Indy REI with T&H Realty

Nick Giulioni exits construction to join T&H Realty, liquidating rental portfolio amid market shifts

27 min Listen to the original Episode page
Real Estate InvestingProperty ManagementMarket AnalysisCareer TransitionMultifamilySingle-Family Rentals

Summary

Nick Giulioni announces his transition from the construction industry to Director of Sales and Marketing at T&H Realty, citing a desire to focus on high-end properties rather than high-volume management. He details liquidating his personal portfolio from 70-75 units down to a target of 10, driven by management fatigue and changing market dynamics. Giulioni and host Jeremy Tallman discuss how buyer power has shifted, with tenants occupying single-family homes struggling to sell due to unrealistic investor yield expectations. The conversation highlights a strategic pivot away from relying solely on cash flow toward appreciation and tax benefits in a higher interest rate environment.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Nick Giuliani states he is liquidating his portfolio to reduce to as few high-end properties as possible, moving away from the high-volume, low-margin strategy he used previously.

    Nick Giulioni · 1:05

  2. 2
    Jeremy Tallman cites Zillow data showing the first week of January has the highest search rates of any week in the year, suggesting a seasonal uptick in activity.

    Jeremy Tallman · 13:12

Episode sections

  1. 0:03 – 0:37

    Introduction and Career Transition

    Jeremy Tallman welcomes Nick Giulioni, who announces he has exited the construction industry and joined T&H Realty as Director of Sales and Marketing. Nick explains he left his previous business ventures to take on this new role after feeling he had scaled back his personal investing activities.

  2. 0:37 – 8:23

    Joining T&H Realty and Operational Philosophy

    Nick discusses his decision to join T&H Realty, citing their strong operational processes and high employee tenure as key attractions. He notes that while he lacks operational strength, he brings sales and marketing energy to complement the company's established systems.

  3. 8:23 – 11:00

    Personal Portfolio Liquidation Strategy

    Nick details his transition from a portfolio of 70-75 units down to 25-30, with a target of 10 units. He explains that he started in 2017 using creative finance and BRRRR strategies but is now liquidating due to management fatigue and market conditions.

  4. 11:00 – 15:05

    Current Market Conditions for Rentals and Sales

    Nick reports that small multifamilies are selling quickly, but tenant-occupied single-family homes are sitting on the market. He attributes this to investors still expecting high cash flow yields that no longer exist, while Jeremy notes interest rates are a primary driver of the buyer's market.

  5. 15:05 – 17:20

    Buyer Negotiation Power and Inspection Issues

    Nick shares that buyers are making aggressive offers but demanding astronomical concessions during inspections. Jeremy confirms the power has shifted to buyers, who are now demanding closing cost and commission concessions, reversing the seller's advantage seen during COVID.

  6. 17:20 – 22:03

    Investing Mindset: Health and Safety vs. Personal Preference

    Nick admits buying many properties sight unseen and being dismayed by their condition, but learned to separate personal living preferences from investment viability. He and Jeremy agree that properties must meet health and safety standards, even if they aren't desirable for owner-occupants.

  7. 22:03 – 26:35

    Evaluating Deals Beyond Cash Flow

    Nick argues that with interest rates around 7%, cash flow is no longer the primary profit center. He advises investors to focus on appreciation, tax benefits, inflation hedging, and forced appreciation, specifically targeting areas with strong historical appreciation potential.

Claims worth verifying

Nick Giuliani exited the construction industry and left his partners to pursue a new role.

Nick Giulioni ·0:37

How to verify: Cross-reference with LinkedIn profile or press releases from T&H Realty announcing his hire date and previous employment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Nick Giuliani joined T&H Realty as Director of Sales and Marketing.

Nick Giulioni ·1:25

How to verify: Check T&H Realty's official website leadership page or LinkedIn profile for Nick Giuliani. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Nick Giuliani's portfolio peaked at 70-75 units in 2017 using creative finance and BRRRR strategies.

Nick Giulioni ·8:40

How to verify: Verify via public property records in Indiana for properties held by Nick Giuliani or his entities during that period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Nick Giuliani currently owns 25-30 doors and aims for 10 units.

Nick Giulioni ·10:17

How to verify: Check current public property records for ownership counts under his name or associated LLCs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Tenant-occupied single-family homes are not selling in the current market.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·11:24

How to verify: Review local MLS data for days on market and sale-to-list price ratios for single-family rentals in Indianapolis. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Interest rates are around 7%.

Nick Giulioni ·22:32

How to verify: Check Federal Reserve data or major lender mortgage rate reports for the period around November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Zillow reported the first week of January has the highest search rates of any week in the year.

Jeremy Tallman ·13:03

How to verify: Search for Zillow's annual or quarterly market reports citing search volume trends by month. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

T&H Realty staff has an average tenure of 5-10 years.

Nick Giulioni ·7:59

How to verify: Review T&H Realty's 'About Us' or 'Team' page for employee start dates or tenure statistics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Nick Giuliani bought most of his properties sight unseen.

Nick Giulioni ·17:25

How to verify: Cross-reference with past podcast episodes or interviews where Nick discusses his acquisition strategy. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Small multifamilies (duplexes, triplexes, quads) are selling quickly.

Nick Giulioni ·11:12

How to verify: Review local MLS data for days on market for small multifamily properties in Indianapolis. For recent events, verify 2026-08-17 through 2026-11-17. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify T&H Realty's employee tenure claims by checking Glassdoor or LinkedIn employee profiles for average tenure duration.
  • Cross-reference the '1% rent-to-value ratio' benchmark with current local market data for the specific markets Nick Giulioni operates in.
  • Review Zillow's annual housing market reports to confirm the seasonal search volume trends cited by Jeremy Tallman.
  • Analyze current mortgage rate trends against the 7% estimate provided to assess the impact on cash flow viability.
  • Check public records for Nick Giulioni's recent property transactions to verify the scale and timing of his portfolio liquidation.
  • Research the operational processes of T&H Realty through their public case studies or third-party reviews to assess their 'processized' claims.
  • Compare current small multifamily and single-family home days on market (DOM) statistics with historical averages to validate the buyer's market assertion.
Full transcriptexpand
0:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hello
0:03
Jeremy Tallman: everyone and welcome to another episode of the Indie Real Estate Investing Podcast. I'm your host, Jeremy Tallman, and with me today once again is Nick Giulioni. Welcome back to the show, Nick.
0:16
Nick Giulioni: Thank you. Really glad to be here and always have a good time doing it.
0:19
Jeremy Tallman: Yeah, so Nick,
0:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you've
0:21
Jeremy Tallman: been on the show a few times.
0:23
Nick Giulioni: Yeah.
0:23
Jeremy Tallman: Always as an investor,
0:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): usually
0:26
Jeremy Tallman: with some properties. pretty awful stories about property managers.
0:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
0:30
Jeremy Tallman: this time you've told me you got some there's been a big change in your life and you got some news to announce. So
0:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): go
0:36
Jeremy Tallman: ahead. Tell us what's new.
0:37
Nick Giulioni: Absolutely. Well, I I've been an investor, uh a vendor of T and H before. And so yeah, definitely some some changes here personally in the last little bit. Actually have gotten out of the construction industry. That was kind of a big, big move for me for sure. Partners and I went our separate directions. And I was sitting there kind of twiddling my thumbs.
0:57
Nick Giulioni: Uh it wasn't enough just to manage my properties and run a couple of wedding venues. I know the last time I came on,
1:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I was
1:05
Nick Giulioni: telling you I was kind of working on liquidating and getting down to as few high-end high end properties as I possibly could. And I'm sure we'll talk more kind of about that down the line here. So yeah, I was kind of twiddling my thumbs and I figured I should find something to do. And thankfully you were willing to to bring me on board here to to be kind of the loudmouth and the outbound
1:25
Nick Giulioni: marketing and sales for for T and H Realty. I'm pretty excited about it.
1:28
Jeremy Tallman: Yeah. So
1:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
1:30
Jeremy Tallman: is a big deal. You're you're now our officially our director of sales and marketing within our leadership team. And
1:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
1:37
Jeremy Tallman: we flirted a little bit over the years Nick right I mean in terms of like should we work together there's some synergies here but this time just
1:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
1:46
Jeremy Tallman: seemed like the timing was right like you exited the con the construction business. I've always respected you a lot. I think you've always had that really cool skill set of being understanding what it uh investing in central Indiana is all about the ins and outs, the wins, the losses There's been a lot of those in your in your career, it seems like
2:05
Jeremy Tallman: so far. And then couple that with like some really deep sales and marketing knowledge. I just think you have a really good mind for that. You know, we've shared different ideas over the years.
2:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
2:17
Jeremy Tallman: so it lined up. It kind of felt like it was time to make it official, and we did. So but why property management? Like
2:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
2:25
Jeremy Tallman: you've had, and it's people can go back and listen, maybe Brooke can share it in the show notes. You've had some really difficult experiences with property managers, but what was it that drew you to want to work for a property management company?
2:38
Nick Giulioni: Yeah, great question. I think that there are a couple directions I can go with this. But I think first of all, I just like tackling the hardest parts of real estate investing, clearly. Construction and now property management. Clearly, I just I like the easy path, clearly. But no. I think I think you know there are a couple things that uh have definitely happened to me over the years. I've worked with property managers uh who
2:58
Nick Giulioni: were really good at marketing, but weren't necessarily so good at the the operations side of things. And to be clear, it's not not all property managers, several that I've worked with, even my
3:10
Nick Giulioni: even my most recent experience has been uh a really good one. But finding uh a a company that really has an operations background is really difficult, specifically within the property the property management space. And I've really respected TNH for a long time, like you and I have kind of talked about here. And what I really saw within uh TNH
3:30
Nick Giulioni: is a company that understood how to do the logistics of property management in a really effective way. That It doesn't mean TNH is perfect by any means. but there there generally is a process for almost everything that's placed in there. And you know, I'm sure some investors might have feelings about not having one person to talk to
3:50
Nick Giulioni: for everything that they could possibly have happen within a property management company. But for me, I was just looking in from the outside and seeing TH. TNH And and you know, transparently, the operation side isn't necessarily my strength. And I saw an operation. opportunity to come in there with a little bit of that sales energy, a little bit of that outbound that TNH
4:10
Nick Giulioni: probably, if not missing, hadn't been prioritizing over
4:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the last
4:14
Nick Giulioni: over the last several years. And at the end of the day, here, I want to help people. I want to help investors. That's kind of been my ethos for the last,
4:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
4:22
Nick Giulioni: don't know, 10 years almost now that I've been been doing this is I want to help investors. stop screwing up. I want to help investors stop making the mistakes that I made, which is you know, working with the the startup property manager who's not established those systems. It's more about the marketing side of things and and help more people know that T N H actually exists
4:42
Nick Giulioni: out there. You you asked me a question, God, three or four years ago now, and you asked me, Hey, like, you know, what do you think about TH? TNH? What do you people think about TNH? And I sat there and
4:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I,
4:55
Nick Giulioni: you know, kind of thought about it and said that nobody has a negative thing to say.
5:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
5:01
Nick Giulioni: I don't think enough people are talking about uh talking about TNH. And so now is my opportunity to come in there and hopefully be the loudmouth that starts a little bit more of the conversation and awareness.
5:10
Jeremy Tallman: Yeah, it was I remember that conversation. I think it was you, me and Brian Schneider if our I remember
5:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right.
5:15
Nick Giulioni: Exactly.
5:16
Jeremy Tallman: And
5:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
5:17
Jeremy Tallman: thing that struck me about that conversation is we have focused, and we won't get too weak into the weeds with this, but just allow me 30 to 60 seconds here. We have focused strongly on what we call inbound marketing. So our whole mission was to educate. It's one of our core values to educate and advise people. So we were about writing content that was helpful to
5:37
Jeremy Tallman: investors, whether they chose to use us or not, we wanted to create better awareness of what it looked like to invest in central Indiana. But we weren't that company that was sending out cold emails and things like that to people. It was more about this is a product we have. You're free to read. You can spend hours on our website site
5:57
Jeremy Tallman: reading about all kinds of things. But that's been our whole mission is to create a marketing industry. engine that people learn from and then when it came time they needed to make a decision, hopefully we were top of mind because we we earned their trust because we created the right content. So yeah, it was an interesting conversation and I think we have started to do more of that
6:17
Jeremy Tallman: and I think you'll probably accelerate it. But so you've been here what, a week and two days? Is that I
6:24
Nick Giulioni: I think I'm six days in now to my appointment. employment. So I'm a seasoned vet at this point.
6:28
Jeremy Tallman: Yeah. So you've had a we've had a couple of sales and marketing meetings. You've had one leadership meeting. You'll have another one today, I guess. But what's surprised you the most, and I know you you're just still very new, but you've met a lot of people now. Um what surprised you the most about being on the th the the other side of things?
6:47
Nick Giulioni: Yeah, I I knew T and H had its stuff together. from a uh you know entirety of of process. I didn't realize just how processized everything was and I respect the heck out of that. I love a a good Gantt chart. I love a good Han Bon board. And I feel like there's one of those for just about any process you could
7:07
Nick Giulioni: possibly imagine from a um you know property management perspective. That fundamentally I think is the thing that surprised me the most. I haven't even looked over all of the different charts that that exist out there within the organization. And I think that's an incredibly positive thing to really be aware of from an investor perspective is TNH
7:27
Nick Giulioni: probably has dealt with all of these situations before, has made a mistake in that, and then has processized it
7:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
7:33
Nick Giulioni: changed that. And so that's the part I what it feels like is nothing is by the seat seed of who's pants within the company.
7:39
Nick Giulioni: And that's something that's uh super, super cool to see as a nerd, as a process nerd. I thought that was really cool. Um, some of the other things that I think are really impressive is the tenure that TNH has. Almost everybody that I talk to, everybody within the the leadership team, uh you know, just about everybody that I've interacted with there in the office, has been there
7:59
Nick Giulioni: five to ten years. It's absolutely incredible. just the amount of experience that exists in that office. And and yeah, I just think that's a really you know a testament to the environment that's been created up to this
8:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): point.
8:14
Jeremy Tallman: Yeah. All right. Let's shift gears a little bit. Let's talk about investing. I think that's what a lot of people well, I know that's why people listen to this podcast. And
8:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when
8:23
Jeremy Tallman: you came on the show, you alluded to it a little earlier, but last time you were on. you're talking about liquidating your portfolio. Can you give everyone kind of a background on again, just a quick catch up on what you had, what you have now, and then what you think that may look like twelve to twenty four months down the road?
8:40
Nick Giulioni: Gosh, yeah. Yeah. So yeah, quick background. Started in twenty seventeen, used creative finance to build my portfolio very quickly, didn't use a whole lot of my own money in order to to do that. use like the Burr strategy, all the stuff that uh gets people really excited there on the Bigger Pockets platform and you know on all these podcasts that exist out there.
9:00
Nick Giulioni: And got my portfolio up to about 70 units, I think in its peak, 70, 75 units uh at ballpark.
9:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
9:08
Nick Giulioni: did some 1031 One exchanges, got a couple of wedding venues, which are you know uh kind of a very different technically, it's a real estate. play. Let me tell you, it's a completely different uh uh you know situation there and and amount of management. And so, you know, about you know, this time last year I was talking to you, and I think I probably had about fifty
9:27
Nick Giulioni: doors uh still left within my long-term rental portfolio. And many of those were purchased in these kind of the the Burr neighborhoods, the C C-class class neighborhoods that so many people were finding. cash flow for a long time. Um, and I was basically saying, like, I would love to get down to like ten doors, if not less. Yes. Because I I was tired of
9:47
Nick Giulioni: management. And admittedly, a lot of that was due to having been worn out pretty effectively by incompetent property management for most of the last decade. Uh I've
9:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): had a
9:58
Nick Giulioni: good manager here for a little bit who is amazing, incredible human being. But it's it's taken a toll on me and I transparently wish I would have hired hired a professional property manager when I started this a decade ago. And so with that in mind, uh I'm down to about twenty-five or thirty doors right now and continuing to to
10:17
Nick Giulioni: liquidate. I'm seeing a lot in the market right now that I'm sure we're gonna talk about, but at a high level, I I am looking to c k again continue down to that ten units or so.
10:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
10:28
Jeremy Tallman: ten doors. I
10:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think
10:28
Jeremy Tallman: that's you've been pretty consistent with that. So that's and I
10:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think
10:32
Jeremy Tallman: you'd mention maybe like you own two wedding venues. So is that two doors? Is that is that kind of in your mind what a amazing
10:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): thing.
10:41
Nick Giulioni: Okay. Now granted, you know, revenue, you know, uh rent to value ratio is pretty pretty darn good on that as compared to uh, you know, single family rental, but obviously a lot more operational risk and stuff there.
10:52
Jeremy Tallman: Sure.
10:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
10:53
Jeremy Tallman: how's it been going? Like we've talked on this podcast a lot in the last three, four months
11:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
11:00
Jeremy Tallman: the market's not great.
11:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
11:02
Jeremy Tallman: know, people are struggling to get things sold. It is firmly, clearly, I think, a buyer's market. What are you what are you seeing saying out
11:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there? Yeah,
11:12
Nick Giulioni: I'm seeing exactly that. I've got a lot of properties on the market right now. And what I generally found is that my small multifamilies, duplexes, triplexes, quads, moved pretty quickly. Those were not a problem uh from a tenanted perspective.
11:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
11:25
Nick Giulioni: piece of this that I wasn't necessarily expecting to be as as profound as it has been is the fact that single family homes that are tenanted simply will not sell. They just they will sit there and sit there and sit there. People still expect their one percent. 1% deals or you know, 0.9% rent to value ratio deals, which obviously just isn't the case today.
11:45
Nick Giulioni: From uh appreciation hasn't kept up with rents at nearly the same pace. And when you're trying to sell an investment property, the investors are still expecting it, unfortunately. And so yeah, my single families just sit there and sit there and sit there, which is obviously pretty demoralizing when you're you're trying to get these. things sold. And so we're
12:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): these are
12:05
Jeremy Tallman: occupied single families. Is that what you mean?
12:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That is correct. Yeah.
12:08
Nick Giulioni: And then, you know, we are vacating properties as um
12:13
Nick Giulioni: uh as we are able, and then those are going on the market and they're doing a little better, but I'll be very transparent with you. We're still s even struggling with those single family homes in the entry level, the hundred to two hundred thousand dollar range. We're really struggling to to find the right home buyers for those right now. It just doesn't seem like they're out there at the
12:32
Nick Giulioni: moment. But I'm curious to you know, Jeremy, from your perspective, is that kind of what you're seeing as well?
12:37
Jeremy Tallman: Yeah, I think it's
12:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
12:39
Jeremy Tallman: know, I've been talking to actually a lot of realtors lately and they all have a s a similar sentiment is that it's super slow right now. Interest rates have been the main driver.
12:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But it
12:50
Jeremy Tallman: is interesting, and I
12:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
12:52
Jeremy Tallman: always had a sense of this, and we've talked about this from a rental, like a rental market perspective, is that when we hit the beginning of the year, January 1,
13:03
Jeremy Tallman: things do pop
13:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
13:05
Jeremy Tallman: little bit. Now we won't get
13:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
13:08
Jeremy Tallman: same pop, maybe we wouldn't as it gets warmer.
13:12
Jeremy Tallman: But I had an agent tell me something super interesting. the other day. She said that if you Zillow has reported that the first week in January has their highest search rates of any week in the year.
13:28
Nick Giulioni: Interesting.
13:29
Jeremy Tallman: Yeah. So I do think there's a general thought out there, and I'm among them, that once we hit the new year, we're gonna see things start to feel a little more normal. But and I would say that's probably true not only for the sales market, for the rental market as well, because those those track so closely. I mean, if I talk about how
13:49
Jeremy Tallman: many showings we've had on our brokerage, it will mirror very closely to up or down, like percentages, as the rental market did. It's just they track so closely. So I suspect now will they train? transact? I don't know, but I do know historically speaking, a lot more people will be looking come January 1. And it
14:09
Jeremy Tallman: does make sense. It's like getting through the holidays, you know, thinking like, hey, if I want to buy something, if I want to move like in you know, March, maybe now I need to start looking and see see what makes sense out there. No one wants to move in January, February. That's not really the point. The point is that activity generally will increase It will track heavily with weather.
14:29
Jeremy Tallman: But yeah, it's a it is clearly a buyer's market out there. For the first time in I'll say three or four weeks, I saw a pending sign in my neighborhood.
14:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
14:38
Jeremy Tallman: was good to see. There's a lot of for sale signs, but finally saw a pending writer on our listings. But it's just it's just tough right now.
14:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
14:45
Jeremy Tallman: I want to circle back to what you mentioned earlier about when residents voting. vacate. Are you giving notice? Are you just allowing people to stay if they perform? Or okay, so you're letting people stay in the property. Just it's just when they give notice is when you're like, Okay, now I'm gonna maybe do a little more work and I'm gonna get this thing
15:05
Jeremy Tallman: retail ready because your your only buyer really is probably or at least your best buyer is someone some another owner occupant.
15:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
15:13
Nick Giulioni: no, it depends on the property for sure. Um I would say my lower end properties, I am giving notice that they need to vacate when their their lease is up. But the you know the the ones that are performing the more you know B class of properties, I'm willing to to kind of wait it out. Uh I'd say personally, simply because again, I I'm looking for simplication of my life.
15:33
Nick Giulioni: And uh yeah, getting getting rid of the the lower end ones is kind of my priority from a high level. I will tell you, there's been an interesting thing though with the potential buyers uh out there. And I'm curious if if you guys are seeing any of this with any of your listings as well. A lot of these buyers are coming in. Yeah, they're coming in with aggressive uh aggressive offers, and
15:53
Nick Giulioni: you know, we negotiate, we get it. The asks that I've been getting on the inspection response have been absolutely astronomical. The number of
16:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): times
16:02
Nick Giulioni: I've I have replied with uh an inappropriate emoji to my agent on one of those instead of you know that saying the things that that I I would like to say have been quite high. Uh and
16:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
16:14
Nick Giulioni: um I think you know if you are a buyer, that might be one of the opportunities to to to remember is that you do have multiple chances to negotiate in these scenarios and the sellers are probably going to be a little desperate here over time.
16:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
16:27
Jeremy Tallman: we've talked about it for a while. I mean, the power shift is now, you know, like I said, I've said this three times now, but it's fully in the buyer's court and they have more power in every phase of the negotiation. It's done like a it's done like a 180 from where it was during COVID. So yes, it's you're gonna get beat up on sale price, you're gonna get asked to
16:47
Jeremy Tallman: pay all kinds of concessions in terms of closing cost. agent commissions, all these things are gonna be part of most offers. And then that's just the beginning, so to speak, because once inspections happen, you're gonna you're gonna get pummeled too as a seller as well. It's just
17:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
17:03
Jeremy Tallman: it's just you have to expect it. I mean, unless you're willing to go in and do all kinds of proactive things to the property, expect to get hammered on inspections too. It's tough. So um, but Nick, I want to ask you a question. The you bought,
17:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
17:20
Jeremy Tallman: I remember right, most of your properties sight unseen. Is that is that true?
17:25
Nick Giulioni: Yeah. Yeah, I still haven't been through most of my properties.
17:28
Jeremy Tallman: Okay. When you and maybe we've talked about this, but when you got to Indiana and you started driving by some of these, I'm sure you did. You're
17:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like,
17:36
Jeremy Tallman: hey, I've owned this property for a year. I
17:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): want
17:38
Jeremy Tallman: to I've never seen I want to go drive by it.
17:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
17:41
Jeremy Tallman: Were you were you shocked? Like, were you like dismayed? I guess is maybe the better word that wow, why would I buy this? Dude, did you have any of those moments?
17:51
Nick Giulioni: Oh, I had many of those moments. There's definitely an emotional part uh of all of this. And I think the the part of this that uh people need to be aware of is like buying a home to to rent out. doesn't need to be the kind of home that you would necessarily live in yourself. Right.
18:07
Jeremy Tallman: And
18:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
18:07
Nick Giulioni: yeah, I think if you know first I had to divorce myself from that. It's like, all right, yeah, I would never live here. That's okay.
18:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right. Now
18:13
Nick Giulioni: is it a good home for the neighborhood and and all of that. I think that was an important distinction that I had personally had to make. Yeah. There were definitely things where I saw 'em saw them and I was like, I can't believe my agent talked me into this
18:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
18:25
Nick Giulioni: at at the time. But but I would say the the vast majority I was okay with, and then some I was like, I want to get the heck out of this neighborhood, which again kind of gets back to my liquidation strategy today, which took a little longer than it probably should have, but yeah, what
18:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
18:40
Nick Giulioni: working towards.
18:41
Jeremy Tallman: Yeah, I think that's an interesting point about
18:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
18:45
Jeremy Tallman: look, I don't fault people for saying I only want to buy properties I'd be comfortable living in. I think that's I think first off you're not gonna scale at all, probably with that with that mindset.
18:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
18:57
Jeremy Tallman: do think there's some basic tenants so you could pull away from that to say, I want this property up to a health and safety level that I could put my daughter in or my son in.
19:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right?
19:10
Jeremy Tallman: I
19:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think I was gonna make
19:11
Nick Giulioni: the joke about my mother in law, but I
19:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): will we'll let that one
19:14
Nick Giulioni: go.
19:14
Jeremy Tallman: Yeah.
19:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think
19:15
Jeremy Tallman: that's I I think that's a reasonable way to think about it. It may not be an area that you would live in yourself, but it is certainly should be up to health and safety standards
19:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
19:27
Jeremy Tallman: you would feel comfortable moving anyone into. And I think those are different things, you know.
19:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
19:33
Jeremy Tallman: Yeah, 'cause because we all want, you know, primary ensuites and two car garages and and all these, you know, comfort things that we've come to to expect. But if you're gonna look for that on every home you buy, you're nothing is gonna even remotely pencil out. Even worse than a actually a good deal might. So
19:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all right.
19:53
Jeremy Tallman: So
19:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
19:54
Nick Giulioni: wonder if I actually just touch on that really fast. Yeah. You asked me a question previously, what surprised me about joining TNH and and getting into the PM space. I every PM I've worn worked with up to this point has kind of been a yes man from a yeah
20:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
20:06
Nick Giulioni: from a taking doors perspective. That's what actually another thing that I hadn't thought about before that surprises me is just how much TNH says no to those kinds of
20:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): donors.
20:16
Nick Giulioni: The health and safety piece is super, super important. And while you might not necessarily want to live in that home, having a PM that's willing to say this isn't the right house, it's not up to say. safety standards, I'd say that's something that's really important for investors here as they go forward. So you know utilize uh both your your agent and your property manager as a checks and balance system,
20:36
Nick Giulioni: I think is something that a lot of investors should be thinking about moving forward, which I did not do and I I I wish I would have.
20:43
Jeremy Tallman: Yeah. I think there's I think that's a good point. We look
20:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
20:48
Jeremy Tallman: think when when we come to people, investors, clients,
20:51
Jeremy Tallman: with a list of things that need to happen before a property is ready, we're truly working in their best interest. The less work we can do on a property, the better. And I think that's, you know, so we have the same motivations there. But what we're looking out for, there are some things that we just won't like issues that we won't stand
21:11
Jeremy Tallman: for. And they really primarily come down to health and safety. We won't negotiate on those with clients. If they refuse to do health and safety issues, we're gonna have to bow out. Cosmetics are something different. We're always going to recommend cosmetics to
21:26
Jeremy Tallman: do a couple things. One, get the most rent dollar,
21:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
21:29
Jeremy Tallman: then maybe more importantly, rent it faster. So we're going to bring those things up that if you don't do these cosmetic things, whatever that looks list look like looks like, you will suffer because of it. You know, you're not you're going to get negative feedback, you're going to get people that pass. So, yeah, it's something we do. We say no a lot
21:49
Jeremy Tallman: because we have to set up our business for long-term success. We've set up our clients for long-term success. And that's something we've never been afraid to say. So, but let's finish on. Talk about
22:03
Jeremy Tallman: today how investors maybe are still evaluating deals and how maybe you think they should be evaluating deals.
22:12
Nick Giulioni: Yeah, I mean I think everybody still looks at cash flow like it's the most important thing in the world. And gosh if I can find a property with cash flow, that'd be a wonderful thing. I don't think that's the market we're in today, particularly with uh interest rates where they're at, you know, I think they're probably sitting around seven percent today or generally in that ballpark. And unfortunately that makes
22:32
Nick Giulioni: it really difficult like we've been talking about with the the values of homes outstripping rent. It's it's definitely been a a little bit of a challenge. So I think if you know you're evaluating a deal of whether or not it makes sense, whether if it's two $200 hundred dollars a month that you've got to sink into it, I think that's probably a mistake in the way that you're you're viewing it. And you know,
22:52
Nick Giulioni: lenders might disagree with me here on this one. But at the end of the day, there are multiple ways you make money in real estate. And I'm sure you've talked about it a million times. There's appreciation, uh, you know, cash flow, unfortunately, today doesn't make a ton of sense. The tax benefits, the inflation hedging, you know, the tons of different ways that you can make money. Look at all of them. Don't just look
23:12
Nick Giulioni: at that one, and also kind of look at the approach. appreciation in specific areas. Don't go for that C class property that's been a hundred thousand dollar property that, yeah, it's grown to $105,000 over the last decade. Like that's a terrible appreciation. Yeah.
23:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
23:26
Nick Giulioni: there's certain parts of Indianapolis that haven't appreciated with
23:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the rest of
23:29
Nick Giulioni: the market. Go find the areas that you know were the B class areas that were $200,000 10 years ago are now $300,000 today.
23:38
Nick Giulioni: Would you spend $200 a month over a decade in order to get a $100,000 return on your money, not counting the loan pay down that you're already getting as part of that $200,000? Anyone who says no is probably being a little foolish in those situations from a pure ROI perspective. And so I think investors need to look
23:58
Nick Giulioni: at all of the wealth drivers, not simply the cash flow. and then invest in areas that have the greatest opportunity to appreciate. You can't guarantee appreciation unless you're doing some type of renovation to the property. But you know, those give you the best possible opportunity to find the areas where there's the path of progress where middle class
24:18
Nick Giulioni: people are going to want to go and buy a home in the future. That's your opportunity in order to build some real wealth for yourself, real wealth for yourself. long term. Um, and then I I think at the end of the day, doing forced appreciation type of opportunities is always still a big uh a big piece of it. You know, going from a 3-1 to a 3-2 or a
24:38
Nick Giulioni: 3-1 and a half makes such a difference. Go find those opportunities to force the appreciation where you can, and I think people are gonna be pretty darn happy. You're probably not gonna get 100% a hundred percent of your money back out, you're probably not gonna cash flow. today. That doesn't mean that you're not getting a great investment.
24:54
Jeremy Tallman: Yeah. That's good stuff. I mean, it's kind of reinforcing everything we've talked about. I just think there should be four profit centers now, not five. Just leave cash flow out of the mix. You know, just think of those things, right? Um,
25:06
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because
25:06
Jeremy Tallman: I think it's always again, I've said it's a ton, but chasing the right property, not chasing a specific return. That's gonna make you one. make your life a lot less stressful, probably make your bank account bigger at the end of the day. Um, and those that that should be the goal, right? Is is picking up quality real estate and just being
25:26
Jeremy Tallman: hyper focused on finding great residents to fill it while it does its work for you in the background. So
25:33
Nick Giulioni: my cash flow properties have cost me more than just about anything else.
25:36
Jeremy Tallman: Yeah. I think and look, I think there's all kinds of case studies that could be talked about there. A real quick story that comes to mind when Scott and I were starting to scale up, we started looking at listings that were in the probably that near East Side. This is twenty, twenty-five years ago, right? And I r uh I remember uh a guy that we knew back then and we told him
25:56
Jeremy Tallman: about it, and he's like,
25:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
25:58
Jeremy Tallman: you want those kind of properties, you can just buy those all day long. You should work harder to find the right property because that's not the right property. Right. And so it kind of struck what stuck with me like, yeah, we need to chase the properties, not not the returns. So a lot of good wisdom and all that. Well well Nick, thanks for being here. I appreciate it. I guess you'll probably be
26:18
Jeremy Tallman: on more often now.
26:20
Nick Giulioni: I look forward to
26:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
26:21
Jeremy Tallman: Yeah. Well we hope everyone has picked up some information that will help them in their investing. We'll be back in two weeks. with another podcast. Until next time, thank you so much for listening and please stay invested in your investment.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights