Retirement GPS - Navigated by Zynergy

Retirement GPS: Reinvesting Dividends vs Taking Cash in Retirement

12 min Listen to the original Episode page
Dividend InvestingRetirement PlanningTax EfficiencyPortfolio RebalancingTotal Return

Summary

Ryan Zaharczyk of Zynergy Retirement Planning argues that total return, not dividend yield, is the critical metric for retirees. He contends that dividends are merely a transfer of profits and that relying on high yields can lead to significant losses if cuts occur, citing AT&T as a cautionary tale. For taxable accounts, he recommends taking dividends and interest as cash first to avoid double taxation, rather than reinvesting them. Zaharczyk also advises against automatic dividend reinvestment, suggesting instead that investors let cash accumulate to rebalance portfolios efficiently.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    That was great until ATT realized they can't afford to continue to pay an 8% dividend because they're not making that kind of money. They had to slash their dividend down to 1%. And the stock also in turn fell about 25% after that happened.

    Ryan Zaharczyk · 5:15

  2. 2
    Automatic dividend reinvestment can disrupt portfolio rebalancing; letting cash accumulate allows investors to use those funds to buy underweight assets (e.g., bonds when stocks are up), maintaining target allocations without selling appreciated assets.

    Ryan Zaharczyk · 8:18

Episode sections

  1. 0:43 – 2:03

    Introduction and Episode Topic

    Ryan Zaharczyk introduces episode 68 of the Retirement GPS podcast, hosted by Zynergy Retirement Planning. He outlines the central question: whether retirees should reinvest dividends or take them as cash income.

  2. 2:03 – 4:02

    Dividends vs. Total Return

    Zaharczyk defines dividends as a transfer of profits to shareholders and emphasizes that total return (dividends plus price appreciation) is the critical metric for investors, not dividends alone. He notes that both components are taxed similarly in taxable accounts.

  3. 4:02 – 5:01

    Psychology of Dividend Income

    The speaker explains that retirees often prefer dividends because they feel like a natural paycheck and avoid the psychological discomfort of selling shares. He argues this is a flawed view, as dividends are not guaranteed and carry similar risks to growth.

  4. 5:01 – 5:55

    Case Study: AT&T Dividend Cut

    Zaharczyk cites AT&T as an example where an 8% dividend was unsustainable and slashed to 1%, causing the stock price to fall approximately 25%. This illustrates that relying on high yields can lead to significant total return losses.

  5. 5:55 – 7:38

    Tax-Efficient Withdrawal Strategy

    For taxable accounts, the speaker recommends using dividends and interest as the first source of withdrawal to avoid double taxation. He advises against reinvesting these cash flows if they are needed for living expenses, as selling other assets to replace them is tax-inefficient.

  6. 7:38 – 9:09

    Rebalancing via Cash Reserves

    Zaharczyk argues against automatic dividend reinvestment in diversified portfolios. Instead, he suggests letting cash accumulate and using it to rebalance the portfolio (e.g., buying bonds when stocks are up), which avoids transaction costs and maintains target allocations.

  7. 9:09 – 12:15

    Taxation by Account Type

    The speaker distinguishes between tax-advantaged accounts (where dividends are not taxed until withdrawal) and taxable accounts. In taxable accounts, dividends are typically taxed at 15% for most brackets, while interest is taxed as ordinary income unless from municipal bonds.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
COCA COLA COKOequityneutralif I'm investing in companies like Coca-Cola or ATT or GE, these companies that have been around for a hundred years and pay a comfortable dividend, that makes me feel more
AT&T INC.Tequityneutralif I'm investing in companies like Coca-Cola or ATT or GE, these companies that have been around for a hundred years and pay a comfortable dividend, that makes me feel more comfortable. Unfortunately, that's not entirely true or entirely accurate. ATT was one of the biggest dividend payers for quite some time, and I had several people come to me and want to put more of their money in ATT to capture their at the time 8% dividend.
S&P 500indexneutralhave 50% of my portfolio in the SP 500 and 50% in the total bond index, I have a straightforward 50-50 portfolio of stocks and bonds. Both pay dividends and interest, right? So the SP 500 will pay its dividends, the bond fund will pay its interest. But let's say that the bond fund is having a bad year and the stock fund is having a good year. Why do I want to take my stock dividends and reinvest them into more stocks when now I've drifted and fifty-five percent of my portfolio is in the SP 500 and 45 is in bonds.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

AT&T cut its dividend from 8% to 1% and its stock fell approximately 25% after the cut.

Ryan Zaharczyk ·5:15

How to verify: Check AT&T (T) historical dividend announcements and stock price data from 2026-2026 via SEC EDGAR filings (Form 8-K) or financial data providers like Yahoo Finance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Dividends are taxed as capital gains in taxable accounts.

Ryan Zaharczyk ·3:42

How to verify: Consult IRS Publication 17 or IRS Form 1040 Schedule D instructions regarding qualified dividends taxation rates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Dividends are typically taxed at 15% for most income brackets in taxable accounts.

Ryan Zaharczyk ·9:29

How to verify: Check IRS Publication 17 for current qualified dividend tax rates based on filing status and taxable income. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Interest is taxed as ordinary income unless from tax-exempt sources like municipal bonds.

Ryan Zaharczyk ·9:57

How to verify: Consult IRS Publication 17 regarding taxation of interest income and municipal bond interest exclusions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Zynergy Retirement Planning is a registered investment advisor located in Red Bank, New Jersey.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·12:05

How to verify: Search the SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure (IAPD) website for Zynergy Retirement Planning, Inc. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Zynergy Retirement Planning is located in Red Bank, New Jersey.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·12:05

How to verify: Check the firm’s Form ADV Part 2A filed with the SEC or state regulators via IAPD. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The podcast episode is episode 68 of Retirement GPS.

Ryan Zaharczyk ·0:43

How to verify: Check the podcast feed or website for Retirement GPS episode numbering. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Dividends are a transfer of profits from a company to shareholders.

Ryan Zaharczyk ·2:03

How to verify: Consult corporate finance textbooks or SEC definitions of dividends in Form 10-K annual reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Total return is the sum of dividends and price growth.

Ryan Zaharczyk ·3:02

How to verify: Verify standard financial definitions of total return from sources like Investopedia or CFA Institute curriculum. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

AT&T had an 8% dividend yield before cutting it.

Ryan Zaharczyk ·5:01

How to verify: Check historical dividend yield data for AT&T (T) prior to 2026 via financial data providers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify AT&T's dividend history and stock price performance around the 2022 cut using SEC filings (DEF 14A) or financial data providers like Bloomberg or Yahoo Finance.
  • Confirm current qualified dividend tax rates for your specific income bracket using IRS Publication 17 or a tax professional.
  • Review your portfolio's current asset allocation to determine if automatic dividend reinvestment is causing drift from target weights.
  • Calculate the tax impact of taking dividends vs. selling shares in your taxable accounts using a tax calculator or software.
  • Check the dividend sustainability of any high-yield holdings by analyzing their payout ratios and free cash flow in recent 10-K or 10-Q filings.
  • Assess whether your brokerage offers commission-free reinvestment and compare the transaction costs of manual rebalancing versus automatic reinvestment.
  • Consult a fiduciary financial advisor to model withdrawal strategies that minimize Medicare IRMAA surcharges and overall tax liability.
Full transcriptexpand
0:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to Retirement GPS. Navigate it by Zenergy, your roadmap to a secure and confident retirement. Each week, we explore strategies, stories, and planning frameworks designed to help you navigate the complexities of life after work. From tax planning to investments, income strategies to
0:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): risk management, our goal is to give you the clarity and confidence you need to make informed decisions. But retirement isn't just about the numbers, it's also about lifestyle, purpose, and peace of mind. We're here to guide you through both the financial details and the personal dimensions of this next chapter.
0:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Let's chart today's course.
0:43
Ryan Zaharczyk: Hello, and welcome back to the episode 68 of our retirement GPS podcast. I'm your host, Ryan Zaharczyk. certified financial planner and president of Zenergy Retirement Planning. And I want to talk today about a question that we get from time to time regarding dividends in your investment accounts. And the question is: should I reinvest my dividends when
1:03
Ryan Zaharczyk: I get into retirement? Or, like my working years, should I let those dividends reinvest back into the funds or into the stocks? And it's understandable because typically reinvesting dividends is automatic, especially in a 401k where income is constantly reinvested back into the portfolio. Cash is reinvested
1:23
Ryan Zaharczyk: back into the portfolio. But in retirement, investors may wonder whether dividends should be deposited into their checking instead, effectively because it's a common belief that if I live off my dividends and my interest, I won't touch my principal, which is not entirely true. in our experience. And when does it make sense to have the dividends automatically
1:43
Ryan Zaharczyk: distributed? When does it make sense to not and leave the dividends within the account? So we're going to dive into this message. This isn't going to be a long podcast because this isn't really that complicated a subject, but we want to make sure that you understand what dividends are, the different types of income that that can be produced from dividends, the different types of accounts and how they're
2:03
Ryan Zaharczyk: taxable, and then what you should do. So let's start with dividends. What happens when dividends are paid? Dividends are effectively a transfer from the company to the shareholder of profits, right? So if a company has a certain amount of profits, let's say a company has $2 per share per quarter of profits. That's $8 a
2:22
Ryan Zaharczyk: year. They may decide that every quarter we're going to transfer $25 cents of that $2 or 50 cents of that $2 to our shareholders. So we're going to keep and reinvest the rest into our business to grow our business. And we're going to take a certain portion of that cash and give it back to shareholders to reward them for their loyalty. And that's what a
2:42
Ryan Zaharczyk: dividend is. The key to remember though is a dividend alone does not equal total return. And one thing that retirees often get hungry hung up on is making sure that they have enough dividends and interest to to pay their needs, to pay for their income requirements. And the answer is no, we we're less concerned about dividends and more concerned about total
3:02
Ryan Zaharczyk: return. Total return is the total of dividends income that is paid throughout the year, as well as the growth of the investment itself, right? So in a simple example, if I have a hundred dollar stock by the end of the year it goes to $105, and then it pays out a dollar in dividends, the total return is the $1 in dividend
3:22
Ryan Zaharczyk: plus the $5 in growth, or six total dollars, 6% in that case. So a 6% growth on a stock may only have 1% of that growth be from dividends and 5% percent from the growth. And we don't really care where it comes from. Both are taxed the same way. Dividends are taxed. as capital gains are. So if it's in a taxable account, we really
3:42
Ryan Zaharczyk: don't care where the growth comes from. I would much rather have a company that grows from 100 to 120 and pays zero dividends than a company that pays five dollars in dividends and gets no growth. And this is something that we often have to talk to our members about to explain to them that dividends are nice. It's cash that's in your pocket, but number one they're not
4:02
Ryan Zaharczyk: guaranteed. And number two, we're mostly concerned about total return, because that's really all the money that goes into your pocket. Why r retirees like dividend income is because it feels like a natural paycheck. It feels like it's income that's coming in. The problem with that is that it only typically comes in once a quarter. So if you're looking for a monthly paycheck,
4:22
Ryan Zaharczyk: dividends are not really a great example of that. There's no investment sale that appears necessary, so they feel like they don't have to sell anything. If I had a hundred shares before, then I have a hundred shares after. And that may s psychologically feel comfortable to say I don't ever have to sell my stock. But the truth is I have no problem selling my stock if the material
4:41
Ryan Zaharczyk: value is a lot more after the sale than it was before the sale. Understanding that dividend paying companies can often be more stable and make you feel more comfortable because if I'm investing in companies like Coca-Cola or ATT or GE, these companies that have been around for a hundred years and pay a comfortable dividend, that makes me feel more
5:01
Ryan Zaharczyk: comfortable. Unfortunately, that's not entirely true or entirely accurate. ATT was one of the biggest dividend payers for quite some time, and I had several people come to me and want to put more of their money in ATT to capture their at the time 8% dividend.
5:15
Ryan Zaharczyk: That was great until ATT realized they can't afford to continue to pay an 8% dividend because they're not making that kind of money. They had to slash their dividend down to 1%. And the stock also in turn fell about 25% after that happened. Once that happened, the total return now was significantly less than anybody who was is counting on that
5:35
Ryan Zaharczyk: 8% dividend. So dividends, although feel comfortable, they're certainly not guaranteed and they have just as much risk as growth. When taking cash dividends makes sense. So the one of the things that retirees often do is we set up regular distributions for our retirees from their portfolios. What we want to do, if they have a
5:55
Ryan Zaharczyk: taxable account that does pay dividends and interest, interests, we want to make sure that we're taking those dividends and interests interest and distributing them. So first and foremost. they're living off of that dividend and that interest. And what do I mean by that? Let's use a simple example that if I have a million dollar portfolio in my brokerage account that's taxable, and I have a million dollars in my pre-tax IRA,
6:16
Ryan Zaharczyk: um, I may want to draw, because it's two million dollars, and if I'm using a simple five 5% percent rule, I may want to draw a $100,000 hundred thousand dollars a year from that portfolio. So let's just say we're gonna round it off and say we're gonna draw $8,000 a month every single month from our portfolio. $4,000 might come from the taxable account,
6:36
Ryan Zaharczyk: $4,000 might come from the pre-tax account, and it might not break out that way.
6:40
Ryan Zaharczyk: We actually do the math to figure out exactly where we want to draw from to minimize our tax brackets. We may actually draw more from the IRA, we may draw less from the IRA, but the first money we're always gonna going take to are the dividends. and the interest from the taxable account. Why? Because that money is already taxed, whether we take it or not. So it doesn't make a lot of sense to reinvest those dividends and interest
7:00
Ryan Zaharczyk: back into the investments and then later turn around and sell the investments. So we just let the cash build in the account. We take the monthly distribution. The cash really It never ever sits very long because every month we're taking it anyway. So the money comes out a few weeks after it's paid. So it's pretty simple to set up a portfolio in that way to make sure that those dividends and
7:20
Ryan Zaharczyk: interest are being paid out as your first distributions, because really it's the most tax-efficient way to do it. It makes very little sense to have your dividends and interest reinvested, pull all of your money from your IRA and pay tax twice. The money that's continuing to accumulate and the money that comes out of the IRA.
7:38
Ryan Zaharczyk: When reinvesting dividends may make sense, if you just don't need the income, right? So if you're in retirement, you really don't need the income, you're not drawing, sure, reinvest the dividends. Now, the question we get a lot is why don't you reinvest the dividends automatically back into the funds that they came from? And I don't believe in that, especially in a diversified portfolio. Let's use another simple example. If I
7:58
Ryan Zaharczyk: have 50% of my portfolio in the SP 500 and 50% in the total bond index, I have a straightforward 50-50 portfolio of stocks and bonds. Both pay dividends and interest, right? So the SP 500 will pay its dividends, the bond fund will pay its interest. But let's say that the bond fund is having a bad year and the stock
8:18
Ryan Zaharczyk: fund is having a good year. Why do I want to take my stock dividends and reinvest them into more stocks when now I've drifted and fifty-five percent of my portfolio is in the SP 500 and 45 is in bonds. Eventually I have to sell some stocks, buy bonds, so I can rebalance back to 50-50. If I just let the
8:38
Ryan Zaharczyk: cash settle in the account, and every so often when I see there's cash in the portfolio, I reinvest it to continue to rebalance, i.e., if the stocks are up and the bonds are down, I'll buy some more of the bond fund using that. cash. And now we're back closer to 50 50 without continuing to reinvest in something that's already done very
8:58
Ryan Zaharczyk: well and is becoming too large a percentage of the portfolio that we have to rebalance anyway. It's really a good way to think about it is to keep us in balance and move us closer to our target portfolio.
9:09
Ryan Zaharczyk: Let's talk about taxation on account types. type. So if you're invested in a retirement account, you don't have to worry about anything any of this, right? Because dividends and interest are not taxable until you pull the money out. So it really doesn't matter. Just reinvest back into the portfolio and give yourself the ability to use your dividends and interest to continue to rebalance back to your target. However, in a taxable
9:29
Ryan Zaharczyk: account, dividends specifically are tax efficient, right? Typically for most people, in most brackets, they're taxed at fifteen 15%. percent.
9:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
9:37
Ryan Zaharczyk: unless you have a really high income or a really low income, you're going to be taxed at 15% on your dividends. That's a pretty reasonable tax in today's world. So let's take that tax and live off that, that income, if we're drawing from our portfolios anyway. Interest is taxed at ordinary income for the most part, unless there's a specific type of account that
9:57
Ryan Zaharczyk: has a tax-efficient tax efficient interest, which would be something like a tax-free municipal bond fund. But otherwise, you're going
10:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
10:02
Ryan Zaharczyk: be taxed at ordinary. income. So we also would want to live off of that because, again, we're already paying the taxes as it comes up.
10:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
10:11
Ryan Zaharczyk: just remember that retirees do not need to choose between living on dividends and spending principle. Dividends and interest and price appreciation are all components of total return. And we want to be really sensitive to the fact that it's total return we care about. We do want to manage some tax strategies where we can, but let's focus on total
10:31
Ryan Zaharczyk: return. Take the cash the retirement plan requires and just make sure that you're accounting for the taxability of the different accounts. That's what we're always looking at when we're planning for retirement for our people here at Zenergy. What are the different types of accounts? What are the brackets we're trying to manage? What's the Medicare thresholds we're trying to manage? And how do we pull to
10:51
Ryan Zaharczyk: efficiently and effectively accomplish our goals, but keep us in those reasonable brackets? That's it, guys. I hope you learned a bit today about how to manage dividends within your accounts. And again, if you have any questions, feel free to reach out. You can shoot us an email. You can call the office. And we'd love to help you out and answer any questions that you
11:11
Ryan Zaharczyk: may have. In the meantime, make sure you subscribe to our podcast so you get this great information. in your inbox every Tuesday morning. And keep learning and keep growing.
11:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): To explore today's topic further, visit our blog Mile Markers at ZenergyRetirement.com/slash blog, where we offer detailed strategies, examples, and downloadable tools to support your retirement journey. Follow us on LinkedIn, Instagram, and Facebook at Zenergy Retirement Planning for weekly insights, checklists, and
11:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): planning reminders. If you found this episode helpful, please subscribe, leave a five-star review, and share it with someone planning for their future. Until next time, keep navigating toward a confident retirement. This podcast is for informational purposes only and is not intended as investment, legal, or tax advice. Listeners should consult their own financial tax and legal advisors
12:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): before making any decisions. Zenergy Retirement Planning is a registered investment advisor located in Red Bank, New Jersey.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Retirement GPS - Navigated by Zynergy

All insights