Economy & Finance

US sells $13B Venezuelan oil with $12.7B discrepancy; Citgo sold to Elliott for $5.89B

39 min Listen to the original Episode page
Venezuela OilSovereign DebtGeopoliticsLegal ImmunityDistressed Assets

Summary

The episode details a $12.7B discrepancy between US sales of Venezuelan oil and recorded revenue in Caracas, with only $300M of $13B in sales reaching official ledgers. Executive Order 14373 granted legal immunity to these funds, though initial sales were routed through Qatar to avoid US legal traps like TRIA Section 201. Citgo was auctioned in Delaware to Elliott Investment Management for $5.89B after courts pierced PDVESA's corporate veil. Meanwhile, 31 tons of Venezuelan gold remain stuck in London due to the UK's 'one voice principle' regarding diplomatic recognition. The US provided $310M in aid for $37B in earthquake damage while political tensions rise over transparency and leadership recognition.

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 2:29

    Venezuela Oil Revenue Discrepancy

    US sold ~$13B of Venezuelan oil since Jan, but only $300M was recorded in Caracas' ledger, per FT analysis. A $12.7B discrepancy exists between oil exports and recorded revenue. GDP grew only 2.5% despite a 25% surge in crude exports.

  2. 2:29 – 7:24

    Legal Structure of Oil Revenue Custody

    Venezuela is compared to a corporate bankruptcy with $150-170B in debts. Executive Order 14373 granted legal immunity to oil revenues held in US Treasury accounts to protect them from creditors. However, the first $500M sale proceeded to an offshore Qatar account instead of a US Treasury account.

  3. 7:24 – 13:53

    Legal Reasons for Offshore Routing

    Routing funds to Qatar avoided two legal traps: TRIA Section 201, which allows terrorism victims to seize assets of entities assisting terrorist groups (applied to PDVESA), and US court recognition of the 2015 National Assembly rather than the interim government. Qatar recognizes whoever holds power, avoiding these jurisdictional conflicts.

  4. 13:53 – 22:46

    Citgo Refinery Auction and Hedge Fund Acquisition

    Citgo, owned by PDVESA, was auctioned in Delaware after courts pierced the corporate veil, ruling PDVESA was an alter ego of the Venezuelan state. Amber Energy (Elliott Investment Management) won the auction for $5.89B. The deal requires OFAC license approval.

  5. 22:46 – 31:35

    Venezuelan Gold Stuck in London

    31 tons of Venezuelan gold (~$4B) are held by the Bank of England. UK courts cannot release it due to the 'one voice principle' and conflicting recognition of Venezuelan leadership. The UK government currently does not recognize the Maduro administration, leaving the gold in legal limbo.

  6. 31:35 – 39:26

    Earthquake Response and Political Context

    Venezuela suffered $37B in earthquake damage. The US provided ~$310M in aid and military support. Interim President Delcy Rodriguez faces public backlash, while Nobel laureate Maria Corina Machado was barred from entering. The US State Department describes the oil revenue arrangement as custodial, while President Trump described it as profitable.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
GoldcommodityneutralUK court documents valued it at around $2 billion in 2020, and since gold has done rather well, it's now worth somewhere north of $4 billion.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

The US government sold roughly $13 billion of Venezuelan oil since January, with only $300 million recorded in Caracas' ledger.

Narrator ·0:00

How to verify: Check Financial Times analysis of Venezuelan oil exports vs. official government ledger data from Caracas.

Venezuela's first quarter GDP grew by just 2.5%, its weakest performance in nearly five years, despite a 25% surge in crude exports.

Francisco Rodriguez ·1:25

How to verify: Check World Bank or IMF data for Venezuela Q1 GDP growth and OPEC/IEA data for crude export volumes.

Earthquake damage to property and infrastructure in Venezuela has been estimated at $37 billion.

Narrator ·2:04

How to verify: Check UN Office for Disaster Risk Reduction reports or Venezuelan government damage assessments.

Venezuela owes between $150 and $170 billion to creditors.

Narrator ·2:38

How to verify: Check IMF sovereign debt reports or creditor lawsuits filed in US/UK courts.

Executive Order 14373 was issued on January 9th to grant legal immunity to Venezuelan oil revenues.

Narrator ·3:50

How to verify: Search Federal Register for Executive Order 14373 and its issuance date.

The first $500 million of Venezuelan crude sales was routed to an offshore bank account in Qatar.

Narrator ·4:54

How to verify: Check US Treasury announcements or news reports on the first post-January oil sale transactions.

Section 201 of the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act (TRIA) allows seizure of blocked assets of entities assisting terrorist groups.

Narrator ·8:40

How to verify: Read 15 U.S.C. § 671 et seq., specifically Section 201 of TRIA.

Citgo is a 113-year-old American company owned by Venezuela's state oil company since 1990.

Narrator ·14:21

How to verify: Check Citgo corporate history or SEC filings for ownership records.

Amber Energy won the Citgo auction with a bid of $5.89 billion.

Narrator ·20:34

How to verify: Check Delaware Court of Chancery records for the Citgo auction results and bid amounts.

Venezuelan gold held by the Bank of England is worth north of $4 billion.

Narrator ·23:23

How to verify: Check Bank of England custody reports or market data on gold prices and Venezuela's reserve holdings.

