Gul Usman argues process velocity, not traction, is the primary predictor of fundraising success
Summary
Gul Usman, founder of Metal, asserts that 'process velocity'—how quickly founders move investors through the pipeline—is the strongest predictor of fundraising success, surpassing traditional metrics like traction or founder background. He contrasts this with his previous experience at Airlift, where rapid expansion across geographies hindered Series C fundraising. Usman advises founders to prioritize long-term strategic positioning over short-term tactical speed and to craft ambitious narratives that appeal to VCs seeking outlier returns. He also emphasizes the critical role of warm introductions and detailed investor updates in standing out in a competitive market.
Key takeaways
- 1 I think the true strategic sort of you know angle there is like where do you see the platform in six months, right? What fundamental outcomes can the platform achieve in six months that it cannot achieve today?
Gul Usman · 32:05
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 0:51
Process Velocity as Fundraising Predictor
Gul Usman states that Metal's data analysis reveals process velocity, rather than traction, cap table, or founder background, is the number one predictor of fundraising success.
- 0:51 – 4:02
Speaker Background and Career Path
Gul Usman recounts his journey from Lahore to Denison University, then roles at Mastercard, Marqeta, and DoorDash, before dropping out of business school to found Airlift.
- 4:02 – 10:21
DoorDash Sales Experimentation
Usman describes joining DoorDash in a sales role after a rejection, where he analyzed restaurant P&Ls to propose higher commission structures, fundamentally changing DoorDash's merchant partnership model.
- 10:21 – 15:18
Airlift Origin and Lessons Learned
Usman founded Airlift to solve mass transit issues in Lahore; he notes the company raised $120M but failed to close a Series C, teaching him the value of independent strategic views over market hype.
- 15:18 – 18:36
Metal's Origin and Problem Statement
Usman explains Metal was built to solve the inefficient, word-of-mouth-heavy process of finding the right investors for specific fundraising scenarios.
- 18:36 – 24:33
Defining Product-Market Fit at Metal
Usman defines product-market fit for Metal as evidence of strangers paying for the product and providing detailed feedback, despite initial skepticism about retention in the fundraising sector.
- 24:33 – 28:31
Metal Platform Capabilities
Usman details Metal's features, including investor discovery, rationale layers, relationship intelligence, and CRM tools, noting they analyze over 5,000 startups annually as of October 2026.
- 28:31 – 31:06
Strategic Growth vs. Tactical Speed
Gul Usman contrasts his previous startup's focus on rapid growth with Metal's strategy of positioning for long-term scaling. He argues that prioritizing a 3-5 year horizon over quarterly metrics leads to better value creation and customer retention.
- 31:06 – 33:31
Urgency vs. Bias for Action
Usman distinguishes between 'bias for action' (tactical speed) and 'urgency' (strategic prioritization). He advises founders to focus on high-impact outcomes over a 6-12 month horizon rather than just deploying features quickly.
- 33:31 – 36:57
Fundraising Preparation and VC Psychology
Usman asserts that preparation is the key to fundraising success, not just traction. He explains that VCs seek outlier returns, so founders must pitch ambitious narratives rather than proving safety, as the median startup fails.
- 36:57 – 39:56
Investor Updates and Communication
The speakers discuss the importance of thoughtful investor updates. Usman notes that VCs only remember a few portfolio companies, so detailed, insightful updates are critical to standing out, whereas generic updates are ignored.
- 39:56 – 43:18
Warm Intros vs. Cold Outreach
Usman states that warm introductions are currently essential in venture fundraising, while cold emails are inefficient unless the founder has exceptional prior achievements. He recommends leveraging network data to find warm intros.
- 43:18 – 44:06
Process Velocity as Key Predictor
Metal's data analysis reveals that 'process velocity'—how quickly founders move investors through the pipeline—is the strongest predictor of fundraising success, surpassing traction, founder background, or cap table quality.
- 44:06 – 46:29
Pipeline Management Tactics
Usman advises founders to replace stalled investor conversations within days rather than waiting weeks. He suggests sending round update emails (e.g., '50% filled') to maintain momentum and prompt decisions.
Claims worth verifying
Process velocity is the number one predictor of fundraising success, ahead of traction, cap table, or founder background.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:19
How to verify: Review Metal's published data reports or whitepapers on fundraising metrics; verify against internal Metal platform analytics if accessible. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Gul Usman worked at Mastercard, Marqeta, and DoorDash before founding Airlift.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:11
How to verify: Check Gul Usman's LinkedIn profile and company press releases or employee announcements from these firms. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Airlift raised $120 million in venture financing.
Gul Usman ·2:49
How to verify: Search Crunchbase, PitchBook, or SEC Form D filings for Airlift's funding rounds. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceGul Usman dropped out of business school after four months.
Gul Usman ·2:49
How to verify: Verify via Gul Usman's LinkedIn profile or public interviews confirming his education timeline. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Tony Shu was an angel investor in Airlift.
Gul Usman ·3:25
How to verify: Check Crunchbase or PitchBook for Airlift's cap table and angel investor list. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Airlift shut down because it was unable to raise its Series C round.
Gul Usman ·12:58
How to verify: Search news archives for Airlift's closure announcement or press releases from 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Metal is backed by A16Z and Y Combinator.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:51
How to verify: Check Metal's website, press releases, or SEC Form D filings for investor information. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceMetal analyzes over 5,000 startups annually as of October 2026.
Gul Usman ·27:05
How to verify: Review Metal's public case studies, press releases, or product documentation for annual activity metrics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Over 25% of Metal's sales calls are driven by referrals.
Gul Usman ·26:45
How to verify: Request internal sales metrics from Metal or verify through public statements on growth drivers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
DoorDash's merchant commission model was fundamentally changed by Usman's experiments.
Gul Usman ·6:27
How to verify: Review DoorDash's historical press releases or investor presentations detailing their merchant partnership evolution. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Gul Usman's previous startup, Airlift, raised $120 million in venture financing before shutting down after failing to secure its Series C.
Gul Usman ·28:31
How to verify: Search for 'Airlift Pakistan funding history' and 'Airlift Series C failure' in news archives or Crunchbase. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The success rate for fundraising attempts is 7-20%, with pre-seed success rates closer to 7-10%.
Gul Usman ·35:11
How to verify: Review Metal's published research reports or industry benchmarks from sources like PitchBook or CB Insights for fundraising success rates by stage. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The median startup fails.
Gul Usman ·36:57
How to verify: Cite Y Combinator's 'Startup School' curriculum or industry studies from the Harvard Business Review on startup survival rates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Metal converts a little less than half of its customers to demo.
Gul Usman ·41:39
How to verify: Review Metal's product marketing materials or case studies detailing their conversion funnel metrics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Process velocity is the strongest predictor of fundraising success, surpassing traction and founder background.
Gul Usman ·43:58
How to verify: Access Metal's proprietary data analysis or white papers on fundraising predictors. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Gul Usman worked at Mastercard, Marqeta, and DoorDash.
Gul Usman ·28:31
How to verify: Check Gul Usman's LinkedIn profile or professional biography. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Airlift was founded in Pakistan.
