Retirement Answer Man

Roger Whitney outlines a three-layer rebalancing framework to ensure liquidity and income security before retirement.

33 min Listen to the original Episode page
Retirement PlanningAsset AllocationLiquidity ManagementRisk ToleranceSocial SecurityFinancial Planning

Summary

Roger Whitney argues that rebalancing portfolios before retirement is critical to prevent individuals from deferring their lives due to market downturns. He identifies three key factors influencing rebalancing priority: guaranteed income sources, the fundedness of the retirement plan, and psychological comfort with volatility. Whitney proposes a framework consisting of three asset layers: a contingency fund for liquidity, an income reserve covering five years of spending, and a long-term portfolio for growth. He also addresses listener questions regarding finding fiduciary planners and the psychological aspects of retirement transition.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    what I do think is important to everybody at this stage is to make sure you have enough liquidity that you are not going to defer your life just simply because a bear market or some other crisis comes. into season. You only have so much time and you only have so many go-go years early on, and you don't want to be in a position, regardless of how much money you have, that a storm coming in like that is gonna make you defer your life.

    Roger Whitney · 1:47

  2. 2
    Guaranteed income sources like Social Security, pensions, or annuities can make rebalancing less critical as they provide immunity to market volatility for basic needs.

    Roger Whitney · 2:56

  3. 3
    $50,000. I'm just picking that number. You're going to have to define how much you want, and that's going to be based off of how comfortable you are and how much cash makes you not feel poor. That's locally. It also is going to be determined by how much clarity you have about your life in that moment. If you're in calm waters life-wise, then you could just stick with, say, that $50,000. as an example. But if you're thinking about buying a house or you have some decisions, you're not sure if they're going to happen or not, then maybe you increase that liquidity, perhaps dramatically, to sort of position yourself for some of these future decisions that seem like they might actually happen.

    Roger Whitney · 13:37

  4. 4
    But the point of the income reserve, its job is to have clarity that you can fund your base grade life and your discretionary spending, typically, for the next, say, five years. That way, if the storm comes in early and retirement, in retirement, you don't have to defer your life.

    Roger Whitney · 16:10

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 1:29

    Introduction and Importance of Liquidity

    Roger Whitney introduces the topic of rebalancing portfolios before retirement, emphasizing the need for liquidity to avoid deferring life due to market downturns. He notes that the importance of rebalancing depends on individual circumstances.

  2. 1:29 – 3:31

    Factors Influencing Rebalancing Priority

    Whitney outlines three factors that determine how critical rebalancing is: guaranteed income (social capital), the fundedness of the retirement plan, and psychological comfort with volatility. He explains how these factors interact to influence risk tolerance.

  3. 3:31 – 4:31

    Retirement Planning Software and Fundedness

    Discussion on how retirement planning software using Monte Carlo scenarios helps assess 'fundedness'; significantly overfunded plans may allow for continued growth-oriented allocations.

  4. 4:31 – 8:51

    Psychological Comfort vs Mathematical Fundedness

    Psychological comfort with volatility is a distinct factor from mathematical fundedness; investors may need to rebalance for safety even if the math supports higher risk.

  5. 8:51 – 9:31

    Rebalancing Framework: The Three Layers

    Whitney proposes a practical framework involving a 'retirement plan of record' and assigning specific jobs to assets. He details three layers: a contingency fund for liquidity, an income reserve for the next five years of spending, and a long-term portfolio for growth.

  6. 9:31 – 12:18

    Calculating the Base Great Life Budget

    A 'base great life' budget must be calculated, covering fixed costs like utilities, health insurance, taxes, and basic entertainment, serving as the floor for spending.

  7. 12:18 – 15:30

    Asset Assignment and Contingency Fund

    Assets should be assigned specific jobs: contingency fund for liquidity, income reserve for 5 years of spending, and long-term portfolio for growth. A baseline contingency fund of $50,000 is suggested, but should be adjusted based on life clarity and upcoming major decisions like buying a house.

  8. 15:30 – 20:06

    Income Reserve for Five Years

    An income reserve should typically cover the next five years of spending to ensure the retirement paycheck is not at risk during market downturns.

  9. 20:06 – 25:11

    Listener Question: Finding a Retirement Planner

    A listener asks how to find a planner to act as an 'insurance policy' for his wife after his death, including tax preparation. Whitney advises looking for a flat-fee planner who can build a relationship with the spouse and suggests separating tax preparation from financial advice for checks and balances.

  10. 25:11 – 27:42

    Listener Question: Non-Financial Aspects of Retirement

    An anonymous listener asks if the industry focuses too much on accumulation and not enough on the psychological transition of retirement. Whitney agrees, stating that planners often give lip service to life changes but fail to ensure plan resilience against storms.

  11. 27:42 – 32:36

    Rockin' Retirement in the Wild and Closing

    Whitney shares a story from a listener who retired early after her husband passed away, citing Social Security benefits and the podcast as key factors. He concludes with a book recommendation, 'Better with Age,' and a call to action for listeners to evaluate their asset allocation.

Claims worth verifying

Roger Whitney has over 35 years of experience as a practicing retirement planner.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:11

How to verify: Check Roger Whitney's professional biography on Retire Agile's website or LinkedIn profile. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Monte Carlo scenarios are a standard feature in retirement planning software used to assess fundedness.

Roger Whitney ·3:51

How to verify: Review documentation for major retirement planning software providers (e.g., eMoney, MoneyGuidePro) or academic literature on Monte Carlo methods in finance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The S&P 500 and NASDAQ returned 15% a year over the last 15 years.

Roger Whitney ·18:23

How to verify: Calculate the Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) for the S&P 500 and NASDAQ indices from 2026 to 2026 using Yahoo Finance or Bloomberg data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Roger Whitney does not like planners doing tax returns because it creates a conflict of interest and lacks checks and balances.

Roger Whitney ·23:12

How to verify: This is a subjective opinion; verify by checking Roger Whitney's published articles or podcast episodes where he elaborates on this preference. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The book 'Better with Age: The Psychology of Successful Aging' was written by F. Alan Castrel.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·30:52

How to verify: Check the book's copyright page or Amazon listing for the author's name. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Rebecca retired in 2024 after her husband passed away in 2021.

Roger Whitney ·28:03

How to verify: This is a listener testimonial; verification would require direct contact with the listener or the firm's internal records, which are not public. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Social Security widows' benefits can be claimed starting at age 60.

Roger Whitney ·28:03

How to verify: Check the Social Security Administration (SSA) website for rules on widow's benefits and eligibility age. For recent events, verify 2026-08-04 through 2026-11-04. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify personal guaranteed income sources (Social Security statements, pension plan documents) to assess baseline cash flow.
  • Use a Monte Carlo retirement calculator (e.g., Personal Capital, Vanguard) to determine the fundedness percentage of your current portfolio.
  • Calculate your 'base great life' budget by summing fixed essential expenses to determine the minimum liquidity needed.
  • Review your current asset allocation against your psychological comfort with volatility, not just mathematical projections.
  • Identify a flat-fee fiduciary planner and verify their credentials (CFP, CPA) and fee structure via the SEC IAPD or NAPFA.
  • Assess the tax implications of rebalancing by consulting a tax professional separate from your financial advisor.
  • Read 'Better with Age' by Roger Whitney to understand the psychological transition of retirement.
  • Evaluate your contingency fund size against upcoming major life decisions (e.g., home purchase, healthcare needs).
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): To
0:01
Roger Whitney: play off a Mike Tyson quote, 4% rules, guardrails, and YouTube influencers sound great until you get punched in the face.
0:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey
0:11
Roger Whitney: there, welcome to the show dedicated to helping you not just survive retirement, but to have the confidence to lean into your life today, knowing that you can navigate whatever unfolds. My name is Roger Whitney. I'm a practicing retirement planner with over 35 years experience and co-founder. of the retirement planning firm Retire Agile. Today on the show, we're going to talk about how
0:31
Roger Whitney: to rebalance a portfolio before retirement. That's sort of a critical time to start thinking about that. And really, you can do this when you're in retirement or anytime that the purpose of your money changes. And we'll talk about what that means. In addition, we're going to answer some of your questions and share one of my favorite things, which is rocking retirement. in the
0:51
Roger Whitney: wild, a story from a listener that is, well, sounds like they're leaning into life, which I love to hear. If you want to get links to resources that we talk about and a daily dose of wisdom every Saturday morning, go to RogerWitney.com and sign up for our noodle email. You can do that right at the bottom of the first page. We'll send out a weekly
1:11
Roger Whitney: dose. And the cool thing is if you hit reply to that email, it goes directly to me. So you can ask a question that we might get on the show or share some feedback, whatever you want to share.
1:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
1:20
Roger Whitney: right, with that out of the way, let's talk about how to rebalance a portfolio.
1:29
Roger Whitney: Before we get into some basic mechanics of rebalancing from a growth allocation to an allocation that will fund your various phases of retirement. Let's talk about how important this is to you. Because it's really about you and determining is this important? Not everything is important to everybody.
1:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,
1:47
Roger Whitney: what I do think is important to everybody at this stage is to make sure you have enough liquidity that you are not going to defer your life just simply because a bear market or some other crisis comes. into season. You only have so much time and
2:07
Roger Whitney: you only have so many go-go years early on, and you don't want to be in a position, regardless of how much money you have, that a storm coming in like that is gonna make you defer your life. So I think all of us need to feel comfortable that hey, these next two, three, four, five years, I am going to live a life.
2:27
Roger Whitney: based on the things that are really important to me, regardless of what's going on in the world. We want to be in that kind of position, regardless of where we're at money-wise. But beyond that, there are some reasons that might make this a lot less of a priority for you. So I want to go over three of the main ones and they interact in some way. So there might be some
2:47
Roger Whitney: combination of these. This may be less of a priority. if you have a lot of social capital, which is essentially guaranteed income.
2:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
2:56
Roger Whitney: if you have Social Security and you have a pension or you have new annuity income, and that income covers most or all of your base great life or your basic needs with some fun,
3:11
Roger Whitney: well, you're somewhat immune to markets. there. So you might not have to rebalance the rest of your portfolio to be more moderate because your life isn't going to be disrupted as easily. That's one of the big arguments for having guaranteed income. You also might make this less of a
3:31
Roger Whitney: priority if you are significantly overfunded, meaning that you have so much income and resources in terms of. investments relative to what you are forecasting you're going to spend for the rest of your life that it would take a lot. I mean, a lot to make that thing not work and make that plan not feasible.
3:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
3:51
Roger Whitney: the typical way of assessing this is using retirement planning software that usually gives you a confidence of success. Monte Carlo scenarios, that's one thing that software is very good at having. helping us suss out is our fundedness. And if it's significantly overfunded, and if you stress test it, it's still overfunded and
4:11
Roger Whitney: highly confident. That might be a reason that you could still have a growth-oriented stance in your portfolio. And then the last one that I'll mention at least today is your psychological makeup. Because you could have a lot of guaranteed income. You could have a lot of assets relative to your spending,
4:31
Roger Whitney: but you could psychologically just not feel comfortable spending money if we go through storms. You could not handle the volatility regardless of what the math says. So even if a storm comes in and it's not really going to impact the trajectory of your retirement plan, psychologically, you're not going to spend money because.
4:51
Roger Whitney: you've lost 30% in a bear market and you're going to defer your life. You're going to defer your time, which is your major diminishing resource. So psychologically, even if the math works, you want to make sure you're positioned to handle volatility. So in this case, if you can handle volatility and you have some evidence that, yeah, I'm not
5:11
Roger Whitney: worried about this and I get the math, and so I'm not going to defer my life, then great. You can make this a little bit less of a priority.
5:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
5:18
Roger Whitney: let's talk about the inverse. If your guaranteed income or social capital is limited relative to the amount that you're spending on your base great life, maybe you should think about rebalancing a little bit more because you're going to need to rely on your financial assets, your investments more to fund
5:38
Roger Whitney: just simply that. base great life, not even talking about the extras. That may mean that this is more important. Another factor that might mean that this is a higher priority is that your plan is constrained. And again, we'll go back to the software. If you're running Monte Carlo scenarios or you're using a free tool at Fidelity or wherever, even if
5:58
Roger Whitney: your advisor is doing this, by the way, if your plan is sensitive.
6:03
Roger Whitney: to market downturns or spending shocks, or let's say your confidence is like 85%. But if we go through a storm or you have a spending hiccup, that confidence number goes down dramatically. Well, then now you're sensitive to what happens in the outside world a little bit. And that means you may need to rebalance your
6:23
Roger Whitney: portfolio to be a little less volatile so you can start. survive those downturns. And again, this math math only takes you so far because it's surviving those downturns means not moderating your early life just simply because we're in a storm. So if you're sensitive or constrained,
6:43
Roger Whitney: which is probably the majority of people, yeah, you probably should think about this rebalancing.
6:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
6:48
Roger Whitney: then the last thing that might make this more important.
6:51
Roger Whitney: is that psychological aspect as well, where you maybe lean a little bit more safety first in how you think about markets. It doesn't matter what the math says, you're not comfortable with spending, which will cause you to defer your life. That may mean that we need a more stable approach to what your allocation is,
7:11
Roger Whitney: regardless of what the math mass says. So those are some things. that might influence how important this is to you.
7:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
7:18
Roger Whitney: how do you approach this rebalancing? I think of this as, and I've used this analogy before, driving. Like when we're in growth mode, we're driving on a flat open highway for decades from investing standpoint. Point. We're just trying to grow, grow, grow. We're putting the pedal to the metal and we're even adding more fuel to the engine
7:39
Roger Whitney: as we go because we're we're investing in markets. But when you start to come towards retirement or you're in retirement, you're entering a road that has some twists and turns to it, meaning that you can't see far ahead. Sometimes there's even fog there because you're not sure what you want w your life to be look like.
7:59
Roger Whitney: And you're not sure what's around the corner, especially as you're transitioning into a retirement, because it's all theory what this life is going to look like.
8:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
8:06
Roger Whitney: what do you do when you're driving? And I do this all the time when I go to Colorado. I'm in West Texas, it's pedaled to the metal within the speed limits. Within the speed limits, because it's flat, it's open, nothing's getting in my way. Then I get off the highway right after I get into Colorado. Now I'm on these twisty roads, and sometimes it's early or it's dusk.
8:27
Roger Whitney: and it's harder to see. The visibility is less clear. I don't know what's around the corner. So what do you do when you're driving? You slow down. Well, that's one thing that you would do in this rebalancing exercise because you may have to change your mind quickly about your priorities, and you're gonna have to be much more agile. So
8:47
Roger Whitney: you want wanna to give yourself some space, just like you would on a twisty road.
8:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And we
8:51
Roger Whitney: got to be careful because we might hit a slippery spot. That's the bear market. So, how do you actually rebalance practically? This is the way that I've learned it and I've developed, and we use it in our practice. And you've no doubt heard on the show before if you've listened. First, you create a retirement plan of
9:11
Roger Whitney: record. That is, in my view, critical because. that is your plan. That is the series of decisions that you made of what your retirement's going to look like and how you're going to fund it. And that gives you something to navigate when things change, whether it's your mind or the markets. So you need to build a vision. How much
9:31
Roger Whitney: does your base great life cost? That is going to be all the things you have to do: utilities, health insurance, taxes. on real estate, your mortgage payment, uh, food, all that stuff, plus some basic entertainment and travel, your base great life. That is like the floor that we never want to
9:51
Roger Whitney: violate. And then you want to calculate how much discretionary spending do you want to have? This is these are the spending that can come or go. I'm going to go on trips every year, but it's a year-by-year year by year decision. I'm going to gift every year. It's a year by year decision. That's more spice of life. We need to know what your projections are on those. That's what
10:10
Roger Whitney: you want to know. And you don't want to know it just for this year. You want to make some forecast over the next 30 years as best you can. And each year you retire, you will have more information so you can refine these as you discover yourself. Gotta have that in place. Next, we need to know how feasible that plan is. And that's organizing your
10:30
Roger Whitney: financial resources, all the income that you're going to receive, all the work income you might receive from part-time work, what your financial assets are, whether you're going to get an inheritance or not, or whether you're going to sell some assets or not, and that money's coming back in, et cetera. We need to organize all those resources and then assess, given this time frame.
10:50
Roger Whitney: is this a safe journey for me to fund the goals that I set? Software is great at this. But generally, software starts to get not so great when we figure out okay, how do I rebalance to fund my life? Because software is going to use withdrawal rates. It's just going to because it's a math
11:10
Roger Whitney: program in the background. And so it's going to, well, if we take this much, you know, we'll rebalance and just sell this amount from our investments as we go. That is not a plan. Well, it is a plan, but it's not a good plan if you want to have confidence to lean into your life today and have some room to navigate changes of
11:30
Roger Whitney: mind and storms, et cetera. It's not a good enough plan. What you need to have after that is you need to reallocate your financial aspects. assets to match your spending and also to give you liquidity or money that's not at risk. So when the world does change
11:50
Roger Whitney: because of a bear market or because you've changed your goals or life has happened to you, you have some money that's not at risk where you can have time to make decisions and navigate. whatever's unfolding. And so the rebalance that you ultimately want to do is you want to look at every
12:10
Roger Whitney: dollar you have in money markets and in 401ks and investments, and you want to assign it a job.
12:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
12:18
Roger Whitney: that job is going to be dependent upon the purpose that that money has. Let's go back to that word utilitos. utilitas. Does it serve its purpose well? Well, you have multiple purposes in retirement. The first purpose is you want to have a financial airbag, which means you want to have money typically locally
12:38
Roger Whitney: that you can fix that air conditioning today if you had to, or you can book that trip because this opportunity of a lifetime came. You want to have enough financial margin of cash locally so you don't feel poor and you don't defer moving quickly when an opportunity comes or when life just happens, your car breaks
12:58
Roger Whitney: down or whatever. So that is a purpose. So we need to have money assigned to that purpose. And that is what we call the contingency fund. How much should you have in that? So you're going to look at all of your assets and you're going gonna to say, this is how much I want in that contingency fund. And here are the dollars I'm giving that purpose. And
13:18
Roger Whitney: that purpose is going to be what we talked about. And then it's gonna be invested in, well, typically high yield money market, short-term CDs, et cetera. The key there is liquidity. Now how much should you have in this contingency fund? I don't know. I don't know anything about your life. Where you're gonna going to define this though is let's just use a baseline of
13:37
Roger Whitney: $50,000. I'm just picking that number. You're going to have to define how much you want, and that's going to be based off of how comfortable you are and how much cash makes you not feel poor. That's locally. It also is going to be determined by how much clarity you have about your life in that moment. If you're in
13:57
Roger Whitney: calm waters life-wise, then you could just stick with, say, that $50,000. as an example. But if you're thinking about buying a house or you have some decisions, you're not sure if they're going to happen or not, then maybe you increase that liquidity, perhaps dramatically, to sort of position yourself for
14:17
Roger Whitney: some of these future decisions that seem like they might actually happen. I might actually move. So I may need more liquidity. And it's starting to sort of be a real thing. So maybe I start building that contingency fund. So I have more money available for all the friction that happens there. Or perhaps it's your daughter or son that, hey, they actually are now getting serious about someone. It looks like
14:37
Roger Whitney: they're gonna engage. That means I might have a wedding next year. So maybe I start building that contingency fund in anticipation. Oh, they broke up. That's so sad. But now we can ramp it back down. So you're gonna going to dial that in. But that's the first.
14:51
Roger Whitney: job that you need to assign some money to. The second job you need to sign some money to is the money that is there to create your paycheck. Because if you are retired and you don't have a ton of social capital or guaranteed income, you're going to be spending more than your income in retirement. That's somewhat what
15:10
Roger Whitney: retirement is. So we need to have money to fill the gap of what you're. your income isn't going to cover for your base grade life and your go-go years. We need to create a payroll reserve or an income reserve is the term we use. And that is the money that's going to fund your paycheck. Because it's really important, in my opinion, that your
15:30
Roger Whitney: paycheck it is clear where it's going to come from. You should know. And you should know that money money's is not at risk. The default I use is. we should know where your paycheck's going to come from for the next five years. There's nothing special about five years. That's just the default. And it and the more overfunded you are, the more you could make it
15:50
Roger Whitney: make it three years or two years or even one year. The more constrained you are, you probably wouldn't want to stick with five years, or maybe you go to six or seven. Same thing on the psychological evaluation. If you're if you're a little bit more safety for first, maybe you make it eight years, even though you're overfunded. See how this is working? These levers interact with each other.
16:10
Roger Whitney: But the point of the income reserve, its job is to have clarity that you can fund your base grade life and your discretionary spending, typically, for the next, say, five years. That way, if the storm comes in early and retirement, in retirement, you don't have to defer your life.
16:30
Roger Whitney: You don't have to start figuring out what you're going to sell in order to fund that gift you're going to give to your daughter or go that trip you're going to take. That is a horrible position to be in. That's not the point of retirement. And that's essentially what a guardrail or 4% rule puts you into is no, I just got to trust the math and sell
16:50
Roger Whitney: when. I need it. That's why we need to rebalance because that's not the reality of retirement planning. Reality is that everybody is a little bit different. And the point is to put them in a position where they can confidently lean into their life today and navigate all the crazy stuff that happens in life.
17:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
17:07
Roger Whitney: that's the second job that your money has to be assigned to, and they're that has to have utilitas. And then the last job. that the money typically has is what's called your long-term portfolio. This is the money, if you're 60 years old, that is going to try to grow for future spending that you're not aware of, for
17:27
Roger Whitney: inflation, and all the other things that could go wrong later in life. That is a long-term portfolio.
17:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
17:33
Roger Whitney: that will, because of the first two layers that we have here, I used to call this a pie cake. I still do. Makes sense to me, not to others. But this third layer, long-term portfolio, is meant to grow for your future self. And that's going to be more the growth-oriented portfolio. Go ahead, have stocks, let that thing go up and down because you have a proper time frame
17:53
Roger Whitney: to set it up for success. This is so important. And virtually, I well, not virtually, I don't really hear anybody talking about this in detail.
18:03
Roger Whitney: And that includes retirement planners or financial planners because we've had this beautiful tailwind. It seems inefficient. It seems inefficient. Why would I have that much money in an income reserve that's invested in, say, you know, a short term treasury ETF or treasuries or CDs? Why would I have that money there when I can earn
18:23
Roger Whitney: 15% a year over the last 15 years in the S SP P. 500 and NASDAQ? That doesn't seem efficient. Mathematically, it may not be, but it's pretty dang efficient if you want to really rock retirement and not be at the whims of the outside world, which is the whole point of the exercise. Wow, I feel like I'm preaching here. Okay, put away the soapbox a little bit. So
18:43
Roger Whitney: you need to map this out. Or your advisor needs to map this out in detail. And then the next question is. once you've mapped it out and you've come to some of these decisions based on your fundedness level, your psychological makeup, and your guaranteed income, how do you execute it? That becomes a whole
19:03
Roger Whitney: nother layer. And we talked about this a little bit in the story I shared. I think it was John, about they wanted to fund their life with post-tax assets, but it put them in a tax bind.
19:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
19:14
Roger Whitney: so we talked about, well, just do it in your pre-tax assets early on because there's no tax consequence. And you've achieved the intent, which is to give yourself some financial margin
19:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
19:26
Roger Whitney: you can navigate life and you can navigate the world. Doing this requires some intentionality, and it requires some decisions that are sometimes uncomfortable because we're going to be selling things that have been vedeved to us. Perhaps they've given us growth. And we may end up
19:46
Roger Whitney: paying taxes on the sales that we did, but it positions, it rebalances your portfolio to serve the new purposes in your life. So your assets have utilitas. They're serving the correct purposes.
20:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All right.
20:01
Roger Whitney: With that said, now we're going to move on to some listener questions.
20:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
20:05
Roger Whitney: let's get to
20:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that.
20:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
20:11
Roger Whitney: it's time to answer your questions. If you have a question for the show, go to askroger.me and you can type in a question or leave an audio question. And we'll try to help you take a baby step towards rocking retirement. We'll put a link to that link, by the way, in our noodle email so you can get to it easily.
20:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
20:25
Roger Whitney: our first question comes from William. related to retirement planners and finding one.
20:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Roger, thank you very much on your Reaps and episode on finding a retirement planner. I do have a question, and I assume many of your listeners are thinking the same way. I'm thinking about finding a retirement planner, one that could also To prepare and file our federal and state returns. My munging money goal is for myself and my wife.
20:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): to have a working relationship with someone so that when I pass, my wife will have someone that can monitor and advise her on financial situations. I have been doing it myself and I enjoy it, but my wife has no interest. A few years back, I had a plan to review our plan and confirm that the plan was good. In my mind, I'm
21:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): not looking for a planner as much as an insurance policy. What approach should I take? Should I outline what I just said above? I have to admit the cost in my mind is something that needs to be negotiated. I understand he or she will have an upfront cost to review our situation, but the real work is when I pass. Thank you
21:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): very much, Roger, for any feedback.
21:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey
21:33
Roger Whitney: William, I think you actually framed it really well. You're looking for an insurance policy, somebody that you can collaborate with a little bit with, but but you're going to be doing it on your own so that your wife has a trusted guide when she needs to do this on her own if you predecease her. I think that's totally reasonable. And it sounds like you've already gone down this path. You've hired somebody
21:53
Roger Whitney: to do a flat fee plan. So you now you have a relationship with them. Is that person somebody your wife could build a connection with? Do you think that they would jive? It could be as simple as just hiring that person once a year to go through the process and reconfirm your work and give you suggestions.
22:13
Roger Whitney: And along the way, your wife is building some collegial relationship with this person and can evaluate whether she has a connection with this person. Because practically speaking, really what we want is it sounds like that if you're to die, who does she call? Who can she trust to be a guide that won't take
22:33
Roger Whitney: advantage of her, that will help her navigate not just all the crazy financial changes, but some of the life stuff and and have patience, etc. That's really what you want. So you want somebody that they can trust, the non non-financial financial spouse, and you want somebody that they connect with. Those are really the criteria. You don't want somebody to help you plan, it
22:52
Roger Whitney: sounds like. And some of the other things that you talked about are you want them to do the tax return. Well, then that's just part of your criteria with these flat fee planners. Do you can you find a planner that will do tax returns in a one-time plan to help validate your work each year? Just put that into the mix. Personally, William, I
23:12
Roger Whitney: don't like planners doing tax returns.
23:15
Roger Whitney: It's convenient for sure, but I like to have an outside CPA do tax returns. And my logic behind that is it creates some checks and balances because the advisor is going to see anything that the CPA is recommending because it will flow through to what's moving around in assets. And the CPA is going to be able to see what's going on with the
23:35
Roger Whitney: assets. And that can be a healthy check and balance to make sure that
23:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there
23:41
Roger Whitney: aren't any red flags or yellow flags or just curiosity. So I like to have them separate. And if you decide to fire one, you don't have to blow everything up and start over. But that's my personal preference. And there are plenty of fantastic planners that do hourly work, that do flat fee work. Now they're generally going to
24:01
Roger Whitney: be younger. They're generally going to be less seasoned, but it doesn't mean that they're not capable at some level. The more seasoned advisors and retirement planners are not going to work hourly. They're not going to work with DIY people, and they're not going to negotiate their fees. So you're probably looking for someone
24:21
Roger Whitney: young, but not too young that has, you know, maybe five or six years in the business and they're willing to do work for someone who really wants to do it on their own. They're willing to work in a negotiated way because they want or need the business. But I think you already have a great framework to start pursuing that. Where those people are, you're going to
24:41
Roger Whitney: really have to hunt and peck them because it ultimately it's going to come down to who can you trust. It's like a real estate deal. If you've ever bought private real estate,
24:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): which
24:49
Roger Whitney: sounds like an odd segue, but
24:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
24:51
Roger Whitney: you can read all the credentials, you can read all the proformas and everything else. Everybody is going to sound great on paper and maybe in talking with them, but really you want to assess connection and do they really know what they're talking about? And that's where those second and third order questions that we talked about last week could come into play. Our next question
25:11
Roger Whitney: comes in from Anonymous. Anonymous says, Do you think conventional retirement planning spends too much time helping people accumulate enough money to stop working and too little time preparing them to replace the mission, structure, challenge, and identity that work provided? Generally, yes, I do. Retirement planning is
25:31
Roger Whitney: treated as a financial investment issue by almost the entire industry, and they give lip service to one. one's life, but not much more. And that that said, each person addresses this life change very differently. Some have no issue at all transitioning into retirement. They don't have an issue with their identity and social networks and all that other stuff.
25:51
Roger Whitney: They just keep on trucking and they just naturally transition into life. Others don't struggle, but they do struggle to detox from the stress fest that was their career. I was talking to someone in the neighborhood the other day. It took him 18 months. He didn't realize how much he had to detox from the pace of work,
26:11
Roger Whitney: the learned behavior that he had. Others don't worry and they just figure it out naturally. And that and then the last group is sort of the one that you're talking about, they do. They think intentionally about this identity. They hold on to that and want to navigate that much more.
26:27
Roger Whitney: intentionally than maybe some others. So I think a good planner needs to meet and understand where the client is within those realms to not just simply force down a life coachy discussion to someone who's really not having any problems with it. But as a general rule, I think
26:47
Roger Whitney: financial planning and retirement planning, they give lip service to it, but it's talking points to get to the investment numbers. And I also think, and this is related to today's show, that as a rule, and again, this is just my personal experience in knowing advisors for 35 years, not saying this is everybody. I don't mean to
27:07
Roger Whitney: cast too broad of a brush, is that we're great at, you know, what are your goals? We're great at is it feasible? We don't do, as a rule, a great job of is it resilient so I can have confidence even if a storm comes in. I think that that part of the financial equation is dramatically overlooked. So hopefully that
27:27
Roger Whitney: answers your question. In my practice, we try to understand where the clients are and lean into what they're hearing and be curious about it. So if they're not having an issue in
27:39
Roger Whitney: the identity and purpose stuff, then we don't have to go there.
27:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
27:43
Roger Whitney: want to give uh just a rocky retirement in the wild story from Rebecca. I don't know Rebecca. She just emailed in. She said, hey Roger, love your podcast, found it quite some time ago, and have been listening ever since. In 2021, my husband passed away. During this difficult time, listening to your podcast really helped me set my path forward.
28:03
Roger Whitney: At that time, I did not know I could get Social Security benefits when I turned 60 until I listened to one of your podcasts. And that leads me to light the fuse to my retirement date. Ooh, that's really cool, Rebecca. I've been retired since 2024 and share your podcast with many ex co workers and fellow widowers. Witterers To say I'm living my best life
28:23
Roger Whitney: does not do it justice. I wake up every morning excited and grateful. Thank you so much for all your knowledge and content.
28:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
28:31
Roger Whitney: first off, Rebecca, thank you for sharing that with me. That is that really fuels me and gives me, I sit here and talk about things I'm thinking about and try to be helpful and don't get a lot of feedback. So hearing this kind of story just warms my heart and makes me love doing what I'm doing. So thank you for sharing that.
28:51
Roger Whitney: And I think it is a good example, whether it's, you know, of finding people that are just dripping on you and loving on you, in this case in retirement planning, and just little tidbits. And you never know when you're going to find one little thing. Could be related to Social Security and widows' benefits. It could be on rebalancing. That would
29:11
Roger Whitney: just help shift perspective a little bit, but you got to hang out with people that you're. you really resonate with. And Rebecca, I'm glad that we've been able to walk this journey with you in a very small way. All right. That said, let's go set a smart sprint.
29:24
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Onimox, get set.
29:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
29:33
Roger Whitney: we're off to set a little baby step you can take in the next seven days to and not just rock retirement, but rock life. All right, in the next seven. days,
29:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
29:40
Roger Whitney: want you to do an honest evaluation of your allocation and ask yourself Is your money doing the job that it's supposed to do for the stage of life that you're in or that you're headed towards? Or are you, and also I'd evaluate are you a little
30:00
Roger Whitney: enamored, a little lulled to sleep by all these. great returns and hesitant to make adjustments that are going to serve the season of life that you're moving into. I think this is an incr a critical point.
30:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
30:14
Roger Whitney: it may be okay that you are fine the way you are, but this is a good time to evaluate that. Even with the the the recent volatility in the current markets, the markets have been vetted good to us. Now's the time. to assess this so you can have utilitas
30:31
Roger Whitney: for your assets and the job and the purposes you're supposed to
30:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): have.
30:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
30:39
Roger Whitney: right, to end the show, we're gonna go off the bookshelf. Another one from Kevin Lyle, coach in the Rock Retirement Club. I love Kevin. The title of the book is Better with AIDS: The Psychology of Successful Aging by F. Alan Castrel.
30:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Here
30:52
Roger Whitney: are Kevin's thoughts. In Better with Age, Alan debunks the all-downhill myth that older does not mean losing all cognitive in life quality. Amen. In fact, many older adults report being happier and less stressed than they were when they were young. Castrel also addresses declining memory and reports that
31:12
Roger Whitney: older adults get better at focusing. on what truly matters, prioritizing meaning, meaningful information, and applying their acquired wisdom to new problems. His ultimate conclusion is that while there is no easy way to avoid, or there is no way to avoid aging, there are many ways to achieve successful aging, which he believes
31:32
Roger Whitney: is about attitude, adaptation, staying curious, and finding personal meaning. Wow, that last. sentence did it for me, Kevin. This book is Better with Age, The Psychology of Successful Aging by Alan Castrel. Kevin gives it a four. All right, with that said, next week, we're going to talk about should I do a Roth conversion this
31:52
Roger Whitney: year? And then in addition to that, I'm going to share a personal story about almost getting scammed. Oh boy. And how you can avoid it. Until then, be well.
32:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
32:06
Roger Whitney: opinions voice in this podcast are for general information only and not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. All performance reference is historical and does not guarantee future results. All indices are unmanaged and cannot Not be invested in directly. Make sure you consult your legal, tax, or financial advisor.
32:27
Roger Whitney: before making any decisions. This podcast may include testimonials and or endorsements.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Retirement Answer Man

All insights