Shane Oliver on David Jones decline, Fed rate hikes, and Anthropic IPO risks
Summary
Shane Oliver and Marius Mariton discuss the structural decline of Australian department stores like David Jones, attributing it to online competition and high rents rather than cyclical factors. Oliver argues that while AI will eventually displace workers, the immediate economic risk stems from a broader slowdown in consumer and business confidence. He warns that hotter-than-expected US inflation data likely ensures a Federal Reserve rate hike in December, contradicting hopes for a pause. Oliver also expresses caution regarding Anthropic's upcoming IPO, citing significant operating losses and a lack of network effects compared to social media platforms. Finally, he highlights the unsustainability of China's $1 trillion trade surplus and its potential to escalate global trade tensions.
Key takeaways
- 1 Department store sales in Australia have halved as a share of total spending over the last forty years, indicating a structural shift rather than a cyclical downturn for the David Jones business model.
Shane Oliver · 3:45
- 2 Well typically in a typical week typical month we create about uh fifteen thousand new jobs in Australia, so in the great scheme of things it's not that big. Um that may well be the case that in recent years, you know, we've still had a reasonably solid jobs market. I guess the counter argument is that A you know, these are people
Shane Oliver · 6:07
Episode sections
- 0:44 – 4:55
David Jones Voluntary Administration and Department Store Decline
Marius Mariton introduces the topic of David Jones entering voluntary administration, noting its long history since 1838. Shane Oliver describes the decline as part of a long-term trend driven by online competition, high rents, and changing consumer habits, noting that department stores' share of total retail spending has halved over forty years.
- 4:55 – 7:41
Job Cuts at Canva and Qantas; AI vs Economic Slowdown
Mariton highlights redundancy rounds at Canva (22% of workforce) and Qantas (850 jobs outsourced to Accenture). Oliver argues that while AI will eventually displace workers, the immediate concern is a broader economic slowdown evidenced by weak consumer and business confidence data, which suggests further job losses or slower job creation.
- 7:41 – 13:16
Creative Destruction and Historical Context
The speakers discuss Schumpeter's concept of creative destruction. Oliver uses the agricultural sector's shift from labor to machinery as an analogy, arguing that while jobs are destroyed in specific sectors, workers are freed up to create value elsewhere, leading to new jobs in other areas of the economy.
- 13:16 – 16:46
Oil Prices and Geopolitical Risks
Oliver warns against assuming oil prices will stay low, citing risks of renewed volatility if tensions with Iran escalate under a potentially mercurial President Trump. He notes that despite shocks like tariffs and oil price swings, the US economy remains resilient due to strong corporate earnings.
- 16:46 – 19:31
US Inflation and Federal Reserve Rate Hikes
Mariton reports hotter-than-expected US CPI data for October. Oliver states this likely locks in a Fed rate hike in December and potentially more in early next year, as core PCE inflation is expected to rise back toward 3.3%, contradicting hopes for a pause in tightening.
- 19:31 – 24:56
Anthropic IPO and Valuation Concerns
The discussion turns to Anthropic's anticipated Nasdaq IPO under ticker ANT. Oliver expresses caution, noting that IPO enthusiasm often fades post-listing, citing SpaceX's post-IPO price decline. He highlights Anthropic's significant operating losses and the lack of network effects in AI compared to social media, suggesting a highly competitive market.
- 24:56 – 31:50
China's Trade Surplus and Global Tensions
Mariton notes China's trade surplus has topped $1 trillion. Oliver argues this is unsustainable and risks increasing trade tensions with the US and Europe. He emphasizes that China needs to rebalance toward consumer spending rather than relying on exports, especially given weak domestic retail sales growth.
- 31:50 – 32:28
Closing Remarks and Disclaimer
Marius Mariton thanks Shane Oliver and wraps up the interview, noting it is early for Christmas discussions. The segment concludes with standard podcast disclaimers regarding general information and potential commercial relationships.
Claims worth verifying
David Jones entered voluntary administration.
Marius Mariton ·0:44
How to verify: Company announcements or news reports from November 2026 regarding David Jones' financial status. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
David Jones was established in 1838.
Marius Mariton ·1:49
How to verify: Company historical records or corporate website of David Jones. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Department store sales in Australia have halved as a share of total spending over the last forty years.
Shane Oliver ·3:45
How to verify: Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) retail trade data comparing current shares to 2026-2026 averages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Canva cut 22% of its workforce.
Marius Mariton ·4:55
How to verify: Canva internal communications or press releases from October/November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Qantas outsourced 850 jobs to Accenture.
Marius Mariton ·5:15
How to verify: Qantas press releases or Accenture partnership announcements from November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
US equity valuations are approximately 19 times forward earnings.
Shane Oliver ·15:55
How to verify: S&P 500 valuation data from financial data providers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
US October CPI headline inflation was 0.4% month-over-month.
