Isabelle Ramdoo argues mining sustainability requires site-specific due diligence and robust institutional capacity over generic ESG scores.
Summary
Isabelle Ramdoo defines sustainable mining not as zero impact, but as the management of acceptable impacts and positive post-closure legacies. She advises investors to shift from portfolio-level management to asset-level due diligence, focusing on site-specific risks like water scarcity and indigenous rights. Ramdoo emphasizes that credible regulation requires functional institutions with adequate resources, warning against confusing regulatory efficiency with deregulation. She critiques current ESG reporting for being input-heavy rather than outcome-focused, noting that 68% of metrics focus on policies rather than actual results. Finally, she warns that the race for critical minerals risks bypassing safeguards, urging that strategic attention should build better governance rather than just accelerate extraction.
Episode sections
- 0:57 – 4:52
Defining Sustainable Mining
Ramdoo argues that sustainability in mining cannot mean zero impact, but rather the management of acceptable impacts, remediation, and durable benefit sharing. She notes that while mines are finite, they can contribute to sustainable development if the post-mining legacy is positive.
- 4:52 – 9:24
Investor Principles for Sustainable Outcomes
Ramdoo advises investors to shift from portfolio-level management to asset-level due diligence, focusing on site-specific risks like water scarcity and indigenous rights. She emphasizes using leverage before financial close to ensure financial models include full lifecycle costs for rehabilitation and closure.
- 9:24 – 17:42
Regulatory Frameworks and Institutional Capacity
The speaker outlines that credible regulation requires strategic planning, functional institutions with adequate resources (e.g., hydrologists, inspection budgets), and enforceable permit conditions. She warns against confusing regulatory efficiency with deregulation.
- 17:42 – 23:48
Social Sustainability Dimensions
Ramdoo defines social sustainability through four dimensions: rights (including Free, Prior, and Informed Consent), distribution (local benefit sharing), representation/accountability (effective grievance mechanisms), and resilience (community programs that survive mine closure).
- 23:48 – 32:58
ESG Reporting Critique and Critical Minerals
The discussion highlights that while ESG reporting creates a common language, it is often input-heavy (68% of metrics) rather than outcome-focused. Ramdoo warns that the race for critical minerals risks bypassing safeguards, urging that strategic attention should build better governance rather than just accelerate extraction.
Claims worth verifying
Sustainability in mining is no longer treated merely as corporate social responsibility but sits at the intersection of climate policy, industrial strategy, national security, and human rights.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Review industry reports from the Intergovernmental Forum of Mining, Minerals and Metals and Sustainable Development or major mining associations published between 2016 and 2026 for shifts in terminology and strategic focus.
Investors have the greatest leverage before financial close, during project design and capital budget allocation.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Analyze mining finance case studies or project finance agreements to identify negotiation points for environmental and social clauses prior to loan disbursement.
A credible regulatory regime requires institutions to have specific capacity, such as hydrologists in environmental agencies and travel budgets for inspectorates.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Compare mining codes with the operational budgets and staffing reports of relevant government environmental and mining regulatory agencies in specific jurisdictions.
Strategic Environmental Assessments (SEA) ask what kind of mining development is appropriate for a region, whereas project-level assessments ask how to manage a specific mine.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Review definitions and guidelines for SEA versus Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) from bodies like the World Bank or national environmental protection agencies.
Free, Prior, and Informed Consent (FPIC) is a terminology and framework mainly relevant in the context of Latin American countries.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Check legal frameworks and indigenous rights legislation in Latin American countries (e.g., Brazil, Peru, Colombia) versus other global regions to verify the prevalence of FPIC terminology.
An OECD report mapped 2,000 metrics used across eight major ESG rating products.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Search for OECD publications on ESG metrics or corporate sustainability reporting that cite the number of distinct metrics used by major rating agencies.
68% of ESG metrics rely on input-based data points (e.g., existence of a policy), while only one-third capture outcomes.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Locate the specific OECD report or study cited by the speaker that provides this statistical breakdown of input vs. outcome metrics in ESG ratings.
ESG ratings diverge because they serve different objectives, such as assessing financial risk to investors versus assessing impact on society and environment.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Compare methodology documents from different ESG rating agencies (e.g., MSCI, Sustainalytics, Bloomberg) to identify differences in their weighting of financial materiality vs. impact materiality.
