The Multifamily Dispatch

Midterm election shifts, rent growth recovery, and refinancing risks in multifamily real estate

49 min Listen to the original Episode page
Multifamily Real EstateInterest RatesRefinancing RiskRent GrowthPolitical RiskImmigrationSupply and Demand

Summary

Hosts Matt Bastnagel and Nick McCracken analyze the impact of Democratic midterm gains on real estate policy, including potential rent control and zoning changes. They review October 2026 data showing positive year-over-year rent growth for the first time in three years, though regional disparities remain significant. The discussion highlights a structural mismatch between housing demand and supply, driven by near-zero immigration and high interest rates. Speakers also examine refinancing risks, noting a 165 basis point spread between maturing and new loan rates, and debate whether the market faces oversupply or undersupply.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    CoStar data shows Pacific region rent growth at 2.6% and Northeast at 2.4%, while the South lags at 0.4% and Mountain at 0.2%, highlighting significant regional divergence in multifamily performance.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 18:14

Episode sections

  1. 0:05 – 3:38

    Introduction and Election Results

    Hosts Matt Bastnagel and Nick McCracken introduce the episode, noting the historic Democratic wave in the midterm elections where Democrats gained significant seats in the House and Senate. They briefly discuss the political landscape before transitioning to market analysis.

  2. 3:38 – 12:40

    Political Implications for Real Estate and AI

    The hosts speculate on how Democratic control may impact real estate, discussing potential rent control, zoning reforms, and the difficulty of building data centers in states like Texas and Ohio due to political shifts. They also touch on the potential slowdown in AI capital expenditures.

  3. 12:40 – 16:47

    Immigration and Tariffs

    Discussion shifts to immigration's role in population growth and housing demand, followed by a debate on tariffs. Nick McCracken argues tariffs will likely remain as a revenue source despite economic criticism, while Matt Bastnagel expresses skepticism about major legislative changes due to gridlock.

  4. 16:47 – 21:51

    Apartment Market Performance (CoStar and Apartment List)

    The hosts review October 2026 data from CoStar and Apartment List, highlighting that year-over-year rent growth has turned positive for the first time in three years. They analyze regional disparities, noting strong performance in Pacific markets like San Jose and weaker performance in the South.

  5. 21:51 – 27:15

    Investment Strategy and JP Morgan Report

    Nick McCracken advises that national rent growth is insufficient for required returns, suggesting investors focus on local mispricing and value-add opportunities. The segment concludes with an introduction to a JP Morgan report titled 'Haunted Housing,' which discusses the complex mix of monetary policy, tariffs, and immigration affecting residential real estate.

  6. 27:15 – 29:47

    Immigration and Housing Demand Mismatch

    Speaker_0 cites David Kelly to argue that US population growth has dropped to 800,000 annually from a 2000-2020 average of 2.4 million, with immigration near zero due to deportations offsetting legal immigration. This results in a calculated demand for only 320,000 new housing units, contrasting sharply with the 1.24 million units expected to be built in 2027.

  7. 29:47 – 32:03

    J.P. Morgan Outlook on Residential Real Estate

    Nick McCracken quotes J.P. Morgan's 'Haunted Housing' report, which suggests that after a bad year in bonds, high-quality fixed income may offer stable returns. The report notes regional housing growth opportunities despite a sluggish national market, while many homeowners face financial challenges.

  8. 32:03 – 33:14

    Builder Behavior and Interest Rate Sensitivity

    Speaker_0 contrasts builder behavior during the pandemic, when high material costs did not stop construction, with the current environment where rising interest rates have caused builders to worry despite resolved supply chain issues. The discussion highlights that financing costs now drive construction activity more than physical constraints.

  9. 33:14 – 35:33

    Harvard JCHS on Immigration and Renter Growth

    Speaker_0 discusses a Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies report stating that recent immigrants are the primary drivers of renter household growth. In 2024, 571,000 net new renter households were formed by immigrants arriving since 2022, offsetting a loss of 230,000 households headed by immigrants who arrived before 2015.

  10. 35:33 – 37:54

    Housing Supply vs. Affordability Narrative

    Nick McCracken and Speaker_0 debate whether the US faces a housing oversupply or undersupply. McCracken argues that while national supply is low, many growth pockets are shrinking rural areas or high-cost regions like the Bay Area. Speaker_0 suggests the 'undersupply' narrative is more dominant because housing is immobile and cannot easily move to where demand exists.

  11. 37:54 – 39:40

    Newmark Report on Multifamily Refinancing Costs

    Nick McCracken summarizes a Newmark article stating that US multifamily borrowers face 41% higher interest costs as loans mature. Loans maturing in Q3 2026 averaged 4.04% interest, while new loans averaged 5.69%, creating a 165 basis point gap. This negative leverage has persisted since Q1 2022, ending 12 years of positive leverage.

  12. 39:40 – 43:02

    Sentiment Shift and Debt Maturity Risks

    Speaker_0 notes a shift in investor sentiment from optimism to pessimism regarding the multifamily market. Newmark data indicates 81% of securitized multifamily debt maturing before 2029 carries rates below 5%, and 39% of properties sold traded below their inflation-adjusted purchase price from end of 2021.

  13. 43:02 – 49:25

    CBRE on Higher-for-Longer Rates

    Nick McCracken discusses a CBRE article on 'Higher-for-Longer' rates, noting that treasury yields are rising due to uncertainty and potential flight to safety. The article argues that cap rates must increase to adjust for these rates, contradicting investor hopes that rates will return to 2-3% levels.

Claims worth verifying

Democrats gained from 214 to a projected 255-259 House seats and from 47 to 56 Senate seats in the midterm elections.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·1:23

How to verify: Official results from the U.S. House of Representatives and U.S. Senate for the 2026 elections. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In 2010, Republicans gained 63 House seats amid the Tea Party movement.

Nick McCracken ·2:13

How to verify: Historical election data from the U.S. House of Clerk or official congressional records. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Apartment List reported year-over-year rent growth of 0.1% in October 2026, the first positive growth in three years.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·17:27

How to verify: Apartment List 'October 2026 Rent Report' (https://www.apartmentlist.com/research/national-rent-data). For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

CoStar reported year-over-year rent growth of 1.6% and occupancy of 92.1% in October 2026.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·17:46

How to verify: CoStar 'October 2026 Multifamily Rent Growth Report' (https://www.costargroup.com/press-room/2026/apartmentscom-releases-multifamily-rent-growth-report-october-2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Pacific region rent growth was 2.6% and the South was 0.4% according to CoStar.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·18:14

How to verify: CoStar 'October 2026 Multifamily Rent Growth Report' regional breakdowns. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Boise, Idaho rent growth was 8.4% and Lansing, Michigan was 5.6% according to Apartment List.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·20:42

How to verify: Apartment List 'October 2026 Rent Report' top market listings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

David Kelly is the Chief Global Economist at JP Morgan.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·25:48

How to verify: JP Morgan official staff directory or the byline of the 'Haunted Housing' report. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The 'Road Act' was a bipartisan housing bill passed before the midterms focusing on single-family housing ownership.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·10:24

How to verify: U.S. Congress legislative records for the 'Road Act' or related housing legislation passed in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Six DSA candidates were elected in reliably blue congressional districts in NY, CO, CA, MI, and PA.

Nick McCracken ·11:04

How to verify: Election results and candidate affiliation records for the 2026 midterm elections in those states. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Population growth from 2000 to 2020 was on average 2.4 million a year, and right now we're at 800,000, one-third of the growth that we had a couple of decades ago.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·27:15

How to verify: Check US Census Bureau population estimates for 2000-2020 and recent annual estimates for 2026/2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Immigration went from an average of 900,000 in the years between 2000 and 2020 to essentially zero today.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·27:15

How to verify: Review US Department of Homeland Security Yearbook of Immigration Statistics for 2000-2020 and recent DHS data for 2026/2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

David Kelly contrasts that with the 1.24 2-4 million of new housing units expected to be built in 2027.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·29:11

How to verify: Search for David Kelly's housing forecasts or US Census Bureau Housing Starts and Completures data for 2027 projections. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In 2024, at the tail end of the surge in immigration. there were 571,000 net new renter households formed by immigrants who entered the country since 2022.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·33:33

How to verify: Access the Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies report 'Immigration Slowdown Poised to Sharply Reduce Renter Household Growth' and verify the 571,000 figure. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The gain from recent immigration is offset by net loss of 230,000 renter households headed by immigrants. who arrive before 2015.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·33:53

How to verify: Access the Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies report and verify the 230,000 net loss figure for pre-2015 immigrants. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Loans maturing in the third quarter of 2026 averaged an interest rate of 4.04% compared with 5.69% on new loans.

Nick McCracken ·38:13

How to verify: Access the Newmark article 'U.S. Multifamily Borrowers Face 41% Higher Interest Costs as Loans Mature' and verify the 4.04% and 5.69% figures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Refinancing at the higher uh you know rate in Q3 would raise interest cost. costs by about 41% on the same loan balance.

Nick McCracken ·38:33

How to verify: Calculate the percentage increase from 4.04% to 5.69% or verify the 41% figure in the Newmark article. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

39 percent of properties sold traded below their previous inflation adjusted purchase price up six percent from the end of twenty 2021.

Nick McCracken ·40:51

How to verify: Verify the 39% figure in the Newmark article regarding properties trading below inflation-adjusted purchase prices. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

$116 billion of multifamily loans are scheduled to mature by the end of 27 and nearly 250 billion through 2028.

Nick McCracken ·46:10

How to verify: Access the Yardi Matrix maturing debt bulletin and verify the $116 billion and $250 billion maturity figures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Roughly eight percent [of maturing loans] have low debt service coverage ratios or high loan to value ratios... if your DSCR is less than point six or if your LTV is above eighty-five.

Nick McCracken ·46:30

How to verify: Access the Yardi Matrix article and verify the 8% figure and the DSCR < 0.6 / LTV > 85% thresholds. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Do your own research

  • Verify CoStar and Apartment List October 2026 rent growth reports for regional and national data.
  • Review J.P. Morgan's 'Haunted Housing' report for analysis on monetary policy, tariffs, and immigration impacts.
  • Check Newmark data on multifamily loan maturity spreads and refinancing costs for Q3 2026.
  • Analyze Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies data on immigrant-driven renter household formation.
  • Assess CBRE reports on 'Higher-for-Longer' interest rate scenarios and cap rate adjustments.
  • Investigate local zoning laws and rent control proposals in jurisdictions with DSA representation.
  • Compare builder construction starts against interest rate trends to assess sensitivity to financing costs.
  • Review government immigration data releases to assess the accuracy of net migration figures.
Full transcriptexpand
0:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Welcome
0:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to the multifamily dispatch. Election day has come and gone and a whirlwind of political change, but the housing market is just as exciting. And there's some potential storms brewing for the single family and multifamily markets. Loan maturities, distress, demographic shifts, but then there's some sunlight peeking through the clouds as apartment performance is better than it's been for three years. I'm Matt
0:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Bosnagle, director of marketing. and Research at JG Companies. And today I'm joined by Nick McCracken, Director of Acquisitions at J and G. CEO Dan Gable is out this week, but it's always an excellent time when Nick McCracken is here. Nick, how are you feeling this week?
0:38
Nick McCracken: Matt, it's uh it's always good to be the understudy of Dan Gable and and get to uh come in when he's out and good to be back on the pod. Um, you know, I've got to say with the midterm elections, we've done quarterly reporting for our investors. Um we're running due diligence on uh our newest investment opportunity. And uh it's it's good to sit down and catch my breath for a minute. I'm I'm a
0:58
Nick McCracken: little winded. So
0:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah, yeah, I bet so. Yeah. Uh and you know, Nick, I bet we could also spend a good hour and a half speculating on the social, economic, and foreign policy implications of the recent e elections, and maybe even longer, because the less I have to say something, the more time it takes for me to say it. Um but before we get into some of the really interesting housing and multifamily reports this week,
1:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): um maybe we can share some brief takes on the recent election.
1:22
Nick McCracken: Yeah, let's do it.
1:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. So um just to summarize, yes, it was a historic wave election. Democrats went from 214 house seats to a projected 259, or maybe it's 256, maybe it's 255. two fifty-five. It's a lot, okay. We'll have to wait for those numbers to come in. And in the Senate, they went from 47 to maybe a projected 56, which may change a little again by
1:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the time we release this, but those are the numbers we're working with right now. Um I'm not gonna you're you're not gonna call your election officials or anything or schedule a recount right now because uh this is not the podcast of record, fortunately.
1:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right, right.
1:55
Nick McCracken: And what are we what are we really waiting on? Are we waiting on Alaska and a handful of others?
1:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
1:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): think Mississippi maybe too. Okay. Um and there there may be some others. as well in terms of like the house seats and stuff. But interesting. I know that uh Mississippi doesn't have a provision for a recount if it's really close. So oh, they'll just fight about it in the courts for maybe in the next year and a half. That's fun.
2:13
Nick McCracken: Great.
2:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Um for some context though, just to uh just kind of put this into context about how historic it may be. Um in 2010, Republicans gained 63 house seats amid the Tea Party movement, and in 2014. Republicans gained nine seats in the Senate. Those previous election waves aren't a perfect comparison because contr
2:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): congressional maps differ from year to year. Um, and there was a different mix of incumbents on the Senate map in 2014. But my point here is that it's an historic election, uh, maybe not a once-in-a-lifetime election, but still really historic. Um, interestingly enough, that 2014 map is the same like states were up for Senate as it is this year.
2:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It was
2:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just
2:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): a different mix of incumbents. Yeah. But really, historic or not, uh, Democrats will have a sizable majority in Congress. And they also won a sizable share of state and local elections, flipping as many as 10 statewide chambers such that Democrats will have a majority of these statewide legislatures. Flipping five seats, Democrats also hold the majority
3:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of the governorships. in states across the country.
3:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So on the local level, on the national level, there is more democratic control. And that's going to mean something for real estate, for investing, and for a lot of little things and big things. That's right. The implications of this political shift, especially as it pertains to the real estate markets that we focus on, the multi-family dispatch, that's gonna going to be a lot of a lot different based on where you live.
3:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Um, whether it's a red state, a blue state, a purple state, um, or or you know, anywhere in between. So here's the fun part guessing about the future and giving a little bit of hot takes. Uh, no, these are all hot takes, and my hot takes here kind of come from the heart, more more than uh years of economic research. So take these with a grain of salt. I've
3:55
Nick McCracken: uh I've got my fair share of hot takes, Matt. So uh I'm definitely gonna share them as well. Let's uh let's get into it.
4:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Good. Yeah, yeah.
4:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Because the best, for me at least, the best hot takes of the uninfection. are the uninformed hot takes. You take them, you laugh a little, and you throw them out, and that's fine.
4:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
4:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Um, and here's one that's really easy for me to make, and I think it's true, though, data centers are gonna be more difficult to build. This was a big part of candidates' platform, so this one doesn't seem so far-fetched.
4:15
Nick McCracken: Yeah, that's right. I think uh I think I would say you're starting off with a lukewarm take here, Matt. Um, I I think this is absolutely gonna going to be the case. Um, you know, it's there's definitely a lot of AI doomerism out there and the election was definitely campaigned on that quite a bit. Um, I think that doomerism is probably a little overbought right now. But regardless, I think a
4:35
Nick McCracken: lot of these projects are going to go on an indefinite pause. Um, you know, there was a lot of development for the AI capacity in Texas. I think now that since Texas shifted, um, you know, that's gonna stop. Same thing with Ohio. There was a lot of, you know, big projects that were slated to be developed in Ohio. I think those are gonna stop as well. Um and so, you
4:55
Nick McCracken: know, really my hot take to attach to this is that
5:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
5:00
Nick McCracken: kind of think AI capex was already kind of s slated to decrease, right? I
5:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): oil
5:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's thinking too, yeah. Like
5:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this is
5:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): maybe an excuse, but the bigger pressure with the debt costs and everything was uh building.
5:12
Nick McCracken: Right, right. So you've got the debt costs we've we've talked about that. Um, you know, now you've got a tech route in markets as well. Um and, you know, I I think we're going to see again just that that AI capex decrease. I think it was coming regardless as investors are looking for return on that spend. It's not quite there yet,
5:32
Nick McCracken: right? So um but with that,
5:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's
5:34
Nick McCracken: no longer propping up the GDP figures either. So you know are we going gonna to have a formal recession? of two quarters of declining GDP growth? Which I think that's a recession, Matt. Uh in 2022 it was not. No. Um we
5:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): decided it wasn't.
5:47
Nick McCracken: Yeah, we decided it wasn't. So so maybe we won't have a recession. But uh I do think that you know the GDP numbers if uh if this capex decreases are definitely going to to be affected in some way. Um I don't think this stops AI, its development, the models getting better, things like that. Um rather I think maybe it accelerates more local adoption, more
6:06
Nick McCracken: you know, ways to generate token efficiency and more on hardware AI. So maybe your phone gets a on hard like on chip, on phone um AI way so that it doesn't have to go to the cloud to be processing all of this this AI.
6:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And and frankly, I wonder if the last like
6:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): five percent of uh of quality of of of AI is takes like five times more compute, if that's if that makes any sense. Like these frontier frontier models are maybe a little bit better, but they have to do so much work and they have to have so much compute in order to get that little sliver of the top of the top.
6:44
Nick McCracken: Yeah, no, that's absolutely right. You know, if you are someone that uses ChatGPT as Google, basically to to ask questions, um,
6:53
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
6:53
Nick McCracken: know, you can do that today with something that runs on your computer and you don't need a supercomputer to do it.
6:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Well, I'm I'm just ready for the uh the RAM prices come down. Although Sam Altman has said that we don't need RAM anymore. People shouldn't own RAM.
7:06
Nick McCracken: Yeah. Well, again, I guess uh, you know, the the if the election is anything to prove, uh, you know, he's he's gonna have uh an uphill battle to uh to take all the RAM.
7:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
7:16
Nick McCracken: uh yeah, I mean he does, you know, his view is that hey, uh you should be more efficient with your devices and send everything to the cloud and we'll take care of it. So it's it's what's certainly one way to look at it.
7:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): You know, time was when we could buy RAM. I don't know, but now no one can. Uh
7:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all
7:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): right. Uh all right, sorry, I gotta kinda got lost in the weeds there, but that but that was fun and interesting too. To get a little bit back to uh multifamily housing economists economist Az. Aziz Sunderjee, his recent LinkedIn post highlights how the Democrat constituency has more renters, which could bring more laws like Mandani style rent control and fewer policies like Trump style 50 year
7:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): mortgages. Um, I think that these policies are more localized to state and city governments. And honestly, I'm not sure that rent control is that high on anyone's priority list right now. Um, in the past three or four years, of low of very low rent growth has really lowered the temperature of that issue. However, you know, it is it is an idea and it is
8:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): an option that uh that has been discussed before. I just don't I just think it seems to be an extreme option. And it is just one option. There are other things that people could do to encourage more building. Maybe they uh they have fewer regulatory hurdles. maybe some zoning tweaks, and um they would let people build a little bit more
8:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): rather than kind of um saying how much people could charge for rents. Yeah. At the national level, you might remember how the Trump administration made a push to open up federal land for housing. Uh, that was that kind of a couple of years ago, I think. Uh, but a lot a lot of this federal land is in areas where people don't really want to live. Uh Republicans are bigger fans of deregulation than him than Democrats, but there is a sizable
8:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): contingent of Democrats, that kind of abundance movement, that could move forward with some zoning and regulatory changes that would encourage housing supply growth rather than trying to intervene and dictate housing price rules through rent control. And I'm also thinking of of situations where it is the not in my backyard and the yes in my backyard, you
9:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
9:09
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the nimbies NIMBY's and the yimbies. YMB's.
9:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
9:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Um, I think that that's where the conflict is gonna be, whatever, whether it's Republican or Democrat, you're going to have a neighborhood that doesn't want um either its accessory dwelling units or it's a big fat apartment building right next door. And then there's going to be a larger government entity that's bigger than that neighborhood that's saying you have to build or you get like you don't get to
9:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): say that anymore. You don't get to say no to apartments.
9:33
Nick McCracken: Right, yeah, yeah. And I I would agree with you. I don't think NIMBYism falls directly on party lines,
9:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right?
9:38
Nick McCracken: Um I I would also think that you're right that I'm not sure that on a federal level much is gonna change here. Uh right. I think market forces have technically been at work for the past couple of years. You talked a lot um about just you know, some of the the federal land initiatives, and again, that's places where people don't want to live. Yeah, you're
9:58
Nick McCracken: not gonna go start a city in Nevada just because the land is available to you.
10:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's what I picture when
10:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): someone
10:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): says federal land, I just think of like the bad lands.
10:06
Nick McCracken: Yeah, exactly. Um as uh I have family members that work in the BLM uh Bureau of Land Management, and you know, there's there's nothing for
10:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): there's no infrastructure for for anything. What do they get? Yeah.
10:19
Nick McCracken: Yeah, that no, you're you're exactly right. Um you know, plus
10:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
10:24
Nick McCracken: at a bipartisan level, I mean, one of the few things that actually got passed through Congress this this year before the midterms was the Road Act, which was uh the the big housing bill um that didn't focus so much on multifamily, um, mainly put some stops on, you know, who can o like own and kind of control the build for rent on the single family housing side.
10:44
Nick McCracken: Um, but they've kind of already passed that, right? So I'm not sure how much on a federal level they're they're gonna go. Um, but I will say to your point about maybe a lot of this coming from the local change, uh, the governor's races and the the city, the city races, um, there were six DSA candidates in reliably blue congressional districts, uh, two in New York, one in Colorado,
11:04
Nick McCracken: one in California, one in Michigan, one in Pennsylvania. Um, and so if you, you know, are gonna see more Mamdani style rent reform, I would expect to see it there first, right? Yeah. Um
11:16
Nick McCracken: as
11:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): indicative of maybe local government control that could m could make that happen.
11:20
Nick McCracken: Yes. Yeah. Right. Um so but you know, local intervention in markets where we play, um, I could see that maybe come in the form of um, you know, changing the way that taxes works, right? Yeah. Um in Indiana specifically, we've had a huge tax bill that has, you know, come and and actually added a lot of benefits. benefit to both homeowners and
11:40
Nick McCracken: multifamily owners that we'll see really start to take effect over the next five years. And that's a good thing. Yeah. However, how schools and the cities themselves are going to be able to fund with an actual reduction in the the future of the tax liabilities that or the the tax revenue that they're going gonna to receive. Um
12:00
Nick McCracken: I I think there there may be some some changes. some referendums being passed to kind of, you know, just maintain the revenue, make sure that the schools are are still, you know, up to up to snuff and and, you know, see what happens there. No,
12:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): no, that's that's a good point.
12:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Th that was one of the referendums that was in on the Indiana ballot on
12:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
12:18
Nick McCracken: right. And it passed. Did
12:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it pass? Okay, yeah. I was about to look it up and then yeah edit that in.
12:22
Nick McCracken: Yeah.
12:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Um in it and I and I always think of like uh the way that Indianapolis and the or the way that Indiana um charges for its roads um kind of disadvantages the uh more urban areas because it's by um because it's by mile right instead of by lane and
12:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and like if if we're gonna get even less tax does that mean even more potholes? So um that's that's a little bit but yeah I'm sure there's a lot of nuance there obviously. Yeah. Um, All right so the next hot take and this is less of a hot take and more of like a watch this space. Um, but I'll be very curious to see how immigration policy might change on the national level. I'm not gonna wade too far
13:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): into this political hornet's nest, except to mention that several reports this week mention one, how big of a factor immigration is to population growth, and two, how much population growth has been slowing in recent years. And that's been actually a growing narrative. that I've been hearing kind of throughout the year and not just in this politically charged moment. I think that
13:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): there is so much room for growth and opportunity in the United States. Um, and Nick, is it possible that increased legal immigration could help our country and an economy grow? Well, audience, feel free to write your answer out in the comments. But again, like I'll just say, watch this space.
13:36
Nick McCracken: Yeah, I'm gonna do it, I'm going to uh keep my head down on that topic. and uh but you know obviously Matt is someone that's trying to model occupancy for all of our acquisition performers. This is definitely something that we are going to have to keep watching and just see how the the data reacts. So
13:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah, yeah. So uh feel free to uh comment and uh to write your ideas in the comments. Uh you can get get real controversial, that's fine. If it gets too controversial, I'll just delete the comments.
14:01
Nick McCracken: Yeah. Uh you know, do a five-paragraph format, you know, at least 250 words, uh, full immigration reform ideas in the comments below.
14:09
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, that's right. And and hey, use Chat GBT to help you out a little bit.
14:13
Nick McCracken: Yeah.
14:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Um, another space to watch is tariffs. I haven't seen a concrete policy depos uh proposal or anything like that. Um, but I think that we're gonna see some congressional pushback against tariffs. But who knows how far any of these efforts will go. Um, because
14:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
14:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): don't know, like things take a long time to to to happen in the in the Congress.
14:32
Nick McCracken: Yeah, that's right. Um, so here's my hot stake for
14:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you,
14:35
Nick McCracken: Matt. Um, and I'm I'm willing to accept the damage that uh that this may cause to my reputation. So um, of course, thoughts here are my own, but um, I think the tariffs are gonna stay. I think they're gonna stick around. Um, I think that you know uh Trump and the Republicans have already been labeled as kind of the bad guys for bringing these in place and we
14:55
Nick McCracken: need the revenue. It's
14:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a revenue
14:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): source
14:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that I want
14:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to get rid of.
14:58
Nick McCracken: Right. Um and you know, I also think there's, you know, name name your economists. They've they've done the math showing the impact on the costs, but um, you know, I think that's only a piece of it versus the inflation from the Iran war, the AI CapEx boom, driving up, you know, computer prices, all of that stuff. So um yeah, again, ever every economist is gonna tell you
15:18
Nick McCracken: how what a bad idea tariffs are, but I think they're gonna stay. At the end of the day, you know, I'm not I'm not sure that that is an awful thing, um, as far as if it's if it's a tax that we have to pay, if there's a revenue shortfall that the government needs, um, you know, I'm not sure that it's the worst way in the world to try to to generate it. Um, again, you know
15:38
Nick McCracken: with the the idea, maybe the implementation is bad, but the idea that, you know, we're basically taxing for the privilege to sell to the largest economy in the world, I can get on board with that. But maybe the implementation needs to change.
15:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It's a tax on us.
15:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
15:54
Nick McCracken: a tax on us.
15:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): But it is a tax and it's bringing in money. And what do those blue what does that blue wave love more than taxes?
16:02
Nick McCracken: Yeah. that's right.
16:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Um finally, despite the dramatic political shift of this wave election, I'm not sure that we're that we'll see big dramatic policies written into law because Trump still has veto power. There may be some compromises and poison pills, maybe, but I can't imagine anything huge getting passed. And I think that works both ways too. And the Democratic majority could potentially
16:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): stifle uh disruptive policies from the right. We may be in for two years of an uneasy balance on the lawmaking side. And uneasy balance sounds a lot better to me than chaotic upheaval. So
16:34
Nick McCracken: yeah. Um, you know, I think the news cycle is is definitely going to find a way to make the next two years very interesting. But um, as far as from the multifamily side, I think we've actually got some stability through gridlock over the next couple of years. So
16:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah, agreed. Um, so let's step off. the hot coals of this political discussion onto the more familiar and comfortable ground of the housing market, starting with apartment performance, where we've got the latest numbers on rent growth and occupancy from apartment list and co star. Uh, I was really gratified that the trends, the positive trends that we've been seeing in the multifamily market, have continued now.
17:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): It's a little bit more subdued because of seasonal rent effects. Rents usually go down a little bit um when on the latter half of the year, especially. you know, October, November, December. But that downturn has been much less severe now than it was compared to previous years. Year over rent growth, year-over-year rent growth is up for both
17:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): apartment list and co star. Apartment list has year-over-year rent growth moving positive for the first time in three years. Um, It's just barely positive, it's at 0.1%, but it's a meaningful number. And that is the product of preparation. persistent positive momentum for the for the really the whole latter half of this year. Coastar also has year over year rent growth at 1.6 up from
17:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): 1.5 last year, and the highest it's been in three years as well, essentially tracking a similar change as apartment list.
17:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
17:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Coastar's occupancy numbers were essentially flat at 92.1%. And apartment list also has occupancy improving proving a little bit, uh, not enough to change the. 93.0 occupancy number, unless we get out to a few more decimal points. Right. But it's clear that occupancy is improving. Regionally, Coastar has a tight group of rent growth leaders.
18:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Pacific leads the pack with 2.6 year-over-year rent growth, northeast at 2.4%, Midwest at 2.3%, and then a big fall off to the south at 0.4%, and Mountain at 0.2%. Uh, Multifamily dispatch members might remember my earlier comments on how Coastar has split up the West Census region into the mountain and Pacific region.
18:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Coastar's free, Nick. Coastar's free to make any map it likes. It's just that officially, Mountain and Pacific are divisions and not regions. They're divisions of the West. Yeah.
18:44
Nick McCracken: So
18:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): they split the West up, and that's not fair. And and that's why we get Pacific doing crazy gray great in the West in the Mountain. region doing not so great.
18:52
Nick McCracken: Yeah. And you know, however, I I think that's great right now because again, what's the narrative is you know the the housing boom in San Francisco and in
19:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): San Jose.
19:03
Nick McCracken: It really
19:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I
19:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): looked. Yeah,
19:04
Nick McCracken: we've looked earlier this year at some of the rent growth numbers of San Jose, and you know, they're kind of leading the charts in terms of you know, metro areas on rent growth. Yeah, a lot of that is situated again kind of a around the AI boom, knowing that these employees are about to, you know, get potentially pretty large cash outs from IPOs, right?
19:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
19:22
Nick McCracken: um, you know, versus again, like in in Colorado where there's a lot of oversupply. So at this at this point in time, you know, I wouldn't be surprised if maybe in a couple of years Coastard decides to go, you know, gerrymander their lines again. But
19:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
19:36
Nick McCracken: but uh uh you know this this is a very helpful view I think in the in the short.
19:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I agree. I mean I mean geo geographically too it would make sense that you split up the biggest region. Um but if it's if you're gonna talk about population, the South is actually the most populous region and you could split that up. Although the names are a little bit weird you'd have to call it like mid South Atlantic or something like that. So it's a
19:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): little bit we should just
19:57
Nick McCracken: do it by football conference, you know like give me
19:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
19:59
Nick McCracken: SEC, the ACC. Yeah.
20:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah
20:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): like Big Ten.
20:02
Nick McCracken: Yeah.
20:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's not ten. All right. Um apartment lists doesn't have regional numbers, but their rent growth map is very similar compared with um Coastar. And markets in the South are doing worse than markets on the north on the whole. The top markets for apartment lists are those tech markets that you mentioned, like San Jose and San Francisco, and then there's Mid Virginia Beach and then a whole bunch of
20:22
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Midwest markets. And then you got Riverside California, which is in Southern California, which is kind of interesting. It's a little bit outside of the high-tech markets like Oakland or or San Francisco, San Jose, right? East Bay. Um uh but if you look at smaller markets, then Boise, Idaho is doing so well at 8.4% rent growth, and
20:42
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Lansing, Michigan is at 5.6%. So those would all be on that list of top markets. They're just below one million uh one million residents, so they just don't register on. the list. Uh uh Boise, I know that's uh that's a really great, a really great market. I remember it was one of the uh quote unquote like oversupply markets for a little while, but seems to be bouncing back incredibly.
21:01
Nick McCracken: Yeah, it does.
21:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
21:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's in the mountain region, so it's lifting that whole region. Maybe
21:05
Nick McCracken: it is. Uh that should be maybe, you know, if if if that's lifting the average, and the average is point 0.2%, two percent, maybe uh yeah,
21:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you know,
21:12
Nick McCracken: the mountain, the mountain average as a whole, specifically more so like Colorado markets, are uh are not doing too well. So
21:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
21:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah, agreed. We'll have more updates on this positive trend in apartment performance as it continues, but these numbers continue to show up. What was once a tentative, a tentative upward trend has solidified into a level of strong performance that we haven't seen for three years. But it's very slow, this upward movement. And the fact that it's happening in the later half of the year, it masks some
21:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of these gains. They are there. Um, and the continued decline in apartment construction and apartment supply growth means that this trend will very likely continue. Um, Nick, am I missing any important details in my bird's eye view of the apartment market here?
21:51
Nick McCracken: Yeah. I think, you know, again, we we highlighted, hey, look, this is all positive growth moving in the right direction. It's small, but it's moving starting to move in the right direction. And we're, you know, seeing things uh, you
22:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
22:01
Nick McCracken: high highest rent growth. that we've seen in three years and in a lot of places nationally. But I think the reality is is what I see is that these numbers are still just not good enough to drive the real estate returns, yeah. The returns that real estate investments require. So it's kind of thinking about this in two ways. One is, and we talked about
22:21
Nick McCracken: this, but the data is at its most granular, regional or divisional. Um and individual assets and markets um can still have mispricing. Boise, Idaho, great example of that. Yeah. Um and then even just, you know, some specific city block, right, can can have mispricing. Um and those are the investments
22:41
Nick McCracken: where um, you know, when we're looking for rent growth, that's what we need to be seeking right now. Um and the second point is that, you know, in lieu of, you know, rent growth that really helps us um you know drive the returns that we're seeking, our return just needs to come from other factors. And you know that's a value add play where it's possible. But
23:01
Nick McCracken: in most cases right now, that's just the basis. And we'll certainly get in later to you know kind of talk about um capital markets and and movement there. But um ultimately if the growth is slower, we just have to adjust our discount for the cash flow flows and pay less. Yeah.
23:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. Uh I thought that was interesting what you did say about kind of the local mispricing and the local mismatches and the ways that some localities could grow much faster than others. We're about to discuss a bunch of reports on the housing market in general. And this
23:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
23:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the national housing market. And one thing that is worth keeping in mind is real estate is very local. Even the issue of housing affordability is very local. And so these reports that we'll discuss here were are going to talk about some things that are dragging down population growth, dragging down housing demand, but that's on the national level. And there are a lot of specific areas that are doing great
23:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and that are growing incredibly. However, you know, there are some places, maybe more populous places, particularly maybe in the south, that uh that may suffer more than others.
23:59
Nick McCracken: Right. Um,
24:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): so yes, these brief apartment performance. reports were light and promising, easy to digest. The next course is a little heavier fair, but these next few reports cover some issues that have steadily grown in prominence this past year. We're now seeing this narrative of housing shortages and housing unaffordability countered by accounts of
24:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): demographic shifts and weakening housing demand drivers. Now, there's a world of nuance behind both of these conversations, and investors. can easily find a place that will have positive growth now and in the future. But as we mentioned earlier, issues of population growth, immigration, and housing affordability will only increase in relevance. And this next group of reports expands on that
24:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): topic. And just one more thing to add with the kind of importance of a specific place, a specific location when it comes to housing um demand and housing affordability. Um That's true, that that cuts both. ways, right? Um something can be some of the reasons why housing is so unaffordable is because it's unaffordable at the places where everyone
24:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): wants to live. And maybe really
25:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): affordable in those federal lands that no one wants to build to. Yes. But it but is not that affordable in like the big cities where everyone wants to live. And um that's that's the reason why people are investing more in these in these cities or more in these suburbs that are more in demand. And that's the whole game, right? It's figuring out those popular places and um
25:22
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and also figuring out maybe the unpopular places, right? Avoiding like the bad lands or the federal yeah.
25:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
25:28
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): okay, so just to start here with this report from JP Morgan. It's called Haunted Housing: The Outlook for Residential Real Estate. I wanted to start with this article from David Kelly, Chief Global Economist at JP Morgan, because it's the most pro provocative of the group. And it's an example of how these competing housing narratives are being digested by groups that aren't looking at the
25:48
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): housing market every single day. Plus, it has such a killer opening paragraph. It starts: the housing market is haunted. It's haunted by the legacy of too easy monetary policy for well over a decade, which allowed prices to vault higher in the post-pandemic boom. It's haunted by terrorists. tariffs and immigration policies that are simultaneously raising the cost of home building and limiting population growth and
26:08
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): thus the demand for new housing. And it's being haunted by the Fed, whose attempts to manipulate the economy are shrugged off by almost all other sectors, leaving housing alone in its vulnerability to rate swings.
26:21
Nick McCracken: To the the recorded version of this article?
26:24
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): No, I didn't. Was it good?
26:25
Nick McCracken: So they yeah, they they have an audio version of uh of this report, and um it's got spooky music, and he's very down drunk.
26:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know, one
26:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of the re one of the reasons I didn't listen to it is because I was like, I just want to read that on the podcast. So that's really funny. Yeah,
26:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): spooky music.
26:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh,
26:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's funny. All right, well, to continue that Halloween themed metaphor of this haunted housing market, we've got a real witch's brew here, Nick, a past history of low rates that conflict with the Fed's. hawkishly high interest rate moves, tariffs and low immigration that make building harder, and low population growth that limits housing demand. David Kelly's horror-themed future has
27:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): lower homeownership leading to lower population growth and a decline in the economic prospects of the middle class. I don't think it's that scary out there, but I do want to uh zero in on one particular particular area worth watching, which is population growth and immigration.
27:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Population growth from 2000 to 2020 was on average 2.4 million a year. Um, that's as David Kelly puts it. And right now we're at 800,000, one-third of the growth that we had a couple of decades ago. Immigration went from an average of 900,000 in the years between 2000 and 2020 to essentially zero today. Um,
27:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and the quote is that deportations are almost canceling out the impact. of positive but diminished legal net immigration. David Kelly doesn't expect much change in immigration policy because much of that emanates from the Trump administration rather than Congress. But he does note that government has stopped publishing timely data on legal
27:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): immigration. I wanna To I want to pause there. I don't have that in my I don't have this in my notes, but I wonder what the meaning of that is. That that there is that um that that we haven't had that timely data on legal immigration. I wonder why. I wonder what the real number is, because you you'd think that you'd see a little bit more
28:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of a catastrophe if it really was zero. That's all I'm saying.
28:18
Nick McCracken: Right. Yeah. Um
28:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
28:21
Nick McCracken: I don't and I don't have a good answer for you. I d I don't know if there's something bureaucratic behind the scenes that's stopping time. timely data. I don't know if just with border closures, um, you know, just in general, um, that they're just, you know, there's no motivation to record that data in a
28:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
28:37
Nick McCracken: a timely manner. Um, but I yeah, you're you're right. I do think it was interesting that they specifically called out um, you know, not just the the numbers, but that, you know, there's a slowdown in how the data trickles in. So yeah.
28:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Um so he did some math too and he said that these reduced population growth numbers of 800,000, if you divide by household size of two and a half people, means that we've got 320,000 um units basically of new housing demand. And David Kelly contrasts that with the 1.24 2-4 million of
29:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): new housing units expected to be built in 2027. So uh clearly there's a mismatch here. Uh again, it's like a three times mismatch. Uh, and he closes on the prospect of look pockets of local growth and a larger decline in housing demand, noting that high rates are keeping people renting. The upshot then for apartment investors is that the
29:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): rental market will likely see more stable demand.
29:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
29:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I actually think that we may see a little bit more shifts in immigration policy than David Kelly. projects. And I'm interested in how much wiggle room there is in the legal immigration numbers, given that the government has stopped publishing timely data on the subject. Yeah.
29:47
Nick McCracken: Yeah. Uh Matt, I want to I want to quote the article's closing um because I agree with it in its entirety. Um it goes on to say for investors after a bad year in the bond market, this suggests a period of solid and stable returns for high quality fixed income. They were There will be plenty of regional opportunities for housing growth, even in a sluggish national
30:07
Nick McCracken: market. However, for many home sellers, home buyers, home builders, housing remains haunted for now with many personal housing nightmares to be endured before housing once again can be the foundation of the American dream.
30:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): You know, I look, I I entered the first paragraph into like check if it's AI, because I really like that first paragraph, and it said it was probably human. So
30:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): good.
30:27
Nick McCracken: Good good on them. Good. Yeah.
30:29
Nick McCracken: They have more writing, uh artistic writing ability than than I do, clearly. So uh isn't
30:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): it fun to read though?
30:36
Nick McCracken: It is, it is. Um so but yeah, you know, going back to this this close, um, you know, again, if if you are buying deals um appropriately or at the right basis, and you know, from which again we'll talk. capital markets shortly, but if you're kind of, you know, being able to navigate the capital market side of
30:56
Nick McCracken: things, um, there could be a period of solid stable returns here kind of coming down the pipe. Um and I also again kind of thought it was interesting that he noted, you know,
31:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
31:06
Nick McCracken: is these are national figures. So on a regional level again, um, you know, there still may be, you know, a there's there's may no reason to be hit the panic alarm in you know, a certain market. Right.
31:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes,
31:17
Nick McCracken: yeah. Um but I'm looking at this um that as just to say, you know, hey, look, again, there's there's plenty of headwinds, but you know, I'm asking for us, how can we position ourselves to benefit from kind of what's coming down the pipe? I think we've already done so in the past couple of years with our, you know,
31:37
Nick McCracken: attempt to, you know, be more conservative. on the underwriting and also just the the lack of volume of our transactions and and new acquisitions over the past couple of years. You know, we're now in a position where, you know, we can benefit from the unwinding um that maybe some of these, you know, builders and things uh that
31:57
Nick McCracken: as a result of capital markets, which we'll get into shortly, um, are going to have issues. with, right?
32:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's the biggest um surprise that I had was in the drama and the real like catastrophe of the pandemic when you know that big tanker was blocked in the canal, when no commodities were coming in, when no buildings materials. I was tracking lumber like so closely because of the lumber was really
32:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): expensive. Yep. And all of these materials, the labor cost. costs were so expensive, but builders kept building. And now, or after the pandemic, oh largely a lot of those, you know, commodities, materials, and labor issues have been resolved. There's not necessarily like a backlog of construction. But now they're really worried.
32:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): The builders were not worried when the world stopped, but they are worried when interest rates are up. Yeah. And that's insane. to me. Yeah.
32:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But I guess
32:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's what runs the world, I guess.
32:53
Nick McCracken: Yeah. No, the fine
32:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean,
32:54
Nick McCracken: the financing made sense at that time, right? But now to to the point of this article, you know, there's there's definitely less population growth to fill some of the you know the vacancies or or their lease of process. And the financing picture has changed. So you know, if they're not able to, you know, they're not gonna going be to able to exit or even refinance at the same numbers at which they built, you know, so many years ago.
33:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, yeah. All right. So um to move to this next, it's a very similar topic, but the Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies also notes that immigration slowdown is poised to sharply reduce renter household growth. Um, rape so recent immigrants, those who arrived in the current year and the previous two, are the main contributors to renter household growth among
33:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): immigrants. That's what it says here in the report. In 2024, at the tail end of the surge in immigration. there were 571,000 net new renter households formed by immigrants who entered the country since 2022. So that's a little bit conflating two or three years there. But still, um, those who arrived before 2022 formed fewer
33:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): renter households in 2024. And um the gain from recent immigration is offset by net loss of 230,000 renter households headed by immigrants. who arrive before 2015. The the point is, um, I think that that immigrants have an outsize effect on renter demand compared to um compared to people that are
34:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that were born here that didn't immigrate here. And I I do think that this kind of sharpens the focus on onto immigration and its impact on the rental market. However, it also seems like maybe it it can help explain that idea of the homeowners. remaining renters or would-be homeowners remaining renters. I wonder if there's some push-bull between that. Um, and then that
34:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): explains how um look
34:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
34:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): numbers for rent growth are growing. They're growing very slowly and they're growing not as fast as we want, but the numbers are there. Um and and if there really was this uh this implosion caused by low integration, you yet you would see that in the rental market, and we're not. seeing that. So that's a little bit of a reason where it's like this uh Harvard Joint Center for Housing
34:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Studies it exists a little bit in the abstract because the hard numbers, the hard amount of the the people that are buying and selling the rents that we track every single month, they're still there. So I wonder what what the deal is. Like there's got to be something missing to this study that doesn't capture what's really happening in the apartment market.
35:12
Nick McCracken: Right. Matt, so going back to this point. from the article that, you know, again, those who arrived before 2022 are forming fewer households in 24, um, it sounds to me that that's just a case of part of assimilating to the United States is to not have children, maybe until you're 30 or or older. So um, but you know, jokes aside, this article made a lot of sense to me.
35:33
Nick McCracken: Um, America is just not naturally growing. Um, you know, the good news is that supply. for housing nationally is apparently still too low. Um, and so you know, in the right pockets, there's that outsized demand. Um, problem is that I see many of those pockets, at least the ones that I personally identified, um, are either shrinking
35:52
Nick McCracken: rural markets um or places where there are challenges to build and or own, um, like the Bay Area.
35:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah.
36:00
Nick McCracken: So um, you know,
36:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): seems to
36:02
Nick McCracken: me like yes, growth is going to slow, but the development pipeline is slowing along with it, just whether or not it's, you know, directly on pace um or not is is to be seen. So
36:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah, and I I also would add that like that these narratives that I the that I talked about, like the housing undersupply versus the housing oversupply, um, they are conflicting. And and the truth is probably somewhere in the middle, yeah, there is that con that conflict between those two narratives of
36:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): housing oversupply and um housing unaffordability housing undersupply. And I still think and maybe it's only because I've been thinking about that narrative for longer, the housing unaffordability unaffordability narrative is a little more dominant, probably a little more true. Um I don't think that the five million plus
36:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of of housing units that we needed, you know, five years ago, I don't think those are have all been built yet. Yeah. And again, it is a highly localized thing. There may be more houses than people right now, but they may not be where they want to live. And you can't pick up a house and move it to where people want to live there very easily. That costs money.
37:13
Nick McCracken: Yeah. So
37:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): no,
37:13
Nick McCracken: I think you're right. I think the oversupply argument comes from um the people looking at their their basis, right?
37:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
37:20
Nick McCracken: Um if you bought your home twenty years ago and I I don't I think you are looking at the data and you're saying, Okay, yeah, there's there's a housing shortage, right? Um, but if you bought your house three years ago like I did, you're gonna say, Hey, look, uh there is there is a housing shortage and unfortunately it's probably not gonna be good for my resale value, but it has to happen, right? Yeah.
37:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah, yeah. Let's move from a little more tangible housing shortages, housing supply, to uh to the more abstract capital markets and the movement of money to and fro and the feeling of distress that uh that may be in the air.
37:54
Nick McCracken: Yes. Um yeah, so let's let's dive right in. Um Newmark had an article um talking about US multifamily borrowers facing forty 41% one percent higher. interest costs as their loans mature. To kind of give a quick synopsis of the article, stated that loans maturing in the third quarter of 2026 averaged an interest rate of
38:13
Nick McCracken: 4.04% compared with 5.69% on new loans. That's a gap of about 165 basis points. Refinancing at the higher uh you know rate in Q3 would raise interest cost. costs by about 41% on the same loan balance. So in Q3 borrowing rates for new loans averaged about
38:33
Nick McCracken: 5.69% against a 5.5% average cap rate. And you know, they go on to explain that this relationship is known as negative leverage, which has been all too common in, you know, probably it says the last few months, I think really the last two or three years for the
38:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): multiple. multifamily sector.
38:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. Um it dips negative, right? It like Q1 of 2022. And it's stayed negative ever since. And before it wasn't it was positive all the way, you know, until as long as that chart goes, which is 2010. So we're looking at basically uh 12 years of positive leverage
39:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): against these four years of negative leverage. And I hate that.
39:16
Nick McCracken: Right. Yeah. Um, it
39:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): just doesn't it doesn't make sense. And and I don't know, it it almost to me seems like there was so much fervor and things were going so great in 2022 that people just didn't let go of it.
39:27
Nick McCracken: Well, you can make the argument in 2022 that we're gonna grow out of it. But as we just spent, you know, the last couple of minutes talking about the population growth and and supply and stuff not helping that case, it makes negative leverage a lot. more difficult to stomach.
39:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
39:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and I wonder like
39:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): if I I I I have sensed a shift in the sentiment among multifilial investors that we covered here on the multifily dispatch. People are bummed down in a way that they weren't before. And um, you know, the people that were holding on the fact that, oh br uh uh you know sunlight's just around the corner, the light of the in inner a tunnel, et cetera, et cetera. Uh I that is not
40:04
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the prevailing sentiment now. I think that I wonder really is if people are gonna start to think, wow, it could get worse.
40:11
Nick McCracken: Yeah. Yeah. Hold hold that thought. We've got another article that that kind of covers that a little bit better. So um, yeah. But uh this this new mark article also talks about how you know 81% eighty one percent of securitized multifamily debt that it uh is going to mature before 2029. twenty twenty nine, carries an interest rate below five percent. And there's a lot of that debt
40:31
Nick McCracken: out there. So um that would say that is the bulk of, you know, securitized multifamily debt is going to expire before twenty twenty nine. Um thirty nine percent of properties sold traded below their previous inflation adjusted purchase price up six percent from the end of twenty 2021. twenty one. Um and again I think that's uh that's
40:51
Nick McCracken: again just a very critical point of us. You know, we talk a lot about the basis, and you know, there's yes, yes, there's negative leverage if you want to refinance today, but if you're buying new, you're you're not stomaching that. You're not
41:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): gonna
41:03
Nick McCracken: take that. So um,
41:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
41:05
Nick McCracken: know, we've we've said this for a while, but obviously it's very clear that it's It's pretty a bad time to sell your property. And for the 39% of multifamily properties that traded. below their their previous value, right? Um, they didn't have the luxury of waiting it out or they wouldn't have done so.
41:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
41:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): forgot I was gonna add something. Um, one of the articles, one of the large reports that I wanted to cover today, just didn't have time for it, was the EU LI, the Urban Lane Institute, paid a long 150 page plus report on the emerging trends in real estate for 2027. And one of the big headlines is like, you're just gonna have to work for it. It wasn't the idea that things are gonna crash.
41:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And I don't think that things are gonna crash in the multifamily market even, even with all these all these debt numbers. I've seen a bunch of trillion number, trillion dollar numbers of debt and like it's not that it's not like that. And people are comparing it to the great financial crisis. When actually if you look at the graphs, we're Or about half. Yeah. Maybe half the or one third the
42:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): level of the great financial crisis, which is still a lot. but it's not we're we're not there. So I I kind of uh I re I resent that that comparison. I think there was like a seeking health article that I read um that was trying to say that that we're just like that and things are things are going, but it's not. I think it's far, far different.
42:16
Nick McCracken: Yeah. I mean it's it's a worthy comparison, but I think you're right. I think really um, you know, this is probably more adjacent to, you know, the savings and loans crisis, which I'm too young to uh to say that. I participated in. But um yeah, it it but I mean, even so to your point, I mean, half of the GFC is still not great. Um so
42:36
Nick McCracken: but uh yeah, so that that was kind of the new mark article. Again, I just thought it was interesting that um,
42:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
42:42
Nick McCracken: again, it just kind of highlights that you know, borrowers that are having to refinance now are, you know, doing so at a much higher cost. of capital. Um and maturities between now and 2029, there's a lot of them. And you know, if nothing changes and we're higher for longer, then you know, they're also gonna have those issues.
43:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah.
43:02
Nick McCracken: So and moving right along to an article from CBRE, higher for longer rates. Um, you know, they they produced this article uh kind of discussing the rapid increase in the treasury yields most recently. Um and the uncertainty about the future direction which is going to have you know and already has had immediate impacts on commercial real
43:22
Nick McCracken: estate um and you know again just kind of highlighting the the severity of the issue um which newmark also did um hilariously we're sitting here recording on a Friday and um treasuries are moving down. I don't know if that's you know because of the tech exodus and you know some flight to safety in the bond market, if
43:42
Nick McCracken: it's uh the Eurobond, what I call the Eurobond exodus, which
43:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
43:46
Nick McCracken: Eurobond for me is anything that's not a German bond, a German bund. Yeah. Um, so there was some exodus from France and Greece um in kind of their sovereign markets and inflows into the US for that. Um could just be the midterms. Um but regardless, rates at least for the past couple of days, seem to, you know, we're
44:06
Nick McCracken: knock on some serious wood, but they seem to be moving in the right direction. But, you know, we're still at levels that we barely topped at the beginning of this year. And before that it was twenty twenty three. Yep. So um And
44:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): again,
44:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the sentiment I think is is not like I don't think that there's hope behind it. It's like all right, they're moving a little bit lower. I don't think that they're gonna go to zero or or you know, back. I don't think the the good times are coming. It's just
44:31
Nick McCracken: that's right. So the the result that they talk about, CBRE talks about, is um that you know, cap rates are going to have to increase or to increase as pricing adjusts for higher for longer rates. And we're already seeing that. Um I think that we agree with that. But you know, to your point, the the reality is, is I think there were some people. out there that said,
44:51
Nick McCracken: no, we we are gonna go back to a three percent interest rate. We
44:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are
44:55
Nick McCracken: gonna go back to a two percent interest rate. That world is coming back. Maybe it's not zero, but it's it can be two and three percent. Yeah. Um, and if you are in that camp, this article is for you, which is that it's it's it's probably not coming, right? Yeah. Um, and so you know, again, whether it's the five percent that we saw a couple of weeks ago, whether it's around the you know, mid four. fours,
45:15
Nick McCracken: mid to high fours that we're in now, whether it's even four and a half percent in the coming months, rates are probably gonna hang out around these levels. And so, you know, if if you if your investments, you know, are you well, let me say this, you will want to be getting a handle on your investments because the market is not coming to bail you out.
45:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Oh, this is like such an obvious thing for anyone that's been in the market for the past three, four years. It's like hey, that thing that's been happening for years and years and years and hasn't changed, it's gonna continue to not change. So like that that's that's funny. Like yes, this article is for you. Yeah.
45:48
Nick McCracken: I love
45:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
45:49
Nick McCracken: That's right. Um
45:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
45:50
Nick McCracken: last article, Yardy Matrix had uh uh an article talking about the uh maturing debt bulletin. Um I kind of highlighted a little bit of it when we were just talking about this uh both these C CBRE B R E and Newmark articles. But essentially they say um $116 billion of multifamily loans are scheduled to mature by the end of 27 and nearly 250
46:10
Nick McCracken: billion through 2028. Most of those that they show are market rate loans um and they have fairly strong credit metrics. Um, but there's a significant portion, roughly eight percent, that have low debt service coverage ratios or high loan to value ratios. And what they're considering um the the weaknesses to be
46:30
Nick McCracken: is if your DSCR is less than point six or if your LTV is above eighty-five.
46:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
46:36
Nick McCracken: Um, which having an LTV above 85% would generally mean um that you know you've lost probably about a third of the equity, because usually those are capped at best at 75%.
46:48
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Oh, so they kind of like just organically got to that. They didn't start it that way.
46:54
Nick McCracken: Yeah, that's right. Um and then having a DSCR of less than point six means that you are not covering, you know, uh 1.0 is covering your debt. So they're not they're not covering their their debt. Um and so, you know, eight percent is a fairly large figure um for what I would consider to be kind of the wide end of the of the the swing
47:14
Nick McCracken: for you know not being able to cover your debt by forty percent or you know having a third of the the equity potentially being lost there. Yeah. So there's probably a lot that plays in the middle ground um that's not in that eight percent.
47:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Mm-hmm.
47:27
Nick McCracken: Um but uh I guess I'll also say, you know, Yardy Matrix did not have a good feel for bank loans, private loans, bridge loans. That was a very small subset of what they reported on. Okay. So to me, you know, anything in the in kind of the the
47:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
47:47
Nick McCracken: are on banks or are on bridge loans are that data's more harder to come by. My guess is is that those are also more likely to be distressed just given the nature of how those loans were put on or what the strategy was when those loans were put on.
48:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah.
48:01
Nick McCracken: Um
48:02
Nick McCracken: so you know, it could be potentially maybe more than than eight percent. But again, their data, eight percent from maybe more of the the securitized market, um, is is worth noting. So
48:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): yeah, yeah. I I think that it's it's it's interesting to think about this as a wave or a tsunami or whatever, you know, whether it's multifamily or political, um, there does seem to be a change. And I'm not sure it's going to be as dramatic or catastrophic as people think. And um, like, you know, like that you that
48:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): ULI report that we didn't cover said, you know, you're just gonna have to work for it. Um and Nick, I guess a little bit of my closing arguments or my closing comments here is that it's not fair this week. There's been a bunch of interesting apartment and housing reports, all published in the exact same week of a really dramatic lesson. Look, a of course, we're gonna cover all of the best reports and data on the apartment
48:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): market, the CRE market, and the housing market. So I will admit, at first it seemed like a challenge fitting in all these topics into one jam-packed episode. But then I remember, of course we can do it on the Multifamily Dispatch podcast and the multifamily dispatch newsletter, which you can find at the Multifamily Dispatch.com and sign up for free. Whew, Nick, the political winds let them blow
49:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to and fro. betwixt and between. This week, as ever, we did it again.
49:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
49:18
Nick McCracken: got through it. That was a lot of information, Matt. It's glad to be back on the pod. And uh yeah, we'll uh we'll see you next week. Thanks. Thanks.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from The Multifamily Dispatch

All insights