Marius Mariton ·17:03
How to verify: US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Consumer Price Index report for October 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
US October core CPI was 0.3% month-over-month.
Marius Mariton ·17:03
How to verify: US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Consumer Price Index report for October 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
China's trade surplus topped $1 trillion.
Marius Mariton ·24:56
How to verify: China Customs Administration trade data for the year-to-date through October 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Speaker received David Jones vouchers and found it harder to use them after the company's voluntary administration.
Shane Oliver ·31:15
How to verify: Check David Jones voluntary administration announcements and news reports from late 2026/early 2026 regarding voucher redemption policies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify David Jones' voluntary administration status and financial health via ASIC or company announcements.
- Check recent Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) data for consumer and business confidence trends.
- Review US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) CPI and PCE inflation reports for October and December forecasts.
- Examine Anthropic's S-1 filing for detailed financials, operating losses, and risk factors before investing.
- Analyze China's National Bureau of Statistics data on retail sales and trade surplus sustainability.
- Compare Anthropic's valuation metrics against peers like OpenAI or Google DeepMind using public filings or market data.
- Assess Federal Reserve meeting minutes and speeches for signals on future interest rate paths.
- Review historical unemployment data post-internet adoption to contextualize current job market shifts.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to Relative Return Insider, where a couple of journos and one super sharp guest
- 0:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): take you on a deep dive into the juiciest headlines,
- 0:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): bold opinions, and hot takes from the wealth management world. We're
- 0:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): breaking
- 0:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): down what's happening, why it matters, and maybe cracking a few jokes along the way.
- 0:24
- Marius Mariton: Well, welcome back to the podcast. Relative Return Insider. I'm your host, Marius Maritan. Well, Corporate Australia has been under a bit of pressure in the past week. Think about David Jones or Qantas cutting jobs. In this podcast, we will also talk about the anthropic IPO, oil prices, US inflation, and some
- 0:44
- Marius Mariton: trade data uh from China. Now when I mean we, I mean most importantly, our valued guest, guests, um Shane Oliver. the chief economist at AMP. How's your week going, Shane?
- 0:55
- Shane Oliver: Uh so far so good Marius. I mean I've had some internet issues. I was happy to get a fiber upgrade on uh Tuesday. You know, I've had traditional N N B N up till now. On Q almost it's slowed down. My N B NBN N has slowed down, but uh on uh Tuesday I was gonna get uh fiber installed which would radically
- 1:15
- Shane Oliver: increase my uh speed. But uh unfortunately there was an issue with the poles, yeah, demarcation dispute between Oscared polls and Tilstra poles. So it's been slowed down, so I've got to wait a bit longer to get faster NBN. But apart from that, it's been good.
- 1:29
- Marius Mariton: All good. Well, we're glad to hear you today. Um we'll talk about tech actually, but uh before let's talk about what's been happening this week with David Jones. Well, listen, I'm not a regular customer at David Jones, but the few times I walked um into a store, uh I I actually noticed that the sign next to
- 1:49
- Marius Mariton: it says, Well, David Jones established in 1838. So that's pretty rare to have a business standing for 188 hundred and eighty-eight years, like anywhere in the world and also in Australia. Now it has entered uh um voluntary administration. Will you will you miss David Jones?
- 2:08
- Shane Oliver: Uh yeah, I mean David Jones has been iconic. Uh down the road from me or half an hour down the road there's a big shopping mall and David Jones store there was built I think in nineteen sixty two and uh sort of dominated. I mean since then there's been a lot of buildings built around it, but it sort of dominated in that mall. and um most shopping
- 2:28
- Shane Oliver: malls you go into Australia, the really big ones, you know, there'd be a David Jones at one end and a Coles or a Meyer sorry, not a Col a Grace Brothers or a Meyer, now they're all Meyer at the other end. So yes, I'll miss it. Uh that David Jones will close down. Um I mean I'm not a big shopper to be honest with you, but uh I often like I do like the
- 2:48
- Shane Oliver: concept of going to one place having everything rather than having to go from one place to another. So in that sense I I don't mind the department store context uh concept. Um but by the same token, uh department stores have been under a lot of pressure, not just in Australia, but globally. Uh it's been an ongoing issue with with
- 3:08
- Shane Oliver: closures of well known department stores or less often. of them. Uh they've had to compete with uh uh the lower end more discounting stores uh online.
- 3:19
- Shane Oliver: Yeah, maybe Dover Jones took a while to get its online offering up and going. Um
- 3:25
- Shane Oliver: uh high rents, you know, particularly those city um uh spaces that they had. Uh and uh the the rise of specialist um retailers as well is has also sort of been a bit of an issue for them. But it's it's been ongoing. You know, when I look at the stats in Australia, retail sales
- 3:45
- Shane Oliver: stats, um, department store sales have fallen a little based about halved as a share of total spending uh compared to where they were forty years ago. Um and so you could you could it's it's not a news New story that David Jones is struggling. It's been sort of struggling periodically on and off for years now. So in that sense it's not new, but it still comes as a
- 4:05
- Shane Oliver: shock when it actually happens, particularly at a time when when retailing generally is struggling because of the impact of higher interest rates uh and higher fuel prices. And then you've got the added issue of what, six thousand people working at David Jones, half the stores closed, they go from thirty-eight eight to nineteen. That's obviously gonna lead to a big loss
- 4:25
- Shane Oliver: of staff for them, which uh and you really feel for those people coming into into Christmas. Yeah. Um that added uncertainty at a time when the jobs market is already cooling.
- 4:35
- Marius Mariton: Yeah, no, well to departments are under pressure and I guess the business model is is changing a little bit, as you say, in Australia and beyond. Um in in general, like beyond that actually, we've seen um you you mentioned jobs. we've seen redundancy rounds uh at Canva, I think that was two weeks ago,
- 4:55
- Marius Mariton: around twenty percent, twenty-two percent of the workforce. This week it was Contas uh outsourcing eight hundred and fifty jobs to Accenture. Um so that's jobs in marketing, jobs in finance procurement, uh some of them being moved to India. So no industry actually seems to be safe.
- 5:15
- Marius Mariton: What are the companies more likely to see those redundancy like tech redundancy like who's next?
- 5:23
- Shane Oliver: That's a good question. Who's next? Because uh I think this will just continue. It's every so often we seem to go through a round of them. I don't know why they come in bunches, but a few years ago there was a bunch of them, uh including some of the banks and of course uh the conservative the concern is obviously that well, maybe this is uh the start of the impact of AI.
- 5:44
- Shane Oliver: Um quite possibly.
- 5:48
- Shane Oliver: Yeah, WiseTech uh and others. I I think Atlassian uh had some, was it last year? So every so often we go through this. I guess on the one hand, as an economist, um I mean it's just numbers in a way. Economists like to deal in numbers. Um you could say, well, you know, a few hundred there, a thousand there.
- 6:07
- Shane Oliver: Well typically in a typical week typical month we create about uh fifteen thousand new jobs in Australia, so in the great scheme of things it's not that big. Um that may well be the case that in recent years, you know, we've still had a reasonably solid jobs market. I guess the counter argument is that A you know, these are people
- 6:27
- Shane Oliver: losing their jobs and and many people will will struggle, so you've got to there's a human cost to this. And B, um now the jobs market is slowing more generally. And so that means is probably more of a worry. On on the one hand, you know, the numbers that you sort of rattled off there is relatively low in the i it relative to that
- 6:47
- Shane Oliver: fifteen 15,000 thousand or so jobs a month that we normally see. Um
- 6:52
- Shane Oliver: But you know, if it continues to rise, then it becomes more of a concern. Um at this stage, I don't think you can put it all down to AI. I I think occasionally we do, but uh longer term that will be an issue. AI will be an issue. Um this stage I think most companies are still trying to get to grips with how best to use AI. Um but there is a
- 7:12
- Shane Oliver: longer-term longer term issue there. But the the shorter term issue is really just the slowdown in the economy. This week we did get some weaker numbers for uh uh consumer competence, business comp confidence, business conditions, orders were down sharply for businesses. Uh that's probably telling us the economy is cooling down fairly rapidly. Uh and and that
- 7:31
- Shane Oliver: unfortunately tells us there's probably going to be more job losses going forward, or at the very least, uh the rate of crash creation of new jobs. will slow down uh quite sharply.
- 7:41
- Marius Mariton: Do you take a similar approach to uh like an um like an old economist like Schumpet uh who was saying, well, some of jobs would be destroyed in tech, or he wasn't obviously mentioning tech specifically or definitely not AI, but
- 7:56
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): some
- 7:56
- Marius Mariton: job would be destroyed in a sector and then created in another one. So it would kind of even out and like could be beneficial in a way. Uh obviously, as we mentioned, like quantas, like some of job those jobs are
- 8:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): actually
- 8:08
- Marius Mariton: outsourced.
- 8:10
- Shane Oliver: Yeah. Well that's the concept of creative destruction.
- 8:13
- Marius Mariton: Yeah, creative destruction.
- 8:14
- Shane Oliver: Uh and it uh
- 8:17
- Shane Oliver: it's true, that's how capitalism works, that's how a capitalist economy works. I mean you can sort of stagnate and and say, you know, mandate that we we all o we forever have a David Jones.
- 8:27
- Shane Oliver: or whatever. Um but that doesn't work too well. You end up with just a mil misallocation of resources in the economy. And it is true that i if I think back, um if you take agriculture, go back a hundred years ago, there was something like twenty-five Twenty five to thirty-five thirty five percent, depending on whose stats you
- 8:47
- Shane Oliver: look at, of the workforce in Australia was employed in agriculture. Now it's uh about I think it's less than one percent. It's very low. Um but we seem to have an abundance of food, so much so that we export a big chunk of it.
- 9:00
- Marius Mariton: Yeah.
- 9:01
- Shane Oliver: Uh so we're producing a lot with less. Uh and so a lot of machines came along, um, like Combine Combined Harvester, for example, which collapsed the time to harvest a crop of wheat or whatever.
- 9:16
- Shane Oliver: dramatically and reduced the number of workers required to do that. So on the one hand, that created a lot of unemployment as the uh agricultural industry shifted from basically heavy dependence on labor to heavy dependence on machines. Um but those people then got jobs elsewhere.
- 9:34
- Marius Mariton: Yeah.
- 9:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
- 9:35
- Shane Oliver: know, it's not as if unemployment
- 9:38
- Shane Oliver: higher because uh agriculture's not employing as many people anymore. People just went to other areas of the economy. And so that's why you don't want to get too negative on all of this, and that's the creative destruction. Yeah.
- 9:49
- Marius Mariton: That
- 9:50
- Shane Oliver: Schumpeter referred to. As those machines came along, it freed up workers. Those machines didn't actually create new jobs. Well they created some new jobs, mechanics and what have you to maintain the machines. Um But the bulk of the jobs were uh came about because people were freed up to do other things uh and that led to new jobs. So
- 10:09
- Shane Oliver: yes, there's gonna be job loss in relation to AI. It's gonna displace workers. Um and and some of them will be in retail.
- 10:21
- Shane Oliver: If you uh think about it, we've had online now what, twenty
- 10:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well,
- 10:25
- Shane Oliver: the internet was was uh introduced more than thirty years ago, believe it or not. Um so it's kinda old. Um
- 10:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
- 10:33
- Shane Oliver: films like you've got email with Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan, I think, in the second half of the nineties, but uh AOL was a big one, America Online. But um that was a long time ago now, uh but unemployment in Australia is I think r I think it's lower than it is back was back then. Similar story in the US. So other jobs were created
- 10:54
- Shane Oliver: by that. Um
- 10:56
- Shane Oliver: but website designer wasn't really a thing back then. It's the same anyway, you had online comes along, and that's disrupted a lot of retailing. A lot of people don't go into shopping centres anymore except to their local cafe, and they might drop into a shop next next next door on the way back to the car or something. But the older old idea of, you know,
- 11:16
- Shane Oliver: going off to a big store to buy all your clothes and whatever it is, that's sort of changed dramatically. A lot of people do it online. Now AI probably accentuates that because you can go on online and say, search for me the the the best value flat T V screen for sale in Australia for delivery in Australia and and find it. Yeah. Um that that sort of thing changes it again,
- 11:36
- Shane Oliver: takes it to a new higher level. So there is gonna be going to an impact there. But history tells us that other jobs will be created. Yes, some will go, but others will come along. And I think it's the same with retailing. There's a store in Sydney which I thought was just a vacant building now. Mark Foyes used to be a well known retailer many decades ago, closed down many, many years ago,
- 11:56
- Shane Oliver: Mark Foyes. Okay. And someone told me it's the Downing Centre Center courts now. So it's but it's the old Mark Foys Voice building. So we've always been changing in retail. I think it's just the nature of the way people do things. Um service delivery is radically different. You can make an argument that used to go into your David Jones and all these people would come up to you
- 12:16
- Shane Oliver: and they are experts on whatever they were doing and that was great and they would help you get your new suit or dress or whatever. Um that's changed now. People didn't want to pay for that sort of service. And
- 12:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
- 12:27
- Shane Oliver: a lot of that service is gone, a lot of it's self service. You know, you find your own thing, sort of thing. Much like when you buy your your fuel, fill up your car. Well, a lot of people won't do that anymore anyway, because they'll have EVs, they'll plug it in at their home. But um you used to go in, like if I think back to when I first started to drive, a lot of the service stations still had have service there.
- 12:47
- Shane Oliver: And that would be embedded in the cost of the fuel. You pay for it. These days people don't want that, they're happy with the self serve. Um so that's something that's long gone. Number of service stations. I in the suburb I grew up in, I reckon there used to be six uh service stations, petrol stations, including total. French
- 13:07
- Shane Oliver: company total was in my suburb. But Now there's one.
- 13:12
- Shane Oliver: One.
- 13:13
- Marius Mariton: Things things are changing. Well speaking of
- 13:16
- Marius Mariton: spe speaking of oil, you um so that's interesting commodity. So we've seen prices falling after the US midterms. Uh do you think this is just uh like a short-term respite?
- 13:30
- Shane Oliver: It could be. I think there's uh I yeah, don't want to get too excited.
- 13:34
- Marius Mariton: Yeah.
- 13:35
- Shane Oliver: Um not that I care anymore because I bought an EV, but um No
- 13:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): need to
- 13:39
- Shane Oliver: brain.
- 13:42
- Shane Oliver: Um
- 13:44
- Shane Oliver: but there's a risk still there. I mean, on the one hand, Trump
- 13:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 13:49
- Shane Oliver: seems to be saying it's highly unlikely that he'll order another round of significant attacks on Iran. Uh the US uh people have said, well, we don't want this war. You know, we didn't want it in the first place, we definitely don't want it now. Republicans themselves. are coming out and saying this wasn't so good. You know, one of them's even announced uh impeachment proceedings in the
- 14:09
- Shane Oliver: House against the War Department Secretary Pete Hexert. So this big back will actually catch it. But Trump is a Mercurial sort of character, and he could easily say, Well, the whole election was a fraud, you know. Who believed the results anyway? Was one of his latest tweets. Um, how could the polls be so wrong? You know, Yeah, which is a bit of a joke because earlier he was criticizing the polls because they
- 14:29
- Shane Oliver: were saying big Democrat wins anyway. The polls were actually right. Um but he might go down the path and say, Oh, well, I don't believe it anymore, and then uh I've got to finish the war off. You know, we we can't let it let Iran get away with this, and then it gets wrapped up again. So there is a chance that could happen, but I think ultimately we've probably send seen peak Pete Trump
- 14:49
- Shane Oliver: uh be peak. gets It's of course. still caused a lot of volatility over the next few years. So that's why I don't want to I don't want to bet too much on oil just going straight down from here. I think there'll be a few bumps along the way. I'm hopeful we've seen the worst, but um I know with Trump, you know, things take uh lots of twists and turns. Um the the interesting thing I think despite the last two years we've
- 15:09
- Shane Oliver: seen so many shocks coming out of the US. Uh tariffs and oil one of them. And yet US economy is still growing. Uh yes, the Fed is having to raise interest rates again, that's a problem, so that's been the price that's paid for all of these shocks. Um, but share markets are still doing okay. Um,
- 15:29
- Shane Oliver: touch would uh continue to do so, but but it but it's obviously risks are there, but markets are have sort of find
- 15:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
- 15:35
- Shane Oliver: way to look through it, and I think that's larger because earnings have been so strong. And at the same time, this is an interesting one. Uh people say, oh, we've got record PEs in the US. Uh well, we don't actually. The the record PE was a year or so ago at uh at twenty-four times. Now it's uh about nineteen times Ford earnings
- 15:55
- Shane Oliver: PE because the market's been a little bit skeptical. It's It's very different to the tech burn when earnings were not so good and tech companies' earnings often didn't exist. Um this time around tech earnings are growing forty eight percent, earnings in the rest of the economy are growing about thirteen, fourteen percent. Um uh obviously energy
- 16:15
- Shane Oliver: shooting the lights out as well, but that's a sort of a one off thing. And but the P's actually come down. Very different to uh twenty the year two thousand when the B P was was uh at very high levels. Mm.
- 16:27
- Marius Mariton: Yeah, so that's an interesting sign for markets. If we wanna go back into macro um and talk a little bit inflation i in the USA. So um October's CPI report will came in a little bit hot hotter than expected with both uh headline and core inflation actually. So the headline figure is
- 16:46
- Marius Mariton: up zero 0.4% point four percent over October. Uh that's actually beyond energy. We talked a little bit about oil, so that's beyond energy, and it goes into a wider range of goods and services. Core inflation, excluding food and energy, was up 0.3%.
- 17:03
- Marius Mariton: So what do you make of
- 17:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that,
- 17:05
- Marius Mariton: especially for the Fed?
- 17:08
- Shane Oliver: Well, I think it locks in another rate hike uh in February. In fact, one Fed governor previously adopt a Dart governor Waller, who was actually appointed by Trump uh back in his first term. Governor Waller has come out and said well we may have to raise by fifty basis points if the CPI, uh the underlying CPI comes in around point three.
- 17:28
- Shane Oliver: Now the funny thing is it came in around point three. He was speaking before the numbers came out. Um so that yeah fortunately firstly locked it in. I think when I last looked the money market was saying a hundred and twelve chance of a twenty five percent hike in December. Now obviously a hundred and twelve percent chance that sounds wacko. It's a hundred percent chance of a twenty five percent hike and a twelve percent
- 17:48
- Shane Oliver: hike chance of a uh that it's not just that that it's fifty. Um so that's factored in and I think three hikes are now three more hikes are factored in. So one December and then a couple more early next. year. Um
- 18:05
- Shane Oliver: interestingly the US CPI was not the data wasn't collected in October last year. Yeah,
- 18:10
- Marius Mariton: for
- 18:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the shutdown
- 18:11
- Shane Oliver: BLS shutdown. Yeah, BLS didn't uh provide the annual comparison. But if you do an interpolation then the annual comparison growth rate's around four percent, so that's a the rise for the headline. And the core was about two point eight percent to up from I think it was about two point six or something the previous month. The problem with that is that it translates to a
- 18:31
- Shane Oliver: core PCE. So the PCE is the private final consumption expenditure deflator, the one that the Fed focuses more on. It had fallen back to three point one percent partly due to data revisions or reweighting by the BLS. Um it it's probably now going to rise again to three point three Um, so it's
- 18:51
- Shane Oliver: going the wrong way. Uh yeah, and it almost makes it certain the Fed's gonna hike again in uh in December and possibly uh early next year as as per the money market expectations. So that's a negative. I think markets were sort of able to look through it a little bit, um,
- 19:10
- Shane Oliver: which is good, um, because of the the strong earnings results we're still getting through. And maybe investors think it's you know, it's fine tuning as opposed to uh you know, a a drastic sort of tightening cycle. But it's still a source of uncertainty when you put it together with the other things. Yeah, it could still lead to an
- 19:30
- Shane Oliver: upset at some point.
- 19:31
- Marius Mariton: Okay. But for now, a hike from the Fed in December. Um moving on to uh well going back maybe to US markets and the Anthropic IPO. So I received a little nice uh ping notification from my broker saying um I could join in into the IPO and recommending to read the
- 19:51
- Marius Mariton: prospectus first. So for context, Anthropic is expected to begin public trading on the Nasdaq under the ticker symbol ANT on Thursday, november nineteenth, 19, 2026. Interestingly, um, the special class F share gives the founders 50.1%
- 20:11
- Marius Mariton: of voting power. So that means public shareholders will not have a majority of voting control. Is that reassuring to see this um like fan founder involvement or is that a limit?
- 20:26
- Shane Oliver: That's a good question. I I think it's probably positive.
- 20:29
- Marius Mariton: Uh-huh.
- 20:30
- Shane Oliver: Um another thing to look at is to what degree the founders are locked in. Are they able to sell soon after the the listing or not? Um
- 20:42
- Shane Oliver: I I I'm I'm being economist, I know the stats.
- 20:47
- Shane Oliver: So I'm usually skeptical sceptical of um uh IPOs because
- 20:53
- Shane Oliver: sometimes they work out and sometimes they don't. It's uh it's an interesting one. They they generate a lot of enthusiasm. There's gonna be a lot of noise next week around the anthropic uh listing. Um I'm sure there'll be a significant amount of demand. Um
- 21:09
- Marius Mariton: CBA C BA and
- 21:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Australian Super
- 21:11
- Marius Mariton: say they were among like the pre IPO investors. So if you're exposed to that.
- 21:18
- Shane Oliver: Well and good. So they'll probably do well because they got in early. Whereas post IPO, you often get
- 21:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
- 21:24
- Shane Oliver: enthusiasm, you get the price, and then then it sometimes comes back down again. SpaceX was an example of that. Yeah, lots of enthusiasm and then I don't know where the price is now, Yeah, but um then it had a bit of a rougher, rougher trot. So you've got to be a little bit wary of these things. But
- 21:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 21:39
- Shane Oliver: think it's gotta be a record IPO, isn't it? They're talking about a hundred billion being raised, um more than the
- 21:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): rec
- 21:46
- Shane Oliver: previous record, which was SpaceX.
- 21:48
- Marius Mariton: Yeah. I'm I've I've
- 21:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): been doing
- 21:50
- Marius Mariton: a quick search and the SpaceX share price has been down since the IPO, which I think was in June
- 21:57
- Shane Oliver: Yeah.
- 21:57
- Marius Mariton: this year, like down thirteen point seventeen percent according to Google Finance. since since the IBF.
- 22:05
- Shane Oliver: Yeah, yeah. I thought it I thought it had struggled a bit. So that's why you've got to be careful about these things. I mean there's a lot of hoopla and it creates excitement at barbecues and dinner parties and stuff, and then the track record of them has been mixed. Um so that's why I'm a bit wary of that approach
- 22:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 22:22
- Shane Oliver: investing.
- 22:23
- Marius Mariton: Yeah, that's one thing to consider because if you look at um at um like at the results of the company, you had an operating loss in the first nine month nine months of twenty twenty six for Anthropic. Uh it reported it reported like uh thirty three point two billion in revenue um so for uh the nine months, uh
- 22:43
- Marius Mariton: first nine months of twenty twenty six, but uh oh however as I said, an operating loss of one point twenty seven billion. in US dollar uh over the same period. So yeah, that's also all those figures to consider, right?
- 22:57
- Shane Oliver: Yeah.
- 22:58
- Shane Oliver: I'm out of no doubt eventually it'll it'll come to a profit.
- 23:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 23:02
- Marius Mariton: yeah.
- 23:03
- Shane Oliver: So that's okay, but you know at the moment it's at a loss and it may take longer than projected. The other thing the other thing to be a little bit wary about with AI
- 23:12
- Shane Oliver: is that it doesn't have the kind economies of scale and networking effects that social media does. Like um if you set up Facebook, which was set up what twenty years ago or something like now, now it's something older people use, but younger people used to use it.
- 23:30
- Shane Oliver: Yeah. Um
- 23:33
- Shane Oliver: Uh so I'm I don't d I don't use uh Facebook. Um but anyway, a lot of people go got to on Facebook Facebook 'cause because everyone else was on Facebook. So it so it had a uh it's got this networking effect.
- 23:43
- Shane Oliver: Uh and then and then the cost of running it was fixed and then the additional cost was close to zero when you get a new customer using it. Um so which is economies of scale. Whereas AI is different to that in the sense that you can use Claude and I can use Chat GPT and it has no diff impact
- 24:03
- Shane Oliver: on interactions between us, you know. A and then you can nick off and use some cheaper product from China or if you can. Um it's it's just it just doesn't matter. So it's it's likely to be a highly competitive space going forward, which also makes me a little bit wary about it. Now that's not to say that there won't be huge productivity gains. I mean you or I uh
- 24:22
- Shane Oliver: regularly use it and we can could see the benefit that it has in roles we do. Um and so that's not to say it's not going to have huge gains longer term. Um, but then that benefits the rest of the market more than necessarily the um uh the AI labs, so to speak. So that
- 24:42
- Shane Oliver: that's another reason why I'd be a little bit cautious. But it's anyone's guess where the IPA will go uh on listening listing up or down. I I I don't really know. It's just I I I have a a bit of awariness about IPAs.
- 24:53
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, fair enough. Well, one last thematic
- 24:56
- Marius Mariton: I wanted to uh cover today was trade, specifically China. So China's trade surplus uh has topped one trillion in US dollar. Um so the surplus uh has crossed Of the trillion dollar mark and that was driven by strong exports and a demand for technology and
- 25:15
- Marius Mariton: AI-related goods. So, Shane, what do you think it means for global trade tensions? Like Donald Trump is meeting with um the Chinese president Xi Jinping next week. So he's more limited in Congress, I guess, but that I was I'm sure he's not exactly
- 25:35
- Marius Mariton: happy that uh China's surplus is growing. So what does it mean for global trade tensions and China's economy and obviously Australia's commodity exports?
- 25:45
- Shane Oliver: Well I don't um
- 25:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 25:48
- Shane Oliver: of course we all say oh well it's good if you've got a trade surplus if you're that that country, but um I I don't think that's a good thing. It should be aiming for balance. Um it's it it's the problem Well what
- 26:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do you mean
- 26:01
- Shane Oliver: with well it i means that you're exporting a lot of stuff and you're not importing as much stuff. So that's how you've got a trade surplus.
- 26:08
- Marius Mariton: It's good.
- 26:09
- Shane Oliver: Um yeah that's good in theory,
- 26:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
- 26:12
- Shane Oliver: not so good uh for your consumers.
- 26:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh, yeah it
- 26:15
- Shane Oliver: it tells me that um you're producing a lot of stuff and exporting it, so other countries get the benefit of that stuff. I mean this is this is upside down to the way Trump would look at it, uh uh, 'cause because he has it as a sort of a trade surplus as a or trade deficit is a sort of part of your scorecard. You've got a trade surplus for a winner, if you trade deficit you're a loser. Um but
- 26:35
- Shane Oliver: uh y you know balance is probably a healthier way to be, but it's not never going to get to that because some countries have more advantages in some areas than others and so on. But um I I think what's happening in China is that they've managed to keep their growth going because of very strong growth in exports. Like exports are up something like thirty five percent over
- 26:55
- Shane Oliver: the year to um the latest figure, which is October. Um they slipped a little bit in the month for most regions, but that looks like an aberration. Imports are up a little bit by more. That was mainly because of computer chips and fuel. Um they're up about forty odd forty two percent I think year on year. But the two have been very strong. and
- 27:15
- Shane Oliver: generally speaking, exports have been a bit stronger than imports, consistent with uh China exporting more and importing less, reflective of softer domestic demand in China. But I I think A the problem with that is it adds to trade tensions. We see that with the US, we see that with Europe, um this fear that China's just trying
- 27:35
- Shane Oliver: to uh produce a whole lot of subsidized cheap stuff and then dominate the world. with it. Um, yeah, we sure we get the benefit of the cheap cars, but um, you know, it does potentially wipe out automakers in other parts of the world. Um
- 27:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): some
- 27:49
- Shane Oliver: of that is exaggerated a little bit because the subsidies aren't necessarily as big as many people like to say they are. But the broader issue is that to to produce sustainable growth in China and rising living standards you really need to see more consumer spending. And if we saw more consumer spending in China, stronger retail sales, and I think the numbers which come out next week on Monday,
- 28:09
- Shane Oliver: so we're doing this on Thursday, next Monday, the sixteenth, I think it is. Monday the sixteenth, the Chinese uh activity data for um October will come out and it's probably gonna going to say retail sales growth running around one percent. That's not good. This is a country which has low levels of consumer spending
- 28:30
- Shane Oliver: and probably needs to be rebalanced towards more consumer spending in the long term.
- 28:35
- Shane Oliver: So if it wants to see high living standards for citizen citizens in China, you've you've got to get more uh consumer spending. And at the moment we're not really seeing that. So it's sort of
- 28:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
- 28:46
- Shane Oliver: yeah, it's a trade surplus. Um but but and uh trying China's to
- 28:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do that.
- 28:51
- Shane Oliver: done very well to export staff, a lot of it's good quality stuff. Just think about the electric cars we're benefiting from in Australia, but um longer term it's not sustainable. You can't you can't keep doing this forever. Um at some point uh China will have to see a rebalance towards greater reliance on consumers. Um if it doesn't do that,
- 29:11
- Shane Oliver: then either the Chinese population might get a bit depressed about it all. Or alternatively the rest of the world will say, Well, you know, y y you've got to get your trade imbalance under control or we're gonna put more tariffs on you. And that's where Trump's been coming from and Europe to to some degree as well. So that's why I think ultimately it's unsustainable, particularly when you're
- 29:31
- Shane Oliver: a country that the world's second biggest economy. Um uh it's it becomes more of an issue if you're a little country, smaller country. is not so big an issue, it's not as noticeable that it it is for China.
- 29:42
- Marius Mariton: Got it. Well we'll keep an eye on on that on uh on Monday, the Chinese activity data and next week the Asia Pacific Economic Corporation Summit in uh Shenzhen, China. I know Anthony Albanese will be traveling and he'll meet with well, Chinese President Xi Jinping and US President Donald Trump will be there as well.
- 30:02
- Marius Mariton: And also, speaking of exports, you'll be happy to know that I've started my Christmas shopping and I bought some
- 30:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Australian good that
- 30:09
- Marius Mariton: I'll bring to my um to my French family. Have you started your um your Christmas shopping?
- 30:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Or is
- 30:16
- Marius Mariton: it too soon?
- 30:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh not
- 30:17
- Shane Oliver: yet. No, not
- 30:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): too
- 30:19
- Shane Oliver: a bit later. I mean I yeah, I should do. I mean now's when the sales are on. What is it? Uh Thanksgiving sales.
- 30:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, okay. We don't call Thanksgiving Black Friday sales.
- 30:27
- Shane Oliver: in Australia, which was post-Thanksgiving in the US. But um yeah, yeah. To me it still still seems academic. It still seems fair way off.
- 30:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, it is.
- 30:39
- Shane Oliver: I know it it'll be upon us pretty soon. One thing I used to do was phone up my credit card providers or yeah, convert my points into David Jones cards. And I've been doing this for twenty 20 years. There They used to be David Jones's. Jones vouchers. Yeah, get a David Jones voucher. And then you know $50, whatever. And then you can include it in gifts you give to people. This is classic
- 30:59
- Shane Oliver: economics. Economists argue that the best gift is purchasing power, not necessarily you choosing the gift for the person. You can debunk this ad nausea.
- 31:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Better allocation of
- 31:09
- Marius Mariton: resources.
- 31:09
- Shane Oliver: Better allocation of resources because you know you get a lot of Christmas presents
- 31:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
- 31:13
- Shane Oliver: presents at your birthday and you
- 31:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 31:15
- Shane Oliver: don't really want that thing, you know, it's all hit and miss. Um uh so surely if you've got vouchers that's a better thing. From an economic utility point of view. So I took that to heart and got those David Jones vouchers and now now I can't I can't do that anymore. I'll be
- 31:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): sure
- 31:32
- Shane Oliver: maybe Yeah I can, but uh it'll be harder.
- 31:35
- Marius Mariton: Yeah, I'll be sure to tell that to my friends and family they that wanna give me like uh um Christmas presents. But yeah, for me if I leave it to December, I get just too busy in December. So I have
- 31:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to start in
- 31:46
- Marius Mariton: November, otherwise it's it's lost. And I Yeah,
- 31:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's lost. Yeah,
- 31:49
- Shane Oliver: fair enough.
- 31:50
- Marius Mariton: So anyway,
- 31:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
- 31:51
- Marius Mariton: this on this, I think it's very soon. It's a little bit soon to talk Christmas, but we'll we'll see you before then. Uh Shane Oliver, Chief Economist at AMP. Thank you so much.
- 32:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thanks,
- 32:01
- Shane Oliver: Varius. Marius. Take care.
- 32:02
- Marius Mariton: Thank you. Dear.
- 32:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 32:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): information featured in this podcast is general in nature and does not take into consideration your financial situation or individual needs and
- 32:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): should
- 32:17
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): not be relied upon. Before making any investment, insurance, tax, property, or financial planning decision, you should consult a licensed professional who can advise whether your decision is appropriate for you.
- 32:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 32:24
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Guests appearing on this podcast may have a commercial relationship with the company. companies mentioned.