JohnBaronPortfolios.co.uk

CREI manager argues rental growth drives returns and predicts double-digit total returns amid high rates

40 min Listen to the original Episode page
UK Real EstateREITsProperty InvestmentDividend IncomeActive ManagementInterest RatesInflationCustodian Property Income REIT

Summary

Richard Shepherd-Cross, manager of Custodian Property Income REIT (CREI), outlines a strategy focused on acquiring smaller UK properties to secure higher yields and active management to drive rental growth. He contrasts CREI's diversified portfolio with single-sector funds, citing positive rental growth across all sectors for the year ending March 2026. Shepherd-Cross dismisses NAV discounts as primary valuation metrics, arguing instead that earnings support dividends, which determine share price. He forecasts interest rates to remain elevated around 4.75%-5% and projects total returns approaching double digits through a combination of 6-7% dividend yield and 3% capital growth.

Episode sections

  1. 0:28 – 2:27

    Introduction and Strategy Overview

    John Human introduces Richard Shepherd-Cross, manager of CREI, who explains the fund's launch in 2014 and its growth from £95m to £700m in gross assets, focusing on long-term secure income from diversified UK real estate.

  2. 2:27 – 5:52

    Portfolio Evolution and Asset Selection

    Shepherd-Cross notes the shift from high street to retail warehousing as the second largest sector, emphasizing the acquisition of smaller properties (£4-15m) outside institutional orbit to secure higher yields.

  3. 5:52 – 11:25

    Active Management and Tenant Relations

    The manager describes close asset management of 175 properties and 400 tenancies, including planning lease events two years in advance and refurbishing buildings to improve EPC ratings.

  4. 11:25 – 14:39

    Diversification and Rental Growth

    Shepherd-Cross highlights CREI's diversified approach, citing positive rental growth across all sectors for the year to March 2026, mitigating risk compared to single-sector funds.

  5. 14:39 – 19:58

    Portfolio Composition and Specific Examples

    The portfolio is UK-wide with industrial/logistics (42% of rent) and retail warehousing (>20%) as largest sectors. Examples include a Leicester showroom and a Plymouth industrial building refurbished to EPC A.

  6. 19:58 – 24:39

    Capital Growth Drivers and Market Cycle

    Shepherd-Cross argues rental growth, not yield compression, drives capital growth, citing high construction costs and inflation. He views the current market as a low point in the cycle.

  7. 24:39 – 31:56

    Corporate Consolidation and Tax Efficiency

    CREI acquires private property companies via share-for-share exchanges to avoid dilution, resolving succession issues and offering tax efficiencies including no SDLT and extinguished chargeable gains.

  8. 31:56 – 34:59

    NAV vs. Earnings and Dividend Focus

    Shepherd-Cross argues NAV is a poor metric for share valuation, asserting dividend yield correlates with risk and earnings support the dividend, which determines share price.

  9. 34:59 – 36:15

    Valuation Metrics and Transparency

    The speaker argues earnings yield is more intuitive than PE and that NAV discounts are not definitive indicators of value. He highlights the trust's transparency by publishing all 174 properties in reports.

  10. 36:15 – 37:25

    Portfolio Disclosure and Dividend Support

    Shepherd-Cross emphasizes that investors should assess the trust's worth based on balance sheet strength translating into earnings growth and dividend support, rather than discount levels.

  11. 37:25 – 38:52

    Interest Rate Outlook and Rental Growth Expectations

    Shepherd-Cross predicts interest rates will remain high around 4.75%-5% due to government challenges and global instability, expecting no yield compression and projecting around 3% annual rental growth.

  12. 38:52 – 39:55

    Total Return Forecast and Inflation Hedge

    The manager forecasts total returns approaching double digits, combining 6-7% dividend yields with approximately 3% capital growth, concluding that owning real assets is advantageous in an inflationary environment.

Claims worth verifying

CREI came to market in 2014 with £95m of property and has grown to £700m in gross assets today.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:24

How to verify: CREI Annual Report and Accounts 2026, specifically the Portfolio Overview and History sections; verify against the company's prospectus from 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The trust holds 174 properties, all of which are disclosed in reports.

Richard Shepherd Cross ·36:35

How to verify: Review the latest Custodian Property Income REIT annual report or website disclosures to confirm the total number of holdings and whether all are listed. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The trust achieved 3.75% annual rental growth over the previous five years.

Richard Shepherd Cross ·38:11

How to verify: Check Custodian Property Income REIT's historical annual reports for the five years prior to the interview date (2026-2026) to verify reported rental growth figures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The trust's strategy targets properties too small for major institutional buyers but beyond the reach of most private investors.

Richard Shepherd Cross ·34:59

How to verify: Review the trust's investment objective and portfolio composition in its latest annual report to confirm the average property value and tenant profile. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Interest rates might decrease if global fighting stops, but this is considered unlikely.

Richard Shepherd Cross ·37:51

How to verify: Assess geopolitical risk indices and central bank policy statements regarding inflation and growth forecasts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Rental growth of 3% per annum is expected to lead to complementary capital growth.

Richard Shepherd Cross ·38:52

How to verify: Compare future rental growth forecasts from property consultancies (e.g., JLL, CBRE) with historical capital growth rates for UK commercial property. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The trust aims to provide income supported by earnings growth.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·36:48

How to verify: Analyze the trust's financial statements to confirm that dividends are covered by recurring earnings and that earnings have grown over time. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify CREI's gross asset growth from £95m to £700m against the fund's annual reports.
  • Check the latest NAV discount and premium data for CREI to assess current market pricing.
  • Review the fund's portfolio disclosure to confirm the number of properties and sectors held.
  • Analyze the dividend coverage ratio (recurring earnings vs. dividend) for the most recent financial year.
  • Compare CREI's rental growth figures against sector averages from property indices like the IPD or RICS.
  • Assess the impact of rising interest rates on the fund's borrowing costs and refinancing risks.
  • Examine the tax implications of share-for-share exchanges for private property acquisitions.
  • Review the fund's EPC rating improvements and associated refurbishment costs in recent reports.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
John Human: Welcome to the John Barron Portfolios Podcast, the podcast that offers you a window into the thinking behind the UK's leading investment companies. Brought to you by John BarronPortfolios.co.uk. Subscribe to get the latest insights on how to manage investment trust portfolios from some of the industry's leading experts and be the first to listen to new investment manager interviews as they released on
0:20
John Human: our website.
0:22
John Human: Hello and welcome to the John Barron Portfolios Podcast. Brought to you by John Barron Barronportfolios.co.uk. Portfolios.
0:28
John Human: I am John Human and I'm very pleased to be joined today by Richard Shepherd Cross, uh, who is the manager of Custodian Real Estate Investment Trust. Welcome, Richard.
0:36
Richard Shepherd Cross: Thank you very much. Thank
0:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you for thank you.
0:38
John Human: No, thank you for coming on. It's uh it's an interesting sector, it's one we've got our eye on. It's um it's it's proving a source of value. Um, it's fair to say the sector's been somewhat out of favour, but that that may be on the turn, and we'll we'll hopefully um discuss that. uh in a few moments. But um perhap perhaps let's start, Richard, by introducing yourself and tell us a bit about you know your your background in and custodian REIT.
0:59
Richard Shepherd Cross: Uh yeah, so uh custodian property income REIT um came to market in 2014. Um very difficult world then. We were told interest rates were gonna be near zero forever. Um and it's the same. uh it's it's the same forecasters who are now telling us that
1:19
Richard Shepherd Cross: we're all doomed and interest rates are gonna stay high. Um
1:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): more
1:25
Richard Shepherd Cross: on that later. Um, so w why did we bring custodian to the market? Uh we had a a pre-public life, we had a portfolio of ninety-five 95 million of property that that's ceded custodian property income rate. Um And we've grown that to uh gross assets of around 700 million today.
1:45
Richard Shepherd Cross: And the
1:46
Richard Shepherd Cross: our reason for being
1:49
Richard Shepherd Cross: our core DNA
1:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
1:52
Richard Shepherd Cross: to provide long term secure income from well diversified UK real estate. And there I'm sure we'll be questioning. will be questions around that, so I won't go into more detail now, but that's what we set out to do in 2014. That single strand of DNA is absolutely
2:12
Richard Shepherd Cross: alive and well in our strategy still today.
2:15
John Human: And so so the strategy is, you know, obviously there's been you know significant growth uh over your listed life. What what's what what's changed about the strategy? Or are you are you have you really stuck to your principles all the way through?
2:27
Richard Shepherd Cross: Our strategy really hasn't changed at all.
2:30
Richard Shepherd Cross: If you were to uh if you were to really dig into the detail, you would see a slight change in the makeup of the portfolio.
2:42
Richard Shepherd Cross: And uh that is entirely normal. One of the benefits of being a diversified fund is you can uh move to those sectors of the market where you see the greatest opportunity for growth. So at IPO we had a little bit uh of a larger presence on the high street and
3:02
Richard Shepherd Cross: very little out-of-town retail. So what we would call retail warehousing. And that's really flipped around completely. Retail warehousing out of town retail sector is now the second largest part of our portfolio. But balance and diversification um was the watchword at the start, and
3:21
Richard Shepherd Cross: that is still consistent.
3:23
John Human: Yeah, yeah. Obviously the focus on the UK and am I right in thinking it's the sort of smaller, more regional uh UK commercial properties within the UK that you're you're most interested in, and if so, why?
3:34
Richard Shepherd Cross: Um that that's right. So um this is something that funnily enough we have um wrestled with, not not in terms of strategy, but in terms of how we describe our strategy.
3:47
Richard Shepherd Cross: So for me, I'm perfectly happy to say we buy smaller properties. But unfortunately, when you use the word smaller, people naturally think, well, smaller must be not as good. And there's just something about the way we use language, you know, um fast is better than. slow, big is better than small. Um, and uh and and these
4:07
Richard Shepherd Cross: are these are sort of um the the way we use language and and how we how have to manage that. What I mean when I'm talking about smaller properties is properties that are out of the orbit of institutional investors, really below their dignity to look at anything under 10 million pounds. And and perhaps that's understandable when they're in.
4:27
Richard Shepherd Cross: investing multiple billions in some cases. And because we're out of the orbit of that institutional money, which tends to have a lower cost of capital, it doesn't require gearing. And because we are beyond the reach of most private investors, there is this wonderful bit of the market where we can
4:47
Richard Shepherd Cross: find good quality, modern real estate. which to everyone listening, you would consider to be perfectly large properties. You know, they are four to fifteen million typically. Um
5:00
Richard Shepherd Cross: we can buy those properties with less competition, which means we get a higher initial yield, a higher running yield, and of course, that supports our principal objective, which is to pay a higher than average dividend income to our shareholders and to
5:20
Richard Shepherd Cross: pay that out of recurring earnings. That's really important to us. That dividend is covered by recurring earnings.
5:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And the
5:28
John Human: cover's quite substantial if I um if I'm right in thinking. Uh I did have the stack. What's what is the
5:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): dividend cover?
5:34
Richard Shepherd Cross: 105% covered at as at uh the March year end.
5:39
John Human: You mentioned um, you know, obviously they come at a higher initial yield, but these are you know perfectly perfectly good modern properties. Do you do you do a lot of active management again to kind of increase the the rental flows from those properties?
5:52
Richard Shepherd Cross: We do. Um, and uh you you you've you've you've picked on one of my pet subjects. A lot of fund managers will tell you that their active management is the secret to success, and they've got this special pixie dust that they can sprinkle onto their portfolios that no one else can do. I consider
6:12
Richard Shepherd Cross: active management to be the minimum expectation from our shareholders. Of course, we should be actively managing the portfolio. And the nature of our portfolio is that we've got 175 properties, 400 tenancies. So they're there every year.
6:27
Richard Shepherd Cross: there are rent reviews, there are lease renewals, there's refurbishment to do. And this is managing real estate. This is what we do. I would describe our management style as close asset management. What do I mean by that? We stick very close to our tenants. You know, we're nothing without our tenants. They're the ones that pay
6:47
Richard Shepherd Cross: the rent. If we don't provide buildings that our tenants like, then they will leave. So working closely with them, um, but also um making them understand that if we invest in their buildings, they're gonna have to pay more rent. And that's a perfectly fair exchange that the vast majority of our tenants are completely happy with. Uh,
7:07
Richard Shepherd Cross: and in many cases, I think, and we're seeing this actually in sort of rental growth uh numbers that are that are coming through into commercial property at the moment. For most businesses, the amount of rent they pay compared to all the other costs of running a business, labor
7:27
Richard Shepherd Cross: costs, compliance, there's a word to strike fear into anyone's hearts. Um, those costs have gone up significantly more than rent. So actually, I think people are finding you. with certainly in industrial and logistics, people are getting um more productivity out of the same amount of space. So
7:47
Richard Shepherd Cross: paying more rent is entirely affordable in most cases.
7:51
John Human: Yeah, absolutely. Um perhaps give us a feel um for for for how you deliver that. What what what's the sort of process and team behind you to to to really make this happen?
8:00
Richard Shepherd Cross: So we we've got a a a team of um nine asset managers. We manage the portfolio ourselves. I think that's really important to stay close to your tenants. Um we will uh as an absolute minimum be inside every one of our buildings at least once a year and speaking to our tenants to find out what they want
8:20
Richard Shepherd Cross: to do, um, whether they need more space, less space, um, brighter space,
8:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
8:26
Richard Shepherd Cross: name it. we'll be having those conversations. Uh, and that means that we are often um thinking about lease events two years in advance. So we're we are rarely caught out by that sort of um surprise departure of the tenant, because we would have been engaging in them
8:46
Richard Shepherd Cross: for for many years. And because we've engaged with them, then then what flow. flows from that is pretty standard asset management. Yes, we uh renew leases, we settle rent reviews. We will also take every opportunity when we get properties back, and sometimes working with tenants while they're still in occupation, to refurbish the buildings and
9:06
Richard Shepherd Cross: to uh improve the environmental performance of the buildings. And I know in the current Trumpian world, talking about the environment isn't quite as fashionable. rational as it was a few years ago, but we can't hide from the fact that legislation requires us to improve the environmental performance of the buildings that we
9:26
Richard Shepherd Cross: manage. And when a property comes back to us, rather than seeing that as a problem, we see that as an opportunity to improve what is called the EPC, the environmental performance certificate, A being the best and and E and F being largely off the scale
9:46
Richard Shepherd Cross: of modern um buildings.
9:49
Richard Shepherd Cross: And lots of examples of where we've done just that. So trying to keep the bot the buildings fit for purpose, The
9:58
Richard Shepherd Cross: relevant to tenants in the in the current market, and where you do that.
10:04
Richard Shepherd Cross: you get the best tenants, you let them quicker, and you get higher rents. So there is also a financial imperative that says we must do this.
10:14
John Human: I I I suspect as well if you if you are looking after your tenants, they stay put. So this must translate into some fantastic fantastic metrics matrix around sort of the the rate of churn in in the tenant base and and the number of voids that you may have at might any given point.
10:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think
10:28
Richard Shepherd Cross: yeah, I think I think that's right. Um, you know, tenants like to put break clauses in their leases because at the start of a lease, five years seems like a long time. Uh when the break comes up after maybe three years, they realize that three years is a very short time. And invariably the tenants don't leave. Um, I don't have the hard
10:48
Richard Shepherd Cross: and fast statistic to go alongside that, but I should think. it's in the order of 80% don't break their leases. Um, and I hope I hope they think that we are reasonable landlords. But you know, businesses grow and they need to move and that's all fine and understood.
11:03
John Human: Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Um, um, yeah, you know, obviously it's quite a large portfolio. I think the the number I have is 174 assets. Is that is that
11:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): correct there
11:11
John Human: or thereabouts? Um, I presume, you know, alongside this this. you know high quality active management that that is is a is another factor that helps you you kind of de-risk the income stream and really as you say keep keep that sustainable dividend flowing.
11:25
Richard Shepherd Cross: That's exactly right. You know, we have um we've lived through um
11:31
Richard Shepherd Cross: and and I think this is this is this is changing, but but maybe not this year, but in the previous five years to this year, we have heard about single sector funds. Um, yeah, that's what everyone was chasing. They were all tracing um logistics, and quite right too, because it was the
11:51
Richard Shepherd Cross: sector that was showing the most growth. Um, but what you have to remember with a single The sector fund, it is also a high risk fund. When that sector is in vogue, as with logistics, high risk, high return. But shopping centers, single sector shopping center funds, high risk,
12:10
Richard Shepherd Cross: terrible returns, because they were very much out of vogue. We have always planned a different furrow. So being a diversified fund and being doggedly diversified when it wasn't fashionable because we felt that it mitigated risk.
12:27
Richard Shepherd Cross: and that our shareholders were looking for that long-term secure income. As I said at the start, our DNA hasn't changed. Well, guess what? Where we are today, all of a sudden we're looking a little bit more fashionable. We have been able to record this year, for the year to March, for the first time in a number of years,
12:47
Richard Shepherd Cross: positive rental growth in all sectors of our portfolio. So industrial and logistics, obviously, it's been growing and growing strongly. Retail warehousing, it's been seeing some good rental growth, not least because it's a very restricted market. There's very little new out-of-town retail development because planners understand that you knacker the
13:07
Richard Shepherd Cross: high street if you build uh retail parks. But of course, as consumers, we love retail parks, free parking, easy to get to. all that all the sort of convenience retail that you need in one place.
13:19
Richard Shepherd Cross: So they're doing really well because the consumers like them, the retailers like them too. But what's changed is we're seeing positive rental growth on Prime High Streets, and we're seeing positive rental growth in regional offices. Not across the board. The regional office market remains.
13:41
Richard Shepherd Cross: pretty uh variable, but core city centre locations, particularly particularly in the sort of big six or seven regional cities of the UK,
13:51
Richard Shepherd Cross: we're seeing we're seeing rental growth
13:54
Richard Shepherd Cross: in offices and on the high street too. So
13:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all
13:58
Richard Shepherd Cross: of a sudden being diversified doesn't feel quite such a bad place to be, because not only are you getting that risk mitigation, but you're getting you're you're hedging your bets on where the growth is going to come from. Actually, we're seeing it in all sectors.
14:10
John Human: Indeed, indeed. Um, perhaps we can sort of try and bring bring this all to life. I know we're we're audio only on this uh this particular chat, so we can't see it, but but we can obviously point people in the direction of your presentations, which will contain all this information. Perhaps talk us through though what what the portfolio looks like in terms of positioning. You mentioned industrial, out-of-town retail. Um, where
14:30
John Human: is it geographically? Where where are these these hotspots? And you know, where do you see the sort of strongest uh sectors and regions for for demand and rental growth?
14:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
14:40
Richard Shepherd Cross: the portfolio goes from Aberdeen to Plymouth and from Chester to Norwich. So it is UK-wide. UK wide. If you were to look at a map of the country and picture the most motorway network and the big regional cities, then you would see dots on the map
14:58
Richard Shepherd Cross: that related to our portfolio that mirrored that pretty closely. 42% of our rent comes from industrial and logistics and over 20% from retail warehousing. Housing, Those are the two largest sectors because that's where we see the strongest rental growth. If we look back
15:16
Richard Shepherd Cross: at our portfolio last year,
15:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
15:20
Richard Shepherd Cross: to the year to March, rental growth in industrial was 4.1%, retail warehousing 2.7%,
15:29
Richard Shepherd Cross: and offices in the high street 1.6 and 1.3% respectively. So 3.3% rental growth overall, and over the last five years, rental growth has as in uh in our portfolio has averaged 3.75%.
15:46
Richard Shepherd Cross: So it's that rental growth that we are chasing all the time. That that's how we pick our portfolio. Our assets you would look at, you consider them modern
15:57
Richard Shepherd Cross: and fit for purpose for the sort of tenants we are pursuing. And perhaps I you know give a couple of examples.
16:03
Richard Shepherd Cross: of uh of assets that we have bought and and and how our strategy works. So in 2014, we bought a magnet and united carpets kitchen showroom uh and carpet shop in Leicester.
16:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
16:22
Richard Shepherd Cross: I mean this is the height of sophistication I can see um uh everyone. thinks this this is this would be a great buy. Why did we buy it? It was yielding eight percent. Uh and
16:35
Richard Shepherd Cross: um they were in occupation, um, both those tenants until last year. So we had um 10, 11 years of solid income supporting the dividend. Magnets Magnet wanted to move out, we've retained um. United Carpets and just renewed the lease to them. When
16:55
Richard Shepherd Cross: Magnet moved out, moved out, we refurbished the building. We took the energy performance certificate from a C to an A, and we've uh and we got a change of use in the planning. So it went from being a Magnet kitchen And showroom to being a farm foods supermarket. And um the value
17:15
Richard Shepherd Cross: went from 2.1 million to 3.5 million. So what does that tell you? It tells you that firstly, we buy properties that we want to own for the long term. One of the first questions we ask when we buy a property is what happens at the end of the lease? If the answer is,
17:31
Richard Shepherd Cross: you don't want that one empty, then that's we don't buy that property. We want properties that at the end of the lease you think we can we can invest the money. we can um refurbish, relax, and the big and the property can have another 10 years of of functional life. Similarly, similarly, and at the different end of the country in
17:51
Richard Shepherd Cross: Plymouth,
17:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
17:53
Richard Shepherd Cross: in 2015. So I'm again
17:56
Richard Shepherd Cross: to you know to um recreating that same story that we own properties for the long term, we acquired an industrial building that was left to Ron Seal. Um, uh, you know the jokes. Uh and um they were in occupation until two years ago. Uh they were paying
18:15
Richard Shepherd Cross: £280,000 a year, and uh that we we paid 3.25 million for the property. We refurbished it when Ron Seal left. Um the refurbishment took the building from an EPC of an E to an A. So this included
18:34
Richard Shepherd Cross: 200 uh kilowatts of uh solar panels on the roof. We let it to um a uh a car battery recycling business that was backed by the government. They've taken a 25-year lease,
18:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they're paying
18:50
Richard Shepherd Cross: £465,000 a year, and the valuation post-refurbishment has gone to 6.4 million up from three and a quarter when we bought it. So I think again, it shows you we will we're lucky in that we have a capital base that allows us to spend the money on the properties when the
19:10
Richard Shepherd Cross: money needs to be spent. Our experience of doing this is that where we've spent money refurbishing buildings, we have been repaid with higher valuations, higher rents, better quality tenants. And we've recovered all the money that we've invested in those buildings and some. And of course, in
19:30
Richard Shepherd Cross: both cases, they continue to provide that long-term secure income that we were set up to deliver. Yeah,
19:37
John Human: absolutely. No, I mean it's very interesting that that sort of you know, obviously the increase in value is one thing. That that's come through obviously rental uh growth as as as you've pointed out, that underpins the dividend. But but there is there is some quite significant capital growth under underlying all this. How how how much does that factor your thinking alongside the the the the provision of of the sustainable
19:57
John Human: yield?
19:58
Richard Shepherd Cross: Um, I think i if if if we br if we break it back. what you know, what what what drives capital growth? Absent yield compression. So unless we've got falling interest rates, um, and particularly falling guilt rates, it is it's perhaps
20:19
Richard Shepherd Cross: the unreasonable to expect us Just to have explicit um capital growth because all of a sudden people think real estate is a lower risk option than perhaps they did before. Because you've always got that floor of guilt rates below which property yields should not fall, unless there is rental growth.
20:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
20:38
Richard Shepherd Cross: if we put yield compression to one side, because I think that's that's that's sort of last decade's news. Where are we now? Interest rates three and three-quarter three quarter percent. I think some people in the market thought. further yield compression um
20:54
Richard Shepherd Cross: would uh see um life coming back to commercial property. I I'm perhaps old enough and ugly enough to remember when interest rates were five percent, and we were delighted that they were as low as five percent. And guess what? Real estate functioned just fine in that environment. So at three and three quarter percent, I don't think we need interest
21:14
Richard Shepherd Cross: rates to be. any lower for real estate to work. The principal driver of capital growth is rental growth. If you hold your yields and your rents go up, your values go up. And in the world we're in at the moment, where I think interest rates will remain broadly where they are, and the Bank of England seem to
21:34
Richard Shepherd Cross: be supporting that. Um not because of anything I've said, but that appears to be what what what what is happening. I think we're going to be in a broadly inflationary environment for some time,
21:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
21:48
Richard Shepherd Cross: not least because the government need to inflate their way out of the current debt position. Don't see how else we fix that one. Um so if intr if inflation's going to run hot for a few years, and and well, I know I know where the target rates. are, but I think we all understand that the interest rate uh the sorry the inflation rates we all feel
22:08
Richard Shepherd Cross: as consumers is somewhat higher than uh the Bank of England's target suggests.
22:15
Richard Shepherd Cross: So if inflation's gonna run a bit hot when inflation is um a factor, what do we see? We see rental growth because costs of construction go up and and we're in one of the we're in an extraordinary period at the moment where uh it is almost not possible to build new commercial
22:34
Richard Shepherd Cross: property because of the cost of construction and let it at
22:40
Richard Shepherd Cross: current rental levels and make a profit. So the developers aren't really developing. There are some pockets where you can do
22:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that,
22:49
Richard Shepherd Cross: um, and those pockets are where there is sufficient demand that rents can grow to previously unseen levels.
23:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
23:01
Richard Shepherd Cross: there's an unusual state of affairs where the capital value of buildings today,
23:10
Richard Shepherd Cross: based on where rents are today, means you couldn't rebuild that building. building based on current values. So we're going to have to see rental growth if we want to see an increase in supply. So that inflationary pressure on build costs is driving rents to grow. And for as long
23:30
Richard Shepherd Cross: as we're not building new, we've got a restricted supply. And that restricted supply is also causing rents to grow. So it's a very good environment for rental growth. Inflation,
23:43
Richard Shepherd Cross: demand over supply,
23:46
Richard Shepherd Cross: and
23:47
Richard Shepherd Cross: that means that investing now, which I feel is a low point in the cycle for commercial property, with that growth means the real value of your pound invested will be preserved.
24:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
24:01
Richard Shepherd Cross: it's really important. to remember everyone gets excited about capital growth, but real estate is an in is an income investment. And the capital growth is a companion to that income growth, but it's an income first investment. Yeah,
24:17
John Human: absolutely. Um given given that we have this sort of uh restricted supply uh that you mention, um how how does has that affected the uh the the opportunities that you're seeing? Is there more competition for assets now than there perhaps were? Um, or or has the interest rate cycle sort of pushed some people into forced selling and and
24:37
John Human: given you greater opportunities?
24:39
Richard Shepherd Cross: June, there's been remarkably little forced selling. Um, and I think that's partly because rents are growing, so those property owners with debt are finding that they can still service the debt. Um, the banks are much, much more cautious they would than they were um in 2008, where they tended to dump
24:58
Richard Shepherd Cross: properties. I think they realize that if they sit it out, they might just get their money back. And if they can service the debt in the uh in the medium term, then then that's what we're seeing. So not a lot of false forced selling. Um f for us, um, we're seeing um opportunity not just in
25:18
Richard Shepherd Cross: um buying and selling uh properties that are in the market. You know, the market volumes are very subdued at the moment. I I read a report um uh last week that suggested that investment volumes are down 34 4% percent in the first half of this year versus the first half of last year. And
25:38
Richard Shepherd Cross: that is probably largely as a result of geopolitical
25:45
Richard Shepherd Cross: nervousness and um
25:49
Richard Shepherd Cross: and the direct impact that's had on guilt rates, and perhaps the hope and expectation that we might see falling rates. I think as we go into the fourth quarter of this year and into next. year, I think the market is going to come to terms with the fact that if you want to get returns out of
26:08
Richard Shepherd Cross: property, sitting and hoping for yield compression is
26:13
Richard Shepherd Cross: not going to be the way it works. You're going to get there by buying well, asset managing your way through that rental growth uh and and uh picking up the value that way. It's just not going to be an easy ride. uh and when when when the market comes to terms with that i think we'll start to see some more uh sales and
26:33
Richard Shepherd Cross: purchases and uh you know greater investment volumes but we're finding the we're finding the value through um corporate consolidation um particularly in in the private sector buying um private property companies in all share transactions
26:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
26:51
Richard Shepherd Cross: And we we acquired three
26:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
26:54
Richard Shepherd Cross: three such companies last year. We've you know got an active pipeline at the moment, um some with terms agreed that we're working through.
27:03
Richard Shepherd Cross: That will all you know come out as as and when we do it.
27:07
John Human: Perhaps tell us a bit about the the companies you did acquire I think Merlin properties, Grove Court properties and Scorpion. Tell us what what what attracted you to those assets, what they bring to the to the custodian story.
27:18
Richard Shepherd Cross: So the uh as as in all transactions, there are there are two sides. So let's consider our side first. Um we have bought regionally diverse portfolios of property at a time that we think is in close to the bottom of the valuation cycle. In fact, probably
27:39
Richard Shepherd Cross: the valuation cycle bottomed out in September 24, so two years ago. Uh, and there just hasn't been enough confidence to see it really uh it really kick on. Um so we've been at the bottom, bouncing along the bottom for a couple of years now. So the the That opportunity window, in
27:59
Richard Shepherd Cross: my view, remains wide open.
28:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
28:03
Richard Shepherd Cross: and buying at the bottom means you're buying uh properties with high yields and um with all that rental growth potential. So we're supporting dividends today and earnings growth in the future.
28:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
28:18
Richard Shepherd Cross: that's why we want to do these deals. And in a perfect world, we would go to the market, raise two or three hundred million, and go and buy these. properties. But we can't raise money in the public markets at the moment because our shares are trading at a discount to net asset value. And if we were to ask our shareholders to support a fundraiser,
28:38
Richard Shepherd Cross: they'd say,
28:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
28:40
Richard Shepherd Cross: you can't do that. That would be dilutive. And I would say, how can it be dilutive to buy property that is going to enhance the dividends in the future?
28:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
28:51
Richard Shepherd Cross: And that's the subject of a separate question about net asset value versus earnings, but that's what people would say. So because we can't do that, um, buying um
29:03
Richard Shepherd Cross: private property companies where we can issue shares at net net asset value in a net asset value for net asset value share exchange, we can grow the portfolio. So then the next question is: well, what's it in it for the private property companies? Very often these are family businesses.
29:23
Richard Shepherd Cross: And as with many family businesses, they don't always, they don't often make it through more than two or three generations. Because people, people's ambitions change generation to generation, families grow in size. and then you end up with a succession problem. Senior generation can't
29:43
Richard Shepherd Cross: pass down to the second generation because who's going to run it? Does anyone want to run it? Are they going to run it on behalf of the uh other members of the family? Uh, or are we just going to sell? But if you sell, you have to suffer huge capital gains. Uh, and if you split it up, how do you split it up equitably?
30:03
Richard Shepherd Cross: So by selling to us in an all-share transaction, you instantly resolve succession because we're now managing the portfolio. You also resolve um equality because rather than passing on a disparate proportion of properties to the next generation, you can you have an equitably
30:23
Richard Shepherd Cross: divisible asset, shares in custodian property income rate REIT, that you can pass on to the next generation. So all of that gets resolved. But better than that, it's very, very tax efficient.
30:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): As
30:35
Richard Shepherd Cross: a corporate transaction, there's no stamp duty land tax, it's 5% savings, nice to have. Because we're a real estate investment trust, the chargeable gain in the company gets extinguished when it joins our REIT REAC group. That means we can pay great. gross price for the share capital of the
30:55
Richard Shepherd Cross: private property company without an offset for the future
31:00
Richard Shepherd Cross: chargeable corporation tax we would have to pay on the chargeable gain. And it is also possible for the family to get rollover relief on their personal CGT liability on the shares they hold in the private. property company as it rolls into custodian. So while they
31:19
Richard Shepherd Cross: don't avoid the payment of that CGT, you mitigate it. You don't have to settle it today. So for all of those reasons, they are very uh compelling propositions, both for the vendor and And for us. So we get to grow our portfolio at a great time in the market.
31:37
John Human: Yeah. Elegant, I think, is the word. to describe that. Um let's let's talk about you mentioned uh the disconnect between net asset value and share prices. It has been narrowing, if I might think, it's probably halved um over the last couple of years. Um from from what I've seen. Perhaps perhaps talk about what is happened to narrow that further.
31:56
Richard Shepherd Cross: I think the the first and The most important thing to say is net asset value is the wrong way to assert. assess the worth of shares in a listed property company. Why is that? Firstly, net asset value is an estimate of what the properties could have
32:15
Richard Shepherd Cross: been sold for three months ago. And it is not only that, it is the aggregate of the estimate of all the individual prices. for which properties could have been sold for three months ago. So it doesn't take account of the fact that surely it's lower risk to have 174 properties than
32:35
Richard Shepherd Cross: one.
32:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
32:37
Richard Shepherd Cross: it doesn't take account of that.
32:38
John Human: Yeah.
32:39
Richard Shepherd Cross: And the second thing to say is as a shareholder, you don't have a unit of net asset value. So it can go up and it can go down, and the share price might not move at all. In fact, the share price might go up and might go down, and the note has a value, might not move at all. So, so sort of so what? And then people will say, well, but ultimately it's what the
32:59
Richard Shepherd Cross: portfolio is worth. So if the company were to be sold, that's what I'd get. Except it's not what you get, because in all the corporate consolidation that we've You've seen in the market over the last three or four years,
33:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
33:14
Richard Shepherd Cross: average. deals have been done at a 10% discount to net asset value. So even when it really matters, you're not getting net asset value. So what are you getting?
33:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
33:25
Richard Shepherd Cross: what should you focus on? What you're getting as a shareholder is your share of the earnings of the company paid to you in a dividend. And as a real estate investment trust, we have to pay out 90% of our net rental profits. Most of us pay out quite a lot more than that. And most of us pay not far off 100%
33:45
Richard Shepherd Cross: of recurring earnings. Some even pay more than 100% of recurring earnings, but that's not our policy.
33:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
33:54
Richard Shepherd Cross: earnings is the most important thing because it's your earnings that support the dividend. It's the dividend that actually determines the share. price. And if you were to, and I've done this exercise, but if you were to get a list of 10 real estate investment trusts that you knew and you understood the
34:13
Richard Shepherd Cross: portfolios they own, and you were to rank them from highest to lowest discounted net asset value, you would have a list that, aside from giving you that ranking, would bear no resemblance to the relative risks of those portfolios, or indeed the dividends you're likely to receive from
34:33
Richard Shepherd Cross: them. If, by contrast, you were to rank them by
34:39
Richard Shepherd Cross: dividend yield, you would see an almost perfect correlation between the highest risk portfolio
34:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
34:47
Richard Shepherd Cross: the lowest risk portfolio in pure property terms.
34:51
Richard Shepherd Cross: What we try and do is have a relatively high dividend yield,
34:59
Richard Shepherd Cross: but for lower property risk, because we've mitigated that through diversification and by fishing in that pond that is neither full of private investors or institutional investors. So we're trying to so sort of you know weave that magic that gives you
35:19
Richard Shepherd Cross: a higher return for lower risk. But by and large, that's what you would expect to see. So dividend yield supported by earnings or may or I mean look, it's PE, isn't it? The inverse of PE is earnings yield. And actually, I think for most investors, earnings yield makes it a bit more
35:39
Richard Shepherd Cross: sense. You know, PE of 20, it's a head scratcher, earnings yield of 5%, everyone understands what you're talking about. That's what my one pound invested is going to earn me year on year. So that's the way to look at it. And I think discount and net asset value is
35:55
Richard Shepherd Cross: it's interesting, but it shouldn't be the determining factor. It isn't the case that something on a 30 discount is better. value than something on a five-discount. It's all to do with quality of property. Balance sheet's really important. Balance sheet strengths are important. But these are they're more difficult concepts to
36:15
Richard Shepherd Cross: wrestle with if you don't know the properties uh inside out. And and but because of our view of what we think is important, if you were to um look at any of the um reports that that we produce for custodian property income rate or go on our website, you will not just
36:35
Richard Shepherd Cross: see the top 10 properties by value, you'll see all 174 properties. So it's totally transparent because it's really important that people understand where their the money is invested,
36:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
36:48
Richard Shepherd Cross: the balance sheet strength is, and how all of that translates to earnings and earnings growth and how that supports the dividend yield. That's the that should be the the the assessment of worth.
37:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah
37:01
John Human: absolutely I think I I've always thought that transparency is is is incredibly important. So I know it's uh to be applauded. Um one one last question. Um here where we sit today in the cycle we've we've discussed that at length. Where where do where are where are we going? What what what's your uh getting the crystal ball out? What what do we expect over the next five years? Where would you like custodian to
37:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be?
37:21
Richard Shepherd Cross: Um
37:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
37:23
Richard Shepherd Cross: yeah, and I mean I've I've touched on some of this already, haven't
37:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I?
37:25
Richard Shepherd Cross: But just to pull it all together, uh I think interest rates are gonna stay broadly where they
37:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are.
37:31
Richard Shepherd Cross: Uh I think that um our our government have got challenges. to deal with that I don't think they're gonna overcome easily. So I think that um guilt rates are gonna remain high. You know, they might, you know, if if we can if we can
37:51
Richard Shepherd Cross: stop um uh all the um fighting in the world, then we might see them come, you know, come in a little bit, but um maybe that is uh a hope too far. I think we're gonna be going in to a uh a more unsettled environment uh globally. So uh guilt rates, you know, four and three-quarters to five percent is probably where they're gonna
38:11
Richard Shepherd Cross: be. So no explicit yield compression. And therefore, people should be looking for uh that rental growth. As I said, over the last five years, we've been running at um three and three quarter percent uh rental growth per annum, but it's a five years where. where interest rates were still rising. So we didn't, and if
38:31
Richard Shepherd Cross: we'd had stable interest rates through that period, it would have been perfectly logical to assume three and three quarter percent rental growth, three and three quarter percent capital growth. But of course, because interest rates were rising, one has counteracted the other. But where we stand today and we look forwards, that's that sort of around three 3% percent per annum rental growth leading to.
38:52
Richard Shepherd Cross: complementary capital growth, I think is um
38:57
Richard Shepherd Cross: is a sensible expectation. So with um dividend yields of six or seven percent and some you know maybe three percent capital growth on top, you know, you're getting not far off double-digit double digit returns from from real estate. And an in inflation. inflationary environment, owning real assets
39:17
Richard Shepherd Cross: feels like a a very good place to be.
39:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
39:20
John Human: absolutely. Couldn't couldn't agree more. It's why we've got our eye on the sector. Um, Richard, thank you so much for talking us through uh custodian uh property income rates. It's uh it's fascinating. Uh and your thoughts on on the broader market. Thank you, thank you so much.
39:32
Richard Shepherd Cross: Thank you.
39:33
John Human: Thank you.
39:35
John Human: Thank you for listening to the John Varon Varron Portfolios Podcast. We hope you enjoyed it. Brought to you by JohnVarronportfolios.co.uk. You can subscribe on our website to get the latest insights on how to manage investment trust portfolios from some of the industry's leading experts and be the first to listen to new interviews as they're released. See you next
39:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights