Demba Nyay on asset allocation importance, Halal diversification, and portfolio construction constraints
Summary
Host Moneem Salam interviews Demba Nyay, Head of Wealth Management at Saturda Capital, about the critical role of asset allocation in investing. Nyay argues that allocation decisions, rather than security selection, drive the majority of portfolio returns and should be tailored to an investor's time horizon and total financial picture. The discussion highlights the expansion of Halal investment vehicles, such as Sukuk and screened equities, which now allow for comprehensive diversification. Nyay also critiques traditional rules like 'age in bonds' and emphasizes the importance of asset location and managing client expectations during market downturns.
Episode sections
- 0:01 – 2:52
Introduction and Guest Background
Host Moneem Salam introduces guest Demba Nyay, Head of Wealth Management at Saturda Capital, to discuss asset allocation. Nyay outlines his 25-year career, starting at Lloyd Tentush in the early 2000s and joining Capital One in 2006 prior to the financial crisis.
- 2:52 – 6:03
The Importance of Early Asset Allocation
Nyay argues that asset allocation should be considered from the beginning of an investor's journey because circumstances change. He defines portfolio theory as investing in assets that behave differently to reduce risk, noting that long-term historical studies are less relevant than managing correlation in the current environment.
- 6:03 – 10:52
Defining Asset Classes and Diversification Vehicles
The speakers define equities, fixed income (Sukuk), real estate, private equity, venture capital, and commodities like gold. Nyay explains that pooled vehicles like mutual funds and ETFs are essential for individual investors to gain exposure to these classes, particularly Sukuk, which often have high minimum investment thresholds.
- 10:52 – 13:31
Portfolio Construction Across Life Stages
Nyay suggests young investors can hold high equity exposure (e.g., 90%) due to long time horizons, while older investors may need more fixed income. He critiques the 'age in bonds' rule, arguing that longevity means many retirees still have decades of investment horizon and should maintain equity exposure for growth.
- 13:31 – 15:22
Asset Location and Holistic Planning
Nyay emphasizes 'asset location,' the strategy of placing assets in appropriate tax-advantaged accounts (Roth, 401k) versus taxable accounts. He stresses that advisors must consider the client's total financial picture, including illiquid assets like real estate and business ownership, when determining allocation.
- 15:22 – 21:23
Managing Client Expectations and Loss Aversion
Nyay addresses the common client complaint of underperforming the S&P 500 due to diversification. He notes that Muslim investors are particularly loss-averse, preferring upside participation but reacting strongly to downside risk, requiring education on the protective role of diversification during market downturns.
- 21:23 – 28:44
Portfolio Optimization and Forecasting Challenges
Nyay explains mean-variance optimization, which uses historical data and forecasts to balance risk and return. He highlights the difficulty of forecasting, citing the S&P 500 P/E ratio rising from historical averages of 18-20 to 25, which skews return expectations and requires practitioner experience to adjust.
- 28:44 – 32:37
Constraints and the Brinson Study
To prevent over-diversification or excessive exposure to risky assets like small caps, Nyay uses constraints in optimization, such as requiring 80% US-based allocation for US investors. He cites the Brinson study claiming 90% of return variability is due to asset allocation, later clarified by Boston and Kaplan to mean 40% of variability between two portfolios.
- 32:37 – 33:51
Asset Allocation Dominance
Speaker 1 states that 90% to 100% of a single portfolio's return is determined by asset allocation decisions, such as choosing between equities, fixed income, or gold, rather than security selection. This includes offsets from transaction costs.
- 33:51 – 34:25
Islamic Asset Availability
The discussion shifts to whether Halal investors can achieve full diversification comparable to traditional institutional investors. Speaker 1 confirms this is now possible due to industry growth over the last 15-20 years.
- 34:25 – 35:55
Specific Halal Asset Classes
Speaker 1 details available Halal assets, including Sukuk from Southeast Asia and the Middle East, screened equities via Saturday Capital, cash alternatives, private equity, venture capital, and Halal REITs.
- 35:55 – 36:21
Dynamic Allocation Framework
Asset allocation is described as an evolving framework rather than a one-time decision, allowing investors to incorporate new Halal exposure as the industry develops.
- 36:21 – 40:23
Personal Practice and Conclusion
Speaker 1 confirms they personally asset allocate their portfolio, citing the importance of broad exposure to different asset classes. The host summarizes the episode's key takeaways regarding Halal diversification.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| BitcoinBTC | crypto | neutral | Do they get Bitcoin? |
| Gold | commodity | neutral | Do they get gold? |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Demba Nyay has been in the industry for about 25 years, starting at Lloyd Tentush in the early 2000s and joining Capital One in 2006.
Unidentified speaker ·1:46
How to verify: Check Demba Nyay's LinkedIn profile or professional biography on Saturda Capital's website for employment history and dates.
Sukuk often have minimum investment requirements of around $250,000.
Unidentified speaker ·9:49
How to verify: Review prospectuses or offering documents for major Sukuk funds or Islamic finance products to confirm minimum investment thresholds.
The S&P 500 P/E ratio used to be around 18 to 20 but is now running at 25.
Unidentified speaker ·24:51
How to verify: Check historical P/E ratio data for the S&P 500 from sources like Yardeni Research, Shiller CAPE, or S&P Dow Jones Indices.
The Brinson study from the early 90s attributed 90% of portfolio return variability to asset allocation.
Unidentified speaker ·31:08
How to verify: Locate the original study by Brinson, Hood, and Beebower (1986) or Brinson, Singer, and Beebower (1991) in financial literature databases.
A later study by Boston and Kaplan in the early 2000s clarified that asset allocation explains 40% of the variability in returns between two portfolios.
Unidentified speaker ·31:47
How to verify: Search for academic papers by Boston and Kaplan from the early 2000s discussing the attribution of portfolio returns and variability.
Nyay spent the better part of the last 15-16 years in wealth management at Capital One.
Unidentified speaker ·2:09
How to verify: Verify Nyay's employment tenure at Capital One via his professional bio or SEC filings if he was a registered representative.
Investors in the Muslim community are noted to be more loss-averse than other risk-averse groups.
Unidentified speaker ·17:21
How to verify: This is a subjective observation by the speaker; verify by looking for academic studies on behavioral finance differences among demographic groups, though this is a claim of observation rather than a hard fact.
Mean-variance optimization is the method used to optimize portfolios by looking at historical performance and forecasting.
Unidentified speaker ·23:34
How to verify: Review standard finance textbooks or investment management firm white papers explaining mean-variance optimization methodology.
Nyay started his career at Lloyd Tentush in the tax department's wealth management practice.
Unidentified speaker ·1:53
How to verify: Check Lloyd Tentush's corporate history or Nyay's professional biography for details on his first role.
The speaker suggests that a 22-year-old having 20% in fixed income seems pretty high.
Unidentified speaker ·12:51
How to verify: This is a subjective opinion expressed by the speaker; it reflects a deviation from the traditional 'age in bonds' rule.
90% of portfolio return is determined by asset allocation, potentially up to 100% when considering transaction cost offsets.
Unidentified speaker ·32:37
How to verify: Verify via the Brinson, Hood, and Beebower study (1986) or subsequent literature on asset allocation attribution analysis.
Saturday Capital screens about 5,000 names on the equity size.
Unidentified speaker ·35:02
How to verify: Check Saturday Capital's website or investor presentations for their screening methodology and universe size.
The Sukuk industry has developed significantly in the last 15-20 years, particularly in Southeast Asia and the Middle East.
Unidentified speaker ·34:25
How to verify: Review Islamic Finance Global reports or World Bank Sukuk issuance data for historical trends in these regions.
Amana Mutual Funds limit securities to those consistent with Islamic principles.
Unidentified speaker ·40:01
How to verify: Read the Amana Mutual Funds prospectus or summary prospectus available at www.amanafunds.com.
Performance data quoted in the podcast represents past performance and is no guarantee of future results.
Unidentified speaker ·38:58
How to verify: Review standard mutual fund disclaimer language in Amana Mutual Funds prospectuses.
Do your own research
- Verify the current S&P 500 P/E ratio against historical averages to assess Nyay's claim about skewed return expectations.
- Review the Brinson study and subsequent analyses by Boston and Kaplan to understand the statistical basis for allocation's impact on returns.
- Check minimum investment requirements for specific Sukuk issuances to confirm accessibility for individual investors.
- Evaluate Saturda Capital's equity screening methodology and the resulting universe of approved Halal stocks.
- Assess personal tax situation and illiquid asset holdings to determine if 'asset location' strategies align with individual circumstances.
- Research the performance of Halal equity indices versus traditional indices to understand potential performance gaps due to screening constraints.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:01
- Unidentified speaker: Welcome to Halal Money Matter, sponsored by Saturda Capital.
- 0:04
- Unidentified speaker: I'm Moneem Salam.
- 0:06
- Unidentified speaker: You know, when a lot of people talk about the fact that when they're making investments, do they only go into 100% equities?
- 0:12
- Unidentified speaker: Do they get Bitcoin?
- 0:14
- Unidentified speaker: Do they get gold?
- 0:15
- Unidentified speaker: And what temp typically ends up happening is that um whatever whatever the latest craze is, whatever it's in the news, whatever's going up, they always ask me the question, should I really be in this, in this, in this uh asset class?
- 0:28
- Unidentified speaker: And so today uh we're joined by uh Demba Nyay, uh and uh he's our uh uh Saturn Capital's uh head of uh uh wealth management.
- 0:37
- Unidentified speaker: Um he's gonna be talking about asset allocation, right?
- 0:40
- Unidentified speaker: Let's we'll take it from both perspectives.
- 0:42
- Unidentified speaker: Number one is why it's important for you to have uh um your all your assets maybe allocated not just in one basket, but in multiple of the baskets, what those baskets look like and how they perform over time.
- 0:54
- Unidentified speaker: And then uh towards the end of it, we'll try to get into a little bit about the mechanics and really talk to Demba about how these these kind of asset allocations are created.
- 1:04
- Unidentified speaker: So I'm really excited to have Demba on this on this podcast.
- 1:07
- Unidentified speaker: And uh welcome Demba.
- 1:08
- Unidentified speaker: As salamu alaikum.
- 1:09
- Unidentified speaker: Alaikum salamu rahmatullah.
- 1:11
- Unidentified speaker: Thank you so much for having me, Maneem.
- 1:13
- Unidentified speaker: I am uh really excited uh about the conversation.
- 1:16
- Unidentified speaker: Um as a as a practitioner um in this industry for a long time, I think um asset allocation um gets overlooked oftentimes, and um it's actually one of the one of the foundations of of investing.
- 1:32
- Unidentified speaker: So I'm glad we're having this conversation today.
- 1:33
- Unidentified speaker: Look forward to absolutely.
- 1:34
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, and and you did talk about your extensive background because just briefly, if you can tell us a little bit about uh you know your your experience at Capital One, maybe before that or after that, that'll be great.
- 1:45
- Unidentified speaker: Appreciate that.
- 1:46
- Unidentified speaker: So yes, I I I have been in the in the industry for about um 25 odd years.
- 1:53
- Unidentified speaker: I um I actually started uh with the Lloyd Tentush, the accounting firm, which um so happened had a wealth management practice in in um in the tax department.
- 2:05
- Unidentified speaker: Um so um really started there in the early 2000.
- 2:09
- Unidentified speaker: Then as you mentioned, I joined Capital One in 06, um, right before the crisis, uh if you remember, and spent the better part of the uh last 15, 16 years in in wallet management, providing investment solutions for our investor investor base.
- 2:25
- Unidentified speaker: You know, that's great.
- 2:26
- Unidentified speaker: So uh thanks for the background.
- 2:28
- Unidentified speaker: So let's let's jump right in.
- 2:30
- Unidentified speaker: Um, you know, I mean that I think that probably my my first question would be, you know, is like I we always tell people, or so you know, whenever I'm talking to people, I always tell them, you know, if they're young, like basically open up a Roth account, uh, open up a taxable account, whatever it is, just buy buy some funds and just keep keep uh you know investing every single year because that's gonna grow over the long term.
- 2:52
- Unidentified speaker: So um, you know, is asset allocation important very, very early on as well as later, or does it come later?
- 2:58
- Unidentified speaker: And what it when when when do you need to start thinking about asset allocation?
- 3:03
- Unidentified speaker: I think you should uh from the beginning.
- 3:06
- Unidentified speaker: And the reason why I say that is that your circumstances are gonna change.
- 3:10
- Unidentified speaker: Yes, that um younger investor starting out um is probably gonna have exposures that are going to be different from someone later in life.
- 3:20
- Unidentified speaker: Uh, but that asset allocation um consideration should be uh paramount from from the from the start on, I guess.
- 3:29
- Unidentified speaker: And so then in that case, let's define what asset allocation is then so the idea here is um um and um maybe if I could go back, so the the um uh portfolio theory is is um is based on the fact that um investing in assets that are uh that behave differently is a good idea.
- 3:53
- Unidentified speaker: But the simple fact that if you take a particular asset class, it may be risky on itself, but marrying that with something that behaves differently will reduce risk.
- 4:04
- Unidentified speaker: So it's important that as the onset, you know, or select which asset classes you want to invest in in determining how you're gonna allocate your your funds.
- 4:14
- Unidentified speaker: So I mean, I think and then the studies that would that there are there always talk about, you know, well, if if you invest your assets for 100 years, this would have been the rate of return, you know, those type of things.
- 4:24
- Unidentified speaker: But you know, to be honest with you, nobody lives 100 years.
- 4:26
- Unidentified speaker: And so like that's probably not a good good measure of of what you're supposed to be doing.
- 4:31
- Unidentified speaker: The second thing is that after 2008, or maybe even if you want to go back earlier, as we get into the zero interest rate environment, it seemed like all asset classes were performing lockstap and borough, right?
- 4:43
- Unidentified speaker: In correlation, they call it when everything when something's going up, everything goes up, and when something goes down, everything goes down.
- 4:48
- Unidentified speaker: So is ad-cell allocation still important, even in an environment where everything's going up or everything is going down at the same time.
- 4:56
- Unidentified speaker: Well, so so uh actually that's that's very key because um the key inside is that different diversification benefits from from uh correlation or um um not being in a single asset class.
- 5:10
- Unidentified speaker: But having said that, yes, uh there's been uh correlation um if you take equities and fixed income more than historically.
- 5:20
- Unidentified speaker: Um but um investments don't don't just um um stop at those two uh broad asset classes.
- 5:29
- Unidentified speaker: There are other um that add lower volatility to the portfolio that should be considered.
- 5:35
- Unidentified speaker: But yes, so to answer your question, there's been greater correlation um in um in recent memory compared to historically, but that does not um um um hide the fact that um diversification still matters uh when it comes to investing.
- 5:53
- Unidentified speaker: Okay.
- 5:54
- Unidentified speaker: So Baba, and when we're talking about asset allocation, I mean it's I think we should go back and really define, you know, what are the different types of assets and what do they actually look like?
- 6:03
- Unidentified speaker: So, you know, you might have equities, which are like just basically buying stocks uh in the market, you know, for you know, different multi publicly traded companies.
- 6:12
- Unidentified speaker: Um you can have fixed income, which for Muslims looks like a sukuk.
- 6:16
- Unidentified speaker: Um it's it's an income certificate where you're you know either exposed to real estate or some kind of commodity and those type of things.
- 6:23
- Unidentified speaker: But what other asset classes are there um that that that you can put into a portfolio?
- 6:28
- Unidentified speaker: It's a very good question.
- 6:31
- Unidentified speaker: So um, yeah, obviously, you know, um uh equities, as you mentioned, and fixing the fundamentals of um um of uh portfolio construction.
- 6:41
- Unidentified speaker: But one thing that we we should always keep in mind is the assets themselves don't need to be um low risk or low risk on an individual basis.
- 6:52
- Unidentified speaker: They just need to move differently at different times to add value to the portfolio.
- 6:58
- Unidentified speaker: So that's where um some um liquid assets, for example, such as um um real estate, um, private equity, uh venture capital can add value to a portfolio.
- 7:10
- Unidentified speaker: Um, commodities is another example, having gold or um other uh sort of similar uh asset classes um that have low volatility, that don't move uh as much as um equities and fixed income do, are uh other asset classes that one could uh consider.
- 7:29
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, and so if I think for an for a for an investor, I mean I think one thing they look at is like, for example, you might have jewelry at home gold.
- 7:38
- Unidentified speaker: Your house itself, if you're owning it or you're on a on a hall mortgage, that's considered your real estate.
- 7:43
- Unidentified speaker: You know, all of these things have to be looked into it from a totality uh when you're thinking about your asset allocation, correct?
- 7:50
- Unidentified speaker: That is correct.
- 7:51
- Unidentified speaker: And then uh so um, as you know, one of the first things we do when we speak to uh to a prospect or a client is um uh talk about doing a financial plan.
- 8:02
- Unidentified speaker: That gives us a an overall or holistic picture of all of their assets.
- 8:08
- Unidentified speaker: Uh, we may not manage all of it um at Satana, but we want to uh take that into consideration as to make when we make a recommendation.
- 8:17
- Unidentified speaker: So all of the assets that you have, um, whether physical or illiquid, are taken into consideration when making recommendations to how you allocate um your funds.
- 8:28
- Unidentified speaker: So, you know, when we're talking about asset allocation, we talked about like equities and stocks or fixed income in Sequo.
- 8:35
- Unidentified speaker: Um, you know, one way to do it is to be able to buy individual stocks, but you probably need a larger portfolio to do that.
- 8:41
- Unidentified speaker: So, what's another way that people can get exposure to uh stocks and also of sequ without having to individually go in and buy?
- 8:51
- Unidentified speaker: That is a very good question, especially when it comes to that ladder, um, the the Sukuk fixed income side.
- 8:57
- Unidentified speaker: Um, you know, it's it's um very difficult for an individual going to the market and doing that themselves with their portfolios.
- 9:05
- Unidentified speaker: So it's important that we have the proper vehicle to give you those exposures.
- 9:10
- Unidentified speaker: Handle that today, you can have mutual funds or ETFs that are pooled vehicles that you can use as a means of actually fulfilling that allocation and uh and on the equity side also.
- 9:22
- Unidentified speaker: So having those pooled vehicles that are very liquid, readily tradable is an important part of actually implementing those asset allocation decisions.
- 9:31
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, so I guess another way to look at it is saying, like, you know, with small amounts of money, you can get into a basket of stocks, like rather than just one, you can do all of them.
- 9:39
- Unidentified speaker: And then on the uh secook side, it's actually even more important because I think the minimum, like so sometimes to buy a what uh a sukuk is like $250,000.
- 9:49
- Unidentified speaker: So how are you going to do that for $5,000 or $10,000 or even $25,000?
- 9:53
- Unidentified speaker: So using a vehicle like a mutual fund actually helps you to be able to get that diversification to have an asset allocation, but with small amounts of money.
- 10:04
- Unidentified speaker: Totally.
- 10:04
- Unidentified speaker: And that's that's what our fixed income team here, for example, as a turner, does they'll they'll create the pool vehicle using you know um the funds that are put together and are able to build uh within their mutual funds or ETF portfolios that are fully diversified that we can in turn use to implement our asset allocation decisions.
- 10:24
- Unidentified speaker: Yes.
- 10:25
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, great.
- 10:26
- Unidentified speaker: And and one last thing, since you since you mentioned this, I will mention also um is that, well, maybe not the last thing, but just judge definitely uh something I want to mention is that I think you brought up a good point.
- 10:37
- Unidentified speaker: I think it's important for us, maybe in a future episode, to talk about the differences between mutual funds and ETFs, which are called exchange traded funds.
- 10:45
- Unidentified speaker: So thank you for reminding me about that.
- 10:46
- Unidentified speaker: And hopefully our listeners can look forward to that uh episode as well.
- 10:52
- Unidentified speaker: So, what does a portfolio for somebody who's just starting off?
- 10:55
- Unidentified speaker: Let's say they got their first job, right?
- 10:57
- Unidentified speaker: Now they're gonna open up a kind of like a let's say a Roth or in their 401k.
- 11:02
- Unidentified speaker: And we're talking just different asset classes.
- 11:04
- Unidentified speaker: Let's not talk about specific investments, but just different asset classes.
- 11:08
- Unidentified speaker: What does it look like for uh a person starting off, person in the middle of their career, and now approaching retirement?
- 11:16
- Unidentified speaker: So so for someone um um just starting to invest, it may very well be appropriate to be very high in uh inequities.
- 11:26
- Unidentified speaker: Uh and the reason why we say that is that their their investment horizon, if you if you look at um the time they're gonna spend working, um 30, 40 odd years, the time they're gonna spend in retirement, they do have enough, uh a long enough time horizon to survive through different market cycles.
- 11:46
- Unidentified speaker: So there may very well be appropriate for them to be heavily uh invested in equities.
- 11:53
- Unidentified speaker: Um as um as your career progresses and um your income also increases, um it may be appropriate to start um um adding other asset classes that are going to govern how your portfolio is gonna is gonna is gonna behave.
- 12:10
- Unidentified speaker: As you come through, uh as you get closer to retirement, um, it may be that um heavy exposures to equity is not as appropriate as it has been in in the past.
- 12:21
- Unidentified speaker: So, like for example, I know I remember uh when I was an advisor way back when um you know there was a rule that said, you know, take your age, and that's how much should be in fixed income or cash, and then the rest of it should be in equities.
- 12:36
- Unidentified speaker: And then but but even then I I find, and now I'm in the market, so might be a little bit more aggressive, but I find even that part of it, let's say if I'm 22 and I'm just getting a job, you know, 20% in fixed income when you're 22 years old, it seems pretty high.
- 12:51
- Unidentified speaker: It does seem pretty high.
- 12:53
- Unidentified speaker: I and I would um not necessarily with that.
- 12:57
- Unidentified speaker: Um I I I think that for for an investor starting out, it's um it's a matter of um uh first of all, establishing your willingness to accept risk, uh, be cognizant of that.
- 13:10
- Unidentified speaker: But at that age, I think um most of the asset allocation decisions should be driven by your ability to take on risk.
- 13:17
- Unidentified speaker: And I'll go back to your investment horizon being uh 50, 60 years, um, that should really be driving uh your asset allocation decisions uh uh more so than your willingness to take risk or any other sort of uh combinations.
- 13:31
- Unidentified speaker: And I think the other thing to remember is that uh asset allocation is not only, for example, we talked about it in your Roth account or 401k, but really it's your overall financial picture, right?
- 13:41
- Unidentified speaker: So, for example, you might be in your Roth 100% in equities, but then have real estate that you have because you're you know owning a house, and you might have a bank account that has cash in it.
- 13:52
- Unidentified speaker: So though you should look at it on a on an overall basis, correct?
- 13:55
- Unidentified speaker: Rather than just your stock portfolio or your investment account.
- 13:59
- Unidentified speaker: Totally, totally agree with that.
- 14:00
- Unidentified speaker: And and that's something that oftentimes gets overlooked, and we refer to it as asset location.
- 14:06
- Unidentified speaker: Um, where should you have um your portfolio?
- 14:09
- Unidentified speaker: So, yes, um, you you may have a a 401k at work, you may invest in in an IRA itself, those are tax advantage accounts, there's certain securities and um portion of your portfolios that should be located there.
- 14:25
- Unidentified speaker: Um, you you as we look at the you know your your full financial picture, for example, um your your house, uh, if you own a business, um, you may want to have an LLC.
- 14:37
- Unidentified speaker: So where you locate your assets, uh, depending on your own sort of investment objectives, goals, and your situation matters also just as asset allocation itself does.
- 14:49
- Unidentified speaker: So you can you can technically have a hundred percent equity portfolio in your in your retirement account because you have other assets that are lying somewhere else in another location, as you mentioned.
- 15:01
- Unidentified speaker: Absolutely.
- 15:01
- Unidentified speaker: And all of that has to be considered by your advisor in sort of making a recommendation.
- 15:06
- Unidentified speaker: It's very important.
- 15:07
- Unidentified speaker: Yes, that um asset allocation is part of the the equation, but asset location is equally as important.
- 15:13
- Unidentified speaker: So, and then the other the other part of this, which is I get I get questions all the time, is you know, uh it's like you have an uh um, let's say an asset allocated portfolio.
- 15:22
- Unidentified speaker: So you have some uh uh equity, maybe you have a little bit of uh fixed income in the form of sukuk, maybe you have some cash, um, and maybe some alternatives like your commodities or real estate, stuff like that, right?
- 15:33
- Unidentified speaker: But then what people tend to do is like I'd say, oh my God, look, the SP is up like 25%, and my portfolio is only up 12%.
- 15:42
- Unidentified speaker: What are you doing wrong?
- 15:43
- Unidentified speaker: And so it's a constant kind of a back and forth with the with clients and people to uh to talk about a difference between asset allocation and what the SP is doing, because that's what most people you know remember when the markets are going up and down.
- 15:56
- Unidentified speaker: So, how would you kind of talk to somebody about um you know how to look at those two differences?
- 16:02
- Unidentified speaker: So um and this is the part where I think we as um sort of as an industry need to do a better job as um as educators, because um having someone look at uh um a single equity benchmark and comparing their portfolio is not really um how they should look at it.
- 16:22
- Unidentified speaker: Um you you give you an example of someone has a diversified portfolio, their blended returns is going to be vastly different um from a pure equity um portfolio.
- 16:35
- Unidentified speaker: Now, the way I would address that, um, and it's uh it may uh sound uh counterintuitive, is that um markets do go up, markets do go down.
- 16:46
- Unidentified speaker: Um the the benefit of having that diversification is when uh things don't always go up, and um your portfolio, when it's if it's properly built, will give you that protection that maybe a pure equity portfolio won't give you.
- 17:02
- Unidentified speaker: So part of the education is um having those conversations about the entire um uh cycle, not only, not always uh when markets go up.
- 17:12
- Unidentified speaker: That's the conversation we need to have our with our clients more often.
- 17:16
- Unidentified speaker: And um and when you have these, how receptive are our clients to that?
- 17:21
- Unidentified speaker: So it's an interesting my my uh uh what I've noted is that our investor base, especially in the Muslim community, are um more loss averse than other risk averse.
- 17:34
- Unidentified speaker: And the way I see it is that um they don't mind uh the upside, they want to participate as much as possible.
- 17:41
- Unidentified speaker: But then when things turn down, they were like, Wow, why didn't you tell me I was exposed to these risks?
- 17:47
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, so they don't like the lost part uh as much as they appreciate the the upside.
- 17:52
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I think that's pretty much across the board the human beings.
- 17:55
- Unidentified speaker: That's that's what everybody wants the good stuff, nobody wants the bad stuff.
- 17:58
- Unidentified speaker: So it's I think that's that's that's pretty uh pretty pretty common.
- 18:01
- Unidentified speaker: But I think that that's that's really important to keep in mind is that you know it's it's it's actually asset allocation is a lot about risk mitigation, right?
- 18:09
- Unidentified speaker: It's about you know when what happens when the markets are going down and down, not only when they're going up.
- 18:16
- Unidentified speaker: And so it that's the really important, and it's a kind of a constant reminder that needs to be needs to take place with the with you know with the clients and stuff like that.
- 18:23
- Unidentified speaker: Um, from doing that.
- 18:25
- Unidentified speaker: Um, okay, so um, you know, so now we talked a little bit about um you know the importance of the asset allocation.
- 18:30
- Unidentified speaker: Um we talked a little bit about you know, maybe from a uh you know, from a from a younger to a middle to an older.
- 18:36
- Unidentified speaker: Can you give us some ballparks of what you think a younger person versus a middle-aged person versus a someone you know closer to retirement or in retirement, but roughly what the numbers look like as far as asset allocation is concerned?
- 18:48
- Unidentified speaker: Sure.
- 18:49
- Unidentified speaker: But you know, I I also have to preface this with the fact that you know every individual circuit circumstance is um um um is different.
- 18:57
- Unidentified speaker: Uh um, but for someone that's just starting out investing, um uh having a portfolio that's close to 90% in equity is is um is is okay because like I said, they will go through different market cycles, they'll have the time to uh to um to benefit from upsides and then they'll rebound from from from downside.
- 19:21
- Unidentified speaker: And uh the interesting part I'll I'll also say is that even uh deep into your career, one can also have um um exposures to equity that that's um above average.
- 19:34
- Unidentified speaker: Um the reason why I say that is that we live longer, we we um we have needs into retirement that are going to be um substantial.
- 19:45
- Unidentified speaker: So having that equity exposure um um is also important to maintain.
- 19:52
- Unidentified speaker: I was just speaking recently to someone that was in his early 50s and was thinking about starting to downgrade or de-risk their portfolio by adding fixed income um at that age, but yet that person still has 30 years of investment in front of them on average.
- 20:10
- Unidentified speaker: So um that equity exposure should not uh automatically decline just based on age.
- 20:17
- Unidentified speaker: Um there's room for people to have uh more exposure that maybe they're willing to take.
- 20:24
- Unidentified speaker: And again, we need to explain that to them um and and give them the reasons why they should stay invested in equities, uh even at um uh what someone would consider an advanced age.
- 20:34
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I mean, the other way to look at this is to be able to say, you know, when you're young, you can afford to be able to uh, you know, it's more about asset growth than asset protection, right?
- 20:44
- Unidentified speaker: Right.
- 20:45
- Unidentified speaker: Um and then as you get older and older, um, you know, becomes that shift begins to happen where you're now you're thinking about, hey, how do I preserve my assets more than try to grow them and hit them out of the ballpark every single year?
- 20:56
- Unidentified speaker: Um, so that's that's kind of like an individual, I guess, an individual kind of decision that needs to be made.
- 21:02
- Unidentified speaker: And there's really um, you know, no wrong answer because it all depends on, or it's not standard answer, I should say, because it all depends on, you know, what's your individual risk tolerance is what makes you stay up at night, at what levels, you know, those type of things.
- 21:14
- Unidentified speaker: So now that we've talked a little bit about asset client uh, you know, asset allocation from a client perspective, I really want to know about what you do on a daily basis on the back end, right?
- 21:23
- Unidentified speaker: How do you construct uh that asset allocation model?
- 21:26
- Unidentified speaker: And I know it's gonna get now, it's gonna get a little bit more technical.
- 21:29
- Unidentified speaker: So let's try to keep it as simple as possible if we can.
- 21:32
- Unidentified speaker: But um, how do you know, like for a client that has, let's say, um low risk rather than high risk, what type of portfolio and what percentages to build uh into that portfolio?
- 21:43
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
- 21:43
- Unidentified speaker: So talking about uh what keeps me up at night, so now we're we're getting into that.
- 21:49
- Unidentified speaker: Um so yeah, once you've selected your um your asset classes, so the promise of uh modern portfolio theory is that uh when um when um these individual asset classes, um as risky as they may be individually, when they put into the park together and optimized, um, they may give you something that's more um um palatable to an investor.
- 22:14
- Unidentified speaker: So um having a mix of equities, fixed income, and other classes um may produce a portfolio that is less risk, less riskier than um disasset classes taken into um into consideration.
- 22:29
- Unidentified speaker: The difficulty is uh in optimizing those portfolios uh um uh really.
- 22:36
- Unidentified speaker: I'll give you a very good example in that um if if uh if someone was asked to to choose uh to flip a coin, um so head you get um $90, they you you get $10.
- 22:57
- Unidentified speaker: The your expected sort of return is 50, 90 plus 10 divided by two.
- 23:03
- Unidentified speaker: But let's say um the flip side of that is um um you flip a coin, head you get 50, tell you get 50.
- 23:12
- Unidentified speaker: Again, your expected return is 50.
- 23:15
- Unidentified speaker: But those are very different proposition, and any investor in a red man would take the latter because you know um I'm I'm sure to get 50 at the end.
- 23:24
- Unidentified speaker: That's my expected return.
- 23:26
- Unidentified speaker: So that's the exercise we go through and we optimize a portfolio and saying what outcome are we gonna get on average when we mix these portfolios?
- 23:34
- Unidentified speaker: And uh that's really the the the interesting part of uh uh mean variance optimization, as we call it.
- 23:40
- Unidentified speaker: And you basically go back um and look at like what each of the asset classes has done historically, and you kind of try to what which is more of like a science slash art, which is predicted for the future, okay?
- 23:54
- Unidentified speaker: So um I I wish we could do that because as we know, um history does not tell us much about what's gonna happen in the future.
- 24:01
- Unidentified speaker: So we need to forecast um this this asset classes as a first step, and that is hard.
- 24:07
- Unidentified speaker: Um uh forecasting anything is is difficult by nature, but um, but we do have um different uh methods and uh methodology that we use to forecast returns before we actually optimize the different asset classes to determine what's uh what's appropriate.
- 24:24
- Unidentified speaker: So can you give me an example of that?
- 24:26
- Unidentified speaker: So if you if you look at equities, for example, um one of the one of the key components of forecast is return is uh uh uh price to earnings and expansion of price to earnings.
- 24:39
- Unidentified speaker: So the difficulty lately is that um um earnings multiple have been increasing, have been running way ahead of um historical averages.
- 24:51
- Unidentified speaker: Um I think the SNP um uh P ratio used to be around um 18 to 20, it's now running at 25.
- 25:01
- Unidentified speaker: So using that as an input in forecasting returns is probably going to sort of uh skew your forecast.
- 25:10
- Unidentified speaker: And we have to take that into consideration, for example.
- 25:12
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, and so just so that um everybody's aware, so price to earnings ratio basically means you take the price of the of the stock that you want to buy and you divide it by the earnings and you get some type of a ratio.
- 25:23
- Unidentified speaker: Um, and that's that for if you do the all of the SP 500, um, same thing for every single price, and then be able to come up with a number that historically was running between 17 to 19, and now you're saying it's about 25 or so, so higher than normal, um, is is is what it is, right?
- 25:39
- Unidentified speaker: And using that as an input, and um uh like I said, and in any type of sort of mathematical uh process that you use, the the inputs are quite important.
- 25:49
- Unidentified speaker: And if these inputs are not grounded in um in reality, then uh you may have results that are not uh sort of usable.
- 25:58
- Unidentified speaker: So how do you ground yourself in reality?
- 26:00
- Unidentified speaker: Because the tendency would be to say, wow, equities have done so well over the past five or ten years that you know the you can have different assumptions based on your mood that day of what the markets are doing.
- 26:11
- Unidentified speaker: So so that this is where it comes uh um, this is where the the benefits of being a practitioner uh matters because uh um I mean, someone has not been, for example, through the 2000 crisis or 2008 crisis, may just think that uh markets just only have one direction, they go up.
- 26:31
- Unidentified speaker: Um so um having practitioners that have the experience that have been exposed through different microcycles uh allows us to be more grounded uh when we make our assumptions.
- 26:42
- Unidentified speaker: So maybe we may not realize as much as possible uh as as much as we may have in the past on certain metrics that we feel like have been have run ahead of uh themselves.
- 26:53
- Unidentified speaker: So being a practitioner allows us to sort of um get more grounded on on these assumptions that we make.
- 27:00
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
- 27:01
- Unidentified speaker: So basically, I think you're going to a professional to say, I've already done the research for you, done the the kind of the mathematical formulas for it, and this is kind of the expected rates of return for each of the different asset classes that are there, right?
- 27:14
- Unidentified speaker: And you can do that on on all different types, even like for example, you can do it on art and other things that are illiquid as well.
- 27:22
- Unidentified speaker: So the the methodology is um is a little bit different depending on the asset classes.
- 27:27
- Unidentified speaker: Now, for most of those um more illiquid um um uh asset classes, it may not be a straightforward formula.
- 27:36
- Unidentified speaker: Uh, for example, you may need to praise art and just look at what um what the what that industry looks like.
- 27:42
- Unidentified speaker: Uh so it is not always a mathematical formula, but there is there are ways of um sort of um not only uh making reasonable assumptions, but also taking into consideration what we don't know.
- 27:56
- Unidentified speaker: Um and again, I don't want to um get too technical here.
- 28:01
- Unidentified speaker: We refer to it as dragon risk.
- 28:03
- Unidentified speaker: So basically, I think uh uh someone famously coined the phrase we we know about um the unknown, the unknown unknowns, the unknown unknowns.
- 28:14
- Unidentified speaker: Uh dragon risk falls into that category of unknown unknowns.
- 28:18
- Unidentified speaker: So and we have to factor that in when we make uh capital market assumptions.
- 28:23
- Unidentified speaker: Okay.
- 28:23
- Unidentified speaker: And then so when you're also looking at these uh asset locations, I mean, you know, you can have like we we talked a little bit about equities, which are stocks, then you can do international stocks, then within international or in domestic, you can do large cap, mid-cap, small cap, make sometimes micro cap, sometimes you can do private.
- 28:40
- Unidentified speaker: So I mean, at some point in time, it's you're getting over diversified, right?
- 28:44
- Unidentified speaker: So how do you how do you like what's the what's the one advice you would get somebody to be able to say, keep it simple?
- 28:50
- Unidentified speaker: You don't have to get complicated.
- 28:52
- Unidentified speaker: Um, or or maybe you do.
- 28:54
- Unidentified speaker: What what's what's what's your advice?
- 28:56
- Unidentified speaker: I I think you don't want to keep it um uh too overly complicated.
- 29:00
- Unidentified speaker: And the way we address that is uh by putting constraints in the optimization process itself.
- 29:06
- Unidentified speaker: Uh by that I mean um if you just look again at individual um asset classes, you mentioned mid-cap, small cap, and large cap just in the US, um, and constrained, um, your portfolio would probably be um 100% of mid-cap stocks because um they probably uh would have would do better over the long term because they've done better in the past.
- 29:29
- Unidentified speaker: So uh the way we address that is putting constraints.
- 29:32
- Unidentified speaker: Um a good example of that is um US resident international.
- 29:39
- Unidentified speaker: So obviously we have a US-based investor um that's probably wanna uh sort of um have their portfolio close to home.
- 29:50
- Unidentified speaker: Um so we will constrain a portfolio and say, hey, make it at least that 80% of the allocation to the allocation is US-based.
- 29:57
- Unidentified speaker: Uh, if you didn't do that, you probably will have a portfolio that's overly exposed to emerging markets or other risky sort of part of the world.
- 30:06
- Unidentified speaker: So having those constraints is part of uh what we do in uh sort of um optimizing a portfolio.
- 30:13
- Unidentified speaker: Okay.
- 30:13
- Unidentified speaker: And then now now that you've done that, you've kind of done your homework, you know what the client risk profile looks like, walk me through a conversation you'll have with the client to say, you know what, you shouldn't be, even though the markets have done well, you shouldn't be 100% in stocks.
- 30:27
- Unidentified speaker: You really need to have this.
- 30:27
- Unidentified speaker: So walk me through that conversation.
- 30:30
- Unidentified speaker: So um the the way we we we really address that is looking at um um uh is is by educating our our investor base on on diversifications and merits of um diversification.
- 30:45
- Unidentified speaker: Um the the one thing I like to quote is that um 90% of a portfolio return can be attributed to asset allocation.
- 30:57
- Unidentified speaker: Um so that is very important to keep in mind.
- 31:02
- Unidentified speaker: And that was based on a study done in the early 90s by uh Brinson and Co.
- 31:08
- Unidentified speaker: That um using you know uh pension fund returns are determined that 90% of um uh a portfolio uh the the variability in a portfolio return to be correct, um um can be traced back to asset allocation.
- 31:22
- Unidentified speaker: That is how important it is to have.
- 31:24
- Unidentified speaker: Now there was So can you can you just break down break that down a little bit?
- 31:27
- Unidentified speaker: Like what does that really mean?
- 31:28
- Unidentified speaker: Like um, does that mean like my returns that I'm getting overall, 90% of that is like where I'm invested asset-wise rather than what stock I'm actually in?
- 31:39
- Unidentified speaker: So um it's uh there was a there's uh thank you for the question because uh there was a later study in the early 2000 by um E.
- 31:47
- Unidentified speaker: Boston and Kaplan that sort of clarified that uh that's the first question that people come back to.
- 31:52
- Unidentified speaker: So uh the way that study was framed was that is it 40%, is it 90%, is it 100% of return?
- 31:59
- Unidentified speaker: Now, um if you compare two portfolios, portfolio A and B, the variability in returns between these two, uh 40% of that is explained by um um asset allocation decision, which means that um, you know, um the security selection process and active management and all that and transaction costs account for 60% of the return variability.
- 32:27
- Unidentified speaker: But if you take a single portfolio and uh you make a decision, should I be 100% equities, should I be 100% cash?
- 32:37
- Unidentified speaker: Well, 90% of that portfolio return is really determined by that asset allocation.
- 32:43
- Unidentified speaker: And sometimes it's closer to 100% because if you take into consideration uh transaction costs and so on and so forth, they're kind of offset.
- 32:52
- Unidentified speaker: So um up to 100% of that asset allocation decision determines your return.
- 32:59
- Unidentified speaker: Uh if you're looking at a single portfolio.
- 33:01
- Unidentified speaker: So that's really what uh what um that um uh the study shows.
- 33:06
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
- 33:06
- Unidentified speaker: So basically in my portfolio, right, I would say that my my determination of whether to be in equities or fixed income like Sukuk or gold or whatever it is, 90% of my return is going to come from these choices rather than the actual what stocks I'm buying or what sukuc I'm buying or what you know, uh uh uh well, there's only one type of gold, but yeah, generally that's that would be the case, right?
- 33:30
- Unidentified speaker: Exactly.
- 33:31
- Unidentified speaker: And then uh the 40% question, if you will ex um will answer whether within that decision now, am I am I uh 6040, 70, 30, 80, 20, that accounts for the rest of it.
- 33:42
- Unidentified speaker: But like I said, the the initial decision really 90% of that is driven by that asset allocation decision.
- 33:48
- Unidentified speaker: And it's quite important uh for us.
- 33:51
- Unidentified speaker: That's great.
- 33:51
- Unidentified speaker: And so now now stepping back also, you know, we've we've come when it comes to Islamic investing or just Islamic finance in general, um, we've come a long way.
- 34:00
- Unidentified speaker: Before, um, if you looked at it, let's say even like 25 years ago, maybe even 20 years ago, um, the very there were very limited choices when it came to halal asset allocation, right?
- 34:11
- Unidentified speaker: Is that still the case now?
- 34:12
- Unidentified speaker: Or do you think we can we can have a proper asset allocation like let's say the big bag big guys do, like pensions or high network individuals?
- 34:21
- Unidentified speaker: Can somebody do that on a complete halal basis?
- 34:25
- Unidentified speaker: Oh, totally, totally.
- 34:27
- Unidentified speaker: So um just on the on the Sukuk and fixed income side, if you will, the industry's gone um so far or come so far in the last or I would say 15, 20 years.
- 34:39
- Unidentified speaker: So it is uh it is possible to build a diversified portfolio by allocating to Sukuk, because I mean if you look at sort of the the Southeast Asia, the Middle East, um, and so on and so forth, there are a lot more issues than 10 or 15 years ago.
- 34:55
- Unidentified speaker: So uh you're able to source um um securities in that in that part of the world and and have a proper allocation.
- 35:02
- Unidentified speaker: And then when it comes to equities, uh again, I think at Saturday Capital we we screen about uh 5,000 uh names on the equity size and uh sort of whittle it down to maybe an approval list that's uh significantly shorter, but again, gives you enough exposure worldwide to build a portfolio.
- 35:22
- Unidentified speaker: Yes, absolutely.
- 35:23
- Unidentified speaker: You can build a totally halal portfolio fully diversified in the Islamic sense.
- 35:29
- Unidentified speaker: Yes.
- 35:29
- Unidentified speaker: Yeah, now and now you have like cash alternatives there, halal, private equity, venture capital, that they're small, yet you can find though those as well.
- 35:37
- Unidentified speaker: And in fact, you can also find REIT, uh real estate investment trusts that are giving you real estate exposure that could be halal as well.
- 35:43
- Unidentified speaker: So the the I guess the point is the industry has developed.
- 35:46
- Unidentified speaker: So no no longer can you say the excuse of though, well, we we don't have any halal assets to be able to allocate, so I'll just put all of my money in equities.
- 35:55
- Unidentified speaker: Totally, totally.
- 35:56
- Unidentified speaker: And then and then the the other thing I would remind, uh I would remind folks is that you know that asset allocation uh decision is not a one-time and forget it, it's a frameworks that evolves.
- 36:06
- Unidentified speaker: So as the industry also evolves, we can participate in in more and more uh exposure within within your portfolio.
- 36:12
- Unidentified speaker: We're already there in terms of diversification, but it's not a static uh decision.
- 36:18
- Unidentified speaker: We we continue to improve on it and fine-tune it.
- 36:20
- Unidentified speaker: That's great.
- 36:21
- Unidentified speaker: And so, you know, sometimes they say uh that uh uh uh doctors make them the worst patients.
- 36:27
- Unidentified speaker: So I'll ask you the question that uh um that probably everybody, every listener is waiting for.
- 36:31
- Unidentified speaker: Do you asset allocate your portfolio?
- 36:33
- Unidentified speaker: Oh, absolutely.
- 36:35
- Unidentified speaker: Uh so you you you like I said, that's that is the fundamental of of investing, having that um that broad exposure um to different asset classes just because they behave differently is the very important decision every practitioner and every investor should make.
- 36:52
- Unidentified speaker: Great.
- 36:52
- Unidentified speaker: Um Papa, thank you so much for uh for for being with us.
- 36:55
- Unidentified speaker: I mean, I think we covered a lot, right?
- 36:57
- Unidentified speaker: We talked about what is out of style asset allocation, you know, what does it look like in different times of your life and it's dependent upon risk.
- 37:04
- Unidentified speaker: And then we did a little bit of a deeper dive as to what you do behind the scenes to be able to come up with an asset allocation model and finally kind of summed it up with saying that hey, um, nowadays, especially in this this day and age, you can as a as a as a uh uh a Muslim uh uh do an asset allocation, complete asset allocation uh in a halal way.
- 37:24
- Unidentified speaker: So I really thank you for your time and and look forward to maybe feature podcasts where you can come on.
- 37:29
- Unidentified speaker: Absolutely.
- 37:30
- Unidentified speaker: Thank you so much for having me and and I look forward to continuing the conversation.
- 37:34
- Unidentified speaker: Appreciate it.
- 37:34
- Unidentified speaker: Thank you.
- 37:35
- Unidentified speaker: Thank you, Slamagum.
- 37:37
- Unidentified speaker: Thank you for listening to Halal Money Matters.
- 37:39
- Unidentified speaker: If you like what you hear, please do rate us on the app stores and also leave us a review.
- 37:44
- Unidentified speaker: It helps other people find us a lot easier.
- 37:47
- Unidentified speaker: The thoughts and opinions expressed on Halal Money Matters do not necessarily reflect the views of Saturda Capital, Amana Mutual Funds, or their affiliates.
- 37:56
- Unidentified speaker: This podcast is prepared based on information Saturna Capital deems reliable.
- 38:01
- Unidentified speaker: However, Saturna Capital does not warrant the accuracy or completeness of the information.
- 38:07
- Unidentified speaker: We do not provide tax, accounting, or legal advice to our clients, and all investors are advised to consult with their tax, accounting, or legal advisors regarding any potential investment.
- 38:19
- Unidentified speaker: Investors should not assume that investments in the securities and/slash or sectors described were or will be profitable.
- 38:27
- Unidentified speaker: Investors should consult with a financial advisor prior to making an investment decision.
- 38:32
- Unidentified speaker: The views and information discussed in this commentary are at a specific point in time, are subject to change, and may not reflect the views of the firm as a whole.
- 38:42
- Unidentified speaker: All material presented in this publication, unless specifically indicated otherwise, is under copyright to Saturna.
- 38:49
- Unidentified speaker: No part of this publication may be altered in any way, copied, or distributed without the prior express written permission of Saturna Capital.
- 38:58
- Unidentified speaker: Performance data quoted herein represents past performance and is no guarantee of future results.
- 39:04
- Unidentified speaker: Investment return and principal value of an investment will fluctuate so that an investor's shares, when redeemed, may be worth more or less than their original cost.
- 39:15
- Unidentified speaker: Current performance may be significantly higher or lower than data quoted herein.
- 39:20
- Unidentified speaker: Performance current to the most recent month end can be obtained by visiting www.amanafunds.com or by calling toll-free 1-800-728-8762.
- 39:34
- Unidentified speaker: Please consider an investment's objectives, risks, charges, and expenses carefully before investing.
- 39:41
- Unidentified speaker: To obtain this and other important information, which you should carefully consider before investing, about the amena funds in a free prospectus or summary prospectus, please visit www.amanafunds.com or call 1-800-728-8762.
- 40:01
- Unidentified speaker: The amana funds limit the securities they purchase to those consistent with Islamic principles.
- 40:06
- Unidentified speaker: This limits opportunities and may affect performance.
- 40:10
- Unidentified speaker: The Aman of Funds are distributed by Saturna Brokerage Services, member FINRA slash SIPC, and a wholly owned subsidiary of Saturna Capital, investment advisor to the Aman of Funds.