Gul Usman ·28:31
How to verify: Search for 'Airlift Pakistan logistics company' in news archives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-05 through 2026-11-05. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Gul Usman's background at DoorDash, Marqeta, and Airlift via LinkedIn or Crunchbase.
- Check Metal's current valuation and funding status via PitchBook or Crunchbase.
- Review Airlift's public case studies or news articles regarding its Series C failure and operational challenges.
- Analyze Metal's product features and pricing model via their official website or G2/Capterra reviews.
- Assess the accuracy of the claim that 'process velocity' is the primary fundraising predictor by comparing it with industry reports from firms like CB Insights or PitchBook.
- Verify the statistic that Metal analyzes over 5,000 startups annually via Metal's press releases or annual reports.
- Research the current success rates for pre-seed/seed fundraising attempts using data from NVCA or S&P Global.
- Evaluate the effectiveness of warm introductions vs. cold outreach by reviewing recent VC hiring or investment trends from sources like TechCrunch or VentureBeat.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Look, we're sitting on like large pools of data. We want to understand what is the most predictable driver of fundraising success, right? And you know, we thought it would be traction and growth and you know who's on your cap table, and we thought it would be founders' prior background and experience and all of those things, right? And it turns out that it's none of those things, it's
- 0:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): something else, it's process velocity, right? The number one predictor of success. It's not your cap capital, table, it's not your traction, it's none of those things is actually uh your process velocity.
- 0:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey
- 0:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): everyone, welcome back to the Ignite podcast. Today we are delighted to have Luzman Gul on the mic. He is the founder and CEO of Metal, the AI operating system for founders raising venture rounds, backed by A16Z and YYC by Combinator. Before Metal, he built airlift in Lahore into one of Pakistan's most ambitious startups after early roles at MasterCard,
- 1:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Marquetta, Marketta and Doordash. Today he's turning six rounds of fundraising. experience into software that hundreds of founders already pay for, including many on Team Ignite. So thanks for that. Thanks for coming on, Goul.
- 1:22
- Gul Usman: Brian, excited to be here. Thanks so much for having me on the show. Uh excited to talk about business, life, and all things fundraising.
- 1:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. I'd love to start yeah this is an episode we've been wanting to do for a while. I'd love to start with your origin story. What's your background? Born
- 1:35
- Gul Usman: and raised in Lahore, Pakistan left the country for the first time. when I was 18, went to college in the middle of nowhere, Ohio, went to Denison, did my undergrad there, uh moved to New York City as my first job at MasterCards headquarters in New York, did that for about a couple of years, and then very quickly realized all the smart, ambitious people I knew were moving into tech, and I
- 1:55
- Gul Usman: jumped on that bandwagon And and started cold emailing a lot of fanners and looking for roles and in and uh you know ended up taking a job. at a company called Marquetta when it was fewer than 20 people in a warehouse in Oakland. Um and so that was my first sort of tech role. Absolutely loved it, right? Got a chance to work with some
- 2:15
- Gul Usman: incredible people and then did that for about close to two years and then moved into DoorDash, which at the time was taking off in a big way. I wanted to be, you know, more more more in sort. of the center of gravity of Silicon Valley at that time. And Doodash was an absolute transformational experience. I learned so much about leadership and culture and product
- 2:35
- Gul Usman: and building culture in a fast moving startup. Um and then did that for about two and a half years and ended up wanting to go to business school. Against Bicep everyone I knew and did that, dropped out after four months. Uh oh
- 2:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): wow. You
- 2:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): dropped out.
- 2:49
- Gul Usman: Yeah, yeah. Dropped out after four months Started my first startup in in twenty nineteen, raised a hundred and twenty million in venture financing over the next half years. Learned a lot about fundraising and some of the inefficiencies in that process. And then use that to start metal, uh, which is uh going to be my life's work over the next 10 years.
- 3:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, I love that. Yeah. And it's funny, anybody who's gone to business school would probably tell you not to go. You know, I I got my MBA and I I get all kinds of people reach out. like, Hey, should I get my MBA? I'm like, No, I think you should probably go start a startup instead. And it it's just so funny that you got that advice. You you got into the program. You're like, you
- 3:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know
- 3:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): what, I'll just drop out and do my own startup. The
- 3:25
- Gul Usman: founder C right DoorDash, Tony Shu, right? He was an angel in my first startup. And, you know, we we got a chance to work together on a bunch of things at Doordash, and he said, Look, girl, like I don't think business school is for you, right? Like, what well, you you should just go start a startup and I was like, No you went to business school and like I know all these other people that went to business school and like I'm gonna go through that experience and it's the right
- 3:45
- Gul Usman: next step. And I was, you know, stubborn and I wanted to do it, and you know, two months in I realized that I was wrong and everyone was right and it's time to move on. And so it was a great school. I went to NCR for four months. It was just incredible experience and incredible people and grade great school. I was just like where I wanted to go. That was not the path.
- 4:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. So
- 4:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you mentioned at DoorDash an internal email titled The Day We Broke Salesforce. What's what's that story?
- 4:08
- Gul Usman: It's interesting how I ended up getting a job at DoorDash, right? I applied for a PISDAF role and I got rejected. I uh first got accelerated through the process and they pushed me straight into final rounds, did a case study, uh, did the final round interview, just you know, did a really bad job uh at that final round interview. It was a case study discussion. and ended up not getting the
- 4:28
- Gul Usman: job. And, you know, I I I loved DoorDash. I I was a huge fan of the people I had met, the culture, and just the general caliber of people I'd met through my interviews. And so uh I decided to go at it again. And so I applied for another role in a different team, and I ended up getting a door to door sales role that was appropriate for fresh
- 4:47
- Gul Usman: grads. And I was, you know, three to four years into my career, right? And so I got the role, and they were like, look, you're a bit overqualified. I was like, it doesn't matter. I want to learn something new. This is actually a terrific learning experience. Like, I'm I'm game for this, right? And so I took the role. And one of the things I realized was that in the whole sales apparatus for DoorDash, it was my first time taking
- 5:07
- Gul Usman: a sales role, right? I did that for three months. In three months, I realized that the whole sales apparatus of products at Doordash Dodash, it wasn't really based built on deep insights on the PL of a restaurant, right? And we were going in and selling to restaurants, you know, an economic value proposition, right, without really knowing their PL in great detail. So I studied the PL,
- 5:27
- Gul Usman: I downloaded 10Ks of restaurant chains and understood their gross margins and net margins and everything in between, and ended up re-restructuring the economics, right? So Dodash was a culture where you could really take autonomy, you could run experiments, you could do things. And so I ran some experiments, right? Because I had that autonomy. And we started getting
- 5:47
- Gul Usman: merchants that were offering us twice the commission of what we were getting at the time. And so the question was: how is this even possible? Right. Because until then, it was always sort of a uh you know sales teammates at Dodash DoorDash butting heads with restaurant owners, right? Restaurant owners were like, are we want 10%. and the salesperson is like, I want 20%. They battled it out and they settled
- 6:07
- Gul Usman: on something, right? This was the first time where restaurants went to DoorDash and said, Hey, no, we don't want to pay 10%. We want to pay 32% in commission, right? And so everyone was like, How is this possible? And so that broke the sales scoring mechanism and the mechanism that the incentive model was built around, broke down, right? Because it was not designed to
- 6:27
- Gul Usman: manage those types of deals because we never thought we'd get those types of deals, right? You know, that email was about the day we broke Salesforce. Uh, this was from my manager at the time, who was uh who's a great manager.
- 6:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's amazing. What was the incentive that all of a sudden the restaurant owners are like, hey, I want to pay you 32% instead of negotiating between that 10 ten and 20. twenty.
- 6:46
- Gul Usman: Default approach, Brian, was we would go to restaurants and we'd be like, hey, you get some sales. You should give us a commission so we can bring you sales. That was the value proposition. You know, what we started doing with some of my experience was we, you know, uh took a restaurant, we predicted how much revenue we can bring to that restaurant by mathematically, statistically
- 7:05
- Gul Usman: modeling out our customer base in the geography of the in the radius of the restaurant, right? Our customer identity density by predicting how much business would generate
- 7:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): their category
- 7:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and things like that. Yeah.
- 7:16
- Gul Usman: Exactly. Right. How much
- 7:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): hey, how
- 7:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): how's this marginal revenue sound to you? Does that sound like would you pay me 30% if I could bring you X
- 7:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): revenue?
- 7:25
- Gul Usman: Right. And then the conversation shifted. They're like, hey, you're gonna bring us eighty thousand dollars and analyze revenue that we don't have today, right? And on the back of that you want, you know, what do you want? Well we're like, you know, the more percentage you can give us, like, you know, you're we're we can just, you know, not charge a delivery fee to customers and that's good for your business. They're like,
- 7:44
- Gul Usman: Oh, this is great. And let us run some numbers. And then they come back and say, Hey, we want to pay you thirty two percent if we can hit these benchmarks. Right. Uh and and by the way, this is how Dodash works today with restaurants. That was a foundational structure for how Dodash Doodash thought about merchant partnerships and and uh I was just lucky to be around really smart people that,
- 8:04
- Gul Usman: you know, allowed me to experiment and try out new things.
- 8:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 8:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and I think there's two really great lessons here. One in management, right? Let your people explore ideas and options and run experiments. I think that's a really great practice. And then two, I love the story of, you know, you started at the bottom at this company, right? You already had three or four years of experience, a door-to-door door to door sales job. I
- 8:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mean,
- 8:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's something they'd give like an 18-year-old. eighteen year old probably. Or maybe a yeah, like you said, a fresh college grad. But, you know, I I have a similar story. When I came to San Francisco, I took a sales job at a startup because I really wanted to work in the industry. I I wanted to work in solar. So I took started at the bottom sales job and and then just worked my way up and the rest is history. But I you have to start somewhere. What
- 8:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): was it about DoorDash? Were you just really attracted to that company and working for that company at that particular juncture in time that you were willing to start at the bottom?
- 8:52
- Gul Usman: Yeah, I think it was two things. One was, you know, this sort of internal clarity and conviction I had that, you know, uh you your career is not linear, right? Your career growth is not linear. It's uh it's actually nonlinear, right? So, you know, you you don't have to move up in financial compensation every two years. And the real barometer
- 9:12
- Gul Usman: of, you know, moving ahead is skilled. skills development, right? Are you learning new skills? And what is the pace of growth? What is the pace of your learning curve? So I think that is one. I think the other thing was just the people I met during my interviews for the first role where I got rejected, right? It's just very thoughtful interviews and a really thoughtful team and environment, right? Where they were really pressing on the
- 9:32
- Gul Usman: fundamentals, tools on things that really mattered, right? And what are the things that matter? Well, what motivates you, right? Why do you want to do this? Right? Why do you want to work twelve hours a day at a startup that has a lot of uncertainty, right? And in so I think I just really enjoyed a lot of my interviews and and you know walked away with a very high sort of view
- 9:52
- Gul Usman: of the team and the people at Doodash. And so that's what, you know, it was not about the business model or the business or the brand or or anything of that.
- 10:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
- 10:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I love the story. And I love how you you you sort of you're it's almost like being self-made in a way, right? Like you're that's like a future founder right there. You know, that story, like if if if VCs are listening, founders are listening, you know, pull that story out and if you're fundraising, right? Tell that story how you started at the bottom and how you added value up the chain and kind of moved up the ranks.
- 10:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's I think that's an amazing story. So Tell so tell us about the origin story for Airlift. This is your first company. So you're you're in business school and you're like, I got an idea.
- 10:29
- Gul Usman: When I moved to Lahore from San Francisco, one of my biggest frustrations was you know having to buy a car, right? That made no sense to me, right? Like I I never owned a car when I was in the US. I I got a car when I needed one, right? And my preferred, you know, way way of getting from one place to another was the subway or you know, hopping on a bus
- 10:49
- Gul Usman: or taking
- 10:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): away. San Francisco
- 10:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): famously doesn't have very good public transit. But yeah That's
- 10:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): very
- 10:54
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): true. That's very true.
- 10:54
- Gul Usman: New York was a lot better. But
- 10:56
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): New York's
- 10:56
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): amazing, yeah.
- 10:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 10:57
- Gul Usman: relatively a lot better, right? Uh but w uh even in SF, right, like it was all like sort of the Caltrain and in Ubers and, you know, when I got to Lahore, it was like, oh you gotta buy a car. Well why do you have to buy a car? Because there is no mass transit. As you've got an entire city, right? and there's no mass transit network, right? And I was like, how is that
- 11:17
- Gul Usman: possible? Well, there is a mass transit, but it's super limited in coverage. It's run by the government and it's enchambles, right? There's no mass transit for the middle class or or people who can pay a dollar for a ride, right? Who don't necessarily, you know, have to travel for free. Uh, and so that was a big gap. And I was like, Well, why is that? And what can we do about
- 11:37
- Gul Usman: it? And you know, the the obvious sort of uh insight that I landed on was, you know, all these cars going in the same direction at the same time, right? Like, what if you, you know, organized an efficient system that had, you know, uh large capacity vehicles uh or higher capacity vehicles uh move from point A to point B and make stops along the
- 11:57
- Gul Usman: way, and then just allowed people to book a seat on the on the on the bus, right? And then you know, I did some research, and that's exactly how mass transit works across the globe. And you know, this idea was not, you know, sort of it was not an outlandish idea by any means. This is exactly how things work in London and New York. Yeah,
- 12:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you build transit routes for it. Yeah.
- 12:19
- Gul Usman: Yeah, exactly. So so I was solving my own problem, and and that's been a patent, Brian. I this listen, is metal is my third product that I'm building, and so the first product was tech enabled mass transit. The second product was quick 30-minute grocery delivery during COVID. And then the third one, Metal, is all three of these, they share one common denominator, which is I'm solving a problem
- 12:39
- Gul Usman: that I experienced that I uh, you know, have thought a lot about and decided to solve.
- 12:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, I love that. Any other takeaways from Airlift? Like what was uh kind of the outcome there? You got g you guys raised this uh record setting series. B there and somehow you transitioned to metal, but I'd love to kind of put a bow on the the airlift story before we move on to metal.
- 12:58
- Gul Usman: Absolutely. I think there was just uh so uh in terms of where we ended up, we were unable to raise our series C round of financing and so un unfortunately had we shut down. But I think there were there were a few things we did really, really well that drove our success and enabled us to find success in a geography where you know this was this had never happened before, right? And then
- 13:18
- Gul Usman: there's some things that, you know, in with hindsight to aid my thinking, I see that we could have done differently. So the things we did well were, you know, hiring and a maniacal emphasis on hiring really, you know, high caliber people that, you know, had a very certain specific type of drive and ambition and what they wanted to
- 13:38
- Gul Usman: achieve in life. And then, you know, building your culture, you know, in a way that is similar to how you build your product, right? Very intentionally, piece by piece, right? And so we we spent a lot of time on, you know, culture and hiring and the environment we build and that paid off in space. And we also had to do
- 13:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
- 13:52
- Gul Usman: because it's very off-savy business. And in these off savvy businesses in the early stages, you really lean on culture and people to to fill the gaps, uh you know, for for systems when you're just getting started. right? Hindsight of aid my thinking, one of the things, you know, I think we could have I could have done better was just like taking a more fiercely independent view into where things are headed. You know, in the height of
- 14:12
- Gul Usman: 2021, everyone wanted to know when are you launching the next five countries and why do you have to go from one country to two to three? Why can you not go into five new countries at the same time? It's just a very different era era, the ZERP SERP era. And so it was as founder CEO, it was my responsibility ultimately to balance things out and to have an independent perspective on how we
- 14:32
- Gul Usman: thought about some of those things, right? And so I think we moved very quickly, which is great, but then we were also expanding the surface area, and we were in many ways a mile wide and an inch deep. Uh, there was too much focus, uh, too much surface area that we were trying to cover, and that was one big learning. And the other big learning was just the the value of having a fiercely
- 14:52
- Gul Usman: independent view into things. As I look back, right, like all the Q commerce companies that were doing what we were doing, they all went down when the market crashed in 2022. And all the companies that had a you know a more independent view into how they were thinking about expansion of surface area and going into new geographies and expanding and growing, they they they came out, they did really well. Right. Um And
- 15:12
- Gul Usman: so that actually thinking directly informs met metal and sort of the space we have chosen and the paths we're
- 15:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on. So
- 15:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you describe metal as the infrastructure layer you wish existed when you were raising. When did that idea click in for you?
- 15:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
- 15:25
- Gul Usman: know, moved on from airlift and I was thinking what I want to do next, right? The question for me was what are problems I experience on a daily basis that, you know, I think are like problems that make me cringe, that I think are just like really, you know, fundamental things. that need to exist but don't exist. And one of such one such thing, Brian, you know, that was top of mind for me
- 15:45
- Gul Usman: was, you know, um my own experience of fundraising. So so let's talk a little bit about that experience, right? And this is a problem. This is a problem we're super passionate about. This is the problem that thousands of founders across the globe are experiencing right now today.
- 15:57
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Tens of thousands. There's twenty 20,000 thousand new fundings every year, twenty 20 or thirty 30,000, thousand, depending on the data set. So this is a huge problem.
- 16:03
- Gul Usman: Huge problem. And you know what is that problem? Let's break it down, right? So the first problem is you are running a very specific type of company in a specific geography at a specific stage, and you want to do a very specific type of round, right? Let's say you want to do a bridge financing as a B2B SaaS
- 16:23
- Gul Usman: company that's built in New York, and you have absolutely incredible groups. growth, right? That's scenario one. Let's talk about a different scenario, right? Let's say you are a consumer company based out of Germany that's building for the European market, and you want to raise a 3ZA round. That's let's call that scenario
- 16:43
- Gul Usman: two, right? So uh the the right investors for each of those two companies are very different types of investors, right? One company is the looking for small checks, filler checks into a seed bridge or seed plus financing or a pre-A round, right? They don't want to raise a lot of capital. Um, and then the other company is raising for a lead investor
- 17:02
- Gul Usman: for Series A and Consumer in Europe, right? And so, you know, uh there's founders that are fundraising, Raising, you know, for very specific scenarios and they have absolutely no way to figure out. what are the right investors for this particular scenario that I'm in right now, right? For this particular business model, for this particular company, this
- 17:22
- Gul Usman: particular stage, this particular geography, this particular sort of spatial space that I'm occupying right now for this specific scenario, right? And there's 10,000 activities that are writing checks. And how are funders finders going about this right now? Well, they're going to people they know and they're asking ask messaging them. on iMessage or WhatsApp or email saying, hey, who do you think I
- 17:42
- Gul Usman: should speak with? Right. And then the other person says, well, don't
- 17:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): text
- 17:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): your VCs on WhatsApp, by the way. That's very annoying.
- 17:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Don't do that. Don't do it. There you
- 17:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): go.
- 17:51
- Gul Usman: Email them.
- 17:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You'll get
- 17:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): blocked. You will get blocked.
- 17:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
- 17:54
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Um
- 17:55
- Gul Usman: and so that's really the problem statement that I zoomed in on, right? And that was something I struggled a lot with. And I felt like, you know, this whole idea of like relying on word of mouth. to sort of figure out which investors to pursue was massively outdated. It felt like you know, you're in 1985, right? Uh, where salespeople used to have a register on which they used to write
- 18:15
- Gul Usman: names and phone numbers of their leads, right? Uh, it felt exactly as archaic and outdated as that, right? And so that was the problem we wanted to solve.
- 18:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No,
- 18:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I love that. So now it's it's serving hundreds of founders. You've partnered with you know Techstars, obviously A16Z's speedrun. You're actually one of the few founders I know that's actually gone through both YC and Speedrun. Tell us about that decision.
- 18:36
- Gul Usman: YC is awesome. Uh we did YC when we had no idea
- 18:43
- Gul Usman: what we wanted to do. And you know I did YC because I felt like you know after that first experience, you know, I wanted to be in a particular uh ecosystem. And and YC was that ecosystem, right? And it was a phenomenal experience, right? I was out there, you know, met some a lot of the partners, met a lot of the founders in our batch. It was absolutely an
- 19:02
- Gul Usman: incredible experience. And then we found product market fit and we were building a business.
- 19:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Wait,
- 19:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): wait, wait. Let's let's tug on that. What uh what is product produ how do you feel it as a founder when you have product market fit? How do you define it? How do you know you have it?
- 19:17
- Gul Usman: Yeah, yeah. So for us, Brian, that was really a combination of uh rapid experimentation and being very perceptive and playing, paying close attention, right? So so let me uh decompose both of those ideas. So we started YC, we didn't know what we wanted to do, we were very open about it, we're like, Look, we we don't know what we want to do. Well, I wanna want to do a startup and this is my background, and they're like, Oh, great,
- 19:37
- Gul Usman: join the program. And then we ran experiments, right? So we set up six uh websites and landing pages, and we tried to get customers for these six, right? And one of them was this idea of a fundraising operating system that provided intelligence on investors and helped founders identify the most likely investors and so on, right? And so the other five, we got some customers, but as we served
- 19:57
- Gul Usman: those customers for those businesses, we were just, I was not a fan of the business, of the customer program. profile, right? It was all over the place. These ideas were really all over the place, right? They were from emerging markets to B2B SaaS to consumer. Um, and so with Metal, what we saw was custom the customer pain, right? One, this problem was very close to my heart,
- 20:17
- Gul Usman: and I felt it and I, you know, had a lot of proximity to the problem. And because of that, I had a sharp sense of intuition on where the problem was. And B, you know, we are we put together like sort of a very quick, you know, uh platform system, you know, some filters and basic stuff like that. And then we got emails from customers that were really long saying you guys need to add
- 20:37
- Gul Usman: these twelve things. Right. Uh we got, you know, uh customers spending, you know, hours with us on call saying, Hey, these are the things you want to fix. Right. We had customers uh, you know, willing to pay real money. And then you know, we had strangers paying money for for for the product, right? And so that was sort of the
- 20:57
- Gul Usman: clear signal that, you know, we have strangers who are paying money. They're busy founders, CEOs of companies, and they're writing long emails with a lot of feedback on where the product should improve. And so that was the clear T layer's evidence of product market fit. Now, the interesting thing was that this was actually a very uh widely, you know, an idea that was, you know,
- 21:17
- Gul Usman: people would look at this and be like, Oh, this is actually a terrible idea, right? Because you've got no retention and you know, you you can't really
- 21:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): founders only raise every two years, roughly. And so that would be my objection as an investor looking at the business. And I probably asked that question when we originally met is Doc, how how do you handle the inevitable churn? But I I'm guessing you're you're measuring retention not month over month, but it's almost probably raise over raise, right? Like year
- 21:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): over year.
- 21:42
- Gul Usman: Well, we do we do measure retention on a on a on a quarterly basis. But you know, I think the key insight there, Brian, is that um for me as a founder, right, when you know my intuition was saying, Hey, I think this can actually be a really exciting business. And part of the reason why this can be really exciting business is because no one else sees uh part of the reason is like no one else sees what we're seeing, right? And so what were we
- 22:02
- Gul Usman: seeing, right? We were seeing extreme customer pain. We were seeing extremely strong product market fit. We were seeing something that every single founder across the globe, millions of founders that are fundraising, they need it, right? That's what we were seeing, right? We didn't know which way this would go over time. And we took a bet and we were like, look, we're gonna figure that out over time. And that turned out to be one of the best decisions because
- 22:22
- Gul Usman: as we went deeper and deeper into the product, we realized that it's not just fundraising, it's investor relationship. relations, right? It's dinner rooms, right? It's uh you know, meeting intelligence, right? It's like all these subproducts in and around fundraising. And then over time, we developed this vision for a compound product in and around fundraising that is now being used before
- 22:42
- Gul Usman: founders race, during the race, and after the race as well. And then my thesis here, Brian, is that if you look at the underlying process that we're bringing efficiency to. it's basically the company investor relationship lifecycle, right? How do they meet? How do they how does the company discover investors? How does it access investors? How does it use its network and you
- 23:02
- Gul Usman: know LinkedIn relationships and all of that to figure out who can induce me to which investors, right? All of that, right? And so, you know, uh, if you just map out that relationship, right, it starts off with you know, investor round prep. preparation, investor discovery, right? Uh and then you close around, right? And then you need to update your investors, and then over time you need to offer them some
- 23:22
- Gul Usman: sort of visibility to the cap table and share price through a cap table solution, right? And so fundraising, investor relations and capital management, these three things are point solutions of the same underlying process, the investor company lifecycle, right? And that lifecycle, by the way, is an ongoing thing, right? If you're if you're a capital company, maybe you start off in the
- 23:42
- Gul Usman: in the post-raise part of that life cycle, right? If you're a fundraising product, maybe you start off in the pre-raise part or the during the raise part of the life cycle, right? But that life cycle is ongoing. And it goes on from the time your company is founded to the time that you either shut down or your IPO UIPO or even after UIPO it continues, right? And so there's definitely a path here for us on
- 24:01
- Gul Usman: lifecycle retention. We've seen profound movements on retention over the years. And you know, that's something we couldn't have predicted or known on the front end when we were just getting started, right? But again, going back to airlift, right? One of the big lessons there was the value of this fiercely independent view into things. And no one had thought about this problem
- 24:21
- Gul Usman: as deeply as I had, right? And I'm really glad I followed my intuition on that. and did not end up not pursuing this because of what I was seeing and hearing from other people around
- 24:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me. So
- 24:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): how did how does it work? So there might be founders and maybe VCs for that matter listening and saying, okay, like this sounds interesting. Fundraising's hard. Like, how how does Metal help me do
- 24:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this?
- 24:46
- Gul Usman: Yeah. So uh when you first uh book a demo call with us, our sales team shows you how. the platform works and all the different subproducts within within the compound product. And and then you know, we set you up on an onboarding call. As part of the onboarding call, we teach Metal, the platform, what your company does. And as part of the onboarding, we integrate your data sources
- 25:06
- Gul Usman: and we build your user memory layer, right? And then, you know, we over the years, we built on millions of data points across many different sources of public. and off-market data. We uh have built this really powerful and rich investor memory layer. So when you come into the platform, we immediately show you what are the most likely investors that are the top five
- 25:26
- Gul Usman: percent picks for your specific company and what are the top 10% fits and what are the top twenty five percent fits, right? And then we give you a ton of intelligence and visibility into why we categorize and rank a given investor the way we do, right? Is it because of portfolio similarities? Is it because they've funded similar companies before? Is it because they are a really
- 25:46
- Gul Usman: good fit for the type of round you want to put together? Is it because they're doing a lot of work and you're supposed to be
- 25:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): able to do that? Interesting. So you have your
- 25:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): own matching algorithm internally that matches the the round and the founder and the stage sector geo to a VC, to an investor, to an angel even, and you say, okay. this the here's the match score internal. Here's the metal match score.
- 26:06
- Gul Usman: Right. Not just that, we give you visibility on the rationale for why that score is what it is, right? And we take into account everything, right? So for example, right, I was checking out metal today, and metal, for me, when I go out of fundraise, right, metal tells me that you should talk to foundation capital. Right. And so I hovered over the FitRank, right, and showed me that look,
- 26:26
- Gul Usman: your you're repeat a repeat fund. founder who's raised 120 million for his first company. And foundation capital explicitly looks for founders that have seen prior startup success. And so for that reason, this is actually a really good fit for you, what you're doing, metal and your founder background is a really good fit for foundation capital. And so I think it's the
- 26:45
- Gul Usman: reasoning layer, it's the rationale that we surface to founders that's is really interesting and powerful for. founders. And that's actually why, you know, more than twenty five percent of all you know sales con calls that we're getting are driven by referrals from founders and investors and word of mouth, right? We're speaking with more than five thousand startups a year on an
- 27:05
- Gul Usman: analyzed basis right now as of October twenty twenty six. A lot of that is driven by a lot of that traffic is driven by word of mouth in and in, you know, this is all driven by sort of a strong product experience. right? So it starts off right and you you said, you know, where does it start? It starts with investor discovery and then it moves into investor insights, right? We give you some really sharp intelligence on each venture, each firm and investor, right? And then it
- 27:25
- Gul Usman: goes into relationship intelligence, right? We integrate with your network data and we show you who you know that's raised capital from a given investor before, right? And and then, you know, I uh like customers that are using Metal, if they're connected with me on LinkedIn, right? They can see that, you know. Goal, uh, you know, when they go to Team Ignite Ventures profile, they can see that we know Goal who is from Team Ignite
- 27:45
- Gul Usman: Ventures, right? And so and then they reach out to me saying, hey, can you introduce us to Team Ignite? Right, and then I follow that along. So uh that's the sort of relationship intelligence piece. And then on top of that, there's a very sophisticated data room product, and then there's communications, and then there's an the investor CRM or a pipel pipe investor pipeline, which is integrated with your calendar and email. Then there's meeting intelligence, right? And
- 28:05
- Gul Usman: then there's investor updates and follow on intelligence on your cap table that gives you visibility to follow on inclinations and patterns of your existing investors. And and there's a lot in between that I'm not covering, but it's a full end to end product. It starts off with investor discovery and then continues beyond the fundraising process as you need to manage your investors and publish investor updates and so on.