Do your own research

  • Verify the $12.7B revenue discrepancy using FT analysis and US Treasury custodial reports.
  • Review Executive Order 14373 and IEEPA powers regarding legal immunity for Venezuelan oil revenues.
  • Check US court rulings on TRIA Section 201 and its application to PDVESA as a materially assisting entity.
  • Examine Delaware court documents regarding the piercing of PDVESA's corporate veil and Citgo auction details.
  • Confirm the status of the $5.89B Elliott Investment Management deal and OFAC license requirements.
  • Research the UK Bank of England's holdings of Venezuelan gold and the 'one voice principle' legal constraints.
  • Audit KPMG's unpublished audits of the US custodial arrangement for transparency.
  • Verify US State Department statements on the custodial nature of oil revenues versus President Trump's profitable characterization.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker: Since January, the United States government has sold roughly $13 billion of Venezuelan oil, and there's an official government ledger online in Caracas that tracks what Venezuela received for it.
0:13
Unidentified speaker: I've had a quick look through it, and I'm pleased to report that it's a very easy read.
0:19
Unidentified speaker: It contains just one entry, a single transfer of $300 million recorded back in March.
0:26
Unidentified speaker: For a country sitting on the largest proven crude reserves on the planet, that's what accountants would describe as a light quarter.
0:35
Unidentified speaker: The 13 billion figure comes from analysis by the Financial Times, which leaves a $12.7 billion discrepancy between the oil that left and the money that arrived.
0:47
Unidentified speaker: Now, I'm sure that there's a perfectly good explanation and that it's all in a spreadsheet somewhere.
0:54
Unidentified speaker: When the US removed Nicholas Maduro in January and installed his vice president Delcy Rodriguez as interim leader, President Trump said the United States was stepping in to get the oil flowing and that the revenues would be held in a custodial capacity.
1:12
Unidentified speaker: The State Department later added that financial monitoring was underway and that billions of dollars had been dispersed to the Venezuelan economy.
1:21
Unidentified speaker: Those billions are proving difficult to locate.
1:25
Unidentified speaker: Francisco Rodriguez, a Venezuelan economist at the Center for Economic and Policy Research in Washington, pointed out to the FT that despite a 25% surge in crude exports this year, Venezuela's first quarter GDP grew by just 2.5%, its weakest performance in nearly five years.
1:47
Unidentified speaker: So the oil is definitely leaving.
1:49
Unidentified speaker: It's just the money coming back that seems a bit shy.
1:53
Unidentified speaker: This is all happening at a terrible time for the country.
1:57
Unidentified speaker: Last month Venezuela was hit by twin earthquakes of magnitude 7.2 and 7.5.
2:04
Unidentified speaker: Thousands of people were killed, tens of thousands were left homeless, and the damage to property and infrastructure has been estimated at $37 billion, close to a third of the entire economy.
2:17
Unidentified speaker: Now, to be fair to the White House, there are good reasons why you might want to hold Venezuela's oil revenues in a safe account rather than handing them over on a wooden pallet.
2:29
Unidentified speaker: To understand why you have to think of Venezuela as a corporate bankruptcy that happens to have a flag and a seat at the UN.
2:38
Unidentified speaker: Years of mismanagement, corruption, and enthusiastic expropriation under Hugo Chavez and Nicolas Maduro have left the country owing somewhere between $150 and $170 billion to a large and deeply unamused group of creditors, Wall Street bondholders, foreign governments, and a long line of companies whose refineries and gold mines were seized without anybody offering to pay for them.
3:06
Unidentified speaker: Now, in a normal corporate bankruptcy, a court steps in and freezes all of the claims so that the business can be unwound in an orderly fashion.
3:15
Unidentified speaker: Without that shield, the moment the company tried to deposit a check, its creditors would be in court trying to grab it.
3:23
Unidentified speaker: Countries don't get bankruptcy courts.
3:26
Unidentified speaker: There's no judge who can tell a hundred creditors to form an orderly queue.
3:31
Unidentified speaker: So if Venezuelan oil were sold on the open market through ordinary commercial banks, dozens of judgment holders would be in federal court grabbing at the proceeds.
3:42
Unidentified speaker: Every tanker leaving port and every dollar sent back to buy spare parts would be seized long before it reached Caracas.
3:50
Unidentified speaker: The solution was Executive Order 14373, issued on January 9th, which used emergency powers under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, or AIPA, to grant legal immunity to Venezuelan oil revenues held in US Treasury accounts.
4:09
Unidentified speaker: On paper, a legal safe house.
4:12
Unidentified speaker: The money is protected from creditors so that it can be used to rebuild the country's collapsed energy sector.
4:19
Unidentified speaker: The difficulty with a legal safe house is that it only works if everybody trusts the person holding the key.
4:26
Unidentified speaker: A bankruptcy trustee has to publish audited financial statements every quarter so that creditors and the public can see that nobody is dipping into the till.
4:37
Unidentified speaker: Six months in, the White House has published almost nothing.
4:41
Unidentified speaker: The quarterly audits promised from KPMG have not appeared, which has led lawmakers from both parties to ask why Congress is being kept in the dark.
4:52
Unidentified speaker: And it only gets stranger.
4:54
Unidentified speaker: When the administration arranged its first sale of Venezuelan crude for $500 million, the money didn't go into a US Treasury account at all.
5:04
Unidentified speaker: It went into an offshore bank account in Qatar, which is not where I would have put it, but then again I've never had to hide half a billion dollars from anyone.
5:15
Unidentified speaker: The reason involves American victims of terrorism and a legal trap that Executive Order 14373 could do nothing about.
5:25
Unidentified speaker: But before we get to that, let me tell you about this week's video sponsor, Taylorstore, who I've been getting all of my new shirts from over the last year.
5:33
Unidentified speaker: Taylorstore make a custom clothes designed for your body.
5:37
Unidentified speaker: So everything you buy from them fits perfectly.
5:40
Unidentified speaker: And to me, that makes a huge difference.
5:43
Unidentified speaker: All you do is enter a few details on their website, they calculate a size for you and make a shirt that fits you perfectly.
5:51
Unidentified speaker: If it's not perfect the first time, they'll remake it for free.
5:55
Unidentified speaker: You can design your own shirt if that's what you want, or you can pick one of their designs.
6:00
Unidentified speaker: The online tool lets you specify everything color shapes, cuffs, fabrics, the type of buttons, and even monograms, so your style really shows through.
6:11
Unidentified speaker: This is their Phoenix white shirt with cutaway classic collar, convertible cuffs, and mother of pearl buttons.
6:18
Unidentified speaker: Taylor Store have helped over 300,000 customers since the company was founded in 2003, and they ship fast.
6:26
Unidentified speaker: So even though your shirts are made to measure, you won't be waiting around for them.
6:31
Unidentified speaker: Unlike traditional retail, nothing is produced in advance.
6:35
Unidentified speaker: So there are no piles of unsold stock, meaning far less waste.
6:39
Unidentified speaker: Taylor Store own their own production facilities, so they've removed all of the unnecessary middle layers that usually push prices up.
6:48
Unidentified speaker: What you're paying for is quality.
6:50
Unidentified speaker: If you want a more practical, smarter way to shop for clothes that fit you perfectly, click the link in the description.
6:57
Unidentified speaker: TaylorStore is offering my viewers 25% off their first order if they use the link and discount code below.
7:05
Unidentified speaker: It's a great way to get clothes custom made at a price that actually makes sense.
7:10
Unidentified speaker: To understand how the White House ended up running Venezuelan crude sales through a bank in Doha, you have to look at the testimony Secretary of State Marco Rubio gave to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee in January.
7:24
Unidentified speaker: Rubio described routing the first $500 million through Qatar as a short-term fix to a short-term problem.
7:32
Unidentified speaker: And there was a real problem.
7:34
Unidentified speaker: PEDEVESA, Venezuela's state oil company, was running out of places to store the oil.
7:41
Unidentified speaker: Tankers were sitting offshore full of extra heavy crude with nowhere to unload.
7:46
Unidentified speaker: And if the oil didn't move, the oil wells would have to be shut down, which risks permanent damage to the wells.
7:54
Unidentified speaker: So the US administration brought in Vital and Trafficura to sell the stockpile, with the proceeds landing in an account in Qatar National Bank under US supervision.
8:07
Unidentified speaker: So why a Qatari bank account?
8:10
Unidentified speaker: Well, as Scott Anderson and Alex Zerdin pointed out in an analysis for lawfare, there were two legal problems associated with putting that money into an American bank account, and they're both good ones.
8:24
Unidentified speaker: Ordinarily, when a president uses AIPA to freeze foreign assets, those assets are protected from court judgments.
8:32
Unidentified speaker: That's how the Bush administration held Iraqi oil revenues after 2003 when the country was being rebuilt.
8:40
Unidentified speaker: But in 2002, Congress passed Section 201 of the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act, or TRIA, which is what lawyers call a notwithstanding provision.
8:51
Unidentified speaker: The statute opens by saying that notwithstanding any other provision of law, anyone holding an unsatisfied court judgment against a terrorist party can seize that party's blocked assets in the United States, including, and this is the part that matters, the blocked assets of any agency or instrumentality of that party.
9:14
Unidentified speaker: And notwithstanding provision is Congress writing a law and adding in advance that it beats whatever else you were about to cite.
9:23
Unidentified speaker: It's the legislative equivalent of I don't want to hear it.
9:27
Unidentified speaker: Venezuela has a big problem with that clause.
9:31
Unidentified speaker: US prosecutors have repeatedly accused the Maduro regime of assisting designated foreign terrorist organizations, the Columbia guerrilla groups FARC and ELN and criminal outfits like Trenda Aguera.
9:45
Unidentified speaker: The Second and 11th circuits have read agency or instrumentality very broadly, holding that it can cover an entity that merely materially assisted a terrorist party or played a significant role in its activities.
10:01
Unidentified speaker: District courts have taken that standard and applied it to PEDAVESA, allowing people holding judgments against FARC to go after a Venezuelan oil company's frozen assets.
10:14
Unidentified speaker: So the State Oil Company of Venezuela is, for the purposes of this particular statute, a subsidiary of a Colombian guerrilla movement, corporate structures can be complicated.
10:27
Unidentified speaker: These judgments run to hundreds of millions of dollars.
10:31
Unidentified speaker: If that first $500 million had touched a bank in New York or a US Treasury account, lawyers for the terrorism victims would have been filing attachment orders long before the wire even cleared.
10:44
Unidentified speaker: The money would have gone straight into litigation and none of it would have reached Caracas.
10:49
Unidentified speaker: By routing it through Doha, the US government put it beyond the physical reach of an American court.
10:56
Unidentified speaker: The second problem is even better, and that's because the White House created it itself.
11:02
Unidentified speaker: It turns out that the person in Venezuela that the US government talks to on the phone is not necessarily the person the US courts think is in charge.
11:13
Unidentified speaker: In Caracas, the administration deals directly with interim president Delcy Rodriguez.
11:20
Unidentified speaker: Inside the federal court system, official recognition policy has been sitting undisturbed since 2019 when Donald Trump recognized opposition leader Juan Guardo.
11:32
Unidentified speaker: As far as the courts are concerned, the opposition-led 2015 National Assembly is still the only body entitled to control Venezuelan state property in America.
11:43
Unidentified speaker: So the executive branch is negotiating with one Venezuelan government while the judicial branch holds the assets for a different one.
11:52
Unidentified speaker: The United States is disagreeing with itself about who runs Venezuela.
11:57
Unidentified speaker: AIPA lets the president freeze assets to stop them from moving.
12:02
Unidentified speaker: It doesn't let him take ownership of them and hand money to someone else.
12:07
Unidentified speaker: That's a wartime power, and this isn't war.
12:10
Unidentified speaker: Freezing is a lock on the door, it isn't a deed.
12:14
Unidentified speaker: So if the administration had put $500 million into a US account and then wired it to Delcy Rodriguez, representatives of the 2015 National Assembly could have walked into court and argued that the executive branch was giving away their money, and they'd have had a point.
12:34
Unidentified speaker: Qatar has no such difficulty.
12:37
Unidentified speaker: Qatar never recognized Juan Guardo or the 2015 National Assembly.
12:43
Unidentified speaker: Qatar recognizes whoever is in the presidential palace, which is a foreign policy with the great advantage of never needing to be updated.
12:53
Unidentified speaker: And the Treasury already knew this trick.
12:56
Unidentified speaker: In September 2023, as part of the deal that freed five American detainees in Iran, the Biden administration authorized the transfer of six billion dollars of frozen Iranian oil revenues out of South Korea and into accounts at Qatari banks, supervised by the Qatar Central Bank.
13:16
Unidentified speaker: Iran never got the cash, the money could only be released to approved vendors for humanitarian goods under US oversight.
13:26
Unidentified speaker: And when Washington wanted the arrangement stopped after October 7th, Qatar stopped it.
13:33
Unidentified speaker: So, faced with a sudden mountain of unsold crude and a courthouse full of people holding writs, Doha was the easy answer.
13:42
Unidentified speaker: The difficulty is that moving cash offshore only works for cash.
13:47
Unidentified speaker: It does nothing for the kind of asset that can't be moved, which brings us to Sitgo.
13:53
Unidentified speaker: If you've driven past a filling station anywhere in the United States, you've seen the red triangle.
14:00
Unidentified speaker: SitGo runs about 4,000 stations, along with pipeline storage terminals and three large refineries in Louisiana, Texas, and Illinois, that between them process over 800,000 barrels of crude a day.
14:15
Unidentified speaker: The facility in Louisiana on its own is the seventh largest refinery in the United States.
14:21
Unidentified speaker: Citco is a 113-year-old American company that has been owned by Venezuela's state oil company since 1990.
14:30
Unidentified speaker: It was the most valuable thing Venezuela owned outside Venezuela, and the Gulf Coast refineries had been specifically re-engineered to handle Venezuelan crude, which is heavy sour and generally unwelcome elsewhere.
14:46
Unidentified speaker: The assumption in Caracas had always been that whatever happened at home, Citco was untouchable, which brings us to the single most expensive lesson in corporate formalities ever administered.
14:59
Unidentified speaker: The reason a creditor normally can't touch a subsidiary that's a corporation is that a corporation is a separate legal person from its owner.
15:10
Unidentified speaker: Your creditors can come after you, they can't come after your company, and they can't come after your company's company.
15:18
Unidentified speaker: This is the entire point of the corporate form, and it's very hard to overcome.
15:24
Unidentified speaker: Courts do occasionally set it aside, piercing the corporate veil, but it is rare and it's treated as an extraordinary remedy for extraordinary facts.
15:35
Unidentified speaker: Delaware courts pierce the veil in a low single digit percentage of the cases where somebody asks.
15:42
Unidentified speaker: You do not get there by being badly run or insolvent or unpleasant.
15:47
Unidentified speaker: You get there by demonstrating over a period of years that the separation was never real in the first place, which Venezuela did repeatedly, publicly, and on the record.
16:00
Unidentified speaker: For two decades, the government in Caracas ran Pedavesa as a cash register with a corporate charter attached.
16:08
Unidentified speaker: When the state needed money for social programs or political favors or to cover sovereign debts, it told Pedavesa to wire the money, and Peduvesa did.
16:18
Unidentified speaker: The president of Venezuela appointed the company's president, its directors, its vice presidents, and its shareholder council.
16:27
Unidentified speaker: Employees were fired for political reasons.
16:30
Unidentified speaker: The government committed the company to selling oil to allies at large discounts and handed out mining rights without asking the company first.
16:39
Unidentified speaker: None of this caused any difficulty inside Venezuela, but it caused a great deal of difficulty in Delaware.
16:47
Unidentified speaker: In 2016, a Canadian mining company called Crystalx won an arbitration award of $1.2 billion against Venezuela after Hugo Chavez nationalized its Las Cristinas gold operation in 2011 without paying for it.
17:04
Unidentified speaker: Venezuela declined to pay the award on the grounds that it didn't want to, so CrystalX registered the judgment in Delaware and went after Pedavesa's shares in PDV Holding, the company that owned Citco.
17:19
Unidentified speaker: The argument was that Pedavesa was the alter ego of the Republic of Venezuela, and that its American assets were therefore available to satisfy Venezuela's debts.
17:31
Unidentified speaker: Now, when the defendant is a sovereign state, the courts don't use ordinary veil piercing.
17:37
Unidentified speaker: They use a 1983 Supreme Court case called BANCEC, which says that a state-owned company is presumed separate from the state unless the state exercises such extensive control that the company is really its agent.
17:53
Unidentified speaker: And CrystalX had been careful.
17:55
Unidentified speaker: They didn't ask the court to declare that Pedevesa was liable for all of Venezuela's debts, they asked for something much narrower, a finding that these particular shares, though they had Pedevesa's name on them, were really Venezuela's property.
18:12
Unidentified speaker: Modest, constrained, nothing to worry about.
18:15
Unidentified speaker: The Third Circuit then affirmed it in language that wasn't narrow at all, and later courts have read it as settling the general question.
18:24
Unidentified speaker: Chris Lex asked for the door to be cracked open, and the appeals court removed the door entirely.
18:31
Unidentified speaker: The alter ego ruling worked on Venezuela's creditors the way a dinner bell works, a queue formed in Delaware, bondholders and expropriation claimants, including Conico Phillips, Gold Reserve, OI Glass, and Tidewater on a first come, first served basis.
18:50
Unidentified speaker: Judge Stark appointed a special master to run a forced auction of PDV holding and pay them out of the proceeds, at which point Venezuelan politics produced its one moment of national unity.
19:05
Unidentified speaker: The Maduro government and the Democratic opposition, who agree on essentially nothing, both denounce the auction.
19:12
Unidentified speaker: The arrangement they were objecting to works like this.
19:16
Unidentified speaker: PDV holding is controlled by the opposition.
19:20
Unidentified speaker: Pedevesa on the ground is controlled by Maduro, and the opposition represents Pedevesa in American courts because the United States doesn't recognize Maduro.
