Arbell Energy proposes quantum dot solar retrofits to boost efficiency and reduce China dependency
Summary
Ronen Lago and Speaker_1 discuss Arbell Energy's quantum dot technology, which claims to exceed 90% efficiency compared to silicon's 20-22% limit. The company targets aging solar farms with a retrofit overlay that clips onto existing panels, aiming to double or triple energy output without replacing infrastructure. Lago highlights the programmable nature of the salt-based ink, allowing for transparent windows or agricultural applications. The speakers outline a strategy of field validation and upfront sales to utilities, citing geopolitical risks from China's market dominance as a driver for Western adoption.
Episode sections
- 0:02 – 3:18
Arbell Energy and the efficiency limits of conventional silicon solar cells
Ronen Lago states that solar accounts for less than 5% of global energy generation and that current silicon technology is 80 years old, limited to ~20-22% efficiency with a theoretical cap of 30%. He claims Arbell's quantum dot technology could achieve over 90% efficiency, potentially 3-4x better than current PV.
- 3:18 – 7:04
How quantum dot TV displays inspired Arbell’s printable solar ink
Lago explains the 'Aurora moment' of reversing QLED TV technology, which transmits light, to instead absorb it for energy. He notes the material is a salt-based nanocrystal ink that can be printed on flexible surfaces like glass or silicon.
- 7:04 – 10:22
Lago’s career in defense, automotive technology and startups, and his decision to invest in Arbell
Lago details his background in intelligence (7 years), CTO roles at Lockheed Martin and Daimler, and founding eight startups. He describes investing personal funds and joining Arbell after being convinced by founder Matan's 'brilliant' but misunderstood physics.
- 10:22 – 12:14
How nanocrystal size determines which wavelengths a solar cell absorbs
Lago explains that nanocrystal radius determines the absorbed wavelength (color). This allows the ink to be 'programmable' to capture specific light spectra while transmitting others, enabling applications like transparent windows or agricultural PV.
- 12:14 – 15:04
Designing solar windows that transmit visible light or let selected wavelengths reach greenhouse crops
The speaker discusses using the programmable ink to create milky transparent windows or 'red windows' for agriculture (AgroPV) that pass useful wavelengths to crops while converting the rest into electricity.
- 15:04 – 20:19
Tradeoffs among cost, flexibility and efficiency, and the challenge of adding more printed layers
Lago asserts cost and flexibility are not major tradeoffs due to cheap salt-based ink and lightweight substrates. The primary challenge is increasing efficiency by adding more layers, with a roadmap to reach 40-50 layers from the current 8-12 in the lab.
- 20:19 – 23:08
Why Arbell chose aging solar farms as its first market for a retrofit
Arbell targets utilities with aging solar farms (25-year lifespan) via a retrofit approach. This lowers risk for utilities who already have infrastructure, allowing them to add a low-cost overlay panel to capture unused light without replacing existing assets.
- 23:08 – 36:09
How the proposed overlay clips onto a panel and connects to its existing wiring
The retrofit involves printing the cell on glass, clipping it onto existing panels, and using a Y-connector to combine the new and old panel outputs. The deployment time is estimated at 1-2 minutes per panel, requiring no new permits or grid changes.
- 36:09 – 38:28
Field testing strategy and market validation
Speaker_1 outlines a strategy to start small with utilities to validate field stability, acknowledging that deep tech requires proving durability in real-world conditions rather than relying on PR. The goal is to demonstrate that the technology works and is manufacturable before scaling awareness.
- 38:28 – 41:39
Business model: Retrofit revenue sharing vs. outright sales
The speakers discuss whether to sell the product outright or use a revenue-sharing model where the provider takes a cut of energy savings. Speaker_1 explains they chose a simple upfront sale model initially to build trust with utilities, avoiding complex financial calculations by CFOs, despite believing revenue sharing could be more profitable later.
- 41:39 – 43:50
Geopolitical risks and opportunities regarding China
Speaker_1 identifies China's control over 90% of the solar market as a major threat due to potential price wars and imitation. Conversely, this creates an opportunity for Western companies in the US and Europe to reduce dependency on China by adopting this new manufacturing technology.
- 43:50 – 45:51
Near-term milestones and future applications
Key milestones include completing lab certification in 2-3 weeks, deploying field pilots to test weather/light conditions, and securing a major retrofit or independent solar farm deployment. Future applications discussed include building-integrated photovoltaics, automotive, and satellite power.
Claims worth verifying
Solar accounts for less than 5% of global energy generation.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·0:56
How to verify: Check global energy mix data from the International Energy Agency (IEA) or U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) for the most recent annual report. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Silicon solar technology is controlled 80-90% by the Chinese market.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·1:50
How to verify: Review manufacturing capacity reports from BloombergNEF or the International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) regarding solar PV production by country. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Current solar panels have a theoretical efficiency limit of 30%.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·2:39
How to verify: Consult academic literature on the Shockley-Queisser limit for single-junction silicon solar cells. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Arbell's ideal cell can capture over 90% of the sun's spectrum.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·4:27
How to verify: Request Arbell Energy's technical white papers or peer-reviewed publications detailing their quantum dot absorption spectra. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Quantum dot material used in TVs has been in use for 20 years.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·5:43
How to verify: Review historical product launches of QLED displays by major manufacturers (e.g., Samsung) and patent filings for quantum dot displays. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceArbell's technology can generate 1 kW of energy from less than 1 gram of material in space.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·6:23
How to verify: Verify against Arbell's technical specifications or published power-to-weight ratios for their prototype cells. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Arbell has 8 patents filed.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·26:43
How to verify: Search USPTO or WIPO patent databases for assignee 'Arbell Energy' or inventor 'Matan' or 'Lago'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Arbell is collaborating with Professor Ted Sargent at Northwestern University.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·33:07
How to verify: Check Northwestern University's press releases or academic publication databases for papers authored by Ted Sargent and Arbell representatives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Retrofit deployment takes 1-2 minutes per panel.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·25:08
How to verify: Review Arbell's installation manuals or case studies from utility partners like Eon. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Current lab prototypes use 8-12 layers.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·17:03
How to verify: Request technical specifications from Arbell Energy regarding their current prototype layer count. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Arbell started with utilities to get traction and find three or four that were willing to work with them.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·36:09
How to verify: Check Arbell Energy press releases or news articles from late 2026/early 2026 for announcements of utility partnerships or pilot programs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The speaker believes that after 12-15 months, if the panel runs for 5-6 months in the field showing stability, they will make a lot of noise.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·36:29
How to verify: Monitor Arbell Energy's public communications and press releases for major product launches or marketing campaigns starting mid-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The company is currently under the radar to avoid being seen as just a research lab, preferring to keep a balance with 'boots on the ground'.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·37:19
How to verify: Review Arbell Energy's website and social media activity for the period 2026-2026 to assess their public relations strategy and visibility. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceSpeaker_1 does not believe in good PRs giving trust; customers need to test and see stability.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·37:59
How to verify: Analyze Arbell Energy's marketing materials and investor presentations to determine if they emphasize technical validation over brand messaging. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
China controls almost 90% of the solar market, including price and supply chain.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·41:41
How to verify: Consult industry reports from BloombergNEF, IEA, or SolarPower Europe on global solar manufacturing market share and supply chain concentration as of 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
China will mimic Arbell's technology and beat them on price.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·42:01
How to verify: Track patent filings and product announcements from major Chinese solar manufacturers (e.g., LONGi, JinkoSolar) for similar quantum dot or printable solar technologies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceLab testing for certification is expected to finish in 2-3 weeks from the time of the interview.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·43:50
How to verify: Check Arbell Energy's website or press releases for announcements of completed lab certification or third-party validation results in late 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The next milestone is deployment of field pilots to test performance in different weather and light conditions.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·44:10
How to verify: Look for news articles or press releases from Arbell Energy regarding the launch of field pilot programs in late 2026 or early 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Arbell aims for a big first deployment as a retrofit or independent solar farm to see someone bet on them.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·44:22
How to verify: Monitor Arbell Energy's announcements for major commercial contracts or project completions in the retrofit solar sector. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Future applications include buildings, cars, and satellites powered by their technology.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·44:42
How to verify: Review Arbell Energy's patent portfolio and product roadmap announcements for developments in BIPV, automotive, and aerospace sectors. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Arbell Energy's patent filings for quantum dot solar cell efficiency claims and layer count.
- Check independent lab certifications for the salt-based nanocrystal ink's durability and weather resistance.
- Review utility financial models to assess the viability of upfront sales versus revenue-sharing structures.
- Analyze China's current solar manufacturing capacity and export policies to evaluate geopolitical risk.
- Investigate the supply chain for salt-based nanocrystals to confirm low toxicity and scalability.
- Compare Arbell's projected 90% efficiency against theoretical Shockley-Queisser limits for multi-junction cells.
- Search for existing competitors in the solar retrofit market and their technological approaches.
- Review Arbell's funding history and Lago's prior startup exits for context on execution risk.
Full transcriptexpand
0:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay.
0:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
0:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): thank you everyone so much for joining another Balerian Space Ventures podcast. It's November 10th, and today I'm joined by Ronan Lago of Arbell Energy. This is the company that is changing solar in a very big way. Uh Ronan, thank you so much for taking the time to join
0:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): us. Thank
0:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you, Adam, for having us uh participate in this event.
0:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, absolutely. So to kick it off high level, um give us a walkthrough of solar panels today and what Arbel is doing to change the current trend of what they are to something new and just change the future of solar. because I think it's quite interesting what you do, but I think you might be able to explain it a little better than
0:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me.
0:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, great. So I think one of the challenges that we're we are aware of the uh big issue with you know lack of energy, all of the data centers, and I and everything like this. Uh and it's a no in fact. But I think uh most of the people are are not really aware that less than 5% out of the energy generation is come from the sun, from the solar. And actually, it was pretty surprised because theoretically, you know, the sun is out there, it's free, it's available, it's clean, it has all the right conditions to become much, much more bigger player, you know, in the energy ecosystem. Let's call it like this. And when we started to investigate it, uh we found out that surprisingly the sun is not the problem. And the problem was actually the technology, the silicon technology, that today is almost 90% of it controlled by China market. Actually, this technology is 80-year-old technology that is limited with their efficiency. I don't know how many people actually. know, but when a solar panel is actually grabbing the sun out of the 100% of the sun, let's call it like this,
2:10only 20% out of it or 22%, he can generate energy out of it. So let's say 80% or 75% out of it is going to the garbage or to the thermal losses. And actually, you need to invest some energy to make the panel cooler so it's even less. And for ages, I think the industry is actually trying to get more and better efficiency, fighting for one percent extra half percent. But it's not there. And also the physical limitation from all of the physics stuff is limited by 30%. So even if everything will be amazing and everything will be ideal. still solar panel, the classic that we know for now, let's say will go to 30%. Uh, this is the maximum. And this was something that uh we took four years ago as as a mission to understand why. Okay, and and what can be done differently, because fighting with the same material, same stuff
3:11will will lead you to you know the same ceiling. Uh uh cup. Uh and we try to look differently. Uh and actually we got an Aurora moment four years ago looking at at uh TV screens made of uh material called quantum dots, a QLED, a Q LED TV, which are a very thick TV and very small one. Uh this material is also used for Google glasses and metaglasses, which created a very high efficiency with a lot of pixel screen, which is popular, that is very light, very flexible. You can use it in different varieties. And what we actually thought, like a microphone and Run call, if it can transmit a lot of light, why we cannot reverse it and make it a solar energy and get all of this light instead of transmitting it like a TV. Uh sounds simple, it's not that simple, but this was kind of the Aurora moment that um took us in. Uh we got into the physics, uh, we look for research in the academic. We haven't seen anyone ever go into this direction. So we actually go even back to the pure physics, pure quantum physics, actually, uh, and managed manage to show.
4:27that with our cell and with our structure, we will be able to grab a bit more than 90% of the sun from an ideal perspective. So it means from limit perspective, we can be three times, maybe even four times, better than the current solar PV. Uh, This is one area which again it's not, as I said, for 80 years. they are proving 1%. Suddenly we are saying we can prove 300% more, 400%. So this is a huge revolution for the market. Um, the other stuff we can actually make it from salt, it's a nanocrystal that we can tune. Uh so you don't need to grow it, you don't need huge manufacturing for it. We actually created an ink. in different colors and like a color printer. You just print our ink on different surfaces. It can be on flexible silicon, it can be on glass, it can be on everything. So even from cost manufacturing, uh, we are very, very cheap. Uh, the material is known, as I said, it's used for TVs for 20 years, so it's safe to use. No uh um recycling issue, nothing. So we kind of took a
5:43known stuff that everyone uses every day, like TVs, and just twist our mind and think differently and said, hey, why not create from it a panel? Um so we can deep dive to a lot of physics, but but this is the idea uh in general, and this is why we think it's not only allow you to use. on the same surface three to four times more energy. Since I can print on very, very light surface, for example, let's take space. If today the equation in space is talking about one kilowatt energy that generates from one kilogram of material out there, we can get this one kilowatt of energy with less. than a gram, uh, which for the space industry it's a huge impact from uh this perspective. Uh we are also talking about uh PAPV, automotive. Think about it, anything that suddenly can turn into a
6:43solar surface, which is something that we can only dream about. Uh, and I think this is the huge revolution. um that our Bell Energy is trying to bring to the market. So sorry for the long answer, but I hope I kind of caught it.
6:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): No, it's quite all right. And yeah, I'm happy to dive more into the tech as we go, but first I wanted to um give you more of a moment to introduce yourself. You're a very seasoned executive with quite a bit of experience. Maybe you can walk us through your career journey, the things you've done. And the moment you saw the opportunity with Arbel of saying, that's what I want to put my time and effort into, um, that's where the future is. Like, where did you really see that?
7:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Um, cool. So so yes, so uh a little bit about my background. I finished my first degree in math. when I was in high school, um, joined the army during that time. I did um an XLX program, um, served for seven years in the intelligence forces, something uh equivalent to the NSA kind of technology partners uh area, dealing with a lot of innovation stuff. Um work in different companies in large companies like Motorola. and Defense Companies and also establish almost eight startups during the way, most of them in AI and Cyber and Silicon. In between, I was a CTO for Lockheed Martin, I was the head of innovation and security for Daimler, Mercedes Benz. So yes, definitely kind of have seen academic perspective, big cooperation perspective, um, and working in the garage. Um I think usually in in all of my almost career, I think that things that push me forward, and this is why they always laugh at me that I'm the classic CTO, that every time I see a program that people say it's not doable or it's not exist or it's too crazy to be real,
8:47Um, this is kind of where I'm getting excited. Um, sometimes they were laughing at me that I'm bringing uh projects to the big corporation after I saw good movies uh and I got ideas from the movies, and they said, Okay, it's in the movie, we cannot do it in reality. So it this was my challenge. Uh and I think in our bell, it was actually the same case. I met um Matana, uh, which was the original founder of the company. uh, and I saw the the blink on his eyes when he tell me about you know this story, and he kind of was very, very frustrated. Uh, he said, I know I have something brilliant. He is a genius, by the way, which is not recognized yet. Uh, I know I have something brilliant. I cannot communicate it. I'm amazing with equations and physics, but people don't understand what I'm saying to them. Uh and everyone said that I'm crazy. And this is where I get in love and with. And I actually invested my personal money in it. Uh and then I joined also to the company. Um but I think the beauty about it,
9:55yes, it's deep physics. It's not there, but um the potential, you know, that it can bring to the market from our my vision is like the change between riding on horses and and change it to cars. You know, it's it's really a huge change. Um and this is what makes me excited about this opportunity.
10:20Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Very nice. And so yeah, I want to go back to the technology, these um, these quantum dots, as you call
10:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): them.
10:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): These are nano crystals that are on the film, without um,
10:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
10:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, making this like a physics lecture, something high-level people can understand. What can those crystals do that conventional cells cannot, to where you're able to capture so much more solar than just traditional solar cells?
10:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So think about those nanocrystals that are very, very tiny, but let's think about them like small balls, okay, with a different radius. Actually, the beauty about them and one of their characteristics that if you give them a different radius, it can grab different color for a moment. One size is blue, one different size is red, different size is. yellow, different size is green. Think about it as a different bowl sizes. And again, I'm coming back to the screens. If you remember, the QLED TVs are very famous because they have different pixels. You can see a huge variety of different colors or color shape. And this is what gives you a very high resolution picture. So it's the same. mechanism, just the opposite. I'm actually able to grab very, very uh a lot of types of uh wavelengths uh in order to create uh the almost the ideal solar cell uh from this perspective. Um we generate a patent structure that actually managed to uh uh transfer. the electricity from those
12:05dots into the sides layer so they can actually get electricity out of it. And I think this is simple. So and and the other things that is very cool about it, that it's actually can be programmable. So because it's an ink and every dot is a different color, I can decide what colors. when I manufacturing it I put inside and what I keep outside. This gives us the flexibility, for example, to do a transparent window, a milky transparent window to grab more. Maybe a red window. We talked with AgroPV. They said, okay, give us the Use only wavelength that is good for the tomatoes, uh, and take all the rest to create. energy. So you can actually find yourself programming actually what uh colors or wavelength you can use uh and need to use, uh, and and all the rest can go almost to energy. Um this is also something amazing that um you cannot do with the regular PV.
13:12Okay, you just cannot control it.
13:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
13:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): and I think this is part of our um innovation and and pattern technology.
13:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, so these
13:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
13:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): these cells, like you can put this like if there's a large skyscraper, it's all glass. You can have this on that glass, and it's like a regular building, except it's generating power. Is that is that correct? Yeah.
13:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): so exactly. So we today you have glasses that filter the UV. So instead of filter the UV, think about it, they can generate energy. Okay, so in the basement of your house or or those big you know towers, you will have batteries that can store it. Um satellites, drones, um even your phone. Think you have a sticker to avoid your scratches? Think it can charge it as well. Um it's ink. Okay, you can actually print it anywhere. Yes, we need to make sure that we have small wires at the end to shift the electricity into this problem, into this uh uh battery or device and things like that, but um. from this point, it's more um product engineering challenge. Let's call it like this, and not the technologies, how you really want to get the energy, when you get it. But it's really open today from our vision, markets that uh are not there for solar PV because different reasons, reason. and
14:46suddenly with our flexibility, because we are light, because we can be flexible. because uh we can program it, uh, it can actually open markets that are not there today.
14:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
15:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): which hopefully will be amazing.
15:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): A lot of markets it can open up, I'm sure. And yeah, with just pursuing this efficiency, you you're also got the low cost, the durability, flexibility. all these things. Which one is the hardest to improve on without making the others worse?
15:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Um so I think it's kind of uh two separate, three separated thing. Okay, and and this is why they have very minor impact on each other. Um the low cost is mainly because. these inks we made in the lab, it's a salt, okay. No special equipment to make them. It's not organic that need to grow, it's working in room temperature. Nothing special there. We can we get it in an envelope via FedEx. Okay, so um it's cheap, it's just cheap, so it's not impacting it. Um the flexibility uh and the lightweight we get from the surface that we print. Of course, if we print it on glass, so again it has the weight of the glass. If we print it on a flexible silicon, it has the weight of the flip silicon. Again, we are ink, so you have no weight as a solar
16:23capability, so the main weight is the surface. that we require to put it on. So this is also not an issue. I think the our challenge today is um doing it more and more efficient. So to grab more and more of the sun, we talk about 90% as the goal of the ideal. Now our goal is to do more and more uh layers, we call it, um, and to get more and more energy. and more and more efficiency. This is kind of where we are heading. Today we are having between 8 to 12 layers in the lab. Our next roadmap is to reach 40 or 50 different layers or different colors, let's call it like this.
17:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,
17:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And maybe in the future, even much more, but but this is kind of our roadmap and this is our biggest challenge. Uh from cost perspective, again, one kilogram of of those dots uh can be used for um I don't know almost 1k panels. Um so again if I need one color or two colors it's it's minor. Again it's it's really really minor.
17:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
17:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So the main challenge that we need to face it is more layers which will give us more efficiency. This is the challenge.
17:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
17:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And the roadmap going forward, um, give us an idea of who those first customers are. You know, the order they sign, where uh these quantum dots are going, where your cells are going, and how much it can can save for this customer.
18:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So um I will start from the end and then I will go. So from saving perspective, again, let's even assume that the cost will be the same because today China is heavily sponsoring the panels, so the panels themselves are cheaper if I go panels to panels. Um But even if the same price, okay, um, still I can give three times more energy for the end customer. So so you know, he he when he sells the energy, he will get three times more money. So for his perspective, the end customers is much faster. If I don't know, it takes him to pay back his uh capex seven to eight years. Usually, now we can do it in two. So it's dramatic. for him. You know, so I think from cost perspective to the end customer, it will be easy. Uh other market like space, automotive, building that we talk are almost blue ocean. You know, so no one is there. You know, if you have a building today that is just generating electricity and now it will be able to generate electricity, it's a pure money for the building. Uh besides Beside, of course, the first installation. But the equation is very, very clear
19:20from this perspective. From our at this point, go to market, we have picked an approach which we are still validating. Based on my experience also and my mistake, usually also with cyber product or big IT product, when I used to come. to you know big technology companies and tell them, hey, we have a cool startup, it's a cool technology, it's a cool innovation. Uh, most of the leader was afraid from it. And everyone, we have a laugh in the community that no C executive will get fired if he will buy Microsoft or IBM. But definitely if he will you buy it, you know, from a new startup. So we are almost in the same year. When you are coming to Dwar do Revolution, a revelation to tell them, hey guys, you worked eight years with this vendor, throw them to the garbage, take someone else crazy enough that has no record in the academy and switch to it, it's harder. So we took a different approach that we have found out after a long discussion with different utilities. The main utilities that we work with on it was Eon from Germany. that were open to us. And we actually found a niche that we call it a retrofit. What does it mean, a retrofit? Today, when they are putting their PVs panel, they are
20:39doing the calculation for 25 years. So, and they assume after 25 years the panels are dead, but they invest all of the Capex on the first day. The panels, the infrastructure, the land. LAN, everything is there. Those panels have degradation in performance of between 15 to 20% of the gradation over the years, which is a lost money. Okay, you will not, it's not worth to replace the panels. You already put everything. So you keep it there, and when you're doing the calculation, when you're taking the loan, you assume okay, I will sell less energy over the year, and it's okay. And what we have uh come up with that coming back to the programmable one, that we can put uh a layer, a panel on top of the existing one, which actually takes the 80% that the solar panel are not using. If you remember, they are using 20 or 25 percent out of it, so we have 70% that they are not using, and actually.
21:39grab it and make extra energy out of it. Now, why it's interesting from them? The risk that they need to take is minor. Okay, it's if it's working, they do more. If not, they will take us out. All of the heavy money, all of the capex is already there anyway. Our extra cost is relative. relatively low because all they need is to put a low-cost panel on top of the existing panel. They don't need new batteries, new grid, new anything. And this is our way to get trust in the market, to show everyone, hey, it's working, hey, it's stable, hey, it's give you more energy. Uh And hopefully uh after. they will test it and they will see it's okay, they will be more confident to throw away their regular PV and switch it to our uh full scale uh uh panel. So it's more a go to market approach, not a technology limitation, but uh it's a philosophy discussion. But I do believe that big revolution should start with the small bites
22:52and not saying everyone throw everything to the garbage and switch. It will not happen. The market will be resist. So we are trying to be uh easy to swallow, let's call it like this. Um, this is where we are targeting.
23:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, and can you walk us through the installation process? In my mind, I I can see it multiple ways. Of you know, you say this is an ink, so I'm like, oh, do they just paint it on, or is it a film like when you put tints on glass and it's just very thin? Like, how do you retrofit it to be the certain design and fit the parameters? Walk us through, you know, installing this.
23:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, so let's assume that um the example that we are approaching with with Ion, that uh we we are printing our cell on on a very tiny glass, not a sticker. The idea they pick a glass because of cleaning perspective. They want to make sure that their robots that clean the panel from dust and everything will be the same. They don't want to switch it. Uh so we took the same encapsulation like the regular PV and printed on it, which is a regular glass. At the frame of those glasses, we are taking out our wire. And then what we say is it's the same connector. What we need they need to switch, we call it a Y connector. Today they have plus going to plus, minus going to minus. With our panel, think about it like a center. sandwich. We have two panels, one on each other. Uh, and now you need a Y cable, one plus from us, and one plus from the original PV. One minus from us, one plus, one minus from the original PV, and they are getting into one connector that gets into the uh inverter and and and everything else. So they don't need to change
24:48anything in their uh big. infrastructure. All they need is to put our panel again on top of it, um, clip it and the at the side that it will not flow away. Okay, it's just again it's a mechanic, and switch the only the connector from regular connector to a Y connector, uh, and that's it. So the deployment process that we are planning is less than a minute or two minutes per panel. something very, very fast. Again, it was also a criteria when we work with the utility. If it's going to be complex to deploy or complex to integrate, they will not take it. Okay, it's anyhow hard to bring innovation into those organizations. So it needs to be very simple that any basic mechanic can do it. No need for new permits. no new uh I don't know, architects, nothing. Just put, plug, and play.
25:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. And I'm assuming there's quite a bit of um proprietary technology and patents that you have for this breakthrough technology. Um if there was a well funded competitor that understood. the approach um and they wanted to reproduce it, why would it still be very hard for them? Why would it still take years if not maybe they'd never be able to fully figure it
26:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): out?
26:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Um it's a good question, you know. Theoretically with enough money, enough people, enough research, enough enough Yes, you know, I I believe you know there are other smart people out there. Uh we do protect ourselves with with some patents. We already have eight patents uh and and more to come. Uh we're just limiting it mainly because of budget, honestly, uh, and not to share too much IP out there. We decided to keep some of our IP not public. especially because of that. We are also separating between the creating the ink and and manufacturing the panel. So no one source will actually have the full formula how to do it. And it's very, very hard to reverse it. Again it's an ink that dry on a surface it's it's a nanometric stuff. So it's very very hard. Telling you that it's impossible, I cannot say. Uh, but but we believe it will take them uh
27:24many years. Uh, but yes, this is why we are now also looking for you know a strong uh partnership with the big venture capitals that will fund us and allow us to move uh fast. Um
27:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
27:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): market. is huge and the potential is huge. I think there is enough place for for everyone.
27:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
27:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): competition is not that bad in some cases, you know, because people trust you more.
27:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
27:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): let's see, again, uh uh it can happen, you know, like any other technology. But I think it's gonna be very, very hard and and we're trying to do everything that we can. um to minimize this risk.
28:06Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And with such a breakthrough product that can benefit so much, um, is part of the idea maybe you license this technology out just so it can be everywhere and get scaled up wise as one company trying to quite literally fuel the world. Um that that's quite a big fish to fry.
28:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, no, uh totally with you. And and I will say even more, one of our strategy at this moment is is to start licensing. We we want to focus on the technology in the next three to four years at least and not manufacturing by ourselves. We will do the ink, we will do the formula. And we already recognize uh factories in the US, Europe and Asia that can actually manufacturing. Definitely the idea is to license this technology and at least part of the technology. As I said, we can say, okay, we do the trend the glasses one for windows in in Asia, the ones for cars in the US, the one for TVs PVs in Germany, for example. So we can also play with this for different market. markets we can manufacture in different areas. And we hope that you know in four or five years maybe we will build our own manufacturer and and do also buy our own. Yes, we have no ambition that uh you know three people from Israel can control the world in in three, four years. It's it's it's a dream, but it will never happen. So definitely licensing
29:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
29:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): will be the approach how to populate, how to get trust in the market, how to ship
29:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it. Um
29:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): yeah, this is this is our currently at least, this is our vision.
29:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Got it. And yeah, I kind of want to go back to the formation of this. The Uh the the person who actually created this technology, was it um? was it Matt Manton, yes.
30:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah,
30:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): when he came up with this and he told you, like, I can't really figure out how to sell this, and you came along and like, how do you go about selling such an idea while not seeming like okay, this is vaporwave, or maybe there's not really a product here because it's so advanced that even experienced people could have a hard time really you know doing the research and proving out that this works. So being able to sell this, I'm sure, is quite an issue. How did you guys change that on your your growth trajectory?
30:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So um I will cut it to two times. At the beginning, it was very, very hard, okay, because as I said, no professor, no academic issues, no one believed in us. Okay. In Matan, okay. He said it's crazy. Uh we are both electrical engineers, we are not physics, we are not chemists, uh, we have no experience, and you know, a professor professors is from the academic that did the quantum physics. but still we came up with a crazy idea that no one thought about it before, and it's and it's raised questions. Uh and it's okay. So I think um this was one challenge that we try to tackle, and and I think it was mainly based on the credibility of our personality and things that we have done in the past that people were still willing to listen to us and not. throw us from uh the stairs. And it was funny many times, you know. We got even to VCs and we tell them, they say it's amazing. After the meeting, they go to ChatGPT or Cloud and they and they put it and you tell them it's not exist, it's not there, it's crazy, and they come back to us to say that you are liars. Uh Chat Chet saying it's impossible.
32:00Yes, it's innovation, it's not there. This is part of the game. So this was one fight. I think the things that now in the last few months that really changed the momentum, it's it's we actually created the models. Okay. So at the end of the day, you put it in the light and it generates energy. You can say you are crazy, you can say it's you know, but the outcome, put it in the light and generate energy. If it's working, great, if not, it's a garbage. Yes, we can fine-tune how good it is, how efficient it is, but as soon as we show that here is a device, here is the energy out, it's you know, got out from theoretical perspective and and to the real life. And now the discussion with the utilities, even and with tech people is. much more tangible. They can dream about how they can implement, where they can implement, uh, now they can touch it and not just dream about it. So it's really, really make uh the change. We do now open three two months ago
33:07an activity with Northwestern University. There is a person there, a professor called uh Ted Sargent, who is uh the guru of Quantum Dot. Before it not related to solar from different perspectives. And we are working with him on a shared paper because we believe that working with them and a paper with them in nature will give us also the academic trust that all of the other professors are looking for. Uh It was very tough to convince him that that uh there is something behind. us and why we are bothering him. But I think he also fall in love in in this technology and and we had a great collaboration with them and and we hope to release a set of paper uh soon in the coming few weeks.
33:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, and energy breakthroughs, they always attracted an enormous amount of excitement and an enormous amount of skepticism. So it's quite normal. And I'm thinking about this with what we saw this past year in the United States with small modular reactors, nuclear reactors coming back online where it was very skeptical of oh, can these work? Oh, they're not gonna going hit to their milestones, it's not gonna going to get approval. And I we saw some companies. achieve criticality. Now some of them they kept their heads down. You didn't even really hear about them until after they achieved criticality and it's working. And some of them were very out in the public when things hadn't been fully proven yet and got a lot of attention, was very good at selling and just kind of brute forced it as they went, was able to raise capital and then hit criticality. What do you think the appro the appropriate approach is for you know having Arbell come out as successful, whether it's keeping your head down, doing peer review papers, just you know, working
35:07working away, or is it do you need to get that uh that hype out, get everyone excited? and raise all the enormous excitement with enormous skepticism, just so you can
35:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
35:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know capture those few people, raise a lot of money, and then scale? What what do you think the right approach is?
35:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): So um I I don't know what is the right approach, okay, but but what the approach that at least
35:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we can
35:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): work, yeah, yeah. Uh at least from our perspective. Um I I'm a big believer in in a small wins. Okay. I think one of the beauty here is we are three people working in a very small lab. We don't need a lot of money, so we can actually do a lot of progress without raising a lot of funds. Uh and again, because it's known material, because there is existing manufacturers, we don't need to invent the wheel. Uh So we can reuse, we pay for it. So it's it's very, very um controlled. Our bump is to get enough awareness, and and we tried after we had the first modules working in the lab. Uh, this is where we start off with the utilities to get some traction. We want to see that our uh vision is is can fit to them, and then we found three or four of them that were able to dream with us, and we want to see that it's working in the field, you know, because many shit happens. Okay. I don't know what's going to be in the field and things like that. So we want to start small. Uh, I believe that I don't know, 12 months from now, 15 months, after the panel will run for five, six months in the field, they show
36:49stability, show it's not a buzzword, it's working, we can manufacture more of it, then yes, we will make a lot of noise. But until then, um yes, we are starting small, mainly because again, it's a deep tech, we will have mistakes, we will have challenges, uh, things is not working like software and things like that. That we will put extra five people and it will work. Science is not working like this. Okay. I can be stuck in calculating formula for two months and until I will break it, it will not work. So, this is again from personal perspective, okay. We believe that be as much as we can under the radar, not too much in the garage, because I saw too many startups keeping themselves in the garage, and then they will come out to meet the market. They found out that they missed miss the market and they don't really understand. the market and the market is thinking differently. Uh so you need to keep the right balance, I think, um, with boots on the ground, um, but not too much. Again, at least this is our approach and so far to get confidence, to get the trust. Um,
37:59I don't believe in good PRs that give you trust. It's it's it's nice, it gives you people on the calls. No one will write you a big check or or put his bets on him because you have a nice paper, you know, article. Uh uh they need to test it, they need to see it's working, they need to see it's stable. Otherwise you are just nice, you know, tagline. timeline.
38:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. It'd be like a research lab rather than an actual company.
38:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Exactly.
38:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Which
38:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): makes
38:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me think
38:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): of
38:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, the the the company approach, the business model here, is it do you think the right approach is to just sell this product outright to a company or you know, a factory, or can you make more money and kind of have everyone win On if you say you go to a factory and you say, Okay, let us put this on your route? roof. And you spend a million dollars on energy per year. Well, at the end of the year, whatever the difference is, if you spend 200,000, not a million, that 800,000 goes to us, and then you have our products. Do you think you make more money just selling it or doing a a more savvy approach like that?
39:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, so um definitely and and again, this was one of the issues that that we'd go to the utilities now with the retrofit that I talked with. I said, guys, I can give you extra 20%, you have zero. Uh take ten, I will take ten, or take fifteen, I will take five. Um you have nothing to lose. You know, you have it, throw it away, Way you get more, we get less. I think the problem was again more logistic. There are big utilities. How they will calculate the revenue, the CFO will get kind of crazy about it. Not because it's not possible or we make enough money. So I think it's definitely we can do more money out there, but we need to be bigger, we need to be more mature and more trustable. At this early stage, I'm I'm in a big believer in keep it simple. Okay, simple approach. simple contract. Yes, we will earn less, but we we need to get our trust in the market. We need to get there as soon as I don't know, three, four years from now, when we will be deployed and better. Yes, we will do this conversation. At this point, we just felt it make more complex the discussion,
40:23and and suddenly we talk about it's four 4% percent of. or 5%. It's out of the revenue and not, you know, it's took the decision to guys, let us put our panels on top of you and let's start. And we wanted to avoid it. We want to start. And this is where taking it as. So this is why we pick this kind of business model at this moment, at least, even if we earn less.
40:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
40:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): again, maybe I'm wrong. Okay, this is part of the beauty that we make. that may need to change over time. But
40:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
40:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and have you thought about just like long roadmap, you know, when things do change in energy, like the most wealthy companies in the world, they're all behind energy a lot of the times. And if they see something that's truly groundbreaking and revolutionary, um
41:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
41:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): lobbyists start getting involved or acquisitions or it can get messy. So
41:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when
41:23Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you're looking down the roadmap, what are some things that might worry you? What are some, you know, awesome opportunities that you're excited for? What are some of those things like down the roadmap that not a lot of people know or understand that you can shed a little light
41:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on? Yeah,
41:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think the main concern that we got raised, but it's also the huge opportunity, and I touched it at the beginning a bit, is China. Okay, and I will explain why. Today, almost 90 plus percent of the solar market is controlled by China. Okay, they're controlling the price, they are controlling the supply. chain. They are actually controlling everything. And the first question we get: okay, China will do it cheaper. China will beat you up. China will mimic you. China will, you know, you're not, you are pooking the dragon and and uh and and they will not like it. Um so this is definitely a threat. But on the other side, when we are talking with the European and the US guys, it's an opportunity because suddenly they can cut their dependency on China. They can create in manufacturing in the US, they can create in manufacturing
42:41in Europe. So for them, being able to be sustainable and to have an energetic uh independency. uh, it's a huge issue. Um so so this is where we kind of see the the the risk that someone will try to hit us or mimic us and the big opportunity that maybe they will want to protect us, the big US company or the U EU companies, big exactly because of that risk. Um So I think this is the main issue that um that we are seeing um at this point at least. It's more political stuff but but it's definitely interesting.
43:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah it's it's definitely can be quite an interesting future once this really gets going. For people who are following Arbell and you know want to stay on top of this, what are some milestones they should keep their eye out for in the next year or two that um
43:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
43:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know you can hint at now?
43:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Um so so I think the basic milestone that we hopefully to finish in two to three weeks is is to finish our lab testing for certification, so to get the approval that that we are okay in lab. And then our next milestone is the deployment outer, the field pilots. I think this is the big step that we are heading to see that it's it's working out there. Usually in the market, you need to wait a few weeks to see it's working in different weather, different light conditions, different stuff. So this is our next um milestone. Um and later, I think, yeah. the first you know, big deployment as retrofit, a big first deployment as an independent solar farm to see someone that's betting on us and put all his money to build his uh first stuff. So this is from it. And then opening new vertica, you know, the new building powered by our bell, a new car powered by our bell, a new satellite powered by our bell. So, you know, I I can take you, you know, for every almost uh uh item that that we are dreaming about, uh, which will be exciting. Um let's see. Uh
45:02we have big dreams, we have big potential, um and we are really hoping to to to really change the market because it's it's really disruptive. Uh it's not yet another nice solution. It's it's really changing eight years old market uh from its roots.
45:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
45:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): so yeah, it's exciting, it's challenging, but it's exciting.
45:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I'll say well, I'm very excited for it. Um,
45:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
45:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I'm sure a lot of people listening are as well. Uh Ronan, I want to thank you so much for taking the time to join us today. This has been a fantastic conversation.
45:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Thank you very much for hosting me, and I hope it was interesting.
45:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Absolutely. And I look forward to staying in touch and seeing what Arbell does in the future.
45:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Thank you very much.
45:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): All right. Take
45:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): care.
45:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Bye-bye.