Margie Casey discusses Coco Plum regulations, real estate market stats, and local amenities in Marathon, FL
Summary
Margie Casey introduces the Coco Plum neighborhood in Marathon, Florida Keys, highlighting its location within city limits which permits seven-day rentals with a license. She describes local amenities including a public beach, wide canals, and nearby businesses like Max Marine and Curry Hammock State Park. The episode details condominium and single-family home pricing, noting ranges from $300k to $15M depending on property type and location. Casey presents weekly market statistics for the Middle Keys, reporting 5 homes sold and 30 under contract for the week ending October 29, 2026. She concludes by encouraging listeners to contact her for property showings and subscribe for future updates.
Key takeaways
- 1 Coco Plum's location within Marathon city limits allows seven-day rentals with a license, a regulatory advantage for short-term rental investors compared to areas with stricter bans.
Margie Casey · 0:20
- 2 The fixed bridge at the Coco Plum Beach Drive channel restricts boat access from certain directions, limiting direct deep-water entry for vessels coming from the Key Colony or Bonefish Channel.
Margie Casey · 2:47
- 3 Max Marine's acquisition of Shelter Bay consolidates boat sales, service, and storage in one location, potentially increasing convenience for residents.
Margie Casey · 3:07
- 4 the number of homes that went under contract, yay, it went up. There were 30 homes in that went under contract last week. And so our average is 34, but that is a definitely a noticeable trend upward. So people are shopping around and catching the deals.
Margie Casey · 7:33
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 0:40
Introduction to Coco Plum Location and Regulations
Margie Casey introduces the Coco Plum neighborhood in Marathon, Florida Keys, located at mile marker 54 within city limits. She notes that city limits permit seven-day rentals with a license, making it popular for investors.
- 0:40 – 1:40
Local Amenities and Public Beach Features
The speaker describes the local fishing village vibe, including seafood fisheries and a deli. She highlights the public beach at the end of Cocoa Plum Drive, noting it is dog-friendly, has amenities, but is shallow and not ideal for swimming.
- 1:40 – 2:47
Infrastructure and Canal Specifications
Coco Plum features pedestrian/bike sidewalks and exceptionally wide canals (150-170 feet wide, 5 feet deep). The speaker warns that the entrance channel has a fixed bridge limiting access and variable tide depths of 3-5 feet.
- 2:47 – 3:53
Local Businesses and State Park
Max Marine operates in the area, having taken over Shelter Bay, offering boat sales and service. Curry Hammock State Park is nearby, featuring trails and access to the Bahama Sandbar.
- 3:53 – 5:54
Condominium Market and Pricing
The speaker details several condo complexes: Bonefish Towers (74 units, 30-day rentals, $379k-$5.6M), Bonefish Townhouses (34 units, weekly rentals, $899k-$1M+), and Cocoa Plum Terraces (studios/1-bed, $300k-$400k). No current listings were found for other named complexes.
- 5:54 – 6:44
Single-Family Home Market and Oceanfront Listings
Single-family homes on deepwater canals typically range from $2M to $3M, with some reaching $5M. An oceanfront 5-bedroom home is listed at $15M but lacks dockage, with permits pending.
- 6:44 – 9:07
Middle Keys Weekly Market Statistics
For the week ending October 29, 2026, 5 homes sold (average 7), with 30 going under contract (average 34). Days on market averaged 94 (trend 116-120). 318 homes were for sale (trend 349), with 18 new listings (trend 12).
- 9:07 – 9:46
Closing and Call to Action
Margie Casey encourages listeners to contact her for property showings, leave comments, and subscribe for future neighborhood updates in Marathon.
Claims worth verifying
Coco Plum is located at mile marker 54 on the Atlantic side within the city limits of Marathon.
Margie Casey ·0:20
How to verify: Check Florida Keys Mile Marker maps and Marathon city zoning maps for Coco Plum boundaries. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Seven-day rentals are permitted in Coco Plum with a city license.
Margie Casey ·0:20
How to verify: Review Marathon, FL municipal code regarding short-term rental regulations and licensing requirements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Coco Plum canals are 150 to 170 feet wide and 5 feet deep.
Margie Casey ·2:16
How to verify: Consult US Army Corps of Engineers navigational charts or local county property records for canal dimensions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The channel at Coco Plum Beach Drive has a fixed bridge and tide depths of 3-5 feet.
Margie Casey ·2:36
How to verify: Check NOAA tide tables for the area and USGS or local engineering maps for bridge clearances. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Max Marine took over Shelter Bay.
Margie Casey ·3:07
How to verify: Search business registration records for Max Marine and Shelter Bay in Florida, or check local news archives for the acquisition. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bonefish Towers has 74 units and is 13-14 stories tall.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·3:55
How to verify: Review building permits or architectural records for Bonefish Towers in Marathon, FL. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bonefish Towers allows 30-day rentals.
Margie Casey ·4:15
How to verify: Review the Bonefish Towers Homeowners Association (HOA) bylaws or rental restrictions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bonefish Townhouses has 34 residences and allows weekly rentals.
Margie Casey ·4:35
How to verify: Review the Bonefish Townhouses HOA bylaws or rental restrictions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
5 homes sold in the Middle Keys for the week ending October 29, 2026.
Margie Casey ·6:46
How to verify: Check MLS (Multiple Listing Service) data for the Middle Keys region for sales closed between October 22-29, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
318 homes were for sale in the Middle Keys as of October 29, 2026.
Margie Casey ·8:27
How to verify: Check MLS inventory data for the Middle Keys region as of October 29, 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-14 through 2026-11-14. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Marathon city zoning codes and Monroe County vacation rental licensing requirements for seven-day rentals.
- Check current listings on MLS or local broker sites for Bonefish Towers, Bonefish Townhouses, and Cocoa Plum Terraces to confirm pricing and availability.
- Review the Middle Keys Association or local MLS reports for the week ending October 29, 2026, to verify sales volume, days on market, and inventory trends.
- Inspect the fixed bridge at Coco Plum Beach Drive for height and width restrictions affecting boat access.
- Research Curry Hammock State Park hours and trail conditions for proximity to Bahama Sandbar access.
- Confirm Max Marine's ownership of Shelter Bay and current service offerings.
- Evaluate the $15M oceanfront listing's permit status and dockage limitations before considering investment.
- Compare Coco Plum's 150-170 foot canal widths against standard Keys canal dimensions to assess boating utility.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Margie Casey: Today, we are going to continue to learn about the best neighborhoods to live in the middle Florida Keys. That would be defined from mile marker 47 to 68. My name is Margie Casey with the Brenner Shale and Casey team of Florida Keys Real Estate Group here to help. And let me introduce you to the Coco Plum
- 0:20
- Margie Casey: neighborhood, which is located at mile marker 54 on the Atlantic side. The neighborhood by the way, is located within the city limits of Marathon, which means seven-day rentals are permitted with a city license. This makes this neighborhood very popular with investors. You can
- 0:40
- Margie Casey: expect to find a quaint fishing village. It has a beautiful vibe when you come onto the quay and you'll see lobster traps and stone crab traps on both sides of the road. There's uh Stingray fisheries where you can buy seafood right off the boats, and then there's a delicious Cocoa Plum deli that makes fantastic
- 1:00
- Margie Casey: sandwiches, box lunches, they sell bait and tackle, and that's also on Cocoa Plum Drive. What most people don't know about Cocoa Plum is it has a public beach. The public beach is located at the end of Cocoa Plum. Drive, and it has parking, restrooms, a covered pavilion,
- 1:20
- Margie Casey: and wetlands behind it. And most of all, it is a dog friendly beach. People love going there and just enjoying the white sand. Now you can swim there, but it is very shallow, so it's not really an ideal swimming beach, but it's the perfect place to dig in with a lounge chair on the weekends and a watch the boat traffic
- 1:40
- Margie Casey: and enjoy the beautiful ocean views. Another thing that's unique about Coco Plum is the bike and pedestrian-friendly sidewalk that runs from one end of the island to the other. And why is that important? Because years and years ago,
- 1:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
- 1:55
- Margie Casey: didn't build sidewalks in many of the neighborhoods in the Florida Keys, and it's just safe and it's more relaxing to be able to walk. on these sidewalks. So I think that's a big asset for Cocoa Plum. Cocoa Plum canals are also known for being exceptionally wide. Most of the Keys canals are about 75 feet.
- 2:16
- Margie Casey: Cocoa Plum, some of them are almost 200 feet, but for the most part, they're about 150 to 170 70 feet, five feet wide, which is fantastic if you have a big boat and you want to turn around. It does have uh a depth of about five feet, and some deeper, of course, in some areas. But what you have to watch is the channel on Cocoa
- 2:36
- Margie Casey: Plum Beach Drive at the very end that you have to come in to get to all of these canals where the homes are, and the tides, depending on the tides, can be somewhere between three and five feet.
- 2:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 2:47
- Margie Casey: a lot of people think the Cocoa Plum channel can wrap around. to these canals that reach into Cocoa Plum residences, but there is actually a fixed bridge, and you're not able to do that coming in through the key colony or bonefish channel. There's some other businesses that are on Cocoa Plum that are very important to know about. Max
- 3:07
- Margie Casey: Marine took over Shelter Bay, and that is a fabulous
- 3:13
- Margie Casey: boat sales. sails. It's got service there, dry storage, and also parts and things like that. And by the way, gorgeous new boats. So if you're looking for a new boat for your new house, you definitely want to stop at Max Marine. Another thing on Cocoa Plum Island is Curry Hammock State Park, which is a beautiful state park. It's got a
- 3:33
- Margie Casey: couple kayak trails, a hiking trail, and it has a famous sandbar right offshore. It's called Bahala Sandbar, and the weekends it's packed. The only way to get there is either by a kayak or by boat, and that's right in front of Cooley Hammock State Park. Now let's talk about what kind of uh home styles you
- 3:53
- Margie Casey: can expect to find on Cocoa Plum.
- 3:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
- 3:56
- Margie Casey: first, the most significant iconic building and the tallest building in the Florida Keys, Bonefish Towers, is located on Cocoa Plum, and there's 74 units in that building, that high rise. Um, I think it's 13, 14 stories. It has resort style amenities, which are fantastic, and the building allows
- 4:15
- Margie Casey: 30-day rentals. Um, there are condos priced in there from $379, which is a steal for a one and one half Beth um condo, up to the $5,600 range. Um There is a unit for sale right now in there where they combine two units. It's the penthouse floor, and the seller is asking a million eighty nine.
- 4:35
- Margie Casey: Fantastic building. It overlooks the Bonefish Townhouses and the town Bonefish Marina, which are two and three bedroom condos. There's 34 residences there, and they allow weekly rentals. So that's a popular place to look for property. Condos there begin around $8.99 and they go to just over a
- 4:55
- Margie Casey: million and they come with a deeded boat slip. Piscay Ave, which is, you know, first when you come off overseas highway and you pass through the fishing village, the pro the street on the right, this is a very popular street to find new homes, new elevated homes on the water, popular vacation rentals.
- 5:15
- Margie Casey: So that's a place to look. These homes have pools, they're you know modern, they're in the two million range, so that's a popular street. Um, other condos that are very popular to find on Cocoa Plum is Cocoa Plum Terraces, which has small studios and one-bedroom condos with assigned a signed dockage,
- 5:35
- Margie Casey: and those are priced in the 300 and 400 range. Um I didn't find anything for sale right now in Cocoa Plum Beach, Tennis Club, the Villas, or Royal Plum or Treasure K. Those are some other condos that are in the Cocoa Plum area. But let's talk about the single-family homes on Cocoa Plum and what you'd expect to find on the deep
- 5:54
- Margie Casey: water canals. There were I found a couple that were around a million, but most of them were are in the two and three million range, and some of them reach up. to 5 million for the larger residences. There's also oceanfront homes on Cocoa Plum, and the most expensive oceanfront home on Cocoa Plum right now is
- 6:14
- Margie Casey: a five-bedroom, four-bath home on a beautiful white sandy beach, but it doesn't have dockage. It says they're applying for a permit, and the asking price is 15 million.
- 6:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 6:26
- Margie Casey: that's something. to think about on Coca Plum. But it is a fantastic neighborhood to look for a home, especially if you're considering renting it out. I think there's a beautiful vibe with Coca Plum. So you want to definitely take a look at that and let us know if you'd like us to show you around. Now each week we do talk about our statistics because
- 6:46
- Margie Casey: we're tracking the middle keys to see what new homes came on the market, what's close. closed, what's under contract, is the market getting better, is it getting worse, and so on. So here's your data for this week. This is week 30, ending yesterday. So uh there were five homes that sold in the last week. Um, our average is
- 7:06
- Margie Casey: now seven, which is trending down a little bit. So less homes are being sold, which is again perfectly normal for this time of the year. Our days on
- 7:15
- Margie Casey: market last week was at uh I think it was at 47, it was abnormally low. This week's the 94. The average is 116. I've been saying all along the average is 120. So the homes staying on the market is the normal trend we've been watching for several months now.
- 7:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
- 7:33
- Margie Casey: the number of homes that went under contract, yay, it went up. There were 30 homes in that went under contract last week. And so our average is 34, but that is a definitely a noticeable trend upward. So people are shopping around and catching the deals. Price reductions, we only had four
- 7:53
- Margie Casey: last week.
- 7:57
- Margie Casey: Trend not much has changed over 30 weeks. The expired listings last week was six. Our trend is five, so it is trending up a little bit. So more homes are starting to expire, which for sellers, pay attention to this because that means less competition. Don't take your home off the market, stay in the
- 8:17
- Margie Casey: market right now. You will have an advantage. The number of homes in the middle keys for sale last as of last week, uh yesterday was 318.
- 8:27
- Margie Casey: Our trend is 349, not much has changed. This is great. We're showing a super stable market in the middle keys. New listings on the market, there were 18 this past week. We've been trending 12, so that not much changed.
- 8:44
- Margie Casey: Still over the past five, six weeks, we're holding. What I did notice was as far as the number of homes that sold. there were five, as we mentioned, the ones that there were more than half of them had been on the market for more than 90 days. So buyers pay attention. If you're outhouse shopping, make sure you really dig in and take a look at
- 9:04
- Margie Casey: those homes that have been marked on the market a long time.
- 9:07
- Margie Casey: If you're searching for the perfect home for you and your family, just know that we're always here to help. Feel free to call me. I'm your host, Margie Casey of the Coconut Wire and of the Brenner Shall and Casey team, and we're here to help you. We know this market very well. We do want to hear your thoughts, so be sure
- 9:27
- Margie Casey: to leave us a comment if you have a question. Share the show with a friend, and make sure you subscribe so that you never miss an episode. We will be talking about another neighborhood and marathon next week. In the meantime, I hope you have a fabulous weekend and I'm glad you stopped by