On Background

YFYS performance test updates and pension boost crackdown discussed with super industry leader

20 min Listen to the original Episode page
SuperannuationRegulationPension PolicyAI InvestmentIndex ProvidersInfrastructure

Summary

Mary Delahunty discusses Treasurer Jim Chalmers' proposed changes to the Your Future, Your Super performance test, including a new CPI+ benchmark for emerging assets and increased competition among index providers. She also addresses the government's crackdown on pension boost products, noting the tension between member innovation and age pension budget impacts. Delahunty advocates for super funds to innovate collaboratively with the government through sandboxes and principled agreements. The episode concludes with a discussion on AI exposure for superannuation, framing it as a key investment theme focused on infrastructure rather than just equity listings.

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 1:02

    Sponsor Read: AIA Embrace advertisement

    Advertisement for well-being programs.

  2. 1:02 – 4:25

    YFYS Performance Test Modernisation

    Mary Delahunty welcomes Treasurer Jim Chalmers' changes to the Your Future, Your Super performance test, citing three key updates: a CPI+ benchmark for emerging assets, expansion to more products, and allowing more index providers to increase competition.

  3. 4:25 – 7:35

    Pension Boost Product Crackdown

    Delahunty discusses the government's move to stop pension boost products, noting that while the sector innovated legally, the products negatively impact the age pension budget, creating a conflict between member benefit and public policy.

  4. 7:35 – 13:52

    Innovation with Government

    Delahunty argues that super funds must innovate with the government as a partner to align member outcomes with public policy, suggesting sandboxing and principled agreement across political cycles.

  5. 13:52 – 16:39

    Superannuation's Long-Term Role

    The speakers discuss Treasurer Chalmers' view that super funds can better communicate long-term savings than governments due to their stability, and Delahunty's agreement that funds should explain economic imperatives like productivity and inflation.

  6. 16:39 – 19:47

    Anthropic Float and AI Exposure

    Delahunty identifies the Anthropic float as a key story, framing AI exposure as a 'barbecue question' for super members and highlighting the investment theme of 'picks and shovels' like data centers and energy infrastructure.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
GoldcommodityneutralAnd he said these magical words. He said, You can make a lot of money in a gold rush by selling the picks and shovels.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

The Treasurer announced changes to the YFYS performance test allowing a CPI+ benchmark on emerging assets.

Mary Delahunty ·2:06

How to verify: Check the Treasurer's media release or speech from 2026-11-18 (day before transcript) regarding YFYS changes, or the subsequent legislative instrument on the Treasury website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The YFYS changes include expansion of the performance test across more products.

Mary Delahunty ·2:26

How to verify: Review the Treasurer's announcement details or the APRA/Treasury consultation paper on the expanded scope of the performance test. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The YFYS changes allow for the consideration of more index providers.

Mary Delahunty ·2:45

How to verify: Check the Treasurer's remarks or the updated Superannuation Legislation Amendment and Regulation Rules regarding index provider eligibility. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Jim Chalmers addressed the ASFA Conference in person, marking his fourth or fifth time doing so.

Lachlan Maddock ·13:30

How to verify: Check the ASFA Conference program or news reports from the ASFA Conference held around 2026-11-19. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Jim Chalmers stated that superannuation funds can do what governments can't regarding long-term savings messaging.

Lachlan Maddock ·13:52

How to verify: Review the transcript of Jim Chalmers' speech at the ASFA Conference or news coverage of his address on 2026-11-18. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Anthropic has floated (IPO).

Mary Delahunty ·16:39

How to verify: Check stock exchange announcements (e.g., NYSE or LSE) for Anthropic's listing date and details. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Mark Delaney was the CIO of Australian Super.

Mary Delahunty ·18:14

How to verify: Check Mark Delaney's professional biography or Australian Super's historical leadership announcements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Superannuation was created as a gift to the parliament and is legislatively required.

Mary Delahunty ·11:39

How to verify: Review the Superannuation Guarantee legislation and historical parliamentary records regarding the introduction of compulsory superannuation in Australia. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Review the specific text of the proposed YFYS performance test changes from the Australian Treasury website to verify the CPI+ benchmark details.
  • Check the current list of approved index providers for superannuation performance tests to assess the competitive landscape.
  • Analyze the cost structure of pension boost products versus standard super products to understand the age pension budget impact.
  • Research the legal definition of 'best interests duty' for superannuation trustees under the SIS Act.
  • Identify major data center and energy infrastructure companies listed in Australia and globally to evaluate the 'picks and shovels' AI investment theme.
  • Look for recent ASFA or industry body submissions on retirement stability to understand the 'principled agreement' concept.
  • Verify the current performance of emerging asset classes against the proposed CPI+ benchmark to assess potential impact on fund rankings.
  • Check for any recent government announcements or policy papers regarding the crackdown on pension boost products.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): This podcast is brought to you by AIA Embrace, supporting well-being through leading programs and partnerships. Whether you're well, unwell, or recovering, let our people embrace your people.

0:12Lachlan Maddock: Hello and welcome to another episode of Investment Magazine on Background. I'm Lotham Malk, editor of Investment Magazine, and I'm joined today not by my usual editorial bloodhounds, but by Mary Delahunty, CEO of the Association of Superannuation Funds of Australia on the site. sidelines of that conference. Mary, how are you going today?

0:30Mary Delahunty: Oh, I'm I'm thrilled to be here with you and to be with all the delegates of the conference. So over 1,200 people here from Superannuation. Um

0:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): kind

0:39Mary Delahunty: of maybe I'm like the renter Bloodhound today, but so I'm happy to be included in that, you know, in that case.

0:45Lachlan Maddock: I want to be clear, this is not a commercial deal. So um you've been flat out, but of course, there have been a couple big stories. that have come out of ASFA already, and you know, there was a bit of coverage in the lead-up, and I can only imagine how uh annoying it is to sometimes deal with journalists. Being journalist myself, I know how annoying it is. Um YFYS changes, what do you make of

1:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): them?

1:06Mary Delahunty: We're really quite pleased, actually. The sector has been saying for a number of years we think the performance test is a is a necessary test to have. in a compulsory system. But it it needs modernisation. It it in a set in if you sort of set and forget it, it's been five almost six years time now, it it won't keep up with the way in which we need to grow investments in this country. And we celebrate our system for its size and its scale. We should also remember that we've grown some incredible institutional investors in the people here. in the capability here. And often that that can be constrained by external tests. And so how do we actually let the investors do their job given they are um pretty world renowned? So the uh test changes that were announced by the Treasury yesterday here are are are really welcome. They come in three parts as your listeners would probably know. The first is to allow for a CPI plus benchmark on emerging assets. And just as I'm saying that, you can obviously see that there's a lot of detail to be worked out there. But we're we're really looking forward to digging into that and getting it done. The second part of that announcement was about the expansion across more products. And this is really represents a a

2:26stronger test in this way. If we believe that the test needs to be something that consumers can really rely on, then it needs to be strengthened across the products that they can choose from as much as is practicable and will again help Treasury and APRA be able to execute that change. And then the third was to um allow for the consideration of more index providers and that also speaks to the marketplace and where it's moved in the last few years as well. We've written interregulation specific um benchmark and indic index providers. And the treasurer noted in his remarks yesterday he'd like to bring some competition to that space, which is uh welcome because at the end of the day it's the everyday, you know, worker in Australia who's paying for access to um to those indexes and they have been written into regulation. So we don't want any sort of non commercial elements um accidentally in there. So pretty good package really.

3:21Lachlan Maddock: It's interesting actually. It's that last detail that I was sort of most gratified by because it does show kind of how far reaching the changes have been. They have been quite granular, even going down to the minutiae of index selection. election. Um and it's interesting also that when discussing it you bring up that idea of the brain drain out of superannuation because that is something I find a lot when I'm talking to investors who have gravitated towards wealth management or family office space. It's just a lot more interesting for them. Yeah. And you want these people to be able to practice uh good investments um in favor of Australia's superannuates.

3:54Mary Delahunty: Oh I I completely agree. Our investors are the that the level of capability that they've built inside their teams, whether that's in asset specific or across like strategic asset allocation skills, they are they're sought after internationally.

4:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

4:09Mary Delahunty: so it is it probably um, you know, unintended consequence, I suppose, of constraining them here that they might actually move offshore and execute their skills there.

4:18Lachlan Maddock: You'd be the least in sovereign wealth funds,

4:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): our

4:20Lachlan Maddock: best investors.

4:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.

4:21Lachlan Maddock: Shouldn't they be working wearing for Australia?

4:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it?

4:22Mary Delahunty: No, they should be here working for Australians, yeah. So let's let them go.

4:25Lachlan Maddock: Exactly. It's in the national interest. But also something that uh I I didn't see coming, um, that Charmers announced on stage yesterday was this change to pension boost products, which have um been developed quite rapidly and appeared on the scene quite rapidly and just as rapidly as sort of been uh you know clamped down upon. So if you can take us through that a little bit.

4:45Mary Delahunty: Yeah, it it's an interesting conversation to have with government at the moment. Um you would have m be aware that governments have encouraged the sector to really innovate around that retirement space and um the sector's ready for that challenge, you know, let's build the world's best retirement system. So the innovation that they've taken to those products was to um enable um a sort of deeming rate on an a lifetime income Um uh and I'm oversimplifying it for the benefit

5:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of yeah.

5:12Lachlan Maddock: I need somebody to oversimplify

5:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but just

5:14Lachlan Maddock: they are just a mystery to me.

5:16Mary Delahunty: Yeah, and it's and retirement can be sort of complex. I don't know whether that's by design or whether that's like that's how retirement is, I don't know. But anyway, the um products themselves were they're

5:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not

5:26Mary Delahunty: uh doing anything wrong. Like this is all legal and they have been developed under that please innovate around retirement sort of framework. Um, but the government can see that it has a public policy lens to this, I suppose, whereas we have a

5:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um

5:42Mary Delahunty: product and you know, member by member sort of lens to it. And so we're trying to make those two things meet. The government can see that if we are accessing um a different way for the government provided age pension to be provided to people who are also in this product, then the expense of the government provided age pension um will go up. And so they want to be able to open this conversation with the sector right now to say, well, that's that's a detrimental public policy outcome, whilst it might be good for each member. And so that's obviously that's within their remit. It's within our remit to say this is good for each member, though, here. And so we need to figure out how those two views align. And so they have announced their intention to um probably put a stop to the way in which those products are being used. And this sector, whilst noting that they haven't done anything wrong, kind of is welcoming of the clarity from the government about how we might put a stop to that then, what the grandfathering arrangements might be for anyone

6:43currently using that product and what the phase out would look like. And so really that's the next step here. What what does clarity look like? in the in the space of this in in the face of this announcement? And the assistant treasurer will be coming along uh later on this afternoon

6:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

6:59Mary Delahunty: he will hopefully provide some of that clarity.

7:01Lachlan Maddock: Yeah, unfortunately I'll uh we'll have to record this almost in advance so we'll dress but I know that it will be very closely watched because those pension boost products um I know that they were definitely controversial in some parts of the industry. And like you said, it's not like anybody was doing anything wrong. Um and it is I suppose a shame that innovation in this way, you know, it something had to be done. Um, because otherwise everybody would do this and then we would have a massive kind of loss on the budget. But do you feel that the government coming through and saying, Oh, we really want you to innovate, we really want you to innovate and then somebody does that and they say not like that. You know, is Now, there a concern in the industry that?

7:35Mary Delahunty: I think the lesson for me is that we need to innovate with the government as a partner so that we can bring that public policy lens to the ideas that the sector will have to improve that retirement space. And so my invitation, I suppose, to the government is we'll come with us on this innovation um in this innovation space and and let's do it together. You you tell us about the public policy outcome. We'll tell you about what the members want. And somewhere in there, that's the sweet spot of how we build the world's best retirement system.

8:07Lachlan Maddock: What what does that collaboration look what does closer collaboration look like? And is that something that can survive the political cycle? Is that something that you can carry forward into new governance potentially? I mean, this one doesn't look like it's going anywhere just yet. Um but if you want to advise By closer close collaboration with government, like there's two, sometimes even three sides of it now.

8:26Mary Delahunty: That is the question, isn't it? And I would say to your listeners, we are recording this at a time when it's socially unacceptable to drink. It's only 1224. But if I had a bottle of wine, we could sort that out. I think um It

8:39Lachlan Maddock: would just

8:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be

8:41Lachlan Maddock: socially acceptable.

8:43Mary Delahunty: Anyway, um the yeah, it that is that is a real problem. It's a problem for not just the innovation and the partnering. it's a problem for super in general that um political cycles can change the nature of the way we do business, but we are naturally long term investors, thinkers, you know, designers. So that that is a um like a Venn diagram that sort of doesn't seem to cross over. But I think the way Another in which we can do it is to I always like to seek principled agreement um between

9:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in

9:15Mary Delahunty: this case parties before we embark on something. And I think what we can see from the language of the opposition, of the government, and of any other sort of parties around the uh grounds is that we all agree that that retirement space needs more attention. And we all agree that it's not beyond us to do it. And so we might disagree on some of the elements. of it, but if we keep moving on principled, you know, that sort of uh high level agreement on issues, you really can get things done. ASFA engages just across the spectrum because we need to bring

9:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that

9:51Mary Delahunty: certainty, that surety to the decisions that funds are making. I think what it looks looks like, and you know, operationally is uh i is close close. conversations that don't necessarily have to be done in newspaper land.

10:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We

10:08Lachlan Maddock: in uh on the front page.

10:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,

10:10Mary Delahunty: on the front page of that it doesn't really need to be a fight when we're trying to work out retirement. Um I and I feel like it's calm and I feel like Treasury and the way in which we work with Treasury is really constructive. So we just need to really be intentional about um as us about sandboxing things and saying if we did this, how would you feel about that? And what about who did this and what about that? And um and and have faith that that doesn't need to be a a fight. Yeah.

10:37Lachlan Maddock: And it does it does feel that some of the internacy and conflicts that defined my early career in financial journalism, retail versus industry, liberal versus labor, Labour um, do seem to have lost some of their intensity. Yes.

10:49Mary Delahunty: Uh

10:50Lachlan Maddock: in the last few years. I I'm not exactly sure why. There does seem to be a bit more agreement about superannuation. Of course there are still people who want to uh throw it open for access to various different things, but I feel that those there there is even a little bit more kind of sensible debate around those rather than people just saying you can't do that. You know, there is that understanding that people want their superannuation. Um but you know for various economic and macroeconomic reasons, it's probably not good for them to have it.

11:18Mary Delahunty: Yeah, and and that's the um that's the social contract, that's the continual trade-off, isn't it? And it's why we as a sector exist with a social licence. We exist because we're legislatively required to, you know, we we exist as a gift to the parliament. But we also need the trust of the people because it is a bargain the whole time. And I see our role as ASFA as being the sensible technical um experts to bring ideas it to practical reality. And so taking the um taking the fight out, taking the bite out of uh policy direction is what what we're pretty good at and that uh walking like sensibly, slowly, deliberately. towards that, it helps to um

12:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it

12:07Mary Delahunty: either obviously helps to be nonpartisan and it helps to but it also helps to have technical experts in your team that really do aid the treasury process and aid um policymakers understanding how super works. We're not banking. We're not insurance

12:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but

12:24Mary Delahunty: we are financial services. And so it's c it's complex and it's our own and we need to keep, you know, reminding people it's a bit different. One of the greatest differences of super as distinct from those other sectors, but the thing that is common across all types of funds is that all superannuation funds are run under a trustee structure. SMSFs, same thing, trustee structure first, retail funds, trustee. Not for profit funds, trustee. So that means that everyone looking after your money has to have your best interests at heart first. That's the combining factor. And that's why I think we've all, you know, learned to really understand what that means in practice and bring a lot of those uh old sort of back to your corner wars to into in to largely. to an end.

13:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

13:16Lachlan Maddock: Duchalmers addressed the conference in person yesterday and this was his fourth or fifth time addressing the conference, though I think it might actually be the first time I've seen him in person. And I suspect the reason is that because the conference was being opened by Alistair Campbell. Are

13:31Mary Delahunty: you saying it wasn't me? Like

13:32Lachlan Maddock: well have been you. Barry, but I understand that uh Jim is taking a bit of time behind the um backstage to talk with Alistair and discuss, you know, uh the thing that has defined both of their lives, which is politics. I made this podcasting, I don't know music. Look, it's a great podcast. I don't know if it's an investment magazine on background, but uh obviously everybody should and does listen to it. But he said something really interesting, which is that superannuation funds in some ways can do what governments can't. Um, in terms of putting that message out there about the importance of long-term retirement savings. Governments change over superannuation. funds are there the whole time. You know, and

14:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how

14:06Lachlan Maddock: many changes of government have there been since compulsory superannuation was created? And that purpose has said central to it.

14:13Mary Delahunty: Yeah, I think that's that was a really interesting observation, wasn't it? Interesting too that, oh well, I think if you unpick that a bit, you wonder what our role might be to uh explain economic imperatives like like productivity, explain how in investment and productivity are linked in this context, how long-term institutional investors can play a role in putting downward pressure on inflation, putting upward movement and momentum behind productivity. You've got to wonder about all of that. But one of the other observations that Alistair made and has done time and again in his Must Listen podcast is about the bank of.

14:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

14:49Mary Delahunty: mean, I was I

14:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

14:51Mary Delahunty: know, we've said social license here, so you could call it that, but it's the um it's sort of the bank of charm and um political capital that you build up in order to have meaningful conversations with the public, which I think I reflect has probably changed a fair bit over the course of governments. And when we tell the storied history of super, it's hard not to bring up Paul Keating. And I remember him as a I mean, I was obviously a baby, but um small child, uh, I remember him just being um just explaining and re-explaining and re-explaining a an issue ra largely complex until you either understood it or you just thought, well, he gets it, all right, whatever.

15:35Lachlan Maddock: And I trust him.

15:37Mary Delahunty: I trust him. And yeah, something like that. And we don't have that sort of cycle anymore. So the way in which you have conversations with the public needs to change and and super needs to be aware of that too. So if we can do things that governments can't because our long term nature versus their short term nature allows us that license, then how do we um have that conversation with the public? And his observation, Alistair's observation about, you know,

16:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

16:03Mary Delahunty: plain language, less spin, more actual talking, that really resonated with me. Just more talking. Um and and explain concepts. People aren't stupid. They're just distracted and it's not there, you know, every day. So

16:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

16:18Mary Delahunty: really took that on board yesterday. I'm gonna be rattling that around for a little bit, to see w I don't know what that means for our sector, but it's meaningful.

16:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

16:25Lachlan Maddock: this is the very last question. This is technically a news podcast, and the tagline is the podcast that takes you behind the news that matters to asset hours. It doesn't have to be a story that matters to asset hours, Mary. Yeah. What is one news story that you're following at the moment and why?

16:39Mary Delahunty: So we are following uh the anthropic float. Um

16:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when

16:45Mary Delahunty: I say we, uh my colleague Scott and I mostly, and we are we are like. we're like, what is going on? Now, why I'm following it from a superannuation perspective is that um we will be asked by this is the barbecue question. Yeah. Yeah, what exposure do AI do super funds have? And I like to be able to explain that yes, there are these, you know, so there are these noisy issuances going on in the world at the moment. Um what I love to hear from Australian investors is where are the they seeing the value? How are they reading that value? Are they participating? Where are they getting their exposure? Because AI as a theme running through the investment strategy of funds is touching pretty much every asset class. And so whilst the news is about, you know, could this be the biggest IPO? i the the broader theme and the barbeque conversation is really about Well, how is my super? exposed to um AI. And so I've really uh I think I've quite enjoyed and I'm enjoying listening to just the knowledge of the investors that we've grown in this country talk about the how that theme's running through. Where they're picking value, how they're seeing value, how they're getting exposure to things that might not be quite so

17:59dramatic, um, as an IPO with a, you know pretty big valuation behind it. And I think um so this is so much, this is like the I'm gonna need to have a t-shirt made. There's been this quote just keeps floating around,

18:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but I'm

18:14Mary Delahunty: gonna credit it to Mark Delaney. I heard him say it. I don't know whether he picked it somewhere else, but Mark Delaney, well known to your listeners, I'm sure, ex-CIO CIO of Australian Super, and was there for a long time. And he said these magical words. He said, You can make a lot of money in a gold rush by selling the picks and shovels. And so it's about seeing the theme and then picking where the value is. We've seen data centers. We will see energy infrastructure that needs to power those data centers as being somewhere where there's value. We'll see other things that pop up around this AI theme that represent exposure to the theme and are not necessarily um the list. listed equity that you can see.

18:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

18:53Mary Delahunty: it goes back to our earlier conversation. Australian investors, the the the people we have grown in this superannuation sector, they're really clever.

19:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

19:01Mary Delahunty: I can't wait to see what they do with this theme.

19:04Lachlan Maddock: People who read news always have uh much more erudite takes on it than people who write it. And the news I'm following at the moment is uh Santafergate, Sand Haifer Gate, which has been revived again after almost a depth. death.

19:14Mary Delahunty: I hear we're having some form of uh commission

19:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of

19:17Mary Delahunty: inquiry, and I think we should, I think the whole nation should stop and think about

19:23Lachlan Maddock: it's it's a buzz. Who

19:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): went

19:24Mary Delahunty: to Bunnings?

19:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When

19:26Lachlan Maddock: the sandpaper

19:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): who

19:27Mary Delahunty: got the sandpaper?

19:28Lachlan Maddock: It's the one, it's the most controversial issue in Australia, aside from superannuation. Everybody's got an opinion. But look, maybe on background isn't the place to dig into that. Mary, thank you for joining me. It's been fantastic. Please tune in again next week.

19:41Mary Delahunty: Thank

19:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you.

19:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): This podcast was brought to you by AIA Embrace. Let our people embrace your people.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights