Speakers analyze AI sell-off drivers, citing valuation resets, leverage unwinding, and shifting sentiment from infrastructure to software.
Summary
Host John Ford and guests Jeremy Siegel, Courtney Garcia, Seema Modi, and Mackenzie Sigalos discuss a broad market sell-off driven by election results, AI valuation concerns, and leverage unwinding. Siegel attributes the drop to a 'blue wave' election and uncertainty over AI data center build-outs, while Garcia highlights deleveraging and tax loss selling. Modi notes a reset in expectations following NVIDIA's earnings and Anthropic's poor IPO performance. Sigalos reports resilience in software stocks like IBM and Adobe, which are outperforming chipmakers. The panel concludes that while consumer spending remains strong, the 'wealth effect' is vulnerable, and a positioning washout is needed for a durable market bounce.
Key takeaways
- 1 The Nasdaq is down for the year, triggering year-end tax loss selling which adds downward pressure on equities.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) · 3:30
- 2 Morgan Stanley argues that AI agents will drive increased software spending, citing Atlassian customers using AI agents as a proof point for higher spending rates.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) · 13:54
Episode sections
- 0:29 – 1:57
Market Sell-Off Overview
Host John Ford reports the Nasdaq is down 4.5%, the S&P 500 is down 3% below 7,000, and the Dow is down 1.3%. NVIDIA shares are down 11.5% for the day and 20% for the week, while Anthropic shares are down sharply but remain above its IPO price.
- 1:57 – 3:30
Causes of the Sell-Off
Guest Jeremy Siegel attributes the sell-off to a combination of negative factors including the 'blue wave' election results, uncertainty over AI data center build-outs, and Jensen Huang's comments. He describes the market reaction as a cascade of trend-riding selling and margin calls.
- 3:30 – 4:46
Leverage and Tax Loss Selling
Guest Courtney Garcia notes that deleveraging is occurring across retail and institutional levels, exacerbated by year-end tax loss selling as the Nasdaq is down for the year. She views the move as a normal pullback in a bull market rather than a recession signal, citing positive staples and healthcare sectors.
- 4:46 – 7:54
Valuation and Expectation Reset
Guest Seema Modi argues the market is resetting expectations, noting that NVIDIA's earnings call made it clear there would be no 'second act' from Jensen Huang. She highlights that Anthropic's IPO did not lift market spirits and that China-related regulatory fears are rattling the semiconductor trade.
- 7:54 – 9:42
Economic Data and Interest Rates
Jeremy Siegel points to strong economic data, including low jobless claims and falling gasoline and diesel prices. He believes the 10-year Treasury yield has stabilized below 5%, killing the prospect of a 50 basis point rate hike and supporting non-AI sectors.
- 9:42 – 13:35
Consumer Spending and AI Infrastructure
Courtney Garcia states consumers are holding up despite negative sentiment, with retail sales and bank balance sheets showing strength. Seema Modi adds that while consumers are spending, much of it is on credit, and notes that three-quarters of GDP growth this year has come from AI infrastructure spending.
- 13:35 – 17:56
Software and Mega Cap Tech Resilience
Guest Mackenzie Sigalos reports that software stocks like IBM, Atlassian, Salesforce, ServiceNow, and Adobe are outperforming chipmakers. She cites a Morgan Stanley note suggesting AI agents drive software spending and highlights Alphabet's strong position due to its valuation (18x forward earnings) and stakes in SpaceX and Anthropic.
- 17:56 – 30:58
Private Credit and Long-Term Outlook
Jeremy Siegel suggests private credit stress depends on whether a recession occurs, noting that CDS rates on hyperscalers have risen. He advises investors to remember the historical 8.9% annual stock market return and stay invested, dismissing the idea that 15-20% returns are the new norm.
- 30:58 – 32:29
Market Sentiment and Positioning
Speakers discuss the shift in sentiment away from AI megacaps like NVIDIA and Anthropic, noting that retail investors had previously added to weakness indiscriminately. They suggest that a 'positioning washout' is needed for a durable bounce, as current sentiment has not yet fully capitulated.
- 32:29 – 35:17
Technical Indicators and Leverage
Guests advise relying on technicals like the put-call ratio and breadth metrics to gauge fear rather than narrative. They note that margin debt growth has peaked and is rolling over, which is a precursor to weaker returns, distinguishing between recessionary and non-recessionary bear markets.
- 35:17 – 36:15
Consumer Strength and Wealth Effect
Consumer discretionary stocks like hotels and cruise lines are holding up well, suggesting potential consumer resilience if rates and oil drop. However, speakers warn that prolonged market declines could erode the 'wealth effect,' which has been supporting spending despite negative real income growth.
- 36:15 – 37:25
Economic Duration vs. Magnitude
The discussion highlights that the duration of a sell-off matters more than its magnitude for economic impact due to high household exposure to equities. While an imminent economic cliff is not priced in, a protracted bear market lasting into late 2027 could weaken the economy, compounded by monetary and fiscal tightening.
- 37:25 – 39:15
Tech Sell-Off and AI Infrastructure Concerns
The Nasdaq 100 dropped over 5%, wiping out yearly gains. NVIDIA fell double digits, losing $2.5 trillion in market value over seven weeks. CoreWeave is down over 70% from its peak. Investors are questioning whether hundreds of billions in AI infrastructure spending will generate sufficient revenue.
- 39:15 – 48:16
Defensive Sectors and Healthcare
Consumer staples (McCormick, General Mills, Kraft Heinz) and utilities (CMS Energy, AEP, Exelon) outperformed. Healthcare stocks rose following price target bumps for Humana and UnitedHealth by TD, citing positive Medicare Advantage outlooks, lifting names like CVS and Johnson & Johnson.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| NVIDIANVDA | equity | mixed | NVIDIA, though, getting hammered right now, along with a lot of the other AI infrastructure names. NVIDIA down 11.5%, the stocks now down 20%. |
| Nasdaq Composite | index | neutral | Like we're actually now seeing the NASDAQ is down for the year, you're gonna see some tax loss selling as well. |
| CATERPILLAR INCCAT | equity | neutral | including the AI infrastructure names like Caterpillar and GE Vernova. You'll see all those names are lower at this hour. |
| Meta PlatformsMETA | equity | neutral | And it's finally taking on meta and consumer AI agents opening access to free users this week, with the bet here. |
| S&P 500 | index | neutral | We're still up on the year on SP. I know we may have just uh been a little bit down on Nasdaq, but nothing unusual in the the long long upward thrust of stock value. |
| BitcoinBTC | crypto | mixed | We are just getting started. Up next, more on this market sell-off as we close out the week. including Bitcoin below 60,000 for the first time in four months. We are live, the New York Stock Exchange. You're watching Closing Bell on CNBC. |
| BullishBLSH | equity | neutral | So take a look at the moves in Coinbase, Circle, and Bullish. |
| JOHNSON & JOHNSONJNJ | equity | neutral | The upgrades seem to lift other healthcare names, including CVS Johnson Johnson, as well as Bristol Myers. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
NVIDIA shares are down 11.5% on the day and 20% for the week.
John Ford ·1:09
How to verify: Check NVIDIA (NVDA) stock price history on Yahoo Finance or Bloomberg for November 20, 2026, and the prior week. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAnthropic's stock erased more than a trillion dollars in market cap since Jensen Huang resigned.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·6:22
How to verify: Calculate the difference in Anthropic's market capitalization between the date of Jensen Huang's resignation and November 20, 2026, using SEC filings or financial data providers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAnthropic's IPO price was $89 per share.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·5:52
How to verify: Review the S-1 filing or prospectus for Anthropic's IPO on the SEC EDGAR database. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe 10-year Treasury yield is 4.92%.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·8:15
How to verify: Check the US Treasury yield data for November 20, 2026, on the US Department of the Treasury website or financial terminals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Three-quarters of all GDP growth this year has come from things related to building out AI infrastructure.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·11:47
How to verify: Review US Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) GDP reports for 2026 and associated industry breakdowns. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Alphabet has stakes worth more than $200 billion combined in SpaceX and Anthropic.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·14:34
How to verify: Check Alphabet's (GOOGL) 10-Q or 10-K filings with the SEC for investment disclosures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAlphabet is trading at 18 times forward earnings.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·14:54
How to verify: Calculate Alphabet's forward P/E ratio using current stock price and consensus analyst estimates for the next fiscal year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bitcoin is trading in the low $58,000 range.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·22:19
How to verify: Check Bitcoin (BTC) price data on CoinGlass or major exchanges for November 20, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Over $500 million in leveraged long positions were liquidated in the past four hours.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·22:39
How to verify: Review CoinGlass liquidation data for the four-hour period preceding the broadcast on November 20, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The VIX is at 35.
John Ford ·21:56
How to verify: Check the CBOE VIX index value for November 20, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
NVIDIA has lost $2.5 trillion in market value over a seven-week period.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·37:45
How to verify: Check NVIDIA's (NVDA) market capitalization data from financial news archives or SEC filings for the period surrounding November 20, 2026, and calculate the difference from the peak value seven weeks prior. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceNVIDIA is experiencing its longest weekly losing streak since the 2008 financial crisis.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·37:45
How to verify: Review historical weekly price data for NVIDIA (NVDA) and compare the current losing streak length to historical data from the 2008 financial crisis period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceCoreWeave is down more than 70% from its peak.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·37:45
How to verify: Check valuation data for CoreWeave from private market valuation reports or recent funding round disclosures to determine its current valuation relative to its historical peak. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Nasdaq 100 wiped out its gains for the year.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·37:25
How to verify: Compare the Nasdaq 100 index value on November 20, 2026, to its value at the start of the 2026 calendar year using financial data providers like Bloomberg or Yahoo Finance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The semiconductor index is down 43% from its highs.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·42:12
How to verify: Identify the specific semiconductor index referenced (likely SOX or similar) and calculate the percentage decline from its 52-week high to the closing price on November 20, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The semiconductor index is up almost 40% on a 12-month basis.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·42:12
How to verify: Calculate the percentage gain of the referenced semiconductor index from November 20, 2026, to November 20, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
NVIDIA contributed close to a quarter of the S&P 500 decline.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·44:16
How to verify: Calculate NVIDIA's weight in the S&P 500 and multiply by its daily percentage decline to estimate its contribution to the index's total point decline, then compare to the S&P 500's total decline. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceNVIDIA broke its long-term uptrend going back to the 2022 lows.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·44:36
How to verify: Analyze NVIDIA's (NVDA) price chart to identify the trendline connecting the 2022 lows and determine if the price on November 20, 2026, closed below this support level. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceReal income growth has been negative while real spending growth has been positive.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·35:56
How to verify: Check U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) data for Real Personal Income and Real Personal Consumption Expenditures for the relevant period in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The top ten largest members in the S&P 500 command approximately 40% of the index.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·34:27
How to verify: Sum the market capitalizations of the top ten S&P 500 constituents and divide by the total market capitalization of the S&P 500 index as of November 20, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify NVIDIA's weekly and daily percentage price changes via NVIDIA Corporation investor relations filings or real-time market data providers.
- Check the 'blue wave' election results and their specific impact on policy uncertainty regarding AI data center regulations.
- Review Nasdaq Composite year-to-date performance to confirm tax loss selling pressures.
- Read NVIDIA's latest earnings call transcript to verify claims about 'second act' guidance and Jensen Huang's comments.
- Monitor the 10-year Treasury yield on the US Department of the Treasury website to confirm the 4.92% level cited.
- Analyze US GDP growth components from the Bureau of Economic Analysis to verify the claim that 75% of growth is AI-related.
- Check the put-call ratio and margin debt growth data from the Options Clearing Corporation and FINRA to assess leverage and fear levels.
- Review consumer discretionary stock performance (hotels, cruise lines) and real income vs. real spending data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): AI is here, transforming how we work, live, and lead. And the women I talk to aren't waiting for the future, they're shaping it. I'm Julia Borston, Senior Media and Tech Correspondent at CNBC. This is CNBC Changemakers, where I talk with the female leaders transforming business as AI reshapes the world. Follow and listen to CNBC Changemakers, women leading in the age of AI, wherever you get your podcasts.
0:29John Ford: Welcome to Closing Bell. I'm John Ford in for Scott Wappner. And we are monitoring a big sell-off on Wall Street as we head into the final hour of the trading. We can see that the NASDAQ is down four and a half percent. The market picture beyond that, the Dow is down just a modest one and a third percent, uh, 600 plus points, but don't let that fool you. The SP 500. which is more representative, is down about 3% below 7,000 at this point. Also, check out shares of anthropic. They are down sharply, still well off the lows of the session and above the IPO price. NVIDIA, though, getting hammered right now, along with a lot of the other AI infrastructure names. NVIDIA down 11.5%, the stocks now down 20%. this week alone. We've got full team coverage of this sell-off with our all-star panel. Joining me now is Wharton School, Professor of Finance, uh Wisdom Tree Chief Economist Jeremy Siegel, Pin Capitalist Courtney Garcia, and Capital Area Planning Groups Malcolm Etheridge. Courtney and Malcolm are CNBC contributors. Uh, Everybody, welcome.
1:35Uh Professor Siegel, gotta start with you on this one. I was looking to this week, this time last week. Oh boy, NVIDIA earnings, anthropic IPO, A, how are investors going to respond to that? And therefore, how is the market going to respond? Both of those things in isolation seem to go well, but the sell-off is dramatic. What does it mean?
1:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
1:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): John, I don't think hardly anyone saw this coming. And uh you know, uh I I it's a it's a group of negative things. The blue wave, the question of whether you know they're gonna get the build out of of the AI data centers, and of course, Jensen Huang is on it. Uh, other but
2:17John Ford: didn't we sell off on
2:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): other
2:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): companies?
2:20John Ford: Why
2:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are we still selling off
2:21John Ford: on that stuff? We we sold
2:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): off on that last week
2:23John Ford: and the week before.
2:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, but you know what? It's these things. are like straws that break the camel's back. You know what I mean? Everyone, I don't care, I don't care. There's everything else is good. And then when those straws keep on going, bang. And that's the shift. And then, of course, listen, we know there's a lot of trend riders uh on these markets. They have their trend lines, they've written it up, and as soon as it goes down, they're selling, and they're selling, and they're selling, and they do. just perpetuate the and then everyone who's leveraged gets a call from their broker. You need margin, um, and you have a a week like this.
3:02John Ford: Uh Courtney
3:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Garcia
3:04John Ford: with me here at the Nicey. The leverage, I was just thinking about that because retail investors have been using leverage for quite a while now to an extent that we haven't seen. And a lot of it's leveraged ETFs, a lot of it is about the popular stuff, which includes uh AI names and the likes of crypto. All of that's down right now. What kind of impact not only do you think that's having on what we're already seeing, but what we might see from here? Yeah,
3:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I think that's happening both on the retail and the institutional level, right? So that's kind of happening across the board where you are gonna see this deleveraging, and as the markets go down further, you're gonna start to see some of that unwind. And then we're also approaching the end of the year here. So if you are showing losses on anything, right? Like we're actually now seeing the NASDAQ is down for the year, you're gonna see some tax loss selling as well. So that can actually put some additional pressure on here. But I think this is not overly negative. Like if you look at the markets right now, we still have staples and healthcare are still positive for the year, which are much less exciting to talk about. But it's not just this broad-based broad base sell-off. You are seeing that investors are trying to find other areas to invest in. And I think at this point in time, we have not had this large of a correction in a while, but they are normal to happen every year or so. So I would actually see that this is much more of a pullback in a longer-term bull market as opposed to the beginning of a recession. Now, when you're seeing this kind of positive data on the underlying economy that we've continued to see.
4:21John Ford: Malcolm, I I have to wonder at a time like this, there's this tendency when you like the market. you tend to think that the price of everything is fair, that the multiples are good. And then when there's a you know a pullback, it's like, oh, I feel like I lost something. It'll get back to normal. What are the chances you think that this is just a repricing and we need to consider the possibility that the multiples don't get back up to where they were before in some of these areas?
4:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, in addition to a repricing, I think it's also a resetting of expectations. I think it's very telling that the world's largest IPO ever going off without a hitch basically yesterday still wasn't enough to lift
4:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): everyone's spirits, closing out the week and bringing a positive sentiment back into this market. I think when I say resetting of expectations, I think a little bit of that at least has to be that it was made abundantly clear on the earnings call on Tuesday from the folks at NVIDIA that there will not be a second act from a Jensen Wong here, where I think investors were initially holding on to a little bit of hope that maybe the AI savior was coming back to the helm. And once it became clear that that wasn't happening, that's where we saw too some of this downward pressure that hasn't been able to reverse course. And so I think, yes, the reset in valuation multiples, but I think also it's reset. in expectations of where we go from here as far as the AI trade is concerned.
5:43John Ford: Interesting. Speaking of NVIDIA, let's get to Seema Modi, who is watching names that are weighing on the market today. Seema.
5:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey John, you
5:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): mentioned anthropic. Excitement around
5:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
5:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): AI lab seems to be waning following its historic IPO debut yesterday. Investors seem to be taking some money off the table with the stock trading uh right below its opening price. of eighty nine dollars a share, trading at eighty six ninety-two at this moment. The stock has now erased more than a trillion dollars in market cap since Jensen Wong resigned. Now trading at its lowest level since November of 2025. And these China concerns, John, and the prospect of more regulation or crackdown on experts, exports, that has certainly rattled the broader semi-trade.
6:59He said the companies that do build overseas will face attacks. Now that would pose a challenge to the neo clouds that are sort of in the midst of this build-out, right, including the AI infrastructure names like Caterpillar and GE Vernova. You'll see all those names are lower at this hour. John. All right,
7:13John Ford: Sima, Tima, thanks. But that would be something. You think about it. Harder to build data centers at home, harder to build data centers abroad. Uh Jeremy Siegel, want to go back to you on the question of the broader economic impact of this questioning of not just the AI trade, I would say AI in general. I've been looking at the beige books, looking at the Fed minutes. This AI and the data centers have become this economic. driver. And now we're seeing questions in the market as well as in the everyday economy and who benefits here. What are the chances that the uncertainty that we're seeing in the market gets reflected more broadly in the economy and then in the market again?
7:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
7:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): John, I mean, all the economic data we get on jobless claims, on those weekly ADTP reports, they've been good. They've been strong. We have two good tailwinds coming up. We have gasoline prices that are headed to a dollar lower than they were just two months ago, even diesel down 60 cents. I was very pleased to see the interest rate finally crack below the 10-year 5%, 492. My opinion is that 50 basis point hike that Waller was talking about. a few days ago, that I think is dead. Um, I do think there'll probably be 25, and I think the market could stand that. But the 10 year going down, that I think is going to stabilize with gasoline a lot of uh or even hike the price of a lot of the non-AI. I We see it today as as as your um um uh people have mentioned already in. in in the in the data about the defensive uh thing. But they
8:55can only go up, I think, if those interest rates are not as high as they've been recently.
9:01John Ford: Right. Okay, and Courtney Garcia, I want to try to bring it back home to the pocketbook and the kitchen table here because next week we're gonna be talking about Black Friday, we're gonna be talking about the holiday season kicking off, and one of the themes. in this market in this economy has been a consumer who, despite all kinds of pricing pressures, has continued to spend. But we're gonna be comping to last year on holiday spending and the pace of things. When you think about those numbers that are gonna be coming in and the economic pressures, how much the credit card delinquencies, you know, where they stand, what needs to happen this holiday season for this market and for consumers to appear to have confidence?
9:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Well, you need to see the consumers are still holding up, which they have been, right? I mean, with the recent retail sales you've gotten, with the recent retail companies coming out showing earnings, whether you're getting the banks coming out and showing the health of the consumers' balance sheets, like all of those have continued to show the consumers generally on good footing. The consumer doesn't feel good, but that doesn't mean they're not spending. And I think that's something they'll probably well will continue unless we see that change in the near term. And they are a large percentage of the US GDP. And that is why it will likely continue the economy going if the consumer keeps spending. Black Friday is a big day that we all want to keep our eye on it as we come towards the end of the year. But if you do continue to see that happen, um that can spark that like Santa Claus rally as you get closer towards the end of the year.
10:21John Ford: That's part of what I wonder about because electronics is a big category around Black Friday, Cyber Monday, etc. And it's gonna be hard probably for some of these retailers to drop prices when memory prices are so high. I don't know how much wiggle room there is. Now, I I really don't know, but it's one of the things that I'll be watching as I try to watch how this entire thing plays out. How much of a factor is that consumer activity in this crucial quarter as we watch with the what markets do for the rest of the year?
10:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, I don't know that we should be anchoring too much to what the consumer is doing. I think that Courtney's making a great point in terms of how the consumer feels versus what they're actually doing. So the consumer sentiment may not be so high, but consumer's willingness to spend is. But I do think that that extra 50 basis points that we're concerned about or we're curious about or at least keeping our eye on could be one of the things that controls whether the consumer still has the capacity to spend. Because we're hearing how much of that spending is being done on credit, is being done by borrowing versus actual cash flow. And that's a bit concerning there. So even if the consumer remains willing to spend, if they lose their capacity to, then that changes the dynamics too. But considering still it's estimated something like three quarters. three-quarters of all of our GDP growth this year has come from things related to spending to build out AI infrastructure. I think that that's
11:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): still where we should be focusing as investors in terms of the quote the current quarter's earnings and what's ultimately going to drive the market both downward and upward out of this trend that we've been in.
11:58John Ford: Yeah, but Professor Siegel, that's sort of what I'm uh poking at and concerned. about because the confidence around AI spending seems to be shaking a bit. We're talking about what happened in the election, we're talking about what happened with NVIDIA, we're talking about how the market responded after anthropic as one little bit of uncertainty. And then it seems like we're relying on a consumer that's been spending more than it appears that the consumer can afford all year, and so therefore we expect big boxes under the tree. I I wonder where that's that sets the bar for
12:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): us. Well,
12:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it's interesting. Uh Jason Furman, who's been on the program, you know, quite a bit, at a great economist, he just did a big study of this, the bull market that we've had the last three or four years. And he came to the conclusion that's uh that consumers really surprisingly spent very little of uh those all those capital gains, which is trillions of dollars. Um uh and that you know that they've they basically held it in their accounts, saved it. Um so hopefully this decline that we see here is not gonna dent the consumer spending uh in the Christmas season. As I say, the tailwinds of uh the lower gasoline prices is gonna going put to hundreds of dollars, I think, in the pockets of many of the consumers and uh you know be a cushion against the stock market uh decline.
13:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
13:20John Ford: keeping an eye on the broader markets, the SP still near session lows, uh, down about 3% at the moment. Meanwhile, some big names in tech are bucking the trend downward today. Mackenzie Sigalos joins us now with more on that. Mac?
13:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Hey there, John. So despite the sea of red across the market today, there's there still are a few brights. bright spots in tech, particularly in software. Now, IBM and Atlassian are trading higher even as chipmakers get hammered. Salesforce ServiceNow and Adobe also holding up better than the Triple Q. In a new note out this morning, Morgan Stanley argues that AI agents could actually drive more software spending, even if people spend less time inside the apps themselves. Atlassian, an early proof point, customers using AI agents with its software are actually increasing their spending twice as fast as those who don't. The bank also likes Salesforce in ServiceNow because even if AI agents replace the apps that people interact with, they still need the customer data and business systems behind them. And that's where these companies stand to make money. And then in Mega Cap Tech, Alphabet Bet is a standout the holding up better than the rest of the Mag 7, and now ahead of NVIDIA in market value. Google also has stakes worth more than $200 billion combined in SpaceX and Anthropic, the two biggest IPOs in history. Now, another big part of the appeal for Alphabet is its price. Google now trading at just 18 times forward earnings after that historic post-earning sell-off. And it's finally taking on meta and consumer AI agents opening access to free users this week, with the bet here. that Google can turn its massive user base into a new revenue stream as
14:54search growth slows. John?
14:57John Ford: All right. McKenzie, thank you. Um, Courtney Garcia, it's interesting that ServiceNow, Adobe, uh Atlassian among the names that are performing not as badly today, because a lot of those application software names have just not been able to catch a break. over the period of time when AI infrastructure and semiconductors have been dominant. So I I wonder as we're looking at how the market is wiggling right now, to what extent there are areas, yes, in tech like software, but other areas that investors ought to reconsider, perhaps with a different thesis.
15:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Absolutely. I mean, I think this goes back to the thesis of investors are not just abandoning equities right now, they're looking for areas of opportunity. And the areas this year that have been exciting are not the exciting ones to talk about, right? Like your value indexes have way outperformed. They're still up like 12% year to date, even though your growth is down. Um, your energy is doing well, you're having commodities are doing well. So it's kind of your like old school companies that have continued to hold up well this year. And it's why you want to make sure you are well diversified. That's within tech, so whether that's software in addition to your semis, but also just in the broader. markets, you want to make sure you're well established here. This has been a really good example of a year that that's held up better for you and you're actually outperforming.
16:09John Ford: Malcolm, what should uh the folks at home consider averaging into, perhaps, um, that you think has a chance to do better than some of the AI names that many have been transfixed
16:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): by? Yeah, I think McKinsey and Courtney were
16:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): leading into it. It's the question
16:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of uh now that
16:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): we've built all of the infrastructure to
16:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do the stuff, which are the
16:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): companies that are actually going to take
16:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): up all these
16:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): different enhancements
16:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that are
16:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that they can do
16:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): with AI and turn that into savings, turn
16:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that into productivity. We
16:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): look at
16:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Anthropic and they're they're doing something like
16:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): $8 million
16:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in
16:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): revenue per full-time employee. That is the standard that's been set in terms of productivity. inside of the enterprise. So all of the companies that are out there spending hundreds of millions of dollars right now to infuse AI throughout their entire people, a group of people, how do we turn that into productivity that is tangible results for shareholders that we can get on these quarterly earnings calls and brag about? And whatever the companies are that have been on your watch list that you think are going to be positively impacted by all of that. AI spends, this is where you start to average into those, to your point, John. It's not the point where you start to stare at the exit and say, oh my God, it's time to just get out all together,
17:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): uh,
17:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): everybody out of the pool. This is where you need to be looking at those names on your watch list and trying to decide who is going to be positively impacted by this trend
17:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and
17:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): where's the next wave that I need to be getting toward.
17:36John Ford: Jeremy Siegel, I want to come a little out of uh left. field here. We haven't talked about private credit in a while, I feel like. And you know, a year ago, it was one of those things, it was all you could talk about, private credit this, private credit that. With all the uncertainty in the market right now, all the questions around rates, what impact do you think uh priv private credit ends up having on the economy, the market overall, and this environment has on private credit?
18:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
18:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think the status of private credit depends on, you know, whether we're headed for a slowdown in the economy. I mean, we all know what's happened to CDS rates uh on the hyperscalers and and uh and and the others in the build out, they've gone up, which of course puts stress on the pricing of a private credit. You know, no one's gonna going to be getting their money out like today, uh 100 cents on the dollar. But I think most of it will be fine as long as we don't have a recession. I don't see a recession uh in the cards. That's usually been the big test for the the private credit. But right now, every market is is stressed by you know this current downturn. But one should remember, you know, w this the average over long periods for the stock market is eight. nine percent a year up, which has generated the trillions of dollars of wealth that we know. Um we had uh people began to think that 15 to 20 was going to be the norm with AI. And we have to bring that down to reality. We're still up on the year on SP. I know we may have just uh been a little bit down on Nasdaq, but nothing unusual in the the long long upward thrust of stock value. Stay with your stocks.
19:19John Ford: Well for the people uh playing with leveraged ETFs and options, it's kind of hard to
19:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): say how
19:24John Ford: much they're up or down. But uh point taken, Professor, I appreciate it. And also Courtney Garcia and Malcolm Everich. Thank you. Let's get over to Oliver Rennick over at the SIBO Global Markets in Chicago taking a look at the aforementioned options action today. Oliver.
19:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey
19:42John Ford: John, we had a brief moment of calm that ended pretty quickly as stocks made new lows, but the relationship between VIX and the SP is still largely in sync as VIX is responding basically one-to-one as SPs keep going down, VIX keeps climbing. What's arguably more interesting to watch into the weekend is a vol on VIX itself. Keep in mind we have VIX. of VIX, which is known as the VIX. That index throughout today was relatively sluggish. So while we were repricing SP volatility dramatically through the VIX, the range expected for VIX itself was moving more slowly. VIX was making higher highs on the month, while VVX was under the month highs. It presents a bit of a Rorschach test for investors, where on one hand you can could look at that and say, VIX is unlikely to go too much higher. But I think the price action makes me see the other version of the picture, which is that we probably want to see V VIX really pop in order to signal a proper flush. John, back to you. Okay, flush.
20:42We'll see what ends up going down. Alvarenick, I'll reennic thank you. We are just getting started. Up next, more on this market sell-off as we close out the week. including Bitcoin below 60,000 for the first time in four months. We are live, the New York Stock Exchange. You're watching Closing Bell on CNBC.
21:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Which
21:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): NHL teams are scoring
21:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): big
21:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): off the ice. CNBC Sports Michael Ozanian has the numbers.
21:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
21:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a Dab Margin in the NHL
21:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): is right there with the NBA. Official NHL team valuations. See the full list at CNBC.com slash sport.
21:36John Ford: Welcome back. Let's get a check on the market. All the major averages are near session lows. You can see the Dow down more than 700 points. That's about 1.5%, not quite that bad. The NASDAQ is down uh four and three-quarters percent at the moment. The SP below 7,000, down three percent. We were just talking to Oliver Rennick, talking about the VIX, the volatility index, uh, a bit of a fear gauge. It's at 35. It was below 20, well below 20 for a long time until recently. Meanwhile, Bitcoin also getting hit today, crashing below 60,000. It's down, let's see, uh over the 24 hours, I think more than 5%. Tanae McKeel has more on that. Tanaeah?
22:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Hey John, yeah, let me start there with Bitcoin now at its lowest level since July, treating trading at the low end of the $58,000 range. Uh, this move started this morning when Bitcoin joined the broader market sell-off, and that down move triggered the surge in forced selling. I'm seeing on CoinGlass uh more than $500 million in liquidations of leveraged long positions just in the past four hours. And I'm already seeing some chatter about how the sell-off undermines Bitcoin's digital gold narrative. So just as a reminder to viewers, digital gold is the longer term investment thesis or a longer term investment thesis. If you subscribe to that, Bitcoin still can and usually does trade more like a risk asset day to day. So it sells off with equities as liquidity tightens, the dollar strengthens, and of course, um as leverage positions unwind. And Oh, yes. Over in crypto equities world, uh, there is a clear divide, which is something I've been noticing. on big market moving days like this. So take a look at the moves in Coinbase, Circle, and Bullish. These uh for much of today have been modest declines coming from names that represent the infrastructure side of the crypto industry that are building businesses around the crypto ecosystem. Uh, the gains, sorry, the losses kind of accelerating, but those have been more modest on the day compared to um what
23:38I want to show you next, which is the Treasury firm's strategy and Bitmine, as well as the exchange Gemini, which is more highly exposed to trading than other exchanges, John. These are businesses that carry higher sensitivity to price, to price, crypto treasury valuations, and of course investor risk appetite. So we are seeing a little bit of a repricing of the crypto ecosystem with more speculative and balance sheet sensitive. names taking the biggest hits today in crypto. John?
24:06John Ford: About that. Yeah, I was looking at strategy down about 8% right now. And I tend to think of it as being in that category of leverage bets. Now we've had retail investors uh getting into leverage ETS, making bets on tech, etc. Strategy was sort of um betting the farm on Bitcoin. And what happens to the farm? when you bet the farm on Bitcoin and the price keeps going down, is the question. Maybe that's the question that we see investors asking here, reflected in those particular names being down more?
24:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah, 100%. I think there is a lot of conviction from a lot of different parties behind strategy specifically. What's interesting is last summer, 2025, you did see all of these companies come out trying to copy. that strategy. And those are the ones that might be a little bit in trouble here. Strategy itself has, of course, been taking measures to ward off concerns around that. They've said very publicly and in their earnings reports that we need to be able to serve our shareholders in times like this. And we can't just, you know, rely on the price of Bitcoin to go up and up and up. So they're working on it. It's forever a concern. But at the end of the day, there is no Bitcoin Treasury company that's going to ever own as much Bitcoin as Treasury owns, uh as Strategy owns. Pardon me. So, you know, if you look at the Bitcoin outlook specifically, I think many are still bullish that we are going to get through this uh rocky transition from winter to summer. Uh that we're gonna see a bull market in 2027.
25:38and uh the concerns will kind of uh
25:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): start
25:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): to fade away. Um
25:43John Ford: yeah, we'll see how long this winter lasts, Tanea. Thank you. We are all over the sell-offs. Stock are getting slammed. You see the major averages there, they are near session lows across the board. One and a half down on the Dow, three plus down on the SP, but NASDAQ is down nearly five percent down SP or are in correction territory. Don't go anywhere. NASDAQ is in negative territory for the year. We got more closing bell after this quick break.
26:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): AI is here, transforming how we work, live, and lead. And the women I talk to aren't waiting for the future, they're shaping it. I'm Julia Borston, Borstin, Senior Media and Tech Correspondent at CNBC. This is CNBC Changemakers, where I talk with the female leaders transforming business as AI reshapes the world. Follow and listen to CNBC ChangeMakers, women leading in the age of AI, wherever you get your podcasts.
26:53John Ford: NASDAQ is now down more than five percent. The major averages all are now at session lows. So let's bring in New Edge Chief Investment Officer Cameron Dawson and head of macro research and strategy at the Schwab Center for Financial Research. Kevin Gordon, happy Friday, guys.
27:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Friday. Good
27:11John Ford: to have you. It is Friday for sure. Cameron, I believe you were looking for a support in the SP around 7,000, and we are now at 6926. So what's
27:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that mean?
27:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah, well, that escalated quickly. We wrote about 7,000 this morning and got there very quickly today. I do think that we are oversold enough for some kind of tactical or tactical or tradable low in the market, at least in the very short term. You can look at things like being externally oversold, look at your RSIs, internally oversold, like the names, a percentage of names above their 50 or 20-day moving averages, showing signs of some flush. You have the VIX spiking today to over 36, put call ratio spiking, showing that people really want downside protection. So all of this suggests that fear has spiked and there's indiscriminate selling, which suggests that probably we can see some kind of a bounce over the course of next week.
28:03John Ford: We could, but this seems like a market that is sensitive to a jump scare. And I'm looking at AMD as an example of that. There
28:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was
28:12John Ford: this Hunterbrook report. Um, there are a number of issues that I see with it as I've looked through it. I'm pretty familiar with AMD, but the market has reacted to it. You can see there, AMD is down another 13 and a half percent today. Granted, all of the AI. connected semiconductor names, infrastructure names are down, but AMD was already down before this. So that makes me wonder, even though all other things being equal, the market might be prime oversold, primed for a bounce. It's also primed for something else.
28:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): It's probably not the ultimate low, is how we would assess things. When we look at earnings estimates for 2027 and 2021. 2028, they look too high, and the market is actually telling you today that they are too high. Because if you look at how much valuations have compressed, the SP trading at 17 times, the stocks index, the semiconductors trading at 14 times, those kind of valuation multiples happen when the market is anticipating earnings cuts. And the lesson in past sell-offs is that you don't buy in anticipation of the cut, you buy the first cut once we actually start seeing estimates get cut. So that could potentially be why we see further lows in this market. But again, in the short term, we do think you can get a tradable bounce.
29:25John Ford: Kevin, so how do we position into the rest of the year? horrible, maybe nearly as horrible as yesterday. Yesterday was almost a complete washout if you look at you know the worst advanced decline spread day for the SP 500 so far this year. Today, yes, you do have more of a bid in the havens, especially if you take it out cross asset and you do look at the bond market finding a bid at the expense of the equity market, I would argue that's a good thing because it is showing that that relationship is sort of coming back into harmony after being
29:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in such a disconnect for for most of this year. But I still think from an you know from an earnings standpoint to Cameron's point, when you do look at what has been driving most of the earnings growth and the earnings share this year, it has definitively been tech. That's been well known for a while. But if you're looking at this from a valuation standpoint, you're trying to assess, okay, what multiple starts to look attractive for the market, keep in mind that almost 80% of the SP 500's PE decline this year has been driven by tech. So if you're going to kind of flip that on its head and look at the fact that maybe earnings estimates
30:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): do need to come down a little bit for next year, if
30:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
30:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): lot of that is concentrated. in
30:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
30:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): tech sector, your valuation analysis is not as strong in terms of making the argument
30:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
30:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): valuations are are more of a support here. But I would also add,
30:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when you
30:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): go back throughout history and the long history of the S P 500,
30:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um I
30:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): think nothing has been a worse market timing tool than valuations, because there is really no relationship between, you know, the
30:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one
30:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): year forward performance for for the market being the SP
30:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
30:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): where your starting point is for a multiple. So I would put maybe multiples down the list in terms of using it as this maybe you know sort of tradable bounce indicator.
30:56John Ford: What do you think,
30:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): though, about
30:58John Ford: sentiment? We we talk about the major averages. I very seldom pe uh hear people who I who I speak to every day have a deep conversation about the major averages. They might talk about the market, but then they talk about a stock. And right now, they're talking a lot about NVIDIA, Yeah. right? And they're talking a bit about NVIDIA. anthropic. And those stories are not clearly exciting stories as much as they would have seemed a month ago. So
31:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the sentiment
31:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): backdrop is interesting
31:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because
31:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I do think that you need to
31:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): maybe
31:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): bifurcate it a
31:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): bit into a
31:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): broader market, excluding
31:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): some
31:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of the AI megacaps,
31:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and then the AA
31:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): mega caps themselves.
31:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Just as a theme,
31:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): just broadly, if you kind of basketted them all together. And
31:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I say
31:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that because after we got the significant drawdown a couple days after. the election,
31:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you had seen not
31:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a sentiment washout and positioning.
31:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There was
31:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): actually, especially within the retail cohort, a lot of adding into that weakness,
31:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but kind
31:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of indiscriminately. Some of the strongest net purchase activity that we had seen, at least
31:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on a
31:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): single stock level, if you aggregate those AI names. So to me, what will be interesting after this week,
31:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): once we
31:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): get the positioning data settled after today, after the close,
32:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um, will be
32:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): if you started to see more of that positioning wash. washout. That's when you start to get the conditions that are,
32:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know, sort
32:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of the breeding ground for a bounce and a more durable bounce higher.
32:09John Ford: Cameron, uh a lot of the more disciplined investors at home are gonna be saying, ouch, this weekend, once things settle out, you know, tomorrow morning, looking at the portfolio. But then they're gonna be wondering first thing next week, is this a buying opportunity? And how do you know? I mean, aside from just yeah, things are cheaper than they used to be, what are the things that you watch to determine is this a good time to either start adding a little bit somewhere or to actually hold your nose and add a lot of something?
32:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Look, I think this is a great time to rely on technicals and not let the narrative or the fear take over. And so what we look for is signs of aggregate fear spiking. So I mentioned things like the put-call ratio being a really great indicator of that. That's how much people
32:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are.
32:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): willing to pay for downside protection versus upside optionality. So if everybody wants downside protection, it means that that fear is all the way on the one side of the boat. We look at other things like flush and breast breath metrics to get the sense of where there has been indiscriminate selling. It's likely after the close today that we will see signs of that. And then the last one is there's a great book by Walter Diemer, and the title of it is When it When the Time Comes to Buy, you won't want to. And that's always very important to remember.
33:19John Ford: So Kevin, uh along those lines of when it's time to jump in, I wonder about the impact of leverage this time around. When so many retail investors have been playing with it for the first time, when there's been so much kind of options dabbling, to what degree does that need to shift, wash out as an indicator? of uh some kind of market shift or capitulation? That
33:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that is one of the indicators, you know, when we sort of put together a checklist of what do you need to see for, you know, a sort of cyclical bear market to start to take hold. One of them is margin debt and the growth in it. Um it's not the level, because in level terms people always point to, oh, it's at an all-time high, this is a red warning sign. However, when you do look at the year year-to-year to year change, or we like to look at on a it 15 15-month change basis, um, that has peaked and is starting to roll over from this extreme optimism territory into a zone that is typically consistent with weaker returns and this kind of weakness lasting. Um, I I would add that if you are going into some sort of cyclical bear, um, I think the distinction between a recessionary and a non-recessionary one makes a big difference here because we have had more instances in the past four or five years. Call it the post-COVID environment.
34:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): where you there are at times you could be less constructive on the equity market, but still constructive on the economy. I think most of that is a function of the fact that we live in this mega cap dominated world where the indexes are still, you know, 40%-ish, you know, with the top ten large, largest members in the S P five hundred still commanding that share of the index. That's what happens, especially on a day like today when you've got massive weakness in tech.
34:48John Ford: I wonder to what degree, Cameron, we are seeing. certain relationships that have defined the market over the past few quarters loosening a bit, if not falling apart. I'm oversimplifying a bit. It felt a while like higher oil, higher rates, lower stocks. But now we've got lower oil, maybe not lower rates yet, but in a way, yes, but also lower stocks. So is that relationship broken? Are there other relationships? we should look for after that?
35:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): If you are wanting to look really, really closely for a silver lining in this market, it's that there are certain parts of consumer discretionary sock stocks that are actually holding up pretty well. Look at hotels, leisure, and cruise lines. Those stocks are not breaking down like we're seeing in other pockets of the market. So it seems like the market is saying, hey, if we get some rate relief, we get some oil relief. maybe consumers can have a better year after underperforming so much under these inflationary pressures. The one thing I'd watch though is that we have to appreciate that the S P 500 strength or broad market strength has been a key driver of the consumers' ability to continue to spend. We've been in a world where real income growth has been negative. Effectively, consumers' incomes are not keeping pace with overall inflation, but real spending. growth has been really positive. The gap between those two, we think is the wealth effect. So if you're in a more protracted bear market, it suggests that you lose the boost from the wealth effect, and that likely will weigh on overall consumption.
36:15John Ford: Kevin, that's why I think that I totally agree. And I that's why I think that duration matters a lot more than magnitude for bear markets in general. Because of that exposure that households have to the market, you're well behind. beyond where you were at the peak in 2000. That was sort of the prior high of all time. So the fact that you've got more of this exposure certainly, yes, helps on the upside when it's contributing to economic strength, especially when you have such weakness in real wage growth. But that, you know, if if turned enough, I mean if you do get enough of
36:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
36:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): protracted sell-off in terms of duration, Generation. that's I think where it can really start to eat away at economic growth. So that's why I think today, I don't think that there's sort of some imminent problem. pricing in from the market of a coming economic cliff. But if it lasts long enough, you could certainly find yourself in a position, you know, well into maybe the back half of 2027 where the economy does start to weaken and buckle a little bit, especially because you've got monetary tightening, but you also have fiscal tightening as well.
37:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
37:06John Ford: right, Kevin, Cameron, thank you. Maybe some Epsom salts, put on your comfy slippers, add it again next week. Now it's got a reset on the market with just over 15 minutes left. in the trading week. The Nasdaq still down more than 5%, touching fresh session lows. Let's get back to Mackenzie Cigalos with more on the tech sell-off. Mac.
37:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
37:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): John, that tech sell-off really gaining momentum going into the close. The Nasdaq 100 down more than 5%, with the broader Nasdaq wiping out its gains for the year. Anthropic on its first full day of trade down more than 10%, but it's really the chipmakers. taking the biggest hit here. NVIDIA plunging double digits on track for its seventh straight weekly decline, its longest losing streak since the 2008 financial crisis. The stock has lost $2.5 trillion in market value over that stretch. AMD also getting hammered alongside the company's building out AI infrastructure. Core Weave, one of the biggest winners of the AI boom, now down more than 70% from its peak. And the selling here is spreading beyond chips and data centers. Software is getting caught up in the broader repricing of tech, Palo Alto Networks, Adobe, among the names trading lower today. And then the bigger concern across the Mag 7, and especially that hyperscaler set, is whether the hundreds of billions of dollars being poured into AI infrastructure will generate enough revenue to justify the spending with investors no
38:25longer willing to give every company. tied to that build-out the benefit of the doubt here. John?
38:30John Ford: That's how it looks, Mac, for sure. Well, up next, we're gonna tell you what's working in today's sell-off. Flooding Bell. Be right back. Twelve minutes for the closing bell. Let's get back to Brandon Gomez for a look at the key sectors to watch. Brandon. Hey
39:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): there, John. Yeah, it can't be all doom and gloom with the major indices sliding, led by the drag on AI-related names. Let's take a look at some of the sectors that are actually holding up as relative winners. First up, consumer staples emerging as the best performing
39:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): sector today, led by McCormick, General Mills, and Kraft Heinz. The SP Consumer Staples metric is up just shy of 1%. You can see that today. And then next up, we have utility names: CMS Energy, American Electric Power, and Exelon Corporation. all edging higher. Others in the sector, Vistra, NRG Energy, and Constellation Energy, yes, in the red, still the SP utility sector flattening out for the day. And then finally, Healthcare. Some names rising after Humana and United Health received price target bumps from TD
39:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): due to a positive outlook on Medicare advantage plans. The upgrades seem to lift other healthcare names, including CVS Johnson Johnson, as well as Bristol Myers. You can see they're pretty flat right now, John. Yeah,
40:05John Ford: Walmart and Home Depot also higher today. Last time I checked. Brandon, thanks. We are all over this sell-off as we head into the final minutes of the trading week. Market jump is next. We are now in the closing bell market zone. Mike Santori Santoli and Fair Leads, Katie Stockton, are here to break down these crucial moments. of the trading day. Plus, Oliver Rennick is standing by live from SIBO Global Markets in Chicago. Mike Santoli, yesterday the bell rang for the biggest IPO ever, and the rest of the market fell out of bed this morning and the rest of the day. It has continued to fall. We're down 5% on the Nasdaq. You would think the rest of the Nasdaq would be happy for anthropic. What happened? Yeah, uh it's totally plausible to think that actually it would be celebrated, it would be considered a pretty much a vote of confidence in the overall AI trade. And it's instead being seen as essentially, you know, insiders uh getting liquidity into uh a very wounded tape, obviously, mostly because of semiconductors and related AI stocks. You know, semis are going undergoing this urgent crisis of faith because
41:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): uh the fact that they were down and they looked cheap and they had two straight quarters of absolutely fabulous earnings, and even NVIDIA had pretty good results and guidance, and no everyone is saying nothing has happened on the demand side to justify this. That means prices are kind of moving without much fundamental rationale in a lot of people's minds. I don't mean that they're overdone. I mean we're just unwinding an extreme heavy. concentration in semis, and that has kind of buckled uh really the the main growth engine of this bull market. So I do think that's what we're dealing with right now. Now it's a matter of have we gotten to, you know, messy extremes? Have we really overshot to the downside? Maybe in the short term, we absolutely have. Uh and I think that's gonna be what we look to for the for the coming days to see if it was if we've reached a point where it's enough for now. I don't know what that catalyst might be that start to you know puncture this uh this feedback
42:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): loop that's uh that's gotten uh stocks
42:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just
42:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): selling off this way. But you know, the tricky part is the semiconductor index is down forty-three percent from its highs, but it's up almost forty percent on a 12-month basis. So you still have gains in there, people feel like they're protecting into year end. It makes it a tricky setup.
42:26John Ford: For sure. And we know you'll have more coming up on overtime. Now to Oliver Rennick over at SIBO. You know, mid-30s for the picks, huh?
42:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
42:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): John,
42:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a very intense close here. Bear market territory for the Nasdaq futures from the highs. Something that in theory could help stabilize things is options on Anthropic, which are expected to begin trading Monday. With yesterday's 20% swing in the stock. 10% right now. It's kind of a textbook case for the need for hedging tools, which can help tame what has come out of the gate an even wilder beast than SpaceX. Ant options will be extremely expensive, not just because Anthropic's volatility is massive, but because market volatility overall is also now huge. But regardless, expensive. expect inelastic demand, not just because anthropic employees will be clamoring for these options, but because everybody right now, as you can hear behind me, are clamoring for options of all forms.
43:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,
43:29John Ford: yeah, Oliver Rennick. Week for sure and a holiday week, a short week. Now it's bringing Katie Stockton. Katie, um, I I almost just want to throw my hands up like this. And do the charts tell us anything that makes us feel differently? I want to mention now that Nasdaq is now down five and a half percent, which I believe is a new session low, uh, to clarify what's really going on here.
43:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Well, of course, if we were to see a reversal, we'd want to see a much better close, and it looks like the NASDAQ 100 is in store. for today. It is a pending breakdown, and that's something that we're seeing on a widespread basis. It's still localized, of course, to the AI trade, semiconductor stocks, and especially NVIDIA. I believe NVIDIA's contribution to the decline today is pretty major, something close to a quarter of the decline in the SP S P 500. So I do think that that's the stock to watch. still from a bottom up perspective. And it has broken down below some key support on the chart, meaning that it has broken its long term uptrend going back to the 2022 lows. And now we have to think about relief rallies as counter trend, meaning they will present a better selling opportunity as opposed to looking at this downdraft perhaps as an opportunity. to add long-term exposure back to the semiconductor space. So it changes our paradigm in a way for this sector in particular. And we'll have to see if the SP 500 follows suit.
45:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
45:03John Ford: wanted to ask you specifically about NVIDIA because we're getting pretty close, I believe, to the point where NVIDIA is off 50% from its all-time highs just six weeks ago. We're not there. yet, but I think we're just a couple of bucks a share away. What's the significance of that kind of drop for a company that also had the quality of earnings and guidance that it just did this week?
45:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Well, from a sentiment perspective, it's a really big deal. And you can see that in what we call the market internal measures. There's measures of sentiment like the Fear and Greed Index, and of course. the VIX today, that that sentiment really surrounds NVIDIA and the anthropic IPO, that's carrying over into transactions. So it's showing that skittishness in the marketplace. But we do look at that at least in the short term from a contrarian perspective. So even the deep decline in NVIDIA with this strength behind the down move, it's actually something that could snap back pretty quickly. and tends to do that when emotions are running as high as they are.
46:07John Ford: Two minutes to go, less than that, until the closing bell. Katie, I wonder what characterizes uh what we tend to see in the last you know month plus of the year as we're looking at the end of Q4, and what signs will you be looking for in that for where things are headed?
46:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I think it's key that we see a rebound initiate next week. It doesn't have to be a huge rebound, but there are typically positive seasonal influences around the Thanksgiving holiday for one, and that would show a reaction to the oversold indications that we do have and that are widespread on a short term basis, referencing things like the DeMarc Mark indicators for the semiconductor stock. So we should see a pretty immediate reaction. I understand that. people wouldn't want to be holding a lot of risk perhaps over the weekend, especially with Bitcoin down near support, testing its own support level. So we want to see that immediate reaction. And if we do, then that would bode well for a strong finish to the year that could at least allow us to put out some hedges and have a better That selling are opportunity for the segments of the markets that have broken down.
47:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
47:13John Ford: viewers are now seeing on their screen. screens that the Dow for the first time today is down more than a thousand points as we're seconds away from the close. The SP down nearly four percent, and the NASDAQ down close to five and a half percent. That's a rough way to end the week. Katie Stockton, thank you. Of course, all of this raises the questions of what's to come next week: a short week, a holiday week, or with that. Thanksgiving, as Katie Stockton just laid out for us. Will the AI trade rebound? Will other areas take over? We'll have to wait and see. Uh, that's gonna do it for now for closing bell. We're gonna send it over into overtime with Minister Lee and Mike Timpoli.
48:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Which NHL teams are scoring better? big
48:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): off the ice? CNBC Sports Michael Ozanian has the numbers.
48:07John Ford: If a dab margin in the NHL is right there with the NBA.
48:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Official NHL team valuations. See the full list at CNBC.com slash sport.