RenMac

Speakers analyze NVIDIA scandal fallout, consumer value-seeking trends, and rising real yields impacting market rotation.

52 min Listen to the original Episode page
NVIDIAConsumer SpendingInflationReal YieldsSemiconductorsFed PolicyRetail EarningsGeopolitics

Summary

Jeff DeGraff and Steve Duttenhoffer discuss the NVIDIA spy scandal, noting stock weakness preceded public news and predicting prolonged penalties for involved firms. Michael Gunther highlights consumer value-seeking behavior, with higher-income shoppers frequenting dollar stores and premium brands missing expectations. DeGraff points to slowing auto sales and collapsed existing home sales due to rising borrowing rates, while Gunther estimates core PCE inflation remains above target. The hosts agree that real yields, rather than inflation expectations, are driving current market rotations toward value and quality stocks.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    I will say this, I think the market knew something was up because it was weaker before it was starting to unravel pretty quickly um before this all came out.

    Jeff DeGraff · 0:00

  2. 2
    Michael Gunther observes that higher-income consumers are making up an outsized share of growth at dollar stores, indicating broad value-seeking behavior.

    Michael Gunther · 6:32

  3. 3
    Michael Gunther estimates core PCE will rise 0.28% in October, translating to a 3.4% annual rate, which remains well above the Fed's target.

    Michael Gunther · 16:46

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 3:27

    Intro and NVIDIA Spy Scandal

    Jeff DeGraff notes NVIDIA's stock weakness preceded public scandal news, suggesting insider knowledge. Steve Duttenhoffer and Jeff DeGraff joke about NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang's attire and the

  2. 3:27 – 10:53

    Consumer Spending Trends with Michael Gunther

    Michael Gunther of Consumer Edge discusses early signals of consumer value-seeking behavior, including higher-income shoppers at dollar stores and weakness in discretionary apparel. He notes a deceleration in spending growth across several sectors from September to October.

  3. 10:53 – 16:24

    Consumer Durables and Housing Impact

    Jeff DeGraff highlights slowing auto sales and collapsed existing home sales due to rising borrowing rates and mortgage delinquencies. He argues consumer spending is moderating but not collapsing, with employment growth remaining strong.

  4. 16:24 – 23:46

    Fed Policy and Inflation Outlook

    Michael Gunther estimates core PCE will rise 0.28% in October, translating to 3.4% annually, well above target. He argues the Fed faces a binary choice: hike rates due to falling unemployment and sticky inflation, or risk over-tightening later.

  5. 23:46 – 26:18

    Export Controls and Geopolitics

    Steve Duttenhoffer and Jeff DeGraff discuss the fallout from the NVIDIA spy scandal, predicting stricter enforcement of export controls and potential legislation in the National Defense Authorization Act. They warn of a potential Chinese retaliation involving rare earth magnets.

  6. 26:18 – 29:55

    NVIDIA Scandal and Semiconductor Rotation

    Jeff DeGraff discusses the impact of a scandal involving NVIDIA and similar companies on the semiconductor sector, noting that while there was a tactical bounce due to oversold conditions, it does not signal a trend change. He highlights that stocks typically remain down about 8-10% for three months following such scandals, and mentions rotation into AMD and AvaG.

  7. 29:55 – 33:37

    CoreWeave Financing and Real Yields

    DeGraff analyzes CoreWeave's decision to fund infrastructure build-outs through customer prepayments rather than public debt, citing higher interest rates as a deterrent. He notes that real yields, driven by the price of time rather than inflation expectations, are favoring value and quality stocks over growth and cyclicals.

  8. 33:37 – 36:20

    Inflation Expectations and Fed Policy

    Michael Gunther argues that stable inflation expectations are misleading because markets assume the Fed will act, causing breakevens to remain stable while real yields absorb the shock. DeGraff agrees, stating that the market believes the Fed will do its job, which suppresses the inflation premium in yields.

  9. 36:20 – 40:08

    Market Efficiency and Price Discovery

    In response to a listener question, DeGraff asserts that while the market can be wrong in the short term, it is dangerous to bet against it consistently. He emphasizes that price is a critical indicator of what the market deems important, often overriding static fundamental metrics like price-to-book.

  10. 40:08 – 44:43

    Political and Economic Watchlist

    Gunther outlines his focus on the US-China AI truce extension through January 10th, internal Democratic party dynamics, and the confirmation of financial regulators. He highlights upcoming retail sales, housing data, and Fed speeches as key economic indicators for the week.

  11. 44:43 – 52:15

    Retail Earnings and Consumer Behavior

    DeGraff and Gunther discuss the upcoming retail earnings season, focusing on Home Depot, Lowe's, TJ Maxx, Target, and Walmart. Gunther notes Walmart is losing share to club stores among lower-income consumers but gaining share among higher-income shoppers, while also highlighting a rapid shift in consumer gas station spending toward Costco.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
NVIDIANVDAequityneutralwas there something Huang at NVIDIA this week?
MicrosoftMSFTequityneutralwe have we have seen at least some companies announce uh you know layoffs. I think Microsoft announced what last week that they were laying off 60,000 people.
Goldcommoditybearishto that, right, you also have gold breaking down, right? So gold made a new low, right?
BitcoinBTCcryptobearishyou've got Bitcoin, which looks like it was a what we call a bull trap. It tried to break out and then failed and is now in the low, you know, 70,000s.
Walmart Inc.WMTequityneutralAnd then of course, uh Target and Walmart. Target obviously a more uh specific story about Target uh itself versus the entire economy, but Walmart will you know be

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

NVIDIA stock was weaker before the scandal started to unravel publicly.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:00

How to verify: Compare NVIDIA (NVDA) stock price charts from late 2026 prior to the public announcement of the spy scandal with the date of the public announcement. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Higher-income consumers made up an outsized share of growth at dollar stores.

Michael Gunther ·6:32

How to verify: Review Consumer Edge transaction data or SEC filings of major dollar store operators (e.g., Dollar General, Dollar Tree) for demographic spending trends. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Deckers and ASICS missed expectations by holding premium pricing.

Michael Gunther ·7:11

How to verify: Check Q3/Q4 2026 earnings reports for Deckers Outdoor (DECK) and ASICS (ASICY) for revenue guidance and actuals versus analyst estimates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Existing home sales collapsed to the lowest level since 2010.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·11:09

How to verify: Consult National Association of Realtors (NAR) Existing Home Sales data for October 2026 and compare to historical data from 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Core PCE will rise 0.28% in October, translating to 3.4% at an annual rate.

Michael Gunther ·16:46

How to verify: Compare this estimate to the actual October 2026 Core PCE Personal Income and Outlays report released by the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA). For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Core CPI is close to 4% over the last three months.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·19:49

How to verify: Check the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) CPI data for the three months leading up to October 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Average hourly earnings is 4% over the last three months.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·19:49

How to verify: Check the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Current Employment Statistics (CES) data for average hourly earnings growth over the prior three months. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Microsoft announced 60,000 layoffs.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·23:07

How to verify: Review Microsoft (MSFT) press releases or SEC filings (Form 8-K) regarding workforce reductions in late 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Jeff DeGraff claims the market knew something was up with NVIDIA because it was weaker before the scandal.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:00

How to verify: Analyze NVIDIA (NVDA) stock price action and trading volume in the weeks preceding the public disclosure of the spy scandal. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Michael Gunther estimates core PCE will rise 0.28% in October.

Michael Gunther ·16:46

How to verify: Compare this specific numerical forecast to the actual Core PCE release from the BEA for October 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

President Trump asked Jensen Huang if he knew if his wife was a spy, and Huang said no.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·26:35

How to verify: Search news archives for reports of Trump's interaction with Jensen Huang regarding his wife's security clearance status around the time of the scandal disclosure. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Stocks involved in major scandals are down about 10% and remain down about 8% three months later.

Jeff DeGraff ·28:23

How to verify: Review Jeff DeGraff's research team's historical analysis of the 10 biggest scandals over the last 20-30 years, or conduct a backtest of stock performance 3 months post-scandal disclosure for major corporate scandals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

CoreWeave's stock was up 25% on strong earnings.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·29:55

How to verify: Check CoreWeave's stock price movement and earnings report details from the date of the report mentioned in the transcript (late November 2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

CoreWeave stated they would not issue debt in public markets and would force customers to prepay.

Jeff DeGraff ·30:15

How to verify: Review CoreWeave's earnings call transcript or press release where they discuss their financing strategy and customer prepayment models. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The 10-year Treasury yield broke out around 4.84%, ran to 5.30-5.34%, and bounced back.

Jeff DeGraff ·32:02

How to verify: Plot the US 10-Year Treasury Yield daily chart for the period leading up to the transcript date to identify the breakout level and subsequent peak. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Bitcoin is in the low 70,000s.

Steve Duttenhoffer ·34:53

How to verify: Check the current price of Bitcoin (BTC-USD) on major exchanges or data providers like CoinGecko/CoinMarketCap. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Costco gained 50 basis points of share in gas station spend within two weeks of the Iran war starting.

Michael Gunther ·46:30

How to verify: Review Consumer Edge's analysis or Nielsen/IRI data on gas station market share shifts following the start of the Iran conflict mentioned in the transcript. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Walmart is losing share among lower and middle-income consumers but gaining share with higher-income consumers.

Michael Gunther ·45:32

How to verify: Check Walmart's recent earnings reports or consumer spending surveys (e.g., NRF, Nielsen) for demographic breakdowns of customer share shifts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Chuck Schumer faces a challenge from Senator Van Hollen for Senate Majority Leader.

Michael Gunther ·41:13

How to verify: Check news reports regarding Senate leadership races and internal Democratic party dynamics for the 2026-2026 term. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Lutnik is expected to leave his cabinet seat before February.