Do your own research
- Verify the 68% statistic regarding input-heavy ESG metrics by reviewing the specific ESG reporting frameworks or studies cited by Ramdoo.
- Check if specific mining projects discussed have undergone Strategic Environmental Assessments (SEA) prior to permitting.
- Review the institutional capacity of regulatory bodies in key mining jurisdictions, specifically looking for staffing levels of hydrologists and inspection budgets.
- Assess whether financial models for target mining companies include full lifecycle costs for rehabilitation and closure, particularly regarding water management.
- Investigate site-specific risks for potential investments, focusing on local water scarcity data and indigenous rights compliance rather than relying solely on corporate ESG scores.
- Look for evidence of effective grievance mechanisms and benefit-sharing agreements at specific mine sites, rather than relying on national-level social impact data.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:01
- Unidentified speaker: Welcome once again to the Shilab Khama Extractive Podcast.
- 0:04
- Unidentified speaker: This time I'm hosting Isabel Ramdu again.
- 0:07
- Unidentified speaker: Isabella is both a friend and uh the director at the Intergovernmental Forum of Mining, Minerals and Metals and Sustainable Development.
- 0:17
- Unidentified speaker: Isabel leads work across all aspects of the mineral project cycle, value chain, and all sorts of mining, including large-scale mining and artisan small-scale mining.
- 0:28
- Unidentified speaker: Isabelle is an economist by training with over 20 years of experience in trade, negotiations, industry policy, among others.
- 0:36
- Unidentified speaker: Isabel, welcome again to the Sheila Kama Extractive Podcast.
- 0:40
- Unidentified speaker: Thank you, Sheila, and thank you for having me again.
- 0:43
- Unidentified speaker: It's always a pleasure.
- 0:44
- Unidentified speaker: All right, I wanted you to wear your policy analyst's hat as it relates to this concept of sustainability.
- 0:52
- Unidentified speaker: First, what do we mean by sustainable mining?
- 0:57
- Unidentified speaker: And given that mineral resources are finite, can we credibly speak of sustainable mining?
- 1:10
- Unidentified speaker: So when we speak about sustainability, I think it's very important to begin with honesty.
- 1:16
- Unidentified speaker: As you see, you know, there is a paradox in this conversation.
- 1:20
- Unidentified speaker: Mining changes landscape, consumes water and energy, produces waste, extracts the finite resource.
- 1:28
- Unidentified speaker: So sustainability cannot mean pretending that mining has no impact.
- 1:33
- Unidentified speaker: I think it means deciding which impacts are acceptable, which must be avoided, and how the remaining impacts are reduced and remedied, and whether the development benefits are durable and fairly shared.
- 1:48
- Unidentified speaker: I must also say that that debate has changed over the last couple of years.
- 1:53
- Unidentified speaker: If we look at about 10 years ago, sustainability was often treated as a corporate social responsibility issue.
- 2:00
- Unidentified speaker: But today, with the discussions around climate change, around industrial development, et cetera, that it sits at that intersection of climate policy, industrial strategy, even national security, with human rights, access to finance, et cetera, still being at the core of it.
- 2:18
- Unidentified speaker: And I would say this is progress because sustainability is not no longer a peripheral issue to the conversation.
- 2:26
- Unidentified speaker: And it is more and more core to the conversation about mining.
- 2:31
- Unidentified speaker: And that also creates a challenge because under pressure to secure critical minerals quickly, we may confuse disclosure with performance or good governance.
- 2:40
- Unidentified speaker: So this means that sustainability to me is not a green card or a label that we give to a commodity or to a sector.
- 2:50
- Unidentified speaker: It is the quality of decisions, institutions, relations across the whole life cycle of the mine, all the way from exploration to closure, and it requires shared responsibility, companies and investors, host government, consuming countries, all of them have a distinct role to play.
- 3:08
- Unidentified speaker: Now, to answer your question, a mine is finite and cannot operate forever, and we know this.
- 3:14
- Unidentified speaker: And I would distinguish between a sustainable mine and mining that contributes to sustainable development.
- 3:21
- Unidentified speaker: So that's the paradox.
- 3:23
- Unidentified speaker: And as we know, a mine exhausts our body and it is not renewable in a way that, for example, a well-managed forest can be.
- 3:32
- Unidentified speaker: This is a legitimate paradox in the question.
- 3:35
- Unidentified speaker: But the depletion of one form of natural capital does not automatically make development pathway unsustainable.
- 3:43
- Unidentified speaker: So the key question is what is left behind?
- 3:47
- Unidentified speaker: What does the project left behind it leaves behind once the mine leaves, uh, or even when the project advances?
- 3:55
- Unidentified speaker: So if a country removes mineral wealth and it is left with polluted water, fiscal liabilities, distrust, this is clearly unsustainable.
- 4:07
- Unidentified speaker: That's interesting.
- 4:08
- Unidentified speaker: So what you're saying is that there's really two aspects.
- 4:11
- Unidentified speaker: There's the aspect of the resource itself, uh, and the fact that it will be depleted.
- 4:19
- Unidentified speaker: And then there's the aspect of how we manage mining or projects, how we mitigate the risk on other resources and how it contributes to uh, say, national development.
- 4:36
- Unidentified speaker: And that looked at that way, on one level, it contributes towards sustainability, but on another, it does deplete resources.
- 4:45
- Unidentified speaker: So you also spoke about investors and governments.
- 4:49
- Unidentified speaker: Let's start perhaps with uh investors then.
- 4:52
- Unidentified speaker: So to achieve this positive outcome or to mitigate severe and irreversible um impacts where we can, what are some of the principles then that should guide the strategies and activities of uh investors in pursuing sustainable development outcomes?
- 5:21
- Unidentified speaker: So, a direct short answer to your question is that investors must move from sometimes what we call portfolio management, which is managing uh you know, the entire portfolio of a company, towards something that's more asset-level, due diligence.
- 5:38
- Unidentified speaker: Uh, look at the price throughout the full life cycle of responsible mining, use binding agreements between two parties, and look at um stewardship, active stewardship to change behavior and maintain the different levels of impacts to be remedied.
- 5:55
- Unidentified speaker: And let me unpack that.
- 5:57
- Unidentified speaker: I think while it is the role of government to set the rules, investors are have a really important role to play.
- 6:04
- Unidentified speaker: I don't think they are passive observers in this whole landscape.
- 6:07
- Unidentified speaker: They often have the greatest leverage actually before financial close, when projects are being designed, uh, when they are thinking about allocating capital budgets, when they are looking at risk allocation, and while these are still being negotiated.
- 6:23
- Unidentified speaker: I would say the first operational principle is therefore to ask mining companies not only whether the project can repay the capital, but under what environmental, social, fiscal, and governance conditions they will do so.
- 6:38
- Unidentified speaker: I think the second important uh element is that the due diligence that I was mentioning earlier must be risk-based and site-specific.
- 6:48
- Unidentified speaker: This is very important because sometimes we've seen that corporate ESG scores can be very generous and general, but they're not enough because two mines owned by one company can have very different exposures to water scarcity, to tailings management, to indigenous rights.
- 7:08
- Unidentified speaker: And therefore, investors must look at these uh assets, the jurisdictions, the operators' track record, the quality of environment and social assessment, and the state's capacity to monitor the project.
- 7:21
- Unidentified speaker: Looking at it from a site uh specific aspect is actually where the leverage is.
- 7:28
- Unidentified speaker: The third element, which is, I would say, uh higher level to those two that I mentioned, is that the mitigation hierarchy must be monitored and implemented because it is real.
- 7:38
- Unidentified speaker: So, first avoid, then minimize, then restore and remedy.
- 7:42
- Unidentified speaker: I think finance should not be available for a project just because the impacts have been well described in reports.
- 7:50
- Unidentified speaker: Some locations or practices may create an acceptable risk where a project can proceed.
- 7:57
- Unidentified speaker: The financial model must include this cost of uh, you know, make sure that the cost of water management, of progressive rehabilitation, of workers' safety, of community engagement and closure is well taken care of.
- 8:12
- Unidentified speaker: Because if those costs make the project uneconomic, then the project was not economically sound to start with.
- 8:19
- Unidentified speaker: And apparently return was being achieved probably by transferring these liabilities to communities or taxpayers.
- 8:26
- Unidentified speaker: Right.
- 8:27
- Unidentified speaker: So that's interesting.
- 8:30
- Unidentified speaker: Uh, because on the one hand, you are recognizing that uh the private sector has leverage, but you also acknowledge that uh they sit somewhere between those who finance them and then those who regulate them in government, and that it is this ecosystem uh that is necessary to ensure sustainable outcomes.
- 8:54
- Unidentified speaker: So let me turn then to the regulators because you you rightly said if we the governments choose to license based purely on bankability, but not looking into the future and saying what is in the horizon, what capacity, what policies, what commitments must we from the get-go secure to ensure remediation at mine closure?
- 9:24
- Unidentified speaker: Then they have performed some optically as regulators and as custodians of the environment.
- 9:31
- Unidentified speaker: So, based on that, then what must regulators do to achieve that threshold that you're aiming for?
- 9:40
- Unidentified speaker: What is it in the current dispensation that is lacking, which, if it were included as part of the regulatory framework, we would ensure those sustainable outcomes?
- 9:53
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, that's a really good question.
- 9:54
- Unidentified speaker: It's the next level, I think, um, of um pieces in the puzzle of sustainability that is really important.
- 10:02
- Unidentified speaker: And I would say there's no uh single global sustainability threshold.
- 10:07
- Unidentified speaker: I think a credible regime must combine very clear rules, must combine strategic planning, um, functional institutions or existing institutions to start with, and then uh institutions that work, transparent decisions, and then um enforceable uh permit conditions, monitoring, etc.
- 10:29
- Unidentified speaker: So it's a whole it's a whole ecosystem, right from um the moment the government decides to give a permit all to the end.
- 10:37
- Unidentified speaker: And I would also be cautious with the word threshold because I think as I was mentioning earlier, sustainability is a context-specific issue.
- 10:46
- Unidentified speaker: For example, water threshold in a dry, arid uh basin will differ very much from a humid one.
- 10:53
- Unidentified speaker: Social risk around indigenous territories will differ from those around, you know, uh more I would say industrial areas.
- 11:01
- Unidentified speaker: Um, but to be clear, context-specific doesn't mean that it has to be optional.
- 11:06
- Unidentified speaker: I think we need a very credible regulatory system that has minimum elements that must clearly be outlined.
- 11:12
- Unidentified speaker: I think that's kind of the core of the question.
- 11:15
- Unidentified speaker: And uh the couple of things here.
- 11:17
- Unidentified speaker: First, I think governments need to have very clear strategic decisions even before they make project decisions.
- 11:26
- Unidentified speaker: What I mean by this is that a project level and environmental social impact assessment, for example, will ask how do we manage this mine?
- 11:36
- Unidentified speaker: But a strategic environmental assessment will ask an earlier question.
- 11:41
- Unidentified speaker: It will ask what kind of mining development is appropriate for this particular region, considering things like cumulative pressure on water, biodiversity, infrastructure, settlement, and economic benefits.
- 11:55
- Unidentified speaker: And I think that aspect of having this distinction between what is strategic and what actually is at post-decision making is key for a regulator.
- 12:07
- Unidentified speaker: The element I would look at is uh which seems obvious, but actually is also to mention, is that institutions must be able to implement the law.
- 12:16
- Unidentified speaker: It looks very obvious, but not always that a sophisticated mining code um will have associated with that agencies that have the necessary uh, you know, people, et cetera.
- 12:29
- Unidentified speaker: So if you have a sophisticated mining code, but you don't have, for example, your environmental agency doesn't have hydrologists, your mining inspectorates do not have travel budget to go and inspect.
- 12:40
- Unidentified speaker: Your local authorities cannot access data.
- 12:43
- Unidentified speaker: I think that will impact on the implementability of the law.
- 12:48
- Unidentified speaker: And that's a clear rule for regulators to make sure that they have adequate human resources and the financial capacity so that um you know regulate regulations are implemented.
- 12:59
- Unidentified speaker: And um, this point is important.
- 13:02
- Unidentified speaker: Um, the benefit of a clear and capable regime is often underestimated because when institutions have capacity, then communities will gain a predictable route to information and remedy.
- 13:15
- Unidentified speaker: Responsible companies will gain greater certainty, governments can distinguish what is credible and what is speculative in terms of projects, and in FINE, good regulations can therefore improve that investment quality and reduce conflict in the longer term.
- 13:30
- Unidentified speaker: It can also shorten timelines.
- 13:32
- Unidentified speaker: I think having good regulations, people think that regulate regulations can uh hold back or be bureaucratic or overburdened.
- 13:42
- Unidentified speaker: Um, but sometimes it can shorten timelines because you save time when you know what your what is expected from you.
- 13:50
- Unidentified speaker: And there is obviously uh some risk of over-regulation, over regulatory overload, uh, if standards are not tailor-made to the jurisdictions they are serving.
- 14:03
- Unidentified speaker: Um, because sometimes, you know, if you have too many of those uh uh standards that are just copied from elsewhere without being harmonized, then you know different agencies will require the same information.
- 14:16
- Unidentified speaker: Um small mines might face um architectures that are not fit for them and therefore favor uh larger mines and then impact on the ability of smaller projects to go ahead.
- 14:27
- Unidentified speaker: And then complexity will favor um the larger operations and not necessarily the small local ones.
- 14:34
- Unidentified speaker: And the answer is not necessarily is not weaker standards.
- 14:37
- Unidentified speaker: The answer is having risk-based regulation that are proportional, that share the data, and that are clear.
- 14:45
- Unidentified speaker: And I would say maybe another uh key aspect here that I kind of mentioned earlier is that permit should be a living management instrument.
- 14:54
- Unidentified speaker: So uh once a license is given, it doesn't stop here.
- 14:57
- Unidentified speaker: It has to be measurable, uh, you know, it needs to live with a project, uh, needs measurable conditions, public reporting, ability to uh inspect over the life of the mine, monitor the information so that when it's needed, it can be changed.
- 15:13
- Unidentified speaker: Um and I would say maybe uh, you know, down in the life cycle of the mine, when you think about closure, that's another very important area because otherwise you you, when mine closes, if you don't have proper plan and regulated closure from the beginning, governments will have to deal with a legacy.
- 15:34
- Unidentified speaker: To build on that one, I would say regulation has also to cover governance and distribution, not just management of uh and environmental management and social management, but also how this gets distributed so that you know people are comfortable with whatever um uh comes out of the mine, beneficial ownership, license allocation, production revenues, subnational transfers actually matter because this is what translates into longer-term and um longer-term benefit sharing.
- 16:08
- Unidentified speaker: Um yeah, maybe I would the last point I would say is that um, you know, there's a lot of discussion these days around improving regulatory efficiency with critical minerals and accelerated production.
- 16:19
- Unidentified speaker: But here again, uh regulatory efficiency, uh we have to be careful with this because it shouldn't be confused with uh deregulation.
- 16:28
- Unidentified speaker: Good reforms need to remove duplication, clarify sequencing, but uh should not compromise on uh what the government has to do to make sure that what is non-negotiable remains non-negotiable.
- 16:44
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
- 16:44
- Unidentified speaker: So listening to you, what is coming across is uh one the multiplicity of issues, two the importance of not only harmonizing them, but be clear about the sequencing, but also uh not making excellence the enemy of good, but instead being clear about what matters, uh what needs to be done to achieve uh the desired outcomes.
- 17:24
- Unidentified speaker: And one of the most important outcomes, of course, at the risk of stage in the obvious, is uh impact on the environment, uh both the physical but the societal environment.
- 17:42
- Unidentified speaker: So when you look at sustainability then through this environmental uh lens, uh how do you see that?
- 17:53
- Unidentified speaker: You know, uh how should we perceive this?
- 17:57
- Unidentified speaker: How should we address this?
- 18:00
- Unidentified speaker: So social or sustainability means uh I would say for communities and and and and uh the environment.
- 18:10
- Unidentified speaker: I think this is this is very important.
- 18:12
- Unidentified speaker: I will call it social sustainability.
- 18:14
- Unidentified speaker: So what it means, it means rights, it means voices, it means fair distribution, it means remedy and resilience so that um communities can influence decisions that affect them, receive a fair share of benefits, and avoid disproportionate harm to retain viable value for the future of the closure of mines.
- 18:37
- Unidentified speaker: So for me, when I hear that, that uh, you know, the the the whole um, if you want, the whole package of social environment, in practice, that means people's land, it means water, it means health, it means safety, it means um, you know, livelihoods, it means cultural identity, it means a whole lot of things that make the soft um side of what makes society function.
- 19:04
- Unidentified speaker: You know, in the there is this famous saying of we talk about ESG, environmental social and governance.
- 19:11
- Unidentified speaker: There is this um interesting analogy that says, environment, we are very clear what it means.
- 19:17
- Unidentified speaker: Governance, we know what it means, but social is the mid like a middle child.
- 19:21
- Unidentified speaker: So it's everything that is left out of environment and governance.
- 19:25
- Unidentified speaker: So to go back to that, I would say that that's kind of what the whole spectrum of issues that we're looking at.
- 19:32
- Unidentified speaker: And that um I would organize the elements that are needed for sustainability for communities and social environment around four dimensions.
- 19:43
- Unidentified speaker: The first one is rights.
- 19:45
- Unidentified speaker: So communities um we have to make sure that they have access to information, to meaningful participation, respect for the land, labor, and human rights.
- 19:54
- Unidentified speaker: Um, that's uh indigenous uh free uh people have free prior informed concept.
- 20:01
- Unidentified speaker: It's a terminology that it's not uh applied worldwide.
- 20:05
- Unidentified speaker: That's mainly um something that is relevant in the context of Latin American countries.
- 20:11
- Unidentified speaker: But it's interesting because it provides us with a framework guided by international standards, by the way, that looks at um what kind of decision-making process people have to be free to um to to uh you know uh give their opinion.
- 20:29
- Unidentified speaker: They need to be consulted even before the project starts, and they need to give the content.
- 20:34
- Unidentified speaker: So that kind of um uh whole of communities approach uh is an important aspect of making sure that people are comfortable when projects are coming their way.
- 20:48
- Unidentified speaker: The second dimension is distribution.
- 20:50
- Unidentified speaker: National revenue or aggregate employment is generally not enough if people closest to the mine and who bear the most impact do not see the the direct benefits to them.
- 21:05
- Unidentified speaker: So we need to ask the real questions about at the local level, closer to the mine, who gets the job?
- 21:12
- Unidentified speaker: Do they have the skills, all the skills required to get those jobs?
- 21:16
- Unidentified speaker: Who wins the procurement contracts if procurement contracts are available?
- 21:21
- Unidentified speaker: Who stands to lose uh access to land, water, and whether, you know, young people, indigenous peoples, women, migrants, um, you know, how do they experience the project?
- 21:33
- Unidentified speaker: And I'm sure this is very different than if you ask the question to somebody who is miles away from the project.
- 21:40
- Unidentified speaker: And that's something that governments have to make sure they they take into account, even if they are the custodian of national wealth.
- 21:50
- Unidentified speaker: Uh, the people who are sitting closer to the mine, we need to make sure that this disaggregated information and data is available to them because averages generally hide a lot of inequality.
- 22:03
- Unidentified speaker: And the third dimension is I would call it representation and accountability because very often local communities are not a homogeneous group.
- 22:13
- Unidentified speaker: They're sometimes not very organized.
- 22:15
- Unidentified speaker: Um, you know, there's no uh syndicate like workers for workers.
- 22:20
- Unidentified speaker: They may not have information that the mind puts that there that are in a language that they understand.
- 22:27
- Unidentified speaker: Um, they may not sometimes be able to read those information.
- 22:32
- Unidentified speaker: And very often, uh, people who say that they're representative of communities are probably not really representative of everyone.
- 22:41
- Unidentified speaker: It's generally the ones that have the loudest and most powerful voices that are heard.
- 22:46
- Unidentified speaker: And um that means that the communities sometimes don't have access to grievance mechanisms and to effective remedies when harm occurs.
- 22:54
- Unidentified speaker: And that's where sometimes the whole project you might have the nicest paper on sustainability or the nicest policy on sustainability, so sorry, on social um uh sustainability, but then if that doesn't uh represent the right people, then you have an issue down the line.
- 23:10
- Unidentified speaker: And the fourth dimension is resilience.
- 23:12
- Unidentified speaker: I would just um mention that one where community programs should not be just a collection of donors or public planning, uh they should actually really be negotiated and reflect the real needs of communities because very often you have those box-ticking or you know, donor-driven programs that doesn't survive the the life of the mind.
- 23:35
- Unidentified speaker: Right.
- 23:36
- Unidentified speaker: So um it's uh again, it seems to me that uh it leans very uh much on the uh ESG uh element.
- 23:48
- Unidentified speaker: And so as a last question, if one looks at ESG reporting, and for that matter, uh the demand for critical minerals and the increase in that demand, what are we seeing?
- 24:05
- Unidentified speaker: Does this auger well for sustainable development outcomes from mining?
- 24:13
- Unidentified speaker: Or are these simply, if you wish, um events that will come and go?
- 24:22
- Unidentified speaker: So uh this is a very interesting question because the ESG conversation is not now we call it ESG, but I think it has evolved and changed over years from social responsibility to um many different names, and now we're using ESG.
- 24:41
- Unidentified speaker: Uh, the whole idea is you know whether these sustainability are supporting the end goal, the outcomes, or are they adding more complexity?
- 24:51
- Unidentified speaker: And I think it's both because um to the to the upside of things, to the positive side of things, I must say that reporting at least has created a common language, it has brought sustainability into governance, and it has exposed risks, which we actually see much uh much, much clearer because these things are in the public domain.
- 25:12
- Unidentified speaker: But at the same time, we have a proliferation, and we've seen it over the last couple of years, of different types of metrics, different types of uh standards, et cetera, that doesn't necessarily uh address the same issue.
- 25:27
- Unidentified speaker: They are input heavy, they are uh very heavy, including for corporates, and then but doesn't necessarily reward projects.
- 25:37
- Unidentified speaker: So I just want to kind of maybe get a little bit deeper into that.
- 25:40
- Unidentified speaker: ESG reporting, I think, has been necessary, but I'm not sure it is sufficient to address the entire sustainability conversation.
- 25:49
- Unidentified speaker: But then I will mention later on, you know, some of the um issues that we might want to balance off because over-regulation kills regulation.
- 25:57
- Unidentified speaker: So on the reporting part, I think it's fair to say, as I was mentioning earlier, we do now have more information available in the public domain on issues such as taxation, governance, human rights, emission, you name it.
- 26:12
- Unidentified speaker: Uh it has made boards and investors more aware and made them ask the right questions on issues that potentially were previously marginalized.
- 26:22
- Unidentified speaker: And it also gave regulators, communities, and markets a basis for comparison.
- 26:27
- Unidentified speaker: I think on that one, we should not dismiss that progress that uh you know, reporting has come.
- 26:32
- Unidentified speaker: And the reporting architecture is also now uh much more mature.
- 26:37
- Unidentified speaker: We have a lot of standards out there, just to mention a few of them: things like International Sustainability Standards Board, Global Reporting Initiatives, uh, EITI, even Europe has its own standards, and then you have a proliferation of voluntary and other um uh more contractual uh binding um standards that uh operators have to adhere to just to be able to make sure they have access to funding.
- 27:04
- Unidentified speaker: So the landscape is getting also very, very crowded.
- 27:08
- Unidentified speaker: And what is more for me on the side of it's not the question of having uh reporting standard, it's the proliferation and what uh do they serve as an objective.
- 27:19
- Unidentified speaker: Very often they serve different users, which is one uh reason why there will not be uniformity.
- 27:25
- Unidentified speaker: I think uh you know we we cannot expect that one day there will be one standard, but it also makes it sometimes very costly.
- 27:32
- Unidentified speaker: And that complexity is real.
- 27:34
- Unidentified speaker: I think if we look at one of the uh uh reports that I was reading recently, EOECD, they did a mapping and they saw that there are no less than 2,000 metrics that are used across eight major uh ESG rating products, which is huge.
- 27:51
- Unidentified speaker: If you make the calculation, you see how many of those metrics.
- 27:54
- Unidentified speaker: And out of that, 68% rely on input-based data points, um, which is things like does the company have a policy?
- 28:04
- Unidentified speaker: Do they have a committee?
- 28:05
- Unidentified speaker: Do they give training?
- 28:07
- Unidentified speaker: And only one-third capture outcomes, which is, you know, the things that people are looking at.
- 28:12
- Unidentified speaker: Does that improve my life, right?
- 28:15
- Unidentified speaker: And the first set of 68%, two-thirds of these data points, I would call them more box-ticking risk uh assessments, whereas only a third are looking at the right issues.
- 28:28
- Unidentified speaker: And this is where sometimes we see the disproportionate um, you know, uh balance between what those metrics are supposed to cover.
- 28:37
- Unidentified speaker: And I think, you know, uh just to say that um, you know, accountability and comparability, as I was saying earlier, the ref these reports reveal those trends.
- 28:46
- Unidentified speaker: They've expose a lot of important challenges that may not have otherwise been there.
- 28:51
- Unidentified speaker: And then on the on the more um negative side, not negative side, but challenging side of things, it is becoming an industry of its own.
- 28:58
- Unidentified speaker: And we've seen this recently with the number of uh consolidation instruments and new agencies that are popping up just to um, you know, um uh address some of those overlapping and conflicting uh issues that we see with those standards.
- 29:15
- Unidentified speaker: And the ratings can also diverge because they ask different questions.
- 29:19
- Unidentified speaker: So some assess sustainability issues, others assess uh whether company affects society and environment, both are legitimate, but users should not treat them as interchangeable.
- 29:31
- Unidentified speaker: And I think that's an important point because very often, you know, we the the the the reason and the reason why these um standards or these these metrics are there do not necessarily respond to the same objective.
- 29:46
- Unidentified speaker: Most of the time it responds to the objective of the investor.
- 29:50
- Unidentified speaker: So to make sure that the investor sees their uh financial uh investment as clean, green, or sustainable, whereas whether that has an impact later on on communities and water, etc., is less of a concern.
- 30:08
- Unidentified speaker: Um and for me, um, you know, ultimately that reporting uh mechanism, which is currently seen as a dashboard, um, it tells us where we are, but it doesn't steer the vehicle.
- 30:21
- Unidentified speaker: Um and I think the objective uh is to have, if the objective is to have better decisions, prevent harms, etc., we have to really assess the extent to which the current uh framework that we have do and for whom do they um do they meet the the requirements.
- 30:39
- Unidentified speaker: And to your last point about uh the trends with critical minerals and the at least the accelerated demand for minerals and metals, we're bound to see more of that, but we are also bound to see uh the pressure that might to some extent compress the needs, because there will be this trade-off between getting access to the resources quickly, but at the expense of what?
- 31:06
- Unidentified speaker: Is it at the expense of regulatory um uh compliance?
- 31:10
- Unidentified speaker: Is this at the expense of land?
- 31:12
- Unidentified speaker: Is this at the expense of people's rights?
- 31:15
- Unidentified speaker: So we are now seeing at the same time uh an increase in requirements from investors, but also a pressure from the side of the market to accelerate processes to have access to more minerals.
- 31:29
- Unidentified speaker: Will that lead to more sustainable mining?
- 31:31
- Unidentified speaker: Is this going to be elusive?
- 31:34
- Unidentified speaker: We have to see in the future.
- 31:35
- Unidentified speaker: I think it's a bit too soon to say.
- 31:37
- Unidentified speaker: But um, that's a clear, a clearly, a clear, a real question for us to ask.
- 31:42
- Unidentified speaker: Because what would that mean if uh the objective is to uh get more?
- 31:48
- Unidentified speaker: Um, if if will this make mining more sustainable or more urgent or more difficult?
- 31:54
- Unidentified speaker: I don't know.
- 31:55
- Unidentified speaker: But yeah, the danger is really to treat critical as a permission to kind of bypass safeguards.
- 32:00
- Unidentified speaker: And the opportunity, I think, is to use this, the strategic attention and public finance to build better governance systems, fairer partnerships, and more resilient supply chains.
- 32:11
- Unidentified speaker: And I was saying earlier, I think investors have a real role to play here.
- 32:16
- Unidentified speaker: Regulators have a real role to play here.
- 32:18
- Unidentified speaker: I think they shouldn't compromise on what they consider as non-negotiable when they are putting in their funding or when they are giving their perm these permits, because it's it's there is a race against time and race among countries to actually get there first.
- 32:36
- Unidentified speaker: But that should not come at the expense of communities, at the expense of sustainable longer term development of countries, and then at the expense of the environment.
- 32:46
- Unidentified speaker: Fascinating.
- 32:47
- Unidentified speaker: Thank you very much, Isabel.
- 32:49
- Unidentified speaker: That's all we had time for, and appreciate you taking time to be on the Sheila Kama Extractive podcast.
- 32:56
- Unidentified speaker: Thank you very much, Sheila.