- 28:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Amazing. So you guys have been growing. quite well. What do you think you're doing differently as a second time founder around growth?
- 28:31
- Gul Usman: Well, I think one of the things is thinking a bit differently about growth, right? So with my first startup, right, the goal was to grow as fast as possible. Right. I think with Metal, the goal is not to grow as fast as possible, right? Instead, the goal is is to to is to position yourself where you can go from two million to 10. ten million in a given
- 28:52
- Gul Usman: year. Right. That is the the the sort of what you're building toward, right? And that requires real value creation. That requires real customer engagement and retention and in really sort of having a sticky customer relationship. And then also the right monetization strategy. Right. And so uh you know I think for for Metal, you know, we we've never really
- 29:11
- Gul Usman: tried to grow like we never really tried to grow a hundred percent you know, quarter over quarter, right? That hasn't been the goal. Instead, the goal has been, hey, let's just keep growing at a really nice pace, right? Whether that's you know, 30% a quarter, whether that's 80% a quarter, that's besides the point, right? And the focus is less on how much we're growing this quarter,
- 29:31
- Gul Usman: right? That is something we care about, that is something we track, that is something we manage to win, where But that is secondary in order of priority, the bigger problem. priority is how do you position yourself to go from two million to 10 million in a given year? And then how do you position yourself to go from 10 to 30 in a given year? Right. And so I think there's a fundamentally different way of looking at growth. It's a fundamentally different way of
- 29:51
- Gul Usman: growing the company. Uh with my previous startup, it was a bit more about the next two quarters and next four-quarters. four quarters. And I think with Metal, it's a bit more about the next three years. Um in which and where we end up over a three to five year time horizon as opposed to the next two quarters or next four quarters. So if we have a big quarter, you know, we don't, you know,
- 30:11
- Gul Usman: sort of jump up in excitement. If we have a bad quarter, we grow by, you know, let's say 20% quarter. We we we care a lot less about that. We do care about that. We care a lot less about that relative to the the real value, which is like how do you position the company to really scale up. in a in a brief time period, you know, as you as you go from and so
- 30:31
- Gul Usman: as a result of that, right, like if you look at like the time it took us to go from zero to one million, you know, uh and then if you look at the time it's taking us to go from one to two million, if you look at the time it's taking us to go from two to three million, like it's a very clear and extremely compelling picture of uh and and so I think having that foresight is something that I have
- 30:51
- Gul Usman: this time around that maybe I didn't have as much of in with my first tutorial.
- 30:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, and what one thing you wrote about is um you now see the urgency as a function of a few things rather than than just a bias for action. Walk us through how kind of your your view changed there.
- 31:06
- Gul Usman: I think if if you're a successful farmer, you you have some level of bias to action, right? I think it's critical. I I I view that as a prerequisite, right? Uh if you if you want to build a startup and if you want to grow fast and those sort of things, right? I think urgency is is is a bit more complex, right? I think one of the things that you know I've learned with experience over the years is, you
- 31:26
- Gul Usman: know, there's things that are super urgent on a on a monthly time horizon, right? And then there's things that are super urgent on a quarterly or a yearly time horizon. Right. And and I think being able to distinguish the two is is really important. Right. And so with my as as a tactical example of that, right? If you're
- 31:46
- Gul Usman: building uh the platform, right, our our product, right? I look at our product not so much in terms of like what can we deploy this month? And I I you know I I I worry a lot less about that. You know, we we do encourage and support bias to action. We want to have deployments every week, you know. we ought to sometimes we do deployments every day, uh, you know, and that's
- 32:05
- Gul Usman: all great, right? But I think the true strategic sort of you know angle there is like where do you see the platform in six months, right? What fundamental outcomes can the platform achieve in six months that it cannot achieve today? Right. And and I think that's you know the sort of urgency to avoid, where, you know, um, you know, advancing the product in a
- 32:25
- Gul Usman: way that helps. you grow from two million to ten million to thirty million, you know, in a in a couple of years. Um and so so I think, you know, urgency and bias to action, these, you know, these are two fundamentally different concepts, at least in my view. You know, bias to action is like, hey, like do you move fast on things? If something needs to get done, do you do that in the next few minutes or do you, you know, mull over that for days, right?
- 32:45
- Gul Usman: Like that's bias biased through reaction. action. Absolutely critical prerequisite if you want to succeed as a founder, right? Or even as an operator, right? I think biased reaction is critical. You have to move fast on things, right? But with that said, the real strategic uh you know thing here is urgency, you know, on larger time horizons, right? And I think that is complex because it requires effective
- 33:05
- Gul Usman: prioritization, right? And it requires, you know, saying no to a do lot of things, right? It requires sort of really thinking deeply on what are the one or two real needle movers here that will really, you know, sort of move things and and change the game over a six to twelve point time horizon.
- 33:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 33:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): after running six rounds yourself and probably hundreds more, maybe thousands more through metal, what's a a common piece of ad fundraising advice that you you advise to handle differently?
- 33:31
- Gul Usman: Yeah, well, uh I think there's a bunch of things. Uh Brian, but w the the preparation goes into a round is is where the magic happens. right? Uh and a lot of you know founders, you know, even at pre-seed, even at seed, even at series A, Series B, right, like the preparation going into the round is really where the round gets gets made, right? Um and so I think this one piece
- 33:51
- Gul Usman: of advice theater piece of advice just like understanding you know the nature of venture investments, right? So VCs are not looking to invest in businesses that have a high probability of working out, right? Uh this that's is not the model. right? The model is like, look, we'll invest in 100 companies and we know 90 of them are going to be unsuccessful and it's fine. You know, what we care deeply about is the
- 34:11
- Gul Usman: potential for outlier returns. Right. And so I think, you know, having a bit of, you know, uh if you're, you know, for pre-seed, you know, founders, seed stage founders, right? I think it's more about like, you know, demonstrating that potential for outlier returns for for investors as opposed to showing why the business will work, right? And then I think for later stage founders, right, it's more like what is the most ambitious story of your
- 34:30
- Gul Usman: company that you can tell? Right. And how do you bring that forward is saying in materials and your intro blurbs and your pitch tags and all of that. A lot of times, Brian, when I get intro blurbs and pitch tags, right, for founders saying, hey, can you introduce us to investors? It's actually very rare for me to come across materials that are really world class. And when I see that, I forward immediately.
- 34:51
- Gul Usman: right? And in and the reason that's rare is because founders are viewing, not because founders are intellectually not capable of doing all those things and thinking about those things critically. I think it's because founders are looking at founders and just another process in their company. Just like you got to hire people and you got to build a product and you got to get an office space, you got to raise a round. Around And so okay, let's go and
- 35:11
- Gul Usman: raise rounds, right? I think what's different about this process is that success rate is seven to twenty percent, right? Uh of all the founders that go out who raise capital across, and I speak based on large data sets across thousands of funders and processes on the platform, right? The success rate is closer to 20%, or so you say it's closer to
- 35:29
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the city. Wow, so one only
- 35:29
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): one in five rounds on the platform actually close.
- 35:33
- Gul Usman: Correct. And that's uh actually very
- 35:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): much
- 35:34
- Gul Usman: in line with industry data. And in uh I think that percentage is about seven. percent for pre seed, right? Of all the founders that are going out to raise a pre seed round is about seven to ten percent that will actually be successful. And then seed is somewhere between, you know, the pre seed and and series of benchmarks.
- 35:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): And so that's the nature of you know venture rounds,
- 35:52
- Gul Usman: right?
- 35:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Like only it's only the top decile or the top quotile of
- 35:57
- Gul Usman: companies and founders that are that are succeeding in these in this process, right? And so given that context. your materials, your round materials,
- 36:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 36:05
- Gul Usman: your narrative,
- 36:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): it's either top quartile or it's working against you. Right. And and so so so either you come up with a
- 36:13
- Gul Usman: really incredible preparation and blurb and Pishtag and
- 36:17
- Gul Usman: it's working against you. Right. It's binary. It's black and white. Right. And so I think that's something that, you know, a lot of founders don't you know have as much perspective on. And it's partly because of media, right? You look at Tecron and you're like, oh, there's all these people that are raising rounds, right? It must be this is just a milestone. You just do this and and you raise a round, and that's the national
- 36:37
- Gul Usman: order of things. And and and then you start fundraising. And then you realize there's actually stuff here that maybe I could have better prepared, right? And then I think for uh founders that already have world-class investors on the cap table, right? I think extreme thoughtfulness in how you manage the cap table, in how you work with the cap table, you know, how you update your investors, you're right.
- 36:57
- Gul Usman: And it's not just about like these 20 bullet point updates, right? It's about like, you know, what are you doing that's different, right? The median founder is unsuccessful, right? That's one of the best things that YC CTGS teaches their portfolio, right? The median founder is going to fail, they're going to be unsuccessful. So this is actually a game. or a sport in which the median is uh
- 37:17
- Gul Usman: you know, the median player ends up not being alive, right? The median startup ends up dying, right? And so if
- 37:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're just
- 37:24
- Gul Usman: gonna, if you're just gonna follow the playbook, if you're just gonna follow what everyone else is doing, right, like you die, right? And so you've gotta think critically and creatively about all these things, like investor updates and how do you want wanna to manage your capital and you know, ultimately, you know, and you know this, Brian. like when VCs talk among themselves, they're you know, they're talking about like the two or three portfolio
- 37:44
- Gul Usman: companies that they're really excited about, right? And you're either one of those two or three companies or you're not, right? And and you know, the way VCs get to know you is through your investor updates and through your communications, right? And so it's important and valuable to not just like plug numbers in a template and hit send, sand. instead, really bring forward. you know, sort of
- 38:04
- Gul Usman: the thoughtfulness with which you're thinking about the business. So those are just some off-the-shelf, you know,
- 38:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know, and I I would say
- 38:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): anecdotally, I and I don't have data to back this up, but anecdotally, I think in my our portfolio, I would agree the
- 38:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 38:16
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): founders who tend to send the most robust, detailed updates tend to be successful. Right? You know, like you know, they lead, there's there's there's a chart here's how the revenue looks, here's, you know, all the problems in the business right now that we're working on. Here are the asks. And yeah, if you're not, if you're not uh
- 38:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): overcommunicating in a very diligent way, then you're probably just you're not running the business in a very diligent way either. So I think that I think that's really important. And then that's something that Metal does do you guys help founders button up those communications?
- 38:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 38:52
- Gul Usman: yeah, yeah. No, this is exactly right. Um, so within master upgrades, right, we've got an AI native solution that helps found so the way it works is think of you're you're a founder CEO and you're working with a world-class analyst, right? And you're like, hey, here's a data damp of all my materials, my tech, my email, whatever the data package looks like, and you drop that in. And then our AI evaluates all of that
- 39:12
- Gul Usman: and comes back to you and says, Hey, these are things the I want to understand about your. financials. These are things I want to understand about your growth. If you're growing really fast, we understand what are the reasons for that. If you're not growing that fast, what are the reasons for that? And it asks you uh all these questions to understand your business, and then boom, it just gives you your investor update. And then it also analyzes that and tells you, Hey, these are areas where you want to add a benchmark, or your update as it
- 39:32
- Gul Usman: stands right now is a seven 7.2 point two on a ten 10.0 point zero scale, and so on and so forth. Right. And so it's designed to you know, sort of make it easier for founders to punch well above their weight and really bring out the thoughtfulness of their
- 39:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
- 39:46
- Gul Usman: their thinking without spending hours on it.
- 39:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. So founders are often told warm intros are everything. Where do you think that is true? And um where do you think it's overrated?
- 39:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think
- 39:56
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it's absolutely
- 39:56
- Gul Usman: true given the topography of the venture industry today, right? Um, how that evolves. if and when that evolves, right? Like that's a different sort of philosophical discussion for another day. But you know, I think today, uh, if you can get a warm interview in masters, I think that is, you know, everything. And if you rely on like cold emails, right,
- 40:16
- Gul Usman: you're in some ways you're working against yourself. Uh, you know, it's not that so so cold emails were let's talk
- 40:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): about
- 40:22
- Gul Usman: cold emails, right? Cold emails, you know, are a really inefficient use of time. right? If you spend three hours setting out cold emails and putting together personalized cold emails or whatever, however, whatever software you use, whatever tools you use, right? Like those three hours are much better spent in terms of like digging out warm intros and making that work, right? Calling up people, figuring out who who
- 40:42
- Gul Usman: knows who, and and you know, making those intros, right? Now, there are exceptions to that, right? What are the exceptions? If you there's something out there about your company, right? Like you're you raised a hundred hundred million for your previous startup, or you sold your previous company for, you know, fifty million dollars, right? Or you, you know, have grown from zero to ten million in ARR in six months,
- 41:02
- Gul Usman: right? Something of that nature, then you know, cold emails are great and they're absolutely
- 41:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): work,
- 41:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah. They will
- 41:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be. If I see that in the
- 41:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in the subject line, we just grew from zero to five million and we're bootstrapped and now we're raising. Okay. That'll probably catch my attention.
- 41:15
- Gul Usman: Right. Exactly. Exactly. Right. And so I think in the absence of you know something that's truly outside about your company, right? I think the the the right thing to do is to go about uh you know go in through networks now. Uh the key thing there is that it seems dawning, you know, because you look, you think through all the people you know and you're like, oh, no one comes to mine. I don't I don't think I know anyone who can induce
- 41:35
- Gul Usman: me to investors. I have a very limited network, right? But the moment you know people
- 41:39
- Gul Usman: integrate their network data into Metal, they're like, oh wow, I've got all this this college roommate who I haven't spoken with in nine years, they're raised from Cosla Ventures. I didn't know that. This is great, right? And that's actually why, you know, we we uh convert uh you know, a little less than half of the customers to demo The the of product, right? Uh because, you know,
- 41:59
- Gul Usman: the the insights that we're making available to founders are really powerful. And so I think it's not the absence of a network that's more problematic for founders, it's actually not knowing who within their network can introduce them to which investors. That's a really problematic thing for founders. And so that's but I would strongly recommend, you know, working your networks, calling up people you know, uh as opposed to
- 42:19
- Gul Usman: you know, sort of trying to code email investors. Uh, I don't think there's anything fundamentally wrong with code emailing. If you're a pre-seed pre seed founder, I think it's fine. Um Uh but you know, I think the more efficient use of time is definitely uh networks, right? Go to events, meet people, you know, uh
- 42:33
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's one of the things we do for founders too is we if you're on the cap table, and you probably know this, we we have fundraising capabilities internally. One is metal, right? That's our external fundraising capability, obviously. But internally I tell founders, we're an unlimited intro machine for you. As many intros as you want for fundraising, we will give them to you. And like here's our 3,000 VCs that we know, go for
- 42:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it. And then, oh, by the way, are there any VCs that we don't know that you want to talk to? Because we can try to go it could go get intros to them as well. And it works, right? And warm intros work.
- 43:03
- Gul Usman: Right. No, absolutely. That's exactly right. And uh, you know, I think that's uh that's great.
- 43:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So your data spans lots of rounds besides the you know seven, 720% twenty percent thing we talked about earlier. Is there any other surprise? surprising things that showed up in the data?
- 43:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,
- 43:18
- Gul Usman: a lot of surprising things, right? So, you know, I'll share a couple just in the interest of time. One of the most surprising things, uh, Brian, is you know, we we we asked a question uh within the team. We said, look, we're sitting on like large pools of data. We want to understand what is the most predictable driver of fundraising success, right? And
- 43:38
- Gul Usman: you know. we thought it would be traction and growth and you know who's on your cap table, and we thought it would be founders' prior background and experience and all of those things, right? And it turns out that it's none of those things, it's something else. It's process velocity, right? And so founders that are uh the the number one pr predictor of success. It's
- 43:58
- Gul Usman: not your capital, it's not your traction, it's none of those things, it's actually uh your process. velocity, right?
- 44:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And momentum in
- 44:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the round.
- 44:06
- Gul Usman: In in the round and in
- 44:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how
- 44:07
- Gul Usman: fast are investors moving through your financing pipeline, right? There's some founders that will if they don't hear back from an investor, they'll mull that over, they'll think about it, and it stays they'll mull that over for weeks and sometimes months, right? And then there's founders that if they don't hear back from an investor in two days, they move that investor out of their pipeline and add new investors. and
- 44:27
- Gul Usman: fill up their top of the funnel and keep going, right? And they're moving at such a high velocity that they end up right like uh closing the
- 44:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): round,
- 44:35
- Gul Usman: you know, fairly quickly. And so I think that's
- 44:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a good thing. Yeah, it's kind of like if you're not
- 44:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): getting if you're not getting momentum with an investor after a few days, they're not leaning in and asking for more info or saying no or yes or hey, send me more info, like it's probably dead and just move on,
- 44:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right?
- 44:48
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Is that kind of the advice?
- 44:50
- Gul Usman: That's exactly right. Right. And in in I think, you know, if you if you want to rekindle conversation with investors, right? Like, sure, you can do that. You can publish, you know, a a meaningful update on the round or the company, you know, or whatever it might be. But you know, I I I don't know.
- 45:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And th those
- 45:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): work by the way, these little round updates. Hey, a week later, I haven't we haven't talked in a week. Hey, I just wanted to let you know we're we're fifty percent filled on the round now. So if you w if you have any questions. or any data you need, let me know to make a decision. Let me know. That's a really great email to send to anybody in the pipeline.
- 45:21
- Gul Usman: Absolutely. No questions about it. That's exactly right. Right. Um Oh,
- 45:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and by the way, we're ninety-five percent full, and I know your check size is roughly that last five percent. That's even that's even a better email.
- 45:33
- Gul Usman: Couldn't agree more. That's Exactly what right.
- 45:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Oh man, that's amazing. Anything else you want wanna to uh I know we're running short on time. Anything else you want to say about metal where to find it online? Any other last thoughts?
- 45:43
- Gul Usman: No, this sounds great. Uh no, Brian, I think that's all from from my end. I think you
- 45:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know
- 45:46
- Gul Usman: we covered some really good ground and I'm excited about the podcast. And this is actually my first one hour podcast, and I think it's great, right? Create space for asking the more foundational and philosophical questions.
- 45:56
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh mo
- 45:56
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): uh you most podcasts are doing what, twenty, 20, thirty 30 minutes, something like that?
- 45:59
- Gul Usman: Exactly. Exactly. I
- 46:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): find that too short. I used
- 46:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to do
- 46:02
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): ninety 90 minutes. because I find the conversation really gets going at about now, about 50 minutes. Yeah. 40, 40 to 50 minutes. That's where you're starting to really get into the meat of the of the content. All right. Thanks
- 46:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
- 46:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): much for coming on. Thanks
- 46:13
- Gul Usman: so much, Ryan. This was a great show. I love being here. And hopefully some of these uh ideas and narratives are useful for the founders out there. If anyone wants to reach me, please reach out. I'm and Gool go at Metal.
- 46:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, thanks so
- 46:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): much.
More from Ignite: Conversations on Startups, Venture Capital, Tech, Future, and Society
Ignite Angel: Why Most Startups Shouldn't Raise Venture Capital with Lance Cottrell | Ep310
Episode discussion: Lance Cottrell argues most startups should avoid venture capital, prioritizing survival and bootstrapping over hypergrowth.
Speakers’ claims: Lance Cottrell, founder of Anonymizer and angel investor, argues that venture capital is unnecessary for most startups and often detrimental to founder control. He emphasizes that survival is the primary metric for early-stage companies, citing his own experience of exiting with cash and zero debt after raising only $2.5 million. Cottrell advises founders to validate assumptions through rapid, low-cost experiments rather than elaborate studies, and warns that AI has eroded software development as a competitive moat. He also highlights the importance of forensic analysis on failed competitors and the limits of productive intellectual work, suggesting a cap of four hours of deep work per day.
Ignite Startups: How Cactus Is Building the AI Operating System for Trades Businesses | Ep309
Episode discussion: Cactus founders discuss building an AI operating system for trades businesses after pivoting from previous ventures.
Speakers’ claims: Co-founders Ajith Govind and Avinash Joshi of Cactus explain their pivot from a CPG AI platform and a chef marketplace to an AI operating system for trades businesses. They argue that voice AI is a commodity and the real value lies in owning the end-to-end customer experience and replacing fragmented legacy software. The founders detail their decision to avoid integration with incumbents like ServiceTitan to maintain platform independence. They target the mid-market segment, citing significant revenue loss from missed calls as a key pain point. Finally, they emphasize the necessity of a human enablement layer for adoption and focus on revenue retention over vanity metrics.