Host debunks nine common financial arguments using data on economy, taxes, housing, and deficits.
Summary
Host Parker Moffett addresses nine common financial arguments often heard during holiday gatherings, framing them as announcements rather than questions. He challenges the notion that the US has the strongest economy by citing Gallup data showing worsening financial sentiment among Americans. The host corrects misconceptions about tax burdens, noting that 40% of Americans pay no income tax, often due to retirement status or standard deductions. He argues that housing unaffordability stems from dual-income households bidding up prices rather than women entering the workforce, and that low interest rates drive prices up rather than making homes affordable. Finally, he compares US and French deficits, highlighting differences in tax collection and spending levels.
Key takeaways
- 1 Actually, it's 40%, not half, and the big share of them are retired and living on Social Security.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 2:30
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 1:06
Introduction and Episode Premise
Host Parker Moffett introduces the concept of addressing common financial arguments heard at Thanksgiving dinners, framing them as announcements rather than questions. He outlines the structure of debunking nine specific claims using data and counter-questions.
- 1:06 – 2:10
The Economy: Size vs. Strength
The host challenges the claim that the US has the strongest economy in history by distinguishing between economic size (GDP) and individual financial well-being. He cites Gallup data showing 55% of Americans feel their finances are worsening, the highest recorded level.
- 2:10 – 3:36
Tax Burden and Income Tax Eligibility
Addressing the claim that half the country pays no income tax, the host corrects this to 40%, noting many are retirees on Social Security. He highlights that minimum wage earners often pay no federal income tax due to the standard deduction but do pay payroll taxes.
- 3:36 – 5:19
Housing Affordability and Dual Incomes
The host refutes the idea that women entering the workforce caused housing unaffordability. He argues that housing prices rose because dual incomes allowed families to bid up prices, and notes that in 1990, when women were already working, houses cost three years of pay versus five today.
- 5:19 – 6:41
Interest Rates vs. Housing Prices
The host argues that low interest rates do not make housing affordable because they drive up prices. He notes that in fall 2024, the Fed cut rates by a full point, yet mortgage rates rose, indicating rates are set by long-term bond markets, not the Fed.
- 6:41 – 7:45
US vs. France Deficits and Spending
The host counters the argument that US deficits are unsustainable by comparing them to France's 5.4% deficit against the US's 6.2%. He points out the US collects a lower percentage of GDP in taxes (17% vs 20% in 2000) while maintaining similar or higher spending levels.
- 7:45 – 11:49
Private Credit and Crypto Risks
The host critiques private credit as a risky asset class, highlighting potential liquidity mismatches and lack of transparency. He also discusses the speculative nature of cryptocurrency, noting its volatility and regulatory uncertainties.
- 11:49 – 13:46
Conclusion and Host Credits
The host concludes by suggesting these arguments stem from fear rather than certainty. He credits economist Kathryn Anne Edwards for the episode's concept and provides standard podcast disclosures regarding his affiliation with Newman Dignon and Shearer.
Do your own research
- Verify Gallup's 'Work and Life' survey data for current financial sentiment trends.
- Check IRS Publication 17 for standard deduction amounts and payroll tax obligations.
- Review Federal Reserve meeting minutes and long-term bond yield data for fall 2024 rate decisions.
- Compare US Treasury Department deficit reports with French Ministry of Finance fiscal data.
- Research historical housing price-to-income ratios from 1990 to present using Census Bureau data.
- Investigate the regulatory framework and risk disclosures for private credit funds.
- Review the podcast host's affiliation with Newman Dignon and Shearer for potential conflicts of interest.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Here's what it's like being a financial advisor at Thanksgiving. Look, the doctor in the family gets asked about a mole. I get told. Nobody at the table has a question about money. They have an announcement. Shows up around the second glass of wine, and it's usually something a man said on television.
0:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
0:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I'm a guy with a license. Now picture being the woman who actually runs the money at the house and having explained to her by a man holding a drumstick. No experience, no license. Just an opinion. Most weeks I hand you a question and send you off to think. Not this week.
0:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
0:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): week I'm going around the table and I'm not being nice about
0:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
0:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Here's what you get:
0:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
0:42Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): each of them is going to announce, why it's wrong with numbers that prove it, and one question that ends
0:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
0:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): One rule for me though, I'm not telling you who to vote for. You most likely have an uncle for that. Alright, announcement number one. Let's say this is from your cousin. Fox News has been on the den since 10, and his brokerage app is open next to his plate.
1:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): He
1:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): says to you, strongest economy in the history of the world. I don't know what everybody's crying about.
1:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Look,
1:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): cousin. the economy is the biggest it's ever been. So is your truck, and so probably is the payment. Big isn't strong. Big is just big.
1:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you're not looking at the economy, you're looking at your account. The top 1% of households own half the stock market, so when it goes up, that's wonderful news for the people who own it. For everybody else, it's a rumor. Here's everybody else. This spring, 55% of Americans told Gala their finances are getting worse. The most ever recorded. Look, they're not crying, cousin. They're counting. I grew up in restaurants. If the place has regular sales and the waiters can't afford to eat there, that's not a strong restaurant. That's a strong owner. Here's the question strong for who? Name one person at this table that's not you. You'll look around and give him a minute. It's a long table. Alright, announcement number two from let's say your uncle. He owns a business. He would like you to know how much he pays in taxes. How this country doesn't pay a dime of income tax. I'm carrying. every one of them. Uncle,
2:30great. Let's go collect. Actually, it's 40%, not half, and the big share of them are retired and living on Social Security. So should we start with grandma? She's right over there across the table. Should we hand her a bigger tax bill? Next, the kid who made your coffee this morning. full time at federal minimum wage, is $15,000 a year. Nobody pays income tax on their first 16. You want him paying? We should just pay him more.
3:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
3:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I've heard the word you snuck in income. Because that kid pays a tax on his very first dollar before he's ever sees seized. it. Two out of three taxpayers pay more of that tax than. income tax.
3:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
3:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it funds the Social Security you're about to start collecting. So remind me, who's carrying who? Your taxes have been cut five times since 2001. You want to pay less tax and you want everybody else to pay more? That doesn't sound like a tax policy. That's ordering the lobster and asking to split the check. So here's the question for your uncle. Which is it, uncle? Lower taxes? Or more people paying them? I'm having a lot of fun at these. Alright, your grandfather now. Two glasses in and it's only two o'clock. He says, nobody can afford a house on one paycheck because all the women went to work. You doubled the workers. It's simply supply and demand. Oh grandpa, so the housing market is your granddaughter's fault. 50 years of interest rates, zoning boards in Wall Street, and the thing you landed on is a nurse with a job? Fine, let's do your plan. Monday morning, every woman at this table quits. First problem:
4:23somebody has to run the hospital you're going to need. Second problem, and you won't like it, you're planning to sell that house for $800,000 to who? A family with one paycheck? You don't want one income price, Grandpa. You want your whole retirement that is based on two income prices. Simply supply and demand. And the dates don't work. By 1990, the women were already at work, and a house still cost about three years of a family's pay. Today it's more than five. The price took off after. They have an alibi. So here's the question: Who's gonna buy your house on one paycheck, Grandpa? Then ask Grandma who's kept the checkbook for 55 years. She's probably been waiting for someone to ask. Alright, number four, why not your father? father-in-law? Retired. He checks the treasury bonds the way other men check a fantasy team. He says, the Fed is killing these kids. Get rates back to 3% and they can all buy houses.
5:27Ask him one thing first. What was the rate on his first mortgage? He'll tell you. He loves telling you. 13.5% and glad to get it. Good. Now, your rate was 13 and you bought a house at 27. Theirs is seven and they can't. So it was never the rate, it was the price. And where did the price come from? Cheap money. When mortgage rates went to three percent, houses didn't get affordable, they got expensive. The payment dropped, so the price climbed up to meet it. You're asking for more of what did this. And the Fed doesn't set the mortgage anyway. In the fall of 2024, it cut a full point and the mortgage rates went up anyway. A mortgage is traced by people lending money for 30 years and they don't take orders. Last thing, those treasures of yours pay 5% and you love them. You want 5% of your money and 3%? on theirs? Here's the question which one are you? giving up? Your 5% or their three? You'll keep the five on his bonds. They always keep the price of their bonds. Alright, next one, your mother's neighbor. He comes every year, but nobody remembers inviting
6:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): him.
6:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): You want free health care in six weeks off? Look at France. Riots. Brogue. That's where it gets you. I love when people bring up France because I checked. France's deficit this year is 5.4% of its economy. Ours? 6.2%. We're running a bigger tab than France. They got health care, child care, and the month of August off. We just got the tab. So it isn't the nice things that break a at country. We skipped the pie and gained the weight anyway. Here's how. In 2000, Washington collected about 20 cents of every dollar this economy made. Now it's 17. We gave ourselves a pay cut and kept the spending. Try that on your house budget. And, sir, you're 71, you've been on government health care for six years. How's that going? He loves it.
7:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): He
7:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): just doesn't call it that.
7:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
7:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): here's a question for your neighbor. We're running a bigger deficit than France. What did we get for ours?
7:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
7:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, at least they got August off. Okay, now for a quick lightning round, because somebody's probably carving. Your sister. Our guy got us into private credit. Nine percent, and it never goes down. You know what else never goes down? My weights if I stay off the scale. That fund isn't steady, it's just unweighed. Ask her when she can get her money out. This June, the biggest one of its kind paid out half of what people asked for. Your nephew, crypto isn't gambling, it's investing, just faster. Faster is the tell. Owning doesn't need to be fast, and the thing that only pays when the next guy pays more isn't an investment. It's hot potato. And that app is what where the trades on Sunday's game are. On one of the big ones this summer, 84% of the action were sports. That's not a market. That's a sports book that went to business school. Your niece. The boomers ruined everything. Your grandmother is a boomer. She has a fixed income and a Buick. The people you're mad at don't have a birth year. They just have a tax attorney. All right. Alright, next announcement. Your cousin's husband. He listens to a lot of podcasts, not this one. If this new Congress starts regulating AI, they'll tank the market. Regulation kills the economy. Let the market sort it out. Okay.
9:06Well, which regulation? Name one. You can't, you never can. It's always regulation. Like it's one big thing in a warehouse somewhere. The turkey was inspected under federal law, you're welcome to the other kind. I'll wait in the car. Your money is in a bank that the government insures before that rule, the market sorted out the banks. 9,000 of them closed in four years, and if your money was inside, that was bad. No one has lost a dime on an insured deposit. You've been regulated since breakfast, and you look fantastic. And I own pieces of companies Owl never set foot in, so do you. The only reason either one of us believes one number that they print is somebody goes to prison is they lie. That's not red tape. That's the product. Now listen to your own thread. Make the richest companies in history follow a rule, and they'll take everybody's four 401k hundred one K down with them. That's not an argument. That's a ransom note. So here's the question which rule do you want gone? Name one. He won't have one. He doesn't have a rule. He just has a feeling. Alright, let's go with your dad. He put himself through college, and you will hear about it before the pie. He'll say something like These kids don't want to work. I paid my
10:25own way. They want it all handed to them. Dad, you did. I believed you. So let's check the price. In 1980, a year state college was about $800. Minimum wage was $310. That's six and a half weeks of work, a summer job with August off. Today it's about $12,000 and minimum wage is seven and a quarter. That's $41. weeks. To do it your way, your grandson starts his summer job in November. Same with the house. Your cost three years of pay, his cost more than five. You got a pension, he got password. Tell me again, who got things handed to him? And nobody wants to work anymore.
11:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
11:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): newspaper printed that same complaint in 1894. They were talking. about your grandfather. These kids don't have a work problem, they have a price problem. And they didn't set the prices. He's sitting right there, by the way, 24, two jobs, back in his old bedroom, listening to you. So Dad, here's the question. What did a year of school cost you? And how many weeks did it take you to earn it? He knows the number. He's proud of it. Make him say it out loud. Okay, I've had my fun and I've been hard on these people. Look, I love these people.
11:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
11:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): here's what I left out. Every one of those announcements is somebody being scared in a loud voice. Your uncle's scared about the business. Your grandfather grandfather's scared of the world he understood left without him. it. Your dad's scared his grandson won't make it, and your nephew's scared he'll never own a thing. Nobody announces what they're sure of. So here's the question for the car, and it isn't about them. What's your announcement? The thing you say every year a little too loud. And what's it covering for? Thank you for listening. You don't have to, and I know
12:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
12:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I got this idea from one of the favorite economists I have, Catherine Ann Edwards, who does it every year on Optimus Economy, with look, more swearing. All the numbers I used are in the show notes. Happy Thanksgiving. I'm Parker Moffat, and this was American Nobles.
13:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): American Nobles is hosted by Parker Moffat, an investment advisor representative of Newman Dignon and Shearer, a registered investment advisor. This podcast is for educational purposes only. It is not individualized investment, tax, or legal advice, and listening does not create a client relationship. Views expressed, including any forecasts, are the hosts as of the date of recording. They are not guaranteed. guarantees and may change. Claire and her family are fictional characters, not clients. Figures describing them are hypothetical for illustration only. Third party information is believed to be reliable but is not guaranteed. Authors, researchers, and organizations mentioned are not affiliated with human dignity and shear and have not endorsed it. If this episode discusses tax and estate rules as they stood on the date of recording, these rules change and vary by state. Any tax comparison is a hypothetical illustration based on assumed values and rates. Discussion of investment type or approach is not a recommendation for any individual. Private investments involve additional risks, including limited liquidity, limited transparency, and higher fees, and are not suitable for every investor. Projections from government reports, including social securities, depend on future legislation and may change. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principle. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Consult a qualified professional before acting on anything discussed. Full disclosures are in
13:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
13:46Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): show notes.