Panelists select seven closed-end funds at AICA Fall Roundtable betting on discount narrowing
Summary
John Cole Scott outlines the 'Lightning Round' picks from the Active Investment Company Alliance's Fall Roundtable, where panelists selected seven closed-end funds. The speakers note that while market headlines are negative, the closed-end fund market has not been 'angry,' creating opportunities for tax loss harvesting. Panelists Dan Silver, Jennero Gennaro Cardona Fox, Ryan Paler, Rob Shaker, David Johnson, and Scott himself chose funds like EIC, FSSL, PWRL, GAB, ETG, OTF, and RFMZ. Scott emphasizes that all selected funds share a thesis of discount narrowing, which could drive returns regardless of NAV movement. He predicts a busy tax loss harvesting season due to NAV declines in specific sectors despite major index stability.
Key takeaways
- 1 Scott highlights a divergence in 2026: major indices are roughly flat (off ~1% through Nov 18), while NAVs are up ~6%, creating opportunities for tax loss swapping in specific sectors.
John Cole Scott · 10:24
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 1:48
Intro and Sponsor Reads
Chuck introduces the show and sponsor CEF Advisors, asking about non-traded BDCs and interval funds. He then introduces the episode topic: the Active Investment Company Alliance's Fall Roundtable and its 'Lightning Round' of fund picks.
- 1:48 – 3:18
Market Context and Roundtable Overview
John Cole Scott discusses the current market environment, noting tough headlines but expecting tax loss widening and extra dividends. He explains the 'Lightning Round' was designed as a fun, accountable game for experts to pick funds for the next 12 months.
- 3:18 – 4:38
Panelist Picks: EIC, FSSL, PWRL
Scott details picks from panelists: Dan Silver picked EIC (CLO fund) due to positive 3-year performance despite a 27% discount; Jennero Gennaro Cardona Fox picked FSSL (secured credit) expecting a merger with FSCO; Ryan Paler picked PWRL (private equity) for faster discount narrowing.
- 4:38 – 6:07
Panelist Picks: GAB, ETG, OTF, RFMZ
Rob Shaker picked GAB (Gabelli fund) expecting a discount bounce after rights offerings and tax loss selling. David Johnson picked ETG (Eaton Vance) for strong NAV performance. Scott picked OTF (BDC) citing AI fears being overdone and RFMZ (muni bond) as a complex play on muni recovery.
- 6:07 – 7:52
Diversity of Picks and Discount Narrowing Thesis
Chuck notes the diversity of the picks. Scott explains that while NAV direction is unknown, all selected funds share a thesis of discount narrowing, which could drive returns regardless of NAV movement.
- 7:52 – 9:41
Public Forum vs. Client Advice
Chuck asks if Scott picks differently in public forums versus for clients. Scott confirms he customizes for clients but uses public picks to highlight attractive pricing and diverse pieces of the closed-end fund universe, acknowledging the unpredictability of future market directions.
- 9:41 – 11:37
Tax Loss Harvesting Season
Scott predicts a busy tax loss harvesting season due to NAV declines in specific sectors despite major index stability. He notes that IRAs can also benefit from tax loss harvesting strategies using closed-end funds.
- 11:37 – 13:17
Conclusion and Next Episode Tease
Scott mentions reinvesting dividends for clients and suggests it is a good time to add to portfolios for long-term income investors. Chuck teases the next episode on Black Friday discount shopping.
Claims worth verifying
CEF Advisors has been closed-end fund specialists for over 35 years.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:00
How to verify: Company history section on CEFdata.com or CEF Advisors investor relations page. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe Active Investment Company Alliance (AICA) hosted its annual fall roundtable in New York City last week (relative to Nov 20, 2026 release).
Chuck ·1:04
How to verify: AICA press releases or event announcements on AICAlliance.org for November 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Dan Silver picked EIC because CLOs have been terrible and the discount was around 27% at the time of the call.
John Cole Scott ·3:38
How to verify: Check EIC's NAV and market price on the date of the roundtable (approx Nov 11, 2026) via SEC filings or fund company website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceEIC's three-year net performance is positive, unlike most of its peers.
John Cole Scott ·3:38
How to verify: EIC's most recent annual or semi-annual report filed on SEC EDGAR, or Morningstar/CEFdata.com historical performance data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceFSSL trades about a third off net asset value (33% discount) and has a 15% yield.
John Cole Scott ·3:58
How to verify: FSSL's NAV and market price on the roundtable date; FSSL distribution history for yield calculation via SEC filings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceJennero Gennaro Cardona Fox believes FSSL has a good chance of merging with FSCO.
John Cole Scott ·3:58
How to verify: SEC filings for FSSL and FSCO for any merger announcements or proxy statements post-Nov 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceFSSL is 95% secured credit.
John Cole Scott ·3:58
How to verify: FSSL's portfolio holdings disclosure in its most recent SEC filing (N-CSR or N-1A). For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourcePWRL is part of a new up-and-coming private equity group of closed-end funds.
John Cole Scott ·4:18
How to verify: PWRL's prospectus or fact sheet describing its investment strategy and fund family structure. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceRob Shaker is known for 'discount carnage' and picked GAB after it went through a rights offering and tax loss selling.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·4:38
How to verify: GAB's historical trading data and rights offering announcements via SEC EDGAR or fund company site. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceETG raised its distribution rate to 8.4%.
John Cole Scott ·5:12
How to verify: ETG's dividend history and distribution rate announcements in SEC filings or on Eaton Vance's website. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDo your own research
- Verify the current discount/premium and NAV performance for EIC, FSSL, PWRL, GAB, ETG, OTF, and RFMZ using their latest monthly NAV reports.
- Check the status and timeline of the potential FSSL-FSCO merger through SEC filings or company press releases.
- Review the distribution rates and coverage ratios for ETG and OTF to assess sustainability.
- Analyze the tax loss harvesting opportunities in specific sectors by comparing current NAVs to major indices.
- Read the AICA Fall Roundtable transcript or summary to verify the specific rationales provided by each panelist.
- Confirm the 27% discount on EIC and 45% discount on OTF against current market data.
- Look for conflicts of interest among the panelists regarding their affiliations with the selected funds.
- Check the performance of major indices through November 18, 2026, to validate the claim of flat performance versus NAV gains.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Are
0:00Chuck: you putting non-traded BDCs or interval funds on your platform? How have their repurchase windows really played out? And how do they compare to listed BDCs and credit ETFs? CEF Data Tracks It, Human Checked, across the full non-listed universe, built by CEF advisors, closed-end fund specialists for over 35 years. For platforms, service providers, sponsors, and boards, CEFdata.com.
0:26John Cole Scott: We're discussing
0:27Chuck: the big takeaways and the ones that can make you the most money from the Active Investment Company Alliance's recent fall roundtable with John Cole Scott of CEF Advisors. This is the Navigator. Welcome to The Navigator, which is all about all-weather all weather active investing and plotting a course to financial success using closed. end funds. The Navigator is brought to you by the Active Investment Company Alliance, which is a unique industry organization in that it represents the entire closed end fund industry, from fund sponsors, creators, and managers down to users and investors. In the search for excellence beyond indexing, the Navigator points you in the right directions. Last week, the Active Investment Company Alliance hosted its annual fall round roundtable table. in New York City. And one of the highlights was a panel discussion, a lightning round, if you will, giving six experts the chance to make a pick for something they'd invest in for the next 12 months until the next fall roundtable. We're discussing those picks and more from the event with John Cole Scott. He's president of CEF EF Advisors and the chairman of the Active Investment Company Alliance. Learn about his firm and dig into its data. at CEFdata.com. Learn more about ACA AICA at
1:43AICAlliance.org. John Cole Scott, great to have you back on the Navigator.
1:48John Cole Scott: Always good to be here, Chuck.
1:50Chuck: The fall round table, really fun event. I'm glad I got to attend. The lightning round, certainly a highlight, or it will be a highlight because it's gonna give your members and our listeners some ongoing coverage over the course of the year. But before we get there, was there a general takeaway you had? Because it's an interesting time for closed-end funds. You've got a market that has been struggling, but closed-end funds trading on sentiment. Man, they have they've gotten pretty well hammered, which some people say like really well positioned for the end of the year.
2:24John Cole Scott: Yeah. So I think the conversations we had last week. that I took away from was dividends have gone X for the month. We'll be reinvesting extra dividends for clients week after next. Excited for that. We don't know when tax loss widening will happen, but it's usually between now and year end. And so we're looking for some opportunities to really be excited for this year, where it's been a tough year. There's been terrible headlines, but it's not been like an angry, angry market in our world. Yeah, discounts have been tough And we're looking forward to 27 for what could be maybe the next leg of growth for different parts of the portfolios.
2:57Chuck: But it's a particularly interesting time to have experts going, yeah, let me try to pick something that's gonna do well for the next 12 months. And that's exactly what you put. You you brought in an interesting panel. Tell us about who you had, why you had this. them, what assignment you gave them, and what we learned.
3:18John Cole Scott: Yeah, basically to get people excited for some ideas and some accountability and a little fun, because this is not investment advice, Chuck, as you probably can tell. This is basically a game and we're seeing who gets the best fortunes in 52 weeks or so. And we brought on uh the people that were in the last panel, panel seven, and had a few other audience members to make it more beefy. We added some regular attendees to the conference, got my partner, Dan Silver, to actually start things off. I'm looking at EIC, which he really just picked it because CLOs have been terrible. The discount was angry around 27% the time he made a call. Three year net performance is actually positive, unlike most of its peers. He just felt eventually ugly turns around and he thought this could do well next year. The next one was one of our hedge fund clients at CF Data, it's Jennero Gennaro Cardona Fox. He picked FSSL, which is about a third off of net asset value, a 15 yield. He focused on 95% secured credit, and he thinks that there's a good chance it merges with his lighter discount cousin FSCO, in his opinion. Third was kind of interesting. Ryan Paler at Hertzfoot Advisors focus on power law, PWRL, part of our new up-and-coming private equity group of closing funds. probably known to our audience. And he just felt like the VC fund that pays distribution is going to narrow discount faster and do better for shareholders, give it better outcomes than the other funds in that space.
4:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Rob
4:38John Cole Scott: Shaker, everyone knows him for discount carnage. He decided to go through some punishing from a rights offering and then also tax loss selling to a U.S. equity fund, kind of a boring one, but those can be fun too, Chuck. G-A-B, G A B, the good. Gabelli fund. And he really thinks that discount can bounce in the next year or so.
4:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
4:55John Cole Scott: then have one of our other attendees, David Johnson, focus on Eaton Vance's ETG at about 11 discount, had recently raised his distribution rate up to only 8.4%, so nothing too crazy, and has a really strong NAB performance versus the other peers at the fund.
5:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
5:12John Cole Scott: we're benchmarking everything to the major sector industry. index. And my picks to balance it out was a BDC, not new to the audience, OTF. I think fears are done overdone on AI. The 45 discount is exciting and actually increases NAB during earnings season for 3Q26, which we liked. And then a steer the ship the other direction, a very complicated Muni bond fund, RFMZ. It is a great muni play where it doesn't. discounts on discounts, leverage on leverage, and you're gonna hope that munis recover. And by the way, OTF and RFMZ act very, very different.
5:47Chuck: It did give you an extra chance, but you are the home team here. So a little home field advantage, really interesting range of picks. Ryan Paler, who we just had on the navigator, talking about power law, which we had Mike Dinsdale from Power Law on the Navigator as well. It kind of shows the diversity of closed-end funds. I'm curious because if you said, Oh, I'm gonna have everybody make their best pick for a calendar year, you could make a pretty interesting unit investment trust out of that.
6:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
6:22John Cole Scott: maybe next year. Yes,
6:23Chuck: but the question would be: do you have an expectation? for how these expert picks will do on the whole? Because again, this was not trying to put together a portfolio. It was not like you come up with one piece, I'll come up with the next. It was not even what's your favorite fund that you would want right now? It was let's talk about something that for the next 12 months you think is going hell bent for leather, right?
6:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
6:50John Cole Scott: is, and honestly. rather good diversification unexpectedly from the attendees, what I really appreciate is I'm the only one that knew all the funds coming up on stage when we started it. And really, I think all of these funds exhibit discount narrowing theses. So now the answer is where do the navs go? And whether we have a market of fear or greed, which kind of drives navs and a little bit of discounts too.
7:12Chuck: Famously, when I was business editor at the morning call. in Allentown, Pennsylvania, we ran a stock picking competition. And the reason I say famously is it was the last time that Merrill Lynch ever allowed any of its advisors to participate in a stock picking competition because the big name broker in town just kind of blew it, just could not play the game. So I want to ask an important question. Next week, you and I will be talking about. discount shopping in closed-end funds in honor of Black Friday. But you are always looking at funds. Do you pick a fund that you're looking at in a public forum like the one you had and say, I'm picking for the rules of the game? And does that mean you pick a fund there differently than if you had your next client in your office going, John, give me a good idea?
8:05John Cole Scott: So I I did choose to break my rule and give two very different balance funds, because that's part of the way you build a portfolio, Chuck, is you don't know which which way the cats will bounce. But yeah, we usually, when we pick these theses, we try to make them very pure in the reason we're doing them. You know, whenever we give journalists notes for stories, often be over a week till it goes publishing, sometimes a month for magazines. And you want things to age well. So yes, I I do say it's different when you do it with a client because you're customizing. Here we're trying to bring out different pieces of the closing fund universe that have attractive pricing. And that the people on stage thought, not knowing next year's results, we think and maybe the discount will do more of the math than whichever the navs go, because no one can tell today whether global stocks, munis still. CLO, or BDCs or other are going to do better in the next anything. So
8:55Chuck: it would have been really interesting to go beyond this. Cause having spent the day at the event, I would have loved to have had, like, hey, thanks for coming. And by the way, your assignment today would be you give us a pick. Like, I would have loved to have been measured the six people on the stage against everybody else in the room going, I got a pick. for you.
9:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
9:16John Cole Scott: there's good news, Chuck, you don't know this, but the survey has the ability to add your own ticker for the event. So any registered attendees or people that go to LinkedIn for ACA can comment there. And we'll kind of kind of organize that and maybe report it some way with maybe a scattered chart or something at the end. So yes, this can be more engaging. Or We're all registered attendees, fill that survey. And if you want to get involved, go to ACA's LinkedIn page. where you can see the full update on this with more granularity, too.
9:41Chuck: Yeah. And because again, ACA represents a pretty wide swath of folks in the closed-end fund space. There could be a lot of different takes. As we come out of the fall roundtable and we're getting into tax loss selling season, I would imagine this is gonna be a really active season. Like just the way the market. market's set up this year, I've got to imagine that this is gonna be a particularly busy season, which might surprise some people given that the market, until at least recently, has generally been up. But am I wrong about that? Like it does it somehow feel like this year gonna be a busier tax Your loss harvesting season than most?
10:24John Cole Scott: I think so. And one of the driving reasons is we've just kind of had lots of things going down in different parts. You know, the our major index is is basically off about a percent this year through the 18th of November, a couple of days before this airs, but the nabs are up about six. And generally, when things are down and yields have been high, it creates more opportunity for that tax loss swapping. I mean, there's some people who have made some money this year in different places and they're they're going to be looking to actually sell lots. But also, just to add this, which we if you have an IRA, you can still benefit from tax loss lines by picking things that are going down too much, even if you don't get the benefit of the trade if you actually owned it. And so I always try to tell people you can tax loss trade benefit even if you only have IRAs and close-end funds, which is kind of maybe a PSA for the world.
11:11Chuck: Widening discounts, they're not something
11:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's not a good thing.
11:15Chuck: you want to see if you own the fund, but they're definitely something you want to see when you buy. So if you've got stuff and you're going to reposition it, there's a lot of stuff that's on pretty big sales. And you could make a pretty compelling case that at some point the market will wake up and narrow those discounts, even if the market itself is not performing quite as well as it has been.
11:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
11:37John Cole Scott: And we're reinvesting for clients. and those that don't take all their cash flow in the next week or so, as I said earlier in the call. And that's honestly, this is a wonderful time to be adding the portfolios if you plan to never sell the structural corpus, which is very normal for a close and fund-based income portfolio for retired investors.
11:54Chuck: Well, we're going to find out a lot more about what you're buying next week when we get to Black Friday and the annual John Cole Scott goes discount. Shopping episode of The Navigator. John, I'm looking forward to that. Thank you for the time today.
12:08John Cole Scott: Always a pleasure.
12:09Chuck: The Navigator is a joint production of the Active Investment Company Alliance and Money Life with Chuck Jaffe. Yeah, I'm Chuck Jaffe. And if you want to learn more about me and my show, go to MoneyLifeshow.com or just look for the show wherever you found the Navigator on your favorite podcast app. To learn more about closed closed-end end funds. interval funds, and business development companies, it's AICAliance.org. That's the website for the Active Investment Company Alliance. My guest here today on the Navigator, John Cole Scott. He's president of CEF Advisors in Richmond, Virginia. He's the chairman of the Active Investment Company Alliance. Learn more about his firm and more importantly, dig into its research and data for yourself at CEFdata.com. The Navigator Podcast. is available every Friday. Make sure you don't miss any episode, but particularly the Black Friday episode next week by following or subscribing on your favorite podcast app. And we will be here on Black Friday with more closed-end fun talk. Until then, happy investing, everybody.