The Property Academy Podcast

Steve McKnight and Adrian Nickel outline four metrics for assessing rental market health in an updated 2026 framework.

14 min Listen to the original Episode page
Rental Market AnalysisVacancy RatesNew Zealand PropertyInvestment MetricsMarket Sentiment

Summary

Steve McKnight and Adrian Nickel present an updated framework for evaluating rental market health, focusing on four key metrics. They begin by defining vacancy rate as active TradeMe listings divided by active Tenancy Services bonds, emphasizing that raw listing counts are misleading without context of total rental stock. The second metric, median rent from MyRent, is noted to reflect asking prices rather than transaction values and can be skewed by property mix. The speakers discuss using 'inquiries per listing' and Tony Alexander's investor sentiment surveys to gauge demand. Finally, they contrast manual verification methods, such as the 'two-week test,' with data-driven approaches, warning against over-analysis.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Raw listing counts are insufficient for market health assessment; one must compare listings against the total rental stock in a suburb to derive a meaningful vacancy rate.

    Steve McKnight · 2:28

  2. 2
    A lower vacancy rate indicates a healthier rental market for landlords; for example, Henderson's 3.4% vacancy rate was deemed healthier than Howick's 5% despite having more absolute listings.

    Steve McKnight · 3:08

Episode sections

  1. 0:07 – 1:29

    Introduction and Vacancy Rate Methodology

    Steve McKnight and Adrian Nickel introduce an update to their rental market health check framework. They identify vacancy rate as the first key metric, calculated by dividing active rental listings on TradeMe by the number of active rental bonds held with Tenancy Services.

  2. 1:29 – 5:19

    Comparative Vacancy Analysis Using Tenancy Services

    Steve explains that raw listing counts are misleading without context. He demonstrates comparing Henderson and Howick, showing that while Henderson has more listings, its larger total rental stock results in a lower vacancy rate (3.4%) compared to Howick (5%), indicating a healthier market for landlords.

  3. 5:19 – 7:43

    Median Rent Trends and Data Limitations

    Adrian introduces median rent as the second metric, sourced from MyRent. Steve cautions that median rent data from TradeMe listings reflects asking prices and can be skewed by the mix of properties available in a given month, rather than actual transaction values.

  4. 7:43 – 10:17

    Inquiries Per Listing and Investor Sentiment

    The speakers discuss 'inquiries per listing' as a demand indicator, noting variations between suburbs like Albany, Howick, and Henderson. Steve also references Tony Alexander's survey of property investors to gauge sentiment on the ease of finding tenants.

  5. 10:17 – 13:56

    The Two-Week TradeMe Test and Investment Philosophy

    Steve proposes a manual 'two-week test' of tracking listing views and duration on TradeMe or Realestate.co.nz to verify market clearing. Adrian contrasts this with his simpler approach, emphasizing that while data is useful, over-analysis can prevent investment action.

Claims worth verifying

Vacancy rate in Alizley (transcribed for Algies Bay or similar) is 2.7%, calculated from 45 TradeMe listings and 1,628 active bonds.

Adrian Nickel ·1:13

How to verify: Check current TradeMe rental listings for the specified Auckland suburb and cross-reference with Tenancy Services bond data for the same period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Henderson has 130 rental listings on TradeMe, while Howick has 62 listings.

Steve McKnight ·1:49

How to verify: Search TradeMe for rentals in Henderson and Howick, Auckland, and count the active results. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Howick has approximately 1,200 total rental properties, resulting in a 5% vacancy rate.

Steve McKnight ·2:48

How to verify: Use the Tenancy Services Market Rent Tool to find the total active rental stock for Howick and divide the 62 listings by this total. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Henderson has 3,800 total rental properties, resulting in a 3.4% vacancy rate.

Steve McKnight ·3:28

How to verify: Use the Tenancy Services Market Rent Tool to find the total active rental stock for Henderson and divide the 130 listings by this total. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Margaday Bridge (Margie's Bridge) has 18 rentals available and a vacancy rate of less than 2%.

Steve McKnight ·4:08

How to verify: Check TradeMe for current listings in Margie's Bridge and verify total stock via Tenancy Services to calculate the rate. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Auckland benchmark for vacancy rate is approximately 3.25% (transcribed as three and a quarter percent).

Steve McKnight ·4:08

How to verify: Review historical vacancy rate data from Quotable Value (QV) or Statistics New Zealand for the Auckland region. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Median weekly rent in Albany is $737, up 12% year-on-year from $615 the previous month.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·5:46

How to verify: Check MyRent or TradeMe historical data for Albany median asking rents for the current and previous months. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Inquiries per listing in Albany is 23, compared to 28 in Howick and 28 in Henderson.

Adrian Nickel ·8:02

How to verify: Access MyRent data for Albany, Howick, and Henderson to view the average inquiries per listing metric. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Tony Alexander's survey indicates that more investors currently find it harder to find tenants than easy, but the trend is improving compared to 6-12 months ago.

Steve McKnight ·9:37

How to verify: Review Tony Alexander's Property Investor Sentiment Survey reports for the relevant time periods. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Steve McKnight owns fewer properties and is less wealthy than Adrian Nickel.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·13:03

How to verify: Review public disclosures or financial statements of Opes Partners/Steve McKnight and Adrian Nickel, or public profiles indicating their respective property portfolio sizes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify current active rental listings on TradeMe against Tenancy Services bond data to calculate real-time vacancy rates.
  • Cross-reference MyRent median rent figures with actual lease agreements to assess the gap between asking and achieved rents.
  • Review Tony Alexander's latest investor sentiment survey for qualitative insights on tenant-finding ease.
  • Check the Tenancy Services Market Rent Tool for suburb-specific total rental stock data.
  • Compare vacancy rates across multiple suburbs (e.g., Henderson vs. Howick) to contextualize absolute listing numbers.
  • Monitor 'inquiries per listing' trends on MyRent to gauge short-term demand shifts.
  • Conduct a manual 'two-week test' on TradeMe or Realestate.co.nz to verify listing visibility and duration.
  • Consider the impact of property mix changes on monthly median rent fluctuations.
Full transcriptexpand
0:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hello and
0:08
Steve McKnight: welcome along to the Property Academy Podcast by Obus Partners. I'm your host, Steve McKnight. And
0:12
Adrian Nickel: I'm Adrian Nickel.
0:13
Steve McKnight: And this is the show that helps Kiwis go from zero to five investment properties so you can be financially free and stick around for the next 15 minutes because you're gonna learn how to tell if a rental market is healthy before you buy. The three numbers you can actually look at and where to get every one of them for free in about 10 minutes. Because about five years ago, we
0:33
Steve McKnight: recorded an episode like this about how to give your city's rental market a health check. That was our most downloaded episode in history. And so it's time for an update because there is new data that you can get from a whole heap of different places. So let's go. with the first one. What's first on our list,
0:53
Steve McKnight: Andrew?
0:53
Adrian Nickel: Number one is supply. So how many rentals are looking for a tenant right now? So you jump on TradeMe, search the suburb, and you count the number of listings, and then you can go to tenancy services, which has got all the rental bond data, and then your listings that you found on Trademe divided by your active bonds will give you your vacancy rate. Now, I'll put some numbers
1:13
Adrian Nickel: on this for you. So if we look at Alizley in Auckland, there are 45 listings at the moment on Trade Me. Quite small. And there are 1,628 bonds, which means that if you divide those, you've got a 2.7% vacancy rate.
1:29
Steve McKnight: The difficulty with that though is is that number good or is that number bad? is And so what I like to do is run a couple of different suburbs. I did this in about five. minutes this morning, right? Because if you just go on trade me and like, okay, I've got a property in Henderson, right? So if you go to Henderson in Auckland at the moment, there are
1:49
Steve McKnight: 130 rental properties on Trademe that are looking for a tenant right now. So that's more than the number of like rentals available in a suburb like Howick. So Howick. has got 62 rentals currently looking for a property right now. But you can't just be like, okay, there are
2:09
Steve McKnight: more properties that are currently looking for a tenant right now in Henderson versus Howick. And so therefore, the Henderson rental market is like worse, is sicker, is not as healthy as the Howick rental market. But actually, the number of people or landlords. looking for rentals doesn't mean
2:28
Steve McKnight: anything because maybe there are way more tenants in Henderson than Howick. Or maybe Henderson is a bigger suburb and just happens to have more houses than Howick. So that could make sense. So we've got to compare it to the number of rental properties that actually exist in those suburbs. And it's really easy to do
2:48
Steve McKnight: this. You go to Tenancy Services, Google Tencks. Tenancy Services Market Rent Tool. It'll come up, you search your suburb, and it shows you how many active rental properties there are in that suburb. Well, it turns out that in Howick, there are about 1,200 total rental properties, which means the vacancy rate there is 5%.
3:08
Steve McKnight: 5% Five percent of rental properties in Howick are currently looking for a tenant. Now there are more than twice as many rentals currently looking for a tenant in Henderson. But if you go and use that tool I just told you about, you would see that there are three thousand eight hundred rentals in total in
3:28
Steve McKnight: Henderson, which means their vacancy rate is three point four percent, which actually means that Henderson has a healthier rental market on these numbers. compared to Howick. But if you just went to trade me and said, How many people looking for a tenant right now? Oh my God, it's higher in Henderson, you would miss the fact that there are more than
3:48
Steve McKnight: three times the number of rental properties actually in Henderson. Probably because more people rent. And there might be more properties within that suburb as well. So I'm just trying to say this is how you can put two and two together to try and get something quite useful. And if you did that analysis, you would see that Margaday Bridge, for instance, has only eighteen rentals available.
4:08
Steve McKnight: And because of that, their vacancy rate is less than two percent, which is well under the Auckland benchmark of about three and a quarter percent. Do you see how I mean it's quite fascinating, right? You could do this in five minutes from the comfort of your bed.
4:20
Adrian Nickel: Yeah, I just like the fact that you're such a nerd. Uh no, you're such a whiz on the old spreadsheet that you you're
4:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not going to do. No, it's a nerd. You can say
4:28
Steve McKnight: nerd. That
4:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people
4:29
Adrian Nickel: that people you think people do that in five minutes. But
4:33
Steve McKnight: you go to two websites, put it in a spreadsheet, equals, you know, X divided by Y. Easy. Easy.
4:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
4:41
Steve McKnight: the thing is, the update here is that back when we did this five years ago, you couldn't get how many properties were rentals in each suburb. And so this is something new that you could like that's quite exciting.
4:55
Adrian Nickel: If you can hear the enthusiasm in his voice, just remember that he's already gone through two weeks of explaining this to Angela, who's had to suffer through hearing about how exciting this new tool is on a Sunday night.
5:05
Steve McKnight: Well, let's come to the next thing. So firstly, we can look at the vacancy rate of the suburb, and of course, we need to compare it to other suburbs in the same city or to the city at large.
5:15
Steve McKnight: Where else can we look if we're doing a bit of a health check?
5:19
Adrian Nickel: So I think the next one is rents. So what's actually happening to rents right now? So we're going to look at median rent in the area and which way it's moving. Now remember, median doesn't mean that you're going to have that exact rent and it's going to follow the market perfectly, but it's better than having no data at all. So we use my rent to get this data and uh
5:39
Adrian Nickel: let's do this now because you've got it on your screen. Go to Albany on the north shore of Auckland, and what's the median rent there at the moment?
5:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The median
5:46
Steve McKnight: weekly rent, and this is what people are asking for, right? This is
5:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
5:51
Steve McKnight: people are asking as opposed to necessarily getting. We get this off TradeMe. Median rent there there's is 737 bucks a week. And this is a good example because it looks like it's up 12%. year on year. And then you go, well, that's interesting because I thought the rental market was flat. Well, this is where, as Andrew said, you've got to be very, very careful
6:11
Steve McKnight: with uh median rents. Because if we look at what's being asked, you know, last month the median rent in that suburb was 615 bucks. This month it's $737. So you might go, holy heck, all but the rental market is booming. Median rent is up like
6:31
Steve McKnight: $120 at a month. It's gonna go to the moon. But actually, it'll be because there are different rental properties looking for a tenant this month compared to last month. And it might have been that there were some smaller or more affordable rental properties that came to market last month. And then this month it just so happens that all of those
6:51
Steve McKnight: cheaper properties got rented. And now what's left on the market might be more expensive or more expensive properties might just have happened to rent in that month. And that pushes the median around, right? So yes, love to look at how the median rent in a suburb is looking, but we also need to be a little bit careful with this. And the good thing about my rent is you can look at that
7:11
Steve McKnight: and see, you know, is it a a consistent trend up, which would give you a little bit more confidence that your rental market's becoming healthy? And when I say healthy, I mean healthier for landlords. Obviously, a landlord would prefer a higher rent and a tenant might prefer a lower rent. Whereas if you've got a very spiky rental change, it's up and down and up and down, that might not tell you as
7:31
Steve McKnight: much about what's happening in the suburb, yeah. The other thing while we're on my rent, Andrew, and I'll hand this to you, is the number of inquiries. per listing. This was something that wasn't available last time.
7:43
Adrian Nickel: Yeah, that's this is cool. So you can look at the median inquiries per listing. So again, go to my rent. Let's stick on Albany. So it says here, 23 per listing. Now, again, we don't know if 23 is good or bad. So if we compare that to say Howick, Howick's had 28. So there is a difference there.
8:02
Adrian Nickel: Again, I wouldn't get too caught up in the fact that, oh, well, there's five more, so we must invest in Howick. You want to look at everything here and also use some common sense when you look at the numbers. But certainly it would appear that Albany right now is getting less inquiries per listing than Howick.
8:17
Steve McKnight: Yeah, and if we look at it compared to Henderson at the moment, there's 28 Eight inquiries per listing on average, right? And so you go, okay, that's actually pretty healthy. So if we did, again, I'll use the example, just go on trade me and say how many rental properties are available? Oh, it's higher in one suburb than the other, we might be misled because we think, oh, that's not particularly healthy.
8:37
Steve McKnight: But then we're like, yeah, but if we compare that to the number of rental properties available, it's not that bad. If we look at the number of inquiries each rental listing is getting, that's pretty good. The issue that you've you've got to remember this though, anytime you look at an individual number, is you could say, okay, currently the median days to rent a property in Henderson
8:57
Steve McKnight: is 21 days. But is that good or bad? You'll need to look at a couple of different suburbs to get that baseline. And so I literally did just look at five random suburbs. Like I sat here at my desk thinking, okay, what are some Auckland suburbs? Aliersley, Howick, Marganay Bridge, Pakuranga, and Henderson. Let's get the numbers for these, have a little look-see,
9:17
Steve McKnight: and see how healthy your rental market might be. One of my other favorite things to do is looking at Tony Alexander's survey of property investors, where he asks them, is it getting easier or harder to find a good tenant? Now, some of this is led by people's perceptions of what they're reading in the media at the specific
9:37
Steve McKnight: time, or the last time they happen to rent a property, which could have been 12 months ago rather than this month. Like I'm a property investor, I've got a pretty decent portfolio, but I'm not looking for a new tenant every single month because I've got tenants who are just quite happy within their properties. So you've got to be a little bit careful about people's perceptions. But that does show that at the
9:57
Steve McKnight: moment, more investors are saying that it's hard to find a tenant compared to easy, but we've also got to look at the direction. That started to ease. If I wound back the clock six months, 12 months ago, way more people said that it was harder to find a good tenant compared to easy. And now that proportion is starting to head the right way. So moving in the right direction,
10:17
Steve McKnight: even though on average property investors are reporting, it is a bit harder. The other thing that I like to look at though is how long a place has actually sat there. And so what you might do is pick 10 rentals in your suburb. You might go on to realestate.co.nz or trade me, look at the rental properties that are currently available,
10:37
Steve McKnight: take a screenshot, and then come back in two weeks and see how many are still there. You could take a screenshot and see how many views has each listing had, because you can see this on TradeMe. trade me Like, oh, I'm literally I'm gonna do it right now to show you. I mean I know this isn't like maybe it's not always so interesting to be like Ed
10:57
Steve McKnight: why are you literally just like clicking on things when we can't actually see that but I could go on a property and say okay this property which is 14C Elliott Street in Howick has 585 and eighty-five views on it. I'm gonna going to screenshot this I'm gonna going to come back in two weeks and see if it's rented and see how many page views it's got so that I can
11:17
Steve McKnight: get a sense of are these properties actually moving? What sort of properties are moving? If you're like really keen to like keep a laser eye focus on what's happening in the market. But look to be honest, if you want to just do the easy version, you get my little spreadsheet, you look at the number of bonds, you look at the vacancy rate,
11:36
Steve McKnight: you compare it, and then you move on.
11:39
Adrian Nickel: And I do think getting these numbers is really useful for giving you confidence to invest. But you've also just got to sometimes take a step back and say, well, actually, nothing's going to be perfect. And I'm going to have some good things and some bad things about any investment. And then I'll have some good times and bad times. You should use some of this data. Just don't go too engineering brain on it and and
11:59
Adrian Nickel: over-analyse over analyze it and try and get everything perfect. Because sometimes chasing the unicorn just means you do nothing.
12:04
Steve McKnight: Well I mean this it's quite interesting you bring it up, right? Because sometimes people describe this podcast as you've got the book smart guy and the street smart guy, right? And I love doing all of this. But I can imagine, Andrew, tell me if I'm wrong about this. You wouldn't be bothered doing most of this, eh?
12:20
Adrian Nickel: No, and and I love that you do it sometimes because I I mean I think the one thing so the the tool that I this is just the one I believe. in now. It's the holy grail to me, the overvalued, undervalued that I go on about all the time. That has changed how I invest.
12:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,
12:34
Steve McKnight: that's good. How
12:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we wouldn't go
12:35
Steve McKnight: oh yeah, can
12:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be the however. I
12:37
Adrian Nickel: I however I look at the property and I think, do the numbers make sense. Am I happy with the cash flow? Do I think it'll go up in value? Great. That's what I look at. And most of the time that's worked out very, very well for me because I just don't over analyze it, like I did at the start, when where I just overanalyse. and just never do anything. But again, that comes down to the experience of doing it. And actually, to be fair,
12:57
Adrian Nickel: probably I could have done with with these ty kind of tools at the start of my investing career where I needed to be brave enough to invest.
13:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
13:03
Steve McKnight: I mean, that's nice of you to say, 'cause I was gonna say the exact opposite and say, Look, I do all of this number crunching, which is great, but at the end of the day, Andrew's got more properties and is richer than me.
13:15
Steve McKnight: So, so you can overanalyze. Pick your poison. And over the last 15 minutes, you've learned how to tell if a rental market is healthy before you buy. The three numbers you can actually look at, where to get every one of them for free in about 10 minutes. Right, let's wrap it up there. But please don't forget to rate review and subscribe to the podcast. Really does help us get the message out to more More people. people.
13:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thanks
13:41
Steve McKnight: for listening to the Property Academy Podcast. I'm your host, Seb at Knight. And I'm
13:44
Adrian Nickel: Andrew Nicole.
13:44
Steve McKnight: We're going to be back here tomorrow with even more daily strategies, tactics, and insights to help you get the most out of New Zealand property market. Until next
13:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from The Property Academy Podcast

The Property Academy Podcast

They Were Turned Down By 4 Banks. Now They Can’t Stop Borrowing

Episode discussion: NZ first-home buyer share hits record 29% as speakers detail leveraging equity and overcoming bank rejections

Speakers’ claims: Steve McKnight reports that first-home buyers accounted for 29% of New Zealand home sales in 2026, the highest share since 2005, with many using deposits under 20%. Speakers present case studies illustrating how investors can leverage equity from owner-occupied homes to fund investment properties, despite initial bank rejections. One client overcame a reduced bank valuation by switching to a lender offering 90% loan-to-value ratios, accepting higher risks. Another couple secured lending after renovating a remote property that four banks had previously rejected. The discussion highlights that mortgage advisors can identify capacity for multiple purchases and that 'Investment Ready' services help borrowers qualify for future loans.

New Zealand PropertyMortgage LendingFirst-Home Buyers
14 min1 assets9 claims to verify
The Property Academy Podcast

Where The Old Money ACTUALLY Lives In New Zealand

Episode discussion: Podcast ranks NZ suburbs by wealth generation, contrasting stable old money areas with high-growth gentrifying locations.

Speakers’ claims: Host Stephen Knight and guest Andrew Nicole rank New Zealand suburbs into old, new, and brand-new money categories to identify gentrification patterns. They classify Epsom, Stanley Point, and Remuera as old money, noting their stability but lower percentage growth. In contrast, suburbs like Wanaka, Ponsonby, and Arrowtown are identified as new or brand-new money, having experienced significant value appreciation due to population shifts and urban renewal. The speakers argue that investing in gentrifying areas historically yields higher returns than established wealthy suburbs. They provide specific historical sales data and investment growth comparisons to support these classifications.

New Zealand Real EstateSuburb AnalysisGentrification
22 min0 assets9 claims to verify
All insights