Bridget and Alyssa discuss surveillance capitalism, data harvesting, and privacy protection strategies.
Summary
Bridget and Alyssais explore Shoshana Zuboff's concept of surveillance capitalism, defining it as an economic model where tech companies monetize personal data to predict and influence behavior. They detail various data collection mechanisms, including inaudible audio tracking, contact harvesting, and facial recognition. The speakers highlight the risks of AI training on personal data and the persistence of harmful content for data generation. Bridget offers practical advice on reducing digital footprints and using tools like VPNs to protect privacy.
Key takeaways
- 1 There was an ad tracker, I think it was in Europe, called Fids Up, and it can detect the presence of mobile phones and their owners by diffusing a tone that's inaudible to the human ear inside a building. So users installing this app that was actually a restaurant guide uh in France would have their physical location tracked via retail outlets speakers as they move around Paris. The experience would be shared by readers of a car magazine app, Auto Journal, and the TV guide app Telestar.
Bridget · 30:57
- 2 Facebook (Meta) accumulated vast data by syncing user contacts, thereby harvesting names and phone numbers from people who did not consent to being on the platform.
Bridget · 32:51
- 3 Facebook's research team announced in 2018 that they could recognize faces in the wild with 97.35% accuracy, approaching human-level performance.
Bridget · 40:39
- 4 We are not scrutinized for substance, but for form. The price you are offered does not derive from what you write about, but how you write it. It is not what's in your sentences, but their length and complexity, not what you list, but that you list, not the picture, but the choice of filter and degree of saturation, not what you disclose, but how you share or fail to, not where you make plans to see your friends, but how you do so, a casual later or precise time and place. Explanation marks and adverb choices operate as revelatory and potentially damaging signals of yourself.
Bridget · 44:50
- 5 Platforms allow hateful or racist content to persist because it generates data on the worldviews and political leanings of those who interact with it.
Bridget · 46:54
- 6 Bridget recommends using a VPN costing approximately $5/month when browsing on computers in public spaces to encrypt data and protect against hackers.
Bridget · 56:26
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 3:13
Introduction and Personal Context
Bridget and Alyssa introduce the episode's heavy topic of surveillance capitalism, inspired by Shoshana Zuboff's book. They briefly discuss their personal financial feelings and Bridget's upcoming Halloween party to set a conversational tone before diving into the main subject.
- 3:13 – 9:16
The Book and Author Background
Bridget introduces 'The Age of Surveillance Capitalism' by Dr. Shoshana Zuboff, noting Zuboff's academic background in philosophy, psychology, and business at Harvard. She describes the book as dense, over 700 pages, and difficult to read, though highly influential.
- 9:16 – 12:10
Definition of Surveillance Capitalism
Surveillance capitalism is defined as an economic model where tech companies collect, analyze, and monetize personal human experience to predict and influence behavior. Bridget argues the primary goal is control and political influence, not just advertising revenue.
- 12:10 – 22:20
Digital Resignation and AI as Surveillance
The speakers discuss 'digital resignation,' where users feel helpless and stop caring about data tracking. Bridget asserts that AI's true purpose is surveillance and data aggregation, using chatbots to extract personal information under the guise of companionship or utility.
- 22:20 – 28:00
Data Collection Mechanisms and Risks
Bridget explains how apps track users even when closed, accessing location, screen time, messages, and contacts. She mentions that companies can use front cameras to gauge emotional states and that data brokers aggregate this information to map relationships and behaviors.
- 28:00 – 29:50
Gilded's Business Model and Privacy Stance
Bridget clarifies that her company, Gilded, does not sell user data. She explains that Gilded charges subscription fees because its revenue model relies on user payments rather than data brokerage, contrasting it with free apps that monetize through data sales.
- 29:50 – 30:56
Device Listening and Physical Security
The speakers confirm that phones and laptops are actively recording audio. Bridget references a photo of Mark Zuckerberg with his laptop microphone covered as evidence of the need for physical privacy measures, noting that users are constantly being tracked.
- 30:56 – 32:48
External Tracking via Inaudible Audio Signals
Bridget describes a European ad tracker called 'Fids Up' that uses inaudible tones to detect mobile phones and track user locations in Paris through retail speakers. This tracking occurred even when users were only using apps like a restaurant guide or car magazine, without the app actively functioning internally.
- 32:48 – 34:03
Data Harvesting via Contacts and Bluetooth
Bridget explains that Facebook (Meta) gained massive data advantages by syncing user contacts to harvest information from non-users. She also notes that Bluetooth technology in stores like Target interacts with phones to enable dynamic pricing and tracking, even when no app is open.
- 34:03 – 39:18
Wi-Fi Vulnerabilities and Google Street View
Bridget highlights the danger of Wi-Fi networks, citing Google Street View's interception of home Wi-Fi data, which included passwords, credit cards, and browsing history. She advises against using public Wi-Fi without a VPN and recommends using cellular data instead.
- 39:18 – 44:34
Facial Recognition and AI Risks
Bridget discusses a US court ruling regarding AI-generated CSAM and the risks of posting children's photos online for AI training. She notes that Facebook achieved 97.35% facial recognition accuracy by 2018, enabling potential government surveillance through public cameras.
- 44:34 – 48:23
Behavioral Data and Hate Content
The speakers discuss how platforms track 'form' over 'substance,' analyzing writing style and engagement to build profiles. Bridget argues that platforms allow hateful content to persist because it generates valuable data on user worldviews and political leanings through reactions and comments.
- 48:23 – 56:06
Reducing Data Footprint and Cognitive Offloading
Bridget shares her personal strategy of reducing social media posting to starve data brokers of current information. The conversation touches on the 'Google effect,' where relying on devices for memory erodes personal identity and real-life connection.
- 56:06 – 58:13
Privacy Protection Steps
Bridget recommends deleting unnecessary apps, turning off Wi-Fi on phones when not at home, using a cheap VPN ($5/month) on computers in public, and stopping social media posts to protect against surveillance and hackers.
Claims worth verifying
The book 'The Age of Surveillance Capitalism' was written by Dr. Shoshana Zuboff, who holds a PhD in psychology from Harvard and was a professor in the Faculty of Business at Harvard.
Bridget ·4:04
How to verify: Check Dr. Shoshana Zuboff's faculty profile at Harvard Business School and her academic CV or Wikipedia page for her degrees and positions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The book 'The Age of Surveillance Capitalism' is over 700 pages long.
Alyssa ·5:08
How to verify: Check the book's product page on Amazon or the publisher's website for the page count. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The book 'The Age of Surveillance Capitalism' has almost four thousand reviews on Amazon.
Bridget ·6:23
How to verify: Search for the book on Amazon and check the number of customer reviews listed on the product page. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The book 'The Age of Surveillance Capitalism' was published in 2019.
Bridget ·14:02
How to verify: Check the copyright page of the book or its publication record on Goodreads/Amazon. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Gilded charges users money for subscriptions rather than selling data.
Bridget ·28:41
How to verify: Check Gilded's pricing page or subscription terms to confirm the revenue model. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
An ad tracker in Europe called 'Fids Up' detected mobile phones and tracked owners via inaudible tones in buildings like restaurants in Paris.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·30:56
How to verify: Search for 'Fids Up ad tracker Europe' or 'Fids Up Paris restaurant tracking' in tech news archives or surveillance capitalism literature. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Facebook synced user contacts to harvest contact information from people who did not have Facebook accounts.
Bridget ·32:48
How to verify: Review Facebook's privacy policy history or news reports from the mid-2010s regarding contact syncing scandals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Google Street View intercepted and stored payload data from home Wi-Fi networks, including passwords, credit cards, and browsing history.
Bridget ·34:11
How to verify: Search for 'Google Street View Wi-Fi data interception' or check Google's official statements and FTC records from 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A recent US court ruling stated that possessing AI-generated CSAM is not a crime if the AI was trained on real people.
Alyssa ·39:37
How to verify: Search US legal databases or news for recent court rulings on AI-generated CSAM and possession laws. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Facebook boasted of 2 billion monthly users uploading 350 million photos every day in 2017.
Bridget ·40:39
How to verify: Check Facebook's 2026 earnings reports or press releases for user and photo upload statistics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Facebook research team announced in 2018 that they could recognize faces in the wild with 97.35% accuracy.
Bridget ·40:39
How to verify: Search for 'Facebook 2018 facial recognition accuracy 97.35%' or Facebook AI research publications from that period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Facebook launched an AI assistant called 'M' in 2015.
Bridget ·42:23
How to verify: Search for 'Facebook M assistant 2015 launch' in tech news archives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Facebook achieved 97.35% facial recognition accuracy by 2018.
Bridget ·40:39
How to verify: Verify via Facebook AI Research (FAIR) publications or press releases from 2018. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A VPN costs approximately $5 a month.
Bridget ·56:26
How to verify: Check current pricing of major VPN providers (e.g., NordVPN, ExpressVPN) for annual or monthly plans. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Google Street View vehicles intercepted home Wi-Fi data.
Bridget ·34:11
How to verify: Search for 'Google Street View Wi-Fi data interception' and review Google's official statements and FTC records from 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Shoshana Zuboff's 'The Age of Surveillance Capitalism' for the foundational definition of the economic model.
- Check the 'Fids Up' ad tracker case studies or European privacy reports for details on inaudible audio tracking.
- Review Google's official statements and legal settlements regarding Google Street View's Wi-Fi data interception.
- Search for the specific US court ruling mentioned regarding AI-generated CSAM and its implications for photo posting.
- Look up Facebook's 2018 research paper on facial recognition accuracy to verify the 97.35% figure.
- Examine social media platform transparency reports on content moderation and data collection practices.
- Research the costs and efficacy of VPN services recommended for public Wi-Fi protection.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Bridget: Action needs to be taken immediately because the problems are so big. Like we are so screwed.
0:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hi,
0:13Alyssa: my name's Alyssa.
0:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
0:15Bridget: my name is Bridget.
0:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
0:16Alyssa: you're listening to Money Feels.
0:18Bridget: The podcast where we share that your entire life has already been bought and sold and will never belong to you again.
0:25Alyssa: Bridget.
0:29Bridget: Sorry.
0:30Alyssa: We're 18 seconds in.
0:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
0:33Bridget: is
0:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): gonna be
0:34Alyssa: devastated.
0:35Bridget: This is gonna be a hard episode, so let's start with an easy question. How does your money feel?
0:41Alyssa: I oh god, is that an easy question? I
0:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): don't know, No, girl.
0:45Bridget: Do your best.
0:47Alyssa: I'm very out of touch with reality right now. I've been working so much that I haven't even had time to spend money. Oh. And it's good in the sense that I'm not spending money, but I just like got my credit card statement and I still have a bill. So I'm like, am
1:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:06Alyssa: spending money? I'm just like very confused and I don't have time to dedicate to my finances. And that's like a I don't like that feeling. So it doesn't feel great, but it it could be worse. There's there's pros and cons to my financial situation right now.
1:20Bridget: Okay.
1:21Alyssa: How does your money feel?
1:22Bridget: I think pretty good. Uh I'm not focused on it obviously because I'm traumatized by the topic that we'll be discussing in this podcast today. But I am planning my Halloween party. We're f we're recording this before Halloween and different years I go like different sizes. We've had really big blowout years where I've had like 75 people in my house and we've had smaller like last year was a very small party because I was traveling before. But this year I've been home the whole month of October. So I've just been planning. I hired a tarot card reader. I hired a bartender. I hired a nanny for all the kids.
1:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So yeah,
1:57Bridget: no, like I'm freaking frickin' stoked, but I am spending a lot on this Halloween party. It's probably gonna cost me like three or four grand when everything's said and done. But you know, it's for the experience. I
2:09Alyssa: love I love it. I feel like everyone needs to have one event that they host annually.
2:13Bridget: Yeah. Yeah. And this is mine and has been for like five years now, and it's so fun.
2:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
2:19Alyssa: love it. I I know I'm going to a Halloween party as well, and I'm just so I'm always just so grateful to people that host because it's so much work. It's so expensive.
2:29Bridget: It is. I mean, this year, because I have the bartender, I actually feel like it's not that much work for me.
2:35Alyssa: Right. As a host, that removes like a large part of the labor.
2:38Bridget: Yeah, like the worst part of the labor too. Like I'm gonna make I really like to make all the treats and dishes beforehand, so I'll do that. But because it's a party at night, it's not like a dinner. I just have to make snacks. And the kids usually like inhale them in the first 40 minutes of the party. And then we have to bring out the second batch that hit
2:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at
2:59Bridget: once.
3:01Alyssa: That's amazing. It's gonna be so much fun. I feel like you need it too. So
3:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
3:05Bridget: I need a good party to cheer me up.
3:07Alyssa: Yeah, so might as well
3:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Might
3:10Alyssa: as well spend the money.
3:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
3:13Alyssa: don't even know where where do we start today, Brittany Bridget. You're the expert as you've written an entire book in your
3:20Bridget: I'm so sorry. You
3:21Alyssa: know what? It's fine. I just didn't read it. So
3:24Bridget: Okay. So we'll we'll talk about the topic that we're talking about today, which is surveillance capitalism. And this is inspired by a book that I read recently by the same title, The Age of Surveillance Capitalism. by uh Dr. Soshana Zuboff. I think that's how I pronounce her name. She's this is just an aside, but she's actually an incredibly brilliant woman. And I knew that immediately reading the book. But after I finished it, I was on her Wikipedia page. And as you know, I was texting you yesterday, and I'm like, oh, and she got this degree and she got this award. And look what she wrote. brought. And I just, I really love super impressive women because her undergrad is in philosophy from I think the University of Chicago. She then got a PhD in psychology from Harvard and was also a professor in uh the Faculty of Business uh Harvard. So, and then got an honorary degree from McGill. Like
4:24truly a brilliant woman that has an incredible history in technology, economics, and psychology, which is such like a powerful trifecta.
4:34Alyssa: What a great combo.
4:36Bridget: Like she knows everything about the world and has philosophy underpinning it. Like, truly extraordinary to read works from people, intellectuals that see the world as she does. I think. Like it I think it's so cool to learn from people that are. this intelligent. The downside, of course, is this book is difficult to read.
4:56Alyssa: Right. You said it was really heavy.
4:58Bridget: It was it was heavy and it's it's actually it requires a high degree of literacy to read. Like, first of all, it's over 700 pages.
5:08Alyssa: Oh my goodness. It's like Mike Mike it's like
5:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Mark
5:11Alyssa: Carney's book.
5:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes.
5:15Bridget: Yeah. And so it it is a slug to go through. It is obviously incredibly well researched, extraordinarily put together. And the language is very, very good. But again, like a high level of reading, which you will notice immediately because I'll probably read some quotes as we do this. But I just want if anyone is planning to read it, and this is the unfortunate thing because I think every person should, but
5:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
5:43Bridget: think because it is so long and dense and difficult that it will be off-putting to the average person. Like I wish she had actually broken it up into like three or four books that could be packaged with easier language and like sold at airports. Like I love a good airport book, right?
5:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know,
6:00Bridget: like you want to get it into the hands of the most people. And unfortunately, I think because she is so smart and her style of r writing is just not that that few people, not everyone will get to read this book. But I might also be wrong. I think it has like almost four thousand reviews on Amazon. So it is clearly getting into the hands of a lot of people, but I think the impact could be larger and more significant if it was easier to read.
6:26Alyssa: Yeah. I mean, well, she's an academic by trade.
6:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
6:29Alyssa: that she's gonna write with that style.
6:32Bridget: Yeah, but I mean, you're if you're listening to Money Feels where we nerd out on economics and psychology all the time, maybe this is like right up your alley.
6:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It probably is, yeah.
6:41Bridget: Like there's lots of people that are like, give me that. I'll I'll spend all of November reading it. But we'll jump right into the topic because this book has been so significant and has completely changed how I see the entire world, not just technology, but politically and economically. Well the economics I already knew very well and have been depressed about for years, as everyone that's listened to our podcast knows. But I didn't understand the tech and the psychology and it's it's very dystopian. So uh not something to listen to if you're having a good day. So if you're having a good day, I'm going to ruin it. So just turn this podcast off and come back when you're already grumpy about something.
7:27Alyssa: Only listen if you're already crying.
7:30Bridget: Yeah. And then we'll make it worse. But then you can like overcome everything together instead of like ruining a perfectly good day. You know what I mean? Sure. Okay. We'll start uh with the definition. And I've compiled so when I uh exported my highlights from the book, uh it was 37 pages
7:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
7:52Bridget: highlights.
7:52Alyssa: But very small considering that it was over 700 pages.
7:56Bridget: Yeah, like I was I was going for brevity because I knew I was going gonna to use it in a podcast. I then uh repurposed those highlights into a Word document that is meant to be the outline for this podcast. It is unfortunately fourteen pages. So but like to be I cut it down by more than half. So I think I did like quite well.
8:15Alyssa: Yeah.
8:16Bridget: I've also incorporated some text messages that I've sent you that I know I've also sent uh I've shared on my Instagram so people have a general idea of what's come coming. But um yeah, let's let lock in because this is going to ruin your day and possibly ruin your life. So apologies in advance.
8:34Alyssa: This is like the craziest introduction I've ever been
8:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
8:38Alyssa: part of.
8:39Bridget: I just hope that I do this subject justice. Like I'm trying to emphasize how like I think that this might be the most important conversation you and I ever have on this podcast.
8:51Alyssa: Yeah.
8:51Bridget: That's how I feel about it. And I'm actually worried that I don't have the skills to communicate how important this information is and how it desperately needs to be heard by quite literally everyone, and action needs to be taken immediately because the problems are so big. Like we are so screwed. I I'm just making it let's just like let's just get in because people are like, now what is she talking about? What's going
9:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on?
9:15Bridget: This is so bad.
9:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And also
9:16Alyssa: just like, you know, this doesn't we're deciding this in the moment, but we can do a series as though you described the book should have had. So if we need to do more than one episode on this topic, we will.
9:26Bridget: Okay, then we'll make this the overview and
9:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we'll
9:29Bridget: just jump into it. So, what is surveillance capitalism? So, surveillance capitalism is an economic model where tech companies collect, analyze, and monetize personal human experience as raw material to predict and influence human behavior. And I think this is such an important definition because I think, first of all, we all know that we are being tracked by all our apps, social media companies, everything. And a lot of us feel very nonchalant about it. We're kind of blessé. We're like, well, I'm not that interesting. It doesn't matter if they know where I'm going or what I'm looking at online. But they are collecting so much. I think we don't realize how much. I didn't realize how much until I read this book. I didn't realize how much could be collected. I also think technology has changed so recently that changes how this data is. analyzed. And
10:29I think a lot of us just believe it's so they can sell us stuff, like everything's collected to feed us more ads, which is true. A lot of it is for the capitalism part of this game. That's what they want. They want you to buy more crap. But it is also to influence human behavior. And we're recording this a few days after we voted in the Alberta. referendum, where Albertans decided we're not going to separate from Canada, but to every other question, essentially decided we're not going to participate in Canada either.
11:01Alyssa: I know. Don't even get me started.
11:03Bridget: Yeah, we're not gonna go over that here, but I'm I'm just bringing that up because I think it is so interesting to me the discourse that's happening online put politically, not just in Alberta, but globally and the impact that is having on people. And I'm not going to go into that in great detail in this conversation, but I want to emphasize that that is the point. That is what all of this for is for is controlling your behavior politically and yeah
11:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and also
11:37Bridget: in compliance with the state. And we'll talk we'll talk a little bit about that in here. But when we're talking about means to an end, that is the end. It's not it is to get you to buy more crap. 100%. They want you to buy a lot of stuff. But fundamentally it is about control. And so opting out and being complacent about your data being scraped and utilized by saying, well, I'm not that interesting. I don't care what they know, whatever. They know where I live, they know what I buy. it doesn't matter, is so dangerous for our democracy.
12:09Alyssa: Yeah, that's actually there's a term for that. It's it's like kind of like how we discovered financial nihilism as a term. It's it's called this digital resignation.
12:18Bridget: Oh.
12:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So basically
12:20Alyssa: there's there's two researchers that came up with this term basically, but it's like most of us aren't okay with being tracked. like you said, but we've decided there's nothing we can do about it. Yeah. And so that therefore looks like consent, but really it's just helplessness, like or learned helplessness. And so it's also comparatively in the money world, it would be like when we stop opening our banking accounts or we stop we start avoiding our money. It's not because we don't care. It's because we feel like we have no power.
12:49Bridget: Yes. And I think that is how most people feel. And I think that is also intentional from the
12:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): company.
12:58Alyssa: 1000%. 1000%. They want you to be exhausted.
13:02Bridget: Yes. That's why why I think in the book they called opting out of anything and not sharing your data or like turning your phone off was a privacy protest.
13:13Alyssa: So
13:14Bridget: now I think about that when I leave my phone at home when I go on a dog walk, I I'm also having a privacy protest.
13:20Alyssa: That's really I'm like, should I just turn my phone off at night? Not gonna do anything.
13:27Bridget: Well actually you can get like these bags that you put it in that block all signals to and from your phone. So that's if you want to take the extreme end. Because when
13:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's off it's
13:36Bridget: actually not really off. Sorry everyone. But
13:40Alyssa: perfect.
13:42Bridget: You have you have to go to great extremes. They really want to track you, is the conclusion. But um anyway, so it is it is about control. And the second major point that I want to make that wasn't in this book because well, she hinted at it, but this book was published in 2019. So it's now seven years old. She's still on the speaker circuit, and I'm sure she's talking about this stuff. I didn't read any more of the author's more recent works, but I can guess what she's gonna say about our current state of affairs. And over the years that you and I have been recording the podcast, we have a few episodes on AI,
14:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
14:22Bridget: I've listened to them over again, and I was pretty slow to develop a concrete opinion on AI. And you can hear that in a lot of the conversations we have. Cause I I develop strong opinions, but I really like them to be affirmed informed, so I take my time. And while everyone was having these outsized reactions to AI, first making art and then taking jobs. and all this other stuff. Like that has been the whole communications up until now. I want to let everyone know that I have come to my conclusion about what AI is for and what the purpose is, and it is surveillance. That's it. That's the entire end game. This is the point of artificial intelligence to collect as much data. as it possibly can about you, to analyze it and categorize it in ways that are useful to technology companies and governments. And I think
15:27that is everything that AI is going towards. I think that was the purpose when they released it to the public. And I think everyone has been completely distracted by absolute non- nonsense, conversations and arguments about productivity and art and whatever, which do I guess we can still have those conversations. They are not non existent, but AI is for surveillance and tracking you. That's the point.
15:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
15:55Alyssa: mean, isn't that how things always go? We always just are only willing to scrape the surface when we're having really intense dependencies. debates about things we should have strong opinions
16:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on.
16:06Alyssa: Like if we really scratched that itch a little bit more, we would uncover exactly what you just said. But it's easier and less scary if we only talk about the surface level issue.
16:15Bridget: I think it's also like all of this is always obscured, right? And it's so dark. And there was that other great book I read by I think Karen Howe.
16:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What was it
16:26Bridget: called? The Empire. of AI? I actually can't. We did an episode on that one too, I think. And that one's really good to read with this the surveillance capitalism as well, because it outlines interestingly how AI has been designed to engage with you so that you give it a ton of information. And we see that in chatbots. chat bots. Like when you're talking to Claude, our chat. or GPT, when the AI is like thinking, it will do that like three dot bubble that you typically see when you're texting a friend. It doesn't need to do that. Like the AI is not thinking. They do that to humanize it. So you feel like you're talking to a real person and you disclose more information. And we know that's true. Like when you think what AI has grabbed for from people over the past three, four, five years, where people are not only using it as a search engine. I know a lot of people have used chatbots primarily for that. Like it's replacing Google, and Google's pretty bummed about it. But people are using it for therapy.
17:32Alyssa: Uh-huh.
17:33Bridget: People are using it for financial advice. They are disclosing everything to it. It is giving you whatever useful conversation you think back, but it is capturing, storing, analyzing that data, attaching it to your name, and it's ending up uh brokered to people who want to buy it. And I think like I think it's so terrifying because some of this I don't think was possible even three years ago. But AI has improved so much in recent years. It's become so good at collecting lots of different kinds of disparate data and putting it together and categorizing it for one individual. Another great book to read on this is The Philosopher in the Valley, which is about the CEO of Palantir. That one really goes into how great AI has been. at letting them, you know, make better tracking for weapons of war because it's improved so much. And so I think the dangers for our data have escalated as AI has improved. I don't actually think it was as dangerous five years ago, ten 10 years ago. Like Facebook was sure trying. Like they were going for. everything, but
18:52they didn't have the technology to aggregate it or categorize or analyze it in a way that's useful. And now AI can do that in literal seconds. And we've entered an environment where these companies have four to five thousand data points on every individual.
19:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh, you
19:17Alyssa: know what? This is making me think of though is like when you mentioned Claude and how it's like meant to track or just get to know who you are and the scariest thought that came up for me is I think that because so many people do use it as a therapist, so to speak, they're sharing their deepest, darkest thoughts that they would never share with a real human being.
19:36Bridget: Yes. No, that is that is the point. Yeah.
19:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's what I'm
19:40Bridget: saying.
19:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Because
19:41Alyssa: I because you know how like when you're being being watched changes you, right? Like there was one researcher I think that did like an after the Snowden leaks. Do you remember that? Yeah,
19:50Bridget: I do remember.
19:57Alyssa: After that, because nobody told them to stop. It's just that knowing that they might be watched. was enough. And I think that surveillance doesn't have to catch you doing anything to change how you behave.
20:10Bridget: Yes.
20:11Alyssa: But a lot of people, for Claude, it's like they don't feel like they're being watched, even though they are.
20:16Bridget: No, you think you're having like a private text message it with your special AI best friend. And I I say this as someone that's guilty of the same thing. Like Claude and I have loved. long conversations about my tennis progression. Like he's always working out a plan for me to improve my skills. He's quite ambitious with it actually. So I've participated in the same granted before I understood how much was being shared. And I don't want to tell anyone like don't use AI, because I I still use AI, but I am more careful of
20:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
20:50Bridget: I declose, and I'm really thoughtful of like what am I giving to big tech, which I think ultimately can end up in the hands of the government. But I actually don't even think the government is the scariest institution now. I do think it is the technology companies because I do think they have this data and the purpose is for influence and control. And they've already shown evidence that they can do that, which will which we will discuss. because I have lots of highlights to share with you in here. But I do want to point out that the risk of your data has increased. And
21:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
21:26Bridget: I mean in risk of your data, I don't mean in like data leaks and stuff, though that is obviously true, but in how they use your data, because now that we are at this point where they say have 4,000 to 5,000 data points, possibly more per person, per user on a platform, they know more than just your email addresses, your passwords, your location. They know your friendships, how often you talk to those people, how often you see them in person. They know your daily patterns of life, probably actually better than you do, which is really crazy to think about. because it's everywhere and it it is categorized. Like it's they know so much about you, I think you would be shocked by how much. But so I think the next thing I want to talk about is how you are being tracked. Because it's not just like what you put into a chat bot is one thing, but it's being added to a dossier of data that's been collected elsewhere.
22:27Alyssa: Yeah. Well, I'm like, this is all they want your feelings, right? They don't want
22:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they want your feelings and they
22:32Bridget: want your thoughts. You're people think passwords and emails and bank information is sensitive, which granted it is. It's sensitive, like you don't want a hacker to get it. But I mean, Google already has that. So does Facebook. Most people use the same password for everything. They know how to get into your banking. They have your email and your passwords. password. They're So they're fine. They don't care about that. They want your thoughts and your feelings. Well,
22:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and I
22:56Alyssa: think that as humans, like we really all have this deep need to be known, and algorithms give us a pretty convincing version of that. It's like, oh my
23:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): God, this app really
23:08Alyssa: gets me.
23:09Bridget: Oh, that just made me like shudder inside so badly. But you're totally right. I'd never thought of it that way. Yeah.
23:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It is tapping
23:18Bridget: into the human psychological n need to be known and seen.
23:21Alyssa: Yeah. And it feels you're like, oh, this feels good, not creepy. But
23:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): oh
23:25Alyssa: but being known by a person goes both ways, right?
23:29Bridget: Yes.
23:29Alyssa: And being known by a platform only goes one way and someone is selling it.
23:34Bridget: It's so gross.
23:36Alyssa: It's so gross. We're
23:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like, oh
23:38Alyssa: my God, like my algorithm is so special. It's like,
23:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): oh, that's
23:41Alyssa: kind of creepy, isn't it?
23:43Bridget: It actually is. Like, we think it's funny now how curated our algorithms are to us. Like basically every person is experiencing the internet in a completely different way, which is wild. But yeah, we take it as like a luxury, but it's actually quite dark.
23:59Alyssa: It's so dark. It's so dark. And like we've talked about which I know you're gonna get into, but it's like it's predetermining the things you should like or will like.
24:08Bridget: It is not even predetermining, it is influencing you. It is nudging you to like certain things. It is making the decision for you. And we and yeah, we will talk into that because that's the darkest aspect of it. But first let's go into like how you're being tracked, because some of these people will know. Uh some of them they won't, uh, because it it's shocking. But obviously, our main thing is our mobile phone. That's essentially like you're wearing a tag all the time that says, Here I am, and this is what I'm doing. And like I'm not asking anyone to go without their phone, but you can make your phone safer because uh one thing that I didn't realize is like many apps that you install on your phone will track you even when they are closed and you're not using the app. And I think all of us have apps that we've downloaded years ago and then like never logged into again. Um, a lot of those apps can track where you are, what you're doing at all times, what your behavior is across other apps. And they might still be accessing your photos or whatever. So one thing I did recently. is I went through my phone and I just deleted all apps that I like don't essentially need. Unfortunately I am left with like all the big tech ones that belonging to Google and Meta. That's I think that's all of
25:28us, but there's tech you can live with and then like you don't need to give your location data to some like random app from another country that you don't know what they're doing with your data. But um, they are tracking you and your behavior across other apps. They also look at your screen time, your search history, your messages, your contact lists. So, and that's how they're building those maps of your relationships with other people. So, again, a lot of this data is scraped and then algamated automated together and then sold. Like data brokers are actually selling it to the these companies that aggregate it, and they do determine all your personal relationships and are even ranking them by how close you are to someone based on how frequently you talk to them and interact with them. Alyssa's face right now. Like I'm just like the horror I felt. Um they also can access uh the cameras on your phone to see. where you are and what you're doing, as well as the front camera where they try to gauge your emotional state by
26:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Stop
26:35Bridget: it. No, I'm serious. So they're looking and they're they're attaching it to your browsing. Like if you're sad, like what websites do you go to? Whose profiles do you look at? What apps do you use? Um how do you behave when you're happy or optimistic?
26:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
26:54Alyssa: literally almost gonna start crying, and I'm like,
26:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): oh my
26:57Alyssa: god, I should flip my phone over.
26:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
26:59Bridget: no, you got like we thought I was I was just leaving my phone at home to go on dog walks to minimize my screen time, but look what I was really protecting myself against. Like, I'm not even kidding. And I will at the end of this episode, I will go into ways that you can uh protect. yourself. But the first the first main one is like delete any apps that you don't use. Like just get them off your phone immediately. Um, the ones that will be left will still do some of these things. Not all of them. Like there are honest app creators out there, um, but then there are some that are really insidious. And again, the ones that are are going to be the worst are the big tech companies, right?
27:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
27:36Alyssa: I'm like, I knew a CEO who owned. a rewards app, and that was always upfront with like in personal conversations, very upfront about the fact that that was the sheer purpose of the app was to collect data. They actually didn't care about that.
27:51Bridget: Yeah. I know who
27:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that is.
27:52Alyssa: Yeah. We it's the same mutual
27:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): friend.
27:55Alyssa: But anyways, I'm like that that's very common for every sort of like financial based app.
28:01Bridget: Which I did didn't realize when I made Gilded, because even though I tend to consider myself a smart person, I'm apparently a dum-dum because I was just trying to make a good financial app. And maybe maybe I should have said this at the beginning, but uh we have to get more content out that says this. But Gilded does not sell or share your data with anyone. And it never actually occurred to us to do so because I only want to give people good financial information. And we do have a significant amount of financial data, obviously, because we can't do accurate projections unless you tell us how much money you have. But I feel so strongly about privacy and data protection. I just I would never share or sell what we have, which is why we have to charge users money. So whenever someone's asked, why is Gilded so expensive? I'm like, because we actually make money from user subscriptions, not from selling the data. If I did sell your data, Gilded would be free. But we don't.
29:00Alyssa: And I think there are a lot of good apps out there that don't have that intention. But you also do have to consider that that could be a possibility down the line with whatever you're using, right?
29:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
29:11Bridget: how do you know? Like unless you're reading everyone's terms and conditions and processing. privacy policy. Granted, I know our privacy policy inside and out, because I had to go over all the lawyer documents when we were making it. But unless you're reading all these dense legal documents and understand what they're saying, it's really hard to know. And every time you get those emails that's like, hey, we updated our terms and conditions, we updated our privacy policy. Unless you are taking the time to read them for every single app, you actually don't know who is collecting what data and how and what they're doing with it. So
29:41Alyssa: yeah, I couldn't even bring myself to read your outline. I'm not reading the
29:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): curves and
29:45Bridget: conditions.
29:46Alyssa: I'm like, and every time it's like cookies, I'm like, Oh, I love I love cookies, except
29:54Bridget: all right. Uh okay, the other thing um your devices are doing are our recording audio. But I think we've known this for a long time. Remember when
30:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we used to always
30:02Bridget: be like, our phones are listening to us, and then we're
30:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like,
30:05Bridget: no, that's a conspiracy. Yeah, they are. Okay.
30:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That was my
30:07Alyssa: favorite. Those were my favorite videos on there, when we'd be like, My boyfriend leaves the room, and I'm like, Diamond ring.
30:14Bridget: Oval. Yeah, your phones are a hundred percent listening to you recording everything. Your your laptops. laptop. It's like really funny. There was this uh photo of Mark Zuckerberg. like published online uh showing him, I don't know, I at Facebook do it or at meta doing meta things and the laptop beside him had the camera, had tape over it, the microphone port was covered. Like and I think that's so funny. If they are
30:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): scared
30:42Alyssa: of his own tech.
30:43Bridget: If they are doing that to their own devices, like we gotta follow. So you can and again, I'll give you the methods to protect yourself towards the end of uh this podcast, but your mobile phone
30:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
30:57Bridget: lot's happening inside the phone, a lot is happening outside of the phone. So this is from the surveillance capitalism book. There was an ad tracker, I think it was in Europe, called Fids Up, and it can detect the presence of mobile phones and their owners by diffusing a tone that's inaudible to the human ear inside a building. So users installing this app that was actually a restaurant guide uh in France would have their physical location tracked via retail outlets speakers as they move around Paris. The experience would be shared by readers of a car magazine app, Auto Journal, and the TV guide app Telestar.
31:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Wow.
31:38Bridget: Why why do we need they like can you imagine downloading a restaurant guide and then it's on your phone and it's not doing anything inside your phone, but there are audio signals interacting with it in the stores you go into to track your location around Paris?
31:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
31:55Alyssa: that's what I mean. Like, none of so much of it is outside of your control. I think that's where that digital resignation comes in, because even that, I sent you a TikTok with about that new Amazon B.
32:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh
32:06Bridget: yeah, that's ever that's just a blatant data. They're not even trying to hide it.
32:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They're like, this is going to
32:11Bridget: listen to everything.
32:18Alyssa: I can't imagine why you would
32:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be
32:19Alyssa: like, Yes, please listen to my conversations and transcribe them. Um, but like your friends don't have a say if you're wearing that.
32:28Bridget: Yes. And that has been a huge problem with these apps from the beginning, which I think shows how like desensitized we are to this. I rem like I'm so old. I remember when it was a scandal when you would make a Facebook account and sync it to your contacts and that was a data grab for Facebook to get all the contact information of people who did not have Facebook accounts. Because
32:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): now
32:51Bridget: once you released your address book, it then had their names and phone numbers, even though they did not consent to that information being on Facebook. And this is actually why Meta probably has most of the data of anyone in the world. Like it's more powerful than any government because of practices like that.
33:11Alyssa: Yes. It uh I don't even know where to start with all of that.
33:15Bridget: I well I'm not done. I'm just gonna keep going. So um yeah so again so these apps could be communicating um with external things. They're really aggressively rolling this out in the US uh with Bluetooth like Bluetooth in Target is like on the shopping carts are on your phones and they're they're heading towards of course like giving different prices based on who you are and we've talked about um that before but your phone like leave your phone in the car write your grocery list on paper and leave your phone in the car because um there's so much interaction happening with external single signals on your mobile device even if you don't have an app active or open on your phone. The other thing that is maybe the scariest, and this is probably what I changed my behavior the most about, is Wi-Fi. Wi-Fi
34:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
34:11Bridget: so sketchy. And um, so when we think of Wi-Fi, all of your data fly flows through your Wi-Fi, right?
34:19Alyssa: It's
34:19Bridget: the connection, all your passwords, email addresses, says everything you connect to has to go uh through that stream. So it's very, very, very sensitive. Just to show how much is in it, I'll share um this story because this shocked me. Like when Google was doing the Google Street View mapping, and you know we've all seen those cars with the cameras before and it's like photographing all the outsides of Sides houses and they're like, oh, we're we're mapping the roads and everyone's like, oh but it's creepy blur pee. people out or whatever. But and we kind of didn't like it, but it happened anyway. Uh they also said they had intercepted and stored payload data from home Wi-Fi networks, which included names, telephone numbers, credit card information, passwords, messages, emails, chats, transcripts, as well as records of online dating, pornography, browsing behavior, medical information, location data, photos, and video and audio files.
35:16Alyssa: How?
35:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Because
35:17Bridget: it's all in your Wi-Fi. So they would drive by, attach to the Wi-Fi signal of every house that they pass, and they claimed they uh accidentally retrieved this. They were they were just they were they in I think they admitted they were like looking for names and email addresses, and then they were like, whoops, we accidentally got their credit card information. and pornography habits. Oopsie. But so uh everything is in your Wi-Fi. They did kind of get in trouble for that, but uh I don't I don't know what happened. Not serious trouble, but I think that shows how vulnerable Wi-Fi really is. Granted, not everyone has the technology that Google has to like walk by a house and access their Wi-Fi networks, but I do want you to be extremely careful on public Wi-Fi networks. I've actually stopped using them entirely without a VPN. I've disconnected my phone from absolutely everything. My phone, like my phone has cellular. There is no reason for me to go on Wi-Fi ever on my phone. And I just don't know. A lot of it is
36:23pretty benign. It's just location tracking, but it's also all this data is in your Wi-Fi. Like everything I just listed goes through there. So it is so dangerous to exchange any kind of personal information on a Wi-Fi network. So just don't do it, I guess.
36:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
36:40Alyssa: but I just go back to I'm like, I there was a point in time where like I had to rely on Wi-Fi because I couldn't afford data. And so it's just like back to that point of like all of this is linked because you're forced to use these things
36:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
36:57Alyssa: you're in a precarious financial situation.
37:00Bridget: Yes. And like, and that's and again, like this is the other thing, is we cannot fully opt out. I can't opt out. I run a tech company.
37:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I have a
37:10Bridget: podcast with you. I cannot not be on the internet. I would love to. at this point. I would love to be invisible. I don't want to have a phone. I don't want anyone to know where I am or what I'm doing, but um I can't. So it's more like at this point, I just want people to have the information so they can make slightly better choices that
37:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): protect
37:30Bridget: them. Like if you can afford cellular data on your phone, the th then use that. Like don't connect to every wire. And I think like for phone plans are pretty generous. Like you can get lots of gate. Maybe you have to reduce how much TikTok you watch at a cafe. Like, and again, your their your home network is generally secure, except for the Google Street View.
37:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
37:53Bridget: But like strangers aren't generally going. I won't I won't share what I know actually. But uh
38:00Alyssa: You have to now.
38:01Bridget: Well I I'm
38:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): don't know Z.
38:02Alyssa: nosy.
38:04Bridget: There are these devices that you can buy and you can use them to access a public like a public Wi-Fi network and see all the devices that are connected to that public Wi Fi network. And then from that you can also see all the Wi Fi networks those devices have ever connected to. And once you have those internet service providers and IP addresses, you can get like the home addresses of those accounts. So again, just like don't use uh cafe Wi-Fi or use a VPN. We can talk about that later. But I just my main thing is just Wi-Fi is super dangerous. And that's all I want you to take away from this.
38:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Clear.
38:42Alyssa: Clear crystal clear.
38:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
38:44Alyssa: hear you Are loud and loud and clear.
38:47Bridget: Now the other way they are getting your data that is super duper dangerous is social media, which we know this. Yes. Uh I don't think we should use social media anymore.
38:57Alyssa: Okay, Bridget.
38:58Bridget: Sorry. Sorry, everyone. For for you and I, we have to because we have to run our lives on there. But I'm quite astounded by how much people share uh in terms of photos, updates, life updates, photos of their kids, especially, I think is extremely dangerous. dangerous uh for so many reasons, especially in this age of AI. We know what people are using AI for and pictures of children. Um recently in the US, the court ruled that they aren't going to consider, I'm even afraid to say these words because I don't know what we can block out, but C S A M.
39:37Alyssa: Yes.
39:39Bridget: That is if it's generated by AI and you possess it, that's not a crime.
39:44Alyssa: What?
39:45Bridget: Yeah. That's
39:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's a recent
39:47Bridget: ruling in the US. And so if you that AI has to be trained on real people, if there's photos of your children online, that's what it might be used for. And um that's that's I think quite dark, but the other the that that's like a bigger concern, I think, than your data. So I do want to just put it here. I want people to think about that. When you're posting pictures of your children online, how is that being used and what's it for? And don't say, oh, I have a private account. It's not no, you don't. Nobody has a private account.
40:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
40:20Bridget: That that's just over. Um and so it this this was a quote from the book um from twenty 2017. seventeen This isn't related to that, but just to show how careful this is, because now they have even more data. But Facebook boasted that it had 2 billion monthly users that were uploading 350 million photos every day. They described it as practically infinite in terms of data. And then by 2018, Facebook research team announced that they had closed the gap and were now able to recognize. faces in the wild with a 97.35% accuracy, closely approaching human-level performance. So the more photos there are of you online, of your children, of your family, especially over time, it's going to go into facial recognition software and like those flock cameras in the US. This can be used by governments for all kinds of phases. fate. Basically, you are going to be tracked everywhere you go all the time. Like it will just come up. You walk into a store, someone's looking at a camera, and your name's under you on the video screen. Like that's where we're headed. So I beg of people listening to this, if you do not have to make your money online as Alys and I do, do not post anything online. I know it's so hard because we want to share with our friends and family.
41:39Text them, that's a little better. Not through WhatsApp because Meta owns that, but just don't post online. Just don't. Like, it's so dangerous. I can't I can't emphasize enough how dangerous it is.
41:51Alyssa: I mean, the the craziest part about all of this is like we are all paying for this. We are sometimes just giving it away for free.
42:01Bridget: Yes.
42:03Alyssa: Like how where how did we get here?
42:07Bridget: Because we tricked people, okay. Like the trick was you are and they're still doing this with AI, okay? Like this is what I want to emphasize. Like the Muse. This is the second time Meta has launched it. It they originally origin tried to get this going in 2015 and it was called M, and it was this. assistant in your messages. Like Zuckerberg's been trying to do this for a long time. I'm looking at this outline. We're not gonna get through this in one episode, Alyssa.
42:36Alyssa: We're gonna be doing a series everyone.
42:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
42:39Bridget: you heard it here first. Multiple episodes. So um they have been the promise has been you're going to have this highly personalized catered experience online that's going to feel good, be efficient. And this is true. Like, actually, my experience online is pretty good. Instagram ads shows me everything I want to buy. I can automate so much work now that I couldn't even do like two years ago. It's excellent. But yeah, we are paying for participation in like our own demise. So that's sad.
43:16Alyssa: Yeah. It's like we all say we care about privacy, like kind of that same thing we already talked about. And then we're like, oh, I'll give it away to you, though, if you give me 10%
43:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): off.
43:26Alyssa: Like it's kind of the same wiring that makes savings really hard for people because you're looking for convenience. And
43:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
43:37Alyssa: the cost comes later and it's fuzzy. we're gonna just pick the thing that's in front of us every single time. And I think that that's how surveillance capitalism operates.
43:47Bridget: Yeah. Yeah. It's I don't know. It's such a bummer. Like I'm getting progressively more depressed. I like I don't even know if we can finish this episode because of my mental state, let alone the length of the content of what we'll have here. But uh just to go back to like the facial recognition that Meta's doing, um, they said it was for more powerful ad targeting, but even more of the uplift would come from the immense machine training opportunities. They mean AI training, because again, this book was written in 2019. By 2018, AI was learning to discern activities, interests, mood, gaze, clothing, gait, hair. body type, and posture. So
44:30Alyssa: perfect. Everything about you.
44:32Bridget: Just what you need. And I think it's interesting too. Like another thing that's really being tracked, um, because you might say you're like, well, I have these accounts, but I don't post anything. But even liking content, commenting, or DMing is enough. That is data. And I
44:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): don't
44:50Bridget: didn't like think of that as data until I read this, but uh, and this is a quote from the book that I thought was really powerful. But it says, We are not scrutinized for substance, but for form. The price you are offered does not derive from what you write about, but how you write it. It is not what's in your sentences, but their length and complexity, not what you list, but that you list, not the picture, but the choice of filter and degree of saturation, not what you disclose, but how you share or fail to, not where you make plans to see your friends, but how you do so, a casual later or precise time and place. Explanation marks and adverb choices operate as revelatory and potentially damaging signals of yourself.
45:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
45:33Bridget: again, like beautiful writing. You can see how intellectual this author is. But they are tracking everything. And one thing that came up in here, and I talked to you about this, we've talked about this our whole career, is why do these social media platforms allow trolls and like racist and violent content? Because we know they have the technology to get rid of it. They see there's comment moderators and they're like, this does not violate our community guidelines. And I didn't understand. why these companies would allow such hateful content to persist. And for a long time, I was like, well, this, the executives are jerks and they don't care about the safety of people online. It's because it generates such powerful data around how people interact with it. Because when someone posts a threat of violence or something racist or something homophobic. there's so much data about the people that interact with it, whether they like the post, whether they share it, whether they comment on it. And so suddenly, not only do you not know this one person is a racist, which you would know and you would just block them, but because you let that racist post be published, you now know the hundreds,
46:48potentially thousands or tens of thousands of people that share those views that you didn't otherwise. So even rage bait and hate content on the internet from trolls, even manufactured, even bots that post this, it's bait to get data and understanding of people's worldviews and political leanings.
47:08Alyssa: Yeah, that's why I don't understand like you and I also talk a lot about how powerful comment sections are. on TikTok in particular.
47:16Bridget: Yeah.
47:17Alyssa: And I think that's actually one of the places where you're you're sharing so much more than you realize.
47:23Bridget: Yes.
47:24Alyssa: Because most people are like, well, I'm not a creator. I don't post on the internet. But they engage in commentary online every day for multiple hours a day.
47:34Bridget: That disclose everything. Like
47:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people
47:37Bridget: in our gilded TikToks, like because I'll publish examples, um, financial examples in our videos, and these are really popular because and they're really fun to do. But inevitably in all the comments it's anonymous accounts going, well I have $1.3 million and I'm not ready to retire. And I'm like TikTok loves to know that about you now. Thanks.
47:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes.
47:55Bridget: They're so happy they have attached your net worth to your username.
48:00Alyssa: Yeah. With like I I think that's most important too is like again, I I do really monitor like how much of my personal life I share publicly online. But to a certain extent, too, it's like it doesn't matter how much I restrict what I share on my public platform because I still use my phone for everything I do in private.
48:23Bridget: It no, it so I don't want people to feel that way. Like I hope no one takes away from this that it's totally hopeless. Every time you restrain yourself, every time you refrain
48:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): from
48:36Bridget: sharing something or posting something, even if you are like, I'm only gonna do it on my private account instead of a public one, or I'm just not going to share Are this one thing, that matters. It is one more data point that you didn't let them have. And I've thought about this a lot because I have been really more offline for the past um few years. Like if you look at my Instagram feed, I like almost never post. I think my last post was in May, because I took my daughter to South Korea, and we actually visited three cities in South Korea, and I wanted to a post for each one, and I never even got to the third city because I'm just lazy at this point. And like my personal Instagram hasn't even updated in that. I I haven't used Facebook in probably seven years. And I don't post to X anymore. And even though I am still online in many ways, when you think of like how much I've diminished the volume of content that I used to provide, I used to share like daily updates in my stories that showed where I was and
49:36what I was eating and what I liked and reviews of books. and clothes and and I don't put that on there. And so these data brokers, like sure, they have about you and I, they probably have like 40,000 data points like 40 to 50,000 because we were chronically online. But data is most valuable when it's current and accurate, right? Once it becomes outdated, it's less accurate. So even the fact that I've reduced how much I post and how frequently
50:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
50:06Bridget: I'm sure they have a pretty comprehensive profile on me, but it is less than it was a year ago
50:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
50:12Bridget: two years ago. And that and that's matters. Like it it is significant. Everything you reduce like is more power for you and less power for them. Like it's funny, I r I listened to our screen time episode recently. and it's funny to listen to it in the context of avoiding surveillance capitalism when I was just trying to like spend less time online. But virtually every single action in there was a way of taking back my privacy and autonomy from these technology companies, even though that was not my intention when I did it. So I
50:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): don't
50:50Bridget: want people. to think that it's hopeless because we are all online and this is how we do our jobs and have a lot of parts of our social life. Like everything that you take back and go analog or spend less time on these platforms is meaningful because you are starving them of data that they want. And you're taking your power and attention
51:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): back
51:14Bridget: to you.
51:15Alyssa: Well, and like not only that, not only are you fighting against the surveillance capitalism, but you're also just like making your day to day life happy, which is the theme of like season nine and season 10, which is like every time you do something by hand, you're strengthening your own memory, or like because
51:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
51:34Alyssa: think there's like research on the Google effect where we get better. at remembering where to find information and worse at remembering the information itself.
51:44Bridget: Yeah, I know.
51:46Alyssa: And so, like, if you have your phone that remembers everything for you, like what happens when your when your friend tells you an important piece of data about their life, like what happens to the act
51:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
51:58Alyssa: remembering? Like remembering what someone told you is a part of how you show. them that you care.
52:04Bridget: Well, we don't want that anymore, right? Everyone has these AI wearable devices that are gonna record your entire conversations and then tell you what's important and send it to you later. Like the cognitive offloading is making us like nothing less than like blobs of skin and cells with no identities. Like it is an erosion of identity. fundamentally at its core, I think. And but it it's all by design that it's really hard to opt out. This is a little bit of a segue, but just because I was thinking about it, there's a wonderful TV show called Upload. I think there's four seasons of it. They really rushed the last season, but it's very funny. It's like a dystopian comedy. And I think it's a few years old now, but they address like AI, uh, wealth inequality, and they also talk about this surveillance. And there's a group of people in the show that are called like the Luds, which I think is short for Luddites, because they've
53:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): opted
53:08Bridget: out and gone like totally off-grid. off grid. And the show is so brilliantly done. I'm actually like stuff. sad that it was a little casual and focused on economy, uh, on a comedy, because I think the insight was like they were just so on the nose with the direction that society's headed, and they make light of it, but the topics are very serious and very dark. So if anyone wants It's like to still think about surveillance, capitalism and AI and wealth inequality and the future of tech. but doesn't want to feel like super depressed about it, you should watch upload.
53:44Alyssa: Oh. I think like what's happening, I I only think I always think about the brain, but I'm like, when we're talking about how we've all become blobs too, I don't think people have stopped wanting connection. It's very clear we all still want that. I think it's now we've gotten to a point where online connection feels safer because you get to control everything. You get
54:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to control
54:05Alyssa: the timing. You can edit yourself. You can leave without it being awkward. You know, real people in real life is very unpredictable. And but the problem is that every time we pick the easier version in life, the in-person one gets harder. Right.
54:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like
54:21Alyssa: every single time you do it. And it's the same way that avoiding anything makes your anxiety worse. And platforms benefit from that because the time that you spend in person with your friends is not data that anyone can sell if your phones are off and put away. Yeah.
54:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No one's wearing
54:38Bridget: an Apple Watch. Yeah.
54:40Alyssa: And
54:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're not every
54:41Alyssa: device. You're like gonna start having house parties where everyone has to put all devices into a box.
54:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
54:45Bridget: thought of it. P so people do do that.
54:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
54:49Bridget: that's kind of like I know they do it at like super wealthy celebrity. Yeah,
54:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): celebrity parties. Yeah, like
54:55Bridget: Taylor Swift made you do it at our wedding and stuff. I thought of like doing it for my Halloween party and just like put a basket out and say, like, phones going here.
55:03Alyssa: It's very spooky. Surveillance capitalism box.
55:06Bridget: Oh my god. I might label it that.
55:09Alyssa: Yeah, you should. I think it's like really obvious that we barely scratched the surface. of this conversation today.
55:16Bridget: I know.
55:17Alyssa: Because I feel like that was just like you said, that was the overview.
55:20Bridget: Girl, I'm not even through the list of how they're tracking you.
55:24Alyssa: Oh.
55:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,
55:25Alyssa: finish us off.
55:26Bridget: No, it's too long. How much
55:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time you
55:28Bridget: got?
55:29Alyssa: Not.
55:32Bridget: We we're not gonna get to it. Um, I'm gonna put a little highlighter where we're stopping. And I suspected this would happen. This is why I told you. I was like, how much time do I have? And you were generous and gave me a lot of time. I didn't realize it would be this much, but I still have a lot to say because I am very passionate about this topic. And I think, like I said, I think this is the most important conversation you and I will have on this podcast. And now it gets to be more than one episode.
56:02Alyssa: I'm happy about it. I think that it needs to be like at least two or three.
56:06Bridget: Yeah. So, but I do think there's some important takeaways here. First, please no one be hopeless. As depressing as this is, fight it. Second of all, please delete any apps you don't need from your phone. That's your task today. Turn off Wi-Fi on your phone, except at home. You can use it at home, but now. whenever you go somewhere, forget all the networks. You don't need Wi-Fi on your phone if you have a good data plan. If you are using a computer at a laptop at a cafe, just get a VPN. They're very cheap. It's like $5 a month. It's so cheap to have a VPN. And that will encrypt your data and protect you when you're browsing in a public space. And stop posting to social media.
56:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
56:51Alyssa: think those are all really low lift, like those are low lift things you can do, and it does make it seem less overwhelming.
56:58Bridget: And that protects you, like first surveillance capitalism is still happening. Base sorry about that, you guys. But that also protects you from a lot of hackers and scammers, which is the whole other danger that we're not really addressing because that's not part of the conversation here. But like just those few things like that's leveling up your privacy and protection from other sources of harm that are out there. So like only good can come of it.
57:22Alyssa: Well, it's it's all like it is. It also is gonna improve your mental health.
57:26Bridget: Yeah. Yeah. Listen to our screen time episode again.
57:30Alyssa: Yes, do that. Do that. Okay, well, I'm excited for for us to continue the conversation next week. Thank you for listening to today's episode of Money Feels. We're so grateful for every single download. Feel free to subscribe to our podcast anywhere you listen, and if you like this episode, you can leave us a glowing five star review. You can also join hundreds of others on our Patreon for bonus content and more.
57:56Bridget: Lastly, you can follow us on Instagram where you will not post anything at mixed up money for Alyssa at uh Birchy British K. Casey for me, and at MoneyFeels Podcast. And we'll see you next time.