Jeremy Vale warns against temporary mortgage buydowns and advocates for strategic leverage and emergency funds
Summary
Jeremy Vale argues that temporary mortgage buydowns are tools designed for builders to close deals during rate spikes, not for end consumers, and warns they create payment shocks for those without predictable income growth. He contrasts these with permanent buydowns, suggesting a break-even analysis under 36-40 months is prudent. Vale distinguishes mortgage leverage from consumer debt, emphasizing the importance of emergency funds and HELOCs as financial backstops. He cautions against lifestyle creep and advises personalized financial planning over cookie-cutter online advice.
Key takeaways
- 1 The 'marry the house, date the rate' strategy is risky because if rates do not drop as expected, borrowers are trapped in higher payments and may find it difficult to refinance out of temporary buydowns or ARMs.
Jeremy Vale · 13:29
- 2 A mortgage is characterized as leverage rather than debt because it allows the homeowner to retain liquidity in other assets that may appreciate or generate income, rather than tying up all capital in home equity.
Jeremy Vale · 26:25
Episode sections
- 0:02 – 2:51
Intro and Guest Introduction
Jason Factor introduces the podcast and guest Jeremy Vale, a financial advisor and host of The Arsenal Money Clip Podcast. They discuss the goal of helping listeners navigate the mortgage industry and financial planning.
- 2:51 – 4:40
Inflation and Cost of Living Shocks
Jeremy Vale discusses how inflation has shifted from being low and concentrated in healthcare/education to affecting everyday items like car insurance, used cars, and lumber. He attributes this to economic shocks, such as geopolitical conflicts impacting energy markets.
- 4:40 – 9:11
Temporary Mortgage Buydowns Explained
Vale explains temporary buydowns as a tool originally designed for home builders during interest rate spikes in the 1980s. He details how a '2-1 buydown' works by using an escrow account to subsidize payments for the first two years, allowing buyers to afford homes when rates are high.
- 9:11 – 11:02
Who Should Use Temporary Buydowns
Vale argues temporary buydowns are best for individuals with predictable future income growth, such as surgeons finishing residency or lawyers on partner tracks. He warns against using them for those on fixed salaries or those prone to 'lifestyle creep,' as payments will reset to higher levels.
- 11:02 – 13:29
Permanent Buydowns and Break-Even Analysis
Vale contrasts temporary buydowns with permanent buydowns, which lower the rate for the life of the loan. He advises calculating the break-even point (upfront cost divided by monthly savings) and suggests it is a good investment if the break-even is under 36-40 months, especially if refinancing is possible.
- 13:29 – 16:00
Adjustable Rate Mortgages (ARMs) and Historical Context
Vale discusses ARMs, noting that rates from 2020-2021 are now resetting. He shares a personal anecdote about taking a 20% 2-year ARM in 2003, which led to payment shocks. He notes that ARMs now represent only about 5% of active mortgages, down from a third in the early 2000s.
- 16:00 – 25:43
The Three Big Expenses and Lifestyle Creep
Vale identifies housing, education, and retirement as the three largest lifetime expenses. He discusses 'lifestyle creep,' where extra income is spent rather than saved, and emphasizes the need to budget for all dollars, including discretionary spending, to avoid debt cycles.
- 25:43 – 30:43
Debt vs. Leverage and Emergency Funds
Vale distinguishes between consumer debt (credit cards, cars) and leverage (mortgages). He argues a mortgage is leverage that allows investors to deploy capital elsewhere. He stresses the importance of emergency funds and Home Equity Lines of Credit (HELOCs) as financial backstops.
- 30:43 – 32:21
Home Equity Line of Credit Mechanics and Use Cases
Jeremy Vale explains that lenders typically offer up to 80% equity on a primary residence, allowing homeowners to access funds beyond their existing mortgage balance. He describes a HELOC as a low-cost, interest-only backstop for unexpected expenses like home repairs, noting it moves with the market balance.
- 32:21 – 33:57
Risks and Strategic Applications of HELOCs
Vale warns that HELOCs can become a slippery slope for those prone to debt cycles, potentially leading to lifestyle creep. He shares an anecdote about a home builder who used a HELOC to pay himself a monthly salary, drawing against business profits to cover expenses, illustrating a specific, non-mass-market use case.
- 33:57 – 37:15
Advisory on Financial Products and Personalization
The speakers emphasize that financial products are not one-size-fits-all and caution against 'too good to be true' online advice. Vale advises listeners to consult trusted advisors to ensure any strategy fits their personalized plan rather than forcing a solution that doesn't match their needs.
Claims worth verifying
The market rate for mortgages at the time of recording was approximately 7.5%, while temporary buydowns offered rates like 5.5%.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·5:33
How to verify: Check historical mortgage rate data from Freddie Mac or the Federal Reserve for the period around the podcast release date (Nov 2026) to confirm the 30-year fixed rate environment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Temporary buydowns originated during the building booms of the 1980s when interest rates jumped to 16-18-20% ranges.
Jeremy Vale ·5:59
How to verify: Review historical mortgage rate data from the Federal Reserve or Freddie Mac for the years 2026-2026 to verify the interest rate environment. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In 2020, interest rates were around 2.5%, and in 2021, they were around 3%.
Jeremy Vale ·6:19
How to verify: Check historical mortgage rate data from Freddie Mac or the Federal Reserve for 2020 and 2021. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In 2023, interest rates jumped into the 5, 6, 7, and even 8% ranges.
Jeremy Vale ·6:35
How to verify: Check historical mortgage rate data from Freddie Mac or the Federal Reserve for 2023. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In the early 2000s, about a third of mortgages were adjustable rate mortgages (ARMs).
Jeremy Vale ·14:44
How to verify: Search for historical mortgage market share data from the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) or Federal Reserve for the early 2000s. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Currently, only about 5% of active mortgages are adjustable rate mortgages.
Jeremy Vale ·15:42
How to verify: Check recent mortgage market share data from the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) or Federal Reserve H.3/H.19 reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
It costs over $400,000 to raise a child in Massachusetts, excluding college expenses.
Jeremy Vale ·17:13
How to verify: Search for the USDA 'Cost of Raising a Child' report or the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Consumer Expenditure Survey for Massachusetts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Some colleges exceed $100,000 per year in total costs (tuition, room, and board).
Jeremy Vale ·19:27
How to verify: Check tuition and fee schedules from private universities in Massachusetts (e.g., Harvard, MIT, Boston College) for the relevant academic year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Credit cards can carry interest rates as high as 23%.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·28:31
How to verify: Check average credit card APR data from the Federal Reserve's Survey of Consumer Finances or banking industry reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) is typically an adjustable-rate, interest-only loan for about 10 years.
Jeremy Vale ·30:03
How to verify: Review standard HELOC terms and conditions from major banks (e.g., Chase, Bank of America) or Federal Reserve data on consumer credit. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Most banks will go to 80% equity on a primary residence, though some may go higher or lower depending on the lender.
Jeremy Vale ·30:43
How to verify: Review lender guidelines for Home Equity Lines of Credit (HELOCs) or Loan-to-Value (LTV) ratios on major bank websites or through a mortgage broker. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jeremy Vale pays $50 a year to keep his line of credit open for ten years.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·31:14
How to verify: This is a personal anecdote; verify by checking typical annual maintenance fees for HELOCs from major lenders, which often range from $0 to $75 annually. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
HELOCs are interest-only products where payments are based on the outstanding balance.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·31:47
How to verify: Review standard HELOC disclosure documents or loan agreements from major financial institutions which specify interest-only payment structures during the draw period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jeremy Vale recommends every homeowner with available equity should have a HELOC.
Jeremy Vale ·32:07
How to verify: This is a subjective recommendation; verify by comparing with standard financial planning guidelines which often suggest maintaining liquidity but do not universally mandate HELOCs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jeremy Vale worked with a home builder who used a HELOC to pay himself a monthly salary.
Jeremy Vale ·33:11
How to verify: This is a specific anecdote; verify by searching for case studies on business cash flow management using HELOCs in the construction industry. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the specific terms of any temporary buydown offer, including the escrow funding source and depletion schedule.
- Calculate the break-even point for permanent buydowns by dividing upfront costs by monthly savings and comparing to your expected holding period.
- Review historical ARM reset data and current active mortgage composition statistics to assess current market risks.
- Assess personal income stability and growth trajectory to determine suitability for payment-reset products.
- Check lender policies on HELOC equity limits (typically 80%) and annual maintenance fees.
- Research the historical performance of 80/20 loans and subprime structures from the early 2000s to understand past risks.
- Consult a fiduciary financial advisor to ensure strategies fit personalized cash flow needs rather than generic online advice.
Full transcriptexpand
0:02Jason Factor: Welcome to Finance with Factor.
0:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Oops, apparently we're already recording, so here we go.
0:07Jason Factor: A place you can come to laugh and learn from local experts who love to discuss everything related to the world of real estate.
0:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Weird passion.
0:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It's but it's one that I actually share a little bit, so it makes me a weirdo with you.
0:24Jason Factor: Each week we'll cover a unique topic. To help you understand the mortgage industry, navigate the home buying process, and grow your business while maintaining a slice of sanity.
0:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Okay, fine. I've been confused by a lot of things over the past few years.
0:42Jason Factor: Now that he's climbed safely atop his soapbox, here's your host, Jason Factor.
0:53Jeremy Vale: Jeremy, who is a friend of mine from the business, he is also host of his own podcast. He's a financial advisor.
1:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:02Jeremy Vale: today I really wanted to pick his brain on a few things that are plaguing homeowners and people in this economy, which is, man, things are getting expensive out there. And And how do we talk about that? How do we plan for that? How do we work around that and still be able to achieve our goals? Um, so Jeremy, welcome to the podcast. Jason, thanks for having me again. I'm welcome. I'm glad to be back. Yeah, I want to give you a chance to introduce yourself because that was a terrible introduction. Yeah, so I'm Jeremy Vale. My business is Arsenal Financial. I'm a recovering engineer, turned financial planner. I've been in finance for about 17 years. now. Certified financial planner out of Norwell, born and raised in Hanover. Our business is in Watertown and Norwell. So just in the in the Boston, south of Boston vicinity. And yeah, like you mentioned, we host a monthly podcast. That's called the Arsenal Money Clip. My partner and I, we try to boil down in real talk some of these financial community. and topics for our listeners. So we're both pretty active in our in our local communities and we try to we try to instill some of that in in what we do, but also try to make sure that some of the some of the talk in the industry uh gets boiled down so that the average consumer can can take that in. Really started
2:21as maybe like our our water cooler chats on Tuesday mornings. And when we got together, because we we work in separate places, we would we would have this discussion and we'd be like, Re we should really record this. So we s we did that for about three years until we actually hit the record button. Where
2:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can
2:40Jeremy Vale: people find your podcast? What's the best place
2:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
2:42Jeremy Vale: all the all the channels, Spotify, I think Gaple Apple, and we can put that in the show notes, I think if you certainly
2:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): were
2:49Jeremy Vale: able to do that too. And financial literacy is a fun word to say, but the reality is financial comprehension is much more important. You hear a lot on the news these days about inflation or the cost of living increasing. Wha what does that really mean in terms of pockets for people though? Yeah. Like how do you how do you plan for that? It's it's a good question. I mean we do plan when we do our planning process, we we certainly assume a certain level of increase in the cost of goods and services. And up until probably five years ago, we hadn't seen much of it. Right? Inflation has been pretty low for a long time. Uh the the places you did see a lot of it were Or in college costs or education expenses and in healthcare. Right. And we've all felt that Right. And now it's just in these last few years where we we've started feeling like, my goodness, car insurance, used cars, right? Roofs on houses or any kind of housing project, right? Lumber. Like
3:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all the little things that
3:52Jeremy Vale: all those things that we didn't feel inflation around for so so long. Now we're well wow. All these fe f all these shocks to the system are starting to happen.
4:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
4:02Jeremy Vale: just to kind of like headline it, a s a certain level of inflation is healthy, it's normal.
4:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
4:07Jeremy Vale: it's when we have these extremes that and these shocks to the system, like for instance, the the war in Iran is causing a lot of a lot of issues in the in the energy markets, right? And and you just feel that because it the shock is so great that a little bit of inflation can be absorbed over time, but when it's a shock, that's
4:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when
4:27Jeremy Vale: you really feel it.
4:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Which leads to volatility in the market, which leads to
4:32Jeremy Vale: gimmicks, if you will, in terms of ways to fix it. When the reality is the best way to fix it is with planning. Yeah,
4:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the tips and
4:41Jeremy Vale: tricks, right? Here's here's the trick. Here's the what do we call the biohack? Here's the biohack of the of the of the problem, right? There's always if there's a problem, we try to biohack it. to some degree, right? In this case, maybe it's a fancy mortgage product, for instance, right? You
4:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): will
4:57Jeremy Vale: start to see those. I certainly can speak to them. The one that you're gonna see a lot of that's drives me insane is a thing called the temporary buy down. I don't know if you're familiar with those. Tell me more. Okay. So a temporary buy down is something that you will start seeing. I see them a lot because my algorithm knows me very well, and we all know our algorithms are designed to make our heads explode. So it shows me a lot of people out there, realtors, loan officers, bankers, saying things like, What if I told you I could get you a five and a half percent rate? Would you then be interested in buying a home?
5:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
5:33Jeremy Vale: the reality is they can get you a five 5.5% and a half percent rate, probably, but the market rate on that product is probably 7.5, because that's where the market is at the time of this recording, contingencies at both the front and back end of this podcast included. But
5:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
5:48Jeremy Vale: reality is what a temporary buy down is. Temporary buy downs were were originated during the building booms when interest rates jumped in the 80s and to like the 16, 18, 20% ranges. Now, the reality is the reason that these things were built, think back to COVID. If you are a home builder building a community of homes in Florida, right? You're building 300 homes in a giant neighborhood through different phases. And someone buys in the first phase at $500,000 in 2020 when rates are 2.5%, and they buy in the second. and then another part of the neighborhood is built in the third in the second phase when during 2021, when rates are still around 3%. Everyone's happy. You're buying a $500,000 home. Over the course of the year, it gets built. You close on your home, you're good to go. Now we get to 2023 and rates jump into the five, fives, sixes, sevens, and even into the eights at times. Now, if you had that home. under agreement in phase three of this building project,
6:55the builder can't, you get to closing and it's time to lock your interest rate. You're six days from closing, 100 days from closing, you're ready to lock your interest rate and close on your beautiful brand new home. Problem is you can't afford that $500,000 home anymore because that $500,000 home is twice what you thought you were paying for it when you got it under agreement and started construction.
7:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
7:15Jeremy Vale: go to the builder and you say, I don't want a $5,000 a month mortgage. I want a $3,000 a month mortgage. They say, We can't really do that.
7:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They
7:23Jeremy Vale: can't undercut and you say, Well, sell to me for $300,000. And they can't do that because they'd undercut the value of everything that they've borrowed, built, and undercut the value within the neighborhood. All your neighbors would hate you if the builder did that. So what they do is they say, Well, what if we make it so that instead of cutting your price $300,000, we give you a credit of X thousands of dollars that you can use to make your effective rate and your effective payment at the same payment that you thought you were getting before.
7:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
7:55Jeremy Vale: the way that the temporary buy down works is you're actually still paying the same thing. So I'm going to make the math easy. This is going to be totally nonsense. nonsensical math. Compliance departments, please don't hate me. I just need to make the numbers round so that I can do them in my head live on air. But let's just say you have a $5,000 a month mortgage payment and you're going to do what's called a temporary buy down. We'll call it a two one buy down. In other words, the first year your effective payment is 2% lower than your note rate. So if my note rate is seven, my effective payment on my first year is now 5%. What they're actually doing with these temporary buy downs is taking a portion of that payment and putting it into an escrow account. So again, totally fake math here, nonsensical math, just for round numbers for the sake of the listening audience. Let's say, let's just pretend 1% equals $1,000. So for the next 12 months, $24,000. is in that escrow account that is going to be moved towards my payment. So my first payment, it was going to be five. It's now $3,000 a month. $2,000 a month comes from that escrow account. And now my payment is still my $5,000 a month payment to the bank, but my effective payment was the 5% rate at $3,000 a month. That will happen
9:11for the first 12 months. The next 12 months, my payment goes up to $4,000 a month. And that $1,000 goes over here. These can be very effective strategies for people that go in eyes wide open. I tend to limit them to people that have what I know to be growth and income. So maybe someone who is working at a startup company, biotech is very big in this area, someone who is who knows the company is going. public in a short period of time or things will be vested and their income structure is going to change wildly. I just spoke with a surgeon who was in his last years of surgical residency. We know what his salary is going to be as an ER surgeon two years from now, and it's certainly not that right now. Someone who's a a lawyer on a partner track. Very different conversations because we know that there is a scripted increase in income over the next X number of years. It's it's contracted, right? So the temporary buy downs can be a way for them to get in with the effective payment that makes it affordable. The reality is these programs were not built for you. They should not be sold to you as the end user. They were built for home builders to ensure their losses and that they can make more money. They were built for the seller. sellers, not for the buyers. And they shouldn't be sold
10:30to the buyers, in my opinion, as an end-all solution to a symptom that is much larger in diagnosis. Would Jason, would it be s more,
10:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
10:43Jeremy Vale: guess, from a consumer perspective, is an adjustable rate mortgage a way to get to a lower payment? It can
10:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be
10:51Jeremy Vale: on in that.
10:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
10:52Jeremy Vale: it can be. It de it really does depend. Adjustable rates go in and out of the market with more volatility. We talked about volatility at the beginning. Adjustable rate mortgages tend to mirror that volatility in many ways. In very volatile markets, sometimes the spread between the the 30 year fixed and your adjustable rates just isn't big enough to make it worth the quote unquote. risk. What I tend to price personally for all of my clients is what I call a permanent buy down. They tend to be much less upfront money than that temporary buy down that we just discussed, where you've got temporary buy down and that can be a very big number for for many people, depending on your interest rate and and how many years you're buying it down for. A permanent buy down is just that. It is a permanent buy down for the life of your loan. And whenever I do that, what I try to do is I run the monthly numbers and your break-even costs on your upfront costs. So if it's $5,000 and you're saving $150 a month, divide that by the $5,000 that you're adding to your closing costs and find out how many months that is. If that's a usually my rule of thumb is if you're around 36 to 40 months. it's probably a decent investment, especially because when you do a rate and term refinance, you can get as much as $2,000 back of your previous
12:12loan's closing costs as part of the loan amount. So assuming you have enough equity that you feel comfortable you're going to be able to refinance in that short term, it can be a very effective strategy to get that rate down, lower your monthly payment at a minimum. minimal upfront cost.
12:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Because
12:29Jeremy Vale: the average bear, government pay down is paying points, essentially, right? That's a that's another term for it. Okay. And you're essentially prepaying a portion of that interest, up a discounted portion of that interest up front to the lender. And it it it's essentially an insurance policy saying that I'm gonna take this lower payment now. with hopes that rates stay or with the idea that rates probably aren't coming down super fast. The temporary buy downs, if you are confident that rates are coming down below that temporary number in the very near future, they can be very effective tools. It's just a a risky move for the the teacher on a fixed salary or or the real life person. who has what we would call lifestyle creep. Can you can you explain that for me and and what that is? Because it gets to the danger of these temporary products in my opinion. Yeah. And just before we get into that, it's to your to your point, though w in 2024, we thought rates were going to go down. And guess what? Rates are not any lower, they're higher and no no signs in the near future that that's going to gonna go down anytime. soon. So that two year risk or or gamble is now. Seeing a lot of people that want to refinance out of those temporary products and and can't.
13:49And I've spoken with a lot of those clients that bit the apple in 2023, thinking that the the the phrase that I really hated was one marry the house, date the rate, marry it marry
14:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): marry
14:01Jeremy Vale: the marry the home. date the rate, stuff like that.
14:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
14:05Jeremy Vale: Because the reality is you're now three years into almost a common law marriage. Right. And you're not getting out anytime soon. And just anecdotally, I don't know if you do you mind if I go into a little anecdote. So and it's how I got into the business in the first place. But I saw an article in the Wall Street Journal yesterday about adjustable rate mortgages. And now those rates that were put in place in the call it 2020, 2021, right? Now they're starting to get out of their fixed period. So for adjustable rate mortgage, and you can you're the expert on this, but it's fixed for a period of time. And then it goes into a variable mode where you're kind of brought up to market value and there's caps and whatnot on
14:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that. But
14:47Jeremy Vale: it was, you know, saying that back in the 2000s, the early 2000s. about a third of mortgages were adjustable rate. So subprime borrowing back pre pre uh global financial crisis and and all the the hairs on the back of my neck stood up because I was that guy, right? I was the guy in 2003 getting a an 80% fixed and a 20% twenty percent two-year two year arm. Two-year Two year arm So I was taking a a lower payment and then what after two years, that fixed period goes away and now all of a sudden there's a six month, every six months it can adjust. And so now my payment, because rates went up quite a bit, they were going up two percent probably from where they were when I started, that cap the cap Gap was 0.75 seven five every six months. So my second mortgage was going up. By the way, the first one was interest only. So it was like a total, it was like the definition of a subprime mortgage. But uh it's interesting. Like obviously the regulation changed quite a bit after the global financial crisis. Now there's only about 5% according to the article. Active mortgages are about 5% adjustable rate, which is pretty, pretty incredible.
16:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah. So
16:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): again,
16:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): to me. buying a home is
16:04Jeremy Vale: your largest
16:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): investment for many
16:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people.
16:07Jeremy Vale: You have three large investments
16:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): in your
16:09Jeremy Vale: life, the way that I see it personally. You have where you live, so your house or homes for some, your education, whether that's yours or that of your heirs or kids or whomever. And then you have your retirement. And those are your three big bucket expenses that most are going to come through for their lifetime.
16:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
16:33Jeremy Vale: treating each one of them with the same level of thoughtfulness becomes important. And looking at them in terms of and with scopes of timeline. So looking at them as investments becomes an important lens to view them through. How do you help your clients do that? I mean, that's kind of what the planning process is. I am not a financial planner. I don't even pretend to play one on podcasts. Yeah, I I think you nailed it. The th the three big biggest expenses that we always talk about are retirement. Oh, by by the way, you can't borrow for that. Yeah. That you gotta sock away the cash for, right? You gotta sock away and you gotta invest. The other two big ones you can borrow, right? Bank will give you money for for your house and the schools or other banks will give you money for your education, right? But yeah, I think he nailed it just in Massachusetts alone. And I I I don't have an updated number on that, but just to raise a child is over four hundred thousand, right? And that doesn't include the college expense. So it's it's a massive undertaking, right?
17:33But when we talk about the planning process, right, that's really where it where the rubber meets the rud, right? Because a lot of times it's where we're just kind of going along as as as best as we can without a real fifty dollars away into savings every paycheck. Not really knowing if that's gonna move the needle or anything like that. But and in the lifestyle creep that to go back to kind of your point, right? If there's and what I've found in all my experiences that if there's extra dollars,
18:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it'll
18:03Jeremy Vale: get spent. It'll get spent one way or another. Right. So if we think about the budgeting process, right, and how we plan, right? We we receive X dollars and we need to find a place for all those dollars to
18:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): go. Right.
18:16Jeremy Vale: Whether it's the education fund, whether it's the retirement fund, whether it's the mortgage and the living expenses, or it's it's an entertainment budget, something like that, right? So all those dollars need to have a goal. And I'm not saying they all need to be squirreled away for the rainy day fund or for deferring life, right? Because I I believe in in the balance and making sure that people are living life and also planning for their dreams and goals at the same time. So it's a balance, right? It's not all about putting every dollar available into an investment and trying to get the best number on. a screen. Right. But if you how does that work as as things start to get more expensive on you, escalating college costs, escalating home prices, or even escalating grocery bills? Yeah. Well, I think part of it, especially on those big expensive goals, is be realistic about what you actually can achieve. Right. If you come to the table, and it's never too late, but if you come to the table with a 12 12-year-old year old and you haven't saved for college yet, well, there's only so much you're gonna be able to do. Right. Colleges now, there are a couple of colleges exceeding a hundred grand a year. Right? Especially in our in our area, right? So when you're all
19:27in tuition, room and board, you're talking 90, 100, a little bit more than that in an annual basis, right? So if you come
19:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as
19:35Jeremy Vale: a 12-year-old twelve year old and you haven't started saving yet. well it's time to start
19:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because
19:41Jeremy Vale: it's better save better to have the reserves available than to not, right? And if you live in them in the Massachusetts area, there's a really good chance you have a pretty good income. If you're both working and or even if one of you is working, you have a pretty good income. And that really reduces your ability to get financial aid because the math is skewed such that income has such a greater a greater contribution to the overall number you can get from a r from a student aid perspective. So like we always say better to save and and and hope you don't need it than to to not save and need it and then you're really limited or or restricted in what you can do. So that's on the global side, right? You're talking big goals, college. Big goals multi Multi-year year things to plan for. Now how does it work if we dial back into what we were just talking about with the daily expenses, where even your daily life, things like filling up your gas tank, get more expensive. How can you plan for that on an income that doesn't escalate with the same prices? Or if let's say you're in an adjustable rate mortgage or you're in a temporary buy down mortgage where where costs can take very large multiple hundred dollar jumps over the course of those twelve months, you get out of that adjustable period or you get out of that temporary buy down period and your mortgage jumps fifteen hundred bucks a month.
21:01How do people realistically plan for that when you talk about something like lifestyle creep, where if you have it, you tend to spend it anyways? Right. Right. Well well, I think the to your point, yes. It is not the it's not easy. This is this is a major problem out there. And it's it it significantly impacts those in maybe the lower incomes or those that are paycheck to paycheck, right? So we're always trying to get clients to not be paycheck to paycheck because the more reserves, the more protection you put in place, the more buffer you have for these things, right? So when you're paycheck to paycheck and let's say gas is three 3% percent of your your expenses, and now all of a sudden gas is up 50%,
21:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well,
21:44Jeremy Vale: that really carves into something else, right? Because the the the amount that comes in is let's just call it fixed for now, right? So when the the when the fixed and when those expenses increase, well, that has to go from come from somewhere else. Right. And so when gas is up, when food is up. when insurance is up, when all the basic living expenses are up, well, that squeezes the other areas. Because you can't go without gas. Probably not. You can't go without food, right?
22:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
22:14Jeremy Vale: what what can I okay, well, we can cut back on our discretionary entertainment budget or cut back on going out to eat. Maybe we don't go on that vacation this year. Maybe we wait a year to buy that new car. Whatever, whatever. it might be. And and you can have the real talk with yourself about, well, is this really my goal? Right? Do I really need X amount for this education fund? Or do I really need this amount for retirement? Right. So it's really about, okay, do I have any room there to squeeze? Right? Often, more often than not, you don't because those are so expensive. Right? But to be vigilant to be vigilant about your budgeting.
22:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
22:55Jeremy Vale: I'm not sa I'm I'm not saying you're like watching it like
22:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): with a
22:59Jeremy Vale: fine tooth comb. Ideally we automate as much as we
23:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can,
23:03Jeremy Vale: but then keep an eye on it. You you want to be the supervisor of the process, right? Automate what you can. So Super maybe maybe that that new that subscription came in,
23:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right?
23:13Jeremy Vale: You you do you you upgraded Spotify to the premium account so you could listen to the Arsenal money clip.
23:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
23:20Jeremy Vale: Maybe you next thing you got Paramount Plus and you got Apple TV and you get all these streaming services that you don't really need. Right. And you see that on your statement, but you need to kind of keep watch of it. And all these upgrades, right? The always bombarded with upgrade to this or upgrade to that, do the delivery, don't go pick up. the thing, right? So just keeping an eye on all that stuff. Just don't put your head in the sand and and pretend it's gonna go away on its own because it won't. Yeah, it's not something that even the best financial planner can do for you. In the end, it comes down to to knowing your own budget and understanding it. I I personally I feel like we live paycheck to paycheck. We do fine, but I and probably. part of this is just money blindness on my part, and that my wife handles all the daily expenses. So I always feel like we're we're paycheck to paycheck. And then sometimes she's like, Yeah, we have money and savings for that. And I'm like, that's funny. That's a fun little bonus I just got. Um and then the weird uh well the the corollary to that is it's okay
24:20to be paycheck to paycheck if all the goals are funded. Yeah.
24:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
24:25Jeremy Vale: Yeah,
24:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and and that's sort of what you're doing. all your dollars you're doing. is.
24:28Jeremy Vale: She's pretty good about every paycheck, taking a portion, making sure it's put in each little bucket. Right. You know, we work with our financial advisor to make sure that those long term big buckets have at least an ambitious goal to them. Whether or not we're ever going to meet that goal is who knows, but probably not. But but at least at least it's there. There's a finish line there that we can cross someday. And when
24:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we
24:54Jeremy Vale: talk about when we talk about the big goals, let's just say the college thing, for instance. Like if you come at twelve, it's like, all right, well what realistically do you want to cover? And we can narrow it down, right? Well well, is four hundred thousand dollars for a four year private school education realistic? Probably not. Right? That's probably not what you're gonna going say to it for. Well maybe a year or two worth of public school education, call it 30,000, 40,000. Well, then maybe that's realistic, right?
25:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
25:25Jeremy Vale: setting expectations on what are we actually planning for here? Yep. And there's nothing wrong with borrowing a bit for certain expenses. I always say, I always try to reframe the mortgage. So this is something that I would getting back to the con concept. of some of these temporary or permanent buy downs and things like that. I always say
25:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there
25:44Jeremy Vale: are debt
25:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
25:45Jeremy Vale: then there is leverage. Debts are things like my credit card and and my car, even my education. My the value of my diploma does not actually go up every day or every year or 30 years from now. Yes, my school might be. better, it might be more prestigious, but I'm not getting any return on that investment beyond what I got from my great friends that I go on vacation with every year, and some great memories that we get to laugh about. That's the value of my education. I got a little bit smarter, I did a lot of dumb things, and I had a great time doing it. Um but a home is a little bit different because a home is an appreciating asset that I have invested in. My mortgage is not debt that I've taken out on my home. It is leverage that I've put against my home so that I can redeploy that X hundred thousand dollars into other directions. Yes, I am paying interest, I am having a payment, and I do have expenses associated with that leverage, but the value. for me is that I can make a X thousand, $5,000 a month mortgage payment every month and maybe $3,000 of that is interest. But it's better than me taking the $700,000 out of my
27:04retirement account and putting it into pay for cash on my home because now I have discretionary money every month that I can hand back to an advisor like Jeremy. I can put into the market in an asset that is accruing interest. My house is worth a million dollars 20 years from now or whatever. When I sell my house, it's worth a million dollars, whether I have a $100,000 mortgage or a $900,000 mortgage. The value of my asset doesn't change based on the investment I'm making in it. And so making sure that I am being intelligent and thoughtful. with that investment to leverage it appropriately and move the money into places that actually accumulate interest or earn me money. And if in 15 years I want to take that thousand dollars a month and dump it into my mortgage, I can do that. But at least it's made me money in the meantime, as opposed to just putting it all into the safety lockbox that is my home's equity.
28:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
28:02Jeremy Vale: that consumer. debt's really dangerous. And it's a slippery slope, right? Because when you when you when we are living in that world where all these things are getting more and more expensive and we're not being vigilant around it, well guess what? Well now the credit card balance starts ticking up. Mm-hmm. Right. And now you and that can be a real runaway train if you let it, right? We've seen it time and time again where you get into a you get into a debt cycle and it just it it's it's very hard to dig out of that,
28:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right?
28:30Jeremy Vale: And like you
28:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): said,
28:31Jeremy Vale: 23% interest on that. Exactly right, exactly right. So there's a lot of times where we're trying to work with clients to get them out of that cycle and then reduce the need for that, right? So when we think about a a reserve or an emergency fund, right? The reason for that is such that you try to try to help mitigate a work outage. But a lot of it is if if something big and expensive breaks, we don't use a credit card for that. Right. Because we don't want to put we don't want to pay the bank interest on something that we can plan for, knowing that it's going to happen at some point down the road. And we just don't know when. And planning for that, and then not using a credit card to take up some of that slow. slack when we have an expense that we just didn't budget for. When working with new homeowners who
29:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
29:23Jeremy Vale: now have fixed your payment, right? So, like let's just assume we got
29:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): our nice 30-year
29:28Jeremy Vale: fixed, we have a $3,000 a month payment. Maybe we put a good 30% down on that home.
29:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do
29:36Jeremy Vale: you have conversations with each of them about things like home? equity lines and those emergency funds to make sure that they have those emergency backstops in place? Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. I always call it I I think of it as layers of the onion, right? If this happens, then we have this. If that happens, then we have this, right? So it's like backstop, backstop, backstop, right? Having all these contingencies in place. I think one of our key tenets in our planning process is flexibility and making sure that whatever life throws at us, obviously we can't plan for every unknown, but we can plan for a lot of them. And if if those things do happen, well, then then we got the backstop in place. It's not going to sink. And for people who aren't familiar with what a home equity line is, I should forgive me, I should have defined the term before I use it. A home equity line is a line of credit against the equity in your home. Sounds simple enough. Essentially, what it is for most people is a it's an adjustable rate, interest only, for usually about 10 years. There are banks and different lenders that allow you to lock at various periods so you can lock in that rate and fix that payment. But essentially what you're able to do is let's say, again, let's just use some round numbers. You have a house
30:43worth a million dollars and you have a $500,000 mortgage. Most banks will go to 80% equity on a primary. Some will go higher, some will go lower, depending on the lender you work with. But let's just assume you have access to 80%. That means $800,000. You have a $500,000 mortgage. That means you have access to a $300,000 line of credit. Once you apply and get approved, you now have that sort of, I literally have the checkbook on my desk. Never used it. Don't ever plan to. I pay $50 fifty a dollars year to
31:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): get a chance.
31:15Jeremy Vale: keep my line of credit open for the next ten years. Uh it's very cheap and an inexpensive backstop to put in place if let's say you have to redo your sighting, which I have to do starting tomorrow, uh the contract will be coming to do that. But it's a very expensive bill. If I can't afford to do that out of pocket, well, I can dip into that home equity line and borrow some of those. costs from the value of my home, knowing that I'm also improving the value of my home. It feels like a very safe bucket to dip into at a nominal cost.
31:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
31:47Jeremy Vale: an interest only. Once you pay it off or make a payment against it, if you take out $100,000, for example, and you pay $50,000. Well, now the new payment is based on that $50,000 fifty thousand dollar value. So it moves with the market. It can be a risky long-term strategy, but for a short-term need, it can be a great way to build those backstops in place. And I recommend every homeowner who has the available equity should have one.
32:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh,
32:14Jeremy Vale: because when you need it, you can't it's sort of like life insurance. Once you really need it, it's very difficult to get.
32:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
32:21Jeremy Vale: it's also a slippery slope, too, though. If you if you're if you're a a person that gets stuck in the debt cycle, right? And you're used to putting putting things on credit and paying interest on credit, then then you're doing that on your home as well. That can that can get really, really challenging over the r over time, right? It gets right back to what we were just talking about with the lifestyle creep and the things like that. It is not an open line of credit to be used for for discretionary funds without advanced planning, is the way I would say it. I've had people that use it regularly. So I actually worked with a home builder once who he owned his own business. Obviously, home building, very expensive thing to do, right? You've got to upfront a ton of expenses. So what he would do is he would take out a home equity line every year
33:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
33:11Jeremy Vale: he would literally pay himself dollars a month out of that home equity. line, and that was his salary every month. And then at the end of the year, he would pay himself based on the profit of his business, and then he would pay off that home equity line. And it was a way for him to make sure that all of his sort of soldiers were out in the field earning money and building homes while paying for his it well, without paying himself a salary, but still being. able to meet his daily expenses. So I
33:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): thought
33:41Jeremy Vale: that was a good creative way to use it, right? Again, leveraging your asset that is your house. Is that a good strategy for my wife and I? No. No. Well, right?
33:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like we don't have to. Any one
33:52Jeremy Vale: of these products, right? There's always a a good use case where it really makes a lot of sense,
33:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
33:57Jeremy Vale: it's not a mass market. It's not for everybody. Yeah. Yep. Right. And I think that's the key takeaway. Whenever you see something online or hear something in a podcast, anything that starts, nobody knows about this, just mute that one and move on to the next one, firstly. But secondly, keep in mind all of these products have proper use cases. It doesn't mean you're the proper use case. And you should always speak with a trusted advisor to run through all your options on the menu and make sure that you're not trying to turn leftover Chinese food into Mexican food because it might not taste quite
34:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right.
34:34Jeremy Vale: Yeah. Yeah. I think that's a great that's a great point. Just make sure that you when you when your radar goes
34:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): up,
34:42Jeremy Vale: it's not too good to be true. It's not the best thing that only you have heard. Right. Um again. always, always, always speak with a trusted, recommended advisor. If you don't have one, reach out to me, reach out to us. We'd be happy to connect you with someone in your market who understands your market, understands your needs, and will take the time to understand you and make sure that your plan is personalized to you. Again, these all of these products out there have use cases, but they're not cookie cutter and they are not meant for everyone. So finding the ones that fit your personalized planned scenario is really the most important part, especially when you're talking about these big lifetime investment buckets like college, houses, retirement.
35:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
35:27Jeremy Vale: know. And and it still holds true to the day to day budgeting as well.
35:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
35:33Jeremy Vale: thank you, Jeremy, for for making time to do this and letting me blow off some steam. Hopefully it was helpful. It was I I always enjoy chatting with you. Uh I love working with you, your clients, and and mutual contacts. So appreciate the time and uh look forward to having you back again soon. Sounds great. Thanks, Jason.
35:56Jason Factor: Thank you for listening to this episode of Finance with Factor. Please remember to like, share, and subscribe. Then, if you really like us, open another podcast app, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or really wherever else you enjoy podcasts. Search Finance with Factor and do it again. The more places you like, share, and follow helps our ratings. But that can be our little secret. Have a question about today's episode or an idea for an upcoming episode? Post a comment. For more content, follow Jason Factor on YouTube, Facebook, and Instagram at Finance with Factor. All content discussed on Finance with Factor is self-published by Jason Factor, Senior Loan Officer, NMLS number 1401985. All rates, guidelines, and advice shared on this episode is subject to change. To contact Jason directly or for a full set of disclosures, visit his website at jasonfactor.com.
37:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Jason Factor, NMLS number 140185, North Point Mortgage Sports Inc. NMLS number 1515, NMLS Consumer Access Stark.
37:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): GoFactor!