Jason Back argues paid leads fail without efficient pipelines and warns against marketing hype
Summary
Jason Back argues that adding paid leads to an inefficient sales system only increases frustration rather than driving growth. He notes that the market is saturated with approximately 3,500 brokers competing on Meta, often against banks with massive budgets. Back highlights that social media lead conversion rates are typically 6-10%, contrary to broker expectations of 80%. He advises brokers to focus on long-term nurture funnels and building large email lists instead of chasing immediate conversions. Finally, he warns against marketing agencies promising guaranteed results, urging due diligence and verification of claims.
Key takeaways
- 1 Jason Back argues that addiction to logic and shared tools like AI leads everyone to the same destination, making differentiation increasingly difficult.
Jason Back · 6:07
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 2:07
Sponsorship and Introduction
Julian Barnes introduces a limited-time discount from Bluestone Home Loans for commercial and construction loans. He then welcomes Jason Back to discuss the economics of lead generation.
- 2:07 – 8:46
The Complexity of Paid Leads and Market Saturation
Jason Back argues that lead generation is not the same as business growth, warning that adding leads to an inefficient system creates frustration. He notes that while technology has improved targeting, the market is crowded with thousands of brokers and banks competing for attention.
- 8:46 – 15:26
High Costs and Low Conversion Realities
Back highlights that successful Meta advertising requires significant budget, testing, and time, with brokers spending $10,000-$15,000 monthly. He emphasizes that conversion rates for social media leads are typically low (6-10%), contrary to broker expectations of 80%.
- 15:26 – 26:32
Lead Indicators vs. Lag Results and Funnel Management
The speakers discuss tracking lead indicators like click-through rates and appointment times rather than just lag indicators like settlements. Back stresses the need for long-term nurture funnels, noting that home loan decisions take years and require persistent engagement rather than immediate conversion.
- 26:32 – 28:51
Audience Building and Vendor Vetting
Back advises brokers to build large email lists (10,000-20,000 contacts) to create a trusted audience for future conversions. He urges brokers to vet marketing partners by speaking to their existing customers and researching competitor strategies before signing contracts.
- 28:51 – 29:31
Vetting Marketing Partners and Avoiding Guarantees
Jason Back advises brokers to critically assess marketing agencies that promise guaranteed appointments or use high-pressure tactics like limited availability. He emphasizes the need for due diligence, including speaking with other brokers who have used the service, rather than relying on marketing claims.
- 29:31 – 30:11
The Reality of Lead Generation Testing
Back argues that lead generation is not an instant solution and involves a process of testing, failing, and winning. He warns against 'magic system' pitches, noting that if a method were universally perfect, it would be widely adopted by all market participants.
- 30:11 – 31:27
Closing Remarks and Contact Information
The discussion concludes with Back reiterating the importance of stamina and research in marketing. He provides contact details for Broker Essentials, including their website and email address, before the host signs off.
Claims worth verifying
Bluestone Home Loans is offering 0.25% per annum off for new commercial property, SMSF commercial, and residential construction loan applications submitted from November 2 to December 11, 2026, and settled within six months.
Julian Barnes ·0:20
How to verify: Check the Bluestone Home Loans promotional page at bluestone.com.au/slash brokers or their official terms and conditions for the specific date window and discount rate. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
There are approximately three and a half thousand brokers doing paid advertisements on Meta.
Jason Back ·5:02
How to verify: Review Meta's advertising library or industry reports from marketing agencies specializing in mortgage broker client acquisition to estimate the number of active broker ad accounts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Banking partners have marketing budgets in the tens of millions.
Jason Back ·5:02
How to verify: Check the annual reports of major Australian banks (e.g., Commonwealth Bank, Westpac, ANZ, NAB) for their marketing and advertising expenditure sections. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jason Back's hypothetical example involves a $57,000 annual investment generating 480 inquiries and 12 settled clients.
Jason Back ·11:18
How to verify: This is a specific hypothetical scenario provided by the speaker; verify by checking the transcript text for the exact figures used in the example. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Social media lead conversion rates are generally around 6%, with 10% considered good.
Jason Back ·17:40
How to verify: Review industry benchmarks from marketing agencies or broker coaching firms regarding average conversion rates for social media-generated mortgage leads. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jason Back suggests brokers should aim to have 10,000 to 20,000 people on their email lists.
Jason Back ·27:12
How to verify: This is a recommendation by the speaker; verify by checking the transcript for the specific audience size targets mentioned. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jason Back has been in the industry for 33 years.
Jason Back ·29:11
How to verify: Check Jason Back's professional biography on Broker Essentials website or LinkedIn profile for career start date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jason Back saw a marketing agency claim they were 'only taking on three brokers' at that time.
Jason Back ·28:51
How to verify: Search recent marketing agency advertisements or social media posts for claims of limited broker slots; verify via Wayback Machine if the specific ad is no longer live. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jason Back intends to call a broker he recognized from a marketing advertisement to ask about the marketer.
