Kasman and Lupton debate US consumer resilience, Fed hawkishness, and financial stress risks amid macro transition
Summary
Bruce Kasman and Joe Lupton discuss a macroeconomic transition characterized by solid growth in tech and broadening non-tech sectors, alongside strong industrial data. Lupton expresses concern that equity market corrections are dragging on consumption via wealth effects, while Kasman argues labor income and falling gas prices support the consumer. The speakers analyze the Federal Reserve's shift to hawkish rhetoric, noting markets are priced for rate hikes despite recent pauses. Kasman identifies financial conditions and credit markets as the primary vulnerability, fearing stress could force a policy pause. They conclude with scenario testing on GDP growth and Fed rate paths, highlighting uncertainty in the near-term policy trajectory.
Key takeaways
- 1 Kasman identifies a rotation in demand where growth is solid due to tech and a broadening base in non-tech sectors, supported by industrial data from Asia and the US.
Bruce Kasman · 0:54
- 2 Kasman argues that central bankers are changing their tune, particularly the Fed, and this shift in intent is beginning to stress financial markets, potentially bringing forward vulnerabilities previously flagged for 2027.
Bruce Kasman · 2:23
- 3 I mean they are the most hawkish they've been in the last twenty five years outside of twenty twenty two, twenty three.
Joe Lupton · 28:49
Episode sections
- 0:37 – 2:14
Macro Transition and Growth Solidity
Bruce Kasman argues that the macroeconomic landscape is undergoing a transition with rotation in demand, noting that growth is holding solidly due to tech and a broadening base in non-tech sectors. He highlights strong industrial data from Asia and the US, suggesting the business sector is in good shape with strong profits expected in the upcoming US release.
- 2:14 – 3:52
Inflation, Fed Policy, and Financial Vulnerabilities
Kasman notes that inflation remains hot and central bankers, particularly the Fed, are shifting their tone, which highlights vulnerabilities. He suggests the equity market correction is linked to this shift in intent, which may stress financial markets, potentially bringing forward risks flagged for the 2027 outlook.
- 3:52 – 7:11
US Consumer Resilience and Data Revisions
Joe Lupton admits his previous under-call on the US fourth quarter is now 'underwater' following a robust retail sales report and upward revisions by the US team. However, Kasman points out that real consumption is still forecast to be flat, with weak utilities services consumption holding back the nominal number.
- 7:11 – 12:14
Wealth Effects vs. Labor Market Dynamics
Lupton expresses concern about wealth effects dragging on consumption due to a ~15% equity correction, citing the correlation between saving rates and wealth-to-income ratios over the last three years. Kasman downplays this, arguing that near-term consumer health is more dependent on labor income, lower headline inflation, and falling gasoline prices.
- 12:14 – 16:45
European Wealth Effects and Labor Markets
The speakers debate the relevance of wealth effects in Europe. Kasman argues that European saving rates did not consistently fall with wealth in the prior three years, questioning the strength of the link. Lupton counters that saving rates were starting to move down in Europe, suggesting a reconnection, though Kasman attributes this to income shocks rather than wealth.
- 16:45 – 19:00
Financial Conditions and Credit Markets
Kasman identifies financial conditions as the primary concern, fearing a quicker transmission of Fed signaling shifts into financial market stress. He distinguishes between equity valuation shifts, which he views as 'small potatoes' for the Fed, and credit market seizing, which would seriously impact financial intermediation and potentially force a policy pause.
- 19:00 – 21:30
Upcoming Data and Manufacturing PMIs
Lupton mentions upcoming flash PMIs as a 'gut check' on whether to read through recent drops in metals and energy prices. Kasman notes that current data from Asia and US industrial production are solid, but a significant drop in manufacturing PMIs would be a negative momentum signal relative to their current forecasts.
- 21:30 – 28:25
Fed Reaction Function and Rate Path
Kasman states the Fed is almost 100% priced for a December hike and likely to hike in January as well. He argues that while equity levels don't matter to the Fed, the speed of the decline and broader financial conditions do. He notes the difficulty in reading individual Fed members like Warsh and Waller regarding their sensitivity to financial stress.
- 28:25 – 31:56
Fed Policy Rate and Growth Forecast Scenario Testing
Bruce Kasman and Joe Lupton discuss the Federal Reserve's reaction function, noting the Fed's recent hawkish rhetoric despite pausing in October. They engage in scenario testing regarding US GDP growth forecasts (around 2-2.3%) and potential Fed rate hikes through March and mid-year 2027.
- 31:56 – 36:42
Risk Profile and Financial Stress Concerns
Joe Lupton expresses concern about wealth effects and potential inconsistencies in forecasts if growth remains strong at 2.3-2.5% with sticky core inflation. Bruce Kasman maintains a balanced view on growth but leans slightly higher on policy rates, while expressing worry about financial stress emerging in 2027.
- 36:42 – 37:31
Closing Remarks and December Payroll Forecast
The speakers conclude the episode, noting the upcoming Thanksgiving holiday. Joe Lupton predicts a strong December payroll number of approximately 175,000, which Bruce Kasman jokingly claims will jinx the data to be weak.
Claims worth verifying
Growth is holding solid due to tech and a broadening base in non-tech demand, supported by industrial data from Asia and the US.
Bruce Kasman ·0:54
How to verify: Check Q3 2026 GDP data and Q4 2026 advance estimates from BEA; review industrial production and export data from US Census Bureau and Asian statistical agencies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Inflation numbers still run hot and central bankers, particularly the Fed, are changing their tune.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·2:23
How to verify: Review latest CPI/PCE reports from BLS/BEP and FOMC meeting minutes/statements for shifts in language regarding inflation and rate policy. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
US retail sales were surprisingly robust, leading to upward revisions by the US team.
