Speakers critique Labor policies on super, tax, and housing, citing economic data and political polling.
Summary
Phil Tarrant and Liam Garman discuss recent political polling showing the Coalition leading, while critiquing Labor's economic policies. They cite ABS employment data showing job losses and Equifax mortgage hardship increases. The speakers argue that government actions, including superannuation reforms and tax enforcement, are harming small businesses and retirees. They also warn of supplier payment crises and construction halts due to high interest rates. Finally, they criticize proposed privacy regulations and public sector wage disparities.
Key takeaways
- 1 Equifax's Q3 2026 consumer credit analysis revealed that mortgage-e mortgage e-hardship hardship accounts increased by 3.34%.
Liam Garman · 14:54
Episode sections
- 0:47 – 4:02
Political polling and election context
Phil Tarrant and Liam Garman discuss recent polling showing the Liberal/National Coalition leading in a three-horse race, with the Coalition's primary vote at 25.5%. They note the upcoming Victorian state election and the potential for a comfortable win for the Liberal candidate Jess Wilson.
- 4:02 – 7:30
Employment data and inflation narratives
Liam Garman cites ABS data showing 43,500 jobs lost and 17,800 unemployed in the latest report. He critiques the government's narrative blaming Iran and global supply chains for inflation, arguing that domestic factors like the refinery fire and policy decisions are equally significant.
- 7:30 – 12:23
Business tax changes and ATO enforcement
The speakers criticize the removal of the small business capital gains tax (CGT) discount and the introduction of 'RoboTax' by the ATO. They argue these measures penalize small business owners and create a hostile environment for entrepreneurship.
- 12:23 – 14:54
Superannuation and annuity reforms
Phil Tarrant discusses the Labor government's plan to ban superannuation products that artificially trim severance balances to maximize age pension benefits. He notes the policy aims to save $480 million over a decade but frames it as an attack on retirees.
- 14:54 – 21:27
Mortgage hardship and negative equity
Liam Garman presents Equifax data showing a 3.34% increase in mortgage hardship accounts in Q3 2026. He argues that current calculations of negative equity ignore selling costs, meaning many homeowners are effectively in negative equity despite nominal price stability.
- 21:27 – 25:51
Supplier payment crises and economic risk
Phil Tarrant explains a payment hierarchy where businesses prioritize tax, super, bank interest, and wages, leaving suppliers unpaid. He warns this 'soft underbelly' of the economy is fractured and could lead to widespread business failures and supply chain disruptions.
- 25:51 – 26:57
Supplier Debt and Court Backlogs
Phil Tarrant argues that suppliers lack leverage to collect debts from other businesses, unlike employees or tax authorities. Liam Garman adds that court systems are clogged with AI-generated lawsuits, further delaying dispute resolution.
- 26:57 – 29:47
Unemployment and Labor Market Rigidity
The speakers discuss rising unemployment and the difficulty businesses face in downsizing due to Fair Work claims. They note that payroll is the easiest area to cut, but legal protections make redundancy processes complex and risky for employers.
- 29:47 – 32:56
Construction Costs and Housing Supply Shortage
Liam Garman warns that high interest rates have increased holding costs for developers, causing a halt in construction. He argues that buying existing property is cheaper than building new due to replacement costs, leading to a future supply shortage.
- 32:56 – 35:16
SMSF Lending Ban and Market Distortion
Phil Tarrant and Liam Garman discuss the government's ban on SMSF lending, noting that Treasury's estimate of 4,000 affected loans was far lower than the industry's estimate of 16,000. They claim the ban caused a flood of buyers rushing to purchase before the deadline.
- 35:16 – 38:27
Wage Growth and Economic Outlook
Liam Garman predicts that wage growth will stagnate or stop as businesses prioritize survival over innovation. He suggests that while capital gains may return to long-term averages (4-5%), this will be relative to stagnant wages, creating a difficult economic environment.
- 38:27 – 43:56
University Degrees and Vocational Training
The speakers criticize the removal of university caps, leading to an oversupply of low-value degrees. They argue for a return to vocational colleges for essential jobs like nursing, which are currently undervalued and understaffed.
- 43:56 – 47:02
Political Responsibility for Rate Hikes
A clip from Question Time attributes 17 of the last 25 rate hikes to the Labor government. Phil Tarrant and Liam Garman debate the accuracy of these statistics, noting that the previous Coalition government also had rate hikes during its tenure.
- 47:02 – 1:00:30
International Economic Context and Debt
Liam Garman reflects on the 2009 GFC and compares Australia's situation to France's debt crisis. He highlights the challenges of high government spending and the difficulty of implementing moderate fiscal cuts in politically volatile environments.
Claims worth verifying
The Liberal/National Coalition primary vote is 25.5%, up 3.5 points.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·2:25
How to verify: Check the specific poll source Phil Tarrant shared on WhatsApp or the original polling agency's release for the week of November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Employment fell by 43,500 and 17,800 people became unemployed in the latest ABS report.
Liam Garman ·4:02
How to verify: Verify against the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) Labour Force data for the relevant month in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Australia's biggest refinery burnt down four or five months prior to the episode.
Liam Garman ·4:56
How to verify: Search news archives for the incident involving the Australian Oil Refining Company (AOR) refinery in Altona, Victoria, dated around mid-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Labor government plans to ban superannuation products that maximize age pension benefits, saving $480 million over a decade.
Phil Tarrant ·12:23
How to verify: Check the Australian Government Treasury website or Financial Review (FR) articles from November 2026 regarding the superannuation annuity overhaul. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Equifax Q3 2026 data shows mortgage hardship accounts increased by 3.34%.
Liam Garman ·14:54
How to verify: Access the Equifax Consumer Credit Analysis Report for Q3 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Arrears rates for first-home buyers on the 5% deposit scheme were under 1% as of June 30, 2026.
Liam Garman ·15:35
How to verify: Check Equifax or ABS housing finance data for the June 2026 quarter. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The interest bill on the Victorian state government's debt is approximately $23 million per day.
Phil Tarrant ·14:30
How to verify: Review the Victorian State Government's annual budget papers or debt management reports for 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The government removed the capital gains tax discount for small businesses.
Liam Garman ·7:30
How to verify: Check the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) or Treasury legislation regarding small business CGT concessions effective from the date of the episode. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The ATO is using an automated system called 'RoboTax' to pursue unpaid tax.
Phil Tarrant ·9:03
How to verify: Search ATO press releases or news reports from late 2026 regarding automated tax compliance systems. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceJess Wilson is expected to win the Victorian election comfortably.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:54
How to verify: Check Victorian election polling data and results for the 2026 state election. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Suppliers have no leverage to collect debts from other businesses, unlike employees or tax authorities.
Phil Tarrant ·25:51
How to verify: Review Australian insolvency law and Fair Work regulations regarding supplier debt collection versus employee wage claims and ATO tax recovery powers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Court systems are clogged with AI-generated lawsuits.
Liam Garman ·26:33
How to verify: Search for recent news reports or court statistics regarding AI-generated legal submissions in Australian courts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Payroll is the easiest area for businesses to downsize.
Liam Garman ·27:21
How to verify: Review Australian Fair Work guidelines on redundancy and dismissal procedures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
High interest rates have increased holding costs for developers, causing a halt in construction.
Liam Garman ·29:47
How to verify: Analyze ABS construction data and developer financial reports for trends in construction starts and holding costs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Treasury estimated 4,000 SMSF loans were affected by the lending ban.
Phil Tarrant ·32:56
How to verify: Search for Treasury estimates or government announcements regarding the impact of the SMSF lending ban. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Industry estimates suggest 16,000 SMSF loans were affected by the lending ban.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·33:17
How to verify: Review industry reports or statements from SMSF industry groups regarding the impact of the lending ban. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The 5% deposit scheme caused a flood of buyers rushing to purchase before the deadline.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·33:53
How to verify: Analyze property sales data for spikes in transactions prior to the 5% deposit scheme deadline. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Wage growth is predicted to stagnate as businesses prioritize survival over innovation.
Liam Garman ·35:16
How to verify: Review ABS wage price index data and business confidence surveys for trends in wage growth and innovation spending. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
RBA cash rate is at 4.85%, the highest in 18 years.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·44:27
How to verify: Check RBA official cash rate announcements and historical data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
HSBC chief economist says Australia is one of the least well-placed developed economies to handle economic shocks.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·44:47
How to verify: Search for HSBC chief economist reports or statements regarding Australia's economic resilience. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceUnder Francois Hollande, France implemented a 75% tax rate on earnings over a million pounds, leading some to domicile in Andorra or Germany.
Liam Garman ·48:49
How to verify: Check French tax legislation from the Hollande presidency (2026-2026) and OECD or national tax authority records on tax migration. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Central banks must track government bond yields when institutional investors believe the government cannot meet interest repayments.
Liam Garman ·49:09
How to verify: Review central bank policy statements and bond yield data during periods of sovereign credit stress (e.g., UK Gilt market crisis 2026) to assess correlation between yield spikes and rate decisions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Labor is pursuing a public register that would name nearly one million discretionary trust beneficiaries.
Liam Garman ·51:52
How to verify: Search Australian Financial Review (AFR) articles from the release date window (Nov 2026) and Australian Government legislative registers for the 'Public Register of Discretionary Trust Beneficiaries' bill. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Greens demanded the public register of trust beneficiaries as a condition to pass Labor legislation.
Liam Garman ·52:11
How to verify: Check Australian Senate voting records and press releases from the Australian Greens for the relevant legislative period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Greens dropped their demand for the public register, but Labor continued to push for it.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·52:30
How to verify: Review Australian Senate voting records and Labor/Greens joint statements to confirm the withdrawal of the Greens' amendment and Labor's continued support. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify ABS employment data for the latest report period to confirm job loss figures.
- Check Equifax mortgage hardship reports for Q3 2026 trends and state-specific data.
- Review ATO publications on 'RoboTax' and small business CGT discount changes.
- Analyze Treasury estimates versus industry data on SMSF lending bans.
- Examine Labor's proposed public register of discretionary trust beneficiaries for privacy implications.
- Compare public sector wage rise statistics with private sector wage growth data.
- Assess construction cost indices and developer holding costs to validate supply shortage claims.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
0:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): is a Momentum Media Production.
0:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
0:07Phil Tarrant: we're live. How are you going? Phil Tarrant. Welcome, Property Buzz, on this Friday morning. Hope you're well.
0:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Back
0:14Phil Tarrant: in the studio with my colleague Lean Garmin to pull apart real estate, property, mortgages, finance, the economy, politics,
0:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
0:24Phil Tarrant: everything in between
0:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on. the
0:27Phil Tarrant: day we get ready for the weekend. Liam, how you going? You could
0:31Liam Garman: good.
0:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
0:32Liam Garman: you know what? It's um there's a lot to unpack in
0:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
0:35Liam Garman: episode, which is actually quite exhausting.
0:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
0:37Phil Tarrant: is very exhausting and um we we sort of spoke about this last time we got together about not being sort of the merchants of doom and gloom and negativity.
0:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We want to
0:45Liam Garman: be positive.
0:46Phil Tarrant: We're trying to be positive.
0:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We're trying to
0:47Phil Tarrant: trying to
0:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): look at all the that all
0:48Phil Tarrant: that's good about the world rather than all that's bad about the world, but um unfortunately, um the saga that is, this government continues. Uh I do note though, um and we sort of telegraphed this maybe a week or so ago, this sort of this quiet this quiet change that's happening potentially in how Australians are are choosing to vote. Um the Libs or the coalition had a pretty reasonable poll I saw come out. over the week, um, which shows that they're performing a little bit better than what they were beforehand and uh two party preferred basis. Um you know it's it's a it's a three horse race in there, certainly now, isn't there?
1:26Liam Garman: And I think the Libs the Libs are out um in the front. They're out in the front for the first time
1:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
1:31Liam Garman: just just in in in what seems to be what seems to be years. But you can't you can't blame people for for looking for an alternative, especially with um that constant barrage of bad news. Um so yeah, the polls are the polls are looking strong for the libs, a lot of uh a lot of movement that way. And of course, we're eight days, seven days, eight days, eight days away from the Victorian election as well.
1:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:54Liam Garman: Jess Wilson down there looks like she's gonna have a well, touch wood, uh, a pretty comfortable comfortable win down there. And actually a lot of polls are.
2:04Phil Tarrant: Well, um, on the WhatsApp community, which um I don't know how you get onto it, but uh is that too loud, is it?
2:11Liam Garman: It's a bit loud. Is
2:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it? Is
2:12Phil Tarrant: it's too loud.
2:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's a bit loud. Um, this
2:14Phil Tarrant: headphones too loud now. Look like an idiot because I'm the only guy.
2:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You're the only one wearing them.
2:17Phil Tarrant: Uh on the WhatsApp community, I actually shared a swing shot, a A s screenshot to which I put the federal swing is beginning.
2:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
2:25Liam Garman: is.
2:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And uh
2:26Phil Tarrant: 25 twenty-five point five percent up three point five points, primary vote. That'd be two two party preferred, would it? Or just pri no primary vote.
2:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Primary vote, yeah.
2:35Phil Tarrant: Primary vote. Um twenty five point five percent in the liberal Nats, a coalition, Labour twenty four point five, one nation twenty three point five, and
2:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): your
2:44Phil Tarrant: friends at the Greens fourteen 14.5 point five.
2:47Liam Garman: Friends. Yeah.
2:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
2:48Phil Tarrant: it's it's a a
2:50Liam Garman: set myself up for
2:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it, didn't I?
2:52Phil Tarrant: It's certainly a three horse race there. But that that certainly is a swing there. And I
2:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think
2:56Phil Tarrant: that is,
2:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
2:57Phil Tarrant: this this fatigue and malaise that most people I and I get sick of it, right? I've got to make sure I don't fall into it myself when I do. But yeah, every conversation I had with people is negative at the moment. Everyone, everyone is
3:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
3:10Phil Tarrant: lot of people, people are looking for hope and leadership and and and and at at least, you know, a view towards how we navigate through this period. And I think back to, you know, the last big sort of seismic issue we had. And COVID is a very different environment to where we are with you know the nature of the economy today and being driven by different means. But you had this outpouring of people who were overcommunicating over communicating and and saying, giving, acknowledging the situation
3:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
3:38Phil Tarrant: giving us a sense for what people are doing and a view towards what the future would look like. We're not seeing any of that at the moment. There there is no acknowledgement. No acknowledgement a around the state of play from the government right now, even though the world is talking about it, or the the whole of Australia is talking about it. There is no acknowledgement. It's like nothing to see here, everything's is a as expected and predicted. We're all okay. And this
4:02Liam Garman: is it's just mind blowing. It is truly mind-blowing. So Charmers comes out um today, oh yes say rather, after the um after the announcement that uh 44,000 people, let me just double check my figures, 43,500 people. Uh well, employment fell by 44,000. 17,800 800 people lost their jobs. And so Dr. Jim, Dr. Jim PhD in Paul Kennedy. Keaton came out saying, of course, we all know where this came from. It's um because of higher interest rates and the challenges coming at us from around the world. Um, and it's it's tiring. You know, it is tiring because every time the RBA comes out and raises interest rates, we hear the same thing again and again and again. Every time there is bad CPI data, it's Iran. Every time we hear interest rates go up, it's Iran. Every time that joblessness goes up, it's Iran. Can I remind people it was only four or five months ago that Australia's biggest refinery burnt down? What why are we talking about that? We knew this about four or five months ago that despite what was going on overseas, that our biggest refinery here burnt down. And people far smarter than us said, okay, this is going to have a major, major,
5:16major impact on our ability to actually do this domestically and our ability to meet energy demands in Australia. So that's one part. The second part is when you've had state governments come out saying, okay, we're gonna have some kind of redundancy in place. We learnt from COVID that you cannot rely on And international supply chains. We've learned from the overseas conflicts, both, you know, in Iran, but also early. earlier in Ukraine and Russia. We can't rely on global supply chains. Let's do it here. And the progressive lift just they seem to tear them down. They're tearing them down when you've got people that are saying, okay, maybe we need to have a redundancy plan of doing it here and going as far as say it'll be more expensive. Okay, so what we've done is we've just surrendered. We've just surrendered to relying on these supply chains. But here's the thing. that we've been speaking about, and we've said it a thousand times times on this podcast. I'm going to say it again. Price per barrel of oil was more expensive in 2022. Price per barrel of oil adjusted for inflation was more expensive in 2008. So the fact that we're just hearing this monotonous drone, it's growing hollow on people
6:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because
6:25Liam Garman: people realize that. okay, so if fuel costs are so uh are so high and this is what's causing um joblessness and this is what's causing the RBA rate hikes, um, and this is so overbearing on inflation, then why is that not seen in other areas of inflation? And I mean um uh the cost of FMCG goods, fast-moving consumer goods, or uh clothing, for example, that we're getting almost exclusively from overseas. And inflation, uh, the cost of a basket of goods on that went up like 3.5% over the year. That's a very fuel-intensive thing. They get shipped in from overseas as well. So why isn't that going up? It really is only pegged to what we're paying at the Bowser. So we're not looking at these other, um, these other contributing factors. And it is growing thin. So um, again, uh yesterday came out 43,000. 43,500 people, employment down by that much, 17,800 people uh became unemployed. And we've got that on the one hand, and then on the other hand, we've got this just continuous attack on the business community. Yeah, it's just this
7:30relentless assault on the business community. So um, again, you and I have spoken about this before, but capital gains tax, right? Capital gains tax. If you really wanted to grow businesses, to grow Australian businesses, if you really cared about that trading in the suburbs in outer metro Melbourne, outer Metro Sydney, outer metro Brisbane, that's having a crack. If you care about that farmer, that's having a crack. If you care about the person with in the fish and chip shop having a crack, why did they lose their CGT discount if they go to sell their? business? Why? Because now, now you own a small business, you own a business, right? Medium-sized business.
8:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Struggling, struggling
8:09Phil Tarrant: small business.
8:10Liam Garman: You know, a lot of business owners out there, and this is not going to be a shock to people. A lot of business owners out there don't actually draw an income from their business. Because they look at it and for decades they've seen, okay, I'm going to draw the bare minimum from it. I'm going to keep it going. I'm going to keep it going. Because we also had a tax structure in place. that said, okay, if you're going to sell this as you're going into retirement, you can sell it without tax. Or if you held it in a trust, you had ways of distributing that income. But in so doing, you were able to keep people employed. You were able to keep high streets vibrant. You were able to keep a supply chain going because it's not just that storefront. That storefront buys from Australian businesses. That storefront trades with Australian businesses. And you've gone after them. You spoke about this for the last two weeks, and it's only growing in in intensity, but Robotax. Robotax. You've got
9:03Phil Tarrant: Robotax. It's one
9:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of these Robotax.
9:05Liam Garman: You've got this automated system coming out there, harassing, harassing small businesses. business owners.
9:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I reckon
9:11Phil Tarrant: everyone's talking about this now. I I started speaking about this maybe two months ago. Robotax, right? Robo I'm saying this is robo debt. Here we are again.
9:20Liam Garman: Yeah.
9:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Here
9:21Phil Tarrant: we are again. Watch what happens. And we're watching it. It's like a train wreck.
9:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And it's
9:26Liam Garman: wrong. It's wrong. People
9:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are getting
9:28Phil Tarrant: it it's it's it's wrong. It's
9:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): largely
9:30Phil Tarrant: all wrong.
9:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
9:31Phil Tarrant: all wrong, right? Um
9:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
9:33Phil Tarrant: and this this robotax thing ain't gonna go away, right? Like I I know this week they're the I I think there's been a win because the tax office has gone, oh, we're gonna stop sending these nudes, they
9:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): call
9:43Phil Tarrant: them nudge letters, right? To
9:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): try
9:44Phil Tarrant: and get people like, I'll pay my bloody tax, I'll pay my super, get stuffed,
9:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right?
9:48Phil Tarrant: You're you're completely wrong. But the stress they're providing there, they're like like rot wheelers
9:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): chasing it down, right?
9:55Phil Tarrant: So so this is the point, right? And just to echo what I said beforehand, show some leadership, please, and be honest. At the absolute minimum, at the absolute minimums, Australia should expect honesty from their government. Okay. So, government, come out and show some leadership. Go, guys and girls, it's not good at the moment, right? They all they do is talk about, oh, you know, we're getting smashed and cost of living and all this sort of stuff, right? Come and tell us it's not good. Yeah.
10:23Liam Garman: Come
10:23Phil Tarrant: and say just acknowledge it's not good and acknowledge why it's. it isn't good that isn't a war in uh uh isn't a war in the Middle East. It's
10:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not because
10:31Phil Tarrant: Australia was a couple
10:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of years. But
10:32Liam Garman: in in Feb and March, when the interest rates started going up, it was because um businesses were doing too well. Do
10:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you remember
10:38Liam Garman: that? Remember
10:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when businesses
10:38Liam Garman: were doing too
10:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): much. Public
10:42Phil Tarrant: service wages going in probably they
10:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): go,
10:43Phil Tarrant: Oh, there's gonna be another uh um rate hike, right? But just acknowledge that it's not okay and just going, oh, we know Australians are copying it right now. Yeah, you see Claire O'Neill talking about, oh, the property market's cooked. And like, just be honest. Say, look, the economy is in not a good state.
10:58Liam Garman: Yeah.
10:59Phil Tarrant: You know, uh we're trying to work hard on fixing it. But you're not gonna get into that. You just told everything is okay. But just every consecutive day and back to the point, I want to be negative all the time, every consecutive day you're seeing the actions and habits and behaviors of a government which doesn't necessarily care about a huge cohort of Australians. And this is a cohort of Australians who typically fuel this nation as business owners. They fuel this nation as taxpayers, right? They're copying it right now. And I see language, and I've spoken about this time and time again. A government should bring people together rather than dividing people. This government has just divided people from their very, very first day in office. Let's take, let's have a referendum on
11:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): an
11:46Phil Tarrant: issue, which they lost, right? Pretty
11:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): distributed. Which
11:49Phil Tarrant: divided, which at
11:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): its
11:50Phil Tarrant: absolute core, I'm putting aside that what the referendum is about. I think we need acknowledgement and considerations for our relationships with First Nations people. I'm putting that aside. But the intent of it was to divide the nation. straight
12:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): off
12:03Phil Tarrant: the bat. And all they've done is been divisive every step of the way. And I see it again, and this just come out, and I've spoken about this at length. The language that the government has used through this whole period of changing the tax regime, that all they're spoken about is inequality and fairness, right? And what is fairness, right? We've spoken again about this. Like people are inequal. in equal. It's just the way it works. And what's fair for one is not fair necessarily fair for another. We see this the latest attack now is this banning this boost products in retirement overhaul, right? And I don't know if if you guys are across this, but labor will ban products that artificially trim severation balances that max out age pension benefits from from yesterday. It's part of a broader broad overhaul of annuities system designed to encourage graduate. Annuities are you put your money somewhere in a and it feeds you a certain amount of money every month, right? In retirement. Uh there's a speech and it was all leaked and stuff. This is from the the Fin Review, right? Um, it comes um um amid widespread fears among super funds that the Abenese
13:03government plans a crackdown on the products. Well, they're having a crack of super funds, right? But here is the language, right? Treasure Jim Chalmers this week said the products, does this sound familiar? Is this from the playbook? Abused loopholes.
13:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,
13:16Liam Garman: loopholes again?
13:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Loopholes. They love
13:18Liam Garman: loopholes.
13:19Phil Tarrant: And inequitable.
13:20Liam Garman: Yeah.
13:20Phil Tarrant: Right? Loopholes in inequitable, right? Maintaining the long-term sustainability of the broader retirement concept. So again, they're saying, oh, there's all these loopholes.
13:28Liam Garman: Yeah.
13:29Phil Tarrant: Oh, um, property investors, oh, they're exploiting loopholes, loopholes, loopholes. So there's loopholes everywhere. By the way, these are loopholes in a tax system that have been around. How
13:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can you actually
13:37Phil Tarrant: have a loophole in a tax system if by law they created this regulation? It's not a loophole.
13:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
13:45Phil Tarrant: what the law is.
13:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So you're saying that the law is
13:47Phil Tarrant: full of loopholes?
13:48Liam Garman: Yeah.
13:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like
13:49Phil Tarrant: are getting around to skirting it, not paying their fair share, blah, blah, blah,
13:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): blah,
13:53Phil Tarrant: blah. This inflationary language, which is hostile.
13:56Liam Garman: Yeah.
13:57Phil Tarrant: Every step of the way, this government, it's hostile. It's take, give, take, give, take, give it. It's not come together, let's work together, let's find a way through this. It's about taking stuff away from people. Loopholes, right? Loopholes are exploited. If you're exploiting a loophole, what's the initial sort of reaction to that? Oh, you're doing something improper.
14:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well, that
14:17Liam Garman: yeah, that's the allegation.
14:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's the allegation. So
14:19Phil Tarrant: they're saying that everyone is acting improperly here.
14:21Liam Garman: So
14:22Phil Tarrant: we're closing
14:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
14:22Phil Tarrant: loophole.
14:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): loop
14:22Phil Tarrant: up. And by the way, this is gonna this is gonna put 480 bucks back, 480 million. bucks back into the the budget.
14:29Liam Garman: Over a decade. Over
14:30Phil Tarrant: a decade. 28
14:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): million
14:31Phil Tarrant: bucks a
14:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): year.
14:34Liam Garman: $480 million, right? Like it's I I saw this actually just before we started talking. I saw this ad my friend sent it through from the um from the Libs in Victoria. But it was something like the interest bill on the Victorian state government's debt, just the interest bill on their debt a day is $23 million. $480. So we're saying $48 million a year is what it's going to say. $48 million a year. And this is going to be your big, um, your big way of driving equality and fixing these budget black holes. I'll tell you what's also hostile. So we had um some data come through today. Um Equifax's Q3 2026 consumer credit analysis revealed that mortgage-e mortgage e-hardship hardship accounts increased by 3.34%. over the September quarter, mostly in Victoria. Surprise, surprise, with the value of outstanding credit associated with late mortgage delinquencies climbing 5.8% year on year, while personal loan limits at risk surged 14.9%. Arrears rates for first
15:35home buyers on the 5% deposit scheme, they do sit under 1%, but that is as of 30 June 2026. Now, I can only imagine the last five months of that are going to be quite pronounced. So that's as of 30 June with those arrears rates for the 5% deposit scheme. But given, given that it's jumping 3.34% with hardship in the last quarter, I'm going to gonna guess that those people that are facing abnormally high interest rates as a result of being first um home. buyers on the 5% deposit scheme are gonna be super high. I read a story on the AFR yesterday or the day before, Phil, about a gentleman, 17 years in the creative industries. Uh
16:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): did you read this one? Yeah, I think that's a good one.
16:17Liam Garman: Um and he 100 job apps, been
16:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): out of work
16:20Liam Garman: for six months or something, uh, and now he's gonna sell his house. Got to sell his house. Guess what? It passes in.
16:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
16:26Liam Garman: and I, this is again, I love using this term because I'm gonna weaponize it. It's
16:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): been
16:31Liam Garman: weaponized against us. So I'm gonna weaponize it back. Um, I'm gonna use the term privilege. When you see everyone in uh the comment section, or you buy a house for 30 years, you buy a house to hold it for 30 years, yeah. Typically you do. Typically you do. Um, when you don't hold it for 30 years is when you're in financial hardship. When you're in financial hardship and you have to sell. and oh my gosh, I've got to pay for food for my kids. I've got daycare costs. I've got this, I've got that. Or maybe you don't have daycare costs because you're at home, but whatever it is, you know, you've got to make ends meet. You've got to survive. And now the value of your debt is worth more than the equity. Okay. You're already at a point where you've you got no money left in the bank. You go to sell
17:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
17:13Liam Garman: you owe the bank more.
17:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
17:15Liam Garman: and I touched on this last week, and it's something that no one is touching on. No one's discussing. But the way that we calculate negative equity is also so far wrong. It's so far off that cool, you know, you go and sell your house for 1 million, 5,000, but you bought it for 1 million. Congrats, you're not in negative equity. Well, when you factor in that $20,000 to $25,000 selling. cost that you pay your real estate agent that $10,000 to $15,000 that you got to market, because keep in mind you're only going to find that, or you're only going to sell that property through realestate.com.au or domain. Hey, listings are going up. You actually might need to spend some Facebook ad money so you stand out. So people actually rock up to the open home. Because you know as well as I do, you speak to a lot of people in in the the real estate industry. A lot of the feedback that I'm hearing. is that, oh my gosh, foot trapping, foot traffic at open homes is pretty bare. You're lucky if one or two people walk through. And those one or two people know that, hey, to buy his market. So we're gonna negotiate you right down to the bone. And they're gonna work out pretty quickly if it's a distress sale. So when you factor in these selling costs, yeah, you might sell at it 1 million, 5,000, bought it at one 1 mil. You're still gonna going to be down 40, 50K. So you're still going to owe the bank.
18:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You're
18:28Liam Garman: still going to owe someone.
18:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
18:30Liam Garman: this is this is what happened. We we, as Australians, we've loved property. We've rug pulled property, rightly or wrongly, it doesn't really matter. We've rug pulled property, which was the bedrock of the Australian financial system, which was the bedrock of the Australian family. It was the Australian family. Even if you have been holding your home for 15, 20 years and you put every single buck in your offset. or you've been paying down quicker, well, congratulations. Uh, if you're in Victoria and you bought a home in the last seven years, chances are if you sell now, you're gonna sell it for less. And for the last seven years, congratulations. You've probably been paying 80% on average a year in interest. So you probably haven't chipped down your mortgage quite as much as you thought you would. We have left Australians very weak. and very vulnerable. And we've left them vulnerable at the exact time that economic headwinds are hitting. And we have let down not just a generation of Australians with a 5% deposit scheme. I've always said that we've let down Gen Zs, we've let down millennials by leveraging them with so much debt with no way out and making them essentially tax wage slaves. But you've let down, you let down everything.
19:37Phil Tarrant: Who would have thought you want tax wage slaves? Like, you know, how do you how do you ensure the coffers of
19:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know
19:42Phil Tarrant: the the the public service is
19:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the same as a lot of people? What about the retiree that was
19:45Liam Garman: hoping to sell and downside?
19:48Phil Tarrant: But putting all this into perspective, right? And there needs to be a frank and honest conversation around the state of the the Australian economy. Now, Australia will be okay. Everyone will be okay. It's gonna be a period of pain, right? And this is the nature of cycles, right? But if you think about where we are right now and how we got here, Liam, most of it around this philosophical idea that was propagated by the government and executed by the government that we need to make housing more affordable for first-time buyers. Everything If assuming that the government is honest and what they told us at that point in time in the budget, like everything was around we need to make housing more equitable and we need to make it more affordable for first time buyers. So everything that's happened subsequent and since then comes back to that particular point. So is housing more equitable and affordable for first time buyers right now? No, it's not. Are a lot of those people that thought that was the case and they backed what the government was providing to in terms of this five billion scheme to in order to do that, are they in a better place as a result of it? No, they're not, right? But let's actually look at and and this is a thing, and and I reckon people I'm I'm I'm starting to see a lot of hints now of
21:01stuff coming out of Canberra.
21:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
21:04Phil Tarrant: lot of the talking points that we come up with months and months and months ago are sort of front and center right now. So so let me introduce another idea, and one of them is is this idea around Robotax, which has been picked up all over the joint. One of the biggest unintended consequences of all of this stuff that's going on right now is at the business level. So no one's really talking about this because it's very, very uncomfortable. But um one of the reasons and the major reasons why you're gonna see a huge spike in in unemployment. Unemployment come out this week was a 4.9%. It's gonna go into the fives.
21:47Liam Garman: Yep.
21:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Is
21:48Phil Tarrant: that businesses can't pay their bills, right? Why can't businesses pay their bills? And this is really, really simple. And and to a to to maybe, maybe people in labor should be listening to this because I can speak simply so they can understand it, right? Um
22:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
22:03Phil Tarrant: reason why people can't pay their bills in business, right, is because businesses at are the lowest priority of getting paid by other businesses at this moment. So let's think about that a moment. Robotax is uh being as aggressive as it ever could possibly be in the history of my relationship with the ATO. Like, you know, we we put it
22:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in the world. Which has been great
22:28Liam Garman: to date, I'm
22:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): sure.
22:29Phil Tarrant: And and and look, but you've got to pay tax, right? Like I get it. It's a privilege to it's a privilege to run a business and hire Australians and provide to Australia. It's a great privilege. I'm really proud of it, right? You've got to pay your tax, right? But let's just talk about how this cascades down, right? With the government with their robo tax being so aggressive, everyone will do whatever they can. to pay the tax offers first because
22:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's
22:55Phil Tarrant: the tax office, right?
22:57Liam Garman: Keep you up at night.
22:58Phil Tarrant: It's horrible. It's the stories I I I get, and it's absolutely horrible. So tax tax ban gets paid first, right? Oh, who gets paid second?
23:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
23:07Phil Tarrant: superannuation. Because now it's payday super. You have to pay the superannuation when you pay the salaries. You don't do it over three months anymore where you can use it to balance your cash flow, et cetera. So you've got to pay super. Otherwise, ATRB at you again sending you letters, yelling and screaming at you, saying, meet your primary requirements of the money that you need to provide for the worker to ensure that the government doesn't have to pay a pension in the future. But I'll park that for a moment. So Suba super gets paid second. Who gets paid third? The bank gets paid. So Aussie's. that have taken the risk to build their own business and take on debt, right? And take on debt to grow their business and run businesses and employ strains, you gotta pay the bank. You've got to pay your interest repayments, right? And you hear about oh, dire mortgage holders, all these mortgage holders who have had all these interest rate increases, myself included. What about all the small business and business owners who have debt in their business?
24:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
24:01Phil Tarrant: of their interest rates. have gone up. They've still got to meet their loan repayments. You never hear about them. All right. They're third, right? Fourth, who gets paid next?
24:10Liam Garman: Employees.
24:11Phil Tarrant: The employees.
24:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
24:13Phil Tarrant: employees get paid. So you've got to pay your employees. They're sort of fourth in in that list of people that need to be paid, right? So you're you're at the fifth level now. Fifth and sixth is, oh yeah, I I I I bought some stuff. from this person and I and and they've invoiced me. I've got to pay that.
24:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They're
24:31Phil Tarrant: not getting paid. Yeah. They're not getting paid because everyone else is getting paid first. The government is getting paid first. Tax, super interest is banks, and the employees. You've got to pay the employees because the employees can pay the tax to the government. So suppliers, there's a this soft underbelly of the supplier relationship in Australia. is so fractured at the moment. It is so fractured and it's about to come so unraveled when people go, Well, I can't pay you, Mr. Supplier,
25:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because I've
25:01Phil Tarrant: got to pay all these other people first. So you're last. This is the building game. This is why builders go bus all the time, right? Because it'll pay all this stuff and then the person
25:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): who does the work says there's nothing
25:10Phil Tarrant: left to pay. So this is all gonna going to come up.
25:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
25:12Phil Tarrant: is what is going to spiral in the economy. over the over the next year is suppliers not getting paid. Suppliers not getting paid. Everyone's also going to get paid first. Bank will get paid first. Tax men will get paid first. Employee will get paid first. Super education is going to get paid first. It's the suppliers, a business to business. Businesses paying other businesses is the soft underbelly of Australia right now. And it's a massive issue. It's a massive issue because what can someone do to collect a debt?
25:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
25:43Phil Tarrant: tax man.
25:43Liam Garman: Right an angry letter.
25:45Phil Tarrant: Ride an angry letter. The tax man will wind your business up and fine you. Right?
25:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
25:51Phil Tarrant: don't pay your super, you get fined. You don't pay your interest, you're going to get foreclosed on. The bank will take you, you're done, you're dusted. Your employees, you've got obligations to them, you've got to provide them. But as a supplier, trying to chase debt from another supplier, there's no leverage.
26:06Liam Garman: Yeah.
26:06Phil Tarrant: There's no leverage. Oh, you know, pay pay your deals. Oh, I'm going to contest it. Send a statute statutory demand to somebody, you've got to pay it in 30 days. I've contested the invoice. I don't think I'm I'm due that. So it it ends. There is no leverage to collect debts from other businesses
26:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): other
26:20Phil Tarrant: than long protracted. Well,
26:21Liam Garman: and then you're in the claims court
26:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for several years. Long
26:23Phil Tarrant: Long-projected protracted claims courts,
26:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): which
26:24Phil Tarrant: are bogged up with other stupid stuff.
26:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
26:26Liam Garman: bogged up with this.
26:27Phil Tarrant: With this sort of stuff. So you can't unless someone wants to pay their bills, you're not getting paid.
26:33Liam Garman: The other thing, yeah, just an interesting side note, um, with our courts being bogged up with AI bogus AI people suing each other. But and it's a small thing, but people um trying to, you know, I don't really know how it works, but they'll they would make the submission to the court and it would just be like all AI generated. But someone has to sit there, someone has to make a determination at whether it's legitimate or not. That takes time, that clogs it all up. Just don't.
26:57Phil Tarrant: You you think about this, right? With unemployment rising, all
26:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): these
26:59Phil Tarrant: people who feel as though they've been unfairly this business, and this is horrible, right?
27:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
27:02Phil Tarrant: don't like people losing their jobs. But already fair work is hammered, hammered with with claims, right? Most of them AI originated. Like, and back to the point, if businesses aren't getting paid, they need to downsize. The easiest place to downsize, the quickest, is typically
27:21Liam Garman: payroll.
27:22Phil Tarrant: Payroll. The other stuff is hard. You might have long leases or whatever. So so payroll. But even even reducing your payroll is very, very difficult. Very, very difficult. You you can't just rock up and say,
27:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): look,
27:33Phil Tarrant: I ain't got enough money. You, you, you, you, you, you ain't got a job no more.
27:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
27:37Phil Tarrant: Fair work things. Well, why are you sacking me? You know? So you're gonna get even more chucked into um
27:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
27:42Phil Tarrant: fair work regime.
27:44Liam Garman: I mean,
27:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and a lot of
27:45Phil Tarrant: people don't like the idea that they're made redundant.
27:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But you can't do it. But couldn't you make a summary number of you stay in there?
27:49Liam Garman: No business owner in Australia wants to do that. No business
27:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): owner,
27:52Liam Garman: no business owner. Well they want to grow. No business owner in Australia wants to exactly. No business owner wants to downsize a headcount. No business owner is out there um wanting to I mean, you know. there are some shifty people. There are some shifty
28:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people. Maybe there
28:05Liam Garman: are people that, you know, they'll dodge an invoice, but um 99% of people are good and 99% of people want to do the right thing. But but there's there's a someone's got their bloody hands in their pocket taking out the wallet.
28:19Phil Tarrant: Yeah.
28:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's a simple thing.
28:21Phil Tarrant: And And unfortunately people are gonna s like they reckon there's a tsunami of redundancies just around the corner.
28:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, right.
28:27Phil Tarrant: Um
28:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
28:28Phil Tarrant: and and we put a tap on the shoulder saying, Your role is redundant. Why is my role redundant? Well, because we're restructuring and because of the restructure, your role is redundant. Um they go, Well, you're replacing me with AI. And going, Well, maybe, maybe not, but irrespective, it's a business strategy, therefore your role is redundant. We we'll will find try and find you another role in the business. So, okay, go through but no, there's no other roles you're made redundant. This is this is it's gotta be online, Donkey Kong. Yeah, um, and a lot of those people who are made redundant will will feel aggrieved by being made redundant appropriately, right? Right,
29:04Liam Garman: fairly.
29:09Phil Tarrant: Bad, poor decision making made by the government, right?
29:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like
29:12Phil Tarrant: I think I think people are starting to understand that now. Yeah.
29:14Liam Garman: Back
29:14Phil Tarrant: to the vote. I think people are now starting to realize that you know you might not necessarily have liked what the Liberal coalition became in its last, you know, um the
29:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the last
29:27Phil Tarrant: cohort of it.
29:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
29:29Phil Tarrant: you know what? They can sort of manage an economy. So choose what you like.
29:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know, you and I you and I flag this what you like.
29:36Liam Garman: Um you and I flag this, especially with property prices. And there is a risk that there is a risk that once we come out on the other side of this and
29:44Phil Tarrant: Which we will.
29:44Liam Garman: We will. And but how do we come out of it? You know, there's a question of how we come out of it. Is there a case that um is there a case that by the end of next year, funnily enough before an election, but by the end of next year the economy is so bad. Like the economy is so bad that the RBA says okay, inflation is the lesser of two evils and we're gonna have to drop the interest rate. In which case, then we're kind of back to where we were before with a hell of a lot more people in this country. And at the same time, in the last 12 to 18 months, construction has just ended. We ended construction in Australia. No one's built. You and I flagged this back in Feb that when you have a nice big apartment block, let's not talk about the dodgy ones. Let's say a nice, really good apartment block. You've got a builder that's doing the right thing. They've got, you know, 20, 30% affordable homes, all that jazz. And it's really good. The amenities, it's built to a great spec. They take on tens of millions of dollars of debt to build that. And looking at construction times now, that could take two years from DA to construction to handing over the
30:47keys, sometimes more, right?
30:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
30:49Liam Garman: now they're not going to hold all. that tens of millions of dollars in debt from day one. Of course, it comes in trenches, but the holding costs have blown up so substantially off of nothing more than just interest rates going up. When you look at those big house and land areas out in the suburbs where you just got row and row and row, thousands of houses, that also takes tens to hundreds of millions of dollars of debt, which means that. whoever's taking on that debt is now incurring millions of dollars more in just lost cost, just cost
31:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): productivity.
31:22Phil Tarrant: Productivity money. So
31:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what does that
31:24Liam Garman: mean? You know, now what does it mean? You know, when we look at housing supply and demand, okay. We know everyone's buying units in Melbourne at the moment. It's in vogue. It's it's the thing to do is to buy units in Melbourne if you're an investor, because people look at it. they kind of fairly do the maths. And this isn't an endorsement. This is um one investing strategy that's out there. People look at the maths, they're like, I could buy a, you know, a a two-bedroom unit in St Kilda. It's a pretty good suburb for 550. And my mate's a builder. How much would it cost to rebuild this? Oh, I wouldn't even bother. Yeah. Why? Oh, because I that would cost me about
32:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
32:01Liam Garman: million dollars of build, so I just wouldn't bother.
32:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So why would you not bother building
32:04Liam Garman: it? Well, because you can buy the existing infrastructure. You could buy an existing home for 500, 550. Supply's over. So
32:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there
32:12Liam Garman: is no supply anymore. And there's gonna come a point, and I get very concerned in two to three years when inflation, uh it when uh population's gone up by another three, four, five hundred thousand, and no new homes have been built. that there are gonna be a lot of people.
32:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They're
32:29Phil Tarrant: gonna look back to this moment.
32:30Liam Garman: Mm-hmm.
32:31Phil Tarrant: Exactly what you've spoken about. You'd be mad to build at the moment. Yeah. You know, you might build some fancy, like, you know, where where I live, there's palm's going up all over the drawing. Big fancy things. They're selling for millions and millions and millions and millions of dollars. Mate, people aren't building that stuff elsewhere. No. You know, because you can't make a it stuck up. Like you you you're buying buildings, apartments under replacement costs by a long way. Yeah,
32:54Liam Garman: by a long
32:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): way
32:55Phil Tarrant: a
32:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): long way.
32:56Phil Tarrant: And a lot of this comes back, and again it's it's it's come back into some of the commentary coming out of Canberra the last um last week or so. Everyone's back talking about the the ban on SMSF lending, you know? What
33:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are they saying
33:07Liam Garman: then?
33:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh, they
33:08Phil Tarrant: they're going back going, Yeah, you know, when you banned lending inside of your super phone, you told us it was four 4,000. thousand. It
33:13Liam Garman: was 16.
33:14Phil Tarrant: No, that's No, they told
33:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): us it was
33:15Phil Tarrant: four. Treasury estimates. Yeah,
33:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah. It was four
33:17Phil Tarrant: thousand. Then they went, no, it's eight thousand. They went, no,
33:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's
33:20Phil Tarrant: more like sixteen thousand.
33:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And that would
33:22Liam Garman: and you know, that was an estimate because no one it's more than
33:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there's
33:25Liam Garman: and I reckon there well there would be more because the I mean that that is an estimate because no one sits there and tallies it up, right? No one tallies it up. That's an estimate from what one industry group, from who we've spoken to and the data that we have. we estimate 16,000. But as you know, with anything in the market, when you announce a change, there's a flood of buyers. So when the government, in its infinite wisdom, says, what was it, October 31, October 1,
33:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we're
33:53Liam Garman: introducing the 5% deposit scheme. Every investor in Australia is like, well, I'm going to jump on before the several hundred thousand kids jump on and add supply or add extra demand. when there's no more supply. Yeah. You know, because you telegraphed it and everyone jumps first. Exact same thing with SMSFs speaking to buyers agents and they're like, well, in uh August and July, we've never had such a busy month ever. Why? Because everyone's buying through the data will never come out. The data will never come out. But it's opaque,
34:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
34:23Liam Garman: would be in a magnitude of probably 10 to times more than what the government said.
34:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like I I don't
34:29Liam Garman: look I don't want
34:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to. Anyway, so no one's
34:30Phil Tarrant: developing. So so this is this comes back to well, this is supposed to be about property, right? Property bars. People will come back to this point going, like what what a good time to buy if if you've got the the gumption to actually go about doing that. And
34:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): maybe
34:45Phil Tarrant: not. And then you listen to other people and go, well, maybe it property probably's is going to be completely reset for a long time. And expect growth. rates of three to four percent
34:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
34:52Phil Tarrant: the
34:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): next period of time. Right. Or or
34:54Phil Tarrant: or it's been fundamentally changed.
34:56Liam Garman: I think the thing is, like, you know, and it's it's a hard thing to say. I I don't know exactly how to word myself with this, but it's it's relative. Yeah. It's relative. So in the private sector, in the private sector, you're not going to go through for the foreseeable future some amazing wave of innovation, AI aside, right? But we know what productivity is. Businesses can't afford to be productive. They can't afford to be innovative because for all the reasons that you outlined before, everyone is just, everyone just getting the D fib, Brady, right? Um, we're not gonna go through this mass renaissance in the Australian business community where we're gonna going to go down to 2% employment, uh, 2% unemployment. where there are going to be jobs galore, where people are going to be bidding for jobs and employees like, well, bloody hell, I just need someone. So I'm going to offer them more money. It's not going to happen. We're going to go through, unfortunately, across the business community, there will be an element where wages will stop rising for exactly the reasons that you highlighted before. So if we look three to four years in the future and we come out on the other side of this interest. rates start dropping. Maybe there's a government in 2028 that changes the tax regime, gets rid of the negative gearing changes, gets rid of the capital gains tax changes, and investor money starts coming in. Let's say it, let's say it goes back to long-term averages, that's four or four
36:16or five percent capital gains a year, right? That's still going to be going up at the same time, wages won't. So it's relative. It's relative, three, four, five percent. might sound quite, yeah, might not sound very big because we're used to 20, 40% per annum returns
36:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in,
36:32Liam Garman: you know, Brisbane or
36:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Stradley. Some
36:34Liam Garman: people were. Some people were, but it is relative. You know, if if your rents go up by 10%, but you haven't had a wage rise in,
36:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
36:42Liam Garman: five years.
36:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You're gonna be back to my
36:44Phil Tarrant: point around being honest to Australians, right? The the government. So so
36:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): why
36:48Phil Tarrant: why can't they say that? Like imagine if that they imagine if they come out and they said, Everyone, look, technology's changing rapidly, you know, and therefore there's gonna be a lot less pressure on wage growth. Yeah. Right. In in in the in the private sector, right? What's gonna drive wage growth in the private sector is a question. But so um
37:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): th
37:10Phil Tarrant: this idea that you're gonna going to keep earning more and more and more income might might be a thing of the past because m machines and automation and stuff is going to erode a lot of the needs of it. Like the jobs of the future aren't necessarily going to be the jobs that you're doing today. And you can go back to the Industrial Revolution. The time of change for when they started doing automation, which machines and people started sewing in their front rooms into a cottage It was a long period of time. The accelerant nature of AI means that that the change of the type of jobs we're doing is going to happen very, very quickly. Yeah. So so this conversations with Australians saying those jobs really aren't going to exist anymore. These are the jobs of the future.
37:48Liam Garman: But I don't think
37:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
37:49Liam Garman: government knows. No one knows. But
37:50Phil Tarrant: but but they could at least say and and the jobs of the future, we have those jobs now. We're just going to need more of them.
37:55Liam Garman: Yeah.
37:56Phil Tarrant: However, a lot of those jobs, most of you people don't want to be doing those jobs.
38:03Liam Garman: With the lanyard class.
38:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
38:04Phil Tarrant: lanyard class.
38:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The lanyard class. And to be clear,
38:07Liam Garman: when we're talking about the wage growth to our listeners, Phil and I don't think this is a good thing. This is not a good thing. This is uh, and especially when we talk about, well, businesses are just on it's a lifeline. They're just trying to survive. And the fact that you've got now um mortgage stress going up like 14%. over a quarter.
38:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What about business mortgage stress is my point? Well,
38:30Liam Garman: I would say it'd be even higher. It would be even higher. It's very dire. And and it's very unfortunate. But to your point about the lanyard class, I mean, let's go back to when Gillard got rid of caps on universities. You know, back then, and I it's not to punch down on people, but how many more Mickey Mouse degrees do we need? And
38:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): by the way, they're trying
38:56Phil Tarrant: to pull them back at least. There's so many Mickey
38:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Mouse. There's so many
38:59Phil Tarrant: Mickey Mouse degrees. And most of the Mickey Mouse degrees, and and and you know, this is is well known.
39:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
39:05Phil Tarrant: Most of the foreign students that come in Australia are are studying, then they're not on these Sansstone Sandstone universities. They're
39:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): doing
39:11Phil Tarrant: Mickey Mouse degrees at Mickey Mouse colleges. And most of it is just a visa roard. 100%.
39:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right. This is, you
39:18Phil Tarrant: know, no one's talking about this. So the point is, government, just have an honest conversation with us.
39:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's what
39:24Liam Garman: we were saying
39:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the other week. Tell us that it's not okay.
39:26Liam Garman: Actually, like, it is so disastrous for what they're doing to young Australians. And I'll tell you like my generation and below, selling them a lie. You know, or go to university, do this degree. and you'll make money. It's like, well, you're gonna leave after three years, like 40 grand in debt. I don't know how much union is now.
39:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's a lot more than 40 grand. Um
39:47Liam Garman: and then you would add on a master's on the other side. Maybe the master's is gonna cost you 30, 40, 50 grand as well. Because oh, you test the job market. Oh man, I didn't even get any interviews. Oh, I better do my master's. Suddenly you're in your mid 20s, your C CV V is threadbare because maybe you've interned here or there, you poured. beers at a pub, not knocking down. That's kind of what you got to do now to survive. But now you're suddenly in your mid 20s and your hundred grand debt from hex is now being indexed to inflation. So it's going to go up four or five percent a year. It's gonna be more than what you can pay it down. And the job that you trained for now no longer exists. Congratulations because the government stopped the caps, stopped the stop caps. Why is it such a controversial thing to say, well, instead of um why can't we go back to colleges like we used to have teaching colleges, nursing colleges, policing colleges? And you know what
40:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): these
40:38Phil Tarrant: universities.
40:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
40:39Liam Garman: they're all universities. And these are very fundamental jobs that we need for
40:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Vocational employment.
40:46Liam Garman: It's vocational employment. You know what? Why don't? And we need more nurses. Yeah. Everyone acknowledges that we need more nurses and they do an amazing job. Okay, cool. Um if we have nursing colleges, well, we can make a nursing college free. And there would probably be, if someone delved into the economics of it, you'd probably look at it and say,
41:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,
41:04Liam Garman: it's but they're in like
41:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): kind of stack. But they're in
41:06Phil Tarrant: lies they're in eyesish about the type of jobs that will be available, right? We need more nurses.
41:10Liam Garman: Yeah.
41:11Phil Tarrant: Like and and and nursing is a calling for a lot of people. right? Um, and and I come from a a long line of nurses in my in my family, like generational, right? It's it's calling. And and but a lot of people they get attracted into it, might be a calling, but once they get into the system of being a nurse, they go,
41:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Whew, it's a
41:32Liam Garman: hard slot. This
41:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we don't have enough of it. them.
41:34Phil Tarrant: This is hard.
41:34Liam Garman: Yeah,
41:35Phil Tarrant: it's a hard job. Yeah.
41:36Liam Garman: The
41:36Phil Tarrant: Lanyer class, they might think it's a hard job because you your cappuccino is not the right temperature, right? It's a hard job. It's a physical job. It's a hard job. It's an emotionally stressful job. And it's an absolute essential job. Teachers as well, coppers, fierys, all of these type of co-water people, right? They're the jobs of the future. They're the jobs we're going to need more of. This,
41:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
41:55Phil Tarrant: know, they announced this with this in-home hospital care, right? To try and free out our beds and stuff. They're the jobs that need happening, right? I tell you, a lot of people don't want
42:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to.
42:03Phil Tarrant: be doing those jobs. So this is where we look to leadership from our elected leaders to actually steer us through this pathway. And I just don't think they've got the ability to acknowledge and/or understand. They certainly don't understand business. They certainly don't understand business. They don't understand budgeting. They don't understand the economy. There's a lot of it they don't understand. What they do understand is how to spend money.
42:29Liam Garman: Oh, they love. Oh, they're good at that.
42:31Phil Tarrant: They're very good at doing that. They're
42:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): very good at doing that. So
42:33Phil Tarrant: that's all we want. But anyway, we're going to get a chance to vote on this. So it's it's starting to happen
42:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at a state level. I
42:39Phil Tarrant: saw even the Minns government here in Israel starting to cop a lot of heat around, you know, um, it was much better under a a liberal arrangement.
42:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know why? what? At
42:47Liam Garman: least he at least he put puts up a the full.
42:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I don't mind him.
42:50Phil Tarrant: I think
42:52Liam Garman: He seems to well out you know, compared to to other labor leaders across Australia, he seems to be um like reasonable. All
42:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right,
42:59Liam Garman: so I Googled uh well no, I didn't Google, I chat GPT'd. Um Mickey Mouse degrees. Um apparently there's a uh oh I don't know, I I can't say that because it might not be um might not be fair. We got a Bachelor of Games at RMIT. Games. Games. QUT offers a diploma in esports.
43:20Phil Tarrant: Esports are massive, man. It's like a esports, it's like, you
43:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
43:24Phil Tarrant: they're rock stars, right? There's stadiums get full of kids playing games.
43:27Liam Garman: Okay.
43:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Let me check
43:28Liam Garman: if it is it.
43:30Phil Tarrant: Look, their Mickey Mouse degrees at least are at a reputable institution. I'm talking about the other degrees which really have no relevance or bearing for anyone.
43:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
43:39Liam Garman: don't know. I think um
43:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Is it
43:41Liam Garman: government subsidized though?
43:42Phil Tarrant: Yeah, that's that's all that matters, right? Government
43:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): subsidized I mean,
43:45Liam Garman: yeah. Anyway.
43:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
43:46Phil Tarrant: got some reaction video. Sorry, um, Patty. We should have called in earlier. We've probably covered a lot. Do we have any teed up and ready to go? We do. We'll have a look, quick look at this.
43:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Question time. I want you
43:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): to stop and answer this one for me. Out of the last 25 twenty-five rate hikes, how many of them do you think Labor was in charge? Is it eight? Maybe thirteen? Could it be nineteen? Well guess what? It's twenty-four of the last twenty-five. And let me ask you a follow-up question. Of those twenty-four, how many do you think Albo was responsible for? Was it three? Or Was it six? Surely it can't be ten. 10. Well guys, guess what? It was seventeen. 17. Now, why am I telling you this? It's because last week the RBA hiked again. And that's the fifth rate hike this year, taking the cash rate to 4.85%, which is the highest it's been in 18 years. And it gets worse. The RBA governor was asked whether any of the advanced economies we compare ourselves to have raised rates by a full percentage point this year. Her answer? No. Now the government says it's all overseas wars and the energy shocks, but HSBC's chief economist says Australia is one of the least well-placed developed economies to handle this, because our economy was already running hot before these shocks actually hit.
45:07Backflip Jimmy will tell you public demand growth has halved. But government spending is actually at its highest share of GDP in over 40 years. And SP say the government and the RBA are working against each other. So who pays for it? Everyday mortgage holders. HSBC now say it's a fifty fifty chance we go into a recession next year, which I actually think is much higher. Anyway, guys, rant over. I need a bloody drink.
45:32Phil Tarrant: Yeah, oh absolutely.
45:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Recession,
45:34Phil Tarrant: we've already spoken about that at length. You know, I'm I'm operating as though we are in one.
45:39Liam Garman: Yeah.
45:39Phil Tarrant: Um it feels as though we are in one. Bit selective on the stats, to be fair, but is that did that say Rud Gillard, Rudd?
45:47Liam Garman: Yeah, I'm
45:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): actually
45:48Liam Garman: I'm I'm looking at this now. Um
45:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
45:50Phil Tarrant: there was only one r rate hike under the the coalition government?
45:55Liam Garman: Yeah. And that was right at the tail end of of Montana.
45:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That was
45:58Phil Tarrant: May.
45:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That was the
45:59Phil Tarrant: May rate hike,
46:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just before
46:00Phil Tarrant: they lost it. So so under
46:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was
46:03Phil Tarrant: it Abbott Turnbull.
46:05Liam Garman: Presumably they were cut.
46:06Phil Tarrant: Abbott Turnbull Morrison, right?
46:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That was
46:08Phil Tarrant: that there was no one before Abbott, was it? Abbott Howard lost the Rudd.
46:12Liam Garman: Yeah. Rudd,
46:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Killer, Rud, Rudd,
46:14Liam Garman: Abbott,
46:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Abbott,
46:15Liam Garman: Turnbull.
46:15Phil Tarrant: Turnbull.
46:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
46:16Phil Tarrant: there's only one rate hike in that whole
46:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): period
46:18Phil Tarrant: right at the end of it. So
46:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there's
46:19Phil Tarrant: that's a downwards rate environment. Selective stats, but
46:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
46:23Phil Tarrant: because I know there was rate hikes under Howard.
46:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
46:26Liam Garman: Yeah. And I'm trying to um I'm trying to get my head around it. So I understand what one of the stats there were I was thinking Rod Gillard Rudd had three rate hikes.
46:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, it was
46:37Phil Tarrant: zero under Rudd, wasn't it?
46:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Or the last one.
46:40Liam Garman: One of them.
46:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh 2009.
46:42Liam Garman: So um now there is a there is an economic argument that because it seems like a very interesting time in just after. the GFC in 2009, why you would raise interest rates because the global economy was so shook. Why would you why would you raise interest rates when businesses were shutting their doors? And I've spoken about this a lot. I was a um
47:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
47:05Liam Garman: was a kid in London at the time. I was growing up in London and um showing my age. But the UK was affected very differently than Australia, very differently. And this this very much does impact how I view the world now because I remember where I lived, because you have high streets, right? You don't really have your Westfields. Our high street, like most other high streets, everything's shut down. Everything. It was, and I was I was maybe 13, 14. You don't really know too different, although it was very telling when suddenly everything is just a pound story. So you're Oh like, that's kind of boring. Yeah. But you don't really know. But that was that was it. And it was like, that for years. So why, when you're in an economic environment like that, and now Australia wasn't as impacted, but it still was, that you would have three rate rises. And there is an economic argument out there, which is um given that the bond yield is a reflection of the institutional lenders and their belief that a government is able to repay their bonds. So that's why your 30-year or 10-year bonds in France are very bad at the moment. Because a lot of bond traders are like, genuinely, I see there being no pathway for countries like France to actually repay their debt. Now, France has the ability to be a very vibrant, innovative country. Their education system is amazing. Like their universities are brilliant. But
48:22anytime anyone tries to come out with moderate cuts, like genuinely very moderate cuts. the whole place burns down.
48:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
48:29Liam Garman: So, and they've tried taxing their way out of it. We spoke about this on a podcast a few weeks ago. But because the way that the EU works, you can just domicile elsewhere. If you are a high-income owner, you can domicile elsewhere. And France has exit taxes if you look to move capital outside of France, but they turn a blind eye if it's in the EU. It's the irony of the European Union where you can just tax. take your money and leave. So when they did have, especially under Francois Hollande, when they had a 75% tax rate on earnings over a million pounds, people just domiciled in Andorra or Germany, right? But there is an argument. Why, why did they raise it? And that's because when government bond yields rise, you do often see that central banks have to not match government bond yields, but they have to start tracking up. So there's not some very large divergence between them. So you could have a risk in the future where if institutional investors and and larger lenders, if they do believe that the Australian government is unable to meet their
49:30interest repayments in the future, that we might have to track up in line with bond yields.
49:36Phil Tarrant: Maybe.
49:37Liam Garman: So
49:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): maybe maybe. maybe we
49:39Liam Garman: don't. And you and I we're we're very cautious to not speculate,
49:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
49:44Liam Garman: you know, we've said, hey, maybe the Australian economy's gonna be so shot next year they're gonna have to lower interest rates. But hey, maybe the Australian government spending is so high that maybe more hikes are on the horizon.
49:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We d don't know.
49:54Phil Tarrant: Do any more uh r uh response videos, Patty? No, just that's yeah, that's the one. That's all right. We've gone, go on for quite a quite a while. I don't know if we've solved anything today. uh Liam. We're just um more problems. More problems. Offered more problems. More more problems. And and I know this is maybe it should be politics buzz, but property and and politics are very comfortable bedfellows at the moment. Uh and politics is I've been talking about this for years, is absolutely dominated by real estate in Australia. Um I'm here and I speak to a lot of. agents, they're hurting out there.
50:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
50:29Phil Tarrant: but there's also some pretty good buying during the market. The issue is though, is everyone's sitting around waiting for what the bottom is. What is the bottom? When are we at the bottom? And you know, it's is everything at the bottom. Some properties are going up, but um like
50:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a good
50:40Liam Garman: friend of mine said, everyone's waiting for the dip, but the keep dip uh the dip keeps
50:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): dipping.
50:45Phil Tarrant: Yeah.
50:45Liam Garman: You Yeah,
50:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
50:46Phil Tarrant: is is it it
50:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): gonna gonna
50:47Phil Tarrant: be a dead cat bounce? or
50:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): something? Is that a save, saying? you know, or is
50:49Liam Garman: that
50:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is that
50:50Liam Garman: like an official? saying?
50:51Phil Tarrant: You think you just invented it?
50:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No,
50:52Liam Garman: no, I didn't. No,
50:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no, it was a friend of mine.
50:55Liam Garman: I didn't know whether, like, I don't know, the dip keeps on dipping to wire and buffing
50:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how long
50:59Phil Tarrant: can it go, right?
51:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): How long can it go? Well
51:01Phil Tarrant: Well, is it like catching a falling knife? You know, is the government
51:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): actually
51:04Phil Tarrant: gonna sit there and catch it at some point?
51:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
51:06Liam Garman: don't this government's too proud, it won't reverse anything. The closest thing it'll do, and you and I spoke about everything's you know, I spoke about this last week. It's just it's just so monotonous. Well, maybe we're are we as bad as charmers, but um um
51:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
51:19Liam Garman: argument with you
51:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know
51:20Liam Garman: a legor of spender and carving out productive versus non-productive assets, maybe they backtrack to that. But that might help the business community, but it doesn't necessarily help when you do have potentially, you know, hundreds of thousands of people in negative equity.
51:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
51:35Phil Tarrant: this goes back to the point that I made that all of this is because they tried to make housing more equitable and fair for first-time buyers. What has that got to do with businesses? What has that
51:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): got to
51:45Phil Tarrant: do with trusts and
51:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): trust
51:47Phil Tarrant: distribution? Talking about
51:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this is publicly we actually haven't
51:52Liam Garman: spoken about I'll give it just a quick rundown for our listeners that might not be aware. So um labor, according to the AFR today, um, a source close to labor within labor. has said that it is still pursuing a public register that would name nearly one million discretionary trust beneficiaries. Of course, financial experts have warned that naming the beneficiaries could put their privacy and safety at risk. Yeah, no crap. Now, this originally, this has been labor policy for a few years. Now it's come up in the headlines for the last week or two because the Greens, um, in agreement to pass some of the labor legislation. this was one of their demands that they want a public register. Like,
52:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
52:30Liam Garman: is this like was it the end of the Roman Republic where it's like Marius and Sulla come up and they're slapping up prescription lists of now these people are outlawed in the Republic? That's what it seems, right? You're gonna be able to Google people. This is wild. But um, the Greens actually dropped their The demand for this, and Labour's still pushing for it.
52:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do
52:47Phil Tarrant: they say why they want it?
52:49Liam Garman: Name and shame, I guess.
52:52Phil Tarrant: Why would you want to shame a million Australians? Or millions. More than a million Australians, because beneficiaries are probably millions of Australians, right? It's like
53:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is it the haves and the have nots. Well,
53:09Phil Tarrant: I saw something
53:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): about three three
53:11Phil Tarrant: and four tradies run their run their businesses through trusts, right?
53:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
53:15Liam Garman: well,
53:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): now even if you're a
53:16Liam Garman: bloody even if you're a Tyler and
53:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
53:19Liam Garman: got no work because there's no building going on, congrats, you might be named publicly. Because because because you have a
53:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's like
53:27Phil Tarrant: again.
53:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Because you have
53:27Liam Garman: a discretionary trust, you're apparently a millionaire. Congrats.
53:31Phil Tarrant: So this is back to the point. Are you doing something wrong? Because like w you only need to list all this if people are deemed to be doing something wrong. So
53:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you you
53:39Phil Tarrant: wouldn't if
53:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you think you're doing something is another
53:41Phil Tarrant: loophole.
53:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's why
53:42Liam Garman: they're that's why they're slapping up everyone's names, because you had day user trust. What do you hell? What what's the
53:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): point of
53:49Liam Garman: trying? Just
53:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
53:51Liam Garman: know, just just apply for the Department of So and So.
53:54Phil Tarrant: So so just
53:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): knock off the four PM. So is
53:56Phil Tarrant: is a government the gonna gotta actually and and you see all this stuff around the back flipping, and then there's they're an easy target at the moment, by the way.
54:03Liam Garman: Yeah,
54:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well, I
54:03Liam Garman: mean, fairly.
54:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They're an easy target. They're an
54:05Phil Tarrant: easy target. Um and and maybe we should see a view maybe on some of these reaction videos of, you know, the other side.
54:13Liam Garman: Yeah.
54:13Phil Tarrant: Um do they generally believe everything is okay?
54:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think
54:17Liam Garman: so.
54:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But that
54:18Phil Tarrant: that could be the the the the greatest gaslighting in the history of gaslighting.
54:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
54:22Liam Garman: I mean, they they probably do think everything's okay because when you come from an APS or you come from a union background, you are so protected. You are so inherently protected. I mean, like, look what happened in Victoria, where you gave preferential contracts to people that would hire the CFM EU. You know, if that's your background, by nature, you know, if labor's in power, one out of every two years on average, you might have eight years of libs, eight years of labor, eight years of libs, eight years, but if on average, you're gonna have this constant flood of money coming your way and you're gonna be safe. You're gonna be safe. You've never actually had to count your pennies. You've never actually had to try. You've never had to go to a workplace where you've had to innovate, you've had to scrap, you've never had a job which relied on inbound leads coming in. So you do Do have a new home to do roofing for. I they are that, I I think they are that divorced. Maybe not Jim. Jim would be given so much confidential information from Treasury that says
55:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that this really-
55:23Phil Tarrant: I do really trust Treasury.
55:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
55:25Liam Garman: I
55:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): trust I
55:27Phil Tarrant: don't think they've got one number right.
55:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, and
55:29Liam Garman: but I think that there's um I think that there's official stats. It's Like I could say to you, um,
55:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
55:35Liam Garman: know, Phil, this is what the math says. but it doesn't really stack up to my gut feeling. My gut feeling's this. We don't hear about the gut feeling. I'm sure that there would be, you know, ek economics PhDs in Treasury that are like, oh, this is really disastrous.
55:52Phil Tarrant: Yeah.
55:52Liam Garman: But it's not going to make the headlines. Like Dr. Chalmers isn't going to say, well, I was talking to a PhD in economics from Treasury and he said I really screwed up. He'll be, he'll pick the numbers from the intern. which said it was the right thing to do.
56:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. Yeah.
56:06Phil Tarrant: Plenty of interns. All right. Well, thank you, uh, Liam. Um, how do you how do you get onto our
56:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): community? Our
56:12Liam Garman: community. Um, we'll drop a link in the show notes. It should actually already be up. If you're watching this live, it should be if you scroll down in the about section. So click that there. If you're joining us over the weekend, um look at the show notes, join the community. Um, talk, be active. If you disagree with us, please feel free to disagree. I'm
56:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um disagree.
56:34Phil Tarrant: We might disagree.
56:34Liam Garman: We wanted we want, you know, unlike where's it, Labor's, where's it, this digital safety bill? Have you heard
56:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of this? This digital safety bill.
56:42Liam Garman: This digital safety bill where um I noted a Labour senator two days ago came out um warning uh a warning about all of the content that's being fed to young Australians, in particular women, um, about having children. Apparently, it's really bad that women should be fed this content and they can now opt out of it. Very peculiar. And then people in the comments noted the peculiarity of this. And um, she said, Well, you can also opt out of my content too, which is mind-boggling mind boggling because now I can just opt. out of hearing the an opposing opinion. I need opposing opinions. You know me, I'm very sitting my ways. I'm a very opinionated
57:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): person.
57:22Liam Garman: I need opposing opinions.
57:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
57:26Liam Garman: a hard democracy.
57:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Sometimes
57:27Liam Garman: I can be wrong. I need content from labor MPs and Labor senators because sometimes I'm going to gonna get it wrong.
57:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
57:34Liam Garman: know, and they had some things which I back. I do agree with a lot of their pre. previous digital safety stuff. You know, um, I per and much to the disagreement of a lot of my friends, I do agree with their kind of under 16 social media stuff. I actually thought
57:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it was
57:47Liam Garman: quite good. Yeah.
57:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Which doesn't
57:49Phil Tarrant: work, by the way.
57:50Liam Garman: It doesn't work, but I think the intent was correct.
57:52Phil Tarrant: Intent's correct.
57:53Liam Garman: Um, I think the intent was correct, and some of their age verification stuff I think is the right thing to do. And I would only have come to that conclusion by seeing their content and seeing their. explanation of it. We can't, I can't, we shouldn't live in a society where I'm just going to opt out of someone else's opinion.
58:09Phil Tarrant: Yeah.
58:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
58:10Phil Tarrant: called putting your head in the sand.
58:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
58:11Phil Tarrant: Nothing to see. And again, back to the point, you know, the heart of the West business system is that you have a government, you have an opposition, and they debate issues.
58:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We need more
58:21Phil Tarrant: debate. We need debate, you know. But a lot of people don't want to hear opposing views anymore. They're offended. We
58:25Liam Garman: just want to talk over each other and
58:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yell.
58:27Phil Tarrant: People are offended by other people's opposing views. And um,
58:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
58:31Phil Tarrant: I'm I'm keen for opposing views. Like I actually want to hear more from people who think everything is okay. Because I I I haven't ran into any of them.
58:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
58:40Phil Tarrant: haven't spoken to anyone.
58:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
58:41Phil Tarrant: don't I don't I haven't spoken to one person who's happy at the moment. Yeah,
58:44Liam Garman: I'm sure.
58:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
58:46Liam Garman: you're uh
58:47Phil Tarrant: who's
58:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): who?
58:48Phil Tarrant: happy at the moment?
58:49Liam Garman: Well, I'm I'm showing I'm trying to play devil's advocate. Maybe if you're like a
58:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): who? I'm
58:53Liam Garman: sure there would be if you're an insolvency lawyer, they're probably doing quite well. It's a terrible thing to say. I'm s literally
59:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
59:00Phil Tarrant: think people people who have government jobs are probably pretty happy.
59:02Liam Garman: They've got their seven percent pay rise or whatever it was.
59:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): On
59:05Liam Garman: average, not everyone got a seven
59:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): percent. You talk
59:07Phil Tarrant: about the greatest inequality
59:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at the moment,
59:09Phil Tarrant: if you want to talk about fairness and and and and inequality.
59:12Liam Garman: People
59:12Phil Tarrant: with government jobs, people without government jobs.
59:14Liam Garman: Yeah. imagine that 15% super I
59:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think
59:17Liam Garman: at 15%
59:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): super I'm
59:18Phil Tarrant: talking about job security. Oh
59:20Liam Garman: jobs oh yeah of course
59:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's the
59:22Phil Tarrant: greatest inequality at
59:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
59:23Phil Tarrant: moment
59:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): job
59:24Phil Tarrant: insecurity
59:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
59:25Phil Tarrant: got a government
59:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): job
59:26Phil Tarrant: you're sweet you know even if you're not you can't get rid of you they'll move you around like
59:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the the
59:31Phil Tarrant: anxiety the anxiety that I'm hearing from people that work
59:34Liam Garman: yeah
59:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): work
59:35Phil Tarrant: just in and around outside of government
59:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
59:37Phil Tarrant: in in in uh private sector stuff. The anxiety of like, I don't know what's gonna happen.
59:41Liam Garman: Well, you know,
59:42Phil Tarrant: it's horrible.
59:43Liam Garman: I'm hearing that maybe in some halls in Canberra the Nespresso pod budget might be cut. Oh wouldn't that be oh my heart? Maybe we should do a fundraiser for them. Maybe we should. We'll do a function.
59:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
59:56Liam Garman: GoFundMe page so they can get their Nespresso pods. I obviously I obviously made that up, but I'm sure in I'm sure I'm in sure that that joke there is some element of truth. Anyway.
1:00:05Phil Tarrant: Alright, Property Buzz, join the community. Thanks for tuning in. We'll see you next Friday. Until then, bye bye.
1:00:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
1:00:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): information featured in this podcast is general in nature and does not take into consideration your financial situation or individual needs and should not be relied upon. Before making any investment, insurance, tax, property, or financial planning decision, you should consult a licensed professional who can advise whether your decision is appropriate for you. Guests appearing on the this podcast may have a commercial relationship with the companies mentioned.