Jason Back ·29:11
How to verify: This is a personal action claim; verify by checking Jason Back's social media (e.g., LinkedIn, Twitter) for any subsequent posts about contacting that specific broker or marketer. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jason Back states there are very few marketers he can trust after 33 years in the industry.
Jason Back ·29:11
How to verify: This is a subjective opinion; verify by checking Jason Back's published content or interviews for specific endorsements or criticisms of marketing partners. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Broker Essentials website is brokeressentials.com.au.
Jason Back ·30:31
How to verify: Visit brokeressentials.com.au to confirm it is the official site for Jason Back's business. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jason Back's email address is [email protected].
Jason Back ·30:31
How to verify: Send an email to the address and check for a reply or auto-responder confirming the identity of the recipient. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bluestone Home Loans has Australian Credit License 390183.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·31:09
How to verify: Search the National Credit Register (NCR) or ASIC's Financial Services Register for Australian Credit License 390183 to confirm the holder is Bluestone Home Loans. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bluestone Home Loans directs brokers to bluestone.com.au/brokers.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·31:09
How to verify: Visit bluestone.com.au/brokers to confirm the existence of the broker referral page. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the current number of active brokers running Meta ads for home loans via Meta's Ad Library.
- Check recent industry reports on average cost-per-lead (CPL) and conversion rates for Australian mortgage brokers.
- Review the specific contract terms of any marketing agency promising 'guaranteed appointments' for hidden clauses or exclusivity.
- Research the marketing budgets of major Australian banks (e.g., CBA, Westpac, ANZ, NAB) in recent annual reports.
- Investigate the track record of 'Broker Essentials' or Jason Back's other ventures for client testimonials and independent reviews.
- Compare the cost of building an organic email list versus paid lead generation over a 12-month period using internal CRM data.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Julian Barnes: What if more of your deals could work? Some clients don't fit neatly in the box. That's where Bluestone Home Loans can help. And for a limited time, we're thanking brokers for supporting our commercial and construction loans with 0.25% per annum off. Visit bluestone.com.au/slash brokers to learn more.
- 0:20
- Julian Barnes: Offer applies to new commercial property, SMSF commercial and residential construction loan applications submitted from 2, November until 11th. 11 December 2026 and settled within six months. Eligibility criteria. TNCs, fees, and charges apply. Australian Credit License 390-183.
- 0:37
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): This is a Momentum Media Production.
- 0:42
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Broker Daily Business Accelerator. Shellfire Surefire strategies and
- 0:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): proven techniques
- 0:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): to fast track your broking business.
- 0:54
- Julian Barnes: Hello, welcome back to another episode of Business Accelerator. I'm your host, Julian Barnes, and with me I have as always Jason Back, founder of Broker Essentials and Broker Coach. Jason mate, how are you? How is your week going?
- 1:07
- Jason Back: It's still going. We've just uh finished up Farnates finance three 360. sixty Uh it has been absolutely amazing, and uh yeah, the conversation. conversations the level of inquiry the come to Jesus moments effectively in the rooms over this week in Melbourne and Sydney have been amazing and uh a big shout out to uh uh obviously the advisor and broker Daly for putting on such an amazing
- 1:27
- Jason Back: event. Uh so yeah but now it's uh the lead on to Christmas and uh more interesting times ahead. It's been a hell of a few weeks and yeah I agree that it's it's there's been some really really interesting conversations. Obviously people are looking at their pipelines. They're looking at how they can grow their business in i i in challenging times, and they're looking to diversify just like we mentioned in our
- 1:47
- Jason Back: last episode. Something that's also been on the lips of a lot of brokers, of course, has been kind of how to widen the pipeline. Now we've attacked this from lots of different ways in the past, Jason. We've also touched on, you know, paying for leads, we've touched on paying for marketing. and whether that works. And that's what I really want to talk about
- 2:07
- Jason Back: is before brokers spend another dollar on marketing, are are they ready to do so or or or should they do it at all? So that's what I really want to talk to you about today. And it came off one of your emails, one of the broker bite emails. I implore people to to sign up to that because they come out, come out with some really, really interesting stuff there. Jason.
- 2:27
- Jason Back: we're seeing more and more marketing agencies targeting mortgage brokers with a lot of promises, you know, qualified, qualified leads, booked appointments, predictable pipelines.
- 2:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Do
- 2:37
- Jason Back: you think this has become a more attractive proposition for brokers looking to grow right now?
- 2:42
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh, we're gonna open up a can of worms here.
- 2:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I mean, it's uh you've
- 2:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): my heart
- 2:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): race has already start started uh it's already gone going through the roof.
- 2:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh look, look. lead gen
- 2:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): in our
- 2:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): market. I uh funny enough, yesterday morning I was uh uh showing uh Annaline, my wife, a um 25-minute lead funnel video by a very well-known marketer, you know,
- 3:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): promising the world
- 3:06
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and the
- 3:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): billion dollar this and Learjets
- 3:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
- 3:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): and Ferraris and
- 3:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all the um
- 3:10
- Jason Back: I I get really nervous about marketers that are ta uh are coming into our market instead of promising the world. And I think we need to separate sort of lead generation from business growth because they're not the same thing. So I think you know, more leads going into an inefficient business simply creates more activity, doesn't necessarily, you know, and it heightens the frustration. Um and
- 3:30
- Jason Back: lead gen to converted
- 3:34
- Jason Back: prospects and loans, they're very, very different conversations. And I think
- 3:40
- Jason Back: in the market we see ourselves in at the moment, um, people will talk about lead gen as the problem.
- 3:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh,
- 3:47
- Jason Back: and they'll go to social media platforms and they'll they'll they'll see the lure of marketers and the promise of you know endless leads as a solution. When in fact I think there's more to it. Jason, obviously,
- 3:58
- Julian Barnes: I
- 3:58
- Jason Back: think that
- 3:59
- Julian Barnes: the
- 4:00
- Jason Back: um
- 4:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): kind
- 4:00
- Julian Barnes: of yes, social media advertising is definitely. in your in your crosshairs when
- 4:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 4:04
- Julian Barnes: in in
- 4:04
- Jason Back: your broker bite this week. I want to push back for a second, see what you think about this. So obviously, this is not a new product. This is not a new idea of, you know, paying for leads, paying for advertising, trying to create a new market. But what has kind of changed in recent kind of months, perhaps even rather than years, is is the tech behind it and the data behind it. What if I said,
- 4:24
- Jason Back: you know, we we've got better data than ever. we've got stronger ways to connect with clients, we've got ways to use, you know, AI and a variety of different tools that didn't even exist a few years ago to target customers in a totally different way. Hasn't the goalpost changed here in a way that's favorable for brokers?
- 4:42
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh,
- 4:42
- Jason Back: I'd say the goalpost has changed, yes, but it's got also more complex and it's more crowded. I mean, the idea of just saying, hey, look, I can chuck up some stuff on meta ads and I can, you know, put a few posts on social media and grab a whole stack of interest would be fine if you were the only broker in the market. But you know, at any one time, there's sort of three and a half thousand brokers
- 5:02
- Jason Back: doing paid advertisements on Meta as an example. So, you know, it's not as simple as saying, well, hey, you're you're also competing in a market where you've got direct competition. So banking partners have also got massive budgets in the you know, the tens of millions. for their marketing budgets. We might have a few thousand dollars. So it's not a fair landscape. You're also
- 5:22
- Jason Back: competing with two of the most expensive words on the internet being home loans and mortgages. So yes, technology is enabling us to dive deeper into the data, to you know, look at segmentation marketing, to really understand the needs of our clients. We also know where they're hanging out. We know we know that they're spending seven hours a day roughly on their phones.
- 5:42
- Jason Back: And, you know, the platforms have got more information. We can niche down further and further into,
- 5:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 5:47
- Jason Back: know, first home buyers between the age of 25 and 35 working in the healthcare in Western Sydney on a Tuesday when the moon's coming out of the west and you know the water temperature is 17 degrees. Uh, Yeah, we can really target them, but so can everybody else. And I think this is where it goes back to, and I did something I talked about this recently, where we're
- 6:07
- Jason Back: talking about our addiction to logic. And the problem when we were addicted to logic and we're addicted to using all these tools is that we've all got access to these tools. So we all we all get to the same destination at the same time. Um, it's getting harder and harder to differentiate yourself. So yeah, it's an exciting time for this sort of stuff, but it's also a really competitive time. I agree with you that there. it's It's
- 6:27
- Jason Back: it's so easy to um when you've got your head down to kind of see one of these tools as your massive competitive edge. But of course, you know, uh AI is the perfect example of this. It changes the game for you, but it changes the game for everyone else. And it's you know how you can use it in a way that is totally divergent from someone else, but also successful, is very challenging to find a totally new
- 6:46
- Jason Back: way. And and the eyeballs of the consumer, which is what we're really talking about here today. And this is where we'll talk the difference between the lead and the prospect. And a lead's not a converted loan. So this whole idea of, you know, there's a sales pyramid that everyone talks about, and I've been talking about for years as well, that sort of says, you know, 3% of your clients are buy already at any one time. They're the 3% we want to
- 7:06
- Jason Back: convert right now, but the other 97% are somewhere else in a funnel. The problem is we don't do funnels well. We're not, you know, we don't really understand that journey. of the client over a time period. They're buying decisions. You know, we use social media to create awareness, but we expect it to convert. But there's a whole process that has to go through that first. And people aren't logging onto social media to
- 7:26
- Jason Back: find a home load. This is where I think when it comes to the difference between advertising and the types of marketing that sits there and the idea of building authority and credibility and through education, you know, there's a whole process. that goes before that. But I think a lot of people go, they get to a marketer, they throw up some ads and they expect the leads to come flowing through and then all covert
- 7:46
- Jason Back: to loans. It's just not the case. Um, we don't have that many people with home loans in this country. Three and a half, four million odd home loans. It's not an unlimited market. So we talked last week about, you know, diversification. We we've just had the finance 360 conference. Um this is again where the opportunity is to start reframing that
- 8:06
- Jason Back: conversation away, maybe from looking at marketing just to the rese mortgages, but to looking at a more holistic approach to your business and your clients' needs over their life. That's really exciting. I think that's where we can start looking at using things like meta and and social media and stuff to building out a wider palette of solutions rather than historically as being really narrow and really competitive.
- 8:26
- Jason Back: Do you see that then? I obviously I I I I totally see what you're saying there. You kind of want to pick your direction before you market it, right? You want to make sure that you know your strategy and and you're not throwing, you know, more noise into an already very, very noisy space. Do you see kind of successful applications of, you know, take meta advertising? Do you see that as a channel
- 8:46
- Jason Back: that is possible to produce solid results? Absolutely. I mean, look, I'm not a massive fan of Facebook or Meta. I I've never loved uh, because I think if you do some of the research and stuff, and there's some been some really interesting stuff come out lately, you probably find that some of the behaviors of companies like that are not necessarily the best interest of anybody involved, whether that be the end user, whether it
- 9:06
- Jason Back: be the businesses that are in there involved. So that may be a side discussion. But I I I think, look, I see many brokers being very successful using um. meta ads as an example to get their messaging and marketing out there. But there's a lot of testing and learning that goes into that process. There's a lot of split testing, there's a lot of money, there's a lot of time, there's a lot of,
- 9:26
- Jason Back: you know, poor quality leads that come through. There's a lot of funnels that need to get created. It's not as simple as just chucking up ads. And also the thing that we know we will talk a little bit about today is the spend is not cheap as well. I mean these are into I've got brokers that I know are spending $10,000 to $15,000 a month on their total marketing spends. So that's including use of
- 9:46
- Jason Back: agency. It's the ad spend as well. It's the creative design. It's not just going into Claude or GPT and saying, hey, create us a couple of copies and some, you know, some images and you know put some more AI slop into what's already a crowded, messy market. These are well designed. creative teams that are positioning their broker's
- 10:06
- Jason Back: authority to build, you know, audience, um, not just random one offs or for a couple of months and then I stop marketing again. So yeah, that it is it is, in my opinion, it is complex. Uh, it is not easy. If you take it down the path of treating it like it's a $10 a day exercise, um, you may as well go out
- 10:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 10:23
- Jason Back: backyard and burn your cash.
- 10:24
- Julian Barnes: Jason, let's take a
- 10:25
- Jason Back: quick break there. Certainly. not to burn our cash back in a sec.
- 10:30
- Julian Barnes: Let's be honest. Being a broker is about more than writing loans. That's why we created It's a Broker Thing, a podcast packed with real stories, market insights, and candid conversations from brokers and industry experts across Australia. Whether you're looking to grow your business, sharpen your skills, or hear how others are navigating the market, there's something in every
- 10:50
- Julian Barnes: episode for you. Search It's a Broker thing wherever you get your podcasts and subscribe today.
- 10:58
- Jason Back: Welcome back to Business Accelerator. Now I want to unpack what you were talking about just before, the break, which kind of understanding that these are actual, the real economics of acquiring a client. And I want to give your kind of hypothetical example you gave in your broker. bite. So hypothetical lead generation example,
- 11:18
- Jason Back: but you've let's work backwards. So you've said a total annual investment on your example of 57 grand before you've accounted for the time spent contacting, qualifying, nurturing those leads. Let's say the campaign generates 480 inquiries across the year. And and then then from that, you know, as you say, how many people are going to be low home loan ready? Maybe.
- 11:39
- Jason Back: only 12 settled clients. That is $4,750. Obviously, that's hypothetical, but this is a real scenario that brokers go through every single day. The numbers will be different, but it will always be was it worth it? You know, that will always be the question, regardless of where the numbers are.
- 11:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 11:54
- Jason Back: that's so easy to say at the end of it, right? Not at the beginning. How can you know brokers work backwards in their settlement? settlements from the settlement rather than from the initial lead? How can they kind of figure out this cost benefit analysis, Jason?
- 12:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Look, I I think one of the things that we've got to start off with this conversation is to say, look, is this the best use of the money?
- 12:14
- Jason Back: Now, again, I'm not discounting that, you know, things like meta-ads and stuff don't work. They they certainly can. And I've, you know, I've been talking with a lot of marketers lately about this and I see some great results,
- 12:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
- 12:25
- Jason Back: you can't have 24,000. brokers all advertising the same thing and expect to get the same results. So I think one of the challenges is when you're looking at your marketing mix is to say, well, where else could this money be allocated to? And what other strategies could we put in place? Could you do some partnership marketing with uh BV accountants, planners, BAs, et
- 12:44
- Jason Back: cetera, where you're putting money into their marketing mix so that you can do a joint marketing side of things I think it's because they make may have more scale. Could you look at micro influencer marketing where you're looking at that local cafe or local business that's got 20 or 30,000 followers and you're doing a bit of a JV with them and you can pay them for shout outs? I mean, these little gorilla tactics
- 13:04
- Jason Back: are more things that I'd be going, well, they don't have to be your only strategies. Facebook ads is only one strategy. It's not the only strategy. So I think first off, he's looking at what do you are sacrifice? sacrificing if you're going down only one path. So you need to be aware there are other, many other things that you can be doing. And the second thing that it comes to you, and we keep talking about leads aren't settled loans.
- 13:24
- Jason Back: And I think that's what it always comes back to for me. You
- 13:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
- 13:27
- Jason Back: if your cost per lead is $20 and leads generated were 100 and you converted five settled loans, it's a 5% conversion. But if your cost per leads was $100 but only generated 20, your conversion's 40%
- 13:39
- Jason Back: right? Which one would you take? That's eight loans. So then you're going, well, hang on. You might get less loans, less leads, but with a higher conversion. And I think this is what always goes back to. Leads are not conversions. Um, it's someone showing interest in a pipeline at a high level of awareness, and it's your job to take them through that process. And that can take years.
- 13:59
- Jason Back: And this is the problem. When it comes to things like meta ads and so many. brokers will tell me, and I'm sure they tell you too, they just don't get the results fast enough. And that's because it takes time for the algorithm to learn, the split testing, probably not done wide enough. Um, we give up after a few months. And that's where I
- 14:19
- Jason Back: see that those that have committed to it and those that have been doing it for many, many years are making it work because the stamina involved can take years. Not just I put up one post and I'm expecting, you know, it to rain leads. It just doesn't work like that. Cause again, if you were the only broker in the market, sure, maybe, but you're not, right? There's
- 14:39
- Jason Back: hundreds of agencies targeting market uh marketers targeting brokers. There's you said thousands of brokers doing paid advertising. They're all basically saying roughly the same thing. They started to move away from traditional sort of uh image and some and some copy to obviously now more video work. Some of that's pretty average, some of it's not too bad. But again,
- 14:59
- Jason Back: all of it's in this evolving environment. So yeah, it it's not hard. And this is where it's really challenging. What advice do you go and seek?
- 15:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
- 15:06
- Jason Back: as you said, the kind of lead versus prospects and and each part of the pipeline to actual money in the bank, you know, actual actu actual conversion into into cash. And that makes me think about, you know, where brokers should be looking. Cause as you say, it is a game of numbers and it is important. You know, leads are important. And making sure that you have, you know, the the the right numbers that
- 15:26
- Jason Back: that create that funnel that ultimately creates at the end the end product, which is money for the business. Where should brokers be looking most then when they're thinking about their the impacts of a marketing campaign or the impacts of anything that they do in fact. what is the kind of the main figures they should be looking at? Look, conversion has always been the biggest ones for me. I mean, that's our number
- 15:45
- Jason Back: one issue, lead lead versus lag. I mean, the end result of people going, well, we want to settle an extra 10 million or 20 million or 50 or 100 million, there's always gonna be that lag indicator number that says, hey, if we do this, this is what success is gonna going to be defined by. But for me, I like the lead indicators. I wanna want to be looking at going, well, if I do put up some advertising or marketing, whether it be through socials or some other
- 16:05
- Jason Back: form of marketing, then I'm starting to go, well, what does that look like? From that marketing awareness as I go through awareness to consideration to decision, how much time, resources do I have to put into that? Um, what is it, whether it's, you know, uh, you know, a dollar per click, whether it's the appointments that generate, how long are those appointments taking, whether they're done by phone or face face-to-face to face or virtual? Um,
- 16:26
- Jason Back: what's the conversion? to the next part of the process? So it might be that again, we go, you get a thousand people click on a lead magnet. All right, well, fantastic. Well, then what's the next part of that process? 500 um actually uh go to the next step in the funnel. Okay, well
- 16:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): then
- 16:40
- Jason Back: how many go to the next step? How many people do we get in front of us that we actually talk to? So I'm looking at all the indicators going further forward because that's going to tell me how successful these things are before. I worry about the number of settlements that are actually going to hit the pipeline. I I worry that sometimes that we under resource our expectations. So I use
- 17:00
- Jason Back: an analogy quite regularly that it's like walking into a, I want to buy a, I don't know, uh down here in Victoria, I want to go and buy a wood fire heater. I can walk into a store, I have am a chat for 15 or 20 minutes, I can get a whole bunch of information, I can make a decision I'm pretty much on the spot and go, hey, yep, that's the one I want. And I can walk out. Salesman happy. I'm happy. How many brokers can say that about a potential lead? They
- 17:20
- Jason Back: speak to you, engage with you. Is it 15 minutes? No, it's normally 45. And it's not just 45. I've got away, do some servicing calculations. It could be another couple of hours. So all of a sudden I've spent three or four hours on a lead that may go nowhere. So our industry is not built like the wood fire heating industry. Um, we've got to take that into account that. you know, when it comes
- 17:40
- Jason Back: to a lot of brokers will tell you that, you know, when they're doing things like social media leads, um, that majority are pretty terrible, you know, generally around about 94%. So this conversion rates are around about six percent. Um, and if you're getting 10% conversion, my God, if you're getting 20%, which sounds horrible, it's actually really good. But brokers go in with an
- 17:59
- Jason Back: expectation what they're gonna going to buy is 80%. conversion. They're not. They're getting at best six to 10%. But
- 18:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
- 18:08
- Jason Back: is again, this isn't the marketer's fault. This is the broker's expectation that social media is some sort of shiny bullet. It's one tool in a variety of tools that has and can be successful if you do the work. And I'm kind of every broker will know that, you know, a a cold digital inquiry is is often going to require more
- 18:28
- Jason Back: work or or perhaps ev it be a be a dead lead compared to, you know, a warmer kind of relationship, like, you know, referrals, things where you know that there's some kind of um grain of uh of prospects in there.
- 18:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And that
- 18:39
- Jason Back: leads me, and you mentioned it there, obviously, you know, every broker has to think when they're looking at potential clients, how which horses do you kind of back with your time, energy and resources? Which do you kind of leave and as you kind of widen, as you say, as you kind of widen your pool of leads, it becomes more and more important that you're choosing the kind of right people, the right places to put your
- 18:59
- Jason Back: resources to make sure that that lead kind of turns into a prospect and make sure that they are the right person. How much time do you think brokers should be realistically expected to kind of spend on contacting, qualifying, nurturing prospective leaders? leads from kind of a digital format rather than a more traditional, warmer uh
- 19:19
- Jason Back: relationship. Look, and this is, and you mentioned at the start, we the market has changed. How we approach the clients, how we get their attention and their eyeballs has evolved. You know, the idea of um old school, you know, getting on the phone and speaking to every client within, say, five minutes of them making an inquiry,
- 19:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
- 19:37
- Jason Back: just doesn't happen these days. And quite frankly, the majority of the people that are potentially scoping you out and doing that audit of you, whether through your socials or your website or a landing page, they're not necessarily expecting that they're going to speak to you. A lot of them are just doing a little bit of prep. They want to download that tool. They want to go to, you know, I was doing a conference the other day where I asked about landing pages and asked
- 19:57
- Jason Back: about gated content. And basically no one in the room said they had any gated content, which for me fundamentally is. the primary purpose of your website: exchange, phone number, email, and name. Now, again, when we're thinking about the buy readiness of our clients and we're expecting these people to click on a link, a lot of them are just doing that awareness, that exploratory phase. And this is where,
- 20:17
- Jason Back: again, what I'd love to see more of is the funnel sides. So once I've downloaded something, then what happens? Do I get a text, an email? Do I get a call? Do I get another follow-up information? Do I get an embedded video? Um, take me on a journey. People want to buy stuff, they just don't want to be sold to. So as soon as I've downloaded your thing or I've clicked on you, I'm getting this, you know, an appointment set
- 20:37
- Jason Back: to say, hey, we just saw you click on this. We want to book an appointment. It freaks people out. So the home loan journey isn't like going down and buying a loaf of bread or a carton of milk. People don't just overnight decide that they want a home. There's a whole psychological process. to this. So I think there's an opportunity to work with good marketers and to do more research and understanding
- 20:57
- Jason Back: about how this works, but it's not something that happens overnight. People need to really do the work here. Um, you you mentioned how much time should they be spending. Well, I keep I keep going back to I want brokers spending 40% of their weeks doing sales activities. And that would include doing, you know, campaign management, you know, working with you know, marketers potentially, or doing it yourself,
- 21:17
- Jason Back: but actually putting the work in, it's not going to happen before. It's not going to be a GTP. It's not going to be a a clawed output. It's going to be a bunch of testing and learning, a bunch of failed things that don't necessarily get any traction. It's going to be persistent, persistent. I mean, And if I had to put a word to it, you know, the challenge with marketing, it's stamina. And
- 21:37
- Jason Back: unfortunately, you know, the industry hasn't need to build up the resilience factor yet because that we've been so busy. And we haven't put our time and effort into this because we haven't needed to. But you're going to need to get match fit when it comes to your marketing. It's going to be incredibly important in 2027. Jason, let's take a quick break there, back in a second.
- 22:00
- Jason Back: Welcome back to Business Accelerator. Now, Jason, another part of your broker bite this week that really interested me is kind of how you can make sure that you actually have the capacity to handle kind of converting and to handle if you are to spend lots of money and you are to get these leads to kind of handle that in and of
- 22:19
- Jason Back: itself.
- 22:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
- 22:20
- Jason Back: raises the very simple question is how can you know? How can you make sure that, you know, let's say you put down that $57,000 fifty seven thousand that dollars we said that should it be successful, we're gonna be able to to turn that, you know, to turn that into a kind of alchemy. Yeah. I mean, this is the thing, working with good marketers as well, they'll know that they can turn and dial up and dial down campaigns. Um, it's not something that you just go,
- 22:40
- Jason Back: hey, we've got a billboard up on the corner of a street now and it's there for six months and come what may. You know, the programs and the technology and and experts in this field can work with brokers to to really really manage that side of things, to test campaigns, to look at what works and what doesn't, to understand the flow and how these inquiries come through. Because you're right, this is it
- 23:00
- Jason Back: goes back to things like speed to lead. The conversion rates where clients are contacted under five minutes is exponentially higher than those that you leave for an hour, two hours a day, etc. et cetera. So again, once you're putting yourself out there, you need to look at your infrastructure, whether you can take these through to potential things like high resource
- 23:20
- Jason Back: intense time frames like phone calls or or a Zoom call, versus it might be next part of a lead funnel. It might take them to an you know a series of embedded videos. And I really quite like the idea of of of of a series of of embedded videos because if people watch your videos and they're watching the sixth one, they're they're really moving through your funnel and they're probably buying buy ready. Um,
- 23:40
- Jason Back: but if it's just uh an email or just a text and some randomness about following up, consumers aren't patient anymore. That they're not going to wait for these things. They, if they don't hear from you, they don't see from you. Um, I created something the other day for a broker where, you know, when they got a lead form from their website, as soon as that lead form went in, they got an instant response. They had
- 24:00
- Jason Back: read and understood the email to say, hey, we got it, we understand your needs. Here's what you've told us. This is exciting. We'll be in touch with you in a certain amount of time. Um, that will placate the potential lead for a shorter period of time. But if I get nothing from you and I don't hear from you, I'll just move on to the next provider. So again, this is where you need to be ready for these sort of things and you need
- 24:20
- Jason Back: to understand that, you know, when it comes to vetting leads, especially through social media, you know, more questions are more. helpful than less questions. The more vetting you can do, the better you can understand them before they get into your pipeline, the better it is for you. Versus what a lot of these lead companies are out there, it's very simple vetting. Um, person's got a pulse. Um, they may or may not have a job,
- 24:40
- Jason Back: they'd love a house. Um, here, talk to them. Well, geez, what do I do with that? I mean, and there's nothing wrong with that person. But remember, it's a lead, it's not a prospect, right? It's someone that you've got now. name, phone, number, and email address. They may not be ready for years. And if we nurtured them properly, they might have friends who are buying and stuff right now, right? That we could talk to, but we don't know how to handle
- 25:00
- Jason Back: them. So we dismiss them, we get rid of them, we we call them rubbish because we don't have the infrastructure to actually nurture them and look after them while they're not by ready. And that fickleness of uh
- 25:09
- Jason Back: of consumers is is so interesting. I remember this obviously goes back a while, but when they introduced credit cards um autofill onto um web browsers, the amount of extra money that um online vendors would make was huge because the amount of people that were making it all the way to checkout and then realizing they'd have to go find their wallet before they bought
- 25:29
- Jason Back: it, they just gave up. They didn't even bother.
- 25:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That's how
- 25:32
- Jason Back: much they actually wanted it. That's how much that they they wanted it. And I guess to go back to my earlier kind of pushback. about technology, th this is an opportunity for brokers in some ways, because if you have a website, you can see exactly the pain points, exactly the friction points where clients may go, Oh, I'm gonna co I'm gonna click off. And and then you have the ability to to kind of fix that,
- 25:52
- Jason Back: right? Look, I and I think one of the things I'd sort of like to bring everyone's attention to again is I'm certainly not saying that this doesn't like, especially when with it and we're not I'm and I don't have a bit of a thing for meta ads and stuff, but I'm not saying it doesn't work. What I'm saying is you have to manage your expectations. Um there are marketers that I know of and and and follow very closely that, you know, they're getting leads
- 26:12
- Jason Back: for a few dollars a lead. And I sit there and go, brilliant, I love it. And it's just a lead, and that's fine. And if I'm paying a few dollars to get someone in my ecosystem so they can be on a list and I can nurture and talk to them for the years to come, it's done its job. But if you're paying $150 a lead and they're not converting, then there is a problem. So this is why I keep going back to one of the
- 26:32
- Jason Back: most important things that brokers are going to have to be doing and they should be doing it right now, is they need to be building their audience, that list, that environment where they've got on an email, on a you know a text, on their socials, on their platforms, they've got a tribe that they can talk to that's listening to them. Now that's where lead generation I think gets undersolved. undersold. It has two
- 26:52
- Jason Back: purposes. One is you're building that audience. And the second thing obviously is we want to convert those leads into loans and that's how the industry gets paid. So we want to take clients a solution, but so few will be ready for that. Then we have to be doing something with that, you know, that lead list. So again, I I sort of go back to that's a really important message I want people to to think that about is
- 27:12
- Jason Back: it's not just one thing about converting loans. There's another purpose to lead gen. The problem is we've just done nothing with it probably for the last 10 or 20 odd years because we probably haven't really needed to. Ideally, I'd love all brokers to have three, four, five, 10, 20,000 people on their lists. Um, and that's their pipeline. And that's what they work. Rather than trying
- 27:32
- Jason Back: to snatch randoms from the internet, let's, you know, work your the market that's listening to you, that that understands. your authority, that follows you, that likes you, that's a much easier conversion discussion. Jason, to close up then, if a broker was considering spending, you know, 10, 20, 50 grand on more
- 27:51
- Jason Back: lead generation over the next twelve months, what's one one or two things that they absolutely need to get right before signing the check? Well when it comes to obviously understanding a budget and again that's only one part of that audit process of are you ready to start going down this path? Um, you need to shop around. Uh there are lots of really interesting
- 28:11
- Jason Back: providers out there. Look, I'm not really wanting to name names today. There's a few obviously that are very targeting uh brokers at the moment. Some I would think are doing okay job. There's others that I don't feel like they probably got the broker's best interest at heart. Um so you need to be very careful. So uh what I'd be looking at doing would be before you go down and cutting checks, do your research. Go
- 28:31
- Jason Back: and look at what other broker marketing is happening and how they're advertising. Is that, does that resonate with you? Would that resonate with your clients? Go and speak to these agencies, get them to put put a proposal together, but speak to their customers, get voice of customer, reach out to these brokers and have an honest conversation. Is this actually working for you? How much time and FE? effort are you
- 28:51
- Jason Back: putting in? I see you're making a whole bunch of videos. I hate videos. That wouldn't work for me. Well, yeah, there's going to be some problems then. So I think a really honest assessment rather than being bamboozled by guarantees and, you know, money backs and we know we're going to fill your pipe and we're going to we're only to I saw one last night where we're wearing only taking on three brokers
- 29:11
- Jason Back: right now. And we generated this. I actually I saw a name in the in that thing. I'm actually calling that broker today. So, hey, tell me about this marketer. Is this actually working? Tell me all about it. Because if it does work, I'll sing that marketer's name from the top of the bloody hills. But I'm what 33 years in, and I gotta tell you, there's very few marketers that I
- 29:31
- Jason Back: can say, hey, there's someone I would trust. There's a handful. So go slow to go fast here, people. Don't rush into this. Do your research, especially. when it comes to proof, proof of concept. Speak to brokers that are doing it. Um, but also recognize that it's not an instant solution. Um, you are going to do some testing, you're going to do some failing, you're going to
- 29:51
- Jason Back: do some wins, um, but it's not all going to be perfect. Because, guys, if it was perfect and there was, again, watching this little model that I saw the other day of 25 minutes of this guy telling me all about his. magic system. If it's that magic, then why isn't everybody doing it? And if it was that magic, then every other market we'd be saying, this is the one system. So
- 30:11
- Jason Back: don't be bamboozled because you think that lead generation right now is the most important thing you need to be to focus on. Yes, it could be, but there are many ways to do that. So, team, it's complex. Take your time, ask lots of questions, do your research, but stamina is the key. Jason, thank you so much for joining me on Business Accelerator. If people want to hear a
- 30:31
- Jason Back: little bit more about yourself and what you are up to at Broker Essentials, where can they go? Well, give us a shout out at uh brokeressentials.com.au. Uh, you can subscribe to my broker bite through there. Otherwise, pop me a line at jason at brokeressentials.com.au. That's all
- 30:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): from
- 30:44
- Jason Back: us
- 30:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
- 30:44
- Julian Barnes: week. Thank you so much, and see you in the next one.
- 30:46
- Jason Back: Bye-bye. Bye bye.
- 30:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 30:49
- Julian Barnes: information
- 30:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): featured in this podcast is generally general in nature and does not take into consideration your financial situation or individual needs and should not be relied upon. Before making any investment, insurance, tax, property, or financial planning decision, you should consult a licensed professional who can advise whether your decision is appropriate for you. Guests appearing on this podcast may have a commercial relationship with the companies mentioned.
- 31:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 31:09
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): deal you Nelly walked away from, it might be worth another look. Because sometimes the difference isn't the client, it's the lender. Find out why more brokers are choosing Bluestone Home Loans. Visit bluestone.com.au slash brokers. Australian Credit License 390183.
More from Broker Daily Podcast Network
Who is really responsible for mortgage fraud?
Episode discussion: Mortgage fraud inquiry, auction slumps, and lender policy shifts dominate broker landscape
Speakers’ claims: Julian Barnes and Speaker 1 analyze a sharp downturn in Australian property auctions, with clearance rates hitting a 2020 low, and investor lending crashing. They discuss a parliamentary hearing where bank CEOs debated the role of brokers in mortgage fraud, highlighting tensions between lenders and the broker channel. The episode covers new lending policies from Macquarie, state banks, and non-banks, focusing on valuation changes and income verification. Speakers also debate the necessity of a centralized broker conduct register versus existing aggregator oversight.
Spotlight: Beyond residential – The diversification imperative
Episode discussion: Jason Back argues brokers must diversify beyond residential mortgages using client data and strategic partnerships.
Speakers’ claims: Jason Back, founder of Broker Essentials, discusses the need for Australian brokers to diversify beyond residential lending due to market uncertainties in 2026. He suggests leveraging existing client data to identify opportunities in commercial lending, asset finance, and retirement planning. Back advises against becoming a generalist, recommending instead that brokers either solve unmet client needs directly or partner with specialists. He highlights asset finance, particularly EV leasing, as a growing segment and warns against the 'tick and flick' referral model if it compromises client experience. The episode concludes with a four-question framework for evaluating new market entry.