The Great Canadian Comeback

Speaker warns of negative equity in Greater Vancouver due to price drops and high mortgages

21 min Listen to the original Episode page
Real EstateMortgagesNegative EquityGreater VancouverBC AssessmentHousing Market

Summary

The speaker defines negative equity as owing more on a mortgage than a home's current market value, citing examples in Greater Vancouver and the Fraser Valley. They explain that mortgage payments primarily cover interest, slowing principal reduction, and present a scenario where a 20% price drop leads to negative equity despite five years of payments. The speaker distinguishes market value from BC Assessment values, arguing that supply and demand dictate price, often leading to overpayment during bidding wars. They note a shift to a buyer's market, particularly affecting condos and townhouses, and outline options including holding, restructuring, renting, or selling.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Negative equity occurs when the mortgage balance exceeds the home's current market value, a situation the speaker notes is frequent in Greater Vancouver and the Fraser Valley for buyers who purchased during the 2021-2022 peak.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 0:19

  2. 2
    Mortgage payments consist of principal and interest; only the principal portion reduces the loan balance, meaning equity buildup is slower than many homeowners assume.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 1:19

  3. 3
    In a hypothetical scenario, a $1M property bought with a $900k mortgage that drops 20% in value to $800k results in negative equity if the balance remains near $900k after five years.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 2:19

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 1:19

    Introduction to Negative Equity

    Speaker 0 defines negative equity as owing more on a mortgage than the home's current market value, using a $900k home with a $1M mortgage as an example. The speaker notes this is occurring frequently in Greater Vancouver and the Fraser Valley, particularly for buyers who purchased during the 2021-2022 market peak.

  2. 1:19 – 2:19

    Mortgage Payment Structure and Principal Reduction

    The speaker explains that mortgage payments consist of principal and interest components. Using a $2,000 payment example, they illustrate that only a portion (e.g., $1,500) reduces the loan balance, while the rest pays interest, emphasizing the need to calculate actual equity buildup over time.

  3. 2:19 – 3:59

    Scenario of 20% Value Drop and Negative Equity

    A hypothetical scenario is presented where a $1M property bought in 2021 with a $900k mortgage drops 20% in value to $800k by 2026. Despite five years of payments, the speaker assumes the mortgage balance remains near $900k, resulting in a negative equity situation where the owner owes more than the property is worth.

  4. 3:59 – 5:56

    Determining Market Value vs. Purchase Price

    The speaker distinguishes between purchase price, BC Assessment, and current market value. They argue that market value is determined by supply and demand, noting that in hot markets, buyers may pay well above true market value due to bidding wars, leaving them vulnerable when prices correct.

  5. 5:56 – 7:15

    Current Market Conditions and Condo/Townhouse Impact

    The speaker states that the current market has shifted to a buyer's market with fewer competing buyers. They highlight that condo and townhouse segments are seeing particularly low values, with some properties selling significantly below their original purchase price or even below the market value at the time of purchase.

  6. 7:15 – 12:15

    Options for Homeowners: Renewal, Renting, and Selling

    Four options are discussed: 1) Keep the home and manage higher renewal rates; 2) Restructure with the lender; 3) Rent out the property (noting high vacancies and rental restrictions); 4) Sell and calculate the shortfall. The speaker warns that selling may result in owing the bank the difference between the sale price and the mortgage balance.

  7. 12:15 – 16:04

    BC Assessment Inaccuracy and Historical Comparisons

    The speaker criticizes BC Assessment values as inaccurate indicators of market price, citing a case where a $2M assessed property sold for $1M. They note that BC Assessments do not account for interior condition and that values dropped ~6% on average from 2025 to 2026, with some properties dropping 15%.

  8. 16:04 – 21:17

    Conclusion and Decision Framework

    The speaker concludes that market value is determined by what buyers are willing to pay, not assessments or past sales. They advise homeowners to evaluate their specific cash flow, time horizon, and rental restrictions before deciding to hold, rent, or sell, rather than reacting to headlines.

Do your own research

  • Verify current Greater Vancouver and Fraser Valley housing price trends using the Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver (REBGV) or BC Assessment data.
  • Review specific mortgage terms and renewal rates for the asset in question, including penalty calculations for breaking a mortgage.
  • Check local rental vacancy rates and zoning/strata bylaws regarding rental restrictions for the specific property type.
  • Research recent comparable sales (comps) in the neighborhood to determine true market value versus assessed value.
  • Calculate the potential shortfall if selling, including realtor commissions and closing costs, to understand the financial impact of a sale.
  • Review the speaker's background and potential conflicts of interest, such as affiliations with real estate or financial services firms.
  • Compare the speaker's 2025-2026 price drop claims against official Statistics Canada or provincial housing market reports.
  • Assess personal cash flow resilience under higher interest rate scenarios if choosing to hold the property.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to the Great Canadian Comeback, where we break down the stories, trends, and shifts happening across Canada and the moves people are making to stay ahead of what's coming next. What exactly happens if your home is worth less than what you owe on your mortgage? So, what exactly does that mean? Well, you owe more on your mortgage than your actual home is worth for numbers. sake, let's just look at let's say your home is worth $900,000 and your mortgage currently is a million dollars. Now, this is something that's happening a lot these days, and a lot of homeowners are asking the question and uh trying to make some decisions around what to do. And you want to understand the information before you panic, and you want to make some educated decisions. So how exactly does something like this work? Well, this situation's happening a lot more than usual, uh specifically out here in Greater Vancouver, the Fraser Valley, um, just real estate as a whole right now. Um, individuals that were buying at the peak of the market, and it's not just necessarily during a certain time frame, but that peak definitely did occur during 2021 and 2022. However, there were some individuals that bought properties even prior to that

1:19time and even after that time that ended up paying way too much for their property. And now they're seeing their values plummet while their mortgage has essentially barely changed. Now, when you're making a mortgage payment, what you want to know about your mortgage payment is a portion of that payment goes to take pay down the principal, and a portion of that payment actually goes to to uh to the interest. So you got the portion that pays the principal down and the portion that you're paying interest on. So let's say if your mortgage is $2,000 and for numbers' sake, we can say fifteen hundred dollars maybe is going to pay down your mortgage and the five 500 hundred is paying your interest. Well, that's what you want to calculate over time. Like, is uh does that make sense to actually continue making certain payments if your the value of your property has gone down? Now, this is happening quite a bit, and uh again, we just want to clarify

2:19like what the value of a property is and how that property value is determined. So, again, how does negative negative equity work and what exactly does a scenario like this entail? Well, it can be something like this: if you bought a property for let's say one million dollars um back in 2021, and let's say you got a mortgage of $900,000 Hundred thousand dollars on that property and you put 10% ten percent down, which is $100,000, a hundred thousand dollars. that mortgage of nine hundred thousand dollars you carry for five years. And uh let's say you're locked in for five years, and here we are in twenty twenty-six. Now, here we are five years later from twenty twenty-one, and prices have come down substantially. Now, for numbers' sake, we'll just say that particular property dropped uh twenty. 20%. So if that million-dollar property dropped 20%, it's worth $800,000.

3:19Your mortgage of 900 has been paid down a bit over those over that course of five years. Um, just to keep numbers the same so we kind of know what's happening with that That's example we were talking about earlier. We can say that um on a million-dollar million dollar property. if your mortgage was nine hundred, now the property is only worth eight hundred and you still owe nine hundred, what exactly do you basically do? Your property is in a negative equity situation and you owe more than what the property value is worth. Now, the the question here is uh a lot of people want to figure out what what um what exactly is the property value and how is it determined? You know, is that coming off an appraisal? Is that coming off the tax assessment, BC assessed value, uh, you know, what is exactly the situation? Well, the problem is regardless of where the property's at and how

4:19you come up with that actual uh number, is the home is worth what you put paid for it at uh at the beginning. So now if you bought that property at that time and uh you know you you ended up paying, let's say, over market value, you ended up buying that property. Now it all comes down to where the market value is right now. How market value is determined definitely does come down to supply and demand. In in a hot market, when demand is really hot and people are bidding up properties, they can go well over market value. And uh it's it's tough to kind of explain because for some individuals they're just be like, oh yeah, I bought this property, it was a million dollars. And, you know, when uh when you kind of scratch the surface, you're like, okay, well the actually the property was listed originally at nine fifty. There was a bit of a bidding war and you ended up winning winning the property for a million dollars. However, the property was actually

5:19only worth around nine hundred at the time. It was listed for nine fifty from the realtor's perspective to, you know, possibly get the owner close to market value. But the market conditions were hot so that homeowner was able to cash out quite a bit more because they they got that property bid up quite high. Uh unfortunately for the new buyer, they picked up that property well over market value. And uh if you bought it well over market value, now here we are five years later when the market's dipped consistently year after year,

5:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): now

5:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you're looking at a property that is nowhere close to that market value anymore. And uh there's no more buyers out there that are competing and bidding properties up. So when you go to try to sell something like that, you're not gonna get that million that you actually bid it for. You're actually not gonna even get what the market value was at that time, which was let's say 900. You're gonna get where the reality of the market is right now, and the reality of the market in a scenario. like that could be well below the million dollar mark. It can be in the range of let's say 800, in some cases 750. And we're seeing that all over the place right now with a lot of homeowners, particularly unfortunately, in the segment of the condo and townhouse market, you're you're seeing a lot. of values just really, really low. And a lot of homeowners are are facing the fact that their property is not worth what they initially paid for it or what they actually think it's worth right now in the market because there's just not the buyers out there. And uh now you're kind of faced with the question: okay, you got four paths in front of you. Do you keep the

7:15home and make the payments and just try to figure out your circumstances and remain manageable? What do you do in a scenario like that? Well,

7:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

7:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): know, you got this property, it's dropping value year after year. You're paying your mortgage payment month after month. Now it's up for renewal, and your interest rate's gone higher. So you're actually gonna be renewing. and paying a mortgage that's gonna be even higher month after month for a property that's going lower. It's uh that's a tough situation to to kind of look at. Or another option is to like ask the lender or broker about a renewal or restructuring of options. Uh maybe, you know, try to get something done, but the the reality of the situation is interest rates. have gone up. So if your mortgage is up for renewal, you're definitely renewing, first of all, for a higher interest rate than it was back at 21. Secondly, your payments are going up monthly, and your property value is dropping. So it's not a situation that uh a lot of homeowners are are, you know, like excited to be looking at. It's uh it's it's a scenario that's that in uh a a lot of real estate circles this doesn't happen very often, but it does happen it does happen because real estate market is cyclical and things like this do happen. So another option is uh explore renting it out. But now when you're renting it out you gotta

8:44calculate where the rent's at, uh what are your expenses to carry that property, vacancy, things like that, restrictions and some uh uh in some of these buildings, you know, there's rental restrictions. So you can't rent out like a condo or or a townhouse or, you know, the the vacancies are really high. And and right now you're seeing rent prices come down as well because vacancies are so high and renters have a lot more leverage in the marketplace and they got a lot more options. They can rent something food

9:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): fo

9:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's a lot better in some cases for similar price points. So it's uh it's a bit of a you know a a con a bit I would say a comp complicated situation where you're looking at these four paths, what exactly do you do with a property like that? And there's a lot of individuals that uh you gotta explore the final the the final option and that final option is to sell the property and and calculate the shortfall. You know, figure out what exactly you're gonna be doing. And um, you know, there's a lot of situations where if you're selling the property and there is a big shortfall, the bank you st you're still gonna owe the bank that shortfall. So

9:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh

9:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): we've seen some scenarios in the marketplace where if someone's selling that property for let's say, you know, nine hundred thousand and they owed uh a million on it, the banks are turning around and be like, okay, where's the shortfall of a hundred thousand dollars? Like one way or another, we're gonna need to get this. And and if they're gonna, I don't know, like put an unsecured loan against you against yourself personally or a scenario like that, it uh you know, it can be a tough situation. But at the end of the day, you need to like talk to some advisors about that to figure out exactly what that scenario is. entails. Um, you know, I've I've talked to some bankruptcy people, some lawyers and things like that that are are dealing with a lot of these situations right now, and they're and it it's looks like a nightmare out there because there's a lot of individuals that owe a lot more than what their property's worth. And uh when they're looking to either sell it or or talk to the bank and try to get rid of it, they're gonna be owing. that uh extra amount of money that's uh that's the shortfall. So the question is, what exactly do you do, right? Do you kind of maybe just walk from the property? Do you let the let the let it go to foreclosure or things like that. And um this is something that we saw massively in two thousand seven, two thousand and eight. And this occurred um a lot in the US. It didn't happen as much in Canada, but it happened

11:15massively in the US, where individuals owed a lot more. They were in a negative equity situation. They just walked from properties left, right, and center. Foreclosures were just all across the board. Banks are absorbing a ton of these uh properties, and they didn't want these mortgages or properties on their balance sheets. And what exactly had happened after that? Banks were are starting to starting to get hit heavily. as well because they couldn't absorb the amount of uh supply that was hitting the marketplace. And what you know, we're seeing a bit of that here in Canada right now. There's a ton of properties and individuals out there that owe a lot more on their property. And the question is what exactly is going to happen as, you know, as people explore their options, are they gonna walk from these properties and just let them go to foreclosure? Um, you know it's a scenario that uh that definitely is something that uh hasn't been seen before, that's for sure. And and some of the mistakes a lot of homeowners are making is uh assuming that the BC assessment equals the sale price. Well, this is a big sticker shock to a lot of individuals. Now, when they look at the BC assessment, they're

12:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like,

12:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Well, my BC assessment came in at this much, like uh you know, I I should get at least assessed value, if not above. Well, unfortunately, those days are long gone. And uh the BC assessed value is not an accurate evaluation of the market price of your property. And the unfortunate Unfortunately, circus uh the the unfortunate situation in and a lot of homeowners is the fact that these assessed values are way off. And uh we've seen a ton of properties and you can do your own individual research as well, see what's uh sold, see what's out there, pull the BC assessment value and see where the sale price is and where the assessed value values is at. And uh in a lot of situations, it can be very shocking. And in some of these situations, we've seen assessed values. Some properties are selling 40%, 50%

13:24below assessed. And I will repeat that number so a lot of you

13:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): can

13:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): understand where I'm coming from. We saw a $2 million Dollar property sell. That was $2 two million BC assessed. So BC assessed. at $2 million, the property sold for $1 million. Now, what does that mean? What does that mean for the BC assessment? What does that mean for the homeowner? It just goes to show that wait a second, the assessment is not accurate. It is not accurate based on the property. A lot of these uh BC assessments. are looking at, I don't know, land value or potential, you know, upside on zoning or something like that, and uh assess value. You know, BC assessment doesn't come into your home. So they're not gonna see the actual condition of the property on the inside. So if your property is, I don't know, completely trashed inside and needs a ton of work, that's gonna reflect on the sale process. price. It's not gonna give you BC assessed value. So there's a lot of scenarios and in place where BC assessment is not very accurate. And then the question is okay, where are the assessed values gonna land? Well, if you've seen from last year to this year, assessed values dropped

14:44almost on average about six percent across the board. Yeah, some properties dropped a lot more. In some cases, we see as much as fifteen percent. Um in others not as high. However, that was from uh twenty twenty-five to twenty twenty-six. Now, are we gonna see something similar now from twenty twenty-six to twenty twenty-seven? I think so, because there's a lot of properties again that are selling for way less than a BCSS value. So now you're gonna have the assessment again adjusted down. downwards. And the question is how much how much more downward pressure can there be on BCSS values? Well, the assessments will have to reflect where the market is at. And and the question is is the sale price, you know, if you're ignoring commissions, you closing costs, potential mortgage penalties, there's a ton of different numbers and figures that need to be factored in. when you are selling a property. And waiting without understanding is uh it's a tough thing to do because there's monthly carrying costs on your property, and your available choices start to diminish as you as you wait to make a decision. And the whole the whole A question that we're trying to answer in this podcast is it we your home. is worth

16:04less than your mortgage, and what are your options? And the question is, what exactly are those options? And now that you look a lot deeper into where values are at, where BC assessments are at, it's not just uh okay, well, let me just think okay, I owe this much, my BC assesses this much. All right, I should be able to sell this property and uh maybe walk away. even breaking even, or maybe walking away with a bit of a profit. That's not necessarily the case. If you look at actually what the market value is of your property, it's not what the BC assessment is, it's gonna be what the market determines, and that's the reality of the free capital system, specifically in the real estate market. Uh, it's just gonna buyers are gonna determine the price, and that's what's happening. right now because it's a buyer's market. And the and it's a tough situation, especially for sellers, because um, you know, if you were buying at the peak or if you're comp if you're in multiple offer situations or you're you're bidding up properties and and you were you were sold the idea that real estate always goes up and and things like that. It's uh this is a tough reality pill to swallow and and and the and the thing is what exactly are you gonna do with that home? Well the right answer depends on a lot of different scenarios. It depends on whether or not you can

17:23cash flow. It depends on the time horizon and personal circumstances. Uh you don't want to be looking at the headlines that are out there. It's uh you know you want to be asking yourself would you hold this property? Would you rent it or sell it or is your home underwater? And what exactly is the situation that you want to do? And the thing is, in a negative equity situation, what is the financial solution? What is the situation that is that requires the right answer? And it's not automatically a reason to sell. You just need to understand the real numbers and figure out what the options are and what exactly you can possibly. do. And the thing is, in a in a situation of figuring out what the property is worth, it's again up to the market. And the market determines the price point. And if you're looking to figure out exactly what that value is, it's not as simple as just going on BC assessment looking like looking at that. And it's and unfortunately. and in a lot of situations um and what homeowners are telling us these days it's like well my neighbor's house you know back in uh eight months ago sold for this much so we're thinking we're gonna probably get around that price point um

18:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it

18:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's not the case because eight months ago the market was a bit different well here we are eight months later and the markets continue to come down uh those price points are not the same and uh that's kind of the scenario that a lot of homeowners are facing. And from buyer standpoint, too, like it's uh it's a bit of a shaky market out there. Like even if you bought something that you thought was a deal uh a little while back, if the market continue to slide, it's not necessarily a deal anymore, right? So it's it's definitely some turmoil and uh it's been happening for quite some time. But the question is if you're in a negative equity situation, what are your options? What do you need to do? And again, some of the options we went through, you know, are either keep the home, continue the payments. Um, if your mortgage is up for renewal, how much higher would your mortgage payments be? Uh would it make sense to continue those on? Second thing is can you talk to your uh to your lender? Can you

19:41figure out something else? But if your mortgage is up for renewal, you're gonna be looking at interest rates that are happening right now. So what exactly does that do for your mortgage payment? How much higher will it go? Uh does it make sense to to hold on to something like that? Um, should you maybe possibly rent it out? Uh does it uh do the rent rules and where rents are at right now make sense? Will you be able to cover your mortgage payment? Will the expenses and things like that cover? Uh will the place actually rent out? Is there enough demand out there for somebody to rent it? And you know it's a it really comes down to situations like that. Or are there restrictions on your on your property? Are you in a building that doesn't allow rentals? Are you in a scenario where something like that can cause some issues? So it's uh that's something you want to definitely look at. And and and the final thing is like does a sale make sense? Does it does it make sense to sell right now? Calculate all your exiting costs, calculate where you're gonna be what payments need to be made and um see what exactly is the options um available to you. So

20:51this was the episode of the Great Canadian Comeback. We're just looking at where the real estate market is at right now. And uh most importantly, you know, what is your home worth? Is it worth less than your mortgage? And what exactly are your options? I hope you guys enjoyed this episode. Thanks for listening to The Great Canadian Comeback. Follow the show for more episodes and check the links in the description. for more information. We'll see you next time.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights