Paul Lang critiques pundits for attributing the Nov 5 sell-off to election results, arguing technicals and priced-in factors drove the move.
Summary
Paul Lang argues that financial news pundits provide detrimental after-the-fact analysis, pinning market moves to available bad news regardless of logical causality. He highlights the November 5th sell-off, criticizing Jordan Gordon Ricardi of UBS for claiming a 'democratic sweep' reduced AI spending, calling this reasoning illogical since election outcomes were known months in advance. Lang contrasts this with technical analysis, noting the sell-off began in early October, prior to the election, and cites his own October 7th letter as evidence. He explains that news hosts use vague conditional statements to avoid being wrong and create survivorship bias by only re-inviting correct guests. Lang advises treating financial news as entertainment rather than a trading tool.
Key takeaways
- 1 The S&P 500 dropped 57% from its 2007 high to its 2009 low but has rallied over 1,000% since, making the 2008 crash barely visible on long-term monthly charts.
Paul Lang · 1:26
- 2 The November 5th 'big red bar' is characterized not as the start of the sell-off, but as the 'ending move' or capitulation of the last sellers realizing no one was buying.
Paul Lang · 7:09
- 3 their personal comments will never ever directly reflect an important statement of what's happening. Let me give you an example of a comment. We have a lot in front of us, war, interest rates, and earnings. But we're in a very bullish time. And I expect the stock prices will continue to keep advancing unless one of those three things interferes. Now, with a comment like that, they're never wrong. If the market goes flying higher, they can a week or two, a month from now, whatever it is, they can look back and say, Look, we told you prices are going to go higher. You should be listening to us. And then if the market drops for any reason, even no reason, they're going to go back and say, Boy, you know, the war didn't end. And we told you that that was going to be something that could step in front of the market and cause Caused this crash. You should have been listening to us. We told you this. So they're always stated like that.
Paul Lang · 8:29
- 4 But then what happens is the guests that say the correct things in hindsight, a month later, a week later, they bring it back on and they brag about what great guests they had and how smart they were. And how if you listen to this show, you'll get these great presenters who tell you what's happening. But the ones that were totally wrong, they just don't bring back. They're not allowed back on and they never mention them again.
Paul Lang · 9:08
- 5 Lang advises listeners to treat financial news as entertainment for personal edification only, stating it is detrimental to trading because it confuses investors with after-the-fact excuses.
Paul Lang · 9:49
Episode sections
- 0:06 – 1:50
Introduction and Market Context
Paul Lang introduces podcast episode 88, directing listeners to the DTS homepage for free resources. He references a prior podcast on pundits and sets up the topic by mentioning a recent market sell-off and a meeting with free members where he analyzed long-term market charts.
- 1:50 – 3:11
Critique of Post-Hoc News Analysis
Lang argues that financial news pundits provide detrimental after-the-fact analysis, pinning market moves to any available bad news regardless of logical causality. He asserts that markets often ignore daily news cycles as these factors are typically priced in long-term.
- 3:11 – 6:09
Case Study: November 5th Sell-Off and Pundit Explanation
Lang highlights the massive sell-off on November 5th, occurring two days after the election. He criticizes a specific explanation by Jordan Gordon Ricardi of UBS, who claimed the crash was due to a 'democratic sweep' reducing AI infrastructure spending, calling this reasoning 'comical' and 'silly'.
- 6:09 – 8:09
Technical Analysis vs. News Narrative
Lang contrasts the news narrative with technical analysis, noting that the sell-off actually began in early October around October 6th-9th, prior to the election. He cites his own 'DTS Daily Market Letter' from October 7th as evidence that he identified the bearish turn before the November crash.
- 8:09 – 10:23
The Mechanics of News Show Bias
Lang explains that news hosts avoid being wrong by using vague conditional statements (e.g., 'bullish unless war/earnings/rates interfere'). They only highlight guests who were correct in hindsight, creating a deceptive impression of accuracy while ignoring incorrect predictions.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| S&P 500 | index | neutral | We had a crash in 2008 where the SP dropped 57%, over 57% from that high in 2007 Seven to the low in 2009. |
| Invesco QQQ TrustQQQ | etf | neutral | Since then, we've retraced a lot of that red bar, all the red bar, but we're in a pretty hard day. daily downtrend on the QQQ. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
The S&P 500 dropped 57% from its 2007 high to its 2009 low and has rallied over 1,000% since then.
Paul Lang ·1:26
How to verify: Check S&P 500 historical price data from Yahoo Finance or SEC filings for the 2026-2026 period and calculate the percentage change from the 2026 high to the current date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceJordan Gordon Ricardi is a UBS Senior Wealth Strategy Associate.
Paul Lang ·4:30
How to verify: Search UBS corporate website or LinkedIn for Jordan Gordon Ricardi's title and affiliation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe market sell-off began in early October, specifically around October 6th-9th.
Paul Lang ·6:09
How to verify: Check S&P 500 or QQQ daily price charts for October 2026 to identify the start of the downtrend. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Paul Lang issued a bearish midterm call in his DTS Daily Market Letter on October 7th.
Paul Lang ·6:49
How to verify: Access the archived DTS Daily Market Letter for October 7th via the Disciplined Trading Strategies website or contact the firm for verification. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The market had a 'big red bar' on November 5th, two days after the election.
Paul Lang ·3:11
How to verify: Check US election date (November 5, 2026) and S&P 500 daily performance for that date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jordan Gordon Ricardi claimed the market crashed due to a 'democratic sweep' reducing AI infrastructure spending.
Paul Lang ·4:50
How to verify: Search news archives for Jordan Gordon Ricardi interviews from November 6, 2026, regarding market commentary. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The market topped out on October 6th, barely made a new high, and then started falling.
Paul Lang ·6:29
How to verify: Check S&P 500 daily price action for October 6, 2026, to verify the local top and subsequent decline. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
News hosts use conditional statements like 'bullish unless war/earnings/rates interfere' to avoid being wrong.
Paul Lang ·8:29
How to verify: Analyze transcripts of major financial news networks (CNBC, Fox Business) for conditional phrasing in market outlooks. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe November 5th sell-off was the 'ending move' of sellers, not the start of the trend.
Paul Lang ·7:09
How to verify: Analyze trading volume and price action on November 5th compared to October 2026 to identify capitulation signals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The election was decided quite a while back, visible in betting markets.
Paul Lang ·5:10
How to verify: Check historical election betting odds from platforms like PredictIt or Betfair for the period leading up to November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the S&P 500 performance data from 2007-2009 and subsequent rallies using Yahoo Finance or S&P Global data.
- Check Jordan Gordon Ricardi's UBS research notes or public statements for the 'democratic sweep' AI spending claim.
- Review the DTS Daily Market Letter from October 7th for Lang's specific bearish call and timing.
- Analyze S&P 500 price charts from October 6-9 to confirm the technical start of the sell-off versus the November 5 event.
- Search for news transcripts from November 5-6 to identify conditional statements used by hosts (e.g., 'unless war/earnings/rates interfere').
- Evaluate survivorship bias by tracking how often incorrect financial guests are re-invited versus correct ones using media monitoring tools.
- Assess the correlation between election results and AI infrastructure spending policies using government budget proposals and corporate earnings guidance.
- Read Lang's 'DTS Daily Market Letter' archives to compare his technical calls with actual market movements.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:06
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hi
- 0:07
- Paul Lang: everyone, Paul Lang from Discipline Trading Strategies with what matters in trading and investing. My podcast series is number 88. If you've been listening to these, I hope at some point that you make it over to the DTS homepage, discipline trading strategies.com, dot com or just Google Discipline Trading and you'll get there. Because if you like the podcast, there's a lot of great videos and other
- 0:27
- Paul Lang: information there about trading and investing. And naturally, if you're serious, there are also paid services, but I would consider it to be the greatest source of free information you will find, useful free information that is, there's a lot of information on the internet, but most of it is not very helpful or just wrong. The title of this is how the pundits explain the sell sell-off. off. Now I did do a prior podcast
- 0:47
- Paul Lang: I know I don't have them in front of me something about the pundits and how they talk and why they can be kind of detrimental to you. This is just a great example. And I also want to incorporate a little bit about that sell-off and what we talked about. I actually had a little meeting with the free members at Discondrading Strategies last night. And I don't normally duplicate what I do at a meeting and turn it into a podcast, but I thought I would
- 1:07
- Paul Lang: in this case because most of you listening to podcasts are probably not at that meeting. It was not a recorded one, just a little get together talking about the market a little bit. It was called a Look at the Market. I start off just kind of showing people a chart of the move that we've had since 2009. And when you see that, it's a little breathtaking. We had a crash in 2008 where the
- 1:26
- Paul Lang: SP dropped 57%, over 57%
- 1:31
- Paul Lang: from that high in 2007 Seven to the low in 2009. But then it turned around and the rally as of today has been phenomenal. It's over a thousand percent rally going into today. The crash of 2008 is barely visible on a monthly chart of the SP. If you include that, that was one thing we talked about. So that's just a little side note here. But then I
- 1:50
- Paul Lang: got into the fact how I really detest hearing people talk about trading and the market and investing when it's all after the fact analysis. That's all you ever hear anymore, especially on news shows. And it can be very detrimental. to you. Just talking theoretically, one day the market has a bad sell-off day, and the pundits have to turn around and
- 2:10
- Paul Lang: find some reason why the market sold off. And any bit of bad news that day, they will pin it to the bad news. Oh, market sold off today as traders feared the possible raise in interest rates or whatever it is. And on some days, they really have to stretch because there's been days where the market has rallied and there's nothing but bad news, or the market has fallen and there's nothing but good news, and they really have to stretch to find
- 2:30
- Paul Lang: some excuse why it happened, but they always do. This is very detrimental to you as a person listening to the news. And by the way, you shouldn't be listening to news or any kind of information that you want to use in your investing and trading because it's all after the fact or incorrect. So what they do is always pin this on the news and it gives you the wrong impression. You start to think, oh, the market fell today.
