Guest Kieran Hughes explains how traditional pensions hold fossil fuels and weapons, and outlines a framework for ethical investing.
Summary
Kieran Hughes defines ethical investing as the active removal of negative industries like fossil fuels, weapons, and tobacco, contrasting it with traditional investing which includes all sectors. He claims that typical pension funds often contain 5-10% in fossil fuels, ~2% in weapons, and ~1% in tobacco, despite investor preferences. Hughes argues that ethical funds can match traditional benchmarks over the long term if they remain well-diversified and focus on fundamentals. He warns against greenwashing, advising investors to verify fund ethos directly with managers rather than relying on marketing imagery. Finally, he proposes a three-step framework: exclude bad companies, add good ones, and engage with the rest to drive improvement.
Key takeaways
Episode sections
- 0:28 – 4:27
Introduction and Definitions of Ethical Investing
Aidan Finnegan introduces guest Kieran Hughes, who defines traditional investing as including all sectors ('good, bad, ugly') and contrasts it with ethical investing, which removes negative industries. Hughes outlines three approaches: exclusionary ethical investing, impact investing for positive returns, and ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) focusing on corporate governance and sustainability.
- 4:27 – 7:42
Hidden Exposures in Traditional Pensions
Hughes claims that while most people say they do not want to invest in fossil fuels, weapons, or tobacco, their traditional pension funds often contain 5-10% in fossil fuels, ~2% in weapons, and ~1% in tobacco. He cites specific companies like BP, Raytheon, and Philip Morris as examples of these holdings.
- 7:42 – 12:05
Transparency and Fund Analysis
The speakers discuss the lack of transparency in standard fund fact sheets, which typically only list the top 10 holdings. Hughes argues that investors must 'lift the bonnet' to see the full list of potentially 2,000 companies to identify significant holdings in undesirable sectors that appear further down the list.
- 12:05 – 16:12
Performance of Ethical vs. Traditional Funds
Hughes asserts that ethical funds do not necessarily take more risk and that their performance generally 'evens out' with traditional benchmarks over the long term, provided they are well-diversified and not too narrow in scope. He emphasizes that diversification and fundamentals must come before ethical screening.
- 16:12 – 21:32
Greenwashing and Due Diligence
The discussion addresses 'greenwashing,' with Hughes suggesting it is often accidental due to a mismatch between industry definitions of sustainability and client expectations. He advises investors to verify fund ethos directly with managers rather than relying on marketing imagery like wind farms.
- 21:32 – 22:29
Conclusion and Actionable Advice
Hughes concludes with a three-step framework for ethical investing: exclude bad companies, add good companies, and engage with the rest to improve them. He states this approach is superior to traditional funds and encourages collective investor pressure to drive corporate behavior.
Claims worth verifying
Almost 100% of Irish people say they do not want their pension invested in fossil fuels, weapons, or tobacco.
Kieran Hughes ·4:27
How to verify: Survey data from Irish financial institutions or consumer advocacy groups regarding pension investment preferences. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Traditional pension funds hold 5-10% in fossil fuels, ~2% in weapons, and ~1% in tobacco.
Kieran Hughes ·4:47
How to verify: Analyze the portfolio holdings of major Irish pension providers' default funds and calculate sector weightings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
BP, Raytheon, and Philip Morris are examples of companies held in traditional pension funds.
Kieran Hughes ·4:59
How to verify: Check the top 100 holdings of major global index funds or Irish pension default funds for these tickers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Fund fact sheets typically list only the top 10 holdings.
Aidan Finnegan ·7:50
How to verify: Review published fact sheets from major fund providers (e.g., Vanguard, BlackRock) to confirm the number of holdings listed. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Ethical funds can have performance that 'evens out' with traditional benchmarks over the long term.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·12:42
How to verify: Compare long-term (5-10 year) total return data of ESG/ethical ETFs against broad market indices like the S&P 500 or MSCI World. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
There are only 2-3 ethical/sustainable funds among the 60-80 funds available on major Irish pension platforms.
Kieran Hughes ·9:27
How to verify: Review the fund menus of major Irish pension providers (e.g., Aviva, Irish Life) and filter for ESG-certified options. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Ethical investing involves excluding bad companies, adding good companies, and engaging with the rest.
Kieran Hughes ·21:32
How to verify: Review the investment policy statements of ethical funds to confirm the presence of exclusionary screens, positive screening, and active ownership/engagement strategies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-03 through 2026-11-03. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Review the full portfolio holdings of your pension fund, not just the top 10, to identify hidden exposures to fossil fuels, weapons, or tobacco.
- Verify the specific exclusion criteria and engagement policies of any ethical fund manager directly, rather than relying on marketing materials.
- Compare the long-term performance and risk metrics of ethical funds against their traditional benchmarks to assess if they 'even out' as claimed.
- Check for conflicts of interest or 'greenwashing' by analyzing the actual sector weights of funds marketed as sustainable.
- Research the definitions of 'impact investing' versus 'exclusionary ethical investing' to ensure alignment with personal values.
- Investigate the corporate governance practices of companies held in ethical funds to understand the 'engagement' aspect of the strategy.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): You're listening to the Irish Times.
- 0:06
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
- 0:07
- Aidan Finnegan: have come to the right place if you care where your hard-earned money is being invested. Not just because you want a good return, of course you do, we all do, but because maybe you don't want to be funding weapons, fossil fuel, or tobacco companies. I'm Aiden Aidan Finnegan, and this is Better With Money from the Irish Times.
- 0:28
- Aidan Finnegan: This episode is for information purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. I'm joined today by Kieran Hughes, who is director of Ethico and a certified financial planner who promotes ethical and sustainable investing. Hi, Kieran. Hi
- 0:42
- Kieran Hughes: Aidan, how are you getting on?
- 0:43
- Aidan Finnegan: I'm good. What is ethical investing and why is it worth doing over regular investing, which we've been exploring at length on this podcast? So I know you have a spiel about how you should be maxing out the pension and all that. Do
- 0:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you want to
- 0:55
- Aidan Finnegan: you want to get that out of the way?
- 0:56
- Kieran Hughes: So once I suppose, look very quickly, once you've uh ideally gone to a certified financial planner, built a plan, looked at the entire household um incomes, expenses, and plans for the future, then people would ask us, you know, around ethical investing, sustainable investing, how can I invest? So to understand what it is, I suppose first of all you need to understand what
- 1:15
- Kieran Hughes: traditional investing is, which is everything. It's the good, the bad, the ugly. So you'll have good companies in there, we'll have a lot of bad companies in there as well, and uh everyone in between, because you know, we don't live in a cartoon. There's a lot of companies doing their best trying to get better. So ethical investing then would be this idea of trying to improve
- 1:35
- Kieran Hughes: um what we invest in. So first of all, there's generally trends. three steps, or there's a few different aspects. With ethical investing, there's traditionally a number of different types. So the traditional or the old school way of doing it was that ethical investing, which was this idea of removing the negative industries.
- 1:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like,
- 1:53
- Kieran Hughes: what do I not want to invest my money in? What do I so fossil fuels, weapons, tobacco, as you mentioned, maybe gambling, maybe alcohol, and that would have been around for many. decades in in different forms. More recently then, we've seen the advent then of impact investing, which is this idea of can I have a positive impact in the world
- 2:13
- Kieran Hughes: but still make a profit because it's not a charity, you know, so I do want to make a return, but it would be nice if I could have a positive impact as well. And then lastly then there's the ESG investing. Um There's a few other ones as well, but we'll keep it simple for today. So ESG investing and ESG is uh environmental, social, and governance. It's essentially how companies are
- 2:33
- Kieran Hughes: run or how companies uh approach these elements around sustainability and uh their their stakeholders and how they're governed. And
- 2:42
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
- 2:43
- Kieran Hughes: a company is run well and uh it takes account of all these things, they're more likely to attract inward investment.
- 2:49
- Aidan Finnegan: Okay. And is there another term for it? Because I would feel like a bit of a knob saying I'm ethically investing, you know, not just because like I have some self-awareness, but also
- 2:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because
- 2:59
- Aidan Finnegan: I don't want to be casting aspersions on other people's investing, you know, traditional investing. Unless they have like individual shares in Lockheed Martin. And then I might cast some aspersions. But you know what I mean? Is that the only term we we go by?
- 3:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 3:13
- Kieran Hughes: I mean, I'm not really. sure that people chat about this around the dinner table anyway.
- 3:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, I can
- 3:18
- Aidan Finnegan: tell you something though. There'll be somebody in the social media comments going, What is this woke investing? And to them I say, Darren 564, would you take the day off?
- 3:28
- Kieran Hughes: Right, right. Um, I mean, look, there's those few that I mentioned have slightly different names for slightly different reasons because they do different things.
- 3:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
- 3:36
- Kieran Hughes: so the ethical investing is is very much about removing the negative. The impact is about including more positive. And the ESG is around focusing on those companies that are are run well. So
- 3:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 3:47
- Kieran Hughes: there isn't one word, I mean, sustainable investing doesn't really hit the nail on the head either. Um, but collectively they make up the group.
- 3:55
- Aidan Finnegan: Okay. And on this podcast, we, you know, we've spent many hours discussing investing in passive global index. funds. And if there are, if that's double dutch to some listeners, I apologize about the jargon. I will leave earlier episodes that in the show notes that we've spent talking about this. It just takes too much time today. And we've a lot to get through, Kieran. But you know, if you invest in an
- 4:15
- Aidan Finnegan: index fund that tracks, say, the SP 500, the 500 top performing companies
- 4:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
- 4:20
- Aidan Finnegan: the US, or if you check where your pension is being invested, like what might you be surprised to find?
- 4:27
- Kieran Hughes: Yeah, I I guess going back to your earlier example of, you know, okay, tell you what, let's say we stood on Grafton Street and we asked 100 people, do they want their pension or their cash invested in fossil fuels, weapons, or tobacco? You can be pretty sure that almost 100% of Irish people will say no. However, if you looked at their pension statement or you took
- 4:47
- Kieran Hughes: a deep dive under the bonnet of what they've invested in, you will find anywhere between 5 and 10% in fossil fuels, about 2% probably on average in weapons, and maybe 1% in
- 4:59
- Kieran Hughes: tobacco. So, like, you know, if you've 100 quid in your pension, you know, five to 10 euros is directly in fossil fuel companies like BP, etc. Um, you know, you're gonna have two euro in in weapons like Raytheon, and then you're gonna have maybe one in in in in tobacco companies like Philip Morris, et cetera. So I suppose most people are just not aware of that.
- 5:19
- Aidan Finnegan: Yeah, yeah. And uh any others, like we've kind of talked about like the big bogeyman, I suppose, but you know, what what else is in there?
- 5:26
- Kieran Hughes: I mean, there's gonna be mining and extraction. There's going to be you're gonna have everything like in a global index, and and in to be fair, most traditional funds with the big providers, diversification is that. It's
- 5:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): gonna going
- 5:38
- Kieran Hughes: have to every industry. every geographical location for the purposes of diversification. One of the byproducts of that, though, is that you're going to have some people will have a preference that they not be there. So you're definitely going to have tech in there. Some people will have an issue with tech, some people don't. And to be fair, that's where a lot of the returns have come from for the last
- 5:57
- Kieran Hughes: 20 or 30 years. So, you know, it's not perfect, but you just have to do your best with it. you know?
- 6:03
- Aidan Finnegan: So if you are feeling that you want to be conscious about where your money is invested and you definitely can identify the red lines like the weapons companies or what have you, you know, where do you stop? Like every company probably has something undesirable at some point in the chain. So, like, how do you figure out what your own tolerance for what ethics is when it comes to your pension will
- 6:23
- Aidan Finnegan: say or or any other type of investing?
- 6:25
- Kieran Hughes: Yeah. Uh I guess it I guess it depends. Everyone's different. And we do get lots of requests in Ethico for various things. But you know, for most people they do have to go for an off-the-shelf solution uh from one of the big providers or or one of the big uh index trackers, et cetera. So, you know, many people will talk about the the big tree, the fossil fuel weapons, tobacco, some geopolitical
- 6:45
- Kieran Hughes: stuff. uh, They'll talk about, you know, there is to go in further afield, then you can get very nuanced on it, but it's really up to the individual. Like you know yourself, when you're looking at something, or you know, when we receive contacts from the website, usually they'll have a few notes made on that around the things that they don't want. And that is step one
- 7:05
- Kieran Hughes: for sure.
- 7:06
- Aidan Finnegan: And you obviously went through this mindset at Set some point because you set up a whole company that's kind of like to promote ethical investing. Like, what was the moment that you kind of thought, Oh geez, am I doing good here?
- 7:18
- Kieran Hughes: Yeah. Yeah. Well, I think, you know, largely speaking, we're probably all on our sustainability journey of different types, whether it's, you know, insulating the house or or the electric car or using the bus more, et cetera. And I guess it was part of that journey for me. You know, every day when you're coming into To work and you're investing money or helping people to invest their savings, then you're kind of saying, Well,
- 7:38
- Kieran Hughes: you know, why? what is under the bonnet here? Because there isn't always,
- 7:42
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 7:42
- Kieran Hughes: know, that that much transparency around it. Like if you look at a fund fact sheet from a from a provider, they'll have the top 10 usually listed.
- 7:50
- Aidan Finnegan: What does the fact sheet show?
- 7:51
- Kieran Hughes: It showed everything. It'll show returns, it'll show geographically where it's located, it'll show, you know, how much is inequities or bonds, etc. et cetera. But it would have say maybe the top 10 holdings, so the biggest overall holdings that are in it. And that's fine. Usually they're the tech companies for the most part because they're so big.
- 8:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 8:09
- Kieran Hughes: like if you get the full list of holdings, which we often do, then you're looking at there could be 2,000 companies in there. Oh. And you're only seeing the top 10.
- 8:17
- Aidan Finnegan: Right.
- 8:17
- Kieran Hughes: So then we would do an analysis on the full list and we'd say, right, well, you know, if you get to number 17 or you get to number 25, you still have some pretty big companies pretty big percentage holdings in there that for the sustainable ethical investor wouldn't usually be acceptable. So basically, you need to lift the bonnet and dig a bit deeper
- 8:37
- Kieran Hughes: and see what's actually in there.
- 8:39
- Aidan Finnegan: Is there an index fund that only has sustainable companies in it? Or how do you actually go about finding how to put this money somewhere like that?
- 8:48
- Kieran Hughes: There's there's probably an index fund or an ETF. for everything under the sun. So, you know, the more you look, the more you will find. Uh, I'm not going to name as you know any specific ones, um, but absolutely go on the research tools, have a look and see and see what's there. Um, but generally my advice would be to work with a
- 9:08
- Kieran Hughes: financial planner, uh with a financial advisor who should have this work done already and should have the analysis done on the funds that are available on the Irish market, particularly for pensions, because pensions generally are going to be with one of the larger providers in Ireland, and they'll have 60 to maybe 80 funds on the platform. And we would argue from an
- 9:27
- Kieran Hughes: ethical, sustainable point of view, maybe two or three of them would meet our criteria. Oh, wow, that's
- 9:33
- Aidan Finnegan: little.
- 9:33
- Kieran Hughes: That's that few. Depending on how far you want to push it, on on how far down that line you want to go. Now they're fantastic funds and they do what it says on the tin and we can stand over them, but people do want genuine options. I think there's maybe nothing worse than
- 9:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do you
- 9:48
- Kieran Hughes: know, like a wind farm on the front of a brochure or something like that, and somebody invests for twenty years and then later they find out, Oh, I didn't realize it would But actually still had fossil fuels in it, or something like that. So
- 9:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that that
- 9:59
- Kieran Hughes: can be an issue. So there's no
- 10:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh um, you know,
- 10:04
- Kieran Hughes: magic bullet. But I mean, also every person in Ireland who's working, paying tax,
- 10:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): paying
- 10:09
- Kieran Hughes: into a pension, you know, they do want to invest for their future and they do want to maximize their outcomes.
- 10:14
- Aidan Finnegan: Absolutely.
- 10:15
- Kieran Hughes: And I suppose it's really just about giving those people an option to do it in a more ethical, sustainable way than just ninety-nine 99% percent of funds that are out there, you
- 10:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know.
- 10:23
- Aidan Finnegan: So, what would people typically come to you asking, and then where might you direct them? As an example, obviously it's not advice you're giving.
- 10:30
- Kieran Hughes: Yeah, uh so with us, I mean, like we're we're a brokerage, we're a broker, and we have agencies with all the big life companies. So, and each of those will have, you know, one or two or maybe three really good funds that would meet our criteria. And we meet with those companies on a regular basis to continually assess those options. So, again, that's part of what we offer and
- 10:50
- Kieran Hughes: what our research. is, is that we're continually checking and keeping up to date with that. So, you know, that and again, that's very much around pension money, which should usually be people's primary focus
- 11:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
- 11:02
- Kieran Hughes: the pension first. Um, so that's generally what who we would work with, the the big brand names in Ireland.
