The Block auction results reveal a 'quote high, reserve low' strategy driving premiums in a downturn
Summary
Speaker 0 reports that five Mount Eliza properties sold for over $3.5 million above reserve during a market downturn, achieving an average premium of 20%. The success is attributed to a quoting strategy that initially set high guides ($3.6–$3.9m) before reducing them to a lower range ($3.45–$3.75m) with reserves at the bottom ($3.45m). This approach leverages buyer psychology by anchoring high and revealing a lower reserve to create a perception of value. The speaker contrasts this with underperforming Daylesford properties, arguing that correct pricing and land size are more critical than marketing alone. A new strategy for 2027 is proposed: quote at the top of the value range and set reserves at the lower end to exploit Victoria's reserve disclosure laws and stimulate competition in weak markets.
Key takeaways
- 1 properties sold at auction. Every property sold substantially above the reserve price and above mostly the reserve, the quoted range that they initially started with. They collectively sold for more than $3.5 million above their reserve prices as a whole, which is the five properties.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 0:25
- 2 had the reserves of 3.45. So, in other words, the reserves were at the bottom of the reduced quoted range. Now, I think this is a really interesting lesson here in regards to buyer psychology and price anchoring, which is one of the things that, like in negotiation, I've learned from um doing all of Chris Voss's courses. is that you wanna like typically anchor pri quite high or anchor low depending on what you're doing. So if you're a real estate agent selling a property, having a really high number as the first thing that people are seeing can be a really good strategy when it comes to, you know, anchoring the value of that particular property and then providing it to the people afterwards and saying, Oh no, well the you know, we initially had it quoted up to three 3.9, point nine, but our reserve now is 3.45. It makes people feel like they could get it for a substantial bargain below what they initially thought the property might have been worth.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 1:44
Episode sections
- 0:05 – 1:24
Introduction to The Block Auction Results
Speaker 0 introduces the topic, noting that five properties in The Block auction sold substantially above reserve, collectively exceeding reserve by over $3.5 million. This occurred during a significant Melbourne market downturn and just before an interest rate increase.
- 1:24 – 2:36
Quoting Strategy and Buyer Psychology
The properties were initially quoted at $3.6–$3.9 million, then reduced to $3.45–$3.75 million with reserves set at $3.45 million. The speaker attributes this success to buyer psychology, specifically anchoring high and then revealing a lower reserve to create a perception of a bargain.
- 2:36 – 4:03
Sales Performance and Market Context
Specific sales results are detailed, with the top property selling for $4.72 million ($1.27 million above reserve). The total sales volume was approximately $20.8 million, with an average premium of 20% above reserve. The speaker emphasizes that these were premium properties in a high-price segment of the Melbourne market.
- 4:03 – 6:59
Pricing vs. Marketing in Real Estate
The speaker asserts that properties only fail to sell due to incorrect pricing or poor marketing. While The Block had exceptional marketing (TV campaign, styling), the speaker contrasts this with last year's Daylesford results, where properties were overpriced relative to their land size and surroundings.
- 6:59 – 8:35
Mount Eliza vs. Daylesford Comparison
Mount Eliza properties succeeded because they offered full-size blocks and high-quality renovations that matched buyer demographics, whereas Daylesford properties were criticized for being small blocks in areas with commercial/industrial influences. The speaker argues that correct pricing is more critical than marketing alone.
- 8:35 – 11:03
The 'Anchor High, Reveal Low' Strategy
The speaker proposes a new auction strategy for 2027: quote properties at the top of their value range (e.g., $2–$2.1 million for a $2 million home) and set reserves at the lower end. This leverages Victoria's new reserve disclosure laws to create psychological appeal without violating underquoting rules.
- 11:03 – 13:22
Market Conditions and Buyer Competition
This strategy is most effective in weaker markets with low buyer confidence, where attracting a wide pool of buyers is difficult. By setting lower reserves, agents can encourage more competition among buyers, letting the market drive the price up from the reserve level.
- 13:22 – 14:39
Advice for Buyers and Future Outlook
The speaker warns that this strategy may become common in 2027, potentially masking true market values. Buyers are advised to conduct rigorous comparable sales analysis and focus on the initial price guide rather than just the published reserve to understand the property's true worth.
Claims worth verifying
All five Mount Eliza properties sold at auction, collectively achieving over $3.5 million above their reserve prices.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:25
How to verify: Check The Block 2026 auction results on the official Channel 10 website or real estate news outlets (e.g., Domain, Realestate.com.au) for the final hammer prices and reserve disclosures for the five Mount Eliza homes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The auction results occurred during one of Melbourne's biggest recorded downturns and a couple of days before an interest rate increase.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:44
How to verify: Cross-reference the auction date with the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) meeting minutes and cash rate announcements for late 2026, and compare with CoreLogic or SQM Research Melbourne market data for that period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The properties were initially advertised with a price guide of $3.6 to $3.9 million, later reduced to $3.45 to $3.75 million, with reserves set at $3.45 million.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:24
How to verify: Review archived listings on Domain or Realestate.com.au for The Block 2026 Mount Eliza properties to confirm the initial price guides and the published reserve prices one week prior to auction. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The top property (Courtney and Sev) sold for $4.72 million, which was $1.27 million above the reserve price.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·2:56
How to verify: Verify the final sale price of $4.72 million for the specific Mount Eliza property via real estate transaction databases (e.g., CoreLogic, SQM Research) or auction result reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The total sales volume for the five properties was approximately $20.8 million, with an average premium above reserve of 20%.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·3:34
How to verify: Calculate the sum of the five final sale prices and the average percentage above reserve using the individual sale data from auction reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Last year's (2025) Daylesford properties on The Block did not sell well, with some staying on the market for months.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:04
How to verify: Check real estate transaction records for Daylesford properties sold during The Block 2026 to see if they sold at auction or were withdrawn/post-auction sales, and review media reports on their market performance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Victoria has upcoming reserve disclosure laws that will make the 'anchor high, reveal low' strategy more viable.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·12:03
How to verify: Review the Victorian Government's legislation regarding real estate agent conduct and reserve price disclosure requirements, specifically looking for laws enacted or proposed around 2026–2027. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The speaker references Chris Voss's negotiation courses as a source for buyer psychology and price anchoring strategies.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:44
How to verify: Identify Chris Voss as a former FBI negotiator and author of 'Never Split the Difference'; verify his courses or books on negotiation tactics like anchoring. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Mount Eliza properties were full-size blocks with beach views or potential, whereas Daylesford properties were small blocks near commercial properties and pet barns.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·7:19
How to verify: Compare the land size (square meters) and zoning/amenities of the Mount Eliza and Daylesford properties using land registry data (e.g., Landata, VicPlan) and local council zoning maps. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The speaker predicts that agents may start using lower reserves to artificially attract more buyers in a weaker market, effectively becoming a new form of underquoting.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·11:23
How to verify: Monitor real estate agent practices and consumer advocacy group reports (e.g., Consumer Affairs Victoria) in 2026 for trends in reserve pricing strategies and complaints regarding perceived underquoting. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the specific reserve prices and final sale prices for the five Mount Eliza properties via Domain or realestate.com.au auction results.
- Check Victoria's current real estate legislation regarding reserve price disclosure requirements to confirm the legality of the 'quote high, reserve low' strategy.
- Compare the land size and zoning of the Mount Eliza properties against the Daylesford properties using council planning schemes to validate the location/size argument.
- Review historical auction clearance rates in Melbourne during previous downturns to assess the sustainability of the 20% premium claim.
- Analyze the marketing spend and media coverage of The Block campaign to quantify the impact of external promotion on buyer demand.
- Research recent sales of similar properties in Mount Eliza and Daylesford to independently verify the 'correct pricing' assertion.
Full transcriptexpand
0:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Block auctions may have just unlocked the new auction quoting strategy for 2027. Now, I think this is a really huge result for what's happened in the market, just with sentiment and everything that's going on at the moment. But if you don't watch the block, and I don't think you necessarily need to for what I'm talking about today, but what I wanted to talk about is essentially all five properties sold at auction. Every property sold substantially above the reserve price and above mostly the reserve, the quoted range that they initially started with. They collectively sold for more than $3.5 million above their reserve prices as a whole, which is the five properties. And more importantly, all of this happened when Melbourne is in one of the biggest downturns in our recorded history. And even interestingly, this all happened a couple of days before the interest rate was increased. And all of the market sentiment out there at the time was saying that the market sentiment was the interest rates were going to increase. So there was this feeling that interest rates are about to go up again. And, you know, our auction clearance rates are at the lowest that they've been in a long time. Last year, it's worth remembering that the block auctions did not sell well. at all. Some of them stayed on the market for months afterwards and they just couldn't transact on them. So I think that this is all really interesting as context, more so in regards to the
1:24quoting strategy that was used throughout the process of these sales. So, what actually happened? When these properties were listed online, they were initially advertised with a range of 3.6 to 3.9 million dollars. Those guides were laid. later reduced to 3.45 to 3.75, and all five properties had the reserves of 3.45. So, in other words, the reserves were at the bottom of the reduced quoted range. Now, I think this is a really interesting lesson here in regards to buyer psychology and price anchoring, which is one of the things that, like in negotiation, I've learned from um doing all of Chris Voss's courses. is that you wanna like typically anchor pri quite high or anchor low depending on what you're doing. So if you're a real estate agent selling a property, having a really high number as the first thing that people are seeing can be a really good strategy when it comes to, you know, anchoring the value of that particular property and then providing it to the people afterwards and saying, Oh no, well the you know, we initially had it quoted up to three 3.9, point nine, but our reserve now is 3.45. It makes people feel like they could get it for a substantial bargain below what they initially thought the property might have been worth. Now,
2:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
2:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): give you just the the snapshot of the numbers, um, and I suppose just quickly, the houses were gorgeous as well. And I I think we can talk about what the the this uh season's block has as an advantage compared to last season's and I think that that's probably worth noting as well. uh particularly because it's not always just market sentiment about how these properties was were selling but to give you just a snapshot of what these properties were quoted and sold for so the winners Courtney and Sev um the property was quoted 3.6 to 3.9 reduced to 3.45 to 3.75 that property sold for 4.72 which is 1.27 million dollars above the reserve price on auction day Rick and Taylor sold theirs for $905,000 above the reserve price. And then the remaining sales were $550, $455, and then $367,000, still above the reserve price, which all were great numbers. That's a total of $20 million, uh $20.8 million essentially, um, with the average premium above the reserve being approximately 20%.
3:37Huge. That is a huge huge number. And these properties weren't initially being advertised at like artificially cheap prices. They were market at premium price points. And then those reserves were revealed to be lower afterwards. So I think that is interesting. It's also probably just interesting noting the price point that it is a fairly substantial price point when you're looking at Melbourne homes in general. But it's good to see that there is a lot of those buyers still actively out there in the market. And these properties were very well done. And it goes to show that people with those budgets are still looking for top quality properties that are fully renovated. Now, what's worth noting is one of the things that I learned when I first came into real estate is that there is only two reasons why a property doesn't sell. It's either pricing or marketing. It's pretty much only those two properties. Like you can imagine that even if there was a completely direct derelict home that is fully infested with termites, needs restumping, it's falling apart, it's in a flood zone, it's also got a heritage overlay on it, uh, and it's on like a you know a half-sized block of land in any suburb that you can think of.
4:43If the agent said that we're selling this for $200, every single person would will put their hands up because $200 for still a house and a block of land in Melbourne is ridiculous. ridiculously cheap, cheap priced. It's the same thing that you know if you had a Ferrari and you said it's for ten thousand dollars, who wants to buy it? Doesn't matter what's wrong with it. Like people are going to throw their hands up and buy it just because it's so cheap that people will take it regardless. But then on the marketing side of things, um you can imagine that some prices are actually priced some properties are actually priced correctly. However, the marketing can sometimes be a huge flop. And we see this when there's shocking sales photos. Um, you know, the contracts aren't ready and they don't roll out on time.
5:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
5:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): lot of times there's no styling, sometimes they're selling properties that have still got tenants in there. The tenants are not clean and the property feels disgusting, even if they just haven't professionally cleaned it. There's been no landscaping done, there's no floor plans that are on the you know the advertisement link. There was no videos ever done. Uh, you know, there's all of these things that can take place. Um, or the worst thing for me is when you're using photos from years ago when the property was vacant and then you arrived there on the day and it turns out the property's tenanted and that wasn't mentioned. And it's all of their stuff and the it's like disgusting and falling apart and there's damage to the home. It's Is when all of these things take into effect, that's just another reason why a property won't sell Now, in regards to these properties on the block, obviously the marketing is probably the best that you could ever imagine for a home. They've got a national TV campaign, they've got uh all sorts of professional styling, photography done, um, social media presence is enormous. Domain has been pushing all of these properties very, very heavily for you know a long period of time. It's a high highly anticipated auction event. There's all different sorts of buyers' advocates that come out. There's a big show feel to it as well, uh, where some people feel like they just want to own one of the block homes for the prestige factor of it being on the block. So probably the best marketing campaign that you can
6:43ever hope for. But marketing alone doesn't guarantee a sale. And I think that that is very obvious when you're looking at why marketing. Mount Eliza performed so much better than Dallasford last year. Now, Dallasford last year obviously had all of the same marketing,
6:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
6:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): when you're looking at them as a property type, the properties in Dallasford, in my opinion, were just simply overpriced. They were a small block of lands for the area. They were large in the scale of Melbourne. But when you're looking at the properties in Dallasford that were on the market at the same price point at the time. these blocks were substantially smaller. They were in a sort of like an owner's corporation community gated community area. There was like a giant pet barn right behind them. They also had um some commercial properties uh and like main roads nearby. There was a few things that just made it feel overpriced for the area. So regardless of how good the marketing campaign is, if you don't have the price aspect right of it. it's just not going to perform well. And that's where they went really well with Mount Eliza. Like these properties um are full-size blocks of land, gorgeous location. A lot of them, you know, have beach views or close to beach views or the potential to add beach views into the actual properties themselves. Incredibly well renovated. Innovated, They ticked off a lot of the boxes for what people are looking for in those marketplaces, which I think is really important. Again, what I think was slightly miss when you're looking at the Dowsford example. And all these properties were not just then presented really well, they matched the demographic of who was looking to purchase them. And then I do believe that they were priced very fairly. Now, those
8:18reserves I think were were low Below for those properties just based on the market and some of the sales in the area and what you're actually getting for the money. Now that is where I think this new auction strategy can potentially be unveiled. So
8:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
8:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): quoting strategy is essentially this anchor high, then reveal a low reserve. And I've got a feeling that we might start to see more of this, particularly with properties that agents know are gonna receive good attention in the marketplace. Now, what do I mean here? So essentially, if you're going to anchor a property high, you can come out and quote it. You don't need to go over the top. And I definitely would not recommend going over the top. But if you've got a property that you think is worth circa $2 million, and what the old strategy would have been is that you might have quoted it 1.8 to 1.9. And that's what many agents did, and that's why so many people were frustrated with underquoting. Now what you could do based on this particular sale is quote this property 195 to 2 million and 50. So, like, you know, 2 million is a fair price, potentially even 2 to 2.1, uh, depending on where you actually think true value is established. And then because you have to publish the reserve one week before the auction, potentially two weeks before the auction, you could even reduce the price guide and then have a reserve at a lower end. Now, there is obviously a risk of putting a lower reserve onto the
9:44property because you're essentially saying that you're willing to sell for a lower amount. And I think if you're doing this strategy, you have to be prepared to commit to that sale. If you do need to sell, then and a lot of people do need to sell, then I think you know, if you're willing to transact at that level regardless, and you're happy if you do achieve this lower number. So if you were happy to actually achieve the 3.45 example for the blocks sale prices, which you know the the television show would have had to have been happy to do, then what you can do is you can put a lower reserve in and potentially say that you're gonna, you know, reduce the price to 1.85 Five to you know 1.9 um and then have the reserve at the bottom of that. range. Now, what happens when you do this is that you can create a bit of a psychological perception of the property to buyers that it could be transacting at a lower value and that you actually have a real possibility of achieving a solid and great price. You're not necessarily getting bargain material, but you're getting a very good property for a very fair price. That needs to be the perception of what's out there. Now, where this is going to work well is when you've achieved the second aspect of the marketing campaign correctly, which is the marketing side of things, right? So if you have got
11:03a large pool of buyers and potentially the property that you're selling as well is going to have, you know, a good array Ray of competition. So it might be appealing to downsizers as well as some investors, as well as like you. young families, as well as potentially um first home buyers supported by family money or something along those lines. So if you've got a wide pool of buyers, the marketing is done very well, you've had a lot of interest throughout the campaign, it could be worthwhile. And what we might see is agents then putting reserve prices lower, which is essentially a new way of underquoting in the market. And I thought that this would happen, and I found it very interesting to see on the weekend that even in the Melbourne market that we're in right now, there was a five out of five sales, uh, you know, auction clearance rate for these particular block homes. Because what you're then able to do is essentially bring in more people and then let competition do the work, which has always been the strategy of auctions and it's how things have sort of played out uh over the weekend with these block auction results.
12:03Now, Victoria's new reserve disclosures make this more of a possibility than what it would have been before in the past. And I think that that is something that is very worthwhile pointing out. And why I think that this might be a big strategy for 2027 is that this can work particularly well in a weaker market. Now, I think it becomes even more interesting when buyer confidence is low. because in a strong market, you're typically going to have people that are more willing to compete. And as prices go up, you could have a reserve that is slowly just increasing with each sale result each week. So it's going to become less applicable. But in a falling market or a market with low confidence, I think attracting people in, you need to do that by being genuinely willing to sell at a discounted rate, which goes to reflect the market conditions that we're in. And I think that that is what the block did really, really well. They they knew that, you know, especially after what happened last year, they needed to get some results on the table. And, you know, being willing to transact at a lower amount, I think was really, really well done and in their favor. So I mean, the final thoughts in this is I think that the block this year was a really interesting result. And I think that I don't necessarily think it's any sort of um turnaround for Melbourne's market sentiment. I don't think that's the case at all. But I do think that it
13:22shows that when there is genuinely exceptional properties that match the buyers of the market, even at these higher price points, which is typically where we're seeing the largest amount of falling and you know the crashing of prices per se, that this is where these results are actually going to have a bigger difference. And I think that we're going to start to see auction campaigns like this come out a lot more over the next year. So if you're a buyer, it's something to be aware of that there is a good chance that reserves could be dropped artificially nearly so that they can try to increase more buyers and get more competition in. So it's going to be really, really important, just as always to make sure that you're doing your comparable sales analysis really well. So you have a very good understanding of what this property is actually worth. And it's worthwhile paying attention to what the property was initially quoted, not just what the reserve price is published at at the time of that. Hopefully that was uh a bit of an insight into what we could see coming next year. And until next week's episode, I'll catch you guys later next time.
14:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): later.