Michael Gunther ·42:14

How to verify: Monitor political betting markets (e.g., Calci) or news reports regarding the tenure of the Treasury Secretary or relevant cabinet member named Lutnik. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify NVIDIA's stock price action relative to the public scandal announcement date using historical price data.
  • Check CoreWeave's financing disclosures and customer prepayment terms in SEC filings or press releases.
  • Review October Core PCE inflation data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis to verify the 3.4% annualized estimate.
  • Analyze existing home sales and auto sales data from the Census Bureau and Federal Reserve to confirm moderation trends.
  • Examine earnings reports and guidance from Deckers, ASICS, Walmart, and TJ Maxx for consumer spending shifts.
  • Assess the impact of rising mortgage rates on housing affordability using Freddie Mac or MBA data.
  • Monitor real yield movements and breakeven inflation rates to understand the drivers of value vs. growth rotation.
  • Investigate potential export control legislation in the National Defense Authorization Act regarding rare earth magnets and semiconductor exports.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
0:00
Jeff DeGraff: like I don't know that much about NVIDIA uh down you know down to the core. Um NVIDIA was a name that was leadership. I will say this, I think the market knew something was up because it was weaker before it was starting to unravel pretty quickly um before this all came out.
0:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
0:17
Jeff DeGraff: so somewhere somebody knew something that was probably gonna be troublesome. Um and you know clearly that was happening.
0:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): RenMac OffScript originated as a weekly internal research meeting designed to summarize and discuss what happened in Washington, the markets, and the economic data over the past week. It was always intended to be and remains a free-flowing conversation with no discernible objective other than to extract the wisdom and opinion of our analysts and their
0:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): expertise. This is a conversation among colleagues. Individual circumstances are unique. and nuanced. Do not mistake these conversations for investment advice because it's not. Here we go.
0:59
Steve Duttenhoffer: All right. Welcome to Red Mac OffScript, where we openly discuss markets, economics, policy, history, and life. It is Friday, November 13th, 2026. I'm Steve Duttenhoffer.
1:09
Jeff DeGraff: I'm Jeff DeGraff.
1:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
1:11
Michael Gunther: Neil Dutta. Detta. I'm Steve Pabler.
1:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:14
Michael Gunther: I'm Michael Gunther.
1:16
Steve Duttenhoffer: Well, what a week uh that was. Huh? Didn't have that on my bingo card to start the year. Start the year? What? The the spy scandal? Like is the thing that oh, that was the only story this past week.
1:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
1:32
Steve Duttenhoffer: mean wait,
1:33
Jeff DeGraff: was there something Huang at NVIDIA this week?
1:38
Steve Duttenhoffer: Insert insert the dad joke. That's
1:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
1:41
Steve Duttenhoffer: Wait, wait, wait. I like how Neil is now going with the blue jean jacket to offset, right? Jensen. Is that your new look, Neil? Are we going with jean jacket? I mean, that is pretty jersey, I gotta tell
1:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you.
1:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
1:53
Jeff DeGraff: God he's on mute.
1:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
1:55
Jeff DeGraff: God he's on mute.
1:56
Steve Duttenhoffer: It's so good. He's such a
1:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mute. You're on
1:59
Jeff DeGraff: mute.
2:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): He You
2:00
Steve Duttenhoffer: still can't hear us.
2:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There
2:03
Steve Duttenhoffer: you go.
2:05
Michael Gunther: I was um no, I'm sorry about that. Do should we uh he popped the uh he popped the AI bubble with his Wang.
2:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh
2:12
Jeff DeGraff: boy, oh boy,
2:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we had to go.
2:14
Jeff DeGraff: We had to go.
2:15
Steve Duttenhoffer: All right.
2:19
Steve Duttenhoffer: I will say this though, I gotta give a shout-out Shout out to
2:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
2:21
Steve Duttenhoffer: uh Ministry of State Security over in China. I mean, right? I mean, but that they that's well played. They actually stuck spy right next to the
2:30
Jeff DeGraff: trick in the book. I mean,
2:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a lot more than Eric Swallow,
2:33
Michael Gunther: I'll tell you that.
2:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What's
2:34
Steve Duttenhoffer: that?
2:35
Michael Gunther: Jensen matters a lot more than Eric Swallow. Um
2:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): start
2:43
Jeff DeGraff: scrutinizing Harry a little bit more. I think Harry might be the red redmac Mac honeypot. We got gotta to be careful
2:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
2:47
Jeff DeGraff: uh
2:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what we've we got
2:48
Jeff DeGraff: with that.
2:49
Steve Duttenhoffer: I also have to give you proud. know props to uh Secretary Bessant, right? I mean, this is uh him shouting down Lutnik. I
2:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean
2:55
Steve Duttenhoffer: he's a real fighter. We should have him come back to our edge conference this year, do like a cage match, right?
3:02
Jeff DeGraff: Well,
3:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
3:03
Jeff DeGraff: don't think he would go for that. But um well look, I I think when you wear a g uh uh a black leather jacket all the time, I mean that thing's gotta be hot. I don't blame him. He probably just is always wanting to take it off. Like it's gotta be hot wearing that thing 24-7.
3:19
Jeff DeGraff: No? All right, back
3:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to the regular sponsor programming. That's right.
3:24
Michael Gunther: I think that's the reason jacket thought. Certainly did.
3:27
Steve Duttenhoffer: Well, uh, Michael Guntner is Gunther is joining us this AM. Uh he's a senior vice president of In a research and market intelligence at Consumer Edge, which is an alternative data and analytics company focused on. consumer spending. They track credit and debit card transactions across the US. So if Neil tells us what the government data says
3:47
Steve Duttenhoffer: about the American consumer, Michael tells us what the consumer actually did swipe by swipe. So Michael, thanks so much for uh joining us this morning.
3:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
3:56
Michael Gunther: no, happy to uh join you guys. Um yeah, happy to talk through you know what we're seeing in the data.
4:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
4:02
Michael Gunther: you know in in recent months and weeks.
4:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
4:07
Jeff DeGraff: Michael, I'm curious about that. Uh you know, I mean absolutely want to hear your your your take on it. But just from a seasonal standpoint, what when do you really w when does the seasonal shopping start uh in the US? I know you know we talk about I think uh Starbucks starts putting uh you know autumn cups out in August, right? Yeah, there you go.
4:27
Jeff DeGraff: Like and then yeah, the snowflakes start coming in October, right? Like it's it feels like they're try always trying to push it uh earlier and earlier. But from from your data, when does the when does the the Christmas holiday uh shopping actually start with consumer?
4:42
Steve Duttenhoffer: Neil's already put up his Christmas tree, so that tells you that right there.
4:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
4:46
Michael Gunther: seems like the uh the the uh amount of sales that are starting early. earlier um you know tend to increase over time. So you know it's a little bit more spread out. I mean, before drawing any big conclusions, we'll wait until uh Black Friday, Cyber Monday. But um, you know, we started to get early signals on what consumers are feeling like,
5:06
Michael Gunther: you know, with Halloween can be spending and things like that. But uh yeah, I mean in the coming weeks we'll we'll get a much clearer picture. Aaron
5:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
5:13
Michael Gunther: So what's your early signals? sense? I mean, I I remember when I was an analyst at Merrill Lynch, like the consumer discretionary folks would literally go to the mall on Black Friday and write that up as like a research note.
5:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um I
5:27
Michael Gunther: thought it was hysterical. I mean, that was kind of funny that they would do that. I mean, it just seems like an excuse just to get out of the office. But um
5:35
Michael Gunther: so I mean,
5:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
5:37
Michael Gunther: what is your early sense? I mean, I I uh fr I I I gather, you know,
5:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
5:42
Michael Gunther: lot of times people say like if you have a strong back to school season, that kind of is all like very well correlated with the strong holiday shopping season. I mean, is that
5:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
5:50
Michael Gunther: mean, what are you seeing in your in your data
5:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
5:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
5:55
Michael Gunther: know in terms of uh consumer spending behavior? Um in the aggregate and like sort of the interesting kind of things you see under the surface?
6:03
Michael Gunther: First off, I'll tell you that's reminding me I used to go when I was a research associate uh to the Stanford Mall and we would eat in the food court,
6:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
6:12
Michael Gunther: you know, get the bourbon chicken and then go to all the different stores in the Stanford Mall and and write down what promotions look like. So I I'm having a little PTSD from what you just said. Um no, and look overall you've heard a lot about uh you know the consumer remaining a little bit more resilient than a lot of people expected. Um, but even before the recent
6:32
Michael Gunther: month, we were seeing a lot of signs of value-seeking behavior, not just from low and middle-income consumers, but higher income consumers who made up an outsized share of growth at dollar stores, for example. And even if you look within In apparel, uh the best performing piece of that by far is. resale. And
6:52
Michael Gunther: then you're seeing weakness in more discretionary categories like footwear and athletic apparel. You know, it's been interesting, that's been one of the softer areas. Um it's not just the Nikes and Lululemons of the world. It seems to be expanding. And one of the interesting things recently is you know, you had companies like Decker's on, and then this morning
7:11
Michael Gunther: ASICs, you know, talking about holding premium pricing. And you know, they seem to have all missed expectations. So maybe there's less consumer appetite for that. Recently, uh we're starting to see a little softening. So there was a deceleration in most industries we track when you look at year-over-year spending growth between September and
7:31
Michael Gunther: October, um, you know, in apparel accessories, in luxury and in department stores. Uh so maybe this. is, you know, a sign of a little bit more, you know, discerning behavior among consumers. And by the way, we're seeing the same sort of thing outside of retail in restaurants, where the best performing subsector is
7:51
Michael Gunther: coffee, where you know, people may be pulling back on more expensive full meals, but they're still making room for Or uh, you know, the small indulgence, you know, at seven, $7, eight $8 dollar latte. So we've been seeing this value seeking behavior build for a while. Maybe the softening now is indicating that you know this is gonna manifest itself in some less
8:10
Michael Gunther: exciting numbers. But again, we'll have to wait to see what happens with Black Friday, Cyber Monday.
8:15
Jeff DeGraff: If you think about the um the Stanford Mall, I think that's a pickleball court now. Is that right? Do you uh I I'm pretty sure that's shut down, it's into a pickleball court.
8:23
Michael Gunther: Oh, right. That's funny. I haven't been there in
8:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): twelve
8:26
Michael Gunther: years, maybe, so I have no idea.
8:28
Jeff DeGraff: Bring your bring your racket next time you go.
8:31
Steve Duttenhoffer: So uh Michael, is that is the is the what drawdown or the drop down and what people are spending? Is that uh I'm gonna assume inflation related, not stock market related, correct?
8:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
8:43
Michael Gunther: I mean
8:45
Michael Gunther: that probably is is the case. I mean, we've started to see more evidence of you know food price inflation. uh creeping in. We have a a receipt level data set that lets us uh have some visibility into that at various retailers like Walmart and Grocers. Um and we're seeing, you know, average transaction sizes in the credit and debacard data move up. So that
9:05
Michael Gunther: certainly could be part of it. And I think some of the dynamics that you're seeing in terms of the winners and losers, you know, seems to indicate that um, you know, the the companies that are communicating value. better. That doesn't always mean the cheapest seem to be doing better. So yeah, it does seem to be related to that. Um and look, we're not seeing a big drawdown in uh spend overall. This is just
9:25
Michael Gunther: a moderation in growth. And you're not necessarily seeing a big slowdown among high-income consumers. If the stock market were to come down more, then maybe that influences high income sentiment a little bit more than it has so far.
9:40
Steve Duttenhoffer: Neil, overall, you're seeing at least what mortgage delinquencies on the rise. I think your take on the consumer is not one that's gonna continue to bolster the economy.
9:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
9:53
Jeff DeGraff: I mean, I I I kind of share Michael's view, which I I mean, if you look at the government data, we had
9:58
Michael Gunther: sort of breakneck growth in consumer spending in the spring and the summer quarter. I mean, I think it was three and a half to four percent in real terms with respect to consumer spending, which is very strong. Um now,
10:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
10:14
Michael Gunther: the government data doesn't always align with some of these private data sources, right? I mean, that's that is true. Um, but you know, generally speaking, uh, I don't think consumer spending in the fourth quarter is going to be nearly as strong as it was in the spring and the summer quarter. Now, that's not saying
10:34
Michael Gunther: much because I don't think that that's that growth was sustainable. I mean, that you know, even when you account for the wealth effect and, you know, the drawdown in savings and so forth, I mean, having 4% consumption sustain is a very, very challenging thing, even in the best of times, to be qu to be. quite perfectly honest. Now,
10:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
10:53
Michael Gunther: know, obviously when what what what Michael's looking at is is um, I mean, I'm sure he has access to all different sorts of of data, but uh you know, one of the things I'll say is that um, you know, in terms of consumer durable goods,
11:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,
11:09
Michael Gunther: you do see some slowing there. Like so, so so so for example, like auto sales have my moderated a little bit, right, from where they were in in Q uh in Q2 and Q3, which makes sense because household borrowing rates have been going up. Right. So if if if car loan rates are rising, like why would you why would you expect auto sales to continue running
11:29
Michael Gunther: at 16 million SAR? Uh we saw earlier this week uh existing home sales basically um you know collapsed. to the lowest level since uh 2010, right? That probably continues given what we're seeing in mortgage rates, right? Pending home sales um have already hit record lows, and those
11:49
Michael Gunther: are signed contracts. So you'd expect closings to remain under pressure. But if housing turnover is zero, very low, I mean, where would you really expect consumer durable goods spending to go? So um yeah, I mean I I I think think the consumer is uh I don't think is going to be as strong of a sort of support
12:09
Michael Gunther: mechanism for the broader economy going forward. Um
12:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
12:13
Michael Gunther: that doesn't mean it's collapsing either. I mean, um I'd love to hear Michael's take on this, but what really breaks the consumer is job loss, right? Ultimately, right? I mean, that they, like, you know, it's um and I I the other thing I'll say is that. you know, from like sort of if you think about it in terms of business cycle analysis, um
12:33
Michael Gunther: consumers never like the signal. Like consumption actually, I mean, there there are recessions where consumer spending actually goes
12:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): up. Like
12:41
Michael Gunther: in 2001, consumption was fine. I mean, it wasn't fine, but it was it was it wasn't actually going down. The signal, in other words, wasn't in consumer spending. That was true also. in uh in 07, right? I mean, consumer spending was kind of hanging in there until the very end.
12:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
12:58
Michael Gunther: the signal usually comes from investment, right? So in terms of like forward signal for for for the broader economy. So
13:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
13:07
Michael Gunther: yeah, I mean, I I think it's really a question around job loss. So you could talk about consumer spending moderating in the fourth quarter. I think that that that makes a lot of sense. Um
13:18
Michael Gunther: but in terms of a consumer breaking,
13:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
13:22
Michael Gunther: that's much harder to see because
13:26
Michael Gunther: employment is accelerating. I mean, if you if you look at the uh the data, um jobs growth is running a lot stronger than it was six to nine months ago. And uh and to me that's important. Yeah,
13:36
Jeff DeGraff: I mean it it doesn't seem like the you know that consumer spending is about to collapse. It just
13:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
13:42
Jeff DeGraff: people are becoming increasingly choosy in what they spend
13:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
13:47
Jeff DeGraff: what they spend
13:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on. Um it
13:49
Jeff DeGraff: also remains to be seen how much increased tax refunds kind of pulled forward a little bit of spending earlier in the year. One of our data sets
13:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
13:58
Jeff DeGraff: we're actually able to see inflows and outflows, and we can isolate tax refund results. recipients.
14:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And there were
14:04
Jeff DeGraff: various parts of
14:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): travel and apparel that
14:07
Jeff DeGraff: seem to have benefited from people that receive
14:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): tax
14:11
Jeff DeGraff: refunds versus
14:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not. So it remains
14:14
Jeff DeGraff: to be seen whether
14:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or not that
14:15
Jeff DeGraff: pulled
14:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
14:15
Jeff DeGraff: forward and
14:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): will then
14:16
Jeff DeGraff: manifest itself in some softer spending later in the year. The same thing goes for, by the way, buy now, pay later. We saw increased adoption of buy now, pay later
14:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): across. uh
14:27
Jeff DeGraff: all groups.
14:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um, but you know, that
14:31
Jeff DeGraff: there's much more
14:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of a
14:31
Jeff DeGraff: concentration,
14:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
14:32
Jeff DeGraff: course,
14:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): among uh middle and low income uh
14:35
Jeff DeGraff: consumers, but even among high
14:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): income consumers,
14:39
Jeff DeGraff: the adoption is
14:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): going way
14:40
Jeff DeGraff: up.
14:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Does that
14:41
Jeff DeGraff: also create an additional
14:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
14:43
Jeff DeGraff: source of spending
14:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that, if that
14:45
Jeff DeGraff: slows
14:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): down,
14:46
Jeff DeGraff: would lead to something later? That you know, we'll have to see. It's interesting also
14:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
14:50
Jeff DeGraff: mentioned that
14:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how.
14:50
Jeff DeGraff: the housing starts
14:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
14:52
Jeff DeGraff: data from yesterday. We've done some analysis recently
14:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): around
14:56
Jeff DeGraff: the composition of home furnishings spend. Home furnishings was one of the areas that actually decelerated the most. It had a strong September in our data, but it really decelerated a lot into October. But even when it was stronger, the composition of those sales really shifted where it's much smaller purchases. So it does. reflect that
15:16
Jeff DeGraff: people are, you know, filling in, um, refreshing a room, buying a lamp versus buying uh a lot of stuff
15:24
Michael Gunther: to furnish a whole entire home. So that's you know showing some further pressure in that key industry.
15:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey,
15:31
Jeff DeGraff: I've got a real quick question. How uh in terms of overall credit and the uptake by the consumer, where where are they? You know, versus history versus disposable income, et cetera? Are they relatively tapped out? Are they, you know, a lot more purchasing power? In other words, you know, uh are are they are they kind of living off tomorrow versus living
15:51
Jeff DeGraff: off today, or where are we on that continuum?
15:54
Michael Gunther: That's a good question. It's not something we can necessarily see in our data outside of you know the buy now pay later as a uh an additional source of credit. on top of credit and debit cards. But yeah, besides that, it's not something we can really glean.
16:08
Jeff DeGraff: Neil,
16:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do you
16:09
Jeff DeGraff: know that off the top of your head?
16:12
Michael Gunther: I don't.
16:15
Steve Duttenhoffer: What you do know off the top of your head, however, is we had CPI data, PPI data this week. What's the Fed gonna do? We had some Fed speak out there too, right?
16:24
Michael Gunther: Yeah, I mean
16:26
Michael Gunther: uh the well the you know the producer price in I mean we had a very, very bad core CPI number earlier in the week. The producer price index that was released earlier this morning takes some of the uh heat off of uh consumer prices. So when you kind of do the uh mapping of CPI and PPI into core
16:46
Michael Gunther: PCE, uh we uh estimate that uh core PCE. is going to rise 0.28%
16:54
Michael Gunther: in October. Um that translates to 3.4% at an annual rate. So that's still way above their target. Um and uh yeah, I mean it's not
17:07
Michael Gunther: it's it's it's a very, very small comfort. Um, you know, the the the relief we're getting from PPI, I doubt it lasts. Uh but but it at any rate,
17:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
17:17
Michael Gunther: the inflation data are horrendous. And, you know, more to the point, I mean,
17:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
17:24
Michael Gunther: the Fed call is conditional, of course, on the economy, right? Like so how you think about the economic outlook determines very much what you think about the Fed, what the Fed will do. Okay. You could tell a pretty good story for why. unemployment's gonna go down.
17:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Look
17:41
Michael Gunther: at jobless claims, look at job finding rates, look at the jobs growth relative to what we think break-even is. So you can tell a pretty
17:47
Steve Duttenhoffer: good story for why unemployment's going down, and
17:50
Michael Gunther: you can tell a pretty good story for why inflation's gonna stay elevated. So
17:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
17:55
Michael Gunther: you have 10 central bankers faced with that set of data, all 10 of them are gonna going to tell you the same thing,
18:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): which
18:01
Michael Gunther: is hike. They don't know. anything else, right? So all these other arguments that you hear, I mean, oh, well, you know, they can't do anything about the tech story, and you know, it's not as rate sensitive, and uh, oh, oil prices just fell because you know, we lost escalation risk after the midterms. Like, none of these arguments hold water. Okay,
18:21
Michael Gunther: like they just don't. It's employment and inflation. Unemployment is falling further below their estimate of Nehru. And inflation is running over a full percentage point above their target. It's really that simple. So you can talk about the timing of how quickly they hike. You can
18:41
Michael Gunther: talk about how they space out the hikes, whether they go 50 or 25.
18:49
Michael Gunther: But the conversation is only in one part of the distribution.
18:54
Michael Gunther: It's just that simple. In terms of the Fed speak this week, I mean Williams was on the tapes. You know, look, I I
19:03
Michael Gunther: uh
19:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
19:04
Michael Gunther: know, he remember Williams uh was the guy that basically torpedoed Of the idea of an October rate hike.
19:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
19:13
Michael Gunther: and And um
19:15
Michael Gunther: he's saying, you know, he's he's on board for a hike in December, it looks like. But he he's he's he prefers a gradual approach.
19:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
19:25
Michael Gunther: he uh he noted today, uh or overnight rather, that uh there's no he doesn't see
19:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
19:31
Michael Gunther: we're not seeing signs of the economy overheating or signs that somehow the economy is out of balance.
19:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
19:39
Michael Gunther: mean, it's interesting because inflation, core CPI, is close to 4% over the last three months, and average hourly earnings is 4% over the last three months. I mean, that's
19:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): kind
19:49
Michael Gunther: of overheating ish. I mean, it's it's uh it suggests that the monet that monetary policy is too accommodative. Uh and then you had We uh Governor Waller, um, who was on the tapes earlier this week, basically putting on the table a 50 basis point move. Now, it doesn't seem like he has much support for that around the table uh based on the Fed
20:09
Michael Gunther: speak, but it's just again, it's a reminder. Like, this was the guy that basically came out and said, don't go in October.
20:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
20:18
Michael Gunther: now he's coming back and saying, maybe we go 50 in December. Like, think about how stupid that sounds. Like, how about you just go in October?
20:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
20:28
Michael Gunther: mean, it's just like it's a it's a little bit ridiculous, right? Like, so I I think this is this is part of the the risk right now with the Fed is that inflation's a lagging indicator and monetary policy itself works with uh lags, right? And if you're falling behind if you're behind the curve, you don't know in real time like how
20:48
Michael Gunther: much you need to do in order to actually. quell the inflation issue. All I can tell you is that the fact that unemployment is likely to fall and inflation remains sticky to the upside means that policy is probably too loose right now. And um
21:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
21:04
Michael Gunther: just creates the risk of a of a sort of catch-up. Um and that means that over-tightening over tightening becomes a risk because they don't wanna um
21:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
21:14
Michael Gunther: know uh
21:15
Michael Gunther: they don't wanna actually uh have much demand destruction. I mean, what Williams was kind of saying that today as well. He's like uh he said something like making sure that we do not do undue harm to our maximum employment mandate. I mean, you have to be willing actually to slow demand down a little bit in order to get inflation to your goal. If you're not willing to slow the labor
21:35
Michael Gunther: market down, then you're not willing to get inflation back. to your target. And if you and if that happens, um
21:44
Michael Gunther: then it just means a bigger financial risk later, right? Because it just means that the Fed will have to uh
21:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
21:52
Michael Gunther: put both feet on the on the brake, so to speak. So yeah, I do think that over tightening is is the dominant risk uh as we go into 2027. Um I think the Fed will go in December.
22:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
22:03
Michael Gunther: think they'll probably go in January.
22:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
22:06
Michael Gunther: I think you should leave another hike open for March. And if inflation is still a problem after that, then
22:16
Michael Gunther: you can start thinking about maybe them going 50. But I do think that over-tightening is
22:21
Michael Gunther: Is a is a risk Um go as we look at 2027. twenty twenty seven.
22:24
Jeff DeGraff: Hey everyone. Quick break from the show.
22:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
22:26
Jeff DeGraff: RenMack Offscript is part of your week, you'll want the free Renmac newsletter too. It's concise, but packed with several of the charts our team are talking about right here on the podcast. Markets, policy, economics, and of course, strategy. All in one quick read that drops Friday afternoons. Off script listeners can sign up now completely free of charge. Grab yours in
22:46
Jeff DeGraff: the show notes or head to renmac.com/slash newsletter. That's Ari r-en-mac.com slash newsletter. Now back to the show.
22:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
22:56
Steve Duttenhoffer: we have we have seen at least some companies announce uh you know layoffs. I think Microsoft announced what last week that they were laying off 60,000 people. Although maybe they should hire a couple of those guys back. No,
23:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): maybe
23:08
Jeff DeGraff: they should fire the entire Outlook team.
23:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean, maybe
23:11
Michael Gunther: maybe one of the maybe the some of those people that did there they weren't those aren't layoffs. Those were those were negotiated buyouts. But um I suspect some of them didn't want the buyouts, which is why I mean I wonder whether it's what was it what one of the employees that didn't want to buy out that uh that decided to blow up the Microsoft Office. Um
23:28
Steve Duttenhoffer: just turn the server back on and off. You'll be fine. Um let's get over to uh to Nvidia though, because I think obviously there's a lot of things we can talk about from a markets perspective, not from a uh you know a gossipy perspective. But Steve, what's the um what's the follow through down there on this?
23:46
Jeff DeGraff: Well, I mean, I guess just go back to what Michael was saying. I thought we talked at the beginning about swiping patterns. One, I thought that was interesting from a political perspective because basically he's telling you if consumers, i.e. voters, are looking for value, they're not feeling good. We've seen that sort of reflected now between the most recent midterms and twenty four. So you know, if the politicians aren't
24:05
Jeff DeGraff: consuming uh the data that Michael's producing, maybe they should. Uh in terms of swiping patterns, perhaps lit to NVIDIA, Jensen Wong, maybe swipe left on a few of these uh dating app profiles
24:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
24:17
Steve Duttenhoffer: this.
24:18
Jeff DeGraff: So that's my attempt
24:20
Jeff DeGraff: here.
24:20
Steve Duttenhoffer: That might be the best joke yet, by the way. Well done.
24:23
Jeff DeGraff: It's a low bar, but I think I cleared it. No,
24:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think all of all of these.
24:27
Michael Gunther: together very
24:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well.
24:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But you
24:29
Steve Duttenhoffer: know, in terms of the fallout, look, we have the basic questions that still remain, you know, who knew what, when, uh, and I think that's where these investigations are going to go.
24:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Because
24:37
Steve Duttenhoffer: we really are don't have a clear impact as to what the national security concerns were. And now there's reason to uh have suspicion over his motives uh in terms of this approach that we saw before that the administration seemed to embrace about making others, including China, very dependent on the U.S. AI stack. You know,
24:56
Jeff DeGraff: Jeff could probably speak about what
24:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
24:58
Jeff DeGraff: impacts are to the other companies. But I mean, I think from a policy standpoint, this probably makes it much more likely that we're going to see some legislation included, most likely in the National Defense Authorization Act, the annual defense policy bill, to increase export controls. So that's going to make it hard. harder for
25:17
Jeff DeGraff: these other companies and other countries to continue to purchase
25:22
Jeff DeGraff: these chips. And I think, you know, you maybe not necessarily need the new legislation. You're going to see, I think, more immediate, probably stricter enforcement at commerce. I think it's this question of the role of Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick that I think Democrats in particular are really going to hone in on. And if the administration is going to make a change, they'd probably have to do it
25:41
Jeff DeGraff: relatively soon because the Republican control of the Senate is
25:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): going
25:46
Jeff DeGraff: to be up, you know, before January 3rd when the new Congress is sworn in. So I mean that's sort of watching right now in terms of the hot seat. What I would watch looking ahead to next week is, you know, if we see this bipartisan push to really clamp down on export controls of sophisticated technology. technologies and chips, China's response is going to be, okay, maybe we go back
26:06
Jeff DeGraff: to clamp down on export controls over these rare earth magnets and things that we need to basically keep our economy humming along. So it's sort of uh a difficult uh diplomatic situation as well.
26:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh and I
26:18
Jeff DeGraff: know President Trump's saying he's not going to raise this next week,
26:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um but you know
26:22
Jeff DeGraff: that's sort of
26:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if this is
26:23
Jeff DeGraff: a direction that the administration is going, uh there's clearly a risk there. So whether it's raised publicly or not, I think it's going to be very much
26:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a a
26:31
Jeff DeGraff: concern next week and beyond with our relationship to China.
26:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
26:36
Steve Duttenhoffer: Trump did ask uh Jensen if if he knew if she was a spy, and he said no. So I think we're good there.
26:43
Jeff DeGraff: That was good enough for Trump,
26:44
Michael Gunther: apparently.
26:46
Steve Duttenhoffer: Jeff, what are you seeing in uh in the technology sector? You you had a report out this morning talking about how the stack wasn't sold, it would just rotated.
26:55
Jeff DeGraff: Well, that was a reaction, right, to NVIDIA and the scrutiny. And there's a little uh company um that uh is very similar to that that's under in fact they've been uh penalized before for selling to the Chinese. Um it's very cheap, um, but uh they were down big because I'm sure the scrutiny is gonna go going to up.
27:15
Jeff DeGraff: And then, you know, it shifted to AvaG and AMD and some of these others. So there's a lot of rotation within the stack. This is going to complicate things just from an index perspective. You know, we turned more bullish on semis last week around some of the capitulation signs that we saw. Again, just for a bounce, Uh, I think it's way too premature
27:35
Jeff DeGraff: to call it a trend change. But you know, taking it to the 50-day moving average on the side. socks, things like that, I think are all you know part of of what you get out of these oversold conditions where there's uh you're starting to see stress in the system. So we're there. It'd be a lot easier, you know, for our call if NVIDIA was participating in that. Maybe that clears the decks. Um, we did some work, Kevin Dempter actually did it on our
27:55
Jeff DeGraff: team on um, you know, kind of the 10 biggest scandals over the last 20 or 30 years. Um, and it's amazing. I guess maybe not really amazing.
28:03
Jeff DeGraff: Uh, you know, the the spy community has known how to do this for for centuries. Uh, but yeah, I think eight of those were um, you know, let's say uh misappropriation of uh of male hormones uh is probably the right way to think about it. Uh you know, just uh it's just amazing the consistency of uh, you know, these
28:23
Jeff DeGraff: CEOs getting themselves in trouble with either employees or or outside. interests. Um what historically happens is the stocks are down about 10%. Uh and that persists. It's not just a bounce back. Um so about three months out, they're still down about eight percent. So um, you know, I think you're probably in the penalty box for a little while. It'd be really important who's the, you know, who's the
28:43
Jeff DeGraff: next uh CEO. Um I I like I don't know that much about NVIDIA uh down, you know, down to the core. Um my own understanding from people that I know that do know um is that while Jensen's a you
28:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know
28:56
Jeff DeGraff: great sort of charismatic leader, he definitely was not kind of the strategic uh
29:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
29:00
Jeff DeGraff: the strategic uh uh visionary of the firm at this point. He certainly was earlier. He's a little bit more of a showman. I I I don't know if that how important that is. Um it's just not our call. Um NVIDIA was a name that was leadership. I will say this. I think the market knew something was up because it was weaker before it was starting to unravel pretty quickly
29:20
Jeff DeGraff: before this all came out.
29:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
29:22
Jeff DeGraff: so somewhere somebody knew something that was probably gonna be troublesome.
29:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
29:27
Jeff DeGraff: and you know, clearly that was happening. So I think
29:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the most
29:30
Michael Gunther: price lead earnings, price leads
29:33
Jeff DeGraff: Pro price pricing leads scandal, right?
29:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
29:37
Jeff DeGraff: I don't know if it was his wife. selling her shares ahead of time, knowing what was coming. I'm not sure exactly who was who was in the know there. Um, I thought the more interesting thing, kind of holistically, about the stack last uh this week was Core Weave, right? Core Weave came out. Uh, they had strong earnings, the stock was up, I think it was 25%, it was up big.
29:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
29:56
Jeff DeGraff: the CDS is didn't really change, so keep that in mind. You've got credit thinking one thing and equities thinking something else, so that's always an important differentiator there. Um and then they came out and said something interesting was which was look, at at these rates in the public markets, it's just not something that we're gonna go out and uh and borrow against. And um, you know,
30:15
Jeff DeGraff: that is that is the the market, that is uh interest rates and the
30:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um uh
30:22
Jeff DeGraff: the participants doing what they should do, right? Which is charging a higher toll. for riskier, uh riskier bets and obviously real rates and everything else. What they did say though, which was interesting, is that they're going to force the customers to prepay, basically, and fund uh fund this build out. And you know, what you saw was Corweave and the like, the
30:42
Jeff DeGraff: those others, uh, other names up while the hyperscalers were down, right? So the idea was hey, you know, how much do you want this? Howard Mason's done some. great work on that for us here in the shop, um, talking about, you know, what what that's gonna look like and um some of the pressure points there. But I think that was interesting and just kind of um saying, look, we're not gonna, we're not gonna go out and issue
31:02
Jeff DeGraff: debt to do this. We're just gonna charge our customers. And that might actually end up being cheaper for both ends, right? Where uh they don't have to charge as much because they're getting uh financing from the customers who have actually a lower cost of capital, et cetera. So we'll see how that ends up playing. But this is, you know, this is kind of that mechanism at work. And uh I think it's important too, just from
31:22
Jeff DeGraff: a treasury standpoint or for from a uh from a policy standpoint, that you know, you can't just you can't just decide that you're gonna go on some quest, uh borrow money or you know, implement policies or do whatever. Uh you have to you you you have to pay the piper to do that. And so, you know, these things have to align at some point. And when they don't, that's where
31:42
Jeff DeGraff: things break. And um that's you know kind of what we did see. We'll see if if this is um you know some uh mechanism to assuage that I don't think that will work but you know we'll s we'll see how that plays out. I thought the most interesting thing um most recently was uh yields bounced exactly where they should have they all came back to the
32:02
Jeff DeGraff: pivot point What a pivot point is, is the point at which they break out. So these charts, the yields broke out. I think for the the 10-year, it was about 484, 43, something like that. Broke out, obviously ran to 530, 534, and then pulled all the way back. And then right when it got to that same breakout level, it bounced again. Right now it was off the
32:22
Jeff DeGraff: CPI report, but from a chart perspective, it just they they acted perfectly. Um they did exactly what you'd expect in an uptrend for yields, right? Now, the interesting part of this is that the the yield component has been really driven by the real yields. It hasn't been driven by the inflation expectations. So it is the price of time. The
32:42
Jeff DeGraff: market is charging people um for the um the price of time. And and that's different than thinking that the inflation as we go out five years or whatever is gonna going be. to you know rampant and therefore the the market is excite excising that tax. Um this is all about real yields. It's about premium. It's about that um uh that price of time. So that tends to impact the the
33:01
Jeff DeGraff: value versus versus growth style uh in favor of value. That tends to uh favor more defensives uh than cyclicals um and that tends to favor quality uh over sort of long duration in in those uh those equities. So, you know, we're at a little bit of a friction point because seasonality tends to be good for just the opposite.
33:22
Jeff DeGraff: But the long term of what's happening and underneath the surface is pretty consistent. And I think it's important. And I think it's going to be an important setup for 2027 as we go.
33:31
Steve Duttenhoffer: Well, you've been talking about real yields uh for a while here. So uh kudos to you for getting that one right as well.
33:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean, I wouldn't
33:38
Michael Gunther: say though that you know, for the Fed, right, like looking at inflation expectations being stable, like they shouldn't take any encouragement from that. I mean, when when you when you go into when you look at like market based measures of inflation and you use that as a signal for like, oh, we must be doing our job perfectly.
33:57
Michael Gunther: Like that that's actually a huge mistake because those those measures are susceptible to the hall of mirrors, right? Because
34:06
Michael Gunther: the markets are assuming that you're gonna do your job and it's up to you to do your job. I would point out that inflation expectations, break-evens, I mean, they've been broadly consistent with 2% for a while. Has inflation actually been consistent with 2%? Absolutely not. So it's almost one of these things
34:26
Michael Gunther: where where
34:29
Michael Gunther: if you just sort of assume that the Fed's going to do its job, then anytime you get some kind of an inflation pressure, it's going to show it's going to bleed into real yields at this point. Right? Like because that's the
34:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): only
34:41
Michael Gunther: way you can pay the piper, right? Because
34:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're
34:43
Michael Gunther: going to assume the Fed's going to do the job. And so they can't look through any supply shock. Therefore, breakevens break evens don't move and and real yields are are the shock absorber. Yes.
34:51
Steve Duttenhoffer: Right.
34:51
Michael Gunther: So
34:52
Jeff DeGraff: 100% right.
34:53
Steve Duttenhoffer: But but in fairness
34:54
Jeff DeGraff: to that, right, you also have gold breaking down, right? So gold made a new low, right? You've got the dollar breaking out, you've got Bitcoin, which looks like it was a what we call a bull trap. It tried to break out and then failed and is now in the low, you know, 70,000s.
35:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
35:08
Jeff DeGraff: and and I agree one 100%. hundred percent. There's no evidence that today's inflation expectations predict tomorrow. tomorrow's inflation. That that does not hold water. So there's no doubt about that. But the composition is important in terms of what does the market think? How's the market position for this? So if the Fed is looking at that saying, hey, we're doing our job,
35:28
Jeff DeGraff: therefore we don't need to do anything, you're 100% right. I think that is a that is a problem. Um my point is what the what the markets are telling us is the Fed uh sorry, the markets do believe that the Fed is going to do their job and therefore they're not requiring that that extra premium in the inflation expectations. Now, if that falls apart, then
35:48
Jeff DeGraff: we've we've got issues, right? But right now the trajectory seems to be decent. And I think uh probably, you know, the the happiest person about this is probably, you know, Treasury Secretary Bessant, which means that his yields that he's issuing are at least in some way, shape, or form, um, you know, they're they're they're being held together and he's not having
36:08
Jeff DeGraff: to pay uh the credibility tax that uh that comes from the uh the fiscal deficit.
36:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Good
36:16
Steve Duttenhoffer: stuff. Let's move to the uh the mailbag. Harry, good morning.
36:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Hi, good morning, everybody. Happy Friday. Today we have a question come from Arjun Sadi.
36:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): His question is Is price ever wrong or is price is always right? And investing authority that must be followed regardless of fundamentals. For example, when the fundamentals of semiconductors seem to be strengthening, but the stock prices and
36:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): technicals are deteriorating,
36:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can
36:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): market
36:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): be getting it wrong? That's it. Thank you, everybody.
36:55
Steve Duttenhoffer: Well, Jeff, is the market always right?
36:58
Jeff DeGraff: You think that's for me, huh?
37:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
37:01
Jeff DeGraff: I have said uh in this business for the 37 years I've been doing it, I didn't know that the first two years, so let's say 35 years, um, the market will fib, but it won't lie. Um, you know, so it'll it'll it'll throw you off. the scent enough um that of course it can be it can be wrong. But I think the the
37:20
Jeff DeGraff: danger is is it wrong enough or is it consistently wrong where betting against it makes sense? And that's where I think the fallacy comes in that um it'll be wrong. It's just like a casino, right? It's it's you you win enough to keep coming back. Uh I don't play in casinos, but a lot of people do.
37:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
37:38
Jeff DeGraff: and so it's it's enough that it it brings people back. Um there's and there's a couple different ways to think about that. Uh and I don't want to get into a long diatrab. One, which is we call temporal differences, right? Uh in other words, what's the difference from a timing perspective? You know, do I feel like, hey, this stock is so cheap that in five years it's gonna be fine?
37:58
Jeff DeGraff: Um that that's a Warren Buffett philosophy. That's fine. Obviously, that's done very well, it suited him very very well. Um, that has nothing to do with the next week, the next month, the next quarter, maybe even the next year, right? So you can be wrong from a temporal standpoint. You can be wrong from a very short-term standpoint versus long-term. So you've got all these different players, um, the citadels of the world, the high
38:17
Jeff DeGraff: frequency traders that are um, you know, are just picking off basis points here and there. Um, they they they don't have that luxury to be, you know, sticking it out for years or quarters. So you've got all these different players that that play in the mix, and you can you can kind of work work them off of each other as we go. And then the other thing is you talk about the fundamentals and
38:37
Jeff DeGraff: where the fundamentals are, but you have to ask, what does that really mean, right? Are the fundamentals improving? Okay, well, where is that within the context of the valuation? Um and that's what we're you know, what we always are looking at. So you might be getting the quote-unquote quote unquote fundamental. fundamentals wrong. In other words, you're getting um the the value is important. Well maybe it's not. Maybe it's the growth that's picking
38:57
Jeff DeGraff: up or deteriorating that's that's uh having the impact on value, right? So I would just want to you want to be very careful about the dimension by which you're going at this. And you know, in my view, um that's exactly why price is so important, because price tends to get that right. And if nothing else, it determines
39:15
Jeff DeGraff: what people are finding important or what the market's finding important. So you might think that price to book is the end-all be-all, and yet the market couldn't care less about that, you know, except for once every 15 years. Is that being right? Yeah, probably not. So
39:32
Jeff DeGraff: I do not believe that the market is always right, but I certainly would say that you don't want to go into the market. believing that the market is always wrong and you're right. And I use that royal you, not you specifically. Um, so that's how we think about
39:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
39:48
Steve Duttenhoffer: Arjun, thanks for the uh the question. We're gonna get you a RenMac Tumblr. Uh, we're gonna put the uh RenMac trucker hats on uh on ice for a little while. So keep those questions coming to everybody out there listening. Uh, we use them on this podcast, and we'll get you now. a nice Renmac tumbler for the holiday season and beyond. Let's go around the horn, talk about
40:08
Steve Duttenhoffer: what we're focused on this upcoming week. Steve Pavlik, we'll start with you in DC.
40:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Sure.
40:13
Michael Gunther: So I'm going to start with China because that's where Trump's meeting we talked a little bit before about this AI impact. But you know this goes back to this truce extension that we sort of have on the books now through January 10th. tenth. Uh you know, I think that's sort of the low bar uh that of expectations. I think it's gonna be just preservation of this truce. You know, been
40:33
Michael Gunther: some talks about, you know, the AI situation, does that work for Jig, the political situation? Does he sort of, you know, look at opportunity to maybe see some weakness there. But I don't think it's really in G's interest to uh again, abandon the truce uh or escalate things at this point. So again, my expectation
40:53
Michael Gunther: is really, I guess no expectation, just you know, preserve the the the truce is sort of how I'm thinking about that. A little closer to home, it was interesting that um Senate uh incoming, I guess Majority Leader Chuck Schumer is gonna get uh challenge from Senator Van Holland from here in Maryland uh for that role there. So um it just you know goes
41:13
Michael Gunther: to show you that we talked before about, you know, because Democrats had such a uh,
41:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
41:20
Michael Gunther: guess, broad election victory, you have some voices there that feel emboldened from the the left wing of the party. Uh and you know, is Van Halen really serious about challenging Schumer? Is he really just gonna try to threaten this to get some concessions from him? One of his concessions congestions may be that he agrees to step aside when his term is up in in 2028. And what does that mean for AOC? So plenty
41:40
Michael Gunther: still going on here. And then in terms of the Hill, you know, mentioned Lutnik, I think there's really a priority here for Republican senators to try to confirm some of these nominees or some federal uh financial regulators still outstanding. Uh saw some of those names mentioned yesterday. So really look for that push here uh if by Senate
41:59
Michael Gunther: Republicans in their remaining moments of control.
42:02
Steve Duttenhoffer: What's the overunder on uh Lutnik staying in the seat?
42:06
Michael Gunther: I have not checked the betting markets. Um but I think that's
42:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that he's gonna be gone before February. Is that
42:14
Michael Gunther: is that what it is that what it says?
42:16
Steve Duttenhoffer: Fifty?
42:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Over fifty percent,
42:18
Michael Gunther: yeah. I mean
42:19
Steve Duttenhoffer: he'll he won't make it
42:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): he won't make it. Is that you or
42:21
Michael Gunther: is that a Calci market? That's a Calci
42:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): market. That's a Calci market. I mean I was gonna say about a coin higher but
42:27
Michael Gunther: You know,
42:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): look, I mean, he just got murdered by another
42:29
Michael Gunther: cabinet secretary on live
42:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): T V like at like within the last hour.
42:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean, we've
42:36
Michael Gunther: always we've always said that the two strongest cabinet secretaries are Marco Rubio
42:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
42:41
Michael Gunther: Secretary Besson. Those are the two strongest cabinet secretaries. They both just
42:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
42:50
Michael Gunther: basically lit into uh Lutnik.
42:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right?
42:53
Michael Gunther: I mean, I don't know. You can make an argument that that that Rubio knew all this information and he decided to hold it until after the midterms.
43:02
Steve Duttenhoffer: He he knew the information for sure. He circulated that uh that briefing. Neil, what are you watching this week other than the uh the drama going on in D C?
43:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
43:10
Michael Gunther: yeah, other than my other than the Calci bet uh on Lutnik, uh I'll be yeah, I'll be I'll be watching um
43:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
43:18
Michael Gunther: you know retail sales. Um
43:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah
43:22
Michael Gunther: the market's looking for uh 0.4% on the control. Um, you know, we'll see. I mean that's that's following a very, very soft September. Um we know that auto sales uh slowed uh over the month of October. Um we'll also be getting data on builder sentiment.
43:41
Michael Gunther: and uh housing starts. Uh so I'm not really expecting much there given what we're seeing in uh in mortgage uh rates. Uh and then lastly, I'll be keeping an eye on uh on the industrial production and manufacturing data because obviously manufacturing has been the uh
43:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
43:58
Michael Gunther: real growth engine of the US economy uh this year because of the AI data center build-out.
44:06
Michael Gunther: And then lastly,
44:09
Michael Gunther: we do have a lot of Fed speaks still.
44:13
Michael Gunther: So
44:16
Michael Gunther: Warsh gives opening remarks at the Productivity and Jobs Task Force Conference.
44:23
Michael Gunther: That's on the 16th. So we'll see how that goes. You know, He keeps talking about this productivity golden age.
44:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know,
44:31
Michael Gunther: we'll see. I mean, there's not, I mean, it's hard to talk about a productivity golden age and also talking about inflation being above the Fed's target. But plenty of Fed speak next week as
44:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well.
44:41
Steve Duttenhoffer: Michael, what are you watching this week?
44:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So uh
44:44
Jeff DeGraff: retail earnings season starts
44:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): next week.
44:46
Michael Gunther: So uh we'll
44:47
Jeff DeGraff: get some clues
44:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on uh
44:48
Jeff DeGraff: housing,
44:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
44:50
Jeff DeGraff: home depot. and Lowe's
44:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are reporting. Uh
44:52
Jeff DeGraff: we'll
44:52
Michael Gunther: see if there's any uh pickup there. In addition to William Sonoma, it'll be interesting to see whether or not they distinguish a lot between you know the brands that are more dependent on you know big furniture versus the actual William Sonoma banner itself. Uh then we'll also get a read-on Read on off-price, off price. so TJ and Raw stores will
45:12
Michael Gunther: be reporting. So we'll see if uh you know demand. for off price remains robust and if they continue to talk about trade uh down from uh higher income consumers. And then of course, uh Target and Walmart. Target obviously a more uh specific story about Target uh itself versus the entire economy, but Walmart will you know be
45:32
Michael Gunther: uh fascinating. With Walmart, by the way, uh we've seen them start to lose share among lower and middle. income consumers, which is uh notable given their historical positioning, but maintaining share gains with higher income consumers. So I think that'll be interesting to see whether or not that sort of value oriented posture
45:52
Michael Gunther: uh continues. And uh, you know, we'll see how much that changes if the stock market starts to turn. Because I guess maybe high high-income income consumers will have to trade down a little bit more.
46:02
Steve Duttenhoffer: Michael, who who is um, or let me say it properly, to whom is Walmart losing share?
46:10
Michael Gunther: It's sort of a a mixture uh among that group, even among you know club stores, uh, they've taken uh some share from Walmart. Uh, you know, Target obviously had a rough time. They started to do a little bit better, so a little bit there, but you know, a lot of a lot of it's I think been uh to club stores. Uh club stores, by the way, uh
46:30
Michael Gunther: were one of the first uh early clues of how consumers were shifting behavior just in terms of gas. We did this whole sort of analysis on uh Costco specifically and then some of the others. Though the within two weeks of the Iran war starting, they gained so much share of gas station spend. It was already elevated, but I think they gained 50 basis points of share. 50
46:50
Michael Gunther: basis points. may not sound like a lot, but just think about how big the gasoline market is. People actually shifted where they were getting their gas. Um so
47:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): totally. I mean, we're one of them, I mean, I might we're one of them. I mean, uh, if you can if you can uh if you have the stomach to wait
47:08
Michael Gunther: in uh in a line,
47:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's uh, you know,
47:12
Jeff DeGraff: I mean it's it's it's totally worth it. I mean they sell
47:14
Michael Gunther: out.
47:14
Jeff DeGraff: at a massive discount relative to most other
47:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um you know
47:20
Jeff DeGraff: gas stations. I I do think it's kind of interesting, like you know, with uh
47:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
47:25
Jeff DeGraff: because obviously everything has sort of been tech tech tech, you know,
47:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um do
47:30
Jeff DeGraff: we start doing, you know, do we start thinking a little bit more about the consumer and sort of traditional areas of the economy going into uh early next year? And um uh
47:40
Michael Gunther: we we don't I mean I live in Brooklyn, so we we have a car because we have kids, but it's not like we're driving every day. But I think that's a good lesson in you know the fact that consumers are paying attention and adjusting behavior quickly. I was surprised how quickly it shifted. I figured it would have taken a little longer. Obviously, that peaked in May when gas hit its its uh peak there,
48:00
Michael Gunther: but it the shift was pretty. immediate.
48:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
48:05
Steve Duttenhoffer: I mean, Walmart, uh I I've never walked into something I spend $350 to $400 and felt better about
48:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
48:14
Steve Duttenhoffer: Certainly not my experience with an airline. Uh and the biggest blueberries I've ever seen. Unbelievable, biggest blueberries I've ever seen. Um Michael
48:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's the first time I've
48:23
Michael Gunther: heard that.
48:23
Steve Duttenhoffer: Yeah. Michael hit the um you know hit the the retailers with earnings, which you know we'll we'll be paying attention to as well. I would just say a lot of the consumer discretionary names we go into this um relatively overbought. They've pulled back a little bit over the last couple of days with with yields. But you know, keep in mind as we t talk about yields, you know, back to support levels. They
48:43
Steve Duttenhoffer: weren't oversold, but they were certainly back to support levels. Who the natural beneficiaries of that trajectory coming in are, and that's discretionary names, right? So the discretionary names got overbought as uh as the yields came in. And so as those yields start to go up, we'd expect that that overbought condition to um to start to bite uh a lot of those discretionary names. So
49:03
Steve Duttenhoffer: that'll be important as we go. And then you've got NVIDIA next week. Um we'll we'll keep the keep the barbs to a minimum. Um so it'll just be interesting to hear their take on everything, you know, the the sequence. of leadership. Um Palo Alto Networks also um is in next week. Uh so a little light on tech, but the ones that are coming in do have some some
49:23
Steve Duttenhoffer: heft to them. Uh and then we'll we'll be watching the stack and the rotation in the stack to just try to get some sense as to where the traction's gonna be. Um do the hyperscalers pick up the bill? Um, do the uh do the semis, you know, end up being uh the uh the the long-term winners, regardless of who pays you gonna need the compute. You know, so far
49:43
Steve Duttenhoffer: that's uh kind of happening, but I certainly uh think it's more of a bounce and counter trend than it is a new bull phase. So um we'll be watching for that. And then this continuation of um consolidations that happen in healthcare. It's easily the strongest uh sector in in our book um and continues to do
50:03
Steve Duttenhoffer: well. Uh a lot of big base breakouts uh taking place. Um there are some overbought conditions, but all things considered, these are not extended names, they're not overowned yet, and they're really nice uh emerging trends, which uh tends to have staying power. So that's on our docket.
50:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh and you
50:20
Jeff DeGraff: mentioned Howard Mason uh
50:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): earlier
50:21
Jeff DeGraff: today. He had a great conference call yesterday on AI
50:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
50:25
Jeff DeGraff: compute and circular financing. So if you didn't uh get a chance to listen into
50:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that uh and you
50:30
Jeff DeGraff: need the replay, let us know.
50:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
50:32
Jeff DeGraff: email sales at redmac.com and we'll get that replay to
50:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you. Why
50:36
Jeff DeGraff: don't we wrap it up there? Michael Gunther, thank you very much for coming from Consumer Edge. Lots of good stuff to uh to pick apart as we go through the rest of the uh holiday shopping season.
50:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
50:46
Steve Duttenhoffer: hopefully Neil will get another new jacket, which would be nice so we can could talk about that next time. I hear one's for sale. I hear there's one for sale. A little darker, a little heavier.
50:57
Steve Duttenhoffer: Neil, by the
50:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): way.
50:57
Steve Duttenhoffer: That's like a
50:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Gucci.
51:01
Michael Gunther: I mean like I knew that. I could tell without
51:04
Steve Duttenhoffer: I know, but it still looks like you're gonna go out into the garage and change your oil. That's I I'm
51:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): sorry. I
51:09
Michael Gunther: wouldn't be doing that. First of all, if you're wearing Gucci, you're getting someone that to do that for you. Uh
51:17
Steve Duttenhoffer: maybe.
51:17
Michael Gunther: Maybe. But anyway, yeah.
51:19
Steve Duttenhoffer: This is where we go off the rails. In any event, thanks
51:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): everybody
51:22
Steve Duttenhoffer: for joining us.
51:26
Steve Duttenhoffer: We'll be back next week. Until then, I'm Steve Duttonhoffer. I'm Jeff D. Graff.
51:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
51:31
Michael Gunther: Neil Detta. I'm
51:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Steve
51:32
Steve Duttenhoffer: Pabler.
51:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
51:33
Michael Gunther: I'm Michael Gunther. Thank
51:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
51:35
Michael Gunther: guys for having me. Thanks,
51:36
Steve Duttenhoffer: Michael. You bet. Thanks for being on. Have a great week, everybody. Hey, it's Steve. Thanks for listening to the show. Small slice of what we do here at Renmac. So if you liked it and aren't already a client, go to renmac.com and request a free trial. You get access to all the political, all the macro, all the technical, and all the economic work we do here, plus screens,
51:55
Steve Duttenhoffer: alert lists, and all the research behind the wall. Work at a financial institution or just an individual, we have the edge you need. So join us here at Renmac. We'd love to have you part of the team. And don't forget to follow us on X, LinkedIn, and YouTube. Thanks for listening to the show.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from RenMac

All insights