Joe Lupton ·4:22
How to verify: Check US Census Bureau retail sales data releases for October 2026 and any subsequent revisions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Real consumption is still forecast to be flat, with weak utilities services consumption holding back the number.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·4:30
How to verify: Review JPMorgan Global Research forecasts for Q4 2026 US real personal consumption expenditures; check BEA data on utilities services. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
US equity holdings are down about 6% this quarter, representing approximately $4 trillion lost.
Joe Lupton ·6:08
How to verify: Calculate S&P 500 performance from start of Q4 2026 to recording date; cross-reference with Federal Reserve Flow of Funds data for household equity holdings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The S&P 500 was up 9 trillion as of the third quarter.
Joe Lupton ·6:08
How to verify: Review Federal Reserve Z.1 Financial Accounts of the United States for Q3 2026 changes in household equity holdings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Saving rates have moved step-for-step with the wealth-to-income ratio over the last three years in the US.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·8:05
How to verify: Plot US household saving rate (BEA) against household wealth-to-income ratio (Federal Reserve Z.1) for 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
European saving rates were starting to move down, suggesting wealth effects were activating.
Joe Lupton ·12:19
How to verify: Check Eurostat or national central bank data for household saving rates in the Eurozone for late 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Fed is almost 100% priced for a December rate hike.
Bruce Kasman ·22:08
How to verify: Review CME FedWatch Tool or similar interest rate derivatives pricing for December 2026 FOMC meeting. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Federal Reserve is using the most hawkish rhetoric in the last 25 years, outside of 2022-2023.
Joe Lupton ·28:49
How to verify: Compare Federal Reserve press conference transcripts and FOMC statement language from 2026 against historical records from 2026-2026 and 2026-2026 using Federal Reserve archival data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Federal Reserve paused rates in October.
Bruce Kasman ·29:01
How to verify: Check the Federal Reserve's FOMC meeting minutes and press conference transcript for October 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
US GDP growth forecast is slightly over 2%, specifically 2.3% in the first half of the year.
Joe Lupton ·30:31
How to verify: Access J.P. Morgan's official US GDP forecast report for Q4 2026/Q1 2026 published on jpmm.com. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Core inflation is sitting noticeably in the city (likely 'sticky' or 'elevated').
Joe Lupton ·33:00
How to verify: Review US Core PCE or Core CPI data for October/November 2026 from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) or Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA). For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Joe Lupton predicts December payroll employment growth will be approximately 175,000.
Joe Lupton ·37:13
How to verify: Compare this number against the actual Non-Farm Payrolls figure released by the BLS in January 2026 for December 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Fed's policy rate is forecast to reach 4.75% in March.
Bruce Kasman ·33:43
How to verify: Check J.P. Morgan's interest rate forecast for March 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Financial stress could emerge in mid-2027 or later due to the Fed's reaction function.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·34:50
How to verify: Monitor the Financial Stress Index (FSI) or similar metrics from the New York Fed or Chicago Fed for signs of stress in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify US Q4 retail sales data and revisions from the Census Bureau to assess Lupton's admission of being 'underwater'.
- Check real vs. nominal consumption trends in the latest GDP report to validate Kasman's point about utilities dragging down numbers.
- Review Federal Reserve meeting minutes and recent speeches (Warsh, Waller) to confirm the 'most hawkish rhetoric in 25 years' claim and assess sensitivity to financial stress.
- Analyze S&P 500 performance and total equity market cap changes to verify the ~6% decline and $4 trillion loss figure cited by Lupton.
- Examine US industrial production and PMI data from Asia and the US to confirm Kasman's assertion of solid industrial data and broadening growth.
- Monitor financial condition indices (e.g., Haver Analytics Financial Conditions Index) to assess the transmission of Fed signaling into credit market stress.
- Review Fed dot plot projections and market-implied probabilities for June 2027 rate paths to evaluate the 'balanced' probability distribution cited by Lupton.
- Check gasoline price trends and labor income data to determine if Kasman's argument for consumer resilience holds against Lupton's wealth effect concerns.
Full transcriptexpand
0:11Bruce Kasman: Welcome to the JP Morgan Weekender. I'm Bruce Kasman.
0:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey
0:16Bruce Kasman: Joe. Joe Lupton is with me again this week.
0:19Joe Lupton: Hey, Papa Bear.
0:21Bruce Kasman: Hey. Before we get going, just realize next week is a holiday week and we will be off next week. So uh we'll take a week off after the exhausting weekend that we're gonna do today.
0:36Joe Lupton: And Outlook.
0:37Bruce Kasman: And Outlook. We're putting our global outlook out early next week. Yes. So I I kind of feel like to me, the right framing of the conversation is to talk about some sort of transition going on here. Um I think in the in the macro space on growth and inflation, we're seeing, I think, some rotation in demand. I think the consumer is coming off a bit, not not not all that much. We can obviously talk about this. Uh, I think growth is holding up solid, and I think part of the solidity of that growth is that the tech stuck tech sector stuff keeps coming. But I think there's a fairly broad base that has been established in terms of uh uh non-tech demand here. I think that's part of the message we're getting from the industrial sector data coming out of Asia and the US. Um,
1:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
1:33Bruce Kasman: know, and I think the basic question we've been debating here on that is whether or not the consumers will. pull back more sharply, or whether in the face of a consumer slowdown, something more negative happens on the business sector side. And without going through the numbers, um, I'm feeling okay about the sort of the solidity of this. And not only, you know, that we're holding up growth in the fourth quarter, but that the base of growth is broadening, that the interaction of that with what has been and what I think we're going to see next week in the U.S. release, which is strong profits, um, is that business sector is in in good shape and that this is gonna,
2:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
2:14Bruce Kasman: know, kick in with the the better hiring numbers. So to me that's that's part of the story. But the other part of the story is that the the
2:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know
2:23Bruce Kasman: the inflation numbers still run hot and the central bankers are changing their tune, particularly the Fed, but not exclusively. And that's, I think, highlighting some of the vulnerabilities we have. Um, not so much that central bankers are going to tighten here and take demand out anytime soon, but that it they're gonna tighten as we see them shift their intent here and begin to stress financial markets. And I think the equity. market correction by itself is probably not primarily tied to central banks, but I think there is a linkage there. And while we're we're talking about those concerns as a a storyline for the 27 Outlook, you know, they might be coming into the frame uh somewhat earlier than we uh have been um flagging.
3:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
3:14Bruce Kasman: to me, the question. is whether
3:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well
3:17Bruce Kasman: well, I guess the question to you, Joe, is whether you want to challenge me more on my in interpretation of the macro space, because you've been more downbeat on the fourth quarter, certainly, and more concerned about some of the risks. But then if we kind of can find our way past that part of the conversation to talk about whether there is more um reason to be concerned, not only that financial vulnerabilities are gonna present themselves but maybe that they present themselves earlier than what we've got forecasted in our um in our uh current thinking
3:52Joe Lupton: yeah I mean look I I think I think that everything you said is is characterizing the situation right
3:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): okay we can stop
3:58Bruce Kasman: right there and
3:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we
3:59Bruce Kasman: can there they're on that note
4:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no you actually
4:02Joe Lupton: what I'm about to say you want me to say more, which is you know, I mean you and I were debating about the the the the current quarter and I was saying I would take the under and and at least this week and it's still early of course, but US team actually revised up their forecast. So my my under call is definitely underwater. Uh and that was on the back of some so you know some a s surprisingly uh robust uh retail sales report.
4:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Robust is
4:29Bruce Kasman: probably not the right way to put it
4:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah
4:30Joe Lupton: that's fair. And actually and you know it is true that it that's a nominal report
4:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean they're
4:34Bruce Kasman: still forecasting a flat real consumption
4:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I was just gonna
4:36Joe Lupton: say it was a nominal report and so the the reading
4:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But it's not just that Joe
4:40Bruce Kasman: you the utilities uh data showed very weak utilities services consumption. So that's that's what's holding back the consumption number
4:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yesterday
4:50Bruce Kasman: October
4:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
4:51Joe Lupton: also holding back the IP numbers as well. Exactly.
4:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
4:55Joe Lupton: But um I I think in general, you know, I feel like the whatever kind of concerns I had for the fourth quarter, um, and and I think to my defense, I was saying this is just more bean counting, and I will we're playing a little bad. Like we're we're we're on board with uh kind of strong growth sticking. sticky inflation, higher rates view. Um I think that's the more important call. And I think I don't know if I feel better. I I guess maybe what you're seeing is certainly continued resilience and consumer through the fourth quarter is good. I think the the profit numbers through the third quarter are are looking good. Uh that always feels a little backward looking, but I don't want to minimize that there's breadth in that.
5:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We're sitting
5:45Bruce Kasman: in November, you're not gonna have profit numbers for the fourth quarter.
5:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, no,
5:48Joe Lupton: I know, I know. But yeah, I well, what I'm getting to, Bruce, though, is the fact that I mean you're hinting at it, I guess, but you're not you haven't said outright that you know the SP just entered contraction territory where we've lost um probably at least by my estimate I was doing it before I got on the call probably about um you know six percent off uh US uh equity holdings this quarter were tracking and it's probably about four trillion dollars. Uh now you are up nine 9 trillion as of the third quarter so you're still up five but
6:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
6:27Joe Lupton: tells a different story. And if you believe the kind of wealth effect was important and it tracked very well for the last three years, it's I'm not going to make a federal case about it, but it moved from something that was aligned with our outlook to more in the zone of something we've been worrying about, which is does this start to not just fade but become more of a a drag? And it's it's in the it's getting into the zone now where I would say, oh, I I guess it is pointing to a little bit of a drag if the stock market were to just stop here and move sideways and start moving up at a you know modest pace over the coming quarters. But all of this is tied to the the well, I don't know how much it's
7:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a but is your is your
7:11Bruce Kasman: let me just make sure I I understand what you're saying because I I want to wanna I wanna kind of give my perspective on it, but I want to understand where you are. Is your concern here wealth effects?
7:22Joe Lupton: Yeah yeah. I mean that that's that's definitely the starting point. That's one of the things you worry about. This the word that I think people are gonna start talking about a lot in the next probably uh you know, within the next two to three months here is the reflexivity point. right? At what point do the Fed hikes start to kind of drive uh, you know, bad outcomes in financial
7:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): markets. Everything you said.
7:47Bruce Kasman: I but I think it's the wrong lens to focus on because I don't think wealth, you know, I think wealth
7:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, no, no. I
7:53Joe Lupton: said it's one of them. Obviously credit markets are gonna be the most
7:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well I think
7:57Bruce Kasman: I think I would downplay the wealth effects if
8:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I wouldn't. I
8:00Joe Lupton: would not downplay it.
8:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
8:01Bruce Kasman: that's my point. I think you're putting too much weight on the wealth effects.
8:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I can't
8:05Joe Lupton: believe you would look at the last three years and how almost like step for step the saving rate has moved with the wealth to income ratio. And and then say, you know what, I don't think this is important.
8:17Bruce Kasman: I didn't say it wasn't important, Joe. I just said I would downplay it in terms of the near-term uh issues. I think in a world in which the consumer is getting more uh labor income and getting lower headline inflation, and I think the move in gasoline prices is is relevant here.
8:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
8:36Bruce Kasman: don't think the focus here is in the near term, meaning I think over the next three to six months, um a concern that wealth effects are going to produce a weak consumer and that's gonna be what kind of creates a problem. for this uh economy or for the Fed. I don't think that's the right way to look at what's happening here. Not not to ignore concerns and I think the concerns are real. I think the concerns are that the equity market is adjusting partly because of the Fed and the shift in the Fed signal. And in that context it has an impact on earnings expectations. And in that context it has an impact on credit access and capital market access more broadly. And through those channels, largely through their impact on the business sector, they have the potential to do damage to growth. That's the way I would look at it.
9:33Joe Lupton: Get to the point where businesses then start
9:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to do that. Well, I don't think I don't think you're going
9:36Bruce Kasman: to see the consumer turn weak here anytime. soon off of wealth effects. And that doesn't mean that if we look at this over a 12 or 18 month period, that what the underlying uh support that households are getting on the balance sheet side from wealth doesn't matter. But I I think if I'm trying to forecast first quarter consumption, I'm gonna put a lot more weight on whether we're getting the jobs and the
9:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think if the stock
9:58Joe Lupton: market, let's say we're we're now past 10, ten, if the stock market stock market's down fifteen percent, it's gonna be a pretty bad Christmas.
10:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): You can't you can't avoid even in a week where you're talking about the consumer having done better than you expect, you can't avoid coming back to talking about.
10:18Joe Lupton: You know, step out of your office and walk across the trading floor right Or now. I mean, it's pretty grim over there. Right?
10:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean,
10:25Joe Lupton: people are like they're they they're kind of a little shell-shocked at what's going on.
10:29Bruce Kasman: Yeah, I just don't think you're kind of appreciating the smoothing of a consumer uh that happens here in both directions. Uh, and especially and importantly, if we're getting the the labor market and health and and and energy price support that I think we're we're likely to get over the next few months. I again I'm not feeling good here because I feel like there is a a new and important challenge. It's a challenge that I certainly thought was a important part of the outlook for 2027, but it might be coming into the picture earlier. There's also, of course, always the question of whether there's something that's being read into the equity market and you could mix into that discussion the fall that's happening in metals prices and the fall in energy prices with a particularly sharp fall in product space and air jet fuel prices, and say that the equity market is just picking up early here, something more negative that's going on in demand that we're not seeing in the data.
11:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
11:32Bruce Kasman: that's always a possibility as well. All I'm saying to you is I do worry about this stuff, but the place where I would focus on is not consumer spending turning uh weak as a result of this in any in any near term sense.
11:46Joe Lupton: Well, I think we can both agree that if the labor market doesn't show up, eventually households are gonna reassess their their kind of income prospects. But
11:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the labor
11:55Bruce Kasman: market is showing
11:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): up.
11:57Joe Lupton: Well, Bruce
11:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): In the US.
11:59Joe Lupton: In the US, right? I mean uh it's it's weak pretty much everywhere else, right?
12:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
12:05Bruce Kasman: it's I'm I'm focusing on the US. I mean, if you're talking about wealth effects, you would not be willing to argue that the wealth effects had a major impact on spending elsewhere.
12:14Joe Lupton: Yeah, I I think I think it has played a role, right?
12:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Saving rates haven't really
12:18Bruce Kasman: gone down anywhere else.
12:19Joe Lupton: Saving rates were starting to move down in Europe.
12:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Starting to
12:22Bruce Kasman: move down. Starting
12:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
12:23Joe Lupton: they did move down, right? So
12:25Bruce Kasman: it's hard to argue that that was a meaningful wealth effect, especially when you didn't have the wealth effects working over twenty you know, over the three or four years before that, where you were highlighting how important wealth effects for the US are, they certainly weren't important for Europe. And now suddenly you're saying the last three or four quarters where you've had
12:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a lot of people.
12:45Joe Lupton: Wrote that piece was that Europe seems to be activating the wealth effect. We wrote that in the Data Watch.
12:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think
12:50Bruce Kasman: Europe was Europe was activating a falling savings rate, the cushioning and income shock. How much of it was wealth and how much of it was that households were willing to look through it, I think is questionable. And I think you don't have the consistency that you might want to argue in the US of looking at wealth effects having a sustained impact on household behavior over the last three or four years, the way, the way you saw it. It just doesn't, it doesn't show up that way in Europe. Between twenty two and twenty-four, there were big wealth effects, but consumers raised their savings rates in Europe.
13:21Joe Lupton: No, no, I I agree. That was a bit of a puzzle, but it looked like it was reconnecting in the last kind of six quarters or so. Um I let's put it, I I don't think uh European households are gonna going be to feeling good if equity markets everywhere are down fifteen to twenty percent.
13:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
13:38Bruce Kasman: I don't think European households are gonna be feeling bad if if energy prices are down and they get a b improvement in the labor market. And that's where the improvement in the labor market is.
13:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well, now
13:47Joe Lupton: we're kind of coming back to
13:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): both
13:50Joe Lupton: agree if the labor if the stock is
13:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not a good thing. Let's
13:55Bruce Kasman: focus on the US for a second. If the you know, if we're sitting here and the equity market has corrected down fifteen percent, let's just say for argument's sake, or whatever number you want to put in, and we get a a a profile of job growth that's meaningfully above a hundred thousand a month, and we get energy prices that are eighty dollars a barrel,
14:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
14:15Bruce Kasman: don't think you're gonna have a weak consumer in the first quarter.
14:19Joe Lupton: Yeah, I I I would say
14:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So that's not the issue there. Okay.
14:23Joe Lupton: Well, I it it would add a little bit.
14:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You were just talking about a you
14:27Bruce Kasman: were talking about a bad Christmas a second ago.
14:30Joe Lupton: Yeah I think I think it will be.
14:33Bruce Kasman: But now you're saying you're you're now kind of saying something I just you just said you didn't think the consumer would would be weak if you had the labor market and the energy price fall and now you're saying it will be. What are you saying? I'm not sure where you're standing on this.
14:46Joe Lupton: Yeah I think you'll have a a soft match batch here. I think sentiment takes a hit but if you're still going to give me jobs through the start of the year, you're still going to give me let's just make it easy. Real, if you're going to give me real income growth of uh say two percent or more, uh then I think you can easily get one and a half to two and a half percent consumer spending, bro.
15:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
15:11Bruce Kasman: that's to me the story. That's not the place to worry about in the short term. Well
15:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): worry about it.
15:29Joe Lupton: But businesses are still going to be hiring.
15:31Bruce Kasman: No, but that's my point, Joe. That I that's my point. You keep going into a wealth effect and I keep going into a a labor market. business behavior effect. That's the difference in what we're talking about here. And my concern is the business sector and the transmission of the business sector through spending and hiring, not through consumers taking a step down and wealth effects. Those are two different channels.
15:55Joe Lupton: If no,
15:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): no, you have to decide you give it away. you
15:58Bruce Kasman: have to decide if you're if you're telling us that the thing that's driven the consumer for the last three years is the wealth effect. That's a that's an effect that's independent of what's happening on labor markets.
16:08Joe Lupton: No, no, I said there are three things driving it.
16:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I know you
16:11Bruce Kasman: did, but you said the wealth effect was going to be
16:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a good thing. Well, that's because I think
16:13Joe Lupton: this is turning into a headwind now.
16:15Bruce Kasman: But you just said I I agree, but you're kind of going back and forth, Jeremy.
16:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No,
16:20Joe Lupton: no, no, I'm not. I'm fine-tuning it. I I'm listening to what you're saying, but I I do think it's a headwind.
16:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
16:26Bruce Kasman: I think there's less. lags. I think there's issues around how impactful this stuff is in terms of very short-term movements. It will be a headwind if it's obviously sustained. But I again, I think to me, the bigger issue here, and we and we're kind of losing sight of it in the in the in the bean counting on on you know the consumer and this on jobs, is whether something is happening in financial conditions. here that either reflects we're just missing the boat on where the economy actually stands, or perhaps more likely
16:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you didn't see
16:59Joe Lupton: I mean I was flagging.
17:03Bruce Kasman: Or more likely that there's a a quicker and more powerful transmission of a shifting going on in Fed uh signaling here that's having some impact on what we've been calling magical thinking in both financial markets and in central bank uh guidance. That to me is the is the big concern is that that that transmission of the shift here is having a more substantial impact than an earlier one, uh, and therefore poses some threats that we haven't been thinking would come into the picture this quickly.
17:38Joe Lupton: Yeah. Yeah. And and then the question, uh well, first I was just gonna say like I it's interesting to hear you sound a little bit more worried about when you're listing the things, the fall and the industrial meadows. You didn't seem too worried about it when I raised it earlier this week.
17:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): By itself
17:55Bruce Kasman: I'm not worried about it at all, especially
17:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all the funky things. Yes.
17:59Bruce Kasman: But when you see all of the things that are happening together in financial markets, you have
18:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to say, are
18:05Bruce Kasman: you missing the dots there? So I think there is a
18:09Joe Lupton: it is something to to worry about in conjunction with everything that we're seeing.
18:14Bruce Kasman: Yeah, I do I think financial conditions are things to worry about right now. That to me
18:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
18:19Bruce Kasman: the is the major issue. And again, I think there's two ways it could be signaling a problem. One is it could be telling us demand. is just not growing as fast as we think. But more importantly, more likely at least I think is it's telling us that there's some, I think, uh connection between the rhetoric shift, the guidance shift from the Fed, and uh financial market that I think has been in somewhat uh a magical thinking in terms of its expectations on earnings uh and credit. availability.
18:52Joe Lupton: Yeah, yeah. I mean next week we'll get the the flash PMIs, which will I probably give us a little bit of a a gut check on how much to read through in this, right? Because if you looked at things like the movements in the the metals prices and then what it would signal on manufacturer would point to a a fairly big correction. here. Um and so if if that holds up, you'll feel a little bit better to look through that. We're looking for a modest tick down on those numbers. But um, you know, if it's put this way, if we're sitting here next week and the manufacturing PMI takes like a point move down, um, you know, again, it's not gonna be the end of the world, but you're gonna say, Oh, this is one. more thing that's kind of moving in that direction. Is that fair?
19:43Bruce Kasman: Yeah, I have to look at the numbers on manufacturing. I mean, we've got like a two or three tenth drop in the aggregate, which would still be running ahead of our fourth quarter GDP forecast. But yeah, I think something a percent, a point or more would be a a momentum signal which would be negative um relative to where we we stand now in our thinking.
20:04Joe Lupton: Yeah.
20:05Bruce Kasman: Um I mean the data coming out of Asia right now on uh exports on production, the US October IP report, none of that is giving me anything to worry about. If anything,
20:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): these
20:18Bruce Kasman: these numbers are coming in pretty pretty solid.
20:20Joe Lupton: Yeah.
20:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So I again
20:22Bruce Kasman: I feel like the bigger issue here is a financial market event that could spill out and become broader and through that channel become a bigger impact on on economic activity. But I think that takes
20:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a lot of people. I mean the question I
20:35Joe Lupton: think maybe the question is like, well, what is it in financial markets? Two questions. One, what is it that we're looking at? Two, what would get central banks and and maybe most importantly the Fed to this is this reflexivity. point, like what would get them to actually dial things back. And my my sense is that in a world where, you know, I think most people feel like there's some froth in equity markets, the last thing the Fed's gonna do is uh, you know, try to put a floor under that.
21:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh well I think there's two It's gonna be
21:09Joe Lupton: the credit kind of as you kind of keep coming back to anything when you see credit seizing, um, you know, if you get kind of bank lending, uh some hiccup in some of the private lending market, um, these are the types of stuff that can rattle uh uh central banks a bit more than uh an equity market correction.
21:30Bruce Kasman: Yeah, so I think you're
21:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
21:32Bruce Kasman: hundred percent right. A valuation shift from an equity market, I think is small potatoes from the point of view of the Fed in terms of thinking about what's going on. Um and I think in order to get the Fed to to seriously consider uh pausing on its on its rate hike cycle, I think you need to have some kind of a a sense that financial intermediation is being affected. And I don't see anything that's happening on that front at this point in time. My concern is that that could be the risk. here that gets materialized as we make our way through the um 2027 outlook. I I mean to me that's that is the probably the biggest downside risk in our forecast. But I think at the same time, we have a Fed that is uh almost 100% priced price to December. I think that's pretty much a done deal. But now we're debating, is it possible? they could consider 50%? Is it possible they'll go three meetings, two, three meetings in a row here? And I think in that conversation, as they sit down in December and they think about how they're guiding us, I do think how much financial markets are moving has some role to play. So right now, my bias,
22:48certainly in our forecast, is actually that they move in. both December and January. And I do think if you had a a further weakening in the equity market, if it started to broaden out more generally, even if it wasn't showing up in the um
23:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
23:03Bruce Kasman: the growth data, I think it could have an impact on whether they go in January or
23:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not.
23:08Bruce Kasman: I you know I think that is a consideration.
23:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do you
23:10Joe Lupton: think if you're still sitting here looking at feeling the way you are about you know, uh the the the the the cycle, which is to say worried but not really seeing anything that is kind of demonstrable, but you still have say a 15% correction, do they go in January as well? Or do they say, let's just kind of wait?
23:32Bruce Kasman: I don't think you can answer that question without being kind of more understanding of all the other stuff. that's going on in the world is hard to know. I uh do I think that equity prices themselves will have a big impact on the Fed? No. But do I think financial conditions broadly will?
23:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And I think that's I know, I'm I'm pushing that
23:51Joe Lupton: point and I I say the same thing, but I'm just wondering like it's one thing to say, oh, we're gonna stop hiking, it's another thing to say, do we really need to go back to back? Right? And now you're at 15% down on the equity market. And no, you're not seeing complete seizing in credit markets. But
24:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): see any
24:12Bruce Kasman: seizing in credit markets to speak of, right? There's definitely things going on in the wide widening of spreads at the very low core credit quality space, but I don't think you're seeing anything yet that kind of raises
24:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that level as I said.
24:25Joe Lupton: I said no, you're you're not seeing that. right? I'm just saying, like, can we be in a world where you're feeling like, yeah, maybe the labor market isn't quite there yet? Let's say you get a sub 100, but it's not doesn't it's like okay. Like in a vacuum, you would say our view of strong growth, sticky inflation is still tracking. Um, but it's it's not it it but it it's not like definitive yet. And then you got 15% fifteen percent down in the acquire. equity markets. Is that gonna it's not gonna remove their desire to be hiking, but might it slow the pace down? But this is important, right? 'Cause that's a that's a December Jan's a trade, right? Um and
25:03Bruce Kasman: well,
25:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's it's
25:04Bruce Kasman: important more generally for the macro environment, how much the Fed shows a resolve and a commitment to tightening policy in the face of sticky inflation. I don't I don't
25:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): again I think
25:16Joe Lupton: December I think if they went December, March, June, September, and they were signaling that, I don't think that would change the macro kind of space, right?
25:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm just saying if
25:31Joe Lupton: they're gonna you said oh it's important if they go December Jan, uh that's it that's important from a macro standpoint. I think if they delay it two months, I don't think it's gonna change.
25:43Bruce Kasman: I I
25:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think it
25:44Bruce Kasman: it it is important in the sense that if they go deck Jan March, then they're actually quickly by the end of the first quarter, they're moving beyond the 450 level they were. If they continue to make a point that they're moving slowly towards 450, moving once a quarter. I think that's a different, a different signal. Now why
26:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they it is why they choose
26:07Bruce Kasman: that one path versus another does does matter. I mean I also think when you talk about equity prices, I think it does matter here. So right now we're down from the highs um on the S P uh what a uh about a little more than 10%, right? Eleven, 11, twelve 12%. percent.
26:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. But
26:28Bruce Kasman: we've made we've made a big move in a very short period of time. Most of that move has happened in the last two weeks, right? Um so um,
26:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
26:36Bruce Kasman: know, if you set if you sort of settle here, and then when you're sitting going into the January meeting, you've gone down another two, three, four percent, and you're down 15% from your highs. I don't think the SP is gonna going to matter. It's everything else. is going to matter.
26:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But if we
26:52Bruce Kasman: go down another 5% every week for the next four weeks or something like that, then you're going to be, you know, you're going to have some kind of concern that's going to
27:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): get
27:02Bruce Kasman: um into the committee calculation. I think the uh the level of the equity market is unimportant for the Fed. The speed
27:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at
27:10Bruce Kasman: which it's moving, the signaling that it's giving it around financial conditions, the risk factor. factors around financial
27:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): conditions are
27:17Bruce Kasman: all important. And I don't think you could put a a metric on if the equity market is at 7,000, this is what the Fed's going to do, or 7300 or whatever you want to put as a metric.
27:27Joe Lupton: Yeah. I mean, that as I said, that's kind of my that's usually the what I suggest as well. I'm just kind of pushing it in my own mind. And I I I I think you need like some. type of headline, something breaking, like whatever, some in financial institution coming like a like a
27:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): ninety-eight. But chill, I think there's a
27:48Bruce Kasman: there's another piece of this which we have to recognize, which is I don't feel like I've got my hands in terms of the very uh kind of incremental choices here as to where this Fed reaction function is. right now. Warsh is a bit of a a difficult read. Waller is very f flirty. Uh certainly he's talking about 50 now. Uh the rest of the committee, I you know, I I think we have a general sense of how they're going to react to macro uh conditions, but when financial stuff comes into the picture, how sensitive they're gonna going to be to it,
28:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
28:25Bruce Kasman: I don't really want to sit here and pound the table saying I have a a great read on this reaction function. I think the more they're worried about financial stress, certainly the more it slows them down. Um and it it does have the possibility of taking what feels to me right now like a a likely path of 25 December, Jan and March,
28:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
28:45Bruce Kasman: independent of the macro uh news, it does have the possibility.
28:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There's no doubt.
28:49Joe Lupton: I mean they are the most hawkish they've been in the last twenty five years outside of twenty twenty two, twenty three.
29:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
29:01Bruce Kasman: you're you're saying that in rhetoric, but they they paused in October.
29:04Joe Lupton: No, no, no, I know. I'm I'm sorry. I'm I'm you're right. I'm talking about in terms of rhetoric. They have talked the most hawkish they have in twenty five years.
29:13Bruce Kasman: And that's an important point. And it's an important point to recognize that that turn has been relatively recent, right? Almost all of
29:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it, I'd say
29:22Joe Lupton: incredibly rapid.
29:23Bruce Kasman: Yeah. So how do you process that in terms of action here is I think not so straightforward. I mean your bias is clear. And I
29:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think that they've
29:33Joe Lupton: been listening to the weekender harp on them for they got so tired. of
29:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): get
29:39Bruce Kasman: off your new testament uh
29:41Joe Lupton: yeah beliefs
29:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): guys
29:43Bruce Kasman: come
29:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on stop
29:44Bruce Kasman: forgiving us
29:46Joe Lupton: what is this the jpm theological seminary
29:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah so um
29:51Bruce Kasman: no um but i do think we we have still a decent amount to learn here about who the heck this this fed is with the new leader and with a rapidly changing environment But um let's sort of end here, kind of just doing a little bit of scenario testing. I mean, you're you're kind of processing all this information now. Let's just take first half of next year. And I'm not actually, I haven't done this exercise in my own mind, so I'm going to throw something out at you that I haven't actually thought about. When you think about, let's say uh our forecast, which has uh two percent um uh
30:31Joe Lupton: whose forecast?
30:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Our GDP forecast?
30:33Bruce Kasman: Our GDP forecast, which has like a little bit over a little bit over two percent GDP growth.
30:39Joe Lupton: Yeah.
30:39Bruce Kasman: Um and uh I don't know what else we want to put into the picture.
30:43Joe Lupton: This is US.
30:44Bruce Kasman: US. Let's just say US.
30:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, they have two
30:46Joe Lupton: three, I think, right?
30:48Bruce Kasman: Do they have two three? Okay.
30:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's
30:50Joe Lupton: what I thought.
30:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so you
30:51Bruce Kasman: take over or under on that you're gonna you're gonna take under
30:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right
30:55Joe Lupton: um uh but uh I will sure to keep in good standing I'll I'll yeah I I want to emphasize the point that I always say like I'll I'll I'll take the under but my modal view is still strong growth and I just think there's a little bit of
31:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you could you could
31:17Bruce Kasman: confuse a lot of people, Joe.
31:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I know but it's not a good thing. But uh just
31:21Joe Lupton: let's let's not
31:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): let's not dwell on that. Let's not dwell
31:23Bruce Kasman: on the Joe on the Joe Lupton psychological profile. We could do
31:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that on
31:27Bruce Kasman: another time. Yeah,
31:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're
31:29Bruce Kasman: you're on the under on growth. Where are you on the Fed policy rate putting four fifty, let's say, as your um or four where are we, four seventy seventy-five five for for March?
31:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Is
31:41Bruce Kasman: our forecast?
31:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
31:42Bruce Kasman: got three more
31:43Joe Lupton: March? Three hikes? Yeah. No, that's that's I can't do any more. Do I think they're gonna do a fifty in there?
31:49Bruce Kasman: No, I was saying is it well, is it under or over on the on the risk profile? You think the risk profile is uh under?
31:56Joe Lupton: Well, I mean you've kind of answered the quick question if you're talking
31:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): about it. let's do it
31:58Bruce Kasman: to mid year. Let's do it to mid year. Mid year we got four seventy-five. Is the risk profile? up over or under on that?
32:06Joe Lupton: I think if if if our forecast is right, they're doing more.
32:11Bruce Kasman: I didn't ask you that. I just asked
32:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you what's your but if we want to have a
32:15Joe Lupton: silly conversation about yeah, I'm worried a little bit about some of these wealth effect issues. I I think if we have I'm looking at our forecast, I think it's inconsistent, right? And and not by a lot, I don't want to sound critical, right? I just think I would put another hike
32:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in.
32:29Joe Lupton: The the the the argument is almost identical to the argument I gave at the beginning.
32:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But then you're saying so
32:35Bruce Kasman: just to make sure, you we
32:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we
32:38Bruce Kasman: you're you're on the under on GDP, but on G R GDP.
32:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Again, mid
32:42Bruce Kasman: year policy
32:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): being four
32:44Bruce Kasman: seventy five, you're you're balanced.
32:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
32:48Bruce Kasman: putting
32:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): words in the back. if you're you are
32:50Joe Lupton: if you're a believer that we're gonna grow 2.3 in the first half.
32:53Bruce Kasman: I'm not
32:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): asking you
32:54Bruce Kasman: that question.
32:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's what I'm gonna say. I don't want to turn this
32:56Bruce Kasman: into a s into a congressional hearing here.
32:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's not. I'm just saying if you're
33:00Joe Lupton: gonna grow two and a half in two point three and you get core inflation, which is still sitting noticeable in
33:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the city. Who won the
33:06Bruce Kasman: 2020 election, Joe?
33:07Joe Lupton: And they won two and a half uh above two and a half, I think you're going to get another hike in June. They're gonna be going to sitting there at the June meeting looking at a first half of 2.3% growth.
33:20Bruce Kasman: Okay, so now answer my question. If if you're if you're if our if we if I tell you policy rates are going to be four seventy five in June, which is giving them three hikes, do you think it's more likely, given the entirety of the distribution, that you'll be at five or four fifty?
33:38Joe Lupton: I didn't understand the the starting point. They're gonna be at 475, you said?
33:43Bruce Kasman: Well, our our our baseline forecast is they go to 475 in March and they go on hold. Okay.
33:48Joe Lupton: Yeah.
33:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): In
33:49Bruce Kasman: June, do you think it's more likely, given the entirety of the distribution, not conditional on our forecast being right, that
33:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they're
33:56Bruce Kasman: at five or low or lower than four 475? seventy-five?
33:59Joe Lupton: Uh uh I think it's balanced.
34:03Bruce Kasman: Okay. That's what I would have that's what I would have put in your mouth if you had let me
34:08Joe Lupton: yeah. Yeah.
34:09Bruce Kasman: Okay.
34:09Joe Lupton: Are you gonna answer?
34:11Bruce Kasman: I think it's balanced on growth and I think it's probably uh slightly higher on on policy rates.
34:19Joe Lupton: Yeah, yeah. Because you you're you don't see for whatever downside near term you
34:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): having said that equal amount of
34:26Joe Lupton: upside.
34:27Bruce Kasman: I I'm still building in at some point in twenty twenty seven, which I worried that I'm too slow in my thinking of financial stress.
34:35Joe Lupton: That goes without saying.
34:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): See,
34:39Joe Lupton: it even took you a little time to catch that joke.
34:42Bruce Kasman: I got it though. I'm not not completely senile at this point. You can tell me when I get there though.
34:48Joe Lupton: Okay.
34:49Bruce Kasman: Um
34:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
34:50Bruce Kasman: I'm not I'm I'm kind of getting close to my nap time, Joe. So I think we're gonna
34:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): get it. Yeah, you're getting
34:55Joe Lupton: worried about the second half slowdown.
34:57Bruce Kasman: Well, I'm worried, I'm worried, and I have been worried that at some point down the road, whether it be mid-year 27 or later, that the path we're on in terms of changing the Fed's thinking, changing um the market's processing of what the Fed reaction function is. creates a stress event. Um, I'm a little worried that it can happen earlier and that we could be getting some signals that it's gonna come much earlier. But my baseline is still that it kind of takes six to twelve months for that for this thing to kind of gel. Because partly because I don't think the Fed's gonna move that aggressively. Um and then at some point here we do get uh get hit. But um, you know, you're right in in terms of thinking it could happen earlier. I don't uh
35:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh well that's
35:46Joe Lupton: that's why, Bruce. I mean, that's why I feel like I'm more I mean, I'm gonna say realistic, but I mean you're you're right to point out that um,
35:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
35:57Joe Lupton: know, despite all of the the the kind of downside risk you that I've been worried about, that we've been kind. of blowing through that. Um but it it it's just easier to see the downsides than the upsides, right?
36:12Bruce Kasman: No, I don't think it has been. But that's been easier for you to see the downsides, I'd say.
36:17Joe Lupton: Well, it's easier to I mean, no, I I frankly, Bruce, I think I would be more open-minded open minded to your view if you ever articulated them, right? I mean, it's just kind of like this gut feel. that I mean, you've
36:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): never seen a business
36:28Joe Lupton: cycle that just can't go on forever,
36:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right?
36:31Bruce Kasman: You can't do this this late in the call because you're just like giving me an ad hominem attack and giving me no opportunity to to respond without
36:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): going on for ten minutes.
36:40Joe Lupton: Very strategic.
36:42Bruce Kasman: Unfortunately we're gonna take next week off, but I think when we start the following week, the that was not that
36:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was not nice,
36:50Bruce Kasman: Joe. But um I'm gonna leave it there and let you off the hook for the moment. So anyway, we're gonna go to the Thanksgiving holiday here. And uh
37:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
37:00Bruce Kasman: want to thank everybody for listening. Hope to have everyone have an enjoyable holiday. And I guess we'll come back and talk just after um Perils payrolls on the 4th fourth of December.
37:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, we're gonna get up to about a
37:13Joe Lupton: hundred hundred and seventy five thousand. on that payroll, right, Bruce?
37:16Bruce Kasman: Oh now you've already jinxed it. We're gonna get a weak number because of that. That's really not nice, Joe. Twice you've been not nice here.
37:23Joe Lupton: Oh
37:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): man.
37:24Bruce Kasman: So okay. So anyway, take care everybody. Hope to continue the conversation on the weekender. Bye.