile, you also are challenging, of course, the rules of the system, but this transition means you have to also be patient and trying to find a compromise, right? As you build the road towards the new world. And today this is where we pause. In two weeks, in part two, we will look at the other end of the road. How these this new way of planning investments is inspiring the UK Treasury to adopt a more systemic view on how they do investment origination and strategic planning. And we will talk also about how investments plan in a region could actually, if thought from a more systemic per perspective, leverage
58:27much more catalytic investments also from other sectors and from other actors than the public sector.
58:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
58:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you for listening to Investing in Regeneration. But before you go, if this conversation sparked new ideas for how we understand, plan or finance projects, I invite you to stay take one small step today. Leave a rating and a review. It helps this podcast reach. the people who are shaping decisions. And please share this episode with a policymaker, a planner, an investor, or anyone who has the agency to influence how projects are originated, designed, and financed. This is not just about spreading a podcast, it's about joining a quiet revolution, reimagining finance, and embracing a new investment paradigm that reconnects people, nature, and the economy. And places finance at the service of life.