- 2:51
- Paul Lang: because of tariffs or because of this or because of that, when in truth the market really doesn't care about that, and or to the extent it has cared, it has been built in for a long time. If you think any of these news items that you hear every day that have been around forever, and all of a sudden you think the market is reacting to that, it's silly to even think that. But we had a great example with the market sell-off that
- 3:11
- Paul Lang: happened last Thursday. So I'm doing this on November 11th. This is kind of a timely thing. but you probably will remember the November 5th red bar because it was one of the biggest red bars in the market that we've seen. And this happened, of course, two days after the election. When I did this presentation, I sent a little note around saying, hey, I don't want to overpromise. I'm not getting you all together to tell you where the high in the market's going to be for the
- 3:31
- Paul Lang: next five years or the low or whatever it is. That's not how we do things. That's not how you make money. You do it by properly finding positions around key areas, et etc. cetera. But the point I wanted to make was that the explanation for that sell-off that day was actually very comical. I was so curious what the news was going to say. I never listened to the news. So the next
- 3:51
- Paul Lang: day, the day after, I went and I Googled. I was wondering what people were saying because there was really no news at all that came out, other than the fact we had the election two days before that. We had an election, we had a day up in the market, and then we had the big crash, if you will. So when I looked it up, everybody said the same thing. I wanted to be very specific. So in this presentation, I actually
- 4:10
- Paul Lang: captured the transcript and actually the video from one of the people who was talking that day. And don't get me wrong, I'm not picking on anybody, but if you want to hear the exact quote, this is actually quoted by Jordan Gordon Ricardi, Riccardi, I think the name is. She's a USB Senior Wealth Strategy Associate. So this is a big person and was being interviewed. So just Google that if you want to see it for
- 4:30
- Paul Lang: yourself. But the key thing is what she said was that she explained Wednesday's rally reflected initial enthusiasm about divided government. Hmm. Okay. And then she said that for the next day when we crashed, but today she was doing this after the market crashed the same day. But today, investors woke up to a very sobering
- 4:50
- Paul Lang: reality. A democratic sweep means less spend on AI infrastructure. So I want you to just imagine what she's saying, that all this big money, these players with billions of dollars that are investing in the funds and in infrastructure, whatever it is, that going back a month ago, that they knew an election was coming up and they had no idea. Now, the truth of it is this
- 5:10
- Paul Lang: election was decided quite a while back, if you look at the betting markets, et cetera. And certainly this was more than a possibility that we would end up with split government. And she's saying that all this big money just sat around, they waited for the election, and then they kind of talked to each other and said, Well, gee, Democrats took over, we have split government. Yeah, I guess that's kind of good,
- 5:30
- Paul Lang: isn't it? And then she literally says the next morning they woke up to the sobering reality that hey, oh, hey, wait a minute. Maybe we won't get the AI spending that we want. through a split government. Oh, maybe this is bad. And they sold everything. I hope you appreciate the utter silliness of this. And again, please, I'm not picking on her or anybody. All the news shows said this. Everybody that was the
- 5:49
- Paul Lang: talking point of the day, so to speak. And there is no other logical news reason that you would see. So they have to pin it on something. But do you see how listening to the news can be such a terrible detrimental thing? Do you really? think that's what happened? That all these big money, smartest people in the world waited till two days after the election to decide the effect
- 6:09
- Paul Lang: of the election? No, no, no. What actually happens is this was decided a long time ago. If you look back at the charts, we actually started quite a big sell-off the beginning of October. The market broke to a new high, topped out on October 6th, barely made a new high, and then the next two days started falling. So I want to put point out the difference between understanding charts and
- 6:29
- Paul Lang: listening to news like that. I went midterm bearish on October 7th. Actually October 7th through the 9th. There's a conditional statement. And when I say that I'm just not repeating that to you after the fact, making something up. I write a newsletter. If you look at the slide notes, I put in there a couple of slide notes, I know it's one showing a chart of one one-on-one I want bearish midterm and also the exact
- 6:49
- Paul Lang: quotes from the newsletter that I do every day called the DTS Daily Market Letter. So this is all recorded, official, down on paper. Many people get this letter. Just making a point that looking at charts, I understood what was happening. And that's when the sell-off started for the election, if you will. It was back on October 6th, 7th, 8th, 9th. That's when it started. It actually culminated on the day of the big red
- 7:09
- Paul Lang: bar when we had everybody finally kind of caving in and was holding on because there wasn't some change regarding. or government that they wanted, whatever it was. So the big red bar that came on the fifth was not a realization that this is happening. It was more kind of the perhaps the ending move, at least temporarily, for the last of the sellers who realize that nobody's buying this,
- 7:29
- Paul Lang: whatever happened here today. That's what it always is. It's not the news, it's the reaction to the news, whatever happens. Since then, we've retraced a lot of that red bar, all the red bar, but we're in a pretty hard day. daily downtrend on the QQQ. So there's a lot of damage done, and things get too low, and big money's not going to keep selling. So they back off, and we have to see how this retracement is handled. This is going to be a
- 7:49
- Paul Lang: short podcast, but I just want to make this point that you always hear after the fact comments on the news, and they are detrimental to listen to because you start to think that what they said is the truth. You start to think that the news that they pinned the move to actually caused the move. And it's not. It's just the excuse that they find afterwards. The news never appears wrong because they do a
- 8:09
- Paul Lang: couple of very clever things. The actual people on the news shows, and I don't care which one you're talking about, it doesn't matter which one it is, but the actual hosts of the news shows have to be very careful because they're running a business and they want to keep people attracted because they have to keep a big audience so they can make money. They're all companies, they have to make big money, and they do a couple of very clever things. One thing is that
- 8:29
- Paul Lang: their personal comments will never ever directly reflect an important statement of what's happening. Let me give you an example of a comment. We have a lot in front of us, war, interest rates, and earnings. But we're in a very bullish time. And I expect the stock prices will continue to keep advancing unless one of those three things interferes. Now, with a comment
- 8:48
- Paul Lang: like that, they're never wrong. If the market goes flying higher, they can a week or two, a month from now, whatever it is, they can look back and say, Look, we told you prices are going to go higher. You should be listening to us. And then if the market drops for any reason, even no reason, they're going to go back and say, Boy, you know, the war didn't end. And we told you that that was going to be something that could step in front of the market and
- 9:08
- Paul Lang: cause Caused this crash. You should have been listening to us. We told you this. So they're always stated like that. Now they will have guests. on that have a more varied opinion. So they get some variety, some sparks, some battles, some fight. But then what happens is the guests that say the correct things in hindsight, a month later, a week later, they bring it back on and they brag about what great guests they had and how smart they were.
- 9:29
- Paul Lang: And how if you listen to this show, you'll get these great presenters who tell you what's happening. But the ones that were totally wrong, they just don't bring back. They're not allowed back on and they never mention them again. So you get this. deceptive view all the time that the show was always right and hear the news events that caused it. And you better learn these things. And that's why you have to keep listening to this news show. Nothing could be further
- 9:49
- Paul Lang: from the truth. It's good entertainment. I listen to the news sometimes for my own personal edification, but nothing to do with trading. It will only confuse and hurt you. I'm gonna keep this very short and make that point. There's two slide notes attached to this one if you're on. a platform that has the slide notes. And I hope you enjoyed this podcast. I hope you enjoy all these podcasts. This is number 88, and
- 10:08
- Paul Lang: this is Paul from DTS. Good trading, everybody.