Jacqueline De Gernier discusses GWI's shift from seat-based to consumption pricing and associated sales challenges
Summary
Jacqueline De Gernier, CRO at GWI, explains the company's transition from seat-based to consumption-based pricing for its Model Context Protocol and API, driven by customer demand for embedded insights. She notes that the product-led growth motion used at Twilio did not transfer to GWI's enterprise customers, who prefer traditional sales processes. De Gernier details the complexities of compensating sales reps for usage-based models, emphasizing that overages cannot count toward quota to ensure proactive usage management. She also highlights the increased risk for vendors in consumption models, requiring Customer Success Managers to prove value continuously to prevent churn. Finally, she describes how GWI funded a Solution Engineering team through internal reorganization and promotions to support customer adoption.
Episode sections
- 0:06 – 7:58
Intro and Quickfire Questions
The host introduces the episode and guest Jacqueline De Gernier, CRO at GWI, highlighting her experience at Twilio and GWI. Jacqueline discusses her hiring philosophy, emphasizing the importance of early hires and learning to trust gut instincts over suppressing them. She also shares her Monday morning routine, which includes checking Slack for deal updates and signing contracts early to support the sales team.
- 7:58 – 16:17
Retrofitting Consumption Pricing
Jacqueline explains GWI's shift from seat-based to consumption-based pricing for its Model Context Protocol (MCP) and API, driven by customer demand for faster, embedded insights. She notes that the PLG-to-SLG motion used at Twilio did not transfer to GWI's enterprise customers, who prefer traditional sales processes due to data governance concerns.
- 16:17 – 20:42
Paying Reps for Usage
Jacqueline details the challenges of compensating sales reps for consumption models, noting that GWI initially kept commissions simple by treating consumption contracts as upfront committed spend. She admits to missing the opportunity to incentivize initial landings and early renewals with accelerators. Crucially, she states that overages cannot count toward quota or commission to ensure reps proactively manage usage and drive renewals.
- 20:42 – 24:30
Customer Success after Signing
The discussion covers the heightened risk for vendors in consumption models, requiring Customer Success Managers (CSMs) to prove value continuously. Jacqueline shares a case where high API usage masked low actual user adoption, leading to churn. She emphasizes that CSMs must go beyond dashboards to understand end-user engagement through QBRs and hackathons. Enterprise reps retain ownership of expansion up to a certain spend threshold.
- 24:30 – 30:09
Funding Solution Engineering
Jacqueline explains how GWI funded a Solution Engineering team and a Forward Deployed Engineer (FDE) without increasing the overall cost base. This was achieved through a reorganization for an agentic roadmap, reallocating budget from eliminated roles, and promoting internally (55% of hires). The FDE role provides free technical support to help customers scale usage, driving further consumption revenue.
- 30:09 – 30:50
Insights Engineers and Deal Desk Implementation
Jacqueline De Gernier suggests that 'insights engineers' could become a new role to help customers derive value from syndicated or custom data. She also advocates for a live deal desk to manage complex consumption deals, prevent misuse of data for model training, and serve as a learning tool for reps.
- 30:50 – 35:43
Lessons Learned and Self-Investment
Reflecting on her transition to GWI, De Gernier advises being more vocal and pushing harder on critical integrations like PLG sign-ups into Salesforce. She also recommends investing in personal development through courses like 'CRO School' to prepare for future leadership roles.
Claims worth verifying
GWI launched its Model Context Protocol (MCP) nearly two years prior to the interview (approx. late 2024/early 2025).
Jacqueline De Gernier ·10:18
How to verify: Check GWI's product launch announcements or press releases from late 2026/early 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
GWI's founder, Tom Smith, previously worked at McCann Erickson.
Jacqueline De Gernier ·9:19
How to verify: Review Tom Smith's LinkedIn profile or GWI's 'About Us' page for founder background. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
GWI's sales team uses Slack channels for deal updates and emoji reactions.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·6:34
How to verify: This is an internal operational detail; verify via GWI's employer branding content or employee testimonials. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
55% of GWI's hires over the last year were internal promotions.
Jacqueline De Gernier ·27:00
How to verify: Verify via GWI's annual diversity/inclusion report or internal communications regarding hiring trends. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Twilio IPO'd with hardly any sales team.
Jacqueline De Gernier ·13:08
How to verify: Check Twilio's S-1 filing or historical analysis of Twilio's sales headcount at the time of its 2026 IPO. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceGWI uses Clay for data and automation.
Jacqueline De Gernier ·27:39
How to verify: Check GWI's tech stack on tools like BuiltWith or job postings requiring Clay experience. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
GWI uses the enterprise version of Claude.
Jacqueline De Gernier ·28:03
How to verify: Check GWI's tech stack or job postings requiring Claude API experience. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jacqueline De Gernier is the CRO at GWI.
Jacqueline De Gernier ·30:09
How to verify: GWI corporate website or LinkedIn profile of Jacqueline De Gernier. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceJacqueline De Gernier previously worked at Twilio.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·30:58
How to verify: LinkedIn profile of Jacqueline De Gernier or Twilio press releases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jacqueline De Gernier previously worked at DocuSign.
Jacqueline De Gernier ·31:29
How to verify: LinkedIn profile of Jacqueline De Gernier or DocuSign press releases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
GWI implemented a live deal desk to manage consumption deals and prevent data misuse for model training.
Jacqueline De Gernier ·33:07
How to verify: GWI press releases or case studies regarding their sales operations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Twilio had thousands of SKUs due to communications APIs sitting on top of carriers.
Jacqueline De Gernier ·32:09
How to verify: Twilio financial filings (10-K) discussing SKU complexity or operational metrics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourcePLG sign-ups did not integrate seamlessly into Salesforce at DocuSign.
Jacqueline De Gernier ·31:29
How to verify: DocuSign earnings calls or operational disclosures regarding PLG integration challenges. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceJacqueline De Gernier took the 'CRO School' with Pavilion.
Jacqueline De Gernier ·34:08
How to verify: Pavilion (Revenue Collective) course catalog or Jacqueline De Gernier's LinkedIn profile. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDo your own research
- Review GWI's latest SEC filings or press releases for details on their pricing model changes and revenue recognition policies.
- Analyze Twilio's historical pricing structure and public statements regarding their PLG-to-SLG motion to compare with GWI's experience.
- Verify the definition and implementation of 'Model Context Protocol' (MCP) and its relevance to data governance in enterprise settings.
- Check for public case studies or customer testimonials regarding churn rates in consumption-based pricing models.
- Research the role of 'Forward Deployed Engineers' (FDEs) in SaaS companies and their impact on customer retention and expansion.
- Investigate the 'CRO School' course mentioned by Jacqueline De Gernier to assess its relevance for leadership development.
- Look for industry reports on the effectiveness of 'deal desks' in managing complex consumption deals and preventing data misuse.
Full transcriptexpand
0:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to Making the Grade, the podcast for founders and go-to-market leaders building and scaling some of the most ambitious B2B tech businesses.
0:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
0:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): season, I'm going to be talking to CROs about what it actually takes to lead a revenue function right now. From navigating more competitive markets, evolving buyer behaviour, behavior, and
0:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how
0:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the CRO role is changing in an AI-driven world. Expect candid conversations, hard-won lessons, and practical advice from leaders who are in the seat right now, grappling with the real work of scaling a business. How do you rebuild your sales playbook when you shift from selling seats to selling consumption? That's the challenge that Jacqueline DeGurnier tackled as CRO at GWI. after leading revenue at Twilio, where consumption was baked in from day one. In this final episode of season three of Making the Grade, Jackie walks through the playbook for moving to consumption-based pricing. From transitioning your team to why your solution engineers become your secret weapon
1:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
1:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): how to rethink compensation. Sensation. Plus, why PLG doesn't always work for enterprise.
1:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think
1:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's the perfect capstone to this season. And I hope you enjoy. Welcome, Jackie, to Making the Grade. It's great to finally have you on. Well,
1:22Jacqueline De Gernier: it's brilliant to be here. I mean, thank you for inviting me.
1:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Really excited to talk to you um today. So we're starting with the quick fire questions. First one is what's the most significant hire that you've ever made? I'm
1:32Jacqueline De Gernier: gonna sit on the fence a little on this one. I think A, every hire is important and significant, but I do think early hires are particularly important. So that might be early hires if you're building a team out, or early hires when you first join an organisation. I think everyone's looking to you, hmm, what type of IC or you know frontline leader is she going to hire? And I think those first hires are very important for that reason as well. So I'll maybe name check a few people if that's all
2:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right. Please They're gonna love to.
2:02Jacqueline De Gernier: So Matthew Gibbons was my first frontline manager hire at DocuSign. He was an internal promotion. I think he'd been part of the very first team that got hired into London, the first team in AMEA. And that was a transition from an account management management role into a new business management role. And so it was quite a big shift for him. Absolutely brilliant. He's gone on to be hugely successful. So He was at Lacework Laceworks. And yeah, great. And then Marina Tosca was my first mid market AE that I hired at Twilio. Phenomenal. And still there and runs enterprise and financial services sales. So yeah, I think I think those early hires are really, really important.
2:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
2:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): completely agree. I remember my first hire at Bright Brightpool Po
2:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was
2:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a guy called Stuart Pick, and uh he was my first AE hire. It was incredible just
2:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
2:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): see him go on to become VP sales and and that's the most rewarding thing,
2:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think,
2:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): as a sales leader
2:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when you hire
2:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): people and you see them grow and and learn. So what's a hiring decision that you would make differently today?
3:02Jacqueline De Gernier: Not so much an individual, but more kind of a thought process, a censorship that maybe I had on myself with some of my early hiring. I really believe in the power of diverse teams, not kind of higher hiring in in the image. of yourself, making sure that you've got people, you know, with different skills, but different backgrounds, et cetera. And I think there were times as we were building out the DocuSign team where someone would be sat in front of me and I just get kind of a gut instinct that perhaps they weren't the right person for the job.
3:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
3:33Jacqueline De Gernier: I would tend to try and suppress that because in my head, that was potentially unconscious bias. And I just wasn't connecting with that person because their personality was different to me. So I tended to suppress it and a couple of times, you know, did make some mishires. You know, great people, you know, they certainly got the right experience, they'd been successful in previous roles, but for whatever reason, did that didn't quite transition and mean success, you know, in our organization. And I've learned over the years that, you know, that. gut instinct is, it's actually, it is based on logic. It's just kind of like hardwired. There's like a neuroscience to it, isn't there? And so I learned to gradually unpack it. Like, what was it that was not kind of quite connecting with that individual? And it might have been that there was language that they used that was perhaps, I don't know, a bit more confrontational than you know, we would normally like. that could suggest a particular attribute, or were they overthinking? Was their communication style not clear? So gradually over the years I've learned that that gut instinct is there for a reason and and actually to listen to
4:39it.
4:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
4:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's so interesting, isn't it? That suppression of bias versus suppression of gut. But I love the fact that you're codifying that gut and thinking, well, what is it actually? Rather than I might have a bias here, you're you're really rationalizing.
4:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, you
4:51Jacqueline De Gernier: have to take a moment and really make sure that it isn't that unconscious bias showing up. Yeah. And
4:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): then what's something you believed about scaling sales that you no longer believe today?
4:58Jacqueline De Gernier: And I think it's the difference between sales and revenue. So I think when you think about sales and selling, it's quite rightly, understandably, all about the opportunities, the deals, the wins, whether that be new business or expansion, about being with the customers, being in front of the customers and kind of building the sales team that's going to be effective, you know, in those sales motions. And so I've certainly worked for revenue leaders in the past that have built incredible businesses and been great in front of customers, don't get me wrong, but have not been so focused on that external kind of market facing, customer facing kind of role that they have. And at the time I sort of questioned that, but I now understand it. You know, you are building a revenue engine, and it is not just about new business and expansion. It's actually about the full revenue lifecycle, right through to managing customer success and the renewal itself, but also building all of the processes and the infrastructure and the enablement and the systems to support that as well. So yeah, that's that's been a big shift, I think, in in my thinking. Yeah.
6:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's so important. And then final quick fire is what's the metric that you check first every Monday morning?
6:11Jacqueline De Gernier: I check all of the normal reports and dashboards that I'm sure others have talked about. I go to Clary, I look at what's changed in our pipeline, and I like to check in on the AI projection, which hopefully hasn't kind of changed too significantly, but I'd keep a close eye on that. It tends to be pretty accurate. But there's two things that I do without fail pretty much as soon as I wake up. And one of them, much to my husband's uh displeasure, but one of them is I check
6:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
6:34Jacqueline De Gernier: deals one channel in Slack. So we have a Slack channel where every deal immediately gets posted with close one notes. I
6:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): love
6:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that there's deals happening overnight while you're speaking
6:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as well. Absolutely. So this is because you've got reps. We've got reps in the US.
6:51Jacqueline De Gernier: we've got Travis on the West Coast, we've got reps in APAC, which I'll come on to in a moment. We have a pretty create we work with a lot of really cool advertising agencies, large brands, and we have pretty cool customers and and the team in turn are very creative. So I've never seen such liberal and creative use of emojis. So there's a lot of emojis that go on those deals.
7:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
7:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a nice way to wake up to a load of emojis in a close one deal.
7:17Jacqueline De Gernier: Absolutely. So I love looking at that and I love kind of adding comments and, you know, uh well deserved QDOS um to those. And then I go to my contract signing folder in email and I always make sure that I cause um I sign before they go to the customer. And I don't want to hold anything up if I can get up and do that first thing at kind of half past six, then they get something out that bit quicker.
7:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
7:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): love that. I love how you're supporting the deals. Even at the lofty CRO stasis, you're in there dishing out emojis and signing signing off contracts. Right, quickfire's done. Um I want to get into the main thing that I wanted to talk to you about today. Because you've seen two sides of the kind of businesses doing consumption based pricing. Um obviously at Twilio, where it was kind of baked into what they did from from the get get-go, go, I think. And then now at GWI where you're kind of retrofitting it whilst they're kind the of plane's still flying, I suppose. And it's that latter experience that I really want to dig into because I know based on the pavilion dinners and revenue leaders that I speak to, a lot of people are making that transition from seat-based to consumption-based, often token-based with AI. And that's not easy sometimes. And there's a lot of challenges that you have to work through. So yeah, I suppose I'd love to start there. So take me back to that moment where you decided. that the way that you had always sold at GWI, which I know is a kind of market research company, when you decided that that wasn't going to serve you in terms of where you needed to go and what was actually happening, I suppose, in
8:38the business at
8:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that time.
8:39Jacqueline De Gernier: Absolutely. Well, I guess taking a step back for a moment, it was more a response to a shift in the market, I think, but also how technology had progressed and developed as well and how we were actually now able to serve our customers in a new way. So what we could see talking to our customers, so traditionally, and and this is just sort of the latest pivot, I guess, for a company like GWI. So our founder, Tom Smith, actually was our customer. You know, he he is a market research analyst and specialist, used to work in McCann Erickson, Ericsson, the big advertising agency. And I think he was working on one of their big travel brands and realized: hang on a minute, there's a product in this. So initially it was a market research, you know, sort of services company, but he always had the platform and the ability to deliver and package those insights via a platform in mind. And so, you know, the last sort of five, six years of sort of focused on selling the platform as a subscription and providing access to the under. the underlying data. But what we could see in the market was that the insights teams that had traditionally sort of packaged up these insights and provided them to the ad sales team, to the marketers, to the leadership team, they were increasingly being asked actually to deliver those insights either with smaller teams or in a
9:58faster, more timely fashion, and increasingly being asked to actually embed those into end-to-end workflows. And so we were really responding to that demand that we could see within our customers. So very fortunate, we were very early to the market with an MCP. So I actually hadn't realized it was its two year birthday, I think, um earlier this week, which had kind of passed me by. So nearly two years to the day that we launched
10:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): our MCP.
10:25Jacqueline De Gernier: Yeah, really early. Absolutely. So we had an API that was used by some of our largest customers, but really, this was the first time that we'd had a product that was capable of being used and therefore kind of valued and priced on a consumption basis. There's two ways to use the MCP. It comes bundled in our seats license. So we have an expert and kind of a non-expert seat license. and you get the ability to connect the MCP to your LLM of choice. So you can use it that way. And we still charge that purely on a subscription basis. But if you're building using the APIs or the MCP, then we price that and charge that on a consumption basis.
11:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Obviously, you had a lot of experience with this model at Twilio, but was there anything that you assumed would carry over from how it worked at Twilio? that you thought would work the same at GWI, which didn't? Yes.
11:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes, there was, there was.
11:20Jacqueline De Gernier: But I think the key thing that didn't transfer that I I really assumed would, and I think others, you know, within GWI had the same assumption was having a PLG to SLG motion. So we had the ability for people to sign up for limited free access to an agent, Agent Spark. And then if they wanted to unlock more sophisticated functions, or if they wanted to scale their usage or scale it across more users, then that would be an entry point to the sales team and you know, a much larger committed spend contract. And that ultimately it didn't pan out that way. That isn't the way that our large enterprise customers and ICP accounts. that we're going after. That isn't how they want to buy from us. In our existing enterprise customers, as
12:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in the PLG, they don't want to do the PLG
12:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): stuff. They don't want to do it. They
12:11Jacqueline De Gernier: just don't want to do it. The insights leaders are very, I mean, they're data scientists, you know, that's their background. And so they're really, you know, quite rightly fiercely protective of how people are using the data and the guardrails that are created. And so they didn't really want to be encouraging other members of their teams to be using Agent Spark without their audiences having been predefined. So that was one issue with our existing customers.
12:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
12:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): hear that so often as well. Revenue is that just think they can slot in a PLG motion ahead of their SLG. And it's like, well, unless that dynamic, that ICP, that buying process is right, it's not going to work out.
12:48Jacqueline De Gernier: Completely. And I think the market had matured as well. I think maybe a few years earlier it might have worked as a new business motion. But I think, you know, IT, CIOs, CTOs, heads of, you know, InfoSec had long since, you know, closed those doors. So that wasn't an entry point for us, but it had been a hugely, I mean, you're right, at Twilio through developer sign ups and free developer accounts. I mean, they IPO'd with like hardly any sales team. It was such a wild success story. Yeah.
13:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's mad. And then when you first put that consumption motion and model in front of your team, what did you find that they struggle to do or maybe couldn't do yet? Because it's quite a shift for a sales team to sell that way.
13:28Jacqueline De Gernier: It is a big shift. And it's one that it's easy to underestimate. I think even having gone through that when I joined Twilio myself, because it was a a a big shift from how we sold at DocuSign and it did take me a while to master. And I was super fortunate. I had some members of the team that had been in Twilio for some time, some really tenured individuals that had moved across from San Francisco to help to build the AMIA business. So I was able to learn from some of the best. And it still took a while to really see, you know, how volume discounts, caps, overages, you know, how and the land and expansion. expand motion in the world of consumption, you know, how all of that fitted together. So I'd been through it myself and I still underestimated. I think the that number one, working with your customer to actually come up with a credible consumption plan based on a real kind of scientific approach of understanding their workflow, understanding the frequency of, you know, the data that needs to be. pulled, who it needs to be pulled by, and using that to extrapolate out a 12-month consumption plan. That's something that we've had to really kind of work with them on. And I think some of our biggest wins so far have been ad sales use cases, where I think it has been probably a little bit easier, A, to be able to do that, but B also to show the ROI that can be
14:48generated ultimately if you're delivering those insights. across, you know, 3,000, 8,000 sellers and giving them the ability to use those in their pitches without having to go to a central team. So that's been the first thing. I think the second thing is that, and it's brilliant once you learn it, that art of using the volume discounts with the usage caps and the overages to trigger early renewals. Overages were seen as evil. evil. People didn't want them in their order for this. I mean, this is, you know, our sellers, not the customers, they didn't want to put them on the order form. There was a sense that the overages needed to be cheaper. Like if they're cheaper, they're not overages, they won't work. And then early renewals has been uh something that we've definitely had to sort of land with the team. So yeah, now now they get it. And I think they can see that when these contracts are constructed in the right way, it's actually a win win. It's great for the customer. They're not overcommitting up front. They're waiting for the proof points before they then do an early renewal and commit to a higher volume to unlock the next discount. But yeah, that's taken some some
15:56time. Yeah.
15:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And compensation is a big thing that people grapple with when they're shifting to to consumption models. And and I I've no doubt that the people that carry the number in your team are kind of trying to get their head around like, how is this going to work for me? Am I going to be losing money here? Do I need to be maximizing that upfront commitment? Tell me how you built that first plan and and maybe any kind of key learnings or things that didn't go well in that first plan.
16:20Jacqueline De Gernier: Definitely some key learnings. I think this is the thing where we've probably got the most wrong, to be honest. And I think it's just the pace that we're changing and adopting. And, you know, uh, you know, some some members of finance are new to consumption as well. So at the moment, to keep it simple, we're selling consumption contracts on upfront committed spend. So we sell them in exactly the same way as we do, you know, our subscription ARR. We don't have split-out split out targets for the different types of ARR, you just have an ARR target. and you draw, you know, you retire against that. So for that reason, we haven't really re-engineered the commission plan and, you know, sort of felt that we didn't need to, but we did. And I think you hit the nail on the head just now. There's a tendency to overcomplicate and get in your own way and want to take down the big deal day one. And I think I think Reps and L seeing it. They're seeing that they can start with a paid trial or a pilot and start quite small, or start with the
17:20full use case and the full set of users, but get the customer to commit to quite a low level of uh volume that they're really comfortable with and then scale from there. But for many of them, there is still this desire, understandably, because it's a it's a habit that's been formed over years, isn't it? There's still a desire to get the big deal day one. And so I think we should have been incentivizing those initial LANs and had accelerators on those. And then early renewals for the account managers or for some of our tiers, the CSM zone, the renewal. I think we should have had an accelerator to also incentivize that as well. So those are definitely a couple of misses
18:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Scalewise helps founders and CROs get the right sales and marketing leadership in place. Whether that's a fractional leader when you need someone fast, or a permanent hire when the brief is clear. My co-founder Gavin and I have both been CROs and VPs of sales, so we understand the function from the inside and we can have the kind of honest conversation about the hire that most recruiters can't. No fluff, no short list. lists padded to look impressive, just the right person, faster. To find out more, visit scalewise.com or feel free to drop me a message on LinkedIn.
18:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
18:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): how do you make it work where I'm assuming the the sales rep commits the or gets the commitment from clients on the consumption? But what if the client ends up doing more? Does the seller own that? uh overage? Do they own, does that count towards their quota and their commission? And over what period of time do they keep it, I suppose?
18:57Jacqueline De Gernier: I'm glad you asked me that. This was something that I had to sort of dig my heels in over. And now I think everyone can see oh, yeah, that makes total sense. Overages cannot go to a rep's quota and they can't earn commission on it. That's what incentivizes them to be tracking the usage on their customer. account as keenly as the customer will be tracking it as well and reaching out to them well ahead of them even approaching overages. You know, if you're six months into an initial 12-month contract and you can see that your customers on track to maybe exceed their volume by month nine, you don't wait till month nine or even month eight. You reach out then and you show them and you walk them through. the data and you explain to them, I can see that you actually qualify for the next volume discount. So if we bring your renewal forward to now, we bring forward that volume discount to now. I'm going to save you X over the next six months. Like that's really compelling. And it's this lovely win win for the customer and for the rep.
19:57But if you pay them on the overages, you take that incentive away. And I found at Twille. Twilio, that was a conversation that you could have with new customers. Like I'm I'm not incentivized to kind of under, you know, we've got to find that sweet spot of volume where you're not overcommitting, but equally you're not undercommitting. And I think um, yeah, being that commercially transparent and open with customers can land really well.
20:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, I love that. And then obviously customer success, I think, plays an important role in consumption business. based pricing and models. Perhaps in some instances, more than sales in a lifetime, depending on how that expansion happens. What is different about those first 90 days of a customer's life? Now they're consumption based, and how and when does the customer success team get involved?
20:45Jacqueline De Gernier: Yeah, this is definitely something that's evolving at the moment and where we're learning. I think you're quite right, the profile, the risk profile with consumption is very different. When a customer's committed to, you know, a subscription, a certain number of seats, you know, there's some risk on them to make sure that those are going to be adopted and used. I think, in fact, Yacko talks about this, doesn't he? Winning by Design. Yeah. And when you move to consumption, particularly if it's full paygo consumption, you know, the risk is pretty much on the vendor to make sure that they're providing. value in perpetuity. So I'm always explaining to because I think some of our customer success managers kind of felt, oh, if it's API and MCP and we're getting embedded into the workflow, what do I then do? And we're kind of concerned about what the CSM role would look like in consumption. And I've been explaining to them actually, this means that we have to constantly be providing that value. because that usage can disappear as quickly as it appears. And so during the first 90 days, we're really tracking. Well, first off, we have deal rooms. So all of the data that's been shared during the first win, that all seamlessly hands over to the customer success team. Um, so they can really see kind of what the success criteria is. the nature of the use case. We're
22:04tracking the activation, we're tracking the time to value, we've got the usage metrics, whether it's API calls or whether it's the MCP queries, we can track that at a token level. But what we have learned is that more than ever, you have to get behind the data. So we had a customer recently that had a very, very high volume of calls. Everyone felt that the usage was really positive, including, I must say, our main point of contact within the organization. They built a beautiful set of dashboards and they built them in a way where they were constantly refreshing and drawing data. So the hence why the call volumes were so high. Nobody was using them. No one in the business ultimately was using them. And so when it got to the point of renewal, new CFO procurement, you know, really. sort of analyzing, you know, every bit of spend, ultimately, unfortunately, that particular use case and that customer churned. And it was a big wake-up call, I think, to us that you know the CSMs couldn't just be relying on the data or that main point of contact. We sort of lose visibility of who the users are with the API and CP use cases. So it's you. yeah, have to get even more embedded into the business, I think. You know, QBRs, hackathons, all sorts of things that you can do to give you that visibility.
23:24And
23:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): then who ultimately owns that renewal? It sounds like it might be the rep, given what you said earlier. But is is does that still sit with them? So they're owning the customer for a certain amount of time, or how does it work?
23:33Jacqueline De Gernier: Yeah, so we have our customers sitting with our enterprise new business team up to a certain threshold of spend so that they can pursue that land and expand, because otherwise you really would see them if they had to hand that over up to
23:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): be maximizing those initial
23:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): volumes.
23:48Jacqueline De Gernier: Of course they would, absolutely. And so we've got some brilliant expansion stories with, you know, sort of some of the world's biggest technology companies that have been won one over the last year. And the new business rep has made the initial land and has then been responsible for driving. that expansion. So Enterprise CSM assigned day one, absolutely kind of in that account with them, but they own the expansion strategy. And
24:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): often that expansion comes at the point of a renewal, I assume. Because it's like, look, you're reaching your limits, come and renew
24:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it. Exactly. Yeah.
24:19Jacqueline De Gernier: Because there is a debate at the moment as to whether at the point of the first renewal it should be handed over.
24:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
24:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): what I was wondering.
24:25Jacqueline De Gernier: Yeah. I'm For me, the most meaningful metric is the level of kind of spend or consumption that they've got to. And so many customers are on a different kind of timeline when it comes to that adoption as well. So I don't I think having an arbitrary first-year renewal, I don't know. I'm No, not sure. I'm I remain to be convinced on that one.
24:49Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's cool. And you talked earlier about some of the complexities that this has brought to the sales process in terms of being able to model out what their usage is going to be. And it sounds like there's yeah, there's probably new skills that haven't to be learned by the reps to to do that. But you also mentioned to me that you built a solution engineering function whilst actually keeping your cost base flat, which I thought was pretty impressive. So I kind of wondered to myself, where did that headcount come from? And and what did the business kind of I suppose have to stop doing to fund it? But yeah, give us a sense. as to how you've done that and why you did that.
25:16Jacqueline De Gernier: Yeah, absolutely. Again, based on experience, uh, Twilio saw just how fundamentally important the solution engineering team is, A to winning those consumption deals. But I mean, you touched on it um just now, actually helping build that usage consumption plan. They really do work very closely with the AEs and the customers on um estimating what the API or MCP. um consumption is going to look like. So I knew certainly about a year, 18 months ago, as we could see consumption really starting to take off, that we were going to need to build out our solution consulting team. We've got some amazing customers, you know, as I say, rolling us out for end-to-end creative workflows, ad sales, etc. But we can see that they could go even faster if they could just get access to more engineering technical support, like they're constrained on their side. In terms of where did the budget and the head count come from?
26:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Everyone wants solution engineers, but how do you fund them? It increases your CAC.
26:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
26:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And so you're often getting challenged. Well, you know, what's the payback
26:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): going to be?
26:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And so, yeah, how did you justify that?
26:20Jacqueline De Gernier: Well, we we went through a re-org uh about well, just under a year ago, and really were purposefully across all functions redesigning the organisation for our agentic roadmap, the way that we need to work with customers going forwards. And so the FDE kind of headcount, for example, that was part of a series of difficult decisions that were made, but resulted in some headcount being and budget being available to reallocate to that higher hire and to a couple of other um solution engineers. But what we're also doing is we're really thoughtfully questioning every single backfill. So as we we do a lot of promotions from within. So about 55% of our hires over the last year have been internal promotions. We've really got the SDR mid market enterprise progression path working really well for us now. So as the SDRs are being promoted, we're constantly asking ourselves do we need another SDR there or do we need, you know, a CSM in this team over here? And yeah, reallocating as and when we can. So another role that we created in the SDR org was really a go to market engineer. So marketing does do some amazing um work with with Clay. We felt it would be really beneficial. to actually
27:39have someone in that team who is entirely focused on the SDR function and how they're using our data. And uh we had an SDR that was really technical and showed a lot of interest in that and had done some brilliant automation. So we've put him through Clay training and he's uh yeah, he's a a a wizard um with Claude, which we use. We've got their enterprise. version so yeah so um so he's also helped us to scale the SDR function but not necessarily through adding additional heads.
28:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's great. And you mentioned forward deployed engineer a hotly talked about role but for those that don't know what it does, maybe break it down. What were you looking for them to do? What are they responsible for in a week?
28:22Jacqueline De Gernier: Absolutely so uh so it's week one for him no pressure But yeah, the idea is so we've got um, you know, an account like L'Oreal, for example, where they initially um had an API trial, they've since committed to a much higher um volume of consumption, but they are they're struggling to get that time internally with their engineering team to scale their use and their use case, which very much focuses on brands and creative. And so the idea is that some someone like Chi can go in there and actually work with them. I mean, that they're probably a bit further along on the journey, but for a new customer, it might be mapping out what that end-to-end workflow looks like, what their data and integration needs are through the workflow, and then actually work with them to help them to build that. So we're certainly doing it as a um a free kind of added value service because it will ultimately just drive more consumption and more usage. And that's kind of, you know, that that's where the revenue driver's gonna come from for us. But I think some organizations are actually charging for their FDE services. Um but it's yeah, uh a sort of solution architect, but you know, post post-win that's really gonna go into the customer organization and work with them. The other role that I'm thinking about at the moment. um, so I started myself's career in legal tech,
29:42and it makes me smile now because it wasn't as hot as it is now. Certainly wasn't seen as a
29:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): sexy face. It really wasn't,
29:49Jacqueline De Gernier: yeah. And Harvey, I know, you know, they're hiring an army of um, you know, legal engineers, they call them. And when you look at the profile, you know, these are fully trained lawyers, so they're trained in the law, they're trained in the model, and they're able to go into organizations and help them kind of in exactly that way. Now we have insight specialists. We have people that go in and actually help organizations to take either our syndicated data or the custom data that we've um developed for them. And then how do they take that data and turn it into really meaningful, valuable insights that their leadership? team can use? And I'm thinking, sure we could probably train them up and have insights engineers. So yeah, I think that, yeah, watch this space. That might
30:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be the next role. Yeah.
30:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Cool. And then I suppose you've it's you've shared a few of these lessons learned over the last kind of ten minutes or so. But look looking back, if you were to do the whole thing again starting next Monday, what would you change or what would you sequence differently about what you've done?
30:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): First
30:50Jacqueline De Gernier: off. this is probably going back a couple of years. I would be a lot more vocal.
30:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): You're probably gonna smile at really. Is that possible?
30:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
30:58Jacqueline De Gernier: think there were ti yeah, I could see round corners having come from Twilios in this super successful, you know, consumption based business. I think I was what, a year into GWI at that point. Like nobody wants to be that bore in the corner of the room constantly harking back to their previous company. But, you know, and I I definitely was surfacing things, but when they perhaps weren't either fully understood or didn't land or weren't, you know, sort of really being listened to at times, I think I could have pushed harder. So things like the PLG sign-ups were not going into Salesforce seamlessly. I'd seen that at DocuSign. So, you know, our um free sign-ups, personal plans, you know, those ended up being a real shop window for the sales-led growth. So I knew how important it was that the reps were going to have visibility of those account signups in Salesforce and then be able to go after them. So that would be kind of one example. The pricing and packaging, the volume discount tiers, the overages, having a data access fee to protect us as seat-based subscriptions migrated over to API spend. Yeah, th those are a few examples.
32:09One other thing, and this is super tactical, but really helpful. Yeah. A live deal desk. So we hadn't had one at DocuSign and we did at Twilio. And the reason we had site I mean, we had thousands of SKUs. It was actually really complex um because of the nature of the communications APIs. You know, they were sitting on top of carriers, etc. So reps would bring their deals to make sure that they were using the SKUs correctly, but increasingly they used it to talk through deal strategy. And we had reps, like it was open. Reps could join and listen to the deal desk so that they could learn from others.
32:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
32:47Jacqueline De Gernier: I pushed for again, pushed for this a couple of years ago. And there was a bit of resistance. We had like a deal desk approval thread, uh approval group in uh uh in um email. Anyway, I about a year ago pushed on it again and said, no, I want to I wanna at least once a week live deal desk. And it's using exactly that way now. And so all consumption deals that aren't being priced using standard terms, there's no approval um chain in Salesforce or in an email. They have to come to a live deal desk call. And that's been super important because some customers are now building external facing solutions using our data. And we have to be really careful that they're not using it to train a model because that's it. You know, we've given them the keys to the castle then. So yeah, I would I would have done that. So you know,
33:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's great advice, Jackie. That's that's awesome. And talking of good advice, and I know you've not been in the CRO role for too long. but you're one of the most experienced revenue leaders, sales leaders that that I know. What's one thing you tell a CRO who's a few years behind you? What's that big bit of advice that you would give them?
33:48Jacqueline De Gernier: Yeah. Well, if I think back a few years, you're right. I've been in the CRO role for for a year now. And if I think back to my previous leadership roles, you know, at Twilio when I was leading Northern Europe, I would say just put it on yourself to invest. in that future growth and that move, hopefully, an ambition to be a CRO. I did the CRO school with Pavilion and absolutely loved it. And it was really powerful, even though I didn't own all of the, yeah, I didn't own the GRR metric at the time. It was really powerful understanding And in the full revenue architecture. So I would say put it on yourself to invest in yourself. to sign up for courses, stretch yourself so that when that CRO role is available, that you can step into it.
34:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's great, Jackie. And yeah, I love that how you've invested in yourself and your career and the fact that you were one of the first members to join Pavilion or Revenue Collective says a lot about you as a revenue leader. And I've so much enjoyed the dinners we've had together, the panels that we've been on together, and just how open you are about your learnings. You've been very vulnerable about some of the challenges that you faced. I think um I love how you champion diversity and inclusion and but I've never really had this type of tactical conversation in the weeds around revenue. And I've and so I've so enjoyed today and the insights that you've shared. It's been incredible, and I'm sure our listeners are gonna you going love to that as well. It's been a real pleasure getting to know you, Jackie. Thank you so much.
35:13Jacqueline De Gernier: Thank you.
35:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
35:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you for listening. to Making the Grade. If this episode resonated, we'd love to hear about it. Feel free to leave us a review. Of course, share it with another revenue leader in your network. And don't forget to subscribe so you never miss an episode. So see you again soon for more practical lessons from people shaping the future of revenue leadership.