The OMC Real Estate Podcast

Podcast: Debt Funds: Why a 15% Return Can Become 9%

16 min Listen to the original
Real Estate Debt FundsTax ImplicationsDepreciationEquity vs. DebtCalifornia Tax LawLiquidity RiskREITs

Summary

The speaker argues that advertised pre-tax returns on multifamily debt funds often appear lower than equity investments after accounting for taxes. While debt funds typically offer regular interest income taxed as ordinary income, equity investments allow for depreciation deductions that can offset taxable income. Using hypothetical figures, the speaker illustrates how a 15% pre-tax debt return may drop to 9% after federal and California state taxes. The discussion highlights that California does not conform to federal bonus depreciation rules, reducing tax benefits for residents. Additionally, the speaker contrasts the limited upside of fixed-rate debt with the appreciation potential of equity, while noting the liquidity restrictions inherent in private debt funds.

Episode sections

  1. 0:04 – 1:12

    Introduction to Debt Funds and Tax Implications

    The speaker introduces multifamily debt funds advertising high returns and highlights that investors often overlook the impact of taxes on these returns.

  2. 1:12 – 4:16

    Mechanics of Debt Funds vs. Equity Syndications

    Debt funds pool capital to lend to real estate operators, providing regular income and repayment priority over equity. Unlike equity syndications, debt investors only receive interest income, which is taxed as ordinary income.

  3. 4:16 – 5:24

    Tax Comparison: Debt Fund vs. Equity Investment

    Using hypothetical numbers, the speaker demonstrates that a 15% pre-tax return from a debt fund can drop to 9% after federal and California state taxes. In contrast, an equity investment with lower cash flow but significant depreciation deductions can result in higher after-tax cash retention.

  4. 5:24 – 9:16

    Depreciation Mechanics and State Tax Differences

    The speaker explains that depreciation allows equity investors to report losses while receiving cash distributions. However, California does not follow federal bonus depreciation rules, which reduces the tax benefit for California residents compared to the federal calculation.

  5. 9:16 – 12:37

    Risk Profiles and Upside Potential

    Equity investors bear more risk than senior lenders but have unlimited upside potential through appreciation. Lenders have limited upside (fixed interest) but face credit risk if property values decline below the loan amount.

  6. 12:37 – 16:01

    Due Diligence and Fund Structure Considerations

    Investors must scrutinize fund structures, such as REITs versus partnerships, and understand liquidity restrictions. The speaker advises checking if returns are pre- or post-fee, the loan-to-value ratios, and the fund's strategy for handling borrower refinancing risks.

Claims worth verifying

Interest income from a conventional lending fund is generally subject to ordinary income tax rates.

Unidentified speaker ·3:41

How to verify: Consult IRS Publication 550 regarding the taxation of interest income and debt instruments.

Holding a loan for several years does not convert regular interest payments into long-term capital gains.

Unidentified speaker ·4:07

How to verify: Review IRS rules on capital gains vs. ordinary income for debt instruments; interest is typically ordinary income regardless of holding period.

California does not follow federal bonus depreciation rules.

Unidentified speaker ·7:33

How to verify: Check California Franchise Tax Board regulations regarding conformity to federal tax laws, specifically regarding bonus depreciation.

Depreciation reduces the tax basis of a property, which can increase taxable gain when the property is sold.

Unidentified speaker ·9:00

How to verify: Review IRS Section 1017 regarding adjustments to basis for depreciation and Section 1250 regarding recapture of depreciation upon sale.

Eligible REIT dividends may qualify for a deduction.

Unidentified speaker ·10:01

How to verify: Consult IRS Section 199A regarding the Qualified Business Income Deduction applicable to REIT dividends.

The speaker's book is titled 'Own Real Estate Not the Headaches'.

Unidentified speaker ·15:06

How to verify: Search Amazon or Audible for the title 'Own Real Estate Not the Headaches' by Vaibhav Puranik.

The speaker's Instagram handle is oldmoneycapital123.

Unidentified speaker ·15:34

How to verify: Search Instagram for the handle @oldmoneycapital123.

The speaker's website is OldMoneyCapital.com.

Unidentified speaker ·15:20

How to verify: Visit OldMoneyCapital.com to verify the domain and content.

