Mercia Podcast

Welsh Budget sets tax rates to mirror England; Milburn review targets youth employment with targeted NI relief

20 min Listen to the original Episode page
Welsh BudgetYouth EmploymentNational InsuranceMinimum WageTax DevolutionPublic Policy

Summary

Mark Morton outlines the Welsh draft budget for 2027/28, noting that devolved property and savings income tax rates will mirror UK defaults, resulting in no effective change for Welsh taxpayers relative to England. He also covers the Alan Milburn review on youth employment, which proposes targeted National Insurance support for 21-24 year olds in retail and hospitality by doubling the NI threshold to £10,000. The review rejects broad NI cuts, citing that previous hikes raised £20 billion for health services. Additionally, the government is backing away from eliminating the 18-20 minimum wage rate and increasing one-off apprentice hiring payments to £2,500. Morton critiques these measures as insufficient and reactive, calling for a broader political reset.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    The proposed NI relief targets 21-24 year olds in retail and hospitality, doubling the NI threshold to £10,000, a move the speaker views as a 'glide path' rather than a comprehensive solution.

    Mark Morden · 12:54

Episode sections

  1. 0:15 – 4:41

    Welsh Budget Draft and Tax Deviation

    Mark Morton discusses the Welsh draft budget, noting that while Wales has limited tax devolution compared to Scotland, it is devolving property and savings income tax rates. The Welsh government has chosen to maintain the same effective tax rates as England and Northern Ireland for the 2027/28 tax year by setting the devolved rates to match UK defaults.

  2. 4:41 – 5:12

    Land Transaction and Landfill Tax Changes

    The Welsh government will keep Land Transaction Tax rates unchanged for 2027/28 but will increase the rate for Landfill Disposals Tax. These changes are part of the devolved powers currently in the draft budget awaiting parliamentary process.

  3. 5:12 – 7:03

    Alan Milburn Review on Youth Employment (NEETs)

    Morton covers Alan Milburn's review on young people not in education, employment, or training (NEETs). He highlights a business leader's critique that government intervention is reactive, likening it to a fire brigade responding to a fire started by previous policies. Morton suggests the issue is societal rather than purely mechanical.

  4. 7:03 – 11:43

    Funding Challenges and Political Reset

    Morton reflects on the broader debate about funding these initiatives, suggesting a shift towards cutting benefits or finding savings in existing departmental budgets. He draws a parallel to the 'Thatcher moment,' arguing that a significant political reset is needed to address societal shifts in welfare dependency and recruitment confidence.

  5. 11:43 – 14:44

    Proposed Targeted Employer NI Support

    Milburn proposes targeted National Insurance support for workers aged 21 to 24, starting with the retail and hospitality sectors. The proposal includes doubling the NI starting point from £5,000 to £10,000 for this demographic, rather than a broad reduction in NI rates.

  6. 14:44 – 19:45

    Minimum Wage and Apprenticeship Grants

    The speaker notes the government is backing away from the manifesto commitment to eliminate the 18-20 minimum wage rate due to negative consequences. He also discusses proposed increases to one-off apprentice hiring payments (£2,000 to £2,500) and provider incentives, criticizing them as insufficient one-off subsidies.

Claims worth verifying

The Welsh government has devolved property and savings income tax rates and will maintain the same effective rates as England and Northern Ireland for 2027/28.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·3:42

How to verify: Check the Welsh Government's draft budget publication for 2026/28 and the Finance Act 2026 provisions regarding devolved tax rates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The Welsh government will increase the rate for Landfill Disposals Tax in 2027/28 but keep Land Transaction Tax rates unchanged.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·4:41

How to verify: Review the Welsh Government's draft budget documents for 2026/28 regarding devolved taxes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Alan Milburn's review proposes doubling the National Insurance starting point from £5,000 to £10,000 for workers aged 21-24 in retail and hospitality.

Mark Morden ·12:35

How to verify: Search for Alan Milburn's report on NEETs and the UK government's response or consultation documents on National Insurance thresholds. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The minimum wage for 18-20 year olds increased by 65% over five years.

Mark Morden ·11:15

How to verify: Check UK Government minimum wage rate history tables published by GOV.UK or the Department for Business and Trade. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The previous government's National Insurance increases raised £20 billion for the health service.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·12:02

How to verify: Review UK Treasury spending reviews or Budget Reports from the previous administration detailing NI revenue and health service funding allocations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

A £2,000 one-off hiring payment exists for recruiting new apprentices aged 16-24, with a proposal to increase it to £2,500.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·16:46

How to verify: Search for UK government press releases or guidance on the 'Apprenticeship Incentive' or 'Hiring Payment' schemes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the Welsh Government's 2027/28 Draft Budget publication for official tax rate settings.
  • Check the Alan Milburn Review on NEETs for detailed recommendations on youth employment.
  • Review UK HMRC data on National Insurance revenue contributions from previous hikes.
  • Analyze ONS data on youth unemployment rates in retail and hospitality sectors.
  • Compare current apprentice hiring payment rates against previous years.
  • Assess the impact of the 18-20 minimum wage rate on employer hiring decisions.
  • Review UK Treasury statements on the £20 billion health service funding from NI hikes.
  • Check for any subsequent parliamentary votes or amendments to the Welsh Budget draft.
Full transcriptexpand

0:02Mark Morden: Hello, welcome to this podcast. My name is Mark Morden, and yeah, it's looking a bit dark outside now, and it's only four o'clock, so I'm starting down that slippery slope. It's all feeling a bit grim.

0:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Just

0:15Mark Morden: a couple of things to keep you informed of, I suppose, this week. One is the Welsh budget. It's all very exciting if you're Welsh. It was interesting. I was lecturing in Shrewsbury in the week, obviously. you're not a million miles away from Wales.

0:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

0:30Mark Morden: I merely said, What is the special day today for tax purposes? And nobody knew. So it would appear that the Welsh budget doesn't have quite the traction of the UK budget generally. Devolution tax-wise in Wales is fairly limited, somewhat more limited than Scotland.

0:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There

0:49Mark Morden: was a comment in PMK. PMQs this week alluding to more sort of devolutionary powers for Wales. So quite what we will see. I think probably the same is on the cards for Scotland. So quite how that will filter down into the tax system. We shall see. However, this Welsh budget, which is uh draft budget, I should say, which has been issued. has a couple of or one particularly slightly different thing. So you will know that the previous Chancellor, whoever she was, she decided that if you have property income or savings income, we don't like you too much and will increase the rate of tax compared to other forms of income. That was a two p increase across the board, so 22, 42, etc. The new guys come in, see no particular comment about the previous. chancellor at all, and say, I really don't like you, let's make it 24 or 44 and so on and so forth. Now, with property income, I can sort of justify in my own mind to some extent. If you live off property income,

1:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): then

1:52Mark Morden: you're not paying any national insurance. I mean, that is living off property income is completely different to having one rental property and so on and so forth. But I can sort of in my own mind say,

2:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if

2:02Mark Morden: you have significant property portfolio, then you pay some sort of equivalent to national insurance. Savings income, the idea that you save hard, generate some interest, and then lose a quarter of it back to the state out of your already earned income, of course.

2:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm

2:18Mark Morden: not so sure about. But anyway, as part of that process, what happened in last year's Finance Act 26, the facility. was given for the Welsh and Scottish governments to devolve the rates of property taxation to their own governments. Now, what we've seen this week from Wales, it would appear that the Welsh government is actually doing that. Wales is a more limited form of devolution than Scotland. So, in terms of the main income tax rates and now the property. savings rates, what happens here is you start with the UK rates. So if we take basic rate of 20 for as an example,

3:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there

3:00Mark Morden: is a default position where you deduct 10p, and then the Welsh government votes to put on XP. Now, what the Welsh government have done since this came in 2019 in terms of main income tax rates is vote back 10p. So the prospect Welsh taxpayers are paying the same rates as English taxpayers and Northern Irish taxpayers, but not Scotland, of course. What has happened here? A similar process now applies for 27-8. So the Welsh Government are saying, okay, devolve those property savings rate or property tax rates to us by the sound of it. But what they have decided to do, so the system is the same: 24 minus ten, 10, what do you want to add back on? And they've chosen 10 again.

3:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So, of

3:42Mark Morden: course, the practical effect for 27.8 is that both for the main income tax rates and now the property rates, Welsh taxpayers will carry on paying the same rates of income tax as people in England and Northern Ireland. Thrill a minute, of course. I've already mentioned Scotland. Similar principle implies in Scotland, the Scottish budget is in December, or draft budget is in December. Obviously, in Scotland, as we know, there is more devolution. Those of you that have Scottish clients will know that six rates of tax apparently are much simpler than three. So devolution there is somewhat more complicated. Whether they will choose to devolve the property tax rates, and of course, if they do, whether they will follow the income tax strategy of six bands,

4:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

4:26Mark Morden: would hope that. they would if they're going to do something, 'cause my good night, you know. If they introduce a separate system for property tax, I'll have to retire because I won't work be able to work out a Scottish taxpayers' tax bill anymore. But we will see. But there may be something similar, so we'll keep you informed with Scotland.

4:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A

4:41Mark Morden: couple of other things that the Welsh Government have devolved the land transaction tax rate, broadly the equivalent of SDLT. They have said for twenty 278 seven eight they're there going are to be no changes in that system. However, for landfill disposals tax, they are increasing the rate as a government. So they are the bits of devolution that apply to Wales in terms of the tax system and the comments that have been made so far, yet to go through a parliamentary process, but they are the statements of the government at the moment.

5:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

5:12Mark Morden: other thing I was interested in, certainly this week, and it's had some press, you know, a bit of leaking going on again, was the whole thing about NEETs. And I think if you look at what Alan Milburn has done, it's a laudable aim of you know, we've got to do something about young people not getting into the jobs market and address the reasons behind that.

5:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There

5:34Mark Morden: was an interesting comment from a business leader I was listening to though this week that said this is a bit like. the fire brigade turning up to put out a fire that you started. And his point, and I I will try and keep away from the more general issues about niche. You know, my personal feeling is

5:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that

5:51Mark Morden: this is much more of a societal issue

5:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): than

5:54Mark Morden: it is a mechanical issue. And that the same applies to welfare in general terms, that somehow in my working life we've shifted. from a you know welfare is an extreme thing to help you in extreme circumstances and actually you try to avoid claiming it to a situation where the view has changed and what are you going to do for me as opposed to help yourself, possibly a little bit. Now it's a very big generalization, but all I'm trying to get at, there's a big societal issue behind it. It almost feels to me like a bit of a Mrs. Thatcher moment in the sense that. the country needs a reset in all sorts of ways. And those of you who are old enough like me to remember Mrs. Thatcher, people still have very strong views on whether she was, you know, saviour or the devil ultimately. But there's not much in between because she said what she wanted to do and she proceeded to do it. Now you may have then liked the consequence of that, you may not, but at least you know, and you know, it's not like we've had somebody with. that view of life in terms of this is my view, I'm going to do it for so long, and it almost feels like we need a bit of a reset. But anyway, we'll see. I don't think we're going to get that reset in the near future.

7:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

7:03Mark Morden: other thing which is quite interesting, I think, in a general sense, tax-wise, budgetary, etc., is this like so many things, is laying open the general. debate about ah, but it's going to cost money. So how are we going to fund it? And it's laying open that general debate of more taxes or cut something. And you can, if you talk to people about this, like I do from time to time, you can feel almost that shift coming now. I've got taxes coming out my ears, cut some benefits. I can almost feel that coming out, but you'll see it in this area where there is some suggestion that the government are going to gently start to say, here's a job, but if you don't take it, you might lose some money. It's not a big stick, let's say, some of this. It's a more of a we want to help you first before we, you know, actually take more serious consequences. In terms of the

7:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

8:00Mark Morden: suppose tax system,

8:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

8:02Mark Morden: the the the three main issues for me of recent times, and you can't say all of this is a new issue. There's clearly a hangover from the pandemic. There's the societal issue that this issue has been sort of creeping up over the years anyway. It's something I'm very passionate about is the university system, personally. A university was unusual when I was young, out of my me and my six friends, only I went, which is not to say I was, you know, any great shapes, but all I'm trying to illustrate is it was unusual. Some left at 16, went to work, etc. You're almost seeing again the unraveling of the university system. So, what is the point of a degree if you're not careful? But getting on that ladder of work in the last certainly term of this parliament has been hit very hard, as we know, by increases in national insurance rates and the cut in the threshold, big jumps in minimum wage. at the same time, and then I think significant fear of what is coming in terms of employment law changes. And as we all know, businesses react to these things when it's dropped on them unexpectedly. I think the interesting thing at the moment is really part of what this report is about.

9:11The consequences of those things don't seem to have been mass redundancies. You know, you've not seen huge layoffs. But what you are seeing, of course, is lack of recruitment. You're seeing somebody retires, you don't replace them, and so on and so forth, business accommodating those costs. And my real question: there are suggested changes to the tax system that I'll come on to, whether they are enough to a unravel what a has happened in the last two and a half years, but b then give businesses the confidence to say it won't change again. And when we're looking at this, in we're virtually halfway through this parliament already, even if you implemented all this stuff today, would you see the outcome

9:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): by

9:57Mark Morden: the time of the next election?

10:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

10:00Mark Morden: we'll see what happens. One of the issues in terms of funding seemed to be suggested by the Prime Minister this week that actually he wants to get on with the start of this, although it's a 10-year plan. You'll hear 10 year plans a lot, but he wants to get on with this. But in terms of funding and that debate over taxation, he is asking existing departments to find even more savings. And of course, what you're starting to get into there, if that reflects in poor service,

10:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): must.

10:26Mark Morden: much as I hate the term austerity, because it wasn't a term that politicians used initially, it was a reflection under George Osborne, David Cameron, that financially we're in a bad place. What are we going to do? Primarily increase taxes or primarily cut costs? And it was the latter that got Bachelor's austerity. And I think you can almost feel that coming again. We'll try and manipulate some money out of existing budgets. but that will, of course, will leave those departments that much worse off again.

10:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But

10:55Mark Morden: you can see that basic public debate playing out in roundabout ways. Interesting comments by Alan Milburn. He specifically raises these points, having talked to employers, the fact that minimum wage has increased by you know for eighteen 18 to twenties 20s has gone up sixty 65% five percent. over five years, is a bit of a hammer blow in terms of employment, national insurance and employment rights. And he makes this comment, he says, I've looked carefully at employer NI. Employees have consistently told me that higher payroll costs have made recruitment more difficult. Or that there are some, again, almost backhanded criticisms of predecessor. judgments, let's say. Answers to this, he is not suggesting a reduction in national insurance. And the problem with that, of course, that the big jumps in national insurance raised 20 billion quid, but that was broadly spent on the health service. So you can't just reverse it without finding 20 billion quid from somewhere, which causes its own problems. So what he is suggesting,

12:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): he's

12:02Mark Morden: he says, rather than try and unravel it, which would cost a huge amount of money, what we are going to do, he says, I would propose a different course, targeted support now, which is the point I was making about finding that money out of existing budgets from various departments, followed by a five-year Five year glide path. Glide path to me is a downward. trajectory. But anyway, I kinda get what it means. To lower national insurance for workers aged 21 to 24.

12:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now

12:35Mark Morden: that in its own right when you read it, so what about 18 to 20s then? Why 21 to 24? Businesses need confidence that the government's ambition is to reduce, not continually increase, the cost of employing a young person. Go back to what I said earlier. But again, what where what would we do in terms of that glide path? So the first suggestion is we target retail and hospitality sectors as a starting point. So this may be what you're seeing next year. And for twenty one to twenty-four year olds, we would double the starting point for NI from 5,000 to 10,000.

13:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I don't

13:14Mark Morden: know if anybody remembers the you know, we're going back a stage here, but again, very targeted. Quite how many people, because I think you know you will know well as I, it's not just retail and hospitality that are feeling the consequences in terms of should we recruit, should we not? So again, quite what effect that will have in the short term, but I think what you mean. may be seeing is that come through for the next tax year. I suspect at the minute it's not going to come through any quicker, but that may be something just to keep an eye on, that we sort of have a differential starting point for NI based on business sector. Other things that he talks about in this report, I mean bear in mind there is already r national insurance relief for under 21s twenty ones and under 25s twenty-fives for the first year of year their employment.

14:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now

14:04Mark Morden: broadly, if they don't earn more than fifty grand, then there's no employer's NI. Of course the problem with that, that is a one off, whatever you want to call it, subsidy, because it's a twelve month issue. It's not a permanent. And of course the the costs that have come in over recent years are permanent per employee. I'm not sure that the existing reliefs really ultimately have a great deal of effect on should I employ somebody else or not, ultimately. He does make the point that there's a lack of understanding regarding these. But again, uh, the tax system is complex. I think the fundamental point, they're not making a big difference. Minimum wage, the point about minimum wage, and I d now you know those of you that have heard me lecture over the summer, the finance. Act, I think it was self evident. We know, particularly eighteen to twenty one year olds, there's been a massive increase in that bracket, go back, you know, sixty-five percent over five years, which which cannot help in this conundrum. Now, part of what's gone under this government was a manifesto commitment commitment to say we want to essentially get rid of the eighteen 18 to twenty 20 rate, we want to make that into the full rate. So what you've seen, these big increases, certainly in the last two years, have been part and parcel of saying we've got we want to get rid of that band. Of course,

15:23the fundamental reason that band is there, and actually it used to be when minimum wage came in, it was 18 to 25 year olds, was to reflect what other countries do to say, look, from an employer's perspective, if I've got an 18 year old straight from school who knows nothing, and a 26 year old applying for the same job who's got eight years of experience, who am I going to take? You don't want to get into that conundrum because that will have you know a disincentivising effect as well. I think the long and short of it is the government are essentially backing away from this commitment to have one minimum wage rate, essentially for eighteens eighteen onwards, within this parliament, because that has caused consequences and they have not. been positive. And you'll see it going forward to twenty seven, you look at the rates announced there, three point nine percent, which is more than most private sector pay rises, but even what you haven't got is the eight, sixteen percent increase in that eighteen to twenty bracket trying to level the playing field. So you're already seeing the government sort of back away. The pr the problem is, of course, those previous two years, five years rises riser are built in. again. So the costs have gone up ultimately, and there's no suggestion of unraveling them ultimately. The other point the government are making here is actually maybe further government grants. So there are some

16:42grant systems around

16:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): been

16:46Mark Morden: suggested, you know, there's a £2,000 one-off hiring payment if you recruit. new apprentices aged 16 to 24. And that's a a fairly recent thing from October of this year. The suggestion here we should increase it

17:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to

17:00Mark Morden: £2,500. Alongside this, there should be a new £2,000 incentive for the provider. That's all well and good, but what's that? That's A maximum of four and a half thousand pounds. That's a one-off subsidy again. That isn't helping in year two, year three, etc. It's a very laudable aim, what Mr. Milburn is trying to address. Uh clearly it's complex, but I think from a tax perspective, if you accept that some of the issue here are the three things that I mentioned to start with, you are not, in my mind, making really big dints in any of them. I mean, employment rights, no, no you U-turn two. on

17:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that.

17:41Mark Morden: What what impact is this going to have on business? I suspect as it stands, my feeling is these suggestions within the tax system are negligible. And it we go back to where we started. Yes, there should be jobs for all young kids, and yes, you know, if they don't take them, maybe there are consequences within the state benefit system. But where are those jobs going to be created? from? Because if you look at the private sector, I don't think these changes in the tax system that are being suggested is suddenly going to lead to a mass of vacancies in the next 18 months, two years. It just doesn't feel like enough. And maybe ultimately there is a bit of that disconnect that becomes a broader political issue between the political class of professional politicians and people who've who run businesses. Maybe there is that. disconnect that a lot of them don't really understand what the sticking point here for businesses is on top of energy costs going up for their shop, on top of all the other things, cost of living, that you know, we as individuals are suffering from. So anyway, bear in mind that this is a proposition to the government. It could be, of course, the government turn around and say, oh, this is not enough. Let's do even more. Um, maybe I'm too old and cynical. I would be surprised if that's the case. Uh, this seems to be the maximum set of proposals. But keep an eye on the tax system,

19:00obviously, we will um already updating tax cards for the Welsh budget. Uh, we'll keep an eye on these figures going forward. Um, obviously, uh, Finance Act will cover all of this as well. So if you've not ordered your tax cards. for next April, plenty of changes to try and explain to clients, including the great personal tax allowance for the old age pensioner, which good luck on explaining that. We'll keep you up to date with further changes before Christmas and in particular the Scottish budget. Take care everyone. Bye.

19:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): For

19:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): information on this topic, please visit mercia hyphengroup.com.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights