Jake & Gino analyze a $30M multifamily foreclosure to highlight overpaying and debt risks in the 2021-2022 boom.
Summary
Jake Barbero presents a financial autopsy of a $30 million multifamily deal that collapsed into foreclosure within 36 months, attributing the failure to overpaying during the 2021-2022 market peak and ignoring subsequent market cycles. He argues that investors made the 'patient mistake' by assuming tailwinds like low rates and population growth would persist indefinitely, failing to anticipate the hypersupply phase. The speakers identify bridge debt as a critical vulnerability when interest rates rise rapidly, noting that lenders have since tightened standards, reducing loan-to-value ratios from 70-75% to 55-60%. Operational challenges, including rising construction costs and record new supply deliveries in markets like Knoxville, further eroded property values and cash flow. Barbero advises investors to stress-test deals against rate hikes, flat rents, and valuation drops to avoid capital calls or forced sales.
Key takeaways
- 1 Real estate market cycles follow a pattern of recession, recovery, expansion, and hypersupply; investors often fail to recognize the transition into hypersupply because they assume current tailwinds will persist in perpetuity.
Gino Barbero · 2:03
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 0:51
Sponsor Read: TrueAge Tests
Gino Barbero promotes TrueAge tests from True Diagnostic, which use epigenetics to estimate biological aging via an at-home finger prick kit. He offers a 20% discount code for listeners.
- 0:51 – 1:33
Introduction: The $30M Foreclosure Case Study
Barbero introduces a financial autopsy of a $30 million multifamily deal that collapsed into foreclosure within 36 months, aiming to teach limited partners and sponsors how to avoid fatal mistakes seen in the 2021-2022 boom.
- 1:33 – 5:36
Market Cycles and Historical Context
The speaker discusses how real estate market cycles repeat or rhyme, citing the 2008-2009 recession and recovery as a parallel to the current environment, noting that speculation and overpaying were prevalent in 2021.
- 5:36 – 9:02
The 'Patient' Mistake: Overpaying and Ignoring Cycles
Barbero describes the 'patient' mistake where investors assume current tailwinds (population growth, low rates) will continue indefinitely, failing to anticipate the hypersupply phase of the market cycle, similar to his own 2006-2007 mistakes.
- 9:02 – 11:51
The 'Fatal Wound': Bridge Debt and Rising Rates
The speaker identifies bridge debt as a 'fatal wound' when interest rates rise rapidly, making refinancing difficult. He notes that lenders now require higher loan-to-value ratios (55-60%) and more equity compared to the 70-75% LTVs seen previously.
- 11:51 – 12:52
Sponsor Read: Wheelbarrow Profits
Barbero promotes the Wheelbarrow Profits program, highlighting student Vince Gethings' success in building an 800+ unit portfolio in Dallas-Fort Worth and claiming the program has facilitated over $5 billion in deals.
- 12:52 – 16:03
Complications: Rising Costs and Oversupply
The speaker details operational complications including supply chain delays, rising material and labor costs, and record new multifamily supply deliveries (e.g., 20% in Knoxville since 2021), which led to flatlining rents and dropping occupancy.
- 16:03 – 22:04
The 'Final Blow': Capital Calls and Cash-In Refinances
Barbero explains that when valuations flatline and debt coverage ratios drop, investors face capital calls or cash-in refinances. He shares his personal experience of selling a property at a substantial loss in 2017 to cut losses rather than speculate further.
Claims worth verifying
TrueAge tests use epigenetics to estimate biological aging and provide a personalized report online in 3-4 weeks.
Gino Barbero ·0:20
How to verify: Visit TrueDiagnostic.com and review product specifications and turnaround times listed on their official website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A $30 million multifamily deal collapsed into foreclosure in 36 months.
Gino Barbero ·0:51
How to verify: Search public county recorder offices or foreclosure databases for a $30M multifamily property foreclosure occurring approximately 36 months after a 2021-2026 acquisition. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In 2021, investors were buying with 4% cap rates and 3% debt, maintaining positive leverage.
Gino Barbero ·5:56
How to verify: Review historical CRE loan data from sources like Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, or the Federal Reserve's Flow of Funds reports for 2026 commercial mortgage rates and cap rates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Lending loan-to-value (LTV) ratios dropped from 70-75% to 55-60% by 2022-2023.
Gino Barbero ·11:31
How to verify: Compare CRE lending data from the Federal Reserve's Financial Accounts of the United States or commercial bank quarterly earnings reports between 2026 and 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceVince Gethings started with a zero-down VA loan in 2013 and scaled to over 800 units.
Gino Barbero ·12:11
How to verify: Search public property records in the Dallas-Fort Worth area for properties owned by Vince Gethings or associated entities, and verify VA loan usage through public filing disclosures if available. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceWheelbarrow Profits has helped students close over $5 billion in multifamily deals across more than 90,000 units.
Gino Barbero ·12:31
How to verify: Request audited performance data or verified closing statements from Wheelbarrow Profits; cross-reference with public property records for units associated with program graduates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In Knoxville, Tennessee, 20% of all multifamily stock was delivered since 2021.
Gino Barbero ·14:31
How to verify: Consult local building permits data, CoStar, or Marcus & Adams reports for Knoxville multifamily deliveries from 2021 to 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Occupancy in the discussed market dropped to 91-92% from 96%.
Gino Barbero ·14:51
How to verify: Review CoStar, Real Capital Analytics, or local property management reports for occupancy trends in the specified Sunbelt market during 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Gino Barbero sold a commercial property in 2017 at a substantial loss after buying it in 2006.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·17:27
How to verify: Search public property records in upstate New York for properties owned by Gino Barbero or Jake Gino with transaction dates around 2026 and 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In 2021, rent growth was projected at 10-15% annually, but actual growth was flat or low single digits.
Gino Barbero ·6:03
How to verify: Compare CRE rent growth forecasts from 2026 with actual rent growth data from CoStar, Reis, or local market reports for 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify current loan-to-value (LTV) and debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) requirements for multifamily bridge loans from major lenders like Wells Fargo, JPMorgan, or regional banks.
- Check recent multifamily supply delivery data for target markets using sources like CoStar, Yardi Matrix, or local MLS reports to assess oversupply risks.
- Review historical cap rate trends and current spread data for the specific asset class and submarket to validate acquisition pricing assumptions.
- Analyze the sponsor's track record and any potential conflicts of interest, particularly if they are promoting their own education programs or deal syndications.
- Confirm the specific interest rate environment and Fed policy outlook at the time of the deal versus current conditions to assess refinancing risk.
- Examine the property's operating expenses and labor cost trends in the local market to verify if operational cost inflation has been accurately modeled.
- Research the specific foreclosure case study details if available, or seek similar public records of multifamily foreclosures in the same geographic area for comparable performance metrics.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
- 0:00
- Gino Barbero: can eat healthy, work out, get enough sleep, and take supplements. But how do you know if any of that is actually working? That's what I like about TrueAge tests from True Diagnostic. TrueAge uses epigenetics to estimate how your body is actually aging. It can show your biological age, how
- 0:20
- Gino Barbero: quickly you're aging, and even how different areas of your body like your heart, your brain, and your liver may. be aging. And it's simple. It's an at-home finger prick. You send the kit back and receive your personalized report online in about three to four weeks. So if you're serious about longevity or
- 0:40
- Gino Barbero: even just curious whether your body is aging faster or slower than your actual age, this is one of the easiest ways to find out. Right now, go to true TrueDiagnostic.com diagnostic.com.
- 0:51
- Gino Barbero: and use the code Jake and Gino for 20% off your entire order. That's TrueDiagnostic.com, code Jake and Gino for 20% off. In 2021, everyone looked like a genius. Now, today the tide has gone out and properties are going back to the bank. How does a
- 1:11
- Gino Barbero: seemingly safe $30 million apartment complex collapse? into foreclosure in just 36 months? Today we're going to be doing a full financial autopsy, and every limited partner, as well as every sponsor, should learn how to avoid these fatal mistakes.
- 1:33
- Gino Barbero: Hello and welcome. This is Gino Barbero of Barbero Barbero360 360 and of Jake and Gino. And today's podcast is fun because it's always fun being the Monday morning quarterback, but it's also important to be the Monday morning quarterback. Because just because you've made a mistake now doesn't mean you can't learn from that mistake and take
- 1:53
- Gino Barbero: that mistake into the next market cycle. I've been quoting Mark Twain recently, and I think it's so important that when you're talking about history, history doesn't
- 2:03
- Gino Barbero: repeat, but it does rhyme. And that is so true when it comes to the market cycle and when it comes to real estate specifically. What happened in 08, 09, that was part of the market cycle. We went into recession, then we went into recovery, then we went into expansion, and then we go into hypersupply, Of supply and it sort of repeats
- 2:23
- Gino Barbero: or rhymes. And that's sort of what happened in this market cycle. And back in 2021, everyone looked like a genius. It was a lot of money floating around, a lot of speculation floating around. People were overpaying. And let's go back to that point because what's going to happen is I want you to take the information you're going to learn today, the knowledge you're going to learn today, and I want you to use that when you're
- 2:43
- Gino Barbero: investing in real estate. Because guess what? Real estate's not the risky element. You're the risky element. I was the risky element. back in 06 and 07. I didn't know what I was doing. I didn't understand the market cycle. I overpaid. I violated and I made so many of the mistakes. And I'm gonna share the mistakes that I made in 08 and the mistakes that I saw in
- 3:03
- Gino Barbero: 2021. So for you going forward, whether you're investing passively or whether you're investing as a sponsor and you're investing for your own deals, this knowledge is going to be used by both. sets of people. So I don't want to hear you say, Oh, investing in real estate's too risky. I'm not going to do it ever again. Don't say that because real estate, if done properly,
- 3:23
- Gino Barbero: can offer incredible benefits. You just have to learn the vehicle. Now, before we start, if you want to get our book, Wheelbarrow Profits, just email me Gino at Jake and Gino.com. I'd love to send over a copy. It talks about buy, right, operate, and exit. That's the three-pillar frame. framework that we have. I didn't have the framework or the map or the
- 3:43
- Gino Barbero: process before I started with Jake. I made a ton of these mistakes that we're going to go through. If you want to avoid mistakes in any area of your life, you have to find people who are successful. Success leaves clues. And those clues, you start working on those clues. And what I want you to do is I want you to be ultimately so curious.
- 4:03
- Gino Barbero: Listen, I've been uh reading a book on the autobiography of Benjamin Franklin. If you haven't read about Benjamin Franklin, that dude is incredible. He was one of 10 children. His father had seven kids with his first wife and had 10 kids with his second wife. He was the 10th of
- 4:22
- Gino Barbero: 10 out of his second wife. So he was the youngest of 17. Now think. about that for a second. Back in the 1720s, you had to be an apprentice. But but what stood out with Benjamin Franklin was that he was so curious about everything. He questioned everything. That's why I'm doing this podcast because I'm questioning and I'm
- 4:42
- Gino Barbero: curious about what happened, about that autopsy. What did we do wrong back in 2021 and 2022? Just remove the pride. It seems as if Ben Franklin. had very little pride. He had very little ego. What I look, what it what it appears to me is he created these different masterminds, these different groups of really highly intellectual people and got them together. And he was
- 5:01
- Gino Barbero: okay not to be the smartest person in the room. If you get a chance to read about Benjamin Franklin, whether it's talking about, you know, the first talking about firefighting, he got together these firefighters that were, you know, public. They were just getting together with volunteers. The post office. He was a printer. He found out about lightning. Like they didn't know what lightning was
- 5:21
- Gino Barbero: back then. He did wrote stuff about electricity.
- 5:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): He
- 5:25
- Gino Barbero: was just an incredible person, but he was just curious. And if there's one thing that I want you to take away from today, just remember this quote Curiosity is the currency of learning.
- 5:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
- 5:36
- Gino Barbero: Ben Franklin had that on steroids, and I hope that's that you can adopt that in your life. Now, the first one, the patient and perfect story. You got a 1980s asset, 150 units in a growing market in the sunbelt. Everything's looking good. You're following the market cycle. There's cheap money there. Cap rates, unfortunately, are really
- 5:56
- Gino Barbero: low. But if you're buying a four forecap cap with 3% debt, you still have positive leverage. That's what you're saying to yourself. And you're seeing
- 6:03
- Gino Barbero: all of this population growth, all of the job growth, things are looking good. You're looking, rents are going up 10 to 15% a year, but you're not thinking to yourself, huh, there's supply coming over on the horizon. We're in expansion right now, but when does that fourth part of the market cycle kick in? The hypersupply, I don't really
- 6:23
- Gino Barbero: know. And the blind spot in this part of the market cycle. you're looking and you're looking assuming yesterday's tailwinds. What's going on today in 2021 is going to continue in perpetuity. Now, if you follow the really smart money, they had bought it right, they were operating it. And around 21 and 22, they started exiting their assets because they saw the
- 6:43
- Gino Barbero: insanity. Like buying a three-cap, Three cap, hoping that rates are gonna really, you know, go uh, I mean, rates are gonna stay where they are for years. Also, cap rates. You're going in, let's say, a four cap, but you're gonna exit at a lower cap rate or the same cap rate three or four years from now. What's the likelihood of that? And also rent growth, rent growth growing for 10 or 15%,
- 7:03
- Gino Barbero: probably not gonna happen, but you're euphoric. You have cheap money and you're like, this is gonna last. So I'm gonna continue along. And I made this mistake back in 06 when I bought. a deal up in New York. Very similar. Remember, it doesn't repeat exactly, but it rhymes. A completely different market. I mean, this was a slower market,
- 7:23
- Gino Barbero: more in upstate New York, about an hour and a half north of the city. But there was speculation. There was what what we call frothiness in the market. I was blinded It a little bit. I thought this is was gonna last forever. There's cheap money, easy to get a loan. There's a lot of tenants there. Business is going really well. I made the same
- 7:43
- Gino Barbero: mistake. I didn't understand that we were getting from expansion into hyper supply and going to go into a recession soon after. I didn't see that. I was blinded by the ease with which I could buy this deal, finance this deal. Unfortunately for me, as a lot of these operators back in 21 and 22 got into, I didn't have any experience.
- 8:03
- Gino Barbero: operating commercial real estate. I just didn't. And as you can see, a lot of these sponsors who bought these deals in 21 and 22, they didn't either. One of the things you need to understand getting into the next part of the market cycle, if you're not an operator of real estate, you need to find somebody who is. Partner up with that person, raise money for that type of
- 8:23
- Gino Barbero: person. Because at the end of the day, and I hate saying that, at the end of the day, but at the end of the day, real estate, any niche you're talking about, whether it's self-storage, single family homes, whether you're talking multifamily retail, it is a business. And understanding that you need to be active in it. It can be
- 8:42
- Gino Barbero: passive. You need to build up to that. But even when you're passive in real estate, you need to understand there's certain principles that you need to follow and and and you know actually have the investment be guided by. And one of them is you need to have somebody who's operating that asset. So that's the patient. 2021, we can go back to 2006. I was the
- 9:02
- Gino Barbero: patient also. I didn't understand that the market cycle is shifting, and I didn't understand that the good times would come to an end. Now, the fatal wounds, same thing that happened in 07 2007 and 08. 2008, It's happened in 22, 2022. 2023. All of a sudden, in 22, you're taking out a loan. That's a bridge debt. And there's nothing wrong with
- 9:22
- Gino Barbero: bridge debt. If you know how to use it, if you can execute with it, and if rates aren't historic lows with inflation that is there, I mean, shouldn't you have understood? I mean,
- 9:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 9:34
- Gino Barbero: didn't. I didn't think rates were gonna go up that quickly. I knew rates had only one way to go, which was up. But did anybody really think that rates were gonna get shot up that quickly in a year? No, it shocked the entire system. But there's the risk using a tool, not understanding that tool,
- 9:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 9:52
- Gino Barbero: then all of a sudden you're caught. And the same thing happened with me in 07. I bought the deal. And when I went to refinance the deal, it was very challenging. It was a really difficult part of the debt market. And that's what happened in 22 and 23. Things were good. You buy your deal, 24 comes, all of a sudden, you're looking,
- 10:12
- Gino Barbero: the horizon's there. I've got three years on this thing and possibly one more year to extend. But when I extend, I took out a rate cap. That's insurance on your rates going up. That's expiring. To buy a new rate cap, it's going to gonna cost me a ton of. money. What do I do? So, the lesson in this part of the market cycle, it's pretty simple.
- 10:31
- Gino Barbero: Understanding where you are and understanding that if you need debt as that vehicle to manipulate to make this deal work, is it going to be a good deal? Remember, you have to buy right, which the financing is part of it. But if you're buying at a really low cap rate and you know interest rates are gonna going to go up, and at some point in the future, cap rates
- 10:51
- Gino Barbero: are going to compress and go up as well. Is that a good strategy? Is it good to do that? Back in 06 and 07, when I bought that deal, I look back at it. I could have still bought it, but I paid a million two for the deal. I should have probably paid sub million dollars for that deal. And I would have been okay. I still would have lost money,
- 11:11
- Gino Barbero: but I overpaid. And then I didn't know how to operate the deal. It that was the reality. And so when you're looking at this part of the market cycle, the fatal wound was the debt. And that's where we are right now. Right now, debt's very difficult. They're not going to give you loan to cost like they did three years ago. Loan to values aren't 70% or 75%.
- 11:31
- Gino Barbero: They're probably 60% and 55% if you're refinancing a deal. They want a lot of skin in the game right now. They want to learn. right? So those are the first two. You have the patient and you have the fatal wound. Let's take a quick time out to hear from our sponsor. And on the other side, we're going to be talking about the complications, what fell apart, and I'm going to give you an exercise so you
- 11:51
- Gino Barbero: don't commit these same mistakes. I want to take a moment to tell you about Wheel of Our Profits. Here's why I think it's worth your attention. Vince Gethings started with a zero zero-down down VA. loan back in 2013. He lived in a house, he renovated it, he netted $130,000. Then
- 12:11
- Gino Barbero: he went all in. He purchased 20 units from Hawaii. He scaled it to over 800 units, launched six businesses, and built the entire portfolio with a mile-deep mile deep focus on Dallas Fort Worth. He is not someone selling a dream from the sidelines. He is an operator who is in still the
- 12:31
- Gino Barbero: seat every day. And the program he leads, Wheelbarrow Profits, has helped students close over $5 billion in multifamily deals across more than 90,000 units. If you've been thinking about how to go from consuming content to actually building a portfolio, go to Wheelbarrow
- 12:49
- Gino Barbero: wheelbarrowprofits.com Profits.com.
- 12:52
- Gino Barbero: and take a look at what they've put together. And we are back. Now we're at part three. Three, the complications. Well, right now the deal is going, renovations are slowing down because remember, there's problems with supply chains. It's taking you six months to get a door. And see, that's why Bridged bridge Debt in and
- 13:12
- Gino Barbero: of itself wasn't bad all alone. But when it's taking you months to turn units instead of weeks, you're seeing you're under a time constraint. And I'll say this: one of a really smart investor that I know told me there's two ways to lose money in real estate. You either run out of money or you run out of time. And in
- 13:32
- Gino Barbero: this part of the market cycle, it appears that a lot of people were running out of time right now. So the complications, all of a sudden, you're material. your materials are jumping up. Your expenses are going up. No one thought expenses would go up this quickly. I don't know why. And now that I look back at it, even myself, well, inflation is running at 9%. Of course, expenses are going to run up. And property taxes went
- 13:52
- Gino Barbero: up a lot, insurance went up a lot, but materials went up. Uh, you're talking about labor. It all went up from $5,000 a unit, $5,500 a unit, to like $7,000 a unit. It's tremendous. And now all of a sudden, rents are slowing down. Oh gosh, rates are going up, rents are slowing down, and expenses are getting higher. And I'm gonna put more salt
- 14:12
- Gino Barbero: on the wound. Which, if we had really stopped and slowed down, the experienced investors knew this. All of a sudden you have new supply coming online. And not just a little bit of new supply. We're talking record amounts of new supply. Just to give you an example, in our market of Knoxville, Tennessee, 20% of all the multifamily in that market has been
- 14:31
- Gino Barbero: delivered since 2021. So in the last five years, we've gotten 20% of all multifamily. What do you think that's going to do to pricing and rents in our market and occupancy? Well, it creates It's a great ability for residents to have no rent control. Rents are going to gonna flatline. flatline.
- 14:51
- Gino Barbero: Occupancy is gonna drop. We're at 96%. Now we were we've recovered to 93%, but you're talking 91%, 92% occupancy for a lot of people in that portfolio. So all of a sudden, you've got a lot of
- 15:03
- Gino Barbero: units coming online. There's concessions. We've got to give some away free stuff. So remember in 21 and 22, you could fog a mirror and people would rent that apartment. It was so easy. Now it's all about retaining. Please let me retain these residents and not raising rents. And also being
- 15:23
- Gino Barbero: able to give out concessions to keep the ones that you have, or to actually rent out the ones you have. Now there's some light at the end of this tunnel because all of a sudden you're saying to yourself, supply is dwindling. Remember, survive till twenty-five. 25. Well, we're at the end of twenty-six. 26, and we do see light at the end of the tunnel. It took a lot longer, even for the
- 15:43
- Gino Barbero: experts. And what's going on in our market right now, a lot less permits. There's a lot less units that are that are going to be delivered at the end of 27. So there we still have some deliveries going on right now. But thankfully for us, and thankfully for a lot of these markets that I talked about, whether it's the Sunbelt, whether it's Nashville, whether it's Charlotte, whether it's Dallas, they
- 16:03
- Gino Barbero: luckily have job and population growth that's going to absorb a lot of these units. But it's going to take a while for that to happen. And it's going to take some time for rents to recover. Now, the fourth one is the final blow: the cash-in, refinance, and the capital call. We thought after three years, we're going to use that bridge to get from A to B and to
- 16:23
- Gino Barbero: be able to refi. All of a sudden, our valuations did. not go up. Our valuations stayed. They flatlined because rents didn't go where we projected them to go. We didn't get the expenses to stay where they were supposed to stay. So all of a sudden, your debt coverage ratio is really not great. It's not a one three or a one-four.
- 16:43
- Gino Barbero: You're hovering at a one-one, one, maybe one, two. So what happens? Well, for you to have this deal to survive, you've got to have a capital call.
- 16:51
- Gino Barbero: Andor you have to have a cash in refinance. That sounds weird because we're so used to cash out refinances. Is it more, I just judicious, or is it more wise to be able to take this deal and continue to survive? Or you just say to yourself, I'm gonna take a haircut and sell this thing. It's very difficult. It's it's an
- 17:11
- Gino Barbero: emotional decision. I ended up back in twenty 2017. seventeen. Remember the deal I talked about in 2006? In 2017, I ultimately ended up selling it for a substantial loss. It was just myself, my brother, it was my family's deal. I had no investors.
- 17:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
- 17:27
- Gino Barbero: sunk a lot of money into the deal. Could I have held on and seen the market take it another three or four years? I'm not sure because the market itself wasn't great. The commercial leases there weren't great. I just had to make that financial decision of yes, I'm going to lose hundreds of thousands of dollars on this deal today. Am I willing to do that today? Or am I
- 17:47
- Gino Barbero: willing to put it off and speculate and try to hold on? That's a very difficult question to answer. Also, with the capital call, do you have your investors put in additional capital to this deal? Now, if you've got a sound business plan and you've stabilized the asset, and you just need a little bit more time
- 18:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 18:05
- Gino Barbero: be able to refinance this thing or to be able to work it out with the bank, then maybe that's a possibility. But if you see the values have dropped so much and putting in extra capital, you're not going to get that money out. I think it's time to unfortunately cut the cord. That's what I ended up having to do, being able to fight another day. Now there's an exercise that I want you to
- 18:25
- Gino Barbero: do. And really when you're reflecting on the deals going forward, every part of the market cycle is different. In this part of the market cycle, being more conservative, looking at cap rates, not going down three or five years when you're exiting it, making sure that your expenses go up modestly, not 1%, maybe a little bit higher, maybe 2%.
- 18:45
- Gino Barbero: And now you may be saying, Well, Gino, if I do that, I'm not gonna find a deal. Well, no deal is better than a bad deal. I've already explained to you what happened to me in 07. 10 years of freaking pain, 10 years of shoveling the snow, 10 years of dealing with those tenants, 10 years of all 10 years of all that capex. I mean, it was worth it to me ultimately
- 19:05
- Gino Barbero: because I learned so many lessons. I would never take that away. But if I could have avoided that and used my money elsewhere, or if I could have learned that lesson differently,
- 19:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I would.
- 19:14
- Gino Barbero: have done it any day of the week. So the first exercise, the first one is the debt test. If rates rise 2%, can your deal survive? Underwrite it that way. If you got, if especially if you're using bridge debt, if you're at 5% and rates go to seven, can your deal survive? If it can, then it may be a go. If it can't, then think twice. The second one is
- 19:34
- Gino Barbero: the rent test. If rents stay flat, does the deal work? Now, obviously, if you're buying a deal that rents are 800 and it's a mom and pop and the rents have been there forever, and you know because you own other assets in the market that down the street you're getting 1100. Well, that's not rent growth. That's just getting it up to the market. Unfortunately, the
- 19:54
- Gino Barbero: problem right now with those deals is that the sellers they still want value. They still want you to pay for their work. You have to buy that at on an actual cap rate. You have to buy that on yield cost. So you know that you're buying it based on those that income and those expenses. So when you do put the work and time into it, then you can recapture it on the back end. Don't overpay. But the rent
- 20:14
- Gino Barbero: test, if your rents stay flat and you're buying a deal that's sort of you know stabilized and you're thinking you're gonna go five or seven percent a year, watch out for the market because our rents this year, maybe 1% last year. they were flat. Next year, maybe 2%. Just be very careful. And the exit test. If the property drops 20%, can we
- 20:34
- Gino Barbero: refinance without bringing extra capital? And this is where you run out of time, right? Back in 08, there were a lot of operators who were still cash flowing their deals, but their debt ran out of time and they cash flowed right into foreclosure. That's what I don't want you to do. Having this property that's still performing, but all of a sudden, around
- 20:54
- Gino Barbero: the area, valuations drop and you go to try to refinance this property and your values dropped, even though you're cash flowing, be careful with that. Once again, two ways to lose money in this business. If you don't have enough CapEx reserves, you run out of money or you run out of time. Ultimately, once again, I'm gonna say it again. This is the framework you have to buy.
- 21:15
- Gino Barbero: it, you have to operate it, you have to exit it. If you want to learn more about that system, just email me gino at jakengino.com. I've taught hundreds of investors on how to buy real estate, how to invest in real estate. It really comes down to having a business. It comes down to having that mindset of okay, here's an asset. What do I want to do with this asset? How can I create value for this
- 21:35
- Gino Barbero: asset? How can I run it like a business? If your deal only works when everything goes right, you're not investing. You're speculating. Once again, two ways to lose money in real estate. You either run out of money or you run out of time. Follow the framework discussed in the show to avoid both.
- 21:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
- 21:50
- Gino Barbero: is Gino Barbero from Jake and Gino and of Barbero360. Thanks for tuning in. I'll see you all on next week's episode.
More from Jake & Gino: Real Estate Investing & Multifamily
Before You Buy a Multifamily Property, Look for These Red Flags
Episode discussion: Speakers warn of red flags in multifamily underwriting and physical inspections amid rising rates
Speakers’ claims: Jake Sensi and Gino Barbo discuss critical red flags for multifamily investors, emphasizing that AI cannot replace physical property tours. They highlight poor maintenance, inconsistent renovations, and inadequate water management as signs of deferred upkeep. The speakers note that current market conditions feature gridlocked pricing, rising interest rates, and softened rent demand, making traditional underwriting models obsolete. They advise discounting offers significantly and focusing on operational metrics like 'percent repaired' to ensure resident retention. Finally, they advocate for a 'buy right, operate, exit' framework, using refinancing to extract equity for scalable growth.
Why Nobody Is Buying or Selling Multifamily Deals Right Now
Episode discussion: Barbero cites frozen multifamily market due to seller anchors, cautious buyers, and tight lending
Speakers’ claims: Gino Barbero describes the multifamily market as a 'Mexican standoff' where no deals are closing because sellers are anchored to peak 2021-2023 prices while buyers and lenders face tighter conditions. He notes that since 2013, his firm averaged two deals per year but has closed none in the current year, contrasting with a 2023 peak of 300 units. Sellers are ignoring higher interest rates (rising from 3-5% to 6.5%), increased operating expenses, and lower occupancy rates. Buyers are cautious due to past losses and capital constraints, while lenders have raised standards to 40% down payments and 1.3x DSCR requirements.