Retire Smarter with Kevin Kroskey, CFP® & Tyler Emrick, CFA® CFP®

Speakers discuss financial strategies for unexpected early retirement before age 65

20 min Listen to the original Episode page
Early RetirementSeveranceHealthcareTax PlanningRetirement Accounts

Summary

Kevin Kroskey and Tyler Emrick address the common scenario of retiring earlier than planned, citing data that 40% of retirees leave the workforce before their target age. They emphasize the importance of stress-testing financial plans to handle sudden job loss, using a case study of a family that navigated a layoff at age 60. The discussion covers immediate financial impacts such as severance tax implications, the treatment of unvested equity, and the 'Age 55 Rule' for penalty-free 401(k) withdrawals. Healthcare coverage options, including COBRA and ACA marketplace alternatives, are analyzed as critical components of the transition. Finally, the speakers advise integrating tax, income, and healthcare decisions to determine whether the goal is permanent retirement or a temporary bridge to re-employment.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Receiving severance as a lump sum can create a significant tax hit, whereas periodic payroll payouts may offer better tax management opportunities.

    Walter · 8:40

  2. 2
    RSUs and stock options may continue to vest after a layoff, creating a future source of income that must be tracked and integrated into the post-employment financial plan.

    Walter · 9:39

  3. 3
    The 'Age 55 Rule' allows penalty-free withdrawals from employer retirement plans (401k/403b) if employment ends after age 55, serving as a liquidity tool for those under 59.5.

    Walter · 10:39

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 4:34

    Introduction to Unexpected Early Retirement

    Speakers discuss the commonality of retiring earlier than planned, citing EBRI data that 40% of retirees leave the workforce before their target age. They introduce the scenario of being laid off at age 60 and the need for a financial plan to handle such transitions.

  2. 4:34 – 8:19

    Importance of Stress-Testing Financial Plans

    Walter shares a case study of a family that stress-tested their plan for early retirement. When the husband was unexpectedly laid off, the prior planning provided confidence and a framework to navigate the new reality, including managing income and healthcare.

  3. 8:19 – 10:19

    Analyzing Severance and Equity Compensation

    The discussion moves to the immediate financial impact of a layoff, focusing on severance packages, tax implications of lump-sum vs. periodic payouts, and the treatment of unvested equity like RSUs and stock options.

  4. 10:19 – 12:53

    Accessing Retirement Accounts and the Age 55 Rule

    Walter explains the 'Age 55 Rule,' which allows penalty-free withdrawals from a 401(k) or 403(b) if you leave your job after age 55. He advises caution, suggesting this rule should be preserved for future use rather than immediately liquidating accounts upon layoff.

  5. 12:53 – 16:28

    Healthcare Coverage and COBRA Considerations

    Healthcare is identified as a top priority. Speakers discuss COBRA coverage, noting it can be expensive but may be preferable if deductibles are already met. They also mention the option to switch to high-deductible plans or wait for ACA marketplace enrollment in 2027 to manage costs.

  6. 16:28 – 20:12

    Integrated Decision Making and Bridging Income

    The speakers emphasize that healthcare, tax, and income decisions are interconnected. They advise determining whether the goal is permanent retirement or a temporary bridge to re-employment, which dictates the strategy for managing cash reserves and future income sources.

Claims worth verifying

The 'Age 55 Rule' allows penalty-free withdrawals from 401(k) and 403(b) plans if employment ends after age 55.

Walter ·10:39

How to verify: IRS Publication 590-B or IRS Code Section 72(t)(2)(A)(v). For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

COBRA coverage typically lasts for 18 months.

Walter ·13:29

How to verify: U.S. Department of Labor Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) COBRA guidelines. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

True Wealth Design offers 20-minute discovery calls.

