Speakers debate Jensen Huang's resignation, index fund concentration, and FCA's new value assessment standards.
Summary
Kate Hudson and Abraham Okusanya discuss Jensen Huang's resignation from Nvidia, debating whether founder-led success justifies weak governance. They analyze whether diversification remains effective in an AI-driven market, with Hudson citing historical concentration trends and Okusanya questioning active management outperformance. The conversation shifts to UK regulatory changes, specifically a government consultation on workplace pensions and the FCA's rejection of 'peace of mind' as sufficient proof of value. Speakers propose using data-driven 'so what?' tests and client testimonials to demonstrate tangible advisory outcomes.
Key takeaways
- 1 active portfolio should have no more than 40 stocks... compare that to like you know SP 500 holding just over 500 companies or maybe slightly less or even the MSCI uh world index that is holding five thousand stocks
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 32:54
Episode sections
- 0:38 – 23:09
Jensen Huang Resignation & Governance Debate
Kate Hudson and Abraham Okusanya discuss Jensen Huang's resignation as Nvidia CEO, debating whether the company's success justifies weak governance. Hudson argues for independent oversight, while Okusanya emphasizes the unique value of founder-led companies.
- 23:09 – 32:54
Diversification vs. Active Management in AI Era
The hosts address claims that diversification no longer works due to AI mega-caps. Hudson cites historical data showing concentration is normal and active managers are more concentrated than index funds, while Okusanya argues outperformance is often statistical luck.
- 32:54 – 34:47
Index Fund Concentration vs Active Management
Speaker 0 argues that active portfolios are more concentrated than index funds like the S&P 500 or MSCI World, which hold hundreds or thousands of stocks. They claim indexing ensures exposure to future winners like NVIDIA, whereas active funds may miss them.
- 34:47 – 38:15
Herfindahl Index and Effective Diversification
Speaker 2 disagrees slightly, introducing the Herfindahl Index to measure the 'effective number of stocks' rather than just the count. They argue that passive cap-weighted indexes can be overweighted in large caps, and that factor-tilted portfolios (like those from Dimensional) may offer better diversification effectiveness.
- 38:15 – 50:34
UK Workplace Pension 'Super Nudge' Consultation
Speaker 3 discusses a government consultation led by Torsten Bell MP on workplace pensions, focusing on retirement products rather than contributions. The goal is to 'super nudge' savers into a default retirement income product, potentially an annuity or CDC scheme, to prevent people from running out of money.
- 50:34 – 58:20
Regulatory Challenges for Advisors and Value Assessment
The speakers debate whether advisors can justify fees for mass-market clients with small pots in default workplace pensions. Speaker 0 highlights regulatory risks in providing guidance without full advice, while Speaker 3 notes the FCA's new stance that 'peace of mind' is not sufficient proof of value.
- 58:20 – 1:05:28
FCA 'So What?' Test for Value
Speaker 2 proposes a 'so what?' test to quantify value for the FCA, moving beyond intangibles like peace of mind to concrete outcomes like tax savings leading to more money or behavioral coaching leading to staying invested. Speaker 0 adds that the FCA requires proof of counterfactuals (what would have happened without the advice) and full cost transparency.
- 1:05:28 – 1:07:00
FCA Value Assessment and Fee Justification
Speaker_0 discusses the FCA's stance that 'peace of mind' is insufficient value, requiring advisers to prove worth through data. They contrast their low fees (9 basis points) with market averages but note that clients still ask 'so what?' regarding the savings. The speaker suggests a methodical, granular approach to embedding value in the business model.
- 1:07:00 – 1:09:16
Measuring Investment Outcomes via Data
Speaker_2 argues that advisers can prove value beyond fees by using platform data to track client behavior, such as net purchases during market downturns versus sales. They suggest using cash flow models to demonstrate progress toward retirement goals and using CRM data to track non-investment outcomes like wills and powers of attorney.
- 1:09:16 – 1:11:32
Client Testimonials as Value Proof
Speaker_3 agrees that data is fragmented but emphasizes that advisers must obtain direct client testimonials to justify their value. They suggest advisers ask clients to articulate in their own words how the adviser prevented them from selling out of the market or running out of money, creating a 'fact pack' of client-sourced evidence.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| NVIDIANVDA | equity | mixed | It's taken a little while to get this organised, so a bit frustrated by technology, but here we are about to talk about things like Nvidia. |
| S&P 500 | index | neutral | Because at the time they were saying that Lynch's run that he went on, I think he beat the SP 500 for something like 12 years on the trot or something. It was insane. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Jensen Huang has stepped down as CEO of Nvidia.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·0:38
How to verify: Check Nvidia's official press releases or SEC Form 8-K for resignation announcements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceNvidia is the largest company in the world by market valuation.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·2:17
How to verify: Check current market capitalization data from financial data providers like Bloomberg or Yahoo Finance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceKate Hudson's firm holds approximately 0.6% of Nvidia in their Global Aware Value Fund.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·3:09
How to verify: Check GSI's fund fact sheets or regulatory filings (e.g., SEC Form N-14 or 13F) for portfolio holdings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceNvidia voted against 10 of its 14 directors at its AGM.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·3:28
How to verify: Check Nvidia's proxy statement (DEF 14A) filed with the SEC for voting results. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceJensen Huang had 60 people reporting to him and no COO or chairman.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·3:48
How to verify: Check Nvidia's organizational chart or proxy statement for executive reporting lines and board structure. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Nvidia's valuation is $5 trillion.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·5:55
How to verify: Check historical market capitalization data for Nvidia around the time of the podcast recording. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceNvidia went public in 1999.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·6:37
How to verify: Check Nvidia's IPO history via SEC filings or financial news archives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceElon Musk's voting control of Tesla was diluted.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·17:39
How to verify: Check Tesla's proxy statements and news reports regarding stock issuances and voting rights changes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In 1932, Standard Oil, Consolidated Gas, General Motors, DuPont, United Gas Improvement, AT&T, and RJ Reynolds made up 32% of the market.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·25:49
How to verify: Check historical market data sources like CRSP or Kenneth French's data library for 2026 market capitalization shares. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
3% of companies have led all growth since returns started being measured.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·26:27
How to verify: Check research by Bessenbinder or similar studies on market concentration and returns. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Active portfolios should have no more than 40 stocks, meaning each holding represents about 2.5% of the money.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·32:54
How to verify: Check the portfolio holdings of the active manager or fund described by the speaker; calculate the percentage of total assets per holding. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The S&P 500 holds just over 500 companies.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·33:15
How to verify: Check the current constituent list of the S&P 500 index on the S&P Dow Jones Indices website or SEC filings of index providers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe MSCI World index holds 5,000 stocks.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·33:35
How to verify: Check the MSCI World Index constituent count on the MSCI website or fact sheets. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe Herfindahl Index measures the effectiveness of diversification.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·35:07
How to verify: Review financial literature or the definition of the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) in economic or investment textbooks. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Torsten Bell MP is influencing workplace pension reforms.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·38:35
How to verify: Search UK government press releases or parliamentary records for Torsten Bell's involvement in pension consultations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Half or just over half of people with pensions want a guaranteed income for life.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·39:15
How to verify: Check the government consultation document on workplace pensions or relevant survey data cited in the consultation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceOver three-quarters of people with pensions do not know the route to a guaranteed income.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·39:34
How to verify: Check the government consultation document on workplace pensions or relevant survey data cited in the consultation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The FCA stated that 'peace of mind' is not a valuable thing in fair value assessments.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·56:56
How to verify: Search for the FCA paper 'Price and Value: Outcome, Good and Pro Poor Practices' published in July 2026 on the FCA website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceIn Australia, clients must consent to fees every year.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·1:01:03
How to verify: Check Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) regulations or the Corporations Act regarding ongoing fee authorization. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The FCA paper 'Price and Value: Outcome, Good and Pro Poor Practices' was published in July.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:01:47
How to verify: Check the publication date of the FCA paper on the FCA website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceSpeaker_0 sells MPS at nine basis points compared to an industry average of 15 or more.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:05:48
How to verify: Check MPS fee disclosures in their product documentation or website; compare with industry average fee data from sources like H1 Global or Morningstar. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The speaker's track record is six basis points relative to the market at a level of twelve.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:05:59
How to verify: Review MPS performance reports or fact sheets for tracking error or relative return metrics against a specified benchmark. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Advisers must do their own value assessment with the FCA every year as a fund manager.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·1:08:20
How to verify: Consult FCA Handbook rules on value assessments for fund managers (e.g., SUP 16 or related guidance) to confirm annual requirements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourcePlatform data can prove net sales and net purchases when the market was down.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·1:07:20
How to verify: Analyze aggregated trading data from major UK investment platforms (e.g., Hargreaves Lansdown, AJ Bell) during market downturns to observe retail investor behavior. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The FCA says peace of mind isn't value.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:05:28
How to verify: Search FCA publications, speeches, or consultation papers from the verification window (2026-08-18 to 2026-11-18) for statements on 'peace of mind' and value. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDo your own research
- Verify Jensen Huang's resignation status via Nvidia's official SEC filings or press releases.
- Check the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) calculations for major index funds versus active portfolios using fund fact sheets.
- Review the UK Treasury's consultation document on workplace pensions led by Torsten Bell MP.
- Read the FCA's final guidance on 'Fair Value Assessments' and the specific criteria for justifying fees.
- Analyze historical sector concentration data for the S&P 500 to assess claims about diversification efficacy.
- Compare fee structures of active vs. passive funds using Morningstar or fund provider disclosures.
- Investigate the definition of 'effective number of stocks' in academic finance literature.
- Look for counter-arguments regarding the long-term performance of factor-tilted portfolios versus cap-weighted indexes.
Full transcriptexpand
0:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to Soapbox. One person can make a difference. An individual can make a difference that is infinitesimally greater.
0:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): But the point is, it's not the individual talents of that active manager. It's just that if you get tens of thousands of active managers, one of them, by pure luck, pure maths, will outperform for a substantial amount of time.
0:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Diversification is your friend. It is your true friend in investment, reducing idiosyncratic risk. And breadth is the answer.
0:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It's Advisor 3.0 Soapbox Edition.
0:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Welcome everyone. Welcome to episode 17 of Soapbox, the best podcast out there for all the financial planning community and beyond. I am joined for our episode today by the wonderful Kate Hulk. Hudson, managing partner and founder, I think we'll find out in a minute, of GSI, who are the boutiquey little mini
0:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mini
1:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): dimensional. Are we allowed to say that? The value investors. And my good friend, longtime buddy Abraham, the what do we call you these days? I'm running out of things to describe you as the disruptor extraordinaire, um, a taste that I have become accustomed to, although I understand there are some people in financial services that haven't yet. So welcome, welcome both. How are you both?
1:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I'm well. I'm well. I uh I'm not a technology expert, as you may know. It's taken a little while to get this organised, so a bit frustrated by technology, but here we are about to talk about things like Nvidia. So nothing thing like bringing that
1:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): into
1:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): the conversation.
1:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So you don't have
1:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): to understand it, you can just invest
1:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in it, right? So that's
1:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Brilliant
1:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Abraham, how are you?
1:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, I'm I I'm very well, Matt. I have been cold worse, so yeah, keep keep looking for all the different ways to insult me. Great as Sor Kate, it's great to have you on. Thank you for making the time.
1:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Brilliant guys, thank you. Uh thank you both for joining. We have lots and lots on the docket today we will do uh our very best to get through all the financial news in a sensible thematic order. So I thought we'd start off just because it's the most topical thing. Kate, you raised this when we were chatting pre pod. We've got the largest company in the world, buy stock market valuation. And depending on when you're listening to this, who knows where the share price will be. Jensen, um, he has stepped down as CEO, the founder, Um, a lot of what NVIDIA is as a company today is because of him, and a lot of the people that still run the company are um mini clones of him, but obviously stepped down for very, very good reasons. I'm glad they got it done quickly. Um and yeah, it's interesting to see how the market reacts to this. Kate, you'll you'll have a view of you as a um as an investor in in these kind of companies.
2:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Look, we hold Nvidia in our global ava aware value fund, not in our focus value because it's definitely not a value company. We hold it underweight the industry uh because it fits our ESG model. It do and uh we you know try and overweight companies that have value and ESG. So Nvidia we hold a small amount of it about 0.6 of of um its market share. So we will be affected um like everyone in the company But one of the things as a ESG integrated investment, you know, governance is an issue for us. And I think this is a governance story. First and last, and almost it is definitely a governance story. Interesting fact at the AGM for Nvidia this year, we voted against 10 of their directors, 10 out of 14. Independence was an issue. And I think there's a question of when do you look at a company for um, you know, yes, it keeps going up, and he was an amazing entrepreneur and a very, very smart man. But he had 60 people reporting to him, no COO, no chairman. When does that actually start to say, when when does the party over and when do we need to start looking at these governance issues of this company? And needless to say that there's I'm not even going to mention the reason he resigned.
4:08He's very much topical at the moment with some other high profile people. You know I think
4:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's been
4:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): quite the week quite the week for it, isn't it? Um two affairs that have probably each um cost in terms of company valuation of a quarter of a trillion each um for the two affairs that have come to light so far. So yes uh it has been quite the week for it. Um Abraham you again you're a massive investor um in in NVIDIA. What's your what's your view?
4:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah so I am yeah uh you know I am I am a holder of a globally diversified portfolio with a little bit of uh value tilts but but way more way more than uh Kate. Why are you holding nine 9.5% point five percent of the largest most successful
4:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): company in
4:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the history of capitalism thus far? I don't want you to answer. Maybe I'll come back to maybe.
5:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Because you hold it in
5:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): other funds. Sorry,
5:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): say that again.
5:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): You hold it in other funds, that's why.
5:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, of course. Of course.
5:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's about diversification.
5:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, I I mean anyway, let's not go down that route. rabbit hole. A couple of things. So I read the story of Jensen, uh his his bio in a book published, I believe, in in 2025. Somebody at at the advisor 3.0 conference, I think it's in 25, somebody mentioned this book to me. And for the life of me, I cannot remember the advisor who told me this. book. Uh, and I kind of just shrugged, and you know, anyway, I got the book. It's called The The Thinking Machine, and it's the story of how Jensen created what we now, you know, know referred to as the biggest company in the world. It's a five $5 trillion dollar uh valuation company. And originally created essentially to make, you know, chips for gamers, you know, for for, you know, and and he pivoted that incredible uh, you know,
6:17into this incredible business that it is today. So I have huge, huge respect. You know, this company was founded in nineteen ninety-three and for most of its life, it went public uh six years later. It became a publicly listed company on the Nasdaq in nineteen ninety nine.
6:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do
6:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you remember nineteen ninety
6:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): nine?
6:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Quite a terrible time to listed
6:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): tech company.
6:44Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): This was
6:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well good
6:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): in ninety 99, nine, bad in two 2000. thousand
6:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, this was just before, just before uh you know, the the the great tech crash, as it's as known. And you know, and for most of this company's life, none of us, you know, even when it was in the public market, this is the beauty of holding a global, a global diversified equity portfolio. We never heard of NVIDIA, we never heard of Jensen, we didn't care. who he slept with. I'm sorry, you know, for most of that period. Anyway, you know, about 10 years ago, we started to hear of this company, and and it's the the rest, as they say, is history. Here is my uh view. Obviously, the guy has had probably one of his one of the worst week weeks of his career. I don't know if you saw this meme on on LinkedIn that kind of just showed the global economy stack and you know like in a as a Jenga stack and then there was a there there's a really uh there's a bit that if
8:01you push it it will would j the old gen Jenga will come down. And somebody labeled that bit as Miss, you know, Mrs. J Jensen's wife. You know that this this you know. Look, my my take, these guys had like a a horrible week. My take is from a a a personal indiscretion side. of thing, that is for him and his family to deal with. I cannot imagine what he must be going through. And when the first part of this news came up about you the know Chinese spies, spice, I was thinking, maybe, just maybe, the world will give. this guy a pass on this one indiscretion. Um we would allow they will allow Congress and uh you know the the the system the investigation that the board's doing to work its way through and and we will get a picture of what took place. But when the second one came out, you know a team member all of this, everybody was like, Yeah, you know,
9:19this is not going anywhere. So Jensen is out. As far as NVIDIA is concerned, here is my take this their product is outsold for the next two, three years. Okay, there is some work to be done on the strategy. and the, you know, maybe product development for the future, you know, but this is not an immediate challenge, if you like. So I'm I'm not worried. I am not worried about about you know this this this company as it were. This is about demand uh for for the next generation of you know of of of technology. That demand demand for AI is is not going anywhere. Who knows what the market will do? We'll see. It's already taken, as you said, uh you know, a quarter of a trillion of its uh market value, which I think actually
10:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): shouldn't need it be shouldn't it be
10:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): worse than that. Uh that that the the visionary visionaire of this business is now moving on. But if if NVIDIA can't survive, the the world largest company cannot survive you know the departure of it of the founder CEO after over 30 years or so of of service, then we have a bigger problem. I'll just touch on uh Kate's point about corporate governance. There is some truth. Uh, sorry, there is part of this that I agree with. You know, like most of his board members have been with him for a long time. You know, there are VCs who back the company in the early days who are still on the board seat. So, yes, you know, there there is room for a little bit more of, you know, of governance and independence uh on the board. I completely. disagree with Kate on like reporting lines, the fact that he doesn't have like like layers and layers of executives running around, uh, God forbid, lying to him. You know, like the executive
11:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know, it's
11:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it's not the number, it's not the number, it's some it's not below him, it's above him. He needed there's an issue when you don't have a chairman and your lead independent director. happens to also be your lawyer. There's a problem where there's n there's an accountability layer above. He was just really important. I don't care whether he's got 60 or six, it's not the number. He was obviously integral to that firm. Like unbelievable. Um, and so it's just that sometimes you need it's not just he had an affair, he had an affair with somebody who's a spy. So the FD. FBI are after them. You know, yeah, if you find a somebody in your in your office that you find the look of after after a Christmas party, that's totally different to having an affair with a spy, which he may not have known, but even worse. It's more about accountability. Who's above him? And where's the succession plan? And where is There somebody saying, Hold on, hold on, Abraham, is that the right thing to do? Are you leading with your with your pen or with your something else?
12:29All
12:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right,
12:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): let's just be clear Let's just be clear, Kate. This is not about Abraham. I agree with you on
12:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): board
12:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): governance. We agree. I don't agree on like executives and reporting line, you know, like he doesn't need uh, you know, several layers of people between him and these sixty 60 people to
12:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do that. No, no, no. He needs someone above up him.
12:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): It's
12:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the biggest
12:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): company in the world. He needs someone above him going, what's
12:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): going on down
12:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): there?
12:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): We agree on that, but just one final point, and I will I will cede uh ground is this is a key thing in you know democratic capitalism. One person can make a difference. I know we say this all of the time. We say, oh, you know, team and you know, whatever. But one person can, an individual can make a difference that that is, you know, like infinitesimally greater. So
13:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): look, it's
13:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it's yeah, it's an
13:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): interesting thing.
13:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So we shouldn't not know everybody isn't the same. You know, the natural law. of the universe is that there are outlier individuals. I am sorry, you know, it's it's not fair, but there are outlier individuals, and we've seen this in the capital market over and over and over and over again. You know, so so you know, the this thing that you know is a is a quite important person in his company, uh the company is. he founded
14:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): yes
14:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): they it's a one he's a one off
14:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): but that
14:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and I'm not having an affair with the guy incredible you
14:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): can be in an incredible human you can be an absolutely incredible human it's a there's parallels with um with Elon Musk there's parallels but investors shareholders have the right to know that the governance of their company the that they're putting their hard-earned money into is some form of oversight of the board and independence on the board. There's they were bringing more people in. I think the board members are going up to thirteen and and the bringing new people in. None of the board had any corporate um uh the security, you know, national security experience. They're the biggest company in the world. And none of their board had that experience. All I'm saying is from an invest from a from a uh company that ha has a fiduciary duty of people's money, no matter how bright and how entrepreneurial, how amazing an individual is, governance is there for a reason.
15:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
15:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): look and I I I I agree.
15:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I agree with
15:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): everything you're saying about
15:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): individual. I I agree agree with
15:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): both with of
15:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you.
15:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think I think where the market's different from what maybe I've been used to for my career. And I did start in ninety-nine, two thousand, which was a terrible time to start as a financial advisor, I have to say. The problem is we've got lots of these founder established companies, the hyperscalers, that are coming to market. They're going from a let's face it, a solo one man. founder kind of and it is men largely, uh, unfortunately, kind of corporate culture where they own everything, they control everything, it's their bright ideas, they get to do everything. And then these things are listing. And as soon as they list, rather than coming sort of creeping up and and sorting their governance as they go up through the stack by size, they're straight in as some of the biggest companies in the world. And we've we've got more of it. You know, we had it with Musk, we've got it with um. and
16:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you know why. Go back to the history of corporate governance, right? Is that in in certainly in Sil Silicon Valley, you know, these bright young things, they founded companies, they took this company public, and then they get loaded by this board or boards. buds who end up you know in many cases uh you know uh sacking the founders destroying value um the the world at some uh the corporate world at some point then decided that actually if these guys founded the company they could be trusted to run the company. Again, this is all up to a point. You know, we had we had uh Steve Jobs, for instance, at Apple, where they founded, they sorry, they sacked the guy, they brought Scully in, they destroyed so much capital value, and then they brought him back and he re reinvented the company. We can go on and on. And so what that shifted certainly in the 1990s is the emergency. the emergence of this like founder CEO, who, you know, and you know, we've seen it's gotten worse where we, you know, these these
17:25guys were being given, if not economic control of their company, but at least voting shares. You know, look at uh uh you know Elon. Elon, for instance, they they they they took i say they took but they they diluted heavily his hold sorry his voting and control of tesla and so this is why you know this is why uh you know now that he's taking spacex public it wants to merge the over
17:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so that it you can can
17:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): re
17:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): gain control of the company
17:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): look at the jo the battle that sorry matt uh I you you know I know you hate me for this, but I yeah, yeah, like what's the word? Uh uh Facebook guy. The battle that is Zuckerberg that that he's gone through with his board uh you know lately, the again the point I'm say it's sorry, the point I'm making is yes, we need better corporate governance, but there is a reason why we've landed in this place that founders are seeking greater and greater control of their companies with super voting shares. There is a reason we got to this place. Board governance, by the way, and I'll shut up, is not a fail-safe, you know, thing for like bad things happening. Uh I I would just say that. Sorry, Matt, you were making a point before I rudely and impolitely interrupted.
19:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think it was the other way around. I think I was I was interrupting you to make my point. But yeah, no, uh I mean look, it is I think we're all grappling with um global stock markets changing very, very swift. swiftly. You don't have to roll back many years to a point where you just didn't these hyper I mean NVIDIA was listed, but it wasn't it wasn't what it anywhere close to what it is today. And now we it seems like not month by month, but you've got so many of these massive companies whose gravity is such that it's shifting the markets. So and I know we're gonna come on and talk about this because I know
19:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm gonna
19:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): be allowed my my AI bit in
19:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
19:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): minute.
19:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay, one question for you. Would you say that corporate governance in the UK stock market, and let me find you another one, French stock market, European stock market, is significantly higher than we get across the pond?
19:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Look, I don't know. I know that we as a as a company that votes. we have s we strongly vote against direct there's often examples where we vote against directors. We have a seventy percent of our portfolios in the US and we vote against a lot of directors in the US. We are very strong on our governance in our voting policy for again, independence and connection between CEO and chairman. There's There are some examples like Barkshare Hathaway. Amazon, we're going to say, but you want that. You want that to be connected. But we can still say we would rather have someone, one person, an independent, lead independent person above, just to also just be an echo. I mean you must have people that you use as mentors to ask, what do you think of this? What do you think of that? You can still be an entrepreneur, but you just need somebody. So board governance is something that as a global company we find that we are constantly voting against management on. Uh, I can't give you the exact stats, but I can get them for you. But it is an ongoing issue. But saying that, you know, we you were talking about um, you know, allowing entrepreneurs to to be who they are. One of the things, being a company that believes markets work, a lot of voting. and a lot of
21:15governance is on remuneration. And often you have an entrepreneur who's getting paid trillions of percentages bigger than other people in the firm. And we say, good on them. If they can build a company that can do a lot of raise a lot of of of profit and income and benefit for a lot of people, let them do it. As long as it's transparent and relevant. So there was an example of Elon Musk said, if he does X, he wants to get paid this ridiculous amount of money. I don't know the exact points. You probably you've got such a mind, Abraham, you probably remember it. And we voted to allow him to do that. If he does that, wow, let him try and pay him accordingly. So when you believe markets work, they they'll either get rid of him like they have with with this is not a this is not a question of uh that he wasn't doing a good job for Nvidia. No way. So let's just leave that there. You know, if it wasn't for these affairs, he'd still be in that job. But let him get
22:15paid and let him earn and let him grow the company like an entrepreneur does, because markets work and the market will would tell us whether they're doing a good job or not. But the market has told us that governance is important because 14 fourteen percent of that company is walked off the shelf where everything else is the same.
22:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, for a few.
22:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): It will be back, but it what it's saying is it's important, you know, and and okay, VW's back and they had a governance issue as well with emissions and people come back. But it is important. Markets work and entrepreneurism is important as
22:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well.
22:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Talking of markets working on I one know one of your other news items that you wanted flag for today, Kate, which I I thought was a brilliant one. And Abraham and I like do like to give an active manager a good kicking on this uh podcast. So there was um some news in CityWire. Um an active manager, I think it was Manchester and London, were putting forward the thesis, let's be generous, that in this new world of AI and these hyperscalers and these mega growth um mega cap. stocks, that diversification doesn't work anymore. You need to be making active decisions, you need to be picking a very concentrated portfolio of stocks. Um I mean, uh it would be interesting to track how they do with this. But um but yeah, I mean it's it's sort of the usual thing, isn't it? Active management, um, the thesis is that it will protect you on the downside, so that's why you need it. And then all of a sudden it seems to have pivoted because it hasn't protected on the downside to this particular guy saying, Well, actually, forget diversification, which is what passive gives you, you'll get diluted or lukewarm returns, I guess. Let's go for these massive companies. He he would have looked like a genius if he'd have been saying this probably five years ago. But let's let's leave that aside for a minute. But what do we think? Is is the stock market you two have your heads in investments every every day. Is the stock market so fundamentally different today than it has been in the past that a
24:08different approach is required?
24:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Interestingly, Matt, you said you started in ninety-nine. I started at Dimensional in ninety nine and I felt like I started again because I'd been working for one of the biggest active managers in Australia, Bankers Trust, who had a gentleman called Kerr Nielsen, and Kerr Nielsen predicted to it's what he claims now, the eighty seven crash and moved out of equities in June 87 or July 87. And so I went from working from BT and I got a job at Dimensional. And people went, Oh my God, you're going passive. You'll be out of there in a few days, Kate. You know, why are you doing that? And interestingly, I just I was dating a guy who'd got a globe glob at the time who had a uh MB. MBA from Chicago and he'd venerate his MBA every morning and I'd been to Univ Chicago, I'd been to the GSB, the Graduate School of Management, graduate school there that they call the GSB, and I knew the quality of the information and knowledge that came out of there, and I thought, let's go and find out. But at the time we were in a boom when it was a technology boom. Times are different, they kept saying. It's different this time. That won't work. Diversification won't work. And in nine year 2000, dimensional lost five billion over $30 billion AUM. And everyone said, David, you've got to change. This isn't working. No, no, we're not going to change.
25:29And then guess what? The market came back and said, You're right. Diversification still matters. But we can go all the way back to 1932. Now you mentioned on Nvidia's grown, these things don't happen. I I mu I have to look at my notes to get the names of the companies because they do they aren't off they don't roll off my tongue. Standard Oil, Consolidated Gas, General Motors, DuPont, United Gas Improvement, ATT, and RJ Reynolds were 32% of the market. Those seven companies were 32% of the market. Funny, the magnificent seven of today. are about 32% of the market. And there's there's some research cooked by Bessenbinder. And interestingly, Bailey Gifford uses it to their advantage because they say what Bessenbinder says, they paid him for his research just to help us out. You know, someone else is paying us Abraham to tell the story that we can use. But basically, he said that of all the companies in on every stock market, 3% has led to all the growth since we've started measuring returns. So if you didn't own every horse in in that race, you've got a damn good chance you're not going to make a winning. You've got to own all of them, because only 3% of those companies actually return any profit at any time over the
26:47last hundred years. So
26:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
26:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): best Bessenbinder and has proven is that concentration is not new. It's prolific over time. We go through long periods in the 30s and the 50s and the 99s when concentration was the norm. It is the norm. So this new time that, well, you know, now we've got concentration, now it's all about active risk, now it's all about finding the three. percent of names. We all know that some people do. You know, you've got examples of people in the world who have been able to do really great active management. Peter Lynch at at Magellan. No one mentions him anymore, but in nineteen ninety he was mentioned he was the name. You want to be a Peter Lynch.
27:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
27:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): know, maybe it's Kerr Nielsen in Australia. There's always one person that they talk about being, you know, n being the person who could find those names. It's just really hard. But the argument that active management that a concentration is new is absolutely not true when you actually look at the data, when you look at the research. Bess and Binder's done is done most of it, but other people have done recent um studies looking at the UK. Um, I will look at my notes again here. Jonathan Fletcher and Michael O'Connell from the University of Strathclyde actually have done a great survey looking at the 50 years of UK equity data. Proves the same thing. Concentration is not a crisis, it's not a bubble, it's not an anomaly, it's how equity markets work. And when you understand that, what you want to do is diversify. And then we we can go on and say we're factor investors. Concentration does not remove the fact that factors outperform the market over the long run. So diversify. and diversify into factors. So there you
28:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): go.
28:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I'll
28:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just smuggle it there.
28:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Before you pull the the pull the
28:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): pin on that grenade and you set
28:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): uh Abraham and I off on a whole different one. Abraham's built this beautiful graphic that that shows exactly this point, right? That shows that there's always been big companies that dominate stock market returns for Four decades. Yeah. And that it's just impossible to find those. Um, I I say Abraham has. I suspect Claude might have had something to do with it, but it is it is lovely. It's a gorgeous, gorgeous illustration of why you just need to own the haystack. Um, as as it's the only way to have the needle in there. Um, and I think I mean Abraham, perhaps we can put that that link out to that if that's allowed in the notes. And I think to be honest, you're Kate, you're absolutely right. The There it's is all very well thinking about NVIDIA. today, but actually, we're all long-term investors here, right? So what we are interested in is well, forget NVIDIA, because they won't be the biggest at some point in the future. We need to know now, if we're going to be making active decisions, who are the NVIDIA in 10 years' time.
29:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
29:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I'm sorry, but no one no one knows that. And you mentioned Lynch. Actually, I'm I'm sure it's Lynch that I've used in um presentations. in the past to illustrate that actually he didn't know what he was doing because he went on a massive run of hugely underperforming, something like 11 years. And there was a really good university study that actually showed statistically that there's always going to be someone, there's always going to be an active manager who is outperforming at any one time, and sometimes with very long track records. But the point is it's not the individual talents of that active manager. It's just that if you get tens of thousands of active managers, one of them, by pure luck, pure maths, will outperform for a substantial amount of time. Because at the time they were saying that Lynch's run that he went on, I think he beat the SP 500 for something like 12 years on the trot or something. It was insane. And everyone was saying, well, that's like a one in a trillion chance that that's down to. luck. But they were measuring the maths wrong. They were measuring the individual chance that he would do it. When if you measure the individual chance that someone will do it, actually, your odds on there's always going to be someone that goes on a run like that. Abraham, over to you.
30:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So so here is the thing. Active portfolios. are more concentrated than index-based or factor-based portfolio.
31:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do
31:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you want to write that down?
31:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I've
31:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): got it tattooed somewhere. I'll just call it.
31:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I put it tattooed on my face. So I'll I refer the gentleman and lady to a paper by. Morningstar titled Bold Portfolios, Are They Worth Their Risk? Introducing a multi-dimensional measure of concentration in equity funds. And what Morningstar did in this paper is essentially go beyond this kind of straw man norm. noise and actually look at concentration across with different dimensions, different metrics. So they looked at, you know, the number of holdings in the portfolio. They looked at the top 10 weight, uh, top 10 holdings weight in the portfolio, they looked at, you know, um stock level. I can't even pronounce this word, HF in sorry, HH index. Uh HH stands for somebody's name. Never mind. They looked at industry level HHI. They looked at sector level. They looked at diversification ratio, and they looked at index fund versus you know active uh type funds. They looked at concentration across
32:27different markets, you know, not just the US. Essentially, the key findings is that index funds are less concentrated by any objective measure of that term than you know than active funds. So for instance, I you well, you know, I used to be told in in in my LA. early days, you know, like investment days, that you know, a good active portfolio should have no more than 40 stocks, right? You know, and by the power of arithmetic, each of them is holding, you know, what is that, two and a half percent of your of your uh of your you know of your of your money. uh And so if you just work on that basis and you compare that to like you know SP 500 holding just over 500 companies or maybe slightly less or even the MSCI uh world index that is holding five thousand stocks when you look
33:35at you know things you know sorry uh you you measure diversification from any objective measure of the world, either in terms of sector exposure or number of holdings or even the concentration in the top 10 holdings, index funds are better, more diversified than than the that than the alternative. And to Kate's point and to Kate's point the beauty of indexing is there may be a company today that is completely uh you know irrelevant to today's return but is the next NVIDIA is the next you know you name your your you know. Chances are that stock is not sitting in your traditional active portfolio, but oh by God, is it sitting in my globally indexed, globally diversified, or globally uh, you know, factor tilted portfolio? It is. And so I don't know what why this these guy's talking. talk.
34:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I I'd like to slide slight sometimes this might be dangerous. territory, but I like to slightly disagree with Abraham on one small note. And I t I say that with my fingers crossed for for bravery here. So um I know you you know you're a a master of knowledge, so the Herfendahl Index is something that you will know. But what the Herfendaal Index does is really measures the effectiveness of diversification. So if you have a hundred a stock with a hundred names, but 99% of that portfolio is in one name, and then 1% is in 99 names, you're not diversified. You can say, oh, we have 100 names. So the Herfendahl index just measures the true effectiveness of diversification. When you compare some large like MSEI MSCI World or the FTSE 500 or any index on a Herf and Dahl index basis, you can improve the effectiveness of diversification. Because by definition, these passive cap weighting indexes are going to be overweighted the large caps, and sometimes they don't have the small caps. So putting another little nod in there for groups like dementia Dimension like like I'm dementia, is that we believe in the Herfendal index. Certification is your friend. It is your true friend in investment reducing idiosyncratic risk. Breadth
36:07is the answer. Not depth, but breadth. You want to go across countries, across sectors, across size, cross factors. And by doing that, you can actually improve your diversification. Uh ask if for those who are listening, have a look at your portfolios and ask them about the effective number of stocks with on our fact sheets, and it'll tell you. that actually, I wish I had it up now, but say the MSEI had 5,000 names, its effective number of stocks might be 200, and our portfolio has 900 names, and our effective number of stocks might be 300. You actually improving your diversification and reducing your risk. That's a way of doing it. A little bit slightly better than a pure index. But we know that um that timeline offers factor-based factor based investors as well. So you're onto that. You know that.
36:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah, Abraham's agnostic. Look, he'll
36:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): he'll he'll sell you
36:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): anything as long as it's not active. But
36:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
36:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): can't but basically coming back to the argument, which was AI is changing, times are changing, concentration is is now the only way to go is to pick the next Nvidia. It used to be to pick the next Google. And actually people at Google were trying to find the next Google. You know, you don't want to be. they've they've done it. So Nvidia is trying to find the next Nvidia. But the thing is that while you have this inia syncratic volatility in the market, you're going to get concentration. When we know something's happening, to me, the definition of risk is the outcome occurring that you did not expect. If you expect markets to be volatile, you manage money to a volatile market. If you expect markets to have concentration risk, you manage your money to knowing that that's happening. You're not going to take away, you can't diversify away market risk and et cetera, et cetera. But the risk of something occurring that you did not expect. We expect concentration. Diversify, diversify, diversify.
37:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): On
37:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): that one, I'm going to drag us kicking and squeeping screening away from investments just for a minute before we lose half our audience down the Herfundale. Herfundel index or HHI as I've just found out from Wikipedia it's uh shortened to so um there were a couple of financial planning topics on the on the docket I stuck those on because you know to me and if I'm telling clients day in day out don't worry about the investments they'll just happen in the background is all about the planning then I've got to do I've got to have a shout out for that on the pod as well. Um so there's a couple of things happening uh so sort of regulatory related. We're definitely seeing the first one is on on workplace pension reforms. We're definitely seeing uh Torsten Bell MP coming in and starting to have an influence now. There's a consultation that the government have launched on workplace pensions. I actually think some of it is well meaning. I think um they're referencing the auto enrollment success, which Kate um we we inherited from the Aussies. uh, which was a good development. They could probably do with just increasing the default um contributions,
38:55frankly, on auto enrollment, but that's not what they're doing. They're focusing on the other end of the journey, which is on what do people do when they retire? What product do they get when they retire? The consultation is very clear in terms of what it wants, so I don't quite know what how much they're going to respond to industry feedback on this one, but um there's clearly a concern. from the very highest levels that half or just over half of people with pensions say they want a guaranteed income for life. And yet well over three quarters actually don't know, don't have any engagement with their pension, don't know how what the route is to that. So the concept they're calling it super nudge, which always always worries me when they take a something like the nudge. unit, which has disbanded now and call it super. Um, is that they will guide people very, very strongly with super nudges into some kind of government built retirement pathway, retirement product. I mean, I'm not entirely sure what that ends up being. It's probably some kind of annuity. Because they're s they're very worried, and Torson says it in the introduction, he says, Well, I'm really worried people are just gonna going to run out of money. Um because they don't understand how they're long they're gonna live. That second point actually is is probably the point at which I start agreeing with him. Maybe as an industry this this um doesn't touch on the sort of clients we're saying
40:14seeing day in, day out, because we're not, as Abraham keeps telling me, we're only dealing with the top nine percent as a financial advice profession um of people in the UK. But it this stuff is important because as part of this, they are saying there's going to be a much bigger role for pension wise. And they're saying that actually they're going to make it harder for advisors to, this is how I read it, to transfer workplace pensions into SIPs and personal pensions, those kind of products, because they want to get this concept of a default and they want to uh they're they not enforce that, but they want to nudge people into going for the default. Open for views. I've got I've got more views if neither of you have got a view, but I'd be interested in in what you guys thought about this
40:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one.
41:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Kate,
41:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do you want
41:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to go first?
41:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, I don't mind going first. Look at
41:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that. You two
41:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): being too polite to each other today. I don't mind this.
41:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Uh look, it's interesting um that you in the nudge, the super nudge, the stronger nudge. If anyone hasn't read the Thalus Thaler's book nudge that came out in 2008, they should. It's so it it changes the way you shop at the supermarket because you're being nudged all the time. But the problem is with nudging is that complexity leads to lack of movement, lack of decision making. There's a thing called, I'm into the terms today, libertarian paternalism. Journalism. And it's Thaler's Taylor's idea that you know you want to nudge people towards good outcomes, but give them an option. to opt out. I am not against what the government is trying to do. I just think we need it comes down to keeping it simple so people make a decision. Because where there is where it's complicated, there'll be no decision and people will miss out. You have behavioral economics will tell you that people are s scared of annuities because they feel like they're going gonna to waste money.
42:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
42:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): we don't know when we're going to die. gonna die. And hopefully mine's gonna be a long way off. But I am also against moving people out of something that works to put them into something that you think your job as a financial advisor is to manage the person's money. I had the the job uh when I was an advisor back in Australia, back in the dark ages, of advising clients at Telstra who are in the telecom DB scheme and they wanted them to go into in the Telstra DC scheme. They were in a really good scheme. And they should have stayed where they were. But they were getting paid to move the money. And that was wrong. So I am a fan of what is right for that client. But so we're going to end up with lots of people with a plot and no plan. And so how do we encourage the plan? And that is advice. And you know, is this a Venn diagram? Is the government trying to force people into a um Australia the pension plan in Australia is not just a little bit, it's a lot and it works because people end up with a pool. In England, they haven't gone far enough. I totally agree with you. Increase it for. Just increase that. But they're gonna end up with small pots of money and they want it to last forever. That was a D DB B scheme. So one
43:13of my problems is when you're in the insurance. how is it fix and flex and fix and I've learned a lot of terms today. How much are they going to get? Is it really going to be enough to live on? Does this money not run out? I'm a bit worried about the actuaries who've planned this forever income and who's going to pay for it when the money runs out. But
43:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as
43:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): an economist, as an economic student, I was forced to agree with the fact that sometimes in economics the theory actually just makes sense even though you don't like it. Like dumping wheat. I don't like dumping wheat. But it would it would, you know, have a huge problem on the price of wheat, and and so the effect is dump the wheat. I don't like it. Well, hold on, economics says it makes sense. And that it's not a great correlation with tensions. But sometimes it is if this makes sense and as a as an advisor, you're not going to get them to put into a SIP. You're not going to be able to move the money. And if you and it's always going to be hindsight. When you move the money, the market will go down and the client will go, oh, it's that's just what happens. But I'm also of the opinion that we need those people who should not be in the default and should be in a better option. That should make it easy. It should be easy for those people to get it. advice and not the government should be putting in this structure that makes it very complicated for a client who does want to get out of the default and get into an option that's probably better for them who have a large amount of pool of money
44:42to get advice that fits with the rest of their assets. So for those people with fifty 50,000 thousand less, I mean the ten $10,000 thousand dollars is the ten $10,000. thousand they said if they tried to up it to £30,000, it would leave 300,000 people without the without the option. That's how many people have pools of pension of less than 30,000 pounds.
45:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
45:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): If
45:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
45:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): put that into an annuity, you're going to get two bits of nothing for the year. And if it's not index linked, what are you going to get then? So I know that's probably not a very clear answer, but my answer is absolutely we need to nudge people into pensions. Absolutely we need to have an actual default and not a choice because no one will make that decision. It has to be simple, has to be automatic because people do not like making decisions. And communication is the main thing that's gonna help there. People do not understand their pension and they think that that money um is should last forever. That's gonna be difficult with small pots. But the competition. complexity of getting people out of there can't be too hard that the people who should not be in the default can't get out. That makes sense.
45:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. So this this guided retirement policy consultation is essentially you said nudge. Um super
45:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): nudge.
45:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Super nudge. It's
45:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): essentially
46:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I
46:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): think it's
46:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): called
46:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): stronger nudge now. Stronger nudge or something.
46:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
46:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. Megan.
46:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Exactly. Mega nudge.
46:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): All these terms. Choice, choice architecture.
46:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Choice
46:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): architecture, yeah.
46:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, is what we're
46:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): told. You know, and uh it ten years ago, eleven years ago, uh Jo George Osborn told us no one would have to buy an annuity. And so therefore, removes the defaults default of people naturally going in. into uh into annuity when they when they want to draw down their it it it stopped forcing people down that route and made the option made it an option. You still had that option, but today you you don't have to frankly do anything until you get to 75 and then it becomes all you know uh complicated. Um so so that that's so so what Thurston's doing, uh who describes himself as a social democrat, I think you can delete the last the second word and just focus on the first one. But anyway, is he calls it making pension pension again, which
47:13is to change. the default to going into some kind of either an annuity or what they are calling uh you know, CDC, you know, but ultimately has the same sort of the same sort of outcome in the sense that you're your m in this in the CDC I imagine your money goes into this pool along with other people. It has to have some kind of longevity guarantee built in so you can't run out of money. They will be able to say to you um was the word uh you can maybe take they can cap your withdrawal that that sort of thing. So so so I wanna want to say it's it's a drawdown all in all but sorry, sorry, sorry, it's it's an annuity in all but name. But anyway, let's not let's not go there. So my point is that the the key is what we are defaulting people into. And and to your point, uh I guess the fear is that we're gonna end up with people with
48:24a A because this looks at you know ports in isolation. So somebody might have, you know, five different ports, but because this is implemented on a port by port basis, you know, the risk is that people get forced into something that's not, you know, that's not suitable for them because once they go into into this door, they may not be able to
48:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they may not be able
48:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to come back. And to your point, uh i i it sounds brutal to say, but this would have the greatest impact on the section of the population who don't currently have uh access to advice. You might argue that maybe it will force more and more people to to take advice and do something before they reach this dates. date. So, but let's say we drag you know 5% more people into the advice net, which is great. We still have something like 80, 85% of the population who risk being dragged into these things. So look, I don't know the answer. I am not sure that it is a meaningful positive improvement on the state. status quo, which is that people uh, you know, just end up with their port uh doing the wrong thing with their port as it's as it stands. I I I really I really don't know.
49:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Or
49:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): spending
49:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
49:53Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): very quickly and having no
49:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah
49:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): and look, I don't think um I don't think as uh the financial advice profession we we're even set up to take another five percent of the population, frankly, as we are at the moment. Maybe, maybe that is changing um with AI and productivity and efficiency and brilliant tools like Timeline um to help us with that. Maybe, but we're still we're still a long way off that. So we do need we do need something for the eighty-five percent. Let's let's just be honest about it. We need we need nudges, we need government to to make it easier for those people. This g this come on comes on and touches on our next point. which is uh around value. I I still believe as we're set up at the moment, are gonna struggle as a profession to add extra value to Kate's um point a minute ago, to an individual who has the majority of their pension pot in their workplace pension, DC pension scheme, uh, who has a decent default option if if that's what they're building, and is getting charged 0.3, 0.4% per annum, all in cost by their workplace pension provider. I really struggle with the idea that advisors are going to add sufficient value to move them into a 1.4, 1.5% environment. Um if if that's all they've got, if there's a decent
51:11retirement option for those people and if that's all they've got. I agree with Kate for bigger pots, but then we're advising the people with bigger pots largely anyway. We've we've already captured big market share in that tiny little bit of the market at the top.
51:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This is a m
51:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): mass market solution. It's not a um
51:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Which is great. It's what we need, right? We need better outcomes for them the m for the majority of people and we'll focus on focus on the outcomes for the the minority. Sorry to say that is is where we're operating as a profession.
51:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah look I I I want to say all professions work like this, but maybe that's not true. But look, I think that I do think that it's possible, you know, we were talking about uh you know the the Aviva uh sort of proposition um last time on the pod. But essentially it is possible to you know, without giving like full-fledged advice, it's possible to, when people are in pension exclusively, you know, money that that's held in pension, it's possible to uh, you know, give people, you know, just high-level guidance on asset allocation, withdraw, you know, withdrawal rate to say. to them, hey, you know, based on your asset allocation, based on your age, maybe, you know, a bit of insight on your on your health, tell us. This is a level of withdrawal that will be sustainable from your from your portfolio, and we can track it going on.
52:44Now, where I disagree with you, or I am tempted to disagree with you, Matt, is when it comes down into what else might be going on in this individual's life that we do not know. So in other words, have we alluded to ports elsewhere, you know, taxes, for instance, the interaction between their spouse's income, interaction between uh, you know, state state benefits, uh, for instance. So so I I I think those are like the issues that that you're gonna bump into, even for the 80, 85 percent of the population. Technology can and will help, but my question is: is our regulatory framework even ready for this? You know, the minute you suggest to someone, we were talking about this yesterday, the minute you suggest to someone, you know, that you know, you know, maybe they
53:46can afford to take a little bit more from their portfolio than they are taking, you are, you are, you are, and you do it on a personalized basis, you are you are certainly heading into the territory of being. caught by by uh you know given advice. God forbid that outcome uh turns out not to be, you know, not to be or even interpreted wrongly differently than what you meant. So I think those are the issues that you know if this framework essentially leads to the path where you know employers and you know, pension providers are in. able to you know put a a a guardrails around things like withdrawals, making clear that once you're in drawdown you can't come back out of it, or once you're in a CDC, you know, making clear the point of no return. I think, you know, the the the the the paper, the policy document used the the I can't remember the term it used, you know, the point of no going back. They didn't say that, but that that's how interpreted it to me. If we can make that clear to people,
54:59and I think they seem to be suggesting that there should be consent once at some point, but once you're on the other side of it, you know, you could end up with your funds being, you know, annual annuit. annuitized at 75 or whatever, uh, depending on how the scheme's set up. Look, I I think this has got it's got some good things. We just have to we'll see how it we'll see how it it it it pans out um in the real world. I am not sure, Tomat, I agree with you that it makes it difficult or more difficult for advisors to uh justify transferring out for.
55:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah, I I mean that is my interpretation. I'm sticking to it. Um, but um we can we can argue that another time. I mean it does lead quite nicely onto our our next point, next news item, which is the FCA are doing some work at the moment around value, so fair fair value assessments, these these wonderful things that we've got used to right across financial services, 'cause of
56:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): course
56:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): it isn't just advisors, it's banks, it's all all the financial institutions. What what are you delivering for the price that you're charging? Um interesting paper from the FCA recently around this. I do love their good good examples, bad examples. Um that's how just how my brain works. frameworks. I I don't like the technical detail as you're both finding out um on this chat. Perfect.
56:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): enough.
56:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): But but I like I like them showing I like them showing this is this is what we we saw these two things. This one was terrible, this one was good. I'm okay I can get that. What what was interesting coming out of this one, particularly for advisors, and I don't know for your side of the fence, um maybe less so, is that they they are being clear that they want people to measure what the outcome what value the outcomes have, right? That you're providing. They did explicitly say in there that you can't say peace of mind is a um is is is a a valuable thing. Which uh, you know, is I mean that's gonna hit some planners hard because that's that's what we trade on. You know, giving that's been for my 25 years in in the industry has been we give peace of mind and clients think that's really important and that's why I'm worth, you know, one 1% percent or one 1.5% and a half percent or whatever it is most of my advisors are charging. And I think that's good because that brings clarity. They're saying you've got to, you've got to demonstrate value. You've got to show us what value you're giving to clients, and you've got to show why you think you're worth what you're charging for that value. There are a couple of little nuggets, and Abraham knows me well enough to know that I'll always jump on a little thing like this.
57:35One thing they did say in their example of bad behavior. is if you've got differential pricing and some people are being charged a lot and some people are being charged not a lot. And when you look at the profitability of a firm, these guys are subsidizing these guys.
57:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Mm-hmm.
57:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
57:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): that as a flat fee advisor only, that looks a lot like percentages to me. So that might be my coming from my my biases from from my place. But I I know I'm in a minority of one amongst uh um all of our listeners pretty much. But I just think it's I think it's interesting because I I think if advisors ignore this and and I would include myself in in this, um this is a quite a dangerous area actually. It's quite a easy area for the FCA to review and pick firms up on.
58:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
58:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): do you want me to go look it's interesting having been in this industry a long time, and we always seem to have to prove our worth uh And you know, you go to the doctor and you come home and you think, Oh, that was a waste of my time. I still feel sick as a dog, and they didn't listen to me. They didn't prove their worth, um, as long as I'm still alive. So it's really because we're dealing with people's money, and there's been so many examples in the world where people have taken that to their own advantage. And as we know, um, and my I was talking earlier about being an Australian, and I was in Australia when we went through a huge review and we all had to go through PS146 exams and you we thought we'd clean it up. And I started working in England in 2008 and it was RDR. And I'm like, oh I've been through this in Oz. I was putting us on a pedestal as I like to do. You look at the Australians, we went through this only for a few years later to be a Royal Commission because clients were charged fees for no service. And these weren't just advisors, these were the big banks. These were large corporates who were basically ripping clients off. So I get that the FCA has to
59:23continue to test and judge is value being made because of the few bad apples that have been in the industry. And yeah, it's tough. It's tough. How do you how do you quantify something that it is peace of mind often? So I thought I'd I would compare or say a few things that I used to. when I was consulting, I used to have to say, We're, you know, we're the largest company in the world, we're the oldest company in the world. And I'm like, is age important? So what? So what that you're old? Is old good or bad? So I thought I'd throw this in and say, so what? So what is my value? I saved tax. So what? So when you're looking at trying to find a list of outcomes that you can give to the the FCA, ask yourself in your business, so if my client, if I save my client tax, so what? Well then they've got more money. So what? So they can retire early or they can help their children or they can buy something that they want. They gave them behavioral coaching. So what? So what does that mean? They stayed invested when the market fell. So what? Or they didn't lose as much as they could and they didn't have regret. So I think it's important to
1:00:23go through the list of of benefits and think it's not just a I save them tax. That's not a benefit. The benefit is that they've got more money in the pocket. Well, what does the more money do? It gives them more freedom. Um and it's trying to trying to it's hard, but how do you how do you quantify that? Anyway, I was just gonna say some one of the one of the and then there's different ways of of of doing that, but one of them is to when a client comes and says sees someone, what are the three things you want to achieve with your financial plan? Or what are and and then have a like a cricket score. Like at the end of the first year, how far close are we to meeting those goals or you know, keeping track and showing that to the FCA? Changes globally. So in Australia now, client doesn't have to say every year a client has to say, I don't agree with the fees. No, not yes or no, no, I want to continue with your service every year.
1:01:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:01:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): that's pretty important message if they don't like you that you're not adding value. But there's I think there's different ways that that the advisor can work around this by not just saying peace of mind and trying to really work out what is it that they're doing for their client, the so what? And keep asking
1:01:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that.
1:01:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So I I will I will encourage people to go and look at this paper. So the this report by by the FCA, which you know was actually published, I think, in July. Um it's called Price and Value Outcome, Good and Pro Poor Practices. The my takeaway from this is that the the the FCA FCA it sees the measure of the way that you would naturally, natural uh you know, interpretation of value very different than we we do. Oh sorry, when we I say we, you know, like from a business, you know, just a pure Your business standpoint. And And and and you know, sadly, uh Kate, some of the things that you were alluding to, frankly, don't seem to count for a lot. So, in other words, you know, you can say, I help clients sit in their seats, you know, during poor market conditions. So what? I like sorry, by the way, I like your thinking, which is
1:02:45like, so what? They didn't sell out, so what? Um, they get their portfolio recovered, so what? They were able to meet their retirement objectives and all that. Now go and prove it. Now go and prove that you were the one who helped them stay invested, and that if they hadn't, so it would be worse if they hadn't. It requires proof. proving everything that you say in your value assessments. It goes more than that. I'll give you an example. In our world, because our product is an you know, I say our product, our you know, MPS and the things that we did is intermediated. Uh, you know, so in other words, we only deliver our proposition. through financial advisors. We not only have to take account of our own costs. Matt, you said
1:03:48your own costs. No, no, no, no, it's not enough. We have to take account of the OCF, the asset manager's cost, and we have to take account of the platform. cost. And yes, Matt, I have to take account of your cost. There, and you make it harder. You know why? There is a thread in our business in timeline that they say, how do we do how do we do value assessment? Because you're you're like for the flat fee-based, and we have to say, and by the way, yours is the easiest to prove. I I there's a term I I used to sorry, there's a term I used to describe this thing internally. I said, well, when you consider the typical client that you're serving, Matt, and the charge, the fee that you typically charge them, uh, you know, if there is any rating as super duper mega value for money, then than then that will apply in this case. Our product governance guy says, said to me, Oh, Abraham, that that's not on the ranking. We can't use that term. My point is this thing requires what they're calling real world testing. So, in other words, you have to test how the value uh you
1:05:07know
1:05:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
1:05:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): ultimately accrues to the end client. So I like what's happening in Australia, which is the advice the client has to consent to the fee every single year. Doesn't count for much in this framework. I mean, maybe it does, maybe you can prove it that it that it does. But the the point is that you have to show that it's you know it it's right for that client, and they are getting value for money and you know, peace of mind, all the soft thing, they're not enough. Even market comparative. comparison, comparative is not enough. You know, because I sit here on my high horse and I said, you know, how cheaper can how less can he be? You know, I'm um I'm I'm I'm selling MPS at nine basis point compared to the industry average at I don't know, 15 or whatever. Yeah, they said, so what?
1:05:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. I'm
1:05:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): saving the client six basis point points relative to to you know the market the market just just on this, they say so what? I said, uh by the way, you know, my my track range is six basis points relative to the market at I think it's twelve. So what? It's impossible. I say it's impossible. It is possible, but you have to you know apply like a methodic way of of you know to to the this in a detailed granular and make sure that it's it's embedded in the business. The good thing about this paper is like there is the good, the good and the bad. And um my
1:06:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people
1:06:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): will not like me for saying this, you know. I have n we you know, I've never liked like the low the lower end portfolios, the portfolios thirties 30s and uh you know twenties and tens. But this may have given me an ex an excuse to want to to want to to want to maybe not
1:06:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): offer
1:06:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): those portfolios anymore.
1:06:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm joking. But
1:06:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you you get my dream.
1:07:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Abraham, you're a tech guy and you know, data proving something, proving an outcome all comes down to not a data. You know, you can either you know proving it with facts. And I guess there are some ways that you can, apart from the fee, because there's is fee what they're coming in for? And is that fee relative if you've lost the money or gained the money, but then you can't control the markets? You know, there's there's ways that I think that you can measure some outcomes, but again, it's somebody smart coming up with some programs that the advisors can use to prove this. So there is a way of proving whether your client sold in a market. You know, look, take the platform data, you can say how much what were was the net sales and what was the net purchases when the market was down. You can prove that. Maybe timeline should come out with how do we prove our net worth data management. A cash flow model can say whether they've met with how well they're going toward progressing to their retirement. You just got to put it right another little algorithm to say, how can I prove that my client, how many of my clients are meeting their cash flow needs and show that to the FCA? How many of my clients, in addition to just getting a portfolio, have a will, have a power of attorney, have something else in place? Because we do more than invest money. We have a and you use your CRM to map to m to monitor that and you make it, you get data. Data is is uh you know, it's
1:08:20it's valuable and it's there. It's just putting it in place so that you can prove that. I mean, we have to do our own value. assessment with the FCA every year as a fund manager. And that's great because we're not as cheap as you, because we're value. No, we are adding value on returns also relative to people in our universe. We are much, much cheaper because we're low cost and we can prove prove our worth on the on the value. But again, we have to do that if every year as a fund manager. And a lot of it comes down to price. but really it's about outcomes. So how do you model and how do you track outcomes? It can be, you know, on a platform data, how much uh how many of them have cash flow modeling, how many of them are meeting their retirement needs. It can be how many of them overreacted to market corrections and that'll come by buys and sells data. It is there. And I think you write some algorithms and you can provide that service to clients. Another another sort string to your bow.
1:09:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
1:09:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it is
1:09:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I I just I I agree that the the data i is there. It's it's fragmented, it's all over the place for for most firms, you know, to be able to put pull pull that together.
1:09:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): But I think in
1:09:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): anything in life, it's a
1:09:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): spare thought for me, because I've got to justify not only the value to my clients and me, but also of Abraham and then also Kate, all through the fact. pack. I mean, I think I think you're both right. I think the the probably for advisors, one of the key things they can do is go and ask the client. Because Kate, to your point, we need it on record that uh the reason that we are the reason that the client hasn't sold out of the market. We are the reason that the client hasn't run out of money because of cash flow. We're the reason why they had more money to give to the kids. You can't, it's no good just saying that. You've uh as as the advisor, you've got to get that from. the clients. The data will flow because I'll just ask Penny and and she'll give it to me in timeline. But it uh it's gotta be the clients. It's got to be in the clients' words. It's the only way to do it.
1:10:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yep. Yep.
1:10:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Listen, uh guys, I've I've had um I've had a wonderful time and I've learned two new words on Wikipedia, which is is always a a good outcome and and fairly typical actually for me with these um these pods. Kate, you've been a brilliant guest. Thank you very much for your your time. Um, it's been fantastic, Abraham. As always, pleasure to hear your dulcet tones on these subjects. Um, and I would like just to say thank you very much. That's a wrap, I think, on episode 17. So well done, guys. Thank you. Kate, we'll see you again.
1:10:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
1:10:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you. Thank you, both.
1:10:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank you,
1:10:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Abraham.