- 11:08
- Aidan Finnegan: And then in terms of like investing in companies that do good, what
- 11:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are
- 11:13
- Aidan Finnegan: they? They they are they could
- 11:15
- Kieran Hughes: be I mean
- 11:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): wind
- 11:16
- Aidan Finnegan: farms, like you said.
- 11:17
- Kieran Hughes: Yeah, yeah, that's part of it. Now again, you don't want to get too pigeonholed into
- 11:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just a
- 11:20
- Kieran Hughes: wind farm fund
- 11:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because that's not very diverse.
- 11:22
- Kieran Hughes: Yes, exactly. It'd be too narrow.
- 11:28
- Kieran Hughes: But sure, renewable energy, um, healthcare, social housing, um there's a a very long list there of of industries that again can turn a few bob, make a few quid for investors, and still have a positive outcome in what they're actually generating into the world as well, you
- 11:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know.
- 11:52
- Aidan Finnegan: Coming up, are the returns from ethical investing as good as traditional funds, or are you taking a bigger risk with your money?
- 12:05
- Aidan Finnegan: In terms of the returns, then are you taking more of a risk?
- 12:10
- Kieran Hughes: Not necessarily, and it's it's something that does come up a lot, right? But I think if the fund is well diversified and it's not too narrow, as we mentioned, and it has all geographical areas in there, um, and it has all industries bar barred the negative, and you've doubled down on some of the positive. There's going to be swings and roundabouts.
- 12:28
- Aidan Finnegan: Yeah.
- 12:29
- Kieran Hughes: So sometimes over a period of time, some of the ethical funds will do worse. And sometimes, like we've seen in the past, they've actually done better than the benchmark or the index. And it just depends over time, but it's not a categorical categorical it does better all the time or
- 12:42
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it is
- 12:42
- Kieran Hughes: worse. What we found on average over the years is that it usually evens out.
- 12:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Okay.
- 12:47
- Aidan Finnegan: Evens out in rel in relation to
- 12:49
- Kieran Hughes: the benchmark, let's say. whatever a traditional fund of the same makeup would be doing, the ethical funds would be in and around the same over the long term. As long, crucially as they're not too narrow in their scope, if
- 13:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they're
- 13:00
- Kieran Hughes: still well diverse. Like you can't throw the baby out with the bat water just because you want to invest sustainably or ethically. You still have to look at the fundamentals of diversification, risk, return, charges, all the basics, and that happens first.
- 13:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 13:14
- Kieran Hughes: then you're into right, what's the ethical, sustainable nature of this fund? It it comes last in the process, but it's super important to the people who come to see us.
- 13:22
- Aidan Finnegan: Yeah.
- 13:22
- Kieran Hughes: Do you know?
- 13:23
- Aidan Finnegan: It's interesting because I suppose a lot of people, and we hear it a lot, that for the general population now I'm talking about, that
- 13:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
- 13:31
- Aidan Finnegan: you know, an all-world ETF is the way to go because of that uh diversification across all these companies. And so if some are performing poorly, the others will lift it up. And there's an element of passivity there because you don't have to think about it.
- 13:47
- Kieran Hughes: Exactly.
- 13:47
- Aidan Finnegan: But with sustainable or ethical investing, I guess you do have to more actively manage that, which it might be intimidating to people who are starting out.
- 13:57
- Kieran Hughes: Well, again, if it's via a provider and it's a service that's being provided, it will be done for you on your behalf. obviously for for a fee, and that's part of the process. So if you were trying to do this yourself, it might be more difficult. I mean, the only true form of complete diversification is, you know, the the global index, where it has absolutely everything, large, small,
- 14:17
- Kieran Hughes: all over the world. But I mean, you mentioned the S P five hundred earlier on. Like that in itself is a form of active because you're making a decision about the US. You're saying I'm going to invest in the US only, rather than you say, you've left out Europe and everything else. So there's very few true true passive investments out there. They'll always have a little bit of a tilt
- 14:37
- Kieran Hughes: or whatever. Now, granted, when you start taking out entire industries from a fund
- 14:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
- 14:43
- Kieran Hughes: and adding in some more, it is moving things around a bit more, but
- 14:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 14:48
- Kieran Hughes: the returns are there to show that on average it evens out. Um, if you were down to very few holdings in a fund, that's a problem. But once you have a decent amount of holdings in there and um
- 15:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
- 15:00
- Kieran Hughes: you it's over time. It's not about looking at last year or the last two years.
- 15:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
- 15:04
- Kieran Hughes: know, it's looking over a long period of time that that works out.
- 15:08
- Aidan Finnegan: There there is the issue of returns. You want good returns
- 15:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because
- 15:12
- Aidan Finnegan: this is why you're putting your money away for your future self. Um But then this obviously requires more specialized research. So is it going to cost you more to do that?
- 15:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 15:22
- Kieran Hughes: mean, if you're working with a certified financial planner or a a QFA, they're going to have their costs there and they're providing a service to deliver everything from the plan right through to products and everything else. Usually Um
- 15:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's
- 15:35
- Kieran Hughes: like what everything, look, I suppose you can try and paint your own house. you can buy the tools, you can buy the paint, and there's always the danger that you make a mess of it or you fall off the ladder. It's the same with you know servicing your car. Yeah, it's every industry, you know. So absolutely.
- 15:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 15:53
- Kieran Hughes: mean, uh go and have a look and try and do the research, but it is going to be more difficult, particularly in the ethical space, yeah, where it's it it's it's a bit more nuance to it and it's not just pick pick. and go.
- 16:03
- Aidan Finnegan: Okay
- 16:12
- Aidan Finnegan: well I mean we've probably all heard about greenwashing where companies exaggerate their environmental credentials
- 16:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 16:18
- Aidan Finnegan: know to look good. Is there an equivalent term in investing?
- 16:21
- Kieran Hughes: Not necessarily I mean a a lot of the the the the the terminology is is transferable. So so for me, I think it in in finance and investing, some of
- 16:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh the
- 16:31
- Kieran Hughes: the greenwashing per se is somewhat accidental. And and it's it it for me anyway, it seems to be a difference between what some of the industry feels is sustainable versus what the client sitting in front of me feels is sustainable.
- 16:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There'd
- 16:43
- Kieran Hughes: be a mismatch there.
- 16:44
- Aidan Finnegan: Yes. So you know, if we saw
- 16:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 16:47
- Aidan Finnegan: a a jar of, I don't know, sauce in a supermarket. and we read the label, we'd be able to tell exactly what's in it and we
- 16:54
- Kieran Hughes: could make
- 16:55
- Aidan Finnegan: a decision based on what we saw. Well, I think that there's an awful lot of sugar's very high up in the ingredient
- 17:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): list
- 17:01
- Aidan Finnegan: there. So I don't think this is as healthy as it's claiming to be. Like how do you do that with investing?
- 17:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 17:08
- Kieran Hughes: as a retail investor, it's going to be difficult
- 17:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to get
- 17:11
- Kieran Hughes: that level of access, to be honest. Um, we would have it as we are partners with um the various companies and we have access to the fund managers and we can interview them in person
- 17:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 17:21
- Kieran Hughes: run down through it. Right. And say, look, what have you been doing for the last 25 years? Has that changed? What is the ethos of the fund? Uh, how does it work? Is that going to change? No, it's not okay. And then these are the holdings. So that's the service essentially we're providing
- 17:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to our
- 17:34
- Kieran Hughes: clients is that we will do essentially the donkey work for them and come back and say, Look, this is a genuinely sustainable fund. This one's telling a few fibs, this one is not at all. And then to give people clarity on what's in it and what's
- 17:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not.
- 17:49
- Aidan Finnegan: Okay. If we have a checklist for somebody who is, they have a pension, they're in a default scheme, they've never really thought about it. Like, is there a checklist of things you can do for to look in and better? understand where your money is going?
- 18:06
- Kieran Hughes: The experience I've had with clients who are maybe in well with some of the larger corporate providers for group schemes, et cetera, is that when they request sustainable information, it's often there's very little provided. It's maybe a fund fact sheet. And again, to be fair, some of the platforms do you have some okay, sustainable, genuine sustainable funds there. But really, when we're working with a client,
- 18:26
- Kieran Hughes: we're doing a full plan. So we're do we're looking at their old pensions, their current work pension, they're doing AVCs, and we're looking across the broad spectrum of saying, we need to do the best we can here where we can. Yeah.
- 18:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 18:38
- Kieran Hughes: you're not going to leave your company group scheme over sustainability because there's an employer contribution. Yes. But do they have a fund on there that's good enough? Hopefully they do. And then you're looking at your old pensions, you're looking at everything else and saying, right. well, we'll go super sustainable over here because we have the option. Um, and it's just about doing the best we can. Like going back to
- 18:58
- Kieran Hughes: the idea of, you know, uh an A-rated house, while it's better than an F-rated house for a BEOR, it's not perfect. Likewise, you know, an electric car or taking the bus or whatever, much, much better options than a petrol car. But again, there is some emissions.
- 19:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Better than better than. Yeah. So we're
- 19:13
- Kieran Hughes: we're never that there's some sometimes we're in this black and white, it has to be perfect. And it's better than. So if you take collectively all the money in pensions and investments in Ireland and they all stayed in traditional funds, or if they all switched to sustainable ethical funds, like that would have a big impact because of the exclusions and the extra investment in positive industries and the
- 19:33
- Kieran Hughes: weight that it would put behind the ESG investing to put pressure on companies to act in a better way. Yeah. You know, so it's not just me or you, it's kind of everybody collectively working together saying this is our preference for how our money is invested.
- 19:46
- Aidan Finnegan: Yeah. Pension companies or brokers or traders or whatever, they're they're going to look at a company that's performing well. And even if we don't like that particular company, you know, if we don't like Elon Musk or whatever, the company that you're investing your pension with is still going to look at who's going to perform the best. And so
- 20:06
- Aidan Finnegan: is it even possible? Is ethical investing kind of an oxymoron?
- 20:10
- Kieran Hughes: Yeah, no, it absolutely is. I mean, first of all, they're not going to know who's going to perform well or not in advance of time. They just have to make a bet. That's essentially all they're doing. So that's the first thing, I suppose. And the second thing is they're going to set out the rules of the fund in advance. So if the rules of the fund have these uh exclusives, exclusions, they can't break those exclusions just because they want to,
- 20:30
- Kieran Hughes: or they think that you know weapons are going to have a good run or tobacco, like they have to stick with that. And then,
- 20:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 20:36
- Kieran Hughes: know, if if they do have a positive uh impact ethos as well, they're not going to break that because they have,
- 20:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 20:43
- Kieran Hughes: know, a ton of investors in there already who joined for that reason. And if they suddenly change their stripes, so to speak, and and and invest in in other ways that don't meet that ethos,
- 20:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
- 20:54
- Kieran Hughes: can't really do that because the other people will leave. Or, you know, so um there's plenty of other funds available. In fact, the vast, vast majority of funds that are available are going to invest in everything the good, the bad, and the ugly. So the sustainable ethical funds will hold a much narrower view of what they can invest in and what they will
- 21:14
- Kieran Hughes: invest in. because that's what their um that's what their investors want.
- 21:18
- Aidan Finnegan: Yeah.
- 21:19
- Kieran Hughes: You know?
- 21:19
- Aidan Finnegan: And and yeah, and I suppose that they have that obligation to their investors
- 21:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to make
- 21:23
- Aidan Finnegan: them money.
- 21:24
- Kieran Hughes: Yeah.
- 21:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hmm.
- 21:25
- Aidan Finnegan: Well, food for thought, Kieran. Thank you very much for joining us today. Is there a final message that you think people should take away from today?
- 21:32
- Kieran Hughes: Yeah, I I think ultimately from a sustainability point of view, for all the jargon and all the waffle, you can boil it down. to three simple points, which is take out the bad companies, add in more good companies, and work with the rest to improve. And if you do that, you've done the best you could hope for, and it'll be a lot better than traditional funds.
- 21:51
- Aidan Finnegan: Kieran Hughes, thank you very much for joining
- 21:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): us.
- 21:53
- Kieran Hughes: Cheers.
- 22:00
- Aidan Finnegan: That's it for this week. If you want to let us know what you think of this episode, be sure to leave a comment on your podcast app. And while you're there, subscribe so you don't have to go looking for future episodes. Next time, we'll be chatting to a 24-year-old Dubliner sharing her journey to her first 100k on Instagram. I'm Aidine Finnegan. This is Better With Money. Talk to you
- 22:20
- Aidan Finnegan: next week.