19:31
Unidentified speaker: The company was defending itself in court on behalf of a government that considers its own lawyers traders.
19:39
Unidentified speaker: Everyone involved objected to the sale.
19:42
Unidentified speaker: Nobody could agree who won the thing being sold.
19:45
Unidentified speaker: The auction took eight years and was not what you'd call orderly.
19:50
Unidentified speaker: Amber Energy, an affiliate of Elliott Investment Management, a hedge fund that has spent 40 years buying claims nobody else wants and then somehow collecting on them, won the first round in 2024 with a conditional bid of just over $7 billion, which the creditors rejected as too low.
20:11
Unidentified speaker: The process restarted.
20:13
Unidentified speaker: Gold reserve bidding through a vehicle called Dalinar Energy came in at $7.4 billion and then raised itself to nearly eight billion.
20:23
Unidentified speaker: Amber won last November with a bid of $5.89 billion in cash structured alongside settlement with the 2020 bondholders.
20:34
Unidentified speaker: Judge Stark approved it last November, writing that it offered the best combination of price and certainty of closing that anyone had submitted.
20:44
Unidentified speaker: Certainty of closing being the operative phrase, the highest number on the table lost to the number most likely to survive contact with the appeals court.
20:55
Unidentified speaker: Gold Reserve responded by asking for the removal of both Judge Stark and the Special Master, citing alleged conflicts, including their financial advisers.
21:06
Unidentified speaker: That motion was denied.
21:08
Unidentified speaker: Elliot, it should be said, is experienced at this.
21:12
Unidentified speaker: This is the fund that spent 15 years pursuing Argentina over defaulted bonds and in 2012 seized an Argentine naval vessel.
21:22
Unidentified speaker: The vessel was a three-masted sailing ship on a goodwill tour with cadets aboard.
21:28
Unidentified speaker: Elliot's subsidiary had it detained in Ghana over a debt of just under $300 million.
21:35
Unidentified speaker: It stayed there for 10 weeks.
21:37
Unidentified speaker: Argentina eventually got it back through the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea.
21:43
Unidentified speaker: The same campaign involved going after the presidential aircraft, the assets of the Argentine Space Agency, and the money Argentina was owed for its stand at the Frankfurt Book Fair.
21:57
Unidentified speaker: So when a hedge fund with that record turns up at a distressed auction, the outcome is fairly predictable.
22:04
Unidentified speaker: Elliot gets a large refining network at a price the sellers dispute.
22:09
Unidentified speaker: Some of the creditors get paid, and Venezuela is left with nothing.
22:13
Unidentified speaker: The deal still needs a license from OFAC, the Treasury Office that administers US sanctions before it can close.
22:21
Unidentified speaker: The Financial Times has noted that Paul Singer, who runs Elliot, was an early financial backer of Marco Rubio's political career.
22:30
Unidentified speaker: Rubio is at the State Department and does not sign OFAC licenses, so make of that what you will.
22:38
Unidentified speaker: So the oil money is offshore and the refinery now belongs to a hedge fund, which brings us to Treadneedle Street.
22:46
Unidentified speaker: Underneath the Bank of England there are thirty one tons of Venezuelan gold.
22:51
Unidentified speaker: It's been there since 2008 for the same reason that a lot of developing countries keep gold in London.
22:58
Unidentified speaker: The Bank of England runs one of the world's largest vaults and offers custody services to central banks, and London is a sensible place to store bullion you might one day want to sell.
23:11
Unidentified speaker: That was the theory.
23:12
Unidentified speaker: In 2018, the bank stopped taking Venezuela's calls.
23:17
Unidentified speaker: This gold makes up about 15% of Venezuela's foreign currency reserves.
23:23
Unidentified speaker: UK court documents valued it at around $2 billion in 2020, and since gold has done rather well, it's now worth somewhere north of $4 billion.
23:34
Unidentified speaker: So Venezuela has, in the last seven years, made a great deal of money on this position and has been entirely unable to do anything about it.
23:44
Unidentified speaker: Now to explain how the gold got stuck, I need to explain a rule of English law called the one voice principle.
23:52
Unidentified speaker: English courts do not decide who the president of a foreign country is.
23:57
Unidentified speaker: They're not equipped for it, and they don't want the job.
24:00
Unidentified speaker: Instead, when the question comes up, the court writes to the foreign office and asks.
24:06
Unidentified speaker: Whatever the foreign office comes back with, the court treats as conclusive.
24:12
Unidentified speaker: The judiciary and the executive must speak with one voice on foreign affairs, so the court simply adopts the government's answer and gets on with the case.
24:22
Unidentified speaker: It's an elegant solution to a hard problem, and it works beautifully right up until the Foreign Office changes its mind.
24:30
Unidentified speaker: In February 2019, the then Foreign Secretary Jeremy Hunt issued a statement recognizing Juan Guaido as the constitutional interim president of Venezuela.
24:42
Unidentified speaker: Guaido, armed with a piece of paper from the British government, appointed his own board to the Central Bank of Venezuela.
24:50
Unidentified speaker: That board wrote to the Bank of England instructing it not to release the gold to Maduro.
24:55
Unidentified speaker: Guaido told the Financial Times in May 2020 that Britain would be financing torture by handing it over.
25:03
Unidentified speaker: At more or less the same time, Maduro's board of the same central bank sued the Bank of England to force it to hand the gold over, proposing that the proceeds go through the UN development program to buy medicine and food during the pandemic.
25:20
Unidentified speaker: So the English courts were presented with one central bank, two boards, both claiming to be the real one, issuing directly contradictory instructions about the same pile of metal.
25:32
Unidentified speaker: Both of them, it should be said, were correct, depending entirely on which government you asked.
25:38
Unidentified speaker: The case went to the UK Supreme Court, which handed down its judgment in December 2021.
25:45
Unidentified speaker: Lord Lloyd Jones held that the one voice principle bound the courts to accept the Foreign Office's statement.
25:53
Unidentified speaker: Guido was the constitutional interim president, and Maduro was not the president for any purpose.
26:00
Unidentified speaker: Now that reads like a win for the opposition, and it was reported as one.
26:05
Unidentified speaker: What Guaido had actually won was the right to stop anybody else from touching the gold.
26:11
Unidentified speaker: He couldn't get it out himself either.
26:13
Unidentified speaker: There were sanctions and further litigation, and the active state questions went back down to the commercial court to be argued about some more.
26:22
Unidentified speaker: The practical outcome of the highest court in Britain ruling in his favor was that the bars stayed exactly where they were.
26:30
Unidentified speaker: And then in December 2022, Venezuela's opposition-led National Assembly voted to abolish Guido's interim government, meaning that he was no longer the interim president of anything, and the British government stopped recognizing him.
26:46
Unidentified speaker: Maduro's lawyers were back in court more or less immediately, making what looked like an unanswerable argument.
26:54
Unidentified speaker: The UK doesn't recognize Guido anymore, his central bank board was his appointment, so the appointment is void and the gold goes to Caracas.
27:04
Unidentified speaker: In June 2023, the Court of Appeal in Deutsche Bank versus Central Bank of Venezuela said no, withdrawing recognition operates forward, not backward.
27:16
Unidentified speaker: Guido was the recognized president at the moment he made the appointments, so the appointments were valid acts of a foreign state when made, and an English court cannot go back and unmake them.
27:30
Unidentified speaker: So today's position is this.
27:32
Unidentified speaker: The courts can't take instructions from Maduro's board because the government didn't recognize Maduro.
27:38
Unidentified speaker: They can't take instructions from Guaido's board either because Guaido no longer holds the office he was recognized as holding.
27:46
Unidentified speaker: The board that has authority over the gold was appointed by a president who no longer exists on behalf of a government that was dissolved by its own parliament.
27:57
Unidentified speaker: The gold is in the custody of a bank that's willing to release it to whomever is entitled to it, and there's nobody left who's entitled to it.
28:06
Unidentified speaker: Last month after the earthquakes, interim president Delcy Rodriguez wrote to King Charles asking him to release the reserves, saying that the gold belongs to Venezuelan people and is needed to deal with the consequences of the disaster.
28:22
Unidentified speaker: I should explain that the king cannot do this, he can't overturn the Court of Appeal, he can't instruct the Bank of England, and the last monarch who tried telling English judges what to do was Charles I, whose disagreement with Parliament ended with the removal of his head.
28:40
Unidentified speaker: The King's real functions are opening Parliament, signing bills that have already passed, and receiving visiting heads of state.
28:49
Unidentified speaker: The letter will have been read, acknowledged, and forwarded to the Foreign Office, which sits on King Charles Street, named after a different King Charles, and the address where this actually gets decided.
29:02
Unidentified speaker: Buckingham Palace has not publicly responded.
29:06
Unidentified speaker: The British government's position is also on the record.
29:10
Unidentified speaker: Speaking as Foreign Secretary earlier this year, Yvette Cooper told MPs that the government would continue not to recognize the leadership in Caracas and acknowledged that this would likely mean the bank continues to withhold the reserves.
29:26
Unidentified speaker: She said it was important to keep pressure in place for a transition to democracy reflecting the will of the Venezuelan people.
29:34
Unidentified speaker: Whether that position holds is now an open question.
29:38
Unidentified speaker: There's a new government in London as of this week, and Ed Miliband has inherited the file.
29:44
Unidentified speaker: Since the gold is stuck on a question of recognition, and recognition is a decision for the foreign office rather than the courts, a change of mind there would do more for Venezuela than any amount of litigation.
29:57
Unidentified speaker: There has been some parliamentary pushback.
30:00
Unidentified speaker: The Labour MP Richard Bergen filed an early day motion at the end of June calling for the immediate release of the gold.
30:08
Unidentified speaker: An early day motion is a formal parliamentary mechanism by which a member of parliament may register an opinion and it has no other effect whatsoever.
30:19
Unidentified speaker: His has 30 signatures, but there are 650 MPs.
30:25
Unidentified speaker: Meanwhile, the UN's emergency appeal, the immediate one for shelter, water, and medical care rather than reconstruction, is looking for $296 million to cover 1.3 million people for six months.
30:41
Unidentified speaker: It has raised $300 million against a funding gap of $627 million.
30:48
Unidentified speaker: Rebuilding is a separate question and a much larger number.
30:53
Unidentified speaker: The UN Office for Disaster Risk Reduction puts the direct physical damage at $37 billion, $24 billion in buildings, $13 billion in infrastructure, and that figure doesn't yet include the cost of reconstruction, so it will rise.
31:11
Unidentified speaker: The gold under Thread Needle Street is worth about $4 billion and it's appreciated by more than $2 billion while the argument about who owns it has been going on.
31:22
Unidentified speaker: So while lawyers in Delaware and London argue about who's entitled to sell or store Venezuela's assets, Venezuela is dealing with what it's like to live in a country whose state has stopped working.
31:35
Unidentified speaker: After the earthquakes, the gaps became difficult to miss.
31:39
Unidentified speaker: The US military is currently running air traffic control at the main international airport in Caracas and helping to operate the coastal ports, because otherwise the relief supplies wouldn't get in.
31:52
Unidentified speaker: This produces some awkward photographs.
31:55
Unidentified speaker: American diplomats and military commanders have been pictured touring disaster sites alongside Diosado Cabello, Venezuela's interior minister who controls the state security forces and the armed groups used against political opponents.
32:12
Unidentified speaker: Cabello was charged in a New York federal indictment in 2020 with conspiracy to commit narco-terrorism and conspiracy to import cocaine.
32:22
Unidentified speaker: The State Department is currently offering up to $25 million for information leading to his arrest or conviction, and he's the last remaining fugitive from that indictment.
32:35
Unidentified speaker: So the United States is simultaneously offering $25 million for this man and standing next to him at a press conference.
32:44
Unidentified speaker: Diplomacy, it seems, requires flexibility.
32:48
Unidentified speaker: But if I was one of those diplomats, I'd be tempted to grab him.
32:52
Unidentified speaker: Interim president Dulcie Rodriguez has had a harder time.
32:57
Unidentified speaker: At her one appearance at a disaster site, she was heckled by survivors telling her to leave.
33:03
Unidentified speaker: She later held a press conference explaining that reports of a chaotic government response were false and had been manufactured by, in her phrase, media laboratories.
33:15
Unidentified speaker: President Trump has been more supportive.
33:18
Unidentified speaker: He has called Rodriguez a terrific person doing a great job, and told reporters that apart from the earthquake damage, it's a happy country again.
33:28
Unidentified speaker: The actual response has been large, something like 30,000 first responders and more than 3,000 foreign rescuers deployed, along with 137 search and rescue dogs from more than 20 countries.
33:42
Unidentified speaker: The best known of them is a border colleague named Tsunami, adopted from a shelter in Caracas nine years ago, who worked at the Turkey-Syria earthquakes in 2023 and has located 26 survivors in this one.
33:57
Unidentified speaker: He is retiring after this deployment.
34:00
Unidentified speaker: The American contribution has been substantial.
34:03
Unidentified speaker: US officials leading the effort say that they have spent around $310 million, diverted over a million pounds of relief supplies, and donated 10 refrigerated containers to help store the dead.
34:17
Unidentified speaker: The Atlantic notes that this still lags well behind what the United States spent after comparable disasters in the region, including the Haitian earthquake of 2010.
34:28
Unidentified speaker: Tom Fletcher, who runs the UN relief effort, says another $300 million is needed to reach more than a million people, requiring life-saving support.
34:39
Unidentified speaker: Meanwhile, the opposition, the people who would have to form the elected government that could actually unlock any of these assets, has not been having a good time either.
34:50
Unidentified speaker: Maria Carina Macado was barred from standing in the 2024 election, spent much of the following year in hiding and won the 2025 Nobel Peace Prize for her work promoting democratic rights and for unifying the opposition behind the demand for free elections.
35:08
Unidentified speaker: When she attempted to return to Venezuela via Curacao after the earthquakes to help coordinate relief, her charter aircraft was turned around in mid-air after Dutch authorities were told her return was not American policy.
35:24
Unidentified speaker: Axios reported that senior US administration officials described her attempt to return as grotesque political opportunism.
35:34
Unidentified speaker: So the Nobel laureate can't get into the country, and the man with the $25 million reward on him is helping direct the relief effort.
35:43
Unidentified speaker: Which brings us to the part that doesn't resolve.
35:47
Unidentified speaker: There is a serious argument for not handing billions of dollars in oil revenue and gold to the current government in Caracas.
35:55
Unidentified speaker: It's largely the same political class that presided over a 75% contraction of the economy, expropriated foreign businesses, and ran the state oil company so far into the ground that a Delaware judge eventually ruled that it was indistinguishable from the state itself.
36:14
Unidentified speaker: Handing that group billions of dollars and asking them to spend it wisely would be optimistic.
36:21
Unidentified speaker: The alternative, currently in operation, is that a foreign government takes control of the oil exports, the refineries and the gold, and holds the proceeds in accounts nobody can audit while the country deals with $37 billion of earthquake damage.
36:38
Unidentified speaker: Both of these are bad options.
36:40
Unidentified speaker: The US State Department's position is that this is custodial.
36:45
Unidentified speaker: The money belongs to Venezuela, disbursements are monitored, and the arrangement exists for the benefit of the Venezuelan people.
36:54
Unidentified speaker: President Trump has described it quite differently.
36:57
Unidentified speaker: The Financial Times reports that speaking in June about the January operation, he said that it took 48 minutes to win that war, that the US had brought millions of barrels of oil out, that the operation had paid for itself 28 times over, and that the US is making a lot of money too.
37:17
Unidentified speaker: Both of these things are being said about the same $13 billion.
37:22
Unidentified speaker: When the State Department is describing a monitored humanitarian trust and the president is on television describing a profitable investment, you can see why members of Congress from both parties have started asking for the accounts.
37:37
Unidentified speaker: And that's the true line in all of these stories.
37:40
Unidentified speaker: Venezuela's oil money is in Doha because American courts might grab it.
37:46
Unidentified speaker: Its refinery was sold at auction in Delaware because a court decided the government and its oil company were the same legal person.
37:54
Unidentified speaker: Its gold is trapped in London because no English court can work out who is authorized to ask for it.
38:01
Unidentified speaker: None of those things happened because anyone doubted the assets belong to Venezuela.
38:07
Unidentified speaker: They happened because sovereign wealth held abroad only stays yours for as long as other people's institutions agree that there's somebody legitimate to give it back to.
38:18
Unidentified speaker: When that stops being clear, ownership turns into a question, and questions get answered by judges, custodians, and creditors, none of whom are Venezuelan and all of whom are following rules that make perfect sense individually.
38:34
Unidentified speaker: An internationally recognized elected government is not just the nice democratic outcome for Venezuela.
38:41
Unidentified speaker: At this point, it's the only mechanism that exists for getting the accounts unfrozen, stopping the auctions and putting anyone in a room who can sign for the money.
38:52
Unidentified speaker: So that's where we are.
38:54
Unidentified speaker: $13 billion of oil that nobody can account for, a refinery sold to a hedge fund, 31 tons of gold that is appreciated by $2 billion while sitting in a vault that no one can open, and a country trying to clear rubble.
39:10
Unidentified speaker: If you found this video interesting, you should watch my video on what Trump's China visit actually achieved next.
39:17
Unidentified speaker: Don't forget to check out our sponsor, Taylorstore, using the link in the description.
39:22
Unidentified speaker: Have a great day and see you in the next video.
39:25
Unidentified speaker: Bye.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-GGUF:UD-Q4_K_XL. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Economy & Finance

Economy & Finance

Is Russia Actually Losing

Episode discussion: Speakers argue Russia faces economic contraction, fuel shortages, and strategic dependency on China amid high casualties.

Speakers’ claims: The episode argues that Russia is losing its economic and military position due to severe structural exhaustion. Speakers cite Ukrainian drone strikes destroying up to 43% of Russia's refining capacity and CSIS estimates of 1.4 million military casualties. They highlight a 0.3% GDP contraction in Q1 2026 and a depleted National Wealth Fund, contrasting these with state media narratives of strength. The discussion emphasizes Russia's growing dependency on China for trade and technology, noting that China now accounts for 35% of Russia's foreign trade.

Russian EconomyMilitary CasualtiesEnergy Infrastructure
36 min2 assets10 claims to verify
Economy & Finance

How Did the Metaverse Fail So Badly

Episode discussion: Meta's Metaverse Ambitions Collapse Amid $88B Losses and Legal Liabilities

Speakers’ claims: Speakers detail how Meta's 2021 rebrand to Meta and pivot to the metaverse failed to gain traction, citing a lack of user adoption and functional products like Horizon Worlds. The episode highlights the collapse of virtual real estate values, with some assets losing 99.6% of their value, and contrasts high-profile marketing with low engagement. Speakers note that Reality Labs accumulated approximately $88 billion in operating losses over seven years, leading to significant stock volatility and eventual budget cuts. The narrative concludes that Meta's strategic failure was compounded by massive legal liabilities regarding social media's impact on children, which erased more market value than the metaverse project itself.

Meta PlatformsMetaverseVirtual Reality
32 min1 assets10 claims to verify
All insights