Do your own research

  • Verify the specific tax rates (federal and state) applicable to your jurisdiction and income level to replicate the 15% to 9% calculation.
  • Check current California state tax laws regarding conformity to federal bonus depreciation rules for real estate.
  • Review the fund's offering memorandum to determine if returns are pre- or post-fee and understand the loan-to-value ratios.
  • Investigate the fund's structure (REIT vs. partnership) to understand the specific tax treatment of distributions.
  • Assess the fund's liquidity terms and restrictions on principal withdrawal compared to publicly traded securities.
  • Evaluate the borrower's refinancing risk and the fund's strategy for handling potential shortfalls during foreclosure.
  • Consult a tax professional regarding the impact of cost segregation studies on equity investment tax benefits.
Full transcriptexpand
0:04
Unidentified speaker: As interest rates moved higher over the last few years, I started seeing more and more debt funds being offered to investors.
0:14
Unidentified speaker: And some of these funds advertise very attractive returns.
0:20
Unidentified speaker: Imagine someone tells you we have a multifamily debt fund targeting a 15% annual return and the loans are secured by real estate.
0:31
Unidentified speaker: You might think 15% backed by an apartment buildings, and I am on the lending side of the investment.
0:38
Unidentified speaker: That sounds pretty good, right?
0:41
Unidentified speaker: Well, it certainly gets your attention.
0:44
Unidentified speaker: But before you invest, there are a few things you need to understand.
0:51
Unidentified speaker: What is the fund actually lending against?
0:54
Unidentified speaker: How much protection does that collateral provide?
0:57
Unidentified speaker: And especially how much of that 15% will you keep after taxes?
1:05
Unidentified speaker: That last question is what I want to spend most of our time today.
1:12
Unidentified speaker: Let's start with what a debt fund actually does.
1:17
Unidentified speaker: A debt fund pools money from investors and uses that money to make or purchase loans.
1:24
Unidentified speaker: There are many kinds of debt funds.
1:26
Unidentified speaker: Some lend to businesses, some invest in consumer loans.
1:29
Unidentified speaker: Today I'm talking about private real estate debt funds, particularly funds lending to multifamily properties.
1:37
Unidentified speaker: An apartment operator might need financing to buy a property, renovate it, or bridge the period before obtaining a longer-term financing.
1:47
Unidentified speaker: The debt fund provides that financing.
1:50
Unidentified speaker: The borrower agrees to pay interest and repay the loan according to its terms.
1:56
Unidentified speaker: The fund collects income, pays its expenses and management fees, and distributes money to its investors.
2:04
Unidentified speaker: You generally own an interest in the fund.
2:07
Unidentified speaker: The fund in turn owns the loans.
2:10
Unidentified speaker: That is different from investing in an equity syndication that owns the apartment building.
2:16
Unidentified speaker: And that difference affects your risk, your potential upside, and your taxes.
2:21
Unidentified speaker: Now, debt funds do have advantages.
2:26
Unidentified speaker: One is potential for regular income.
2:28
Unidentified speaker: If borrowers make their payments, the fund may distribute cash monthly or quarterly.
2:34
Unidentified speaker: Another is repayment priority.
2:37
Unidentified speaker: Within the same property, a senior lender generally gets paid before the equity investors.
2:43
Unidentified speaker: The owner's equity provides a cushion that can absorb losses before the senior loan is affected.
2:51
Unidentified speaker: A fund can also spread its investments across several loans, borrowers, and properties, thereby reducing the risk.
3:00
Unidentified speaker: And for someone who wants income without managing tenants and overseeing renovations, that can be appealing.
3:09
Unidentified speaker: But the details matter.
3:11
Unidentified speaker: A first mortgage on a conservatively financed property is very different from a junior loan on an aggressive development project.
3:20
Unidentified speaker: The words real estate debt cover a wide range of risks.
3:27
Unidentified speaker: Now let's get into the issue that investors overlook most of the time.
3:34
Unidentified speaker: Taxes.
3:35
Unidentified speaker: For this discussion, assume you are investing through a regular taxable account.
3:41
Unidentified speaker: The income from a conventional lending fund generally comes from interest, and taxable interest is generally subject to ordinary income tax rates.
3:53
Unidentified speaker: Being secured by an apartment building does not automatically give the lender the depreciation deductions available to the building's owner.
4:02
Unidentified speaker: The borrower owns the property, the lender owns a loan.
4:07
Unidentified speaker: Holding that loan for several years also does not turn its regular interest payments into a long-term capital gains.
4:16
Unidentified speaker: So let's put some numbers around this.
4:18
Unidentified speaker: Suppose you invest $100,000 in a multifamily debt fund.
4:24
Unidentified speaker: For our example, assume the fund actually earns and distributes $15,000 to you over the year after its fees.
4:33
Unidentified speaker: That is a 15% cash return before your personal taxes.
4:39
Unidentified speaker: Now assume federal taxes take 30% of that income and California takes another 10%.
5:02
Unidentified speaker: So you receive $15,000, but you kept $9,000 only.
5:08
Unidentified speaker: Your 15% return becomes a 9% return over those assumed taxes.
5:15
Unidentified speaker: This illustrates the point.
5:24
Unidentified speaker: Now, how could an equity investment in an apartment building be different?
5:29
Unidentified speaker: When you invest in a partnership that owns a rental real estate, your share of the property's income and deductions generally flows through to you.
5:38
Unidentified speaker: One of those deductions is depreciation.
5:42
Unidentified speaker: Depreciation allows the owner to deduct the cost of eligible property over time.
5:48
Unidentified speaker: It is a tax deduction that does not require an equivalent cash payment in that year.
5:55
Unidentified speaker: So a property can generate cash while reporting much less taxable income.
6:01
Unidentified speaker: A cost segregation study can accelerate some of these deductions by identifying eligible components of the property that have shorter tax lives than the building itself.
6:12
Unidentified speaker: Depending on the property and the applicable rules, some components may also qualify for bonus depreciation.
6:21
Unidentified speaker: Let's take another hypothetical $100,000 investment, this time in a multifamily equity partnership.
6:31
Unidentified speaker: Suppose your share of rental profit before depreciation is $10,000 and the partnership distributes $10,000 in cash, much less than 15% distributed by the debt fund.
6:46
Unidentified speaker: Now suppose your allocated federal depreciation deduction is $20,000.
6:53
Unidentified speaker: For federal tax purposes, that $10,000 of income becomes a $10,000 rental loss.
7:02
Unidentified speaker: You still receive $10,000 of cash.
7:05
Unidentified speaker: Assuming sufficient tax basis and applicable rules are satisfied, you can have cash in your bank account while reporting a federal rental loss from that investment.
7:18
Unidentified speaker: That is one reason comparing a debt fund's advertised yield with an equity investment's cash distribution can be misleading.
7:28
Unidentified speaker: But because we are using California in this example, we need to go one step further.
7:33
Unidentified speaker: California does not follow the federal bonus depreciation rules.
7:38
Unidentified speaker: So just for illustration, suppose your California depreciation deduction is only $2,000.
7:46
Unidentified speaker: Your $10,000 of rental profit would then leave $8,000 of California taxable income.
7:54
Unidentified speaker: At our assumed 10% state tax rate, that would mean $800 in California tax.
8:03
Unidentified speaker: You would keep $9,200 of your $10,000 cash distribution.
8:09
Unidentified speaker: Compare that with the debt example, where you kept $9,000 from the $15,000 distribution.
8:16
Unidentified speaker: The equity investment paid less cash before taxes, but in this particular equity example, you kept slightly more after current taxes.
8:28
Unidentified speaker: These are the hypothetical numbers chosen to explain the mechanics of it.
8:33
Unidentified speaker: Actual depreciation allocations, distributions, and tax bills will vary.
8:38
Unidentified speaker: And this is a one-year comparison.
8:42
Unidentified speaker: It does not establish which investment will go give you better lifetime return.
8:48
Unidentified speaker: I want to just give you a disclaimer here.
8:51
Unidentified speaker: Depreciation often gives you tax deferral.
8:55
Unidentified speaker: It does not necessarily make the income permanently tax-free.
9:00
Unidentified speaker: It reduces the tax basis, which can increase taxable gain when the property is sold.
9:06
Unidentified speaker: Some depreciation-related gain can be taxed differently from the remaining long-term gain.
9:11
Unidentified speaker: So you need to consider what happens during ownership and what happens at the exit.
9:16
Unidentified speaker: There's also a distinction about risk that is easy to oversimplify.
9:23
Unidentified speaker: Equity investors usually take more risk than senior lenders in the same property.
9:29
Unidentified speaker: They are paid after the lenders, and their capital is typically the first to absorb losses.
9:35
Unidentified speaker: But the tax difference is not simply a reward for accepting more risk.
9:40
Unidentified speaker: It comes from the nature of the investment, interest from lending compared with the property ownership, depreciation deductions, and potential gains when the property is sold.
9:51
Unidentified speaker: And fund structure matters.
9:54
Unidentified speaker: A debt fund organized as an REIT can produce different tax results from partnership passing through interest income.
10:01
Unidentified speaker: Eligible REIT dividends may qualify for a deduction.
10:05
Unidentified speaker: So before investing, ask how the fund expects to report your income.
10:10
Unidentified speaker: Now let's move beyond taxes to another difference, appreciation.
10:15
Unidentified speaker: With a straightforward loan, your expected compensation is agreed interest and repayment of principal.
10:23
Unidentified speaker: Suppose the apartment building performs extremely well.
10:26
Unidentified speaker: The operator improves the property, increases its income, and sells it for substantially more than the purchase price.
10:34
Unidentified speaker: The equity investors may participate in that increase in value.
10:39
Unidentified speaker: The lender generally receives what the loan agreement provides.
10:44
Unidentified speaker: The building becoming much more valuable does not automatically increase the lender's payoff.
10:51
Unidentified speaker: Some debt investments include profit participation on other features.
10:56
Unidentified speaker: Loan values can also change, but ordinary lending generally has a more limited upside than ownership.
11:04
Unidentified speaker: Now, a limited upside would be easier to accept if the original investment were completely safe.
11:11
Unidentified speaker: But debt is not risk-free.
11:15
Unidentified speaker: Let's say an apartment building is valued at $10 million and a fund makes a $7 million senior loan against it.
11:23
Unidentified speaker: At the beginning, there appears to be a $3 million equity cushion.
11:28
Unidentified speaker: Now imagine the property gets into trouble and can only be sold for $6 million.
11:34
Unidentified speaker: There's a $7 million loan, but only $6 million of property value available to support repayment.
11:42
Unidentified speaker: Even before selling expenses, legal fees, other costs, there is a shortfall.
12:00
Unidentified speaker: And a foreclosure can take time.
12:02
Unidentified speaker: During that period, interest payments may stop, expenses may continue, and investors may have to wait for their money.
12:10
Unidentified speaker: Even without such a large decline in value, a borrower can struggle to refinance when the loan matures.
12:19
Unidentified speaker: There are also risks at the fund level.
12:22
Unidentified speaker: The fund may borrow money itself, concentrate its loans in one market, or limit investor withdrawals.
12:29
Unidentified speaker: Regular distributions do not necessarily mean you can withdraw your principal whenever you want.
12:37
Unidentified speaker: So when you see a 15% target, spend some time understanding how the fund expects to earn it.
12:45
Unidentified speaker: Is that number before or after fees?
12:48
Unidentified speaker: Is it cash yield or a projected total return?
12:51
Unidentified speaker: Is the fund making senior loans or taking more junior position?
12:55
Unidentified speaker: How much is being lent relative to property's value?
12:59
Unidentified speaker: And what would happen if the borrower could not refinance?
13:03
Unidentified speaker: A target return is a projection.
13:06
Unidentified speaker: Your actual return depends on loans performing and the fund managing them well.
13:13
Unidentified speaker: Does all of this mean you should never invest in a debt fund?
13:16
Unidentified speaker: Of course not.
13:18
Unidentified speaker: Debt can have a useful role in your portfolio.
13:22
Unidentified speaker: You may value current income, contractual payments, and a position ahead of equity in the repayment order.
13:29
Unidentified speaker: You may be comfortable exchanging some potential appreciation for these features, but evaluate the actual trade-off.
13:37
Unidentified speaker: Understand the credit risk, understand the withdrawal terms, and calculate what you expect to keep after taxes.
13:45
Unidentified speaker: In a taxable event, ordinary interest income can face a larger current tax bill than a cash distribution from a real estate equity investment supported by depreciation deductions.
13:58
Unidentified speaker: That difference can be substantial.
14:01
Unidentified speaker: A 15% headline deserves a closer look when your spendable return may be closer to 9% under assumptions we discussed.
14:12
Unidentified speaker: And an equity investment deserves an equally careful look at the operating risk, tax limitations, and eventual sale taxes.
14:20
Unidentified speaker: But before committing money, take the funds tax information to your CPA and work through the comparison for your own situation.
14:30
Unidentified speaker: Again, don't trust me or do something solely based on this podcast episode.
14:36
Unidentified speaker: It is very important to consult the relevant professionals.
14:41
Unidentified speaker: That is how you make a decision based on the return you can actually use.
14:48
Unidentified speaker: If you would like to understand multifamily syndications in more detail, how they work, how to evaluate sponsors, what due diligence to perform, and how to use modern AI tools to help with the process, please check out my book, Own Real Estate Not the Headaches.
15:06
Unidentified speaker: It's available in paperback, hardcover, Kindle ebook, and audiobook formats on Amazon.
15:12
Unidentified speaker: Search for Own Real Estate Not the Headaches by Vaibau Puranik on Amazon or find the audiobook on Audible.
15:20
Unidentified speaker: You can also visit OldMoneyCapital.com where we share educational articles and case studies.
15:27
Unidentified speaker: Click a request a call button to schedule a conversation with me or another member of our team.
15:34
Unidentified speaker: And if you haven't already, subscribe to our YouTube channel OldMoney Capital and follow us on Instagram at oldmoneycapital123.
15:46
Unidentified speaker: If you found this episode useful, please share it with someone who is evaluating the telephone.
15:53
Unidentified speaker: This is the OMC Real Estate Podcast.
15:55
Unidentified speaker: My name is Bhalibaba Purani, and thank you very much for listening.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-GGUF:UD-Q4_K_XL. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights