Noise Cancelling with Neil Woodford

Neil Woodford argues UK pension mandates and cheap valuations drive market appeal amid pension fund exodus

37 min Listen to the original Episode page
UK EquitiesPension FundsCapital AllocationValuationMacroeconomicsCorporate GovernanceBuybacksFTSE 100

Summary

John Adair and Neil Woodford discuss the structural decline of UK pension fund ownership in domestic equities, which has dropped from over 50% in 1997 to 4% today. Woodford criticizes the Financial Times for misattributing market shrinkage to buybacks rather than the exit of domestic institutional investors. He proposes a mandate requiring pension funds to hold UK equities equal to international holdings, citing £54bn in annual tax relief subsidies. The speakers highlight that UK shares trade at 14.9x earnings versus the S&P 500's 26x, with strong returns on capital supporting undervaluation claims. Adair notes UK economic resilience with 0.7% Q3 growth, while Woodford maintains buybacks serve as a valid benchmark for capital allocation.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Q3 growth 0.7%, the fastest since uh 2021, the fastest quarter growth since 2021.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 33:20

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 4:06

    Introduction and FT Critique

    John Adair introduces the topic, noting the UK stock market relies on buybacks and foreign bidders after pension funds exited. Neil Woodford criticizes the Financial Times for misidentifying the causes of the market's shrinkage, blaming symptoms like stamp duty rather than the root cause.

  2. 4:06 – 9:08

    Pension Fund Exodus and Market Structure

    Adair highlights that UK pension fund ownership of domestic shares dropped from 53% in 1997 to 4% today. With UK equity funds seeing 10 years of outflows, overseas investors now hold 59% of the market, leaving companies and foreign bidders as the primary buyers.

  3. 9:08 – 15:37

    Share Buybacks vs. Investment

    Woodford argues against the binary view that buybacks replace investment. He posits that buybacks should be the benchmark for capital allocation; if a company can generate higher returns buying back shares than investing in growth or acquisitions, it is a valid use of capital.

  4. 15:37 – 20:48

    Corporate Governance and Accountability

    The discussion addresses Michael Jensen's 1989 argument that debt disciplines management better than equity. Woodford counters that active fund managers and hedge funds still hold management to account, noting the shift from deferential relationships in the past to more challenging ones today.

  5. 20:48 – 31:49

    Proposed Mandate for Pension Funds

    Woodford proposes mandating UK pension funds to hold at least as much in UK equities as they do in international equities. He argues this is fair given the £54bn annual taxpayer subsidy via tax relief and would restore liquidity, encouraging IPOs and reducing reliance on buybacks.

  6. 31:49 – 33:20

    Valuation and Performance Outlook

    Adair notes the FTSE 100 trades at 14.9x earnings versus the S&P 500's 26x. Woodford maintains his view that UK shares are undervalued relative to their returns on capital and believes they will outperform, citing resilience despite geopolitical and energy headwinds.

  7. 33:20 – 34:23

    UK Economic Resilience vs Consensus

    Speaker 1 asserts the UK economy is growing faster than consensus expectations, citing Q3 growth of 0.7% as the fastest since 2021. This resilience persists despite challenges like elevated energy prices, higher interest rates, and taxes.

  8. 34:23 – 35:27

    Valuation and Buyback Drivers

    Speaker 1 argues the UK equity market is fundamentally cheap relative to history and peer groups, particularly the US. This undervaluation drives over £100bn in share buybacks and bids in the current year, alongside attractive return on equity and capital metrics.

  9. 35:27 – 36:27

    Market Attractions Without Mandation

    The speaker maintains the UK market remains attractive due to cheap valuations, continued buybacks, international buying, and growing dividends, even if pension funds do not return. He suggests a potential mandate for pension funds would be favorable but is not strictly necessary for the market's appeal.

  10. 36:27 – 37:20

    Research Publication Details

    Speaker 1 directs listeners to noise cancelling.co for a full research piece containing charts and detailed arguments, expected to be published within a day or two.

Claims worth verifying

UK pension funds used to hold 53% of their assets in UK shares in 1997, but today hold only about 4%.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·4:06

How to verify: Check Bank of England or Association of British Insurers historical data on UK pension fund asset allocation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

UK pension funds and insurers owned 45.7% of the UK stock market at the last full count, now 4.2%.

John Adair ·4:34

How to verify: Verify against the latest UK Office for National Statistics or Bank of England data on institutional ownership of UK equities. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

UK equity funds have had 10 straight years of outflows.

John Adair ·4:34

How to verify: Check Investment Management Association (IMA) or Morningstar UK data for annual net flows in UK equity funds. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Overseas investors now own 59% of the UK stock market.

John Adair ·4:34

How to verify: Verify against Bank of England or London Stock Exchange Group data on investor nationality breakdown. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

UK companies spent £56 billion buying back shares this year.

John Adair ·4:51

How to verify: Check Refinitiv or Bloomberg data on UK share buyback volumes for the current calendar year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Foreign bidders announced £73 billion of takeovers of UK listed companies, the most since 2018.

John Adair ·4:51

How to verify: Check Refinitiv or Bloomberg M&A data for UK-listed company acquisitions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

FTSE 100 companies alone bought back £58.6 billion.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·5:04

How to verify: Check Refinitiv or Bloomberg data on buybacks specifically within the FTSE 100 index constituents. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

UK pension tax relief costs the taxpayer about £54 billion a year.

John Adair ·20:48

How to verify: Verify against UK HMRC statistics on pension tax relief expenditures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The FTSE 100 trades on 14.9 times its earnings.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·31:49

How to verify: Calculate current FTSE 100 price-to-earnings ratio using index provider data and constituent earnings reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The S&P 500 trades on 26 times its earnings.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·31:49

How to verify: Calculate current S&P 500 price-to-earnings ratio using index provider data and constituent earnings reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Q3 growth was 0.7%, the fastest quarter growth since 2021.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·33:20

How to verify: Check UK Office for National Statistics (ONS) GDP data for Q3 2026 (or relevant year) and compare historical quarterly growth rates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The UK economy performed better than Bank of England, OBR, or consensus beliefs.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·33:40

How to verify: Compare actual UK GDP growth figures against Bank of England Inflation Report forecasts, OBR forecasts, and consensus economist surveys for the relevant period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

UK equity valuations are objectively way below peer groups and low relative to history.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·34:42

How to verify: Calculate current P/E or P/B ratios for the FTSE 100 or UK All Share against historical averages and peer indices (e.g., S&P 500, Euro Stoxx 50) using data from Bloomberg or Refinitiv. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

UK return on equity and return on capital are very attractive and compare favorably with the US.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·35:02

How to verify: Compare aggregate ROE and ROIC metrics for UK-listed companies against US-listed companies using financial data providers like Bloomberg or FactSet. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Over 100 billion of share buybacks and bids were seen in the UK in the current year.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·35:07

How to verify: Sum total value of announced and completed share buybacks and M&A transactions in the UK for the specified year using data from Dealogic or Refinitiv. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

UK equity yields are above those of peer economies.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·35:46

How to verify: Compare the dividend yield of the FTSE 100 or UK All Share against yields of peer indices (e.g., S&P 500, DAX) using financial data sources. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The full research piece is published on noise cancelling.co.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·36:27

How to verify: Visit noise cancelling.co to locate the article authored by Neil Woodford. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify UK pension fund ownership percentages by checking the Association of British Insurers (ABI) or Pensions and Lifetime Savings Association (PLSA) historical data reports.
  • Confirm the £54bn annual cost of UK pension tax relief using HMRC statistics or Treasury fiscal reports.
  • Check the FTSE 100 and S&P 500 trailing P/E ratios via Bloomberg, Refinitiv, or Yahoo Finance to validate the 14.9x vs 26x valuation gap cited.
  • Review the Thames Water financial distress timeline and debt levels through Companies House filings or major financial news archives to assess the 'debt discipline' argument.
  • Analyze UK Q3 GDP growth figures from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) to verify the 0.7% growth claim and consensus forecast discrepancies.
  • Examine recent UK IPO activity and M&A transaction volumes using Dealogic or S&P Capital IQ data to validate the £18bn new listings vs £73bn takeovers figures.
  • Assess the feasibility and political likelihood of a pension fund UK equity mandate by reviewing UK government policy statements and Treasury consultations.
  • Compare UK corporate return on equity (ROE) and return on capital employed (ROCE) metrics against US peers using S&P Global Market Intelligence or FactSet.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
John Adair: The British stock market has two reliable buyers left. One is the companies themselves buying back their own shares, the other is foreign bidders who buy the whole company and take it off the market. The people who used to own it, Britain's own pension funds, have gone. The Financial Times has spent the last fortnight explaining why the UK market is shrinking. Neil Woodford thinks it has the
0:19
John Adair: causes wrong. He also thinks there's a way to bring back the missing buyer, and it's one no Chancellor has been willing to use.
0:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
0:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): think it's a betrayal of the UK taxpayer. The taxpayer has funded hundreds of billions of benefits for these pension funds, and yet the pension funds have run away from the UK economy. In effect, that's a betrayal.
0:45
John Adair: Hello and welcome to Noise Cancelling. I'm John Adair, and with me, as ever, is Neil Woodford. There are three things in this episode. that we're going to cover. First, what the FT got wrong about why the UK market is shrinking. Second, who is actually buying UK shares now and why that makes share buybacks a very different story from the one you've read. And third, Neil's fix,
1:05
John Adair: which is to make pension funds buy British and what all of it means if you own UK shares today. Neil, in one line before we start, is the UK stock market dying or is it being bought?
1:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Um it's definitely being bought. I wouldn't say dying, but I s would say that it's in ill h in ill health. It's not thriving, that's for sure.
1:25
John Adair: Well, before we get into it, everything that Neil writes, including the piece behind this episode, is in the noise cancelling app. It's free to download, it's free to join, and you can get it on iPhone and on Android, and it will read all of Neil's pieces to you if you'd rather listen. So the FTE has run three pieces on this in a fortnight. One was on American venture capital firms closing their London
1:45
John Adair: offices, one was a big read called the Giant British Corporate Sell-off, and one was a shorter piece called Market Failure, which is the one Neil that you took issue with. Between them, they give the standard explanation. The UK has no big technology companies. Companies are spending their cash on buying back shares when they should be investing. and that it's happening everywhere. So it
2:04
John Adair: isn't really a British problem. Neil, you called that FT piece muddled thinking. Tell people what it said and what you think it got wrong.
2:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well he got what he got wrong was the causes. It included some like stamp duty, the the burden of listing companies in the UK, which are not helpful but are not the fundamental causes of the shrinking equity market. It described the phenomenon as I don't. an international event. It tried to sort of portray what was happening to the UK as not
2:32
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): particularly unique and that
2:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): this was happening to a broad spread of markets across the world. It cited an academic paper suggesting that public equity ownership had had its day. uh It referred back to this paper that was written 37 thirty-seven years ago by the Harvard Business Review. And it it's a very academic paper saying basically you don't need
2:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): public equity ownership to hold businesses to account. What you need is basically the sanction of interest, regular interest payments, and and the ability to recall debt, which I think is is is a total and utter misread of how how businesses are held to account and what the and how the and the best way
3:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): to hold them to account, frankly, it is not through the sanction of of calling in debt. And it also said that part of the reason for the market's problem is that the UK doesn't have a viable scaled tech sector. Now, I think there are there's some truth in that argument, but
3:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it is by no means the the the cause of the problems that the UK is grappling with today. So um it it it's a reason for evaluation differential, for example with the US, but it is not the cause of of the of the problem.
3:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
3:49
John Adair: the FT's got a list of symptoms.
3:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What
3:52
John Adair: we're gonna do next is show you the cause and it comes down to one question you can ask of any market. Who is the buyer? Stay for the back half as well because that's where Neil sets out what he would do about it and whether UK shares are worth owning if nobody does anything.
4:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): If the Chancellor of the Government never fixes this,
4:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): should investors still own UK shares? The answer is if
4:14
John Adair: you'd rather skip to that section, use the chapter markers down below. So ask who the buyer is. That's the rule for this episode, and it explains almost everything about the UK market. In 1997, UK pension funds held 53%. of their assets in UK shares. Today it's just about 4%. British pension funds and insurers owned
4:34
John Adair: 45.7% of the UK stock market. At the last full count, it was 4.2%. They didn't sell to other British savers. UK equity funds have had 10 straight years of money going out, and overseas investors now own 59% of the market.
4:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
4:50
John Adair: who is left to buy?
4:51
John Adair: This year, UK companies have spent £56 billion buying back their own shares. Foreign bidders have announced £73 billion of takeovers of UK listed companies, the most since 2018.
5:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
5:04
John Adair: the amount of new money companies raised on the London market last year was about £18 billion. pounds. FTSE 100 companies alone bought back £58.6 billion.
5:15
John Adair: That's more than three to one. Neil, you sat on the other side of this for 35 years. What does it do to a market when its own institutions stop buying?
5:24
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It's a massive headwind and has been for and was a large, a large headwind for for most of my career. When the biggest owners of the equity market exit almost entirely their their their whole holdings in that market. It doesn't take a genius to work out that that's going to be
5:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): a massive headwind. When you've got that sort of weight of selling and disinvestment going on, it creates a massive headwind for listed businesses. But of course, it doesn't just affect those that are already listed. It also, because there's no new capital really coming into the market. and because the
6:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): biggest owners are exiting, companies that would otherwise have thought that an IPO and a public listing was the natural home, if you like, or the natural evolution of their of their maturity, if you like. They go from young technology companies, for example, that they they get venture capital funding, then they get scale-up scale up capital, and then their IPO,
6:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): naturally, and and raise capital like Anthropogiz. Anthropic is, for example, in its IPO and carry on growing. That door was slammed in the face of British companies, really, as a result of this massive disinvestment. And it explains in large part why there is a complete absence of
6:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): new companies coming to the UK equity market. It's it's a travesty, uh, but it is a direct product of that. sort of huge amount of selling that that took place through the last two decades at least.
6:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And now, as as you've already said, John, I mean, the UK pension funds, which were once which used to own roughly half the market, now own 4% of To the market. And
7:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): possibly the thing that irritates me the most is that they own. significantly more in international equities than they own in the UK. And remember, these are funds that get UK taxpayer subsidies effectively. And that tax relief is paid by UK taxpayers. It just seems to me a very
7:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): sort of lopsided relationship where
7:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
7:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): pension funds accept the the the benefits that are funded by by the economy effectively.
7:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): um, but don't invest in the economy. They go and invest everywhere else.
7:45
John Adair: What changes when the share register is overseas and passive?
7:48
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): If the businesses are owned internationally, then then
7:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
7:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): value that accrues to to the shareholders of that business doesn't accrue to people in the economy, if you like. It it it's it's leakage.
8:00
John Adair: Do you think other investors are looking at the UK? and thinking, if you won't buy your own market, why should we?
8:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, I think I think that is that is um
8:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
8:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): is definitely it's not something that that fund managers global fund managers would say necessarily publicly, but you can just imagine why they would allocate or wouldn't allocate to the UK equity market because the demand. domestic institutions in the UK don't allocate it to uh
8:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): allocate to it either. And remember, this is not this is not
8:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): normal. We were just an outlier. We we went a bit mad, frankly, in the UK. Um and
8:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
8:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): maybe the big government benefited from that because of course, whilst pension funds were selling UK equities. they were busy buying lots of index and guilts that the government was issuing to fund its ludicrously inflated spending um uh habit. But but nevertheless, the fact is that that pension fund ownership of the
9:04
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): domestic market in the UK is an outlier, an extreme outlier.
9:08
John Adair: Neil, let's talk about buybacks because the FT reads the £56 billion
9:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
9:13
John Adair: buybacks that have happened as the market draining away. Now, for those that don't know, a buyback is simple. A company uses its spare cash to buy its own shares and then cancels them. So there are fewer shares and each one that's left owns a bigger slice of the business. The charge against them is that bosses do it to flatter earnings per share and hit their
9:32
John Adair: bonus targets. The government commissioned a study on exactly that in 2019, and it looked at 10 years. of FTSE 350 companies and found none that had used a buyback to hit an earnings target and no link between buybacks and lower investment. Neil, when a management team told you they were buying back shares, how did you decide whether that was a
9:52
John Adair: good use of your investors' money?
9:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): This is a big subject, but but there are a number of really important things here. First of all, academics and the FT articles sort of port portrayed buybacks as as a sort of as an either-or. You know, businesses either invested in growth, for example, um, or they or they funded share buybacks. And and the this sort
10:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): of binary view of the world is is fundamentally wrong. Firstly. But secondly, it bad-mouthed Mouth the whole idea of a buyback in the first place, which I think is a complete misread. Buyback Buybacks some sort. themselves are or the return from buying back shares in a business should be the
10:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): benchmark against which investing in growth capital, buying another business, for example, should be measured.
10:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
10:42
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): know, when a company decides how to allocate capital, it ought to have some kind of benchmark or test
10:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
10:49
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): says, well, yes, we should do that. or no, we shouldn't do that. And the benchmark or test should be,
10:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
10:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): some extent, there are other benchmarks that can be used. But the f the benchmark I liked the most was, well, we could use that capital to buy back our own shares. And the return to our shareholders of buying back shares would be X. And if if buying another business in another geography is lower than X, then we really need to have a really really
11:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): good reason why we had to buy that business
11:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): instead of buying back our own shares. This is all slightly academic because most businesses, most good businesses, at the end of each year generate more cash than they need to fund the investment in the growth capital in that business. And what tends to happen. is that
11:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): businesses look at the growth investments that they need to fund to ensure the competitive position of the business and fund those semi-automatically, albeit that every project, of course, is assessed and the returns are assessed, etc. There is a then there are tests that all good companies would would apply to
11:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): investment, but nevertheless, most good companies.
12:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): generate more cash than they need to fund those sorts of investments. And buybacks tend to be what companies think about when they've done that investing. When they've done the investment that they need to keep the business vibrant and growing and competing well,
12:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
12:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): look at a share buyback as an option with what to do with the rest. Some companies used to it many years ago before. share buybacks became more popular, companies would accumulate cash on their balance sheets and then see that see that as a sort of uh as a pot of cash to go out and buy other companies with,
12:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): often destroying value in the process. Now we Or have a a different uh a sort of culture where that spare cash at the end of each year.
12:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): is is assessed or used often to buy back shares in the company if that delivers an appropriate return. And it's and it's an entirely legitimate way to allocate capital. And it's something that I argued for when I sat down in front of businesses and talked to them about
13:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): excess cash on balance sheet or uh or business. businesses that that had virtually no leverage, for example. You know, w where it was appropriate and where share prices and valuations were depressed, it seems to me to be entirely appropriate for a company to buy back its shares, particularly when the return on that investment is gonna exceed the
13:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): returns on other projects.
13:33
John Adair: The only thing is, though, their record isn't that flattering. And maybe they need to read some of your education pieces on Noy. noise cancelling. UK companies bought back the most in two thousand seven and again in twenty eighteen, close to the top of the market. In two thousand and nine at the bottom, they bought almost nothing, and some of the biggest buyers have stopped this year. So when you say buybacks
13:52
John Adair: show boards think their shares are cheap, why should we trust their judgment?
13:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Uh well they are in a good position to assess value, but they're not they're not the best judgment. judges of that, by the way. I mean, that's why farm managers exist, frankly, because they're trained to to make these sorts of valuation judgments. The people who run businesses of are good at running businesses. They're not necessarily good at making valuation
14:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): judgments. The discipline that management teams need to think about when they're buying back shares is what are the returns going to be in the future from that share buyer back to our existing share. shareholders. It's not something that should be done and assessed over a very short time period. It should be assessed over a very long time period. And that's why people
14:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): get a little bit sort of mixed up with, well, they bought back this many shares when the share price was here. Shouldn't they be buying back more here? There are all sorts of things going on in the corporate landscape that that that can affect um how much ready cash, for example, is available for for for share
14:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): buybacks. Companies can be constrained because they might be considering making an acquisition. So they might indeed not want to buy back shares because they have in mind in X number of years or months to to to fund a big acquisition. They can, of course, pay dividends. You know, there are other ways to return value to shareholders. They can, of course,
15:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): increase the dividend. They don't have to buy back shares. So it's not as binary or as easy a decision to uh as journalists like to think. It's a quite a complex decision, and and there are lots and lots of moving parts. It's it as ever, in real life, it's much more complex than academics or journalists
15:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): like to think.
15:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
15:37
John Adair: the paper that the FT leaned on is worth spending a couple of minutes on because it's the best argument against everything Neil has just said. It was written in 1989 by a Harvard professor called Michael Jensen. His argument was that public companies waste their spare cash because shareholders are too scattered to stop them. His answer was debt. Load the company with borrowing,
15:57
John Adair: take it private, and the interest bill forces managers to behave every single quarter. It was hugely influential
16:03
John Adair: but it was also badly timed. Within months, the buyout boom collapsed, and the buyout firms Jensen admired have since listed themselves on the stock market. The UK has run this experiment as well. Thames Water was taken off the market and spent more than a decade under private owners, with the interest paid on time while the debt kept climbing. It now owes more than £20
16:23
John Adair: billion and is negotiating with its lenders. But Jensen had a point. that's hard to wave away. He said institutional shareholders weren't doing their job. In the UK, they've since sold up. Neil, you say shareholders hold management to account better than lenders do, with British institutions down to 4% of the market. Which
16:43
John Adair: shareholders?
16:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
16:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): they're not the only pension Hedge funds are not the only owners of UK equities.
16:49
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): There are many other shareholders, domestic shareholders, for example, retail investors
16:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): in funds, in investment trusts and unit trusts.
17:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So there are other
17:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): fund managers representing the interests of investors. Hedge funds, for example, are another community of investors. Typically, very high net worth investors are the people that they represent. But those hedge fund managers are there holding management to account. So it's not it's the absence of
17:24
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): large pension funds from the UK market doesn't mean that there are there are no fund managers holding management to account in the UK. Um there are many, and I did uh throughout this period, um, whenever I sat down with management teams of companies that I'd invested in on behalf of my investors,
17:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): m I saw my job as representing their interests, representing the interests of my investors, and and it was my job to hold those management teams to account, to challenge to challenge them uh on the decisions that they'd they've taken and to try um to steer them towards the sorts of decisions that
18:04
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): would that I believe would be better for the business and better for its shareholders and and by implication, therefore, better for the investors in the funds that I ran. So there are plenty of people holding these management teams to account. Um and and they do a pretty good job, I think, on the whole. Much better job than might
18:24
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): have been the case, you know. 20, 30 years ago. When I first started in the city, the relationship between fund managers and the people who ran companies was very deferential. I remember um sitting down with some of the sort of the the titans of the
18:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): time, like Maxwell, for example, who ran Mirror Group newspapers. I wasn't a shareholder in his company, but um I I had a very interesting series of meetings with other shareholders with him.
18:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Lord Hanson, I remember, uh, you know, there were other people like that that were very intimidating. And the relationship between institutional fund managers and those corporate captains was very, very deferential. Um it was very clear that that those businesses did really what they wanted to do. And
19:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): some
19:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): sort of,
19:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
19:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): mean, I'm not saying that they made all terrible decisions. I think some of them made very good decisions, but um, it was a very, very different relationship. That changed, that changed dramatically through my career. And by the time I was running bigger funds um uh at Woodford Investment Management and and at Investgo, the relationship
19:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): had completely changed, and that differential relationship. had had been replaced by one where management were on the whole, not always, but on the whole, willing to listen to their shareholders and and and respond to them.
19:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
19:51
John Adair: one last piece before we get onto what Neil would do. Between buybacks and takeovers, somewhere around three 3-4% to four percent of the UK market is being retired every year. For most of the last century, around it ran the other way. Companies issued more shares every year, and existing owners were diluted.
20:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
20:08
John Adair: shrinking market can pay the people who own it. When a company's taken over, shareholders get a premium. This year, that's included EasyJet, Segro, and Intertech. When a company retires shares below what they're worth, the remaining owners gain. But it doesn't always pay. AIM has been cheap, shrinking and bid for and has gone
20:28
John Adair: nowhere in 10 years. And when a company moves its listing to New York, shareholders get no premium at all. The company just leaves. So the rule again: ask who the buyer is and ask what they're paying. Now, if you skip to this part, this is where Neil sets out what he'd actually do. Three facts first. Pension tax relief costs the taxpayer about £54 billion
20:48
John Adair: a year. UK pension funds hold about 4%. of their assets in UK shares, and the law that passed this year, which was sold as a power to direct pension money, covers private assets only. It can't be used for listed shares, and it can't be used at all before 2028. Neil, what would you do?
21:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
21:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): think there are a couple of points to make before I tell you what I would do. Th The first is that is that this has been going on for a long time, the shrinking equity market. has been
21:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
21:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): challenge, frankly, for the UK equity market for for decades now. Two decades, really, at least. Um it's a big problem. And as I've written in the noise cancelling research piece to go with this episode, I highlight why that is a challenge for the UK economy.
21:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Without going into the detail here
21:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): in my opinion, and I think it it's objectively true, that a properly functioning equity capital market
21:48
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): provides
21:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): a properly functioning equity capital market
21:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): serves the needs of its host economy. And if that equity market is dysfunctional, if it shrinks too much, for example,
22:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
22:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): if companies can't raise capital on the market, either in secondaries or IPO, if if the the market is shrinking too far, it starts to to become unable to serve the needs of its host economy. And that is not a good outcome. That's a terrible outcome,
22:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): frankly.
22:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): for an economy like the UK. So my view is that this is an urgent problem. This is not something that governments should sort of think about when they've run out of other ideas. This is this should be right at the top of their agenda of things that need to be structural things that need to be addressed in the
22:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): UK. And so for me, it's a critically important problem.
22:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): For
22:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): government, it doesn't appear to register, frankly. So they don't really take it that seriously. But in the background, I think it's a serious challenge for the UK economy in the future,
23:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
23:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it carries on. And I don't see how it won't carry on unless something is done to solve or to change things. the course that the market is sort of embarked on. So
23:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
23:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you accept that part of the argument, then then the next
23:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): piece becomes more logical. And my view is that governments should mandate pension funds that receive and have received huge
23:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): UK taxpayer benefits in the form of tax reliefs for years. All those pension funds, frankly, have an obligation, in my view, to support this key piece of the UK's economic infrastructure. So I would mandate
24:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): all UK pension funds that receive.
24:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): UK taxpayer funded benefits in the form of tax relief. I would mandate them to hold, for example, you could come up with all sorts of different answers, but I would mandate that they have to own at least as much in the UK as they own in UK equities, at least as much in UK equities as they own in international
24:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): equities. That would seem fair to me.
24:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It wouldn't, I think, have any sort of dramatic effect on the actuarial assumptions about what sort of long-term returns they'd be able to make for their for their beneficiaries. But I think it would have a massive impact, a massive beneficial impact on the UK equity market.
24:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): If those massive funds
24:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just
24:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): started to allocate a bit more or change their allocation and started to increase their allocation to the UK equity market rather than keep eroding it, then all sorts of sort of benign things start to happen, all sorts of positive things start to happen. Companies might think, well, there's a new population of
25:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): buyers coming to the market. I can raise more capital. I can I can IPO my business. The market's valuations might start to increase. International buyers who can who might see, for example, domestic institutions buying the UK market might think, well, I need to get in there ahead of that wave of new buying that's going
25:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): to come. More UK companies might end up staying in the UK rather than being bought by US companies.
25:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Really exciting tech companies, and and I again I've written about a few of them in in the um in the noise cancelling research piece. You know, really interesting tech companies might think at last, well, actually I could IPO in the UK and I don't have to go to the Nasdaq. So there are
26:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): all sorts of benefits that would flow
26:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): from, I think,
26:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): mandating UK pension funds to change their asset allocation so that they have, as I've said, at least as much in UK equities as they have in international equities. But I think it it it isn't going to be something that will happen voluntarily. I think these pension funds need to be mandated by the government to do that.
26:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
26:25
John Adair: Neil, let me just put the scene Savers case to you because if you're a member of one of these pension schemes, over the last 10 years, UK shares returned about 5% a year. Global shares returned about 10%. So you'd be forcing people's pensions into the market that's performed half as well.
26:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Wouldn't that be yeah, I I I I sort of accept that, but I'm I'm I'm the sort of fund manager who likes to buy low and sell high. It's a objectively true
26:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
26:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): the UK equity market is about the lowest valued developed
26:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): equity market anywhere in the
27:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): world.
27:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Its valuation is depressed relative to other markets, other peer markets, and to its history. And it's very depressed relative to the returns that UK companies earn. on average. When you look at the returns on equity, the return on capital employed of different indices in the
27:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): UK and compare those with the returns, for example, in European
27:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): economies or even in the US, the return on capital return on equity is very similar. What, in other words, what you know you're doing when you're buying eco equities is buying a cheap app. asset.
27:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Frankly, pension funds should be should be running towards that opportunity, not running away from it.
27:47
John Adair: The scale of this as well needs looking at because on the estimates in the research piece, your rule means somewhere between £270 billion and 510 billion pounds of buying activity into a market where about two £2 billion pounds of new companies float in a single year.
28:03
John Adair: Who is going to be selling to them and at what price?
28:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, I think there's an opportunity to buy secondary and there's an opportunity to buy primary. If pension funds
28:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): were net buyers of the UK equity market, it would change the dynamic. Instead of this sort of three to one ratio, which we had last year, for example, over three to one, where buybacks were three times as big as the IPOs, you might have an uh an environment where the IPOs were three times the the the share buybacks. Companies will
28:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): look at the dynamics of the UK equity market and think right now they'll think, well, there's no point in the IP. There are no buyers of my stock. Even if I'm able to get an IPO away, who are gonna going to be the investors that are gonna? going to buy my stock, you know, in the future? And when I need to come
28:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): back to the market to raise a bit more capital to fund the next uh chapter of my growth, will those investors be there for me? Will they will they fund my CapEx? Or will they fund my growth story? And the answer to that right now is no, they won't be there. You c can no business, no company.
29:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): in that situation would
29:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do
29:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): that analysis and come up with the conclusion that they should IPO in the UK. And that's why we have no IPOs. I think that really matters for the UK economy, actually. It really matters for the UK science and technology sector. It really matters for our international competitiveness as an economy. If
29:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
29:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): a in a sort of parallel universe, we we were confronting a situation where we knew over a period of time UK pension funds were going to double their allocation to the UK equity market, that would change all of that analysis. That would change that dynamic completely. And as I've said I think the result would be many more IPOs.
29:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And that would be a good thing. Aaron
29:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell Well
29:59
John Adair: there are only three places in the world which make pension funds hold domestic shares, China, Hong Kong, and India. Australia gets its funds to hold forty-five percent of their shares at home with a tax credit on dividends, which is what Britain abolished in nineteen ninety-seven. Why is your argument, Neil, to force it when you could instead reward it?
30:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Tax credit would involve the government. I mean, i it's it's a mechanism for sure. But of course it's it's it's a a mechanism that would affect that is in effect a tax cut. And uh this government is not interested in cutting taxes. Um this government is incre is it is only
30:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): interested in increasing taxes. So I d I just don't think that is a an option, you know, a realistic option um for the UK right now. The two things that I think the
30:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): first of all, mandation doesn't cost the government anything. Okay? It just involves what I think would be a relatively brave political decision. But I think there will be huge economic benefits that would flow from it. Okay, so other people don't mandate, but other
31:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): other economies around the world don't have our challenge. The only solution that I can see is where we mandate something that I think is perfectly reasonable and balanced. Why wouldn't you mandate when when the UK taxpayer is is every year giving
31:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): tens of billions of tax relief to these funds? Um they owe it to the UK economy to invest. in it. And that's what they should be doing. Aaron
31:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
31:42
John Adair: If you've just come straight to this chapter, this is what it means if you own UK shares, whether any of this ever happens or not.
31:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now the
31:49
John Adair: FSE 100 trades on 14.9 times its earnings. The SP 500 is on 26, and that gap has been there since 2016. twenty sixteen. But the UK isn't as cheap as it was. Three years ago it was on about 10 times.
32:03
John Adair: Neil, in December last year, you said UK shares would return in the mid teens this year and beat America.
32:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): To
32:10
John Adair: the end of October, the UK is up eleven point one percent and the US is up twelve percent.
32:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do
32:15
John Adair: you stand by that call?
32:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, and and what I didn't know at the time, of course, is is that uh the war in Iran would kick off. Um so it's done remarkably well against that backdrop. And let's not forget, of course, that the UK, as described by all sorts of um
32:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): highly regarded economic bodies, is uniquely vulnerable to an energy price crisis. So um even against that backdrop, the UK equity market has done pretty well. Last year, uh I think it outperforms uh um the SP 500. five hundred and I think it outperforms from memory um
32:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): the European index too. So, you know, the UK is performing well as an index,
33:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
33:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I believe will continue to do so. Uh uh, particularly in my world where the economy performs much better than consensus believes, and where inflation doesn't Don't go anywhere near as high as as the more recent lunatic forecasts. You know, today we've seen yet another sort of, I think, positive that backs up what I've been arguing all year,
33:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): which is that the Equ economy is growing and will grow more uh faster than the consensus beliefs. Q3 growth 0.7%, the fastest since uh 2021, the fastest quarter growth since 2021. So look, the economy's economy is doing much better despite all of the challenges that we've had to
33:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): confront this year in terms of elevated energy prices and higher interest rates, higher taxes, of course, which have which have come through this year as well. The fact is, the economy is much, much more resilient than either the Bank of England, the OBR, or consensus economics beliefs. believes. And in
34:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): an environment where the economy carries on doing that, and I believe it will, of course, that is a supportive backdrop for what I would argue is is the the appeal of the UK equity market.
34:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
34:12
John Adair: Neil, let's take your fix off the table and put it to one side. Let's assume no chancellor ever acts. The pension funds never come back. Does the case for owning UK shares still stand?
34:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Absolutely. It it it it it is clearly an attractive equity market. The economy is performing better than people thought, much better, frankly. I mean, it the the gap between how it's doing and it the and consensus expectations I I is has rarely been
34:42
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): wider in my experience. The economy is doing well, the valuation of the equity market is is objectively way below. its peer group, low relative to its history. The return on equity, return on capital in the UK is very attractive and compares very favorably with that in peer
35:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): economies, and certainly favorably with the US.
35:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It is a fundamentally cheap index. And And and that's, I think, clearly reflected in the tens of billions, in fact, over 100 billion of share buybacks and bids that we've seen this year alone in the UK. Now that's going to continue, in my view. As long as the
35:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): market stays as cheaply valued as it is, you're going to continue to see companies share buy back their shares, retire higher equity. They're going gonna to you're going gonna to see uh international buyers come in and and continue to. to to buy UK businesses wholesale um and and of course dividends are gonna grow carry on
35:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): growing um uh uh uh as well too and the yield in the UKPT market is of course above that and it's peer economies too. So look there are many many attractions to UKPT market even without uh the mandation that I've I talked about on this episode. If that came along,
36:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think it would be a uh you know a very, very favorable outcome for the economy, a very good outcome for the economy. But but the uh the the market retains its attractions uh even without that.
36:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
36:19
John Adair: we've talked about the research piece
36:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
36:21
John Adair: you've written that covers what we've talked about today. Where can people read that full argument?
36:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, they can.
36:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): see that on noise cancelling.co. Uh it'll be published, I think, um in the next day or two. And I think it's a good read. I I mean I would say that I wrote it, but but uh I I think it covers this in some detail. There's some really interesting charts in there.
36:42
John Adair: So who is the buyer? In the UK Okay, right now, it's the companies and the bidders. Neil wants the pension funds back and he'd actually make them come back. But until somebody does, a shrinking market pays you when you're bought out or when shares are retired cheaply, and it pays you nothing when a company simply leaves. Neil's Full Piece, with all the charts, is in the Noise
37:02
John Adair: Cancelling app. It's free to join on iPhone and on Android, and it will read Neil's pieces to you. Neil Earl and I will be back with more next week. Until then, take care.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Noise Cancelling with Neil Woodford

All insights