Jason Watt and Shale McDonald argue financial planning should prioritize avoiding big mistakes and creating optionality over pure math.
Summary
Jason Watt and Shale McDonald discuss a framework for financial planning that prioritizes avoiding large impulsive mistakes, creating optionality for life changes, and aligning money with values. Watt critiques the traditional focus on mathematical retirement outcomes, citing Carl Richards' view that plans should answer if one will be okay. They use the example of boat purchases to illustrate common financial pitfalls driven by impulse. The hosts advocate for simulation exercises and clear decision frameworks to help clients navigate non-linear life events and unexpected risks.
Key takeaways
- 1 Jason Watt suggests that a financial plan should create 'optionality,' allowing clients to adapt to life changes without derailing their financial trajectory.
Jason Watt · 3:09
- 2 They are I'm gonna say like I don't know what that one cost, but wouldn't be unusual probably to drop eighty 80 grand to get into a pontoon boat.
Jason Watt · 9:31
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 1:06
Introduction and Gantt Chart Anecdote
Jason Watt discusses his recent work on a detailed Gantt chart for an engineering company, contrasting this with Shale McDonald's hospitality industry background. They briefly joke about the prevalence of project management tools in different sectors.
- 1:06 – 4:32
Thesis on Financial Planning Goals
Jason Watt outlines his three core objectives for a financial plan: helping clients avoid big mistakes, creating optionality for life changes, and aligning money with personal values. He contrasts this with traditional plans focused solely on mathematical retirement outcomes.
- 4:32 – 7:33
Critique of 'Am I Going to Be Okay?'
The hosts discuss Carl Richards' view that a plan's purpose is to answer 'Am I going to be okay?'. Shale McDonald critiques this as potentially short-term or symptomatic, arguing it misses the alignment of money with values and proactive risk prevention.
- 7:33 – 12:14
Avoiding Big Mistakes: The Boat Example
Jason Watt identifies buying a boat as a common 'big mistake' driven by impulse. He shares anecdotes about expensive pontoon boats and the Edmonton River Queen, noting that while not all boat purchases are bad, many are financially draining due to high costs and low utility.
- 12:14 – 15:57
Framework for Large Purchases
Shale McDonald suggests financial planners should provide a framework defining purchase thresholds and consultation triggers. Jason Watt agrees, emphasizing the need to show clients how large spending impacts their retirement timeline rather than simply saying 'no'.
- 15:57 – 21:55
Creating Optionality and Managing Change
The hosts discuss 'creating optionality' as preparing for life's non-linear changes. They note that even wealthy individuals face risks, and financial plans must include insurance and decision-making tools to handle unexpected events like illness or job loss.
- 21:55 – 22:51
Simulation and Decision Tools
Jason Watt advocates for simulation exercises in financial planning to prepare clients for both positive and negative outcomes. He emphasizes the importance of having a process and decision tools in place when significant life events occur.
- 22:51 – 23:50
Conclusion and Next Steps
The hosts conclude the episode, noting they will address the third goal of 'aligning money with values' in a future episode. Jason Watt encourages listeners to subscribe and provide feedback.
Claims worth verifying
Jason Watt spent time working on a detailed Gantt chart for an engineering company.
Jason Watt ·0:15
How to verify: No external verification possible; personal anecdote. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Carl Richards says the purpose of a financial plan is to answer one question: 'Am I going to be okay?'
Jason Watt ·4:32
How to verify: Search for Carl Richards' published works, blog posts, or books (e.g., 'The One Page Financial Plan') for this specific quote. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Pontoon boats are not cheap, and it is unusual to drop $80,000 to get into one.
Shale McDonald ·9:30
How to verify: Check current retail prices for pontoon boats on manufacturer websites or dealer listings (e.g., Bennington, Crestliner) to verify if $80k is a typical entry price. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Edmonton River Queen has had 'miserable stories' and has not paid for itself.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·10:53
How to verify: Search news archives and business records in Edmonton, Alberta, for financial reports or news articles regarding the ownership and profitability of the Edmonton River Queen. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jason Watt has done dinner cruises on the Mekong and Scheldt rivers but not the North Saskatchewan.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·11:33
How to verify: No external verification possible; personal anecdote. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jason Watt has heard the argument that people at a certain level of net worth no longer need financial planning.
Shale McDonald ·19:21
How to verify: Search financial planning industry literature or forums for discussions on 'financial independence' thresholds where advice is deemed unnecessary. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jason Watt states that if you have a billion dollars, any problem life throws at you can be bought to address it.
Shale McDonald ·19:38
How to verify: No external verification possible; rhetorical claim. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Review Carl Richards' book 'The One Page Financial Plan' to understand the 'Am I going to be okay?' framework.
- Analyze the total cost of ownership for recreational assets like boats, including depreciation, maintenance, and insurance, using industry data from sources like the National Marine Manufacturers Association.
- Evaluate your own financial plan for 'optionality' by stress-testing it against non-linear life events such as job loss, illness, or market crashes.
- Check if your financial advisor uses simulation tools (e.g., Monte Carlo simulations) to model outcomes, rather than just deterministic projections.
- Identify your personal 'big mistake' triggers by reviewing past large purchases for signs of impulse buying or lack of consultation.
- Verify that your insurance coverage adequately protects against the risks that would derail your financial plan, such as disability or life insurance.
- Look for conflicts of interest if your advisor recommends specific financial products or services that generate commissions.
- Compare your financial plan's alignment with personal values against a purely mathematical retirement projection.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Shale McDonald: Hi, and welcome back to the Financial Bullshit Podcast. I'm Shale McDonald and I'm here with my co-host, Jason Watt. How are you, Jason?
0:08Jason Watt: I'm doing really well. Actually, I had a very positive meeting a couple hours ago, and I did just spend a bunch of time working on a fairly detailed Gantt chart, which I don't know.
0:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
0:22Jason Watt: Yeah, like that's um
0:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): i
0:25Jason Watt: it's you I don't know. Like you really have to have be in a mindset for that kind of thing, right?
0:30Shale McDonald: Yeah. A mindset that I'm not sure I've ever been in.
0:33Jason Watt: Man, I don't know.
0:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It was
0:34Jason Watt: it was a lot. I the company that I'm working at here is like fundamentally an engineering company. So Gantt charts are par for the course. Yeah.
0:42Shale McDonald: Right.
0:43Jason Watt: But they're a lot.
0:47Shale McDonald: Yeah. Glad I don't really have to do them in my in in my opinion. industry, but
0:52Jason Watt: you could. You could pull
0:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it off. Yeah,
0:54Shale McDonald: yeah,
0:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah.
0:54Shale McDonald: Yeah.
0:55Jason Watt: Yeah. Imagine the shock people would have if they showed up to work one day in a hospitality business and there's
1:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): just
1:00Jason Watt: Gantt charts
1:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): everywhere.
1:02Shale McDonald: Oh man. Yeah, I feel f feel sorry for them already.
1:06Jason Watt: Nice. All right. I wanted to do something today, Shell. Michelle, I wanted to pick up a little bit on the conversation we had when we looked at Greg's financial plan. planning comic panel.
1:17Shale McDonald: Right.
1:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
1:18Jason Watt: it's something that I don't think we've talked about much. You know, this is I'm gonna maybe expose myself here where people can say that I am the one purporting bullshit. I'm curious to hear if this happens.
1:29Shale McDonald: Okay.
1:30Jason Watt: Okay. Or promoting promulgating? What's the right word here? Sure.
1:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah. And
1:34Jason Watt: on
1:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the other hand.
1:34Shale McDonald: Promulgating's a good one. Yeah.
1:36Jason Watt: Right. So that's definitely a twenty 25 five cent worth, right? So I, you know, I spent a lot of time teaching financial planning and helping people to hopefully get better at their financial planning practices, all that good stuff, right?
1:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
1:51Shale McDonald: So promulgating a lot of stuff.
1:53Jason Watt: That's right. Um, probably some bad stuff in there. So
1:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
1:57Shale McDonald: nobody's perfect.
1:58Jason Watt: It's inevitable.
1:59Shale McDonald: Yeah.
2:00Jason Watt: But one of the things that I I don't know, probably a decade ago or so I started thinking about is really what are we actually trying to do with a financial plan?
2:09Shale McDonald: Right.
2:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
2:10Jason Watt: I think this kind of ties into some of we talked about history of financial planning process a little bit here and there, contents of a financial plan. But in the end, you're putting in what can be an awful lot of work here, and it should do something. for the client.
2:28Shale McDonald: Right. I think we, you know, talked about this in a previous episode, like specifically, like what should a financial plan try to do for a for a person?
2:39Jason Watt: It's fair. So I wanted
2:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
2:40Jason Watt: go through my I I have three things that I think a good financial planning process will achieve.
2:47Shale McDonald: Right.
2:47Jason Watt: And I wanted want to get your take on these, like the the layperson's take. here, Shale.
2:51Shale McDonald: Yeah.
2:53Jason Watt: So, okay. My three things, I'll outline them broadly and then maybe we break them down point by point.
2:59Shale McDonald: Sounds good.
2:59Jason Watt: Fair. Okay. So number one, I would like for this to help the client to avoid big mistakes.
3:06Shale McDonald: Sounds pretty broad. Okay.
3:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
3:09Jason Watt: It should create optionality.
3:11Shale McDonald: Right.
3:12Jason Watt: Okay. And it should create align, allow you to or set up the circumstances where you can align your money with your values.
3:21Shale McDonald: Right.
3:22Jason Watt: Okay.
3:23Shale McDonald: Okay.
3:23Jason Watt: So and those are broad. I think they're they're all deliberately broad.
3:27Shale McDonald: Right.
3:28Jason Watt: But I do think that as a client in a financial planning engagement, if you walked away with a financial plan where you thought it was going to do those three things, I think that financial planning process would have achieved, I think, the best things it can achieve.
3:48Shale McDonald: Right. Okay.
3:51Jason Watt: Now, I will point out here that I think a lot of traditional financial planning practice would focus on like some mathematical outcome.
4:02Shale McDonald: Right.
4:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know,
4:03Jason Watt: the like, will I have enough to retire or what's my estate plan look like, or something like that.
4:08Shale McDonald: Right. Well, and I think like, you know, to be effective in delivering your three main goals, I think, you know, the underlying plan would have to provide sound math. you know, about
4:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the math has to
4:28Jason Watt: be there. You certainly aren't getting away from doing the math here, right?
4:31Shale McDonald: No. Yeah.
4:32Jason Watt: Yeah. And I I will point out that there's a different way to approach this. And I know we've talked about this before, and I'm sure you're sick of hearing me quote him, but Carl Richards would say that the purpose of a financial plan is to answer one question of one question only.
4:46Shale McDonald: Okay.
4:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
4:47Jason Watt: that is: Am I going to be okay?
4:52Shale McDonald: Yeah, I guess so.
4:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
4:54Jason Watt: mean, and I do get that. Like that's fair. I'm, but I think you could make the same argument about going to see your mechanic or your doctor.
5:02Shale McDonald: Right. And and like that to me,
5:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
5:06Shale McDonald: don't know why, but it feels short term to me. Like I it it it feels like I don't I don't really know how how this ties in but it feels a little bit like treating the symptom and not the cause or something. Like I I I don't know. Like it it I I know that doesn't really make sense, but it just seems sort of like,
5:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
5:25Shale McDonald: know, am I gonna be okay? Well, here, you know, like here's a patch that you can put on that's gonna make it so that, you know, you're so so that financially uh you're minimizing your risk. But like when it doesn't when it's not taking into account things like how your money aligns with your values and, you know, giving you tools to prevent you from getting into, you know, potentially bad situations down the road, then I, you know, then I think that it's not really, you know, like, am I gonna be okay? Is not necessarily the only thing that I feel like people should want to have answered, you know.
6:10Jason Watt: Yeah. And I think that's fair. It it may be, you know, too broad a question, right?
6:15Shale McDonald: Yeah. Or maybe it's just like the you know, like it's the emergency treatment, you know, like
6:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's just
6:21Shale McDonald: away oh yeah,
6:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I see what you're saying.
6:22Shale McDonald: my fears and then,
6:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
6:24Shale McDonald: know, and then we can stop talking about this money thing or something. Right.
6:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But it
6:28Jason Watt: doesn't really necessarily give me a roadmap or it doesn't necessarily tell me what to do. And you know, if if the answer if the answer is no, you know
6:37Shale McDonald: Yeah, exactly. Yeah,
6:40Jason Watt: so yeah, so that's where I I do want to get a little more specific. And I will say I don't want to let anybody off the hook here. Like if a client comes to me and says, I want to make sure that you know my children are gonna have their education paid for, right?
6:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
6:56Jason Watt: know, that that probably does tie in pretty tightly with align your money with your values. Like that person has now explicitly described a value, right?
7:04Shale McDonald: Yeah. Yeah.
7:06Jason Watt: Or implicitly, I'm not sure which, but anyways, pretty
7:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): much. Yeah, I think
7:10Jason Watt: it's explicit. So the financial plan should match that. Like you can't get away from answering the client's concerns.
7:19Shale McDonald: Yeah.
7:19Jason Watt: By by using some, you know, esoteric concept here. We use, well, this is what our financial plans do, right?
7:26Shale McDonald: Right.
7:27Jason Watt: Yeah. Okay. So can we work through these sort of item by item here?
7:31Shale McDonald: Yeah. Let's do it.
7:32Jason Watt: Okay.
7:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
7:33Jason Watt: I want
7:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
7:33Jason Watt: start with. Okay. Go ahead, Sergio.
7:35Shale McDonald: Avoid big mistakes. Is that the one that you wanted to start with?
7:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think that's a good
7:38Jason Watt: start. So okay. And I I know that it's still going to happen. Okay. When I used to deal with students all the time, right? When I had and especially like in my financial planning classes, you sort of have students for, you know, 18 to 20 months kind of for that long cycle.
7:56Shale McDonald: Right.
7:57Jason Watt: And you would actually get to vicariously know some of that. student's clients.
8:04Shale McDonald: Right. Okay.
8:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
8:06Jason Watt: Cause they would come to you like in, you know, week two, they would tell a little story.
8:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
8:11Jason Watt: then in week eight, they would come back and they'd be like, oh, and here's what happened. And then in week 20, they're like, oh, I met the person and now here's what's going on.
8:19Shale McDonald: Right.
8:20Jason Watt: And I ran into an awful lot of stories here about. I'm gonna pick on one big mistake if I can, Shale.
8:29Shale McDonald: Sure.
8:30Jason Watt: Buying a boat.
8:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay. Okay.
8:34Shale McDonald: Yeah, yeah.
8:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
8:35Jason Watt: don't want to universally characterize buying a boat as a mistake.
8:39Shale McDonald: I mean, you know, like I I I don't know. I suppose there's there are file financial circumstances under which it might make sense, but I gotta say that, yeah, I I've rarely seen any good outcomes in terms of the people or companies that I've seen buy boats.
8:57Jason Watt: There's a couple jokes that go along with this. So like boat stands for bring another thousand.
9:02Shale McDonald: Okay.
9:03Jason Watt: Yeah.
9:04Shale McDonald: Yeah.
9:05Jason Watt: So or bring on, bring some
9:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): whatever it is. And then
9:09Jason Watt: Yeah, so and then boat is a hole in a water that you just dump money into. Like
9:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): st
9:14Jason Watt: so stuff like that. Now I w
9:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
9:17Jason Watt: the like in my extended family, we there is a boat. There's a pontoon boat at a river in Ontario.
9:24Shale McDonald: Okay.
9:25Jason Watt: And not cheap. Pontoon boats are not cheap, Shell. I don't know if
9:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you've
9:28Jason Watt: ever priced at a pontoon boat, but
9:30Shale McDonald: nope, not so far.
9:31Jason Watt: They are I'm gonna say like I don't know what that one cost, but wouldn't be unusual probably to drop eighty 80 grand to get into a pontoon boat.
9:39Shale McDonald: Okay.
9:39Jason Watt: Yeah.
9:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
9:40Shale McDonald: think I know what kind of boat you're talking about.
9:43Jason Watt: It's like it's it looks pretty simple. Like it's really just two kind of big flotation devices. Yeah.
9:48Shale McDonald: With a platform
9:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in the
9:50Shale McDonald: middle, and then like most or a lot of houseboats are pontoon boats, probably.
9:54Jason Watt: Yeah. Yeah.
9:54Shale McDonald: Yeah,
9:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's right.
9:55Jason Watt: Yeah. And they got amazing use out of that pontoon boat. And we used to go out there, and you know, you'd have supper, and then you'd float up and down the river. and whatever. Like it was great.
10:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
10:05Jason Watt: was really lovely.
10:06Shale McDonald: That sounds nice.
10:08Jason Watt: Yeah.
10:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And with money
10:10Shale McDonald: for the experience, just obviously not a, you know, it's not something that's gonna pay dividends, that's for sure.
10:19Jason Watt: It's fair. Yeah. So I would not say every boat purchase is a big mistake, but I heard a shocking number of stories where somebody like impulse bought a boat
10:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
10:32Jason Watt: then ended up, you know, keeping the boat for a year or two years or trying so desperately hard to get value out of their boat
10:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
10:42Jason Watt: just never could actually manage to do it.
10:46Shale McDonald: Yeah. I don't know if there's like a a point in time where it might be worth doing it. an episode about the Edmonton River Queen.
10:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
10:53Shale McDonald: and I don't know if you know anything about it. But there's like a riverboat in Edmonton that's changed hands a few times in the last couple of decades. And um, yeah, so far, nothing but miserable stories as far as
11:10Jason Watt: supposed to happen. I've never actually been on the Riverboat Queen, but I
11:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know
11:13Jason Watt: what's it's supposed to you're supposed to get on it. sail up the river, have a nice dinner, sail back.
11:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Have a meal. Yeah. Yeah.
11:19Jason Watt: I have done that. Yeah.
11:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Not in the middle of the year. Yeah, and it
11:21Shale McDonald: it has been, it has no, and and and that boat has been doing that, at least for part of the summer season for several years. But yeah, it's
11:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
11:30Shale McDonald: don't think paying for itself and never has, and probably never.
11:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I've done that on
11:34Jason Watt: the Mekong and I've done that on the Schelt. I've never done that on the North Saskatchewan.
11:38Shale McDonald: Wow.
11:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): On
11:39Shale McDonald: the Mekong. I would, I would like to.
11:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That was an
11:41Jason Watt: awesome experience. I absolutely would do that again. All right. So what should happen here, though, in my mind, is as part of this process of going through the financial planning exercise, it should be made clear to this client. Okay. And I sort of like, I think it's easy to say like it's the client's fault. They didn't consult. the financial planner in the process of buying this boat. But I would pin an awful lot of this on the financial planner.
12:14Shale McDonald: Right. I think it occurs to me
12:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as
12:20Shale McDonald: a lay person that if you want to provide this, you know, the ability for your client to avoid. big mistakes, that you would need to provide some kind of framework for the types of the types of and size of purchases that they might want to consider as, you know, like things that are, you know, probably easy wins, things that are potentially precarious, and things that might be outright dangerous to their financial situation.
12:57Jason Watt: That is a very wise answer, Shell.
13:00Shale McDonald: Oh, thanks. What a great
13:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): compliment.
13:04Jason Watt: So, but yeah, I think you're right. The and this is something that I think does not get communicated necessarily, but you know, some clients should probably be perfectly. comfortable dropping a hundred thousand dollars on an impulse buy.
13:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
13:20Jason Watt: is defin like there's definitely a group out there who can do that. And yeah, you're right. I think that there should be some sort of framework presented for, you
13:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
13:32Jason Watt: how big do you go before you call me your financial planner? Now
13:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're
13:38Jason Watt: gonna see this go wrong sometimes. So people will know that the financial planner's instinct here is gonna be to say no.
13:46Shale McDonald: Right. Yeah. But
13:48Jason Watt: again, I think
13:49Shale McDonald: Or to be conservative. And they might look at the financial planner's advice in terms of what types of purchases they should be considering making and be like, well, the financial planner's just trying to be conservative, and I I don't, you know, and I I don't necessarily feel like I have. to be that way or or something, especially if you have disposable income or something like that. So, you know, obviously it's tricky as a financial planner to, you know, like you can't make your clients' decisions for them. But yeah, I think, you know, like I said, providing a framework, you know, and and hopefully building some trust puts them in a better position to want to consult. you for you know potentially large purchases or or just just to think think about how it's going to affect their financial plan if they make certain moves.
14:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think
14:38Jason Watt: though you you did a good job of presenting this where you said sit down with that client and show them sort of what the cap they can spend before they need to, you know, consult you is. And if you kind of if you frame that for the client in a way that they see your thought process on that.
14:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
14:56Jason Watt: they see that your thought process is is not to, you know, jump on everything and say, no, we can't do that.
15:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
15:03Jason Watt: rather, you know, we're gonna weigh. Is this thing gonna be fun for you? Are you gonna get great experiences? Is there
15:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): gonna going
15:09Jason Watt: be to a return here?
15:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
15:12Shale McDonald: what's this gonna going to look like in terms of how it's going to affect? what you already have in place?
15:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
15:16Jason Watt: And it, you know, does it derail things? One of the framing tools that I like here for what are the consequences of a decision? And I think we talked about this once before, but in a different context, is if I do this thing, then how much does it set back or accelerate my ability to retire on on track?
15:38Shale McDonald: Right. Yeah.
15:39Jason Watt: So I think that that's where there is a good opportunity here, like you say, to build a framework. You know, what would constitute like a big mistake?
15:50Shale McDonald: Yeah. Yeah.
15:51Jason Watt: Yeah. Okay.
15:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
15:52Jason Watt: gonna chalk that up to a win for shale. That's a good one. Can we go on to number two here?
15:56Shale McDonald: Okay. Yeah.
15:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
15:57Shale McDonald: that would be create optionality.
15:59Jason Watt: Okay. And does this make sense, Tia? to you? Do you see where I'm going with this?
16:03Shale McDonald: Uh let me see if I understand it. So I guess what I'm thinking is that this means that you know it puts the client in a position where if things change, that they have ways to deal with that change without it. potentially ruining their financial outcomes.
16:31Jason Watt: And as you well know, things do change.
16:34Shale McDonald: Yeah.
16:35Jason Watt: So,
16:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
16:36Jason Watt: the and like you're a good example here, Shell, since I've known you, uh, you've bought a house, you've wrestled with your past debts, you have switched jobs maybe three times, I think.
16:49Shale McDonald: Yeah. I mean probably at least, but yeah, three big
16:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): ones. I
16:53Jason Watt: think, yeah, I think three in there. I don't think it's not like a ton in hospitality, especially. It's not a ton. Like you pretty stable for a guy in the hospitality business. But but I would say your and some of those are are good and some of those are bad, but all of these things are, you know, they they all create situations where there things could go better or could go worse, right?
17:18Shale McDonald: Right. Yeah.
17:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
17:20Shale McDonald: if you're making decisions about them, it's very it's always very difficult to know what, you know, whether they're going to make things better or worse. It's just, you know, life is like that. Some of those decisions are very nuanced and complicated.
17:36Jason Watt: So I think that, yes, exactly. Like the new nuance and complications are what we have to think about here. And what are the tools that I can put in place so that when life throws those,
17:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
17:48Jason Watt: I'm gonna say some bad, some good, right? Whatever it is. But when life throws things at me that are not just, you know, straightforward linear outcomes, how able am I to adjust to those?
18:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay. And
18:03Jason Watt: I think a financial plan that contemplates that to some extent. Now you're gonna get things that are way, way off you know, the expected plan.
18:12Shale McDonald: Right, of course.
18:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
18:14Shale McDonald: I I think that like
18:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
18:17Shale McDonald: know, it's also tricky to like I think the tendency would be to say that like you know the best way to create optionality is just to create the most possible money you know like the best way to deflect unexpected outcomes is just by having the money to cover them and so I think that you know there would be a tendency here to like simplify it down to the math of what's the best possible return. And but I if if I'm like reading the if I if I'm reading these three points correctly, I I think that that maybe is is to some extent trying to steer away from that type of mentality.
19:10Jason Watt: Okay, so I think you're right. I think that the tendency might be here to say. you know, if you just invested, generate a monster return, kind of anything that might seem like a problem is not a problem.
19:21Shale McDonald: Right.
19:22Jason Watt: And I don't know. I mean to some extent, I suppose that's true if you could generate so much money. And you know, this is where the like I've heard this argument, Shale, that people at a certain level of net worth no longer need financial planning.
19:38Shale McDonald: Right.
19:40Jason Watt: And I guess there's some truth to that. You know, if you've got a billion dollars, you know, any problem life throws at you, you're gonna have enough money to buy whatever can be bought to address it.
19:53Shale McDonald: Yeah. Uh yeah. Yeah.
19:56Jason Watt: Now, there would still be problems that money can't deal with.
20:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right.
20:01Shale McDonald: And well, like I I don't
20:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
20:02Shale McDonald: it just it also occurs to me that like people with a billion dollars there's like a way higher propensity for people with a billion dollars to lose a billion dollars. You know, like if you have a billion dollars cash, that's one thing. But most people with a billion dollars don't have a billion dollars cash. Most most people with a million dollars saved don't have a million dollars cash. It's not liquid in the same way. And so it's I don't know. I I feel like once you you know, I'm sure that there are strategies that you can employ that if if you have that kind of wealth that can protect you in perpetuity. But you know, i if you're you can lose investments, you know, pretty badly. So I don't know.
20:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
20:50Jason Watt: I uh that that's fair. Like more money, more problems, Shell. So where are you going here?
20:56Shale McDonald: I guess so. Yeah.
20:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
20:58Jason Watt: yeah. I do think though that whatever, like there are things where you don't have enough time to accumulate enough. This is why we have insurance, right? So, you know, I can say, well, invest at it, invest for long term, generate returns, keep your costs low, and you'll probably have enough money to manage your retirement, but it does not help if you get sick in a week or if you're in a car crash in two years or whatever the case is, right?
21:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
21:24Jason Watt: the yeah, the optionality does have to kind of cover the whole range of events that can happen.
21:30Shale McDonald: Right. And so, you know, then I guess like in a more concrete way, what we're talking about is like diversifying where we're putting our money so that it is covering as many possible outcomes as as it can.
21:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Is
21:49Shale McDonald: that
21:50Jason Watt: yeah, I I think the other thing to go along with this is it's not just a financial set of outcomes. You know, one of the things that I think we can do that is quite useful in a financial planning exercise
22:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
22:02Jason Watt: a big bit of simulation.
22:05Shale McDonald: Right. Okay.
22:06Jason Watt: So if something goes wrong, or for that matter, if something goes right, how are we going to react to it?
22:14Shale McDonald: I see. Yeah.
22:15Jason Watt: And some of that is financial, but some of it is also creating a bit of
22:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
22:22Jason Watt: decision tools, right? So some, you know. the recognition that when things go wrong, you know, slow down, have a process, have people you can call, look at
22:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
22:34Jason Watt: tools you have, then make your decision.
22:37Shale McDonald: Right. Right.
22:39Jason Watt: Okay. And I think so, in that sense, a good financial planning process should you know broadly empower a better set of financial outcomes.
22:48Shale McDonald: Right.
22:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
22:51Jason Watt: And my last here, okay, is to align money with values.
22:56Shale McDonald: Yeah.
22:58Jason Watt: Okay. So I think maybe we leave this for another episode, Shale. We're sort of at time here.
23:05Shale McDonald: Okay. Sure. Yeah. I mean it's it's a pretty, yeah, it it's a pretty in-depth topic, I feel like. Pretty
23:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): pretty.
23:15Shale McDonald: nuanced.
23:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All right.
23:18Jason Watt: Thanks very much for listening. I'm curious for feedback on that. There was a little bit more thoughtfulness, I think, in our discussion there. So that led to some ums and pauses that I would normally take out, but I felt like they contributed to some of the we could hear the thinking happening there, or you could see the smoke pouring out of my ears. At any rate, uh please like, subscribe, pass it on to a friend, leave a comment, all that good stuff. And we'll see you next week. Thanks so much.