Tyler Emrick ·19:19

How to verify: True Wealth Design website (truewealthdesign.com) or contact information provided in the episode description. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the EBRI statistic on early retirement rates using the Employee Benefit Research Institute's public data reports.
  • Review IRS Publication 590-B to confirm the specific conditions and limitations of the 'Age 55 Rule' for penalty-free 401(k) withdrawals.
  • Compare current COBRA premium costs against potential ACA marketplace subsidies using Healthcare.gov or a broker to assess affordability.
  • Consult a tax professional to model the tax impact of lump-sum vs. periodic severance payouts based on your specific tax bracket.
  • Check your employment contract and equity agreement to determine post-termination vesting schedules for RSUs and stock options.
  • Review your current health insurance deductible status to evaluate whether switching to a high-deductible plan under COBRA is cost-effective.
  • Confirm the ACA open enrollment dates for 2027 to understand the timeline for securing individual market coverage.
  • Assess your cash reserve runway to determine if you can self-insure and wait for the next open enrollment period without risking a coverage gap.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,

0:00Tyler Emrick: Tyler, I'm gonna start today's episode off with kind of a very standard thought process. I would say that most people have a retirement age in their minds of 65. Maybe some folks say 67, but you've kind of been saving and planning your whole life, circling around those kinds of dates for many years, right?

0:18Walter: That's right. But well, what happens when your employer has a different plan, right? You're 60 years old and expecting to work another handful of years and all of a sudden your position is being eliminated and you're laid off.

0:29Tyler Emrick: Yeah. 60 is a pretty big change. I mean, that's not 64, and I'm only off by a year of what I plan. We're talking a significant chunk of time.

0:36Walter: Oh, absolutely. And well, it's more common than I think what most individuals realized. I mean, the um Employee Benefit Research Institute, so E EBRI, B R I. um, your studies are showing that a significant number of employ uh retirees. actually leave the workforce well uh before they originally planned to. Sometimes it's health related, sometimes it's layoffer changes to their company.

0:59Tyler Emrick: Yeah. And then you're faced with this really tough decision. Do I try to make retirement work now way earlier than I thought it would? Or do I try to look for another job at 60 and the difficulties that come along with that?

1:10Walter: Exactly. And before making that decision, you know, there's some important things to consider. You know, severance, healthcare, how are you going to access your investments? What are you going to live off of? Do you keep your retirement plans where they are? So all these things, that's what we're going to dive into today.

1:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey,

1:32Tyler Emrick: it's another episode of Retire Smarter. I'm Walter Storholt alongside Tyler Emmerich. He's a certified financial planner, a chartered financial analyst, and one of the wealth advisors at True Wealth Design. Find us online at TrueWealth Design.com. Tyler, great to be with you again this week talking about retiring early. Sounds great. Let's retire early.

1:51Walter: Yes, absolutely. Yes. Early retirement's always good, assuming that you're prepared for it and comfortable, right? Um, which kind

1:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of

1:57Walter: gets into the crux of the lead-in lead in a little bit. So what what prompted the podcast today was I I kind of ran across the Employee Benefit Research Institute. So this is EBRI. I'm not sure many listeners are going to run into EBRI all that much, but uh they put out like retirement confidence surveys and retirement studies and the like. And what struck me is they said about 40% of retirees retired earlier than planned. So almost half of retirees are retired.

2:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's a lot.

2:25Walter: It felt like a lot to me. right?

2:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

2:28Walter: then I started to think about it. And um actually I've had a few individuals uh in the past year where actually they were forced uh into that retirement, right? Uh yeah, they had some company layoffs, employer changes, uh, and the like. So it got me thinking, like, well, hey, what if you find yourself in this situation, right? Where, hey, you had thought you were at the home stretch, right? Maybe a handful of years to go, and then all of a sudden, something happens. Boom. You know, your employer does a layoff or something changes and you're no longer working. What needs to be kind of on that old to-do list or what are some of the things that you need to be, you know, kind of having in mind to help you navigate that unexpected decision of like, hey, I guess I'm gonna potentially be retired now. How do you start to wrap your arms around it?

3:11Tyler Emrick: Yeah. As someone who just moved across the country and should know very well that things don't always go according to plan, um, that still surprises me as a number. I mean, you would think when you're spending your whole life kind of working toward a date, planning around it, thinking about it, targeting it for forty percent to not work out that way and to retire earlier than that is a bit surprising.

3:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That struck me

3:32Walter: for sure. Yeah. Um

3:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and again,

3:34Walter: with the last year that I've had, I've had more than a few um you know case studies. right, or situations where this had kind of come up. So it was really kind of top of mind for me. And um, so I was like, hey, let's uh let's kind of dive in and and you know, just kind of talk about it and make sure that uh hopefully no listeners are finding themselves in this particular situation, right? Uh but if

3:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

3:54Walter: uh but if you do, maybe we'll be a little bit more prepared for it. And 'cause And because

3:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're

3:58Tyler Emrick: focusing a little bit more on the unexpected, uh like the negative unexpected early. retirement, not the I planned so well.

4:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Correct. It

4:06Tyler Emrick: turns out we can retire earlier, so now let's do it. This is a little bit more of that like you've been laid off or job position cut or health or some other

4:14Walter: 100%. But you have to kind of but but what you said there is I think important because I'll do my shameless plug on financial planning, right? And like, hey, why is the financial plan so important? Uh it's because then you have a plan. that's put in place to kind of help you through these unexpected transitions or life events, right? If you've done a lot of that work up front, um, then it makes this, it's never going to be smooth when you have an unexpected transition into potential retirement or a job change, but it helps give you, I think, a little bit more confidence that, all right, hey, I can breathe. Let's go through and and how much time do I have? What are my options? And and you kind of can approach it. from that, from that side of things, right? I actually uh earlier this year I had met with a family where um they had kind of set up a meeting with me saying, hey, um uh the wife actually wanted to retire. She's like, hey, I'm kind of I'm done. Can we do it? Let's stress test the plan a little bit, right? You know, uh, I was planning to work a couple more years. What happens if I actually, you know, kind of just say, hey what, I'm done. You know, let's let's go through. And part of that process from a planner standpoint is to walk them through like some of the even worst case scenarios. Not only like, hey, can this can this work? Can it happen? Right. But then what happens if your husband uh you know loses his position, right? Uh and and that type of thing. And

5:34we we spent a lot of time kind of going through some of those what-if scenarios and got her to a point to where she's like, all right, hey, I'm gonna go ahead and put in my notice. I'm gonna go ahead and retire this year. You know, and they, you know, we had I basically come to grips and comfortable with that decision. And then, you know, about six months goes by, and then I got an email from them saying, Hey, actually, my husband, you know, got laid off, right? Completely unexpected. You know, husband had planned to work for a handful of years later, right? Um, but completely unexpected. out of the blue. And now they're again trying to wrap their arms around. We just thought about this big decision, and now we're kind of thrust into another one. So it was like, hey, let's get back in here. I know we great that we stress tested this, right? Great that we thought of this as a worst case scenario. Let's come in and let's start to peel back the onion a little bit and really start to get like, what does this mean for us? Right. And and how how do we need to kind of think about the next hit. handful of months and and that transition and what it looks like. Right. So so that front end work, they had no idea that he was going to get laid off, of course, right? Um, but but that planning work ahead, you know, I think gave them quite a bit of confidence and said, all right, hey, you know, we can do this. Let's kind of look go through and look at our options. Right. So

6:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

6:45Walter: should be doing maybe not that all the time, right? We think about it from

6:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a

6:49Walter: planning standpoint, Wallet walled is like, as hey, when do I become financially independent? When do I not have to work uh and and and still accomplish all the goals that I wanted to? So that's kind of using that plan and putting it in place to um, you know, give you some confidence. Uh, and when these events come up, you know, feeling a little bit more comfortable about it or as comfortable as you can, of course.

7:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): What would your life look like if you designed it around your true wealth? It's a powerful question and one that true wealth design helps individuals, families, and business owners answer every day. With a fully integrated approach to financial planning, tax strategy, investments, and business advisory, their team can bring clarity and confidence to every part of your financial life. Take the first step toward a stronger financial future with a no cost, no obligation discovery meeting. Just click the link in today's show description to get started.

7:36Tyler Emrick: It's amazing to see uh like where. that stress test really paid off running it through that worst case scenario and not planning for a sunny day, not even planning for a cloudy day. Like you you guys prepared for a hurricane and

7:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): got

7:50Tyler Emrick: them through the tornado, if that makes

7:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): sense.

7:52Walter: Correct. No, no, absolutely. But as I I think about their situation, right? We kind of had this almost pick list of like, well, what are like the big items that they need to have on the radar? What needs to get done now? What can kind of wait a little while longer? And um, that's what I think I wanted to kind of use the bulk of the time today. Here is just kind of you know walking through what that pick list looked like and where you should be kind of focusing your time if you find yourself in a similar situation, right? Um, and the family that I was talking about, right? There was a layoff.

8:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

8:20Walter: generally, when we think about getting laid off, um, it's gonna going to be very important to understand like, well, what does what is the company offer? offering you in the form of like a severance package, right? How long are you going to potentially get paid? And how does that come to you? One of the key things that'll be a theme throughout this is like trying to get an understanding of like, what does this do from the money that's going to come down into my pocket to live off of? And what is this going to do from a tax standpoint, right? Um, If your severance is going gonna to get paid out to you and alum in a lump sum, right, within a month of you leaving, that could be a pretty big tax hit. What do we want to do with with that, right? The more likely case is that that severance is paid out through normal payroll for a period of time, right? You know, however many months that they're willing to uh to pay out. But we need to understand when does that start? How is that payout potentially going to come? Are you gonna going be to eligible for any of the other benefits? that might be afforded to you? These things are like RSUs, so restricted stock units, non qualified stock options, right? What happens with these with the ones that have invested? So if you have some of the more complex stock option offerings through your employer, no, that severance package is going to give you the an idea of like, well, what happens with this equity compensation that I might not have available? to me

9:39currently and maybe it hasn't fully vested, but is it going to automatically invest now? When does that money come? You know, um, I had an individual that uh he had a similar situation where he had gotten laid off and he had had these RSUs, right? And they continued to venture the next handful of years. And that's gonna going to be a source of potential income for him uh in the coming years as they continue to vest, v. right? So understanding that again, we're trying to get an understanding of well, what's going to be coming into you and when and how to how can we use that to our advantage? Other things would be like PTO time getting paid out. And then,

10:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so

10:19Walter: that's kind of like the compensation side of things. And then I turn turned my attention to like, well, what other benefits are going to be afforded to you that you need to kind of make. decisions off of? This would be things like your 401k, 403B, or employer retirement plan. Uh, and the family that I had talked to about before, they actually qualified for what's called age 55 rule, which is this quirky rule where you can actually pull money from your retirement accounts from a company that you leave after the age of 55. So, like you think about like a rule like that. Well, hey, you're thrust into potentially an early retirement. You might need to lean on some of your assets. Well, hey, getting access to your 401k without a 10% penalty because you're under 59 and a half. I mean, that's a pretty big advantage, right? So, like, that's going to drive, well, do I keep my 401k there or not? Or do I keep a portion of it in there? Right. So those some of those other benefit things, especially when it comes to like the retirement. plans, I generally say that should be a little bit lower on the list, Walt. Normally you want to make sure that you don't qualify for some of these quirky rules where you can potentially get access to it penalty-free or whatever the case is. Uh, and that way you're not just saying, hey, I'm done with this employer. The layoff, Off, I'm out, I want all my money out of there. Right. Which could be a very natural, like, I think, thought process.

11:39for some of this. Well, hey, you want to make sure you're not kind of shooting yourself in the foot by just going ahead and making some of those decisions. So normally when I look at those retirement plans, hey, take your time, digest, kind of work through some of the more pressing stuff, like, hey, my severance comp, what am I going to potentially live off of? That type of thing, uh, I think should be, you know, kind of looked at first, right?

11:59Tyler Emrick: Yeah. For so many families, the income obviously. incredibly important to discuss that what's coming in, but almost just as important is the what's going out and that healthcare part of the equation. And for some families, that may rank even higher depending on their state.

12:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's

12:14Walter: probably the number one wall, right? Hey, we talked about the plan. If you haven't got trust tested your plan, hey, you know, let's let's look at what the plan looks like. What's what's available, right? If I need to go back to work, how much do I need to earn to kind of get me to the plan results that that get me there? Right? Can I take a part-time job? Do I really need to be looking for full time? Can I maybe step away and do some consulting? Or no, hey, can I can I cut the cord, be done, and just you know, kind of be retired a little earlier than expected? So that plan, like, hey, that's that's that's the first kind of snapshot and understanding. Obviously, we talked about income coming in, very big on the priority, what's going to be coming into you from those severance and stock options and some other things that might be afforded to you. You hit the nail on the head. The third big one is going to be your health care. No doubt about it. Now, a lot of times for individuals that find themselves in this situation, you're going to be offered some type of Cobra coverage,

13:08Tyler Emrick: right?

13:09Walter: Uh, So the importance there is trying to understand like, well, when does Cobra actually start? Sometimes through these severance. packages, you know, your employer might pay a portion of your COBR recoverage for a period of time. Are they going to do that? Most individuals would be able to get Cobra for about 18 months. Some can get it longer, Walt, but but generally speaking, hey, your worst case option would be keeping Cobra, which for those of you that have never had to go on Cobra, Cobra is again just the exact same health insurance that you have through your employer. right? But instead of the employer covering some of the cost, you generally just got to float the entirety of that cost. So Cobra payments can be, can be a bit pricey, right? Uh when we get down to it. But you know, in circumstances where you've maybe already hit your deductible, you don't want to go on a new plan, maybe you've already earned quite a bit of money for the year, you know, maintaining that cover Cobra coverage for a period of time can be potentially the right choice. for sure. So you'd want to understand that, right? When does my Cobra coverage start? Is my employer going to be covering any of that? Um, do I have an option to switch between plans? Right. I have individuals that you know normally go on like a low deductible healthcare plan. They don't choose the high deductible one. But when you start looking at Cobra coverage and you look at the cost difference between a low deductible plan and a high deductible plan, there can be thousands. of dollar difference in premiums

14:29per month, you know, between just those options that are afforded to you within your employer. So the question becomes is do you have an option to say, you know what? Hey, I chose the low deductible plan, but now, you know, can I switch over to the high deductible option that would be afforded to me and kind of go through from there, right? These are some of the things as you're trying to wrap your arms around the healthcare side, you know, understanding Cobra, your options and the timing on Cobra is going to be certainly step one, right? Uh, well, as we kind of get down to the nitty-gritty. And you know, then well, is Cobra going to be the only option that's afforded to you? Can you jump on a spouse's coverage? Maybe that's very valuable. Hey, if you can't jump on a spouse's coverage, what does individual healthcare plans look like? Right. Um, and not only what do they look like, but you know, hey, maybe I can't take an individual healthcare plan now, but do I want to, once we turn the calendar year to 2027 in this scenario, maybe you would want to start fresh in 2027 under an individual healthcare plan through Obamacare and the ACA network? You might want to do that because maybe you have enough cash reserve to live off of and we can manage your income low and you can get healthcare premiums and such. in some of these cities to bring down that healthcare cost and make it much, much affordable for you and your family. So this is where a good advisor is going to start walking you through some of those

15:48options, right? Um, and when they know your situation, they're gonna be able to kind of steer you, paint that picture very clearly and help you kind of navigate. Well, do I stay on Cobra? Do I get on individual healthcare? Do I jump on my spouse's coverage? But that healthcare. normally is going to be right up their wall with one of the top priorities that you kind of got to work through and and and and go.

16:10Tyler Emrick: Yeah. And there's a lot of layers. This is like layers within layers kind of packed into this kind of discussion and conversation. Anytime we're talking about retiring earlier, and then when the suddenness of it is a piece of the equation, um, that that again just adds to the the layering of all these decisions.

16:28Walter: Correct, which is kind of like what I wanted to leave everybody with, right? Is basically

16:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just

16:32Walter: talking and through how all these things can kind of work in conjunction with each other. And these decisions should not necessarily be made in a vacuum, right? You can't necessarily choose your healthcare plan that you want to be on until we understand what your tax situation and your income situation's gonna look like. We can't really do that until we know, well, hey, are you gonna officially retire? Or are you just trying to buy yourself a little time to breathe and then you'll slowly start working for work back again? And that's the game plan. So all of these decisions work in conjunction with each other. Um, and we kind of look at them in steps. So that's why I kind of painted that picture to recap, right? Hey, can I retire? What's the plan look like? What'll be our game plan? Are we actually retiring or are we just kind of buying some time? We're gonna going to continue to look for work and we expect to be back to work within the next six months or year. Well, hey, how long can I wait to go back to work? Right. And and trying to get a framework for what the plan can support and what your timelines are going to be, then you can start to get down into some of the more granular decisions, which need to be healthcare and where your money is going to come from during that transition period, or maybe if you go into full retirement, we're going to start building out that. income plan on where that money is going to potentially come from. But Walt, it's certainly important to say, you know, all these decisions are intertwined. And, you know, kind of it's worth your time to understand or at least have

17:51someone in your corner that understands that can help navigate you through some of these decisions. Right. You know, um the goal isn't necessarily always to decide, hey, am I going gonna to be forever retired right this second? Those are big questions that don't necessarily need to get answered right here at the beginning. But it's it's really important to understand what type of financial flexibility that you have, uh, to kind of make those decisions and what timeline you're on. And then everything can kind of go down from there.

18:16Tyler Emrick: You're you're building a bridge to retirement. Um, but the way that the bridge gets built and the speed at which it needs to be built changes a lot depending on if this uh early retirement is sudden or not. And so that's where having somebody in your corner to not only plan for these things in advance, but even more so if it happens suddenly to you, uh boy, that really

18:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): pays for itself

18:38Tyler Emrick: and really helps because yeah, you've you've built the bridges before and you know how to build them quickly when the need arises to have them done that fast.

18:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): 100%. And having the team in

18:47Walter: place to, hey, if you gotta got to go and get an individual healthcare plan, well, who's gonna going shop to that for? me? How do we gonna work that? If I'm gonna be a consultant, maybe I do a small business plan. Hey, how does my retirement plans work? Where's my money gonna come from? You know, it's all intertwined.

18:59Tyler Emrick: Yeah, absolutely. Well, if you'd like to see if you're a good fit to work with the true wealth design team specifically, you can do that very easily. Link in the description of today's show. Click on that, put in your info, and you can book a time that's convenient for you. About a 20 20-minute minute discovery call. Uh you can be, of course, uh in person in Northeast Ohio or anywhere in the country and meet remotely. Um, folks work all over the country with True Wealth Design, so don't hesitate to reach out if you're somewhere else. Uh, you can also go to true wealthdesign.com and look for the Let's Talk button as well as other great resources there as well. Tyler, great episode today. Thanks for walking us through what can be a scary situation, but one that's got a lot of options, some clarity that can be found going through that process as well, and uh and how you usually take folks through that. So appreciate it. Oh

19:46Walter: yeah, no, that was fun. We'll catch you on the next one for sure.

19:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

19:48Tyler Emrick: we'll see everybody next time back here on Retire Smarter. Information provided is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment tax or

19:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): legal advice. Information is obtained from sources that are deemed to be reliable, but their accurateness and completeness cannot be guaranteed. All performance reference is historical and not an indication of future results. Benchmark indices are hypothetical and do not include any investment fees.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights